RecordWell Data

_03052026-539

City of Hendersonville · Sumner County · meeting of Mar 5, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Hendersonville

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HENDERSONVILLE SPECIAL CALLED BEER BOARD HEARING 03/05/2026 5:00 pm CONFERENCE ROOM 2 Present: Larry Farina, Rick Fox, Michael Krasnow, Timothy Manion, Dave Moomy, and David Pigna Absent: Andy Kaczmarek and Terri Goodwin Others Present: Tamara Ingersoll - City of Hendersonville, Lance Wray- City Attorney, Gabrielle Alvarado - City of Hendersonville, Russ Edwards - City Judge, Natasha Tice - City of Hendersonville, Almurad Abdulla - Exxon food & Fuel, Lawren Lassiter -Attorn~y for Abdulla, Thomas Holman - Hendersonville Police Department, Christopher Odom - Hendersonville Police Department, and Joshua Lackey - Hendersonville Police Department I. Called to order by Rick Fox at 5:03 pm II. Acceptance of March 5, 2026, Special Called Beer Board Hearing Agenda Motion: Timothy Manion Second: Michael Krasnow No discussion Vote: Unanimous Ill. Public Comments None IV. Alcohol Compliance Check Hearings 1. Exxon Food and Fuel 1082 West Main Street Hendersonville, TN 37075 Discussion: Rick and Judge Edwards explained the rules and procedures for the hearing. Judge Edwards swore in everyone who would be testifying . Questioning began with Mr. Wray and Mr. Holman. Mr. Holman explained that he is a Detective Sargeant with HPD on the evening shifts. He supervises a team of 7-8 detectives . One of his secondary responsibilities is oversight of alcohol compliance stings. This entails receiving funding from the Drug & Alcohol Coalition . The next step is utilizing an individual between 18-20 years old, and registering them as a confidential informant . After explaining the process, they will go with the Cl to markets or gas stations and request the Cl to attempt to purchase alcohol. If able to be purchased, the alcohol is immediately removed from the Cl. Mr Holman was present on 10/21/25 during the conduction of the compliance checks. He pulled up to the pump, and watched the Cl enter the store from his vehicle. Officer Odom, in plain clothes, followed the Cl in. The Cl was asked for, and provided, their underage ID, and was able to purchase and walk away with alcohol. The Cl that was used for this sting was 20 years old, as stated on her ID. This was Det. Holman's 3rd sting at this location, in the last 2 years, and they have failed 2 out ofthe 3. The Cl used for this sting was the same Cl used previously, but the clerk was a different clerk. Mr. Lassiter was given the chance to question Det. Holman, who explained that this sting began with the West end of town . They hit every gas station down Main St, then New Shackle, and then Indian Lake. There were 24 stores checked, and they did not include restaurants as this sting was for package stores and gas stations . Det Holman stated that he was familiar with the previous sting, but he cannot recall who the clerk was. He believes there was no ID presented or asked for at that time and that the clerk had stated they knew the Cl. Mr Holman did not recognize Mr. Abdulla from any of the stings and there have not been any additional stings since the one performed on 10/21/25 . 3 stores out of the 24 checked that day failed the alcohol compliance. Officer Christopher Odom was then called to testify . He explained that he works for the Hendersonville Police Department and was a part of the compliance checks being performed that day. His duties were to follow the Cl into the store while in plain clothes and to charge the clerk accordingly if he witnessed alcohol being sold to the Cl. This was officer Odom's first time meeting this Cl, and he didn't recall what the driver's license stated . He observed the Cl go into the alcohol section, grab an alcoholic drink and bring it to the counter where the alcohol & ID were scanned multiple times . The clerk looked at the Cl and allowed the sale to go through . Officer Odom stated he believed there was a beep when the ID was scanned. This was Officer Odom's first and only series of compliance checks that he has performed. He performed about half of the checks that day, as the officers alternated who went in and who stayed in their vehicle. He does not believe Mr. Abdulla to be the one who sold the alcohol, and he wrote the citation himself. Fayyaz Hussain was the clerk who was charged, but Officer Odom did not follow up to know that an order of expungement was enacted for the case. He stated that he has had about maybe 10 to 20 citations for sale to a minor but he has not followed up on any of them . He noted that the business did have many signs present stating ID was required and that they did not sell to minors. Officer Joshua Lackey was then called. He described how he accompanied Detective Sargent Holman and Officer Odom performing alcohol compliance checks on the night of 10/21/25. He was involved in about 12 or 13 of the checks. He was