RecordWell Data

March 24, 2025 (Zoning Session)

Knox County · Knox County · meeting of Mar 24, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Knox County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

KNOX COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS ZONING SESSION The Knox County Board of Commissioners met in Regular Session to consider the Zoning Agenda on Monday, March 24, 2025 at 5:00 p.m. in the Main Assembly Room of the City-County Building, Main Street. Those members present were Commissioners Damon Rawls, Courtney Durrett, Gina Oster, Shane Jackson, Angela Russell, Terry Hill, Rhonda Lee, Adam Thompson, Andy Fox, Larsen Jay and Kim Frazier. The Junior Commissioner members present were Junior Commissioners Jakhi Powell, Audrey Zanders, Estella Tarbox, Shylyn Whitcomb, Pierce Broussard, Olivia Price, Jackson Kingsford, Charity Davis, Olivia Graves and Matthew Greenwood. Junior Commissioner Keya Patel was absent from the meeting. Also present were Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville- Knox County Planning, Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, and a member of the news media. Commissioner Oster, Madam Chair, presided. The following proceedings were had and entered of record to-wit: * * * * * * IN RE: ROLL CALL - (5:00 P .M.): Mrs. Haley Wilson, Clerk Recorder, called the roll. * * * * * * IN RE: PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG: Commissioner Fox led the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. * * * * * * IN RE: AMENDMENTS TO THE AGENDA: There were no Amendments to the Agenda. * * * * * * IN RE: CONSIDERATION OF APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM THE PREVIOUS MEETING HELD ON FEBRUARY 19, 2025: Consideration of approval of minutes from the previous meeting held on February 19, 2025 was before the Board of Commissioners. Commissioner Durrett moved to approve the minutes from the previous meeting held on February 19, 2025. Commissioner Frazier seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay and Frazier voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. * * * * * * IN RE: PUBLIC FORUM – AGENDA ITEMS ONLY: The Public Forum speakers requested to speak during the agenda items. * * * * * * IN RE: ZONING REQUESTS: 1. Consideration of the request of Terry Romans for rezoning from A Agricultural to CN Neighborhood Commercial was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 1907 East Governor John Sevier Highway, Parcel ID 111 03606. (9th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 1-M-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. He also spoke on the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Terry Romans, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Ms. Janice Pritchett, area resident, was present and spoke in opposition to the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Commissioner Fox moved to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-101 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Terry Romans for rezoning from A Agricultural to CN Neighborhood Commercial as per Planning Commission’s recommendation. Commissioner Jackson seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Hill, Lee, Fox and Jay voted aye. Commissioners Thompson and Frazier voted no. Commissioner Russell abstained from voting. The motion carried 8-2-1-0. Property located at 1907 East Governor John Sevier Highway, Parcel ID 111 03606. (9th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 1-M-25-RZ) * * * * * * 2. Consideration of the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 6 dwelling units per acre was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 205 North Wooddale Road, Parcel ID 062 047. (8th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 12-D-24-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Drew Staton, representing Mesana Investments, LLC, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. The following area residents were present and spoke in opposition to the request: Ms. Michelle Hoskins, Ms. Megan Stinnett, Ms. Nancy Manning, Mr. Ty French, Ms. Jennifer Blakely, and Mr. Michael Sullivan. Mr. Joseph Bailey, concerned citizen, was present and spoke in opposition to the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Ms. Sheila Blakely, area resident, and Mr. Wendell Chittum, area resident, were present and spoke in opposition to the request. Commissioner Thompson moved to deny the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 6 dwelling units per acre. Commissioner Frazier seconded the motion. Commissioner Jay moved as a substitute motion to approve the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 4 dwelling units per acre with the condition of internal sidewalks for pedestrian connectivity inside the development and for future connectivity. Commissioner Hill seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Hill and Jay voted aye. Commissioners Jackson, Russell, Lee, Thompson and Frazier voted no. Commissioner Fox abstained from voting. The substitute motion failed 5-5-1-0. Commissioner Jay moved as a substitute motion to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-102 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 2 dwelling units per acre with no conditions. Commissioner Hill seconded the motion. Commissioner Jackson moved as an amendment to the substitute motion to approve the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 6 dwelling units per acre with a one- half (½) acre pocket park; and frontage of sidewalks on Wooddale Road that Knox County would maintain. There was no second to the motion. The amendment failed due to lack of a second. Upon roll call vote of the substitute motion to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-102 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 2 dwelling units per acre with no conditions, Commissioners Durrett, Oster, Russell, Hill, Jay and Rawls voted aye. Commissioners Jackson, Lee, Thompson and Frazer voted no. Commissioner Fox abstained from voting. The substitute motion carried 6-4-1-0. Property located at 205 North Wooddale Road, Parcel ID 062 047. (8th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 12-D-24-RZ) * * * * * * 3. Consideration of the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 5 dwelling units per acre was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 2748 and 2720 Cunningham Road and 6930 Shady Lane, Parcel ID 048 027 (part of), 028 (part of), and 02802. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 1-I-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Drew Staton, representing Mesana Investments, LLC, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Mr. Wayne Kline, Attorney representing area residents, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Mr. Jerry Key, President of Beaver Brook Golf and Country Club, was present and spoke in opposition to the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Commissioner Lee moved to approve the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 2 dwelling units per acre with the following conditions: 1) The ingress and egress to the development be exclusively through Cunningham Road directly across from Imperial Lane on the north of Cunningham Road; no access shall be utilized from Shady Lane or cut into or out of the development; 2) a traffic study will be required in the concept plan phase; and 3) a vegetation buffer shall be created and maintained without Residential development on the Shady Lane side of the property for the entire length of the property on the side running next to Shady Lane with a buffer being 30 feet wide; and the vegetation shall include the existing pines and a roll of evergreen giants running the length of the west side of the property planted 15 feet apart inside the buffer. Commissioner Russell seconded the motion. Commissioner Durrett moved as a substitute motion to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-103 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Mesana Investments, LLC for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 3 dwelling units per acre with the following conditions: 1) The ingress and egress to the development be exclusively through Cunningham Road directly across from Imperial Lane on the north of Cunningham Road; no access shall be utilized from Shady Lane or cut into or out of the development; 2) a traffic study will be required in the concept plan phase; and 3) a vegetation buffer shall be created and maintained without Residential development on the Shady Lane side of the property for the entire length of the property on the side running next to Shady Lane with a buffer being 30 feet wide; and the vegetation shall include the existing pines and a roll of evergreen giants running the length of the west side of the property planted 15 feet apart inside the buffer. Commissioner Jay seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Oster, Hill, Fox, Jay, Rawls and Durrett voted aye. Commissioners Jackson, Russell, Lee, Thompson and Frazier voted no. The substitute motion carried 6-5-0-0. Property located at 2748 and 2720 Cunningham Road and 6930 Shady Lane, Parcel ID 048 027 (part of), 028 (part of), and 02802. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 1-I-25-RZ) * * * * * * 4. Consideration of the request of Randy Guignard for rezoning from PR Planned Residential up to 5 dwelling units per acre to PR Planned Residential up to 10 dwelling units per acre was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 0 Rifle Range Drive, Parcel ID 048 070. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-C-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Randy Guignard, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Commissioner Oster asked if there was any opposition to the request. There was no response. Commissioner Lee moved to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-104 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Randy Guignard for rezoning from PR Planned Residential up to 5 dwelling units per acre to PR Planned Residential up to 10 dwelling units per acre as per Planning Commission’s recommendation. Commissioner Frazier seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay and Frazier voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. Property located at 0 Rifle Range Drive, Parcel ID 048 070. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-C-25-RZ) * * * * * * 5. Consideration of the request of Amy Sherrill for rezoning from CA General Business to RB General Residential was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 7420 Ledgerwood Road, Parcel ID 028ME026. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-D-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Michael Smith, representing Amy Sherrill, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Commissioner Oster asked if there was any opposition to the request. There was no response. Commissioner Lee moved to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-105 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Amy Sherrill for rezoning from CA General Business to RB General Residential with the following condition: developer to build sidewalks along their frontage and signs/markings necessary to facilitate a safe pedestrian crossing. Commissioner Frazier seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay and Frazier voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. Property located at 7420 Ledgerwood Road, Parcel ID 028ME026. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-D-25-RZ) * * * * * * 6. Consideration of the request of Benjamin C. Mullins for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 12 dwelling units per acre was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 2520 West Beaver Creek Drive, Parcel ID 067 057. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-I-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Benjamin Mullins, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Commissioner Oster asked if there was any opposition to the request. There was no response. Commissioner Lee moved to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-106 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Benjamin C. Mullins for rezoning from A Agricultural to PR Planned Residential up to 12 dwelling units per acre subject to the following conditions: 1) They can do up to 14 permits for this parcel or they can build a no left turn lane, whichever comes first; and 2) replanting 5 trees per acre with at least half of them being shade trees. Commissioner Hill seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay and Frazier voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. Property located at 2520 West Beaver Creek Drive, Parcel ID 067 057. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-I-25-RZ) * * * * * * 7. Consideration of the request of Adrian Perju for rezoning from A Agricultural to RA Low Density Residential was before the Board of Commissioners. Property located at 0 Sharp Road, Parcel ID 056FE030. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-J-25-RZ) Mr. Mike Moyers, Knox County Senior Deputy Law Director, was present and swore in those who were to testify in the matter. Ms. Amy Brooks, Executive Director for Knoxville-Knox County Planning, was present and spoke on the matter. Mr. Adrian Perju, applicant, was present and spoke on behalf of the request. Mr. Jim Snowden, Director for Knox County Engineering and Public Works, was present and spoke on the matter. Commissioner Oster asked if there was any opposition to the request. There was no response. Commissioner Lee moved to approve Resolution RZ-25-3-107 - Resolution of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, approving the request of Adrian Perju for rezoning from A Agricultural to RA Low Density Residential as per Planning Commission’s recommendation. Commissioner Thompson seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Rawls, Durrett, Oster, Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay and Frazier voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. Property located at 0 Sharp Road, Parcel ID 056FE030. (7th Commission District) (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-J-25-RZ) * * * * * * IN RE: AMENDMENT TO THE AGENDA: 1. At this time, Mr. Benjamin Mullins, addressed the commission regarding his rezoning request Resolution RZ-25-3-106 (Planning Commission’s file number: 2-J-25-RZ) which was heard earlier at the meeting. (See Page ______) No additional action was taken. * * * * * * IN RE: ZONING APPEALS: No Zoning Appeals received. * * * * * * IN RE: AMENDMENTS TO THE KNOX COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE: IN RE: CONSIDERATION OF AN ORDINANCE OF THE COMMISSION OF KNOX COUNTY, TENNESSEE, AMENDING THE KNOX COUNTY CODE, APPENDIX A – ZONING, ARTICLES 2.20, 4.91, 5.11, 5.12, 5.13, 5.22, 5.31, 5.32, 5.33, 5.34, 5.36, 5.37, 5.38, 5.40, 5.41, 5.42, 5.50 AND 5.51 TO ALIGN ZONING REGULATIONS WITH DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (DHS) LICENSURE RULES FOR CHILD CARE AGENCIES AND TO STREAMLINE THE PROVISION OF CHILD CARE SERVICES (AMENDING ORDINANCE O-90-9-130, ADOPTED SEPTEMBER 10, 1990) – O-25-3-101 - (FIRST READING): Consideration of an Ordinance of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, amending the Knox County Code, Appendix A – Zoning, Articles 2.20, 4.91, 5.11, 5.12, 5.13, 5.22, 5.31, 5.32, 5.33, 5.34, 5.36, 5.37, 5.38, 5.40, 5.41, 5.42, 5.50 and 5.51 to align zoning regulations with Department of Human Services (DHS) licensure rules for child care agencies and to streamline the provision of child care services (amending Ordinance O-90-9-130, adopted September 10, 1990) was before the Board of Commissioners on first reading. Commissioner Frazier moved to approve Ordinance O-25-3-101 - Ordinance of the Commission of Knox County, Tennessee, amending the Knox County Code, Appendix A – Zoning, Articles 2.20, 4.91, 5.11, 5.12, 5.13, 5.22, 5.31, 5.32, 5.33, 5.34, 5.36, 5.37, 5.38, 5.40, 5.41, 5.42, 5.50 and 5.51 to align zoning regulations with Department of Human Services (DHS) licensure rules for child care agencies and to streamline the provision of child care services (amending Ordinance O-90-9-130, adopted September 10, 1990) on first reading. Commissioner Jackson seconded the motion and upon roll call vote Commissioners Jackson, Russell, Hill, Lee, Thompson, Fox, Jay, Frazier, Rawls, Durrett and Oster voted aye. The motion carried 11-0-0-0. * * * * * * IN RE: PUBLIC FORUM – OPEN TOPICS: No one requested to speak. * * * * * * IN RE: OTHER BUSINESS: No other business received. * * * * * * IN RE: ADJOURNMENT: There being no other business to come before the Knox County Board of Commissioners, Commissioner Oster declared the meeting adjourned. * * * * * * KNOX COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS ____________________________________________ GINA OSTER, MADAM CHAIR

Source: Knox County website. First collected Oct 7, 2026.