Board of Historic and Architectural Review Regular Meeting Agenda
City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · meeting of Jul 2, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
July 2, 2026
HISTORIC &
ARCHITECTURAL
REVIEW BOARD
Board of Historic and Architectural Review
July 2, 2026
Public Safety Operations Center
2130 S Military Hwy, Chesapeake, VA 23320
5:30 PM
A. Call To Order
B. Roll Call
C. Approval of June 4 regular meeting minutes.
D. Committee Reports
E. Administrative Approvals
F. Zoning Report
G. Old and New Business
a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates
H. Consent Agenda Items
I. Regular Agenda Items
1. 1144 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-051)
Replacement of concrete front porch steps with wooden steps.
2. 1239 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-047)
Replacement of existing standing-seam metal roof with 26-gauge 5V crimp in silver;
replacement of existing siding with double 5” smooth vinyl siding in gray color; after-
the-fact replacement of existing front porch columns and railing with rounded solid-
core moulded columns and wooden rails with 2”x 2” (actual) square balusters; after-
the-fact replacement of existing wooden windows with 2-over-2 vinyl windows with
simulated divided lites (SDLs) with wood trim; and replacement of the existing side
door with siding.
3. 1120 Jackson Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-049)
After-the-fact like-for-like repair/replacement of soffits, fascia boards, porch beam,
and tongue-and-groove porch floorboards; After-the-fact like-for-like rewrapping of
fascia boards, porch beam, and windows. After-the-fact replacement of wooden
porch ceiling with vinyl and modern front door with 6-lite, 2-panel wooden door.
After-the-fact replacement of wooden 6-over-1 wooden windows with 1-over-1 vinyl
windows. After-the-fact replacement of handrail with two wrought iron handrails.
4. 1238 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-054)
Replacement of wood siding with composite siding with like-for-like
repair/replacement of existing trim, fascia, and soffits; replacement of asphalt
shingle roof with metal roofing on the porch roof and over the bay windows;
installation of K-style gutters.
5. 1520 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-055)
Replacement of existing wooden dog-ear privacy fence with new vinyl/PVC privacy
fence.
6. 1329 Jackson Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-058)
After-the-fact replacement and installation of fencing with X-rail gate.
J. Public Input
K. Legal Guidance
L. Adjournment
These applications and related documents are available for public review on the Planning Department’s website
through the following link: https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/AgendaCenter/Board-of-Historic-Architectural-
Review-4
The City of Chesapeake will provide reasonable accommodations and services necessary for sensory-impaired and
disabled persons by contacting the Facilities Maintenance Administrator, Public Works at (757) 382-8951 at least
three-working days in advance and language assistance to individuals with limited English proficiency to the extent
possible by contacting the Planning Department at (757) 382-6176 at least 10 days in advance of this meeting. *While
this is not a public hearing, the public and any one or several members of the Chesapeake City Council may choose
to attend.
1 1
Meeting Minutes
Historic and Architectural Review Board (HARB)
June 4, 2026
Public Safety Operations Center
ROLL CALL
HARB Members Present: Chair Frank Lilley, Vice Chair Scott Grinels, Ervin Young, Kaydee Moore
Staff: Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Adam Lantz, City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Jessica
Hadley, City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Carlos Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Officer – Developments and Permits; Nat
McCormick, Community Designer Manager – Planning Department
Chair F. Lilley called the meeting to order at 5:35 p.m.
MINUTES
Approval of May 7 regular meeting minutes.
Motion to approve May 7 minutes as presented made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present
voting for (4-0).
COMMITTEE REPORTS
None.
ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS
A. Nagorniuk reported five (5) administrative approvals since the May 7 meeting.
ZONING REPORT
None.
OLD AND NEW BUSINESS
a.a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates, Residential Rehabilitation Grant funding priorities with John Harbin,
Director
· Motion to move the agenda item to the end of the meeting, made by S. Grinels and seconded by E. Young,
with all members present voting for (4-0).
· John Harbin provided updates regarding one application approved by the Chesapeake Land Bank this month for
grant funding.
· John Harbin led a discussion with HARB members regarding the South Norfolk Residential Rehabilitation Grant
Program (SNRRGP) evaluation criteria, types of projects evaluated and approved, and priorities for types of
projects funded.
CONSENT AGENDA
None.
REGULAR AGENDA
1. 1409 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-041)
Construction of roof over rear deck.
· Motion to accept the application as written, made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members
present voting for (4-0).
2. 1238 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-044)
Removal of 2 roof skylights as part of roof repair.
2 2
· Motion to accept the application as presented, made by S. Grinels and seconded by K. Moore, with all
members present voting for (4-0).
PUBLIC INPUT
None.
LEGAL GUIDANCE
A.Lantz notified attendees that Jessica Hadley will begin serving as the City Attorney’s office representative to the Board
starting in August. A. Lantz provided some guidance regarding the ability of an approved, active COA to “stay with the house”
and transfer to the new homeowner who wishes to do the same scope of work to match the letter of an existing COA.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion to adjourn the meeting made by S. Grinels and seconded by E. Young, with all members present voting yes (4-0).
Meeting adjourned at 6:58 p.m.
_ MEETING MINUTES APPROVED: ____
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 1
Sta Report Version June 23, 2026
Proposal Replacement of concrete front porch steps with wooden steps.
Address 1144 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built 1904 (Contributing)
Applicant Rebecca Detmer After-the-Fact YesG No "
Owner Rebecca Detmer Special Power of Attorney (-: G %7 "
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk
Application Address 1144 Chesapeake Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-051
Staff Recommendation Approval
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 2
Aerial Map
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing to replace collapsed concrete front porch steps with new wooden steps, with
existing handrails to remain/be re-installed.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Steps and Flooring
AD #1:;791+ 879+0 :;-8: )6, @77916/ :07<4, *- 9-;)16-, )6, 9-:;79-, ): .-):1*4-D
BD &-84)+-5-6; 7. 01:;791+ :;-8: )6, @77916/ :07<4, *- ,76- 16F316, ): .-):1*4-D '7 )+01-=- 9-84)+-5-6;
in-kind, new materials should match the historic material, composition, shape, size, and other visual
qualities. (pg. 73)
General Analysis
The existing concrete steps may not have been original to the home, as many homes in the district typically
included brick piers/steps, stucco’d steps, or wooden steps. The 1928 Nomination survey report for the
property describes the porch as a “wrap-around” with “wood” as primary material with “plain wood Tuscan
columns on aluminum-covered piers…and wood balustrade. ” With this is mind, wooden steps would be
an appropriate alternative material. The existing wooden turned handrails will be re-installed upon
completion of the steps.
Sta find the proposed replacement steps to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and
therefore recommend approval.
Staff Findings
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 4
Additional Photos
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 5
1144 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-051 6
",2)+-6; 9-:1,-6;: >-9- 67;1?-, 7. ;0- )8841+);176 )6, 89787:-, :+78- 7. >793 16 ) 4-;;-9 :-6; 76 $<6- BCE
2026.
1.1. eBUILD Application
Supplemental Documents
Public Notification
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 1
Sta Report Version June 24, 2026
Proposal Replacement of existing standing-seam metal roof with 26-gauge 5V crimp in silver;
replacement of existing siding with double 5” smooth vinyl siding in gray color; after-the-fact
replacement of existing front porch columns and railing with rounded solid-core moulded columns and
wooden rails with 2”x 2” (actual) square balusters; after-the-fact replacement of existing wooden
windows with 2-over-2 vinyl windows with simulated divided lites (SDLs) with wood trim; and
replacement of the existing side door with siding.
