RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Meeting Packet (PDF)

City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Aug 18, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Suffolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

SUFFOLK PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA FOR AUGUST 18, 2026 PREPARED BY THE CITY OF SUFFOLK DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT KEVIN WYNE, AICP, DIRECTOR OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT THE REGULAR MEETING WILL BE HELD AT 2:00 P.M. IN THE SUFFOLK CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS OF THE CITY HALL BUILDING IF YOU CANNOT ATTEND OR NEED SPECIAL ACCOMODATIONS AT THE MEETING, PLEASE CALL THE CITY OF SUFFOLK DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AT (757) 514-4060 PRIOR TO 12:00 NOON ON FRIDAY, AUGUST 14, 2026. ANITA HICKS CHAIRMAN Page 1 AGENDA SUFFOLK PLANNING COMMISSION August 18, 2026 2:00 P.M. 1. Call to Order A. Invocation B. Pledge of Allegiance C. Roll Call 2. Approval of minutes from previous meeting 3. Public Hearings: A. ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT, OTA2026-009, initiated by the City of Suffolk, for amendments to repeal Section 31-415, enact Section 31-415.1, and amend Appendix B-13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia. The purpose of the text amendment is to update and refine the Code of the City of Suffolk, Chapter 31, Unified Development Ordinance. B. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT, CPA2026 -01, initiated by the City of Suffolk, to revise Chapter 2, “Land Use and Growth Management,” of the 2045 Comprehensive Plan to incorporate policy language and action strategies regarding cumulative acreage caps and limits for utility-scale solar facilities. 4. Old Business 5. New Business A. Staff Report – ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT OTA2026-07: proposed amendments to Sections 31-301(a), 31-306(i)&(g), 31-307(a), 31-309(d), 31-413(g), 31-509(c), 31-603(e), 31-604(e)&(h), 31-605(b), 31-606 (a)&(c), 31-612(b), 31-701(b)&(d), 31-702(e), 31-708(a), 31-801(c), and Appendix B, of the Unified Development Ordinance, Chapter 31 of the Code of the City of Suffolk. B. Status Report - City Council Meeting, July 15, 2026 C. Status Report - Preliminary Plats Approved - None 6. Commissioner’s Comments 7. Adjournment 1 MINUTES SUFFOLK PLANNING COMMISSION July 21, 2026 2:00 P.M. The meeting of the Suffolk Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, July 21, 2026, at 2:00 p.m., in the Council Chambers of the Municipal Building, 44 2 W. Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia, with the following persons present: MEMBERS: Oliver Creekmore Mary Ellen Baur Gerald Goodman Thomas Powell Selena Thornton-Manuel Johnnie Edwards David Bosselman STAFF: William Hutchings, Jr., City Attorney Kevin Wyne, Dir. of Planning & Com. Dev. Margaret Pittenger, Asst. Dir. of Planning William Mellon, Zoning Administrator Caitlin Aubut, Land Use Planning Manager Jonathan McBride, Comp. Planning Manager Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner Shannon Wolfe, Senior Planner Cassidy McKelvie, Senior Planner Isabella Reynolds, Planner I Yasaman Maleki, Planner I Matthew Madariaga, Planner I Catina Myrick, Administrative Analyst The meeting was called to order by Kevin Wyne, Director of Planning and Community Development. Commissioner Baur offered the Invocation and led the Pledge of Allegiance. The roll was called by Mr. Wyne and a quorum was present. ELECTION OF OFFICERS: ` 2 Anita Hicks was nominated as Chairman. This nomination and election of Anita Hicks as Chairman of the Suffolk Planning Commission was passed by a recorded vote of 7 to 0. Oliver Creekmore was nominated for Vice-Chairman. This nomination and election of Oliver Creekmore as Vice- Chairman of the Suffolk Planning Commission was passed by a recorded vote of 6 to 0 to 1. (Commissioner Creekmore abstained). APPROVAL OF MINUTES: The minutes of the previous meeting were approved as written. PUBLIC HEARINGS: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00009, Dogs at Lionheart: submitted by Leslie Benson, applicant and property owner, in accordance with Sections 31-306, 31-406, and 31-702 of the Unified Development Ordinance, to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a commercial kennel on property located at 2170 Joshua Lane, Zoning Map 24, Parcels 26. The affected area is further identified as being located in the Holy Neck Borough, zoned A, Agricultural zoning district. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan designates this area as outside the growth area, Rural Agriculture Land Use Type. The first item of business was introduced by the Vice-Chairman followed by a staff report by Shannon Wolfe, Senior Planner. Ms. Wolfe stated that this application is to establish a commercial kennel. The subject property is approximately 93 acres and contains Epps Farm Supply store, horse boarding, and several other agricultural uses such as chicken swaps and vegetable sales. While the applicant recognizes that the number of dogs on the property has the potential to produce noise, the size of the 3 property, surrounding vegetation, property, and the nearest residential home being approximately 500 feet away reduces the possibility for noise nuisance, and there has been no known noise complaints to date. The size of the property allows the dogs to be housed and exercised within the interior of the farm while maintaining separation from neighboring properties. The provided narrative stated that the Dog’s at Lionheart has been operating on the property for 20 years and was established in 2006, with dog breeding and offering dogs for adoption to families and individuals. The program focuses on raising dogs, primarily German Shephard’s with good temperament, sound health, and the potential to not only be a companion dog but also a service dog. The owner works with dog trainers to evaluate each dog to determine whether or not they are a good fit to be a service dog or would be much better suited as a companion. Service dogs are placed with first responders and military veterans injured in the line of duty as well as families with children on the autism spectrum to provide emotional support and increase independence. The program currently consist of 20 females, 6 males and up to 30 puppies under one year of age. The applicant proposed to keep up to 60 dogs onsite for breeding purposes; however, it is important to note that state law caps a commercial breeder at 50 dogs over 1 year of age without approval of governing body. The applicant stated that daily operations and care of the dogs are handled by the owner, one paid employee, and 10 volunteers, with approximately four 4 individuals in addition to the owner present on the property during normal business hours. One person will be present over night to monitor all the animals on the property. During a normal day, the dogs are taken out of their enclosures in groups of 10-15 at a time for walks, jogging, and supervised exercise around the property approximately every two hours. Buckets of food and water are kept out all day to allow the dogs to graze as they wish. During the summer , ice is placed in the water throughout the day to keep it cool. The owner states she maintains the financial resources necessary to provide ongoing food, veterinary care, housing, and overall management for all dogs on the property and even has a life insurance policy to cover their care. In conclusion, this application does sufficiently satisfy the criteria as set forth in the UDO. Therefore, staff recommended approval of this application with the conditions noted in the staff report. Chief Animal Control Officer Lanier gave her comments based on her observations at the property. The public hearing was opened and speaking in favor of this application was Leslie Benson, property owner. Also speaking in favor of this application was Sue Reznak – she advised she train dogs and evaluates their suitability for service dog training. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Debra Price, 2171 Joshua Lane, 5 Suffolk, VA. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Katherine Duke, 2172 Manning Road, Suffolk, VA. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Jesse Rountree, 9900 Hillpoint Blvd., Suffolk, VA. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Kimberly Wimbrough, 2120 Joshua Lane, Suffolk, VA. Also, speaking in favor of this application was an employee, but did not state their name for the record. There being no speakers in opposition, the public hearing was closed. After discussion by the Commission, Commissioner Goodman made a motion to approve this application with the conditions, seconded by Commissioner Baur and passed by a recorded vote of 6 to 1. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00016, Tiny Town Home Childcare: submitted by Janell Turner, applicant and property owner, in accordance with Sections 31-306, 31-406, and 31-701 of the Unified Development Ordinance, to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a family day home for up to 12 children on property located at 1017 Meadows Reach Circle, Zoning Map 26F, Parcel HM*6. The affected area is further identified as being located in the Chuckatuck Voting Borough, zoned PD, Planned Development Overlay Zoning District. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan designates this area as part of the Central Growth Area, Traditional Neighborhood Land Use Type. The next item of business was introduced by the Vice-Chairman followed by a staff 6 report by Isabella Reynolds, Planner I. Ms. Reynolds stated that this conditional use permit is to expand an existing family day home for up to 12 children. The subject property provides 5 parking spaces in the driveway and 3 off -street parking on Meadows Reach Circle, which is sufficient parking for the proposed use. A proposed condition of approval is that a minimum of 8 parking spaces shall be provided and maintained for the use. The fenced in outside play area is approximately 2,950 square feet, which exceeds the minimum requirement of 1,000 square feet of fenced outside play space. The applicant proposed to use 1,069 square feet which meets the indoor space requirement. The applicant currently operates the family day home with up to 4 children, which is permitted as a matter of right. Currently, the applicant operates Monday to Friday from 7 AM to 5 PM. The current hours of operation are proposed to stay the same with the expansion of the family day home . The outdoor play will be permitted only from 8 AM to 6 PM . To mitigate any potential adverse impacts, a proposed condition of approval will limit the outdoor play hours to 8 AM to 6 PM. The applicant did note that they remove d the trampoline from their back yard. In conclusion, this conditional use permit request does sufficiently satisfy the criteria as set forth in the UDO. The applicant currently operates a family day home for up to 4 children, which is permitted as a matter of right. The proposed expansion of the family day home i s not anticipated to have adverse impacts to the surrounding 7 community. Therefore, staff recommended approval of this application with the conditions noted in the staff report. The public hearing was opened and speaking in favor of this application was Janell Turner, property owner. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Tanika Jones, 1019 Meadows Reach Circle, Suffolk, VA. Also, speaking in favor of this application was Ja’Ron Vanderhall, Child Care Capacity Coordinator of Minus 9-5, 855 W. Brambleton Avenue, Norfolk, VA. There being no speakers in opposition, the public hearing was closed. After discussion by the Commission, Commissioner Edwards made a motion to approve this application with the conditions, seconded by Commissioner Goodman and passed by a recorded vote of 7 to 0. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00017, Zoenita’s Loving Arms Home Daycare: submitted by Simone Hunter, applicant and property owner, in accordance with Sections 31-306, 31-406, and 31-701 of the Unified Development Ordinance, to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a family day home for up to 12 children on property located at 145 Patriots Walke Drive, Zoning Map 27M, Parcel 35. The affected area is further identified as being located in the Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned RLM, Residential Low- Medium Zoning District. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan designates this area as part of the Central Growth Area, Suburban Neighborhood Land Use Type. The next item of business was introduced by the Vice-Chairman followed by a staff report by Caitlin Aubut, Land Use Planning Manager . M s. Aubut stated that the 8 applicant desires to establish a home daycare operation to accommodate up to 12 children, with daytime care hours from 6:00 AM to 6:00 PM and, at a future time, overnight care from 7:00 PM to 6:00 AM. In support of their request, the applicant submitted a floor plan, site photos, sketch plan of the outdoor play area and parking, and a narrative describing the operation of the family day home. The applicant proposed to utilize about 701 square feet of their 2,622 square foot home for the care of up to 12 children as depicted on the floor plan. The proposal meets the indoor space requirements of UDO. The parking spaces associated with the family day home use may be off-street or on-street where permitted within 200 feet of the property. The subject property is served by an approximately 31- foot by 18-foot driveway, which the applicant has designated as off-street parking for two vehicles. The applicant also provided three on-street parallel parking spaces along the south side of Patriots Walke Drive. The sketch plan depicts a 3,802 square-foot outdoor play area within the rear yard of the subject property. The applicant provided photos showing the grassy lawn area and a white vinyl fence that surrounds the play area. For family day homes, the UDO requires an outdoor play area of at least 1,000 square feet to be enclosed by a fence and located in such a way to provide “maximum peace and tranquility to adjoining residential uses and to protect the safety of the children”. The outdoor play area complies with the requirements of the UDO. In summary, it was staff’s opinion 9 that the site in question is appropriate for the establishment of a family day home operation to provide care for up to 12 children. Staff believe the expanded operation would not have adverse impacts on the surrounding area and; therefore, recommended approval of this application with the conditions noted in the staff report. The public hearing was opened and speaking in favor of this application was Simone Hunter, property owner. There being no speakers in opposition, the public hearing was closed. After discussion by the Commission, Commissioner Thornton-Manuel made a motion to approve this application with the conditions, seconded by Commissioner Edwards and passed by a recorded vote of 7 to 0. EXCEPTION REQUEST, CEX2026-00002, 306 Princess Arch: submitted by Karrie Engler and Robert Nickerson, applicants and property owners in accordance with Section 31-415 of the Unified Development Ordinance, to grant an Exception to the development criteria and buffer area requirements of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area to permit the removal of an existing shed and construct a larger shed encroaching within the Resource Protection Area buffer, on property located at 306 Princess Arch, Zoning Map 20C, parcel 2*134. The affected area is further identified as being located in the Cypress Voting Borough, zoned RLM, Residential Low- Medium Density Zoning District. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan designates this area as a part of the Northern Growth Area, Suburban Neighborhood Land Use Type. The next item of business was introduced by the Vice-Chairman followed by a staff report by Cassidy Mckelvie, Senior Planner. Ms. Mckelvie stated that the applicant requested an exception to encroach into the 50- foot landward portion of the RPA 10 buffer to construct a new 384 square -foot shed. The majority of the proposed shed (312 square feet) would be within the RPA buffer. The remaining 54 square feet of the proposed shed would be outside of the RPA buffer. The applicant proposed to remove the existing 166 square -foot shed from the 50- foot seaward portion of the buffer and a 350 square-foot area of concrete from the existing pool patio within the 50-foot landward portion of the buffer. Following the completion of the project, the total impervious coverage within the RPA buffer would be reduced by 201 square feet as proposed. The applicant also proposed using a plywood barrier along the construction access path to reduce land disturbance within the RPA buffer. A total 1,645 square feet of land disturbance within the RPA buffer is proposed with this request. No vegetation is proposed to be removed with this application. The applicant proposed to plant five (5) planting units back within the buffer for the 1,645 square feet of disturbance. The proposed WQIA meets the requirements of five (5) planting units established by the Buffer Manual. The existing dwelling was constructed in 2001 a fter the implementation of the CBPA regulations. The subject property currently contains a shed, a garage, and an attic that can be used for storage space. Staff considers the circumstances spurring this exception request to be self-imposed as the proposed shed could be smaller and placed elsewhere on the subject property outside of the RPA buffer. Although the applicant proposed to reduce the overall 11 disturbance by using temporary plywood barriers along the construction access path, staff believes the proposed shed could be smaller and still afford relief. The proposed shed appears to be larger than those on adjoining properties, making it incompatible in size with the surrounding neighborhood. Staff does not consider this application to be the minimum necessary to afford relief, as the shed could be reduced in size and placed entirely outside of the RPA buffer. Staff does not consider the request for the development of an accessory structure within the RPA buffer to be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the exception regulations for the CB Overlay District, as such structures are not necessary to support the primary use of the subject property. In summary, staff found that this exception request does not satisfy the criteria outlined in Section 31-415(f)(5)(C) of the UDO. Therefore, staff recommended denial of this application. However, should this application be approved, staff recommended the Commission add the conditions as noted in the staff report. The public hearing was opened and speaking in favor of this application was Robert Nickerson & Karrie Engler, property owners. There being no speakers in opposition, the public hearing was closed. After discussion by the Commission, Commissioner Goodman made a motion to approve this application with the conditions, seconded by Commissioner Bosselman and passed by a recorded vote of 5 to 2. 12 ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT, OTA2026-006, initiated by the City of Suffolk, for amendments to Sections 31-406(c), 31-407(c), 31-408(b), 31-602(a), 31- 602(b), 31-602(c), 31- 603(e), 31- 606(a), 31- 701(c), and 31- 724 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the Citty of Suffolk, Virginia. The next item of business was introduced by the Chairman followed by a staff report by Caitlin Aubut, Land Use Planning Manager. Ms. Aubut stated that this ordinance text amendment is proposed amendments to various sections of the UDO. 1) Manufactured Housing and Single -Family Design Standards – H.B. 655 mandates that localities must permit manufactured houses on individual lots within zoning districts where site -built single-family housing is allowed as a matter of right and cannot regulate manufactured homes—from a zoning perspective—differently than site-built single-family dwellings, so long as a manufactured home is sited on its own lot and converted to real property. This necessitates several changes to the UDO. One such change is proposed in §31- 406(c), Table 406-1, to allow manufactured homes within all zoning districts that permit single-family dwellings by-right. §31-408(b)(5) is proposed to be removed, since this section regulates manufactured homes specifically within the Agricultural (A) zoning district and is rendered essentially moot by the state code change. The special design standards for manufactured housing in §31-602(c)(4) are proposed to be removed in favor of uniform residential design standards. There are existing residential design standards in §31- 602(c)(b), and additional standards are proposed in this section to ensure construction method parity 13 between site-built, modular, and manufactured homes. By establishing uniform single- family residential design standards, the City can protect neighborhood character and ensure the construction of quality homes designed for longevity. To that end, §31- 602(c) is proposed to be updated so that all newly built single-family dwellings must adhere to the mandatory requirements. 2) Small-Lot Residential Zoning - H.B. 1212 requires that all localities within the Commonwealth with a population of 50,000 people or more must have a residential zoning district with a minimum lot size not exceeding 3,000 square feet and a minimum lot width not exceeding 30 feet. The new section allows a locality to adjust an existing zoning district to meet this requirement, and this option has been utilized to bring the UDO into compliance with §15.2-2286.2 of the Code of Virginia. Suffolk’s RU -12 zoning district currently has a minimum required lot area of 3,630 square feet and a minimum lot width of 50 feet, and thus serves as a logical candidate for minor adjustments to meet the requirements of H.B. 1212. Since the more intense zoning district RU -18 has a minimum lot width of 40 feet, this is also proposed to be reduced to 30 feet to be congruent. These changes are proposed in Table 407-1 within §31-407(c) of the UDO, which outlines the minimum dimensional requirements for lots within zoning districts. 3) Off-Street Parking - H.B. 888 require that localities must provide reduced parking requirements for single - family and multifamily housing developments that are located within a half-mile from 14 mass transit stations/facilities serving fixed routes (such as bus routes and rail routes). The bill specifically excludes proximity to on -demand transportation (such as paratransit and micro-transit), ferries, and school bus routes from the reduced parking requirement. To comply with this state code change, staff proposed two new footnotes to be added to the off -street parking requirements table within §31- 606(a)(7). 4) Battery Energy Storage Accessory to Solar Facilities - H.B. 891 requires all localities in the Commonwealth to permit battery energy storage as a by-right accessory use in conjunction with utility-scale solar energy facilities. On March 18, 2026, City Council adopted amendments to §31-701(c)(3) through Ordinance 26-O-029 to permit Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) in the M-2 zoning district solely as an accessory use to permitted manufacturing uses. This previous amendment to the UDO specifically excluded BESS in conjunction with any other uses, including solar energy facilities. To comply with the new statewide mandate, staff proposed an amendment to §31- 701(c) of the UDO to permit BESS as an accessory use in any zoning district where a solar energy facility has been approved via a Conditional Use Permit (CUP), provided the BESS storage capacity does not exceed 100% of the nameplate generatin g capacity of the associated solar facility. Please note that this proposed amendment only allows BESS as an accessory use to either a solar energy facility or to a permitted manufacturing use in the M-2 district, with the 18 MWh limitation still in effect for 15 the latter. 5) Utility-Scale Solar Facilities and New Statewide Mandates - A final component of this proposed text amendment is a small change to the supplemental regulations for solar energy facilities in §31-724, driven by the approval of H.B. 711. These bills, which amend §15.2- 2288.8(A) of the Code of Virginia, preserve City Council’s ability to approve solar projects on a discretionary basis via Conditional Use Permit, but require CUPs approved for solar facilities to comply with criteria that is supported by the policies within the Comprehensive Plan. Many of the current supplemental regulations in §31-714 of the UDO still comply with the new state law and adhere to the policies of the Comprehensive Plan. Therefore, staff propose d language to be added to two subsections; the “purpose” preamble in §31-724(a) of the supplemental regulations has been modified to note that the standards are derived from the polices set forth in the Comprehensive Plan and that the section does not intent to conflict with the provisions of the Code of Virginia, and a line within §31- 724(b) is proposed to be modified to note that solar facilities subject to state code provisions may be deemed to be substantially in accord with the Comprehensive Plan. In summary, the aforementioned changes to the UDO are proposed to comply with recent changes to the Code of Virginia and modify select standards in response to new statewide mandates imposed by the General Assembly. Therefore, staff recommended approval of this ordinance text amendment as noted in Exhibit B in staff report. 16 The public hearing was opened. There being no speakers in favor or in opposition, the public hearing was closed. After discussion by the Commission, Commissioner Goodman made a motion to approve this ordinance text amendment, seconded by Commissioner Baur and passed by a recorded vote of 6 to 1. STATUS UPDATE: Mr. Wyne reported on the results of the June 17th City Council meeting. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. MT: Goodman 2ND: Baur TO: Approve w/conditions MT: Edwards 2 ND: Goodman TO: Approve w/conditions MT: Thornton- Manuel 2ND: Edwards TO: Approve w/conditions MT: Goodman 2ND: Bosselman TO: Approve w/conditions VOTE: 6-1 VOTE: 7-0 VOTE: 7-0 VOTE: 5-2 CUP2026-09 CUP2026-016 CUP2026-017 CEX2026-02 PRESENT ABSENT YES NO YES NO YES NO YES NO Baur, Mary Ellen X X X X X Bosselman, David X X X X X Creekmore, Oliver X X X X X Edwards, Johnnie X X X X X Goodman, Gerald X X X X X Hicks, Anita X Powell, Thomas X X X X X Thornton-Manuel, Selena X X X X X PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING July 21, 2026 MT: Goodman 2ND: Baur TO: Approve MT: 2 ND: TO: MT: 2 ND: TO: MT: 2 ND: TO: VOTE: 6-1 VOTE: VOTE: VOTE: OTA2026-06 PRESENT ABSENT YES NO YES NO YES NO YES NO Baur, Mary Ellen X X Bosselman, David X X Creekmore, Oliver X X Edwards, Johnnie X X Goodman, Gerald X X Hicks, Anita X Powell, Thomas X X Thornton-Manuel, Selena X X PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING July 21, 2026 STAFF REPORT DESCRIPTION ORDINANCE TEXT AMENDMENT O TA2026-009: Presented for your consideration, attached please find proposed amendments to repeal Section 31-415, enact Section 31-415.1, and amend Appendix B -13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia. The purpose of the text amendment is to update and refine the Code of the City of Suffolk, Chapter 31, Unified Development Ordinance due to a change in circumstance. APPLICANT: The proposed ordinance text amendment has been initiated by the City of Suffolk. PUBLIC NOTICE: This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements set forth in Section 15.2- 2204 of the Code of Virginia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance. STAFF ANALYSIS ISSUE AND BACKGROUND The Chesapeake Bay and its tributaries constitute one of the most important and productive estuarine systems in the world, providing economic and social benefits to the citizens of the City of Suffolk and the Commonwealth of Virginia. The health of the Bay and its tributaries is vital to maintaining Suffolk’s economy, natural resources, and the welfare of its citizens. The waters of the Chesapeake Bay watershed have been degraded significantly by numerous sources of pollution, including nonpoint source pollution from land development. These waters are worthy of protection from further degradation. Certain lands adjacent to shorelines, and river and stream banks have an intrinsic water quality value due to the ecological and biological processes they perform. With proper management, they offer significant ecological benefits by providing water quality maintenance, wildlife habitat, and pollution control, as well as flood and shoreline erosion control. These lands, designated by the City of Suffolk as Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas (CBPA), shall be developed in such manner as to protect the quality of water in the Bay. The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Overlay District regulations were adopted to implement the requirements and stated purposes of The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act (Bay Act) (Va. Code §§ 62.1-44.15:67 - 62.1-44.15:79) and the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Designation and Management Regulations (Regulations) (9 VAC 25-830-10 et seq.) promulgated thereunder. The performance standards established by these regulations provide the means to minimize the potential for erosion and sedimentation, reduce land application of nutrients and toxins, and maximize rainwater infiltration. Indigenous ground cover, especially woody vegetation, is effective in holding soil in place and preventing site erosion. Existing riparian buffers and other vegetation filter stormwater runoff. By minimizing impervious cover, rainwater infiltration is enhanced, and stormwater runoff is reduced. Planning Commission August 18, 2026 OTA2026-009 Page 2 of 3 In 2020, the Virginia General Assembly passed regulations in Virginia Code § 62.1-44.15:72 that required the State Water Control Board to develop criteria enabling local governments to encourage and promote “coastal resilience and adaptation to sea-level rise and climate change” through their Bay Act programs by requiring a resiliency assessment be conducted to understand the impacts of climate change and sea level rise on any proposed land development within RPAs, based on the potential impacts. The General Assembly also passed requirements in Virginia Code § 62.1-44.15:72 that required the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) to develop criteria enabling local governments to encourage and promote the “preservation of mature trees or planting of trees as a water quality protection tool and as a means of providing other natural resource benefits” through their Bay Act program. These regulatory changes require that the local ordinance include definitions for mature trees, canopy, and understory trees; protection of mature trees during development; preservation of mature trees through trimming and pruning; removal of mature trees is limited to fewest trees feasible and consistent with the best available technical advice; require replacement for removal with trees in a number and location appropriate to site conditions and maximizing the buffer function of protecting water quality; and inclusion of native species in tree replanting is preferred. Staff is proposing amendments to repeal the current Chesapeake Bay regulations in Section 31-415 in their entirety to be replaced with the proposed Section 31-415.1 which follows the structure and requirements of the State Model Ordinance and includes the changes required by the changes in State Code, and also amendments to Appendix B-13. The proposed amendments are as follows: Section 31-415.1 • Add required definitions for Adaptation measure, Canopy tree, Mature tree, Nature- based solution, and Understory tree • Add requirements for protecting and preserving mature trees in the buffer areas • Add requirement to submit a resiliency assessment in accordance with Section 31- 415.1(i) during plan/project review • Add requirements that native species are preferred for plantings within the buffer areas and that trees are required as part of the mitigation • Revise requirements for replacement of trees and woody vegetation removed to be in accordance with State requirements. • Clarify that shoreline erosion control projects within the buffer areas must be consistent with the Wetlands ordinance and Virginia Marine Resource Commission (VMRC) guidelines • Add standards when the use of fill is proposed for adaptation measures • Specify requirements for the landscape plan including a mitigation plan required to be submitted with the plan of development for any development or redevelopment within the CBPA areas Planning Commission August 18, 2026 OTA2026-009 Page 3 of 3 • Provide an exemption from the CBPA requirements for living shorelines that receive approval from VRMC or the Wetlands Board • Clarify that appeals of determinations or decisions made by Planning Commission regarding CBPA areas shall be submitted by the aggrieved party by petition to the Circuit Court • Add a section enumerating penalties for violations of this section consistent with State Code Appendix B-13 • Add a section enumerating penalties for violations of this section • Remove outdated references to the Chesapeake Bay Local Assistance Department (CBLAD) • Add the requirement to submit a resiliency assessment, according to Section 31-415.1(i) • Remove references to submitting a stormwater management plan and an erosion and sediment control plan as these requirements are covered by other sections of City Code RECOMMENDATION In that regard, the proposed text amendment shown in the attached Exhibit B is presented for your favorable consideration with a staff recommendation for approval. Attachments • Proposed Ordinance • Exhibit A – Planning Commission Recommendation • Exhibit B – “Amendments to repeal Section 31-415, enact Section 31-415.1, and amend Appendix B-13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia” ORDINANCE NUMBER AN ORDINANCE TO REPEAL SECTION 31 -415, ENACT SECTION 31 -415.1, AND AMEND APPENDIX B -13 OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA; OTA2026-009 WHEREAS, the City of Suffolk, Virginia has initiated the aforementioned amendments to the Code of the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance for the purpose of updating and improving clarity and consistency due to a change in circumstances; and, WHEREAS, the specified amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance as shown in Exhibit “B” are in compliance with the 2045 Comprehensive Plan, as adopted; and, WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has made a recommendation as stated in Exhibit "A"; and, WHEREAS, the procedural requirements for the consideration of this request by the Planning Commission have been met. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, that: Section 1. Exhibit “B,” “ Amendments to repeal Section 31- 415, enact Section 31- 415.1, and amend Appendix B-13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia” which is attached hereto, is hereby incorporated as part of this ordinance; Section 2. Sections 31-415, Section 31- 415.1, and Appendix B-13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia are hereby amended to read as referenced in Exhibit “B”; and Section 3. All phrases, clauses, sentences, paragraphs, subsections, sections and chapters of the Code not amended hereby remain in full force and effect. This ordinance shall be effective upon passage and shall not be published. READ AND PASSED: TESTE: Erika S. Dawley, City Clerk Approved as to Form: _________________________________ William E. Hutchings, Jr., City Attorney Exhibit “A” RESOLUTION NO. 26-08-01 CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING COMMISSION A RESOLUTION TO PRESENT A REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL RELATING TO OTA2026-009 AN ORDINANCE TO REPEAL SECTION 31-415, ENACT SECTION 31-415.1, AND AMEND APPENDIX B-13 OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA. WHEREAS, the City of Suffolk, Virginia has initiated the aforementioned amendments to Chapter 31 of the Unified Development Ordinance for the purpose of updating and improving clarity and consistency due to a change in circumstances; and WHEREAS, the specified amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance as shown in Exhibit “B” are in compliance with the 2045 Comprehensive Plan, as adopted; and WHEREAS, the procedural requirements for the consideration of this request by the Planning Commission have been met. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, that: Section 1. Findings. The Suffolk Planning Commission finds that the proposed ordinance amendments are reasonable and warranted. Section 2. Recommendation to City Council. The Planning Commission recommends to the City Council of the City of Suffolk, Virginia that the proposed amendments be; _____a. Adopted as submitted without modification. _____b. Denied, and that Council not pass the proposed ordinance. _____c. Adopted with the modifications set forth on the attached listing of specific recommendations, and that Council adopt the proposed Ordinance with such modifications. READ AND ADOPTED: TESTE: “Exhibit B” “Amendments to repeal Section 31-415, enact Section 31-415.1, and amend Appendix B-13 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk, Virginia” SEC. 31-415. CHESAPEAKE BAY PRESERVATION OVERLAY DISTRICT (CB). (a) PURPOSE AND INTENT. (1) The purpose of this Section is to implement the requirements of Section 62.1-44.15:67 et seq. of the Code of Virginia (the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act). The intent of the Overlay District is to provide special regulatory protection for the land and water resources located within the designated Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area in the City of Suffolk. Land use development standards are established herein for the purpose of implementing the goals, objectives criteria and standards set forth in the City of Suffolk Chesapeake Bay Preservation Program. (2) The requirements of this Section supplement the City's land development codes, including existing zoning and subdivision Ordinances and regulations. It imposes specific regulations for development and other land use within the City of Suffolk Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area. In the event of inconsistency between the provisions of this Section and the provisions established in other applicable Ordinances, the more restrictive or stringent provisions shall apply. (3) This Ordinance from which this Section derives is enacted under the authority of Section 62.1-44.15:67 et seq. (the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act) and Section 15.2- 2283 of the Code of Virginia. This Section implements the City of Suffolk Chesapeake Bay Preservation Program. (b) AREAS OF APPLICABILITY. (1) The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Overlay District shall apply to all lands identified as CBPAs as specified on the Official Preservation Area District Maps and shall include RPA's and RMA's. The maps together with all explanatory matter thereon, are hereby adopted by reference and declared to be a part of this Section. (2) This Section shall only apply to the City of Suffolk Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area, hereafter referred to as the Preservation Area District. The preservation area district shall be delineated on official preservation area district maps. The maps show the general location of CBPAs and should be consulted by persons contemplating activities within the City prior to engaging in a regulated activity. If the boundaries of a CBPA include a portion of a lot, parcel or development project, the entire lot, parcel or development project shall comply with the requirements of the overlay district. However, the Director upon the submittal of an environmental site assessment prepared in accordance with Subsection (e) of this Section, may determine that the portion of property outside the CBPA is not subject to the provisions of this Section. (3) The Official Preservation Area District Maps are hereby declared to delineate the general location of CBPAs and specific locations of IDAs. Site specific boundaries of RPAs and RMAs shall be delineated by the applicant during the development review process subject to final approval by the Zoning Administrator. (4) The Planning Director when requested by an applicant wishing to construct a single- family residence or accessory structure may waive the requirement for an environmental site assessment and perform the delineation. (c) GENERAL PERFORMANCE CRITERIA. The following standards shall apply to all development activities in the Preservation Area District. (1) No more land shall be disturbed than is necessary to provide for the proposed use or development. Land disturbance shall be limited to the area necessary to provide for the desired use or development. In accordance with an approved development plan, the limits of land disturbance, including clearing or grading, shall be strictly defined by the construction footprint. These limits shall be clearly shown on submitted plans and physically marked on the development site. (2) Indigenous vegetation shall be preserved to the maximum extent practicable, consistent with the use or development proposed. When forests or developed woodlands exist on the site and proposed development requires the cutting or clearing of trees areas proposed for clearing shall be identified on the proposed development plan. These plans shall be submitted as part of the development review process. A grading permit will be required prior to any clearing or cutting associated with the proposed development. (3) All development exceeding a disturbed land area of 2,500 square feet shall be accomplished through a process of development review as stated in Subsection (e) of this Section. (4) All land disturbance activities exceeding an area of 2,500 square feet (including construction of single-family houses and installation of septic drain fields but otherwise as defined in Section 62.1-44.15:51 of the Code of Virginia) shall comply with the City of Suffolk Erosion and Sediment Control Regulations. (5) All necessary federal, state and other permits which regulate activities in wetlands shall be required to be submitted as part of the development review in Subsection (e) of this Section prior to authorization of grading and other site construction activities to begin. (6) On-site treatment systems not requiring a Virginia Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (VPDES) permit shall: A. Have pump- [out] accomplished for all such systems at least once every five years. 1. If deemed appropriate by the Health Department and subject to conditions the Health Department may set, owners of such systems, as an alternative to the mandatory pump-out have the option of having a plastic filter installed and maintained in the outflow pipe from the septic tank to filter solid material from the effluent while sustaining adequate flow to the drainfield to permit normal use of the septic system. Such a filter should satisfy standards established in the Sewage Handling and Disposal Regulations (12 VAC 5- 610 et seq.) administered by the Virginia Department of Health. 2. Furthermore, in lieu of requiring proof of septic tank pump-out every five years owners of on-site sewage treatment systems shall submit documentation to the City every five years, certified by an operator or on-site soil evaluator licensed or certified under Chapter 23(Section 54.1-2300 et seq.) of Title 54.1 of the Code of Virginia as amended, as being qualified to operate, maintain or design on-site sewage systems, that the septic system has been inspected, is functioning properly, and the tank does not need to have the effluent pumped out of it. B. For new construction, a reserve sewage disposal area with a capacity not less than that of the primary sewage disposal area shall be provided. Any lot or parcel recorded prior to October 1, 1989 is not subject to this requirement, if such lot or parcel is not sufficient in capacity to accommodate a reserve sewage disposal site, as determined by the City of Suffolk Health Department Building shall be prohibited on the area of all sewage disposal sites until the structure is served by public sewer or an on-site sewage treatment system which operates under a permit issued by the State Water Control Board. All sewage disposal site records shall be administered to provide adequate notice and enforcement. As an alternative to the 100% reserve sewage disposal site, owners of such system have the option of installing an alternating drainfield system meeting the following conditions: 1. Each of the two alternating drainfields in the system shall have, at a minimum, an area not less than 50% of the area that would otherwise be required if a single primary drainfield were constructed. 2. An area equaling 50% of the area that would otherwise be required for the primary drainfield site must be reserved for subsurface absorption system that utilize[s] a flow diversion device, in order to provide for future replacement or repair to meet the requirements for a sewage disposal system. Expansion of the primary system will require an expansion of this reserve area. 3. The two alternating drainfields shall be connected by a diversion valve, approved by the Health Department, located in the pipe between the septic (aerobic) tank and the distribution boxes. The diversion valve shall be used to alternate the direction of effluent flow to one drainfield or the other at a time. However, diversion valves shall not be used for the following types of treatment systems: a. Sand mounds; b. Low-pressure distribution systems; c. Repair situations when installation of a valve is not feasible; and d. Any other approved system for which the use of a valve would adversely affect the design of the system, as determined by the Health Department. 4. The diversion valve shall be a three-port, two-way valve of approved materials (i.e., resistant to sewage and leakproof and designed so that the effluent from the tank can be directed to flow into either one of the two distribution boxes). 5. There shall be a conduit from the top of the valve to the ground surface with an appropriate cover to be level with or above the ground surface. 6. The valve shall not be located in driveways, recreational courts, parking lots, or beneath sheds or other structures. 7. In lieu of the aforementioned diversion valve, any device that can be designed and constructed to conveniently direct the flow of effluent from the tank into either one of the two distribution boxes may be approved if plans are submitted to the Health Department and found to be satisfactory. 8. The owner(s) shall alternate the drainfields every 12 months to permit the yearly resting of half of the absorption system. 9. The City shall ensure that the owner(s) are notified annually of the requirement to switch the valve to the opposite drainfield. C. For development proposals, a reserve sewage disposal area with a capacity not less than that of the primary sewage disposal area shall be provided. Any lot or parcel recorded prior to October 1, 1989 is not subject to this requirement, if such lot or parcel is not sufficient in capacity to accommodate a reserve sewage disposal site, as determined by the City of Suffolk Health Department. (7) Development and redevelopment shall meet all requirements of the Virginia Stormwater Regulations and all City policies that are appropriate to site development. (8) All development and redevelopment projects shall delineate those site areas not covered by impervious surfaces to be maintained or established in vegetation. Where vegetation is not proposed the developer shall demonstrate why planting for such portions of the site are impracticable types of planting and vegetation proposed shall be in accordance with the standards of the most recent edition of the American Nursery and Landscape Association ("ANLA") (formerly the American Association of Nurserymen), The American Standard For Nursery Stock, (1996), which document is hereby incorporated by reference as if set forth in its entirety herein. Said document may be obtained by contacting ANLA at 1250 1 Street NW, Suite 500, Washington, D.C. 20005 (202/789-2900). (9) Land upon which agricultural activities are being conducted, including but not limited to crop production, pasture and dairy and feedlot operations, shall have a soil and water quality conservation assessment conducted that evaluates the effectiveness of existing practices pertaining to soil erosion and sediment control, nutrient management, and management of pesticides and, where necessary, results in a plan that outlines additional practices needed to ensure that water quality protection is being accomplished consistent with the Act and this chapter. A. For erosion and sediment control recommendations the goal shall be, where feasible, to prevent erosion from exceeding the soil loss tolerance level referred to as "T," as defined in the "National Soil Survey Handbook" of November 1996 in the "Field Office Technical Guide" of the U. S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service. However, in no case shall erosion exceed the soil loss consistent with an alternative conservation system, referred to as an "ACS", as defined in the "Field Office Technical Guide" of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service. B. For nutrient management, whenever nutrient management plans are developed, the operator or landowner must provide soil test information, consistent with the Virginia Nutrient Management Training and Certification Regulations (4 VAC 5- 15-10 et seq.). C. For pest chemical control, referrals shall be made to the local cooperative extension agent or an integrated pest management specialist of the Virginia Cooperative Extension Service, Recommendations shall include copies of applicable information from the "Virginia Pest Management Guide" or other extension materials related to pest control. D. A higher priority shall be placed on conducting assessments of agricultural fields and tracts adjacent to Resource Protection Areas, However, if the landowner or operator of such a tract also has Resource Management Area fields or tracts in his operation, the assessment for that landowner or operator may be conducted for all fields or tracts in the operation. When such an expanded assessment is completed, priority must return to Resource Protection Area fields and tracts. E. The findings and recommendations of such assessments and any resulting soil and water quality conservation plans will be submitted to the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District Board, which will be the plan-approving authority. (10) Silvicultural activities in Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas are exempt from these regulations provided that silviculture operations adhere to water quality protection procedures prescribed by the Department of Forestry in its "Best Management Practices Handbook for Forestry Operations." The Department of Forestry will oversee and document installation of best management practices and will monitor the in-stream impacts of forestry operations in Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas. (d) DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA FOR RESOURCE PROTECTION AREAS. (1) PRESERVATION AREAS. The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area shall consist of three areas for purposes of determining applicable development restrictions: (1) a Resource Protection Area and (2) a Resource Management Area. Intensely Developed Areas may be a component of each area. These areas are defined and established as follows: A. RESOURCE PROTECTION AREA (RPA). (i) Resource Protection Areas shall consists of lands adjacent to water bodies with perennial flow that have an intrinsic water quality value due to the ecological and biological processes they perform or are sensitive to impacts which may cause significant degradation to the quality of state waters. In their natural condition, these lands provide for the removal, reduction or assimilation of sediments nutrients and potentially harmful or toxic substances in runoff entering the bay and its tributaries, and minimize the adverse effects of human activities on state waters and aquatic resources. 1. Components: (a) Tidal wetlands; (b) Nontidal wetlands connected by surface flow and contiguous to tidal wetlands or water bodies with perennial flow; (c) Tidal shores; (d) Drinking water reservoirs from the water's edge; (e) A vegetated buffer area not less than 100 feet in width located adjacent to and landward of the components listed in Subsections (a) through (d) above, and along both sides of any water body with perennial flow. (ii) Development criteria include the following: (a) Land development may be allowed in the Resource Protection Area only if it (i) is water dependent; (ii) constitutes redevelopment; (iii) constitutes development or redevelopment within a designated intensely developed area; (iv) is a new use established pursuant to this Section; (v) is a road or driveway crossing satisfying the conditions set forth in this Section; (vi) is a flood control or stormwater management facility satisfying the conditions set forth in this Section; or (vii) fences that meet the minimum requirements of this section. 1. A water quality impact assessment in accordance with Appendix B shall be required for any proposed land disturbance. 2. A new or expanded water-dependent facility may be allowed provided that the following criteria are met: (a) It does not conflict with the Comprehensive Plan; (b) It complies with the performance criteria set forth in this Ordinance; (c) Any nonwater-dependent component is located outside of Resource Protection Areas; and (d) Access to the water-dependent facility will be provided with the minimum disturbance necessary. Where practicable, a single point of access will be provided. 3. Redevelopment outside locally designated Intensely Developed Areas shall be permitted in the Resource Protection Area only if there is no increase in the amount of impervious cover and no further encroachment within the Resource Protection Area, and it shall conform to applicable erosion and sediment control and stormwater management criteria set forth in this Section as well as all applicable stormwater management requirements of other state and federal agencies. 4. Roads and driveways not exempt under this Section and which, therefore, must comply with the provisions of this chapter, may be constructed in or across Resource Protection Areas if each of the following conditions is met: (a) No reasonable alternatives exists to aligning the road or driveway in or across the Resource Protection Area; (b) The alignment and design of the road are optimized, consistent with other applicable requirements, to minimize (i) encroachment in the Resource Protection Area and (ii) adverse effects on water quality; (c) The design and construction of the road or driveway satisfy all applicable criteria of this chapter, including submission of a water quality impact assessment; and (d) The road or driveway proposed in or across the Resource Protection Area receives site plan, subdivision or plan or development approvals. 