CHZC Meeting Minutes - February 2025
City of Chattanooga · Hamilton County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Chattanooga
This document is no longer listed on City of Chattanooga's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CHATTANOOGA HISTORIC ZONING COMMISSION
MEETING MINUTES
February 20th, 2025
The duly advertised meeting of the Chattanooga Historic Zoning Commission was held on February 20th,
2025,
at
9:30
a.m.
in
conference
room
1A
of
the
Development
Resource
Center
Building.
Chairman Skip Pond called the meeting to order at 9:31 A.M.
Roll Call: Admin Support Shelby Ogle called the roll.
Member Attendance: Clif McCormick Piper Stromatt Brandon Panganiban Todd Morgan John Cavett John Brennan Nathan Bird Matt McDonald Skip Pond
Staff Attendance: Presenter: Cassie Cline Admin: Shelby Ogle Admin: Karen Murphy Cannon City Attorney: Andrew Trundle City Attorney: Chris McKnight
Swearing In: Admin Support Shelby Ogle swore in people addressing the Committee.
Rules and Regulations: Chairman Skip Pond explained the rules and procedures, order of business, and
announced
the
meeting
is
being
recorded.
Approve Minutes: Chairman Skip Pond presented the January 16th, 2025 Meeting Minutes to be voted on. No
amendments
need
to
be
made.
Matt
McDonald
motioned
to
APPROVE
the
January
minutes.
Piper
Stromatt
seconded
the
motion.
All in favor . The motion carries 7-0.
1
Staff Review Cases: Historic Preservation Planner Cassie Cline presented the Staff Review cases to the
Commission.
- HZ-25-3: 5416 St. Elmo Ave.: COA Renewal - HZ-25-5: 4705 St. Elmo Ave.: Exterior Rehabilitation - HZ-25-7: 4626 St. Elmo Ave.: Siding Replacement - HZ-25-8: 101 Morningside Dr.: Fence
OLD BUSINESS
- HZ-24-128: 4705 St. Elmo Ave.: Front Porch, Windows + Parking
Staff Presentation: Historic Preservation Planner Cassie Cline presented the report to the Commission.
Relevant Guidelines Covered : 6.9 Driveways + Paving, Page 41 6.25 Porches, Porch Columns and Railings, Page 59 6.41 Windows, Page 74
Applicant Presentation: Applicant Matthew Lewis presented to the Commission that they are planning to
keep
the
windows
at
the
front
of
the
house,
but
the
rest
of
the
windows
need
to
be
replaced.
He
stated
that
they
are
all
different
materials
and
not
historic
in
nature.
He
said
that
he
wants
the
windows
to
be
consistent
throughout
the
house
and
he
would
prefer
to
have
1
over
1
windows
throughout.
The
Applicant
then
spoke
about
the
proposed
changes
to
the
front
porch.
He
stated
that
the
porch
would
be
8ft
in
depth
at
the
front
and
5ft
in
depth
at
the
side.
He
presented
that
they
would
use
tongue
in
groove
and
that
it
would
run
perpendicular
to
the
house.
He
stated
that
they
would
propose
to
use
round
columns
similar
to
a
neighboring
house
and
that
the
railings
will
be
36in
high.
He
stated
that
the
front
stairs
would
be
wood
to
match
the
porch.
He
then
presented
that
the
proposed
driveway
would
be
a
pea
gravel
concrete
and
they
would
like
to
put
it
in
the
front
yard
as
opposed
to
the
back.
Community Response: The following was a public comment that was emailed and presented to the
Commission:
“Cassie, Thanks again for sending the agenda and case information out. I am working Early Voting and will
have
to
be
there
Thursday
and
therefore
can't
make
the
HZ
meeting.
Comments
on
a
couple
of
cases
are
below.
Thanks.
CASE HZ-24-128 4705 St. Elmo Avenue
Section 6.9 of the Guidelines states that parking areas should be in the rear of the house and there is
access
to
the
property
from
the
rear.
As
I
recall,
there
is
an
alley
behind
these
houses
in
the
4700
block.
The
addition
of
a
driveway
on
the
front
seems
to
be
in
conflict
with
the
Guidelines.
Backing
out
into
St.
Elmo
Avenue
seems
to
me
to
be
a
traffic
hazard
but
that
possibility
is
not
within
the
purview
of
the
HZ
Commission.
The present windows look good to me. I have passed this house many, many times over the last
70-plus
years
and
I
am
glad
to
see
the
windows
preserved.
TIM MCDONALD SUNNYSIDE AVENUE”
2
Discussion: The Commission began their discussion by questioning Staff about the existing windows and if
they
were
damaged
beyond
repair,
to
which
Staff
responded
that
they
were
not.
The
Applicant
confirmed
that
he
wanted
to
remove
the
windows
that
were
not
historic
and
place
windows
that
matched
the
rest
of
the
first
floor
of
the
home.
