RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of May 13, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL Tuesday, May 13, 2025 | 7:00 PM Council Chamber- City Hall 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 AGENDA I. Invocation Councilmember Faraldi I.1. Pledge of Allegiance led by Scout Troop 180 II. Recognitions II.2. National Economic Development Week Proclamation II.3. National Travel and Tourism Week Proclamation II.4. Recovery Court Month Proclamation III. Consent Agenda III.5. Consideration of approving the minutes from the March 25, 2025, City Council meeting. III.6. Consideration of approving the minutes from the April 8, 2025, City Council meeting. IV. Public Hearing IV.7. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-032 approving the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) project recommendations for FY 2026 CDBG and HOME Program entitlement funds to be included in the 2025 Annual Action Plan. IV.8. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-033 granting a non-exclusive limited franchise to Rosedale Investments, LLC and Rosedale Owners Association, Inc. for use, maintenance, and work on certain encroachments in the public rights-of- way at 1600 Graves Mill Road. IV.9. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-034 amending Section 36-270 of the City Code for purposes of changing an exception to the City's Amusement Tax. IV.10. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-035 granting Hillcats Baseball, LLC an exclusive franchise right to use the City of Lynchburg’s / Bank of the James Stadium for its baseball games, events, and related uses. IV.11. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-036 authorizing a Water & Sewer Contract between the City of Lynchburg and CertainTeed, LLC that, among other terms, will set fixed rates for water and wastewater services. IV.12. Consideration of introducing Ordinance #O-25-037 approving the FY 2025 Third Quarter Adjustments. IV.13. Conduct a public hearing to receive citizen input regarding appointments, or reappointments, to vacancies that will exist June 30, 2025, in School Board Districts I, II, III. Page 1 of 207 V. Public Comment V.14. Hear from a citizen regarding "the City Public Library at the Plaza, health and safety concerns". (Joshua Pratt) V.15. Hear from a citizen regarding "fears members of the LGBTQ+ encounter". (Theresa O'Dell) V.16. Hear from a group representative regarding "lighten the burden". (Gregory Berry)(City Elders) V.17. Hear from a citizen regarding "capital improvements at the library”. (Crystal Howell) V.18. Hear from a citizen regarding "Council member Misjuns inappropriate email to city employees". (Susan Stengel) V.19. Hear from a citizen regarding "what's happening in Lynchburg". (Peter Cefaratti) V.20. Hear from a citizen regarding "Lynchburg Public Library oversight needed". (Colin Plank) V.21. Hear from a citizen regarding "support [of] the current tax rate and funding for the library, schools, and pool". (Stacey Cheatham) VI. General Business VI.22. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-038 amending the FY 2025 City Capital Projects Fund budget and appropriating $125,000 to improve parking at the Ed Page entrance to the Blackwater Creek Trail. VI.23. Consideration of introducing Ordinance #O-25-039 amending the FY 2025 City Capital Projects Fund budget and appropriating $5,250,000 to create a fan experience project at the City of Lynchburg’s Bank of the James Stadium in conjunction with the 2025 Hillcats Franchise Agreement. VI.24. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-___ amending the Lynchburg City Council's Rules of Procedure to amend subsection B(12) and include a new subsection B(15) under Section 5-3 - Public Comment. VII. Closed Session Page 2 of 207 March 25, 2025 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 25th day of March, 2025, at 4:00 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Training Room, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of FY2026 Budget, Agenda Item #1, Council conducted a work session regarding the Water, Sewer, and Stormwater FY 2026 Operating and Capital Budgets and Proposed Rates Presentation. Director of Water Resources Timothy Mitchell provided an overview of the Water, Sewer, and Stormwater Enterprise Funds FY 2026 Operating Budgets and Capital Improvement Program as well as the recommended Water, Sewer, and Stormwater rate increases needed to fund ongoing expenses and capital needs while taking into account increasing personnel, contractual, and inflationary expenses. Councilmember Wilder asked what would happen if Council did not approve the rate increases. Mr. Mitchell replied that the first thing they would do would be to scale back capital improvement projects. Councilmember Misjuns asked how they were equipped to handle the water plant experiencing a massive power outage. Mr. Mitchell said they had stand-by generators at all critical facilities, and they performed regular exercises. He said there were two water treatment plants in the City, so there was redundancy in the system. He said they were reviewing the recent events in Richmond to ensure they did not face a similar situation. He said he was confident in the backup systems because they performed regular exercises. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt provided updates and addressed questions regarding the FY 26 Budget. Councilmember Reed expressed concerns about spending nearly $3 million on Wiggington Road improvements to benefit a single development when the development stood to generate over $225 million from the sale of the units. She asked if Council has ever been asked to contribute millions for road improvements tied to a development. Ms. Witt could not recall such an instance, and Community Development Director Tom Martin confirmed it was highly unusual, noting that while there were projects like Rosedale involving payback over time, none matched this scale. Page 3 of 207 March 25, 2025 Councilmember Faraldi noted that the total cost of the Wiggington Road improvements would be more because of the interest on the bonds. Councilmember Timmer shared appreciation for City staff prioritizing this project as it has been neglected for decades. She asked the staff whether SMART SCALE funding could be reallocated to other road priorities to potentially free up funding for the project. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick explained that SMART SCALE funding is not flexible, and revenue sharing is limited each year. Redirecting funds would impact other projects. External funding through earmarks is highly unlikely. Councilmember Misjuns asked if the inability to move funds between projects means the $14 million roundabout on Vassar Street and Langhorne Road is the only option moving forward. Mr. Patrick noted that the project is mainly funded by SMART SCALE. The relocation of a water line from the Peddler Reservoir adds costs, which are covered by revenue sharing in this year’s budget. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there is a way to shift the funds from the Vassar Street/Langhorne Road project to the 501/221 project. Mr. Patrick replied that it is unlikely but staff would look into it. Councilmember Misjuns questioned the feasibility of completing the Bedford Avenue Bridge replacement within one year, as well as the timeline for the Hollins Mill Bridge. Ms. Witt explained that the cash flow for the project may extend beyond 12 months. However, once the contract is signed, the project is appropriated within that fiscal year. Councilmember Misjuns raised concerns about both bridges being closed simultaneously and requested staff consider delaying projects to avoid overlapping closures. Councilmember Reed suggested that any canceled project funds should be reappropriated to the Schools due to their underfunding. Councilmember Timmer acknowledged that road infrastructure is a primary city responsibility and has been neglected since annexation. She highlighted the city’s broader deferred maintenance issues. Councilmember Faraldi inquired about the Bedford Avenue improvements. Mr. Patrick answered that the focus is primarily on pedestrian safety. Councilmember Faraldi expressed disappointment in removing $1.4 million for traffic safety improvements in the Bedford Avenue area, especially given the ongoing development and investment in the area. Councilmember Misjuns inquired about the funding sources for past infrastructure projects, specifically Greenview Drive and Enterprise Drive. Staff agreed to research the funding for Greenview Page 4 of 207 March 25, 2025 Drive and confirmed that VDOT funded the Enterprise Drive project. Councilmember Misjuns highlighted that public funds have historically supported major developments and emphasized that Wiggington Road, which serves multiple city subdivisions, is in need of long-overdue improvements. Ms. Witt provided clarified details of the Property Toolkit. Councilmember Misjuns inquired about a new state law allowing penalties on commercial structures. Mr. Martin noted the Ordinance would need to be updated to include it. Councilmember Misjuns also asked about the City’s progress in recovering demolition costs from property owners. Ms. Witt replied that the City often recovers demolition costs through tax sales and aims to avoid writing off these expenses. Ms. Witt provided information about tax relief for the elderly and disabled. Councilmember Wilder asked how someone would qualify for the tax relief program. Commissioner of the Revenue Mitch Nuckles explained that the income limit for qualification is $48,200, with the primary restriction being income. Councilmember Wilder inquired about whether there is a specific time period for submitting applications. Mr. Nuckles responded that renewal applications are sent in June and due by August 1st. Staff uses various methods to notify applicants and considers hardship cases. Vice Mayor Diemer asked if there is verification on net worth. Mr. Nuckles said the department has access to income tax information to verify. Ms. Witt shared that staff is compiling responses to questions from the Budget & Brews events and plans to publish them on the City’s website next week. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #2, Council was briefed regarding 2811 Campbell Avenue - CUP - Pawn Shop. City Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided the presentation to Council. LPP, LLC, is petitioning to amend the conditions of the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the existing pawn shop at 2811 Campbell Avenue. A CUP was previously issued for the pawn shop in 2014. The petitioner has requested that the conditions of that CUP be modified to adjust operating hours and allow the sale/pawn of firearms. Page 5 of 207 March 25, 2025 The property is zoned R-3, Medium Density Residential District. The Comprehensive Plan 2013- 2030 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Traditional Residential use for the subject property. Small retail uses can be consistent with this land use designation. The Planning Commission motion to approve the petition failed in a tie vote. The Planning Commission Bylaws, Article VII - Voting, 7.2 states: "A tie vote shall be a rejection of the motion presented." Councilmember Faraldi asked if the ATF issued a license for the business. Ms. Frischeisen replied that the ATF issued a firearms license in 2021, but the zoning administrator at the time was not aware there was a CUP in place that specifically prohibited firearm sales. Councilmember Faraldi asked if using a CUP to limit business operations is still practiced. Ms. Frischeisen explained it is not. Councilmember Faraldi asked if resuming a discontinued zoning practice would violate the current ordinance or set a new precedent. Ms. Frischeisen explained that due to changes in authority, Council – not the Board of Zoning Appeals – must now handle requests to amend conditions for lawful non- conforming uses. This case is considered unique, and not intended to set a precedent. City Attorney Matthew Freedman confirmed that any amendments to the conditional use permit would need City Council approval. Ms. Frischeisen explained that rezoning could create challenges, including setbacks, buffers, and the potential for undesirable uses near residential areas. Councilmember Faraldi asked what staff’s recommendation was. Ms. Frischeisen explained that staff recommended approval of the amended conditions based on the fact that the business has been operating since 2021 without issue. Councilmember Faraldi asked if this were to stay in, if they would forbid the sale of knives anywhere. Mr. Freedman responded that he supposed they could as part of a CUP, but he was not aware of that. Councilmember Faraldi said that he hoped Council would adopt staff’s recommendations as he understands them, and hopefully this would not turn into anything more than a simple approval. He said he would not be at the next meeting and reiterated that he hoped Council would adopt this. Councilmember Misjuns asked staff to follow up with information on any other properties that may have similar restrictions. Ms. Frischeisen said that it would likely be through a CUP, and staff could look into it. Councilmember Misjuns asked staff to also look into whether the City restricted people from obtaining federal firearms licenses for their personal residences, as they would need to reverse that if it Page 6 of 207 March 25, 2025 was the case. He clarified that it is a license to be a firearms dealer, as sometimes you needed that license just for antiques, collectibles, etc., and he wanted to ensure they weren’t restricting that. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder announced that Beacon of Hope was hosting an event during the first week of April called HOPEx. He said that he was thankful for the work done by Beacon of Hope. Councilmember Timmer said she had three encounters with the fire department in the past two weeks. She said that an ambulance was on fire, and the fire department responded. She said that she received a text message from a constituent containing images depicting an open flame fire, and the fire department responded. She said that the fire department recently drove down her street, and she recognized the driver of the fire truck. She gave a shout-out to the fire department and acknowledged its frequent activity in the City. She said she wanted to shout-out Jevon, who helped her clean out brush and bulk waste from her yard. She said that people at Park View Mission had a tour opportunity, and she appreciated the work they were doing. She asked that staff look into providing councilmembers a work space in City Hall to meet with constituents, print materials, and work with staff. Councilmember Misjuns said he appreciated staff addressing assessments being sent to the wrong addresses. He said that the City was not adequately communicating the proposed tax rate to residents, and he suggested more emphasis on the proposed tax rate when materials were sent out to residents. He said that he wanted to see more information regarding the maintenance plan for EMS equipment. He said that the equipment was in a poor state, and they should reconsider CIP allocations to meet the equipment maintenance needs. Vice Mayor Diemer said he wanted to provide an update on the visits he had been having with different City departments. He said that he almost lost his hearing visiting the bell tower in the courthouse. He said that the fire department ride along was the least eventful. He said he visited the new airport director, but the visit was cut short due to an emergency landing. He said he had to postpone a tour of the water department, but he wanted to reschedule it. He said he agreed with the confusion over assessments, and he believed the City could improve communications. He said that regarding the budget dashboard, they should have a graph or chart that showed a breakdown of revenues by ward. He said that he wanted to highlight the Habitat for Humanity team who recently completed a residence in Ward 3. Page 7 of 207 March 25, 2025 He said he attended the unveiling and saw the family move in. He said that it was important to help families achieve homeownership and generational wealth. Mayor Taylor said that Vietnam Veterans Remembrance Day was upcoming, where they recognized the veterans' courage, sacrifice, and dedication that helped shaped the freedoms they enjoyed. He said an event would be held on Friday at Monument Terrace, and he offered thanks to Dr. Beth White for initiating the proclamation request in honor of her late husband. // On the motion of Councilmember Timmer, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, by the following recorded vote, Council elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the award of a public contract involving the expenditure of public funds, where discussion in an open session would adversely affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the public body, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(29) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, the subject of the closed meeting being specific to a future contract between the City and CertainTeed; and for the purpose of a briefing by staff to Council on public safety and vulnerability, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(19), of the Code of Virginia, 1950 as amended; and to discuss appointments for vacancies to the following Boards and Commissions: Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Committee, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, and Planning Commission, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. The motion did not include Item #6, in consideration of a closed session to review and/or evaluate the performance of the City Attorney pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. Councilmember Timmer suggested Council consider a rules change, and there was an opportunity to move away from premature action and establish a process of deliberation. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Misjuns made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and Page 8 of 207 March 25, 2025 WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Wilder, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // Councilmember Misjuns made the motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to appoint Gary Woodson to the Planning Commission for a term expiring December 31, 2027. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would be voting in opposition due to the fact that he felt there were other candidates more qualified. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Faraldi, Reed, Wilder 3 On motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was recessed at 6:35 p.m. Page 9 of 207 March 25, 2025 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 25th day of March, 2025, at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Reed led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Agenda Item #1, Mayor Taylor recognized the LCA Bulldogs for winning the VHSL Class III State Championship. He congratulated Head Coach Frank Rocco, his staff, and team captains Gideon Davidson, Easton Ware, Ryan Sissney, and James Deyo. He said that Coach Rocco was named Region 3C and Seminal District Coach of the Year. // In the matter of Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #2, copies of the minutes of the February 18, 2025 City Council meeting were previously furnished to Council, and on the motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 In the matter of Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #2, copies of the minutes of the February 25, 2025 City Council meeting were previously furnished to Council, and on the motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #4, Citizen Deborah Trefzger addressed Council regarding the City Budget. She expressed concerns about books in the public library for attacking the image of God. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #5, Citizen Katie Yergler addressed Council regarding building a stronger community through civil discussion. Page 10 of 207 March 25, 2025 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Jamie Maxwell, representing The Lynchburg Firefighters Association, addressed Council regarding the aging fire department infrastructure. He said he would provide a presentation showing the deteriorating conditions. He displayed ceiling tiles from Station 1 and 8 covered in black mastic asbestos and asked if it was worth the risk to the health of firefighters. He said it was urgent that Council fund fire station improvements. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen Greg Berry, representing City Elders, addressed Council regarding support for Councilmember Misjuns. He called for a full audit of City finances and the establishment of a Library Board. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #8, Citizen Joshua Pratt, representing Action Mission, addressed Council regarding moral and ethical direction of the City of Lynchburg in regards to leadership from the City Council. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #9, Citizen Margaret Johnson addressed Council regarding public safety. She said that on February 7, 2019, a Lynchburg Police Officer assaulted her, causing her to lose all of the teeth on the left side of her mouth. She asked that Council examine this matter. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Citizen Ronald Storer addressed Council regarding wisdom for City Council. He said that councilmembers who were Christian should meditate on God's word when making decisions. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #11, Citizen William Maxson addressed Council regarding the West Point Village rezoning decision. He said that the decision left him with a feeling of corruption from Council because it was inconsistent with previous decisions. He requested that Council consider a traffic circle to mitigate traffic impacts. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #12, Citizen Peter Cefaratti addressed Council regarding an agenda item. He called for an audit of City finances. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #13, Citizen Jason Cholewa, representing Opposition Group to the Rezoning of 805-916 Wiggington Road, addressed Council regarding voting inconsistencies related to rezoning by Councilmembers. He criticized City Council for inconsistent rezoning decisions and prioritizing corporate interests over community concerns, demanding transparency and accountability. Page 11 of 207 March 25, 2025 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #14, Citizen Chris Adams was not present. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #15, Citizen Jon Fallen addressed Council regarding the Lynchburg Public Library in the CIP. He expressed support for the Lynchburg Public Library and encouraged Council to fund the library renovations. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #16, Citizen Dierdra Flavin addressed Council regarding support for the Lynchburg Public Library. She said that the library was professionally managed by the City Manager, and the establishment of a Library Board would be an unnecessary expansion of City government. She said that parents were responsible for monitoring their children's library access. She said that the library had an established process to review books of concern, initiated by a simple form submission, but zero books had been challenged in the last decade. She asked Council to support investment in the library. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #17, Citizen Hope McRorie, representing We the People, addressed Council regarding property value. She expressed concerns about her increasing property values, and she requested an audit of City finances. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #18, Citizen Gary Taylor was not present. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #19, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-25-025 approving the relocation of Lynchburg City Council's Work Session meetings to the Second Floor Training Room for the remainder of the 2025 calendar year. Mayor Taylor said that the item was discussed during a previous work session. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney briefed Council on the request. To ensure seamless streaming of City Council committee meetings, all Council work sessions must be held in the same location. Since the 2025 City Council meeting calendar has already been set, City Council must suspend their Rules of Procedure relating to the location of meetings to allow for a new schedule to be set for the remainder of 2025. The resolution will be effective for a time period of May 13, 2025 - December 9, 2025. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to adopt Resolution #R-25-025 and amend the end date to July 31, 2025. Page 12 of 207 March 25, 2025 City Attorney Matthew Freedman explained that the resolution was essentially correcting the actions of Council from July 2024. He said that this resolution would not impact the decisions of Council to set the 2026 calendar in July. Councilmember Misjuns said that he did not want to make changes to the rules of procedure if they were going to make changes later in the year. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Parks and Recreation, Agenda Item #20, Council considered adopting Resolution #R- 25-026 accepting the return of real estate from Lynchburg City Schools specific to Heritage Elementary and Heritage High Schools. Mayor Taylor stated that the item was previously discussed during the March 11 work session. Parks & Recreation is requesting acceptance of a former Heritage High School athletic facility as part of Heritage Park. The facility would be renovated using existing capital funding to provide a much-needed multipurpose field in an area of the City that has limited public recreation options. As part of the renovations, field lighting would be added to extend the availability of the field's use. The Lynchburg City School Board unanimously approved the return of real estate at their March 4, 2025 meeting. Councilmember Timmer motioned, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to adopt Resolution #R-25-026. Councilmember Misjuns expressed the need for a public park and investment in parks and recreation in Ward 3. Vice Mayor Diemer thanked staff and noted that the park would fulfill standing promises. Councilmember Wilder emphasized the importance of investing in community assets like Heritage Park to enhance quality of life and attract people to Lynchburg. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Page 13 of 207 March 25, 2025 // In the matter of Recovery Court, Agenda Item #21, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-25- 027 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $17,490 for support of the Lynchburg Adult Recovery Court docket to address public health crisis. Mayor Taylor stated that the item was previously presented to the Finance Committee. Adult Recovery Court Program Director Taylor Jones provided the presentation to Council. The Lynchburg Drug/Recovery Court is a court docket within the existing Circuit Court that is designed to enhance public safety by providing an integrated system of treatment and judicial supervision that results in a reduction in substance use/dependency and recidivism. The Lynchburg Drug/Recovery Court began in March 2017 as the result of a grant from the Supreme Court of Virginia. The Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services State Opioid Response (SOR) team has awarded the Lynchburg Adult Recovery Court a grant of $17,490 to address the public health crisis caused by escalating opioid misuse, opioid use disorder (OUD), and opioid-related overdose across the nation. These funds can be used to: (1) increase access to U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)- approved medications for the treatment of opioid use disorder (MOUD); (2) support the continuum of prevention, harm reduction treatment, and recovery support services for OUD and other concurrent substance use disorders; and (3) support the continuum of care for stimulant misuse and use disorders, including those involving cocaine and methamphetamine. At its March 25, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Financial Services and Roads to Recovery, Agenda Item #22, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-25-028 to authorize the City Manager to execute a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Roads to Recovery, Inc. (R2R); and consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-029 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $193,422 for purposes of providing funds to establish and deliver withdrawal management services. Mayor Taylor stated that the item was previously presented before the Finance Committee. Chief Financial Officer Page 14 of 207 March 25, 2025 Donna Witt provided the presentation to Council. The City receives funds from the OAA through direct distributions and grants. R2R has applied to utilize City grant funds to establish and deliver withdrawal management services for individuals with opioid and other substance-use disorders in the City. The OAA has awarded R2R $193,421.31 for this purpose. In order to accept the grant funds and transfer the funds to R2R, City Council is requested to authorize the City Manager to sign the MOU between R2R and the City and also adopt the resolution to appropriate the funds. At its March 25, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required. Mayor Taylor disclosed that he was a contractor for Roads to Recovery, so he would abstain from the vote. Councilmember Faraldi disclosed he was on the Board of Horizon Behavioral Health, but he was able to engage on the matter independently. He expressed concerns that they did not go through an RFP process for the request. Ms. Witt explained that the funds had to be used specifically for opioid abatement and recovery. She said that if they issued an RFP, there were several national non-profits who could be awarded the funds, but then the funds would not be used within the community. She said their goal was to work with local non-profits. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick explained that the City partnered with Roads to Recovery in an application process reviewed by the state to access the pool of funds; it was not the City unilaterally allocating the funds. He said that this was more akin to a grant application process. Ms. Witt noted that another non-profit had reached out to her, and she was investigating whether they could apply these rules to their request. Councilmember Misjuns asked what would happen if they did not use the funds. Ms. Witt replied that there was no guidance as to what would happen if the funds were not spent. Councilmember Timmer acknowledged citizen concerns about the audit committee, and supported exploring it as a long-term solution while emphasizing the value of leveraging available funds. Page 15 of 207 March 25, 2025 Councilmember Faraldi clarified for the record that the MOU on page two includes a warehouse clause authorizing a grant application for FY25 programming service costs totaling $193,000, confirming the MOU’s financial relevance. Vice Mayor Diemer expressed the need for fairness and broader outreach to other organizations, expressed support for the project and its current participant, and advocated for reestablishing the audit committee to strengthen financial oversight. Ms. Witt confirmed that staff will review the use of funds to ensure compliance, following the same procedures used for CDBG and Horizon funds. Councilmember Timmer called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote on the MOU was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Faraldi 1 Abstain: Taylor 1 At its March 25, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval of Resolution #R- 25-029, appropriating the funds. