Hendersonville Planning Commission Agenda (PDF)
City of Hendersonville · Sumner County · meeting of Jan 6, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Hendersonville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HPC Agenda
01/06/2026
1
HENDERSONVILLE PLANNING COMMISSION
AGENDA
Main Meeting Room
Tuesday, January 6th 2026
6:30 PM
1. OPENING PRAYER
2. ROLL CALL
3. PUBLIC COMMENT (AGENDA ITEMS ONLY)
4. ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA
5. MINUTES:
Minutes of December 2nd, 2025
6. CONSENT AGENDA
SP-006994-2025: Offices for Rock Castle Wealth Management – Site Plan
Owner: RBWF Properties
Location: 119 Maple Row Boulevard, Parcel 1590 D 017.00
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten
7. DEVELOPMENT PLANS:
DP-006913-2025: TBN (Millenia Cottages) – FDP
Owner: Trilogy Asset Investments Inc.
Location: 645 E Main Street, Parcel 158A A 008
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten/Zachary Coleman
(Deferral from November 4th & December 2nd HPC Meeting)
HPC Agenda
01/06/2026
2
8. SITE PLAN
SP-006994-2025: 1 Twenty at Sanders Ferry – Site Plan
Owner: Stephen Pinaire
Location: 120 Sanders Ferry Rd, Parcel 160M C 017.00
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten
(Waiver Request)
SP-007014-2025: Heritage Park – Site Plan
Owner: City of Hendersonville
Location: 119 East Drive, Parcel 164 F 001.00
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten
(Waiver Request)
SP-006994-2025: Nashville Tempered Glass Warehouse – Site Plan
Owner: Grants Fireworks Property Management
Location: 100 Jessica Lauren Ct, Parcel 146 100.00
Lead Planning Staff: Caitlin Shinn
(Waiver Request)
9. OTHER
SUB-006966-2025: Mansker Farms Phase 18 Section 1 Setback Deviation – Final Plat
Owner: Wilson Bank & Trust
Location: 124 Manor Way, Parcel 1144I N 020.00
Lead Planning Staff: Caitlin Shinn
(Deferral from December 2nd HPC Meeting)
Development Impact Fees: City of Hendersonville
Lead Planning Staff: Keith Free/ Zachary Coleman
Election of Officers
10. STAFF-LEVEL PROJECTS, APPROVED:
SUB-007027-2025: Rock Castle Wealth Management Offices– 3-Page Plat Amendment
(119 Maple Row Boulevard)
HPC Agenda
01/06/2026
3
11. STAFF-LEVEL PROJECTS, PENDING:
SUB-006988-2025: C.L Powell – Final Plat
(134 Powell Dr)
S - 11/13/25
Lead Planning Staff: Caitlin Shinn
SP-007029-2025: First Presbyterian Church Pavilion
(172 West Main St)
A – 12/18/25
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten
SUB-006708-2025: Meadows of Indian Lake Ph 4 Sec 3 Lots 248 & 249 Consolidation –
Final Plat
(344 & 342 Raintree Dr)
A – 12/18/25
Lead Planning Staff: Caitlin Shinn
SUB-006891-2025: Molly Walton Industrial – Final Plat
(157 Molly Walton Dr)
A – 12/18/25
Lead Planning Staff: Timothy Whitten
SP-007030-2025: Stonecrest Ph 5, Sec 2 & 3 Elevation Amendment
(1351 Saundersville Road)
A – 12/18/25
Lead Planning Staff: Caitlin Shinn
12. PLANNING DIRECTOR COMMENTS:
2025 Year End Report
13. ADJOURNMENT
1
This is a 0.58 acre vacant lot located at 119 Maple Row Boulevard, adjacent to and south of
Cornerstone Primary Healthcare. It is zoned General Commercial (GC). GC zoning is to the
north, west and south. SR-1 zoning is to the east.
The proposed use is a 4,818sf office building. 12 parking spaces are required and 18 are
proposed. A type B landscape buffer is being provided along the SR-1 zone line. Access to the
site will be via an existing joint-access with Cornerstone Primary Healthcare. Cross-access will
be provided to the future development to the south.
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2025
HPC PROJECT #: SP-006994-2025
PROJECT NAME: Offices for Rock Castle Wealth Management
PROJECT TYPE: Site Plan
PROJECT LOCATION: 119 Maple Row Boulevard, Parcel 1590 D 017.00
WARD: Ward 2
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
3
FRONT ELEVATION FACING MAPLE ROW BLVD
4
REAR ELEVATION FACING EAST
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
comments:
1. Provide NES-approved electric service plan prior to building permit application.
2. Show underground electric service to building.
3. Cross-access easement must be recorded prior to building permit issuance.
Submitted by Timothy Whitten, RLA, AICP, Assistant Planning Director (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. All comments have been resolved.
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
5
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. No Comments
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. See note on sheet C1.05.
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
UPDATE TO STAFF REPORT & COMMENTS:
• At its November 4th meeting, the HPC voted to defer TBN Music City to allow the
developer to go back and add parking for the Independent Living cottages. The plan has
been revised to meet all parking requirements. This has been done by adding one
surface parking space per cottage unit (or two additional spaces per structure). The
applicant is no longer requesting a waiver of any parking requirements. The plan
has also been revised to address previous staff comments. One other minor change
that has been made since the last HPC meeting is that one of the cottages that fronted
on Music Village Boulevard has been relocated to the first row of units on the north side
of the property. The total number of units remains unchanged.
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2026
HPC PROJECT #: DP-006913-2025
PROJECT NAME: TBN (Millenia Cottages)
PROJECT TYPE: Final Development Plan
PROJECT LOCATION: 645 E Main Street, Parcel 158A A 008
WARD: Ward 5
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
• Since the definition of Independent Living was a topic of discussion at the last meeting,
the full definition from the zoning ordinance has been provided below:
• The following staff comments have been added to this revised plan:
All proposed sidewalks are to be constructed in conjunction with the first phase (i.e. the
cottages). A three foot grass strip is required between each pair of cottage parking
spaces.
3
THE UPDATED FDP
The Preliminary Development Plan for TBN Music City went before the Planning Commission in
January of 2024 and received a negative recommendation to the Board of Mayor & Aldermen. BOMA
then approved the PDP (see image below) following the applicant’s commitment to retain and
refurbish the Twitty Mansion. The BOMA plan reduced the number of Independent Living cottages
from 96 to 90 due to keeping the Twitty Mansion, and showed retention of the brick wall and entrance
along East Main Street.
STAFF REPORT: 1
4
PDP APPROVED BY BOMA
5
PROPOSED FDP
Now, TBN is moving forward with a request to approve the Final Development Plan (FDP). The PDP
that was approved by BOMA proposed 90 Independent Living cottages, 80 Assisted Living units, a
clubhouse and pool, a chapel, 39,300sf of Office and supporting retail, and retention of the existing
theater, barn, and Twitty Mansion. The proposed FDP removes the Assisted Living facility with its 80
units and expands the Independent Living cottages from 90 to 110 units. Unit density for the cottages
is reduced from 5.82 units/ac. to 4.94 units/ac (15 units/ac is the maximum allowed by the zoning
ordinance). It retains the Twitty Mansion (now fully renovated) and the theater, but shows the existing
barn to be replaced with a new barn/storage facility. The two office outparcels that were proposed on
either side of the Main Street entrance have been reduced to one outparcel to the east of the
6
entrance, for a total of 12,650sf vs the previous 39,300sf. Ingress/egress points on Main Street have
been reduced from two to one. Ingress/egress points on Caudill have been increased from 2 to 3.
Overall, the revised layout is similar to the PDP, but presents a very different appearance to East
Main. Instead of having a large assisted living facility and two office buildings facing Main Street, now
the cottages will take the place of all but one of the office buildings and will back up to Main Street
and the existing brick wall.
Parking requirements for the Independent Living cottages is 2 spaces per unit, plus one per
employee. The zoning ordinance states that garages are not allowed to count towards required
parking. TBN is requesting a waiver to allow garages to count towards required parking. The current
layout provides one space in the driveway and one in the garage for units types A through E. Unit type
F meets the required parking since it has two spaces in each driveway. See the attached waiver
request letter from the applicant.
Exterior building elevations of the proposed cottages, clubhouse and barn have been provided. The
siding material on the cottage unit types is not defined. Per images that were included with the PDP,
staff is requiring that the applicant work with staff through the site plan process to provide a sizeable
percentage of brick/stone on each unit and otherwise increase the design quality to be more
equivalent to those initial images (see Planning staff comment #5). The clubhouse
PROPOSED COTTAGES
7
PROPOSED CLUBHOUSE
PROPOSED STORAGE BARN
______________________________________________________________________________________________
ESTIMATED NEXT STEPS IN THIS FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN APPROVAL PROCESS:
1. BOMA General Committee Meeting (Dec. 9, 2025, estimated)
2. BOMA Regular Meeting (Jan. 13, 2025, estimated)
______________________________________________________________________________________________
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
1. In the applicant response to staff comments, it is stated that there are no improvements
proposed to the existing parking lot north-east of the theater and that therefore no
landscaping improvements should be required to it until such time that changes are made.
However, the plans show the existing parking lot to be completely reconfigured on multiple
sheets. Please resolve the conflict.
2. A 20’ Type B buffer is shown along the edge of the parking lot that is north-east of the
existing theater. If the existing parking lot is to be retained, the full 20’ width may not be able
to be obtained without removing some of the pavement width.
3. Amend the Proposed Uses chart as follows to bring it into compliance with the chart
approved with the PDP:
• “General Business” should be “General Business Services”
• Add “Restaurant Quick Service (limited to coffee shop”
4. Sheet L1.0 does not show the proposed office outlot as shown on the other sheets – revise.
8
5. The provided cottage elevations do not match the level of design and quality of materials
shown with the PDP. The PDP illustrations showed units with deep porches and eaves, a
mixture of brick, stone and fiber cement board, and other architectural features. While the
proposed cottages do not have to match the illustrations, the overall quality of design and
materials should be at least equivalent. Work with staff through the site plan stage to refine
the elevations and bring them more into alignment with what is shown with the PDP.
6. Proposed materials on the barn elevations are not called out, but appear to resemble CMU
block. CMU is not a permitted material. Work with staff to meet and exceed City building
design requirements
7. Since the cottages are now proposed to back up to East Main Street, preserve all of the
existing brick wall to help serve as a screen from the street. In addition, provide evergreen
screening between the wall and the units.
8. The chart on sheet C2-00 lists unit types A through D, but the layout plan and elevations
show units E and F. Update the chart to reflect counts for all unit types.
Submitted by Timothy Whitten, RLA, AICP, Assistant Planning Director (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. No Comments
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. No Comment.
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. No Comments
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
1
This site is a vacant 4.7 acre parcel located at 120 Sanders Ferry Road. It is zoned General
Commercial (GC) and is bounded by GC zoning to the north, east and south. To the west is
Dockside Neighborhood zoning. Drakes Creek Inn and Sanders Ferry Business Park are to the
immediate north. Sanders Ferry Pub & Pizza is across Sanders Ferry to the south-east.
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2025
HPC PROJECT #: SP-006992-2025
PROJECT NAME: 1 Twenty at Sanders Ferry
PROJECT TYPE: Site Plan
PROJECT LOCATION: 120 Sanders Ferry Rd, Parcel 160M C 017.00
WARD: Ward 2
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
In
2018
a site
plan
was
approved by the Planning Commission for a mixed-use development consisting of 54 two-story
residential units over 30,000sf of commercial retail space. That site plan has since expired, and
the zoning changed from Old Town Commercial to General Commercial.
The proposed development is for 3 buildings and associated parking. Buildings 1 and 2, located
closest to Sanders Ferry, will be single story commercial retail tenant spaces totaling about
21,500sf. The third building, at the rear of the property, will be a two-story headquarters for
Pinaire Roofing, a commercial roofing company.
3
Access to the site will be via a full ingress/egress and a right-in/right-out off of Sanders Ferry
Rd. Cross access will be provided to the Sanders Ferry Business Park parking lot to the north.
175 parking spaces are required based on the currently projected mix of retail and restaurant
uses. 176 spaces are being provided.
The applicant is requesting three waivers:
Waiver Request #1
The zoning ordinance allows for the use of high-quality architectural metals to be used on a
case-by-case basis, and these are proposed in limited quantities on the two retail buildings,
and in greater quantities on the front of building 3. The primary material should be brick or
stone, and buildings 2 and 3 meet this requirement. On building 3, high-quality architectural
metal is the predominant material on the front (east side), though there is a good amount of
brick on it as well. On the north and south sides of building 3, brick does wrap around the front
corners, but the predominant material on those sides is standard metal siding, not the high-
quality metal panels used on the other buildings. On the rear, facing west, is 100% standard
metal siding. In the image below of building 3, proposed brick is shown highlighted in red. The
areas highlighted in yellow is the standard metal siding for which the waiver is being requested.
Building 3 is remote from the street. The front will have the most exposure. The north side faces
4
the rear of Drakes Creek Inn. The south side faces wooded undeveloped commercial property.
It is expected that this property will develop soon. The rear faces heavily wooded commercial
lots which have commercial development on their Walton Ferry frontage.
5
Waiver Request #2
The zoning ordinance requires that at least 75% (not 50% as stated by the applicant below) of
replacement trees (replacement trees are those planted to replace existing trees that have
been removed) be canopy type trees, rather than smaller ornamental type trees. The purpose
of this requirement is to maintain and increase the city’s overall percentage of tree canopy.
6
100% of the replacement trees required for this project are proposed to be ornamental type
trees that do not develop a broad canopy (a total of 30). 54 canopy trees meeting other
landscape requirements are proposed to be planted.
Waiver Request #3
The zoning ordinance requires that a minimum of 20% of the overall lot area have a pervious
surface, i.e. not paved or have a building covering it. The applicant is proposing to provide
17.5% pervious area.
7
8
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
1. Provide stamped site/topo survey.
2. Provide minimum 5’ wide foundation planting bed at building 2.
3. Provide a cross access easement to facilitate a future shared commercial access drive that
could connect through from Canfield Place to Cages Road.
4. Provide fence detail. Fence should be decorative black aluminum.
5. Dumpster may need to be relocated to allow for connection to south.
6. Work with staff to provide wall articulation on the proposed buildings.
7. Parking data must state the building square footage associated with each parking ratio.
8. Provide NES-approved electric service plan.
9. Show underground electric service to buildings.
10. Minimum of 75% of replacement trees must be shade type trees.
11. Provide full irrigation plan prior to building permit application.
12. The taller brick parapet should extend the full length of building 2 to screen the RTUs and to
present a better appearance to the street.
13. The south elevation of building 2 needs further refinement. Works with staff on revisions.
14. 3” caliper evergreen tree will need to have a specified height of 10-12’ ht.
15. On the building elevations, identify the different types of architectural metal panels being
proposed.
Submitted by Timothy Whitten, RLA, AICP, Assistant Planning Director (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. Please provide a roadway improvement plan for Sanders Fery Road which shows the pavement
widening and markings to be constructed along the Sanders Ferry Road frontage. The plan
should shift the existing taper for the two-way left turn lane south so that three travel lanes are
delineated along the development’s Sanders Ferry Road frontage. The pavement widening
should facilitate three 12’ lanes, though the actual lane widths may vary to provide smooth tie-
ins into the existing lane striping.
2. If stormwater detention is not provided for this development, the grading and drainage plan
must be revised such that runoff bypassing the proposed inlets remains onsite. Please provide
hydraulic routing calculations evaluating the proposed storm pipe system during the 25 year
and 100 year design storms.
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
9
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. Hendersonville Subdivision Regulations 3.7.1– Provide a utility plan that indicates the location
of the proposed hydrants, fire service main sizes, lengths, locations, weights, materials, point of
connection to city main; the sizes, types and locations of valves, valve indicators, regulators,
meters and valve pits; and the depth that the top of the pipe is laid below grade. ACTION:
Provide a utility plan that indicates the location of the proposed hydrants, fire service main
sizes, lengths, locations, weights, materials, point of connection to city main; the sizes, types
and locations of valves, valve indicators, regulators, meters and valve pits; and the depth that
the top of the pipe is laid below grade per Hendersonville Subdivision Regulations 3.7.1
2. Provide a hydrant layout that meets the fire flow requirements and identify each source and the
calculated flow rate. ACTION: Provide hydrant flow test.
3. IFC 2018 D103.5 – Gates securing the fire apparatus access road shall comply with all of the
following: gate width shall not be less than 20 feet, gates shall be swinging or sliding type,
electric gates shall be equipped with means of opening the gate by fire department personnel
for emergency access. Emergency opening devices shall be approved by the fire code official.
(Knox lock or Knox override) Methods of locking shall be submitted for approval by the fire code
official. ACTION: Meet gate requirements per code IFC 2018 D103.5: gate width shall not be
less than 20 feet, gates shall be swinging or sliding type, electric gates shall be equipped with
means of opening the gate by fire department personnel for emergency access. Emergency
opening devices shall be approved by the fire code official. (Knox lock or Knox override)
Methods of locking shall be submitted for approval by the fire code official.
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. See note on cover sheet and C5.0
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
615 Design Group, LLC | 1517 Hunt Club Blvd, Suite 300, Gallatin, TN 37066 | 615-829-6899
www.615designgroup.com
December 11, 2025
City of Hendersonville – Planning Department
101 Maple Drive North
Hendersonville, TN 37075
RE: Waiver Requests for 1 Twenty at Sanders Ferry
On behalf of our client and project team for 1 Twenty at Sanders Ferry , we respectfully submit the
following waiver requests for consideration as part of the site plan review:
1. Waiver Request – Use of Metal Siding in GC – General Commercial Zoning (Building 3)
We request approval to allow metal as a permitted siding material on Building 3 (office building) within
the GC zoning district.
Metal siding is an intentional architectural component of the proposed design and complements the
material palette of the adjacent commercial buildings. The elevations demonstrate a cohesive, high -
quality aesthetic that aligns with the City’s goals for commercial development. The front elevation of the
office building provides an articulated and visually appealing façade that supports the appropriateness of
this material in this context.
2. Waiver Request – Replacement Tree 50% Canopy Requirement
We also request a waiver from the requirement that 50% of all replacement trees be canopy species.
Due to site constraints, existing utility placement, and building/parking configuration, meeting the full
canopy tree requirement is not feasible without creating conflicts affecting long -term tree health or
project functionality. The landscape plan, however, provides a thoughtful and balanced mix of canopy and
understory trees that maintains visual quality, supports buffering, and enhances the overall character of
the development.
This requested deviation still fulfills the intent of the ordinance while accommodating practical limitations
of the site.
3. Waiver Request – Minimum 20% Pervious Area Requirement
We also request a waiver from the minimum requirement that 20% of the site be provided as pervious
area.
During the course of site design, the City of Hendersonville Fire Department required wider and more
extensive fire lanes throughout the site to meet emergency access and life -safety standards. These
requirements significantly increased the amount of paved areas on the site, making compliance with the
20% pervious area requirement infeasible at this stage of the project.
The current site layout reflects a good-faith effort to balance ordinance requirements with critical fire and
life-safety needs, and the requested waiver allows the project to move forward while maintaining
compliance with public safety standards.
615 Design Group, LLC | 1517 Hunt Club Blvd, Suite 300, Gallatin, TN 37066 | 615-829-6899
www.615designgroup.com
Thank you for your time and attention. We look forward to working with City staff throughout this process.
If you have any questions at all regarding this request, you may contact me at 615-829-6899 or at
cj@615designgroup.com.
Thank you,
CJ Murrell, P.E.
615 Design Group
1517 Hunt Club Blvd, Suite 300
Gallatin, TN 37066
1
The Planning Commission approved the concept plan for Heritage Park in October of last
year. Now, Hendersonville Parks is submitting the site plan for HPC approval. This passive
park will include walking trails, a multi-purpose facility, playground, pavilions, and 40 parking
spaces. The existing barn will be renovated.
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2025
HPC PROJECT #: SP-007014-2025
PROJECT NAME: Heritage Park
PROJECT TYPE: Site Plan
PROJECT LOCATION: 119 East Drive, Parcel 164 F 001.00
WARD: Ward 4
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
Parks is requesting a waiver from the requirement to provide landscape islands within the
proposed parking lot. The zoning ordinance requires landscape islands to be provided every
ten parking spaces and at the ends of all parking runs.
In the first image below, the areas shown in green are where landscape islands would be
required.
3
4
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
1. Indicate the proposed square footage of the multi-purpose building.
Submitted by Timothy Whitten, RLA, AICP, Assistant Planning Director (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. Please resolve comments related to stormwater quantity and quality requirements.
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. No Comments
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. See note on sheet C2-01 about fire hydrant.
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
kimley-horn.com 10 Lea Avenue, Suite 400, Nashville, TN 37210 615-564-2701
WAIVER REQUEST
To: Hendersonville Planning Department
From: Alisha Eley
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.
Date: 12/11/2025
Subject: Heritage Park: Waiver Request
Heritage Park is a proposed public park amenity using Local Parks and Recreation Fund (LPRF)
grant funding awarded to the City of Hendersonville. Amenities within the proposed park include a paved
trail, natural mowed trail, playground, multipurpose building, and an event pavilion. The design proposed
is thoughtful to provide minimal disturbance to the existing site and to consider cost effective solutions to
supply the many amenities on site while staying within the construction budget.
The design team and Parks Department would like to request the following requirement waived for the
following reasons:
1. 11.4.7 | INTERIOR PARKING LOT LANDSCAPING: The parking lot islands become a maintenance
nightmare for the Parks Department staff who is already overburdened with current maintenance needs.
