RecordWell Data

Board of Historic and Architectural Review Regular Meeting Agenda

City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · meeting of Jun 4, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

H I S T O R I C & A R C H I T E C T U R A L R E V I E W B O A R D J u n e 4 , 2 0 2 6 Board of Historic and Architectural Review June 4, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center 2130 S Military Hwy, Chesapeake, VA 23320 5:30 PM A. Call To Order B. Roll Call C. Approval of May 7 regular meeting minutes. D. Committee Reports E. Administrative Approvals F. Zoning Report G. Old and New Business a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates, Residential Rehabilitation Grant funding priorities with John Harbin, Director H. Consent Agenda Items I. Regular Agenda Items 1. 1409 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-041) Construction of roof over rear deck. 2. 1238 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-044) Removal of 2 roof skylights as part of roof repair. J. Public Input K. Legal Guidance L. Adjournment These applications and related documents are available for public review on the Planning Department’s website through the following link: https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/AgendaCenter/Board-of-Historic-Architectural- Review-4 The City of Chesapeake will provide reasonable accommodations and services necessary for sensory-impaired and disabled persons by contacting the Facilities Maintenance Administrator, Public Works at (757) 382-8951 at least three-working days in advance and language assistance to individuals with limited English proficiency to the extent possible by contacting the Planning Department at (757) 382-6176 at least 10 days in advance of this meeting. *While this is not a public hearing, the public and any one or several members of the Chesapeake City Council may choose to attend. 1 Meeting Minutes Historic and Architectural Review Board (HARB) May 7, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center ROLL CALL HARB Members Present: Chair Frank Lilley, Vice Chair Scott Grinels, Ervin Young, Dave Walski Staff: Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Adam Lantz, City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Carlos Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Officer – Developments and Permits; Nat McCormick, Community Designer Manager – Planning Department Chair F. Lilley called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m. MINUTES Approval of April 2 regular meeting minutes. Motion to approve April 2 minutes as presented made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (4-0). COMMITTEE REPORTS None. ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS A. Nagorniuk reported eight (8) administrative approvals since the April 2 meeting. ZONING REPORT None. OLD AND NEW BUSINESS a. Chesapeake Land Bank updates Nat McCormick provided updates regarding South Norfolk Residential Rehabilitation grant applications, two for repainting and one for HVAC system repair, reviewed by the Chesapeake Land Bank Authority (CLBA) this month. Questions from Board members about Bainbridge lots owned by CLBA. Discussion and planning for collaborative discussion between HARB and CLBA regarding grant funding priorities. CONSENT AGENDA None. REGULAR AGENDA 1. 1437 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-008); 1439 Chesapeake Avenue (PLNCAPP-2026-009) After-the-fact replacement of front door; remove existing handrail on steps; and replacing 5 fence panels with 8x6 wood panels.  Discussion clarifying whether railing(s) were previously existing, whether railings are required.  Motion to approve the application as presented made by D. Walski and seconded by E. Young, with all members present voting for (4-0). 2. 1415 Jackson Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-025) Installation of wheelchair ramp on front porch.  Applicant proposed to amend the width of a portion of the proposed ramp to allow for space between the ramp and primary building; discussion among applicant and Board members to confirm location, design, and dimensions of ramp.  Board discussion of permanence/ lifespan of ramps in the Historic District. 2  Motion to approve 1415 Jackson Avenue with the amended changes to allow top decking to be 48 inches, posts to go above handrail as stated to match existing, and to allow measurement changes to meet any code requirement required by the City made by F. Lilley and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (4-0). 3. 1543 Rodgers Street (PLN-CAPP-2026-035) After-the-fact installation of fence.  Discussion of fencing styles, mitigation of visual style from adjacent properties and paved public street(s). Applicant proposed to cover installed wooden fence with dog-ear picket fencing and gate on the exterior of the fence.  Comment in support from applicant’s neighbor.  Motion to approve 1543 Rodgers to allow the fence to stay with the addition of dog-ear pickets on the exterior of the fence and gate to meet the height of existing lattice fencing made by F. Lilley and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (4-0). PUBLIC INPUT None. LEGAL GUIDANCE None. ADJOURNMENT Motion to adjourn the meeting made by D. Walski and seconded by E. Young, with all members present voting yes (4-0). Meeting adjourned at 6:58 p.m. MEETING MINUTES APPROVED: ________________ 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 1 Staff Report Version May 27, 2026 Proposal Construction of roof over rear deck. Address 1409 Seaboard Avenue Year Built 1926 (Contributing) Applicant Kenneth Neuens After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒ Owner Kenneth Neuens Special Power of Attorney Yes ☐ No ☒ HARB Hearing Date June 4, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1409 Seaboard Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-041 Staff Recommendation Approval 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 2 Aerial Map 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing to construct a roof/canopy over the backyard deck, to include: 1. 