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Faraldi 1 Abstain: Taylor 1 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #23, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-25-030 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $36,705 to purchase computer equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office, and the Lynchburg Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Mayor Taylor stated that the item was previously presented to the Finance Committee. Chief of Police Ryan Zuidema provided the presentation to Council. The City of Lynchburg was awarded $36,705 in Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant funding. The Lynchburg Police Department will use this funding to purchase computers and computer memory upgrades ($31,070). The Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office will use funds to purchase a Toshiba Page 16 of 207 March 25, 2025 Document Output and Management Station ($3,795). The Lynchburg Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney will use funds to purchase a laptop computer and computer accessories ($1,840). No local matching funds are required. At its March 25, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval of Resolution #R- 25-030. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. Councilmember Misjuns said that the Finance Committee unanimously recommended approval. No second was required. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #24, Council conducted a second reading and considered adopting Ordinance #O-25-022 amending the FY 2025 Water Capital Projects Fund Budget and appropriating $10,025,194 for the Lead and Copper Water Service Line Project. Director of Water Resources Timothy Mitchell provided the presentation to Council. On January 15, 2021, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) published the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions, which later took effect on December 16, 2021. These revisions laid out a series of new actions for all water utilities in the United States. The goal of this initiative is to identify lead sources in a water system, implement and/or optimize corrosion control treatment, and establish a plan to eliminate all sources of lead in the water supply system. As required by the new Lead and Copper Rule Revisions, we developed an initial Lead Service Line (LSL) Inventory and submitted it to the State by the required deadline of October 16, 2024. The LSL Inventory is required to identify all service line materials on both public and the private side. Lynchburg has over 26,000 public and private service lines. After the initial inventory approximately 19,000 service line materials remain unknown most of which are on the private side. Any service line that as an unknown service material is assumed to be lead and treated as lead until the material is confirmed. By 2027 all service lines and galvanized lines requiring replacement must be identified and a replacement plan developed, then by 2037 all lead service lines and galvanized service lines requiring replacement must be replaced. Page 17 of 207 March 25, 2025 On November 8, 2024, VDH awarded the City $10,025,194 in additional funding for continued inventory efforts and replacement of lead service lines and galvanized service lines requiring replacement. This funding can be used to replace both the public side and private side service lines. This additional funding includes $3,659,196 as principal forgiveness and $6,365,998 as a loan with optional 20-year and 30-year terms. Interest rate will be determined based on market rate in the month before loan closing, subject to the required minimum interest rate of 1.00% per annum for a 20-year loan or a 1.50% per annum for a 30-year loan. Councilmember Timmer motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt Ordinance #O-25- 022. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Wilder, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting adjourned at 8:34 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 18 of 207 April 8, 2025 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of April, 2025, at 4:00 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Training Room, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns 5 Absent: Chris Faraldi, Jacqueline Timmer 2 // In the matter of the Work Session Agenda Overview, City Manager Wynter Benda announced that on Monday, April 14 at 3 p.m., the first steel structures of the Riverfront Park Amphitheater would be raised. He said that the Kiwanis Centennial Riverfront Playground would open on Friday, May 2 at 3 p.m. with a ribbon cutting ceremony. // In the matter of the Budget, Agenda Item #1, Council conducted a work session regarding the FY 2026 Budget. Fire Chief Greg Wormser provided a presentation to Council on the state of the Fire Department infrastructure and equipment. Councilmember Misjuns asked how much of the Striker equipment was past its service life and what the service life was. Chief Wormser replied that none of the stretchers or stair chairs were beyond the service life. He said that the service life for the stretchers was 15 years. Councilmember Misjuns said that documentation from Striker indicated the service life was seven years for stretchers, and 51 pieces of equipment stocked by the Fire Department was beyond the service life, including 11 stretchers. He expressed concerns about exposure to PFAS in turnout gear, so he encouraged establishing a replacement plan to get PFAS-free gear. He asked if there had been asbestos tests of the flooring material in fire stations. Chief Wormser replied that in 2019, OSHA performed asbestos tests, which indicated less than 2% of the glue used had mastic asbestos. He said that they had started replacing flooring in the stations, and there were only a couple of stations that had not yet had flooring replaced, Station 1 and Station 8. Councilmember Misjuns requested information on the schedule for completing the floor replacements for Station 1 and Station 8. He requested information on how many people had been accepted into the paramedic school and how many had completed the program. Page 19 of 207 April 8, 2025 Councilmember Reed requested information regarding how many times over the past two years councilmembers had expressed concerns about the flooring in fire stations and gear for firefighters and requested funding for replacement. Councilmember Misjuns requested an audit of the $132,500 dollars appropriated in FY 24 for Station 8 renovations, which included floor replacement. Vice Mayor Diemer asked how the Fire Department managed equipment not covered by maintenance agreements. Chief Wormser stated that the team which serviced the equipment would be available later in the month, and the department paid for the costs out of its budget. He said that last year, the department spent about $160,000 on the maintenance agreement and items not covered by the maintenance agreement. Data Analyst Sean Conway provided a presentation on the City's structure inventory. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick provided a presentation on the public services that the City provided. Councilmember Misjuns requested information regarding how the City compared in terms of public school enrollment. He said that the City needed to work on lobbying the state to increase state funding for human services, which was based on population. He said that the City's caseload was comparable to Virginia Beach despite a drastically smaller population. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt provided a presentation on transportation projects. // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #2, Council was briefed regarding FY26 Community Development Advisory Committee recommendations for Community Development Block Grant and HOME Program Entitlement funds. Grants Manager Melva Walker briefed Council on the matter. The Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) met on April 3, 2025 and reviewed the applications that were submitted. The attached worksheets provide the project requests and CDAC recommendations. // In the matter of the School Board, Agenda Item #3, Council was briefed regarding the 2025 School Board Appointment Process. Clerk of Council Alicia L. Finney briefed Council on the matter. Outlined below is the 2025 proposed schedule: Page 20 of 207 April 8, 2025 • May 13, 2025 - Conduct a public hearing to receive citizen input regarding potential candidates • May 27, 2025 - Continuation of a public hearing to receive citizen input regarding potential candidates. At the close of the public hearing and while remaining in open session, Council will review and discuss applications filed with the Clerk of Council to determine those individuals to interview. • June 10, 2025 - Finalization of choosing candidates during General Business • June 11 - June 23, 2025 - Hold a slate of special meetings for the purpose of conducting interviews with candidates. These will be live-streamed as well as open to the public. • June 24, 2025 - City Council will discuss candidates during General Business and appoint three members to the School Board for new terms commencing July 1, 2025 and expiring June 30, 2028. Councilmember Misjuns expressed support for Council using a ballot method for School Board appointments. He also stated that he would like staff to conduct residency checks. Ms. Finney noted that Councilmember Faraldi had indicated to her that he would not support a ballot process. She said that if Council wanted to consider a ballot process, they could schedule a vote on it at the June 10 meeting under General Business. Vice Mayor Diemer said he supported proof-of-residency requirements and a ballot process, but he wanted to review a specific process. Ms. Finney said she could compile options for Council to consider and vote on. // In the matter of the Hillcats, Agenda Item #4, Council was briefed regarding the New Hillcats Baseball Franchise and Amendment to Local Amusement Tax Exceptions. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick briefed Council on the matter. The City administration and the new ownership group of the Lynchburg Hillcats have been negotiating a new franchise agreement for the use of the city-owned Bank of the James baseball stadium. The proposed franchise will see the future of baseball in Lynchburg secured for the next 15 years. The agreement will see the city make a $5.2 capital investment in the stadium facility. This investment is based on the expected local revenue the Hillcats will generate for the city over the next 15 years through, rent payments, sales and meals tax, and admissions tax. Page 21 of 207 April 8, 2025 Currently the Hillcats do not pay admissions tax based on local code exemption for sporting events that take place in a city owned facility. The new franchise will requires that this exemption be removed so that the expected admissions tax revenue will help fund the improvements to the facility. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #5, Council was briefed regarding FY 2025 Third Quarter Adjustments. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt briefed Council on the matter. The General, City/Federal/State Aid, Forfeited Assets, Children’s Services Act (CSA), Water, Sewer, Airport, Risk Management, City Capital Projects, Stormwater Capital Projects, and Airport Capital/Grant Projects Fund are amended to reflect the FY 2025 Third Quarter Adjustments. // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #6, Council was briefed regarding the CertainTeed Water and Sewer Contract. Director of Water Resources Tim Mitchell briefed Council on the matter. Historically, the City of Lynchburg has entered into Water and Sewer Contracts with very large industrial water users. For the past several decades, there has been a contract in place for the industry located at 1801 Concord Turnpike. Previous contracts were with RockTenn and Westrock. Currently, CertainTeed, a subsidiary of Saint-Gobain North America, owns and operates the facility specializing in a specific building product. CertainTeed is Lynchburg's single largest water and sewer user, providing critical revenues to the Water and Sewer Funds. Our Water and Sewer contracts are based on a cost of service methodology that looks at the specific infrastructure that provides service to the facility and the specific treatment costs for the volume of water purchased and volume of sewer used including high-strength waste in the form of Total Suspended Solids (TSS) and Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD). The methodology is also consistent with the terms of our CSO Consent Order which includes certain financial requirements associated with contract customers. This cost of service study is performed by an independent outside consultant and is updated every five years. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Misjuns requested clarification regarding the ordinances requiring a super majority for Council votes, specifically regarding department appropriations and aid to various associations, including public libraries. Mayor Taylor announced that April was Child Abuse Prevention Month, a time to reaffirm the City's commitment to protecting children. He said that child abuse, maltreatment, and neglect had lasting Page 22 of 207 April 8, 2025 impacts, and prevention required the effort of the entire community. He said that Lynchburg stood united against violence towards children. He said the City should work together to create a safe and nurturing environment for all. He thanked the Exchange Club for bringing attention to this cause, as well as the local and regional organizations which worked towards this cause. // The meeting recessed at 6:23 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of April, 2025, at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns 5 Absent: Chris Faraldi, Jacqueline Timmer 2 // Mayor Taylor led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Agenda Item #1, Mayor Taylor introduced a proclamation recognizing Telecommunicators. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema accepted the proclamation. Deputy Director of Emergency Services Amy McDaniel provided remarks to Council honoring Telecommunicators Week. // In the matter of the Agenda, Vice Mayor Diemer motioned, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to amend the agenda to include Citizen Jamie Maxwell under Public Comment. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns 3 Noes: Wilder, Reed 2 Absent: Faraldi, Timmer 2 // In the matter of Consent, Agenda Item #2, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-25-027 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $17,490 for support of the Lynchburg Adult Recovery Court docket to address public health crisis. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt Resolution #R-25- 027. Page 23 of 207 April 8, 2025 Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Faraldi, Timmer 2 // In the matter of Consent, Agenda Item #3, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-25-030 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $36,705 to purchase computer equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office, and the Lynchburg Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt Resolution #R-25- 027. Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Faraldi, Timmer 2 // In the matter of Consent, Agenda Item #4, copies of the minutes of the March 11, 2025 City Council meeting were previously furnished to Council, and on the motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Faraldi, Timmer 2 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #5, Council conducted a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-031 amending previously approved conditions for an existing pawn shop at 2811 Campbell Avenue. City Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided a presentation to Council. LPP, LLC, is petitioning to amend the conditions of the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the existing pawn shop at 2811 Campbell Avenue. A CUP was previously issued for the pawn shop in 2014. The petitioner has requested that the conditions of that CUP be modified to adjust operating hours and allow the sale/pawn of firearms. Page 24 of 207 April 8, 2025 The property is zoned R-3, Medium Density Residential District. The Comprehensive Plan 2013- 2030 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Traditional Residential use for the subject property. Small retail uses can be consistent with this land use designation. The Planning Commission motion to approve the petition failed in a tie vote. The Planning Commission Bylaws, Article VII - Voting, 7.2 states: "A tie vote shall be a rejection of the motion presented." Ryan Somers, LLP LLC, representing the petitioner, presented comments to Council. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt Resolution #R-25- 031. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Faraldi, Timmer 2 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Dahn Carey was not present to address Council. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen Theresa O'Dell was not present was not present to address Council. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #8, Citizen Jamie Plank addressed Council regarding Lynchburg Public Library children's materials. She expressed concerns about books in the public library that promoted gender fluidity, gender transitioning, and homosexual relationships. She requested that Council establish a Library Board to control the books available in the public library. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #9, Citizen Karen Quigg addressed Council regarding common sense values. She said that any public school book which advocated sexual perversion and deviancy must be removed. Page 25 of 207 April 8, 2025 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Citizen Deborah Armstrong addressed Council regarding deficiencies inherent in Wiggington Road to handle the deluge of traffic along its corridor. She requested Council improve traffic safety through sidewalks, bike lanes, and road widening. She suggested the consideration of an additional entry and exit on Chapel Lane. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #11, Citizen Cora Cefaratti addressed Council regarding the budget. She expressed concerns about the proposed real estate tax rate of $0.89. She asked for more information about the cost of fixing the leaks in the public pool and the renovations for the library. She said that the City should set an equalized real estate tax rate and consider alternative methods to generate revenue, such as selling property. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #12, Citizen Peter Cefaratti addressed Council regarding the development on Wiggington Road. He said Council should encourage the development of large, vacant parcels to expand the tax base. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #13, Citizen Beth White, representing Citizens United for Lynchburg, addressed Council regarding double standards. She expressed concerns for citizens who felt threatened by councilmembers and feared bullying and harassment from other citizens. She expressed concerns that a Library Board would serve as a further extension of government bureaucracy. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #15, Citizen Denise McDonald addressed Council regarding support for Lynchburg Public Library renovation CIP. She emphasized the importance of reading. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #14, Citizen Greg Berry, representing City Elders, addressed Council regarding Church and State. He said that the words, "separation of church and state" were nowhere in the Constitution, which was a lie to diminish the influence of God on the United States. He emphasized the greatness of the United States. He suggested Council establish a Faith Board comprised of faith leaders appointed by Council. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #16, Citizen Thomas Brennan addressed Council regarding supporting our Public Library. He emphasized the importance of the public library. Page 26 of 207 April 8, 2025 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #17, Citizen Michael Bremer addressed Council regarding protecting the CIP for schools. He said that Council should only consider transportation CIP projects for reappropriation. He said that Council should not disrupt the CIP for deferred maintenance of school buildings to fund Wiggington Road improvements. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Jamie Maxwell, representing the Lynchburg Firefighters Association, addressed Council regarding a matter. He expressed concerns about the conditions of fire stations and the carcinogens that firefighters were regularly exposed to via their equipment. He presented ceiling tiles covered in black mastic asbestos to Councilmember Reed. Councilmember Reed called a point of order. She said that Mr. Maxwell was threatening her, and she did not feel safe. She said she was not threatened by the ceiling tiles but by the comments directed at her by Mr. Maxwell. Vice Mayor Diemer called a point of order. He said that public comment should not engage councilmembers directly or leave the podium. // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #18, Council conducted a second reading in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-029 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $193,422 for purposes of providing funds to establish and deliver withdrawal management services. The City receives funds from the OAA through direct distributions and grants. R2R has applied to utilize City grant funds to establish and deliver withdrawal management services for individuals with opioid and other substance-use disorders in the City. The OAA has awarded R2R $193,421.31 for this purpose. In order to accept the grant funds and transfer the funds to R2R, City Council is requested to authorize the City Manager to sign the MOU between R2R and the City (adopted by City Council on March 25, 2025) and also adopt the resolution to appropriate the funds. Councilmember Misjuns called a point of order. He asked counsel if there was still a quorum since Councilmember Reed left the meeting and Mayor Taylor intended to abstain from the vote. Deputy City Attorney Hope Townes replied that Council had a quorum so long as four members were present, which they were, so they were able to vote on the matter. Page 27 of 207 April 8, 2025 Clerk of Council Alicia Finney explained that Councilmember Faraldi had requested to defer the matter to the second meeting in April; however, there was no second regularly scheduled meeting in April, so the matter would be deferred to May 13th and staff indicated that the matter was time sensitive. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Resolution #R- 25-029. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Wilder, Misjuns 3 Noes: 0 Abstain: Taylor 1 Absent: Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 3 // The meeting adjourned at 8:07 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 28 of 207 City Council Agenda Item IV.7. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY May 13, 2025 Melva Walker, Grants Manager AGENDA ITEM # IV.7 Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-032 approving the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) project recommendations for FY 2026 CDBG and HOME Program entitlement funds to be included in the 2025 Annual Action Plan. RECOMMENDATION Hold a public hearing and adopt a resolution approving the allocation of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2026, Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program entitlement and reprogrammed funds and incorporating them into the FY 2026 CDBG Fund and HOME Fund Budgets and Program Year (PY) 2025 Annual Action Plan. SUMMARY The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) funds the CDBG and HOME Programs. The City has available the following estimated entitlement and reprogrammed funds to use for eligible CDBG and HOME activities during FY 2026 (PY 2025). CDBG AVAILABLE FUNDING/SOURCE AMOUNT HUD Entitlement Allocation $722,622 Total CDBG Funding Available $722,622 HOME AVAILABLE FUNDING AMOUNT HUD Entitlement Allocation $302,774 Recaptured Funds $100,000 Total HOME Funding Available $402,774 The public was notified of the public hearing through a public notice advertisement published in The News and Advance on April 28, 2025, and through various sources of social media. The Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) met on April 3, 2025, and reviewed the applications that were submitted. Attachment C provides the CDAC recommendations for funding amounts and a brief description of the projects. Page 29 of 207 All CDBG and HOME Program entitlement and reprogrammed funds will be expended in accordance with the primary objectives of these programs. The City estimates that over 70 percent of the CDBG FY 2026 funding will benefit low-to-moderate income persons according to HUD regulations. All applications submitted for funding consideration are available for review in the Grants Administration Office, Second Floor, City Hall. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the City Council will review the recommendations of the CDAC and approve the funding allocations to be included in the FY 2026 CDBG and HOME Fund Budgets and PY 2025 CDBG and HOME Program Annual Action Plan. PRIOR ACTION(S) April 3, 2025: Community Development Advisory Committee Meeting FISCAL IMPACT FY 2026 Estimated Entitlements: CDBG - $722,622** HOME - $302,774** HOME - $100,000 Recaptured Funds (FARRR Foundation/Lighthouse Beloved Community Land Trust) **NOTE: HUD HAS NOT PROVIDED THE FINAL ENTITLEMENT ALLOCATIONS FOR THE ANNUAL ACTION PLAN FOR FISCAL YEAR (FY) 2026; THEREFORE, THE FISCAL IMPACT IS ESTIMATED AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE. CONTACT(S) Melva Walker, Grants Manager ATTACHMENT(S) 1. R-25-032 2. Presentation 3. CDAC Recommendations (CDBG) - Attachment A 4. CDAC Recommendations (HOME) - Attachment B 5. CDBG HOME Application Summaries - Attachment C 6. CDAC Meeting Notes - Attachment D REVIEWED BY Date: May 05, 2025 William Martin, Community Development Director Date: May 06, 2025 Page 30 of 207 Kent White, Assistant City Manager Date: May 07, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 31 of 207 RESOLUTION: #R-25-032 BE IT RESOLVED that the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program FY 2026 entitlement, and reprogrammed funding allocations are hereby approved for incorporation into the FY 2026 CDBG Fund and HOME Fund Budgets and PY 2025 CDBG and HOME Program Annual Action Plan as outlined in Attachments A and B which is expressly incorporated herein by reference. Adopted: May 13, 2025 Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 32 of 207 FISCAL YEAR (FY) 2026 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) AND HOME PROGRAM CDAC RECOMMENDATIONS - PROJECT ALLOCATIONS May 13, 2025 Page 33 of 207 FY 2026 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN ENTITLEMENT AMOUNTS Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) - $722,622* HOME Program - $302,774* Reprogrammed Funds** 100,000 $402,774 *Fiscal Year 2025 Entitlement Amounts (FY 2026 Projected) **(FARRR Foundation/Lighthouse Beloved Community Land Trust) Page 34 of 207 CDAC RECOMMENDATIONS CDBG - FY 2026 PROJECT ALLOCATIONS Amount CDAC Requested Recommendations NAME FY 2026 FY 2026* City Administration $137,537 $137,537 Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan - Phase 2 Improvements (Dunbar Community Schoolyard) 500,000 476,692 Miriam's House / CVCoC** -Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) 65,000 65,000 Miriam's House - Extreme Weather Center 42,000 30,000 Blue Ridge Mountains Council, Inc. Boy Scouts of America – Scoutreach (Parks & Recreation Department) 19,160 13,393 Total CDBG $763,697 $722,622 *CDAC recommended that if the CDBG entitlement amount either increases or decreases, 85% would go to Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan – Phase 2 Improvements and the remaining 15% would be split between Extreme Weather Center and the Scoutreach Program. **CVCoC - Central Virginia Continuum of Care Page 35 of 207 CDAC RECOMMENDATIONS HOME PROGRAM - FY 2026 PROJECT ALLOCATIONS Amount CDAC Requested Recommendations NAME FY 2026 FY 2026* City Administration $ 30,000 $ 30,000 Rush Homes - Carolyn's Place - Rental Housing (CHDO**) 100,000 97,774 Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity - Homeownership Program 175,000 175,000 Lyn-CAG - First Time Homebuyer Homeownership Assistance 100,000 100,000 Total HOME $405,000 $402,774 *CDAC recommended that if the HOME entitlement amount either increases or decreases, the funding be divided equally between Rush Homes, Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) and Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG). **CHDO - Community Housing Development Organization Page 36 of 207 . 722,622.00$ City Council Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount FY2025 Requested Recommendation Awarded NAME Award FY 2026 FY 2026 FY 2026 City Administration 137,537.00$ 137,537.00 $ 137,537.00 $ Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan - Phase 1 Improvements 478,105.00 Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan - Phase 2 Improvements (Dunbar Community Schoolyard) 500,000.00 476,691.70 Totals 615,642.00$ 637,537.00$ 614,228.70$ -$ CDBG - Public Service 15% Allocation of Entitlement Funds $ 108,393.30 City Council Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount FY2025 Requested Recommendation Awarded NAME Award FY 2026 FY 2026 FY 2026 Miriam's House / CVCoC -Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access $ 65,000.00 $ 65,000.00 $ 65,000.00 Miriam's House - Extreme Weather Center 42,000.00 42,000.00 $ 30,000.00 Blue Ridge Mountains Coucil, Inc. Boy Scouts of America - Scoutreach 19,160.00 13,393.30 Totals 107,000.00$ 126,160.00$ 108,393.30$ -$ Total CDBG $ 722,642.00 $ 763,697.00 $ 722,622.00 $ - *CHDO - Community Housing Development Organization CVCoC - Central Virginia Continuum of Care Habitat for Humanity- Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Total CDBG Available CDBG and HOME Allocations Worksheet 2025-2026 - Page 1 Fiscal Year (FY) 2026 ATTACHEMENT A Page 37 of 207 45,416.16$ HOME Amount Available City Council 402,774.40$ Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount FY2025 Requested Recommendation Awarded NAME Award FY 2026 FY 2026 FY 2026 City Administration 30,000.00$ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ Rush Homes - Carolyn's Place - Rental Housing (CHDO) 75,000.00 100,000.00 97,774.40 Habitat for Humanity - Homeownership Program 114,304.00 175,000.00 175,000.00 Lyn-CAG - First Time Homebuyer Down Payment Assistance 89,304.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 Total HOME 308,608.00$ 405,000.00$ 402,774.40$ -$ FY 2025 FY 2026 Difference % CDBG Entitlement $722,622.00 $722,622.00 $0.00 0.00% Reprogrammed Funds 20.00 0.00 (20.00) -100.00% Program Income 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00% TOTAL $722,642.00 $722,622.00 ($20.00) 0.00% Administration CAP $144,524.40 $144,524.40 $0.00 0.00% Public Service CAP $108,393.30 $108,393.30 $0.00 0.00% HOME Entitlement $302,774.40 $302,774.40 $0.00 0.00% Reprogrammed 5,834.00 100,000.00 94,166.00 1614.09% Administration CAP $30,277.44 $30,277.44 $0.00 0.00% CHDO Required $45,416.16 $45,416.16 $0.00 0.00% CHDO* Requirement CDBG and HOME Allocations Worksheet 2025-2026 - Page 2 Fiscal Year (FY) 2026 ATTACHMENT B Page 38 of 207 ATTACHMENT C 1 Summary of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Funding Requests Fiscal Year (FY) 2026 received from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Following is a brief summary of each of the applications received for consideration of CDBG and HOME Program funding. Entire applications are available and can be reviewed in the Grants Administration Office. The Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) notes for the recommendations are included in Attachment A. Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Applicants City Administration (Grants Administration) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $137,537 $137,537 Funding is used to cover the personnel, operating, and HUD-required training costs associated with managing the CDBG Program. Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan – Phase 2 Improvements (Dunbar Community Schoolyard) (City - Department of Community Development/Lynchburg City Schools) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $500,000 $476,691.70 The Dunbar Community Schoolyard is a common-sense and cost-effective solution to increasing access to park space in the Diamond Hill Neighborhood. The Dunbar Middle School campus is located within a ten-minute walk of 75% of Diamond Hill Neighborhood residences. Investing in the campus as a green and inviting park, open to the public after school and on weekends, transforms the shared public space into a positive gathering place for youth, families, and neighbors. The Dunbar campus is approximately 16 acres in size. Schoolyard improvements at this site would be implemented in phases. Phase 1 is currently underway and focuses on the area south of Dunbar Drive (between Dunbar Drive and Fourteenth Street). Phase 2 will focus on pedestrian and spectator improvements along and north of Dunbar Drive. Overall, the schoolyard project improves the use of public space by creating safe pedestrian pathways, incorporating seating, installing appropriate fencing, investing in low-maintenance landscaping, and enhancing recreational opportunities. Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) - Miriam’s House/Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $65,000 $65,000 Miriam's House as the Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, in partnership with the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, will continue Page 39 of 207 ATTACHMENT C 2 providing a homeless hotline, Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA), for households experiencing a housing crisis. This service was created in 2014 to comply with the Department of Housing and Urban Development's requirement that every community have a coordinated intake process for homeless services in order to be eligible for federal homeless assistance grants. Each year, the CVCoC receives approximately 1 million dollars in federal and state homeless assistance grants to leverage this local investment. Funding for the CHIA program is used to employ a full- time Coordinated Entry Specialist that connects households experiencing homelessness or those about to become homeless with the right level of intervention to quickly resolve their crisis. The CHIA program assesses each caller for safety, homeless diversion, and available resources to ensure that every household is provided with a homeless response service such as street outreach, shelter, or homeless intervention. In 2024, there were over 3,925 households experiencing a housing crisis that were served through the CHIA program. Lynchburg Extreme Weather Center – Miriam’s House/Department of Human Services FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $42,000 $30,000 Miriam’s House, as the Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, in partnership with the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Human Services, requested $42,000 in CDBG funding in support of services to assist individuals experiencing a housing crisis that are further complicated by extreme temperatures. There is no alternative warming shelter in the Lynchburg area outside of this funding opportunity. The US Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Homeless Management Information Center identified a 273% increase in unsheltered homelessness from 2019 to 2024. Miriam’s House would issue a request for proposals (RFP) for subrecipient(s) to operate the cold weather shelter, including the necessary staff and resources to run the facility, coordinate volunteers and ultimately connect unsheltered individuals to the temporary shelter during extreme temperatures. The structure would allow the Continuum of Care and the City to ensure the cold weather shelter could operate as a low barrier facility focused first on providing respite for the unsheltered and then, through that trust relationship, connect individuals with additional services. Blue Ridge Mountains Council, Inc. Boy Scouts of America – Scoutreach Program (Parks and Recreation Department) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $19,160 $13,393 Scoutreach is the Boy Scout of America's commitment to making sure that all young people have an opportunity to join Scouting, regardless of their circumstances, neighborhood, or ethnic background. Scoutreach meets the developmental needs of youth in urban settings. Scouting, by emphasizing ethics and moral values, addresses many of the social concerns of parents and youth in our country. Scouting prepares urban and rural youth to be leaders, to accept responsibility, and to care about principles Page 40 of 207 ATTACHMENT C 3 and causes beyond their own self-interest. Our biggest asset in urban and rural neighborhoods is a well-defined program based on values, learning by doing, fun, and positive role models. Boy Scouts of America plans to continue to offer Scoutreach to youth in Lynchburg's central city neighborhoods, by partnering with the Lynchburg Parks and Recreation Department throughout the school year. Currently there are two (2) centers where Scouting is being offered. These Centers are Yoder and Fairview serving 15-20 youth at each of the Centers. However, all youth that attend the other neighborhood centers are invited to participate in the Scoutreach Program and come to either Yoder or Fairview Centers for the Program. Page 41 of 207 ATTACHMENT C 4 HOME Program Applicants City Administration FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $33,000 $30,000 Funding is used to cover the personnel, operating, and training costs associated with managing the HOME Program. Rental Housing Development – Rush Lifetime Homes, Inc. (Rush Homes) Certified Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $100,000 $97,774 NOTE: The City is required to commit 15 percent of its HOME Program entitlement funds to a certified CHDO. Rush Homes is the only certified CHDO that applied for FY 2026 HOME funds. Carolyn’s Place Phase II will be located at 1015-1019 Pinehurst Street. Rush Homes is preparing to break ground on Carolyn’s Place, a 48-unit affordable housing development designed to address the critical need for affordable, accessible housing for individuals with disabilities and low incomes. Carolyn’s Place will feature a mix of efficiency, one-, two-, and three-bedroom units, and more than half of the units will incorporate universal design standards. The project will utilize modular construction to streamline the process, with leasing expected to begin in late 2027. Rush Homes will be incorporating the HOME American Rescue Plan (ARP) funds into this development. The HOME ARP eight (8) units are specifically to be developed for individuals and families who meet the HOME-ARP definition for the Qualifying Population as defined in HUD Notice CPD-21-10. The qualifying population is generally individuals and families who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Often, individuals and families meeting the qualifying population also have a disability, the population whose affordable housing needs are the mission of Rush Homes. In addition, five (5) of the units will be reserved for individuals with intellectual disabilities, with supportive services offered through partnerships with Miriam’s House and Horizon Behavioral Health. Homeownership Program - Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $175,000 $175,000 Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) develops homeownership opportunities for families with low income who cannot afford, or qualify for, conventional bank mortgages at market interest rates. GLHFH builds good quality, modestly appointed homes and sells them to qualified applicants. The target population for the program is Page 42 of 207 ATTACHMENT C 5 families whose income falls in the range of 40% to 80% of HUD's Area Median Income (AMI), adjusted for size of family. GLHFH solicits funding, materials, and volunteer labor from the community, allowing the organization the ability to maintain low construction costs. GLHFH is therefore able to sell the home to a qualified family with a no-interest mortgage loan. GLHFH will use HOME funds as down-payment assistance for its homebuyers. The down payment covers the difference between the sale price and the amount the family can afford to pay over the term of the loan, using their current income. Monthly payments are calculated for affordability. GLHFH defines "payment affordability" as not more than 30% of monthly income, though we strive for 25%, when possible, to make our homes affordable for families in the lower tiers of HUD AMI income. GLHFH will use HOME funds as homeownership assistance for its homebuyers. The homeownership assistance covers the difference between the sale price and the amount the family can afford to pay over the term of the loan, using their current income. Monthly payments are calculated for affordability. GLHFH defines “payment affordability” as not more than 30% of monthly income, though Habitat strives for 25%, when possible, to make the homes affordable for families in the lower tiers of HUD AMI income. GLHFH plans to serve five (5) families with these funds. Homeownership Program - Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) FY 2026 Request CDAC Recommendation $100,000 $100,000 Lynchburg Community Action Group, Inc. (Lyn-CAG) has requested $100,000 in HOME funds to assist Lynchburg residents in becoming first time home buyers. Lyn-CAG will use these funds for homeownership assistance by providing closing cost assistance to assist low-moderate income individuals and families purchase a home within the City. Currently, those who have low- to moderate incomes are having problems obtaining affordable housing due to not being able to have the three to 10% down payment that is needed to close on a home. In addition, with the current market rates continuing to increase these funds will provide the gap financing so that eligible clients may become first-time homebuyers. Lyn-CAG plans to serve ten (10) families with these funds. Page 43 of 207 Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) Meeting April 3, 2025 City Hall, 2nd Floor Training Room 10:00 a.m. Meeting Notes *Note: CDAC members have not reviewed and approved these notes Attendance included: CDAC Members: Council Member Dr. Sterling Wilder, Chair; Council Member Jacqueline Timmer, Vice Chair; Dr. Brenda Farmer (Fairview Heights Representative); Sandra Mitchell (College Hill Representative); Sally Schneider (Diamond Hill Representative); Kimberly Dyke-Harsley (Daniel’s Hill Representative); Roman Franklin (White Rock Hill Representative) City Staff: Melva Walker (Grants Manager); Gabrielle Bateman (Grants Coordinator); Rhonda Allbeck (Assistant Director of Financial Services); Samantha Morton (Financial Services Senior Accountant); Rachel Frischeisen (City Planner, Planning Division); Reid Wodicka (Deputy Superintendent of Operations & Strategic Planning, Lynchburg City Schools) Guests/Applicants: Greg Tyree, (Family Services Manager, Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity [GLHFH]); Donna Vincent (Executive Director, GLHFH); Sarah Quarantotto (Miriam’s House/Central Virginia Continuum of Care [CVCoC]); Olyvia Brown-Coles (Miriam’s House/Central Virginia Continuum of Care [CVCoC]); Tracey Ballagh (Executive Director, Rush Homes); Tamara Rosser (Chief Executive Officer, Lynchburg Community Action Group [Lyn-CAG]); Jessica Thompson (Program Manager of Housing Counselor Services, Lyn-CAG) Page 44 of 207 Ms. Walker started the meeting at 10:00 AM. Ms. Walker welcomed everyone to the meeting and invited the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) members to introduce themselves. The Committee members present introduced themselves and the neighborhoods that they represented. Ms. Walker introduced the City staff that was present. Ms. Walker explained that CDAC will have a bit more responsibility this year due to the creation of the 2025-2029 Five-Year Consolidated Plan. Ms. Walker laid the foundation for the meeting by going through the meeting’s agenda and explaining what would be discussed prior to and following the applicants’ presentations. A copy of the agenda was provided to each CDAC member, applicants, and the public. Ms. Walker reviewed a PowerPoint presentation of the Program Year 2023/Fiscal Year 2024 accomplishments from the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) for the CDBG, HOME, and Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) programs. She said that City staff is required to give this performance report to the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) each year and to provide the report to the Committee. A copy of the CAPER PowerPoint was provided to each CDAC member. Ms. Walker explained the role of the CDAC members is to review all CDBG and HOME Program applications and make a recommendation from which project(s) the City and city neighborhoods would best benefit. Ms. Walker said that City Council will conduct a public hearing to review the recommendations of the CDAC. A public notice would be published and invited all CDAC members to attend the public hearing if desired. Ms. Walker reviewed the goals for the 2025-2029 Consolidated Plan that were approved earlier this year by City Council on February 25th. The annual goals were provided in the CDAC packets to which each member could relate them to the project applications. Ms. Walker asked for questions. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked if housing goals were listed in order of importance. Ms. Walker advised that they were not. Ms. Walker advised that the applicants would now present a brief overview of their projects and that the Committee members would have the opportunity to ask questions regarding the plans for their projects. She explained that she would first call CDBG applicants to present followed by HOME Program applicants. Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan – Phase 2 Improvements (Dunbar Schoolyard) - Ms. Walker introduced Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner, and Reid Wodicka, Deputy Superintendent of Operations & Strategic Planning, Lynchburg City Schools, to present on the Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan – Phase 2 Improvements (Dunbar Schoolyard). Ms. Frischeisen thanked CDAC and introduced the Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan and the work that they have been doing already, including the creation of the plan by City staff and approval of the neighborhood plan by City Council on December 10, 2024. She explained that part of the neighborhood plan is the establishment of community schoolyards at Dunbar Middle School and Payne Elementary in Page 45 of 207 order to increase access to parks in the community. She explained that Phase 1, which received CDBG funding in the previous year, is currently underway and focuses on the area south of Dunbar Drive and includes improved lighting, seating, pedestrian pathways, fencing and landscaping. Ms. Frischeisen explained that the funding request for this year is for Phase 2 which would continue those improvements along and north of Dunbar Drive. Mr. Wodicka then began further presenting on the project. Mr. Wodicka discussed the creation of the Strong Neighborhoods Alliance which was created to be a cross-city group to support neighborhood improvements across the city by first understanding residents’ perspectives. He explained that cities are rethinking how schools are to be used and how it can be used to further support the neighborhood. Mr. Wodicka asked for questions. Ms. Schneider asked if the plan was to expend the amounts that the project had already received first before using Phase 2 amounts. Mr. Wodicka explained that the projects would be working in parallel. Ms. Walker explained that part of the delay in spending was due to needing to coordinate with the water line repairs. Ms. Dyke-Harsley spoke in support of the program and in support of the city representatives who were actively seeking out neighborhood opinions and knocking on doors. Ms. Walker invited Miriam’s House staff to present the application for Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA). The presentation was given by Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director of Miriam’s House and serves as the Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) coalition. One of the requirements for the CVCoC is that the community provide a coordinated, central intake process for anyone who is homeless or about to become homeless and has a way to access the system. The mechanism in place to provide this central access is through CHIA (Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access). CHIA, the homeless hotline, which has been in place for over ten (10) years, when an individual or household is experiencing a housing crisis, they can call the CHIA hotline. The goal of the hotline is to divert or prevent households from ever experiencing homelessness. Every caller is provided a problem-solving conversation so that hopefully they will not become homeless or have to enter a homeless shelter. The hotline can help triage individuals to appropriate community resources, including rent assistance to help prevent homelessness, and a variety of other partners to try to divert as many people from homelessness as possible. The requested funding of $65,000 funds the Coordinated Entry Specialist who answers the phone and makes the necessary referrals as well as adding the data collection to the shared database with other homeless response providers. Ms. Walker invited Miriam’s House staff to present the application for the Extreme Weather Center (EWC). The presentation was given by Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director of Miriam’s House. Ms. Quarantotto explained that project was in partnership with the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Human Services. The project’s goal is to have funding in order to put out a request for proposals to an organization or entity to operate a warming center/shelter for the next winter season. Ms. Quarantotto explained that unsheltered numbers have risen in Lynchburg over the past couple of years. She hopes that the coming shelter at the Ramp Church Page 46 of 207 will help with that. She explained that Salvation Army in the past year were able to run an extreme weather center during the extreme cold. She explained that the requested funding is to help with shelter operations and would be provided to a non-profit in the community that applies for the funding in order to run such a shelter. Dr. Farmer applauded the work at Salvation Army this past year. Ms. Schneider asked whether there is going to be provisions for the extreme heat in the summer. Ms. Quarantotto explained that the city already does a really good job providing cooling stations in the summer during the day and that there was not really a service gap in that area. She explained that since the funds are limited, they want to direct it at the more extreme need in the winter. She also explained that hopefully the Ramp Church’s day shelter should help with the summer needs as well. Ms. Timmer asked about the metrics of the decrease of homelessness but increase in unsheltered numbers. Ms. Quarantotto explained that following 2020, there were a lot of official rulings and benefits due to COVID relief programs that helped keep people housed but that a lot of those have ended. She explained that while they were concerned about the possibility of going back to the pre-2020 numbers, they have not seen that happen likely due to the number of programs and housing that were created in the interim years. She explained that the higher number of unsheltered persons was due to the lack of shelter beds. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked if those sleeping in cars were considered unsheltered. Ms. Quarantotto said that they were. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked whether there was a Board requirement for lived experience of homelessness for Miriam’s House. Ms. Quarantotto explained that there is a requirement for lived experience on the board of the CVCoC and how the board for the CVCoC worked to determine needs and oversee the process. Dr. Wilder asked what her priority would be between CHIA and the EWC. Ms. Quarantotto advised that she would prioritize CHIA but that it was hard to choose. She explained that the EWC was a really important program but that Ramp Church might help alleviate that need but that we don’t know if that is the case yet. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked how many of the people seeking assistance were recently incarcerated individuals. Ms. Quarantotto advised that she would need to look back at the data in order to determine this but explained that institutions who work with previously incarcerated individuals in the area are required to make an effort to help prevent homelessness. (Note: After the meeting, Miriam’s House staff researched the homeless data and advised City staff that in the last year there was one individual enrolled in the homeless response system who came directly from a correctional facility). Ms. Walker advised that the next program would be the Scoutreach program but no representative for the Blue Ridge Mountain Council, Inc. Boy Scouts of America was at the meeting. Councilwoman Timmer asked if the Lynchburg City Schools could work with the Boy Scouts for the outreach efforts. Mr. Wodicka advised that while he does not know anything about that project, but Lynchburg City Schools would be happy to work with them. Page 47 of 207 Ms. Walker reviewed HOME program requirements and introduced Rush Homes. She explained that Rush Homes was the only Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) and therefore HUD required that 15% of HOME funds be allocated to CHDOs. Ms. Ballagh explained how the Carolyn’s Place project has evolved over time. She explained that they were requesting an increase in funding and that the intent is to build in a modular model. Rush Homes has requested and received approval from City Council to rezone the property. She explained that they plan to build an entrance on Florida Avenue across from the Jubilee Center and hopes to create a partnership with the center and with the churches in the area. She is hoping to use the requested $100,000 to help leverage the remaining funding. She reviewed the funds that Rush Homes is also applying for. Ms. Ballagh asked for questions. Councilwoman Timmer asked if Ms. Ballagh could define Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH). Ms. Ballagh advised that PSH is for those who are chronically homeless. She explained that PSH comes with a project-based voucher which means that residents do not take the vouchers with them. She explained that those project-based vouchers were not renewed by the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, as the program did not have the required tax credit funding. She explained that the eight (8) units are going to be held for those who are chronically homeless. Councilwoman Timmer asked what the numbers look like for the residents who are able to move beyond Rush Homes. Ms. Ballagh explained that most residents who move on from Rush Homes tend to move on to either assisted living or pass away. Ms. Dyke-Harsley thanked Rush Homes for their work and also thanked Rush Homes for their intent to help protect the Earth. Ms. Ballagh advised that their intent is to preserve as much of the wooded area as possible due to environmental concerns. Dr. Farmer asked whether the criteria for Carolyn’s Place and Florida Terrace will be the same. Ms. Ballagh advised the design of Carolyn’s Place will be a little different from Florida Terrace and that will inform some of the availability to different groups. Dr. Farmer asked about the requirement for a certain amount of money in order to become a resident. Ms. Ballagh advised that the Tax Credit funding requirements for rental eligibility could be received by setting up an appointment with the housing manager. Dr. Farmer thanked her for her service. Dr. Wilder asked if this was the largest project they have ever worked on. Ms. Ballagh advised that it was. Dr. Wilder asked what the timeframe was on the project. Ms. Ballagh advised that they will be required to complete within the four (4) years required to expend the funding. Ms. Walker introduced Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH), explaining it was a Homeownership project through down payment assistance. Ms. Vincent explained that the HOME applicants all work together and partner to help with housing in the city. Ms. Vincent explained how they were able to work on developing the infrastructure for Knott Street in the past. She explained that they have built over 319 homes in Lynchburg. She thanked CDAC for the HOME funding that has helped with their program. She explained that the project is a “guesstimate” for the down payment assistance and that they are requesting more in order to try to make it so the families they serve only pay 25-30% of their income. She explained that while Page 48 of 207 the numbers they are serving might be smaller, the impact is profound. She explained that the loans they provide are 0% interest and that all houses in the future are going to be built to age in place. Mr. Tyree explained their criteria for selecting families include need, ability to pay, and willingness to partner. Mr. Franklin explained that his mother accepted a Habitat for Humanity home and that he is now the owner of that home and that he really wanted to speak in support of Habitat. Ms. Timmer said that she loved reading the application and was excited about the children that were able to move into the homes and hopefully will be able to inherit the homes. She also was particularly excited by the intention to build the homes for aging in place. Mr. Tyree explained that even now that if they partner with a disabled family, that they do build to ADA specifications. Ms. Schneider said that she appreciates that they do the market value so that housing values in the area are not negatively affected. Ms. Vincent explained that for Knott Street, that they did speak with concerned neighbors in the area and had explained how it would be beneficial for the neighborhood. Dr. Farmer also commended the program. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked if when a house is lost to foreclosure, whether the house is then sold to those who meet Habitat requirements. Ms. Vincent explained that the law requires that they sell the house but that they cannot put restrictions on who can buy. She explained that Habitat also has the option to repurchase the home and can rehab the house. She explained though that foreclosure is the very last option. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked about the neighbor issues listed in the application and what the issue that could not be resolved was. Ms. Vincent explained that it had to do with Fair Housing laws and a “Not in My Backyard (NIMBY)” mindset. Dr. Wilder complimented the program. Ms. Walker introduced Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) First Time Homebuyer program. Ms. Rosser advised that the program is designed to help low to moderate income individuals to be able to achieve a part of the American Dream through homeownership and help build generational wealth. She spoke to the partnership between all of the applicant organizations in helping build a better living environment for Lynchburg citizens. Ms. Thomas took over the presentation. She explained that she is a HUD housing counselor. She explained that they asked for the same amount that they did last year. She explained that the underwriting process is long but that she is thankful for the experience in helping people become homeowners. Ms. Dyke-Harsley spoke in support of the program as she herself had gone through the program. She explained how she was able to use the certificate from the counseling program only in the nick of time. She asked if the time for that certificate eligibility was lengthened. Ms. Thomas explained that the certificate is good for two (2) years. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked if conventional loans or other types of loans are eligible. Ms. Thomas advised that she has only seen FHA or VA loans but that is not a requirement. Dr. Wilder spoke in support of the program. Ms. Walker thanked the applicants. She then introduced the allocation worksheet. Ms. Walker advised that they would be using last year’s entitlement numbers as the allocations for the upcoming year had not yet be received by the City and that they would discuss what CDAC would prefer to be done if there was an increase or a decrease in the money available. Page 49 of 207 Ms. Walker advised that they were using the previous year’s entitlement amount of $722,622 for determining CDBG allocation recommendations. Ms. Walker said that the City may only allocate 15% of CDBG funds, which is $108,393.43, towards public service activities, which included CHIA, EWC and Scoutreach. Dr. Wilder suggested leaving the $65,000 for CHIA. He recommended that they then reduce the other two projects- EWC and Scoutreach. Ms. Schneider then stated that a representative from the Blue Ridge Mountain Council for the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) was not here and that there was a housing crisis so she recommended not allocating anything to BSA Scoutreach and dividing the 15% between CHIA and EWC. Ms. Dyke-Harsley stated that there was need for leadership in young men’s lives and that she did not feel it was right to penalize the children for the adults not appearing at the meeting. Ms. Dyke-Harsley asked whether the CDBG funding was the only funding that the City of Lynchburg was providing for their adult residents at the Extreme Weather Shelter. Ms. Quarantotto said it was and wanted to clarify that children/families also stay at the Extreme Weather Center. She also clarified that Miriam’s House will require that the EWC be run from December to March this coming winter. Ms. Dyke- Harsley asked if private donor funding was available for the EWC. Ms. Quarantotto advised that it would depend on who received the contract for the EWC and whether they were willing/able to supplement the funding through other funding sources. Vice Chair Timmer moved to vote for $65,000 for CHIA, $30,000 for EWC, $13,393 for Scoutreach. Mr. Franklin seconded. Dr. Wilder, Ms. Timmer, Mr. Franklin, Ms. Mitchell, Dr. Farmer, and Ms. Dyke-Harsley voted in favor of the motion. Ms. Schneider voted opposed to the motion. The majority of votes were in favor of the motion and it was approved. Ms. Timmer motioned for approval of the CDBG allocation recommendation amounts of City Administration with $137,537, Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan with $476,691.70, CHIA with $65,000, EWC with $30,000, and Scoutreach with $13,393. Dr. Wilder seconded the motion. The Committee was unanimously in favor of the motion. Ms. Walker asked what CDAC wanted to do if they received additional CDBG funding. CDAC proposed that 85% would go to Diamond Hill and that the remaining 15% be split between EWC and Scoutreach. Ms. Dyke-Harsley motioned to approve this proposal. Sandra Mitchell seconded the motion. The Committee was unanimously in favor of the motion. Ms. Walker asked what CDAC wanted to do if they received less CDBG funding. Roman Franklin motioned to decrease Diamond Hill by 85% of decrease and split the remaining 15% decrease between EWC and Scoutreach. Dr. Farmer seconded the motion. Dr. Wilder, Ms. Timmer, Mr. Franklin, Ms. Mitchell, Dr. Farmer, and Ms. Dyke-Harsley voted in favor of the motion. Ms. Schneider voted opposed to the motion. The majority of votes were in favor of the motion and it was approved. Ms. Walker directed the Committee to the top of the Allocation Worksheet for the HOME Program. She stated that the number they would be using is $402,774.40, which includes the previous year’s entitlement funds of $302,774.40 and reprogrammed funds of $100,000. Page 50 of 207 Ms. Walker explained that in order for the City to receive the HOME Program entitlement funds, the City is required to give a Community Development Housing Organization (CHDO) 15% of its HOME funds. The amount of required funds that need to be awarded to a CHDO agency this year will be $45,416.16. Ms. Walker explained the only applicant certified by City staff as a CHDO in the city is Rush Homes. Ms. Walker clarified that more funds may be awarded; however, no less than $45,416.16 shall be awarded to the CHDO agency. Initially the Committee members suggested splitting the difference between the projected allocation amount and the requested amount between GLHFH, Rush Homes and Lyn-CAG. Ms. Ballagh advised that they would be ok with the full difference being removed from Rush Homes in order to provide the full requested amounts for GLHFH and Lyn-CAG. Ms. Schneider moved to reduce RUSH homes by $2,225.60, which was the difference between the anticipated funds and the requested amounts, and to keep all other allocations to the requested amounts. Ms. Timmer seconded the motion. The Committee was unanimously in favor of the motion. Ms. Walker asked what the Committee would like to do if the City receives additional HOME funds. Dr. Wilder suggested that if they get more divide by three, if they get less divide by three. Ms. Schneider suggested that if there is an increase that it go to Rush Homes. Dr. Wilder made a motion to divide any increase or reduction in funding by three between Rush Homes, GLHFH and Lyn-CAG. Dr. Farmer seconded. Dr. Wilder, Ms. Timmer, Mr. Franklin, Ms. Mitchell, Dr. Farmer, and Ms. Dyke-Harsley voted in favor of the motion. Ms. Schneider voted opposed to the motion. The majority of votes were in favor of the motion and it was approved. Ms. Walker discussed the 2025-2029 Five-Year Consolidated Plan and the future CDAC Meeting in May. Ms. Walker asked what date would work best for the Committee that is prior to the 21st. The Committee decided that May 20 would work for all Council members at 6:00 PM. Ms. Walker reviewed the tentative, scheduled dates that the public hearings would be conducted by City Council. Dr. Wilder adjourned the meeting at 12:24 PM. Page 51 of 207 City Council Agenda Item IV.8. