RecordWell Data

Wetlands Board Meeting Packet (PDF)

City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Jul 16, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Suffolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD AGENDA FOR JULY 16, 2026 PREPARED BY THE CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING DIVISION CASSIDY MCKELVIE, SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD SECRETARY A MEETING WILL BE HELD AT 6:00 P.M. IN THE SUFFOLK CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS OF THE CITY HALL BUILDING IF YOU CANNOT ATTEND OR NEED SPECIAL ACCOMMODATIONS AT THE MEETING, PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL THE CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING DIVISION AT 757-514-4060 OR PLANNINGEMAIL@SUFFOLKVA.US PRIOR TO 12:00 NOON ON WEDNESDAY, JULY 15, 2026 GEOFFREY HINSHELWOOD CHAIRMAN AGENDA SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD July 16, 2026 6:00 P.M. I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Annual Election of Officers IV. Approval of Minutes from the February 19, 2026 meeting. V. Public Hearing A. VMRC2023-0895 submitted by David Spencer, a pplicant and owner, for a permit to modify and extend an existi ng riprap revetment located at 6954 Respass Beach Road along the James Ri ver; further iden tified as Tax Map 7A(1)*3. VI. Restoration Hearings - None VII. Permit Extensions - None VIII. Old Business - None IX. New Business A. Discussion of permit identification numbers X. Compliance and Inspections – None XI. Adjournment 1 MINUTES SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD February 19, 2026 6:00 P.M. The meeting of the Suffolk Wetlands Boar d was held on Thursday, February 19, 2026, at 6:00 p.m., in the City Council Cham bers of the City Hall Building, 442 West Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia. MEMBERS: Geoffrey Hinshelwood, Chairman Darius Davenport, Vice-Chairman Richard Vroman Kathy Doerner Kittrell Eberwine, III Bryan Cattenhead STAFF: Cassidy McKelvie, Wetlands Board Secretary Margaret Pittenger, Assistant Director of Planning Rebecca Powers, Assistant City Attorney III ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Chairman Hinshelwood. The roll was then called by Mrs. McKelvie, who informed Chai rman Hinshelwood that a quorum was present. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: The minutes of the previous meeting were approved as presented by a voice vote of 6 to 0. Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board February 19, 2026 2 PUBLIC HEARING: VMRC2025-2641, submitted by Matthew Otto of Corblu Ecology Group, LLC, applicant, on behalf of Colonial Pipelin e Company, owner, for a permit for the maintenance of an existing 16-inch diamet er underground pipeline with associated tidal wetland impacts to the Nansemond River, Chuckatuck Creek, Bennett’s Creek, and their tributaries. Ms. McKelvie gave a presentation and overview of the project. Staff recommended approval of VMRC2025-2641as proposed. The public hearing was opened, and Matt Wy ant, Senior Environmental Scientist with Colonial Pipeline Company, spoke in favor of the application. The floor was opened for those who were in opposition of the application, and there was no opposition. The public hearing was closed. Following discussion by the board, Vice Chairman Davenport made a motion to approve VMRC2025-2641 with the proposed conditions. The motion was seconded by Board Member Eberwine and was approved by a voice vote of 6 to 0. Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board February 19, 2026 3 PERMIT EXTENSION: VMRC24-1833 submitted by Jullan Hernandez, Cr ofton Construction Services, Inc., agent and applicant, on behalf of VP Properties LLC, Brent Mudd, property owner, for a permit to replace a 350-foot portion of an existing 495-foot timber bulkhead. This project does not qualify for a General Permit. The property is located on 1500 Steeple Dr, along the Chuckatuck Cr eek; further identified as Zoning Map 5B*45, zoned M-1, Light Industrial Zoning District. Ms. McKelvie gave a presentation and overview of the project and the reason for the extension. Staff recommended approval of the permit extension for VMRC24-1833. Following discussion by the board, Board Member Eberwine made a motion to approve VMRC24-1833 with the proposed conditions. The motion was seconded by Board Member Vroman and was approved by a voice vote of 6 to 0. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD DATE: FEBRUARY 19, 2026 MT: Vice-Chairman Davenport 2ND: Board Member Eberwine TO: APPROVE W/ CONDITIONS BOARD MEMBERS ATTENDANCE VMRC25-2641 VOTE: 6-0 PRESENT ABSENT YES NO Chairman Geoffrey Hinshelwood X X Vice-Chairman Darius Davenport X X Sidney Hazelwood X Bryan Cattenhead X X Richard Vroman X X Kathy Doerner X X Kittrell Eberwine X X Ellis Dallas - Alternate Kaitlyn Price - Alternate SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD DATE: FEBRUARY 19, 2026 MT: Board Member Eberwine 2ND: Board Member Vroman TO: APPROVE W/ CONDITIONS BOARD MEMBERS ATTENDANCE VMRC24-1833 VOTE: 6-0 PRESENT ABSENT YES NO Chairman Geoffrey Hinshelwood X X Vice-Chairman Darius Davenport X X Sidney Hazelwood X Bryan Cattenhead X X Richard Vroman X X Kathy Doerner X X Kittrell Eberwine X X Ellis Dallas - Alternate Kaitlyn Price - Alternate CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 W. WASHINGTON STREET, P.O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 July 16, 2026 Suffolk Wetlands Board City of Suffolk, Virginia Dear Board Members: Attached for your consid eration is information pertaining to Joint Pe rmit Application (JPA) VMRC23-0895, submitted by David Spencer, applicant and property owner, for a permit to modify and extend an existing riprap revetment located at 6954 Respass Beach Road along the James River, further identified as Tax Map 7A(1)*3. Information and maps pertaining to this request are attached for your consideration. Please contact me if you have any questions in advance of the July 16, 2026 meeting. Respectfully submitted, Cassidy McKelvie Cassidy McKelvie Wetlands Board Secretary Attachments DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning STAFF REPORT DESCRIPTION PROPOSED PROJECT: The applicant is requesting a Wetlands Board permit, VMRC23-0895, to modify and extend an existing riprap revetment due to erosion and st ructural undermining. A total of 6 square feet of ve getated tidal wetlands and 202 squa re feet of non-vegetated tidal wetlands are proposed to be imp acted between mean low wate r (MLW) and mean high water (MHW) with this project. Imp acted vegetation is proposed to be replaced along the toe of the proposed riprap below 1.5x the Mean Tide Range (MTR). APPLICANT: Submitted by David Spencer, applicant and property owner. LOCATION: The subject property is located at 6954 Respass Beach Road (Tax Map 7A(1)*3) along the James River and Streeter Creek. PERMIT HISTORY: None. Based on aerial imagery, the ex isting riprap appears to have been present as early as January 2006. VIMS REPORT: An assessment from the Virginia In stitute of Marine Science (VIMS) was provided for this application in June 2023. The letter with the asse ssment results is attached as Exhibit “E”. The assessment found that no significant adverse environmental impacts are anticipated due to the construction of the project. The letter further states that saltmarsh cordgrass ( Sporobolus alterniflorus , formerly Spartina alterniflora) almost exclusively grows between MTR and MHW. As such, VIMS has recommended that the revegetation of the saltmarsh cordgrass be planted within their natural tide range to provide the greatest likelihood of surviv al and growth. However, if the vegetation is planted at the