RecordWell Data

Board of Historic and Architectural Review Regular Meeting Agenda

City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · meeting of Apr 2, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

H I S T O R I C & A R C H I T E C T U R A L R E V I E W B O A R D A p r i l 2 , 2 0 2 6 Board of Historic and Architectural Review April 2, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center 2130 S Military Hwy, Chesapeake, VA 23320 5:30 PM A. Call To Order B. Roll Call C. Approval of February 5 regular meeting minutes. D. Committee Reports E. Administrative Approvals F. Zoning Report G. Old and New Business a. Chesapeake Land Bank updates H. Consent Agenda Items I. Regular Agenda Items 1. 1430 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2025-127) After-the-fact front porch renovation and like-for-like window replacement; like-for- like repair/restoration of existing front door. 2. 1432 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-015) Replacement of all existing wooden windows with new vinyl windows. J. Public Input K. Legal Guidance L. Adjournment These applications and related documents are available for public review on the Planning Department’s website through the following link: https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/AgendaCenter/Board-of-Historic-Architectural- Review-4 The City of Chesapeake will provide reasonable accommodations and services necessary for sensory-impaired and disabled persons by contacting the Facilities Maintenance Administrator, Public Works at (757) 382-8951 at least three-working days in advance and language assistance to individuals with limited English proficiency to the extent possible by contacting the Planning Department at (757) 382-6176 at least 10 days in advance of this meeting. *While this is not a public hearing, the public and any one or several members of the Chesapeake City Council may choose to attend. 1 Meeting Minutes Historic and Architectural Review Board (HARB) February 5, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center ROLL CALL HARB Members Present: Chair Frank Lilley, Vice Chair Scott Grinels, Ervin Young, Kaydee Moore, Dave Walski Staff: Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Jessica Turner, City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Carlos Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Officer – Developments and Permits; Nat McCormick, Community Designer Manager – Planning Department Chair F. Lilley called the meeting to order at 5:32 p.m. MINUTES Approval of January 8 regular meeting minutes. Motion to approve January 8 minutes as presented made by K. Moore and seconded by F. Lilley, with all members present voting for (4-0). COMMITTEE REPORTS None. ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS A. Nagorniuk reported eight (8) administrative approvals since the January 8 meeting. ZONING REPORT None. OLD AND NEW BUSINESS a. Chesapeake Land Bank updates Nat McCormick provided updates regarding four South Norfolk Residential Rehabilitation grant applications reviewed by the Chesapeake Land Bank Authority this month. b. Planning updates Anna Nagorniuk reported the PLN-TXT-2025-017 text amendment scheduled to be heard by City Council on February 17. Nat McCormick discussed Planning staff’s ongoing historical property information database project. CONSENT AGENDA None. REGULAR AGENDA 1. 1238 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-001) Reissue PLN-CAPP-2024-009 for replacement of existing wooden siding vinyl “double 4” siding..  Motion to accept the application as presented made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (5-0). PUBLIC INPUT None. 2 LEGAL GUIDANCE None. ADJOURNMENT Motion to adjourn the meeting made by S. Grinels and seconded by D. Walski, with all members present voting yes (5-0). Meeting adjourned at 6:22 p.m. MEETING MINUTES APPROVED: _____________ 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 1 Staff Report Version March 31, 2026 Proposal After-the-fact front porch renovation and like-for-like vinyl window replacement; like-for-like repair/restoration of existing front door. Address 1430 Seaboard Avenue Year Built 1915 (Contributing) Applicant Tanyi Ndieb Nso After-the-Fact Yes ☒ No ☐ Owner Dante Teo LLC Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐ HARB Hearing Date April 2, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1430 Seaboard Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2025-127 Staff Recommendation Approval with Stipulations 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 2 Aerial Map 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing the after-the-fact removal of the front porch enclosure and reconstructing the porch to include: 1. Replacement of existing 4”x4” columns with 6”x6” turned wooden columns; 2. Like-for-like replacement of existing tongue-and-groove porch floorboards; 3. Installation of wooden railings with 2”x2” spindles and 2”x6” beveled top handrail 4. Like-for-like repair/restoration of existing front door. Applicant is also proposing: 5. After-the-fact installation of vinyl windows on the side elevations to be original dimensions of 2’-8” x 5’; 6. Like-for-like repair of vinyl lap siding. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Porches 1. Historic porches should only be altered, including addition, deletion, or expansion, based on documented historic conditions. Steps and Flooring 1. Historic porch steps and flooring should be retained and restored as feasible. 