Finance Committee Meeting Agenda Packet (PDF) *RESCHEDULED*
City of Hendersonville · Sumner County · meeting of Jan 27, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Hendersonville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF HENDERSONVILLE
FINANCE COMMITTEE
January 27, 2026, at 6:00 p.m.
101 Maple Drive North, Hendersonville, TN 37075
Anyone needing accommodations due to disabilities, please contact the ADA Coordinator at 615- 822-1016 at least 24 hours
prior to the meeting.
I. Cal
l to Order by the Chairman
II. Accept
ance of agenda
III. Minut
es
A. Approva
l of December 9, 2025, meeting minutes
IV. Pu
blic Comments
V. Ordi
nances and Resolutions
1. Rea
ding of ordinance 2026-02, an ordinance amending budget ordinance 2025-09 to
reflect mid-year adjustments to the City’s 2026 fiscal year budget
VI. Ot
her Agenda Items
2. Disc
ussion: Receive and File 2024 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (to be
provided at the meeting)
3. Dis
cussion of letter from Sumner County regarding payment of Adequate Facilities
Tax (AFT)
4. Disc
ussion of letter to Sumner County regarding funds bequeathed to the
Hendersonville Public Library
5. Sales
Tax Analysis Report (to be provided under separate cover)
6. Hot
el-Motel Tax Report (to be provided under separate cover)
7. Inve
stment Earnings Analysis (to be provided under separate cover)
8. Stor
mwater Report (to be provided under separate cover)
9. Publi
c Safety, Infrastructure, Parks & Paving (PIPP) Fund Report (to be provided
under separate cover)
10. Othe
r Business
VII. A
djournment
Clary
1
Pages
2-6
7-13
14-71
72-74
1
FINANCE COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES
December 9 , 2025
CONFERENCE ROOM 1 @ 6:00 pm
Present: Jeffrey Sasse, Mark Burgdorf, Mark Evans
O
ther Staff Present: Mayor Jamie Clary, Jesse Eckenroth, Tamara Ingersoll, Lance Wray
C
alled to order at 6:00 pm by Chairman Jeffrey Sasse
M
otion to accept the December 9, 2025, Finance Committee agenda
Motion: Mark Burgdorf
Second: Mark Evans
Vote: Approved Unanimously 3-0
M
otion to approve the September 23, 2025 meeting minutes
Motion: Mark Evans
Second: Mark Burgdorf
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
C
itizens’ Comments
None.
O
rdinances and Resolutions
Reading of Ordinance 2025-25, an ordinance amending the Hendersonville Municipal Code, Title 20
establishing impact fees for the City of Hendersonville
D
iscussion:
Alderman Burdgorf indicated that he thinks that they need to discuss these ordinances and then send
them on to BOMA for a broader discussion with the whole board. Alderman Sasse agrees and noted
that the two impact fee ordinances are similar but do have defining differences. One is residential only
and the other is residential and commercial.
M
ayor Clary indicated that the biggest difference is the fees that would be collected over the next 5
years. In 2027 the rate would be $5,000 and would increase by $500 each year through 2030. This
ordinance applies only to residential and 1/3 of the fees fund parks and 2/3 fund roads. This is based on
the study that was completed pursuant to State law.
A
lderman Evans was surprised this came up now. It seems a bit rushed and Alderman Burgdorf agrees
with this statement. He wants to make sure we take the time to ensure that the best ordinance for the
City is approved.
A
lderman Sasse asked if it was possible to hold a public hearing on impact fees. It is possible and we
typically hold public hearings on the second reading.
2
2
M
otion to forward to BOMA with a neutral recommendation: Jeff Sasse
Second: Mark Burgdorf
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
R
eading of Ordinance 2025-26, an ordinance amending the Hendersonville Municipal Code, Title 20
establishing credits for assessed impact fees
D
iscussion:
Mayor Clary indicated that it is important that the credits be approved if impact fees are approved.
Alderman Sasse indicated that ordinance 2025-23 has the credits included and asked Mr. Wray why the
credits were included in one ordinance but done as a separate ordinance for the other. Mr. Wray
indicated that this was done at the preference of the sponsor.
M
otion to forward to BOMA with a neutral recommendation: Jeff Sasse
Second: Mark Evans
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
R
eading of Ordinance 2025-23, an ordinance amending the Hendersonville Municipal Code, Title 20
establishing impact fees for the City of Hendersonville
D
iscussion:
Alderman Sasse noted that this ordinance was set at 50% of what was recommended and is for both
residential and commercial. It is split 50% for parks and 50% for roads for residential and 100% for roads
for commercial.