toe of the proposed riprap, below the 1.5xMTR, it is recommended that the relocated vegetation be monitored for at least one year to determine the likelihood of survival. PUBLIC NOTICE: This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements set forth in Sectio n 28.2-1302 of the Code of Virgin ia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Un ified Development Ordinance. A copy of staff’s report was provided to the applicant on July 2, 2026. STAFF ANALYSIS ISSUE The applicant is requesting a permit from the Su ffolk Wetlands Board to modify and extend an existing riprap revetment due to beach erosio n and structural undermin ing. The project will include a total of 869 square feet of new riprap, most of which will be placed within the Resource Protection Area (RPA) buffer. Th e existing return wall is propos ed to be lengthened by 52 feet and widened up to 7 feet. Construction access w ill be taken from the driveway adjacent to the project area. A total of 6 square feet of vegetated tidal wetla nds and 202 square feet of non-vegetated tidal wetlands are proposed to be impacted between MLW and MHW. Impacted vegetation is proposed to be replaced along the toe of the proposed riprap below 1.5x MTR. The impacts to non-vegetated Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 VMRC23-0895 Page 2 of 5 wetlands are proposed to be self-compensating. Vegetation and land disturbance wi thin the RPA buffer is proposed w ith this project and will be covered separately through a Chesapeake Ba y Preservation Area ( CBPA) Encroachment application filed with the Cit y.. A preliminary Water Quality Impact Assessment (WQIA) and buffer restoration plan are provided in attached Exhibit “C”. The project is anticipated to take approximately 90 days to complete. The first week will include preparing the site for construction and removing an existing timber walkway. The installation of the revetment is proposed in the following ten weeks. The final week will consist of demobilization and stabilization. Due to the project site being lo cated along the James River, ther e are approximately 27 miles of open water fetch to the northwest and approximately 32 miles to the northeast. The applicant has indicated that the wave energy expected from the amount of fetch would exceed the recommended guidelines for a typical living shoreline involving a sill as ve getation and substrate would be at a greater risk of washing out. The installation of a breakwater was also considered as an alternative solution. The applicant has indicated that the design and size of a breakwater for this site would need to be effective for fetch approaching from two directions. The applicant stated that th e size and impacts from such a structure would be larger and more significant than what is proposed for the revetment. CONSIDERATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS 1. The VIMS assessment for this application found that no significant adverse environmental impacts are anticipated, as less than 10 square feet of saltmarsh cordgrass are proposed to be impacted and is intended to be replaced in-kind. VIMS expressed concern regarding the likelihood of survival for the relocated vegetation. As such, monitoring of the relocated vegetation for a period of no less than one year is proposed as a condition of approval for this permit. 2. This project does not require authorizat ion from the Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) as all proposed work is located landward of MLW. Permitting and approvals from other agencies, including, but not limited to, the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality and the Army Corps of Engineers, may be required prior to any land disturbing activities. Ob taining all required permits a nd approvals is proposed as a condition of approval for this permit. 3. The proposed 6 square feet of vegetated tidal wetland impacts are proposed to be replaced in-kind on the subject property. 4. According to Section 31-415(d)(1)(D)(i)(d) of the City of Suffolk’s Unified Development Ordinance, trees and woody vegetation may be removed, necessary control techniques employed, and appropriate vege tation established to protect or stabilize a shoreline in accordance with the best availa ble technical advice and app licable permit conditions or requirements. This project is considered a shoreline erosion control project, which is a Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 VMRC23-0895 Page 3 of 5 permitted use within the RPA buffer. A CBPA Encroachment application will be required for this project and is proposed as a condition of approval for the permit. 5. Pursuant to Section 34-325 of the Suffolk City Code, the Wetlands Board shall prevent the despoliation and destruction of wetlands while accommodating necessary economic development in a manner consistent with wetlands preservation. Section 34-327 states that a Wetlands Permit may be issued by the Boar d only if the applican t demonstrates the following: a) The anticipated public and private benefi t of the proposed activity exceeds its anticipated public and private detriment. Benefits from the proposed project ar e anticipated to be greater than any detriments, as the modification and extension of an existing revetment will reduce the effect of erosion at the project site and protect the existing dwelling. b) The proposed development conforms with the standards prescribed in Code of Virginia, § 28.2-1308 and guidelines promulgated pursuant to Code of Virginia, § 28.2-1301. i. Wetlands of primary ecological significance shall not be altered so that the ecological systems in the wetlands are unreasonably disturbed. All proposed wetland impacts are propos ed to be replaced on the subject property. Therefore, no wetlands, nor their ecological systems, of primary ecological significance are expected to be unreasonably disturbed. ii. Development in Tidewater Virginia, to the maximum extent practical, shall be concentrated in wetlands of lesser ecological significance, in vegetated wetlands which have been irreversibl y disturbed before July 1, 1972, in nonvegetated wetlands which have been irreversibly disturbed prior to January 1, 1983, and in areas of Tidewater Virginia outside of wetlands. Due to the presence of the existing riprap revetment, it is plausible that the adjacent tidal wetlands were previously disturbed during prior construction. Although the initial date of the re vetment is unknown, aerial imagery suggests that it has been present for over 20 years. Furthermore, the project goals of reducing erosion at the property, proximal to an existing dwelling, could not be achieved if the project were relocated. c) The proposed activity does not violate the purposes and intent of Chapter 13 Title 28.2 of the Code of Virginia, (§ 28.2-1300 et seq.) and of Article VIII of the Suffolk Code of Ordinances. The intent of these regulations and th e purpose of the Board is to allow for necessary economic development in a manner consistent with wetlands preservation. The proposed modificatio n and extension of the existing riprap revetment is necessary to prevent further erosion of the subject property proximal Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 VMRC23-0895 Page 4 of 5 to the existing dwelling. RECOMMENDATION It is staff’s opinion that the pr oposed permit for the modificati on and extension of an existing riprap revetment meets the requirements establis hed by Section 34-327 of Suffolk City Code. Therefore, staff recommends approval of permit application VM RC23-0895 with the following conditions: 1. The Wetlands Permit for this project shall expire on July 16, 2027, after which time this permit shall be void. Permit coverage may be extended by the Board, at its discretion, provided that a written request describing the reasons for the extension and the requested new expiration date is submitted to the Suffolk Planning Division no later than May 16, 2027. 2. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than 48 hours prior to the commencement of any work under this permit. 3. Any vegetated tidal wetlands impacted during this project shall be replaced on the subject property in kind. The applican t will notify the Board once all work is complete and the relocated vegetation has been planted. The Suffolk Planning Divi sion will conduct an initial inspection of the project site once co mpleted. The Suffolk Planning Division will return to the site one year following the initial inspection date to ensure the survival of the relocated vegetation. If the relocated vegetati on does not appear to be in good condition during either inspection, an alternative mitigation plan shall be submitted by the applicant for consideration by the Board. 4. The permittee shall comply with all applicab le laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations affecting the conduct of the project. The gr anting of this permit shall not relieve the permittee of the responsibility of obtaining any and all other permits or authority required for the project, including but not limited to approvals from the Department of Environmental Quality, the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the City of Suffolk. 5. No work under this permit shall be conducted until a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Encroachment application has been receiv ed and approved by the Suffolk Planning Division for the proposed land disturbance an d vegetation removal within the Resource Protection Area Buffer. 6. All phases of the project shall conform in all particulars to the permittee’s application for Wetlands Permit. The duly authorized agents of the Board shall have the right to enter upon the premises at any reasonable time for the purposes of inspecting the work being done pursuant to this permit. 7. The permittee shall, to the greatest extent practical, minimize the adverse effects of the project upon adjacent properties, wetlands, and the natural resources of the Commonwealth. Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 VMRC23-0895 Page 5 of 5 8. This permit shall not be transferred without the prior written approval of the Board. 9. This permit may be revoked at any time by th e Board upon the failure of the permittee to comply with any of the terms and conditions hereof. Attachments • Proposed Permit • Exhibit A – Wetlands Board Application Checklist JPA Application • Exhibit B – JPA Application • Exhibit C – WQIA • Exhibit D – VMRC Report • Exhibit E – VIMS Report • Exhibit F – Communications with applicant and agent • Exhibit G – Site Photos CITY OF SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD Wetlands Permit 23-0895 Granted July 16, 2026 Expires July 16, 2027 Pursuant to Chapter 13 of Title 28.2 of the Code of Virginia (1950, as amended) and the City of Suffolk Wetlands Ordinance, the City of Suffolk Wetlands Board, hereinafter referred to as the Board, hereby grants unto David Spencer, applicant and property owner herein after referred to as the permittee, pe rmission to undertake the following described project. Location: 6954 Respass Beach Road along the James River; further identified as Tax Map 7A(1)*3. Description of Project: Modification and extension of an existing riprap revetment. Conditions: 1. The Wetlands Permit for this project shall expire on July 16, 2027, after which time this permit shall be void. Permit coverage may be extended by the Board, at its discretion, provided that a written request describing the reasons for the extension and the requested new expiration date is submitted to the Suffolk Planning Division no later than May 16, 2027. 2. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than 48 hours prior to the commencement of any work under this permit. 3. Any vegetated tidal wetlands impacted during this project shall be replaced on the subject property in kind. The applican t will notify the Board once all work is complete and the relocated vegetation has been planted. The Suffolk Planning Division will conduct an initial inspection of the project site once completed. The Suffolk Planning Division will return to the site one year following the initial inspection date to ensure the survival of the relocated vegetation. If the relocated vegetation does not appear to be in good condition during eith er inspection, an alternative mitigation plan shall be submitted by the applicant for consideration by the Board. 4. The permittee shall comply with all ap plicable laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations affecting the conduc t of the project. The gran ting of this permit shall not relieve the permittee of the responsibility of obtaining any and all other permits or authority required for the project, including but not limited to approvals from the Department of Environmental Quality, the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the City of Suffolk. 5. No work under this permit shall be conducted until a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Encroachment application has been received and approved by the Suffolk Planning Division for the proposed land disturbance and vegetation removal within the Resource Protection Area Buffer. 6. All phases of the project sh all conform in all particulars to the permittee’s application for Wetlands Permit. The duly authorized agents of the Board shall have the right to enter upon the premises at any reasonable time for the purposes of inspecting the work being done pursuant to this permit. 7. The permittee shall, to the greatest extent practical, minimize the adverse effects of the project upon adjacent properties, wetla nds, and the natural resources of the Commonwealth. 8. This permit shall not be transferred without the prior written approval of the Board. 9. This permit may be revoked at any time by the Board upon the failure of the permittee to comply with any of the terms and conditions hereof. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of Suffolk Wetlands Board has caused these presents to be executed on its behalf by CITY OF SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD By:__________________________________ (Chairman or designee) -  DEQ: Permit application fees required for Virginia Water Protection permits – while detailed in 9 VAC25-20 – are conveyed to the applicant by the applicable DEQ office (ht tp://www.deq.virginia.gov/Locations.aspx). Complete the Permit Application Fee Form and s ubmit it per the instructions to the address listed on the form. Instructions for submitting any other f ees will be provided to the applicant by DEQ staff.  V MRC: An application fee of $300 may be required for projects impacting tidal wetlands, beaches a nd/or dunes when VMRC acts as the LWB. VMRC will notify the applicant in writing if the fee is r equired. Permit fees involving subaqueous lands are $25.00 for projects costing $10,000 or less and $100 f or projects costing more than $10,000. Royalties may also be required for some projects. The pr oper permit fee and any required royalty is paid at the time of permit issuance by VMRC. VMRC s taff will send the permittee a letter notifying him/her of the proper permit fees and submittal r equirements.  