The small parking lot is surrounded by landscape and will still receive some shade from the many
proposed street trees and from mature canopies of nearby existing trees. Furthermore, the waiving of the
landscape island requirement allows the site to use funds for amenities elsewhere on the site.
Sincerely,
Alisha Eley, PLA, LEED AP, ASLA
Kimley-Horn | 10 Lea Avenue, Suite 400, Nashville, TN 37210
Direct: 615.564.2713 | Mobile: 937.733.9790 | Main: 615 564 2701
RECEIVED
Dec 11 2025
PLANNING DEPT
RESUBMITTAL
1
The applicant, Grant’s Fireworks Property Management, is requesting approval for the construction of
a new warehouse facility. The proposed site for this development is the currently vacant parcel
located at 100 Jessica Lauren Court. This property is situated at the corner of Lavern Circle and
Jessica Lauren Court. The property is zoned as Heavy Commercial (HC) under the current zoning
ordinance. The property to the north, east, and west are also zoned Heavy Commercial (HC) with the
vacant property to the south being zoned Industrial (I).
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2025
HPC PROJECT #: SP-006994-2025
PROJECT NAME: Nashville Tempered Glass Warehouse
PROJECT TYPE: Site Plan
PROJECT LOCATION: 100 Jessica Lauren Ct, Parcel 146 100.00
WARD: Ward 5
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
The new building totals 12,950 square feet, consisting of 1,500 square feet of office space and
11,450 square feet of warehouse space. While 16 parking spaces are required, 17 parking
spaces are being provided.
3
4
The applicant is also requesting two waivers for the project. The first waiver is for the 60%
glazing requirement.
Commercial walls facing the street require 60% glazing. The proposal does not meet this
standard, as the wall facing Jessica Lauren Court provides only 26% glazing, and the wall facing
Lavern Circle provides only 14.5% glazing.
Waiver Request
Front facing Jessica Lauren Court
Side facing Lavern Circle
The second waiver is to permit an Overhead door facing a public street.
The developer has addressed the Zoning Ordinance requirement for additional landscaping or
screening by incorporating supplementary plantings into the site plan. Review of the building
5
elevations indicates that the area surrounding the structure features multiple overhead doors
positioned to face the street.
Waiver Request
Zoning Ordinance Requirements
In May 2019, the property at 103 and 104 Jessica Lauren Court was granted Site Plan approval
by Planning Commission. This property is to the northeast of 100 Jessica Lauren Court.
6
The following waivers were requested and granted for the property.
Waivers Granted to 103 & 104 Jessica Lauren Court in May 2019
Waiver Letter
7
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
1. The 10-foot landscape buffer on south end of property needs to be called out on the plans.
2. Electric needs to be shown on the utility plan.
3. NES approved electrical service plans are required prior to final stamping of plans.
4. Water meters need to be screen with landscaping.
5. Resolve conflict of tree and water meter by shifting tree forward.
6. Show FDC on landscape plans.
7. Full irrigation plans are required.
8. Provide dumpster elevations.
Submitted by Caitlin Shinn, Planner (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. All Comments have been resolved.
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. Hydrant flow test required before stamp.
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. Revise notes on utility sheet.
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
615 Design Group, LLC | 1517 Hunt Club Blvd, Suite 300, Gallatin, TN 37066 | 615-829-6899
www.615designgroup.com
December 11, 2025
City of Hendersonville – Planning Department
101 Maple Drive North
Hendersonville, TN 37075
RE: Waiver Requests for 100 Jessica Lauren Court
On behalf of our client, we respectfully submit this letter requesting approval of two waivers associated
with the proposed development at 100 Jessica Lauren Court . These requests are being made in
accordance with the applicable provisions of the City of Hendersonville Zoning Ordinance.
1. Waiver from 60% Glazing Requirement (Section 12.3.6.5 – Heavy Commercial Zoning)
We are requesting approval to deviate from the required 60% glazing along the primary façade. Due to
the functional needs of the building layout and the operational requirements of the end user, achieving
the full glazing percentage is not feasible. The proposed façade treatment will maintain an attractive and
cohesive design consistent with surrounding development and the intent of the zoning district.
2. Waiver to Permit an Overhead Door Facing a Public Street (Section 12.3.6.9)
We also request a waiver to allow an overhead service door to face a public street . This orientation is
necessary based on site access, building programming, and circulation requirements. The design
incorporates appropriate architectural treatments and screening measures to ensure that the door is
visually minimized and remains compatible with adjacent properties and the corridor.
We appreciate the City’s consideration of these requests and believe the proposed improvements meet
the intent of the zoning ordinance while allowing the site to function safely and effectively. Please let us
know if additional documentation, renderings, or design information is needed ahead of review.
Thank you for your time and attention. We look forward to working with City staff throughout this process.
If you have any questions at all regarding this request you may contact me at 615-829-6899 or at
cj@615designgroup.com.
Thank you,
CJ Murrell, P.E.
615 Design Group
1517 Hunt Club Blvd, Suite 300
Gallatin, TN 37066
RECEIVED
Dec 11 2025
PLANNING DEPT
RESUBMITTAL
1
UPDATE TO STAFF REPORT:
The applicant is coordinating with the Mansker Farms Homeowners Association (HOA) regarding the
proposed changes. As of the date of this staff report, the HOA Board has not provided a formal
response but has confirmed in writing that a decision will be available prior to the January 6, 2026,
Planning Commission meeting.
AGENDA DATE: January 6th, 2025
HPC PROJECT #: SUB-006966-2025
PROJECT NAME: Mansker Farms Ph 18 Sec 1 Setback Deviation
PROJECT TYPE: Final Plat
PROJECT LOCATION: 124 Manor Way, Parcel 1144I N 020.00
WARD: Ward 3
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
HOA Letter Confirmation
October 29, 2025 Staff Report:
The applicant, Wilson Bank & Trust, is requesting multiple deviations for the property located at
124 Manor Way. This parcel is situated within the Mansker Farm Planned Development, Phase
18, Section 1.
Mansker Farms Planned Development has the required minimum building setbacks of 30’ front
setback, 5’ side setback, and rear setback of 10’ and required maximum lot coverage
allowance of 30%. Lot coverage is a portion of a lot that is occupied by buildings or structures,
including accessory structures, expressed as a percentage of the total lot area.
Properties to the west and south of the subject parcel are currently undeveloped. To the east,
the property falls within Phase 19 Section 1A of the Mansker Farm development, which is
actively under construction. Immediately beyond this property to the east, the area along the
road is designated open space.
3
Historical Context
The property was initially purchased by an individual who successfully applied for the original
variances from the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). The current applicant, Wilson Bank & Trust,
has recently acquired the property back from the original owner and is now seeking to rectify
the construction errors made by the previous owner.
In December 2021, the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) granted several variances for this
property:
1. A variance reducing the south/rear building setback from 10 feet to 7.9 feet for the
main residence.
2. A variance reducing the setback for a retaining wall over 5 feet tall from 5 feet to 1
foot, with the stipulation that footers could not trespass onto an adjacent
property.
3. A variance increasing the maximum lot coverage from 30% to 38%.
4
Since the 2021 BZA approval, Staff has determined that, as this property lies within a Planned
Development, any further changes or deviations must be reviewed and approved by the
Planning Commission.
Exhibit for BZA Variance Approval
5
Existing Conditions
Existing Conditions
6
Proposed Requested Deviations
The applicant is now requesting approval for the following additional deviations:
Existing Conditions
Building Setback Encroachments:
1. Front Setback: To allow the front building wall to encroach 1.8 feet over the required front
setback, which would establish a new front building setback of 28.2 feet. (See image 1 on page
6.)
2. Right Side Setback: To allow the right building wall to encroach 0.23 feet over the required
right-side setback, which would establish a new right-side building setback to be 4.77 feet. (See
image 1 on page 6.)
3. Rear Setback: To allow the rear building wall to encroach 1.9 feet over the previously amended
rear setback of 7.9 feet by BZA, which would establish a new rear building setback of 6 feet. (See
image 2 on page 6.)
7
Image 1
Image 2
8
Accessory Structure Encroachments:
4. HVAC Unit: To allow the HVAC to encroach 0.4 feet into the allowed 70% encroachment. 70%
of the required 5’ setback is 3.5 feet. The new encroachment for the HVAC would be 80% at 1
foot from the property line. (See image 2 on page 6)
5. Retaining Wall: A deviation is requested to allow a retaining wall over 5 feet in height to be
placed along the property line and driveway, instead of the required 5-foot separation distance.
See image below.
Newly Proposed Driveway with retaining wall
9
Lot Coverage:
The last request is in regards to the requirements of Mansker Farm Planned Development that a
maximum of 30% of the lot maybe covered by buildings or structures. For this lot, 30% would
10
be 2,993 square feet for all allowed structures or buildings on the property. The Board of
Zoning Appeals granted an increase in the lot coverage from 30% to 38%, which changed the
allowed square footage to 3,791. The house was built with 3,985 square feet, which is 40% lot
coverage, which is a difference of 194 square feet and a 2% increase from the allowed lot
coverage. The applicant is requesting the additional 2% lot coverage, bringing the total
requested lot coverage to 40%.
11
The proposal includes the removal of the existing front driveway and sidewalk to facilitate the
construction of the new driveway and access point.
Demo Plan
Right Side of Home – Stairs and HVAC encroach into setbacks
12
Rear of home – existing wall is over property line
Left side of home from rear view
13
End of 3-car garage and existing sidewalk/stairs
STAFF COMMENTS – PLANNING DEPARTMENT: 2
1. When removing old driveway, the sidewalk and curb will need to be restored.
Submitted by Caitlin Shinn, Planner (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – PUBLIC WORKS: 3
1. See Markups.
Submitted by Stephen Winzenread, PE, Assistant Public Works Director/City Engineer (December
17th, 2025)
14
STAFF COMMENTS – FIRE DEPARTMENT: 4
1. No comments.
Submitted by Chris Willyard, Deputy Fire Marshal (December 17th, 2025)
STAFF COMMENTS – UTILITY DISTRICT: 5
1. No Comments
Submitted by David Brigance, HUD Construction Supervisor (December 17th, 2025)
CORNERSTONE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
SURVEYING
120 Main Street Portland, TN 37148
(T): 615-864-0940
Violations/Exceptions Summary for 124 Manor Way
Violations being addressed with proposed improvements:
1. Rear retaining wall being relocated entirely onto subject property and
built to meet code requirements.
2. Western stairs reconfigured to have landing on property and meet
building code.
3. Sidewalk in ROW to be extended to property line to meet subdivision
regulation requirements.
4. Existing driveway and roadside retaining walls to be removed,
reconfigured and reconstructed to allow for more vehicular friendly
access and address several code issues.
5. Existing sidewalk along front of house to be removed to address code
issues.
Exception being requested in order of priority:
1. Building Setback Encroachment #1: Front setback (1.8’)
2. Building Setback Encroachment #2: Right Side setback (0.23’)
3. Building Setback Encroachment #3: Rear setback (1.9’)
4. Accessory Structure Encroachment #5: Retaining Wall
5. Accessory Structure Encroachment #4: HVAC Unit
Impact fees are defined as one-time charges levied by local governments on new development.
They are charged to developers to help municipalities recover infrastructure and public service
costs. These collected fees are often used by agencies to mitigate the impacts that new
developments incur with respect to traffic congestion, infrastructure (water, sewer, traffic signals),
public parks, public safety and more.
Impact fees are commonly used by cities across the nation. The State of Tennessee allows
municipalities to impose impact fees on new development. The City of Hendersonville’s charter
also establishes the City’s authority to enact impact fees, subject to the Board’s adoption.
Cities in close proximity to Hendersonville that have implemented impact fees, include but are not
limited to: Franklin, Murfreesboro, La Vergne, Smyrna and White House.
The City has discussed impact fees at BOMA meetings, committee meetings and at standalone
public workshops. In 2019, BOMA voted not to enact impact fees at that time primarily due to the
potential impact on commercial and industrial development in the city limits, as opposed to
neighboring cities with no commercial impact fees. As such, at no time has the City ever had a
formal impact fee. However, at times some developments have offered the City voluntary fees
which were accepted, but no formal fee has ever been required.
Impact fees differ for residential and nonresidential use. Residential use includes single-family
dwellings (including townhomes) and multi-family dwellings. The only difference, from an impact
study perspective, between single-family and multi-family dwellings is the higher occupancy rate
of 2.56 per single-family dwelling versus the occupancy rate of 1.65 per multi-family
dwelling. The higher occupancy rate of single-family dwellings equates to more demand (use) on
the system and therefore the fee would reflect the mathematical equity according to occupancy
rate. Nonresidential uses include commercial, office, industrial and institutional. Fees for
nonresidential uses are based on the demand that those types of uses/developments typically
generate. For example, impact fees are higher for commercial development (shopping center)
versus industrial development (manufacturing plant) due to the increased traffic (vehicle trips)
and demand on city services that commercial uses produce vs. industrial uses.
The attached Impact Fee Study is being used as the basis for developing two differing Ordinances
(one for Residential Fees only and one for Residential + Commercial fees). The Impact Fee Study
identified the maximum allowable impact fees for various development types to ensure new
development pays its fair share of infrastructure costs.
AGENDA DATE: January 6, 2026
RESOLUTION/ORDINANCE # WILL BE ASSIGNED IF MOVED TO GC OR BOMA
HPC PROJECT #: N/A
PROJECT NAME: Development Impact Fees
PROJECT TYPE: N/A
PROJECT LOCATION: Citywide
WARD: All
STAFF REPORT: 1
FINAL STAFF
REPORT &
COMMENTS
2
BOMA is currently seeking the opinion of the Planning Commission on pursuing Development
Impact Fees for the City of Hendersonville and welcomes a discussion between members of the
Commission to come to a consensus in support of or against the fees.
FISCAL IMPACT: 2
Revenue generated by impact fees is only eligible for use on capital expenditures that mitigate
impacts of new developments. Total revenue collections are determined by the level of activity but
can be calculated for residential by multiplying the number of residential units built by the amount of
the fee and for nonresidential by multiplying the square footage/1,000 by fee amount.
DISCUSSION: 3
MOTION AND VOTE:
ATTACHMENTS: 4
1. October 29, 2025, Impact Fee Study - Public Safety & Transportation
2. January 26, 2024, Impact Fee Report - Parks
Impact Fee Study Prepared for: City of Hendersonville, Tennessee October 29, 2025
4701 Sangamore Road Suite S240 Bethesda, MD (301) 320-6900 www.TischlerBise.com
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee [PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ................................................................................................................ 3 Tennessee Legal Framework ............................................................................................................ 3 General Legal Framework ................................................................................................................. 3 General Methodologies .................................................................................................................... 5 Cost Recovery (Past Improvements) .................................................................................................... 5 Incremental Expansion (Concurrent Improvements) ........................................................................... 5 Plan-Based (Future Improvements) ..................................................................................................... 6 Conceptual Impact fee Calculation ................................................................................................... 6 Credits ............................................................................................................................................. 6 Proposed Impact Fee Components ................................................................................................... 7 Proposed Impact Fees ...................................................................................................................... 8 Fire ......................................................................................................................................... 9 Methodology ................................................................................................................................... 9 Proportionate Share ......................................................................................................................... 9 Service Units .................................................................................................................................. 10 Residential .......................................................................................................................................... 10 Nonresidential .................................................................................................................................... 11 Fire Facilities – Incremental Expansion ........................................................................................... 12 Existing Standards and Cost Factors ................................................................................................... 12 Projected Demand .............................................................................................................................. 13 Fire Apparatus – Incremental Expansion ........................................................................................ 14 Existing Standards and Cost Factors ................................................................................................... 14 Projected Demand .............................................................................................................................. 16 Impact Fee Study – Plan-Based ....................................................................................................... 16 Debt Credit .................................................................................................................................... 17 Proposed Fire Impact Fees ............................................................................................................. 18 Projected Revenue from Fire Impact Fees ...................................................................................... 19 Police .................................................................................................................................... 20 Methodology ................................................................................................................................. 20 Proportionate Share ....................................................................................................................... 20 Service Units .................................................................................................................................. 21 Residential .......................................................................................................................................... 21 Nonresidential .................................................................................................................................... 22 Police Facilities – Incremental Expansion ........................................................................................ 22 Existing Standards and Cost Factors ................................................................................................... 22 Projected Demand .............................................................................................................................. 24 Police Vehicles – Incremental Expansion ........................................................................................ 25 Existing Standards and Cost Factors ................................................................................................... 25 Projected Demand .............................................................................................................................. 26 Impact Fee Study – Plan-Based ....................................................................................................... 26 Proposed Police Impact Fees .......................................................................................................... 27 Projected Revenue from Police Impact Fees ................................................................................... 28 Transportation ...................................................................................................................... 29
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
ii
Methodology ................................................................................................................................. 29 Proportionate Share ....................................................................................................................... 29 Vehicle Trip Generation Rates and Adjustments ............................................................................. 29 Residential Trip Generation Rates ...................................................................................................... 29 Nonresidential Trip Generation Rates ................................................................................................ 30 Trip Rate Adjustments ........................................................................................................................ 30 Commuter Trip Adjustment ............................................................................................................... 31 Adjustment for Pass-By Trips ............................................................................................................. 31 Average Weekday Vehicle Trips ......................................................................................................... 32 Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) ......................................................................................................... 33 National Average Trip Length ............................................................................................................. 33 Expected Vehicle Miles Traveled ........................................................................................................ 33 Actual Vehicle Miles Traveled ............................................................................................................ 34 Local Adjustment Factor ..................................................................................................................... 35 Local Trip Lengths ............................................................................................................................... 35 Local Vehicle Miles Traveled .............................................................................................................. 35 Street Network Capacity and Usage ................................................................................................... 36 Projected VMT ............................................................................................................................... 37 Capacity Improvements – Incremental Expansion .......................................................................... 38 Development Fee Report – Plan-Based ........................................................................................... 38 Proposed Transportation Impact Fees ............................................................................................ 39 Projected Revenue from Transportation Impact Fees ..................................................................... 40 Appendix A: Land Use Assumptions ...................................................................................... 41 Residential Development ............................................................................................................... 41 Persons Per Housing Unit ................................................................................................................... 41 Existing Population and Housing Units ............................................................................................... 42 Projected Population and Housing Units ............................................................................................ 42 Nonresidential Development ......................................................................................................... 43 Existing Employment and Floor Area ................................................................................................. 44 Projected Employment and Floor Area .............................................................................................. 44 Development Projections ............................................................................................................... 46 Appendix B: Land Use Definitions ......................................................................................... 47 Residential Development ............................................................................................................... 47 Nonresidential Development ......................................................................................................... 48