A
lderman Evans asked why one looks at only residential and the other looks at both residential and
commercial. Alderman Sasse indicated that this was sponsor preference. Alderman Evans is interested
in know what the hope of the commercial side is and is there any downfall to it.
M
otion to forward to BOMA with a neutral recommendation: Jeff Sasse
Second: Mark Burgdorf
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
R
eading of Ordinance 2025-24, an ordinance to amend Title 5, Municipal Finance and Taxation, to allow
for the acceptance of partial payments for City of Hendersonville real and personal property taxes
D
iscussion:
Director Ingersoll explained that beginning with the 2026 the City would be able to accept partial
payments on property taxes. We would be able to establish payment plans between October and
February for citizens who request one. Historically, our software did not have the capability to do so.
However, we implemented new technology this year that now has that capability. The biggest benefit
would be to fixed income citizens who often qualify for the tax relief or tax freeze programs.
3
3
Previously a question was brought asking if this would encourage commercial property owners to only
pay partial on their tax bills. Director Ingersoll indicated that this shouldn’t be an issue. A majority of
the large commercial taxpayers don’t pay their taxes until January or February and that likely won’t
change.
A
lderman Burgdorf noted that he thinks this is a great plan and requested to be a co-sponsor of this
ordinance.
A
lderman Sasse noted that this is a good plan and asked if they would be able to pay in two payments
or would it be more. Director Ingersoll explained that the plan for payments is included in the ordinance
and allows for 5 monthly payments which mirrors what Sumner County and Gallatin both do. The
minimum payment amount is set at $50 and any relief payments received applies to the last payment.
This is set up based on recommendations from MTAS and following TCA.
M
otion to forward to BOMA with a positive recommendation: Jeff Sasse
Second: Mark Burgdorf
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
A
t 6:19 pm a motion to take a 10 minute break was made by Alderman Sasse, seconded by Alderman
Burgdorf, approved unanimously.
A
t 6:29 pm the meeting resumed.
R
eading of Resolution 2025-45, a resolution to establish a purchasing card policy for the City of
Hendersonville and to replace the existing credit card policy, dated July 14, 2009, with said purchasing
card policy upon implementation of the purchasing card program
D
iscussion:
Director Ingersoll explained that the P-Card program would replace the City’s existing credit card
program. Under the current program most departments have one credit card that is signed out when an
employee needs to make a purchase. For departments that don’t have a card assigned to them, they
check out the credit card from Finance. This process is very inefficient and the card sharing does not
follow internal control best practices. The P-card program allows a lot of flexibility to set limits based on
department operational needs. Finance would have the ability to immediately turn a card off if
necessary.
A
lderman Burgdorf asked if Finance would be coordinating the implementation of this program and
Director Ingersoll confirmed that Finance would be.
A
lderman Evans asked if Finance would set the limits. Director Ingersoll explained that department
heads would recommend the limits for their staff but the approval would happen in Finance. For
Finance staff, the final approval of limits would be done by the COO. Finance will be monitoring the
program and will adjust the limits based on actual usage. Finance is developing a training program and
4
4
anyone who is assigned a card will be required to attend the training. The proposed policy outlines
allowable and prohibit uses of the cards and explains the consequences of violating the policy.
A
lderman Sasse asked if we would be changing the credit card company and Director Ingersoll indicated
that they City would be changing credit card companies. The intention is for us to piggyback on the
Statewide contract with US Bank. There are no fees for implementation and depending on the amount
spent using the cards, the City may earn rebates.
M
otion to forward to BOMA with a positive recommendation: Mark Evans
Second: Mark Burgdorf
Vote: Approved unanimously 3-0
O
ther Agenda Items
D
iscussion of property tax bills for 1455 and 1473 Center Point Road
Director Ingersoll indicated that the Mayor requested this be added to the agenda to get input from the
Finance Committee on how to proceed with these. These properties were donated to the City in
October 2024. There were taxes due to both the city and the county on those properties by the
developer when the City assumed ownership that were not paid. The developer has indicated that since
the properties were donated to the City, they do not intent to pay these taxes. The total due is just
under $1,000.
A
lderman Burgdorf asked if either of these properties are utilized by the City in any way. Mayor Clary
indicated that they are not and they likely cannot be.
Th
e Mayor would like direction on what to do with the taxes. He thinks we likely need to pay them. The
Finance Committee agrees that these taxes from 2024 should be paid.