L WB: Permit fees vary by locality. Contact the LWB for your project area or their website for fee i nformation and submittal requirements. Contact information for LWBs may be found at h ttp://ccrm.vims.edu/permits_web/guidance/local_wetlands_boards.html. FOR AGENCY USE ONLY Notes: JPA # APPLICANTS Part 1 – General Information PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL ANSWERS: If a question does not apply to your project, please print N/A (not applicable) in the space provided. If additional space is needed, attach 8-1/2 x 11 inch sheets of paper. Check all that apply Pre-Construction Notification (PCN) NWP # _____________________ (For Nationwide Permits ONLY - No DEQ- VWP permit writer will be assigned) Regional Permit 17 (RP-17) County or City in which the project is located:_________________________________________ Waterway at project site:___________________________________________________________ PREVIOUS ACTIONS RELATED TO THE PROPOSED WORK (Include all federal, state, and local pre application coordination, site visits, previous permits, or applications whether issued, withdrawn, or denied) Historical information for past permit submittals can be found online with VMRC - https://webapps.mrc.virginia.gov/public/habitat/ - or VIMS - http://ccrm.vims.edu/perms/newpermits.html Agency Action / Activity Permit/Project number, including any non-reporting Nationwide permits previously used (e.g., NWP 13) Date of Action If denied, give reason for denial Application Revised: October 2019 5 Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh 23-0895 Part 1 - General Information (continued) 1. Applicant’s legal name* and complete mailing address: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ 2. Property owner(s) legal name * and complete address, if different from applicant: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ 3. Authorized agent name * and complete mailing Contact Information: address (if applicable): Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ * If multiple applicants, property owners, and/or agents, each must be listed and each must sign the applicant signature page. 4. Provide a detailed description of the project in the space below, including the type of project, its dimensions, materials, and method of construction. Be sure to include how the construction site will be accessed and whether tree clearing and/or grading will be required, including the total acreage. If the project requires pilings, please be sure to include the total number, type (e.g. wood, steel, etc), diameter, and method of installation (e.g. hammer, vibratory, jetted, etc). If additional space is needed, provide a separate sheet of paper with the project description. Application Revised: 2FWREHU 6 757 403-2860 Tyrostonehouse@gmail.com 757 477-4787 David@MarineEngineeringLLC.com DAVID SPENCER 6954 RESPASS BEACH RD SUFFOLK, VA 23435 N/A MARINE ENGINEERING LLC C/O DAVID KLEDZIK 1932 CHARLA LEE LN VIRGINIA BEACH, VA 23455 Construction to modify an existing riprap revetment to protect home from 27 mile NW fetch. See elaborated justification in Rev 1 resubmittal email. Length and width of existing quarrystone return wall to be increased due to erosion of beach and structural undermining. Five small trees (shown on plan), shrubs & ivy along bank to be removed for access and clearance to install revetment return wall. Tree & vegetation replacement proposed in redeveloped planting bed. Two areas of vegetation (6 sf total) within riprap to be impacted by new quarrystone. Replacement vegetation distributed along toe of proposed riprap below 1.5xMTR in compensation. Non-vegetated, rock on rock or sand impacts are proposed to be self-compensating. Construction to use shore based equipment and single accessway from stree t. No grading or additional clearing is proposed. Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map Part 1 - General Information (continued) 5. Have you obtained a contractor for the project? ___ Yes* ___ No. *If your answer is “Yes” complete the remainder of this question and submit the Applicant’s and Contractor’s Acknowledgment Form (enclosed) Contractor’s name* and complete mailing address: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ email __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________________ * If multiple contractors, each must be listed and each must sign the applicant signature page. 6. List the name, address and telephone number of the newspaper having general circulation in the area of the project. Failure to complete this question may delay local and State processing. Name and complete mailing address: Telephone number (____) __________________ 7. Give the following project location information: Street Address (911 address if available)_________________________________________ Lot/Block/Parcel#___________________________________________________________ Subdivision________________________________________________________________ City / County___________________________________ ZIP Code_____________________ Latitude and Longitude at Center Point of Project Site (Decimal Degrees): ________________________ / -________________________ (Example: 36.41600/-76.30733) If the project is located in a rural area, please provide driving directions giving distances from the best and nearest visible landmarks or major intersections. Note: if the project is in an undeveloped subdivision or property, clearly stake and identify property lines and location of the proposed project. A supplemental map showing how the property is to be subdivided should also be provided. 8. What are the primary and secondary purposes of and the need for the project? For example, the primary purpose may be “to protect property from erosion due to boat wakes” and the secondary purpose may be “to provide safer access to a pier.” Application Revised: October 2019 7 Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh Part 1 - General Information (continued) 9. Proposed use (check one): ___ Single user (private, non-commercial, residential) ___ Multi-user (community, commercial, industrial, government) 10. Describe alternatives considered and the measures that will be taken to avoid and minimize impacts, to the maximum extent practicable, to wetlands, surface waters, submerged lands, and buffer areas associated with any disturbance (clearing, grading, excavating) during and after project construction. Please be advised that unavoidable losses of tidal wetlands and/or aquatic resources may require compensatory mitigation. 11. Is this application being submitted for after-the-fact authorization for work which has already begun or been completed? ___Yes ___No. If yes, be sure to clearly depict the portions of the project which are already complete in the project drawings. 12. Approximate cost of the entire project (materials, labor, etc.): $___________________________ Approximate cost of that portion of the project that is channelward of mean low water: $____________ 13. Completion date of the proposed work:________________________________-_____________ 14. Adjacent Property Owner Information: List the name and complete mailing address, including zip code, of each adjacent property owner to the project. (NOTE: If you own the adjacent lot, provide the requested information for the first adjacent parcel beyond your property line.) Failure to provide this information may result in a delay in the processing of your application by VMRC. Application Revised: October 2019 8 Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh Part 3 – Appendices (continued) Appendix B: Projects for Shoreline Stabilization in tidal wetlands, tidal waters and dunes/beaches including riprap revetments and associated backfill, marsh toe stabilization, bulkheads and associated backfill, breakwaters, beach nourishment, groins, jetties, and living shoreline projects. Answer all questions that apply. Please provide any reports provided from the Shoreline Erosion Advisory Service or VIMS. NOTE: It is the policy of the Commonwealth that living shorelines are the preferred alternative for stabilizing tidal shorelines (Va. Code § 28.2-104.1). Information on non-structural, vegetative alternatives (i.e., Living Shoreline) for shoreline stabilization is available at http://ccrm.vims.edu/coastal_zone/living_shorelines/index.html. 1. Describe each revetment, bulkhead, marsh toe, breakwater, groin, jetty, other structure, or living shoreline project separately in the space below. Include the overall length in linear feet, the amount of impacts in acres, and volume of associated backfill below mean high water and/or ordinary high water in cubic yards, as applicable: 2. What is the maximum encroachment channelward of mean high water?