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY May 13, 2025 Joseph Newland, City Engineer AGENDA ITEM # IV.8 Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-033 granting a non-exclusive limited franchise to Rosedale Investments, LLC and Rosedale Owners Association, Inc. for use, maintenance, and work on certain encroachments in the public rights-of-way at 1600 Graves Mill Road. RECOMMENDATION After the conclusion of the public hearing, adopt the Ordinance granting the franchise. SUMMARY The City proposes granting Rosedale Investments, LLC and Rosedale Owner's Association, Inc., as part of the development and subdivision at 1600 Graves Mill Road (i.e. Rosedale), a non-exclusive franchise right to maintain an improperly installed culvert in a soon-to-be dedicated right of way of the City. The general purpose of the franchise is to ensure the culvert is properly inspected, maintained, and owned by Rosedale Investments, LLC and/or Rosedale Owner's Association, Inc. and not the City unless certain criteria in the franchise have been met. PRIOR ACTION(S) Rosedale Encroachment Franchise Bid Review, Call, and Acceptance - May 13, 2025 Work Session FISCAL IMPACT CONTACT(S) Joseph Newland, City Engineer William Martin, Community Development Director ATTACHMENT(S) 1. O-25-033 2. Proposed Subdivision Plat - Exhibit A 3. Proposed Personal Guaranty REVIEWED BY Page 52 of 207 Date: May 08, 2025 Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works Date: May 08, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Date: May 08, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 53 of 207 1 19057\0043\12530241v1 ORDINANCE: #O-25-033 Tax Map No(s). 23904004 AN ORDINANCE GRANTING A NON-EXCLUSIVE LIMITED FRANCHISE TO ROSEDALE INVESTMENTS, LLC AND ROSEDALE OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. TO PERMIT THE USE, MAINTENANCE, AND WORK OF AND UPON CERTAIN ENCROACHMENTS IN THE PUBLIC RIGHTS-OF-WAY OF THE CITY AT 1600 GRAVES MILL ROAD, LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA 24502 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: ARTICLE I. GRANT AND PURPOSE A. Rosedale Investments, LLC, a Virginia limited liability company (“Rosedale”), is the owner of a certain parcel of real property located at 1600 Graves Mill Road, Lynchburg, Virginia, 24502, containing approximately 62.305 acres and designated as Parcel ID #23904004 (the “Property”). B. Rosedale is developing the Property as a mixed-use project (the “Project”). C. Rosedale desires to dedicate to the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, a municipal corporation (the “City”), certain portions of the Property (collectively, the “Dedicated Area”) as shown on that certain subdivision plat entitled “Plat Showing Rosedale City of Lynchburg, Virginia”, dated April 19, 2022, revised September 14, 2023 and March 18, 2025, made by Perkins & Orrison (the “Plat”), with City File No. D-2527, a copy of which Plat is expressly incorporated herein, is identified herein as Exhibit A, and will be recorded contemporaneously with this Franchise in the records of the Clerk’s Office of the Circuit Court for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. D. As shown on the Plat, a culvert, referenced on the Plat as “Plate Arch,” runs under a portion of the Project, including a portion of the Dedicated Area. The portion of the culvert that runs under the portion of the Dedicated Area is referenced herein as the “Encroachment.” E. The United States Environmental Protection Agency (the “EPA”) and the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (the “DEQ”) have initiated administrative actions with respect to the Property, including the Encroachment. The EPA has issued a Notice of Potential Violation dated September 18, 2023 (the “EPA NOV”). The DEQ has issued a Notice of Violation dated November 15, 2022 (the “DEQ NOV”). Page 54 of 207 2 19057\0043\12530241v1 F. Rosedale has advised the City that Rosedale expects these administrative proceedings will be resolved through a consent decree entered by the United States District Court for the Western District of Virginia (“Consent Decree”), which will incorporate a Restoration and/or Remediation Plan approved by the EPA/DEQ (the “Remediation Plan”). G. The EPA/DEQ and Rosedale are currently negotiating the terms of the Consent Decree and the Remediation Plan, and the schedule for implementing any remedial actions or corrective actions required by the Consent Decree and/or the Remediation Plan is unknown. H. Rosedale and the City wish to allow the subdivision of the Property and the development of the Property to proceed, subject to appropriate provisions to address the ongoing issues between the EPA/DEQ and Rosedale, including the Consent Decree and Remediation Plan. I. Rosedale has established Rosedale Owners Association, Inc., a Virginia corporation (“ROA”), pursuant to that certain Declaration of Easements, Covenants and Restrictions, a copy of which is contemporaneously recorded with this Franchise in the Clerk’s Office of the Circuit Court of the City (the “ROA Declaration”). J. Except as otherwise set forth herein, Rosedale and the ROA wish to retain any potential liability and responsibility related to the Encroachment, including all remedial action and corrective action required by the Consent Decree and/or the Remediation Plan. K. Rosedale, the ROA, Thomas P. Bell (“Bell”), and the City are entering into this Franchise for the purpose of providing for the rights and obligations of the parties, including the perpetual maintenance, repair and care of the Encroachment. L. Subject to the provisions, conditions, and restrictions hereafter set forth in this Franchise, the City herein and hereby grants a non-exclusive limited franchise, right, privilege, easement, and authority to Rosedale and the ROA, hereafter, collectively, the “Franchisees,” to use, work upon, maintain, and/or remove the Encroachment. M. This Franchise shall permit the Franchisees to use, work upon, maintain, and/or remove the Encroachment exclusively shown on the Plat. This Franchise shall in no way be construed to permit the Franchisees to expand or extend the Encroachment or to create additional encroachments upon the Dedicated Area in any way unless a written amendment to this Franchise is completed. The Franchisees shall not become vested with any further rights beyond what is previously described due to the existence of this Franchise or the Encroachment. Page 55 of 207 3 19057\0043\12530241v1 N. The City has agreed that the obligations agreed-to by Rosedale, Bell, and the ROA under this Franchise collectively constitute good and sufficient security required by Virginia Code § 15.2-2104. ARTICLE II. TERM A. Unless this Franchise is sooner terminated in accordance with the terms described herein, this Franchise will be in effect for a term of thirty-nine (39) years, beginning on June 1, 2025, and ending May 31, 2064, at 11:59 p.m. This Franchise is intended to be a long-term arrangement, and at the expiration of the stated term, the City and the Franchisees will negotiate in good faith for a renewal of this Franchise under mutually acceptable conditions. B. At the end of the aforesaid term, unless a renewal of this Franchise has been negotiated, this Franchise shall continue as a month-to-month tenancy, subject to all terms and conditions contained in this Franchise. Such month-to-month tenancy shall continue until such time as the City gives the Franchisees thirty (30) days written notice of the termination of the month-to-month tenancy. In the event the City elects to terminate the Franchise after the expiration of the initial term, the City shall become solely responsible for the Encroachment notwithstanding anything set forth herein to the contrary, provided that the ROA and Rosedale, if applicable, shall remain liable for all obligations arising under this Franchise prior to the termination by the City. ARTICLE Ill. CONSTRUCTION, W O R K , A N D REPAIR A. Franchisees, at their cost and expense, shall maintain the Encroachment in good operating condition and shall pay all costs associated with the operation and maintenance of the Encroachment. Any work, maintenance, repair, improvements, and/or changes to the Encroachment, including removal, shall be solely the responsibility of Rosedale and the ROA except as otherwise set forth herein. The City shall have no duty whatsoever to inform the Rosedale or the ROA of any needed maintenance, work, repair, improvements, and/or changes to the Encroachment. Rosedale and the ROA shall perform such maintenance, work, repair, improvements, and/or changes in accordance with all reasonable and applicable workman-like standards as well as in accordance with any applicable City, state, and federal laws and regulations. B. Rosedale and the ROA, at their sole expense and where required, shall obtain all necessary permits and/or approvals from all City, state, and federal agencies. C. In the event any maintenance, work, repair, improvements, and/or changes are required on the Encroachment, and such maintenance, work, repair, improvements, and/or changes materially interfere with the City’s operations in any way, as determined in good faith by the City, then Rosedale and the ROA Page 56 of 207 4 19057\0043\12530241v1 shall be solely responsible for the actual costs of such additional work that results from the interference. D. Without limitation to the foregoing, the Franchisees further agree to the following: 1. Take all actions necessary to comply with the Consent Decree, Remediation Plan, and/or any other order(s), requirement(s), and/or obligation(s) necessary to resolve the outstanding issues with the EPA and DEQ, including the EPA NOV and the DEQ NOV. 2. Conduct an annual inspection by a qualified inspector and provide an annual written report to the Erosion and Sediment Control Administrator, City of Lynchburg, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, VA 24504, describing the condition of the Encroachment. The report shall be due on January 31 of each year, and the inspection shall have been performed within two (2) months prior to the report due date. The report shall state the site name and address, the owner’s name, the inspection date, the inspector’s name and qualifications, and shall describe any deficiencies with and/or required maintenance of the Encroachment. 3. Remediate any deficiencies identified by the annual inspection and written report and conduct a follow-up inspection and provide a follow-up report on such remediation within four (4) weeks of the date of the annual written report subject to the extension authorized in Paragraph B of Article IV. 4. Conduct periodic informal inspections of the Encroachment for excess sediment, debris, trash, or other impediments and pollutants. 5. Remove and properly dispose of sediment from the Encroachment when the flow or storage of the stormwater has been materially restricted or reduced by sediment. 6. Remove and properly dispose of trash, debris, loose brush and other growth from the Encroachment, as needed. 7. Remove and properly dispose of any oil or grease which has accumulated within the Encroachment. 8. If applicable, periodically cut any brush and other woody growth on and around the Encroachment as needed. 9. Make all other repairs and improvements that are reasonably necessary to keep the Encroachment operating in compliance with all applicable City Ordinances, and all state and federal laws, requirements, and regulations. ARTICLE IV. MAINTENANCE, INSPECTION , AND REPAIR Page 57 of 207 5 19057\0043\12530241v1 A. The City shall have the right and option, upon five (5) days written notice to Rosedale and the ROA, to inspect the Encroachment. The City may provide a written report that describes any deficiencies and required maintenance of the Encroachment. Rosedale and the ROA shall promptly remediate any deficiencies identified by the City’s written report. B. In the event the remediation of deficiencies set forth in any report(s) provided under Articles III or IV of this Franchise cannot be reasonably cured within the time limits, the Franchisees shall have such additional, reasonable time as may be required as long the Franchisees are taking diligent and reasonable steps to resolve the same and provide the City with written notice of those steps. C. In the event the Franchisees fail to inspect, report on, or properly maintain the Encroachment within the above specified time limits, the City may, following at least fifteen (15) days’ prior written notice to the Franchisees (provided no notice shall be required in an event of an emergency), take whatever steps it deems necessary to maintain the Encroachment in compliance with City Ordinances and federal and state laws, requirements, and regulations and this Franchise. D. It is understood and agreed by the Franchisees that the City is under no obligation to inspect and/or maintain the Encroachment and this Franchise shall not be construed to impose such an obligation on the City. If such inspection and/or maintenance by the City is performed due to the failure of the Franchisees to do so, the Franchisees shall be jointly and severally obligated to reimburse the City for the reasonable costs of such inspection and/or maintenance within thirty (30) days of receipt of written notice from the City to the Franchisees, which notice shall include invoices and/or other written detailed evidence of the costs incurred by the City to cure the failure of the Franchisees to maintain the Encroachment. Bell shall personally guaranty the obligations of the Franchisees in this Paragraph until the release of Rosedale under Paragraph F of this Article IV and shall execute a Guaranty Agreement in connection with this Franchise to that effect. Any costs not reimbursed by the Franchisees, or Bell, as applicable, to the City following this time may be recorded as liens against the Property, provided any and all liens shall be subordinate to the rights of any lender granted a deed of trust on any portion of the Property regardless of the date such deed of trust is recorded and further provided that the City shall not take any action to disturb the rights of any bona fide, unrelated third party leasing any portion of the Property. E. In the event any of the Agencies, as defined below, require that any part of the Encroachment be removed (the “Removal”), the Franchisees, jointly and severally, shall be solely responsible for all costs incurred in connection with the Removal. If the City incurs costs related to the Removal due to the failure of the Franchisees to remove any part of the Encroachment as required by the Agencies, the Franchisees shall be jointly and severally obligated to reimburse the City for all reasonable costs incurred by the City within thirty (30) days of receipt of written notice from the City, which notice shall include invoices and/or other written Page 58 of 207 6 19057\0043\12530241v1 detailed evidence of the costs incurred by the City to cure the failure of the Franchisees to conduct the Removal. Bell shall personally guaranty the obligations of the Franchisees in this Paragraph until the release of Rosedale under Paragraph F of this Article IV and shall execute a Guaranty Agreement in connection with this Franchise to that effect. Any amounts unpaid to the City following this time may be recorded as liens against the Property, provided any and all liens shall be subordinate to the rights of any lender granted a deed of trust on any portion of the Property regardless of the date such deed of trust is recorded and further provided that the City shall not take any action to disturb the rights of any bona fide, unrelated third party leasing any portion of the Property. F. Upon the occurrence of the contingencies in this Paragraph F of Article IV, the ROA, its successors and assigns, shall be solely responsible for the obligations under this Franchise, and Rosedale and Bell shall be released from all obligations under this Franchise (the “Release”): 1. A resolution acceptable to the EPA, DEQ, the Virginia Department of Historic Resources, the U.S. Corps of Engineers, and any other state or federal agency reviewing violations related to the Project (collectively, the “Agencies”) is reached concerning the Project; and 2. The completion of any remedial work required by the Agencies. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any Liabilities (as defined in Paragraphs A and B of Article VI) arise prior to the Release, Rosedale shall remain responsible, jointly and severally with the ROA, for the Removal, and to defend, indemnify, and hold the City, its employees, officials, and agents harmless from all Liabilities. G. Notwithstanding anything set forth herein to the contrary, in the event the City or the Virginia Department of Transportation (“VDOT”) elect to make changes or improvements to Graves Mill Road which require alterations or improvements to be made to the Encroachment, the City and/or VDOT, as applicable, shall be responsible for all costs and expenses associated with the necessary changes or improvements to be made to the Encroachment. ARTICLE V. DAMAGE TO PROPERTY Unless caused by the negligence or intentional misconduct of the City, its employees, or its officials, the City shall in no way be liable for any damage to the Encroachment. Rosedale and the ROA shall be responsible for repairing or replacing any damages to the City's property or the like that are caused by the acts or omissions of Rosedale, the ROA, their employees, or their agents related to the Encroachment. ARTICLE VI. INDEMNIFICATION AND INSURANCE A. INDEMNIFICATION – GENERAL. Rosedale and the ROA, jointly and severally, Page 59 of 207 7 19057\0043\12530241v1 shall indemnify, hold harmless, and defend the City, its employees, officials, and agents, from and against any and all lawsuits, claims, causes of action, liabilities, demands, damages, disability, losses and expenses, of any nature whatsoever, including reasonable attorneys’ fees (“Liabilities”), resulting or in any manner arising out of: (i) the Encroachment; (ii) Rosedale’s or the ROA’s breach of obligations under this Franchise; or (iii) the negligent or intentional misconduct of Rosedale or the ROA, its members, employees or agents, unless such Liabilities are a direct result of the negligence or intentional misconduct of the City, its employees, or its officials. The City shall notify Rosedale and the ROA of any Liabilities subject to indemnification and defense hereunder and the parties shall cooperate with all reasonable requests for information, documents, testimony, or other assistance appropriate to a resolution of such Liabilities. B. INDEMNIFICATION – CORRECTIVE ACTION/REMOVAL. Rosedale and the ROA, jointly and severally, shall indemnify, hold harmless, and defend the City, its employees, officials and agents, from and against any and all lawsuits, claims, causes of action, liabilities, demands, damages, disability, losses, and expenses, of any nature whatsoever, including reasonable attorneys’ fees (“Liabilities”), resulting or in any manner arising out of the Removal, and any remedial action or corrective action required to address the EPA and DEQ administrative actions. The City shall notify Rosedale and the ROA of any Liabilities subject to indemnification and defense hereunder and the parties shall cooperate with all reasonable requests for information, documents, testimony, or other assistance appropriate to a resolution of such Liabilities. C. The indemnification requirements described hereunder shall survive termination or expiration of this Franchise for a period of five (5) years beyond the same. D. INSURANCE. Rosedale and the ROA shall both obtain and maintain, at their sole cost and expense, with financially reputable insurers authorized to do business in the Commonwealth of Virginia, Commercial General Liability insurance for bodily injury, property damage, and all risk fire and casualty insurance coverage (multi- peril) in a limit of not less than USD$3,000,000 (Three Million Dollars) per occurrence and USD$5,000,000 (Five Million Dollars) in the annual aggregate; 1. Rosedale and the ROA shall further deliver to the City a Certificate of Insurance, satisfactory in form and content to the City, evidencing that the above insurance is in full force and effect. Rosedale and the ROA shall, at least thirty (30) days prior to the expiration of the policies, furnish the City with renewals or binders for the policies, or the City may order the required insurance and charge the cost to Rosedale or the ROA. Any and all such insurance policies shall name the City, its employees, officials, and agents as additional insured parties and shall include or be endorsed to include contractual liability. 2. The insurance required hereunder shall be primary, and any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the City shall be in excess of and shall Page 60 of 207 8 19057\0043\12530241v1 not contribute with any insurance required of Rosedale and the ROA under this Franchise. Any deductibles or self-insured retentions applicable to the required coverage shall be paid by Rosedale and/or the ROA, as applicable, and the City shall not be required to participate therewith. All rights of subrogation against the City, its employees, officials, and agents are hereby waived, and such waiver of subrogation rights shall be shown on the aforesaid Certificate(s) of Insurance. 3. Nothing contained in this Franchise shall limit Rosedale’s and/or the ROA’s indemnification obligations to the City to the limits of the insurance certified or carried. 4. Notwithstanding any of the other provisions of this Franchise, in the event the Franchisees fail to (i) maintain the required insurance coverage throughout the term of this Franchise or (ii) deliver a new and valid binder or certificate verifying such coverage and such failure continues for five (5) days following the Franchisees’ receipt of written notice from the City, the City may order the required insurance and charge the cost to Rosedale and/or the ROA. Bell shall personally guaranty the obligations of the Franchisees in this Paragraph until the release of Rosedale under Paragraph F of Article IV and shall execute a Guaranty Agreement in connection with this Franchise to that effect. Rosedale and/or the ROA, as applicable, shall reimburse the amounts paid by the City to obtain the insurance required by this Article VI upon demand and any amounts unpaid to the City within ten (10) days following written demand may be recorded as liens against the Property, provided any and all liens shall be subordinate to the rights of any lender granted a deed of trust on any portion of the Property regardless of the date such deed of trust is recorded and further provided that the City shall not take any action to disturb the rights of any bona fide, unrelated third party leasing any portion of the Property. ARTICLE VII. COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS The grant of this Franchise is subject to all ordinances, resolutions, and procedures of the City as the same now exist or may be hereafter adopted, amended, revised, or codified, in lawful exercise of any power granted to the City by the Virginia General Assembly or any other lawful body. The City agrees that, except in cases of emergency, it will give the Franchisees thirty (30) days advance written notice of all such rules and regulations adopted by the City before the Franchisees shall be required to comply therewith. In performing its responsibilities under this Franchise, the Franchisees will comply with all applicable state and federal laws and regulations and all federal, state and local laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations currently in force or subsequently adopted that may apply to their obligations under this Franchise. ARTICLE VIII. AMENDMENTS TO FRANCHISE Page 61 of 207 9 19057\0043\12530241v1 The City and the Franchisees may modify this Franchise from time to time; however, such modifications will be in writing and approved by the Lynchburg City Council. ARTICLE IX. TERMINATION OF FRANCHISE A. The City retains the right to withhold or withdraw any and all privileges granted under this Franchise and to terminate this Franchise at any time if the Franchisees or Bell fail to comply with any of the provisions of this Franchise. Exercise of this right by the City shall be in addition to and not in place of any other rights which the City has under the terms of this Franchise. Prior to exercising this right, the City Manager, or such other person or persons as the City Manager may from time to time designate, shall provide the Franchisees and/or Bell, as appropriate, with written notice of the failure to comply with the terms of this Franchise or default. The Franchisees and/or Bell shall have thirty (30) days from receipt of such notice to remedy any such default, provided that in the event the Franchisees and/or Bell cannot cure the default within the thirty (30) day period, the Franchisees and/or Bell shall have such additional, reasonable time as may be required as long they are taking diligent and reasonable steps to resolve the same and provide the City with written notice of those steps. B. If there are instituted by or against the Franchisees or Bell proceedings in bankruptcy or insolvency during the term of this Franchise, the City may terminate the same at any time thereafter. The exercise of this right by the City shall be in addition to and not in place of any other rights which the City has under the terms of this Franchise. Any successors, assignee or assignees, trustee, or receiver of the Franchisees or Bell resulting from proceedings in bankruptcy or under any insolvency law shall be subject to and bound by all of the provisions, terms, conditions, and limitations of this Franchise. C. The City retains the right to withhold or withdraw any and all privileges under this Franchise and to terminate this Franchise at any time if there is a taking of the Franchisees’ property by way of a court of competent jurisdiction, which precludes the Franchisees and/or Bell from satisfying their obligations under this Franchise. Exercise of this right by the City shall be in addition to and not in place of any other rights which the City has under the terms of this Franchise. In the event the City elects to terminate the Franchise in connection with a taking, the City shall become solely responsible for the Encroachment notwithstanding anything set forth herein to the contrary, provided that the ROA, Rosedale, and/or Bell if applicable, shall remain liable for all obligations arising under this Franchise prior to the termination by the City. ARTICLE X. NOTICES A. Rosedale has designated Bell to serve as the responsible individual for execution of the responsibilities of the Franchisees under this Franchise. The Franchisees shall inform the City regarding any change in the designee in writing according to this Article X. Page 62 of 207 10 19057\0043\12530241v1 B. Notices, demands, requests, and other writings made by the parties pursuant to this Franchise shall be made to the following addresses via (i) hand delivery, (ii) certified mail, return receipt requested, or (iii) overnight carrier, and shall be deemed given upon receipt or refusal of acceptance, unless otherwise communicated in writing: Rosedale: Rosedale Investments, LLC Attn: Member/Managing Member 103 West Edge Way, Ste H Lynchburg, VA 24502 ROA: Rosedale Owners Association, Inc. Attn: President 103 West Edge Way, Ste H Lynchburg, VA 24502 Bell: 103 West Edge Way, Ste H Forest, Virginia 24551 A copy of any notice sent to Rosedale, the ROA, or Bell shall be contemporaneously sent to: Whitlow & Youell, PLC Attn: Cooper Youell 28A Kirk Avenue, SW Roanoke, VA 24011 City: City of Lynchburg, Virginia Attn: City Manager 900 Church Street – 3rd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 and City of Lynchburg, Virginia ATTN: City Engineer 900 Church Street – 2nd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 Page 63 of 207 11 19057\0043\12530241v1 A copy of any notice sent to the City shall be contemporaneously sent to: City of Lynchburg, Virginia Attn: City Attorney 900 Church Street – 3rd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 ARTICLE XI. MISCELLANEOUS A. TAXES. Rosedale and the ROA shall pay all real estate taxes and any other charges or fees that may be assessed against the portion of the Property owned by Rosedale and/or the ROA, but no real estate taxes and any other charges or fees shall be assessed or charged in connection with the Encroachment. B. SUCCESSORS . This Franchise and the rights and responsibilities of the same shall run with the title to the land and shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the Franchisees, successor owners, and assigns of the Franchisees’ property. Neither the City, the Franchisees, nor Bell may assign this Franchise or any of the rights and/or responsibilities described herein without the written consent of the others, which will not be unreasonably withheld. Notwithstanding any other part of this Franchise, the City Manager, in his discretion, shall have the authority to permit such assignments on behalf of the City without the same being approved by the Lynchburg City Council. Notwithstanding the foregoing, once the conditions set forth in Paragraph F of Article IV of this Franchise have been satisfied, Rosedale may transfer any portion of the Property to a bona fide, unrelated third-party purchaser without the consent of the City. C. SEVERABILITY . In the event that any provision of this Franchise, or portion of the same, shall be construed to be invalid or unenforceable by a court of competent jurisdiction, then such provision or portion shall be stricken, and the remaining portions of this Franchise shall remain in full force and effect. D. GOVERNING LAW. This Franchise shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and any legal proceedings related to the same shall be filed in the courts of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia and in no other forum. E. ENTIRE FRANCHISE. All provisions with respect to this Franchise are expressly contained herein. No representative or agent of the City or the Franchisees has made any representation or promise with respect to this Franchise not contained herein. F. RESERVATION OF RIGHTS. It is distinctively understood that all privileges and uses of the City's property and right-of-way, except to the extent herein permitted to the Franchisees, are expressly reserved by the City to use at its discretion as the City deems advisable. Page 64 of 207 12 19057\0043\12530241v1 G. REMEDIES NOT EXCLUSIVE. All rights and remedies described in this Franchise shall be cumulative and additional to all other rights and/or remedies available at law or in equity. H. BINDING EFFECT. This Franchise shall be binding and inure to the benefit of the City, the Franchisees, and Bell and their respective representatives, successors, and permissible assigns. Further, upon being admitted 'of record' in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, this Franchise shall constitute a covenant running with the land. Notwithstanding the foregoing, once the conditions set forth in Paragraph F of Article IV of this Franchise have been satisfied, only the property owned by the ROA shall be subject to any liens arising out of the failure of the ROA to perform its obligations under this Franchise. I. INDEPENDENT ENTITIES. Nothing contained in this Franchise shall be construed as or deemed to make either the City or the Franchisees the agent, partner, or joint venture of the other, except as may otherwise be provided in this Franchise. Nothing contained in this Franchise shall give the Franchisees any authority to represent the City before any court or governmental or regulatory agency without the express prior written authorization of the City. Unless otherwise provided in this Franchise, neither the City nor the Franchisees shall be responsible or held liable for the acts or omissions of the other. Further, in performing any services or engaging in any actions pursuant to this Franchise, the Franchisees are and shall be acting as independent contractors, responsible to all parties for their acts and omissions, and the City shall not be liable for the same. J. THIRD-PARTY RIGHTS. Nothing in this Franchise shall be deemed to create any rights to those who are not expressly made a party to this Franchise. The parties to this Franchise are the City, the Franchisees, and Bell. K. COUNTERPARTS AND SIGNATURES. This Franchise may be executed in counterparts. Each of which when so executed shall be deemed to be an original and all of which taken together shall constitute one document. Further, this Franchise may be executed and/or sealed electronically. An electronic signature and/or seal shall be equally as enforceable as an original signature or seal. L. HEADINGS. Marginal headings contained in this Franchise are for convenience only and shall not be considered to amplify, relate, modify, or otherwise affect any of the terms, provisions, or conditions of this Franchise. M. FORCE MAJEURE. The Franchisees shall not be held in default under, or in noncompliance with, the provisions of this Franchise, nor suffer any enforcement or penalty relating to noncompliance or default (including termination, cancellation or revocation of this Franchise), where such noncompliance or alleged defaults occurred or were caused by events which constitute a Force Majeure. For purposes of this Franchise, “Force Majeure” means an event or events reasonably beyond the ability of the Franchisees to anticipate and control, and includes, but is not Page 65 of 207 13 19057\0043\12530241v1 limited to, acts of God, incidences of terrorism, war or riots, labor strikes or civil disturbances, floods, earthquakes, fire, explosions, epidemics, hurricanes, or tornadoes. ARTICLE XII. METHOD OF ACCEPTANCE This Ordinance shall be and become effective as a Franchise and shall constitute a contract between the City, the Franchisees, and Bell once adopted by the Lynchburg City Council and executed by the Franchisees and Bell. The Franchisees and Bell shall execute this Ordinance prior to the said adoption by the Lynchburg City Council or within ten (10) days of the same. ARTICLE XIII. ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE This Ordinance was duly adopted by the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia on the 13th day of May, 2025, and shall be effective as of the 1st day of June, 2025. Certified:_ ______________________ Clerk of Council Approved as to Form: ____________________ City Attorney/Designee Page 66 of 207 14 19057\0043\12530241v1 ARTICLE XIV. ACCEPTANCE OF FRANCHISE By joining in this Ordinance through signature of their duly authorized representatives, the Franchisees and Bell do hereby accept the entirety of the same as of its adoption date. ROSEDALE INVESTMENTS, LLC (SEAL) By:______________________________ Printed Name:_____________________ Its: Manager (SEAL) ROSEDALE OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. By:_____________________________ Printed Name: Thomas P. Bell Its: President THOMAS P. BELL ________________________________(SEAL) Page 67 of 207 15 19057\0043\12530241v1 Exhibit A: Page 68 of 207 16 19057\0043\12530241v1 Page 69 of 207 17 19057\0043\12530241v1 Page 70 of 207 18 19057\0043\12530241v1 Page 71 of 207 19 19057\0043\12530241v1 Page 72 of 207 Page 73 of 207 Page 74 of 207 Page 75 of 207 Page 76 of 207 Page 77 of 207 {9824/77/00217172.DOCX;1 }1 19057\0043\12481445v1 GUARANTY AGREEMENT THIS GUARANTY AGREEMENT (“Guaranty”) is made effective as of June 1, 2025 by Thomas P. Bell (“Guarantor”) to secure the obligations owed by Rosedale Investments, LLC, a Virginia limited liability company (“Rosedale”), and the Rosedale Owners Association, Inc., a Virginia corporation (“ROA”), under Articles III, IV, and VI (hereinafter, “Maintenance/Removal Obligations”) of the Franchise Agreement with the City of Lynchburg, Virginia (“City”) dated June 1, 2025 (“Franchise”). 1. Guaranteed Obligations. In consideration of the substantial direct and indirect benefits derived by Guarantor under the Franchise and this Guaranty, and to induce the City to enter into the Franchise by providing good and sufficient security, Guarantor hereby absolutely, unconditionally, and irrevocably guarantees the full and prompt performance of the Maintenance/Removal Obligations in accordance with the Franchise. 2. Nature of Guaranty; Waivers. a. This Guaranty is an absolute, unconditional, irrevocable and continuing guaranty, and will remain in full force and effect until the release of Rosedale under Paragraph F of Article IV of the Franchise (“Guaranty Period”). During the Guaranty Period, Guarantor hereby unconditionally and irrevocably waives any right to revoke this Guaranty and acknowledges that this Guaranty is continuing in nature and applies to all Maintenance/Removal Obligations until the expiration of the Guaranty Period. b. This Guaranty is a guaranty of performance and payment, and not merely of collection, and the City shall not be required or obligated, as a condition of the Guarantor’s liability, to make any demand upon or to pursue any of his rights against Rosedale or the ROA, or to pursue any rights which may be available to it with respect to any other person who may be liable for the Maintenance/Removal Obligations. c. Guarantor hereby unconditionally and irrevocably waives promptness, diligence, notice of acceptance, presentment, demand for performance, notice of non- performance, default, acceleration, protest or dishonor and any other notice with respect to any of the Maintenance/Removal Obligations, provided Guarantor is not waiving any notice or demand rights specifically set forth in the Franchise. d. The Maintenance/Removal Obligations shall not be discharged or impaired or otherwise affected by, and Guarantor hereby irrevocably waives any defenses to enforcement he may have (now or in the future) by reason of: (i) Any illegality, invalidity or unenforceability of any Maintenance/Removal Obligations or this Guaranty or any related agreement or instrument, or any law, regulation, decree or order of any Page 78 of 207 {9824/77/00217172.DOCX;1 }2 19057\0043\12481445v1 jurisdiction or any other event affecting any terms of the Maintenance/Removal Obligations; (ii) Any change in the time, place or manner of payment or performance of, or in any other terms of the Maintenance/Removal Obligations, or any recission, waiver, release, assignment, amendment or other modification of this Guaranty; (iii) Any taking, exchange, substitution, release, impairment, amendment, waiver, modification or non-perfection of any other guaranty for the Maintenance/Removal Obligations, or any manner of sale, disposition or application of proceeds of any other assets to all or part of the Maintenance/Removal Obligations; (iv) Any change, restructuring or termination of the corporate structure, ownership or existence of Guarantor or any insolvency, bankruptcy, reorganization or other similar proceeding affecting Guarantor or his assets or any resulting restructuring, release or discharge of any Maintenance/Removal Obligations; (v) The failure of the City to assert any claim or demand or to exercise or enforce any right or remedy under the provisions of this Guaranty or otherwise; (vi) The existence of any claim, set-off, counterclaim, recoupment or other rights that Guarantor may have against the City, except as otherwise set forth in the Articles V and VI of the Franchise; and (vii) Any other circumstances (including, without limitation, any statute of limitations), act, omission, or manner of administering this Guaranty or any existence of or reliance on any representation by the City that might vary the risk of Guarantor or otherwise operate as a defense available to, or a legal or equitable discharge for, Guarantor. 3. Events of Default. The occurrence of any of the following shall be an “Event of Default”: a. Failure by Rosedale or the ROA to perform the Maintenance/Removal Obligations in accordance with the Franchise; b. (i) A court having jurisdiction shall enter a decree or order for relief in respect of either Rosedale or the ROA in an involuntary case under Title 11 of the United States Code entitled “Bankruptcy” (as now and hereinafter in effect, or any successor thereto, the “Bankruptcy Code”) or any applicable bankruptcy, insolvency or other similar law now or hereafter in effect, which decree or order is not stayed; or any other similar relief shall be granted under any applicable federal or state law; or Page 79 of 207 {9824/77/00217172.DOCX;1 }3 19057\0043\12481445v1 (ii) An involuntary case shall be commenced against either Rosedale or the ROA, under any applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, or other similar law now or hereafter in effect; or a decree or order of a court having jurisdiction for the appointment of a receiver, liquidator, sequestrator, trustee, custodian or other officer having similar powers over either Rosedale or the ROA entered; or the involuntary appointment of an interim receiver, trustee or other custodian of either Rosedale or the ROA for all or a substantial part of Rosedale’s or the ROA’s property shall have occurred; or a warrant of attachment, execution or similar process shall have been issued against any substantial part of the property of either Rosedale or the ROA and, in the case of any event described in this clause (ii), such event shall have continued for 60 days unless dismissed, bonded, or discharged; or c. An order for relief shall be entered with respect to Rosedale or the ROA, or Rosedale or the ROA commence a voluntary case under the Bankruptcy Code or any applicable bankruptcy, insolvency or other similar law now or hereafter in effect, or shall consent to the entry of an order for relief in an involuntary case, or to the conversion of an involuntary case to a voluntary case, under any such law, or shall consent to the appointment of or taking possession by a receiver, trustee or other custodian for all or a substantial part of their property; or Rosedale or the ROA make an assignment for the benefit of creditors; or Rosedale or the ROA shall be unable or fail, or shall admit in writing their inability, to pay their debts as such debts become due; or d. Either Rosedale or the ROA challenges, or initiates any proceedings to challenge, the validity, binding effect, or enforceability of the Franchise. 4. Remedies. Upon the occurrence of any Event of Default specified in Section 3, the City may, by written notice to Guarantor, declare the default. If such default is not cured within ten (10) days of such written notice, Guarantor shall assume all Maintenance/Removal Obligations and accomplish full and prompt performance of all outstanding Maintenance/Removal Obligations within fourteen (14) days. In the event Guarantor fails to accomplish such performance to the reasonable satisfaction of the City, the City will be entitled to preliminary and permanent injunctive relief requiring the cure of the default without the need for a showing of irreparable harm. 5. Fees and Costs. If an Event of Default occurs, and the City incurs costs or expenses in enforcing its rights under this Guaranty, including reasonable attorney’s fees and the costs and expenses of litigation, Guarantor shall be responsible for such costs and expenses. 6. Release of Guaranty. Following the release of Rosedale under Paragraph F of Article IV of the Franchise, this Guaranty shall automatically terminate and be of no further force and effect. 7. Notices. All notices, demands, requests, consents, approvals and other communications required or permitted hereunder (collectively, “Notices”) shall be made to the following Page 80 of 207 {9824/77/00217172.DOCX;1 }4 19057\0043\12481445v1 addresses via (i) hand delivery, (ii) certified mail, return receipt requested, or (iii) overnight carrier, and shall be deemed given upon receipt or refusal of acceptance, unless otherwise communicated in writing: Guarantor: Thomas P. Bell 103 West Edge Way, Ste H Lynchburg, VA 24502 With a copy of any Notice sent contemporaneously to: Whitlow & Youell, PLC Attn: Cooper Youell 28A Kirk Avenue, SW Roanoke, VA 24011 City: City of Lynchburg, Virginia Attn: City Manager 900 Church Street – 3rd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 and City of Lynchburg, Virginia ATTN: City Engineer 900 Church Street – 2nd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 With a copy of any Notice sent contemporaneously to: City of Lynchburg, Virginia Attn: City Attorney 900 Church Street – 3rd Floor Lynchburg, VA 24504 7. Subrogation. Guarantor waives and shall not exercise any rights that it may acquire by way of subrogation, contribution, reimbursement, or indemnification until all Maintenance/Removal Obligations have been indefeasibly satisfied and discharged in full. 8. Preservation of Rights. No delay or omission by the City to exercise any right or power arising hereunder will impair any such right or power or be considered a waiver of any such right or power, nor will the City’s action or inaction impair any such right or power. Page 81 of 207 {9824/77/00217172.DOCX;1 }5 19057\0043\12481445v1 The City’s rights and remedies hereunder are cumulative and not exclusive of any other rights or remedies which the City may have under other agreements, at law, or in equity. 9. Illegality. If any provision in this Guaranty should be invalid, illegal, or unenforceable in any respect, it shall not affect or impair the validity, legality, and enforceability of the remaining provisions of this Guaranty. 10. Changes in Writing. No modification, amendment or waiver thereof, or consent to any departure by Guarantor from, any provision of this Guaranty will be effective unless made in a writing signed by the City, and then such waiver or consent shall be effective only in the specific instance and for the purpose for which given. 11. Entire Agreement. This Guaranty constitutes the entire agreement and supersedes all other prior agreements and understandings, both written and oral, between Guarantor and the City with respect to the subject matter hereof. 12. Successors and Assigns. This Guaranty will be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the Guarantor and the City and their respective successors and assigns; provided, however, that Guarantor may not assign this Guaranty in whole or in part without the City’s prior written consent. 13. Governing Law and Jurisdiction. This Guaranty shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and any legal proceedings related to the same shall be filed in the courts of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia and in no other forum. 14. Execution. A faxed, emailed, or electronic signature affirming this Guaranty constitutes an original signature. WITNESS the due execution hereof as a document under seal, as of the date first written above, with the intent to be legally bound hereby. _____________________________(Seal) Thomas P. Bell Page 82 of 207 City Council Agenda Item IV.9. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY May 13, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager AGENDA ITEM # IV.9 Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-034 amending Section 36-270 of the City Code for purposes of changing an exception to the City's Amusement Tax. RECOMMENDATION After the public hearing, adopt the Ordinance amending City Code Section 36-270. The effective date of this Ordinance will be June 1, 2025. SUMMARY Currently the Hillcats pay no amusement tax on ticket sales based on an exception in the local code. Proposed investment in the city-owned stadium in the new franchise is significantly funded by amusement tax revenue. Current Exception Language: “No tax shall be payable under this division for admission to the following amusements or entertainments: (b) Athletic events that are held at a municipal facility or any amusement or entertainment that is sponsored by the city" Proposed Exception Language “No tax shall be payable under this division for admission to the following amusements or entertainments: (b) Youth athletic events that are held at a municipal facility or any amusement or entertainment that is sponsored by the city. “Youth athletic events” shall mean athletic events involving a majority of players who are under eighteen (18 ) years of age.” Additional admissions tax will only be paid by those who attend Hillcats games. PRIOR ACTION(S) Business Item Briefing (BIB) - April 8, 2025 FISCAL IMPACT Projected $2.45 Million in new tax revenue over next 15 years CONTACT(S) Page 83 of 207 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Mitchell Nuckles, Commissioner of the Revenue ATTACHMENT(S) 1. O-25-034 2. Amusement Tax Pres REVIEWED BY Date: May 08, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Date: May 08, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 84 of 207 1 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981, BY AMENDING SECTION 36-270 OF DIVISION 5 OF ARTICLE V OF CHAPTER 36; SUCH AMENDMENT CHANGING SUBSECTION (B) OF THE EXCEPTIONS FROM THE AMUSEMENT TAX TO REFLECT YOUTH ATHLETIC EVENTS INSTEAD OF ATHLETIC EVENTS ORDINANCE: #O-25-034 WHEREAS, prior to the adoption of this Ordinance, a public hearing was held before the Lynchburg City Council in order to receive public feedback on the proposed amendment after such public hearing was duly advertised in accordance with the requirements of § 58.1-3007 of the Code of Virginia. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: 1. That the Code of City of Lynchburg, 1981, be and the same is hereby amended and reenacted by amending Section 36-270 of Division 5 of Article V of Chapter 36 of such code as follows: Sec. 36-270. Exceptions. No tax shall be payable under this division for admission to the following amusements or entertainments: (a)  Athletic events held by a college or university for teams or athletes that regularly participate in such college's or university's athletic programs and dances held by a college or university. (b)  Athletic events that are Youth athletic events held at a municipal facility or any amusement or entertainment event that is sponsored by the city. “Youth athletic events” shall mean athletic events involving a majority of players who are under eighteen (18) years of age. (c)  Dances or any athletic or cultural event conducted by an elementary or secondary school, public or private. Fundraising activities such as carnivals and other amusement or entertainment events shall be subject to the tax provided for in section 36-262 of this division. (d)  Any athletic event that is held as part of the Virginia High School League All-Star Games. (e)  Amateur participants in sports tournaments. For purposes of this exemption a sports tournament shall be defined as a series of sports or athletic contests taking place during a limited period of time rather than throughout a regular season, where all the participants or teams are amateur, includes teams or participants from outside the region 2000 area and which has been sanctioned by an appropriate sanctioning body. Examples of sports tournaments include but shall not be limited to, bowling tournaments, miniature golf tournaments, softball tournaments, basketball tournaments, skating tournaments and similar sport activities. 2. That this Ordinance shall become effective on June 1, 2025. Adopted: May 13, 2025 Certified: ________________________ Clerk of Council Page 85 of 207 AMUSEMENT TAX CODE CHANGE Tuesday, May 27, 2025 Page 86 of 207 CHANGE TO LOCAL AMUSEMENT TAX EXCEPTION • Currently the Hillcats pay no amusement tax on ticket sales based on an exception in the local code • Proposed investment in the city owned stadium in the new franchise is significantly funded by amusement tax revenue • Current Exception Language: “No tax shall be payable under this division for admission to the following amusements or entertainments: (b) Athletic events that are held at a municipal facility or any amusement or entertainment that is sponsored by the city • Proposed Exception Language “No tax shall be payable under this division for admission to the following amusements or entertainments: (b) Youth athletic events that are held at a municipal facility or any amusement or entertainment that is sponsored by the city. “Youth athletic events” shall mean athletic events involving players under 18 years of age.” • Additional admissions tax will only be paid by those who attend Hillcats games. Page 87 of 207 City Council Agenda Item IV.10. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY May 13, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager AGENDA ITEM # IV.10 Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-035 granting Hillcats Baseball, LLC an exclusive franchise right to use the City of Lynchburg’s / Bank of the James Stadium for its baseball games, events, and related uses. RECOMMENDATION After the Public Hearing, adopt the Ordinance granting the franchise. SUMMARY The Lynchburg Hillcats baseball team is under new ownership and is seeking a new 15-year franchise agreement with the city, through the 2029 season, to allow the Hillcats to use public infrastructure (Bank of the James Stadium) to operate a minor league baseball team. Under the proposed franchise, the city will collect annual rent, parking rights fee, naming rights fee, and local taxes (sales, meals, amusement) as a result of baseball operations. This revenue will support $5.25M in up-front investment for improvements to the city-owned Stadium. The improvements are primarily fan experience amenities and required MLB stadium requirements. It also includes a $150K annual maintenance reserve to ensure completion of basic maintenance needs and on-going compliance with MLB stadium requirements. This agreement is contingent upon two other Council actions tonight. The first is an amendment to the city code to eliminate an exception to the city's amusement tax. The second is a budget amendment to add the $5.25M capital improvement project to the city's FY 2025 CIP. PRIOR ACTION(S) Hillcats Baseball Franchise Bid Review, Call, and Acceptance - May 13, 2025 Work Session Business Item Briefing (BIB) - April 8, 2025 FISCAL IMPACT $5.25M CIP project to improve the Bank of the James Stadium. $150K annual maintenance reserve. $7+M in city revenue over the next 15 years. CONTACT(S) Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Page 88 of 207 ATTACHMENT(S) 1. O-25-035 2. Proposed Franchise Agreement - Hillcats Baseball, LLC 3. Exhibit A 4. Performance Bond - Hillcats Baseball, LLC 5. Franchise PH REVIEWED BY Date: May 08, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Date: May 08, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 89 of 207 1 AN ORDINANCE GRANTING HILLCATS BASEBALL, LLC, AN EXCLUSIVE FRANCHISE RIGHT TO USE THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG’S / BANK OF THE JAMES STADIUM (3180 FORT AVENUE, LYNCHBURG, VA 24501) FOR ITS BASEBALL GAMES, EVENTS, AND RELATED USES ORDINANCE: #O-25-035 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: ARTICLE I. AUTHORIZATION TO GRANT A BASEBALL STADIUM FRANCHISE 1. That a franchise, as shown in that certain document entitled “A Baseball Stadium Franchise Agreement by and between the City of Lynchburg and Hillcats Baseball, LLC”, dated April 1, 2025, is hereby approved, and Hillcats Baseball, LLC is granted an exclusive franchise right to use the City of Lynchburg’s / Bank of the James Stadium (3180 Fort Avenue, Lynchburg, VA 24501) for its baseball games, events, and related uses as provided in the said agreement. Said agreement is expressly incorporated herein by reference. 2. That the City Manager, on behalf of the City of Lynchburg, is hereby authorized to execute all documents and take all actions necessary to effectuate the said franchise and agreement for the City of Lynchburg. ARTICLE II. ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE This Ordinance was duly adopted by the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia on the 13th day of May, 2025, and shall be effective upon adoption. Certified: _______________________ Clerk of Council Page 90 of 207 2 ARTICLE III. ACCEPTANCE / ACCEPTANCE OF FRANCHISE By joining in this Ordinance through signature of its duly authorized representative, Hillcats Baseball, LLC hereby agrees to the entirety of the same as of its adoption date. HILLCATS BASEBALL, LLC By:______________________________ Printed Name:_____________________ Its:______________________________ State/Commonwealth/___________ of __________________, } City/County of ___________________, to - wit: } The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on behalf of Hillcats Baseball, LLC, by __________________, its ____________________, on this ______ day of ____________, 2025. ___________________________ Notary Public My Commission Expires:___________________ My Registration No._______________________ Affix Notary Seal: Page 91 of 207 1 A Baseball Stadium Franchise Agreement by and between the City of Lynchburg and Hillcats Baseball, LLC Dated April 1, 2025 Page 92 of 207 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ARTICLE TITLE PAGE I DEFINITIONS 3 II TERM OF AGREEMENT 5 III TEAM USE OF STADIUM 5 IV STADIUM OPERATION AND SERVICES 7 V FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICES 9 VI ADVERTISING, MARKETING AND BROADCAST RIGHTS 11 VII COMPENSATION PAYABLE BY THE TEAM TO THE CITY 11 VIII FACILITY MAINTENANCE 12 IX UTILITIES 14 X TEAM SUPPLIED EQUIPMENT 14 XI SCHEDULING 14 XII INDEMNIFICATION AND INSURANCE 15 XIII EVENTS OF DEFAULT AND REMEDIES 16 XIV PARKING 18 XV TRAFFIC CONTROL AND POLICE PATROL 19 XVI ASSIGNABILITY OF FRANCHISE SUBJECT TO PRIOR CITY APPROVAL 19 XVII TEAM BASEBALL GAME TICKETS 19 XVIII DESTRUCTION OF STADIDM 19 XIX CONDEMNATION 20 XX SIGNAGE 20 XXI FORCE MAJEURE 20 XXII NO RELOCATION OF TEAM 21 XXIII ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF BOND STATUS 21 XXIV MISCELLANEOUS 21 Page 93 of 207 3 CITY OF LYNCHBURG BASEBALL STADIUM FRANCHISE AGREEMENT THIS BASEBALL STADIUM FRANCHISE AGREEMENT (Franchise) is made and entered into as of April 1, 2025, by and between the CITY OF LYNCHBURG, a municipal corporation of the Commonwealth of Virginia (City) and HILLCATS BASEBALL, LLC, a Virginia Limited Liability Company d/b/a LYNCHBURG HILLCATS OF THE CAROLINA LEAGUE (Team), who are the sole parties to this Franchise. WHEREAS, Hillcats Baseball LLC has purchased ownership and will operate a baseball team in the City of Lynchburg. WHEREAS, that Team, The Lynchburg Hillcats, is a member of the Class A Advanced Carolina League of Minor League Baseball. WHEREAS, Hillcats Baseball, LLC and the City desire that The Lynchburg Hillcats remain in the Carolina League and continue to play their home baseball games at Lynchburg City Stadium, Bank of the James Stadium (Stadium). NOW, THEREFORE, WITNESSETH: that for and in consideration of the mutual covenants and promises contained herein, and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is mutually acknowledged, the City and the Team agree as follows: ARTICLE I DEFINITIONS For purposes of this Franchise, the terms defined in this section shall have the meanings specified herein whether stated in the plural or singular. Section 1.01. "BASEBALL SEASON" shall mean the period commencing April 1st of each full calendar year of this Franchise and ending on the date on which the Team's last home game is played during the same calendar year including any and all post-season competition, exhibition, play-off and All-Star games, pursuant to the Carolina League schedule. Section 1.02. "CITY EVENTS" shall mean all events or activities held at the Stadium, except a Team Event or Team Special Event, under the auspices of the City including events coordinated with the City by an outside entity or promoter. The Virginia Commonwealth Games is such an event. Section 1.03. "CITY STADIUM SERVICES" shall mean those services which are required for City Events at the Stadium. These services may include but are not limited to Food and Beverage Services and Team Stadium Services. Section 1.04. "COMMON AREAS" shall mean all portions of the Stadium except the Team Areas as defined in Section 1.10 and any areas designated for City use. Section 1.05. "FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICES" shall mean all food and beverage services required or appropriate for any and all events at the Stadium or its parking areas, including without limitation, dining, catering, vending and food and beverage service, through fixed and portable food and beverage service stands, vending machines, roving vendors, and snack bars at Food and Beverage Service Areas in the Stadium or its parking areas. Section 1.06. "FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICE AREAS" shall mean all areas, together with improvements, fixtures and trade fixtures, which are used in connection with the operation of Food and Beverage Services in the Stadium or its parking areas, as described in Article V hereof. Section 1.07. "GROSS REVENUE" shall mean all receipts from the sale of individual game or season tickets for Team Events and Team Special Events held at the Stadium, including all Sky Box rental and Food and Beverage Services income at Team Events and Team Special Events held at the Stadium, all parking revenue (if Team initiates a parking fee), advertising sales including, but not limited to, naming rights, outfield fence advertising, scoreboard message center Page 94 of 207 4 advertising sold by the Team, program advertising, program sales, the sale of Team merchandise by the Team or any agent of the Team, the sale of royalty and logo rights, the sale of radio, television, cablevision, movie, or other video rights, sponsorships, and any and all other fees and revenues generated from Team Events and Team Special Events excepting from such amounts only any state and local sales taxes and meals taxes applicable to such transactions. The City retains any revenue derived from City Events with the exception of food and beverages sold by HillCats Catering or third-party contractors or concessionaires under contract with HillCats Catering unless otherwise agreed by the City and Team. The City retains the right to provide its own food and beverages or use an outside caterer for any City Events that are not open to the public in place of Hillcats Catering or third-party contractors or concessionaires under contract with HillCats Catering. Section 1.08. "REQUIRED UTILITIES" shall mean all required water, sewer, electric, cable television and gas services for the playing field, on-site parking lot and all other areas of the Stadium. Section 1.09. “SCOREBOARD” shall mean the main electronic scoreboard and message center located inside the Stadium. Scoreboard may consist of areas for team scores, advertising and a video screen. Section 1.10. "STADIUM" shall mean