5. Flood control and stormwater management facilities that drain or treat water from multiple development projects or from a significant portion of a watershed may be allowed in Resource Protection Areas, provided that (i) the City has conclusively established that location of the facility within the Resource Protection Area is the optimum location; (ii) the size of the facility is the minimum necessary to provide necessary flood control, stormwater treatment, or both; (iii) the facility must be consistent with a stormwater management program that has been approved by the Chesapeake Bay Local Assistance Board; (iv) all applicable permits for construction in state or federal waters must be obtained from the appropriate state and federal agencies, such as the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality and the Virginia Marine Resources Commission; (v) approval must be received from the City prior to construction; and (vi) routine maintenance is allowed to be performed on such facilities to assure that they continue to function as designed. It is not the intent of this subdivision to allow a best management practice that collects and treats runoff from only an individual lot or some portion of the lot to be located within a Resource Protection Area. 6. Fences located within the Resource Protection Area may be reviewed administratively without an exception request, provided that the following design requirements which collectively maintain the functional value of the buffer are met: (a) Fences should be designed so that they do not inhibit or alter surface flow. Water must be able to flow under and through the fence unimpeded. (b) Fences should be located to avoid the removal of the vegetation. (c) Any disturbance associated with the installation of the fence shall be mitigated. A Minor Water Quality Impact Assessment shall be submitted in accordance with the requirements outlined in Appendix B-13(b) of this Ordinance. (b) All sites for which development activities are proposed shall be subject to the requirements detailed in Section 31-415(c) general provisions. B. RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AREA (RMA). The Resource Management Area (RMA) is that component of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area that is not classified as the Resource Protection Area and may include flood plains, highly erodible soils associated with steep slopes, highly permeable soils, nontidal wetlands outside of the RPA and other lands necessary to protect water quality. Development standards for the RMA are set forth as follows: (i) All sites for which development activities are proposed shall be subject to the requirements detailed in Subsection (c), general provisions. (ii) When forests or developed woodlands exist on the site and proposed development requires the cutting or clearing of trees, areas proposed for clearing shall be identified on the proposed development plan. These plans shall be submitted as part of the development review process. A grading permit will be required prior to any clearing or cutting associated with proposed development. (iii) Land disturbance shall be limited to the area necessary to provide for the desired use or development. (iv) In accordance with an approved development plan, the limits of land disturbance, including clearing or grading, shall be strictly defined by the construction footprint. These limits shall be clearly shown on submitted plans and physically marked on the development site. (v) Ingress and egress during construction shall be limited to one access point unless otherwise approved by the Planning Director. (vi) Indigenous vegetation shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible consistent with the use and development permitted. (vii) Land development shall minimize impervious cover consistent with the use or development permitted. C. INTENSELY DEVELOPED AREAS (IDA). Intensely Developed Areas (IDA) are those areas designated by the City of Suffolk as an overlay of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas within the City's jurisdiction. IDA's shall serve as redevelopment areas in which development is concentrated as of the local program adoption date and where little of the natural environment remains and provided that one of the following conditions exists: (i) development has severely altered the natural state of the area such that it has more than 50 percent impervious cover; (ii) public sewer and water is constructed and currently serves the area as of September 1990 and this condition does not include areas planned for public sewer and water; or (iii) housing density is equal to or greater than four dwelling units per acre. Development standards for the IDA are the same as the standards of the RMA or RPA and consistent with this Section. D. BUFFER AREA REQUIREMENTS. To minimize effects of human activities on the other components of the Resource Protection Area, state waters, and aquatic life, a 100-foot buffer area of vegetation that is effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering non-point source pollution from runoff shall be retained if present and established where it does not exist. The buffer shall be located adjacent to and landward of any other component of the RPA. The 100-foot buffer area shall be deemed to achieve a 75 percent reduction of sediments and a 40 percent reduction of nutrients. Not withstanding permitted uses, encroachments, and vegetation clearing, as set forth in Subsection (d)(1)a., the 100-foot wide buffer area is not reduced in width. When agricultural or silvicultural uses within the buffer area cease, and the lands are proposed to be converted to other uses, the full 100-foot wide buffer area shall be reestablished In reestablishing the buffer, management measures shall be undertaken to provide woody vegetation that assures the buffer functions are maintained or established. The following additional performance criteria shall apply in the buffer area: Source: Hampton Roads Planning District Commission, Vegetative Best Practice Guide for Nonpoint Source Pollution Management (Dec. 1992), at 100. (i) In order to maintain the functional value of the buffer area, indigenous vegetation may be removed only, subject to approval by the City, to provide for reasonable sight lines, access paths, general woodlot management, and best management practices including those that prevent upland erosion and concentrated flows of stormwater as follows: (a) Trees may be pruned or removed as necessary to provide for sight lines and vistas, provided that where removed, they shall be replaced with other vegetation that is equally effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering non-point source pollution from runoff. (b) Any path shall be constructed and surfaced so as to effectively control erosion. (c) Dead, diseased, or dying trees or shrubbery and noxious weeds (such as Johnson grass, Kudzu and multiflora rose) may be removed and thinning of trees allowed as permitted by the City pursuant to sound horticultural practices. (d) For shoreline erosion control projects, trees and woody vegetation may be removed, necessary control techniques employed, and appropriate vegetation established to protect or stabilize the shoreline in accordance with the best available technical advice and applicable permit conditions or requirements. (ii) When the application of the buffer area would result in the loss of buildable area on a lot or parcel recorded prior to October 1, 1989, encroachments into the buffer area may be allowed through an administrative process without the need of an exception pursuant to Section 31-415(f)5(), in accordance with the following criteria: (a) Encroachments to the buffer area shall be the minimum necessary to achieve a reasonable buildable area for a principal structure and necessary utilities; (b) Where practicable, a vegetated area that will maximize water quality protection, mitigate the effects of the buffer encroachment, and is equal to the area of encroachment into the buffer area shall be established elsewhere on the lot or parcel; (c) The encroachment may not extend into the seaward 50 feet of the buffer area. (iii) When the application of the buffer area would result in the loss of a buildable area on a lot or parcel recorded between October 1, 1989 and March 1, 2002, encroachments into the buffer area may be allowed through an administrative process without the need of an exception pursuant to Section 31-415(f)(5), in accordance with the encroachment requirements of this Section and the following criteria: (a) The lot or parcel was created as a result of a legal process conducted in conformity with the subdivision regulations; (b) Conditions or mitigation measures imposed through a previously approved exception shall be met; (c) If the use of a best management practice (BMP) shall be evaluated to determine if it continues to function effectively and, if necessary, the BMP shall be reestablished or repaired and maintained as required; and (d) The criteria in Subsection 31-415(d)(1)D.(ii) of this Section shall be met. (iv) On agricultural lands the agricultural buffer area shall be managed to prevent concentrated flows of surface water from breaching the buffer area and noxious weeds (such as Johnson grass, kudzu, and multiflora rose) from invading the buffer area. (a) If specific problems are identified pertaining to agricultural activities which are causing pollution of the nearby water body with perennial flow or violate performance standards pertaining to the vegetated buffer area the City, in cooperation with the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District, shall recommend a compliance schedule to the landowner and require the problems to be corrected consistent with that schedule. This schedule shall expedite environmental protection while taking into account the seasons and other temporal considerations so that the probability for successfully implementing the corrective measures is greatest. (b) In cases where the landowner of his agent or operator has refused assistance from the Peanut and Water Conservation District in complying with or documenting compliance with the agricultural requirements of this chapter, the district shall report the noncompliance to the local government. The landowner shall be required to correct the problems within a specified period of time not to exceed 18 months from their initial notification of the deficiencies to the landowner. The City, in cooperation with district, shall recommend a compliance schedule to the landowner. This schedule shall expedite environmental protection while taking into account the seasons and other temporal considerations so that the probability for successfully implementing the corrective measures is greatest. (v) In addition to the standards set forth above, development within the IDA shall comply with the following: (a) Development within Intensely Developed Areas shall maintain, to the maximum extent possible, a natural vegetated buffer adjacent to the a water body with perennial flow and utilize appropriate best management practices landward of the buffer. No removal of natural vegetation shall be permitted in the buffer, except for permitted water-dependent facilities or except as provided for under the buffer standards, above. (b) All development and redevelopment projects shall delineate those site areas not covered by impervious surfaces to be maintained or established in vegetation. Where vegetation is not proposed the developer shall demonstrate why planting for such portions of the site are impracticable. Types of planting and vegetation proposed shall be in accordance with the standards of the most recent edition of the "American Standard for Nursery Stock" published by the American Association of Nurserymen. This information shall he submitted during development review or as part of an Erosion and Sediment Control Plan as specified in Appendix B. (vi) Buffer area exemption for IDA. An application for development approval within the IDA may be exempt if a request for an exception is made as part of the development review as described in Subsection (f)(4) of this Section. If the immediate establishment of the buffer area within IDA's is impractical, measures that establish the buffer in these areas over time in order to maximize water quality protection, pollutant removal, and water resource conservation will be required. Such measures shall be included in a buffer management plan, except if a request for an exception is made as part of the development review as described in Subsection (f)(4) of this Section. (e) DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCESS. All development not otherwise exempted by the provisions of this Section must be approved through a process of development review In addition to the requirements of Section 31-307 of this Ordinance and the requirements of Article 5 (the Subdivision Ordinance) of the City of Suffolk, the development review process shall consist of the plans and studies identified as follows: (1) A site plan prepared in accordance with the requirements of Section 31-307 of this Ordinance; or a subdivision plat prepared in accordance with the requirements of Article 5 of this Ordinance. (2) An environmental site assessment consistent with Appendix B, Section B-13. (3) A stormwater management plan consistent with Appendix B, Section B-12. (4) A soil erosion and sedimentation control plan consistent with Section 31-610. (5) Installation and bonding requirements. A. Where buffer areas, landscaping, stormwater management facilities or other specifications of an approved plan are required, no Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued until the installation of required plan materials and/or facilities is completed, in accordance with the approved site plan. B. When the occupancy of a structure is desired prior to the completion of the required landscaping, stormwater management facilities, or other specifications of an approved plan, a Certificate of Occupancy may be issued only if the applicant provides to the City a form of surety satisfactory to the City in an amount equal to the cost associated with completing the required landscaping or stormwater management facilities and/or maintenance costs for any required stormwater management facilities during the construction period. C. After all required actions of the approved site plan have been completed, the applicant must submit a written request to the City of Suffolk for a final inspection. If the requirements of the approved plan have been completed to the satisfaction of the City such unexpended or unobligated portion of the surety held shall be refunded to the applicant or terminated within 60 days following the receipt of the applicant's written request for final inspection. (f) ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES. (1) WATER QUALITY ASSESSMENT. A water quality assessment shall be prepared in accordance with Appendix B, Section B-13 for any proposed development within the RPA, and shall be reviewed as follows: A. Upon the completed review of a Minor Water Quality Impact Assessment, the Director shall determine if any proposed modification or reduction to the buffer area is consistent with the provisions of this Section and make a finding based upon the following criteria: (i) The necessity of proposed encroachment and the ability to place improvements elsewhere on the site to avoid disturbance of the buffer area; (ii) Impervious surface is minimized; (iii) Proposed best management practices, where required, achieve the requisite reductions in pollutant loadings; (iv) The development, as proposed, meets the purpose and intent of this Section; (v) The cumulative impact of the proposed development, when considered in relation to other development in the vicinity, both existing and proposed, will not result in a significant degradation of water quality. B. Upon the completed review of a major water quality impact assessment, the Director will determine if the proposed development is consistent with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance and make a finding based upon the following criteria in conjunction with Subsection (e) of this Section. (i) Within the RPA, the proposed development is water-dependent; (ii) The disturbance of wetlands will be minimized; (iii) The development will not result in significant disruption of the hydrology of the site; (iv) The development will not result in significant degradation to aquatic vegetation or life; (v) The development will not result in unnecessary destruction of plant materials on site; (vi) Proposed erosion and sediment control concepts are adequate to achieve the reductions in runoff and prevent off-site sedimentation; (vii) Proposed stormwater management concepts are adequate to control the stormwater runoff to achieve the required standard for pollutant control; (viii) Proposed revegetation of disturbed areas will provide optimum erosion and sediment control benefits; (ix) The design and location of any proposed drainfield will be in accordance with the requirements of Subsection (c), above. (x) The development, as proposed, is consistent with the purpose and intent of the preservation area district; (xi) The cumulative impact of the proposed development, when considered in relation to other development in the vicinity, both existing and proposed, will not result in a significant degradation of water quality. (2) NONCONFORMING USE AND NONCOMPLYING STRUCTURES. A. An application for the expansion of a nonconforming principal structure may be approved by the Planning Director through an administrative review process provided that the following findings are made: (i) The request for the waiver is the minimum necessary to afford relief; (ii) Granting the waiver will not confer upon the applicant any specific privileges that are denied by this Ordinance to other property owners in similar situations; (iii) The waiver is in harmony with the purpose and intent of this Section and does not result in water quality degradation; (iv) The waiver is not based on conditions or circumstances that are self- created or self-imposed; (v) Reasonable and appropriate conditions are imposed, as warranted, that will prevent the waiver from causing a degradation of water quality; (vi) Other findings, as appropriate and required by City are met; and (vii) In no case shall this provision apply to accessory structures. (3) PUBLIC UTILITIES, RAILROADS AND FACILITIES EXEMPTIONS. A. Construction, installation, operation, and maintenance of electric, fiber-optic, natural gas, and telephone transmission lines, railroads, and public roads and their appurtenant structures in accordance with the City's Erosion and Sedimentation Control and Stormwater Management Ordinance requirements will be deemed to constitute compliance with these regulations. (i) Any exemption of public roads is further conditioned on the following: The road alignment and design has been optimized, consistent with all applicable requirements, to prevent or otherwise minimize the encroachment in the Resource Protection Area and to minimize the adverse effects on water quality. B. Construction, installation, operation, and maintenance of water, sewer and natural gas underground telecommunications and cable television lines owned, permitted or both, by the City or regional service authority will be exempt from the criteria of this Overlay District that: (i) To the degree possible, the location of such utilities and facilities should be outside Resource Protection Areas. (ii) No more land will be disturbed than is necessary to provide for the proposed utility installation. (iii) All such construction, installation, and maintenance of such utilities and facilities will be in compliance with all applicable state and federal permits and designed and conducted in a manner that protects water quality. (iv) Any land disturbance exceeding an area of 2,500 square feet complies with all erosion and sedimentation control requirements of the City of Suffolk. (4) EXEMPTIONS IN RESOURCE PROTECTION AREAS. A. The following land disturbance activities in Resource Protection Areas may be exempt from the criteria of this part provided that they comply with items B. and C. below: (i) water wells; (ii) passive recreation facilities such as boardwalks, trails, and pathways; and (iii) historic preservation and archaeological activities. B. Any such land disturbance must be approved by the City of Suffolk. A plan indicating the area to be disturbed shall be submitted for approval as of the development review process, Subsection (e) of this Section. C. Any land disturbance exceeding an area of 2,500 square feet shall comply with the erosion and sediment control requirements of the City of Suffolk. (5) EXCEPTIONS. A. A request for an exception to the requirements of the (Development Criteria for Resource Protection Areas) and (Buffer Area Requirements) of this Article shall be made in writing to the Planning Commission. It shall identify the impacts of the proposed exception on water quality and on lands within the Resource Protection Area through the performance of a water quality impact assessment which complies with the provisions of Appendix B-13(a) (Water Quality Impact Assessment). B. The City of Suffolk shall notify the affected public of any such exception requests and shall consider these requests in a public hearing in accordance with Section 15.2-2204 of the Code of Virginia, except that only one hearing shall be required. C. The Planning Commission shall review the request for an exception and the water quality impact assessment and may grant the exception with such conditions and safeguards as deemed necessary to further the purpose and intent of this Article if the Planning Commission finds: (i) Granting the exception will not confer upon the applicant any special privileges denied by this Article to other property owners in the Overlay District; (ii) The exception request is not based on conditions or circumstances that are self-created or self-imposed, nor does the request arise from conditions or circumstances either permitted or non-conforming that are related to adjacent parcels; (iii) The exception request is the minimum necessary to afford relief; (iv) The exception request will be in harmony with the purpose and intent of the Overlay District; not injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare, and is not of substantial detriment to water quality; and (v) Reasonable and appropriate conditions are imposed which will prevent the exception request from causing a degradation of water quality. D. If the Planning Commission cannot make the required findings or refuses to grant the exception, the Planning Commission shall return the request for an exception together with the water quality impact assessment and the written findings and rationale for the decision to the applicant. E. An applicant may appeal the decision of the Planning Commission, in refusing to grant an exception, to the City Council. An appeal must be filed within 30 days from the time a decision is rendered by the Planning Commission and give public notice thereof as required by this Ordinance and decide the same within 60 days. In exercising its powers, the City Council may, in conformity with the provisions of this Ordinance, reverse, or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify any order, requirement, decision or determination appealed from and make such order, requirement, decision or determination as ought to be made and, to that end, shall have all the powers of the Planning Commission. The City Council shall consult with the Planning Commission in relation to any appeal and may require documentation of any Planning Commission decision prior to hearing the appeal. The City Council may affirm, reverse or modify the Planning Commission's decision and shall notify the Planning Commission of its actions. F. A request to an exception to the requirements of provisions of this Article other than the (Development Criteria for Resource Protection Areas) and (Buffer Area Requirements) shall be made in writing to the Planning Director. The Planning Director may grant these exceptions provided that: (i) Exceptions to the requirements are the minimum necessary to afford relief; and (ii) Reasonable and appropriate conditions are placed upon any exception that is granted, as necessary, so that the purposed and intent of this Section is preserved. (iii) Exceptions to Section (c) (General Performance Criteria) may be made provided that the findings noted in Section (f)(5)c. above are made. (iv) If the Planning Director cannot make the required findings or refuses to grant the exception, the Director shall return the request for an exception together with the water quality impact assessment and the written findings and rationale for the decision to the applicant. Within 30 days from the date of denial, the applicant may apply to the Planning Commission for an exception. G. No exception shall be authorized by the Planning Commission except after notice and a hearing, as required by Section 15.2-2204 of the Code of Virginia, except that only one hearing shall be required. H. An applicant may appeal the decision of the Planning Commission, in refusing to grant an exception, to the City Council. An appeal must be filed within 30 days from the time a decision is rendered by the Planning Commission and give public notice thereof as required by this Ordinance and decide the same within sixty (60) days. In exercising its powers, the City Council may, in conformity with the provisions of this Ordinance, reverse, or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify any order, requirement, decision or determination appealed from and make such order, requirement, decision or determination as ought to be made and, to that end, shall have all the powers of the Planning Commission. The City Council shall consult with the Planning Commission in relation to any appeal and may require documentation of any Planning Commission decision prior to hearing the appeal. The City Council may affirm, reverse or modify the Planning Commission's decision and shall notify the Planning Commission of its actions. SEC. 31-415.1. CHESAPEAKE BAY PRESERVATION OVERLAY DISTRICT (CB). This ordinance shall be known as the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance (Ordinance) of the City of Suffolk, Virginia. (a) FINDINGS OF FACT. The Chesapeake Bay and its tributaries constitute one of the most important and productive estuarine systems in the world, providing economic and social benefits to the citizens of the City of Suffolk and the Commonwealth of Virginia. The health of the Bay and its tributaries is vital to maintaining Suffolk’s economy, natural resources, and the welfare of its citizens. The waters of the Chesapeake Bay watershed have been degraded significantly by numerous sources of pollution, including nonpoint source pollution from land development. These waters are worthy of protection from further degradation. Certain lands adjacent to shorelines, and river and stream banks have an intrinsic water quality value due to the ecological and biological processes they perform. With proper management, they offer significant ecological benefits by providing water quality maintenance, wildlife habitat, and pollution control, as well as flood and shoreline erosion control. These lands, designated by the City of Suffolk as Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas (CBPA), shall be developed in such manner as to protect the quality of water in the Bay. (b) PURPOSE AND INTENT. (1) This Ordinance is adopted to implement the requirements and stated purposes of The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act (Bay Act) (Va. Code §§ 62.1-44.15:67 - 62.1- 44.15:79) and the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Designation and Management Regulations (Regulations) (9 VAC 25-830-10 et seq.) promulgated thereunder. The intent of the Suffolk City Council and the purpose of this Ordinance are to: (1) protect existing high quality state waters; (2) prevent any further increase in water pollution; and (3) restore state waters to a condition or quality that will permit all reasonable public uses and will support the propagation and growth of all aquatic life, including game fish, which might reasonably be expected to inhabit them. The performance standards established by this Ordinance provide the means to minimize the potential for erosion and sedimentation, reduce land application of nutrients and toxins, and maximize rainwater infiltration. Indigenous ground cover, especially woody vegetation, is effective in holding soil in place and preventing site erosion. Existing riparian buffers and other vegetation filter stormwater runoff. By minimizing impervious cover, rainwater infiltration is enhanced, and stormwater runoff is reduced. (2) The designation of any area as a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area shall be in addition to, and not in lieu of, the zoning district classification of these areas, and shall be subject to all applicable provisions of this Ordinance, the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance, Subdivision Ordinance, Erosion and Stormwater Management Ordinance, and other applicable ordinances. (c) DEFINITIONS. The following words and terms used in this Ordinance shall have the following meanings unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. Accessory structures or uses. Any structure located on a lot or parcel not identified as a principal structure as defined herein. Accessory structures include, but are not limited to, detached garages, gazebos, free-standing decks, storage buildings or tool sheds, guest houses, and similar forms of development that are incidental and subordinate to the principal structure. Accessory uses include, but are not limited to, in-ground pools, patios, terraces, tennis courts, synthetic turf, and other impermeable landings that do not permit infiltration to groundwater. Any modification or expansion to an accessory use must be reviewed and approved using a formal exception process unless proposed within a locally designated Intensely Developed Area. Adaptation measure. A project, practice, or approach to mitigate or address an impact of climate change including sea-level rise, storm surge, and flooding including increased or recurrent flooding. Agricultural lands. Those lands used for the planting and harvesting of crops or plant growth of any kind in the open, pasture, horticulture, dairy farming, floriculture, or the raising of poultry and/or livestock. Applicant. Any person submitting any application required or permitted pursuant to any of the provisions of this Ordinance, and any person on whose behalf such an application is submitted. Best management practice. A practice, or a combination of practices, determined by a state or designated area-wide planning agency to be the most effective practicable means of preventing or reducing the amount of pollution generated by nonpoint sources to a level compatible with water quality goals. Best management practice, structural. A best management practice that requires the design and certification of a licensed design professional. Board. The City of Suffolk Planning Commission shall be designated as the City of Suffolk Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Board. Buffer area. An area of natural or established vegetation managed to protect other components of the Resource Protection Area listed under Section 31-415.1(d)(2)(A)-(D) of this Ordinance from significant degradation due to land disturbance. Caliper. The diameter of a tree measured six (6) inches above existing grade. Canopy tree. A tree that typically reaches 35 feet in height or taller when mature. Channelward: In the direction of the channel or waterway. Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area (CBPA). Any land designated as such on the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Map adopted by the Suffolk City Council, subject to confirmation by the City of Suffolk Administrator on a site-specific basis pursuant to 9 VAC 25-830-110 of the Regulations and § 62.1-44.15:74 of the Bay Act. A Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area shall consist of a Resource Protection Area and a Resource Management Area. City of Suffolk Administrator. The Director of Planning and Community Development or such other person or persons as they may designate to perform the duties, or to exercise the authority, of the City of Suffolk Administrator pursuant to the provisions of this Ordinance. Construction footprint. The area of all impervious cover created by development or redevelopment of land, including, but not limited to, buildings, roads, driveways, parking areas and sidewalks, and any other land disturbed for the construction of such improvements. Critical root zone. The area encompassing all of the roots extending to the dripline of a tree. Daylighted stream. A stream that had been previously diverted into an underground drainage system, has been redirected into an above ground channel using natural channel design concepts as defined in Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:51, and where the adjacent lands would meet the criteria for being designated as a Resource Protection Area (RPA) as defined within this Ordinance. Development. The construction, substantial alteration, or installation of any improvement (including residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, recreation, transportation, or utility facilities or structures) upon a parcel of land, or any land disturbance associated therewith. Diameter at breast height (DBH). The diameter of a tree measured at a point four and one- half (4 1/2) feet above the existing grade, or the natural surface or contour of a site. Dripline. An imaginary perpendicular line extending downward from the outermost tips of the branches of a tree to the ground. Fill. Material such as sand, soil, gravel, or crushed stone which is placed in an area, often to adjust elevation or create land contouring. Floodplain. All lands that would be inundated by flood water because of a storm event of a 100-year return interval (1% annual chance of occurring). This includes any land area susceptible to being inundated by floodwaters from any source. Freeboard. An additional amount of height above the Base Flood Elevation used as a factor of safety (e.g., 2 feet above the Base Flood) in determining the level at which a structure's lowest floor must be elevated or floodproofed to be in accordance with state or community floodplain management regulations. Highly erodible soils. Those soils (excluding vegetation) with an erodibility index (EI) from sheet and rill erosion equal to or greater than eight (8). The erodibility index for any soil is defined as the product of the formula RKLS/T, where K is the soil susceptibility to water erosion in the surface layer; R is the rainfall and runoff; LS is the combined effects of slope length and steepness; and T is the soil loss tolerance. Highly permeable soils. Soils with a potential to transmit water through the soil profile. Highly permeable soils are identified as any soil having a permeability equal to or greater than six inches of water movement per hour in any part of the soil profile to a depth of 72 inches (permeability groups “rapid” and “very rapid”) as found in the National Soil Survey Handbook of November 1996 in the Field Office Technical Guide of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service. Impervious cover. A surface composed of any material which significantly impedes or prevents natural infiltration of water into the soil, including, but not limited to, roofs, buildings, streets, parking areas, and other structures and the components thereof, concrete, asphalt, or compacted gravel surface. Infill. Utilization of vacant land in previously developed areas. Intensely Developed Areas (IDA). Those designated by the City of Suffolk pursuant to to 9 VAC 25-830-100. IDAs are redevelopment areas where development is concentrated and little of the natural environment remained as of October 1, 1989, and which is so designated on the map of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas adopted by the Suffolk City Council pursuant to Section 31-415.1(d)(4) of this Ordinance. IDAs shall comply with the performance criteria for redevelopment. Land disturbance or land disturbing activity. Any man-made change to the land surface that may result in soil erosion or has the potential to change its runoff characteristics, including construction activity such as the clearing, grading, excavating, transporting, and filling of land. Limit of Moderate Wave Action (LiMWA). The LiMWA is an informational line that can be found on flood maps for some coastal areas. On a flood map, it is shown as a black line with black arrows that point to areas where wave heights are between one and one-half (1.5) and three (3) feet. It also marks the inland limit of the Coastal Zone A. Living Shoreline. A shoreline management practice that: provides erosion control and water quality benefits; protects, restores, or enhances natural shoreline habitat; and maintains coastal processes through the strategic placement of plants, stone, sand fill, and other structural and organic materials. When practicable, a living shoreline may enhance coastal resilience and attenuation of wave energy and storm surge. Pursuant to Va. Code § 28.2- 104.1, living shorelines are recognized as the preferred alternative for stabilizing shorelines in the Commonwealth. Only living shorelines shall be permitted for shoreline management unless the best available science shows that such approaches are not suitable. Mature tree. A canopy tree with a diameter at breast height (DBH) of 12 inches or greater or an understory tree with a DBH of four (4) inches or greater. Nature-based solution. An approach that reduces the impacts of sea-level rise, flooding, and storm events through the use of environmental processes and natural systems (such as living shorelines dry swales, wet swale, grass channels, constructed wetlands, detention ponds, and rain gardens). Nonpoint source pollution. Pollution consisting of constituents such as sediment, nutrients, and organic and toxic substances which are washed from the land surface in a disuse manner by stormwater, such as runoff from agriculture and urban land development and use. Nontidal wetlands. Those wetlands other than tidal wetlands that are inundated or saturated by surface or ground water at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances do support, a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions, as defined by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency pursuant to Section 404 of the federal Clean Water Act in 33 CFR 328.3b. Noxious weeds. As defined in Va. Code § 3.2-800, any living plant, or part thereof, declared by the Board of Agriculture and Consumer Services through regulations to be detrimental to crops, surface waters, including lakes, or other desirable plants, livestock, land, or other property, or to be injurious to public health, the environment, or the economy, except when in-state production of such living plant, or part thereof, is commercially viable or such living plant is commercially propagated in Virginia. Including, but not limited to plants such as Johnson grass, kudzu, and multiflora rose. Other structural and organic materials. Materials or features that provide added protection or stability for the natural shoreline habitat components of a living shoreline that attenuate wave energy and do not interfere with natural coastal processes or the natural continuity of the land-water interface. They may be composed of a variety of natural or man-made materials, including rock, concrete, or vegetation-based fiber such as coir logs, oyster shells, and geotextiles; however, structural features shall be free from contaminants, including structural metal such as rebar, and shall be adequately secured to prevent full or partial dislodging or detachment due to wave action or other natural forces as per Va. Code § 28.2- 104.1. Person. An individual, fiduciary, corporation, firm, partnership, association, organization, or any other entity or combination thereof. Principal structure. A primary structure that is necessary to use the land in the manner permitted by the underlying zoning classification. For the purposes of this Ordinance the term principal structure shall not include appurtenances including (i) a required parking area as set forth in Section 31-606 of the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), (ii) a driveway connecting the required parking area to the public right-of-way, and (iii) a sidewalk connecting any outside entrance or exit of the principal structure to the required parking area. Plan of development. For the purposes of this Ordinance, plan of development means any process for site plan review in local zoning and land development regulations designed to ensure compliance with Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:74 and with this Ordinance, prior to issuance of a building permit. Public road. A publicly owned road designed and constructed in accordance with water quality protection criteria at least as stringent as requirements applicable to the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT), including regulations promulgated pursuant to the Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act and Regulations a. Code § 62.1-44.15:24 et seq.). This definition includes those roads where VDOT exercises direct supervision over the design or construction activities, or both, and cases where roads are constructed or maintained, or both, by the City of Suffolk in accordance with Section 31-612 of the Unified Development Ordinance of the City of Suffolk. Redevelopment. The process of developing land that is or has been previously developed in approximately the same physical location or footprint. Resilience. The capability to anticipate, prepare for, respond to, and recover from significant multi-hazard threats with minimum damage to social well-being, health, the economy, and the environment. Resource Management Area (RMA). That component of a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area not classified as a Resource Protection Area. Resource Management Areas include land types which, if improperly used or developed, have the potential for causing significant water quality degradation or for diminishing the functional value of a Resource Protection Area. Resource Management Areas shall be provided contiguous to the entire inland boundary of the Resource Protection Area. Resource Protection Area (RPA). That component of a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area comprised of lands adjacent to water bodies with perennial flow which have an intrinsic water quality value due to the ecological and biological processes they perform or are sensitive to impacts which may result in significant degradation to the quality of state waters. Silvicultural activities. Forest management activities, including but not limited to the harvesting of timber, the construction of roads and trails for forest management purposes, and the preparation of property for reforestation that are conducted in accordance with the silvicultural best management practices developed and enforced by the State Forester pursuant to Va. Code § 10.1-1105 and are located on property defined as real estate devoted to forest use under Va. Code § 58.1-3230. Special flood hazard area (SFHA). An area having special flood, mudflow or flood-related erosion hazards and be shown on a Flood Hazard Boundary Map (FHBM) or designated as Zone A on the flood hazard boundary map Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM). Zone A usually is refined into Zones A, AO, AH, A1-30, AE, A99, AR, AR/A1-30, AR/AE, AR/AO, AR/AH, AR/A, VO, or V1-30, VE, or V after detailed ratemaking has been completed or publication of the flood insurance rate map. The SFHA is the area where the National Flood Insurance Program’s (NFIP’s) floodplain management regulations must be enforced and the area where the mandatory purchase of flood insurance applies. Storm surge. The resulting temporary rise in sea level due to the action of wind stress on the water surface and low atmospheric pressure created during storms which can cause coastal flooding. Surge is the difference from expected tide level. Storm tide is the total water level. Subdivision. The division of any parcel of land into two (2) or more lots or parcels. The term shall include all changes in lot lines, the creation of new lots involving any division of an existing lot or lots and, if a new street is involved in such division, any division of a parcel of land. When appropriate to the context, the term shall also include the process of subdividing and the territory subdivided. Substantial alteration. The expansion or modification of a building or development that would result in a disturbance of land exceeding an area of two thousand five hundred (2,500) square feet in the Resource Management Protection Area only. Tidal shore. Land contiguous to a tidal body of water between the mean low water and mean high water levels. Tidal wetlands. Vegetated and nonvegetated wetlands as defined in Va. Code § 28.2-1300. Understory tree. A tree that typically reaches 12 to 35 feet in height when mature. Use. An activity on the land other than development including agriculture, horticulture, and silviculture. Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act. Article 2.3 (§ 62.1-44.15:24 et seq.) of Chapter 3.1 of Title 62.1 of the Code of Virginia. Waterbody with perennial flow. A body of water that flows in a natural or manmade channel year-round during a year of normal precipitation. This includes, but is not limited to streams, estuaries, and tidal embayments and may include drainage ditches or channels constructed in wetlands or from former natural drainageways, which convey perennial flow. Lakes and ponds, into, out of, or through which a perennial stream flows, are a part of the perennial stream. Generally, the water table is located above the streambed for most of the year and groundwater is the primary source for stream flow. Water-dependent facility. A development of land which cannot exist outside of a Resource Protection Area, and which must be located on the shoreline by reason of the intrinsic nature of its operation. These facilities include ports, the intake and outfall structures of power plants, water treatment plants, sewage treatment plants, storm sewers, marinas and other boat docking structures, beaches and other public water-oriented recreation areas, fisheries, or other marine resources facilities. (d) AREAS OF APPLICABILITY. (1) The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance shall apply to all lands which are designated as Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas within the City of Suffolk. Such lands are designated as Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas and are depicted on the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Map. (2) Resource Protection Areas shall include the following components: A. Tidal wetlands. B. Nontidal wetlands connected by surface flow and contiguous to tidal wetlands or water bodies with perennial flow. C. Tidal shores. D. Drinking water reservoirs from the water's edge. E. A buffer area not less than 100 feet in width located adjacent to and landward of the components listed in subsections (A) through (D) above of this subsection, and along both sides of any water body with perennial flow. The full buffer area shall be designated as the landward component of the Resource Protection Area notwithstanding the presence of permitted uses, encroachments, and permitted vegetation clearing in compliance with Section 31-415.1(f), general performance standards and Section 31-415.1(g), development criteria for resource protection areas RPA development criteria, through compliance with Section 31- 415.1(m), administrative approvals and formal exceptions of this Ordinance. (3) Resource Management Areas shall consist of all lands within Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas which are not designated as Resource Protection Areas. These lands, if improperly used or developed, have a potential for causing significant water quality degradation or for diminishing the functional value of the Resource Protection Area. (4) Intensely Developed Areas are an overlay to the Resource Protection Area that serve as redevelopment areas in which development was concentrated and where little of the natural environment remained as of October 1, 1989. Development within IDAs shall comply with the requirements of the redevelopment performance standards of this Ordinance. (5) Designation of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area boundaries shall not be subject to modification unless based upon reliable, site-specific information as provided for in Section 31- 415.1(e) of this Ordinance. (e) INTERPRETATION OF CHESAPEAKE BAY PRESERVATION AREA BOUNDARIES. (1) The Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Map adopted by the Suffolk City Council shall be used for planning purposes as a guide to the general location of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas. (2) The City of Suffolk Administrator shall, on all properties located within a designated Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area where land disturbance, development or redevelopment is proposed and as part of the plan of development review process pursuant to Section 31-415.1(j) of this Ordinance or during the review of a water quality impact assessment pursuant to Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance, ensure or confirm that: A. A reliable site-specific evaluation of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area boundaries is conducted to determine whether water bodies on or adjacent to the development site have perennial flow, and B. That Resource Protection Area boundaries are adjusted, as necessary, on the site based upon the site-specific evaluation. (3) Perennial flow determinations for site-specific evaluations shall be performed using one of the protocols acceptable to the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality as referred to in the document adopted by the Commonwealth of Virginia entitled Determinations of Water Bodies with Perennial Flow Guidance on the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Designation and Management Regulations. For nontidal wetlands connected by surface flow and contiguous to perennial streams, the Atlantic and Gulf Coast Regional Supplement to the 1987 USACOE Wetlands Delineation Manual and the Resource Protection Areas: Nontidal Wetlands Guidance on the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Designation and Management Regulations adopted by the Commonwealth of Virginia, should be consulted. (4) A site-specific evaluation must be performed and certified as complete and accurate by a qualified professional. To be qualified, a professional must: (i) work or be certified in a related field such as stream ecology, hydrology, or hydrogeology; (ii) have secondary education, post- secondary education, or technical training in a related field such as stream ecology, hydrology, or hydrogeology; and (iii) have field experience performing or substantially assisting with the performance of a site-specific evaluation using the protocol employed. As an alternative, the City of Suffolk Administrator may, at their sole discretion, conduct a site-specific evaluation using a professional qualified pursuant to this subsection for any purpose. (5) When a delineation of a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area, or any component thereof, has been approved or established by the City of Suffolk Administrator, the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Map shall be amended by the City of Suffolk to reflect such delineation. (f) GENERAL PERFORMANCE STANDARDS. The general performance standards set forth in this Section are intended to prevent a net increase in nonpoint source pollution from new development and development on previously developed land where the runoff was treated by a water quality protection best management practice. Except as otherwise provided herein, the following standards shall apply to all development and redevelopment in both Resource Protection Areas and Resource Management Areas of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area: (1) Land disturbance shall be limited to the area necessary to provide for the proposed use or development. The limits of land disturbance, including clearing, grading, or filling shall be strictly defined by the construction footprint as shown on the approved plan of development. A. Clearing shall be allowed only to provide for necessary access, site drainage, water quality best management practices, and/or the installation of utilities and primary and reserve drainfield sites as detailed on a Virginia Department of Health sewage disposal construction permit. The limits of land disturbance shall be clearly shown on all plans submitted and physically marked on the site. B. Ingress and egress during construction shall be limited to one access point, unless otherwise approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator. (2) Existing indigenous vegetation shall be preserved to the maximum extent practicable consistent with the use or development proposed and in accordance with the current version of the Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook. A. Mature trees shall be protected during development and only removed where necessary, including to provide for the proposed use or development. B. Existing trees over six (6) inches diameter at breast height (DBH) shall be preserved outside the construction footprint. C. Diseased trees or trees weakened by age, storm, fire, or other injury may be removed when approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator. Other woody vegetation on site shall also be preserved outside the approved construction footprint. When a diseased tree or tree weakened by age, storm, fire, or other injury is to be removed, tree restoration should occur according to the Riparian Buffer Modification & Mitigation Manual (Buffer Manual) (2003), prepared by the Chesapeake Bay Local Assistance Division of the Department of Conservation and Recreation and as may be amended by the Commonwealth of Virginia. Native species shall be preferred for all replacement plantings. D. Prior to commencement of any construction activities, including but not limited to clearing, grading, excavating, filling, or trenching, and including safety fencing, signs, or such other suitable protective barriers as may be required by the City of Suffolk Administrator, shall be erected to protect the critical root zone for any tree or stand of trees to be preserved on the site, as well as to protect the critical root zone of trees on adjacent properties that extend onto the site. E. A waiver may be granted to allow reasonable access to the site and work area, with specific conditions to be established by the City of Suffolk Administrator. Protective barriers shall remain so erected throughout all phases of construction. The storage of equipment, materials, debris, or fill shall not be allowed within the area protected by the barrier. (3) Land development shall minimize impervious cover to promote infiltration of stormwater into the ground consistent with the use or development. During the design phase of development, use of the following means of minimizing impervious cover are encouraged: A. Placement of parking areas under multiple-family, office, or commercial buildings. B. Use of shared parking where possible in mixed use developments. C. Construction of no more than the minimum number of parking spaces required by the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance. D. Use of modular grid pavers on private property and in low-traffic zones. E. Use of low impact development, better site design, and/or cluster development land development planning techniques in lieu of conventional design as set forth in the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance. (4) Any development or redevelopment involving land disturbance of 2,500 square feet or more shall be accomplished through a plan of development review process as set forth in Section 31-415.1(j) of this Ordinance, and other such requirements set forth in City of Suffolk ordinances. (5) Any land disturbing activity, as defined in Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:24, exceeding an area of 2,500 square feet, including, but not limited to, construction of all single-family homes, septic tanks, and drainfields, but otherwise as defined by § 62.1-44.15:24 or § 62.1-44.15:51 of the Code of Virginia) shall comply with the requirements of the City of Suffolk Erosion and Stormwater Management Ordinance. Enforcement for noncompliance with the erosion and sediment control requirements referenced in these criteria shall be conducted under the provisions of the State Water Control Law Va. Code § 62.1-44.2 et seq.) and attendant regulations. (6) Land-disturbing activities in a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area that are equal to or greater than 2,500 square feet but less than once acre shall comply with the requirements of 9 VAC 25-875-740 and 9 VAC 25-875-750. (7) All on-site sewage treatment systems not requiring a Virginia Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (VPDES) permit shall be pumped out at least once every five (5) years, provided that: a. Subject to conditions established by the Western Tidewater Health District of the Virginia Department of Health (VDH), the owners of such systems may, in lieu of pumping out such systems every five (5) years, have a plastic filter installed and maintained in the outflow pipe from the septic tank to filter solid material from the effluent while sustaining adequate flow to the drainfield to permit normal use of the septic system. Such a filter shall satisfy standards established in the Sewage Handling and Disposal Regulations (12 VAC 5-610) administered by VDH; and b. In lieu of requiring proof of septic tank pump out every five (5) years, the City of Suffolk may allow owners of on-site sewage treatment systems to submit documentation every five (5) years, certified by a an operator or onsite soil evaluator licensed or certified under Chapter 23 (§ 54.1-2300 et seq.) of Title 54.1 of the Code of Virginia as being qualified to operate, maintain, or design onsite sewage systems, that the septic system has been inspected, is functioning properly, and that – as of the date of inspection – pump-out of the effluent was not deemed necessary. c. For new construction not served by public sewer or other system requiring a VPDES permit, a reserve sewage disposal site with a capacity at least equal to that of the primary sewage disposal site shall be provided. This requirement shall not apply to any lot or parcel recorded prior to October 1, 1989, if such lot or parcel is not sufficient in capacity to accommodate a reserve sewage disposal site, as determined by the Western Tidewater Health District. Building or construction of any impervious cover shall be prohibited on the area of all sewage disposal sites, including reserve sewage disposal sites, until the property is served by public sewer or an on-site sewage treatment system operating under a VPDES permit. All sewage disposal site records shall be administered to provide adequate notice and enforcement. As an alternative to the reserve sewage disposal site, the owners of such systems may install an alternative drainfield system meeting the following conditions: 1) Each of the two (2) alternating drainfields in the system shall have at a minimum, an area not less than fifty (50) percent of the area that would otherwise be required if a single primary drainfield were constructed. 2) An area equal to fifty (50) percent of the area that would otherwise be required for the primary drainfield site shall be reserved for subsurface absorption systems that utilize a flow diversion device, to provide for future replacement or repair to meet the requirements for a sewage disposal system. Expansion of the primary system shall require an expansion of the reserve system. 3) The two (2) alternating drainfields shall be connected by a diversion valve, approved by the Western Tidewater Health District, located in the pipe between the septic tank and the distribution boxes. The diversion valve shall be used to alternate the direction of effluent flow to one (1) drainfield or the other at a time. Diversion valves shall not be used for the following types of treatment systems: a) Sand mounds. b) Low pressure distribution systems. c) Repair situations when installation of a valve is not feasible. d) Any other approved system for which the use of a valve would adversely affect the design of the system, as determined by the Western Tidewater Health District. 4) The diversion valve shall be a three-port, two-way valve of approved materials (i.e., resistant to sewage, leak-proof and designed so that the effluent from the tank can be directed to flow into either one (1) of the two (2) distribution boxes). 5) There shall be a conduit from the top of the valve to the ground surface with an appropriate cover to be level with or above the ground surface. 6) The valve shall not be located in driveways, recreational courts, parking lots, or beneath sheds or other structures. 7) In lieu of a diversion valve, any device that can be designed and constructed to direct the flow of effluent from the tank into either one (1) of the two (2) distribution boxes may be approved if plans are submitted to the Western Tidewater Health District and determined to be satisfactory. 8) Owners shall alternate using the drainfields every 12 months to permit the yearly resting of half of the absorption system. 