Address 1239 Seaboard Avenue Year Built 1905 (Contributing)
Applicant Mary Wilches After-the-Fact Yes " )< W
Owner Hustle Investment Group LLC Special Power of Attorney Yes " )< W
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk
Application Address 1239 Seaboard Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-047
Staff Recommendation Approval
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 2
Aerial Map
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing the following alterations:
1.1. *2=9.02:2;@ <3 2D6?@6;4 ?@.;16;4T?2.: :2@.9 ><<3 C6@5 IMT4.A42 L, 0>6:= :2@.9 ><<G;4 6; ?69B2>S
2.2. Replacement of existing vinyl siding with double 5” smooth vinyl siding in gray color;
3.3. After-the-fact replacement of existing front porch columns and railing with rounded solid-core
moulded columns and wooden rails with 2”x 2” (actual) square balusters;
4.4. After-the-fact replacement of existing wooden windows with 2-over-2 vinyl windows with simulated
divided lites (SDLs) with wood trim;
5.5. Removal of existing side door on rear addition of the home, to be replaced with vinyl siding.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Roofs
IQ '3 @52 56?@<>60 ><<G;4 :.@2>6.9 6? ;< 9<;42> .B.69./92R A?2 .; .9@2>;.@6B2 :.@2>6.9 @5.@ 0<;B2E? . ?0.92 .;1 @2D@A>2
?6:69.> @< @52 56?@<>60 :.@2>6.9S >232>2;02 @52 >2=9.02:2;@ :.@2>6.9 H<C 05.>@ 6; #5.=@2> P @< 4A612 @52 ?2920@6<; <3
an appropriate alternative material.
a. Provide photographic documentation illustrating the historic roof cannot be repaired, as well as
documentation of the sources checked for the historic material. (pg.64)
Wood Siding and Trim
1. Maintain historic wood siding, trim, and ornamentation to the maximum extent possible.
a. Trim and ornamentation should not be added or deleted without adequate physical or documentary
evidence.
2. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic trim and ornamentation replacement
applies:
a. Replacement material must match the existing or documented historic siding, trim and ornamentation in
42;2>.9 0<:=<?6@6<;R ?5.=2R ?6F2R =><G92R .;1 G;6?5Q
b. Avoid wrapping historic trim or ornamentation with another material.
c. Refer to Chapter 9, Alternative Materials for information on selecting an appropriate alternative material
when necessary. (pg. 72)
Porches
1.1. Historic porches should only be altered, including addition, deletion, or expansion, based on documented
historic conditions.(pg.72)
Handrails
1.1. Historic porch handrails and balustrades should be retained and restored.
a. If portions of handrails or balustrades are missing or damaged, they should be replicated and replaced in-
kind.
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 4
2. If a porch no longer has a handrail, but there is evidence a handrail was previously in place, the historic handrail
should be replicated based on pictorial or physical evidence. If no historic or pictorial evidence remains, or if no
handrail existed historically and is required for fall protection, use a contemporary, compatible rail like the one
illustrated below or a simple metal rail like cast iron. (pg.74)
Windows
1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows.
IQ '3 . 56?@<>60 C6;1<C ;221? @< /2 >2=9.021R :.@05 @52 56?@<>60 C6;1<C 6; ?6F2R 16:2;?6<;?R 0<;G4A>.@6<;R .;1
materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars
between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL).
a. Provide detailed photographic documentation of deterioration of each window proposed for replacement to the
HARB.
b. Provide dimensioned drawings of the existing historic windows and the proposed replacement windows to
illustrate they match.
KQ +52 ?6F2 <3 @52 56?@<>60 <=2;6;4 ?5<A91 ;<@ /2 :<16G21 U120>2.?21 <> 2;9.>421V .? . >2?A9@ <3 <> @< .00<::<1.@2
C6;1<C >2=9.02:2;@Q *2=9.02:2;@ C6;1<C? ?5<A91 /2 ?6F21 .==><=>6.@29E @< G@ @52 56?@<>60 <=2;6;4Q
LQ &6?@<>60 C6;1<C <=2;6;4? ?5<A91 ;<@ /2 :<16G21 <> 296:6;.@21 @< .00<::<1.@2 6;@2>6<> 05.;42?Q U=4QNLV
Doors
JQ &6?@<>60 1<<> <=2;6;4? ?5<A91 ;<@ /2 :<16G21 <> 296:6;.@21 @< .00<::<1.@2 6;@2>6<> 05.;42?Q U=4QNOV
General Analysis
Roof
-5692 @52 $2?64; %A61296;2? ?@><;49E 2;0<A>.42 9682T3<>T9682 >2=9.02:2;@ <3 05.>.0@2>T12G;6;4 ?@.;16;4T?2.:
:2@.9 ><<3?R @52 =><=<?21 L, 0>6:= :2@.9 ><<G;4 6? .; .9@2>;.@6B2 :.@2>6.9 @5.@ 5.? ?<:2@6:2? /22; 122:21
appropriate for homes in the historic district.
Siding, Side Door
The existing siding on the home appears to be a mix of vinyl and asbestos underneath. Applicant(s) have
begun removing the vinyl siding, revealing the original wood siding as seen in photos. Now, applicant is
proposing double 5” smooth siding, which appears to be consistent with the dimensions of the previously
existing vinyl siding. The applicant is also proposing to remove the side door located on the rear addition
and replace it with vinyl siding to match. While the Guidelines prohibit changing the number of historic
<=2;6;4?R @52 >2.> .116@6<; 5.1 .9>2.1E /22; :<16G21 <B2> @52 E2.>?R C6@5 B6;E9 ?616;4 .1121 @< 2;09<?2
what likely used to be a screened back porch. Therefore, removing the door would have minimal impact
on the overall character, though adding windows for additional natural light and a more appealing side
elevation would be encouraged.
Porch
The 1987 nomination report for the property details the materials of the porch as primarily “wood” with
“heavy turned posts. ” The existing wooden columns appear to be original to the home, and the applicant
is proposing PVC solid-core “turned” columns to align with the appearance of the original columns. The
existing railings on the porch are to be replaced with a wooden railing system consisting of a top and bottom
rail with 2”x2” actual size balusters between, which is more similar to the typical 4-piece handrail often
seen in the district on vernacular-style homes.
Windows
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 5
A majority of the existing windows on the home appear to be wooden 2-over-2 windows that are original to
the home. The existing wooden windows were removed after-the-fact and the applicant is proposing new
replacement 2-over-2 vinyl windows with simulated divided lites (SDLs). While the Design Guidelines
promote like-for-like replacement of original wood windows, the SDLs will help make the proposed vinyl
replacement windows more aligned with the recommendations of the Design Guidelines and the historic
character of the home.
Sta find the proposed work to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore
recommend approval.
Staff Findings
Additional Photos
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 6
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 7
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 8
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 9
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 1010
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 1111
1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-047 1212
"17.02;@ >2?612;@? C2>2 ;<@6G21 <3 @52 .==960.@6<; .;1 =><=<?21 ?0<=2 <3 C<>8 6; . 92@@2> ?2;@ <; (A;2 IKR
2026.