D
iscussion of letter to Sumner County regarding funds bequeathed to the Hendersonville Public Library
Mayor Clary indicated that he has sent a letter to the new Library Board on this situation but has not
received a response.
D
iscussion of letter from Sumner County regarding payment of adequate facilities tax (AFT)
Mr. Wray indicated that a new letter is still requesting payment. There is some other information being
verified by Codes. As soon as Codes was aware of the requirement to confirm AFT payment, they have
been doing so. The committee requested that this item be placed on the January agenda to continue
discussion.
S
ales Tax Analysis
State Sales Tax Analysis – Sales tax for the month of October 2025 totaled $669,845. This represents a
$37,407 increase compared to October 2024, and a $107,990 increase compared to this point in FY2025.
L
ocal Sales Tax Analysis – Sales tax for the month of October 2025 totaled $1,852,701. This represents a
$95,590 increase compared to October 2024, and a $196,583 increase compared to this point in FY2025.
5
5
H
otel-Motel Tax Analysis
Occupancy tax collections for the month of October 2025 totaled $49,946. This represents a $8,448
increase compared to October 2024, and a $30,207 increase compared to this point in FY2025.
I
nvestment Activity
The City of Hendersonville’s interest earnings for the month of November 2025 was $97,106 which is a
$9,183 increase compared to November of 2024, and a $10,677 increase compared to this point in
FY2025. It is important to note that the investment revenues are anticipated to come in lower than the
previous fiscal year due to lower interest rates and the budgeted use of funds that were able to be
invested in the prior year.
S
tormwater Fund Report
The current balance in the Stormwater Fund is $2,044,637. The majority of the revenues for the
Stormwater Fund are received between November and February as they are billed and paid with
property taxes.
P
ublic Safety, Infrastructure, Parks & paving (PIPP) Fund Report
Tax collections for the month of November 2025 totaled $693,276. Total revenues through November
2025 total $2,888,452. Year to date expenditures total $1,821,005 bringing the balance in the PIPP Fund
to $5,887,363. Details of activity in this fund are available on the City website:
https://www.hvilletn.org/469/Investing-In-Hendersonville.
M
otion to Adjourn
M
otion: Mark Evans
Second: Jeff Sasse
Vote: Approved unanimously 2-0 with Burgdorf absent for the vote
A
djourned 6:48 pm
____
__________________________
Jeffrey Sasse, Chairman
6
ORDINANCE 2026-02
Spo
nsor: Clary
AN O
RDINANCE AMENDING BUDGET ORDINANCE 2025-09 TO REFLECT MID -
YEAR ADJUSTMENTS TO THE CITY’S 2026 FISCAL YEAR BUDGET
W
HEREAS, on June 16, 2025, the City’s governing body passed Ordinance 2025-09 (the “Budget
Ordinance”) adopting the City’s operating budget for Fiscal Year 2026;
W
HEREAS, the Budget Ordinance was based on projected revenues and anticipated expenditures
for Fiscal Year 2026;
W
HEREAS, there have been over six (6) months of actual revenue, expenditure activity and
other adjustments, and the City desires to amend the budget ordinance mid- year to reflect this
activity and these adjustments:
NO
W, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF MAYOR AND
ALDERMEN OF THE CITY OF HENDERSONVILLE, TENNESSEE AS FOLLOWS:
S
ECTION 1: That the salary rate for all employees on pay scale TP01 be increased by 6.7% ,
effective the with the pay period beginning March 7, 2026, as shown in Exhibit A.
S
ECTION 2: That the City’s Fiscal Year 2026 Budget Ordinance, Ordinance 2025-09, is hereby
amended in accordance with the mid-year budget adjustments set forth in the attached Exhibit B.
T
his ordinance shall take effect on the earliest date allowed by law.