_______feet. Channelward of mean low water?_______feet. Channelward of the back edge of the dune or beach?_____feet. 3. Please calculate the square footage of encroachment over: • Vegetated wetlands __________square feet • Non-vegetated wetlands __________square feet • Subaqueous bottom __________square feet • Dune and/or beach __________square feet 4. For bulkheads, is any part of the project maintenance or replacement of a previously authorized, currently serviceable, existing structure? ____ Yes____ No. If yes, will the construction of the new bulkhead be no further than two (2) feet channelward of the existing bulkhead? _____Yes ____No. If no, please provide an explanation for the purpose and need for the additional encroachment. Application Revised: October 2019 17 Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh ________________________________________________________ Part 3 – Appendices (continued) 5. 6. 7. Describe the type of construction and all materials to be used, including source of backfill material, if applicable (e.g., vinyl sheet-pile bulkhead, timber stringers and butt piles, 100% sand backfill from upland source; broken concrete core material with Class II quarry stone armor over filter cloth). NOTE: Drawings must include construction details, including dimensions, design and all materials, including fittings if used. If using stone, broken concrete, etc. for your structure(s), what is the average weight of the: Core (inner layer) material__________ pounds per stone Class size ________ Armor (outer layer) material __________ pounds per stone Class size ________ For beach nourishment, including that associated with breakwaters, groins or other structures, provide the following: • Volume of material • Area to be covered ___________ cubic yards channelward of mean low water ___________ cubic yards landward of mean low water ___________ cubic yards channelward of mean high water ___________ cubic yards landward of mean high water ___________ square feet channelward of mean low water ___________ square feet landward of mean low water ___________ cubic yards channelward of mean high water ___________ cubic yards landward of mean high water • Source of material, composition (e.g. 90% sand, 10% clay):___________________________ • Method of transportation and placement: • Describe any proposed vegetative stabilization measures to be used, including planting schedule, spacing, monitoring, etc. Additional guidance is available at http://www.vims.edu/about/search/index.php?q=planting+guidelines: Application Revised: October 2019 18 Received by VMRC April 14, 2023 /blh R=50.00'L=54.12' SEQUENCE & TIME LINE OF CONSTRUCTION (CONSTRUCTION TIMELINE 9/1/25 TO 12/31/25 SUBJECT TO CHANGE) 1. OBTAIN ALL NECESSARY PERMITS 2. HOLD PRECONSTRUCTION MEETING 4. INSTALL CONTRUCTION & ACCESSWAY LIMITS 5. INSTALL SILT FENCE SEAWARD OF SOIL DISTURBANCE 6. REMOVE TIMBER ACCESS RAMP & WALKWAY 7. TEMPORARILY REMOVE EXIST STONE AT TOE TO DRESS FABRIC 8. INSTALL RIPRAP AND EXTEND RETURN 9. RESTORE LIMITS WITH IN-KIND REPLACEMENT 10. REMOVE E&S CONTROLS AFTER LAND DISTURBANCE HAS BEEN STABILIZED 11. INSTALL BUFFER & PLANTS AT FIRST SEASONAL OPPORTUNITY. 80' 40' 0' 2025 MARINE ENGINEERING LLC - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.C PROPERTY LINE #6954 EBB FLOOD PROPERTY LINE SCALE: 1" = 80' LOT 3 DAVID SPENCER RESPASS BEACH RD 100.00' N 75°53'34" W PIN (F) ±422' N 21°31'00" E 20' JAMES RIVER SITE PLAN OF PROPOSED RIPRAP PROJECT EXISTING CONDITIONS (PROPOSED SHOWN AS LIGHT DASH) STREETER CREEK MLW MHW 1.5XMTR EXISTING TIMBER ACCESS RAMP & WALKWAY TO BE REMOVED PROPOSED REVETMENT RETURN EXTENSION PIER WALKWAY REMNANTCONSTRUCTION ACCESS & LIMITS 2308 SF DISTURBANCEDRIVEWAY EXISTING RIPRAP REVETMENT EXISTING PIER REMNANT GRAVEL PATHWAY LOT 2 HARRY THOMPSON LOTS 4&5 DAVID SPENCER ±605' N 56°18'06" W LOT 2F EARL BEASLEY APO RIPRAP CONTINUES EBB FLOOD LOT 6*36 HRSD 15' EASEMENT 100' RPA 50' RPA TURF/BED/NATURAL BORDER RACK LINE TURF TURF BED BEDBED NATURAL Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map RIPRAP TIEDOWN 1 2 A 50' 71' B 63' 56' C 100' 80' ANY DISTURBED GROUND COVER OR VEGETATION (TURF, SHRUBS, OR TREES) SHALL BE REPLACED IN-KIND. SILT FENCE AS NEEDED SCALE: 1" = 20' PROPOSED RIPRAP DETAILS CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS FOR RIPRAP REVETMENT: MARINE CONSTRUCTION GRADE MATERIALS VDOT CLASS 1 , 2 & 3 GRANITE QUARRYSTONE RIPRAP GEOTEXTILE FABRIC, SIMILAR TO US 670 CONCRETE, 3000 PSI CONSTRUCTION ACCESS BY DRIVEWAY X1 PROPOSED RIPRAP REVETMENT A-B NEW STRUCTURE ALONG SLOPE B-C STABILIZE EXISTING STRUCTURE CLASS 2-3 ARMOR & CLASS 1-2 CORE FILL VOIDS WITH CLASS 1 REDUCE SIZES TOWARD PT A MHW MLW EXISTING RIPRAP REVETMENT REMOVE EXISTING QUARRYSTONE AS NEEDED TO DRESS FILTER CLOTH AND POSITION NEW RIPRAP EXISTING GRAVEL PATH DWELLING 2 SF VEG IN RIPRAP 4 SF VEG IN RIPRAP 1.5XMTR (RACK LINE) 22' 20' 20' 8' B A C52' 47' X3 CONSTRUCTION ACCESS AND LIMITS X2 REMOVE 5 SMALL TREES, BRUSH, SHRUBS, & IVY ALONG BANK TO INSTALL RIPRAP (REPLANT & REPLACE IN BUFFER) PHRAGMITES WETLAND IMPACTS: 6 SF VEGETATED 202 SF NON-VEGETATED (STONE ON STONE OR SANDY INTERTIDAL BOTTOM) PVC 5' 1 2 TREE PROTECTION RELOCATE DISPLACED SPARTINA ALONG TOE OF REVETMENT BEACH 50' RPA 100' RPA 0' 20'10' 1.5XMTR Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map S A UARRYSTONE RIPRAP US 670 EWAY EVETMENT ONG SLOPE TRUCTURE S 1-2 CORE TH CLASS 1 WARD PT A REMO TO D 2 SF VEG IN RIPRAP 4 SF VEG IN RIPRAP ) 20' 20' B C' 47' X3 X2 S DISPLACED ALONG TOE EVETMENT BEACH 1.5XMTR BORDER / GRADE9.7' MLW0.00' 2.80' MHW 4.20' 1.5 X MTR TOP OF BANK10' MLW0.00' 2.80' MHW 4.20' 1.5 X MTR BORDER / GRADE9.3' MLW0.00' 2.80' MHW 4.20' 1.5 X MTR 0.00' 0.00' 0.00' 5' 10' 5' 10' 5' 0.00' 5' 10' 15' 20' 0.00' 5' 10' 15' 0.00' 5 ' 10' EXISTING GRADE & CONCRETE BORDER PROPOSED GRADE & CONCRETE BORDER PROPOSED GRADE & CONCRETE BORDER EXISTING GRADE EXISTING GRADEREMOVE OVERBURDEN SOIL EXISTING REVETMENT PROPOSED TOE EXTENSION PROPOSED RIPRAP REVETMENT EXTEND NEW TOE ON FABRIC PULL EXISTING STONE TO REDRESS AND EXTEND FABRIC REMOVE SOFT OVERBURDEN SOIL & SHARP OBJECTS PREPARE SMOOTH BED FOR FABRIC AND STONE MAX SLOPE 11 1.5 TOE 2' - 4' INTO FIRM SOIL INTERTIDAL BEACH UPLAND SECTION X3 SECTION X2 SECTION X1 PROPOSED RIPRAP DETAILS SCALE: 1" = 5' SILT FENCE EXISTING SPARTINA TO BE DISPLACED EXISTING SPARTINA RELOCATED BELOW 1.5XMTR GENTLE & GRADUAL SLOPE FOR WAVE ATTENUATION WITH LESS SCOUR AT TOE & GREATER RETENTION OF SUBSTRATE TO SUPPORT VEGETATION 15' Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map SITE Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map Cassidy L. Mckelvie A pril 14, 2026 City of Suffolk VA Reference: WQIA for David Spencer at 6954 Respass Beach Rd Dear Ms. Braziel, I have included a response in Italic for each item of the WQIA below. A minor water quality impact assessment pertains only to development within CBPAs which causes no more than 10,000 square feet of land disturbance and requires any modification or reductions of the landward 50 feet of the 