_06252026-768
Williamson County · Williamson County · meeting of Jun 25, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Williamson County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Minutes
Williamson County
Board of Zoning Appeals
6:00 P.M. June 25, 2026
Members Present Staff Present
Don Crohan, Chairman John Bledsoe, Codes Compliance Director
Andrew Ring, Vice -Chairman Aaron Holmes, Planning Director
Karen Emerson-McPeak, Secretary Kristi Ransom, County Attorney
Matthew Roberts Floyd Heflin, Engineering Director
Jeff McCoy
Kim Waggoner
The Williamson County Board of Zoning Appeals met in regular session on June 25, 2026 in the Executive
Conference Room of the Williamson County Administrative Complex. Chairman Don Crohan began the meeting by
reading a public statement stating that the Board of Zoning Appeals is made up of five citizens nominated as Board
members by the Co unty Mayor and confirmed by the County Commission. One member is a Planning
Commissioner, one member may be a County Commissioner, and the remaining members are not otherwise
connected with County Government. He went on to say the Board will hear from anyone who has anything to say to
the Board relevant to the request at hand. However, the Board will not view or hear anything that does not have a
direct bearing on the item or issue being heard. He requested that all comments be addressed to the Board.
Chairman Crohan asked the members to consider the minutes from the May 28 , 2026 meeting. Vice
Chairman Andrew Ring made the motion to approve the minutes of the May 28, 2026 meeting as presented and
Matthew Roberts seconded the motion. The motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
OLD BUSINESS
ITEM 1
A REQUEST BY ROBERT RUSSELL FOR AN APPEAL OF STAFF’S DE TERMINATION THE
PROPERTY REFERENCED BY TAX MAP 159, PARCEL 01104, AND LOCATED ON BO LANE IS AN
ILLEGAL LOT OF RECORD AND THE DETERMINATION THAT THE REVIEW OF A LARGE LOT
EASEMENT SUBDIVISION IS REQUIRED, A VARIANCE FROM THE ACCESS AND PLATTING
REQUIREMENTS, AND OTHER VARIANCES, IF NEEDED. THE PROPERTY IS ZONED RURAL
DEVELOPMENT-5 (RD-5) AND IS LOCATED IN THE 5TH VOTING DISTRICT.
John Bedsoe reminded the Board that at last month’s hearing at the request of Staff this item was deferred
until the June meeting to give more time to review the informa tion provided. Since that time Robert Russell has
requested that this item be deferred until the August 2026 meeting. He sent the request after the agenda had been
advertised, so the Board must vote to accept his deferral.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring made a motion to accept the deferral until the August 2026 meeting. Secretary
Karen Emerson-McPeak second the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 1
ITEM 1
A request by James and Heidi Howerton (property owners), for a variance to allow the
construction of a swimming pool within the 100-year floodplain on the property listed as 6713
Flat Creek Road, College Grove, TN (Map 177 Parcel 03804). The property is zoned Rural
Development-5 (RD-5) and is located in the 2nd Voting District.
Jeff McCoy summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the property, the site plan and
photos of the property.
Mrs. Howerton stated when they purchased their farm in 2019, they imagined they were buying their long-
term home to raise their children and to have a place their grandchildren could visit. That would include a future
pool. When they purchased the house, they were given a certificate of elevation saying the home was not in a
floodplain. It came up just to the back of the house and some to the west of the house. They contacted FEMA to get
something showing they were not in the floodplain for the pool company. FEMA said the area had been amended
and the flood certificate said the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) was 714’ and is now 714.6’. It has increased to include
almost all of the property. They wouldn’t have purchased the property if they had known this in the beginning. They
will have a hydraulic study done to show they will not change the floodplain if the variance is granted.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing. Seeing no one to speak, the public hearing was closed.
Matthew Roberts asked the applicant, even though the elevation changed, the proposed location was always
going to be in the floodplain, correct?
Mrs. Howerton said yes, they had hoped to put the pool in the area to the left of the house, but now the
floodplain is included there as well. They are asking for a variance to put the pool in the backyard for the safety of
their children so they can see them clearly.
Chairman Crohan said the existing elevation certificate does not show the house in the floodplain when you
bought the house.
Mrs. Howerton said the house was not in floodplain when they bought the house. She stated they knew that
part of the backyard was in the floodplain when they purchased the home. The original flood map shows it touching
the back right corner of the porch. The elevation certificate made them think this home was not in the floodplain,
and they thought they could build the swimming pool out of the floodplain to the right of the house.
Chairman Crohan said the amendment from FEMA shows a six-inch difference.
Mrs. Howerton advised that they have now been required to purchase flood insurance.