First Reading: ______________________
Second Reading:
AP
PROVED:
J
AMIE CLARY, Mayor
ATTEST:
___________________________________
T
AMARA INGERSOLL, City Recorder
AP
PROVED AS TO FORM:
7
____________________________________
LANCE A. WRAY, City Attorney
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY
Ordinance 2026-02
Sponsor: Clary
Committee: Finance
Date of Committee Meeting: January 27, 2026
Committee Recommendation:
8
City of Hendersonville, TN
FY2026 Salary Tables - Eff 03-07-2026
TEMP GRADE CHANGE
Current Grade Rate Proposed Grade Rate
Effective 06/22/2025 Effective 03/07/2026
GRADE TP01 GRADE TP01
STEP/LEVEL 1 STEP/LEVEL 1
HOURLY RATE 19.3410$ HOURLY RATE 20.6368 $
Exhibit A
9
Fund Account Name
Current
Budget
Requested
Expenditure
Amendment
Requested
Revenue
Amendment
Use of Fund
Balance /
Reserves
Adjusted
Budget Notes
1 General LOCAL OPTION SALES TAX 22,084,000 $ 300,000 $ 22,384,000 $ Sales tax revenue slightly higher than budgeted
2 General STATE SALES TAX 7,700,000$ 150,000$ 7,700,000$ Sales tax revenue slightly higher than budgeted
3 General INTEREST EARNINGS 850,000$ 46,000$ 850,000$ Investment income slightly higher than budgeted
4 General CONTRIBUTIONS-PARKS SPONSORS 25,000$ 52,000$ 77,000$ Donations received by Parks
5 General SKATE PARK RENOVATIONS - $ 50,000$ 50,000$ Revnovation to skate park funded with donations
6 General CONTRIBUTIONS & DONATIONS 30,725$ 16,319$ 47,044$ Donations received by Parks
7 General MAINT - MARY'S MAGICAL PLACE 81,291$ 16,319$ 97,610$ Mary's Magical Place Maintentance - Funded with donations
8 General FY26 - SF GREENWAY MARKING POS 1,500$ 2,000$ 3,500$ Greenway Trailmarkers - Funded with donations
9 General USTA TENNIS GRANT - $ 20,300$ 20,300$ USTA grant for Memorial Park tennis improvements
10 General MEMORIAL PARK TENNIS IMPROV - $ 20,300$ 20,300$ Memorial Park Tennis - Funded with USTA grant funds
11 General FUEL TANK REPLACEMENT - $ 200,000$ 200,000$
Replacement of fuel tanks at Free Hill Rd. - Gasoline system currently
inoperable.
12 General FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM REPLAC - $ 350,000$ 350,000$
Replacement of fire suppression system at City Hall that is beyond its
service life.
13 General FIRE HVAC AND FOUNDATION - $ 85,000$ 85,000$ Replace HVAC and repair foundation at Fire Station 3
14 General LANDSCAPING SERVICES 60,000$ 31,000$ 31,000$ 91,000$ Use of Tree Bank
15 General PRIOR YEAR REFUNDS - $ 58,325$ 58,325$ 58,325$ Refund of Tree Bank funds to Grace Place
16 General BEAUTIFUL HENDERSONVILLE SUPPL 10,500$ 2,455$ 12,955$ Storage container for Beautiful Hendersonville
17 General HR-MEALS AND INCIDENTALS 500$ 3,000$ 3,500$ Public Safety recognition event
18 General IT-COMPUTERS 523,000$ 20,000$ 543,000$ Increased software cost beyond projections
19 General FIN-COMPUTERS 21,000$ (7,600)$ 13,400$ Property Tax now included in MUNIS in IT budget
20 General FIN-OTHER PROFESSIONAL SVCS 169,943$ (25,000)$ 144,943$ Technology implementation less than anticipated
21 General FIRE-REPAIR & MAINT - VEHICLES 250,000$ 140,000$ 390,000$ Repairs necessary to keep vehicles in service
22 General FIRE-OVERTIME SALARIES 158,000$ 180,000$ 338,000$ Necessary for staffing coverage
23 General FIRE-SALARIES - RETIREMENT PAY 80,000$ 375,000 $ 455,000 $
Payout of vacation and sick leave for two retirements not identified
in the original budget process
24 General PARKS-WATER 40,000$ 20,000$ 60,000$
There have been multiple issues with the well system and leaks this
FY.