9) The City of Suffolk Administrator shall ensure that the owners are notified annually of the requirement to switch the valve to the opposite drainfield. (8) Prior to the authorization and initiation of grading or other on-site activities, all wetlands permits required by law shall be obtained and evidence of such submitted by the applicant to the City of Suffolk Administrator. (9) Agricultural lands shall have a soil and water quality conservation assessment conducted that evaluates the effectiveness of existing practices pertaining to soil erosion and sediment control, nutrient management, and management of pesticides and, where necessary, results in a plan that outlines additional practices needed to ensure that water quality protection is accomplished consistent with this Ordinance. A. Recommendations for additional conservation practices need address only those conservation issues applicable to the tract or field being assessed. Any soil and water quality conservation practices recommended as a result of such an assessment and are subsequently implemented with financial assistance from federal or state cost-share programs must be designed consistent with cost-share practice standards set forth in the January 1999 Field Office Technical Guide of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service or the June 2000 edition of the Virginia Agricultural Best Management Practices (BMP) Manual of the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation, respectively, and accomplish water quality protection consistent with this Ordinance. Unless otherwise specified in this Section, general performance standards pertaining to the various agricultural conservation practices being assessed shall be as follows: (i) For erosion and sediment control recommendations, the goal shall be, where feasible, to prevent erosion from exceeding the soil loss tolerance level, referred to as "T," as defined in the "National Soil Survey Handbook" of November 1996 in the Field Office Technical Guide of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service. However, in no case shall erosion exceed the soil loss consistent with an Alternative Conservation System as defined in the Field Office Technical Guide of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service. (ii) For nutrient management, whenever nutrient management plans are developed, the operator or landowner must provide soil test information, consistent with the Virginia Nutrient Management Training and Certification Regulations (4 VAC 50- 85). (iii) For pest chemical control, referrals shall be made to the local cooperative extension agent or an Integrated Pest Management Specialist of the Virginia Cooperative Extension Service. Recommendations shall include copies of applicable information from the "Virginia Pest Management Guide”, or other Extension materials related to pest control. B. A higher priority shall be placed on conducting assessments of agricultural fields and tracts adjacent to Resource Protection Areas. However, if the landowner or operator of such a tract also has Resource Management Area fields or tracts in his operation, the assessment for that landowner or operator may be conducted for all fields or tracts in the operation. When such an expanded assessment is completed, priority must return to Resource Protection Area fields and tracts. C. The findings and recommendations of such assessments and any resulting soil and water quality conservation plans will be submitted to the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District Board, which will be the plan-approving authority. (10) Silvicultural activities in Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas are exempt from this chapter provided that silvicultural operations adhere to water quality protection procedures prescribed by the Virginia Department of Forestry in the Fifth Edition (March 2011) of “Virginia’s Forestry Best Management Practices for Water Quality Technical Manual.” The Virginia Department of Forestry will oversee and document installation of best management practices and will monitor in-stream impacts of forestry operations in Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas. (g) DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA FOR RESOURCE PROTECTION AREAS. (1) In addition to the general performance standards of Section 31-415.1(f) of this Ordinance, the following standards shall apply to all use, land disturbance, development, or redevelopment proposed within the Resource Protection Area: A. Land development may be allowed in the Resource Protection Area subject to approval by the City of Suffolk Administrator only if such development (i) is water dependent; (ii) constitutes redevelopment; (iii) is a new use established pursuant to Section 31-415.1(g)(3) of this Ordinance; (iv) is a road or driveway crossing satisfying the conditions set forth in subdivision (v) of this section below; (v) is a flood control or stormwater management facility satisfying the conditions set forth in subdivision vi of this section; or (vii) fences that meet the minimum requirements of this section. In addition, the following conditions shall apply: (i) A Water Quality Impact Assessment as set forth in Section 31-415.1(h) and Appendix B- 13 of this Ordinance shall be required for any proposed land disturbance in the RPA. (ii) A resiliency assessment as set forth in Section 31-415.1(i) of this Ordinance shall be required for any proposed land development during the plan of development or other project review process in the RPA. (iii)A new or expanded water dependent facility may be allowed provided that the following criteria are met: a. Such facility does not conflict with the comprehensive plan. b. It complies with the general performance standards set forth in Section 31-415.1(f) of this Ordinance. c. Any non-water dependent component of such facility is located outside of the Resource Protection Area. Restaurants, parking areas, in-ground pools, patios, and indoor or outdoor dry dock boat storage facilities are accessory to the water-dependent use. As they are not considered water-dependent facilities, they must be reviewed through the formal exception process d. Access to such facility will be provided with the minimum land disturbance necessary. Where practicable, a single point of access will be provided. (iv) Redevelopment outside of designated Intensely Developed Areas shall be permitted in the Resource Protection Area only if (i) there is no increase in the amount of imperious cover; (ii) no further encroachment within the Resource Protection Area; and (iii) such redevelopment conforms to applicable erosion and sediment control criteria and stormwater management criteria set forth in the Suffolk Erosion and Stormwater Management Ordinance and the Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act and the attendant regulations, as well as all applicable stormwater management requirements of other state and federal agencies. (v) Roads and driveways not otherwise exempt from the provisions of this Ordinance, as per Section 31-415.1(l)(1) of this Ordinance, may be constructed in or across Resource Protection Areas provided each of the following conditions is met: a. The City of Suffolk Administrator finds that there are no reasonable alternatives to aligning the road or driveway in or across the Resource Protection Area. b. The alignment and design of the road or driveway are optimized, consistent with other requirements, to minimize (i)encroachment into the Resource Protection Area and (ii) adverse effects on water quality. i. Driveways may be constructed of asphalt, concrete, pavers, bricks, gravel, etc. The imperviousness of each material will be based on current industry standards. Pervious concrete, asphalt, and pavers may be used but must meet Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act Regulations, must be designed by a professional engineer and supported with a geo-technical report. ii. Driveways may be no wider than 10-feet unless a greater width is required pursuant to some other standard adopted by the Suffolk City Council. iii. The parking pad for a one or two-car garage may be no larger than 22 feet in width by 18 feet in length. iv. A single 10-foot x 17-foot turn-around with ten-foot turning radius may be allowed. Additional access drives shall be designed to be fully outside the RPA. c. The design and construction of the road or driveway satisfy all applicable criteria of this Ordinance, including submission of a water quality impact assessment. d. The City of Suffolk Administrator reviews the plan for the road or driveway proposed in or across the Resource Protection Area in coordination with City of Suffolk site plan, subdivision, and other applicable plan of development reviews. (vi) Flood control and stormwater management facilities that drain or treat water from multiple development projects or from a significant portion of a watershed may be allowed in Resource Protection Areas, provided that: a. Such facilities are allowed and constructed in accordance with the Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act and its attendant regulations, and provided that: b. The City of Suffolk Administrator conclusively establishes that the location of the facility within the Resource Protection Area is the optimum location. c. The size of the facility is the minimum necessary to provide necessary flood control or stormwater treatment, or both. d. The facility is consistent with a comprehensive stormwater management plan developed and approved in accordance with 9 VAC 25-875-660 of the Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Regulations. e. All applicable State and Federal permits are obtained from the appropriate federal and state agencies having jurisdiction, such as the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the Department of Environmental Quality, and the Virginia Marine Resources Commission. f. Approval is received from the City of Suffolk Administrator prior to construction. g. Routine maintenance is performed on such facilities to assure that they continue to function as designed. h. Best management practices (BMPs) that collect and treat runoff from an individual lot, project, or portion thereof may not be located within a Resource Protection Area. (vii) Fences located within the Resource Protection Area may be reviewed administratively without an formal exception request, provided that the following design requirements which collectively maintain the functional value of the buffer are met: a. Fences shall be designed so that they do not inhibit or alter surface flow. Water must be able to flow under and through the fence unimpeded. b. Vegetation may only be removed to provide for the actual placement of the fence. Where vegetation is removed, it must be replaced with other native vegetation that is equally effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion and filtering stormwater runoff. c. Any land disturbance associated with the installation of the fence shall be mitigated in accordance with the requirements listed in the Buffer Manual. A Water Quality Impact Assessment shall be submitted in accordance with the requirements outlined in Appendix B-13(b) of this Ordinance. d. Fences should be located so as to avoid the removal of trees. (2) Buffer area requirements. The 100-foot-wide buffer area shall be the landward component of the Resource Protection Area, as set forth in Section 31-415.1(d)(2) of this Ordinance. Notwithstanding the existence of permitted uses, encroachments, and vegetation clearing, as set forth in this subsection, the buffer area shall not be considered reduced in width. To minimize the adverse effects of human activities on the other components of the Resource Protection Area, state waters, and aquatic life, a 100-foot-wide buffer area of vegetation that is effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering nonpoint source pollution from runoff shall be retained if present and established where it does not exist. Where such buffer must be established, the planting of trees shall be incorporated into the reestablishment of the 100-foot buffer, as appropriate to site conditions and in such a manner to maximize the buffer function. Inclusion of native species in tree planting is preferred. A. The 100-foot-wide buffer area shall be deemed to achieve a 75 percent reduction of sediments and a 40 percent reduction of nutrients. B. Where land uses such as agriculture or silviculture within the area of the buffer area cease and the property is proposed to be converted to other land uses, then a minimum 100-foot- wide buffer shall be reestablished with woody vegetation. In reestablishing the buffer, management measures shall be undertaken to provide woody vegetation that assures the buffer functions set forth in this chapter. Where such buffer must be reestablished, the planting of trees shall be incorporated into the reestablishment of the 100-foot buffer, as appropriate to site conditions and in such a manner to maximize the buffer function. Inclusion of native species in tree planting is preferred. (i) A comprehensive planting plan for the entire buffer area that will ensure survivability of vegetation and viability of the newly established buffer shall be submitted and approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator prior to approval of a new land use or development plan (including subdivision) for the property. (ii) The comprehensive planting plan should provide for the planting of a standard buffer adjacent to all impacted RPA features and along all water bodies with perennial flow on the site. The planting plan should also provide for management measures such as proper monitoring and maintenance of the installed woody vegetation that assures the buffer functions set forth in this Ordinance. (iii)If, prior to plan of development approval, the City of Suffolk Administrator determines that the 100-foot buffer is adequately vegetated and meets the pollutant removal criteria listed within this subsection, replanting additional vegetation may not be necessary. In these cases, the full 100-foot RPA buffer should be allowed to naturally regenerate, and no land disturbing activities should be permitted within this area. (iv) The Buffer Manual should be consulted to determine the best methods for planting the 100-foot buffer in such a way as to meet the pollutant removal criteria listed within this subsection. (3) Permitted encroachments into the buffer area. A. When the application of the buffer area would result in the loss of an adequate buildable area, as determined by the City of Suffolk Administrator, on a lot or parcel legally recorded prior to October 1, 1989, the City of Suffolk Administrator may, through an administrative review process, permit an encroachment into the buffer area as set forth in Section 31-415.1(m) of this Ordinance and with the following criteria: (i) Encroachments into the buffer area shall be the minimum necessary to achieve a reasonable buildable area for a principal structure and necessary utilities. For the purposes of this subsection, reasonable buildable area shall mean that area reasonably necessary for a principal structure and necessary utilities with compatible bulk and scale to those in the surrounding neighborhood or area. Detached accessory structures shall not be eligible for encroachment authorizations. (ii) Where practicable, a vegetated area that will maximize water quality protection, mitigate the effects of the buffer area encroachment, and is equal to the area of encroachment into the buffer area shall be established elsewhere on the lot or parcel. Where established, such vegetated area shall include the planting of trees as appropriate to site conditions. Inclusion of native species in tree planting is preferred. (iii) Encroachments into the buffer area may not extend into the seaward fifty (50) feet of the buffer area. (iv) Encroachments into the buffer area processed through an administrative review shall be subject to the findings required by Section 31-415.1(m) of this Ordinance but without the requirement for a public hearing, such findings to be made instead by the City of Suffolk Administrator. This provision shall not apply to accessory structures. B. When the application of the buffer area would result in the loss of a buildable area on a lot or parcel recorded between October 1, 1989, and March 1, 2002, the City of Suffolk Administrator may permit an encroachment into the buffer area or an encroachment may be permitted by administrative waiver, as set forth in this Ordinance and in accordance with the following criteria: (i) The lot or parcel was created through a legal process conducted in conformity with the Subdivision Ordinance in effect at the time the lot was platted. (ii) Conditions or mitigation measures imposed through a previously approved administrative waiver or formal exception shall be met. (iii)If the use of a best management practice (BMP) was previously required, the BMP shall be evaluated to determine if it continues to function effectively and, if necessary, the BMP shall be reestablished or repaired and maintained as required. (iv) The criteria in subsection Section 31-415.1(g)(3)(A) of this Ordinance shall be met. (4) Permitted modifications of the buffer area. A. To maintain the functional value of the buffer area, existing vegetation may be removed subject to approval by the City of Suffolk Administrator. Such removal shall only be allowed to provide for reasonable sight lines, access paths, general woodlot management, BMPs (including those that prevent upland erosion and concentrated flows of stormwater), shoreline erosion control projects, or adaptation measures. Such buffer modifications shall be permitted under the following conditions, and consistent with the requirements of this Ordinance: (i) In general, where the removal of trees within the buffer area is proposed, mature trees shall be preserved and trimmed or pruned in lieu of removal as site conditions permit and removal should be limited to the fewest number of trees feasible. Where tree planting for mitigation, conservation landscaping, or for buffer reestablishment is proposed, inclusion of native species in tree planting is preferred. (ii) Trees may be pruned or thinned as necessary to provide for sight lines, vistas, and access paths, provided that where removed, they shall be replaced with other vegetation that is equally effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering nonpoint source pollution from runoff. a. When trees are proposed for removal within the RPA to provide for sight lines, vistas, and access paths, they shall be replaced with trees as appropriate to site conditions and in such a manner as to maximize the buffer function and to protect the quality of state waters. The boundaries of this area shall be determined in a manner acceptable to the City of Suffolk Administrator and be based on identified vantage points and the portion of the shoreline to be viewed. b. Trees and other woody vegetation may not be removed where reasonable sight lines, vistas, or access paths can be created by the pruning of trees alone. Pruning shall be performed in accordance with the Buffer Manual. c. A written request for a determination by the City of Suffolk Administrator that the proposed removal of vegetation from the RPA buffer is in accordance with the requirements of this subsection is required. Such request shall include a plan showing the following: (i) the vantage points for the sight lines, vistas, and access paths (ii) the portion of the shoreline to be viewed or accessed, (iii) the area in which trees are to be pruned or removed, (iv) the location of all trees six inches or greater in diameter at breast height or as required by the City of Suffolk Administrator, and (v) the location of the trees to be removed or pruned. The request shall also indicate the type, location and number of replacement vegetation proposed. d. Trees and other woody vegetation may not be pruned or removed from the buffer area until a written determination is obtained from the City of Suffolk Administrator that the proposed activity is in accordance with the requirements of this Ordinance. e. Any path shall be constructed and surfaced to effectively control erosion. Paths serving individual residential lots shall be no more than four (4) feet in width except as necessary for handicapped access. (iii) Noxious weeds and dead, diseased, or dying trees or shrubbery may be removed provided that where removed, they shall be replaced with other vegetation that is equally effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering nonpoint source pollution from runoff. Any other vegetation may not be removed from any RPA component listed in Section 31-415.1(d)(2)(A) through (E) of this Ordinance or within a perennial stream. a. All dead, diseased, or dying trees must be verified by the City of Suffolk Administrator prior to their removal. b. When questions arise concerning the health of the trees proposed to be removed, the property owner shall be responsible for providing documentation from a certified landscape professional or arborist as to the health and viability of the trees. Such documentation shall be subject to review and approval of the City of Suffolk Administrator. c. No land disturbance in the buffer area may occur or result from the removal of dead or diseased trees or noxious weeds. d. Dead, diseased, or dying trees must be replaced with trees with 1-inch minimum caliper at a 1:1 rate or with 15-inch minimum height shrubs at a 3:1 rate, absent conditions that suggest a higher or lower replacement ratio. e. Removal of noxious weeds is permitted in the buffer area provided they are replaced with vegetation equally adapted for the growing environment. The City of Suffolk Administrator may approve a plan to allow natural revegetation of the areas where noxious weeds are removed pursuant to sound horticultural practices on a case-by- case basis. f. For projects greater than 2,500 square feet of disturbance in the RPA, the replacement vegetation shall be protected by a surety bond of the full amount of the landscaping costs and is subject to inspection one year after planting to ensure survival. g. For removal of trees larger than six (6) inches DBH, a buffer modification plan is required. 1) The buffer modification plan shall be reviewed by the City of Suffolk Administrator prior to removal of the tree(s). Upon approval of the plan the property owner may remove the tree(s) specified in the plan. 2) Tree restoration shall be required within 90 days of removal. A subsequent inspection for the replanting of tree(s) shall be performed by the City of Suffolk Administrator. If in the opinion of the City of Suffolk Administrator, the replanting requirements may lead to further future structural damage to the principal building, the replanting requirement may be reduced or waived. 3) Site clearing shall be allowed only to provide necessary access, positive site drainage, water quality BMPs, and the installation of utilities, as approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator through the plan of development review process outlined under Section 31-415.1(j) of this Ordinance. Prior to clearing or grading, suitable protective barriers, such as safety fencing, shall be erected five (5) feet outside of the dripline of any tree or stand of trees to be preserved. These protective barriers shall remain throughout all phases of construction. The storage of equipment, materials, debris, or fill shall not be allowed within the area protected by the barrier. 4) A violation penalty of $1,000 per tree removed without an approved woodlot management plan shall be assessed. Violators must still meet the provisions of this Ordinance to include designated tree replacement requirements. Property owners, contractors, and any other individuals associated with the removal of a tree without a buffer modification permit approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator are subject to this penalty, or subject to the criminal provisions of the City of Suffolk Unified Development Ordinance. 5) Where areas to be preserved within the RPA are encroached upon and trees are removed without approval, replacement of existing removed trees and other vegetation shall be achieved at a ratio of three (3) trees planted to one (1) tree greater than six (6) inches diameter at breast height removed, or by such other measures as in the judgment of the City of Suffolk Administrator will adequately compensate for the removal of such trees and other vegetation. Replacement trees shall be a minimum two (2) to two and one-half (2½) inches caliper at the time of planting. (iv) For shoreline erosion control projects, trees and woody vegetation within the footprint of the shoreline erosion control project may be removed, necessary control techniques employed, and appropriate vegetation established to protect or stabilize the shoreline in accordance with the best available technical advice and applicable permit conditions or requirements. a. The removal of mature trees for the installation and maintenance of proposed shoreline erosion control projects shall only be permitted as necessary and consistent with the best available technical advice, approved project plans, and applicable permit conditions or requirements. b. Where vegetation is proposed for removal within the buffer area as part of a shoreline erosion control project, a water quality impact assessment with vegetative mitigation equal to the area of encroachment is required. Trees shall be incorporated, as appropriate to the site conditions and the project specifications. In addition, vegetation in the form of a mixture of grasses, sedges, flowers, and shrubs can be used by property owners to provide natural stabilization of shorelines. Inclusion of native species is preferred. c. Existing trees, proposed plantings, and clearing limits must be shown on the Joint Permit Application and/or Water Quality Impact Assessment. d. Shoreline erosion control within the RPA shall be consistent with the Wetlands Act (Chapter 13 Title 28.2), the Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) Tidal Wetlands Guidelines which provide for “minimum standards for the protection and conservation of wetlands,” and “ensure protection of shorelines and sensitive coastal habitat from sea level rise and coastal hazard.” Shoreline management and alteration projects should be coordinated to address the requirements of the most updated Tidal Wetlands Guidelines in conjunction with the requirements of this ordinance. 1) Installation of living shorelines is the required adaptation measure for stabilizing tidal shorelines unless the best available science indicates that such approaches are not suitable for the site on which the practice is being considered, as determined by the Virginia Marine Resources Commission. Such projects should be coordinated to address the requirements of the VMRC Tidal Wetlands Guidelines current at the time of application submission in conjunction with the requirements of this Ordinance and Chapter 34 Article 8 of the Code of the City of Suffolk. 2) Approval from the VMRC is also required for adaptation measures proposing the use of sea walls, riprap, groins, or other structural means of stabilization within tidal wetlands. Such projects shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the City of Suffolk Administrator that vegetative techniques cannot be effectively utilized and shall incorporate elements of living shoreline approaches into permitted projects to the maximum extent possible. 3) If a hardened shoreline structure is allowed, the applicant shall be required to incorporate elements of living shoreline approaches into permitted projects, to the maximum extent possible per the best available science. (v) Adaptation measures proposed for location within the Resource Protection Area, shall meet the following conditions: a. The selected adaptation measure shall be a nature-based solution that uses environmental processes, natural systems, or natural features identified as being appropriate for existing site conditions. b. An identified adaptation measure shall be selected from one of the following sources: Chesapeake Bay program approved BMP list, the Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook, the Virginia Stormwater BMP Clearinghouse, the VMRC Tidal Wetlands Guidelines, or be a project that is eligible for funding by the Virginia Community Flood Preparedness Fund Grant. 1) Adaptation measures should consist of trees, vegetation, stone, or enhance existing natural elements. c. Adaptation measures approved for use in the RPA shall be designed, installed, and maintained in accordance with the applicable specifications for the selected adaptation measure. d. Adaptation measures should be placed channelward of the proposed development whenever possible and should maximize the preservation of mature trees and other natural vegetation to minimize adverse impacts to the RPA and to maximize water quality benefits. e. The use of fill as a component of an adaptation measure may be permitted, provided it meets the following conditions: 1) The grading and slope created by the use of fill shall be no greater than necessary based upon the project specifications and implemented in a manner that minimize the impact of run-off. a. Slopes should be equal to or less than 10% to support water quality conditions, including infiltration. b. Slopes less than or equal to 5% or that convey sheet flow of velocities less than one and one-half (1.5) feet/second are preferred, to reduce runoff and tidal wave energies. c. Slopes greater or different than the above may be necessary based upon certain site conditions and adaptation measure specifications. In such instances, submittal of additional calculations and engineering plans, and assessments of the impacts of the use of fill on existing vegetation, wetland migration and water movement, both landward and channelward, in support of the proposed slope shall be required. 2) Fill shall have the necessary biogeochemical characteristics, including sufficient organic content, to support the growth of vegetation and adequate permeability to allow infiltration consistent with project specifications. The applicant shall: a. Provide documentation specifying the proposed depth, extent, and type of fill material proposed for use. b. Provide documentation that the proposed soils are compliant with the requirements governing the use of lightly contaminated soil consistent with the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (9 VAC 20-81 et seq.) or permitting requirements for upland placement of dredge soil, if applicable. c. Provide documentation that the newly placed fill is revegetated with multi-strata vegetation inclusive of canopy and understory trees, shrubs, and ground cover consistent with the guidance found in the Buffer Manual. Inclusion of native species is encouraged. d. Ensure that the fill area is vegetatively stabilized within seven (7) days. 3) The use of fill shall not exacerbate stormwater run-off, and lateral flow onto adjacent properties shall be controlled. a. Appropriate erosion and sediment control and stormwater management measures shall be incorporated into the design specifications, including the establishment of positive and proper drainage. b. If the adaptation measure triggers separate stormwater management requirements, then these criteria should be considered in conjunction with those requirements. c. Larger scale adaptation measures may require the use of stormwater calculations to ensure these criteria are met. d. Any impacts on the management of stormwater upland of the Resource Protection Area created by the use of fill shall be mitigated, as necessary. 