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The City of Hendersonville, Tennessee, retained TischlerBise to prepare this study to analyze the impacts of development on City capital facilities and to calculate impact fees based on that analysis. Through interviews and discussions with City staff, TischlerBise developed the proposed impact fees discussed in this study. Methodologies and calculations are presented in this report as supporting documentation for an update to the Impact Fee program in the City of Hendersonville. Impact fees are collected from new construction at the time a building permit is issued and used to construct system improvements needed to accommodate new development. An impact fee represents future development’s proportionate share of capital facility needs. Impact fees do have limitations and should not be regarded as the total solution for infrastructure funding. Rather, they are one component of a comprehensive funding strategy to ensure provision of adequate public facilities. Impact fees may only be used for capital improvements or debt service for growth-related infrastructure. In contrast to general taxes, impact fees may not be used for operations, maintenance, replacement of infrastructure, or correcting existing deficiencies. This update of Hendersonville’s impact fees includes the following components: 1. Fire 2. Police 3. Transportation Tennessee Legal Framework While the State of Tennessee does not have specific authorizing legislation for impact fees, the State does grant the power for municipalities with a mayor-aldermanic charter to impose impact fees on new development. As a mayor-aldermanic charter city, the City of Hendersonville may: “Establish, open, relocate, vacate, alter, widen, extend, grade, improve, repair, construct, reconstruct, maintain, light, sprinkle and clean public highways, streets, boulevards, parkways, sidewalks, alleys, parks, public grounds, public facilities, libraries and squares, wharves, bridges, viaducts, subways, tunnels, sewers and drains within or without the corporate limits, regulate their use within the corporate limits, assess fees for the use of or impact upon such property and facilities, and take and appropriate property therefor under § 7-31-107 -- 7-31-111 and § 29-16-203, or any other manner provided by general laws.” (Tenn. Code Ann. § 6-2-201 (15)) General Legal Framework Both state and federal courts have recognized the imposition of impact fees as a legitimate form of land use regulation, provided the fees meet standards intended to protect against regulatory takings. Land use regulations, development exactions, and impact fees are subject to the Fifth Amendment prohibition on taking of private property for public use without just compensation. To comply with the Fifth Amendment, development regulations must be shown to substantially advance a legitimate governmental interest. In the case of impact fees, that interest is in the protection of public health, safety, and welfare by ensuring development is not detrimental to the quality of essential public services. The means to this end are also important, requiring both procedural and substantive due process. The process followed to receive
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
4
community input (i.e., stakeholder meetings, work sessions, and public hearings) provides opportunities for comments and refinements to the impact fees. There is little federal case law specifically dealing with impact fees, although other rulings on other types of exactions (e.g., land dedication requirements) are relevant. In one of the most important exaction cases, the U. S. Supreme Court found that a government agency imposing exactions on development must demonstrate an “essential nexus” between the exaction and the interest being protected (see Nollan v. California Coastal Commission, 1987). In a more recent case (Dolan v. City of Tigard, OR, 1994), the Court ruled that an exaction must also be “roughly proportional” to the burden created by development. However, the Dolan decision appeared to set a higher standard of review for mandatory dedications of land than for monetary exactions such as impact fees. There are three reasonable relationship requirements for impact fees that are closely related to “rational nexus”, or “reasonable relationship” requirements enunciated by a number of state courts. Although the term “dual rational nexus” is often used to characterize the standard by which courts evaluate the validity of impact fees under the U.S. Constitution, we prefer a more rigorous formulation that recognizes three elements: “need,” “benefit,” and “proportionality.” The dual rational nexus test explicitly addresses only the first two, although proportionality is reasonably implied, and was specifically mentioned by the U.S. Supreme Court in the Dolan case. Individual elements of the nexus standard are discussed further in the following paragraphs. All new development in a community creates additional demands on some, or all, public facilities provided by local government. If the capacity of facilities is not increased to satisfy that additional demand, the quality or availability of public services for the entire community will deteriorate. Impact fees may be used to recover the cost of development-related facilities, but only to the extent that the need for facilities is a consequence of development that is subject to the fees. The Nollan decision reinforced the principle that development exactions may be used only to mitigate conditions created by the developments upon which they are imposed. That principle clearly applies to impact fees. In this study, the impact of development on infrastructure needs is analyzed in terms of quantifiable relationships between various types of development and the demand for specific capital facilities, based on applicable level-of-service standards. The requirement that exactions be proportional to the impacts of development was clearly stated by the U.S. Supreme Court in the Dolan case and is logically necessary to establish a proper nexus. Proportionality is established through the procedures used to identify development-related facility costs, and in the methods used to calculate impact fees for various types of facilities and categories of development. The demand for capital facilities is measured in terms of relevant and measurable attributes of development (e.g., a typical housing unit’s average weekday vehicle trips). A sufficient benefit relationship requires that impact fee revenues be segregated from other funds and expended only on the facilities for which the fees were charged. Impact fees must be expended in a timely manner and the facilities funded by the fees must serve the development paying the fees. However, nothing in the U.S. Constitution or the state enabling legislation requires that facilities funded with fee revenues be available exclusively to development paying the fees. In other words, benefit may extend to a general area including multiple real estate developments. Procedures for the earmarking and
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
5
expenditure of fee revenues are discussed near the end of this study. All of these procedural as well as substantive issues are intended to ensure that new development benefits from the impact fees they are required to pay. The authority and procedures to implement impact fees is separate from and complementary to the authority to require improvements as part of subdivision or zoning review. As documented in this report, the City of Hendersonville has complied with applicable legal precedents. Impact fees are proportionate and reasonably related to the capital improvement demands of new development. Specific costs have been identified using local data and current dollars. With input from City staff, TischlerBise identified demand indicators for each type of infrastructure and calculated proportionate share factors to allocate costs by type of development. This report documents the formulas and input variables used to calculate the impact fees for each type of public facility. Impact fee methodologies also identify the extent to which new development is entitled to various types of credits to avoid potential double payment of growth-related capital costs. General Methodologies There are three general methodologies for calculating impact fees. The choice of a particular methodology depends primarily on the timing of infrastructure construction (past, concurrent, or future) and service characteristics of the facility type being addressed. Each methodology has advantages and disadvantages in a particular situation, and can be used simultaneously for different cost components. Reduced to its simplest terms, the process of calculating impact fees involves two main steps: (1) determining the cost of development-related capital improvements and (2) allocating those costs equitably to various types of development. In practice, though, the calculation of impact fees can become quite complicated because of the many variables involved in defining the relationship between development and the need for facilities within the designated service area. The following paragraphs discuss three basic methodologies for calculating impact fees and how those methodologies can be applied. Cost Recovery (Past Improvements) The rationale for recoupment, often called cost recovery, is that future development is paying for its share of the useful life and remaining capacity of facilities already built, or land already purchased, from which future development will benefit. This methodology is often used for utility systems that must provide adequate capacity before future development can take place. Incremental Expansion (Concurrent Improvements) The incremental expansion methodology documents current level-of-service (LOS) standards for each type of public facility, using both quantitative and qualitative measures. This approach assumes there are no deficiencies or surplus capacity in existing infrastructure, and future development is paying only its proportionate share for growth-related infrastructure. Revenue will be used to expand or provide additional facilities, as needed, to accommodate future development. An incremental expansion cost methodology is best suited for public facilities that will be expanded in regular increments to keep pace with development.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
6
Plan-Based (Future Improvements) The plan-based methodology allocates costs for a specified set of improvements to a specified amount of development. Improvements are typically identified in a long-range facility plan and development potential is identified by a land use plan. There are two options for determining the cost per demand unit: (1) total cost of a public facility can be divided by total demand units (average cost), or (2) the growth-share of the public facility cost can be divided by the net increase in demand units over the planning timeframe (marginal cost). Conceptual Impact fee Calculation In contrast to project-level improvements, impact fees fund growth-related infrastructure that will benefit multiple development projects, or the entire jurisdiction (referred to as system improvements). The first step is to determine an appropriate demand indicator for the particular type of infrastructure. The demand indicator measures the number of demand units for each unit of development. For example, an appropriate indicator of the demand for park facilities is population growth, and the increase in population can be estimated from the average number of residents per housing unit. The second step in the impact fee formula is to determine infrastructure units per demand unit, typically called level-of-service (LOS) standards. In keeping with the parks example, a common LOS standard is park amenities per resident. The third step in the impact fee formula is the cost of various infrastructure units. To complete the parks example, this part of the formula would establish the cost for purchasing and/or constructing new park amenities. Credits Regardless of the methodology, a consideration of credits is integral to the development of a legally defensible impact fee. There are two types of credits that should be addressed in impact fee studies and ordinances. The first is a revenue credit due to possible double payment situations, which could occur when other revenues may contribute to the capital costs of infrastructure covered by the impact fee. This type of credit is integrated into the fee calculation, thus reducing the fee amount. The second is a site-specific credit or developer reimbursement for dedication of land or construction of system improvements. An example would be if a developer builds a park with improvements and dedicates to the City. This type of credit is addressed in the administration and implementation of the development fee program. For ease of administration, TischlerBise normally recommends developer reimbursements for system improvements.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
7
Proposed Impact Fee Components Figure 1 summarizes service areas, methodologies, and cost components for the proposed fees. Figure 1: Proposed Service Areas, Methodologies, and Cost Components
Calculations throughout this report are based on an analysis conducted using Excel software. Most results are discussed in the report using two, three, and four decimal places, which represent rounded figures. However, the analysis itself uses figures carried to their ultimate decimal places; therefore, the sums and products generated in the analysis may not equal the sum or product if the reader replicates the calculation with the factors shown in the report (due to the rounding of figures shown, not in the analysis).
!"#"$$%F'()*+,-#(
."FI-#"$
."FI-#"(
0F"%
12$3(
4"#2I"F'
56#F"7"63%,(
89:%6$-26 ),%6;<%$"= 12$3(
0,,2#%3-26
>-F" 1-3'?-=" !@0 >-F"(>%#-,-3-"$A(>-F"(
0::%F%3*$
B"I",2:7"63(>""(
4":2F3
)2:*,%3-26A
C"M-#,"(NF-:$
)2,-#" 1-3'?-=" !@0 )2,-#"(>%#-,-3-"$A(
)2,-#"(C"M-#,"$
B"I",2:7"63(>""(
4":2F3
)2:*,%3-26A
C"M-#,"(NF-:$
NF%6$:2F3%3-26 1-3'?-=" !@0 .3F""3(
57:F2I"7"63$
B"I",2:7"63(>""(
4":2F3 CFN
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
8
Proposed Impact Fees Proposed impact fees will be assessed per dwelling unit for residential development, and per 1,000 square feet of floor area for nonresidential development. The proposed impact fees represent the maximum allowable amount feasible for each development type, and this represents future development’s fair share of the cost for the appropriate capital facilities. Hendersonville may adopt fees that are less than the amounts shown; however, a reduction in impact fee revenue will necessitate an increase in other revenues, a decrease in planned capital improvements, and/or a decrease in level-of-service standards. All costs in the Impact Fee Study represent current dollars with no assumed inflation over time. If costs change significantly over time, impact fees should be recalculated. Figure 2: Proposed Impact Fees
!"#$%F'()*"%+ ,-.-I0 ,123 ,-4.051 ,-6.1I-
78%9":()*"%+ ,336 ,;65 ,3.3;2 ,0.I;4
<#=8>9?")% ,553 ,-02 ,6.3I6 ,5.5-;
@A**F?B")% ,-.360 ,I;0 ,I.23- ,-6.6;3
CMM"BF'N'C9FF?'!F?G"BF> ,313 ,;6- ,1.53- ,3.22I
<#>9"989"A#)% ,-.42; ,23I ,0.315 ,-4.5I1
H?AIA>F=
(FF>
JF>"=F#9")%'(FF>'IF?'O#"9
LA#?F>"=F#9")%'(FF>'IF?'-.444'!M8)?F'(FF9
HA%"BF !9?FF9 H?AIA>F=
(FF>
O#"9'!"NF
OFGF%AI*F#9'P+IF
HA%"BF !9?FF9("?F
("?F
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
9
FIRE Methodology The fire impact fee includes components for fire facilities, fire apparatus, the cost of calculating the fire impact fees, and a credit for existing fire debt. Fire impact fees are based on the incremental expansion methodology for facilities and apparatus and the plan-based methodology for the cost of calculating fire impact fees. Costs are allocated to both residential and nonresidential development using different demand indicators for each type of development. Residential impact fees are calculated on a per capita basis, then converted to an appropriate amount for each type of housing unit based on persons per housing unit factors. Nonresidential impact fees are calculated using nonresidential vehicle trips. Trip generation rates are highest for commercial/retail development and lowest for industrial development, whereas trip rates for office/institutional development fall between the other two categories. Using vehicle trip rates ensures that impact fees are consistent with the relative demand for fire services from nonresidential development. Proportionate Share TischlerBise recommends functional population to allocate the cost of fire infrastructure to residential and nonresidential development. Functional population is similar to what the U.S. Census Bureau calls "daytime population.” This approach accounts for people living and working in a jurisdiction, but it also considers commuting patterns and time spent at home and at nonresidential locations. OnTheMap is a web-based mapping and reporting application that shows where workers are employed and where they live. It describes geographic patterns of jobs by their employment locations and residential locations as well as the connections between the two locations. OnTheMap was developed through a unique partnership between the U.S. Census Bureau and its Local Employment Dynamics (LED) partner states. Residents that do not work are assigned 20 hours per day to residential development and 4 hours per day to nonresidential development (annualized averages). Residents that work in Hendersonville are assigned 14 hours to residential development and 10 hours to nonresidential development. Residents that work outside Hendersonville are assigned 14 hours to residential development. Inflow commuters are assigned 10 hours to nonresidential development. Based on 2022 functional population data for Hendersonville, the most recent year available, the cost allocation for residential development is 76 percent while nonresidential development accounts for 24 percent of the demand for fire infrastructure.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
10
Figure F1: Functional Population
Service Units Residential The “service unit” used for residential development is persons per housing unit (PPHU). This is a measure of, on average, the number of persons residing in each housing unit. As shown in Figure F2, there are 2.56 persons per single family unit and 1.65 persons per multifamily unit. Factors have been calculate based on data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2023 ACS 5-year estimates (further discussed in Appendix A). Figure F2: Persons Per Housing Unit (PPHU)
!"#$%"&'$() !"#$%& '"()*%
+*H$-.'*/0-$H1*% 234563 7*0()8!$9 7*0()
J")1&"%H).;*H.<*(=1%L 5342?? 6@ 2554A2@
B#/-*9"&.J")1&"%H) 6C4255
B#/-*9"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 54??@ 3N FN456@
B#/-*9"&.*0H)1&".7"%&"()*%M1--" 6F4AF5 3N 52@4FN6
J")1&"%H1$-.G0HH*H$-34@N?4266
!"#$%"&'$()*+,(-" ./0
12&-"#$%"&'$()
;*%IJ*(=1%L.J")1&"%H) 5342?? N 3624AF6
O*H).L*M$H"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 6@422A
J")1&"%H).B#/-*9"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 54??@ 3@ 5?4?@@
;*%IJ")1&"%H.<*(="().N1%O-*J.M*##0H"()P 324A?A 3@ 32A4?A@
;*%(")1&"%H1$-.G0HH*H$- 5554N66
12&-"#$%"&'$()*+,(-" 340
+*H$-345?64@NN
5"6(&%*7&$'#*$&*3833
G*0(M"Q.RSGS.T"%)0).U0("$04.V%+P"X$/.Y//-1M$H1*%.$%&.LB7!.V(1L1%I!")H1%$H1*%.B#/-*9#"%H.GH$H1)H1M)4.
R"()1*%.2S65SN.N"#/-*9#"%HPS
!"#$%F'()*"%+ H-./
01%2"3()*"%+ 4-/.
4-'!FF'5)#6'78F'9881*:2";#8
<F=F%;:*F#2'L+:F ?F@8;#8':F@'
A;18"#$'7#"24
BF8"6F#2")%'<F=F%;:*F#2':F@'7#"2
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
11
Nonresidential TischlerBise recommends using nonresidential vehicle trips as the nonresidential service unit for fire infrastructure. Average weekday vehicle trip ends for nonresidential development are from the 11th edition of the reference book, Trip Generation, published in 2021 by the Institute of Transportation Engineers. A trip end represents a vehicle either entering or exiting a development (as if a traffic counter were placed across a driveway). Trip ends for nonresidential development are calculated per thousand square feet. The basic trip adjustment factor is 50 percent for all nonresidential development except commercial and institutional. For commercial and institutional development, the trip adjustment factor is less than 50 percent because retail uses attract vehicles as they pass by on arterial and collector roads. For example, when someone stops at a convenience store on the way home from work, the convenience store is not the primary destination. For an average size shopping center, the ITE (2017) indicates that on average 34 percent of the vehicles that enter are passing by on their way to some other primary destination. The remaining 66 percent of attraction trips have the shopping center as their primary destination. Because attraction trips are half of all trips, the trip adjustment factor (0.66 X 0.50 = 0.33) is approximately 33 percent of the trip ends. Using the current estimates of nonresidential square footage, TischlerBise applies the trip generation rates and adjustment factors to calculate average weekday vehicle trips for nonresidential development in Hendersonville. TischlerBise estimates that there are 69,915 average weekday vehicle trips attributable to existing nonresidential development in Hendersonville. Figure F3: Current Estimate of Nonresidential Vehicle Trips
!"#"$%F'"() !"# *+, -#.I01234 +56F 7879 7879
+4F" :(6) ;%2" K+, -2=>?)'"() !"#I:(6)?K"@I+56F?
*(2>?)563$ ABC DD8 NFG9 98H !"#$ 7IG9J OI998
;%''"5L63$ ABC J78 MGF8D MMH %!"!% MID8D MGIJGG
NOO6L"IPIN)@"5IB"5#6L"? ABC GD8 D8FJN 98H &"'! DIQ8J D8IMND
*(?)6)>)6%(3$ ABC 978 77F9Q MMH ("'& 7I8M7 D9IDNG
+%)3$IR%(5"?62"()63$I+56F? )*+*%&
-2=>?)"2I
01234IK+,
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
12
Fire Facilities – Incremental Expansion Existing Standards and Cost Factors Hendersonville currently provides 53,357 square feet of fire facilities to existing development and plans to maintain the existing level of service by constructing additional fire facilities to serve future development. To allocate the proportionate share of demand to residential and nonresidential development, this analysis uses proportionate share factors shown in Figure F1. Hendersonville’s existing LOS for residential development is 0.6062 square feet per person (53,357 square feet X 76 percent residential share / 66,898 persons). The nonresidential level of service is 0.1832 square feet per vehicle trip (53,357 square feet X 24 percent nonresidential share / 69,915 vehicle trips). Based on recent fire station construction costs in Tennessee this analysis uses a construction cost estimate of $450 per square foot. For fire facilities, the cost is $272.78 per person (0.6062 square feet per person X $450 per square foot) and $82.42 per vehicle trip (0.1832 square feet per vehicle trip X $450 per square foot). Figure F4: Existing Standards for Fire Facilities
!"#$%F'(F)* +H-.%"/0""(
+(.(F)*/1 23445
+(.(F)*/6 123275
+(.(F)*/8 43282
+(.(F)*/2 83655
+(.(F)*/9 :3892
+(.(F)*/7 73555
+(.(F)*/: ;356;
<)(.= 98389:
L)#(/'"%/+H-.%"/0))( ?295
@AF#(F*B/+H-.%"/0""( 98389:
C"#FD"*(F.=/+N.%" :7F
6569/G)'-=.(F)* 7734;4
+H-.%"/0""(/'"%/G"%#)* 5H7576
L)#(/'"%/G"%#)* ?6:6H:4
I)*%"#FD"*(F.=/+N.%" 62F
6569/J"NF$="/<%F'# 7;3;19
+H-.%"/0""(/'"%/J"NF$="/<%F' 5H1486
L)#(/'"%/J"NF$="/<%F' ?46H26
+)-%$"O/L"*D"%#)*MF=="/0F%"/!"'.%(N"*(
O"M"=P)QP+"%MF$"/ROS+T/+(.*D.%D#
C"#FD"*(F.=
L)#(/0.$()%#
I)*%"#FD"*(F.=
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
13
Projected Demand Hendersonville plans to maintain the existing level of service for fire facilities over the next 10 years. Based on a projected population increase of 10,455 persons, future residential development demands approximately 6,338 square feet of fire facilities (10,455 additional persons X 0.6062 square feet per person). With projected nonresidential growth of 9,478 vehicle trips, future nonresidential development demands approximately 1,736 square feet of fire facilities (9,478 additional vehicle trips X 0.1832 square feet per vehicle trip). The growth-related cost of fire facilities is $3,633,057 (8,073 square feet X $450 per square foot). Figure F5: Growth-Related Need for Fire Facilities
!"#$%FG(%)* +,-*G."IG01G2*
345356017$I"G2""* ."IG8"I-,%
349:;6017$I"G2""* ."IG<"=)L?"G@I).
A"-)F"%*)$? B,%I"-)F"%*)$? @,*$?
636C 55D:N: 5NDN9C F3DCC9 96D:35 C;D;CG
6365 5GDNF; G3D:3; F9D9:C 96DN5: CFD9C;
636G 5:DN:N G9DG3; F9D:9N 9;D9;; CFDNC6
636: G3D3;F G6D595 F6DFC; 9;D;33 CCDGC;
636N G9D3:3 G;DCF6 F;D3:5 9;DFG3 C5DCC5
63;3 G6D96C GFDF:6 F;DG63 9;D5F6 CGD;56
63;9 G;D9G9 GCDF;5 FFD;CF 9;D:9G C:D9G9
63;6 GFD695 G5DF3F FFDN:: 9;DNNF C:DN:6
63;; GCD656 GGD;:5 FCD569 9FD9GF CNDGNC
63;F G5D;3G G:D;:6 F5D6CC 9FD;C5 53D596
63;C GGD;C; GND;N; F5D::N 9FDCF6 59DF;3
H%LI"$-" 93DFCC NDFG: 5D;;: 9DG;5 :D3G;
I6D:C9D:GG IG:9D9:3 I;D5;;D3CG
@J."G,KGH%KI$-*I7L*7I" L"M"?G,KG0"IM)L"
!"#$%FGK,IG2)I"G2$L)?)*)"-
NI,O*=PA"?$*"FGQR."%F)*7I"-
2)I"G2$L)?)*)"- IFC3
S"$I 8,.7?$*),%<"=)L?"G@I).- 017$I"G2""*
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
14
Fire Apparatus – Incremental Expansion Existing Standards and Cost Factors Hendersonville currently provides 36 units of fire apparatus to existing development and plans to maintain the existing level of service by acquiring additional apparatus to serve future development. Based on costs provided by staff, the weighted average cost of the existing fleet is $554,613 per unit. The analysis uses this cost as a proxy for future apparatus costs. Figure F6: Existing Fire Apparatus Inventory
!"#$%F'(F)* +*F(# +*F(H-)#( .)(I0H-)#(
1222H34"%F$I*H5I60"H784'"% 1 922J;2K= 922J;2K=
.I$(F$I0HL"#$8"H.%IF0"% 1 92;??? 92;???
@"(HABF# J 9C?;??? 9K?;???
J??=H5MN*"H784'"%H-8#()4H-FI##F# 1 9G=H;??? 9G=H;???
J?11H5MN*"H1??IH70I(J)%4HOILL"%H.%8$B 1 9J;???;??? 9J;???;???
J?1JH-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL)HJH?? 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?1JH-F"M%)0"(H.IF)" 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?1JH5MN*"H784'"%H-8#()4H-FI##F# 1 921?;??? 921?;???
-OLP5HQF%"RL"#$8"HO)I(HSCCMQ.T 1 9N??;??? 9N??;???
1JHQ(UHLF6FLHV800HP*J0I(IX0"HO)I(HYF(FHR)()% J 9JJ;??? 9NN;???
J?1CH5MN*"H.['F))*H784'"%H 1 922J;2K= 922J;2K=
J?1CH5MN*"H-[$0)*"H1??IHOILL"%H.%8$B 1 91;222;HKH 91;222;HKH
J?1HH-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL) J 92H;??? 912?;???
J?1HHA+.7V5PH5*6F*"H 1 922J;2K= 922J;2K=
J?1HHA'I%(I* 1 91;1??;??? 91;1??;???
J?1KH\IYI#IBFHR80"H 1 91K;??? 91K;???