6” x 6” wooden columns with moulding at top and bottom; 2. 15’ x 20’ black architectural shingle roof with a 4:12 slope; 3. 2” x 10” wooden rafters and beams, 15’ in length; 4. Like-for-like repair/installation of Dutch-lap vinyl siding at ledger locations. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Roofs 3. If the roof is not historic, then an alternative replacement material can be proposed, provided it does not detract from the character of the building; see Chapter 9 for guidance on the selection of an appropriate alternative material. a. Provide documentation showing what material historically existed on the roof. Decks And Patios 1. Decks and patios should only be constructed at the rear of a building, unless there is historic evidence that these features existed in a more prominent location on the site within the district’s period of significance. a. Decks and patios not visible from a paved public street do not require a COA. 2. Limit physical impacts to the contributing primary building when installing decks or pergolas/canopies over patios by designing these structures to be freestanding to avoid direct connections to the building itself. If direct connections to the historic building are necessary for structural stability, minimize the size and number of connections. General Analysis There is an existing back deck, accessible by a door at the rear of the home, that is currently not visible from a paved public street. The proposed roof/canopy would be visible from the cross-street of Park Avenue. The proposed roof structure, supported by 6”x6” wooden columns with top and bottom moulding, would extend from the rear wall of the house over the existing deck. Aside from the roof/canopy and columns, the deck will remain uncovered, with no walls or netting, etc. Roofing material will be black architectural shingle to match existing shingle roof on the primary structure. Rear decks and patios, located at the rear of buildings, are afforded more flexibility due to the less prominent location. The proposed roof/canopy aligns with typical porch/deck roof design within the Historic District and will be compatible with the existing architectural design of the primary building. Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 4 Staff find the proposed roof/canopy to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval. Staff Findings Additional Photos 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 5 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 6 1409 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-041 7 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on May 28, 2026. 1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: May 5, 2026 Record Number: pln-capp-2026-041 Record Name: Kenneth Neuens Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Rear Roof Over Half Deck. 15 out by 19 long. Rafters are 2 x 10 x 15. The shingles match the Roof that is already in there. A 2 x 10 x 19 a beam (4) 6 x 6 Post. Address: 1409 SEABOARD AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone NEUENS KENNETHYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1340000003380 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Kenneth Michael Neuens NEUENS KENNETH Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description rear roof over deck 15 deep 19 long 2x10 x15 long shingles match the house 6x6 post Zoning Sign Off Yes Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - Page 1 of 3 pln-capp-2026-041 See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built new construction Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED Page 2 of 3 pln-capp-2026-041 RELOCATIONS Completed application form CHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. CHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 pln-capp-2026-041 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 1 Staff Report Version May 27, 2026 Proposal : Removal of two skylights as part of like-for-like roofing repair/replacements. Address 1238 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built c. 1910 (Contributing) ApplicantAnne Conger After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒ Owner Anne Conger Special Power of Attorney Yes ☐ No ☒ HARB Hearing Date June 4, 2026 Staff Planner Olivia Knox Application Address 1238 Chesapeake Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-044 Staff Recommendation Approval 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 2 Aerial Map 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing: 1. Removal of Skylights: Removal of two (2) skylights with installation of in-kind slate shingles in place on primary roof 2. Slate Roof Repair: Like-for-like replacement of broken, loose, and/or missing slate shingles on primary roof 3. Shingle Roof Repair: Like-for-like replacement of damaged plywood, underlayment, and architectural asphalt shingles on secondary roof located at northwest corner South Norfolk Design Guidelines Roofs (pg. 53) 2. Retain the original roof shape and form. 3. Repair historic roofing materials. (a) Patch damaged areas with new material that matches the historic material in size, texture, and other visual qualities. (c) If portions of historic roof details are damaged, deteriorated, or missing, these should be repaired or replaced in kind. 4. If replacement of the historic roofing material is necessary, replacement should be in-kind. Slate (pg. 55) 1. Retain and restore historic slate roofs. 