4) The use of fill for an adaptation measure shall not negatively impact septic systems and drainfields located within the RPA. Where present, the proximity of the adaptation measure using fill should be considered such that the fill will not interfere with the proper function or maintenance of either of these features. 5) The use of fill shall be consistent with any applicable state and federal floodplain requirements and Section 31-416.2 of this Ordinance. The applicant shall provide documentation to verify that proposed adaptation measures do not conflict with any constraints or requirements of floodplain management or flood control provision, including federal floodplain management regulations found in Title 44 CFR Part 60. The allowance of fill under these provisions does not negate those independent requirements. 6) The placement of fill allowed by either the Living Shoreline Group 1 or Group 2 general permits to establish appropriate elevations to support required vegetation shall be consistent with the fill requirements of this subsection, in that a change in slope or land elevation may not alter water flow in contravention with the fill requirements of this subsection. f. The preservation of existing natural vegetation shall be maximized, including mature trees, and land disturbance consistent with design specifications shall be minimized. g. Adaptation measures shall comply with all federal, state and local requirements, including any required permits and conditions such as the need for a Water Quality Impact Assessment. h. Nothing in these provisions shall be construed to authorize approval or allowance of an adaptation measure in contravention of floodplain management requirements, including the requirements contained in Section 31-416.2 of the Unified Development Ordinance. B. On agricultural lands, the agricultural buffer area shall be managed to prevent concentrated flows of surface water from breaching the buffer area, and appropriate measures may be taken to prevent noxious weeds from invading the buffer area. Agricultural activities may encroach into the buffer area as follows: (i) Agricultural activities may encroach into the landward 50 feet of the 100-foot-wide buffer area if at least one (1) agricultural best management practice is being implemented on the adjacent land and such best management practice, which in the opinion of the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District Board, addresses the predominant water quality issue (either erosion control or nutrient management). In such cases, the combination of the undisturbed buffer area and the best management practice(s) shall achieve water quality protection, pollutant removal, and water resource conservation at least the equivalent of the minimum 100-foot buffer area. If nutrient management is identified as the predominant water quality issue, a nutrient management plan, including soil tests, shall be developed consistent with the Virginia Nutrient Management Training and Certification Regulations (4 VAC 50-85) administered by the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation. (ii) Agricultural activities may encroach within the landward 75 feet of the 100-foot-wide buffer area when agricultural best management practices which address erosion control, nutrient management, and pest chemical control, are being implemented on the adjacent land. The erosion control practices must prevent erosion from exceeding the soil loss tolerance level, referred to as "T," as defined in the National Soil Survey Handbook of November 1996 in the Field Office Technical Guide of the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resource Conservation Service. A nutrient management plan, including soil tests, shall be developed, consistent with the Virginia Nutrient Management Training and Certification Regulations (4 VAC 50-85) administered by the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation. In conjunction with the remaining undisturbed portion of the buffer area, this collection of best management practices shall be presumed to achieve water quality protection at least the equivalent of that provided by the minimum 100-foot buffer area. (iii)The buffer area shall not be required to be designated adjacent to agricultural drainage ditches if at least one (1) best management practice which, in the opinion of the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District Board, addresses the more predominant water quality issue on the adjacent land (either erosion control or nutrient management) is being implemented on the adjacent land. (iv) If specific problems are identified pertaining to agricultural activities that are causing pollution of the nearby water body with perennial flow or violate performance standards pertaining to the vegetated buffer area, the City of Suffolk Administrator, in cooperation with the Peanut Soil and Water Conservation District, shall recommend a compliance schedule to the landowner and require the problems to be corrected consistent with that schedule. This schedule shall expedite environmental protection while considering the seasons and other temporal considerations so that the probability for successfully implementing the corrective measures is greatest. (v) In cases where the landowner or the landowner's agent or operator has refused assistance from the local soil and water conservation district in complying with or documenting compliance with the agricultural requirements of this Ordinance, the district shall report the noncompliance to the City of Suffolk Administrator. The City of Suffolk Administrator shall require the landowner to correct the problems within a specified period not to exceed 18 months from their initial notification of the deficiencies to the landowner. The local government, in cooperation with the district, shall recommend a compliance schedule to the landowner. This schedule shall expedite environmental protection while considering the seasons and other temporal considerations so that the probability for successfully implementing the corrective measures is greatest. (5) Buffer requirements for Intensely Developed Areas. Where the City of Suffolk Administrator has determined that buffers are to be established, they shall be designed in accordance with the standards established in the Buffer Manual. When considering the reestablishment of a buffer within an Intensely Developed Area, the City of Suffolk Administrator shall encourage the planting of trees, including native species, as a component of such buffer reestablishment measure. (6) Buffer mitigation standards. The following standards shall apply in cases in which buffer mitigation is required pursuant to the provisions of this Ordinance due to land disturbance, development, or redevelopment within a Resource Protection Area: A. For new impervious cover: (i) Buffer restoration of an area equal to two (2) times the proposed land disturbanc in the Resource Protection Area shall be provided. The City of Suffolk Administrator or the Board shall allow a lesser area of buffer restoration if the property owner demonstrates that site conditions or structural treatment methods are such that a lesser buffer restoration area will adequately protect water quality. (ii) In-ground pool water surface, decks, pavers, and gravel driveways shall be considered impervious cover for buffer restoration calculations. (iii) In accordance with the Buffer Manual, for the buffer to function as intended, it shall contain the full complement of vegetation that includes canopy trees, understory trees, shrubs, and ground cover, whether the ground cover is vegetation, leaf litter, or mulch. The composition of the buffer restoration area shall be per the Buffer Manual. (iv) Salt- and flood-tolerant plant species shall be planted below the five-foot contour to ensure greater survival of the plantings, where appropriate. (v) Trees shall not be planted within 15 feet of the shoreline where such planting would result in marsh shading or interference with the integrity of shoreline structures. (vi) Buffer restoration shall be located in the Resource Protection Area, including in areas occupied by turf or where impervious cover is removed. To the extent possible, such restoration shall be located in the 50-foot seaward portion of the buffer area. The City of Suffolk Administrator may require a site evaluation to determine the location and extent of vegetation needed to meet this requirement where specific site conditions warrant, including, but not limited to, the presence of steep slopes and existing vegetation recommended for buffers in the Buffer Manual. (vii) All trees, plants, and groundcover required as buffer restoration shall be maintained and not removed or allowed to revert to turf. B. For shoreline erosion control projects, mitigation for land disturbance and/or the removal of vegetation within the RPA shall be in accordance with the Buffer Manual; provided that trees shall not be planted within 15 feet of the shoreline where such planting would result in marsh shading or interference with the integrity of existing or proposed shoreline structures. C. For buffer area establishment or restoration, vegetation shall consist of a mix of canopy trees, understory trees, shrubs, and groundcovers that achieve the buffer functions set forth in Section 31-415.1(g)(2) of this Ordinance. The density of plants, the type of plant materials, and planting techniques shall be as specified in the Buffer Manual. (i) Groundcover (non-woody) plants and riparian buffer grasses augment necessary woody planting materials and are not to be used in lieu of trees and shrubs. (ii) Foundation plantings, within five (5) feet of a structure are not counted towards restoration and replacement requirements. (iii) The use of native plants is strongly encouraged, and invasive species are discouraged. (iv) A buffer establishment or restoration plan and narrative shall include the following information, at a minimum: a. Property owners’ contact information including name, mailing address, email address, and phone number. b. Subject property address, property lines, and location of physical improvements or structures such as houses, sheds, pools, patios, decks, driveways, etc. c. The type, number, and location of trees greater than 3-inches DBH within the “seaward” 50-feet of the buffer area and trees greater than 6-inches DBH in the “landward” 50-feet of the RPA buffer. d. Type, number, and location of mature trees within the RPA buffer. e. Proposed planting schedule, to include the type, number, and location of replacement trees and shrubs. f. Location, limits, and depth of proposed fill. g. Designation of trees to remain and trees to be removed. h. Proposed tree protection measures. i. Appropriate erosion control measures. j. Expected date of completion. k. A current physical survey should be used as a base map for the plan. A GIS map obtained from the city’s website may be used for less complicated projects at the discretion of the City of Suffolk Administrator. l. The plan and narrative must have sufficient information for staff inspection. (h) WATER QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT. (1) The purpose of a water quality impact assessment is to: (i) identify the potentially adverse impacts of proposed development on water quality and lands within Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas consistent with the goals and objectives of this Ordinance; (ii) ensure that, where use, development or redevelopment takes place within Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas, it will be located on those portions of a site and in a manner that will be least disruptive to the natural functions of Resource Protection Areas and other sensitive lands; and (iii) specify means to avoid, minimize and mitigate the impacts of development for water quality protection. (2) A water quality impact assessment must demonstrate that the undisturbed buffer area, enhanced by vegetative plantings and any other best management practices will result in the removal of no less than 75 percent of sediments and 40 percent of nutrients from post-development stormwater runoff and will retard runoff, prevent erosion, and filter non-point source pollution equivalent to an undisturbed 100-full buffer area. (3) A water quality impact assessment in accordance with Appendix B-13 shall be required for any proposed land disturbance, development, or redevelopment within a Resource Protection Area consistent with this Section, and for any other development in Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas that may warrant such assessment because of the unique characteristics of the site or intensity of the proposed use or development as deemed by the City of Suffolk Administrator. (4) A water quality impact assessment shall include the following information: A. A narrative that describes the nature of the proposed RPA encroachment, provides justification for the proposed impacts to the RPA, and addresses the findings required in Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance. (i) An analysis of the anticipated reduction in buffer function due to the proposed land development, its impact on the buffer area, proposed mitigation or adaptation measures, and the anticipated effect of the proposed project on water quality. (ii) A description of the extent and nature of any proposed disturbance or disruption of wetlands. (iii) Impacts of the proposed development on topography, soils, surface and groundwater hydrology on the site and adjacent lands. (iv) Source location and description of proposed excavation and fill material. (v) For any water-dependent activity, the location of, and potential adverse impacts upon, shellfish beds, submerged aquatic vegetation, and fish spawning and nursery areas. (vi) A statement of any anticipated future land disturbance within the RPA. (vii) All federal, state, and local permits required for the development of the site. B. A site drawing to scale which depicts the following: (i) Delineation of the RPA components, including the 100-foot buffer area and the location of any water body with perennial flow, and the RMA boundary, if necessary. (ii) Existing topography, soils information (including depth to groundwater and infiltration rate), where appropriate), surface and groundwater hydrology, wetlands and, if necessary, drainage patterns from adjacent lands. (iii) Location and nature of the proposed encroachment into the buffer area, including limits of clearing or grading and the area of land disturbance; location of any structures, driveways, or other impervious cover; type(s) of paving material(s); area of proposed impervious cover; and location of proposed utilities, including sewage disposal systems or reserve drainfield sites. (iv) Location and area (in square feet) of existing impervious cover. (v) Existing vegetation, including the number and type of trees and other vegetation to be removed in the RPA to accommodate the proposed buffer encroachment or modification. (vi) Proposed vegetative mitigation plan equal to the area of land disturbance within the existing buffer area. (vii) Type and location of proposed additional best management practices that may be necessary to mitigate for the proposed encroachment. (viii) Type and location of proposed adaptation measures necessary to address the impacts of storm surge, sea level rise, and flooding. (i) RESILIENCY ASSESSMENT. (1) Submittal of a resiliency assessment that considers the potential impacts of sea level rise, storm surge, and flooding on buffer function in light of a proposed RPA encroachment is required to be conducted by the applicant and submitted with any plan of development or other review process proposing disturbance in the RPA. Such an assessment is to be based upon the RPA as delineated at the time of the proposed land development and is required in addition to all other requirements of this and other local ordinances. At a minimum the resiliency assessment should contain the following information: A. A scaled drawing or aerial image of the proposed project that includes the RPA boundary, required setbacks, existing topography, and a graphic depiction of the anticipated impacts of sea level rise, flooding, and storm surge on the parcel and the proposed project, based upon a review of approved models and forecasts, to include the following: (i) For sea level rise, use the 2017 National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Intermediate-High scenario projection curve or any subsequently updated version thereof on the project site. Sea level rise data can be accessed on the AdaptVA website, maintained by the Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS). When determining potential sea-level rise impacts, the applicant should use the model to identify both the extent of anticipated inland migration, as well as the water depth. (ii) For storm surge, use the most up to date NOAA hydrodynamic Sea, Lake, and Overland Surges Hurricanes (SLOSH) model on the project site. Storm surge data can be accessed on the AdaptVA website. Applicants shall use the Category 1 Flood Height at a minimum. (iii) For flooding, use the most up to date Special Flood Hazard Area and the Limit of Moderate Wave Action (LiMWA) model on the project site according to the Virginia Flood Risk Information System (VFRIS) model in conjunction with the requirements and application of Section 31-416.2 of the Unified Development Ordinance. VFRIS includes the Flood Insurance Rate Maps, flood insurance studies, and associated models produced by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and is available on the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation (DCR) website. When identifying flooding impacts, the applicant may rely on existing use and application of the relevant Special Flood Hazard Area. This data is also accessible on the AdaptVA website. (iv) The anticipated impacts shall be based upon a thirty (30) year timeframe, unless the applicant demonstrates that the lifespan of the project proposed for development is less than thirty (30) years based upon the information in B(ii) above as approved by the City of Suffolk Administrator. Where a lifespan of less than 30 years is proposed, the applicant shall provide documentation of proposed building materials, anticipated quality of construction, design specifications, and other materials or information in support of a predicted lifespan of less than 30 years for the project. B. A resiliency assessment form and narrative that analyzes the results of the data and graphic research, and provides the following information: (i) Define the intended service life of the proposed structure(s). (ii) Identification of any proposed impact directly from proposed impervious cover or structures in the RPA and the extent of such impact. (iii) Identification of extent of impact on the current buffer area including impacts to existing vegetation from the landward movement of water and vegetative migration. (iv) Describe the extent to which anticipated impacts can be or have been mitigated by altering the location design, size, or orientation of proposed structures or impervious cover, by preserving and/or supplementing existing buffer areas as provided for in Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance, and/or by considering other limiting site conditions including required setbacks and parcel size, and/or by proposing an adaptation measure in accordance with the provisions of Section 31-415.1(h). (v) Identification of the utilization of existing local programs that already take potential impacts into account through the building permit or site design review processes, such as freeboard requirements enacted through Section 31-416.2 of the Unified Development Ordinance. C. The City of Suffolk Administrator will review the resiliency assessment form and narrative along with the water quality impact assessment and determine whether the anticipated impacts necessitate an alteration or conditions to the proposed project or implementation of an adaptation measure for approval. (i) In considering whether a requirement for project alteration or adaptation measure is appropriate, the City of Suffolk Administrator will ensure that the proposed alteration or adaptation measure is practical, achievable, and necessary to mitigate the identified impact. (ii) Where possible, consideration will be given to modifying the proposed development size or location, such that the extent of land disturbance or impervious cover can be reduced to avoid or minimize the area or areas of the parcel that the assessment indicates will be impacted. (iii) If the resiliency assessment reveals that impacts on the parcel can be addressed by structural design or siting alterations, then supplemental information on the potential alterations shall be provided for consideration by the City of Suffolk Administrator. Supplemental information may include additional sketches or plans, including plan and section views, building specifications, and other supporting materials. (iv) Approval may be conditioned on the implementation of the proposed alterations, conditions, or adaptation measure. (v) The resiliency assessment may also indicate that no alterations, conditions, or adaptation measures are required, in which case the applicant may proceed through the remainder of the approval process. D. Should an impact from sea-level rise, storm surge, or flooding be identified that exceeds available design alterations, approval of the proposed project should then be conditioned with the requirement for an adaptation measure and the following information provided: (i) Describe the proposed adaptation measure(s) for the site as selected from one of the sources listed in Section 31-415.1(i)(1) of this Ordinance and submit documentation of the proposed adaptation measure and its suitability for use on the site, such as design specifications, construction methods and materials that will provide shoreline stabilization until vegetation is established, and a proposed maintenance plan. (ii) Describe how the selected adaptation measure meets the requirement for being a nature-based solution. (iii) Describe how the selected adaptation measure(s) comply with applicable regulatory or permitting requirements. Submit a water quality impact assessment pursuant to Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance and a site plan pursuant to Section 31-415.1(i) of this Ordinance detailing the proposed placement of the adaptation measure, existing and proposed topography and vegetation, proposed limits of clearing and grading, and mitigation for the area of land disturbance within the RPA. Additionally, provide documentation of as-built documentation of the final design and installation, including photographs, and final inspection is required upon completion of installation. E. The resiliency assessment may be submitted as a standalone document as part of the plan of development process or it may be submitted as part of a water quality impact assessment pursuant to Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance for those projects disturbing less than 2,500 square feet. F. Based upon the assessment, the City of Suffolk Administrator shall, as necessary and appropriate, require conditions, alterations, or the installation of adaptation measures as part of the proposed land development consistent with the requirements of the Act and this chapter. (j) PLAN OF DEVELOPMENT PROCESS. (1) Any development or redevelopment in the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area shall be accomplished through a plan of development process consistent with Va. Code §15.2-2286 A(8). Approval shall be rendered for a plan prior to commencement of any land-disturbing activity on site or the issuance of any building permit. Plans and information required under this subsection may be coordinated or combined as deemed appropriate by the City of Suffolk Administrator. All information required in this subsection shall be drawn to the same scale as the preliminary site plan or final subdivision plat and certified as complete and accurate by persons duly licensed by the Commonwealth of Virginia to practice as such. Any applicant, or potential applicant, may confer with such departments and other agencies of the City of Suffolk as may be appropriate concerning a general development or redevelopment proposal before submission of an application. Such a conference shall not be construed as an application for approval of such a proposal. (2) Except as otherwise provided herein, the plan of development process for any development or redevelopment in a CBPA, shall consist of the plans and information identified below: A. A site plan or a subdivision plat which meets the requirements of the Section 31-307 or Article 5 of the Unified Development Ordinance, as appropriate, and which includes the following information: (i) RPA and RMA boundaries (or a note stating that the remainder of a parcel is designated as RMA) as identified during the site-specific CBPA determination conducted pursuant to Section 31-415.1(f) of this Ordinance, and the location of the following environmental features: a) Tidal wetlands. b) Tidal shores. c) Nontidal wetlands connected by surface flow and contiguous to tidal wetlands or water bodies with perennial flow, the location and extent of which shall be determined in accordance with the procedures specified in the United States Corps of Engineers’ Wetland Delineation Manual, Technical Report Y-87-1, January 1987, Final Report, the Regional Supplement to the Army Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual: Atlantic and Gulf Coastal Plain Region (Version 2.0) ERDC/EL TR 10-20, and the Regional Supplement to the Army Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual: Eastern Mountain and Piedmont Region (Version 2.0) ERDC/EL TR 12-9. d) Drinking water reservoirs. e) A buffer area not less than 100 feet in width and located adjacent to and landward of the components listed above and along both sides of any water body with perennial flow. (ii) Evidence of the site specific CBPA boundary determination, inclusive of perennial flow determinations and wetland delineation studies, as appropriate to the site conditions. (iii) Limits of land disturbance and all areas of clearing, grading, access ways and staging areas and the total area of land disturbance, as well as total area of land disturbance proposed within the RPA. (iv) Depiction of the buildable areas that are allowed on each lot. Buildable areas shall be based upon the performance criteria specified in 31-415.1(f). (v) Plat notations of the requirement to retain an undisturbed and vegetated 100-foot wide buffer area, as specified in 31-415.1(g); septic pump-out and 100% reserve drainfield site requirements for onsite sewage treatment systems, when applicable; and the permissibility of only water dependent facilities or redevelopment in Resource Protection Areas, including the 100-foot wide buffer area. (vi) Location of all approved existing and proposed septic tanks and drainfield areas, including reserve areas, and the location of all existing and proposed wells and utilities. (vi) A statement that excavation material and debris from construction shall be disposed of in a lawful manner. (vii) Existing and proposed impervious cover and the total amount of impervious cover proposed for the site, as well as total amount of impervious cover proposed within the RPA. (viii) Evidence that all applicable wetland permits required by law have been obtained prior to authorization of grading or other on-site activities shall be provided. (ix) Additional information shall be requested, and reasonable and appropriate conditions shall be imposed by the City of Suffolk Administrator, if necessary, to preserve the purpose and intent of this Ordinance. B. A water quality impact assessment, according to Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance. C. A resiliency assessment, according to Section 31-415.1(i) of this Ordinance. D. A landscape plan that delineates or complies with the following: (i) The location, size, and description of existing and proposed plant material. All existing canopy trees and understory trees on the site of six (6) inches or greater diameter at breast height shall be shown. Where there are groups of trees, stands of trees may be outlined, except for mature trees, which shall be individually identified. The location and specific number of mature trees, canopy trees, and understory trees to be preserved on the project site shall be indicated on the plan. Mature trees, canopy trees, and understory trees and other vegetation to be disturbed or removed to create a desired construction footprint shall be clearly identified. Mature trees shall be protected during development and only removed where necessary, including to provide for the proposed use or development. (ii) A description of the proposed measures for mitigation shall include (i) a replanting schedule for trees and other vegetation removed for construction, including a list of plants and trees to be used for mitigation; (ii) a demonstration that the design of the plan will preserve mature trees, canopy trees, and understory trees and other vegetation on the site and will