J?1=H-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL) J 9NK;=?C 92C;N?K
J?1GH-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL)H1H?? J 9NK;=?C 92C;N?K
J?1GH7F"%$"H5*J)%$"%H784'"% J 91;2GH;2CN 9C;2=1;GKG
J?12H-F"M%)0"(H.IF)" 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?12H-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL)H1H?? 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?J1H-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL)HJH?? 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?JJHQ)%LH77]H5S'0)%"% 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?JJH7F"%$"H5*J)%$"%H784'"%H 1 922J;2K= 922J;2K=
J?JCH-F"M%)0"(H.IF)" 1 9NK;=?C 9NK;=?C
J?JHH-F"M%)0"(HAF0M"%IL)HJH?? J 9NK;=?C 92C;N?K
J?JCH7F"%$"H5*J)%$"%H784'"% 1 9G12;?2? 9G12;?2?
J?JNH7F"%$"H5*J)%$"%H784'"% 1 922J;2K= 922J;2K=
J?JHH7F"%$"H5*J)%$"%H3"%FI0H1?=IHOILL"%H.%8$B 1 91;222;HKH 91;222;HKH
.)(I0 CK 9HHN;K1C 912;2KK;?KJ
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
15
To allocate the proportionate share of demand to residential and nonresidential development, this analysis uses proportionate share factors shown in Figure F1. Hendersonville’s existing LOS for residential development is 0.00041 units per person (36 units X 76 percent residential share / 66,898 persons). The nonresidential level of service is 0.00012 units per vehicle trip (36 units X 24 percent nonresidential share /69,915 vehicle trips). For fire apparatus, the cost is $226.83 per person (0.00041 units per person X $554,613 per unit) and $68.54 per vehicle trip (0.00012 units per vehicle trip X $554,613 per unit). Figure F7: Existing Standards for Fire Apparatus
!"#$%F"'()*"+H$"(-"+(./#F 01123456
78#9F#/$(./#F9 64
:"9#'"/F#H;(<%H+" =4L
?@?1(AB-C;HF#B/ 443DND
./#F9(-"+(A"+9B/ @F@@@25
GB9F(-"+(A"+9B/ 0??4FD6
HB/+"9#'"/F#H;(<%H+" ?2L
?@?1(I"%#J;"(O+#-9 4N3N51
./#F9(-"+(I"%#J;"(O+#- @F@@@5?
GB9F(-"+(I"%#J;"(O+#- 04DF12
<BC+J"L(M"/'"+9B/*#;;"(N#+"(O"-H+FP"/F
HB/+"9#'"/F#H;
Q"*";RBSR<"+*#J"(TQU<V(<FH/'H+'9
:"9#'"/F#H;
GB9F(NHJFB+9
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
16
Projected Demand Hendersonville plans to maintain the existing level of service for fire apparatus over the next 10 years. Based on a projected population increase of 10,455 persons, future residential development demands approximately 4.3 units (10,455 additional persons X 0.00041 units per person). With projected nonresidential growth of 9,478 vehicle trips, future nonresidential development demands approximately 1.2 units (9,478 vehicle trips X 0.00012 units per vehicle trip). The growth-related cost of fire apparatus is $3,021,069 (5.4 units X $554,613 per unit). Figure F8: Growth-Related Need for Fire Apparatus
Impact Fee Study – Plan-Based The cost to prepare the fire impact fee equals $20,274. TischlerBise recommends that Hendersonville update its report every five years. Based on this cost, proportionate shares, and five-year projections of new development from the Land Use Assumptions detailed in Appendix A, the cost is $2.95 per person and $1.07 per vehicle trip. Figure F9: Impact Fee Study Expense
!"#$%FG(%)* +,-*G."IG(%)*
0100023(%)*- ."IG4"I-,%
0100035(%)*- ."IG6"7)89"G:I).
;"-)F"%*)$9 <,%I"-)F"%*)$9 :,*$9
505= LL?@A@ LA?A3= 5B12 @1L CL10
505L LB?A2C B0?@0C 5B1@ @1B CL1=
505B L@?A@A B3?B0C 5@15 @1A CB13
505@ B0?0C2 B5?L3L 5@1L A10 CB1L
505A B3?0@0 BC?=25 5A13 A13 C@15
50C0 B5?35= B2?2@5 5A1= A15 C@1B
50C3 BC?3B3 B=?2CL 5A1A A1C CA15
50C5 B2?53L BL?202 C012 A12 CA1@
50CC B=?5L5 BB?C@L C01@ A1L 201C
50C2 BL?C0B B@?C@5 C315 A1B 201A
50C= BB?C=C BA?CAC C31L A1@ 2312
D%8I"$-" 30?2== A?2B@ 21C 315 =12
N5?CB3?2BA NL2A?=A0 NC?053?0LA
F"$I
G)I"GH..$I$*I- N==2?L3C
JI,K*7L;"9$*"FGMN."%F)*II"-
6"7)89"G:I).- (%)*-
:O."G,PGD%PI$-*II8*II" Q"R"9G,PGS"IR)8"
!"#$%FGP,IGG)I"GH..$I$*I-
4,.I9$*),%
!"#"$$%F'()*+,-#(
."F/-#" 01$2 ."F/-#"(34-2 567"%F(
08%49"
01$2(:"F(
."F/-#"(34-2
;"$-<"42-%, =>?)1:*,%2-14 5@AAB CADN5
!14F"$-<"42-%, AF?G"8-#,"(HF-:$ F@5>= CIDJ=
)F1:1F2-14%2"(.8%F"
K-F" CAJ@A=F
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
17
Debt Credit The fire impact fees include a credit for existing debt service. Hendersonville has bond financed recent fire facilities construction and the purchase of fire apparatus. A credit is necessary since new development will pay the fire impact fee and will also generate property tax revenue used to repay existing debt service. As shown in Figure F10, the principal portion of existing debt service equals $3,742,747 over the next 9 years. To allocate the proportionate share of demand to residential and nonresidential development, this analysis uses proportionate share factors shown in Figure F1. Annual principal payments are divided by projected population and vehicle trips in each year to estimate the principal payment per person and vehicle trip. To account for the time value of money, annual principal payments per person and trip are discounted using a net present value formula based on an interest rate of 4.0 percent. The total net present value of future principal payments is $34.46 per person and $10.49 per vehicle trip. Figure F10: Fire Debt Credit
!"#$%"&'$() *+&,"#$%"&'$()
-.(,"/01234 -.(,"/05634
5758 98:;<26: 968=<=1; 22<>:> 92?16 9=65<612 2:<:=8 95?76
5752 9277<65: 9682<;52 21<:6; 92?15 9=66<=7; 17<>7; 95?76
5751 9651<;>= 9;56<>=7 2><:>: 96?1= 9=75<81= 1=<17; 9=?6;
575> 965:<=8; 9;52<=82 17<7;6 96?22 9=75<::1 15<2=2 9=?65
575: 96;5<2:1 9;5><>87 1=<7>7 96?2; 9=7;<>61 1;<865 9=?6=
57;7 96;6<62: 9;;7<=:1 15<=58 96?8> 9=76<51; 16<6>5 9=?67
57;= 9516<:>: 957><::5 1;<=1= 95?>2 928<::1 18<6;2 97?>1
57;5 9516<:>: 957><::5 16<5=2 95?>5 928<::1 12<676 97?>2
57;; 9516<:>: 957><::5 18<525 95?1> 928<::1 11<;>2 97?>8
@+'() 9;<165<161 95<>66<6>1 967?6> 9>:><58: 9=5?;;
6?73 6?73
9;6?62 9=7?6:
=?/-AB/+C/'."/C+A,/DA,,"&'/N+&%#/C+,/C$,"/#'('$+&#/(&%/(FF(,('A#
G",/H".$D)"/
@,$F
I$#D+A&'/!('" I$#D+A&'/!('"
*"'/G,"#"&'/H()A" *"'/G,"#"&'/H()A"
J"(, G,$&D$F()= G+FA)('$+&G",/G",#+& H".$D)"/
@,$F#
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
18
Proposed Fire Impact Fees Infrastructure components and cost factors used to calculate the proposed fire impact fees are summarized in the upper portion of Figure F11. The total capital cost is $468.10 per person and $141.54 per vehicle trip. Fire impact fees for residential development are assessed per housing unit and vary proportionately according to the number of persons per housing unit. For a single-family unit, the fee of $1,198 is calculated using a cost of $468.10 per person multiplied by 2.56 persons per housing unit. Fire impact fees for nonresidential development are assessed per 1,000 square feet and vary proportionately according to the number of average weekday vehicle trips. For industrial development, the fee of $337 per 1,000 square feet is calculated using a cost of $141.54 per vehicle trip multiplied by 2.38 AWVT per 1,000 square feet. Figure F11: Proposed Fire Impact Fees
!""#$%F'%("() $%*)#'"+#H"+*%($%*)#'"+#-+.'
!.+"#!I0.1.)."* 2343546 263573
!.+"#8''I+I)9* 233:56; 2:65<7
="L"1%'F"()#!""#?"'%+) 235@< 2A5B4
!.+"#="C)#$+"M.) N2;757:F N2AB57@F
-%)I1 27:65AB 2A7A5<7
G.(H1"#!IF.1I 35<: 2AJA@6
O91).L!IF.1I A5:< 2443
M(M9*)+.I1 35;6 2;;4
$%FF"+0.I1 A353A 2AJ436
NOO.0"#P#N)Q"+#G"+L.0"* <573 24:4
M(*).)9).%(I1 457< 2AJB<7
A5#G""#RI(M#S*"#8**9F').%(*
S(.)#-I'" H"+*%(*#'"+#
T%9*.(H#S(.)A
H+%'%*"M
!""*
="L"1%'F"()#-I'"
?"*.M"().I1#!""*#'"+#S(.)
U%(+"*.M"().I1#!""*#'"+#AJBBB#GV9I+"#!"")
8PX-#'"+
AJBBB#GV#!)A
H+%'%*"M
!""*
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
19
Projected Revenue from Fire Impact Fees This section summarizes the potential cash flow to Hendersonville based on adoption of the proposed fire impact fees. The cash flow projections are based on the development projections discussed in the Land Use Assumptions section and the proposed fire impact fees. If development occurs at a more rapid rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will increase at a corresponding rate. If development occurs at a slower rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will decrease at a corresponding rate. Projected impact fee revenue equals $6,233,403 over the next 10 years and total projected expenditures equal $6,674,400. Figure F12: Projected Revenue from Fire Impact Fees
!"#$%FG(F)"*+H-.%-I0G(F)"* 1#%)2
3-"*G3)4-2-%-*. 56786679:;G 59G 56786679:;G
3-"*GK==)")%>. 5679?@798AG 59G 5679?@798AG
B*C*2#=M*I%G3**GE*=#"% 5?97?;FG 59G 5?97?;FG
!"#$% &'(')*(*++, &+,&'(')*(*++,
(-I02*G3)M-2GH>2%-I3)M-2G JIO>.%"-)2 L#MM*"4-)2MNN-4*GOGM%F*"JI.%-%>%-#I)2
5@7@AP 5;;? 566; 5@7;?P 5;8; 5@79:F
=*"G>I-% =*"G>I-% =*"GQ(3 =*"GQ(3 =*"GQ(3 =*"GQ(3
R.0GSI-% R.0GSI-% Q(3 Q(3 Q(3 Q(3
T).* ?9?: ?@796? 87@98 ?7;:P 67@9@ @7A9P ?796?
U*)"G@ ?9?8 ?@76PP 87@PP ?7;;9 67@66 @7AFP ?798:
U*)"G? ?9?; ?@7;F6 87?;9 ?7;P6 67@8: @7AA9 ?79AA
U*)"G6 ?9?P ??79AP 876:6 ?7;A: 67@AP ?796? ?7@6F
U*)"GF ?9?A ??7F:F 87F6: ?7P9; 67?6@ ?79;: ?7@8A
U*)"G: ?969 ??7P9A 87:@; ?7P?9 67?8F ?7@@A ?7?9:
U*)"G8 ?96@ ?67@8F 87899 ?7P66 67?A; ?7@8F ?7?F@
U*)"G; ?96? ?67:?9 878P? ?7PF: 6766@ ?7?@9 ?7?;P
U*)"GP ?966 ?67P;: 87;8F ?7P:P 6768: ?7?:8 ?76@8
U*)"GA ?96F ?F7?69 87PF; ?7P;@ 67F99 ?769F ?76:F
U*)"G@9?96: ?F7:P8 87A?A ?7PP6 67F6: ?76:6 ?76A6
67::6 P?6 @?8 66F FF: 68@
&*(-.'(/01 &'1.('21 &*-(12. &.)'(**0 &1*2(*20 &1/+()21
587?667F96
5878;F7F99
@9IU*)"GJI4"*).*
34"567#68,96:6;<6
3**GL#M=#I*I%
U*)"
V"#P*4%*OG3**GE*C*I>*
1#%)2G+H=*IO-%>"*.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
20
POLICE Methodology The components of Hendersonville’s police impact fee include facilities, vehicles, and the cost of calculating the police impact fees. Police impact fees are based on the incremental expansion methodology for facilities and vehicles, and the plan-based methodology for the cost of calculating police impact fees. Costs are allocated to both residential and nonresidential development using different demand indicators for each type of development. Residential impact fees are calculated on a per capita basis, then converted to an appropriate amount for each type of housing unit based on persons per housing unit factors. Nonresidential impact fees are calculated using nonresidential vehicle trips. Trip generation rates are highest for commercial/retail development and lowest for industrial development, whereas trip rates for office/institutional development fall between the other two categories. Using vehicle trip rates ensures that impact fees are consistent with the relative demand for police services from nonresidential development. Proportionate Share TischlerBise recommends functional population to allocate the cost of police infrastructure to residential and nonresidential development. Functional population is similar to what the U.S. Census Bureau calls "daytime population.” This approach accounts for people living and working in a jurisdiction, but it also considers commuting patterns and time spent at home and at nonresidential locations. OnTheMap is a web-based mapping and reporting application that shows where workers are employed and where they live. It describes geographic patterns of jobs by their employment locations and residential locations as well as the connections between the two locations. OnTheMap was developed through a unique partnership between the U.S. Census Bureau and its Local Employment Dynamics (LED) partner states. Residents that do not work are assigned 20 hours per day to residential development and 4 hours per day to nonresidential development (annualized averages). Residents that work in Hendersonville are assigned 14 hours to residential development and 10 hours to nonresidential development. Residents that work outside Hendersonville are assigned 14 hours to residential development. Inflow commuters are assigned 10 hours to nonresidential development. Based on 2022 functional population data for Hendersonville, the most recent year available, the cost allocation for residential development is 76 percent while nonresidential development accounts for 24 percent of the demand for police infrastructure.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
21
Figure P1: Functional Population
Service Units Residential The “service unit” used for residential development is persons per housing unit (PPHU). This is a measure of, on average, the number of persons residing in each housing unit. As shown in Figure P2, there are 2.56 persons per single family unit and 1.65 persons per multifamily unit. Factors have been calculate based on data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2023 ACS 5-year estimates (further discussed in Appendix A). Figure P2: Persons Per Housing Unit (PPHU)
!"#$%"&'$() !"#$%& '"()*%
+*H$-.'*/0-$H1*% 234563 7*0()8!$9 7*0()
J")1&"%H).;*H.<*(=1%L 5342?? 6@ 2554A2@
B#/-*9"&.J")1&"%H) 6C4255
B#/-*9"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 54??@ 3N FN456@
B#/-*9"&.*0H)1&".7"%&"()*%M1--" 6F4AF5 3N 52@4FN6
J")1&"%H1$-.G0HH*H$-34@N?4266
!"#$%"&'$()*+,(-" ./0
12&-"#$%"&'$()
;*%IJ*(=1%L.J")1&"%H) 5342?? N 3624AF6
O*H).L*M$H"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 6@422A
J")1&"%H).B#/-*9"&.1%.7"%&"()*%M1--" 54??@ 3@ 5?4?@@
;*%IJ")1&"%H.<*(="().N1%O-*J.M*##0H"()P 324A?A 3@ 32A4?A@
;*%(")1&"%H1$-.G0HH*H$- 5554N66
12&-"#$%"&'$()*+,(-" 340
+*H$-345?64@NN
5"6(&%*7&$'#*$&*3833
G*0(M"Q.RSGS.T"%)0).U0("$04.V%+P"X$/.Y//-1M$H1*%.$%&.LB7!.V(1L1%I!")H1%$H1*%.B#/-*9#"%H.GH$H1)H1M)4.
R"()1*%.2S65SN.N"#/-*9#"%HPS
!"#$%F'()*"%+ H-./
01%2"3()*"%+ 4-/.
4-'!FF'5)#6'78F'9881*:2";#8
<F=F%;:*F#2'L+:F ?F@8;#8':F@'
A;18"#$'7#"24
BF8"6F#2")%'<F=F%;:*F#2':F@'7#"2
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
22
Nonresidential TischlerBise recommends using nonresidential vehicle trips as the nonresidential service unit for police infrastructure. Average weekday vehicle trip ends for nonresidential development are from the 11th edition of the reference book, Trip Generation, published in 2021 by the Institute of Transportation Engineers. A trip end represents a vehicle either entering or exiting a development (as if a traffic counter were placed across a driveway). Trip ends for nonresidential development are calculated per thousand square feet. The basic trip adjustment factor is 50 percent for all nonresidential development except commercial and institutional. For commercial and institutional development, the trip adjustment factor is less than 50 percent because retail uses attract vehicles as they pass by on arterial and collector roads. For example, when someone stops at a convenience store on the way home from work, the convenience store is not the primary destination. For an average size shopping center, the ITE (2017) indicates that on average 34 percent of the vehicles that enter are passing by on their way to some other primary destination. The remaining 66 percent of attraction trips have the shopping center as their primary destination. Because attraction trips are half of all trips, the trip adjustment factor (0.66 X 0.50 = 0.33) is approximately 33 percent of the trip ends. Using the current estimates of nonresidential square footage, TischlerBise applies the trip generation rates and adjustment factors to calculate average weekday vehicle trips for nonresidential development in Hendersonville. TischlerBise estimates that there are 69,915 average weekday vehicle trips attributable to existing nonresidential development in Hendersonville. Figure P3: Current Estimate of Nonresidential Vehicle Trips
Police Facilities – Incremental Expansion Existing Standards and Cost Factors Hendersonville currently provides 29,373 square feet of police facilities to existing development and plans to maintain the existing level of service by constructing additional police facilities to serve future development. To allocate the proportionate share of demand to residential and nonresidential development, this analysis uses proportionate share factors shown in Figure P1. Hendersonville’s existing LOS for residential development is 0.3337 square feet per person (29,373 square feet X 76 percent residential share / 66,898 persons). The nonresidential level of service is 0.1008 square feet per vehicle trip (29,373 square feet X 24 percent nonresidential share / 69,915 vehicle trips).
!"#"$%F'"() !"# *+, -#.I01234 +56F 7879 7879
+4F" :(6) ;%2" K+, -2=>?)'"() !"#I:(6)?K"@I+56F?