The
Commission
then
discussed
the
bay
windows
and
that
they
should
remain
since
they
are
historic
windows
to
the
home.
The
Commission
then
discussed
the
request
for
the
driveway
to
be
in
the
front
of
the
house
instead
of
off
the
alley.
They
stated
that
the
access
to
the
alley
should
be
prioritized
over
making
a
new
curb
cut
and
having
the
driveway
off
of
St
Elmo
Ave.
The
Commission
then
discussed
how
they
would
need
to
see
a
rendering
of
the
front
porch
for
review
and
it
was
recommended
that
the
Applicant
defer
another
month
to
allow
time
for
the
Applicant
to
supply
that.
Commission Motion and Vote:
- Piper Stromatt made a motion to APPROVE the window and driveway requests for case #: HZ-24-128:
4705
St.
Elmo
Ave.,
with
the
following
conditions:
- Bay window to remain as is. - 2/2 windows to be replaced with 1/1 sashes. - Front windows on the front facade and door to remain. - Windows to remain on site. - Replacement parts are to consist of sashes only. - Concrete pad off alley. and DEFER the front porch request to the March 2025 meeting.
Matt McDonald seconded the motion.
All in favor.
The motion carries 7-0.
NEW BUSINESS
- HZ-24-13: 5410 St. Elmo Ave.: Correction Notice, Exterior Rehabilitation
Staff Presentation: Historic Preservation Planner Cassie Cline presented the report to the Commission.
Relevant Guidelines Covered : 6.6 Decks, Page 38 6.9 Driveways + Paving, Page 41 6.11 Fences, Page 43 6.13 Foundations, Page 45 6.33 Siding, Page 70 6.41 Windows, Page 74
Applicant Presentation: Applicant Daryl Smith presented to the Commission that they did do work that was
outside
of
the
scope
of
what
was
previously
approved
by
the
Commission.
He
stated
that
they
did
not
know
the
extent
of
the
deterioration
of
the
home
prior
to
submitting
for
their
original
Certificate
of
Appropriateness.
The
Applicant
then
spoke
to
all
the
work
they
completed
on
the
back
porch
as
well
as
the
exterior
of
the
home.
Community Response: The following was emailed comments that were presented to the Commission: “To the Historic Zoning Committee:
My name is Alexandra Frank, and I am a Chattanooga and St. Elmo resident. I have personally seen
our
neighborhood
transform
over
the
last
year
because
of
the
tireless
and
dedicated
work
of
individuals
committed
to
restoring
our
community.
3
5410 St. Elmo Avenue is one such example. Over the course of the renovation, 5410 St. Elmo Avenue
transformed
from
a
dilapidated
eyesore
(with
zero
seeming
historical
significance)
to
a
charming
and
meticulous
reminder
that
all
things
can
be
made
new.
Renovations
such
as
the
one
that
occurred
on
5410
St.
Elmo
Avenue
should
be
met
with
enthusiasm
and
pride...
not
correction
notices.
If
the
historic
zoning
committee
is
truly
vested
in
maintaining
historic
districts,
they
should
welcome
and
encourage
renovation
efforts,
such
as
the
one
that
occurred
at
5410
St.
Elmo.
My
reading
of
the
current
guidelines
prioritizes
preservation
of
historical
value
to
improve
the
neighborhood.
5410
St.
Elmo
Avenue
is
a
wonderful
example
of
a
renovation
effort
that
uncovered
historical
value
in
a
property
that
was
not
offering
anything
to
improve
the
neighborhood.
Through
the
careful
efforts
of
the
renovators,
5410
St.
Elmo
Avenue
now
exudes
the
historical
value
the
committee
seeks
to
maintain.
Correction notices, such as this one, discourage renovation and penalize individuals who seek to go
through
the
appropriate
channels.
One
need
only
walk
through
the
neighborhood
to
see
the
dozens
of
properties
that
would
benefit
from
the
care
and
attention
bestowed
upon
5410
St.
Elmo
Avenue.
Yet,
the
committee
is
actively
discouraging
those
efforts
through
tenuous
correction
notices
such
as
this
one.
It is my sincere wish for this correction notice to be dismissed. The historic zoning committee should
see
renovations,
such
as
the
one
completed
at
5410
St.
Elmo
Avenue,
as
vital
allies
in
their
mission
to
preserve,
maintain,
and
improve
historic
neighborhoods.
Thank you for your consideration.
Alexandra”
Discussion: The Commission began their discussion by stating that the only real issue is that they went
outside
of
the
approved
scope
of
work
and
they
applauded
the
Applicant
for
the
work
that
they
have
done.
Commission Motion and Vote:
- Nathan Bird made a motion to APPROVE case #: HZ-24-13: 5410 St. Elmo Ave.