present during this check but remained back in the vehicle to radio dispatch and provide paperwork to officer Odom when needed. Next to testify was Mr. Almurad Abdulla, who explained that he is the owner of the store along with his daughter Aliyah Abdulla. His wife Rozina Charania handles the store, and he helps out with external things. Mrs. Charania is the one who attended the last alcohol compliance hearing. Mr. Abdulla is in the store about once a week, while Mrs. Charania is there 7 days a week, and their daughter is not involved in the operations. They have owned the store for almost 10 years, and have had a previous alcohol compliance failure about 5-6 years ago. Mr. Abdulla does not deny that alcohol was sold to someone who was underage. The business, and all of its employees are certified as responsible vendors. Fayyaz Hussain was not certified as a responsible vendor for that location until after the incident occurred . He was not a regular employee; he was only working there on a temporary basis for 3 days to cover the store while Mr. Abdulla and Mrs. Charania were out of town for their daughter's wedding. Mr. Hussain had previously owned his own store, and was familiar with selling alcoholic beverages. Mr. Abdulla works at another store, but this Exxon is the only one he owns. When a new worker is hired, he or his wife will stand with them for a few days and train them. They show them how to scan the ID, make sure the picture matches the person, and that they are over the age of 21. Gilbarco is the name of the POS system that they use that is provided by Exxon. The screen will say either accept or do not accept. Every employee is instructed to both scan and look at the ID. The business is a very small operation with only 3 employees. It wasn't known at the time but Mr. Hussain was suffering through some medical issues and that was why he was confused at the time of the incident. He had gotten hair plugs and did not inform Mr. Abdulla of this fact. Mr. Abdulla is very upset about this situation himself as he does not want to have alcohol sold to minors. He did not appear at the last hearing as he thought his wife would be able to explain the situation well enough on her own. Since the violation, there have not been any changes made other than to continue to remind the employees to check ID. He does not know what other changes he can make or what more he can do. He came himself this time to the hearing and did not send his wife because she can get very nervous. The sale of alcoholic beverages brings in about $2000 a month, so about $24,000 a year. His wife gets up at 3 AM daily and opens the store at 4 AM. They tried to find someone they trusted to replace his wife at the store while they were away. A video of the incident was shown. Mr. Abdulla stated that he is absolutely sorry that this incident occurred and it is so regrettable. Mr. Hussein had told Mr. Abdulla that he was certified as a responsible vendor at his store in Portland but had not shown proof of certification. Mr. Abdulla had asked him at church if he would be willing to help out for a few days and if knew everything to which he said he did and that he had run a store for years. Mr. Abdullah told Mr. Hussain to make sure to scan IDs and he knows that he did not have any intentions to sell to a minor, he was just confused due to medical issues. The other two workers at the store, one has been there for a year and the other maybe six months. Mr. Hussain is around 40 years old, owned his own store, and sold beer on a regular basis. An expungement would not have been possible if Mr. Hussain had ever been previously charged. Det. Sgt. Hollman was asked if there was any common denominator in the stores that failed and what he thought Mr. Abdullah could have done better. He replied that he liked that the store has it posted in multiple locations that ID will be checked and alcohol will not be sold to anyone under 21, but unfortunately there is a human element. The Responsible Vendor Training certificates are included as exhibit 1. Mr. Wray explained that permittees that are certified under the responsible vendor program are treated differently. As long as the certification is effective during the time of the violation and so long as the clerk making the sale has complied with the requirements of TCA 57-5-606, the most the Board can do is impose a civil penalty not to exceed $1,000 for each offense. If the certification does not apply then the board can suspend, or offer a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 in lieu of suspension. We do not know for a fact that Mr. Hussein was certified during this violation as required by TCA 57-5-606. We also do not know if Mr. Abdullah was certified at the time, as the certification that we have here is dated February 2026. Mr. Lassiter addressed the issue of employee certification, he noted that while no certificate was produced, testimony indicated Mr. Hussain represented that he was trained . He argued that Mr. Abdullah relied on that representation and believed Mr. Hussain understood applicable requirements . Mr. Abdullah exercised judgment in selecting an individual he believed to be qualified , including a person known through his church, and did not intentionally disregard the law. He asserted that the evidence supported a finding that Mr. Abdullah attempted to comply, even if those efforts were ultimately insufficient. He asked the Board to consider the testimony of Mr. Abdullah, describing him as honest, remorseful , and cooperative in appearing before the Board. He noted that Mr. Abdullah took steps following prior issues and was attempting to operate the business responsibly while managing personal obligations . Mr. Lassiter emphasized that the violation resulted from human error rather than intentional misconduct, stating that Mr. Abdullah did not intend to sell beer to a minor and was not regularly present at the store, relying on staff to follow the law. Mr. Lassiter argued that Mr. Abdullah demonstrated respect for the Board by appearing, retaining counsel, and presenting supporting information . He further stated that Mr. Abdullah made efforts to improve staffing and compliance following the incident . Mr. Lassiter concluded by requesting that the Board consider the specific facts and circumstances of the case, emphasizing that each case is unique and should not be subject to a uniform penalty, and urged the Board to impose a measure proportionate to the facts presented. Mike stated that , based on experience in the convenience store industry, employee noncompliance is a common issue but emphasized that the video evidence showed the clerk intentionally overriding the system and entering a false date of birth . Tim expressed concern regarding management practices, questioning the decision to leave the business under the control of an unfamiliar individual and suggesting alternative measures such as increased staffing, schedule adjustments, or temporary closure. He stated that responsibility ultimately rests with ownership and that consequences were warranted . David characterized the matter as a distinction between intent and violation, stating there was no indication the owner intended for the violation to occur; however, the sale to a minor was undisputed. He further noted the absence of evidence of employee certification and compliance with standard requirements . Dave commented that the situation reflected passive management, noting the owner's limited presence at the establishment and lack of oversight of employee conduct . Rick then provided remarks, referencing the establishment 's prior 45-day suspension and a subsequent compliance check in whi ch the same location failed while other previously cited establishments passed. He expressed concern regarding potential patterns of noncompliance and noted that employee certificat ion appeared to have occurred only after the compliance check. He further observed that the clerk involved was an experienced individual , increasing the expectation of compliance Motion to Suspend the Beer Permit for Exxon Food & Fuel for a period of 90 days effective 3/6/26 Motion : Dave Moomy Second: Larry Farina Discussion: None Vote : Unanimous Motion to Adjourn: Timothy Manion Second: Rick Fox Discussion: None Vote : Unanimous ~E:rtt Rick Fox, Chairman Exhibit 1 Resp@nsible TRAINING CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT Fayyaz Hussain SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED THE Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor 10/27/2025 DATE OF COMPLETION 10/27/2026 ,-, ANDREW TYNDAl.l, CEO DATE OF EXPIRATION 2025072711567678 1 of 6 Resp@nsible TRAINING CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION THIS S TO CERTIFY THAT Almurad Abdulla SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED TI-iE Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor 02/09/2026 DATE OF COMPLETION 02/09/2027 ,-. ANDREW TYNDALL, CEO DATE OF EXPIRATION 2026410914126478 2 of6 Exhibit 1 Resp(j)nsible TRAINING CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION Jessica Worley Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor 08/12/2025 08/12/2026 AHOAEWTYN)MJ.. 3 of 6 Exhibit 1 Resp@nsible TRAINING CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT Rozina Charania SUCCESS ULL Y COMPLETED THE Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor 08/15/2025 DATE OF COl\iPLETION 08/15/2026 ~· ANDREW TYNDALL, CEO DA.TE OF EXPIRATION 202524159466678 4 of6 Exhibit 1 Resp nsible TRAINING CERTIFICAT OF COMPLETION Cynthia Cheney -- Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor - - 09/04/2025 09/04/2026 202 120-. l l l.S478 5 of6 Resp@nsible TRAINING CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION Melissa Allen L C PlETED Tennessee Responsible Beer Vendor 09/20/2025 £13/20/2026 ANDRfWlYM>All. 2025592010514878 6 of6

Source: City of Hendersonville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.