25 General PARKS-SALARIES - PT REGULAR 319,500$ 90,000$ 409,500$
Necessary to fund required Parks part time employees. Also adds
6.7% increase to employees on pay scale TP01
26 General SALARIES - PERM EMPLOYEE - REG 12,756,600 $ (250,000) $ 12,506,600 $ Savings due to vacancies
27 General E-911 SUMNER CO EMERG COMMUN 1,860,561 $ (75,000) $ 1,860,561 $ Actual cost is less than budgeted
(635,000)$ Net Non-Operating Budget Impact
23,145$ Net Operating Budget Impact
(23,145)$ Existing Operating Budget Surplus / (Deficit)
- $ Remaining Surplus / (Deficit) After Amendment
EXHIBIT B
BUDGET AMENDMENT WORKSHEET - ORDINANCE 2026-02
10
1 110-000-00000-0000-0000-431600-
2 110-000-00000-0000-0000-433510-
3 110-000-00000-0000-0000-436100-
4 110-002-00000-0000-0000-436700-
5 TBD
6 110-002-00000-0000-0000-436700-MMPLC
7 110-000-110-000-44700-0015-0000-526500-15004
8 110-000-41920-0033-0000-534200-33045
9 TBD
10 TBD
11 TBD
12 TBD
13 TBD
14 110-000-41700-0022-0000-525400-
15 110-000-41700-0022-0000-574310-
16 110-000-41620-0013-0000-532900-BEAUT
17 110-000-41690-0012-0000-528700-
18 110-000-41690-0016-0000-536000-
19 110-000-41500-0014-0000-536000-
20 110-000-41500-0014-0000-525900-
21 110-000-42200-0043-0000-526100-
22 110-000-42200-0043-0000-511300-
23 110-000-42200-0043-0000-511500-
24 110-000-44700-0015-0000-524200-
25 110-000-44700-0015-0000-511800-
26 110-000-42100-0042-0000-511100-
27 110-000-41620-0013-0000-521800-
Finance Use Only - Account Codes
11
DATE: January 27, 2026
ORDINANCE/RESOLUTION # Ordinance 2026-02
SPECIFIC REQUEST/
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of Mayor and Alderman conside r
Ordinance 2026-02, a mid -year budge t ordinance,
amending the Fiscal Year 2025/2026 Budget for the City of
Hendersonville.
REPORT PREPARED BY: Tamara Ingersoll, Finance Director
BACKGROUND: 1
On an annual basis the city appropriates funds to facilitate the orderly operations of local government
services. The city’s budget year, or fiscal year, begins July 1st and ends June 30th. The budget is segregated
between multiple funds, the General Fund being the primary fund used for the city’s operations. The
General Fund is divided amongst the different departments and functions of the city. Each department
within the General Fund i n segregated into three groups of expenses: salaries/benefits, assets, and
operations. The expense groups have itemized expense accounts (line items) within the group that serve
as a budgeting guide, but the budget is ultimately constrained by the total group budget and not by the
individual line items. The mid-year budget review serves as a time to review and revise the budget based
on 6-months of actual activity and updated projections.
DISCUSSION: 2
Fiscal Year 202 5-2026 continues to yield revenue growth. The budgeted revenue numbers have been
revised to reflect six months of actual revenues and the updated projections for the remaining six months.
The revenue projections for the General Fund budget are expected to increase by approximately $585,000.
The revenue growth is primarily driven by an increase of $300,000 in Local Option Sales Tax, $ 150,000 in
State Sales Tax , and various other revenues. The primary additional expenses being proposed with the
mid-year review:
• Project prioritization
1. Fuel tank replacement at Free Hill Road
2. Fire suppression system replacement at City Hall
3. HVAC replacement and foundation repairs at Fire Station 3
• Repairs and Maintenance of vehicles
• Salary adjustments for retirement payouts
FISCAL IMPACT: 3
The additional General Fund revenue projections amount to $584,619 and the expenditures being proposed
with the mid-year review are divided into two categories:
• Operating expenses - $472,855
• Non-operating expenses - $812,944
The amendments result in a balanced operating budget.
STAFF
REPORT
12
O23-03 Staff Report
Page 2
ATTACHMENTS: 4
Exhibit A is attached to Ordinance 2026-02 and includes the proposed salary table for pay grade TP01.
Exhibit B is attached to Ordinance 2026-02 and itemizes every proposed budget amendment.