1.1. eBUILD Application
Supplemental Documents
Public Notification
City of Chesapeake
Department of Planning
Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness
Record Detail Information
Record Type: Certi fi cate of Appropri ateness Record Status: Pendi ng Board Revi ew Fi le Date: May 12, 2026
Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-047
Record Name: 1239 Seaboard Avenue
Expi rati on Date:
Descri pti on:
Parent Record Number: Replacement of exi sti ng standi ng-seam metal roof wi th
26-gauge 5V cri mp i n si lver; replacement of exi sti ng si di ng
wi th double 5” smooth vi nyl si di ng i n gray color;
after-the-fact replacement of exi sti ng front porch columns
and rai li ng wi th rounded soli d-core moulded columns and
wooden rai ls wi th 2”x 2” (actual) square balusters;
after-the-fact replacement of exi sti ng wooden wi ndows
wi th 2-over-2 vi nyl wi ndows wi th si mulated di vi ded li tes
(SDLs) wi th wood tri m; and replacement of the exi sti ng
si de door wi th si di ng.
Address: 1239 SEABOARD AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324
Owner Information
Pri mary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone
Hustle Investment Group
LLC
Yes
Parcel Information
Parcel No:
1280000001830
Contact Information
Organi zati on NameName Contact Type Phone
Mary Wi lches Hustle Investment Group LLC Appli cant
Address
Application Specific Information
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION
Descri pti on Replacement of exi sti ng standi ng-seam metal roof wi th 26-gauge 5V
cri mp i n si lver; replacement of exi sti ng si di ng wi th double 5” smooth
vi nyl si di ng i n gray color; after-the-fact replacement of exi sti ng front
porch columns and rai li ng wi th rounded soli d-core moulded
columns and wooden rai ls wi th 2”x 2” (actual) square balusters;
after-the-fact replacement of exi sti ng wooden wi ndows wi th 2-over-2
vi nyl wi ndows wi th si mulated di vi ded li tes (SDLs) wi th wood tri m;
and replacement of the exi sti ng si de door wi th si di ng.
Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-047
Zoni ng Si gn Off Yes
Economi c Hardshi p No
PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE
Appli cati on After-the-Fact -
After-the-Fact Fee Pai d -
Approved Admi ni strati vely -
Approvi ng Planner -
Approval Date -
Certi fi cate Number -
See supplemental submi ttal requi rements -
Board Approved Certi fi cate Number -
I, _______________, hereby grant permi ssi on for Ci ty Staff &
members of the Hi stori c Archi tectural Revi ew Board to enter
my si te to vi ew exteri or areas related to thei s Certi fi cate of
Appropri ateness Appli cati on.
-
Structure Desi gnati on -
GENERAL INFORMATION
Year Structure Bui lt 1905
Is thi s an After-the-Fact appli cati on? No
$250 After the Fact fee, i f requi red. -
One ori gi nal deli vered to the Planni ng Department OR a copy
attached to the on-li ne appli cati on
-
One di sk contai ni ng all photos OR photos attached to on-li ne
appli cati on
-
? Completed and notari zed power of attorney form i f the
appli cant i s not the property owner.
-
NEW CONSTRUCTION
Completed appli cati on form. -
Surveyed si te plan (i ncludi ng proposed bui ldi ngs,
structure(s), parki ng, etc.)
-
Front and si de elevati ons -
Samples -
Arrangement of proposed exteri or li ghti ng. -
Photographs of the property and adjoi ni ng or opposi te
properti es.
-
ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES
Completed appli cati on form. -
Surveyed si te plan or ci ty tax map -
Elevati ons -
Photographs of the exi sti ng structure and property. -
Samples, photos, and brochures -
Arrangement of proposed exteri or li ghti ng. -
Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-047
Proposed si gns wi th appropri ate detai l as to character and
locati on.
-
ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS
Completed appli cati on form. -
Wri tten descri pti on of work to be performed CHECKED
Photographs of the bui ldi ng/structure. -
2 quotes each are requi red for the followi ng: -
Photos numeri cally keyed -
RELOCATIONS
Completed appli cati on form -
Photographs of the bui ldi ng or structure to be relocated and
adjacent properti es.
-
Photographs of the premi ses to whi ch the bui ldi ng or
structure wi ll be relocated.
-
Wri tten descri pti on of reasons for the relocati on and the
proposed use of the vacated property.
-
DEMOLITIONS
Completed appli cati on form -
Photographs of the bui ldi ng or structure to be demoli shed to
i llustrate i ts state of di srepai r.
-
Wri tten report on condi ti on of bui ldi ng or structure. -
Wri tten descri pti on of work to be performed -
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
Speci al Power of Attorney attached -
METAL ROOFS
Explanati on CHECKED
Info requi red to replace metal roof wi th metal roof. -
Pi cture -
Speci fi cati on Sheet -
Roof color sample -
Info requi red to replace metal roof wi th archi tectural shi ngles. -
Quotes -
Roof color sample (asphalt) -
Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-047
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 1
Sta Report Version June 25, 2026
Proposal After-the-fact like-for-0./* 5*4&.5C5*40&(*1*27 3+ 63=.76B +&6(.& '3&5)6B 435(- '*&1B &2)
;76/<-J)6,J/977=- 879+0 C779*7)9,:I ".;-9J;0-J.)+; 413-J.79J413- 9->9)8816/ 7. .):+1) *7)9,:H 879+0
beam, and windows. After-the-fact replacement of wooden porch ceiling with vinyl and modern front
door with 6-lite, 2-panel wooden door. After-the-fact replacement of wooden 6-over-1 wooden windows
with 1-over-1 vinyl windows. After-the-fact replacement of handrail with two wrought iron handrails.
Address 1120 Jackson Avenue Year Built 1924 (Contributing)
Applicant Debbie Sherwood After-the-Fact Yes " %7 K
Owner Mary O’Leary Special Power of Attorney Yes " No K
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk
Application Address 1120 Jackson Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-049
Staff Recommendation Approval with Stipulations
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 2
Aerial Map
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing the following after-the-fact alterations:
1.1. #./*D+35D0./* 5*4&.5C5*40&(*1*27 3+ 63=.76B +&6(.& '3&5)6B 435(- '*&1B &2) 732,8*D&2)D,5339*
879+0 C779*7)9,:I
2.2. Like-for-like rewrapping of fascia boards, porch beam, and windows;
3.3. Replacement of wooden porch ceiling with vinyl;
4.4. Replacement of existing modern front door with 6-lite, 2-panel wooden door;
5.5. Replacement of wooden 6-over-1 wooden windows with 1-over-1 vinyl windows;
6.6. Replacement of single handrail with two wrought iron handrails.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Wood Siding and Trim
1. Maintain historic wood siding, trim, and ornamentation to the maximum extent possible.
a. Trim and ornamentation should not be added or deleted without adequate physical or documentary
evidence.
2. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic trim and ornamentation replacement
applies:
a. Replacement material must match the existing or documented historic siding, trim and ornamentation in
/-6-9)4 +7587:1;176H :0)8-H :1A-H 897B4-H )6, B61:0G
b. Avoid wrapping historic trim or ornamentation with another material.
c. Refer to Chapter 9, Alternative Materials for information on selecting an appropriate alternative material
when necessary. (pg. 72)
Steps and Flooring
DG #1:;791+ 879+0 :;-8: )6, C77916/ :07<4, *- 9-;)16-, )6, 9-:;79-, ): .-):1*4-G
EG &-84)+-5-6; 7. 01:;791+ :;-8: )6, C77916/ :07<4, *- ,76- 16J316, ): .-):1*4-G '7 )+01-=- 9-84)+-5-6; 16J316,H
new materials should match the historic material, composition, shape, size, and other visual qualities.
)G (0-6 9-84)+16/ )6 -6;19- 879+0 C779H -6:<9- ;0- 6-> C779 1: :478-, )>)@ .975 ;0- 01:;791+ *<14,16/ ;7
-41516);- >);-9 16B4;9);176 1::<-:G
FG $. 9-84)+-5-6; 16 316, 1: 67; 87::1*4-H 5);-91)4 :-4-+;176 .79 879+0 C779: )447>: .79 +7587:1;-: 79 :@6;0-;1+: ,<-
;7 ;0- 0791A76;)4 6);<9- 7. 879+0 C779:H >01+0 4151;: ;0- =1:<)4 158)+; 76 ;0- 7=-9)44 01:;791+ +0)9)+;-9 7. ) *<14,16/G
(pg. 73)
Handrails
2. If a porch no longer has a handrail, but there is evidence a handrail was previously in place, the historic handrail
should be replicated based on pictorial or physical evidence. If no historic or pictorial evidence remains, or if no
handrail existed historically and is required for fall protection, use a contemporary, compatible rail like the one
illustrated below or a simple metal rail like cast iron. ((pg.74)
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 4
Windows
1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows.
EG $. ) 01:;791+ >16,7> 6--,: ;7 *- 9-84)+-,H 5);+0 ;0- 01:;791+ >16,7> 16 :1A-H ,15-6:176:H +76B/<9);176H )6,
materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars
between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL).
a. Provide detailed photographic documentation of deterioration of each window proposed for replacement
to the HARB.
b. Provide dimensioned drawings of the existing historic windows and the proposed replacement windows
to illustrate they match. (pg.75)
Doors
@A ";.67.2, 13)*52 )3356 (&2 '* 5*40&(*) :.7- & ).=*5*27 )335 67<0*B 4539.)*) .7 .6 (314&7.'0* :.7- 7-* 67<0* 3+ 7-*
building.
a. Only replace historic doors that cannot be repaired; avoid wholesale replacement of all historic doors in
a building.
b. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic door replacement apply:
i. Replacement doors should match the historic doors as closely as possible in general composition,
:0)8-H :1A-H 897B4-H /4):: <:)/-H 8)6- ,1=1:176H 5<6;16 ;@8-H /4)A16/H ;-?;<9-H )6, B61:0G
ii. Replacement should be limited to the door itself to reduce the replacement of historic fabric and
impacts to the building envelope. (pg.78)
General Analysis
Porch and Fascia, etc.
%-* &+7*5D7-*D+&(7 0./*D+35D0./* 5*40&(*1*27 3+ +&6(.& '3&5)6B 63=.76B 435(- '*&16B &2) ?335'3&5)6 &032,
with rewrapping of said features and windows would have been administratively reviewable items. While
the Design Guidelines prioritize restoration and like-for-like repair/replacement of existing wood features
such as the porch ceiling, the replacement of the wooden porch ceiling boars with vinyl has minor visible
impact to the character of the home.
Front Door
The existing front door was likely a modern door, and the applicant installed a new 6-lite 2-panel door with
wood appearance, which is an appropriate door style for Craftsman-style homes.
Windows
Applicant replaced existing wooden windows with 1-over-1 vinyl windows. The 1987 nomination report for
the property states that the original window style was 6-over1. The applicant has proposed a 6-over-1
window product in addition to the 1-over-1; however, this 6-over-1 grid is an inconsistent style, with 3 rows
of 2 lites rather than the traditional look of 2 rows of 3 lites in the top pane. The most appropriate vinyl
window alternative would be a traditional 6-over-1 grid with simulated divided lites (SDLs). If applicant is
unwilling to modify the window product accordingly, 1-over-1 would be better preferable to the proposed
6-over-1 vinyl window with 3 rows of 2 lites in the top pane.
Handrails
The existing single metal rail on the front steps does not appear to be original to the home. The new metal
handrails installed are an appropriate wrought-iron-like style that has a more subtle impact on the
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 5
character of the home. Applicant should ensure handrails are installed appropriately according to building
code.
$7&= >2) 7-* :35/ :.7- 7-* *;(*47.32 3+ 7-* 5*40&(*1*27 9.2<0 :.2)3:6 73 '* (326.67*27 :.7- 7-* $387-
Norfolk Design Guidelines and recommend approval with the stipulation #1.
1.1. Replacement vinyl windows be the appropriate 6-over-1 grid style with simulated divided lites
(SDLs).
Staff Findings
Recommended Stipulations dated June 25, 2026
Additional Photos
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 6
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 7
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 8
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 9
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 1010
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 1111
1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-049 1212
",2)+-6; 9-:1,-6;: >-9- 67;1B-, 7. ;0- )8841+);176 )6, 89787:-, :+78- 7. >793 16 ) 4-;;-9 :-6; 76 "</<:;
24, 2023.
1. 1.
eBUILD Application
Supplemental Documents
Public Notification
City of Chesapeake
Department of Planning
Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness
Record Detail Information
Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: May 15, 2026
Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-049
Record Name: 1120 Jackson Avenue
Expiration Date:
Description:
Parent Record Number: After-the-fact repair and replacement of soffits, fascia
boards, porch beam, and tongue and groove porch
floorboards, all like-for-like. Rewrapped fascia boards,
porch beam, and windows, all like-for-like. Replaced
wooden porch ceiling with vinyl and modern front door with
6-lite, 2-panel wooden door. Removed and replaced
6-over-1 wooden windows with 1-over-1 vinyl windows.
Replaced single handrail with two wrought iron handrails.
Address: 1120 Jackson AVE, Chesapeake, VA 23324
Parcel Information
Parcel No:
1120
Contact Information
Organization NameName Contact Type Phone
Debbie Sherwood Applicant
Address
Application Specific Information
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION
Description After-the-fact repair and replacement of soffits, fascia boards, porch
beam, and tongue and groove porch floorboards, all like-for-like.
Rewrapped fascia boards, porch beam, and windows, all
like-for-like. Replaced wooden porch ceiling with vinyl and modern
front door with 6-lite, 2-panel wooden door. Removed and replaced
6-over-1 wooden windows with 1-over-1 vinyl windows. Replaced
single handrail with two wrought iron handrails.
Zoning Sign Off No
Economic Hardship No
PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE
Application After-the-Fact Yes
After-the-Fact Fee Paid -
Approved Administratively -
Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-049
Approving Planner -
Approval Date -
Certificate Number -
See supplemental submittal requirements -
Board Approved Certificate Number -
I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff &
members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter
my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of
Appropriateness Application.
-
Structure Designation -
GENERAL INFORMATION
Year Structure Built 1924
Is this an After-the-Fact application? Yes
$250 After the Fact fee, if required. -
One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy
attached to the on-line application
-
One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line
application
-
? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the
applicant is not the property owner.