*(2>?)563$ ABC DD8 NFG9 98H !"#$ 7IG9J OI998
;%''"5L63$ ABC J78 MGF8D MMH %!"!% MID8D MGIJGG
NOO6L"IPIN)@"5IB"5#6L"? ABC GD8 D8FJN 98H &"'! DIQ8J D8IMND
*(?)6)>)6%(3$ ABC 978 77F9Q MMH ("'& 7I8M7 D9IDNG
+%)3$IR%(5"?62"()63$I+56F? )*+*%&
-2=>?)"2I
01234IK+,
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
23
Based on recent police station construction costs in Tennessee this analysis uses a construction cost estimate of $500 per square foot. For police facilities, the cost is $166.85 per person (0.3337 square feet per person X $500 per square foot) and $50.41 per vehicle trip (0.1008 square feet per trip X $500 per square foot). Figure P4: Existing Standards for Police Facilities
!"#$%F'(F)* +H-.%"/0""(
1)2F$"/!"'.%(3"*( 456578
1)2F$"/9**": 446;<<
=)(.2 L?6<5<
@)#(/'"%/+H-.%"/0))( AB88
C:F#(F*D/+H-.%"/0""( L?6<5<
N"#FF"*(F.2/+G.%" 5;H
L8LB/1)'-2.(F)* ;;6I?I
+H-.%"/0""(/'"%/1"%#)* 8J<<<5
@)#(/'"%/1"%#)* A4;;JIB
O)*%"#FF"*(F.2/+G.%" L7H
L8LB/L"GF$2"/=%F'# ;?6?4B
+H-.%"/0""(/'"%/L"GF$2"/=%F' 8J488I
@)#(/'"%/L"GF$2"/=%F' AB8J74
+)-%$"M/N"*F"%#)*OF22"/1)2F$"/!"'.%(3"*(
O)*%"#FF"*(F.2
@)#(/0.$()%#
P"O"2Q)RQ+"%OF$"/SPT+U/+(.*F.%F#
N"#FF"*(F.2
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
24
Projected Demand Hendersonville plans to maintain the existing level of service for police facilities over the next 10 years. Based on a projected population increase of 10,455 persons, future residential development demands approximately 3,489 square feet of police facilities (10,455 additional persons X 0.3337 square feet per person). With projected nonresidential growth of 9,478 vehicle trips, future nonresidential development demands approximately 956 square feet of police facilities (9,478 additional vehicle trips X 0.1008 square feet per vehicle trip). The growth-related cost of police facilities is $2,222,217 (4,444 square feet X $500 per square foot). Figure P5: Growth-Related Need for Police Facilities
!"#$%FG(%)*+,-*G."IG01G2*
345556017$I"G2""* ."IG8"I-,%
34933:017$I"G2""* ."IG;"<)=L"G
?"-)F"%*)$L @,%I"-)F"%*)$L A,*$L
B3BC DDN:F: DFNF9C BBN5B5 6N3C3 BFN565
B3BD D6NFG5 63N:35 BBND6B 6N95F BFN:99
B3B6 D:NF:F 69N635 B5N3B9 6NB53 53NBC9
B3B: 63N35G 6BND9D B5N563 6N5BB 53NDFB
B3BF 69N3:3 65NCGB B5N69F 6NG9C 59N95G
B353 6BN9BC 6GNG:B BGN3D: 6NC93 59NC6:
B359 65N969 6CNG5D BGNG96 6ND3D 5BN3B5
B35B 6GNB9D 6DNG3G BGN6DD 6N63G 5BNGDF
B355 6CNBDB 66N5:D BCN99C 6N:35 5BNF96
B35G 6DN536 6:N5:B BCNGD5 6NF35 55N5D6
B35C 66N5C5 6FN5F5 BCN:9B :N33C 55N:96
93HIIGJ%=I"$-" 93NGCC FNG6: 5NG:F FCD GNGGG
K9N6GGN5FD KG66N:B9 KBNBBBNB96LI,M*<H?"L$*"FGNO."%F)*7I"-
!"#$%FGP,IG8,L)="G2$=)L)*)"-
I"$I 8,.7L$*),% ;"<)=L"GAI).- 017$I"G2""*
AQ."G,PGJ%PI$-*I7=*7I" R"S"LG,PG0"IS)="
8,L)="G2$=)L)*)"- KC33
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
25
Police Vehicles – Incremental Expansion Existing Standards and Cost Factors Hendersonville currently provides 171 police vehicles to existing development and plans to maintain the existing level of service by acquiring additional vehicles to serve future development. Based on costs provided by the Hendersonville Police Department, the weighted average cost of the existing fleet is $44,630 per unit. The analysis uses this cost as a proxy for future vehicle costs. To allocate the proportionate share of demand to residential and nonresidential development, this analysis uses proportionate share factors shown in Figure P1. Hendersonville’s existing LOS for residential development is 0.0019 units per person (171 units X 76 percent residential share / 66,898 persons). The nonresidential level of service is 0.0006 units per vehicle trip (171 units X 24 percent nonresidential share / 69,915 vehicle trips). For police vehicles, the cost is $86.70 per person (0.0019 units per person X $44,630 per unit) and $26.20 per vehicle trip (0.0006 units per vehicle trip X $44,630 per unit). Figure P6: Existing Standards for Police Vehicles
!"#$%F'(F)* +*F(# +*F(H-)#( .)(/0H-)#(
1+2# 345 6478393 6:844;844;
<F$=L'H.%L$=# 33 64:8?:9 673784:9
1"@/*# 3A 65;8BB; 6:::8;99
.)(/0 3A3 6448:59 6A8:538?9;
C"FDN("@HFG"%/D"H'"%H+*F( 6448:59
HIF#(F*DH+*F(# 3A3
J"#F@"*(F/0H1N/%" A:O
B9B7H<)'L0/(F)* ::8?;?
+*F(#H'"%H<"%#)* 9L993;
-)#(H'"%H<"%#)* 6?:LA9
M)*%"#F@"*(F/0H1N/%" B4O
B9B7H2"NF$0"H.%F'# :;8;37
+*F(#H'"%H2"NF$0"H.%F' 9L999:
-)#(H'"%H2"NF$0"H.%F' 6B:LB9
1)L%$"NHO"*@"%#)*GF00"H<)0F$"H!"'/%(P"*(
-)#(HQ/$()%#
R"G"0S)TS1"%GF$"HURV1PH1(/*@/%@#
M)*%"#F@"*(F/0
J"#F@"*(F/0
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
26
Projected Demand Hendersonville plans to maintain the existing level of service for police vehicles over the next 10 years. Based on a projected population increase of 10,455 persons, future residential development demands approximately 20.3 units (10,455 additional persons X 0.0019 units per person). With projected nonresidential growth of 9,478 vehicle trips, future nonresidential development demands approximately 5.6 units (9,478 additional vehicle trips X 0.0006 units per vehicle trip). The growth-related cost of police vehicles is $1,154,771 (25.9 units X $44,630 per unit). Figure P7: Growth-Related Need for Police Vehicles
Impact Fee Study – Plan-Based The cost to prepare the police impact fee equals $20,274. TischlerBise recommends that Hendersonville update its report every five years. Based on this cost, proportionate share, and five-year development projections from the Land Use Assumptions in Appendix A, the cost is $2.95 per person and $1.07 per vehicle trip. Figure P8: Impact Fee Study Expense
!"#$%&G(%)* +,-*G."IG(%)*
010023(%)*- ."IG4"I-,%
010005(%)*- ."IG6"7)89"G
:"-)&"%*)$9 ;,%I"-)&"%*)$9 <,*$9
=0=L 55?@3@ 53?32L 2A010 B210 2C210
=0=5 5C?3BA C0?@0A 2A=10 B215 2CA15
=0=C 5@?3@3 C2?C0A 2AB10 B=12 2C512
=0=@ C0?0AB C=?525 2A512 B=15 2C@1C
=0=3 C2?0@0 CA?LB= 2A@12 BA1= 2@21A
=0A0 C=?2=L CB?B@= 2B012 BA1C 2@A1@
=0A2 CA?2C2 CL?BA5 2B=12 BB1A 2@51B
=0A= CB?=25 C5?B0B 2BB1= BB1@ 2@310
=0AA CL?=5= CC?A@5 2B51= BL1B 23215
=0AB C5?A0C C@?A@= 2B@1= B510 23B1=
=0AL CC?ALA C3?A3A 2L01A B515 23513
20DNIGF%8I"$-" 20?BLL 3?BC@ =01A L15 =L13
G305?BC= G=B@?=33 G2?2LB?CC2HI,I*7D:"9$*"&GJK."%&)*LI"-
!"#$%&GM,IG4,9)8"G6"7)89"-
N"$I 4,.L9$*),% 6"7)89"G<I).-
<N."G,MGF%MI$-*IL8*LI" O"P"9G,MGQ"IP)8"
4,9)8"G6"7)89"- GBB?5A0
(%)*-
!"#"$$%&'()*+,-#(
."&/-#" 01$2 ."&/-#"(34-2 567"%&(
08%49"
01$2(:"&(
."&/-#"(34-2
;"$-<"42-%, =>?)1:*,%2-14 5@AAB CADN5
!14&"$-<"42-%, AF?G"8-#,"(H&-:$ F@5>= CIDJ=
)&1:1&2-14%2"(.8%&"
)1,-#" CAJ@A=F
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
27
Proposed Police Impact Fees Infrastructure components and cost factors used to calculate the proposed police impact fees are summarized in the upper portion of Figure P9. The total capital cost is $256.50 per person and $77.68 per vehicle trip. Police impact fees for residential development are assessed per housing unit and vary proportionately according to the number of persons per housing unit. For a single-family unit, the fee of $657 is calculated using a cost of $256.50 per person multiplied by 2.56 persons per housing unit. Police impact fees for nonresidential development are assessed per 1,000 square feet and vary proportionately according to the number of vehicle trips. For industrial development, the fee of $185 per 1,000 square feet is calculated using a cost of $77.68 per vehicle trip multiplied by 2.38 vehicle trips per 1,000 square feet. Figure P9: Proposed Police Impact Fees
!""#$%F'%("() $%*)#'"+#H"+*%($%*)#'"+#-+.'
H%I.0"#!10.I.)."* 2344567 278593
H%I.0"#:";.0I"* 2645<8 2=45=8
L"?"I%'F"()#!""#@"'%+) 2=5A7 2358<
-%)1I 2=74578 2<<546
B.(CI"#!1F.IM =574 247<
NFI).G!1F.IM 3547 29=H
I(JF*)+.1I =5H6 2367
$%FF"+0.1I 3=5=3 2A96
OLL.0"#M#O);"+#B"+?.0"* 759= 29=3
I(*).)F).%(1I <597 27<A
35#B""#N1(J#O*"#P**FF').%(*
L"?"I%'F"()#-M'" PQ:-#'"+
3R888#BS#!)3
H+%'%*"J
!""*
O(.)#-M'" H"+*%(*#'"+#
T%F*.(C#O(.)3
H+%'%*"J
!""*
@"*.J"().1I#!""*#'"+#O(.)
U%(+"*.J"().1I#!""*#'"+#3R888#BSF1+"#!"")
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
28
Projected Revenue from Police Impact Fees This section summarizes the potential cash flow to Hendersonville based on adoption of the proposed police impact fees. The cash flow projections are based on the development projections discussed in the Land Use Assumptions section and the proposed police impact fees. If development occurs at a more rapid rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will increase at a corresponding rate. If development occurs at a slower rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will decrease at a corresponding rate. Projected impact fee revenue equals $3,418,827 over the next 10 years and total projected expenditures equal $3,397,262. Figure P10: Projected Revenue from Police Impact Fees
!"#$%FG(F)"*+H-.%-I0G(F)"* 1#%)2
3#2-4*G5)4-2-%-*. 678777879:G 6; 678777879:G
3#2-4*GK*F-42*. 6989=>8::9G 6; 6989=>8::9G
?*@*2#AB*I%G5**GC*A#"% 67;87:>G 6; 67;87:>G
1#%)2 6M8ME:87F7G 6;G 6M8ME:87F7G
(-I02*G5)B-2GHI2%-J5)B-2G OILI.%"-)2 M#BB*"4-)2NOO-4*GPGN%F*"OI.%-%I%-#I)2
6F=: 6>7M 69Q= 6E>Q 6>79 6=:E
A*"GII-% A*"GII-% A*"GR(5 A*"GR(5 A*"GR(5 A*"GR(5
S.0GTI-% S.0GTI-% R(5 R(5 R(5 R(5
U).* 7;7= 798;M7 F89;F 78:=Q M89;9 98E;Q 78;M7
V*)"G9 7;7F 798MQQ F89QQ 78::; M89MM 98E>Q 78;F=
V*)"G7 7;7: 798:>M F87:; 78:QM M89F= 98EE; 78;EE
V*)"GM 7;7Q 778;EQ F8M=M 78:E= M89EQ 78;M7 789M>
V*)"G> 7;7E 778>=> F8>M= 78Q;: M87M9 78;:= 789FE
V*)"G= 7;M; 778Q;E F8=9: 78Q7; M87F> 7899E 787;=
V*)"GF 7;M9 7M89F> F8F;; 78QMM M87E: 789F> 787>9
V*)"G: 7;M7 7M8=7; F8FQ7 78Q>= M8MM9 7879; 787:Q
V*)"GQ 7;MM 7M8Q:= F8:F> 78Q=Q M8MF= 787=F 78M9F
V*)"GE 7;M> 7>87M; F8Q>: 78Q:9 M8>;; 78M;> 78M=>
V*)"G9;7;M= 7>8=QF F8E7E 78QQM M8>M= 78M=M 78MEM
M8==M Q7M 97F MM> >>= MF9
!"#$$%#&%' !$%(#")' !"$#""* !$+,#"%, !+()#%'" !"'*#+$*
6M8>9Q8Q7:
6M8ME:87F71#%)2G+HA*IL-%I"*.
9;JV*)"GOI4"*).*
-./01231456171891
3"#P*4%*LG5**GC*@*II*
5**GM#BA#I*I%
V*)"
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
29
TRANSPORTATION Methodology The transportation impact fee includes components for street improvements, and the cost of calculating the transportation impact fees. The incremental expansion methodology is used for street improvements, and the plan-based methodology is used for the cost of calculating the transportation impact fees. Proportionate Share The transportation impact fees will allocate the cost between residential and nonresidential based on trip generation rates, trip adjustment factors, and trip lengths. Vehicle Trip Generation Rates and Adjustments Average weekday vehicle trips are used as a measure of demand by land use. Vehicle trips are estimated using average weekday vehicle trip ends from the reference book, Trip Generation, 11th Edition, published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) in 2021. A vehicle trip end represents a vehicle entering or exiting a development (as if a traffic counter were placed across a driveway). To calculate the impact fees, trip generation rates are adjusted to avoid double counting each trip at both the origin and destination points. The basic trip adjustment factor is 50 percent. As discussed further below, the impact fee methodology includes additional adjustments to make the fees proportionate to the infrastructure demand for particular types of development. Residential Trip Generation Rates For residential development, TischlerBise uses trip generation rates published in Trip Generation, Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE), 11th Edition (2021). The prototype for single-family development is Single-Family Detached Housing (ITE 210) which generates 9.43 average weekday vehicle trip ends per dwelling unit. The prototype for multi-family development is Multifamily Housing Low-Rise (ITE 220) which generates 6.74 average weekday vehicle trip ends per dwelling unit.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
30
Nonresidential Trip Generation Rates For nonresidential development, TischlerBise uses trip generation rates published in Trip Generation, Institute of Transportation Engineers, 11th Edition (2021). The prototype for industrial development is Manufacturing (ITE 140) which generates 4.75 average weekday vehicle trip ends per 1,000 square feet of floor area. For office development, the proxy is General Office (ITE 710), and it generates 10.84 average weekday vehicle trip ends per 1,000 square feet of floor area. The prototype for commercial development is Shopping Center (ITE 820) which generates 37.01 average weekday vehicle trips per 1,000 square feet of floor area. For institutional development, the proxy is Government Office (ITE 730), and it generates 22.59 average weekday vehicle trip ends per 1,000 square feet of floor area. Figure T1: Average Weekday Vehicle Trip Ends by Land Use
Trip Rate Adjustments To calculate transportation impact fees, trip generation rates require an adjustment factor to avoid double counting each trip at both the origin and destination points. Therefore, the basic trip adjustment factor is 50 percent. As discussed further in this section, the development fee methodology includes additional adjustments to make the fees proportionate to the infrastructure demand for particular types of development.
!"# $%FG()*+)H-".I0-#()1*+)H-".I0-#()1#F023H%%1-4%.567G.%-8%%9
:3)% ;(I9 4%.-$F)-;(I9<4%.-#F023H%%<$%FG()-;(I94%.-#F023H%%
<<=LI?@9-!()719.IG2 <A===-56-89 BCME FC<= <CGE HFE
<F=!()719.IG2-4G.+ <A===-56-89 FCFE ICJ< <C<H MHB
<B=OG(7LGM97.I(? <A===-56-89 BCEG ICG< <CMJ GIM
<G=*G.%@371I(? <A===-56-89 <CE< GC=G =CFB IAJGF
IGBN11I19%)-LIOI(? P%) ICH= BCIB =CH< (G
IGBN11I19%)-LIOI(? <A===-56-89 BC<J BCIB =CJJ <A=<I
F<=Q39%2 .33F ECJJ <BCFB =CGH (G
H<=Q310I9G2 <A===-56-89 <=CEE FCEE ICMH FG=
E<=R%(%.G2-SLLIM%-TGO?-1IU%V<A===-56-89 <=CMB FCFF FCIH F=E
EI=O%)IMG2P$%(9G2-SLLIM% <A===-56-89 FHC== MCE< BC<F IBI
EF=R3O%.(F%(9-SLLIM% <A===-56-89 IICGJ ECBG FC=F FF=
EG=SLLIM%-4G.+ <A===-56-89 <<C=E FCGB FC<F FI=
EH=X%1%G.M@-Y-$%O-:%(9%.<A===-56-89 <<C=M FCFE FCIJ F=B
EE=R71I(%11-4G.+ <A===-56-89 <ICBB BC=B FC=M FIG
MI=5@300I(?-:%(9%.-TGO?-1IU%V<A===-56-89 FEC=< <ECBI IC<I BE<
<C-".I0-R%(%.G9I3(A-!(19I979%-3L-".G(103.9G9I3(-#(?I(%%.1A-<<9@-#)I9I3(-TI=I<VC
LG()-;1%-[-5IU%
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
31
Commuter Trip Adjustment Residential development has a larger trip adjustment factor of 63 percent to account for commuters leaving Hendersonville for work. According to the 2009 National Household Travel Survey (see Table 30) weekday work trips are typically 31 percent of production trips (i.e., all out-bound trips, which are 50 percent of all trip ends). As shown in Figure T2, the U.S. Census Bureau’s OnTheMap web application indicates 87 percent of resident workers traveled outside of Hendersonville for work in 2022. In combination, these factors (0.31 x 0.50 x 0.87 = 0.13) support the additional 13 percent allocation of trips to residential development. Figure T2: Commuter Trip Adjustment
Adjustment for Pass-By Trips For commercial and institutional development, the trip adjustment factor is less than 50 percent because this type of development attracts vehicles as they pass by on arterial and collector roads. For example, when someone stops at a convenience store on the way home from work, the convenience store is not the primary destination. For the average shopping center, ITE data indicate 34 percent of the vehicles that enter are passing by on their way to some other primary destination. The remaining 66 percent of attraction trips have the commercial site as their primary destination. Because attraction trips are half of all trips, the trip adjustment factor is 66 percent multiplied by 50 percent, or approximately 33 percent of the trip ends.
!!"#$%F#'($!)%*%'+!H'F!-.I0%'+!%'!1#'F#I$.'*%22# 34556
!!"#$%F#'($!7.889(%'+!:9($%F#!1#'F#I$.'*%22#!;.I!-.I0 <=4L=3
!!?8@2.A#F!"#$%F#'($ <B4C33
MNHI#!.;!?8@2.A#F!"#$%F#'($!7.889(%'+!:9($%F#!1#'F#I$.'*%22#!;.I!-.I0 5LF
GH$#!HI.F9I(%.'!JI%@$O =6F
LFF%(%.'H2!HI.F9I(%.'!JI%@$O O3F
"#$%F#'(%H2!JI%@!LFM9$(8#'(!NHI(.I C3F
JI%@!LFM9$(8#'(!NHI(.I!;.I!7.889(#I$
M.9II#O!PQMQ!7#'$9$!G9I#H94!:'JN#RH@!L@@2%IH(%.'!S*#I$%.'!CQ<3QTU!H'F!)?1V!:I%+%'PV#$(%'H(%.'!?8@2.A8#'(!
M(H(%$(%I$4!<6<OQ
OQ!LII.IF%'+!(.!(N#!XH(%.'H2!1.9$#N.2F!JIH*#2!M9I*#A!S<66BUY4!@9R2%$N#F!%'!V#I#8R#I!<6OO!S$##!JHR2#!36U4!N.8#P
RH$#F![.I0!(I%@$!HI#!(A@%IH22A!36QBB!@#II#'(!.;!\@I.F9I(%.']!(I%@$4!%'!.(N#I#" I)I(=.;P3MN O C3NOMMMQJCOMLOONMCQQPCMNMJ
S(="0%.B"%=")%.B()R1*"H)#R=").R*.A.V?FB I)I(=.;J3LQ O P3LJMMMQJPNMMPQNMPLJNMMCP
SS(="0%.B"%=")%.B()RT((#".[(*8)#.A.!H8Y.468< I)I(=.;J3LJ O P3MJMMMQJPQMLCJOMJJJCMNJJ
B(-@*)#R.B()R L"0%.I)H#.A.F8<"=H)* I)I(=.;P3ON O O3LOMMMQJOQMMOOPPMNNLPNMPMC
F8<"=H)*.T*2R L"0%.I)H#.?%=""%.A.?)#R"=0.S"==5.B()RI)I(=.;P3PJ O O3OJMMMQJPLMONJPJMNNQPPMNOC
1#R"=0(#.!)#" G)0%.I)H#.A.;68Y"=*)#R.[H**0.4= I)I(=.;P3PO O O3OOMMMQJPLMMOOOMOCNOMLNM
;68Y"=*)#R.[H**0.4=1#R"=0(#.!#.A.G)0%.4= I)I(=.;O3OC O O3MNMMMQJOCMJPPOMOCNPJMNNL
SG)0%.4=H2" F#RH)#.!)@".BR.A.F#RH)#.!)@".BR I)I(=.;J3NQ O P3CJMMMQJPPMQJQNMJJJCMLJJ
T(#H%).R)=@P)5 G)0%.I)H#.A.;68Y"=*)#R.[H**0.4B I)I(=.;P3QO O C3JOMMMQJONMLJONMPLQLMOPN
X*"#Y=((@.L)5 1#R="P0.B6#.A.V?FB I)I(=.;J3QP O O3JOLMLQJOJMOLMOPMNOOPPMJMM
S;)*RP"**.4=H2" ;(6#%5.!H#".A.;"#%"=.R(H#%.B()R I)I(=.;P3JL O O3PMMMMQJPLMOLCPJMPQCPPMJNN
;)$"0.T"#R.B()RX)0%(#.A.4(6$*)0.T"#R I)I(=.;P3NO O C3OOMMMQJOMMNNOQMNJJLMOCO
S=""FH**.B()R B(-@*)#R.B()R.A.T((#".[(*8)# I)I(=.;J3NO O P3OOMMMQJPJMLNOOMMNPCMJPO
ST((#".[(*8)# S=""FH**.B()R.A.S(="0%.B"%=")% I)I(=.;J3OO O J3OOMMMQJ CMMLO OMJJJ MMJ
!"#$% &'()) *)+(+& *,*-*,).&&*&,-/'+.0,).0
?(6=-"_.["#R"=0(#2H**".R6Y*H-.L(=@0
S;(6#%0."0%H8)%"R.Y)0"R.(#.(%F"=.-(8<)=)Y*".=()RP)5.2(*68"0.)#RU(=.<=H(=.0%6R5.2(*68"0
B()R S=(8.A.G( ;*)00 ;)<)-H%5.