2. Repair broken, cracked, or missing slate promptly to prevent water infiltration. (c) New slate used to make repairs should match the historic in type, color, size, shape, and overall pattern. General Analysis Skylight The existing skylights located on the southwestern portion of the roof are not original features of the home, as evidenced by the Nomination Report. Additionally, the applicant reported that the skylights are experiencing water seepage due to natural wear and deterioration over time. The Guidelines encourage the removal of non-original elements and support in-kind restoration of historic properties to maintain the architectural character of both the individual structure and the district as a whole. Removing the skylights and restoring the roof to its original form is consistent with the South Norfolk Historic District Preservation Philosophy, which states that “features and finishes that are character- defining to an architectural style should be retained and restored.” Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 4 Due to the skylights’ visibility from the public right-of-way, restoring the roof to its original architectural appearance will further support the historic character and integrity of both the property and South Norfolk Historic District. Slate Roofing In-kind replacement of individual slate shingles is an administrative review item and is consistent with the Design Guidelines. Architectural Shingle Roofing In-kind replacement of architectural shingles is an administrative review item and is consistent with the Design Guidelines. The applicant has noted that this COA will be the first of multiple phases of property improvements, with the intention of restoring the property to its original historic context. Staff find the proposed work to be consistent with the Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval. Staff Findings 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 5 Additional Photos 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 6 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 7 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 8 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 9 1238 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-044 10 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on May 28, 2026. 1. Roofing Quote 2. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification contact@roofartistry.com ROOF REPAIR MAY 06, 2026 ANNE CONGERS 1238 Chesapeake Avenue Chesapeake, VA 23324 INTRODUCTION Anne, We had discussed the siding, roof, and gutter repairs, and we can certainly help with the gutters and roof. However, we strive to provide the best value and service as possible, and I'm not confident that we can properly handle the siding repairs you need. I don't want to do you a disservice, so the estimate below only includes the roof and gutter work we had discussed. This includes repairing the broken slate on the top roof, an option to install new gutters and downspouts around the house and garage, an option to replace the front porch with shingles, an option to replace the top back shingle roof, another to remove the skylights and roof over and the last is to repair the leak on the front porch and the damaged siding directly below it. Many of the pictures can be seen in the report, however, you can see all of the pictures through the link here Please don't hesitate to call or email me if you have any questions or concerns. Thank you for allowing me to look at your roof and I'd like to ask that you choose us to solve all your roof issues. I look forward to hearing from you soon and I hope you have an outstanding day! Paul Anderson Roof Artistry (757)955-0107 Paul@RoofArtistry.com www.RoofArtistry.com INSPECTION ROOF ISSUES SLATE ROOF REPAIR Description Replace broken slate tiles -Remove 4 damaged slate tiles. -Replace with new, matching as best available to existing, and secure with slate hooks to prevent slippage. -Secure the loose plumbing vent pipe to the siding. -Clean up and haul away all job related debris. Estimate subtotal $896.42 Total $896.42 SHINGLE ROOF REPLACEMENT Description Replace the shingle roof -Remove existing shingles down to the roof deck on the front porch. -Inspect entire roof deck for any damaged plywood and rafters. -Replace 1 sheet of damaged plywood. *Additional plywood replacement is charged at $125 per sheet for labor and material. *Plank boards replacement is charged at $9 per linear foot for labor and material. *Rafter repairs are charged at $9 per linear foot for labor and material. -Install synthetic underlayment across the entire roof deck. -Install Starter Shingles along all roof edges with at least 4 nails per. -Install CertainTeed Landmark Lifetime Architectural Shingles per manufacturer's specifications, installing six 1 ¼” roofing nails per shingle. -Install new wall flashing. -Install new CertainTeed Shadow Ridge hip and ridge cap shingles. -Clean up and haul away all job related debris. -Run magnets around the house to