-
NEW CONSTRUCTION
Completed application form. -
Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings,
structure(s), parking, etc.)
-
Front and side elevations -
Samples -
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. -
Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite
properties.
-
ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES
Completed application form. -
Surveyed site plan or city tax map -
Elevations -
Photographs of the existing structure and property. -
Samples, photos, and brochures -
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. -
Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and
location.
-
ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS
Completed application form. -
Written description of work to be performed -
Photographs of the building/structure. -
Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-049
2 quotes each are required for the following: -
Photos numerically keyed -
RELOCATIONS
Completed application form -
Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and
adjacent properties.
-
Photographs of the premises to which the building or
structure will be relocated.
-
Written description of reasons for the relocation and the
proposed use of the vacated property.
-
DEMOLITIONS
Completed application form -
Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to
illustrate its state of disrepair.
-
Written report on condition of building or structure. -
Written description of work to be performed -
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
Special Power of Attorney attached -
METAL ROOFS
Explanation -
Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. -
Picture -
Specification Sheet -
Roof color sample -
Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. -
Quotes -
Roof color sample (asphalt) -
Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-049
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 1
Sta Report Version June 23, 2026
Proposal Replacement of wood siding with composite siding; replacement of asphalt shingle roof with
3+9'2 755@4- 54 9.+ 657). 755, '4* 5;+7 9.+ ('> </4*5<8F /489'22'9/54 5, %G89>2+ -:99+78D
Address 1238 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built 1910 (Contributing)
Applicant Anne Conger After-the-Fact YesH No "
Owner Anne Conger Special Power of Attorney Yes H No "
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk
Application Address 1238 Chesapeake Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-054
Staff Recommendation Approval
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 2
Aerial Map
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing siding and roof alterations to include:
1.1. Replacement of existing wood siding with new 4” composite siding in green and ivory color(s) resembling
Benjamin Moore Historical Colors palette, with like-for-like repair/replacement of existing trim, fascia, and
so its;
2.2. &+62')+3+49 5, +=/89/4- '86.'29 8./4-2+ 755, </9. 4+< 89'4*/4-G8+'3 3+9'2 755@4- 54 ,7549 657). '4* '(5;+
the bay windows;
3.3. Installation of K-style gutters and downspouts on primary structure and detached garage.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Roofs
3. If the roof is not historic, then an alternative replacement material can be proposed, provided it does not detract
from the character of the building; see Chapter 9 for guidance on the selection of an appropriate alternative material.
a. Provide documentation showing what material historically existed on the roof. (pg. 64)
Gutters and Downspouts
1. If additional gutters and downspouts are needed to ensure water is being adequately shed from the roof, they
8.5:2* 3'9). 9.+ 3'9+7/'2 '4* 675@2+ 5, 9.+ ./8957/) -:99+78D #, 9.+ -:99+78 '4* *5<4865:98 '7+ 35*+74E 9.+> 8.5:2*
match the existing modern gutters and downspouts.
2. Gutters and downspouts may be installed on buildings where they did not historically exist. New gutters and
downspouts should be installed in a way that does not permanently damage historic materials. Options for achieving
this include sensitively installing the gutters to ensure they can be removed in the future without damaging historic
materials or placing new gutters and downspouts on secondary elevations.
3. Choose a gutter form that is compatible with the style of the building. (pg.65)
Wood Siding and Trim
1. Maintain historic wood siding, trim, and ornamentation to the maximum extent possible.
a. Trim and ornamentation should not be added or deleted without adequate physical or documentary
evidence.
2. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic trim and ornamentation replacement
applies:
a. Replacement material must match the existing or documented historic siding, trim and ornamentation in
-+4+7'2 )53658/9/54E 8.'6+E 8/?+E 675@2+E '4* @4/8.D
b. Avoid wrapping historic trim or ornamentation with another material. (pg. 72)
General Analysis
Siding
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 4
Applicant is proposing to replace the existing rotten wood siding with a quality durable composite material
that is intended to resemble traditional wood siding in appearance and dimension (approximately 4-inch-
wide siding) to help maintain the home’s character. As part of the siding work, like-for-like repairs and
replacement of siding and window trim, fascia, and so its are also proposed.
&55@4-
"662/)'49 /8 675658/4- 95 7+62')+ 9.+ 35*+74 '86.'29 8./4-2+ 755@4- </9. 89'4*/4-G8+'3 3+9'2 755@4- 54
the front porch roof and above the bay window on the side elevation. This will help restore some of the
home’s original character by installing a historically appropriate material on highly visible portions of the
home.
Gutters
Gutters are an administrative-review item. Proposed gutters and downspouts will help protect the
897:)9:7+8 ,753 <'9+7 *'3'-+E '4* 9.+> '7+ '667567/'9+2> 25)'9+* '254- 97/3 6/+)+8 '4* 755A/4+8 95 (+
less obtrusive. While the Design Guidelines advocate for installing gutters and downspouts in a way that
minimizes impact to historic materials (in this case, columns), the downspouts will be installed along the
columns as a necessity to divert water from the hipped roof.
Sta find the proposed work to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore
recommend approval.
Staff Findings
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 5
Additional Photos
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 6
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 7
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 8
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 9
"*0')+49 7+8/*+498 <+7+ 459/@+* 5, 9.+ '662/)'9/54 '4* 675658+* 8)56+ 5, <571 /4 ' 2+99+7 8+49 54 $:4+ BCE
2026.
Public Notification
1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-054 1010
1.1. eBUILD Application
2.2. “United Exteriors” Quote
Supplemental Documents
City of Chesapeake
Department of Planning
Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness
Record Detail Information
Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: June 4, 2026
Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-054
Record Name: 1238 Chesapeake Ave Chesapeake, VA 23324
Expiration Date:
Description:
Parent Record Number: Replace wood siding with composite siding in color
like-for-like on the primary structure; replace asphalt
shingles with metal roofing on the porch roof and over the
bay windows; add K-style gutters on the primary and
accessory structures.
Address: 1238 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324
Owner Information
Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone
CONGER ANNEYes
Parcel Information
Parcel No:
1280000000250
Contact Information
Organization NameName Contact Type Phone
Anne Conger Applicant
Address
Application Specific Information
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION
Description Replace wood siding with composite siding in color like-for-like on
the primary structure; replace asphalt shingles with metal roofing on
the porch roof and over the bay windows; add K-style gutters on the
primary and accessory structures.
Zoning Sign Off No
Economic Hardship No
PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE
Application After-the-Fact -
After-the-Fact Fee Paid -
Approved Administratively -
Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-054
Approving Planner -
Approval Date -
Certificate Number -
See supplemental submittal requirements -
Board Approved Certificate Number -
I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff &
members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter
my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of
Appropriateness Application.
-
Structure Designation -
GENERAL INFORMATION
Year Structure Built 1900
Is this an After-the-Fact application? No
$250 After the Fact fee, if required. -
One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy
attached to the on-line application
-
One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line
application
-
? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the
applicant is not the property owner.
-
NEW CONSTRUCTION
Completed application form. -
Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings,
structure(s), parking, etc.)
-
Front and side elevations -
Samples -
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. -
Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite
properties.
-
ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES
Completed application form. -
Surveyed site plan or city tax map -
Elevations -
Photographs of the existing structure and property. -
Samples, photos, and brochures -
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. -
Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and
location.