The Lynchburg City Stadium, Bank of the James Stadium, as shown on Exhibit “A”, including stadium lights, scoreboard, message board, City-owned concessions equipment, public address system, and other furniture and fixtures incident to stadium operations. Section 1.09.01. “SKY BOX” shall mean the private fully furnished suites with outdoor balcony located on the upper level of the Stadium. Section 1.09.02. “STADIUM BOX OFFICE shall mean the physical space in the Stadium where tickets are sold for admission to games and events. Section 1.09.03 “FIELD” shall mean the actual playing surface of the Stadium including dugout, bullpens, field lining, pitcher’s mound, and bases. Section 1.10. "TEAM AREAS" shall mean the Team administrative office area, locker room area, training area, press box area, dugouts, batting cages, ticket office, Team merchandise store area and all Sky Boxes in use during Team Events. Section 1.11. "TEAM EVENTS" shall mean any Carolina League scheduled Team baseball game or other baseball-related event, such as practices or exhibition games, held at the Stadium by the Team with the approval of the City pursuant to Article XI, Section 11.02 hereof, other than a Team Special Event. Section 1.12. "TEAM SPECIAL EVENTS" shall mean any events, other than Team Events, sponsored by the Team with City approval. Section 1.13. "TEAM STADIUM SERVICES" shall consist of the following: a. Facility Services - shall mean the operation and staffing of the Stadium scoreboard, the public address system, the Stadium Box Office, all ticket booths, usher services, first- aid room, on-site and supplemental parking lot security services, the opening and closing of the Stadium, the operation of all Stadium utilities at all Team Events and Team Special Events. b. Field Maintenance - shall include, but not be limited to, maintenance of the playing field including without limitation, periodic mowing, watering, fertilizing and other chemical treatments required to maintain the field at professional stadium quality, sod replacement resulting from the use of the field, specialized turf care, such as aeration and other treatments which are required to maintain the quality of the field, and the maintenance of all unsodded areas of the field. c. Field Preparation - shall mean field preparation in advance of baseball games which shall include, but not be limited to, lining the field, preparation of the unsodded areas of the field, installation of bases, other such services needed to fully prepare the field for Team baseball games, and restoration of the field surface as required for uses of Page 95 of 207 5 the field other than baseball games. d. Janitorial Services - shall mean the cleaning and maintenance of all Team Areas and Common Areas during and after all Team Events, Team Special Events, and City Events held in the Stadium, including, but not limited to, the stocking of all restrooms with paper products as required prior to such events, the disposal of all trash collected from such areas immediately after such events, the pickup of all trash and debris from the on-site Team parking areas no later than 6:00 a.m. on the morning following such events and any needed clean-up of trash and debris from public areas surrounding the Stadium or such on-site parking areas as may be used by attendees of the Stadium. All Janitorial Services provided to the Team Areas and Common Areas shall include all action necessary to maintain the areas in a clean and attractive manner and in compliance with all legal requirements. e. Pre-Event Field Preparation - shall mean the preparation of the field for any Team Event or Team Special Event, as may be required for such event including, but not limited to, conversion of the playing field for other athletic events, installation of any supplemental seating equipment, installation of stage or platform equipment and/or temporary lighting which may be required for the event. Pre-Event Field Preparation shall be performed by the Team or, when necessary, by other parties under the supervision of the Team. ARTICLE II TERM OF AGREEMENT Section 2.01. TERM. The term of this Franchise shall commence as of April 1, 2025, and shall be for a period of fifteen (15) years, ending with the conclusion of the 2040 Baseball Season. Section 2.02. RENEWAL. At the beginning of the thirteenth (13 th) year of the Franchise, the City and the Team shall enter into a discussion regarding renewal of the Franchise for an additional term of five (5) years under the same terms and conditions. However, the City or the Team may negotiate and request changes to the terms and conditions for such renewal that may be considered mutually beneficial and appropriate at that time. The renewal of the Franchise shall be approved by the Lynchburg City Council in accordance with applicable Virginia law. ARTICLE III TEAM USE OF STADIUM Section 3.01. GRANT OF USE AND OPERATION RIGHTS. Subject to the provisions of Section 3.02, the City hereby grants to the Team the exclusive right to use the Stadium on the days scheduled for Team Events and Team Special Events during the term hereof and its renewal term, for and in consideration of the compensation payable by the Team to the City under Article VII hereof and the obligations assumed and undertaken by the Team hereunder. Subject to the terms and conditions of this Franchise, the City hereby grants to the Team, and the Team hereby accepts from the City, the rights and responsibilities herein set forth in and to the Stadium ‘as is’, ’where is’, and without warranty. The Team shall not use the Stadium for any purposes other than those specifically set forth herein. This Franchise does not confer upon the Team any title, leasehold or other estate of any kind, or any interest in or to the Stadium, other than the rights pertaining to the Stadium set forth herein. The Team shall not have the power to, nor shall it attempt to, create or permit the creation or continuance of any lien, encumbrance or charge which is or might become a lien, encumbrance or charge against the Stadium, other than against Team personal property. Section 3.02. RESERVATION OF RIGHTS BY THE CITY. All rights to occupy, use, enjoy or derive benefit from the Stadium, not expressly granted herein to the Team, are reserved by the City during the term hereof and any renewal term. Without in any way limiting or defining the extent of the reservation of this Section, the City expresses its intent to schedule athletic contests or other events at the Stadium and to retain revenues from City Events for the City's benefit with the exception of any food and beverages sold by Hillcats Catering or third-party contractors or concessionaires under contract with Hillcats Catering unless otherwise agreed upon by City and Team. The City retains the right to provide its own food and beverages or use an outside caterer for any City Events that are not open to the Page 96 of 207 6 public in place of Hillcats Catering or third-party contractors or concessionaires under contract with Hillcats Catering. Section 3.03. USE FOR HOME GAMES. The Team agrees to play all its home games (estimated to be seventy- five (75) in number during a full Carolina League season) during its Baseball Season at the Stadium, beginning with the 2025 Baseball Season through the term of this Franchise. In addition to permitting the Team to use the Stadium for its home games during the Baseball Season including playoffs, the City shall permit the Team to use the Stadium for scheduled Team practices, tournaments, and when applicable, Carolina League All Star Game play on those dates approved by the City and the Team in accordance with the provisions of Article XI, Section 11.02 hereof. The Team shall be permitted to conduct promotional events before and after baseball games with all such events being scheduled pursuant to said Article XI, Section 11.02. During the term hereof, the Team will have access to all Team Areas in the Stadium and will be provided designated storage space during the Baseball Season and between Baseball Seasons at the Stadium. The City shall not be liable for any damages to or loss of any of the Team's property or the property of its employees, agents or volunteers. The Team, its employees, agents and volunteers in placing their property at the Stadium, do so at their own risk. Section 3.04. STARTING TIMES FOR TEAM EVENTS AND TEAM SPECIAL EVENTS. No Team Event or Team Special Event shall be scheduled to start later than 8:30 p.m. or end later than 11:30 p.m. on Sunday through Thursday, and 12:00 a.m./midnight on Friday or Saturday, without the prior written approval of the City. In the case of a Team double header baseball game, this Section shall not preclude the second game from being played upon the completion of the first game nor preclude completion of a game following a rain or fog delay or completion of a game that has gone into extra innings. In the event that a game is still in progress after the above stated end times, special actions shall be taken to reduce noise originating in the Stadium, including minimizing the use of the public address system to only essential announcements. Section 3.05. FIREWORKS. Fireworks shall only be allowed as permitted by the City Fire Marshal, with the following restrictions: (1) fireworks shall not be shot from or in such a way as to damage the artificial turf field in the adjacent football stadium, (2) no excessively loud, "cannon" type fireworks shall be used, (3) fireworks displays shall be limited to Friday and Saturday evenings and, (4) opening day or night as well as the night before or day of Memorial Day, Juneteenth, Independence Day, Labor Day, and two (2) additional days as agreed upon by the City and the Team. No fireworks show shall commence after 10:00 p.m., unless there has been a rain or fog delay or the game has gone into extra innings, in which case the fireworks show shall commence no later than 10:30 p.m. Any trash or debris from a fireworks display shall be removed from the Stadium and its field within twelve (12) hours of the conclusion of the display. The Team will be responsible for repairing, or paying for repairs to any damage to the artificial turf or Stadium resulting from a fireworks display. Section 3.06. COMPLIANCE WITH APPLICABLE LAWS, ORDINANCES. In its management, occupancy or use of the Stadium, the Team shall not permit the violation of any applicable federal, state and City laws, regulations, codes or ordinances, whether currently in force or subsequently adopted that may apply to the Team's use of the Stadium. Section 3.07. REPAIR OF DAMAGE. In its management, occupancy or use of the Stadium, the Team shall not permit the structure to be damaged by its use or neglect. Any damage caused by the use of the Stadium shall be promptly reported to the City and will be repaired at the Team's expense by the City in an acceptable workmanlike manner, with the damaged portion of the structure restored to its original condition prior to such damage and in compliance with all of the applicable zoning, fire code, building and health department statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations. Such expenses shall be paid by the Team within thirty (30) days of a written request by the City. Section 3.08. MODIFICATIONS TO STRUCTURE. The Team shall not make any material structural modifications to the Stadium without the prior written approval of the City. The Team shall be solely responsible for the cost of any structural modifications, must comply with federal, state and local building codes, regulations and ordinances in making such modifications, and any structural modifications the Team makes to the Stadium will become the property of the City. Section 3.09. COMPLIANCE WITH OCCUPANCY LIMITATIONS. In its management, occupancy, or use of the Stadium, the Team shall not permit the Stadium occupancy limitations to be exceeded. The use of temporary seating and/or seating in areas other than those areas designated as permanent seating areas or in such supplemental seating Page 97 of 207 7 areas as may be designated by the City, is subject to the prior approval of the City. Section 3.10. ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE AREA. In consideration of the Team playing its home games at the Stadium during its Baseball Season, and providing City Stadium Services as provided herein and to facilitate the provision of such services, office space in the Stadium, along with batting cage facilities, will be provided for the use of the Team on a year-round basis while this Franchise is in effect. All furnishings and equipment required for such space(s) shall be the sole responsibility of the Team. The Team shall provide all Janitorial Services required for the office space and adjoining non-public restrooms and batting cages and shall maintain such areas in a clean condition at all times. Upon reasonable prior notice to the Team, the City may inspect the areas. Upon termination of this Franchise, the Team shall surrender possession of the areas to the City in the same condition as received, normal wear and tear excepted. Section 3.11. TEAM MERCHANDISE SALES STORE. The Team shall have the right, on a year-round basis, to use the merchandise sales store in the Stadium for sale of the Team merchandise items. Section 3.12. TEAM AREA FURNISHINGS. The Team shall be responsible for the provision of all furnishings required for its utilization of the Team Areas, including washers and dryers and vending machines, except for any lockers permanently installed in such areas by the City. Section 3.13. IMPROVEMENTS. The Team shall make no improvements in the Team Areas or any portion of the Stadium without the prior written approval of the City. The Team shall be solely responsible for the cost of any improvements, must comply with federal, state, and local building codes, regulations, and ordinances in making such improvements, and any improvements the Team makes to the Stadium will become the property of the City. Section 3.14. WASTE OR NUISANCE. The Team shall not commit or permit any waste on or about the Stadium while this Franchise is in effect nor shall it maintain, commit or permit the maintenance or commission of any nuisance on or about the Stadium or use the Stadium or Team Areas for any unlawful purposes. ARTICLE IV STADIUM OPERATION AND SERVICES Section 4.01. TEAM STADIUM SERVICES. The Team will provide all Team Stadium Services required for Team Events and Team Special Events held in the Stadium and will retain, employ, compensate, train and manage sufficient numbers of polite and well-groomed personnel to provide such services in a high quality and professional manner while this Franchise remains in effect. Section 4.02. COMMUNITY RELATIONS. The Team agrees to work in good faith with the City to develop programs to minimize the adverse impact of the Stadium’s operation on the neighborhoods in which the Stadium is situated or which are directly affected by the Stadium. Section 4.03. CITY STADIUM SERVICES. The Team shall provide the City with City Stadium Services as required for all City Events held in the Stadium. The cost of said services shall not exceed the actual cost for such services to the Team during such City Events and shall be calculated and accounted for on the basis of each separate City Event with the assessment of costs for such services to be in accordance with the schedules for such services as provided for in Article IV, Sections 4.04 and 4.05 hereof. Notwithstanding the provisions of this Agreement relating to City Stadium Services, if the Team is in default under the terms of this Franchise and the applicable period of time, if any, for curing such default has passed, the City expressly reserves the right to assume management and operating responsibility for City Events at the Stadium upon reasonable prior notice to the Team. Section 4.04. SCHEDULE OF SERVICES AND COSTS. The Team and the City, prior to the commencement of each Baseball Season, shall adopt a Schedule of Services and Costs to be utilized in the assessment of costs for City Events and events sponsored by a promoter or outside entity. The costs of such City Stadium Services shall be reimbursed to the Team within thirty (30) days of the submission of an appropriate invoice to the City, outside entity or promoter. Section 4.05. CITY STADIUM SERVICES & SCHEDULE OF SERVICES AND COSTS. The cost of City Stadium Services shall be assessed in accordance with the Schedule of Services and Costs, which shall be approved in writing by the Team and City upon the expiration of the prior year's Schedule of Services and Costs, or upon such later date as agreed to by the parties. At no time will the charges in such schedule or subsequent schedules agreed upon exceed Page 98 of 207 8 the actual costs of providing such services by the Team. The schedule shall be reviewed and modified, upon the agreement of the parties, if necessary, prior to the start of each Baseball Season during the term of this Franchise. Section 4.06. PROMOTION OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG. The Team agrees that it will actively promote the tourism attributes and attractions of the Lynchburg region and will work with the City’s Department of Economic Development and Tourism to promote the development and success of athletic activities in the Lynchburg region, including, but not limited to, the Virginia Commonwealth Games. Section 4.07. QUALITY OF TEAM STADIUM SERVICES AND CITY STADIUM SERVICES. Team Stadium Services and City Stadium Services by the Team shall be provided in a manner to promote the use of the Stadium, attract the public to Team and City events scheduled at the Stadium, and shall be of acceptable quality consistent with the standards required of a professional Minor League Baseball facility. Should the quality of services be unacceptable to the City, notice shall be provided to the Team and the Team shall have thirty (30) days to improve the quality of such services. The City reserves the right, subsequent to the passage of said thirty (30) day period, to undertake corrective action with its own resources and invoice the Team for the cost of such corrective action. The cost shall be paid by the Team within thirty (30) days of receipt of such invoice. This Section does not authorize the City to retain, terminate, supervise, or take other direct actions relating to the employees of the Team. Section 4.08. STADIUM OPERATION SERVICES. Such services shall include the retention, employment, compensation, training and management of the required personnel for the provision of City Stadium Services for City Events, coordination with the food and beverage staff pursuant to the Food and Beverage Services Agreement referred to herein at Article V, Section 5.01 hereof, and the monitoring of all elements of required City Stadium Services as described in Article I, Section 1.03 hereof. Section 4.09. OPERATION OF STADIUM BOX OFFICE. The Team, in addition to providing ticketing services for all of its home Baseball Season games, shall operate the Stadium Box Office during home Baseball Season games and at other times to conduct advance ticket sales for Team Events. The Team shall provide all Janitorial Services required for the Stadium Box Office and shall maintain it in a clean condition at all times. The City shall have the right to operate the Stadium Box Office during City Events and shall leave it in a better or same condition as it was found. Section 4.10. EVENT SECURITY SERVICES. The Team will be responsible for providing security for all Team Events and Team Special Events where the public is in attendance and shall hire a minimum of one (1) uniformed off-duty City of Lynchburg Police Department l a w - e n f o r c e m e n t o fficer. More law-enforcement personnel may be required at the direction of the Chief of Police of the City. Should, for any reason, off-duty City of Lynchburg Police Department law-enforcement officers be unavailable for such employment as required herein, other appropriate security officers, provided the same are reasonably approved by the Chief of Police of the City, may be hired by the Team. There shall be at least two (2) such officers employed at each Thursday, Friday, and Saturday Team baseball game held at the Stadium as well as any Sunday, Tuesday, and Wednesday games if attendance is expected to be in excess of 750 attendees. The number of officers provided at Team promotional events, other Team Events, Team Special Events, and City Events shall be adequate for the security of those persons attending the particular event and the provision of security for the Stadium and its contents, including all on-site parking lots. If Team employees are utilized for such purposes, they shall be uniformed and equipped with appropriate radio communications equipment. T h e o fficers or other security personnel shall be directed to be at the Stadium no later than one-half hour prior to its opening to the public and until at least one-half hour after the Stadium is closed to the public. When necessary, the Team, through a designated security representative, shall consult with the Chief of Police of the City, or the Chief’s designee, to determine the adequacy of intended security for Team Events, Team Special Events, and City Events. The quality of the services provided for in this Section shall be expressly subject to the notice and substitute performance rights reserved to the City generally under Article IV, Section 4.07 hereof. In addition, any private security personnel utilized by the Team shall be considered as employees or independent contractors of the Team and in no manner considered or construed to be employees or agents of the City. Section 4.11. CITY NOTICE TO TEAM OF REQUESTED LEVEL OF FACILITY SERVICES. The City shall, in advance of each City Event held in the Stadium, complete a memorandum of understanding with the Team with details for the City Event and what support services are needed from the Team within thirty (30) days of the scheduled event. Page 99 of 207 9 Section 4.12. FIELD RESTORATION COSTS AND DAMAGE TO THE FIELD. All costs of field restoration required as a result of damage to the field shall be borne by the party scheduling the event causing the damage to the field and shall be payable as an element of either Team Stadium Services or City Stadium Services as the case may be. Section 4.13. NO SMOKING FACILITY. The Stadium shall be designated and operated as a non-smoking facility, with the exception of certain designated smoking areas separate from Stadium seating, and no tobacco, electronic cigarette or vaping products, shall be sold or marketed therein. Section 4.14. PROHIBITION AGAINST FOOD AND BEVERAGES BEING BROUGHT INTO THE STADIUM. The City shall post signs in appropriate locations in the Stadium which shall prohibit patrons from bringing any food or beverages into the Stadium for Team Events, Team Special Events, and certain other events. Section 4.15. PUBLIC ADDRESS ANNOUNCEMENTS REGARDING CITY AND CITY EVENTS. The Team agrees to make appropriate public address announcements and announcements on the Scoreboard message center in regard to future City Events to be held in the Stadium and/or other City facilities not scheduled for the same time as any Team Events or Team Special Events. ARTICLE V FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICES Section 5.01. GRANT OF EXCLUSIVE LICENSE TO TEAM. The City hereby grants to the Team an exclusive food, beverage, and team merchandise license, except as otherwise provided for in Article V, Sections 5.06 and 5.07 herein, permitting the sale of food and beverages from those areas of the Stadium designated for the same by the City and the Team while this Franchise is in effect. The grant of this exclusive license includes the right of the Team to provide Food and Beverage Services in the said areas, either directly or by entering into a Food and Beverage Services Agreement granting a license to operate the same and certain merchandise sales to such professional Food and Beverage Services third-party contractors or concessionaires as may be acceptable to the Team and reasonably approved by the City. The aforesaid described exclusive license shall remain in effect while this Franchise remains in effect, but shall terminate when this Franchise terminates. The City reserves the right to contract with outside vendors for Food and Beverage Services at City Events held outside of the Stadium, in the parking lot or other open areas. Section 5.02. CITY APPROVAL OF TEAM FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICES CONTRACT. The Team shall advise the City when it intends to enter into a Food and Beverage Services Agreement. The material terms of such Food and Beverage Services Agreement shall include food products liability coverage comparable to the coverage required in Article XII, Section 12.04 hereof. Such agreement shall be approved by the City in writing, and the material provisions of said agreement shall not be modified except with the prior written approval of the City. Should the Food and Beverage Services Agreement be terminated, the Team shall have the right to provide Food and Beverage Services and certain merchandise sales as described in the agreement either directly or through a Food and Beverage Services Agreement entered into with another professional Food and Beverage Services third-party contractor or concessionaire with the selection being subject to the written approval of the City. If the Team undertakes the self-operation of Food and Beverage Services, the Team shall provide the same level of quality service and price provided at first-class professional baseball facilities. In the event the Team enters into a Food and Beverage Services Agreement with a third- party contractor or concessionaire, such contractor or concessionaire shall be experienced in such services. Section 5.03. FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICE AREA JANITORIAL SERVICES. Janitorial Services to the areas designated for Food and Beverage Services shall be provided (i) pursuant to the Food and Beverage Services Agreement entered into by the Team, if any, or (ii) by the Team directly. Section 5.04. MENU AND PRICE LIST. The menu and price list of food and beverages to be sold in the Stadium shall be provided and posted by the Team. Prices should be comparable to other Minor League Baseball parks in the Carolina League. Page 100 of 207 10 Section 5.05. TEAM MERCHANDISE ITEMS. The City hereby grants to the Team the right to sell Team merchandise items from those areas designated for the same by the Team and the City. The Team shall provide all Janitorial Services required for such areas and shall maintain such areas in a clean condition at all times. Section 5.06. CONCERT AND OTHER ENTERTAINMENT MERCHANDISE. The Team and the City acknowledge that the sale of concert and other entertainment merchandise may be conducted through either (i) the City directly, during City Events scheduled under Article XI, Section 11.03 hereof, (ii) the Team during Team Special Events, or (iii) the event promoter or organizer. Such sales shall be from areas other than those areas designated for the sale of Team merchandise items unless the Team otherwise approves of the use of such areas, which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed. The Team shall have the right to approve the sale of such merchandise items in advance of their sale which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld, conditioned, or delayed, and which approval shall be directed solely to assuring that the merchandise items sold are not substantially similar to Team merchandise items. The Team shall have no responsibility for the collection and payment of any sales taxes due or payable incidental to such sales. Section 5.07. COMPLIANCE WITH STATE AND LOCAL RULES AND REGULATIONS. The Team shall assure that the areas designated for Food and Beverage Services are operated in a clean and healthy manner and in compliance with all rules, regulations, statutes and ordinances, whether currently in force or subsequently adopted/enacted that may apply to the Team's use of such areas. Section 5.08. COMPLIANCE WITH STATE ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE STATUTES AND REGULATIONS. The Team shall assure that the provision of Food and Beverage Services complies with all statutes and regulations concerning the sale of alcoholic beverages. The compliance of the areas designated for Food and Beverage Services with all statutes and regulations concerning the sale of alcoholic beverages shall be the sole responsibility of the Team. Section 5.09. LICENSES AND PERMITS. The Team shall obtain and maintain all licenses and permits which may be required by the Commonwealth of Virginia, the City, or any other governmental agency or body for the use, operation or management of the Stadium. The Team shall at all times observe all rules and regulations pertaining to such licenses and permits and avoid any loss or suspension thereof. The Team shall assure that all applicable state and/or local permits and licenses for the provision of Food and Beverage Services in the Stadium will be obtained either directly or, during the period of the Team's agreement with its experienced third-party contractors or concessionaires, by said contractors or concessionaires, for the provision of Food and Beverage Services. Section 5.10. QUALITY OF FOOD AND BEVERAGE SERVICES. The Team acknowledges that the provision of high-quality Food and Beverage Services in a manner pleasing to the public is of utmost importance to the overall success of the Stadium and events held in the Stadium. The Team shall make all reasonable efforts to assure that food is of high quality and consistent with the goals of the Team and the City to enhance attendance at all events held in the Stadium. Section 5.11. BEVERAGES 1N BOTTLES, GUM AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS. In the provision of Food and Beverage Services either directly by the Team or through its third-party contractors or concessionaires, no beverages in glass bottles, gum, tobacco, electronic cigarette or vaping products, fireworks, magic markers, silly string and other nuisance items or items prohibited by applicable law or City ordinance will be sold in the Stadium. Section 5.12. USE OF STADIUM PICNIC AREA. P i c n i c a r e a s i n t h e S t a d i u m , a s d e s i g n a t e d b y t h e C i t y a n d t h e T e a m , may be utilized for casual dining services during any Team Event or Team Special Event. Section 5.13. LOCAL VENDORS. The Team, directly and/or in its relationship with Food and Beverage Services third-party contractors or concessionaires, may, and is encouraged to, permit appropriate licensed local food and food service supply vendors to sell and/or supply their existing products having a local reputation within the Stadium during events. Page 101 of 207 11 ARTICLE VI ADVERTISING, MARKETING AND BROADCAST RIGHTS Section 6.01. TEAM MARKETING RESPONSIBILITIES. The Team shall market and enter into contractual arrangements for the use of those areas of the Stadium designated as Sky Boxes and for the provision of advertising space on the outfield advertising wall or fence and the Scoreboard message center. The Team shall additionally be responsible for marketing internal and concourse Stadium advertising which may be available during the term of this Franchise. All advertising shall be in good taste and consistent with the overall goals of the Team and the City to provide family entertainment through baseball and other athletic and recreational events at the Stadium. No tobacco advertising shall be permitted at any time. In no event shall the Team or the City, except in connection with the sale of any naming rights, locate any advertising upon the exterior or roof of the Stadium. Advertising may be placed by the Team in all suitable areas within the interior of the Stadium. The Team shall retain all advertising revenue, including outfield advertising and scoreboard advertising, as part of its Gross Revenue. The installation of any new exterior mounted digital message board or billboard and its content is subject to City approval. Section 6.02. IMPROVEMENTS TO SKY BOX AREAS. The Team or the Sky Box licensee may make improvements, such as furniture, fixtures and finishes to the Sky Box areas. Furniture, fixtures and finishes shall remain the