pick up nails. *Magnets will pick up nails on paved and other flat surfaces, but may not get all in grass or around plants. Warranty 50 Year Limited Lifetime Material Warranty Lifetime Workmanship Warranty 10 Year No Leak Guarantee Estimate subtotal $5,922.85 Total $5,922.85 SIGNING Slate Roof Repair $896.42 Name: Anne Congers Gutter & Downspout Replacement $5,413.47 Address: 1238 Chesapeake Avenue, Chesapeake, VA Shingle Roof Replacement $5,922.85 Optional Upgrades Description Qty Unit price Line total Skylight Removal -Remove the slate tiles around and both skylights from the left rear section of the slate roof. -Cut out the existing roof deck and install plywood over the openings. -Install leak barrier directly to the roof deck. -Install new slate tiles to fill in the area, matching as best available to existing. -Clean up and haul away all job related debris. 1 $6,400.00 $6,400.00 Roof & Siding Repair -Remove the wall flashing and shingles along the left rear wall over the left door on the front porch. -Cut and remove the damaged roof deck. -Inspect the rafter for damage. *Rafter repairs are charged at a rate of $9 per linear foot for labor material. -Replace damaged roof deck with new plywood. -Install leak barrier directly to the roof deck. -Install new wall flashing and shingles, matching as best available to existing. -Remove the damaged siding to the left of the door. -Inspect for damaged studs. -Replace damaged wood siding with new. -Apply two coats of exterior paint to the new siding, matching as best available to existing. -Clean up and haul away all job related debris. 1 $3,200.00 $3,200.00 Customer Comments / Notes Anne Congers: Date: 22 Landmark, shown in Georgetown Gray LANDMARK® • Two-piece laminated fiberglass-based construction • Classic shades and dimensional appearance of natural wood or slate • Lifetime limited transferable warranty* • 10-year algae-resistance warranty • extra-wide nailing area for accurate installation • 10-year SureStart™ protection • 15-year 110 mph wind-resistance warranty • Wind warranty upgrade to 130 mph available. CertainTeed starter and CertainTeed hip and ridge required • CertainTeed Starter and hip and ridge accessory available (see details in back of brochure) * See warranty for specific details and limitations. CertainTeed products are tested to ensure the highest quality and comply with the following industry standards: Fire Resistance: • UL Class A • UL certified to meet ASTM D3018 Type 1 Wind Resistance: • UL certified to meet ASTM D3018 Type 1 • ASTM D3161 Class F Tear Resistance: • UL certified to meet ASTM D3462 • CSA standard A123.5 Wind Driven Rain Resistance: • Miami-Dade Product Control Acceptance: Please reference www.certainteed.com to determine approved products by manufacturing location. Quality Standards: • ICC-ES-ESR-1389 & ESR-3537 Scan code for more information COLOR AVAILABILITY Burnt Sienna Cobblestone Gray Colonial Slate Driftwood Resawn Shake Pewter Moiré Black Hunter Green Heather Blend Georgetown Gray Weathered Wood City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: May 11, 2026 Record Number: pln-capp-2026-044 Record Name: 1238 Chesapeake Avenue Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: In-kind repair of the primary roof with slate replacement. Removal of two skylights with installation of slate roofing in place. In-kind asphalt replacement of the rear roof at the property’s northwest corner. Address: 1238 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone CONGER ANNEYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1280000000250 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Anne Conger Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description In-kind repair of the primary roof with slate replacement. Removal of two skylights with installation of slate roofing in place. In-kind asphalt replacement of the rear roof at the property’s northwest corner. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Page 1 of 3 pln-capp-2026-044 Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1900 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. - One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application - One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application - ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. - NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) - Front and side elevations - Samples - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. - ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan or city tax map - Elevations - Photographs of the existing structure and property. - Samples, photos, and brochures - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. - ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: CHECKED Page 2 of 3 pln-capp-2026-044 Photos numerically keyed CHECKED RELOCATIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. - Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. - Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. - DEMOLITIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. - Written report on condition of building or structure. - Written description of work to be performed - SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached - METAL ROOFS Explanation - Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. - Picture - Specification Sheet - Roof color sample - Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. - Quotes - Roof color sample (asphalt) - Page 3 of 3 pln-capp-2026-044

Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.