<"=.!)#"
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
35
Local Adjustment Factor Expected VMT reflects anticipated travel demand on the entire roadway system; therefore, it is necessary to calibrate demand. To calibrate demand on the street network, actual travel demand of 602,207 VMT, based on local traffic counts provided by Hendersonville Public Works, is compared to expected travel demand of 2,535,259 VMT. The ratio between actual VMT and expected VMT equals 0.240, and this ratio provides the local adjustment factor used to adjust national average trip lengths by type of land use. Figure T7: Local Adjustment Factor
Local Trip Lengths Shown below in Figure T8, TischlerBise applies the local adjustment factor to the national average trip lengths to calculate local trip lengths. The analysis uses local trip lengths shown below to calculate VMT. Figure T8: Local Trip Lengths
Local Vehicle Miles Traveled Multiplying average weekday vehicle trips and local trip lengths by existing development units provides VMT generated by existing development. Existing development generates 607,207 VMT. Figure T9: Existing VMT by Land Use
!"#$%F'()* +,-./,-
0123"#34'()* /.565./57
!"#$%F'#8'0123"#34'()* ,9/:,
;8"%F'!4<$=#L3?#'@%"#8A
!"#"$%F'"() *+)H%(+$-.#I 0%1+$ 0%1+$
23F" 24HF-0"(I)5 .67-8+1)%4 24HF-0"(I)5
9H(I$"-8+'H$3 :;<=L L<?@L ;<?;
AB$)HC8+'H$3 :;<=L L<?@L ;<?;
M(6BN)4H+$ F<GL L<?@L ?<LF
H%''"41H+$ =<FL L<?@L :<;I
JOOH1"-L-J)5"4-9"4#H1"N F<GL L<?@L ?<LF
M(N)H)B)H%(+$ F<GL L<?@L ?<LF
9%B41"M-?L??-*N29-+(6-2HN15$"4OHN"-+(+$3NHN-O%4-$%1+$-+67BN)'"()-O+1)%4
!"#"$%F'"() !"# *+H -#.I0123 4%56$ 7879 7879
+3F" :(;) K%2" ="LI+?;F@+?;FI4"(.)L !"# =A+
B;(.$"IC6';$3 M: 7E8 9FGH IF7I 7EJ8I7 H8HJ88O
AL$);MC6';$3 M: 77E HF79 IF7I NJE8N OIJO79
*(2L@)?;6$ OBC EE8 7FIO 7F8O 7JP9O EIJNHO
K%''"?5;6$ OBC O78 E7F7E EFIG IJE8E 97JNEP
QRR;5"ISIQ)L"?IB"?#;5"@ OBC O78 9FH7 7F8O EJG8O 7EJ9HO
*(@);)L);%(6$ OBC PE8 PFH9 7F8O 7J8I7 IEJ9NE
+%)6$ N8PJ78P
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
36
Street Network Capacity and Usage As shown in Figure T6, Hendersonville provided an inventory of road segments including segment lengths and lane quantities. The analysis uses average daily traffic counts provided by Hendersonville’s Public Works Department. Multiplying each segment’s length by the number of lanes yields the number of lane miles per segment, and multiplying the traffic counts by the segment lengths provides the average weekday vehicle miles traveled (VMT). Hendersonville’s existing arterial network supports 607,207 VMT on 126.64 lane miles. Shown below, Figure T10 documents the capacity of Hendersonville’s street network. Based on a total of 1,181,204 vehicle miles of capacity (VMC), the street network provides a capacity of 9,327 vehicles per lane mile, (126.64 lane miles / 1,181,204 VMC). The current daily volume on Hendersonville’s street network is 607,207 VMT. The resulting ratio is 1.95 VMC / VMT (1,181,204 VMC / 607,207 VMT). The baseline VMC / VMT ratio for any incremental expansion method is 1.0 (i.e., VMC = VMT); therefore, the current ratio of 1.95 VMC / VMT exceeds the current LOS ensuring new capacity built with impact fees will not exceed the current LOS. Figure T10: Arterial Network Capacity and Usage
!"#$%&'$()&*+%), -./0/1
2)3+4%)&*+%),&"5&6$7$4+#8 -9-:-9.;1
6$7$4+#8&7)<&'$()&*+%) =9L.?
2)3+4%)&*+%),&"5&!<$@)% /;?9.;?
2*!&7)<&'$()&*+%) 19?=A
2*6&B&2*!&C$#+" -0=A
M<#)<+$%&6$7$4+#8&C$#+"
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
37
Projected VMT Transportation impact fees rely on data pertaining to existing and future average weekday VMT. Multiplying the average weekday VMT rates for new development prototypes by the projection of new residential and nonresidential development provides existing and projected VMT. As shown in Figure T11, existing development generates 602,207 VMT, and projected development generates an additional 96,478 VMT over the next 10 years. Shown below, Hendersonville currently serves existing development with 126.64 lane miles in its existing street network. To account for excess capacity in the street network, the analysis divides existing arterial lane miles by the VMC / VMT ratio to calculate 65.10 adjusted lane miles (126.64 lane miles / 1.95 VMC per VMT). Hendersonville needs to construct approximately 10.3 lane miles of street improvements over the next 10 years to maintain the existing levels of service. Figure T11: Projected VMT
!"#"$%F'"() !"# *+H -#.I0123+45F 6%78$ -#.I0123
+3F" 9(5) :%2" ;+H -2K=L)'"()+45FI6"(.)?;@+
A5(.$"IB8'5$3 C9 MNF GHIJ OJL JHMJ NGHMN
@=$)5MB8'5$3 C9 MMN OHNI OJL JHMJ NJHNJ
*(2=L)458$ OAB NNF IHNP PFL MHFQ IHGP
:%''"4758$ OAB QMF JNHFN JJL NHJG NOHGN
RSS57"ITIR)?"4IA"4#57"LOAB QMF NFHQI PFL MHFQ NNHMG
*(L)5)=)5%(8$ OAB NNF MMHPG JJL MHFQ NPHPJ
U8L" N M J I P NF NFMV"84
MFMP MFMO MFMN MFMQ MFMG MFJF MFJP *(74"8L"
A5(.$"MB8'5$3I9(5)L MNWFJM MNWJQQ MNWNIJ MMWFGQ MMWIPI MMWQFG MIWPQO JWPPJ
@=$)5MB8'5$3I9(5)L OWNFO OWNQQ OWMNF OWJPJ OWIJP OWPNN OWGMG QMJ
*(2=L)458$IOAB MWNPQ MWNNF MWNQJ MWNGP MWQFN MWQMF MWQQJ NMO
:%''"4758$IOAB JWNFN JWNJJ JWNOP JWNGQ JWMJN JWMOI JWIJP JJI
RSS57"ITIR)?"4IA"4#57"LIOABNWGFQ NWGIQ NWGGF MWFJM MWFNP MWNNG MWJPJ IIP
*(L)5)=)5%(8$IOAB MWFJM MWFOP MWFGG MWNJI MWNOG MWMFP MWJGJ JON
A5(.$"MB8'5$3I+45FL NMIWGPMNMNWFOJNMGWNNINJNWMQPNJJWJGONJPWPFNNIOWFOM MNWNNF
@=$)5MB8'5$3I+45FL MPWGMP MOWMNP MOWOMP MOWGNI MNWJMI MNWONJ MGWIMM JWIGO
X"L52"()58$I+45FL NPFWQNNNPJWJJQNPPWNGQNPQWMPGNOFWNNGNOJWNQFNNPWIQJ MIWOFO
*(2=L)458$I+45FL OWPPF OWPNG OWOFG OWOJQ OWOOQ OWOGQ OWQIQ MGQ
:%''"4758$I+45FL JNWQNN JQWMOO JQWOPG JGWFPO JGWIPN JGWQOM INWGPM IWFNI
RSS57"ITIR)?"4IA"4#57"LI+45FLNFWJIN NFWPOF NFWNQI NNWFNJ NNWMIO NNWIQI NMWNPI MWINJ
*(L)5)=)5%(8$I+45FL NPWNIN NPWJGN NPWOPN NPWGFG NOWNNN NOWIJQ NNWQJG MWOGJ
Y%(4"L52"()58$I+45FL OGWGNP NFWQFJ NNWNFJ NMWONO NJWPIM NIWIQM NGWJGJ GWINQ
+%)8$I;"?57$"I+45FL MMFWNGMMMIWNIFMMNWPFNMJFWQNPMJIWMOMMJNWOOMMPIWQNO JIWFQI
!"#$%&'(! )*+,-*+).),+/.)-),0**)01,220)/1,/3.)11,.-/+*0,)21 3),/+2
-((=8$I*(74"8L" GWPJI GWPPQ GWPQJ GWOFQ GWOJJ GWNOO 3,+))
-7)=8$I68("I@5("L NMOHOI NMQHO NJFHO NJMHO NJIHO NJOHO NIOHQ MFHN
-((=8$I*(74"8L" MHF MHF MHF MHF MHF MHF MHF
-2K=L)"2I68("I@5$"L OPHNF OOHN ONHN OQHM OGHM NFHM NPHI NFHJ
-((=8$I*(74"8L" NHF NHF NHF NHF NHF NHF NHF
C"(2"4L%(#5$$"WI+"(("LL""
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
38
Capacity Improvements – Incremental Expansion The transportation impact fee includes a component for construction of additional capacity improvements, and the analysis uses an incremental methodology to maintain the existing level of service for capacity improvements. As shown in Figure T12, the analysis uses VMT to calculate existing level-of-service standards. Hendersonville' currently provides 126.6 lane miles of capacity improvements, so the existing level of service is 1.070 lane miles per 10,000 VMT (126.6 lane miles / 1.95 VMC per VMT / (607,207 VMT / 10,000)). As shown in Figure T12, the analysis uses a cost of $5,269,267 per lane mile, which was provided by Hendersonville’s Public Works Department. For capacity improvements, the cost is $563.57 per VMT (126.6 lane miles / 1.95 VMC per VMT / 607,207 VMT X $5,269,267 per lane mile). Figure T12: Existing Standards for Capacity Improvements
Development Fee Report – Plan-Based The cost to prepare the transportation impact fee equals $27,032. TischlerBise recommends that Hendersonville updates its report every five years. Based on the 5-year cost, proportionate share, and 5-year projections of future development from the Land Use Assumptions document, the cost is $0.56 per VMT. Figure T13: Impact Fee Study Expense
!"#$%F'(%)*+'%H-.' /012341235
67-#$-+8%)*+'%H-.'# 923:3
;H!%<%;H=%L*$-" 9:40
?@AB#$'@%)*+'%H-.'# 3C:4
2M20%;H= 3M512M5
)*+'%H-.'#%F'(%9M1MMM%;H= 9:M5M
!"#$%F'(%;H= /03E:05
F"B(G'H%I'+@'(#"+J-..'%OBL.-G%M"(N#%O'F*($P'+$
!"#$%Q*G$"(#
)'J'.R"SRF'(J-G'%T)UFV%F$*+@*(@#
!"#"$$%&'()*+,-#(
."&/-#" 01$2 ."&/-#"(34-2 567"%&(
08%49"
01$2(:"&(
."&/-#"(34-2
.2&""2 ;<=>?@< A,,( B??CMNF G=>HB= ;?I5J
)&1:1&2-14%2"(.8%&"
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
39
Proposed Transportation Impact Fees Input variables for the transportation impact fee are shown in the upper section of Figure T14. The total capital cost is $564.13 per VMT. Transportation impact fees for residential development are assessed per housing unit and vary proportionately according to the number of VMT per housing unit. For a single-family unit, the fee of $10,836 is calculated using a cost of $564.13 per VMT multiplied by 19.21 VMT per housing unit. Transportation impact fees for nonresidential development are assessed per 1,000 square feet and vary proportionately according to the number of VMT. For industrial development, the fee of $2,792 per 1,000 square feet is calculated using a cost of $564.13 per VMT multiplied by 4.95 VMT per 1,000 square feet. Figure T14: Proposed Transportation Impact Fees
!""#$%F'%("() $%*)#'"+#,-.
I)+"")#0F'+%1"F"()* 2345637
8"1"9%'F"()#!""#:"'%+) 2;634
.%)<9 234=6>5
?1@#A""BC<M
,-.
IN(@9"#!<FN9M >F6G> 2>;HI54
-J9)NO!<FN9M >5675 27H7=3
?1@#A""BC<M
,-.
0(CJ*)+N<9 =6F3 2GH7FG
$%FF"+LN<9 >46F7 2FH37>
MNNNL"#O#M)P"+#I"+1NL"* >>6GF 24H57>
0(*)N)J)N%(<9 >3635 2IH745
8"1"9%'F"()#.M'" Q+%'%*"C
!""*
R(N)#INS" Q+%'%*"C
!""*
:"*NC"()N<9#!""*#'"+#R(N)
T%(+"*NC"()N<9#!""*#'"+#>H;;;#IUJ<+"#!"")
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
40
Projected Revenue from Transportation Impact Fees This section summarizes the potential cash flow to Hendersonville based on adoption of the proposed transportation impact fees. The cash flow projections are based on the development projections discussed in the Land Use Assumptions section and the proposed transportation impact fees. If development occurs at a more rapid rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will increase at a corresponding rate. If development occurs at a slower rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure and the impact fee revenue will decrease at a corresponding rate. Projected impact fee revenue equals $54,425,254 over the next 10 years and total projected expenditures equal $54,503,556. Figure T15: Projected Revenue from Transportation Impact Fees
!"#$%FG(F)"*+H-.%-I0G(F)"* 1#%)2
(%"**%G345"#6*4*I%. 789:8;K:88= 7;789:8;K:88=
>*6*2#54*I%G?**G@*5#"% 7AB:;KA 7; 7AB:;KA
1#%)2 789:8;K:88= 7;789:8;K:88=
(-I02*G?)4-2CME2%-F?)4-2C 3IGE.%"-)2 H#44*"I-)2JOO-I*GLGJ%F*"3I.%-%E%-#I)2
7M;:NK= 7B:B98 7A:BOA 7O:8BM 7=:KBM 7N:B=K
5*"GEI-% 5*"GEI-% 5*"G.PGO% 5*"G.PGO% 5*"G.PGO% 5*"G.PGO%
Q.0GRI-% Q.0GRI-% S(? S(? S(? S(?
T).* A;A8 AM:;KA =:M;= A:B8N K:M;M M:O;N A:;KA
U*)"GM A;A= AM:KNN =:MNN A:BB; K:MKK M:O9N A:;=8
U*)"GA A;AB AM:B9K =:AB; A:BNK K:M=8 M:OO; A:;OO
U*)"GK A;AN AA:;ON =:K8K A:BO8 K:MON A:;KA A:MK9
U*)"G9 A;AO AA:989 =:9K8 A:N;B K:AKM A:;B8 A:M=O
U*)"G8 A;K; AA:N;O =:8MB A:NA; K:A=9 A:MMO A:A;8
U*)"G= A;KM AK:M=9 =:=;; A:NKK K:AOB A:M=9 A:A9M
U*)"GB A;KA AK:8A; =:=NA A:N98 K:KKM A:AM; A:ABN
U*)"GN A;KK AK:NB8 =:B=9 A:N8N K:K=8 A:A8= A:KM=
U*)"GO A;K9 A9:AK; =:N9B A:NBM K:9;; A:K;9 A:K89
U*)"GM;A;K8 A9:8N= =:OAO A:NNK K:9K8 A:K8K A:KOK
K:88K NAK MA= KK9 998 K=M
VVVVVVVVVVV7=:KB=:BMB 7K8;:8BM 7K:MOA:NAM 7A:NK8:O=M 7K:M=8:A=K
789:9A8:A89
789:8;K:88=
P"#X*I%*GG@*6*IE*
P"#X*I%*GG?**G@*6*IE*
1#%)2G+H5*IG-%E"*.
M;FU*)"G3II"*).*
?**GH#45#I*I%
U*)"
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
41
APPENDIX A: LAND USE ASSUMPTIONS The City of Hendersonville, Tennessee, retained TischlerBise to analyze the impacts of development on its capital facilities and prepare impact fees based on that analysis. The population, housing unit, and job projections contained in this document provide the foundation for the impact fee study. To evaluate demand for growth-related infrastructure from various types of development, TischlerBise prepared documentation on demand indicators by type of housing unit, jobs and floor area by type of nonresidential development, and average weekday vehicle trip generation rates. These are the service units and demand indicators used in the impact fee study. Impact fees are based on the need for growth-related improvements, and they must be proportionate by type of land use. The demographic data and development projections are used to demonstrate proportionality and to anticipate the need for future infrastructure. These metrics are used to allocate costs of development equitably among various types of development. To calculate base year estimates, the analysis uses data from the U.S. Census Bureau, Esri Business Analyst, and information from Hendersonville staff. Impact fee studies typically consider a ten-year horizon, with the expectation that fees will be updated every three to five years. Residential Development Persons Per Housing Unit According to the U.S. Census Bureau, a household is a housing unit occupied by year-round residents. Development fees often use per capita standards and persons per housing unit (PPHU) or persons per household (PPH) to derive proportionate share fee amounts. When PPHU is used in the fee calculations, infrastructure standards are derived using year-round population. When PPH is used in the fee calculations, the development fee methodology assumes a higher percentage of housing units will be occupied, thus requiring seasonal or peak population to be used when deriving infrastructure standards. TischlerBise recommends that impact fees for residential development in Hendersonville be imposed according to the number of year-round residents per housing unit. This methodology assumes some portion of the housing stock will be vacant during the year. Persons per housing unit (PPHU) calculations require data on population and the types of units by structure. Since 2010, the census has not obtained detailed information using a “long-form” questionnaire. Instead, the U.S. Census Bureau uses a continuous monthly mailing of surveys, known as the American Community Survey (ACS), which has limitations due to sample-size constraints. For example, data on detached housing units are now combined with attached single units (commonly known as townhouses). For development fees in Hendersonville, single-family units include detached stick-built units, attached units, and mobile homes. Multi-family units include structures with two or more units, and all other housing units. Figure A1 below shows the 2019-2023 5-year ACS estimates for Hendersonville. Single-family units averaged 2.56 persons per housing unit (52,188 persons / 20,379 housing units) and multi-family units averaged 1.65 persons per housing unit (9,843 persons / 5,949 housing units). In 2023, Hendersonville’s housing stock averaged 2.36 persons per housing unit. Housing unit estimates from ACS will not equal
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
42
decennial census counts of units. These data are used only to derive the custom PPHU factors for each type of unit. Figure A1: Persons per Housing Unit
Existing Population and Housing Units The 2020 Census estimates for Hendersonville include 61,753 persons and 24,963 housing units. By applying the building permit data shown below in Figure A2 to 2020 US Census estimates, TischlerBise estimates the 2025 housing stock includes 27,138 housing units – 21,032 single-family units and 6,106 multi-family units. The analysis converts housing units to population using the occupancy factors shown in Figure A1. The 2025 population estimate is 66,898 persons. Figure A2: Recent Historical Housing Permit Data
Projected Population and Housing Units To project future population growth, the analysis uses the residential construction data shown in Figure A2. This results in an estimated total increase of 4,377 housing units by 2035. To project future population, the analysis holds the occupancy rate factors in Figure A1 constant throughout the 10-year time horizon. Applying the PPHU factors to the projected housing unit increase results in an estimated increase of 10,455 persons over the next ten years.
!"#$%F'()*"%+H -.IH001111111 H2I3341111111 .560 .4I7821111111 !"#$ 88539 356H9
:;%<"'()*"%+.
2I037111111111 -I303111111111 H582 -I232111111111 %"$# ..569 850.9
=><)% 6.I47H1111111 .3I2.31111111 .532 .6I7.01111111 !"&$ H44549 -5779
!>;?@FA1B5!51CF#M;M1E;?F);I1.4H2'.4.71F*F?"@)#1C>**;#"<+1!;?GF+1-'HF)?1IM<"*)<FM
H51J#@%;KFM1KF<)@LFKI1)<<)@LFK1M<>N#L>;MFOI1)#K1*>P"%F1L>*F1;#"<M5
.51J#@%;KFM1KNF%%"#$M1"#1M<?;@<;?FM1N"<L1<N>1>?1*>?F1;#"<MI1QRMI1)#K1)%%1><LF?1;#"<M5
S>;M"#$
:"T
R)@)#@+1
Q)<FS>;M"#$1=+UF VF?M>#M S>;MFL>%KMVF?M>#M1UF?1
S>;MFL>%K
S>;M"#$1
B#"<M
VF?M>#M1UF?1
S>;M"#$1B#"<
!"#$ %F'()"*+#,F)-./)0F1#,F)-230#)*4'F05*
!"#$ %!! !$ %&#
!"!" '!# " '!#
!"!# %&( #') &$%
!"!! ')% )" %(%
!"!' !(% !%* &##
!"!% !)& " !)&
230#) 67896 :;: 67<6<
=''/#)*=>"$#(" 9?? @6 :9@
A"5FB"'0F#)*C3'50$/M0F3'*2$"'B5
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
43
Figure A3: Residential Development Projections
Nonresidential Development In addition to data on residential development, the calculation of development impact fees requires data on nonresidential development. TischlerBise uses the term jobs to refer to employment by place of work. In Figure A4, gray shading indicates the nonresidential development prototypes used by TischlerBise to derive nonresidential floor area and average weekday vehicle trips. The prototype for industrial development is Manufacturing (ITE 140) with an average of 528 square feet of floor area per employee. For office & other services development, the proxy is General Office (ITE 710) with an average of 307 square feet of floor area per employee. Institutional development uses Government Office (ITE 730) with an average of 350 square feet of floor area per employee. The prototype for commercial development is Shopping Center (ITE 820) with an average of 471 square feet of floor area per employee. Figure A4: Nonresidential Demand Units
!"!# !"!$ !"!% !"!F !"!' !"(" !"(#
)*+H-.H*I 0 ! ( 1 # 0"
!"#$%&'(") **+H-H *.+-/0 *H+-H- .1+10/ .2+1H1 .3+234 ..+040 21+/44
5"$6()789)('6
23456H-7*8369 !0:"(! !0:(FF !0:%1( !!:"'F !!:1#1 !!:F"' !1:#F$ (:##(
;<6=3>7*8369 $:0"$ $:0FF $:!%" $:(#( $:1(# $:#0% $:'!' F!(
:"'&% 3.+20H 3.+4.* 3H+120 3H+/42 3H+HH- 3-+03* 02+424 /+0..