property of the Team or the licensee and be removed at the end of their agreement. No furniture, fixtures or finishes may be permanently affixed to the Sky Boxes other than the hanging of pictures, without City approval. Team or Licensee will be responsible for the cost to repair or restore any areas of the Sky Boxes as a result of their installation of furniture, fixtures or finishes. Any structural or mechanical system changes shall be subject to prior written approval of the City and such changes shall become part of the Stadium and the property of the City. Section 6.03. TEAM SALE OF SCOREBOARD MESSAGE CENTER ADVERTISING FOR TEAM EVENTS. The Team shall have the right to sell Scoreboard message center advertising to be displayed at Team Events to be held at the Stadium. The sale of Scoreboard message center advertising for such events shall not preclude the City from the advertising of future City Events to be displayed at no cost to the City. All revenues generated by the sale of such advertising by the Team shall be the property of the Team. The cost of providing staffing for the Scoreboard message center shall not be an element of City Stadium Services. The City reserves the right to use the Scoreboard message center for City Events and to promote the City for municipal, tourism, and economic development purposes. Section 6.04. EXCLUSIVE BROADCAST RIGHTS. The Team shall have the exclusive right to (i) broadcast, televise and cablecast all Team Events and Team Special Events held in the Stadium while this Franchise is in effect, and (ii) to retain all income and revenue generated by such broadcast rights. ARTICLE VII COMPENSATION PAYABLE BY THE TEAM TO THE CITY Section 7.01. TEAM GROSS REVENUE. The Team will retain all Gross Revenue from Team Events and Team Special Events. Section 7.02. ANNUAL RENT. The Team, without notice or demand, on or before April 1st of each year this Franchise is in effect, shall pay to the City $132,500 as annual rent ("Annual Rent"). The Annual Rent will increase each year by the actual CPI for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia area. Section 7.03. SALES AND MEALS TAX. The City will retain all sales and meals tax revenue generated by Team Events and Team Special Events. Section 7.04. ADMISSIONS TAX. The City will retain all admissions tax revenue generated by Team Events and Team Special Events from the sale of tickets. The current Admissions Tax for the City of Lynchburg is 7%, and it may be subject to modification by the Lynchburg City Council. In the event the Admissions Tax is increased, the additional revenue generated above the previous 7% rate will be added to the Repair, Replacement and Maintenance Funds described in this Franchise. Section 7.05. NAMING RIGHTS REVENUE. The Team, on or before April 1st of each year this Franchise is in effect, shall pay to the City an annual Naming Rights Fee of $25,000. The Team will have the right to sell Naming Page 102 of 207 12 Rights to the Stadium and retain 100% of the revenue. The Team is responsible for all associated commissions and fulfillment expenses. All Naming Rights shall be in good taste and consistent with the overall goals of the Team and the City to provide family entertainment through baseball and other athletic and recreational events at the Stadium. Naming Rights associated with tobacco products shall not be permitted at any time. ARTICLE VIII FACILITY MAINTENANCE Section 8.01. FACILITY MAINTENANCE. The City agrees to furnish the Team with a field that is in playable condition. The Team will maintain the Stadium turf and facilities as set forth in this Franchise. Section 8.02. ONE-TIME CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS. The City agrees to fund up to $5.25 Million in one- time capital improvements to the Stadium inclusive of all project costs to include all Architectural and Engineering fees and any other fees associated directly therewith. Improvements are intended to take place in the first two (2) years of this Franchise, if possible. The Team will have the right to make recommendations for improvements to the City and to make such procurements subject to City approval. All improvements to the Stadium will be and remain the property of the City. The City will pay all invoices. In the event the City approves the Team paying an invoice, the Team will invoice the City only after satisfactory completion of work, as determined by the City. The City will then have thirty (30) days after receipt of an invoice to pay the Team. Section 8.03. STRUCTURAL AND SYSTEMS MAINTENANCE. Routine maintenance, operation and repair of all structural components of the Stadium and all heat, ventilating, air conditioning, plumbing and electrical systems shall be the responsibility of the City. The Team shall follow City procedures to request maintenance and repairs, and the City shall have sole authority over scheduling repairs depending on staff levels and funding. The Team shall be responsible for repairs caused by abuse, neglect, damage, and/or vandalism by its employees, umpires, concessionaires, agents, Stadium opponents or attendees during Team Events or Team Special Events. The City shall make necessary repairs and invoice the Team for these repairs. The City shall not be responsible for any loss of revenues to the Team resulting from a building systems failure. Requests for payments hereunder shall be fulfilled within thirty (30) days of a request. Section 8.04. CUSTODIAL SERVICES. The Team shall be responsible for the routine daily cleaning of the clubhouse, office areas, non-public restrooms and other administrative areas. The Team shall also be responsible for cleaning the public restrooms, Common Areas, seating areas, picnic areas, and clubhouse after each Team Event or Team Special Event. The Team will furnish sufficient equipment and supplies such as soap, paper products and cleaning supplies that are needed for its own use, visiting teams and the general public. The Team is responsible for the removal of all trash and debris from the site in accordance with all applicable regulations and City ordinances. All areas shall be maintained in a clean and attractive manner and in compliance with all applicable legal requirements. The City shall perform heavy cleaning, including, but not limited to, washing windows and walls, stripping floor tile, and shampooing carpet in all areas of the Stadium during the off season. Section 8.05. ON-SITE PARKING AREA CLEAN-UP. The Team shall be responsible for picking up all trash, broken glass, etc., in the Stadium parking area and on street parking in surrounding neighborhoods by 9:00 a.m. the morning following a Team Event or Team Special Event. Should these services not be completed by that time, and upon reasonable notice to the Team, the City reserves the right to conduct such services and invoice the Team for services provided. Requests for payments hereunder shall be fulfilled within thirty (30) days of a request. The City shall be responsible for the onsite parking area cleanup for all City Events and subject to City approval, the Team may provide this clean-up for City Events and invoice the City for services provided if necessary. Section 8.06. EMERGENCY REPAIRS. The City will provide emergency repair services to the Stadium after the City's normal operating hours. The Team shall follow the City's procedures to request these services. To request emergency repairs after hours, the Team should call Lynchburg Emergency Communications with the nature of the request and duty personnel will be contacted to respond. In order to keep the City's overtime costs to a minimum, the Team shall reserve the request of this service for extreme emergencies, including, but not limited to, failure of building systems that would cause the cancellation of an event, structural damage to the facility or a threat to the life safety of the public or employees. Section 8.07. EXTERIOR SITE AND FIELD MAINTENANCE. The City shall be responsible for routine maintenance of the grounds and landscaping surrounding the Stadium. The City's responsibility shall include mowing, Page 103 of 207 13 landscape maintenance, including the replacement of trees and shrubs, and parking lot maintenance and repair. The Team shall provide daily routine maintenance for the field, including, but not limited to, mowing the infield and outfield, spot seeding, watering, all infield maintenance, marking, trash pick-up, edging infield, and repairing damage to the field due to Team Events or Team Special Events. All field maintenance practices or enhancements used by the Team are subject to prior written approval by the City and shall meet professional baseball standards. The Team shall be required to provide all tools and equipment necessary to perform field maintenance. The Team shall supply marble dust, red clay, "weblight", sand, and any other specialized field materials. The Team shall purchase and handle field covers at its own effort and expense. The Team shall provide broad leaf weed control, pre-emergent herbicide applications, seed, and fertilizer and shall perform periodic activities beyond routine daily maintenance such as aerating, overseeding, and warning track renovation. All pesticides shall be applied, stored, and disposed of in accordance with all applicable regulations. Section 8.08. LONG-TERM FIELD MAINTENANCE. The City's written consent shall be necessary prior to the Team's undertaking of a major turf replacement. In the event of a major turf replacement, the Team shall submit a report to the City, specifying in detail the nature and cause of the damage to the turf and the cost of replacement. Sod removal and/or replacement necessitated by the conversion of the Stadium’s field for athletic events or resulting from damage to the field occurring at Team Events, Team Special Events, or City Events, shall be handled pursuant to Article IV, Stadium Operation and Services, of this Franchise. Field renovation would qualify as a capital expense to be funded from the capital reserve as outlined in Article VIII, Section 8.13 hereof. Section 8.09. SITE SECURITY. The Team assumes full responsibility for the security of those portions of the Stadium it occupies and/or uses pursuant to the terms of this Franchise and it is understood that any property placed at the Stadium is so placed at the risk of the owner. The City shall not be responsible for any loss of or damage to property which the Team, any of its players or any visiting team may sustain at the Stadium, regardless of how such loss or damage occurs. The Team is expressly prohibited from using the football field or the running track adjacent to the Stadium without the City’s approval. Section 8.10. LIGHT BULB REPLACEMENT. The Team will be responsible for all light bulb replacement in the interior and exterior of the Stadium while this Franchise is in effect, excluding field lights. The City agrees to maintain field lights at or above Minor League Baseball standards. Section 8.11. MAINTENANCE OF ELECTRONIC SCOREBOARD, PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEM, AND ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARD. The Team shall be responsible for the maintenance and repair of the Scoreboard, the electronic message board, and the public address system. Upon termination of this Franchise, the public address system, the Scoreboard, and the electronic message board will remain the property of the City. Any manuals, software, or records relating to the operation of this equipment shall be given to the City. If Team elects not to use any of the $5.25M in capital improvements for a new Scoreboard and new electronic message board, then the Team, not the City, will pay the cost for any replacement Scoreboard or major repair of the current Scoreboard during the term hereof. Section 8.12. REPLACEMENT OF CAPITAL ITEMS. W h i l e t h i s F r a n c h i s e i s i n e f f e c t , the Team shall replace as necessary all capital items that are not the responsibility of the City under the provisions of this Franchise consistent with the provisions of Article VIII, Section 8.13 hereof, including the Scoreboard and the electronic message board. The City shall undertake to pursue its remedies under any warranties for all capital items and original construction. Any recoveries realized shall be reimbursed to the Team to the extent the Team has incurred expenses under this Section. The City shall be responsible for scheduling all Capital Improvement Projects related to the Stadium including the Scoreboard, the electronic message board, and the public address system depending on available funding. Requests for payments hereunder shall be fulfilled within thirty (30) days of a request. Section 8.13. REPAIR, REPLACEMENT AND MAINTENANCE FUND. The City will establish a $150,000 annual reserve account, to be maintained by the City, for mutually agreed upon expenditures of a capital nature such as repair, replacement, maintenance and improvements of the Stadium structural elements and associated equipment. Subject to City approval, Funds may be used for repairs and replacement in Sky Boxes and a new Scoreboard. Capital expenditures shall consist of those items having an initial cost in excess of $10,000 and which are required to be assigned a useful life in accordance with Internal Revenue Service rules and guidelines for amortization purposes. The funds will roll over each year with any excess funds added to the $150,000 in the following year. In the event the spending should exceed $150,000 in any year, then any savings in other years will be used to offset any years overages. Page 104 of 207 14 Section 8.14. MLB OR CAROLINA LEAGUE REQUIRED OR MANDATED IMPROVEMNENTS. The City will make its best efforts to include these in the “Repair, Replacement and Maintenance Funds” as listed in Section 8.13 above. If any Major League Baseball (“MLB”) or Carolina League required or mandated improvements result in the “Repair, Replacement and Maintenance Funds” exceeding $150,000 in any given Baseball Season, the overage amount will be shared equally between the City and the Team. Section 8.15. PDL TERMINATION. In the event that MLB terminates the license agreement with Lynchburg and the team desires to change from a natural grass field to Artificial Turf, the City and the Team agree to address the issue of sharing costs of repairing or converting the field in the next or renewed franchise. ARTICLE IX UTILITIES Section 9.01. E L E C T R I C A L , WATER, SEWER, CABLE SERVICE. The City shall be responsible for providing and funding all utilities at the Stadium, including electricity, water, and sewer. W h e r e a b l e , t he City shall also provide a cable television drop for free basic cable service a s p a r t o f a local cable franchise held by the City. Cable service above and beyond this free service is the responsibility of the Team. The Team shall responsibly consume the utilities provided to keep the cost to the City at a minimum. ARTICLE X TEAM SUPPLIED EQUIPMENT Section 10.01. TEAM SUPPLIED EQUIPMENT. The Team shall provide, at its sole cost and expense, the following items (the "Team Supplied Equipment"): all equipment necessary for Food and Beverage Services, other than currently existing City-owned equipment; Batting Cages apparatus; the furniture and office equipment for the areas designated for ticketing, merchandise sales, Press Box, and administrative offices; and any other Team equipment necessary for its operations. If any Team Supplied Equipment is removed by the Team, the Team shall repair and restore, at its sole cost and expense, any damage caused by its removal. ARTICLE XI SCHEDULING Section 11.01. AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES. The Team and the City agree that all scheduling for events in the Stadium will be coordinated in a fashion to maximize the beneficial use of the Stadium by the City and the Team. Section 11.02. SCHEDULING TEAM EVENTS. By October 1 st of each year, the City and the Team shall mutually and reasonably approve all Team Special Events and Team Events to take place at the Stadium during the succeeding calendar year. The Team shall have priority in the selection of its home Baseball Season dates, tournament game dates, and Carolina League All-Star game dates, if applicable, and will be provided (number to be determined) rain dates during the home Baseball Season prior to the scheduling of City Events during the Baseball Season. Section 11.03. SCHEDULING CITY EVENTS. No later than October 1 st of each year while this Franchise is in effect, the City will provide to the Team a listing of those City Events which are priority events for purposes of scheduling during the Baseball Season. In no case shall the City preempt the Team's Baseball Season with a single or multi-day event. The Team shall submit its approved home Baseball Season schedule to the City as soon thereafter as such schedule is approved by the Carolina League and Major League Baseball. Any dates reserved for post-season play by the Team shall be released and canceled on the schedule from the time that the Team is mathematically eliminated from post-season competition. The Team shall notify the City of requested dates for Team Special Events no later than October 1 st of each calendar year. The balance of the events scheduled at the Stadium shall be scheduled with conflicts in requested dates being resolved by the parties on the basis of the following criteria: (a) The date the request was received by the City or Team, as the case may be; Page 105 of 207 15 (b) The requested event's ability to maximize the productive long-term use of the Stadium; and (c) The goal of the City to provide the opportunity of equal access to the Team to maximize scheduling of Team Events after the scheduling of those City Events which are priority events. Section 11.04. ACCESS FOR BASEBALL PRACTICES. The Team shall have reasonable access to the Stadium to conduct practices during the Baseball Season. A "practice" shall consist of required drills and workouts under coaching supervision at which all players are required to appear and shall be scheduled so as not to interfere with otherwise scheduled events at the Stadium. Section 11.05. COORDINATION OF SCHEDULING. All scheduling will be coordinated with the Team to assure that the required City Stadium Services can be provided by the Team without hindering the provision of Team Stadium Services as required for the Team's use of the Stadium. ARTICLE XII INDEMNIFICATION AND INSURANCE Section 12.01. INDEMNIFICATION. The Team agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City and its respective officers, agents, employees and volunteers, from any and all claims brought against them for personal injury, death, property damage and any other losses, damages, charges or expenses, including attorneys' fees, which are in connection with, or by reason of any act, omission or negligence of the Team, its officers, employees, contractors, agents, players, or of any occupant, visitor or user present on or about the Stadium in connection with the Team's activities pursuant to this Franchise. The indemnity set forth in this Article XII shall survive the termination or expiration of this Franchise. The Team agrees to have its insurance companies waive any rights of subrogation that such companies may have against the City and such waiver shall be shown on the certificates of insurance described in this Article. Further, the Team agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its officials and employees, from any and all environmental liability arising out of the use and operation of the Stadium during the term of this Franchise. Section 12.02. INSURANCE POLICIES ON TEAM PROPERTY. The Team shall, effective as of the commencement date of this Franchise, obtain policies of insurance on any property or equipment placed within the Stadium or on surrounding City property and maintain such policies on all its property or equipment placed in the Stadium or on surrounding City property during the term of this Franchise. Such policies shall provide for fire, theft, vandalism and extended coverage for the Team’s equipment. The City shall have no responsibility or liability whatsoever with respect to any loss, theft of, or damage to the personal property of the Team, its employees, officers, agents, contractors, players, players for opposing teams, umpires, concessionaires, employees and agents of concessionaires, stadium attendees, and others. Section 12.03. INDEMNIFICATION FOR LOSS, THEFT OR DAMAGE TO PERSONAL PROPERTY. The Team agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its officers, directors, employees and agents with respect to any claim or liability for loss, theft of, or damage to personal property of the Team, its employees and players, players for opposing teams, umpires, concessionaires, employees and agents of concessionaires, stadium attendees, and others, except to the extent that such loss, theft or damage is caused by the acts of the City, its employees, or agents. Section 12.04. REQUIRED TEAM POLICIES OF INSURANCE EFFECTIVE AS OF COMMENCEMENT DATE. The Team shall, effective as of the commencement date of this Franchise and thereafter while this Franchise is in effect, keep in full force and effect the following policies of insurance: Comprehensive general liability insurance, including products liability insurance against any and all claims and losses arising out of its activities under this Franchise in the following minimum amounts: Bodily injury and property damage coverage with a combined single limit of $3,000,000.00. Umbrella Liability Coverage and Umbrella Liability Policy in an amount not less than $5,000,000.00 for any one occurrence in excess of the aforementioned general liability insurance. Page 106 of 207 16 Liquor Liability Coverage - The Team, either directly or through its Food and Beverage Services third-party contractors or concessionaires, shall provide and keep in full force and effect while this Franchise is in effect, liquor liability coverage in the amount of $3,000.000.00. Food and Vending Liability Coverage - the Team, either directly or through its Food and Beverage Services third-party contractors or concessionaires, shall provide and keep in full force and effect while this Franchise is in effect, food and vending liability coverage in an amount of $3,000,000.00. Workers Compensation - the Team shall provide and keep in full force and effect during the term of this Franchise, workers compensation insurance in full compliance with the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia. Section 12.05. NAMED INSUREDS AND CERTIFICATES OF INSURANCE. Where permitted by Virginia law and policy, all of the insurance policies described in Article XII, Section 12.04 herein shall show the Team and the City, its officials, officers, and employees, as named insured parties as their interests may appear. The insurance required of the Team herein shall be primary and any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the City is secondary and applies only in excess of and shall not contribute with the insurance obtained by the Team. Any deductibles or self-insurance retention applicable to the required coverage shall be paid by the Team and the City shall not be required to participate therewith. The Team shall deliver to the City a copy of said insurance policy or certificate of insurance with the necessary endorsements to the City's Risk Manager showing the same to be in full force and effect before occupying the Stadium; upon renewal of this Franchise; and, at other times throughout the term of the Franchise when the City requests confirmation of insurance coverage. The Team must give the City ten (10) calendar days advance written notice of any cancellation, nonrenewal, or modification of coverage, and a binder or certificate verifying new coverage in accordance with the requirements herein prior to any change, cancellation or nonrenewal date. In the event of such cancellation or nonrenewal notice, the Team shall obtain and pay all premiums for the renewal or replacement of the insurance required hereunder. The Team shall, at least sixty (60) days prior to the expiration of the policies, furnish the City with renewals or "binders" for the policies, or the City may order the required insurance and charge the cost to the Team, which such costs shall be paid to the City within thirty (30) days of a written request. The failure of the Team to maintain such insurance coverage throughout the term of this Franchise shall be grounds for the immediate termination hereof. The Team's responsibility to the City hereunder is not limited to the amount of such insurance coverage. All insurance will be obtained by the Team from insurance companies authorized by Virginia's State Corporation Commission to do business in Virginia. ARTICLE XIII EVENTS OF DEFAULT AND REMEDIES Section 13.01. EVENTS OF DEFAULT. The occurrence of any one or more of the following events constitutes a default under this Franchise: Section 13.01.1. Failure by the Team to pay to the City any fees or other payments due hereunder when due and payable, and such failure shall continue for ten (10) days following written notice (which notice shall not be required for a default in any payment required pursuant to Article VII); Section 13.01.2. Failure by the City or the Team to make the c apital improvements required by Article VIII, Section 8.02; Section 13.01.3. Failure by the Team to observe or perform in any material respect any other covenant, agreement, condition or provision of this Franchise (other than as specified in Section 13.01.1), and such failure shall continue for thirty (30) days after notice thereof from the City to the Team; provided, however, the Team shall not be in default with respect to matters which cannot reasonably be cured within thirty (30) days so long as within thirty (30) days after such notice the Team gives written notice to the City of its inability to cure within such thirty (30) day period and immediately commences such cure and diligently proceeds with best efforts to complete the same at all times thereafter and the Team provides the City with detailed status reports of its current and future efforts to cure such default; further provided that all such defaults shall be cured no later than one hundred eighty (180) days after notice of default from the City; Page 107 of 207 17 Section 13.01.4. Failure by the City to observe or perform in any material respect any other covenant, agreement, condition or provision of this Franchise (other than as specified in Section 13.01.2), and such failure shall continue for thirty (30) days after notice thereof from the Team to the City; provided, however, the City shall not be in default with respect to matters which cannot reasonably be cured within thirty (30) days so long as within thirty (30) days after such notice the City gives written notice to the Team of its inability to cure within such thirty (30) day period and immediately commences such cure and diligently proceeds with best efforts to complete the same at all times thereafter and the City provides the Team with detailed status reports of its current and future efforts to cure such default; further provided that all such defaults shall be cured no later than one hundred eighty (180) days after notice of default from the Team; Section 13.01.5. The levy upon or under writ of execution or the attachment by legal process of the interest of the Team under this Franchise, or the filing or creation of a lien in respect of such interest, which levy, attachment, or lien shall not be released, discharged, or bonded against within sixty (60) days from the date of such filing; Section 13.01.6. The Team makes an assignment for the benefit of creditors, or applies for or consents to the appointment of a trustee or receiver for the Team or for the major part of its property or admits in writing its inability to pay or is unable to pay its obligations as they come due; Section 13.01.7. A trustee or receiver is appointed for the Team or for the major part of its property and is not discharged within sixty (60) days after such appointment; Section 13.01.8. Bankruptcy, reorganization, insolvency or liquidation proceedings, or other proceedings for relief under any bankruptcy law, or similar law for the relief of debtors, are instituted by or against the Team, and, if instituted against the Team, are allowed against it or are consented to by it or are not dismissed within one hundred eighty (180) days after such appointment; Section 13.01.9. The Stadium shall be abandoned, deserted, or vacated by the Team, even though at such time the Stadium may not be then used (because of the time of the year) for Baseball Season games; or Section 13.01.10. Failure by the Carolina League to sustain the operation of a professional baseball league by scheduling a minimum number of home games in excess of sixty (60) per Baseball Season. Provided, however, such failure may be cured by the Team if it is able to consummate an affiliation with another professional baseball league whose financial condition, quality of baseball, number of teams and games, all as determined by the City in its sole and absolute discretion, is satisfactory, by November 15th of the year in which the Carolina League failure occurs. Such change of leagues may result in the Team requesting the City change the terms of this Franchise. Any agreed upon changes would begin with the first year of a Franchise extension. Section 13.02. REMEDIES IN THE EVENT OF DEFAULT. If a default occurs under Section 13.01 of this Franchise, and the applicable period of time, if any, for curing such default has passed, the City and Team (the "Parties") shall have the rights and remedies hereinafter set forth, which shall be distinct, separate and to the extent not mutually exclusive, cumulative and shall not operate to exclude or deprive the Parties of any other right or remedy allowed by this Franchise or applicable law, including without limitation, the City's right to advance any sums to be paid to third parties by the Team or otherwise remedy the Team's default and to be reimbursed by the Team for the City's costs and expenses on account thereof. No delay or omission to exercise any right or power accruing under any default shall impair any such right or power or be construed to be a waiver thereof, but any such right and power may be exercised from time to time and as often as may be deemed expedient. Section 13.02.1. If one of the Parties is in default, and the applicable period of time, if any, for curing such default has passed, the non-defaulting party may terminate this Franchise effective as of the date of its notice or as of the end of the then current Carolina League Baseball Season by giving to the defaulting party notice of the non-defaulting party's election to do so, and all rights, title and interest of the Parties hereunder shall expire at the end of the then current Carolina League Baseball Season. Section 13.02.2. If the City exercises the remedy of termination, the Team shall vacate the Stadium no later than thirty (30) days following the date of the Team's receipt of the City's notice of termination and deliver exclusive possession thereof to the City, and the City may then or at any time thereafter, re-enter and take complete and peaceful possession of the Stadium, with or without process of law, and the City may remove all occupants and property therefrom, using such force as may be necessary, without being deemed in any manner guilty of trespass, eviction or forcible entry and Page 108 of 207 18 detainer and without relinquishing the City's right to any fees due to the City or any other right given to the City by this Franchise or by operation of law. Section 13.02.3. All property removed from the Stadium by the City pursuant to a default by Team under any provisions of this Article XIII or by law may be handled, removed or stored by the City at the cost and expense of the Team, and the City shall in no event be responsible for the value, preservation or safekeeping thereof. The Team shall reimburse the City for all costs and expenses incurred by the City in such removal and storage charges against such property so long as the same shall be in the City's possession or under the City's control. All property not removed from the Stadium or retaken from storage by the Team within sixty (60) days