provide maximum erosion control and overland flow benefits from such vegetation; (iii) a demonstration that existing plants are to be used to the greatest extent possible; and (iv) a demonstration that where the planting of new trees or vegetation is required, native species will be used to the greatest extent possible. If no mitigation or planting is required, existing trees may be delineated as required above on the site plan or subdivision plat. (iii) A delineation of any required buffer area and any plant material to be added to establish or supplement the buffer area. Trees should be used for mitigation and supplementation of the buffer area to the extent practicable and as appropriate to the site conditions and project specifications. Where possible use of native species is preferred. (iv) Within the buffer area, identification of the trees to be removed for sight lines, vistas, access paths, best management practices, and shoreline stabilization projects, as applicable, and the location, type, and size of replacement trees and vegetation proposed for mitigation. Mature trees shall be preserved and trimmed or pruned in lieu of removal as site conditions permit. Any removal of mature trees should be limited to the fewest number of trees feasible. When mature trees are removed to provide for sight lines and vistas, access paths or BMPs, they shall be replaced with trees as appropriate to site conditions. The location, type and size of replacement trees and other vegetation proposed for mitigation for the removal of trees from the buffer area shall be shown on the landscape plan. (v) A depiction of grade changes or other work adjacent to trees within the RPA and RMA which would adversely affect them. Specifications shall be provided as to how grade, drainage, and aeration would be maintained around trees to be preserved. Specifications shall also be provided for the protection of existing trees and vegetation during site work and construction. (vi) A description of the limits of clearing of existing vegetation, based on all anticipated improvements within the RPA and RMA, including buildings, drives, and utilities. (vii) All supplementary or replacement plant materials shall be in a healthy condition. Plant materials shall conform to the standards of the most recent edition of the American Standard for Nursery Stock, published by the American Nursery and Landscape Association, and shall be installed according to standard planting practices and procedures. (viii) Where areas to be preserved within the RPA are encroached upon and trees are removed without approval, replacement of existing removed trees and other vegetation shall be achieved at a ratio of three (3) trees planted to one (1) tree greater than six (6) inches diameter at breast height removed, or by such other measures as in the judgment of the City of Suffolk Administrator will adequately compensate for the removal of such trees and other vegetation. Replacement trees shall be a minimum two (2) to two and one-half (2½) inches caliper at the time of planting. (4) Performance and bonding requirements. A. For projects greater than 2,500 square feet of disturbance within the RPA, prior to the approval of the site development plan within the RPA, the applicant shall furnish to the City of Suffolk Administrator a reasonable performance bond, cash escrow, letter of credit or other legal surety, or any combination thereof acceptable to the Suffolk City Attorney, to ensure that measures may be taken by the City of Suffolk, at the applicant's expense, should the applicant fail, after proper notice, within the time specified, to initiate or maintain appropriate conservation action which may be required of them as a result of the approved site development. B. After all required actions of the approved plan have been completed, the applicant shall submit to the City of Suffolk Administrator a request for a final inspection. C. Once the final inspection is approved, the surety provided will be kept for 12 months to ensure the plant material has survived. (k) NONCONFORMING BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES. (1) The City of Suffolk Administrator may permit the continued use, but not necessarily the expansion, of any structure in existence on October 1, 1989. The City of Suffolk Administrator may waive or modify the criteria of this Section for structures on legal nonconforming lots or parcels, provided that: A. There will be no net increase in nonpoint source pollutant load. B. Any development or land disturbance exceeding 2,500 square feet complies with all erosion and sediment control requirements. (2) Additions and modifications to existing legal principal structures may be processed through an administrative review of the application by the City of Suffolk Administrator and shall be subject to the findings required by Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance. Such findings are to be made by the City of Suffolk Administrator, but without the requirement for a public hearing. This provision shall not apply to accessory structures, as defined by Section 31- 415.1(c) of this Ordinance, which are not permitted uses within the Resource Protection Area and require submittal to the formal exception process. (3) A nonconforming use and development waiver shall become null and void 12 months from the date of issuance if the City of Suffolk Administrator documents that no substantial work has commenced. The City of Suffolk Administrator shall notify the permittee of the revocation of the waiver in writing. (4) Reconstruction or restoration of any nonconforming building or structure destroyed or damaged by reason of casualty loss shall be allowed, provided that the area encompassed by such building or structure, as reconstructed or restored, is not extended or enlarged and is subject to the requirements of this Ordinance and other City of Suffolk ordinances. (l) EXEMPTIONS. (1) Exemptions for public utilities, railroads, and public roads, and facilities. A. Construction, installation, operation and maintenance of electric, natural gas, fiber optic, and telephone transmission lines, railroads, public roads and their appurtenant structures are deemed to comply with this Ordinance provided such activities are performed in accordance with (i) regulations promulgated pursuant to the Virginia Erosion and Stormwater Management Act (Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:24 et seq.); (ii) an erosion and sediment control plan and a stormwater management plan approved by the City of Suffolk as required; or (iii) local water quality criteria at least as stringent as the state requirements. Exemptions for public roads shall also be subject to the following conditions: (i) The road alignment and design are optimized and consistent with other applicable requirements to prevent or otherwise minimize (i) encroachments into Resource Protection Areas and (ii) adverse effects on water quality. (ii) Such appurtenant structures shall include, but are not limited to, bridges, guard rails, lighting and traffic-control devices, fences, and berms. B. Construction, installation and maintenance of water, sewer, underground cable and telecommunications lines and natural gas lines owned or permitted by the City of Suffolk, or a regional service authority, shall be exempt from this Ordinance provided that: (i) To the degree practicable, the location of such utilities and facilities shall be outside RPAs. (ii) No more land shall be disturbed than is necessary to provide for the proposed installation. (iii) All construction, installation, and maintenance of such utilities and facilities shall comply with all applicable state and federal requirements and permits and shall be designed and constructed in a manner that protects water quality. (iv) Any land disturbance exceeding an area of two 2,500 square feet complies with all requirements of the Erosion and Stormwater Management Ordinance. (2) Exemptions in Resource Protection Areas. Land disturbances in RPAs associated with water wells, passive recreation facilities such as boardwalks, trails and pathways, and historic preservation and archaeological activities may be exempt from the criteria of Section 31-415.1 (g) provided that the following are demonstrated to the satisfaction of the City of Suffolk Administrator: A. Any required permits, except those to which this exemption specifically applies, shall have been issued. B. Sufficient and reasonable proof is submitted to the City of Suffolk Administrator that the intended activity will not deteriorate water quality. C. Any land disturbance exceeding an area of 2,500 square feet shall comply with the Erosion and Stormwater Management Ordinance. (3) Exemptions for silvicultural activities. Silvicultural activities located within designated CBPAs shall be exempt from the requirements of this Ordinance provided that silvicultural operations adhere to water quality protection procedures prescribed by the Virginia Department of Forestry in the Fifth Edition (March 2011) of Virginia’s Forestry Best Management Practices for Water Quality Technical Manual. The Virginia Department of Forestry will oversee and document installation of best management practices and will monitor in-stream impacts of forestry operations in CBPAs. A. The exemption of silvicultural activities only applies to those operations that install and properly implement all necessary forestry best management practices. Failure to properly install or maintain any of the forestry BMPs within the RPA would automatically eliminate the silvicultural exemption status under this Section and may subject the property owner to penalties for violations under Section 31-415.1(o) of this Ordinance and possible enforcement actions from the Virginia Department of Forestry. B. Silviculture entails the continued production of trees, wood, or wood products and any related actions that occur during the management of the land for these purposes. Silviculture does not include clearing a site in preparation for future development nor does it involve the removal of stumps for any reason. If the City of Suffolk Administrator determines that the intended use of the site is not silvicultural in nature, all exemptions from this Ordinance are null and void and the project would have to comply with all requirements of this Ordinance. This may include preserving the full 100-foot RPA buffer or replanting it in woody vegetation, if necessary, and full compliance with all erosion and sediment control requirements if more than 2,500 square feet of land has been disturbed. (4) Exemptions for living shorelines. A living shoreline, as defined by Va. Code § 28.2-104.1 is exempt from additional performance criteria requirements of Section 31-415.1(g), including a water quality impact assessment in Section 31-415.1(h), provided the project minimizes land disturbance, maintains or establishes a vegetative buffer inland of the living shoreline, complies with the fill conditions in Section 31-415.1(g)(4)(A)(v)(e) of this Ordinance, and receives approval from the VMRC or the local wetlands board, as applicable. (m) ADIMINSTRATIVE WAIVERS AND FORMAL EXCEPTIONS. (1) General requirements. Applications for administrative waivers and formal exceptions from the requirements of Section 31-415.1(f), general performance standards, and Section 31-415.1(g), development standards for RPAs, shall be made in writing and filed with the City of Suffolk Administrator. Such applications shall identify any potential impacts of the proposed waiver or exception on water quality and on lands within the RPA through the performance of a water quality impact assessment, pursuant to Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance, and shall examine the impacts of sea level rise, storm surge, and flooding on the project through the performance of a resiliency assessment, pursuant to Section 31-415.1(i) Section 109. Each application for a administrative waiver and formal exception shall be approved, denied, or approved with conditions according to the review process outlined in the following subsections. No application for an administrative waiver or formal exception to Sections 31- 415.1(f) and 31-415.1(g) of this Ordinance shall be granted under this Section without meeting the following findings: A. The requested administrative waiver or formal exception to the criteria is the minimum necessary to afford relief. B. Granting the administrative waiver or formal exception will not confer upon the applicant any special privileges that are denied by this Ordinance to other property owners who are subject to its provisions and who are similarly situated. C. The administrative waiver or formal exception is in harmony with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance and is not of substantial detriment to water quality. D. The administrative waiver or formal exception request is not based upon conditions or circumstances that are self-created or self-imposed. E. Reasonable and appropriate conditions are imposed, as warranted, that will prevent the allowed activity from causing a degradation of water quality. F. Other findings, as appropriate to the City of Suffolk Administrator, are met. (2) Administrative waivers. The City of Suffolk Administrator shall approve, deny, or approve with conditions an application requesting an administrative waiver following the review of a complete application, as defined under Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance. No such application shall be accepted by the City of Suffolk Administrator unless accompanied by a WQIA, Resiliency Assessment, and a nonrefundable fee in the amount determined by the Suffolk City Council. A. The City of Suffolk Administrator may establish such review policies as they deem expedient in implementing the intent of this Ordinance. In approving an application, the City of Suffolk Administrator shall, if warranted, include reasonable and appropriate conditions that will prevent the degradation of water quality. B. No administrative waiver or formal exception shall be granted to Section 31-415.1(f) of this Ordinance, general performance standards, unless the City of Suffolk Administrator makes the findings required in Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance. C. Administrative waivers to provisions within sections of this Ordinance other than Section 31-415.1(f) or Section 31-415.1(g) 106 or 107 may be granted, provided that: (i) Administrative waivers to the criteria shall be the minimum necessary to afford relief. (ii) Reasonable and appropriate conditions upon any administrative waiver granted shall be imposed, as necessary, so that the purpose and intent of this Ordinance is preserved. (3) Formal exceptions. Exceptions from the criteria of Section 31-415.1(g) of this Ordinance, development criteria for Resource Protection Areas, require public notice and a public hearing before the Board. Complete applications for an exception shall be submitted to the City of Suffolk Administrator for review and evaluation prior to being forwarded to the Board for consideration. No such application for an exception shall be accepted by the City of Suffolk Administrator unless accompanied by a WQIA, Resiliency Assessment, and a nonrefundable fee in the amount determined by the Suffolk City Council. Such fee shall include all costs of notification and advertising. A. The City of Suffolk Administrator shall review complete applications for an exception to the requirements of Section 31-415.1(g) of this Ordinance, including the water quality impact assessment and resiliency assessment, and provide the Board and the applicant with copies of the submitted materials, an evaluation of the required findings and potential impacts of the proposed exception, and such other information as may aid the Board in considering the application no less than five (5) days prior to the scheduled hearing. B. Not later than 60 days after the receipt of a complete application, the Board shall hold a public hearing on such application. Notice of the time and place of the hearing shall be published no less than once per week for two (2) consecutive weeks prior to such hearing in a newspaper having a general circulation in the City of Suffolk. The second such notice shall appear not less than five (5) days nor more than 21 days prior to the hearing. C. The Board shall notify, by first class mail, all property owners adjacent to the subject property and each waterfront property owner across the waterway from the subject property, if the water body is less than 500-feet wide, of the public hearing at least five (5) days prior to the hearing. D. The Board may make, alter and rescind rules for its procedures not inconsistent with the provisions of this Ordinance; provided, however, that a quorum shall be not less than a majority of the members of the Board, and provided further, that the concurring vote of a majority of the members of the Board present and voting shall be required to grant any exception. E. The Board shall approve, deny, or approve with conditions an application requesting an exception to the requirements of Section 31-415.1(g) following the review of a complete application and a determination that the proposed project meets the findings required by Section 31-415.1(m)(1) above. (4) No application for relief from Section 31-415.1(f) or Section 31-415.1(g) of this Ordinance shall be considered complete where a resiliency assessment, as outlined in Section 31- 415.1(i) of this Ordinance has not occurred or the proposed adaptation measure allows for the use of fill in a Resource Protection Area in contravention to the requirements of Section 31-415.1(g)(4)(A)(v)(e) of this Ordinance. (n) APPEALS. (1) Any order, determination or decision made by the City of Suffolk Administrator or any administrative officer in the administration or enforcement of this Ordinance, including any decision on an application for an administrative waiver, may be appealed by any person aggrieved by the decision to the Board by application filed with the City of Suffolk Administrator within 15 days from the date of such order, determination or decision. Such application shall state with particularity the grounds of such appeal. Any application failing to do so shall be rejected by the City of Suffolk Administrator. The filing of an appeal shall not stay any proceedings in furtherance of the action appealed from. (2) The fees and notice requirements for appeals under subsection (1) hereof shall be as set forth in Section 31-415.1(m) of this Ordinance. (3) Any party aggrieved of a decision of the Board may, within 30 days of the date of such decision, petition the circuit court to review such decision. The procedure in such cases shall be as provided in Va. Code § 15.2-2314, as amended. (4) No party having failed to appear at the hearing before the City of Suffolk Administrator or the Board and having failed to object to the application at that time shall be deemed to be an aggrieved party; provided, however, that the City of Suffolk shall have standing to appeal any decision of the City of Suffolk Administrator or the Board irrespective of not having appeared before the City of Suffolk Administrator or the Board as otherwise required by this Ordinance. (5) The circuit court may affirm, reverse, or modify any decision of the Board, and may impose any reasonable conditions in its judgment; provided, however, that no decision of the Board shall be disturbed unless the court shall find: A. The decision appealed from was based upon the erroneous application of the criteria set forth in Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance or was based upon grounds other than those set forth therein. B. There was no substantial evidence upon which the Board could have made all findings required by Section 31-415.1(m)(1) of this Ordinance. C. The decision of the Board was plainly wrong. D. The Board failed to impose reasonable and appropriate conditions intended to prevent the variance from causing or contributing to a degradation of water quality. (o) VIOLATIONS; PENALTIES. (1) Without limiting the remedies which may be pursued under this Ordinance, any person who (i) violates any provision of this Ordinance or (ii) who violates, fails, neglects, or refuses to obey any notice, order, rule, regulation, variance, exception, or permit condition authorized under this Ordinance shall, upon such finding by the circuit court, be assessed a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000.00) for each day of violation. Such penalties may, at the discretion of the court assessing them, be directed to be paid into the treasury of the City of Suffolk for the purpose of abating environmental damage to or restoring Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas within the City of Suffolk, in such a manner as the court may direct by order, except that in the event the City of Suffolk or its agent is the violator, the court shall direct the penalty to be paid into the treasury of the Commonwealth. (2) Without limiting the remedies which may be pursued under this Ordinance, and with the consent of any person who has violated any provision of this Ordinance, or who has violated, failed, neglected, or refused to obey any notice, order, rule, regulation, variance, exception, or permit condition authorized under this Ordinance, the Suffolk City Council may provide for the issuance of an order against such person for the one-time payment of civil charges for each violation in specific sums, not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000.00) for each violation. Such civil charges shall be paid into the treasury of the City of Suffolk for the purpose of abating environmental damage or restoring Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas in the City of Suffolk, except that in the event the City of Suffolk or its agent is the violator, the civil charges shall be paid into the treasury of the Commonwealth. Civil charges shall be in lieu of any appropriate civil penalty that could be imposed under Section 31-415.1(o)(1) of this subsection. Civil charges may be in addition to the cost of any restoration required by the Suffolk City Council. (3) In addition to, and not in lieu of, the penalties prescribed in subsections (1) and (2) hereof, the City of Suffolk may apply to the circuit court for an injunction against the continuing violation of any of the provisions of this Ordinance and may seek any other remedy authorized by law. (4) Upon notice from the City of Suffolk Administrator that any activity is being conducted in violation of any of the provisions of this Ordinance, such activity shall immediately be stopped. An order to stop work shall be in writing and shall state the nature of the violation and the conditions under which the activity may be resumed. No such order shall be effective until it shall have been tendered to the owner of the property upon which the activity is conducted or his agent or to any person conducting such activity. Any person who shall continue an activity ordered to be stopped, except as directed in the stop-work order, shall be guilty of a violation of this Ordinance. (p) SEVERABILITY. The provisions of this Ordinance shall be deemed to be severable, and if any of the provisions hereof are adjudged to be invalid or unenforceable, the remaining portions of this ordinance shall remain in full force and effect and their validity shall remain unimpaired. (q) VESTED RIGHTS. The provisions of this Ordinance shall not affect the vested rights of any person under existing law. (r) ENFORCEMENT. This Ordinance shall be enforced by the City of Suffolk Administrator, who shall exercise all authority of police officers in the performance of their duties. Such authority shall include, without limitation, the authority to issue summonses directing the appearance before a court of competent jurisdiction of any person alleged to have violated any of the provisions of this Ordinance. APPENDIX B - SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS … B-13. ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTATION WITHIN CHESAPEAKE BAY PRESERVATION AREA. (a) WATER QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT. (1) PURPOSE AND INTENT. The purpose of the water quality impact assessment is to: (i) identify the impacts of the proposed development on water quality and lands within the Resource Protection Areas (RPAs) of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Overlay District and other environmentally-sensitive lands; (ii) ensure that, where development does take place within RPAs and other sensitive lands, it will be located on those portions of a site and in a manner that will be least disruptive to the natural functions of RPAs and other sensitive lands; (iii) to protect individuals from investing funds for improvements proposed for location on lands unsuited for such development because of high ground water, erosion, or vulnerability to flood and storm damage; and (iv) specify mitigation which will address water quality protection. (2) WATER QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT REQUIRED. A water quality impact assessment in accordance with Section 31-415.1(h) of this Ordinance is required for any proposed development within the CBPA, including any buffer area encroachment or modification enchroachment as provided for in the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Overlay District regulations. (3) RESILIENCY ASSESSMENT REQUIRED. A resiliency assessment in accordance with Section 31-415.1(i) of this Ordinance is required for any proposed development within the CBPA, including any buffer area encroachment or modification as provided for in the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Overlay District regulations. (b) MINOR WATER QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT. A minor water quality impact assessment pertains only to development within CBPAs which causes no more than 10,000 square feet of land disturbance and requires any modification or reductions of the landward 50 feet of the 100 foot buffer area. A minor assessment must demonstrate through acceptable calculations that the remaining buffer area and necessary best management practices will result in removal of no less than 75 percent of sediments and 40 percent of nutrients from post-development stormwater runoff and that will prevent runoff and filter nonpoint source pollution the equivalent of the full undisturbed 100-foot buffer. A minor assessment shall include a site drawing to scale which shows the following: (1) Location of the components of the RPA, including the 100 foot buffer areas; (2) Location and nature of the proposed encroachment into the buffer area, including: type of paving material; areas of clearing or grading including the amount of disturbance with the RPA; location of any structures, drives for other impervious cover; and sewage disposal systems or reserve drain field sites; (3) Type and location of proposed best management practices to mitigate the proposed encroachment. (4) Location of existing vegetation and re-vegetated areas as shown on the site drawing. (c) MAJOR WATER QUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT. A major water quality impact assessment shall be required for any development which (i) exceeds 10,000 square feet of land disturbance within CBPA's and requires any modification or reduction of the landward 50 feet of the 100-foot buffer area; (ii) disturbs any portion of any other component of an RPA or disturbs any portion of the buffer area within 50 feet of any other component of an RPA; or (iii) is located in an RMA and is deemed necessary by the Planning and Community Development Director. The information required in this Section shall be considered a minimum, unless the Director determines that some of the elements are unnecessary due to the scope and nature of the proposed use and development of land. The following elements shall be included in the preparation and submission of a major water quality assessment: (1) All of the information required in a minor water quality impact assessment, as specified above; (2) A hydrogeological element that: A. Describes the existing topography, soils, hydrology and geology of the site and adjacent lands. B. Describes the impacts of the proposed development on topography, soils, hydrology and geology on the site and adjacent lands. C. Indicates the following: (i) Disturbance or destruction of wetlands and justification for such action; (ii) Disruptions or reductions in the supply of water to wetlands, streams, lakes, rivers or other water bodies; (iii) Disruptions to existing hydrology including wetland and stream circulation patterns; (iv) Source location and description of proposed fill material; (v) Location of dredge material and location of dumping area for such material; (vi) Location of and impacts on shellfish beds, submerged aquatic vegetation, and fish spawning areas; (vii) Estimation of pre- and post-development pollutant loads in runoff; (viii) Estimation of percent increase in impervious surface on site and types of surfacing materials used; (ix) Percent of site to be cleared for project; (x) Anticipation, duration and phasing schedule of construction project; (xi) Listing of all requisite permits from all applicable agencies necessary to develop project. (xii) Describes the proposed mitigation measures for the potential hydrogeological impacts. Potential mitigation measures include: 1. Proposed erosion and sediment control concepts; concepts may include minimizing the extent of the cleared area, perimeter controls, reduction of runoff velocities, measures to stabilize disturbed areas, schedule and personnel for site inspection; 2. Proposed stormwater management system; 3. Creation of wetlands to replace those lost; 4. Minimizing cut and fill. (3) A landscape element that: A. Identifies and delineates the location of all significant plant material, including all trees on site six (6) inches or greater diameter at breast heights. Where there are groups of trees, stands may be outlined. B. Describes the impacts the development or use will have on the existing vegetation. Information should include: (i) General limits of clearing, based on all anticipated improvements, including buildings, drives and utilities; (ii) Clear delineation of all trees which will be removed; (iii) Description of plant species to be disturbed or removed. (iv) Describes the potential measures for mitigation. Possible mitigation measures include: 1. Replanting schedule for trees and other significant vegetation removed for construction, including a list of possible plants and trees to be used; 2. Demonstration that the design of the plan will preserve to the greatest extent possible any significant trees and vegetation on the site and will provide maximum erosion control and overland flow benefits from such vegetation. 