?H4@HI+A4B366H:-
CH44H++HH
0">.H*I-
M4EIH*+H
!"# $%FG()*+)H-".I0-#()1*+)H-".I0-#()1#F023H%%1-4%.567G.%-8%%9
:3)% ;(I9 4%.-$F)-;(I9<4%.-#F023H%%<$%FG()-;(I94%.-#F023H%%
<<=LI?@9-!()719.IG2 <A===-56-89 BCME FC<= <CGE HFE
<F=!()719.IG2-4G.+ <A===-56-89 FCFE ICJ< <C<H MHB
<B=OG(7LGM97.I(? <A===-56-89 BCEG ICG< <CMJ GIM
<G=*G.%@371I(? <A===-56-89 <CE< GC=G =CFB IAJGF
IGBN11I19%)-LIOI(? P%) ICH= BCIB =CH< (G
IGBN11I19%)-LIOI(? <A===-56-89 BC<J BCIB =CJJ <A=<I
F<=Q39%2 .33F ECJJ <BCFB =CGH (G
H<=Q310I9G2 <A===-56-89 <=CEE FCEE ICMH FG=
E<=R%(%.G2-SLLIM%-TGO?-1IU%V<A===-56-89 <=CMB FCFF FCIH F=E
EI=O%)IMG2P$%(9G2-SLLIM% <A===-56-89 FHC== MCE< BC<F IBI
EF=R3O%.(F%(9-SLLIM% <A===-56-89 IICGJ ECBG FC=F FF=
EG=SLLIM%-4G.+ <A===-56-89 <<C=E FCGB FC<F FI=
EH=X%1%G.M@-Y-$%O-:%(9%.<A===-56-89 <<C=M FCFE FCIJ F=B
EE=R71I(%11-4G.+ <A===-56-89 <ICBB BC=B FC=M FIG
MI=5@300I(?-:%(9%.-TGO?-1IU%V<A===-56-89 FEC=< <ECBI IC<I BE<
<C-".I0-R%(%.G9I3(A-!(19I979%-3L-".G(103.9G9I3(-#(?I(%%.1A-<<9@-#)I9I3(-TI=I<VC
LG()-;1%-[-5IU%
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
44
Existing Employment and Floor Area TischlerBise obtains 2024 employment estimates for Hendersonville from Esri Business Analyst. To estimate floor area, the analysis multiplies each sector’s employment total by the employment density factors shown in Figure A4. For 2024, total employment equals 23,861 jobs and estimated floor area equals 9,682,706 square feet. Figure A5: Existing Nonresidential Development
Projected Employment and Floor Area The analysis uses employment and floor area projections to illustrate the possible future pace of service demands, revenues, and expenditures. To the extent these factors change, the projected need for infrastructure will also change. If development occurs at a more rapid rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure will increase at a corresponding rate. If development occurs at a slower rate than projected, the demand for infrastructure will also decrease. The projections are based on compound annual growth rates for Industrial, Commercial and Office & Institutional jobs, which were derived from the Nashville Area Metropolitan Planning Organization’s job estimates for Sumner County in 2017 and 2045. The MPO estimates Industrial jobs will grow by 0.45% per year, Commercial jobs by 1.03% per year, Office & Other Services jobs by 2.12% per year, and Institutional Jobs by 1.65% per year. These growth rates were then applied to the 2024 ESRI job figures to produce estimates for 2025 through 2035. Nonresidential floor area growth was calculated by applying the employee density factors shown in Figure A4 to the growth in jobs. Based on these assumptions, the 10-year projections include an increase of 3,435 jobs and approximately 1.25 million square feet of nonresidential development in Hendersonville.
!"!# $%FG%()*+H -.I0F%*1%%)!"!#*23)450)%6
7+839 J+)0;*7+83 <%F*7+8! 1;++F*=F%0>
?(6I3)F40;# @A9BC !!M @!N !AF#@ACFC
G+55%FG40;@ CA@!! !FM #F9 >A"CBAFBN
HHH4G%*I*H)J%F*-%FO4G%3C CA"N! !@M >"F 9ANCNA>C>
?(3)4)I)4+(0;F CA"C9 !@M >>" 9ABBNANCB
J+)0; !>ANC9 9""M BACN!AF"C
9L*23F4*MI34(%33*=(0;N3)*H(;4(%A*MI34(%33*-I550FNA*!"!#L
!L*JF4<*O%(%F0)4+(A*?(3)4)I)%*+H*JF0(3<+F)0)4+(*2(P4(%%F3A*99)J*264)4+(*Q!"!9RL
>L*J43GJ;%FM43%*G0;GI;0)4+(*Q!"!#*S+83*T*3.I0F%*H%%)*<%F*S+8RL
#L*U0S+F*3%G)+F3*0F%*G+(3)FIG)4+(V*U0(IH0G)IF4(PL
@L*U0S+F*3%G)+F3*0F%*P%)04;V*=GG+55+60)4+(*I*1++6*-%FO4G%3L
CL*U0S+F*3%G)+F3*0F%*H)J%F*-%FO4G%3V*$F+H%334+(0;A*-G4%()4H4G*I*J%GJ*-%FO4G%3L
FL*U0S+F*3%G)+F3*0F%*26IG0)4+(0;*-%FO4G%3V*X%0;)J*G0F%*I*-+G40;*=3343)0(G%L
Y+(F%346%()40;
G0)%P+FN
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
45
Figure A6: Nonresidential Development Projections
!"!# !"!$ !"!% !"!& !"!' !"(" !"(#
)*+H-.H*I 0 ! ( 1 # 0"
!"#$%F"'()
2345+6I7*8 #9!0' #9!1! #9!$$ #9!&' #9(0( #9((% #91#% !(%
:;<<HI=7*8 $9#&' $9$#% $9%!# $9%'1 $9&$1 $9'(1 %9!'& %"!
>??7=H-@->6AHI-BHIC7=H+$9!00 $9(1( $91%% $9$01 $9%#1 $9&'% %9$$" 0910'
23+676567;3*8 $90$0 $9!$( $9($$ $91%0 $9#%& $9$&$ %9!#$ 09"%%
*%)+$ ,-./01 ,-.21- ,-.03- ,2./45 ,2.215 ,2.022 ,6.46/ 3.-32
7%(8'9:;<$%%8;=8'+
2345+6I7*8 !9%#%9'!%!9%%"9!(1!9%&!9#'#!9%'#9"00!9&"%91&(!9&!"9"0"!9&&(91'"0!#9""#
:;<<HI=7*8 (90"09(!0(90((90$&(90$#9(1!(90'%9&1$(9!("9$&1(9!$(9&#'(91(19'0#(("9!"!
>??7=H-@->6AHI-BHIC7=H+09'"%9'#$09'1&9(&&09'&'9$%%!9"(09&1"!9"%19&'%!900&9&$%!9(#(9"'!1(#9&''
23+676567;3*8 !9"(09&1#!9"$#9($1!9"''91(%!90(19"%!!90$'9!%&!9!"#9"$#!9('(9"#!(##9(1$
*%)+$ 5.655.1215.5/6./2-/1.136.121/1./20.645/1.,0,.3-,/1.-16.01///.14-.2-5/.,-4.-2,
DH34HI+;3C788H9-
EH33H++HH
0"F.H*I-
23=IH*+H
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
46
Development Projections Provided below is a summary of Citywide development projections used in the impact fee study. Base year estimates for 2025 are used in the impact fee calculations. Development projections are used to illustrate a possible future pace of demand for service units and cash flows resulting from revenues and expenditures associated with those demands. Figure A7: Development Projections Summary
!"!# !"!$ !"!% !"!F !"!' !"(" !"() !"(! !"(( !"(* !"(#
+H-.I0.H1 ) ! ( * # $ % F ' )"
!"#$%F'(") **+H-H *.+-/0 *H+-H- .1+10/ .2+1H1 .3+234 .0+2.2 ./+32* .4+3*3 .*+01. ..+040 21+/44
5"$6()789)('6
23456.I7H8369 !):"(! !):(FF !):%*( !!:"'F !!:*#* !!:F"' !(:)$* !(:#!" !(:F%# !*:!(" !*:#F$ (:##(
;<6=3>7H8369 $:)"$ $:)FF $:!%" $:(#( $:*(# $:#)% $:$"" $:$F! $:%$* $:F*% $:'!' F!(
:"'F% 3.+20H 3.+4.* 3H+120 3H+/42 3H+HH- 3-+03* 3-+.*/ 01+313 01+*0- 02+1.. 02+424 /+0..
;<#%"=<>)'
?4@<-=13H6 #:!)' #:!*! #:!$$ #:!F' #:()( #:((% #:($" #:(F* #:*"F #:*(( #:*#% !(F
AB88.1C3H6 $:#F' $:$#% $:%!# $:%'* $:F$* $:'(* %:""$ %:"%% %:)#" %:!!* %:!'F %"'
MEE3C.IFIM=G.1I2.1H3C.- $:!)) $:(*( $:*%% $:$)* $:%#* $:F'% %:"** %:)'( %:(*# %:#") %:$$" ):**'
?4-=3=<=3B4H6 $:)$) $:!$( $:($$ $:*%) $:#%F $:$F$ $:%'% $:'"' %:"!( %:)(F %:!#$ ):"'#
:"'F% 3/+2H1 3/+41/ 3/+H0/ 34+2*- 34+41- 34+H44 3*+31* 3*+4*0 3*+-3* 3.+3-* 3.+*.2 0+/-2
?")@>6A8BCA8D'A8NF2+111G
?4@<-=13H6 !:%#F !:%%" !:%F( !:%'# !:F"% !:F!" !:F(( !:F*# !:F#F !:F%) !:FF( )!$
AB88.1C3H6 (:)") (:)(( (:)$# (:)'F (:!() (:!$* (:!'% (:(() (:($# (:*"" (:*(# ((*
MEE3C.IFIM=G.1I2.1H3C.- ):'"F ):'*F ):''" !:"(! !:"%# !:))' !:)$* !:!)" !:!#$ !:("* !:(#( **#
?4-=3=<=3B4H6 !:"(! !:"$# !:"'' !:)(* !:)$' !:!"# !:!*) !:!%F !:()$ !:(#* !:('( ($)
:"'F% -+.-- -+-2. 21+10. 21+24- 21+3H3 21+/1H 21+404 21+**4 21+.-* 21+-3- 22+1*4 2+3*4
I.4@.1-B4H366.:IJ.44.--.. )">0.H1I
?4C1.H-.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
47
APPENDIX B: LAND USE DEFINITIONS Residential Development As discussed below, residential development categories are based on data from the U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey. Hendersonville will collect impact fees from all new residential units. One-time impact fees are determined by site capacity (i.e., number of residential units). Single-Family: 1. Single-family detached is a one-unit structure detached from any other house, that is, with open space on all four sides. Such structures are considered detached even if they have an adjoining shed or garage. A one-family house that contains a business is considered detached as long as the building has open space on all four sides. 2. Single-family attached (townhouse) is a one-unit structure that has one or more walls extending from ground to roof separating it from adjoining structures. In row houses (sometimes called townhouses), double houses, or houses attached to nonresidential structures, each house is a separate, attached structure if the dividing or common wall goes from ground to roof. 3. Mobile home includes both occupied and vacant mobile homes, to which no permanent rooms have been added, are counted in this category. Mobile homes used only for business purposes or for extra sleeping space and mobile homes for sale on a dealer's lot, at the factory, or in storage are not counted in the housing inventory. Multi-Family: 1. 2+ units (duplexes and apartments) are units in structures containing two or more housing units, further categorized as units in structures with “2, 3 or 4, 5 to 9, 10 to 19, 20 to 49, and 50 or more apartments.” 2. Boat, RV, Van, etc. includes any living quarters occupied as a housing unit that does not fit the other categories (e.g., houseboats, railroad cars, campers, and vans). Recreational vehicles, boats, vans, railroad cars, and the like are included only if they are occupied as a current place of residence.
Impact Fee Study Hendersonville, Tennessee
48
Nonresidential Development The proposed general nonresidential development categories (defined below) can be used for all new construction within Hendersonville. Nonresidential development categories represent general groups of land uses that share similar average weekday vehicle trip generation rates and employment densities (i.e., jobs per thousand square feet of floor area). Commercial: Establishments primarily selling merchandise, eating/drinking places, and entertainment uses. By way of example, Commercial includes shopping centers, supermarkets, pharmacies, restaurants, bars, nightclubs, automobile dealerships, and movie theaters. Industrial: Establishments primarily engaged in the production, transportation, or storage of goods. By way of example, Industrial includes manufacturing plants, distribution warehouses, trucking companies, utility substations, power generation facilities, and telecommunications buildings. Institutional: Public and quasi-public buildings providing educational, social assistance, or religious services. By way of example, Institutional includes schools, universities, churches, daycare facilities, hospitals, and government buildings. Office: Establishments providing management, administrative, professional, or business services. By way of example, Office includes banks, business offices, medical offices, and veterinarian clinics.
Impact fee Report
Prepared for:
Hendersonville, Tennessee
January 26, 2024
4701 Sangamore Road
Suite S240
Bethesda, MD 20816
301.320.6900
www.TischlerBise.com
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
[PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................. 1
Tennessee Legal Framework ......................................................................................................................................... 1
General Legal Framework ............................................................................................................................................... 1
General Methodologies ..................................................................................................................................................... 3
Cost Recovery (Past Improvements) ............................................................................................................... 3
Incremental Expansion (Concurrent Improvements) .............................................................................. 3
Plan-Based (Future Improvements) ................................................................................................................ 3
Conceptual Impact fee Calculation .............................................................................................................................. 4
Credits ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
Proposed Fee Methodologies and Cost Components ........................................................................................... 4
Impact fee Schedule ........................................................................................................................................................... 5
PARKS IMPACT FEES .................................................................................................................................... 6
Methodology ................................................................................................................................................................ ......... 6
Proportionate Share .......................................................................................................................................................... 6
Demand Units ....................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Park Land – Incremental Expansion ........................................................................................................................... 6
Park Improvements – Incremental Expansion ....................................................................................................... 8
Projected Demand for Growth-Related Parks Infrastructure .......................................................................... 9
Park Land .................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Park Improvements .............................................................................................................................................. 10
Maximum Allowable Parks Impact fees .................................................................................................................. 11
Projected Parks Impact fee Revenue ........................................................................................................................ 12
APPENDIX A: LAND USE ASSUMPTIONS ................................................................................................... 13
Summary of Growth Indicators .................................................................................................................................. 14
Residential Development .............................................................................................................................................. 15
Persons Per Housing Unit ................................................................................................................................... 15
Residential Estimates ........................................................................................................................................... 16
Residential Projections ........................................................................................................................................ 16
APPENDIX B: LAND USE DEFINITIONS...................................................................................................... 17
Residential Development .............................................................................................................................................. 17
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
ii
[PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2023, the City of Hendersonville retained TischlerBise to analyze the impacts of future development on
park facilities and to calculate impact fees based on that analysis. Through interviews and discussions with
staff, TischlerBise developed the proposed impact fees discussed in this report. Impact fees are collected
from new construction at the time a building permit is issued and used to construct system improvements
needed to accommodate future development. An impact fee represents future development’s
proportionate share of capital facility needs. Impact fees do have limitations and should not be regarded
as the total solution for infrastructure funding needs. Rather, they are one component of a comprehensive
portfolio to ensure provision of adequate public facilities needed to serve future development. In contrast
to general taxes, impact fees may not be used for operations, maintenance, replacement of infrastructure,
or correcting existing deficiencies.
The City of Hendersonville has experienced steady residential growth in recent years, and this growth is
expected to continue in the future. As a result, Hendersonville must plan for future park improvements if
existing levels of service are to be maintained.
TENNESSEE LEGAL FRAMEWORK
While the State of Tennessee does not have specific authorizing legislation for impact fees, the State does
grant the power for municipalities with a mayor- aldermanic charter to impose impact fee s on new
development. As a mayor-aldermanic charter city, the City of Hendersonville may:
“Establish, open, relocate, vacate, alter, widen, extend, grade, improve, repair, construct, reconstruct,
maintain, light, sprinkle and clean public highways, streets, boulevards, parkways, sidewalks, alleys, parks,
public grounds, public facilities, libraries and squares, wharves, bridges, viaducts, subways, tunnels,
sewers and drains within or without the corporate limits, regulate their use within the corporate limits,
assess fees for the use of or impact upon such property and facilities, and take and appropriate property
therefor under § 7-31-107 -- 7-31-111 and § 29-16-203, or any other manner provided by general laws.”
(Tenn. Code Ann. § 6-2-201 (15))
GENERAL LEGAL FRAMEWORK
Both state and federal courts have recognized the imposition of impact fee s as a legitimate form of land
use regulation, provided the fees meet standards intended to protect against regulatory takings. Land use
regulations, development exactions, and impact fees are subject to the Fifth Amendment prohibition on
taking of private property for public use without just compensation. To comply with the Fifth Amendment,
development regulations must be shown to substantially advance a legitimate governmental inter est. In
the case of impact fees, that interest is in the protection of public health, safety, and welfare by ensuring
development is not detrimental to the quality of essential public services. The means to this end are also
important, requiring both procedural and substantive due proce ss. The process followed to receive
community input (i.e., stakeholder meetings, work sessions, and public hearings) provides opportunities
for comments and refinements to the impact fees.
There is little federal case law specifically dealing with impact fees, although other rulings on other types
of exactions (e.g., land dedication requirements) are relevant. In one of the most important exaction
cases, the U. S. Supreme Court found that a government agency imposing exactions on development must
demonstrate an “essential nexus” between the exaction and the interest being protected (see Nollan v.
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
2
California Coastal Commission, 1987). In a more recent case (Dolan v. City of Tigard, OR, 1994), the Court
ruled that an exaction must also be “roughly proportional” to the burden created by development.
However, the Dolan decision appeared to set a higher standard of review for mandatory dedications of
land than for monetary exactions such as impact fees.
There are three reasonable relationship requirements for impact fees that are closely related to “rational
nexus”, or “reasonable relationship” requirements enunciated by a number of state courts. Although the
term “dual rational nexus” is often used to characterize the standard by which courts evaluate the validity
of impact fees under the U.S. Constitution, we prefer a more rigorous formulation that recognizes three
elements: “need,” “benefit,” and “proportionality.” The dual rational nexus test explicitly addresses only
the first two, although proportionality is reasonably implied, and was specifically mentioned by the U.S.
Supreme Court in the Dolan case. Individual elements of the nexus standard are discussed further in the
following paragraphs.
All new development in a community creates additional demands on some, or all, public facilities provided
by local government. If the capacity of facilities is not increased to satisfy that additional demand, the
quality or availability of public services for the entire community will deteriorate. Impact fees may be used
to recover the cost of development-related facilities, but only to the extent that the need for facilities is
a consequence of development that is subject to the fees. The Nollan decision reinforced the principle
that development exactions may be used only to mitigate conditions created by the developments upon
which they are imposed. That principle clearly applies to impact fee s. In this study, the impact of
development on infrastructure needs is analyzed in terms of quantifiable relationships between various
types of development and the demand for specific capital facilities, based on applicable level- of-service
standards.
The requirement that exactions be proportional to the impacts of development was clearly stated by the
U.S. Supreme Court in the Dolan case and is logically necessary to establish a proper nexus. Proportionality
is established through the procedures used to identify development -related facility costs, and in the
methods used to calculate impact fees for various types of facilities and categories of development. The
demand for capital facilities is measured in terms of relevant and measurable attributes of d evelopment
(e.g., a typical housing unit’s average weekday vehicle trips).
A sufficient benefit relationship requires that impact fee revenues be segregated from other funds and
expended only on the facilities for which the fees were charged. Impact fees must be expended in a timely
manner and the facilities funded by the fees must serve the development paying the fees. However,
nothing in the U.S. Constitution or the state enabling legislation requires that facilities funded with fee
revenues be available exclusively to development paying the fees. In other words, benefit may extend to
a general area including multiple real estate developments. Procedures for the earmarking and
expenditure of fee revenues are discussed near the end of this study. All of these procedural as well as
substantive issues are intended to ensure that new development benefits from the impact fees they are
required to pay. The authority and procedures to implement impact fee s is separate from and
complementary to the authority to require improvements as part of subdivision or zoning review.
As documented in this report, the City of Hendersonville has complied with applicable legal precedents.
Impact fee s are proportionate and reasonably related to the capital improvement demands of new
development. Specific costs have been identified using local data and current dollars. With input from City
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
3
staff, TischlerBise identified demand indicators for each type of infrastructure and calculated
proportionate share factors to allocate costs by type of development. This report documents the formulas
and input variables used to calculate the impact fee s for each type of public facility. Impact fee
methodologies also identify the extent to which new development is entitled to various types of credits
to avoid potential double payment of growth-related capital costs.
