Audit and Finance Committee Meeting Agenda and Documents — Agenda Minutes
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Audit and Finance Committee · meeting of May 14, 2025 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING NOTES
AFC Members in Attendance: Mr. Kevin Carroll, Mr. Jim Holland.
Staff in Attendance: Dr. Joe Casey, County Administrator, Matt Harris, Deputy County Administrator,
Finance and Administration; Gerard Durkin, Budget Director; Khara Durden, IA Director; Steve Sanderson,
IA Assistant Director; Mary Martin Selby, HR Director, Consuela Wilson, Accounting Director; Stephanie
Brown, Procurement Director.
Audit and Finance
Committee of the
Board of Supervisors
DATE: May 14th, 2025
Time: 2:00 p.m.
Location: Room 502
Attendees:
Kevin Carroll
Jim Holland
Dr. Joe Casey
Matt Harris
Stephanie Brown
Khara Durden
Gerard Durkin
Steve Sanderson
Mary Martin Selby
Consuela Wilson
Item Person Responsible Outcome
1. Mercer - Medical Claims Audit Findings
Mary Martin Selby/
Sharon Heuring/
Carlene Smith/
Kathy Woollum
2. Budget Updates
Matt Harris/
Gerard Durkin
3. Internal Audit:
a. FY25 Audit Plan and Hotline Activity Update
b. FY26 Proposed Audit Plan Review and Approval
c. Periodic Reports:
i. Budget, Community Contracts, February 20, 2025
ii. FY25 Audit Follow-Up, February 27, 2025
Khara Durden/
Steve Sanderson
AFC School Board in attendance: Ms. Ann Coker, Chair, Ms. Lisa Hudgins, Vice Chair, Bob Meister,
Chief Financial Officer and Dr. John Murray, Superintendent.
Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at 2:01 P.M.
1. Mercer – Medical Claims Findings: Mary Martin Selby, HR Director
a. Mary introduced the county and schools medical audit project that the AFC had requested and turned
it over to Kathy Woollum, Partner, with Mercer, a national HR Consulting firm that conducted the
audit. Ms. Woollum leads Mercer’s Richmond offices.
b. Kathy Woollum shared, that Carlene Smith oversaw the process of this audit and Sharon Heuring,
was the project lead.
c. Kathy continued by sharing the executive summary, audit process and key findings.
d. There were 16 errors identified during the audit:
13 overpayments totaling $1,874
1 underpayment in the amount of $8
2 non-financial
e. Within the claims population, we identified 69 claims totaling $4,754 in erroneous payments.
f. The top error categories were:
Not covered, 31% of all errors
Benefit determination, 25% of all errors
Duplicates, 25% of all errors
g. The cause of errors included:
10 errors were systemic in nature, which are of special concern as their impact can be widespread.
6 errors were processor-related.
h. Elevance disagreed with 7 of 16 errors assessed.
i. Time for questions and answers was provided.
j. Dr. Casey shared the processes of acquiring Health Insurance and explained that the quantity of
audits and frequency is based on the findings. Dr. Casey also shared that the County and School
insures several thousand employees and their families.
k. Mary Martin Selby shared that out of almost 300,000 CY2022 claims under review by Mercer, 150
claims were identified as requiring additional follow up. And of the 150, there were 16 errors
identified by Mercer. All findings have since been corrected or are being currently adjusted and will
reflect as a credit on an upcoming billing statement.
l. Anthem (Elevance) maintains they provide industry-leading program integrity services through their
Program Integrity Aligned Incentives (PIAI) program. With a team of over 2,100 associates
exclusively focused on preventing and recovering overpayments and eliminating fraud, waste and
abuse, the program monitors provider billing and prevents and recovers overpayments due to
provider billing errors and fraud, waste and abuse. Their program integrity framework is built on
collaboration that drives transformation. Utilizing their people, tools and innovations, their claims
editing, data mining, complex clinical auditing, special investigation unit (SIU) and identification of
other coverage programs, delivered $3,181,039 in savings for Chesterfield in 2022.
2. FY25 Budget Update: Matt Harris, Deputy County Administrator; Gerard Durkin, Budget Director
a. Matt Harris provided details of FY25 items, with budget amendments required for the designated
items. The budget amendments do not require changes to the FY26 budget.
b. Public hearing for FY25 budget amendments will take place May 28
th at the BOS meeting.
c. Matt concluded with a timeline of FY25 year-end allocations.
3. Internal Audit: Khara Durden, IA Director; Steven Sanderson, IA Assistant Director
a. Khara Durden shared FY25 activities.
i. All projects are completed or have been started. No projects have not been started.
b. Steven Sanderson shared the Hotline activity update with time for questions provided.
c. Khara presented FY26 Proposed Audit Plan covering 25 projects and requested AFC committee
member approval.
d. Feedback on proposed FY26 Audit Plan included Kevin Carroll suggesting an audit specific to the
methods of how land values are determined by the Real Estate Assessors Office, currently a project
not on the plan. Kevin shared that audits show that the County is doing things the way it should. Dr.
Casey recommended assigning this to special projects and requests, if possible. Khara agreed to
consider revision or addition to the FY26 proposed audit plan.
e. Khara requested approval for FY26 Audit Plan; approval was granted by Mr. Jim Holland and Mr.
Kevin Carroll.
f. Khara concluded with sharing results of the FY25 Audit follow-up report.
g. Budget, Community Contract audit results will roll forward to the next AFC meeting due to time
constraints.
Meeting adjourned at 2:57
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.