County Engineer Floyd Heflin stated the Howerton’s contacted him when they received the letter requiring
them to carry flood insurance. This was a limited detail study, and when the house was built, they used this graphic
depiction to show that it was out of the floodplain. Now they have more detailed LiDAR topography . The cross
sections show it is more impacted than what the FEMA map shows.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 2
Mr. Heflin recommended that they submit to FEMA for a letter of map amendment to get an elevation
certificate. If you can show the lowest adjacent grade is above flood elevation, and the lower floor is above they will
write a letter saying there is flood plain on the property , but the structure is out. They reassessed the base flood
elevation so the lowest adjacent grade according to FEMA is below the flood elevation. They would not give them
the exemption for the flood insurance requirement.
Chairman Crohan said that he was concerned an inground pool would change the floodplain on this property
and how this would affect the properties downstream.
Mr. Heflin said the hydraulic study would address that. The FEMA regulations do not restrict or prohibit the
construction of a pool in the floodplain because they do not insure it, but with any encroachments they want to know
that it will not have any adverse effects on adjacent properties. Even if the Board grants this variance, they will have
their Engineer do a study to show it doesn’t increase flood elevations by no more than a foot.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring made a motion to approve the request for variance in accordance with Section
19.05(B)(2) and Section 5.02 with the condition that the homeowners submit a hydraulic study to guarantee they do
not adversely affect the floodplain.
Matthew Roberts seconded the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 2
A request by Lee Schumann for a rear setback variance at 2234 Dominick Drive (Map 058B
Group D Parcel 02100). The property is zoned Municipal Growth Area-1 (MGA-1) and is
located in the 5th Voting District.
John Bledsoe summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the property, the site plan and
photos of the property.
Lee Schumann said the hardship here is the corner lot and the configuration of it. Most of the neighbors in the
subdivision can increase the value of their homes and have a n outdoor living space. The way this lot is shaped
inhibits improvements. The 30-foot setback comes to their house. They have the support of three neighbors.
Seth Kruse (contractor) stated they would be increasing the property values in the neighborhood by building
the cover over the existing patio.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing. Seeing no one to speak, the public hearing was closed.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked if the concrete slab was existing.
Mr. Kruse replied yes.
Mr. Schumann said that a roof would help with shade and the water going into my back door.
Secretary Emerson-McPeak asked if the house was at the rear setback area?
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 3
Mr. Bledsoe replied it is at the rear setback.
Mr. Kruse advised that since it’s the corner lot, that is the way they had to set the house.
Mr. Schumann said that the only area to build is in a setback, and they do not have another option.
Matthew Roberts made a motion to approve the variance due to the circumstances of the lot allowing the 17-
foot encroachment of the rear setback.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring second the motion.
The motion received a vote of two in favor and two opposed. Vice Chairman Ring and Mr. Roberts voted
yes.
Secretary Emerson-McPeak and Chairman Crohan voted no. The motion failed for lack of a majority vote;
and therefore the variance request was denied.
ITEM 3
A request by Debbie Chadwick of the Rochelle Center (Orrin Ingram and The Land Trust
for Tennessee, property owners) f or approval of a Special Event – Extensive Impact
(Chukkers for Charity) at 1475 Moran Road (Map 026 Parcel 022.00). The property is zoned
Rural Preservation 5 (RP-5) and is located in the 9th Voting District.
Jeff McCoy summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the property, the site plan and
photos of the property.
Debbie Chadwick said they have come before the Board for the last thirteen to fourteen years since the
Extensive Impact permit was required. They always try to meet or exceed the requirements. They use off duty police
officers to maintain the level of safety that their Charity and Williamson County expect.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing. Seeing no one to speak, the public hearing was closed.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked if they had changed anything.
Mrs. Chadwick replied there are no changes, noting that everything seems to work well as is.
Mrs. Emerson-McPeak asked if they were prepared for rain or a heat wave.
Mrs. Chadwick replied that they were prepared, noting that they have experienced all those things in the
past. The Charity Board hires off duty police offices and emergency medical technicians to be on the property.
Some of the children and adults have disabilities, so they try to be overly prepared.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring made a motion to approve the Special Use under Section 11.05(D)(7).
Secretary Emerson-McPeak seconded the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 4
ITEM 4
A request by T-Square Engineering on behalf of property owner 4655 Development LLC for
a variance request from the Williamson County Zoning Ordinance Article 14 Section
14.03(B)(1) (Required Areas to be Placed in Open Space), a variance from Article 14 Section
14.04 (Design Standards for Open Space Set -Asides), a variance from Article 12 Section
12.04(E)(4)(b) (Open Space Requirements) and a variance from Article 13 Section 1303(B)(5)
(Steep Topography and Slippage Soil Protection Standards) to allow for the construction of
an 11 lot Major Conservation Subdivision. The property is located at 4655 Harpeth -
Peytonsville Road (Map 144, Parcel 07001, Map 155 Parcels 01501, 01502, 01503, 01504). The
property is zoned Rural Development-5 (RD-5) and is located in the 2nd Voting District
John Bledsoe summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the property, the site plan and
photos of the property.