GENERAL METHODOLOGIES
There are three general methodologies for calculating impact fees. The choice of a particular methodology
depends primarily on the timing of infrastructure construction (past, concurrent, or future) and service
characteristics of the facility type being addressed. Each methodology has advantages and disadvantages
in a particular situation, and can be used simultaneously for different cost components.
Reduced to its simplest terms, the process of calculating impact fee s involves two main steps: (1)
determining the cost of development- related capital improvements and (2) allocating those costs
equitably to various types of development. In practice, though, the calculation of impact fees can become
quite complicated because of the many variables involved in defining the relationship between
development and the need for facilities within the designated service area. The following paragraphs
discuss three basic methodologies for calculating impact fee s and how those methodologies can be
applied.
Cost Recovery (Past Improvements)
The rationale for recoupment, often called cost recovery, is that future development is paying for its share
of the useful life and remaining capacity of facilities already built, or land already purchased, from which
future development will benefit. This methodology is often used for utility systems that must provide
adequate capacity before future development can take place.
Incremental Expansion (Concurrent Improvements)
The incremental expansion methodology documents current level -of-service (LOS) standards for each
type of public facility, using both quantitative and qualitative measures. This approach assumes there are
no deficiencies or surplus capacity in existing infrastructure , and future development is paying only its
proportionate share for growth- related infrastructure. Revenue will be used to expand or provide
additional facilities, as needed, to accommodate future development. An incremental expansion cost
methodology is best suited for public facilities that will be expanded in regular increments to keep pace
with development.
Plan-Based (Future Improvements)
The plan-based methodology allocates costs for a specified set of improvements to a specified amount of
development. Improvements are typically identified in a long -range facility plan and development
potential is identified by a land use plan. There are two options for determining the cost per demand unit:
(1) total cost of a public facility can be divided by total demand units (average cost), or ( 2) the growth-
share of the public facility cost can be divided by the net increase in demand units over the planning
timeframe (marginal cost).
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
4
CONCEPTUAL IMPACT FEE CALCULATION
In contrast to project-level improvements, impact fees fund growth-related infrastructure that will benefit
multiple development projects, or the entire jurisdiction (referred to as system improvements). The first
step is to determine an appropriate demand indicator for the particular type of infrastructure. The
demand indicator measures the number of demand units for each unit of development. For example, an
appropriate indicator of the demand for park facilities is population growth, and the increase in
population can be estimated from the average number of residents per housing unit. The second step in
the impact fee formula is to determine infrastructure units per demand unit, typically called level- of-
service (LOS) standards. In keeping with the parks example, a common LOS standard is park amenities per
resident. The third step in the impact fee formula is the cost of various infrastructure units. To complete
the parks example, this part of the formula would establish the cost for purchasing and/or const ructing
new park amenities.
CREDITS
Regardless of the methodology, a consideration of credits is integral to the development of a legally
defensible impact fee. There are two types of credits that should be addressed in impact fee studies and
ordinances. The first is a revenue credit due to possible double payment situations, which could occur
when other revenues may contribute to the capital costs of infrastructure covered by the impact fee. This
type of credit is integrated into the fee calculation, thus reducing the fee amount. The second is a site -
specific credit or developer reimbursement for dedication of land or construction of system
improvements. An example would be if a developer builds a park with improvements and dedicates to
the City. This type of credit is addressed in the administration and implementation of the development
fee program. For ease of administration, TischlerBise normally recommends developer reimbursements
for system improvements.
PROPOSED FEE METHODOLOGIES AND COST COMPONENTS
Shown below, Figure 1 summarizes the method ology and cost allocation components used for
Hendersonville’s parks impact fee report. Costs were allocated only to residential development , as
nonresidential development generated negligible demand for park facilities. P opulation was used as the
cost allocation factor.
Figure 1: Proposed Impact fee Methodologies and Cost Components
Infrastructure
Category
Service
Area
Cost
Recovery
Incremental
Expansion Plan-Based Cost
Allocation
Parks Citywide N/A Park Land, Park
Improvements N/A Population
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
5
IMPACT FEE SCHEDULE
Impact fees for residential development will be assessed per dwelling unit, based on the type of unit. The
fees shown in Figures 2 represent the maximum allowable impact fees – the proposed impact fees fund
100 percent of growth-related park infrastructure. Hendersonville may adopt impact fee s that are less
than the amounts shown; however, a reduction in impact fee revenue will necessitate an increase in other
revenues, a decrease in planned capital improvements and/or a decrease in Hendersonville ’s LOS
standards. All costs in the impact fee study are in current dollars with no assumed inflation rate over time.
If cost estimates change significantly over time, impact fees should be recalculated.
Figure 2: Maximum Allowable Impact fees
A note on rounding: Calculations throughout this report are based on an analysis conducted using Excel
software. Most results are discussed in the report using one-, two-, and three-digit places, which represent
rounded figures. However, the analysis itself uses figures carried to their ultimate decimal places;
therefore, the sums and products generated in the analysis may not equal the sum or product if the reader
replicates the calculation with the factors shown in the report (due to the rounding of figures shown, not
in the analysis).
Residential Development
Single Family 2.63 $7,197
Multi-Family 1.78 $4,871
1. See Land Use Assumptions
Development Type Persons per
Housing Unit1
Proposed
Fees
Fees per Unit
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
6
PARKS IMPACT FEES
METHODOLOGY
The Parks impact fee includes components for park land and park improvements. Parks impact fees use
the incremental expansion methodology . Costs are allocated only to residential development using
persons per housing unit to allocate costs.
PROPORTIONATE SHARE
TischlerBise recommends allocating 100 percent of the cost of parks infrastructure to residential
development since nonresidential development generates negligible demand for parks infrastructure.
DEMAND UNITS
Residential impact fees are calculated on a per capita basis, then converted to an appropriate amount for
each type of housing unit based on the number of persons per housing unit (PPHU). As shown in Figure
PR1, the current PPHU factors are 2. 63 persons per single-family unit and 1.78 persons per multi-family
unit. These factors are based on the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2017-2021 American Community Survey 5-year
estimates (further discussed in Appendix A).
Figure PR1: Demand Units
PARK LAND – INCREMENTAL EXPANSION
As shown below in Figure PR2, the City of Hendersonville has 514 acres of existing park land. In order to
maintain existing levels of service the City plans to expand its current inventory of park land to serve future
development. To determine the existing level of service, the current land inventory is compared to the
current number of residents in the City. This results in a level of service of 0.0079 acres per person (514
acres X 100 percent residential share / 65,059 persons).
The cost of an acre of land is estimated at $275,000, based on an estimate provided by the City. For park
land, the cost per demand unit is $2,172.65 per person (0.0079 acres per person X $275,000 per acre).
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
7
Figure PR2: Park Land Level of Service
Description Acres
Batey Farm 75
Drakes Creek Park 135
Mallard Point Boat Launch 4
Memorial Park 44
Rugby Park 13
Sander Ferry Park 70
Veterens Park 28
Volunteer Park 45
Warrior Bike Trail 24
Durham Farm Parkland 76
Total 514
Cost per Acre $275,000
Existing Acres 514
Residential Share 100%
2023 Population 65,059
Acres per Person 0.0079
Cost per Person $2,172.65
Source: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Cost Allocation Factors
Residential
Level-of-Service (LOS) Standards
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
8
PARK IMPROVEMENTS – INCREMENTAL EXPANSION
As shown in Figure PR3 below, City of Hendersonville parks contain 142 improvements. The City plans to
expand its current inventory of 142 park improvements to serve future development. The analysis
allocates 100 percent of demand for park improvements to residential development. Hendersonville ’s
existing level of service is 0.0022 improvements per person (142 improvements X 100 percent residential
share / 65,059 persons).
Based on the total replacement cost of $36,687,141 for Hendersonville’s existing 142 park improvements,
the average replacement cost is $259,273 per improvement. For park improvements, the cost per demand
unit is $563.91 per person (0.0022 improvements per person X $259,273 per improvement).
Figure PR3: Park Improvements Level of Service
Description Improvements Unit Cost Replacement Cost
Concession Stand 8 $391,597 $3,132,773
Boat/Kayak Access 2 $48,680 $97,360
Fishing Pier 2 $53,505 $107,010
Disc Golf Course 1 $16,038 $16,038
Playground 11 $261,214 $2,873,359
Football Field 1 $315,618 $315,618
Baseball / Softball Field 16 $237,743 $3,803,881
Batting Cage 5 $51,198 $255,988
Basketball Court 1 $15,000 $15,000
Lacrosse Field 2 $1,286 $2,572
Soccer Field 24 $618,529 $14,535,424
Multi-Purpose Field 3 $200,000 $600,000
Tennis / Pickleball 12 $126,612 $1,519,339
In-line Hockey Rink 2 $2,000,000 $4,000,000
Sand Volleyball 3 $10,000 $30,000
Picnic Shelters 21 $102,384 $2,150,054
Charcoal Grill 10 $500 $5,000
Skate Park 1 $130,178 $130,178
Dog Park 1 $39,097 $39,097
Model Airplane Field 1 $28,591 $28,591
Maintenance Facility 1 $243,883 $243,883
Restroom Facility 14 $198,998 $2,785,976
Total 142 $259,273 $36,687,141
Cost per Improvement $259,273
Existing Improvements 142
Residential Share 100%
2023 Population 65,059
Improvements per Person 0.0022
Cost per Person $563.91
Source: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Level-of-Service (LOS) Standards
Residential
Cost Allocation Factors
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
9
PROJECTED DEMAND FOR GROWTH-RELATED PARKS INFRASTRUCTURE
Park Land
To accommodate projected development over the next ten years, Hendersonville will acquire additional
park land as development occurs. Figure PR4 forecasts growth-related demand for park improvements.
Hendersonville’s population is projected to increase by 11,127 persons by 2 033. Using the 2023 LOS,
future residential development will demand approximately 88 additional park acres (11,127 additional
persons X 0.0079 acres per person). Based on demand for 88 park acres and a cost of $275,000 per acre,
the growth-related expenditure on park improvements is $24,175,912.
Figure PR4: Growth-Related Demand for Park Land
Demand Unit Cost per Acre
2023 65,059 514
2024 66,172 523
2025 67,284 532
2026 68,397 540
2027 69,510 549
2028 70,623 558
2029 71,735 567
2030 72,848 576
2031 73,961 584
2032 75,074 593
2033 76,186 602
10-Yr Increase 11,127 88
$24,175,912 Growth-Related Expenditures
Year Population Acres
Type of Infrastructure Level of Service
Park Land $275,000
Demand for Park Land
0.0079 Acres per Person
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
10
Park Improvements
To accommodate projected development over the next ten years, Hendersonville will construct additional
park improvements as development occurs. Figure PR5 forecasts growth-related demand for park
improvements. Hendersonville’s population is projected to increase by 11,127 persons by 2033. Using the
2023 LOS, future residential development will demand approximately 24.2 additional park improvements
(11,127 additional persons X 0. 0022 improvements per person). Based on demand for 24.2 park
improvements and an average cost of $ 259,273 per improvement, the growth -related expenditure on
park improvements is $6,274,815.
Figure PR5: Growth-Related Demand for Park Improvements
Demand Unit Cost per Unit
2023 65,059 141.5
2024 66,172 143.9
2025 67,284 146.3
2026 68,397 148.8
2027 69,510 151.2
2028 70,623 153.6
2029 71,735 156.0
2030 72,848 158.4
2031 73,961 160.9
2032 75,074 163.3
2033 76,186 165.7
10-Yr Increase 11,127 24.2
$6,274,815
Level of Service
per Person0.0022 Units
Type of Infrastructure
Park Improvements $259,273
Demand for Park Amenities
Year Population Units
Growth-Related Expenditures
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
11
MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE PARKS IMPACT FEES
Infrastructure components and cost factors used to calculate maximum allowable Parks impact fees are
summarized in the upper portion of Figure PR6. Residential impact fees are calculated using a cost of
$2,736.55 per person and the average number of persons per housing unit. For a single -family unit, the
fee of $ 7,197 is calculated using a cost of $ 2,736.55 per person multiplied by 2. 63 persons per housing
unit.
Figure PR6: Maximum Allowable Parks Impact fees
Fee Component Cost per Person
Park Land $2,172.65
Park Improvements $563.91
Total $2,736.55
Residential Development
Single Family 2.63 $7,197
Multi-Family 1.78 $4,871
1. See Land Use Assumptions
Development Type Persons per
Housing Unit1
Proposed
Fees
Fees per Unit
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
12
PROJECTED PARKS IMPACT FEE REVENUE
Revenue projections assume implementation of the maximum allowable Parks impact fee s and that
development over the next ten years is consistent with the development projections in Appendix A. To
the extent the rate of development either accelerates or slows down, there will be a corresponding
change in the impact fee revenue. As shown in Figure PR7, projected fee revenue equals approximately
$30 million over the next ten years compared to projected expenditures of approximately $30 million.
Figure PR7: Projected Parks Impact fee Revenue
Growth Share Existing Share Total
Park Land $24,175,912 $0 $24,175,912
Park Improvements $6,274,815 $0 $6,274,815
Total $30,450,726 $0 $30,450,726
Single Family Multi-Family
$7,197 $4,871
per unit per unit
Hsg Unit Hsg Unit
Base 2023 19,799 6,421
Year 1 2024 20,063 6,655
Year 2 2025 20,328 6,889
Year 3 2026 20,593 7,123
Year 4 2027 20,857 7,357
Year 5 2028 21,122 7,592
Year 6 2029 21,387 7,826
Year 7 2030 21,652 8,060
Year 8 2031 21,916 8,294
Year 9 2032 22,181 8,528
Year 10 2033 22,446 8,762
2,647 2,340
$19,050,813 $11,399,913
$30,450,726
$0Existing Development Share
Fee Component
Year
10-Year Increase
Projected Revenue
Projected Fee Revenue
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
13
APPENDIX A: LAND USE ASSUMPTIONS
The City of Hendersonville retained TischlerBise to prepare this study to analyze the impacts of
development on the city’s capital facilities and to calculate development impact fees based on that
analysis. The population and housing unit projections contained in this document provide the foundation
for the development impact fee study. To evaluate the demand for growth -related infrastructure from
various types of development, TischlerBise prepared documentation on demand indicators by type of
housing unit. These metrics are the service units and demand indicators used in the development impact
fee study.
Development impact fees are based on the need for growth -related improvements, and they must be
proportionate by type of land use. The demographic data and development projections are used to
demonstrate proportionality and anticipate the need for future infrastructure. Development impact fee
studies typically look out five to ten years, with the expectation that fees will be updated every three to
five years. The estimates and projections of residential and nonresidential development in this Land Use
Assumptions document are for areas within the boundaries of Hendersonville, Tennessee. The map below
illustrates the areas within the Hendersonville Development Impact Fee Service Area.
Figure A1: Development Impact Fee Service Area Map
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
14
SUMMARY OF GROWTH INDICATORS
Key development projections for the Hendersonville development impact fee study include housing units
and nonresidential floor area. TischlerBise estimates population and housing units using US Census data.
The projections contained in this document provide the foundation for the Development Impact Fee
Study.
These projections are used to estimate development impact fee revenue and to indicate the anticipated
need for growth-related infrastructure. The goal is to have reasonable projections without being overly
concerned with precision. Because development impa ct fee methods are designed to reduce sensitivity
to development projections in the determination of the proportionate- share fee amounts, if actual
development is slower than projected, fee revenue will decline, but so will the need for growth -related
infrastructure. In contrast, if development is faster than anticipated, Hendersonville will receive more fee
revenue, but will also need to accelerate infrastructure improvements to keep pace with the actual rate
of development.
During the next 10 years, TischlerBise projects an average annual increase of 499 housing units per year.
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
15
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
Current estimates and future projections of residential development are detailed in this section including
population and housing units by type.
Persons Per Housing Unit
According to the U.S. Census Bureau, a household is a housing unit occupied by year -round residents.
Development impact fees often use per capita standards and persons per housing unit (PPHU) or persons
per household (PPH) to derive proportionate share fee amounts. When PPHU is used in the fee
calculations, infrastructure standards are derived using year- round population. When PPH is used in the
fee calculations, the development impact fee methodology assumes a higher percentage of housing units
will be occ upied, thus requiring seasonal or peak population to be used when deriving infrastructure
standards. TischlerBise recommends that Hendersonville impose development impact fees for residential
development according to the number of persons per housing unit.
Occupancy calculations require data on population and the types of units by structure. The 20 20 census
did not obtain detailed information using a “long- form” questionnaire. Instead, the U.S. Census Bureau
switched to a continuous monthly mailing of surveys, known as the American Community Survey (ACS),
which has limitations due to sample -size constraints. For example, data on detached housing units are
now combined with attached single units (commonly known as townhouses, which share a common
sidewall, but are constructed on an individual parcel of land). For development impact fees in
Hendersonville, detached stick -built units, attached units, and mobile home units are included in the
“Single-Family” category. The second residential category includes duplexes and all other structures with
two or more units on an individual parcel of land. This is referred to as “Multi-Family” category. (Note:
housing unit estimates from ACS will not equal decennial census counts of units. These data are used only
to derive the custom PPHU factors for each type of unit).
Figure A2 below shows the ACS 202 1 5-Year Estimates for Hendersonville . Single-family units averaged
2.63 persons per housing unit ( 50,101 persons / 19, 038 housing units) and multi -family units had an
average of 1.78 persons per housing unit (10,350 persons / 5,805 housing units).
Figure A2: Persons per Housing Unit by Type of Housing
Single-Family Units1
50,101 18,403 2.72 19,038 2.63 76.6% 3.30%
Multi-Family Units2
10,350 5,162 2.01 5,805 1.78 23.4% 11.10%
Total 60,451 23,565 2.57 24,843 2.43 100.0% 5.10%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2017-2021 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates
1. Includes detached, attached (i.e. townhouses).
2. Includes dwellings in structures with two or more units, and mobile home units.
Housing
Mix Vacancy RateHousing Type Persons Households Persons per
Household Housing Units Persons per
Housing Unit
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
16
Residential Estimates
This analysis projects housing units based on building permit data provided by Hendersonville staff. By
applying the building permit data shown below in Figure A 3 to 2020 US Census estimates, TischlerBise
estimates the 202 3 housing stock includes 26,220 housing units – 19,799 single-family units and 6,421
multi-family units. The analysis converts housing units to population using the occupancy factors shown
in Figure A2. The 2023 population estimate is 65,059 persons.
Figure A3: Residential Building Permits
Residential Projections
TischlerBise projects future residential development beyond the 2023 base year using the building permit
data shown in Figure A3. Over the next 10 years, this results in an increase of 2,647 single-family units and
4,166 multi-family units. To project future population, the analysis converts housing units to population
using the occupancy factors shown in Figure A2. For this study, it is assumed that the housing unit size will
remain constant. TischlerBise projects a 10-year increase of 4,987 housing units and 11,127 persons (2,647
single-family units X 2.63 persons per housing unit + 4,166 multi-family units X 1.78 persons per housing
unit).
Figure A4: Residential Development Projections
Year Single Multi Total
2019 344 97 441
2020 245 137 382
2021 230 328 558
2022 202 115 317
2023* 303 493 796
AVERAGE 265 234 499
*Prorated
2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2033
Base Year 1 2 3 4 5 10
Population
Single Family 52,961 53,657 54, 353 55,049 55,745 56,441 59,922 6,962
Multi-Family 12,098 12,515 12, 931 13,348 13,765 14,181 16,264 4,166
Population 65,059 66,172 67, 284 68,397 69,510 70,623 76,186 11,127
Housing Units
Single Family 19,799 20,063 20, 328 20,593 20,857 21,122 22,446 2,647
Multi-Family 6,421 6,655 6, 889 7,123 7,357 7,592 8,762 2,340
Total 26,220 26,719 27, 217 27,716 28,215 28,714 31,207 4,987
10-Year
IncreaseHendersonville
Impact fee Report
Hendersonville, Tennessee
17
APPENDIX B: LAND USE DEFINITIONS
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
As discussed below, residential development categories are based on data from the U.S. Census Bureau,
American Community Survey. The City of Hendersonville will collect impact fees from all new residential
units. One-time impact fees are determined by site capacity (i.e., number of residential units).
Single-Family Units:
1. Single-family detached is a one-unit structure detached from any other house, that is, with open
space on all four sides. Such structures are considered detached even if they have an adjoining
shed or garage. A one-family house that contains a business is considered detached as long as the
building has open space on all four sides.
2. Single-family attached (townhouse) is a one-unit structure that has one or more walls extending
from ground to roof separating it from adjoining structures. In row houses (sometimes called
townhouses), double houses, or houses attached to nonresidential structures, each house is a
separate, attached structure if the dividing or common wall goes from ground to roof.
Multi-Family Units:
1. 2+ units (duplexes and apartments) are units in structures containing two or more housing units,
further categorized as units in structures with “2, 3 or 4, 5 to 9, 10 to 19, 20 to 49, and 50 or more
apartments.”
2. Boat, RV, Van, Etc. includes any living quarters occupied as a housing unit that does not fit the
other categories (e.g., houseboats, railroad cars, campers, and vans). Recreational vehicles, boats,
vans, railroad cars, and the like are included only if they are occupied as a current place of
residence.
3. Mobile home includes both occupied and vacant mobile homes, to which no permanent rooms
have been added. Mobile homes used only for business purposes or for extra sleeping space and
mobile homes for sale on a dealer's lot, at the factory, or in storage are not counted in the housing
inventory.
Source: City of Hendersonville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.