RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jun 10, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION Tuesday, June 10, 2025 | 4:00 PM 2nd Floor Conference Room- City Hall 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 AGENDA I. Welcome Larry Taylor, Mayor II. Work Session Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager III. Work Session Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager III.1. FY 2026 Budget Work Session IV. Business Item Briefing(s) V. Roll Call V.2. Discuss the Multiple Public-Facing Video Copies of the Defamation of a Lynchburg Citizen Currently Posted on City Media Channels. (Vice Mayor Diemer) VI. Closed Session Page 1 of 24 Page 2 of 24 WHAT IS PPTRA? • Personal Property Tax Relief Act of 1998 • Qualifies for Relief: A passenger car, motorcycle, pickup truck or panel truck owned by an individual, up to a certain weight • Does not Qualify for Relief: Motor homes, trailers, boats and farm use vehicles; or any vehicle used for business purposes more than 50% of the time for individuals; and no commercial vehicles. Page 3 of 24 WHAT IS THE PPTRA RELIEF FORMULA? In Lynchburg (varies across the state): • The current tax rate is 3.8%, which amounts to $3.80 per every $100 of assessed value • A 100% tax relief on the first $1,000 of the vehicle's value • In 2026, a 30.64% tax relief on the vehicle’s value from $1,001 to $20,000 • No tax relief for the portion of a vehicle's assessed value over $20,000 Page 4 of 24 EXAMPLE OF CURRENT TAX STRUCTURE ($3.80) Value of Vehicle Total Tax Local Tax Relief PPTRA Tax Relief on $20,000 value (30.64%) Tax Amount Paid After PPTRA Tax Above $20,000 value Tax Amount Paid Above $20,000 Amount Citizen Pays $1000 $38 100% $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $20,000 $760 0% $232.86 $527.14 $0 $0 $527.14 $30,000 $1140 0% $232.86 $527.14 100% $380 $907.14 $40,000 $1520 0% $232.86 $527.14 100% $760 $1,287.1 4 Page 5 of 24 PPTRA RELIEF FOR LOCALITIES • Counties, cities, and towns are reimbursed by the Commonwealth for providing the required tangible personal property tax (PPTRA) relief (§ 58.1-3524) • In 2006, the Commonwealth established that the State will pay a total of $950 million for each tax year in reimbursements to localities • Reimbursement is based on the proportion of actual payments to a city based on the year 2005, compared to the actual payments of all counties, cities, and towns in Virginia in the same year • The City of Lynchburg receives $5.5 million in PPTRA reimbursement for providing tax relief Page 6 of 24 PROPOSED TAX RELIEF FORMULA • The tax rate would decrease from $3.80 to $1.30 per every $100 of assessed value • 100% tax relief would increase from $1,000 of vehicle’s value to $20,000 of vehicle's value • No tax relief for the portion of a vehicle's assessed value over $20,000 • The City would still be eligible for PPTRA reimbursement from the State in the amount of $5.5 million for providing tax relief Page 7 of 24 EXAMPLE OF PROPOSED TAX STRUCTURE ($1.30) Value of Vehicle Total Tax Local Tax Relief PPTRA Tax Relief on $20,000 value (30.64%) Tax Amount Paid After PPTRA Tax Above $20,000 value Tax Amount paid Above $20,000 Proposed Amount Citizen Pays Current Amount Citizen Pays $1000 $38 100% 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 $20,000 $760 100% 0 0 0 0 $0 $527.14 $30,000 $1140 100% on $20,000 0 0 100% $130 $130 $907.14 $40,000 $1520 100% on $20,000 0 0 100% $260 $260 $1,287.14 Under the proposed tax structure, ~45,500 vehicles would incur $0 in taxes. Currently, ~5,500 vehicles incur $0 in taxes. Page 8 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: REVENUE Current Structure Proposed Structure $22,000,000* $8,000,000 Revenue +/- - $14,000,000 $3.80 & $1,000 exempt $1.30 & $20,000 exempt • The proposed changes to the Personal Property Tax rate will reduce revenue by ~$14,000,000. * FY26 Proposed Revenue Page 9 of 24 From To $0.89 $1.025 Change + $12,246,498 6.5% $1 8.5% $3 + $1,035,954 + $866,300 Real Property: Lodging Tax: Lodging Fee: = = = HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: REVENUE • Increased revenue from adjusting the Real Property Rate, Lodging Rate, and Lodging Room Fee would allow for passing the budget as proposed. Total Revenue Adjustment: $14,148,752 Page 10 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: RENTERS • 50% of household units in the city are Renter Occupied. • 83% of Renter Occupied Households have at least 1 vehicle (owned or leased). • The average vehicle, valued at $10,000, costs $264 year in PPT at the current rate. # Vehicles # Renter Households % Renter Households Annual Savings per Renter Household 0 2,569 17% 0 1 6,597 45% $264 2 4,207 28% $528 3 924 6% $792 4 382 3% $1056 5 147 1% $1320+ Source: 2018-2022 Census American Community Survey Page 11 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: HOMEOWNERS • 81 % of single-family residential properties are assessed below $300,000. • 91.5% are assessed below $400,000. Proposal Rate $0 -$100k $100k-$200k $200k-$300k $300k-$400k Original $0.89 $890 $1,780 $2,670 $3,560 PPT Reduction $1.025 $1,025 $2,050 $3,075 $4,100 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $767 $1,534 $2,301 $3,068 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $808 $1,616 $2,424 $3,232 Page 12 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: HOMEOWNERS Proposal Rate Home $100,000 Car 1 $10,000 Car 2 $10,000 Total Original $0.89 $890 $264 $264 $1,418 PPT Reduction $1.025 $1,025 $0 $0 $1,025 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $767 $264 $264 $1,295 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $808 $264 $264 $1,336 $100,000 $219,100 $400,000 Proposal Rate Home $100,000 Car 1 $30,000 Car 2 $30,000 Total Original $0.89 $890 $907 $907 $2,704 PPT Reduction $1.025 $1,025 $130 $130 $1,285 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $767 $907 $907 $2,581 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $808 $907 $907 $2,622 $10,000 $30,000 Page 13 of 24 Proposal Rate Home $219,100 Car 1 $10,000 Car 2 $10,000 Total Original $0.89 $1,950 $264 $264 $2,478 PPT Reduction $1.025 $2,246 $0 $0 $2,246 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $1,680 $264 $264 $2,208 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $1,770 $264 $264 $2,298 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: HOMEOWNERS Proposal Rate Home $219,100 Car 1 $30,000 Car 2 $30,000 Total Original $0.89 $1,950 $907 $907 $3,764 PPT Reduction $1.025 $2,246 $130 $130 $2,506 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $1,680 $907 $907 $3,494 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $1,770 $907 $907 $3,584 $100,000 $219,100 $400,000 $10,000 $30,000 Page 14 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: HOMEOWNERS Proposal Rate Home $400,000 Car 1 $10,000 Car 2 $10,000 Total Original $0.89 $3,560 $264 $264 $4,088 PPT Reduction $1.025 $4,100 $0 $0 $4,100 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $3,068 $264 $264 $3,596 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $3,232 $264 $264 $3,760 Proposal Rate Home $400,000 Car 1 $30,000 Car 2 $30,000 Total Original $0.89 $3,560 $907 $907 $5,374 PPT Reduction $1.025 $4,100 $130 $130 $4,360 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $3,068 $907 $907 $4,882 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $3,232 $907 $907 $5,046 $100,000 $219,100 $400,000 $10,000 $30,000 Page 15 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: HOTEL OWNERS • Average increase in real property tax: $9,650 annually • Maximum increase in real property tax: $24,165 annually • The combined % of taxes and fees per room booking increases from 7.11% to 10.33% for the average room rate of $164. Proposal Rate Median $7,250,000 Average $7,148,882 Original $0.89 $64,525 $63,625 PPT Reduction $1.025 $74,313 $73,276 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $55,608 $54,832 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $58,580 $57,763 Rooms Current Tax Current Fee Proposed Tax Proposed Fee 1 $10.66 $1 $13.94 $3 50 $533 $50 $697 $150 100 $1,066 $100 $1,394 $300 150 $1,599 $150 $2,091 $450 Real Property Lodging 7.11% @ Average $164 rate 10.33% @ Average $164 rate Page 16 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: MULTI- FAMILY • Properties: ~300 • Median: $812,250 • Average: $3,192,227 Proposal Rate Median $812,250 Average $3,192,227 Max $67,500,000 Original $0.89 $7,229 $28,411 $600,750 PPT Reduction $1.025 $8,326 $32,720 $691,875 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $6,230 $24,484 $517,725 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $6,563 $25,793 $545,400 Page 17 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: COMMERCIAL • Properties: ~2,275 • Median: $232,000 • Average: $825,000 Proposal Rate Median $232,000 Average $825,000 Max $47,000,000 Original $0.89 $2,065 $7,350 $418,300 PPT Reduction $1.025 $2,378 $8,456 $481,750 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $1,779 $6,334 $360,490 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $1,875 $6,672 $379,760 Page 18 of 24 HOW WILL THIS AFFECT: INDUSTRIAL • Properties: ~450 • Median assessed value: $222,500 • Average assessed value: $1,151,930 Proposal Rate Median $222,500 Average $1,151,930 Max $27,000,000 Original $0.89 $1,980 $10,252 $240,300 PPT Reduction $1.025 $2,281 $11,807 $276,750 Equalization - Flat $0.767 $1,707 $8,835 $207,090 Equalization – 2 Year $0.808 $1,798 $9,308 $218,160 Page 19 of 24 QUESTIONS • How would the proposed real estate tax rate increase affect housing demand and home sales, compared to the equalization rate? • What impact would the rate increase have on local economic growth, including jobs and construction, versus equalization? • How might the rate increase lower home values, and how does this compare to equalization? • How would reduced home values affect residents’ wealth, especially for low-income and minority homeowners, compared to equalization? • How does eliminating the car tax and relying more on real estate taxes increase exposure to market fluctuations, and how does keeping the car tax with equalization help? Page 20 of 24 TAKE AWAYS • Who benefits : • More residents of Lynchburg will benefit from a reduction in car tax than would benefit from a reduction in real estate tax. • Renters will benefit the most in the shorter term. • Homeowners, especially those who own more expensive vehicles and/or who own more vehicles. • Who does not benefit: • Commercial property owners. • Hotel owners if both real estate and lodging taxes increase. • Multi-Family residential owners. Page 21 of 24 Page 22 of 24 Page 23 of 24 Page 24 of 24

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.