Allison Corolla with T-Square Engineering, on behalf of the applicant, stated most of these variances are due
to the existing conditions. The parcel 15.02 has three variances located on that lot. This home was built in 2008 and
is incorporated into the development to provide additional access to the private right-of-way rather than the access
that currently serves the property. The stream buffer as well as all the steep slopes are proposed to be preserved
entirely. The steep slopes analysis plan on the property shows that the steep topography bisects the property. There
is no way to gain access to the rear of the property without transgressing all the steep slopes. They are proposing a
location where the crossing will be a minimum, also crossing the stream at a ninety-degree angle as required by
engineering regulations. The existing driveway on Lot 1 will not be disturbed. They are not proposing a new
driveway or tree removal in that area.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing.
County Commissioner Judy Herbert said that the Planning Department does an excellent job in their
regulations to balance property rights and neighbor’s concern. She understands allowing one variance, but this
property has seven variances. This piece of property is not suited for that many homes and she asked the Board to
deny these variances.
County Commissioner Betsy Hester said that she also represents the 2nd District. It appears this property has
many challenges with the multiple variances that have been requested , including the drainage. She stated her
concern about the steep topography and the variance from the slippage soil protection. How will it affect the people
downstream from this property? They will have to connect to Fairhaven for their sewage system. She asked that this
be denied.
Richard Sack is the property owner for 4659 Harpeth Peytonsville Road, and his property is on the site
map next to the stream. He was never consulted about any of these plans. He did not get anything in the mail
because his property was part of the plan. He said he found the plan to be unethical.
Attorney Kristi Ransom asked Mr. Sack to clarify which property was his.
Mr. Sack pointed out his property.
Attorney Ransom asked the applicant to confirm that at least five of the variances they are requesting are
located on Mr. Sack’s property, noting that he has not consented to this request.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 5
Applicant Huntly Gordon said those variances exist on the property and they are including that lot in the
subdivision because they have to incorporate what exists. But because it is included in the subdivision, it is an
existing condition that requires the Board’s approval to include that lot.
Attorney Ransom replied that they do not have the authority under the Zoning Ordinance to request a
variance on Mr. Sack’s behalf. He has not asked for those variances. Mrs. Ransom stated that the Zoning Ordinance
did not give the Board authority to take action on the variances located on Mr. Sack’s property.
Huntly Gordon said that property is included for one reason, and that is at the staff’s request.
Attorney Ra nsom said she understands, but the Zoning Ordinance says who has the authority to file
applications and Mr. Sack has not authorized this application. The variances on his property are not properly before
this Board to take action on. They can take action on the variance request on the remaining property, but not Mr.
Sack’s. She suggested it may be best to request a deferral until this is figured out.
The applicant requested a deferral.
The public hearing continued with Beth Newman that lives at 4665 Harpeth Peytonsville Road, in front of
this development. She was very concerned about the water runoff from this possible development. There have been
several houses built right down the road. And after the clearing a lot of trees she believes the creek behind her house
will now flood the pasture when it rains and they will have to rescue their animals. Her concern is flooding and
erosion.
Doug Sadler lives at 4650 Gander Branch Road. Since the 2010 flood, more single-family homes have been
built. They have a bridge over the creek with no sides and every time there is heavy rain, they cannot leave their
property. He stated it seems to be getting worse every year. The erosion from upstream fills the creek with muddy
water every time it rains. The development on Lewisburg Pike across from Harpeth Peytonsville Road is going to
cause water issues too. It’s not just upstream but also downstream affected by the developments, that is what they
are asking the Board to consider now to avoid more flooding issues.
Attorney Ransom informed Chairman Crohan that in his action to grant the deferral the Board may also wish
to continue the public hearing rather than close it in case the plans change, so that people have the opportunity to
comment on whatever changes are made to their plan.
Chairman Crohan said it would be his suggestion that they continue the public hearing.
Vice Chairman Ring made a motion to defer this item to the next meeting and to continue the public hearing.
Matthew Roberts seconded the motion. Motion was approved for deferral and to keep the public hearing
open by unanimous voice vote.
ITEM 5
A request by Kent Johnson for a rear setback variance at 2209 Bowman Road (Map 105D,
Group D, Parcel 01200). The property is zoned Neighborhood Conservation (NC) and is
located in the 11th Voting District.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 6
Jeff McCoy summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the property, the site plan and
photos of the property.