100 foot buffer area. A minor assessment must demonstrate through acceptable calculations that the remaining buffer area and necessary best management practices will result in removal of no less than 75 percent of sediments and 40 percent of nutrients from post -development stormwater runoff and that will prevent runoff and filter nonpoint source pollution the equivalent of the full undisturbed 100- foot buffer. A minor assessment shall include a site drawing to scale which shows the following: Since the proposal includes modifications to the 50 ft seaward portion of the RPA, a minor WQIA alone is insufficient but provided here to augment major WQIA that follows. (1) Location of the components of the RPA, including the 100 foot buffer areas; RPA lines are shown on site plan. (2) Location and nature of the proposed encroachment into the buffer area, including: type of paving material; areas of clearing or grading; location of any structures, drives for other impervious cover; and sewage disposal systems or reserve drain field sites; The proposed encroachment is a riprap revetment involving the extension and redevelopment of an existing return wall with limited ground disturbance from temporary construction access way that extends from driveway. Removal of small trees, shrubs, and ivy for access and installation of proposed revetment is needed. No paving or sewage systems proposed. (3) Type and location of proposed best management practices to mitigate the proposed encroachment. Rooftop stormwater disconnection to surface of a/b soils and buffer installation arrangement shown on landscape plan separate from JPA site plan . (4) Location of existing vegetation and re -vegetated areas as shown on the site drawing Upland vegetation on lot cons ists primarily of turfgrass , ivy, planting beds, trees, and naturally covered bank . The construction access way and limits crossing the lawn would be replanted with turfgrass to restore to existing condition. Disturbance to planting bed and natural bank is shown on siteplan and will be restored as detailed on separate landscape plan. A major water quality impact assessment shall be required for any development which (i) exceeds 10,000 square feet of land disturbance within CBPA's and requires any modification or reduction of the landward 50 feet of the 100-foot buffer area; (ii) disturbs any portion of any other component of an RPA or disturbs any portion of the buffer area within 50 feet of any other component of an RPA; or (iii) is located in an RMA and is deemed necessary by the Planning and Community Development Director. The information required in this Section shall Marine Engineering LLC 1932 Charla Lee Ln Virginia Beach, VA 23455 757 477-4787 David@MarineEngineeringLLC.com  Page 2 May 6, 2026 be considered a minimum, unless the Director determines that some of the elements are unnecessary due to the scope and nature of the proposed use and development of land. The following elements shall be included in the preparation and submission of a major water quality assessment: This project involves extending the return length of an existing quarrystone riprap revetment along an eroding bank that is in close proximity to residential dwelling. The shoreline and beach have been scoured by waves and currents from large fetch exceeding 27 miles . The existing return has been partially undermined and needs redevelopment involving greater length and a deeper toe. The proposed riprap return wall extension and redeveloped toe will impact 661 SF uplands and 208 SF wetlands respectively. Two timber access walkways will be removed for construction access. 2308 SF of upland land disturbance to turfgrass and planting bed at top of bank including ivy, shrubs, and trees in the 50 foot landward and seaward portions of the RPA is anticipated from temporary construction access that extends from driveway. When original riprap revetment was designed, the length of existing return structure did not extend far enough landward nor the proper toe depth to protect the bank beside the home. The proposed revetment will provide containment of soils along bank face and the border will provide a continuous barrier to prevent stormwater erosion from top of bank. The VRRM redevelopment worksheet indicates required load reduction achieved using rooftop disconnection to a/b soils. (1) All of the information required in a minor water quality impact assessment, as specified above; Provided above in Minor WQIA section. (2) A hydrogeological element that: A. Describes the existing topography, soils, hydrology and geology of the site and adjacent lands. The topography of the lot and surr ounding area is relatively level with a portion of runoff into wetlands. The soils appear to be loam, sand, silt, & clay. The hydrology of the surface layer appears to be well-drained soil. The geology of the area is coastal plain sediments. B. Describes the impacts of the proposed development on topography, soils, hydrology and geology on the site and adjacent lands. Coastal plain soil to be excavated from proposed riprap toe to provide stability and resist scour from undermining structure. Excavated soil if suitable or c lean sand is proposed as needed for backfill near point B to increase bank angle for riprap to be installed. I mpacts are isolated and temporary, the global topography, soils, hydrology, and geology will remain unchanged. The proposed riprap on face of bank does not appear to have any permanent consequence to said features other than protection from erosion . C. Indicates the following: (i) Disturbance or destruction of wetlands and justification for such action; The riprap revetment return is designed such that only an unavoidable minimum disturbance and destruction to wetlands will occur. The majority of revetment is landward of wetlands to protect uplands adjacent to the existing home. The impacts to wetlands include an area adjacent to the toe of the existing return to widen the structure, and two isolated pockets of protected vegetation embedded in the existing riprap. The vegetation will be disturbed because the riprap has become undermined and must be redeveloped to remain effective at protecting a residential dwelling. The vegetation may be carefully removed and replanted as the stones are extracted and reinstalled during construction. Then the same vegetation can be replanted at a similar elevation within the stones along toe of the new structure. (ii) Disruptions or reductions in the supply of water to wetlands, streams, lakes, rivers or other water bodies; Site is located on relatively high ground and does not block watershed by impeding surface flow to water body.  