-
ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS
Completed application form. CHECKED
Written description of work to be performed CHECKED
Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED
Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-054
2 quotes each are required for the following: CHECKED
Photos numerically keyed CHECKED
RELOCATIONS
Completed application form -
Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and
adjacent properties.
-
Photographs of the premises to which the building or
structure will be relocated.
-
Written description of reasons for the relocation and the
proposed use of the vacated property.
-
DEMOLITIONS
Completed application form -
Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to
illustrate its state of disrepair.
-
Written report on condition of building or structure. -
Written description of work to be performed -
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
Special Power of Attorney attached -
METAL ROOFS
Explanation -
Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. -
Picture -
Specification Sheet -
Roof color sample -
Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. -
Quotes -
Roof color sample (asphalt) -
Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-054
Page 1 of 4
=IJAC9J=
Prepared For
9[[R ;\[TR_
./05 ;UR`N]RNXR 9cR
;UR`N]RNXR ) LN /00/1
%052& /.-*36-/
United Exteriors
/260 GbNYVaf ;a) "/-.
LV_TV[VN :RNPU) L9 /0121
FU\[R7 (C\OVYR 424*/65*145-+ EmPR 424*131*----
=ZNVY7 OVYY8b[VaRQ*ReaR_V\_`+P\Z
MRO7 ddd+b[VaRQ*ReaR_V\_`+P\Z
=`aVZNaR " ./24/
<NaR -3,-/,/-/3
Description
IA<AD?) ?KJJ=HI) IE>>AJ) JHAC ;EAB
=cR_YN`a P\Z]\`VaR `VQV[T V` ZNQR S_\Z UVTU QR[`Vaf ]\YfZR_+ Aah` `b]R_ Qb_NOYR NTNV[`a dRNaUR_)
ObT`) N[Q SNQV[T*YN`a` dNf Y\[TR_ aUN[ d\\Q \_ cV[fY+ Aah` k_R _R`V`aN[a N[Q VZ]NPa _R`V`aN[a+
>\_ f\b_ W\O Vah` aReab_RQ YVXR _RNY d\\Q Oba d\[ha _\a \_ dN_]+
*HRZ\cR ReV`aV[T `VQV[T N[Q _R]YNPR dVaU =cR_YN`a ;\Z]\`VaR `VQV[T) %P\Y\_ a\ OR QRaR_ZV[RQ&
*A[`aNYY 4,.3i 1he5h \`O `URNaUV[T) N[Q U\b`R d_N] ORS\_R V[`aNYYV[T `VQV[T
*=cR_YN`a `aN_aR_) W*PUN[[RY S\_ dV[Q\d` N[Q Q\\_`) \ba`VQR N[Q V[`VQR P\_[R_` dVYY OR b`RQ
*A[PYbQR` d\\Q _R]NV_ S\_ QNZNTRQ dV[Q\d .`a `a\_f
*9 [Rd TNOYR cR[a dVYY OR V[`aNYYRQ
*JUR LR_Vg\[ O\e dVYY OR _RZ\cRQ
*EIA GbNQ dVYY OR b`RQ S\_ `RNYN[a dUR_R [RPR``N_f
*BVTUa OY\PX`) `]YVa OY\PX` S\_ U\`R OVO`) \baYRa`) N[Q Q_fR_ cR[a` dVYY NYY OR cV[fY
*9 P\[aNV[R_ dVYY OR \[`VaR S\_ NYY QRO_V` N[Q dVYY OR ]_\cVQRQ Of K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_`
MUR[ W\O V` Q\[R aUR P\[aNV[R_ dVYY Z\cRQ \j `VaR
*MR dVYY V[`aNYY H*.0 V[`bYNaV\[ N` [RRQRQ Na aUR P\`a \S #63 ]R_ _\YY
IE>>AJ
*A[`aNYY FYf?RZ UVQQR[ cR[aRQ cV[fY `\ma \[ NYY \cR_UN[T`+ ;\Y\_ a\ OR dUVaR Q\R` [\a V[PYbQR
b[QR_ S_\[a ]\_PU+
JHAC ;EAB
*>NO_VPNaR N[Q A[`aNYY FL; a_VZ P\VY \[ NYY SN`PVN) _NXR O\N_Q`) S_VRgR O\N_Q`) N[Q _Rab_[`+
?KJJ=HI
*A[`aNYY 2i dUVaR `RNZYR`` TbaaR_` N[Q 0i e 1i \cR_`VgRQ Q\d[`]\ba` \[ U\ZR N[Q QRaNPURQ
TN_NTR
:f `VT[V[T aUV` Q\PbZR[a) aUR Pb`a\ZR_ NT_RR` a\ aUR `R_cVPR` N[Q P\[QVaV\[` \baYV[RQ V[ aUV`
Q\PbZR[a+
*F9HJA9B HEE>
Page 2 of 4
*HRZ\cR ReV`aV[T `UV[TYR` \[ .`a `a\_f d_N] N_\b[Q ]\_PU _\\S N[Q _R]YNPR dVaU N `aN[QV[T `RNZ)
NYbZV[bZ ZRaNY _\\S %P\Y\_ a\ OR QRaR_ZV[RQ&
*JUR_R V` N `ZNYY `RPaV\[ \S _\\S \[ k_`a `a\_f \cR_ dV[Q\d aUNa dR dVYY V[`aNYY aUR `NZR ZRaNY
_\\k[T N` aUR d_N] N_\b[Q ]\_PU+
CAI;=BB9D=EKI
*MR dVYY _RZ\cR N SRd b[b`RQ ]V]R`
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY NYdNf` V[`aNYY aUR `VQV[T `f`aRZ NPP\_QV[T a\ aUR ZN[bSNPab_R_h`
`]RPVkPNaV\[` N` dRYY N` Y\PNY N[Q `aNaR ObVYQV[T P\QR`+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY OR _R`]\[`VOYR a\ PYRN[ b] NYY QRO_V` _RYNaRQ a\ aUR W\O N_\b[Q aUR ]_\]R_af
V[PYbQV[T aUR fN_Q) ONPXfN_Q) TbaaR_`) l\dR_ORQ`) RaP+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY OR _R`]\[`VOYR VS N[f QNZNTR \PPb_` a\ TbaaR_`) ]YN[a` N[Q QRPXV[T+
9[f ]YN[aR_`) QRPX Sb_[Vab_R dVYY UNcR a\ OR Z\cRQ Of U\ZR\d[R_ ]_V\_ a\ V[`aNYYNaV\[+
'9[f V[Wb_VR` aUNa \PPb_ a\ aUR `VQV[T P_Rd N_R aUR _R`]\[`VOVYVaf \S aUR P\[a_NPa\_) [\a aUR
U\ZR\d[R_+ K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` V` SbYYf YVPR[`RQ N[Q V[`b_RQ
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY `aN_a aUR W\O \[ aUR NT_RRQ b]\[ QNaR N` Y\[T N` dRNaUR_ ]R_ZVa` N[Q
aUR_R V` [\ \aUR_ Ob`V[R`` P\Z]YVPNaV\[` dVaU QRYVcR_f a_bPX \_ ZNaR_VNY`+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` `P\]R \S d\_X \[Yf V[c\YcR` aRN_V[T \j `VQV[T ZNaR_VNY` N[Q aUR V[`aNYYNaV\[
\S
aUR [Rd `VQV[T `f`aRZ+ A[ aUR RcR[a \S _\aaRQ d\\Q aUR_R dVYY OR N[ NQQVaV\[NY PUN_TR ]R_ `URRa
\S ]Yfd\\Q+ #25 ]R_ 1$e5$ `URRa
MR dVYY [\a OR _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ N[f _R]NV_` aUNa V[PYbQR `a_bPab_NY
QNZNTR \[ aUR ]_\]R_af
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY [\a OR _R`]\[`VOYR V[ aUR RcR[a \S S_NZRQ ]VPab_R` \_ QRP\_NaV\[` SNYYV[T
\j aUR dNYY) [NVY ]\]` \_ P_NPX` \[ `URRa_\PX QbR a\ [NVYV[T N[Q ON[TV[T \[ aUR ReaR_V\_ aUV`
b`bNYYf
[RcR_ UN]]R[` Oba dR _RP\ZZR[Q a\ aNXR aURZ Q\d[ ORS\_R dR `aN_a aUR W\O
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY [\a OR _R`]\[`VOYR V[ aUR RcR[a \S [NVYV[T N[ 9,; YV[R QbR a\ ONQ
V[`aNYYNaV\[ S\_Z aUR @L9; ;\Z]N[f %PVaf P\QR `aNaR` /i \j _\\S QRPX ]Yb` `aRRY ]YNaR&+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY [\a OR _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ N[f QNZNTR \_ P_NPX` \[ Q_VcRdNf PNb`RQ Of aUR
QRYVcR_f a_bPX` O_V[TV[T aUR ZNaR_VNY` a\ aUR ]_\]R_af \_ aUR a_N`U _RZ\cNY P\Z]N[f+
Page 3 of 4
Ib]]YVR_ V` YVNOYR S\_ aUV`) dR UNcR `RR[ aUV` UN]]R[ \[PR V[ NYY aUR fRN_` dR UNcR ORR[ V[