Todd Morgan seconded the motion.
All in favor.
The motion carries 7-0.
- HZ-25-4: 1614 W. 55th St.: Shed
Staff Presentation: Historic Preservation Planner Cassie Cline presented the report to the Commission.
Relevant Guidelines Covered : 6.22.C New Construction, Page 52
Applicant Presentation: Applicant James Currie presented to the Commission that the shed is prefabbed
and
will
be
on
a
block
foundation.
He
then
stated
that
the
shed
would
be
made
out
of
metal.
Community Response: The following was emailed comments that were presented to the Commission: “Cassie,
Thanks again for sending the agenda and case information out. I am working Early Voting and will
have
to
be
there
Thursday
and
therefore
can't
make
the
HZ
meeting.
Comments
on
a
couple
of
cases
are
below.
Thanks.
CASE HZ-25-4 1614 West 55th Street
4
I am usually concerned about the building of sheds in the Historic District of St Elmo, but this design
seems
to
resemble
the
primary
house
on
site
and
if
not
visible
from
a
right-of-way,
does
not
seem
to
be
in
conflict
with
the
neighborhood.
My
property
is
several
blocks
away,
however,
and
the
immediate
neighbors
may
have
other
comments.
TIM MCDONALD SUNNYSIDE AVENUE”
Discussion: The Commission began the discussion by asking the Applicant if they plan to make the shed
match
the
house
and
they
stated
that
they
do.
Staff
pointed
out
that
in
the
historic
guideline
update,
a
request
like
this
would
be
able
to
be
staff
approved.
Commission Motion and Vote:
- Brandon Panganiban made a motion to APPROVE case #: HZ-25-4: 1614 W. 55th St. .
Nathan Bird seconded the motion.
All in favor.
The motion carries 7-0.
- HZ-25-6: 4415 Seneca Ave.: Addition + Fence
Staff Presentation: Historic Preservation Planner Cassie Cline presented the report to the Commission.
Relevant Guidelines Covered : 6.1 Additions, Page 33 6.11 Fences, Page 43
Applicant Presentation: Applicant Bradley Neuroth presented to the Commission that they are wanting to
put
an
addition
on
the
house
across
the
back.
The
Applicant
stated
that
they
were
unaware
that
a
Certificate
of
Appropriateness
was
not
received
for
the
front
fence
and
stated
that
they
are
willing
to
do
whatever
needs
to
be
done
to
be
considered
in
compliance
with
the
requirements.
The
Applicant
also
stated
that
they
plan
to
reuse
all
existing
openings
and
will
repurpose
the
windows
and
doors
into
the
addition.
Community Response: No community comments.
Discussion: The Commission began their discussion by asking about the roofline of the addition and how it
will
line
up
with
the
rest
of
the
roof,
to
which
the
Applicant
stated
that
given
the
pitch
that
the
roof
for
the
addition
needs
to
be;
the
new
roof
will
be
slightly
higher
than
the
existing
roof
to
allow
for
proper
drainage
and
head
space.
The
Commission
then
asked
the
Applicant
questions
about
the
scope
of
the
project
including
questions
about
the
siding
and
the
front
door.
The
Commission
then
discussed
the
fence
issue
and
its
not
being
in
compliance
with
the
requirements
and
also
about
how
it
was
noncompliant
when
the
Applicant
bought
the
property.
Commission Motion and Vote:
- Piper Stromatt made a motion to APPROVE case #: HZ-25-6: 4415 Seneca Ave., with the following
conditions:
- Aluminum siding to be removed and repaired. - Addition siding to be hardie lap siding with transition at addition transition. - Board and batten to remain on foundation. - Front facade approved as submitted in material list. - Windows to be reused on addition. - Fence on front to be modified by swagging or lowered by 1’ 0” by owner discretion.
5
Nathan Bird seconded the motion.
All in favor.
The motion carries 7-0.
Other Business
Next Meeting Date: March 20, 2025 (Application Deadline, February 21, 2025 by 4 p.m.)
Historic Guidelines Update: Staff updated the Commission on the historic guidelines update and stated
that
they
are
currently
out
for
public
review
and
comment
until
March
4th.
Staff
then
asked
the
Commission
to
tell
their
communities
about
using
the
Google
Form
for
any
comments.
Staff
also
informed
the
Commission
that
there
have
been
some
districts
that
want
to
be
historic
conservation
districts
and
that
designation
would
only
govern
new
construction,
additions,
and
demolitions.
Nathan Bird motioned to adjourn the meeting. Todd Morgan seconded the motion. All in favor.
Meeting was adjourned at 10:57 a.m..
____________________________________ _________________________ Clif McCormick, Vice-Chairman Date
____________________________________ _________________________ Admin Assistant Date
6
3/21/2025
Source: City of Chattanooga website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.