2. Replacement of historic steps and flooring should be done in-kind as feasible. To achieve replacement in-kind, new materials should match the historic material, composition, shape, size, and other visual qualities. a. When replacing an entire porch floor, ensure the new floor is sloped away from the historic building to eliminate water infiltration issues. Handrails 1. Historic porch handrails and balustrades should be retained and restored. a. If portions of handrails or balustrades are missing or damaged, they should be replicated and replaced in-kind. 2. If a porch no longer has a handrail, but there is evidence a handrail was previously in place, the historic handrail should be replicated based on pictorial or physical evidence. If no historic or pictorial evidence remains, or if no handrail existed historically and is required for fall protection, use a contemporary, compatible rail like the one illustrated below or a simple metal rail. Windows Additionally, the details of window shape, size, location, glass divisions, and surrounding features also impart character and assist in defining architectural style. As such, windows are inherently character defining features and should be retained. Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 4 1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows. 2. If a historic window needs to be replaced, match the historic window in size, dimensions, configuration, and materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL). a. Provide detailed photographic documentation of deterioration of each window proposed for replacement to the HARB. b. Provide dimensioned drawings of the existing historic windows and the proposed replacement windows to illustrate they match. 4. The size of the historic opening should not be modified (decreased or enlarged) as a result of or to accommodate window replacement. Replacement windows should be sized appropriately to fit the historic opening. 5. Historic window openings should not be modified or eliminated to accommodate interior changes. (pg.72- 76) General Analysis Front porch The removal of porch enclosures/screening on front elevations is generally supported by the Design Guidelines. The turned wooden columns are proposed on the basis of photographic evidence of the underlying original columns that were discovered during the current work on the property. Upon further review/discussion, the proposed railings were found to be inconsistent with the standards within the Design Guidelines. The top rail appears to be a 2”x6” board to be beveled on the corners. The nominal 2”x2” pickets are slimmer than typical wooden handrails seen throughout the District, and they are to be horizontally bordered by other 2”x2”s, creating pockets between the pickets that will gather water. The handrails on the steps should be affixed to the 6”x6” posts and extend all the way down the stairs to the ground, with a bottom post at the end, rather than the additional posts affixed to the stairs as depicted. The original porch floor appears to have been (temporarily) covered during the enclosure of the porch, and the applicant is proposing a like-for-like replacement of wooden tongue-and-groove porch floorboards. Existing roof, beams, and fascia will remain as is. The applicant is also proposing like-for-like repair/restoration of the front door, which is an administratively-approvable item. Windows After-the-fact work included modification of one window opening on the north side of the home to be smaller than the existing opening, and one window opening reframed to be a side door, which is inconsistent with the Design Guidelines. Now, the applicant is proposing to restore both window openings to the original dimensions of 2’-8”x5’ , repair the existing vinyl siding, and install double-hung vinyl windows. The previously existing windows were also vinyl. Staff Findings 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 5 Staff find the proposed work, with the exception of the railings, to be consistent with Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval with stipulation #1. 1. That proposed railings be revised to be consistent with the typical railing standards of the Design Guidelines. Additional Photos Stipulations dated: March 31, 2026 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 6 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 7 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 8 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 9 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 10 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 11 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 12 1430 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2025-127 13 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on March 26, 2026. 1. eBuild Application 2. Special Power of Attorney Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: December 9, 2025 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2025-127 Record Name: 1430 Seaboard Ave, Chesapeake, VA 23324 Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: - Address: 1430 SEABOARD AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone DANTE TEO LLCYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1340000002850 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Tanyi Ndieb Nso Dante Teo LLC Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Installation decking board on the front porch, installation of a new deck 5×10 in the back porch, replace side door, back door, front door and side door. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2025-127 Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1915 Is this an After-the-Fact application? Yes $250 After the Fact fee, if required. CHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. UNCHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2025-127 RELOCATIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2025-127 LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY RESOLUTION OF Dante Teo. LLC After a meeting of the members of __Dante Teo, LLC, A Wyoming limited liability company, and pursuant to the Operating Agreement, it was resolved as follows: 4. ____________________ Tanyi Ndieb Nso _________________________ Leonard Ayamba Ndifon ______________________ David Lobe _______________________ Nsuh Cho Contantine Docusign Envelope ID: 7CA39FEA-C9CD-4375-A8AF-7ADEDCEFCE22 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 Docusign Envelope ID: B21A173F-CC5C-4925-AF72-DF2ED22ECBA4 2. Resolved that Tanyi Ndieb Nso is empowered to apply for permits, purchase, sell, transfer, and convey, any property owned by Dante Teo LLC 3. That Tanyi Ndieb Nso are hereby authorized to execute all documents required to complete all transaction as contemplated and set forth above on behalf of Dante Teo, Dante Teo, LLC. 1. That Tanyi Ndieb Nso is the Manager and Leonard Ayamba Ndifon David Lobe, Nsuh Cho Contantine , Eric Mbionyi , Osong Egbe, Eugene Tayo And Timah Ndi are all Members of Dante Teo LLC, and may act on Behalf of the Company. That Tanyi Ndieb Nso hereby states no endorsements or ratifications have been made to the Articles of Organization or the Operating Agreement since August 8, 2024 for Dante, Teo, LLC. _____________________ Eric Mbionyi ______________________ Osong Egbe ______________________ Eugene Tayo ______________________ Timah Ndi Docusign Envelope ID: 7CA39FEA-C9CD-4375-A8AF-7ADEDCEFCE22 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 3/6/2025 Docusign Envelope ID: B21A173F-CC5C-4925-AF72-DF2ED22ECBA4 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 1 Staff Report Version March 23, 2026 Proposal Replace all existing wood windows with new vinyl windows. Address 1432 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built 1915 (Contributing) Applicant Orion Hall After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒ Owner John Austin Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐ HARB Hearing Date April 2, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1432 Chesapeake Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-015 Staff Recommendation Denial 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 2 Aerial Map 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing to replace all existing wooden windows, including 1-over-1 and 12-over-1 windows, with new double-hung vinyl windows with contoured grids and new vinyl picture windows. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Additionally, the details of window shape, size, location, glass divisions, and surrounding features also impart character and assist in defining architectural style. As such, windows are inherently character defining features and should be retained. 1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows. 2. If a historic window needs to be replaced, match the historic window in size, dimensions, configuration, and materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL). a. Provide detailed photographic documentation of deterioration of each window proposed for replacement to the HARB. b. Provide dimensioned drawings of the existing historic windows and the proposed replacement windows to illustrate they match. (pg.75) General Analysis The Design Guidelines discourage “wholesale replacement of historic windows.” There is insufficient documentation of the extent of damage to the existing wooden windows to warrant replacement of all existing windows. The proposed vinyl replacement windows do not match the material of the existing windows, and they do not have simulated divided light (SDL) muntins, making them inconsistent with the Design Guidelines. Staff find the documentation and proposed work to be inconsistent with Design Guidelines and therefore recommend denial. Staff Findings Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 4 Additional Photos 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 5 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 6 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 7 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 8 1432 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-015 9 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on March 26, 2026. 1. eBuild Application 2. Special Power of Attorney Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Submitted File Date: February 23, 2026 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-015 Record Name: 1432 Chesapeake - New Windows Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Replace all existing windows at 1432 Chesapeake with historically compatible windows maintaining the existing openings, proportions, and exterior appearance. Address: 1432 CHESAPEAKE AVE 1, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone AUSTIN JOHN VALENZUELA Yes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1340000001960 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone John Austin Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Replace all existing windows at 1432 Chesapeake with historically compatible windows maintaining the existing openings, proportions, and exterior appearance. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-015 Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1915 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: CHECKED Photos numerically keyed CHECKED Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-015 RELOCATIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-015

Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.