Ob`V[R``+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY \jR_ N[ .- fRN_ YNO\_ N[Q V[`aNYYNaV\[ dN__N[af NY\[T dVaU aUR `VQV[T+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` dVYY \_QR_ Rea_N ZNaR_VNY` S\_ `\ZR W\O` V[ PN`R aUR_Rh` QNZNTRQ ZNaR_VNY`
\_
Rea_N dN`aR+ JUR_R dVYY OR [\ _RSb[Q` V[ aUR RcR[a \S YRSa \cR_ ZNaR_VNY`+
'K[VaRQ =eaR_V\_` _R^bV_R` ]NfZR[a a\ OR _RPRVcRQ NSaR_ P\Z]YRaV\[ \S aUR W\O+ HRab_[ PURPX`
dVYY UNcR N #12+-- PUN_TR a\ P\cR_
ON[XV[T SRR` N[Q NQZV[V`a_NaVcR P\`a`+
Subtotal #56)42-+--
Total $89,750.00
Page 4 of 4
:f `VT[V[T aUV` Q\PbZR[a) aUR Pb`a\ZR_ NT_RR` a\ aUR `R_cVPR` N[Q P\[QVaV\[` \baYV[RQ V[ aUV`
Q\PbZR[a+
IVT[RQ \[7 -3,-1,/-/3
9[[R ;\[TR_
1520 Chesapeake Avenue PLN-CAPP-2026-055 1
Staff Report Version June 22, 2026
Proposal Replace current fence with a six-foot white vinyl fence.
Address 1520 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built 1900 (Contributing)
Applicant Kara & Mark Caplinger After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒
Owner Kara & Mark Caplinger Special Power of Attorney Yes ☐ No ☒
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Staff Planner Lydia Utton
Application Address 1520 Chesapeake Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-055
Staff Recommendation Denial
1520 Chesapeake Avenue PLN-CAPP-2026-055 2
Aerial Map
1520 Chesapeake Avenue PLN-CAPP-2026-055 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing to construct a six-foot white privacy vinyl fence to replace the current six-foot
wooden dog ear privacy fence.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Fences, Walls, and Hedges
1.
a. For new fencing, the material, style, and height should be in keeping with the character of the
associated building’s architectural style, as well as the surrounding district. All fencing, walls, and
hedges should meet the provisions of the City of Chesapeake Zoning Ordinance, Article 12, Section
722 - Architectural guidelines and Article 14, Section 201 - Fences,walls and hedges on residential
property, as outlined below:
i. For interior lots, fence requirements are as follows:
Front yard: A maximum height of 4 feet, 50% open
Side yard: A maximum height of 6 feet
Rear yard: A maximum height of 6 feet
Hedges: Hedges are restricted in height to the same height as fences
2. Appropriate new fencing materials include:
a. Vertical wood pickets; wood fences may be painted or stained. Common types include:
• 50–100% open: Common Picket, Dog Ear Picket, Gothic Picket, Angled Picket
• 0–49% open: Solid Board Dog Ear, Solid Board Gothic, Solid Board Picket, Shadowbox,
Framed, Arched, Scalloped
b. Wrought or cast iron or metal tubular to mimic iron in a simplified design. Common types include:
• Staggered Traditional, Traditional, Modern
3. Inappropriate fencing types include:
a. Vinyl, PVC, or synthetic fences unless meeting the requirements outlined in Chapter 9,
Alternative Materials.
b. Chain link fencing; chain link fences may be approved for use in rear yards or side yards on mid-
block lots where they will not be visible from the paved public street, but
(pg. 100)
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1520 Chesapeake Avenue PLN-CAPP-2026-055 4
General Analysis
The Design Guidelines require new fencing materials and styles to be compatible with the associated
building’s character and the surrounding district. Appropriate materials include wood, wrought or cast
iron, or metal tubular to mimic iron in a simplified design.
Vinyl, PVC, and other synthetic fencing materials are specifically listed as inappropriate unless they meet
the exceptions in Chapter 9, which the proposal does not. The proposed fence is not a compatible material
for the context of the District and is inconsistent with the Design Guidelines.
Staff finds the proposed work to be inconsistent with the Design Guidelines and therefore recommends
denial.
Staff Findings
Additional Photos
1520 Chesapeake Avenue PLN-CAPP-2026-055 5
Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on June 24,
2026.
1. eBUILD Application
Supplemental Documents
Public Notification
City of Chesapeake
Department of Planning
Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness
Record Detail Information
Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Submitted File Date: June 8, 2026
Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-055
Record Name: 1520 CHESAPEAKE AVE
Expiration Date:
Description:
Parent Record Number: REPLACE PRIVACY FENCE WITH WHITE PVC FENCE
Address: 1520 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324
Owner Information
Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone
1520 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 214CAPLINGER MARK A &
KARA
Yes
Parcel Information
Parcel No:
1340000002050
Contact Information
Organization NameName Contact Type Phone
KARA CAPLINGER CAPLINGER MARK A & KARA Applicant (757) 277-1631
Address
1520 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 214
Application Specific Information
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION
Description REPLACE PRIVACY FENCE WITH WHITE PVC FENCE
Zoning Sign Off No
Economic Hardship No
PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE
Application After-the-Fact -
After-the-Fact Fee Paid -
Approved Administratively -
Approving Planner -
Approval Date -
Certificate Number -
See supplemental submittal requirements -
Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-055
Board Approved Certificate Number -
I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff &
members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter
my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of
Appropriateness Application.