3. Demonstration that indigenous plants are to be used to the greatest extent possible. (4) A wastewater element, where applicable, that: A. Includes calculations and locations of anticipated drain field or wastewater irrigation areas; B. Provides justification for sewer line locations in environmentally sensitive areas, where applicable, and describes construction techniques and standards; C. Discusses any proposed on- site collection and treatment systems, their treatment levels, and impacts on receiving watercourses. D. Describes the potential impacts of the proposed wastewater systems, including the proposed mitigative measures for these impacts. E. Identification of the existing characteristics and conditions of sensitive lands included as components of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas, as defined in this Article. F. Identification of the natural processes and ecological relationships inherent in the site, and an assessment of the impact of the proposed use and development of land on these processes and relationships. (bd) SUBMISSION AND REVIEW REQUIREMENTS. (1) Five copies of all sSite drawings and other applicable information as required by Subsections (ab) and (c) above shall be submitted to the Director for review. (2) All information required in this Section shall be certified as complete and accurate by a professional engineer or land surveyor, or landscape architect licensed to practice in the Commonwealth of Virginia. (3) A minor water quality impact assessment shall be prepared and submitted to and reviewed by the Director in conjunction with Section 31-415.1(g)(d) (development review) of this Ordinance. (4) A major water quality impact assessment shall be prepared and submitted to and reviewed by the Director in conjunction with a request for rezoning, conditional use permit, or in conjunction with Section 31-415.1(g)(d) of this Ordinance. (5) As part of any major water quality impact assessment submittal, the Zoning Administrator may require review by the Chesapeake Bay Local Assistance Department (CBLAD). Upon receipt of a major water quality impact assessment, the Director will determine if such review is desired and may request CBLAD to review the assessment and respond with written comments. Any comments by CBLAD will be incorporated provided that such comments are provided by CBLAD within 30 days of the request. (e) EVALUATION PROCEDURE. (1) Upon the completed review of a minor water quality impact assessment, the Director will determine if any proposed modification or reduction to the buffer area is consistent with the provisions of Section 31-415.1 and make a finding based upon the following criteria. (2) The necessity of proposed encroachment and the ability to place improvements elsewhere on the site to avoid disturbance of the buffer area; (3) Impervious surface is minimized; (4) Proposed best management practices, where required, achieve the requisite reductions in pollutant loadings; (5) The development, as proposed, meets the purpose and intent of Section 31-415.1; (6) The cumulative impact of the proposed development, when considered in relation to other development in the vicinity, both existing and proposed, will not result in a significant degradation of water quality. (7) Proposed mitigation measures will work to retain all buffer area features and result in minimal disturbance to all components of the RPA. (f) Upon the completed review of a major water quality impact assessment, the Director will determine if the proposed development is consistent with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance and make a finding based upon the following criteria in conjunction with Section 31-415.1. (1) Within the RPA, the proposed development is water dependent or redevelopment; (2) The disturbance of wetlands will be minimized; (3) The development will not result in significant disruption of the hydrology of the site; (4) The development will not result in significant degradation to aquatic vegetation or life; (5) The development will not result in unnecessary destruction of plant materials on site; (6) Proposed erosion and sediment control concepts are adequate to achieve the reductions in runoff and prevent off-site sedimentation; (7) Proposed stormwater management concepts are adequate to control the stormwater runoff to achieve the required standard for pollutant control; (8) Proposed re-vegetation of disturbed areas will provide optimum erosion and sediment control benefits as well as runoff with pollutant removal functions equivalent to a full 100-foot undisturbed buffer area; (9) The design and location of any proposed drainfield will be in accordance with the requirements of Section 31-415.1 of this Ordinance; (10) The development, as proposed, is consistent with the purpose and intent of the preservation area district; (11) The cumulative impact of the proposed development, when considered in relation to other development in the vicinity, both existing and proposed, will not result in a significant degradation of water quality. (g) WETLANDS AND STREAM DELINEATION. ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT. An wetlands and stream delineation environmental assessment shall be submitted with the water quality impact assessment and shall clearly delineate the following: (1) Tidal wetlands, tidal shores, nontidal wetlands connected by surface flow and contiguous to tidal wetlands or water bodies with perennial flow, highly erodible soils, highly permeable soils and floodplains. (2) A 100-foot buffer area located adjacent to and landward of any of the other components of the RPA as defined in Appendix A to this Ordinance. The plans shall indicate the location and type of all required buffer areas and clearly delineate the extent of the RPA boundaries. (3) Any planting, buffer management mitigation, buffer alteration or similar plans or information as required elsewhere in this Ordinance. (34) Wetlands delineation using Federal Manual for Identifying and Delineating Jurisdictional Wetlands (1987). (h) A stormwater management plan containing the following: (1) Location and design of all planned stormwater control devices. (2) Procedures for implementing non-structural stormwater control practices and techniques. (3) Pre- and post-development non-point source pollutant loadings with supporting documentation of all utilized coefficients and calculations. (4) For stormwater facilities, verification of structural soundness shall be certified by the appropriate authorized design professional. (5) The stormwater management plan shall establish a long-term schedule for inspection and maintenance of stormwater management facilities and include all maintenance requirements and persons responsible for performing the maintenance. When the designated maintenance responsibility is with a party other than the City of Suffolk then a maintenance agreement shall be executed between the responsible party and the City. (6) The stormwater management plan shall be consistent with Article 6, sections 31-601 and 31-611 and Section B-12 of this Ordinance. (7) On-site facilities for the ultimate development of the contributing watershed. (8) All engineering calculations shall be performed according to the Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook. (i) An erosion and sediment control plan shall be submitted that satisfies the requirements of Section 31-415.1 and the Erosion and Sedimentation Control Regulation of this Ordinance. … STAFF REPORT DESCRIPTION COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT CPA2026-001: Presented for your consideration, attached, please find proposed amendments to the Suffolk 2045, The city of Suffolk Comprehensive Plan (hereafter referred to as the 2045 Comprehensive Plan) in order to address the changes in Virginia State Code regarding review of solar farm applications . The purpose of the text amendment is to update and refine the 2045 Comprehensive Plan of the City of Suffolk to reflect the priority to preserve prime agricultural soils, mitigate rural land fragmentation, and establish an explicit policy foundation for regulatory limitations, including cumulative acreage limits and a cap on approval of utility-scale solar development. APPLICANT: The proposed plan text amendment has been initiated by the City of Suffolk. PUBLIC NOTICE: This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements set forth in Section 15.2- 2204 of the Code of Virginia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance. STAFF ANALYSIS ISSUE AND BACKGROUND This proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendment (CPA) aims to amend the 2045 Comprehensive Plan text to clearly identify the importance of limiting solar facilities on agricultural land and to ensure that the limitation on acreage dedicated to solar facilities is directly referenced as a strategy in the Comprehensive Plan. Recent legislation passed by the Virginia General Assembly , most notably House Bill 711 and Senate Bill 347, along with provisions in the Code of Virginia (such as Sections 15.2- 2232 and 15.2-2316.6 through 15.2- 2316.9) have reshaped how local governments in the Commonwealth evaluate and regulate utility-scale solar facilities. Pursuant to Section 15.2 -2232 of the Code of Virginia, any public utility or solar energy facility must be evaluated for "Substantial Accord" with the locality's adopted Comprehensive Plan prior to establishment. Under statutory guidelines and recent legisl ative enactments governing utility- scale solar regulation , local authority to condition approvals, impose siting criteria, or enforce cumulative acreage limits hinges upon explicit policy support established within the local long- range planning document. To enhance the locality’s legally defensible regulatory framework for conditional approvals, the City intends to anchor local utility-scale restrictions directly within the 2045 Comprehensive Plan narrative and outcomes. Driven by statewide energy policy and regional grid interconnectivity, utility- scale solar developers have targeted rural acreage across Hampton Roads. In Suffolk, market demand is concentrated heavily on agricultural parcels situated near major electrical transmission lines and Planning Commission August 18, 2026 CPA2026-001 Page 2 of 2 substations. Unregulated land conversion risks converting active cropland into industrial energy uses, threatening the long-term viability of the City’s agricultural supply chains, local agribusiness operations, and agrarian support services. Absent comprehensive policy controls, market forces and state regulatory changes may continue to enable the persistent conversion of active farmland, undermining the City’s rural footprint. Pursuant to the state’s legislative framework and planning standards, staff proposes to incorporate targeted text amendments into Chapter 2 (Land Use & Environment) and Chapter 8 (Outcomes & Actions Matrix) of the 2045 Comprehensive Plan: • Text Amendment in Narrative (Chapter 2): Incorporating language establishing that market-driven solar conversion threatens active farmland continuity, and declaring that targeted regulatory interventions , such as implementing a sensible cap on total approved Conditional Use Permits (CUPs) and cumulative acreage limits , are required to safeguard Suffolk’s rural economy. • Modification to Action Item L.6.3 (Chapter 8 Matrix): Amending Action L.6.3 to transition it from a passive monitoring strategy to an active policy directive, explicitly authorizing a citywide cap on approved Conditional Use Permits (CUPs) and set maximum cumulative acreage limits for utility-scale solar facilities. RECOMMENDATION Overall, staff propose this Comprehensive Plan Amendment to protect prime farmland, prevent land fragmentation, and establish policy authority for UDO solar limitations, including cumulative acreage caps and CUP limits , in accordance with State Code. In that regard, the proposed text amendment within the attached Exhibit “ B” is presented for your favorable consideration with a staff recommendation for approval. Attachments • Public Comments • Proposed Ordinance • Exhibit A – Planning Commission Recommendation • Exhibit B – Amendment to Chapter 2 of Suffolk 2045, The City of Suffolk Comprehensive Plan PUBLIC COMMENTS FOR CPA2026-001 Public Comment Form, CPA2026-001, Utility-Scale Solar Cap Policy 08/06/2026 2:00 PM (EDT) Public Comment Form Please be advised that this form is for public comment for CPA2026-001, only. All comments provided will be made available to Planning Commission members and the general public. All comments provided by 5:00 PM ON AUGUST 11, 2026, no less than one week prior to the Planning Commission’s scheduled meeting, will be made available to Planning Commission members and the general public and included within staff's report. All comments received after the deadline may be presented in person by the commenter at the scheduled public hearing. Page 1/2 Submission ID: b56c04fc-4795-4557-ba7a-18aec5ef2835 Receipt ID: Not supplied First Name Betty Last Name Copeland Street Address 6148 Old Myrtle Rd City Suffolk State Virginia Zip Code 23434 Comment MY HUSBAND AND I HAVE PROPERTY AT 6148 OLD MYRTLE ROAD- SUFFOLK, VA 23434. OUR PROPERTY IS NEXT TO THIS PROPERTY WHERE THE SOLAR FARM AREA IS ASKED TO BE PLACED. WE ARE ASKING CITY COUNCIL NOT TO ALLOW THIS TO BE PLACED THERE. POWER LINE/ LINES HAVE BEEN IN THIS AREA AT PROPOSED ENTRANCE FOR YEARS. THEY TOO HUM 24 HRS A DAY. ALSO THIS AREA AT THE ENTRANCE SITE SITS ADJACENT TO THE CEMETERY AS WELL. THIS CEMETERY WOULD BE AFFECTED AND IS ABOUT 100 FEET FROM IT. THE AREAS LOCATION IS ALSO WETLAND. THE ANIMALS ARE GOING TO BE AFFECTED AS WELL AS THE FARM LAND THAT HAS BEEN THERE MANY YEARS. ALSO THE ROADS ARE EXTREMELY NARROW. BARELY PASSABLE WHERE MANY ACCIDENTS HAVE HAPPENED. FIRE AND RESCUE AS WELL, DEATHS, AND JUST THE CURVE AT THE OLD MYRTLE RD AND ARCHERS MILL RD IS ON A SLIGHT ANGLE CAUSES THE ROAD TO BE SLIPPERY. THE SOLAR FARM PROBLEMS CONCERNS OF THE NOISE LEVELS, WATER AND DISTANCE TO AIDE DUE TO FIRES IN THIS AREA, "OUR" WATER SUPPLY, AND THE DETERIORATION IN THE PANELS. IS IT SAFE TO REGROW OUR FOOD IN THIS SOIL? DO YOU HAVE THE PAPER WORK TO BACK UP THIS APPLICATION ALL LAWS? "DO YOU WANT THIS IN YOUR BACK YARD?" AS IS NEEDED FOR THIS TYPE OF APPLICATION WE HAVE FOUND FROM PAST SOLAR FARM APPS ALL INFO HAS NOT BEEN RESEARCHED. PAST COUNCIL MEETINGS HAVE COMMENTED THIS TOO. AM ASKING YOU TO RECONSIDER AND DENEY THIS APPLICATION. STOP LOSING OUR LAND AND OUR WILD LIFE. STOP HEAVY EQUIPMENT FROM DESTROYING OUR ROADS. WHO IS GOING TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ROADS ONCE THEY ARE GONE? PLEASE DONT LET THIS SOLAR FARM COME TO THIS AREA. JUST LOOK AT THE ONE ON 460. IT LOOKS TERRIBLE. THEY DONT KEEP THIS PROPERTY CUT. 460 IS AN AWFUL SITE COMING DOWN THE ROAD. WE HAVE TO KEEP OUR PROPERTY CUT AND THEY SHOULD TOO. WE CANT WAIT 45 DAYS TO CUT OURS. THEY SHOULD KEEP IT CLEANED AS WELL. SO THE PROPOSED SITE ON OLD MYRTLE'S SOLAR FARM DO YOU THINK THATS GOING TO BE KEPT CLEAN AND CUT? I DOUBT IT. BEING PUT INTO THIS AREA THEY WANT KEPT IT ANY DIFFENT AND MAYBE WORSE IN AN AREA YOU CANT SEE BUT SO FAR. PROBABLY NOT. WE ARE ASKING SUFFOLK CITY COUNCIL TO DENY THIS APPLICATION. Page 2/2 Submission ID: b56c04fc-4795-4557-ba7a-18aec5ef2835 Receipt ID: Not supplied ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 2 OF SUFFOLK 2045, THE CITY OF SUFFOLK COMPREHENSIVE PLAN; CPA2026-001 WHEREAS, the City of Suffolk, Virginia, has initiated an amendment to Suffolk 2045, The City of Suffolk Comprehensive Plan , hereinafter referred to as the 2045 Comprehensive Plan, to reflect the priorities of preserving prime agricultural soils and to establish an explicit policy foundation for regulatory limitations, including cumulative acreage limits and a cap on approval of utility-scale solar development; and WHEREAS, the specified amendments to the 2045 Comprehensive Plan are as shown in Exhibit “B” as adopted; and, WHEREAS, said amendment has been reviewed in accordance with Section 15.2-2229 of the Code of Virginia which specifies that after the adoption of a comprehensive plan all amendments to it shall be recommended and approved and adopted, respectively, as required by Section 15.2-2204; and WHEREAS, after said review, the Planning Commission of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, has determined it is advisable to amend the 2045 Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 15.2-2223 of the Code of Virginia, the amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan has been developed following a thorough, careful, and comprehensive examination of the existing conditions and trends of growth; community goals and concerns provided by the residents of community and business leaders of the City of Suffolk; and of the probable future requirements of the City of Suffolk and its inhabitants; and WHEREAS, the amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan, has been developed with the purpose of guiding and accomplishing a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, which will best promote the health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity, and general welfare of the inhabitants; and WHEREAS, the amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan, has been advertised and reviewed by the Planning Commission in compliance with the requirements of State Law; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission has made a recommendation as stated in Exhibit "A"; and, WHEREAS, a Public Hearing before the City Council was duly advertised as required by law and held on the 16th day of September, 2026 at which public hearing the public was presented with the opportunity to comment on the proposed amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan, and following which the City Council considered the above stated issues. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, that: Section 1. Exhibit “A”, “Planning Commission Recommendation”, Exhibit “B”, “Amendments to Suffolk 2045, The City of Suffolk Comprehensive Plan ”, which are attached hereto, are hereby incorporated as part of this ordinance. Section 2. Findings. A. City Council finds that the proposed amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan is reasonable and warranted due to changes in circumstances; and has considered the following factors and finds that the proposed amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan is consistent with: 1. the existing use and character of property within the City; 3. the suitability of the property for various uses; 4. the trends of growth or change; 5. the current or future requirements of the community as to land for various purposes as determined by the population and economic studies and other studies; 6. the transportation requirements of the community; 7. the requirements for airports, housing, schools, parks, playgrounds, recreation areas and other public services; 8. the conservation of natural resources; 9. the preservation of flood plains; 10. the preservation of agricultural and forestal land; 11. the conservation of properties and their values; and 12. the encouragement of the most appropriate use of land throughout the City. Section 3. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan is hereby amended to read as provided in Exhibit “B”, as recommended by the Planning Commission in Exhibit “A”. This ordinance shall be effective upon passage and shall not be published or codified. READ AND PASSED: __________________________ TESTE: __________________________ Erika Dawley, City Clerk Approved as to Form: _______________________________________ Williams E. Hutchings, Jr., City Attorney EXHIBIT “A” RESOLUTION NO. 26-08-02 CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING COMMISSION A RESOLUTION TO PRESENT A REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL RELATING TO CPA2026-001 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 2 OF SUFFOLK 2045, THE CITY OF SUFFOLK COMPREHENSIVE PLAN WHEREAS, the City of Suffolk, Virginia has initiated an amendment to Suffolk 2045, The City of Suffolk Comprehensive Plan, hereinafter referred to as the 2045 Comprehensive Plan,to reflect the priority to preserve prime agricultural soils, mitigate rural land fragmentation, and establish an explicit policy foundation for regulatory limitations, including cumulative acreage limits and a cap on approval of utility-scale solar development; and WHEREAS, said amendment is in accordance with Section 15.2-2229 of the Code of Virginia which specifies that after the adoption of a comprehensive plan all amendments to it shall be recommended and approved and adopted, respectively, as required by Section 15.2-2204; and WHEREAS, after said review, the Planning Commission of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, has determined it is advisable to amend the 2045 Comprehensive Plan; and WHEREAS, the procedural requirements for the consideration of this request by the Planning Commission have been met. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of Suffolk, Virginia, that: Section 1. Findings. The Suffolk Planning Commission finds that the proposed amended 2045 Comprehensive Plan is reasonable and warranted due to a change in circumstances; and has considered the following factors and finds that the proposed amendment is consistent with: 1. the existing use and character of property within the City; 2. the suitability of the property for various uses; 3. the trends of growth or change; 4. the current or future requirements of the community as to land for various purposes as determined by the population and economic studies and other studies; 5. the transportation requirements of the community; 6. the requirements for airports, housing, schools, parks, playgrounds, recreation areas and other public services; 7. the conservation of natural resources; 8. the preservation of flood plains; 9. the preservation of agricultural and forestall land; 10. the conservation of properties and their values; and 11. the encouragement of the most appropriate use of land throughout the City. Section 2. Recommendation to Council. The Planning Commission recommends to the City Council of the City of Suffolk, Virginia that the proposed amendment be: a) That the 2045 Comprehensive Plan be amended as presented in Exhibit “ B” attached and that the proposed Ordinance be approved, without modification. b) Denied, and that Council not adopt the proposed Ordinance. c) Adopted with the modifications set forth on the attached listing of specific recommendations, and that Council adopt the proposed Ordinance with such modifications. READ AND ADOPTED:_________________________________ TESTE:________________________________________ EXHIBIT “B” “AMENDMENT TO CHAPTER 2 OF SUFFOLK 2045, THE CITY OF SUFFOLK COMPREHENSIVE PLAN” Suffolk 2045 28 Source: USDA 2023 Total Active Farmland in Suffolk (Acres) 20122002 40000 0 30000 20000 10000 5000047,40947,409 60000 50,60050,600 2022 42,53342,533 Suffolk’s Agricultural Heritage Suffolk is comprised of a large amount of high-quality cropland, much of which can produce a wide variety of crops with high yields. As a result, the agricultural industry continues to play a significant role within the city. However, there are many factors that threaten its continued viability and the preservation of the lands it requires. As the city continues to grow, increasing land values have put development pressure on these agricultural lands, while the continued development of historically contiguous agricultural lands presents challenges to the city’s farming community. Development regulations, specifically as they relate to minor subdivisions and utility scale solar facilities, have also led to large pasture areas and crop lands being fragmented, diminishing the ability of land to be cultivated efficiently. According to the United States Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) “Commodity Costs and Returns” data published in October 2023, stagnant crop values and increased production costs have negatively impacted the net value of crops and overall profits. This data shows values fell for one of the more prominent crops in the city, peanuts. Between 2012 and 2020, the net value of peanut production fell by nearly 500 percent per planted acre. Several factors contributed to this trend: • The increase in operation costs has outpaced consumer prices for crops. • Federal subsidization of the farming industry has not adjusted with inflation or increased participation in federally sponsored programs. • The farming industry is being disproportionately impacted by the country’s aging population. The year-over-year loss of productive agricultural lands in Suffolk has also mimicked national trends. According to the “Farms and Land in Farms 2022 Summary” published by the USDA in February 2023, agriculturally productive cropland has decreased by 8,822 acres since 2002, representing a loss of 17.5% of productive crop land in the city. Understanding the significance of the City’s agricultural heritage has been a key principle in each iteration of the City’s Comprehensive Plan since 1998. This plan reaffirms these principles and expands on previous goals through the creation of specific actions that acknowledge the agricultural industry’s history in the City and the importance of its preservation. 2. Land Use and Growth Management 69 L.6 P reserve farmland and rural character. This objective is closely connected to Actions E.1.3 and E.1.4 Chapter 3, Economic Development. L.6.1 Re view and evaluate amendments to the City’s development ordinances and related Codes to promote the preservation of farmland and protect the agricultural industry. Consider increasing residential lot sizes for rural agriculture lands and limiting uses in areas identified as prime agricultural land. Consider a tiered zoning approach to establish criteria for the designation and retention of larger plots for agricultural uses. Discourage expansion of public utilities and other growth-inducing public facilities into agricultural areas to minimize development pressures on those areas. Evaluate the potential of Purchase of Development Rights (PDR) and Agricultural Reserve Programs to protect farmland and the agricultural industry. L.6.2 I dentify and monitor economically productive land and agricultural activities to help guide policy decisions. Farms require sufficient acreage for continued viability. Areas that are flatter and have prime soils are critical to certain agricultural activities, while some specialty agriculture may take place in areas that have different soil types and may have more topography. Defining the amount of agricultural land that is currently available and monitoring the annual change provides a method for ensuring preservation of this land. An active inventory can help inform policy and regulatory decisions that limit prime farmland from being transformed to other uses, maintaining essential agricultural areas for production. L.6.3 C ontinue to monitor the impact of recent zoning ordinance amendments on utility-scale solar development and where appropriate consider additional amendments. Monitor the implementation of the most recent amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (Section 31-724, Adopted 12/20/24) and consider additional amendments as appropriate to protect agricultural land uses in the city. Agricultural Education Other communities throughout the region and the state have benefitted from agricultural education programs geared toward youth. Such programs can help to foster an interest in and excitement about working in the agricultural industry. Programs such as the Isle of Wight County Schools Agricultural Land Lab, a school-owned 30-acre working farm where students enrolled in can experience hands-on learning, may be a model for Suffolk. RESULTS OF THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF July 15, 2026 A. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00004, Myrtle Mitigation Bank: to establish a wetlands mitigation bank on property located at 2101 Buckhorn Drive, Zoning Map 30, Parcel 14. B. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00010, Bizzy Bees Learning Experience: to grant the Conditional Use Permit to establish a family day home for up to 12 children on property located at 113 Mallard Drive, Zoning Map 25E, Parcel 3B*1. C. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST, CUP2026-00012, New Leaf Solar: to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a solar energy facility on property located on Old Myrtle Road, Zoning Map 22, Parcel 3. Approved w/conditions Approved w/conditions Denied

Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.