Property owner Kent Johnson and contractor Adam Stern were present to represent the request. Mr. Johnson
said he did not have anything to add to staff’s presentation.
Mr. Stern said that from his understanding of codes, this house established the rear setbacks for the entire
subdivision, and it has the smallest backyard of the subdivision. They are asking for a variance for this property,
because there is not enough room to place the garage at the back of the house. They will have a 3-car garage, and it
will have a man cave. It will be appealing to the community and will make the area more useable as they cannot get
a pickup in the existing garage.
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing. Seeing no one to speak, the public hearing was closed.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked if the garage could be moved to the front of the house?
Mr. Stern replied if they did that, it would eliminate use of the existing garage. They have moved it back so
they can still use one of the two existing garage bays with the new structure. It would extend behind the house 12
feet.
Mrs. Emerson-McPeak asked the staff if a garage could be moved to the front?
Planning Director Aaron Homes replied that it cannot.
Mr. Johnson noted that their septic area is in the front yard.
Matthew Roberts asked what was the TVA easement that was being referred to on the plans.
Mr. Johnson said the TVA lines that are there are well within that easement. They have a letter from
TVA saying they can do this because they are not under these lines.
Mr. Roberts asked if the TVA lines run over Castlewood Drive.
Mr. Johnson replied that is correct.
Chairman Crohan asked the applicant if he intends to build a two-car garage.
Mr. Johnson responded that was correct and that there will be no living space above, just the garage.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring made a motion to approve the 15-foot variance to Article 10, Section 10.02
(L)(1)(2) and Section 5.02 (F) due to the irregular shape of the corner lot.
Matthew Roberts second the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 7
ITEM 6
A request by Nathan McVey of T-Square Engineering (Charles Crews, Property Owner)
for a Special Use to allow a Private Landing Strip and a variance for a disturbance o f
steep slopes. The properties are located at 5600 Boy Scout Road (Map 74, Parcels 1.02,
1.03, 1.04, 1.05, 1.06, 1.07 and 1.08, Map 94, Parcel 33.02, and Map 95, Parcel 18.03), are
zoned Rural Preservation-5 (RP-5) and located in the 1st Voting District.
Aaron Holmes (Planning Director) summarized the Staff Report with a PowerPoint presentation on the
property, the site plan and photos of the property.
Nathan McVey with T-Square Engineering advised that the owner, Charles Crews, was present and is a pilot.
They have an existing grass airfield strip behind the home on Boy Scout Rd. He wishes to make it a n all-season
surface and move it up the hill to give him better clearance. The present airfield will not be used and will go back to
a hay field after the new runway is built. The 3000-foot runway has some slopes in the area. Pinewood Road
naturally has some hilltops and ridges, and they will do their best to thread the hilltops . They concur with the
conditions in the staff report
Chairman Crohan opened the public hearing.
Rebecca Stanley lives at 5815 Old Hwy 96, which backs up to Charles Crews. She stated she does not oppose
this request if it’s used for Mr. Crews only, and it’s not a field for other s to use. She was concerned about fuel
storage and any effects on spring water and neighbor’s wells.
Secretary Karen Emerson-McPeak asked staff to identify the steep slopes on the map.
Mr. Holmes identified the areas of the steep slopes that would be disturbed.
Chairman Crohan asked what type of lighting would be used and when.
Charles Crews replied there would be no specific hours of use. The use of the lighting would be extremely
minimal. Currently they are not using the existing runway at night. They would like to add lighting to the new
runway for night use.
Chairman Crohan said his concern was a plane coming in all hours of the night, the lights would be
disturbing to the neighbors. They would like to know some kind of time frame of use.
Mr. Holmes noted that when this is presented to the Planning Commission a photometric plan will be
required.
Chairman Crohan said another concern is the fuel and how that will be monitored.
Mr. Crews said that they would have special tanks like those located on the landfill next door.
Vice Chairman Andrew Ring made a motion to approve the Special Use in accordance with Section 5.01 and
Section 11.04 (D)(16) of the Zoning Ordinance with the fol lowing stipulations, the recording of a deed
consolidating the nine (9) properties , execution of a Stormwater Maintenance Agreement and submission of an
Operation and Maintenance Plan for stormwater improvements, submittal to and approval by the County Engineer
of both the stormwater calculations and the grading and drainage plan , and all signage must be approved per
Ordinance requirements along with the lightening. Also, approval for the variance for the disturbance of the slopes.
Matthew Roberts second the motion. Motion was approved by unanimous voice vote.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 8
ITEM 6
General Public Comment
No citizens were present to speak.
With no other business to come before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at approximately 7:40 P.M.
__________________________
Secretary’s Signature
___________________________
Date
.
Board of Zoning Appeals Minutes June 25, 2026 Page 9
Source: Williamson County website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.