-
Structure Designation -
GENERAL INFORMATION
Year Structure Built 1917
Is this an After-the-Fact application? No
$250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED
One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy
attached to the on-line application
UNCHECKED
One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line
application
UNCHECKED
? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the
applicant is not the property owner.
UNCHECKED
NEW CONSTRUCTION
Completed application form. UNCHECKED
Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings,
structure(s), parking, etc.)
UNCHECKED
Front and side elevations UNCHECKED
Samples UNCHECKED
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED
Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite
properties.
UNCHECKED
ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES
Completed application form. UNCHECKED
Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED
Elevations UNCHECKED
Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED
Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED
Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and
location.
UNCHECKED
ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS
Completed application form. UNCHECKED
Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED
Photographs of the building/structure. UNCHECKED
2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED
Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED
RELOCATIONS
Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-055
Completed application form UNCHECKED
Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and
adjacent properties.
UNCHECKED
Photographs of the premises to which the building or
structure will be relocated.
UNCHECKED
Written description of reasons for the relocation and the
proposed use of the vacated property.
UNCHECKED
DEMOLITIONS
Completed application form UNCHECKED
Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to
illustrate its state of disrepair.
UNCHECKED
Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED
Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED
METAL ROOFS
Explanation UNCHECKED
Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED
Picture UNCHECKED
Specification Sheet UNCHECKED
Roof color sample UNCHECKED
Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED
Quotes UNCHECKED
Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED
Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-055
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 1
Staff Report Version June 23, 2026
Proposal After-the-fact replacement and installation of fencing with X-rail gate.
Address 1329 Jackson Avenue Year Built 1953 (Non-Contributing)
Applicant Anthony Ryder After-the-Fact Yes ☒ No ☐
Owner Alexandria Moore Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐
HARB Hearing Date
July 2, 2026
Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk
Application Address 1329 Jackson Avenue
Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-058
Staff Recommendation Not Available N/A
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 2
Aerial Map
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 3
Project Proposal
Applicant is proposing an after-the-fact replacement of existing wooden fencing like-for-like and
installation of wooden X-rail gate.
South Norfolk Design Guidelines
Fences, Walls, and Hedges
1. Retain historic fences, walls, and hedges. Replace missing or damaged fencing and walls with new
materials that match the historic. If large amounts of historic decorative fencing are missing, carefully
salvage the remaining portions to the maximum extent possible and install the historic salvaged material
at the front or prominent sides of a building, then replicate the missing material.
a. For new fencing, the material, style, and height should be in keeping with the character of the
associated building’s architectural style, as well as the surrounding district. All fencing, walls, and
hedges should meet the provisions of the City of Chesapeake Zoning Ordinance, Article 12, Section
722 - Architectural guidelines and Article 14, Section 201 - Fences,walls and hedges on residential
property, as outlined below:
i. For interior lots, fence requirements are as follows:
Front yard: A maximum height of 4 feet, 50% open
Side yard: A maximum height of 6 feet
Rear yard: A maximum height of 6 feet
Hedges: Hedges are restricted in height to the same height as fences
2. Appropriate new fencing materials include:
a. Vertical wood pickets; wood fences may be painted or stained. Common types include:
• 50–100% open: Common Picket, Dog Ear Picket, Gothic Picket, Angled Picket
• 0–49% open: Solid Board Dog Ear, Solid Board Gothic, Solid Board Picket, Shadowbox,
Framed, Arched, Scalloped
b. Wrought or cast iron or metal tubular to mimic iron in a simplified design. Common types include:
• Staggered Traditional, Traditional, Modern
3. Inappropriate fencing types include:
a. Vinyl, PVC, or synthetic fences unless meeting the requirements outlined in Chapter 9,
Alternative Materials.
b. Chain link fencing; chain link fences may be approved for use in rear yards or side yards on mid-
block lots where they will not be visible from the paved public street, but
(pg. 100)
Project Proposal
Staff Analysis
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 4
General Analysis
The after-the-fact like-for-like replacement of the existing wooden dog-ear fence would have been an
administrative review and presents no issues aside from the after-the-fact nature.
The after-the-fact wooden X-rail gate is not an explicitly stated approved fencing style within the Design
Guidelines and therefore required review by the HARB. There is little to no contextual evidence to support
nor oppose this particular style of fence, and the property is designated as non-contributing, which affords
some flexibility in selection of more “modern” alternative materials and styles as long as it aligns with the
greater context of the historic district.
Staff finds insufficient context to make a determination regarding consistency with the Design Guidelines
and therefore withholds a recommendation.
Staff Findings
Additional Photos
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 5
1329 Jackson Avenue — PLN-CAPP-2026-058 6
Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on June 24,
2026.
1. eBUILD Application
Supplemental Documents
Public Notification
City of Chesapeake
Department of Planning
Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness
Record Detail Information
Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: June 8, 2026
Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-058
Record Name: 1329 Jackson ave
Expiration Date:
Description:
Parent Record Number: Rebuild and redesign of side fencing turned into gate with
historic style aesthetic
Address: 1329 JACKSON AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324
Owner Information
Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone
MOORE ALEXANDRIA MYes
Parcel Information
Parcel No:
1340000001720
Contact Information
Organization NameName Contact Type Phone
Anthony C Ryder Applicant
Address
Application Specific Information
NATURE OF THE APPLICATION
Description Redesign of original fencing turned into a gate temporary garden
fencing has been up for almost three years and wanted a better
looking access point
Zoning Sign Off No
Economic Hardship No
PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE
Application After-the-Fact -
After-the-Fact Fee Paid -
Approved Administratively -
Approving Planner -
Approval Date -
Certificate Number -
Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-058
See supplemental submittal requirements -
Board Approved Certificate Number -
I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff &
members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter
my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of
Appropriateness Application.
-
Structure Designation -
GENERAL INFORMATION
Year Structure Built New construction
Is this an After-the-Fact application? Yes
$250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED
One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy
attached to the on-line application
UNCHECKED
One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line
application
CHECKED
? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the
applicant is not the property owner.
UNCHECKED
NEW CONSTRUCTION
Completed application form. UNCHECKED
Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings,
structure(s), parking, etc.)
UNCHECKED
Front and side elevations UNCHECKED
Samples UNCHECKED
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED
Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite
properties.
UNCHECKED
ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES
Completed application form. UNCHECKED
Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED
Elevations UNCHECKED
Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED
Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED
Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED
Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and
location.
UNCHECKED
ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS
Completed application form. CHECKED
Written description of work to be performed CHECKED
Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED
2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED
Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED
Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-058
RELOCATIONS
Completed application form UNCHECKED
Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and
adjacent properties.
UNCHECKED
Photographs of the premises to which the building or
structure will be relocated.
UNCHECKED
Written description of reasons for the relocation and the
proposed use of the vacated property.
UNCHECKED
DEMOLITIONS
Completed application form UNCHECKED
Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to
illustrate its state of disrepair.
UNCHECKED
Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED
Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED
METAL ROOFS
Explanation UNCHECKED
Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED
Picture UNCHECKED
Specification Sheet UNCHECKED
Roof color sample UNCHECKED
Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED
Quotes UNCHECKED
Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED
Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-058
Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.