Page 3 May 6, 2026 (iii) Disruptions to existing hydrology including wetland and stream circulation patterns; Proposed riprap along face of bank does not disrupt hydrology of groundwater or tidal waters. (iv) Source location and description of proposed fill material; Coastal plain soil excavated from proposed riprap toe & bed or clean sand from upland as needed are proposed for backfill near point B. (v) Location of dredge material and location of dumping area for such material; There is no dredge material with the proposed quarrystone riprap revetment. (vi) Location of and impacts on shellfish beds, submerged aquatic vegetation, and fish spawning areas; There is no anticipated impact to shellfish beds, SAV, or fish spawning with the proposed quarrystone riprap revetment. (vii) Estimation of pre- and post-development pollutant loads in runoff; Based on the VRRM, the post development pollutant loads in runoff are below allowable limits . Predevelopment Total Phosphorus (TP) available for removal = 0.05 lbs/yr TP reduction required (0.0 2 lbs/yr) Postdevelopment TP calculated = 0.03 lbs/yr due to rooftop disconnection with sheetflow on pervious soil. (viii) Estimation of percent increase in impervious surface on site and types of surfacing materials used; Existing impervious 27% 0.9% increase may be due to quarrystone riprap along face of bank. (ix) Percent of site to be cleared for project; 1.7% along bank for access and riprap installation. (x) Anticipation, duration and phasing schedule of construction project; Duration of project anticipated to be 90 days. First week to install construction limits for access and remove timber ramp / walkway. Following 10 weeks to install revetment. Final week for demobilization & stabilizing ground. (xi) Listing of all requisite permits from all applicable agencies necessary to develop project. JPA submitted and permit under review by Corps and VMRC. (xii) Describes the proposed mitigation measures for the potential hydrogeological impacts. Potential mitigation measures include: 1. Proposed erosion and sediment control concepts; concepts may include minimizing the extent of the cleared area, perimeter controls, reduction of runoff velocities, measures to stabilize disturbed areas, schedule and personnel for site inspection;  Page 4 May 6, 2026 Minimizing c onstruction limits & use of silt fence extending along top of bank seaward of disturbance s. 2. Proposed stormwater management system; Sheet flow infiltration in grass strip & planting beds 3. Creation of wetlands to replace those lost; Impacted sandy and rocky wetlands along toe of existing revetment will be replaced by rocky wetlands 4. Minimizing cut and fill. (3) A landscape element that: Applicant will select plant species from native list arranged with mulch to be shown on landscape plan. A. Identifies and delineates the location of all significant plant material, including all trees on site six (6) inches or greater diameter at breast heights. Where there are groups of trees, stands may be outlined. Tree groups, planting beds, & turf grass areas are delineated. B. Describes the impacts the development or use will have on the existing vegetation. Information should include: (i) General limits of clearing, based on all anticipated improvements, including buildings, drives and utilities; Construction access from driveway and proposed riprap along bank to impact turfgrass , planting be d, small trees, and natural scrub vegetation along bank as shown on site plan. (ii) Clear delineation of all trees which will be removed; 5 small trees along the bank to be removed are indicated on the site plan. (iii) Description of plant species to be disturbed or removed. Turfgrass, planted shrubs, small volunteer trees,& natural scrub vegetation on bank. (iv) Describes the potential measures for mitigation. Possible mitigation measures include: 1. Replanting schedule for trees and other significant vegetation removed for construction, including a list of possible plants and trees to be used; Based on guidance of the riparian manual, up to 6 planting units are proffered for the 2308 square feet of disturbance including temporary disturbance if required ; 6 canopy trees, 12 understory trees, & 18 shrubs. The Applicant will select particular species which will be included on separate landscape plan . 2. Demonstration that the design of the plan will preserve to the greatest extent possible any significant trees and vegetation on the site and will provide maximum erosion control and overland flow benefits from such vegetation. No significant trees or vegetation are proposed for removal. Planting bed & vegetation will be replaced that provides upland runoff flow protection for the areas temporarily impacted and will slow overland stormwater sheetflows providing for greater percolation and less runoff. The proposed revetment will further protect from erosion of bank due to stormwater overland runoff and elevated sea wave action. 3. Demonstration that indigenous plants are to be used to the greatest extent possible.  Page 5 May 6, 2026 The plants proposed are to be selected from the Riparian Buffer Manual plant list. (4) A wastewater element, where applicable, that: A. Includes calculations and locations of anticipated drain field or wastewater irrigation areas; No wastewater element is proposed or impacted for this project. B. Provides justification for sewer line locations in environmentally sensitive areas, where applicable, and describes construction techniques and standards; No wastewater element is proposed or impacted for this project. C. Discusses any proposed on-site collection and treatment systems, their treatment levels, and impacts on receiving watercourses. No wastewater element is proposed or impacted for this project. D. Describes the potential impacts of the proposed wastewater systems, including the proposed mitigative measures for these impacts. No wastewater element is proposed or impacted for this project. E. Identification of the existing characteristics and conditions of sensitive lands included as components of Chesapeake Bay Preservation Areas, as defined in this Article. The existing characteristics of the RPA is residentially developed uplands with high bank actively eroding and scoured intertidal zone facing open water with significant fetch from two directions. . F. Identification of the natural processes and ecological relationships inherent in the site, and an assessment of the impact of the proposed use and development of land on these processes and relationships. This site location is part of a developed residential neighborhoo d adjacent to a marsh and open water. Other than a riprap revetment for protection, no change in use or development is proposed that may impact existing natural processes and ecological relationships . The high bank of subject site has been susceptible to erosion which is encroaching toward dwelling. The small trees along the bank are subject to wave action & scour with soil losses into waterbody. The proposed revetment is anticipated to protect these resources. I hope these responses provide sufficient information for your review. Sincerely, David Kledzik, PE SCALE: 1" = 40' LANDSCAPE PLANTING PLAN B A C52' 47' PHRAGMITES EXISTING TREES BEACH 0' 40'20' RESTORE TURFGRASS BUFFER & BED RESTORATION PLANTED WITH NATIVE PLANTS SUCH AS FROM APPENDIX A OF THE RIPARIAN BUFFERS GUIDANCE MANUAL TO COMPENSATE FOR 2308 SF OF TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION ACCESS AND PERMANENT RIPRAP ON BANK: 6 CANOPY 12 UNDERSTORY 18 SHRUBS RESTORE TURFGRASS PLANT LEGEND CANOPY UNDERSTORY SHRUBS 2026 MARINE ENGINEERING LLC - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.C #6954 PROPERTY LINE LOT 3 DAVID SPENCER RESPASS BEACH RD MLW MHW PROPOSED REVETMENT RETURN EXTENSION ABC DRIVEWAY EXISTING RIPRAP REVETMENT GRAVEL PATHWAY LOTS 4&5 DAVID SPENCER 100' RPA 50' RPA TURF/BED/NATURAL BORDER RACK LINE TURF TURF BED & TREES 1.5XMTR Virginia Marine Resources Commission Permit Application 20230895 Printed: Wednesday October 1, 2025 3:50 PM Applicant: David Spencer 6954 Respass Beach Road Suffolk, VA 23435 Application Number: 20230895 Engineer: Kirsten Travis Application Date: April 14, 2023 Locality: Suffolk Permit Type: No VMRC Permit Nec. Waterway: James River Permit Status: No Permit Nec Expiration Date: Wetlands Board Action: Public Hearing Date: Project Description: Revetment Virginia Marine Resources Commission Photos for Permit Application 20230895 Printed: Wednesday October 1, 2025 3:50 PM Date Photo Taken: 2023:06:15 15:05:16 Date Photo Taken: 2023:06:15 15:05:25 June 29, 2023 Ms. Lauren Chartrand Environmental Engineer Virginia Marine Resources Commission 380 Fenwick Road, Bldg. 96 Fort Monroe, VA 23651 Dear Ms. Chartrand: I have completed my assessment of the proposal by