FY2026 - Original
Budget Ord 2025-09
Balance After
Ord 2025-16
Balance After
Ord 2025-21
FY2026 Amend
Ord 2026-02
Balance After
Ord 2026-02
Revenues 64,805,960 64,805,960 64,816,685 496,000 65,312,685
Expenditures 64, 781,487 64,819,587 64,839,830 472,855 65,312,685
Surplus/(Deficit) 24,473 (13,627) (23,145) 23,145 0
FY2026 - Original
Budget Ord 2025-09
Balance After
Ord 2025-16
Balance After
Ord 2025-21
FY2025 Amend
Ord 2024-23
Balance After
Ord 2026-02
Revenues 10,112,924 10,112,924 10,293,641 88,619 10,382,260
Use of Reserves 89, 325 89,325
Expenditures 25,283,169 25,283,169 25,671,443 812,944 26,484,387
Subtotal (15,170,245) (15,170,245) (15,377,802) (635,000) (16,012,802)
PLUS: Project Rebudgets 6,231,927 6,231,927 6,231,927 0 6,231,927
Surplus/(Deficit) (8,938,318) (8,938,318) (9,145,875) (635,000) (9,780,875)
FY2026 - Original
Budget Ord 2025-09
Balance After
Ord 2025-16
Balance After
Ord 2025-21
FY2025 Amend
Ord 2024-23
Balance After
Ord 2026-02
Operating - Suplus/ (Deficit) 24,473 (13,627) (23,145) 23,145 0
Non-Operating - Surplus/(Deficit) (8,938,318) (8,938,318) (9,145,875) (635,000) (9,780,875)
(8,913,845) (8,951,945) (9,169,020) (611,855) (9,780,875)
Estimated FY2025 YE Unassigned Fund Balance as Budgeted 21,665,110
A
ctual FY2025 YE Unassigned Fund Balance 21,536,294
Use of Fund Balance 8,913,845 8,951,945 9,169,020 611,855 9,780,875
Remaining Unassigned Fund Balance 12,622,449 12,584,349 12,367,274 11,755,419
Minumim Required Unassigned Fund Balance 10,799,074 10,805,425 10,808,800 10,887,625
Surplus/(Deficit)
General Fund
Budget Summary Comparison - Original FY 2026 Budget and Amendments
Operating Budget
Non-Operating Budget (Capital & Special Projects)
OPERATING and NON-OPERATING
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
City of Hendersonville
101 Maple Drive North Hendersonville, TN 37075 Telephone (615) 822-1000
www.hvilletn.org
MEMORANDUM
TO: Finance Committee
CC: Mayor, Jamie Clary, Chief of Operations, Jesse Eckenroth, Director of Codes, Greg Story
Board of Mayor and Aldermen,
FROM: Lance Wray, City Attorney
RE: County Demand for Reimbursement of Unpaid Adequate Facilities Tax owed by Commercial
Developers
DATE: September 18, 2025
I. Background
▪ In 1999, the County adopted a Private Act authorizing “Adequate Facilities Tax (AFT)” on all
new Residential and Industrial development within the County. (The Act is attached as Exh 1).
▪ An AFT is somewhat like an impact fee, but more specifically is a privilege tax on development
used to raise general revenue for the government, not necessarily tied to the specific costs of
new development, and the funds can be used for existing deficiencies or operations and
maintenance, not just capital projects.
▪ “Industrial” according to the Act “means the development of any property for use by any person
in a business classified as industrial under the United States Government Standard Industrial
Classification Manual.
▪ Development applicants pay the County’s AFT at the County. If ultimately the building permit
is to be issued by an incorporated city of Sumner County, the city require s evidence that the
AFT has been paid to the County.
▪ According to the County’s Act, “[t]he issuance of a building permit by any city official, without
certificate from the county that the tax has been paid, shall render the city liable to the county
for the sum or sums that would have been collected by the county had the certificate of tax paid
been required by the city.
▪ Since inception of the Act approx. 25 years ago, the City has ensured that the County has been
paid its AFT on all new residential and industrial development within the City.
▪ It appears that i n or around the beginning of 2024, the County made a legal determination that
“Industrial” development also include s “Commercial” development, on the basis of certain
48
County AFT Demand Memorandum 2
development activities or products grouped under the United States Government Standard
Industrial Classification Manual.1
▪ On February 10, 2024, the County sent out a n email addressed to city mayors, followed by a
letter days after addressed to “City Mayors and their Legal Departments” under the subject
heading “Classifying Industrial as defined in the OSHA (SIC) Standard Industrial Classification
Manual.” The letter stated that “AFT payments are required on Residential and Industrial, but
appears there may be some confusion on what qualifies as Industrial.” The letter went on to state
that it was providing “attachments…. for quick review and reminder as what qualifies for
Adequate Facility Tax collection as prescribed by the Standard Industria l Classification (SIC)
Manual. The (SIC) Manual can be viewed upon opening attachment #2.” “Please note that Major
Groups as defined in Division A through Division J of the (SIC) Manual would qualify as
Industrial therefore would require AFT payment prior to issuance of building permits. ” (The
February 2024 correspondence is attached as Exh 2)
▪ No where in the County’s February 2024 correspondence does it mention that AFT was being
assessed, and the City was required to verify AFT payments on permits for “ Commercial”
development. The letter merely directed that the City refer to the several industries listed under
“Major Groups as defined in Division A through Division J of the United States Government
Standard Industrial Classification Manual (under which there is also no mention of the term
“Commercial”) and make determinations if any of the listed industries applied as “Industrial”
development. Upon face value of the lett er, and even after its careful review including the
attachments, the letter is wholly unclear that the City had any duty, or was being directed to
begin verifying AFT payments to the County on “Commercial” development.