David Spencer to widen and lengthen a portion of an existing riprap revetment along the James River (VMRC 2023-0895) and find no significant adverse environmental impacts resulting from the project as proposed. The project will impact less than 10 square feet of saltmarsh cordgrass (Sporobolus alterniflorus, formerly Spartina alterniflora) embedded within the revetment, but relocation of this vegetation is planned near the toe of the new revetment section. The application states that the saltmarsh cordgrass will be replanted at an elevation below 1.5 times the mean tide range; however, saltmarsh cordgrass almost exclusively grows between the elevations of mean tide and mean high water. If relocation is authorized we recommend planting only within their natural tide range to provide the greatest likelihood of survival and growth. Although this is a small amount of tidal wetlands vegetation growing within the revetment, which can affect their level of habitat and water quality functions, we forward the following recommendations for consideration. The success of vegetation relocation is suspect since the plants will be placed in a situation of greater exposure to wave energy (the rock substrate currently provides some protection to the roots and lower stems). Also, natural communities of saltmarsh cordgrass have not naturally established in the target relocation area even though there are local seed sources. We recommend consideration of monitoring the relocated vegetation for a period of at least one year to determine the likelihood of survival. If relocation fails we recommend consideration of alternative methods of compensatory mitigation. Alternative compensatory mitigation methods may also be considered if relocation is not considered an appropriate strategy. Please contact me if you have questions or require further information. Sincerely, Lyle Varnell Associate Director for Advisory Services Received by VMRC June 29, 2023 /blh Outlook VMRC 23-0895 associated documents for 6954 Respass Beach Rd FromDavid@marineengineeringllc.com <info@marineengineeringllc.com> DateThu 5/7/2026 9:15 AM To Cassidy L. Mckelvie <cmckelvie@suffolkva.us> 6 attachments (3 MB) VMRC23-0895 - Plan Comments - 1st Submittal.pdf; Respass Beach Rd #6954 Landscape Buffer Planting.pdf; Respass Beach Rd #6954 Wetlands Checklist .pdf; Respass Beach Rd #6954 WQIA.pdf; VMRC23-0895 - Comments - 2nd Submittal.pdf; JPA - VMRC23-0895 - AddInfo_Rev2 - 6954 Respass Beach Rd.pdf; You don't often get email from info@marineengineeringllc.com. Learn why this is important Good Morning Cassidy, I have resubmitted the JPA Revision 2 through CENOA and have attached these associated files for you including theJPA. I’ve tried to address all the previous comments and hope this gets the project back on track. I did not get anacknowledgement for my responses to the second submittal comments and I hope you were able to recheck the redand purple colored envelope lines drawn on my site plan and see that they deviated from the lines of what I hadproposed to cove a larger area than what I put on application. Please contact me to clarify if needed. Revision 1 of site plan addressed redline comments on the 1st submittal and reduced the width of the riprap returnwall.Revision 2 of site plan clarifies impact of riprap to non-vegetated beach. I have also attached the WQIA, Landscape Planting Plan, checklist, and JPA resubmittal Rev2 (also formallysubmitted to CENAO) Updated responses to Grace’s comments: Additional justification for the proposed riprap revetment as best alternative for shoreline protection in lieu of a livingshoreline combined with a sill or breakwater structure.There are 27 miles of open water fetch to the NW toward Williamsburg and 32 miles to the NE towards CapeCharles. These distances greatly exceed recommended guidelines for a typical living shore involving a sill since winddriven water levels and breaking waves would easily overtop the sill to wash out plants & substrate. Anotheralternative considered was installing a breakwater to protect shoreline from wave energy. The design would need tobe effective for fetch approaching from two directions. To accomplish this the size of the structure would be muchlarger than the proposed revetment. Unfortunately, the cost would be prohibitive for a residential budget. Additionally, the impacts associated with construction access and footprint would be much more. Such a largeproject would also include greater risks such as scour to surrounding bottom and wetlands from currents & waves. Entrapment of debris could layer over plants, presenting a maintenance issue for habitat health. Considering thehigh cost, much greater disturbance from installation, greater impacts to bottom and intertidal related to size of thebreakwater, and the risks associated with larger structures clarifies that a revetment is more suited to this project thana breakwater or living shore. Sequence and timeline revised.(Construction timeline 9/1/26 TO 12/31/29 (subject to change) Please let me know you received this and advise if I should be sending to another address. Thank you. Sincerely, David KledzikMarine Engineering LLCManager(757) 477-4787 From: David Kledzik To: MRC - jpa Permits Subject: JPA - VMRC23-0895 - AddInfo_Rev1 - 6954 Respass Beach Rd Date: Monday, August 25, 2025 2:21:26 PM Attachments: JPA - VMRC23-0895 - AddInfo_Rev1 - 6954 Respass Beach Rd.pdf Dear VMRC, Please accept this JPA Rev 1 resubmittal to revise / add info and forward to all as needed. In response to Suffolk planning comments, additional justifications to support the necessity of proposed revetment are provided and additional information has been added to the site plan. There are 27 miles of open water fetch to the NW toward Williamsburg and 32 miles to the NE towards Cape Charles. These distances greatly exceed recommended guidelines for a typical living shore involving a sill since wind driven water levels and breaking waves would easily overtop the sill to wash out plants & substrate. Another alternative considered was installing a breakwater to protect shoreline from wave energy. The design would need to be effective for fetch approaching from two directions. To accomplish this the size of the structure would be much larger than the proposed revetment. The cost for a breakwater project such as this would be prohibitive for a typical residential home owner and the impacts associated with construction access and footprint would be much more too. Such a large project would also include greater risks such as scour to surrounding bottom and wetlands from currents & waves. Entrapment of debris could layer over plants, presenting a maintenance issue for habitat health. Considering the high cost, much greater disturbance from installation, greater impacts to bottom and intertidal related to size of the breakwater, and the risks associated with larger structures clearly shows that a revetment is more suited to this project than a breakwater. The width of proposed return extension has been reduced between points A-B, to lessen the footprint of additional riprap. RPA lines, timeline notes, additional scale and north arrow info have been added to the site plan. The reduction of riprap is in the RPA, therefore there are no changes of quantitative impacts to wetlands or beach previously included in JPA. Sincerely, David Kledzik, PE Manager Marine Engineering LLC 757 477-4787 Additional Information/Revisions Recieved by VMRC Aug 25, 2025 map S A UARRYSTONE RIPRAP US 670 EWAY EVETMENT ONG SLOPE TRUCTURE S 1-2 CORE TH CLASS 1 WARD PT A REMO TO D 2 SF VEG IN RIPRAP 4 SF VEG IN RIPRAP ) 20' 20' B C' 47' X3 X2 S DISPLACED ALONG TOE EVETMENT BEACH 1.5XMTR

Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.