▪ On April 10, 2025, fourteen (14) months after the February letter, the County Codes office mailed
a letter directly to the City’s Codes Director (as well as to the Mayor and the City Attorney)
stating that “there has been no AFT payments on commercial builds in the City of
Hendersonville” although “[i]t was recently determined that payment on commercial builds are
required” (my emphasis added). The letter went on to inform that “[p]lease consider this as a
notification that AFT payments should be made on commercial builds to the Sumne r County
Building & Codes Office” (my emphasis added). This is the first that the City had any
indication that AFT was now being assessed on all Commercial development. (The April
10, 2025 correspondence is attached as Exh 3).
▪ Immediately after receiving the letter, t he City’s Codes Director called the County Codes
Director to confirm that all commercial development was being assessed AFT, and after which
the City’s Codes Director immediately began implementing a process to verify payments of the
County’s AFT on all commercial development for all new commercial permit applications.
▪ On July 7, 2025, the County sent a letter to the City informing that the City had failed to require
evidence of payment of the County’s AFT on commercial development dating back to February
2024 (the date of the first letter) and as such, the City was directly liable for payment of all such
unpaid AFT. The letter included a list of twenty-six (26) commercial permits issued by the City
on which the County did not collect AFT, the total of which is $225,841.60. The letter demanded
payment within “14 calendar days from the date of this letter …. in the sum of $225,841.60 .”
(The July 7, 2025 correspondence is attached as Exh 4)
1 “Commercial” is not listed under the United States Government Standard Industrial Classification Manual. However, various
development industries are listed that would be considered “commercial”.
49
County AFT Demand Memorandum 3
II. Findings
City Codes researched the County’s list of twenty-six (26) permits having unpaid AFT on
commercial development, to include research for the dates each commercial permit application was
made and when each commercial permit was issued, and found as follows:
o 1 permit has been determined that the AFT was actually paid and evidence was provided
and verified by the City (Permit # 030707-2025, 135 Walton Ferry Rd, $3,670.40).
o 25 permits (all remaining) have been determined to have application dates prior to the
County’s letter of April 10, 2025, and 1 of which was prior to the February 2024 letter.
o 17 permits have been determined to have issue dates prior to the County’s letter of April
10, 2025.
III. Brief Legal Analysis
There are arguably significant legal issues in favor of the City as to whether or not a county
can establish such a liability and enforce such a claim against a municipality , derived from language
contained in the county’s own private act, an absent any written mutual agreement. These would include
Constitutional issues (see, for example, the above mentioned Comptroller Report referencing the City
of Gallatin which prevailed against a similar claim (pp. 6-7)), as well as statutory issues. For example,
the County’s attempt to assess the citizens of Hendersonville for taxes presumably owed by permittees
to the County, may be contrary to State law relative to unenforceable indemnification. Additional legal
issues may apply such as whether or not the City had effective notice.
IV. Recommendations
1). Advise against an appropriation of $225,841.60 from the citizenry coffers at this time for
reasons including the following:
a). For approximately 25 years the City has been a good steward of ensuring that the
County is paid its AFT owed on residential and industrial development within the City. Th e sudden
change of interpretation to include commercial development under the definition of industrial
development after such a long period is something for staff that came completely out of left field and
caught everyone off guard . The February 2024 letter from the County addressed to “City Mayors and
their Legal Departments” contained, in hindsight and after a close r review, a monumental change.
However, arguably, its significance was not matched by the clarity of the letter in that:
i). it was without clear indication that the County would begin immediately to assess
AFT on commercial development; and
ii). it was without any direction that the City was to immediately begin verifying AFT
paid to the County for commercial development.
The letter merely acknowledged that there may be “some confusion on what qualifies for AFT
collection” and by way of explanation simply directed the City to refer to the various industrial groupings
under the Standard Industrial Classification Manual and make determinations if certain commercial
projects fell under industrial groupings. Again, nowhere in the February 2024 letter, nor under the
Standard Industrial Classification Manual Groupings lists is “commercial” stated. I would argue that this
50
County AFT Demand Memorandum 4
was insufficient and appropriate notice to the City. Yet, 17 of the 26 total permits for which the County
claims the City is liable were issued between this February 2024 letter and the next communication, the
April 2025 letter. In other words, the City had no awareness that the County had begun assessing AFT
on commercial development within the City until the April 2025 letter from the County.
b). As mentioned, after the February 2024 letter there was to my knowledge nothing
further conveyed by the County to the City until the April 2025 letter. The April 2025 letter, sent directly
to the City Codes Director, was clear that the County assessed AFT on commercial development, and
that the City should begin verifying for such. Upon receipt of the letter, the City Codes Director
immediately responded and contacted the County Codes Director for affirmation. After which, the City
Codes Director immediately began processing and implementing measures within the Codes and other
departments to ensure verification of AFT paid for commercial developments, beginning with all new
applications. No applications made after the April 2025 letter have gone without AFT payment
verification.
c). At all times relevant hereto, the City has acted in good faith. As soon as, in fact the
second after the City was properly and effectively notified that the County was collecting AFT on
commercial development, and as a result the City was to begin verifying for such, the City immediately
began verifying for all new permit applications.
d). The AFT owed to the County is owed by the respective permitt ees, and not the
citizens of the City. It is unknown what measures or actions the County is employing or has employed
against them and I am unsure what if anything would prevent that.
e). In the 2008 Comptroller Reporter, it was recommended to the County to have mutual
agreements in place with the City to clearly identify each parties roles and responsibilities. There has
not been any such Agreement.
f). Legally, it is believed that the enforceability of the County’s claim is on very shaky
legal ground.
2). Memorialize and send a formal response to the County containing these findings.
3). Make inquiry to the County if it is taking any measures to pursue the actual AFT
debtors, and if not, why not?
4). Consider whether or not to make a request to the legislative delegation for
submission of an AG Opinion.
End of Memorandum
Attachments:
Exh 1: The County’s Private Act authorizing AFT
Exh 2: The County’s February 2024 correspondence
Exh 3: The County’s April 10, 2025 correspondence
Exh 4: The County’s July 7, 2025 correspondence
51
EXHIBIT 1
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
EXHIBIT 2
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
EXHIBIT 3
67
68
EXHIBIT 4
69
70
71
From: Jamie Clary
To: Tamara Ingersoll
Subject: Finance Committee packet
Date: Tuesday, December 2, 2025 10:08:35 AM
Attachments: image001.png
Tamara:
Good morning. Below is the text of the letter I sent to the Sumner County Library Board.
Thank you.
Jamie Clary
Mayor of Hendersonville, Tennessee
Dear Erika:
Thank you for your service on the county’s library board. I appreciate your willingness to
lead a very important opportunity that we provide our residents.
I am delighted with some of the changes to the library board and am eager to work with
you. For years I have been campaigning for the Hendersonville library to have as many
operating hours as the Gallatin library. With new board members in place under your
leadership, I see an opportunity to renew this effort.
This letter is a follow-up request from a letter I sent almost a year ago.
In 2024 Shirly Phipps, a long-time Hendersonville resident, passed away. Through her
last will and testament, she left a generous gift of $321,164.21 to the Hendersonville
library. The will states, “I leave ten percent (10%) of my estate to the HENDERSONVILLE
PUBLIC (MARTIN CURTIS) LIBRARY in Hendersonville, Tennessee” (caps original). Mrs.
Phipps’ executors issued checks to Sumner County in the amount of $321,164.21.
I am unsure why only one library owner received funds from the bequest. As 50 percent
owner, the City of Hendersonville should have received 50 percent of the bequest.
Following that error, I inquired about this bequest but received no responses from
72
previous chairman Joanna Daniels. My previous letter stated to members of the library
board, “As a 50 percent owner of the library, the City of Hendersonville looks forward to
discussing the use of these funds and how they can benefit the patrons of the library in
Hendersonville.”
To my knowledge nobody from the City of Hendersonville has been invited to
discussions regarding the use of the bequest. The library board did not discuss my
request. I never received acknowledgement from the library board about my request.
At this time, I respectfully ask again the library board transfer 50 percent of the bequest
to the City of Hendersonville. That would be $160,582.10. That money would allow me to
revisit my longtime effort to increase the operating hours of the Hendersonville library.
Documents and discussions are very clear that the City and County share library
ownership evenly. However, the only action directing use of the funds came from a
county resolution to accept the entirety of the bequest. That is troubling in that the
decision did not include the other owner, the City of Hendersonville, and had no
application that would benefit the library.
Hendersonville’s finance committee met several months ago and asked that I follow up
about these funds. The committee members still await the county’s response to our
request. I hope that the library board can provide a response before the end of this year.
I look forward to receiving a response that includes the funds mentioned above.
Sincerely,
Jamie Clary
Mayor of Hendersonville, Tennessee
73
74
Source: City of Hendersonville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.