after the end of the term, however terminated, shall be deemed conclusively to have been conveyed by the Team to the City as by bill of sale without further payment or credit by the City to the Team. Section 13.02.4. The City may enforce the provisions of this Franchise and may enforce and protect the rights of the City hereunder by a suit or suits in equity or at law for the specific performance of any covenant or agreement contained herein, or for the enforcement of any other appropriate legal or equitable remedy, including recovery of all moneys due or to become due from the Team under any of the provisions of this Franchise. Section 13.02.5. Upon the occurrence of any event with which the giving of notice or the passage of time would constitute a default by the Team, and until such event has been cured by the Team, the City shall be excused from the payment of any amounts which are or may become due to the Team by the City. If such event is subsequently cured, any such amounts not paid by reason of this subsection 13.02.5 shall be paid without interest. Section 13.02.6. The Team may enforce the provisions of this Franchise and may enforce and protect the rights of the Team hereunder by a suit or suits in equity or at law for the specific performance of any covenant or agreement contained herein, or for the enforcement of any other appropriate legal or equitable remedy, including recovery of all moneys due or to become due from the City under any of the provisions of this Franchise. Section 13.03. LIQUIDATED DAMAGES PAYABLE TO THE CITY UPON TERMINATION OF STADIUM FRANCHISE PURSUANT TO SECTION 13.02. The Team shall pay the City liquidated damages, in the amount of $100,000 a year for the remaining years of the lease term, plus the payment of any outstanding debt and the payment of any unamortized amount of the City funded initial $5.25M capital improvements, in the event the Team terminates this Franchise prior to the end of its term. City funded improvements will be depreciated on a straight-line basis over the term of this Franchise. Further, such liquidated damages are deemed by the parties not to be a penalty of any kind whatsoever. ARTICLE XIV PARKING Section 14.01. USE OF CITY PROPERTY SURROUNDING THE STADIUM. In the event parking fees are instituted, any fees charged by the Team for access to parking shall be reasonable and consistent with such fees charged for comparable parking within the Carolina League and at other minor league ballparks in the Carolina League. All revenue from such fees shall be the sole property of the Team. The City acknowledges that the Team has the sole right to enact a parking fee and to engage the services of a professional parking management company to operate all parking areas. If the Team enacts a parking fee it will pay the City a $25,000 Parking Rights Fee on an annual basis on or before April 1st for each year there is a parking charge. In the event parking fees are subject to taxation of any kind, the Team, not the City, shall be solely responsible for such taxation. Section 14.02. SNOW REMOVAL FOR ON-SITE PARKJNG. The City shall remove snow from the on-site parking areas connected to the Team’s administrative office and shall assure that the Team has access to the same on a year-round basis. Section 14.03. PARKING AREA RESPONSIBILITIES. In the event that the Team charges fees for parking, the Team shall have the responsibility through its professional parking management company, or otherwise, to provide parking lot attendants and clean-up services. Page 109 of 207 19 Section 14.04. TEAM PARKING SPACES. Ten (10) parking spaces shall be made available to the Team on a year-round basis for the employees of the Team. T h e l o c a t i o n o f t h o s e t e n ( 1 0 ) p a r k i n g s p a c e s s h a l l b e d e c i d e d u p o n b y t h e T e a m a n d t h e C i t y . The assignment of such parking spaces to particular individuals shall be the sole responsibility of the Team. Section 14.05. PARKING MANAGEMENT PLAN. The City and the Team shall jointly develop a Parking Management Plan to address the situation when an athletic event, such as a football or soccer game, is occurring at the same time as a Team Event so that parking for spectators of the City athletic event is accommodated without charge. The plan shall be communicated to the athletic departments of both City high schools. ARTICLE XV TRAFFIC CONTROL AND POLICE PATROL Section 15.01. TRAFFIC CONTROL. Traffic control on all public streets around the Stadium shall be the responsibility of the City. The City, exercising its discretionary police powers, shall provide police officers of the Lynchburg Police Department when necessary to assure traffic control before and after Team Events and Team Special Events in the Stadium and will additionally be available to respond to parking lot security problems as required. ARTICLE XVI ASSIGNABILITY OF LICENSE SUBJECT TO PRIOR CITY APPROVAL Section 16.01. ASSIGNABILITY. This Franchise is personal to the Team, and the Team shall not at any time assign, sell, or transfer this Franchise, or any part thereof, while this Franchise is in effect without the City's prior written approval. Further, in the event the Team is sold, consolidated, merges or is acquired by another entity, the City shall have the right to terminate this Franchise. The consideration of the City of any requested assignment or transfer may include, but shall not be limited to, the approval or disapproval of the Carolina League of such assignment or transfer. No proposed assignment shall be considered by the City unless the request for consent thereto shall be in writing and accompanied by the assignees proposed assumption of the Team's past unperformed and future obligations, resumes of its principals, reasonable financial information, and proposed financial security. Under no circumstances shall the Team be relieved of any of its obligations hereunder by any such transfer. No assignment shall, in any way, affect or diminish the Team's obligations to perform all of the terms, conditions and provisions contained in this Agreement. ARTICLE XVII TEAM BASEBALL GAME TICKETS Section 17.01. COMPLIMENTARY TICKETS. The Team shall provide the City with twenty (20) complimentary tickets for each Team Event. Tickets will be in the highest non-VIP ticket price category and are to be used in conjunction with City-sponsored youth and senior programs, or as the City otherwise deems appropriate. The Team, at no cost to the City, shall also provide the City a mutually agreeable number of premium seat tickets and Sky Box usage for economic development purposes and to promote the City’s Stadium. The Team will hold such complimentary tickets until one hour before the start of each Team Event for which tickets have been requested by the City. ARTICLE XVIII DESTRUCTION OF STADIUM Section 18.01. PARTIAL DESTRUCTION. If the Stadium is partially destroyed by any cause and can be repaired or restored to its prior condition and the destruction does not render the Stadium unusable, as determined by the City, this Franchise shall continue in full force and effect. The City shall, at its expense, promptly commence and diligently complete the restoration of the Stadium to the same condition as of the commencement date of this Franchise, reasonable wear and tear excepted. All repair activities shall be timed and organized in such a manner as to facilitate the Team's ability to hold Team Events at the Stadium to the degree feasible. However, the Team shall be responsible for repairing or replacing any damages to the Stadium caused by the acts or omissions of the Team, its employees, umpires, concessionaires, contractors, agents, Stadium attendees, or its opponents. Page 110 of 207 20 Section 18.02. TOTAL DESTRUCTION. In the event the Stadium is completely and totally destroyed by fire or other casualty, and after consultation with the Team, the City in its sole discretion may elect whether to repair or restore the Stadium or to terminate this Franchise. Such election shall be exercised by the City by giving written notice to the Team within ninety (90) days after such destruction. If the City so elects, this Franchise shall terminate as of the date of such casualty and the Team's obligation to pay annual minimum compensation payments and other payments shall terminate and be prorated as of such date. If the City elects not to terminate this Franchise, the City shall proceed as promptly as practical to repair and restore the Stadium to its condition existing immediately prior to such destruction. Section 18.03. ASSISTANCE BY THE CITY IN LOCATING A TEMPORARY FACILITY. If the Stadium becomes unavailable on a temporary basis by reason of either the partial destruction of the Stadium or the repair or restoration of the Stadium after total destruction, or for any other reason attributable to the actions of the City, the City shall utilize all reasonable efforts to assist the Team in locating an adequate temporary facility in the surrounding area. ARTICLE XIX CONDEMNATION Section 19.01. CONDEMNATION. In the event that any portion of the Stadium is taken from the City pursuant to any right of eminent domain exercised by any governmental entity or pursuant to any governmental order and such taking renders the Stadium unfit for its intended purpose, then this Franchise may be terminated by the City by notifying the Team. The Team shall have no right to any portion of any award granted with respect to such taking except that the Team shall have the independent right to make a claim against the condemner for and retain any award based thereon for the reasonable value of costs by the Team for the expenses incidental to relocating from the Stadium and for the lost value of this Franchise. ARTICLE XX SIGNAGE Section 20.01. SIGNAGE. The Team shall post signs in the parking areas indicating that vehicle owners assume the risk of damage from fly balls and other hazards. The Team shall also post signs within the Stadium warning spectators of the dangers of flying balls and broken or flying bats. The Team shall also be responsible for all claims arising out of personal injuries or property damage caused by flying balls and broken or flying bats, and it shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless the City, its respective officers, agents, employees and volunteers, as provided in Article XII hereof, for any liabilities which arise in connection with the same. ARTICLE XXI FORCE MAJEURE Section 21.01. The parties hereto, respectively, shall not be in default of this Franchise if either is unable to fulfill, or is delayed in fulfilling, any of its obligations hereunder, or is prevented or delayed from fulfilling its obligations, in spite of its employment of best efforts and due diligence, as a result of natural disasters, catastrophic events, casualties to persons or properties, war, governmental preemption in a national emergency, enactment of a law, rule or regulation or a change in existing laws, rules or regulations which prevents any party's ability to perform its respective obligations under this Franchise, or actions by other persons beyond the exclusive control of the party claiming hindrance or delay. If a party believes that a hindrance or delay has occurred, it shall give prompt written notice to the other party of the nature of such hindrance or delay, its effect upon such party's performance under this Franchise, the action needed to avoid the continuation of such hindrance or delay, and the adverse effects that such hindrance or delay then has or may have in the future on such party's performance. Notwithstanding notification of a claim of hindrance or delay by one party, such request shall not affect, impair or excuse the other party hereto from the performance of its obligations hereunder unless its performance is impossible, impractical or unduly burdensome or expensive, or cannot effectively be accomplished without the cooperation of the party claiming delay or hindrance. The occurrence of such a hindrance or delay may constitute a change in the obligations of the parties or compensation, for example, and may result in the need to modify this Franchise accordingly. Page 111 of 207 21 ARTICLE XXII NO RELOCATION OF TEAM Section 22.01. The Team agrees not to relocate from the Stadium without City approval. The Team acknowledges that the City will be irreparably harmed by the transfer of the Team's Baseball franchise to a location other than the Stadium during the term (or renewal term) of this Franchise. A breach of this section shall constitute an event of default under this Franchise, and shall entitle: (i) The City to terminate this Franchise immediately and without notice; and (ii) The City to receive liquidated damages as stipulated in A r t i c l e X I I I , Section 13.03 hereof. ARTICLE XXIII ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF BOND STATUS Section 23.01. As a material and substantial inducement for the City to enter into this Franchise, the Team agrees that it will not undertake any action or fail to take any action or permit any of its officials, agents or employees to act or fail to act (including, without limitation, entering into one or more management contracts with respect to the Stadium), if any such act or omission shall cause the City to be in default of any of its obligations under or in connection with the bonds issued to finance renovation of the Stadium or shall cause interest paid or hereafter paid on such bonds from time to time to be liable for, or otherwise subject to, taxation by the Commonwealth of Virginia or the United States of America. ARTICLE XXIV MISCELLANEOUS Section 24.01. NONDISCRIMINATION. The Team shall not discriminate, nor permit discrimination, against any person in its employment practices, in any of its contractual arrangements, in all services and accommodations it offers the public, and in any of its other business operations on the grounds of race, color, sex, or national origin, nor exclude any person from participation in, nor deny the benefits of or be otherwise subject to discrimination in the use of the Stadium or providing services on the grounds of race, color, sex, or national origin. Additionally, the Team shall not discriminate against and will make all reasonable efforts to accommodate persons with disabilities as required by the Americans with Disabilities Act. Section 24.02. GOVERNING LAW. This Franchise shall be construed under and in accordance with the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia and all litigation shall have venue in the courts located in the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. Section 24.03. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Franchise, with its Exhibit, constitutes the final, complete. and exclusive written expression of the intent of the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof which will supersede all previous verbal and written communications, representations, agreements, promises or statements concerning this Franchise. Section 24.04. TAXES AND ENCUMBRANCES. The Team shall pay promptly when due, any and all personal property and other taxes imposed. The Team shall not permit any mechanics liens or other encumbrances or liens to exist against the Stadium and shall within thirty (30) days of any such lien or encumbrance being asserted against the Stadium as a result of action or inaction by the Team either cause the same to be released of record, bond or obtain title insurance coverage satisfactory to the City over such lien and proceed diligently to contest the same in good faith. Section 24.05. SEVERABILITY. If any one or more of the provisions contained in this Franchise shall for any reason be held to be invalid, illegal, or unenforceable in any respect, and if such holding does not affect the ability of the Team to perform and have access to the Stadium as provided for herein, such invalidity, illegality or unenforceability shall not affect any other provision hereof, and this Franchise shall be construed as if such invalid, illegal or unenforceable Page 112 of 207 22 provision was not contained herein. Section 24.06. NOTICES AND ADDRESSES. All notices required to be given under this Franchise shall be given by date-and-time stamped facsimile, hand delivery with signed receipt, overnight or other courier with signed receipt, or by return receipt certified or registered mail, addressed to the proper party at the following addresses, or at such other address as may be subsequently given pursuant to this Section, and shall be deemed given within seven (7) days of being sent or provided: If to the City: City of Lynchburg, VA Attn: City Manager 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 If to the Team: Hillcats Baseball LLC Attn: Dylan Narang 1545 35th St. NW Washington, DC 20007-2753 Section 24.07. AMENDMENT/MODIFICATION. The City and the Team may agree to modify this Franchise from time to time, however, no amendment, modification, or alteration of the terms of this Franchise shall be binding unless in writing, dated subsequent to the date hereon, and approved in accordance with Section 15.2-2105 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. However, as determined on a case-by-case basis by the City Manager, minor modifications that do not invoke the requirements of the aforesaid code section and the correction of Scriveners’ Errors may be accomplished by the parties without approval of the Lynchburg City Council. Section 24.08. RIGHTS AND REMEDIES CUMULATIVE. The rights and remedies provided by this Franchise are cumulative and the use of any right or remedy by either party shall not preclude or waive its rights to use any or all other remedies. Said rights and remedies are given in addition to any other rights the parties may have by law, statute, ordinance or otherwise. Section 24.09. HEADINGS ONLY FOR REFERENCE. The titles of articles and sections of this Franchise are for reference purposes only and shall be of no binding effect. Section 24.10. STATUS OF PARTIES. Parties hereto shall be deemed and construed as independent contractors with respect to one another for all purposes and nothing contained in this Franchise shall be determined to create a partnership or joint venture between the Team and the City with respect to the parties' activities conducted at the Stadium pursuant to the terms of this Franchise. Section 24.11. WAIVER. The waiver by either the Team or the City of any default or breach by the other party of any of the provisions of this Franchise shall not be deemed a continuing waiver or waiver of any other breach by the other party of the same or another provision of this Franchise. Section 24.12. BINDING EFFECT. This Franchise shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. Section 24.13. REFERENCES TO THE CITY AND THE TEAM. All references to the City and the Team in this Franchise shall be deemed to also be references to such officers, employees, or other designees of the City or the Team as may be appropriate to implement the terms of this Franchise, including officers or employees of any sports authority or similar entity. Section 24.14. EXHIBITS. All exhibits attached to this Franchise are expressly incorporated into the same and are a part of this Franchise as if fully set out herein. Page 113 of 207 23 Section 24.15. SURRENDER. Upon the expiration of this Franchise, or on the sooner termination hereof, the Team shall peaceably and quietly leave, surrender and yield up to the City, the Stadium, free of all occupants and free of all claims by the Team or any other person or entity against the City for any repairs, replacements, or improvements made to the Stadium. The Stadium shall be returned to the City, including all operational and mechanical systems, in good working order and repair. Any removable property of the Team, which shall remain in the Stadium after the expiration of this Franchise or sooner termination thereof and after the removal of the Team from the Stadium, may, at the option of the City, and after written notice to the Team, be deemed to have been abandoned, and either may be retained by the City as its property or may be disposed of in such manner as the City may see fit. Upon the expiration or sooner termination of this Franchise, the Team shall also assign to the City such of its licenses, entertainment contracts, and contracts for goods and services which the City, at its option, requires in writing to have the Team assign to it, providing that the City shall be responsible to fulfill only such of those obligations of the Team which arise after such assignment and are attributable to periods after such assignment and be entitled to only those rights which fairly may be apportioned to such obligations. To facilitate such assignments, the Team further agrees to incorporate a provision in each of such contracts, sub-franchises, and licenses by which the other party to that agreement agrees to any future assignment of the Team's rights and obligations thereunder to the City in accordance with the terms of this paragraph. Upon the expiration or sooner termination of this Franchise, the City shall have the benefit of any and all guarantees or warranties which the Team may possess or be entitled from any person or entity who performed any work or made or supplied any improvements, installations and/or equipment for or to the Stadium which provide for repairs or replacements by the guarantors or warrantors. As to all such guarantees and warranties which are freely assignable, the Team shall, promptly upon request by the City, assign the same to the City. If the Team elects not to seek renewal of this Franchise, the Team agrees that it will use its best efforts to ensure a smooth transition of the Stadium and business conducted therein back to the City. Section 24.16. TIME OF THE ESSENCE. Time is of the essence regarding any date in this Franchise and the Exhibits attached hereto. Section 24.17. CONTRACT REVIEW. In advance of entering into any agreement concerning the Stadium, the Team shall provide a copy of such agreement to the City for its approval. Section 24.18. MEDIATION. Upon the agreement of the City and the Team, a dispute, except for any claimed default or termination of this Franchise under Article XIII, which cannot be otherwise resolved within thirty (30) days, may be referred to a mediation panel consisting of the City Manager, a Team representative, and a neutral party selected by the Team and the City and expeditiously resolved in accordance, if necessary, with a vote of the majority of the panel. The panel's decision shall be final and conclusive. Section 24.19. TEAM SIGNS. The City hereby grants the Team the right, subject to the written prior approval of the City, to place a sign or signs, at the Team's sole cost and expense, upon the exterior facade of the Stadium indicating that the Stadium is the home of the Team. Section 24.20. CAROLINA LEAGUE CHANGES. The Team shall reasonably a n d promptly provide the City with notice of any proposed modification in the Carolina League Standards, the Carolina League By-Laws, any of the Team's agreements with the Carolina League, and the composition of the member teams in the Carolina League. Such notice shall include the complete text of any modification. A copy of the Carolina League Standards, the Carolina League By-Laws, any of the Team's agreements with the Carolina League, and the composition of the member teams in the Carolina League shall be provided to the City Manager within thirty (30) days of this Franchise being fully executed. Page 114 of 207 24 Section 24.21. LOSS OF REVENUE. The City shall not be liable for any loss of revenue the Team may experience as a result of the repair, maintenance, improvement, or operation of the Stadium property, rights of way, and other publicly owned facilities that are adjacent to the Stadium. Section 24.22. THIRD-PARTY BENEFICIARIES. No third-party beneficiaries are intended by this Franchise. Section 24.23. EXECUTION OF FRANCHISE. This Franchise may be executed in counterparts, each of which when so executed shall be deemed to be an original and all of which taken together shall constitute one enforceable document. Further, this Franchise may be executed and/or sealed electronically. An electronic signature and/or seal shall be equally as enforceable as an original signature or seal. Section 24.24. BOND / GOOD AND SUFFICIENT SECURITY. Where requested by the City, pursuant to Section 15.2-2104 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, the Team shall execute a surety or other bond for the benefit of the City, in an amount not to exceed $1,000,000, to provide the City with good and sufficient security that the Team will adhere to its obligations and duties under this Franchise. Section 24.25. NOVATION. This Franchise shall operate as a novation and replace that certain franchise adopted by the Lynchburg City Council on February 23, 2016, accepted by the Lynchburg Baseball Corp., and assigned to the Team as of October 25, 2024. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Team and the City, or duly authorized agents on their behalf, hereby execute and seal this Franchise as of the date first written above. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) (Signature Pages Follow) Page 115 of 207 25 Hillcats Baseball, LLC By: __________________ Its: ___________________ Printed Name: ____________________ State/Commonwealth/___________ of __________________, } City/County of ___________________, to - wit: } The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on behalf of Hillcats Baseball, LLC, by __________________, its ____________________, on this ______ day of ____________, 2025. ___________________________ Notary Public My Commission Expires:___________________ My Registration No._______________________ Affix Notary Seal: Page 116 of 207 26 City of Lynchburg By: __________________ Its: ___________________ Printed Name: ____________________ (SEAL) Attest: ________________ Its: ___________________ Printed Name: ___________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________ City Attorney/Designee State/Commonwealth/___________ of __________________, } City/County of ___________________, to - wit: } The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on behalf of the City of Lynchburg, by __________________, its ____________________, on this ______ day of ____________, 2025. _____________________ Notary Public My Commission Expires:___________________ My Registration No._______________________ Affix Notary Seal: Page 117 of 207 Page 118 of 207 Page 119 of 207 Page 120 of 207 1 FRANCHISE PERFORMANCE BOND KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That Hillcats Baseball, LLC, the Franchisee ("Principal"), whose principal place of business is located at 1545 35th ST NW, Washington, DC 20007 and ("Surety"), are held and firmly bound unto the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, the Franchisor ("Obligee"), in the amount of ONE MILLION AND 00/100 DOLLARS ($1,000,000), for the payment whereof Principal and Surety bind themselves, their heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, jointly and severally, firmly by these presents. WHEREAS, Principal has entered into a franchise agreement entitled “A Baseball Stadium Franchise Agreement by and between the City of Lynchburg and Hillcats Baseball, LLC”, dated April 1, 2025, with Obligee for the purposes of having an exclusive franchise right to conduct its baseball games, events, and related uses as provided in the said agreement, which such agreement ("Franchise") is by reference expressly made a part hereof. NOW, THEREFORE, WITNESSETH: the condition of this obligation is such that, if the Principal shall promptly and faithfully perform the Franchise in strict conformity with the terms, provisions, covenants, and conditions of the same, then this obligation shall be null and void; otherwise it shall remain in full force and effect and enforceable by the Obligee against the Principal and the Surety. PROVIDED, that any alterations which may be made in the terms of the Franchise, or in the obligations to be performed under it, or the giving by the Obligee of any extension of time for the performance of the Franchise, or any other alterations or forbearance on the part of either or both of the Obligee or the Principal to the other shall not in any way release the Principal and the Surety, or either of them, their heirs, executors, administrators, successors or assigns, from their liability hereunder, notice to the Surety of any such alterations, extensions, or forbearance being hereby waived. No action shall be brought on this bond unless brought within one (1) year after the termination or expiration of the Franchise so long as no renewal of the Franchise is sought. The Surety represents to the Principal and to the Obligee that it is legally authorized to do business in the Commonwealth of Virginia. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) Page 121 of 207 2 Signed and sealed this day of ____________________, 2025. (SEAL) Principal By: Witness: Title: (SEAL) Surety By: Attorney-in-Fact I, ________________________, the duly appointed Attorney-in-Fact for ________________________, do hereby certify that my Power of Attorney related thereto has not been revoked, and where applicable, may be found of record in the Clerk’s Office of the Circuit Court of _____________________, Virginia in Deed Book ___________ at Page ___________ or under Instrument No. ___________. Further, a copy of my Power of Attorney is attached hereto. Attorney-in-Fact AFFIDAVIT AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF ATTORNEY-IN-FACT COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA (or, alternatively, Commonwealth or State of ) CITY/COUNTY OF to wit: I, the undersigned notary public, do certify that personally appeared before me in the jurisdiction aforesaid and made oath that he/she is the attorney-in-fact of _______________________, the Surety, and that he/she is duly authorized to execute on its behalf the aforesaid bond as its act and deed. Given under my hand this day of , 2025. __ Notary Public My Commission expires: My Registration No.____________________ Affix Notary Seal: Approved as to Form: Date: City Attorney/Designee Page 122 of 207 HILLCATS FRANCHISE AGREEMENT Tuesday, May 13, 2025 Page 123 of 207 PROPOSED ACTION • City Staff has negotiated new 15 year franchise agreement with the Lynchburg Hillcats Baseball Team • Staff Recommends City Council Approve the proposed Franchise Agreement • Approval Requires three actions by City Council • Approval of the Franchise Agreement • Removal of existing amusement tax exemption from City Code that is unique to the Hillcats • Amendment of the FY 2025 – FY 2029 Capital Improvement Plan to add new project to improve fan amenities at the city owned baseball stadium Page 124 of 207 PRIOR ACTIONS • 1886 – Lynchburg’s first professional baseball team “The Lynchburgs” begin playing • 1940 - City Stadium – now Bank of the James Stadium – constructed • One of the oldest active ballparks in minor league baseball with 85 years of continuous operation. • February 2016 – City Council granted 10-year franchise to Lynchburg Baseball Corp to allow the Lynchburg Hillcats Baseball Team to continue to play it’s games at Bank of the James Stadium • Fall 2024 - Hillcats Baseball LLC, led by Mr. Dylan Narang, purchased the Lynchburg Hillcats Baseball Team • October 2024 – City Council adopts resolution consenting to sale and allowing the assignment of the current franchise agreement to the new ownership group • Current Franchise expires at the end of the 2025 baseball season • Current – City Staff has negotiated new franchise agreement with the Hillcats to keep professional Baseball in Lynchburg for another 15 years Page 125 of 207 FRANCHISE OVERVIEW • Allows Hillcats to use public infrastructure (Bank of the James Stadium) to operate a minor league baseball team • Existing franchise expires after current 2025 baseball season • New franchise will replace final year of current agreement • Proposed 15 year term through 2039 baseball season • City will collect annual rent, parking rights fee, naming rights fee, and local taxes (sales, meals, amusement) as a result of operations • Revenue will support $5.25M in up front investment for improvements to the Stadium • Primarily fan experience amenities and alignment with MLB stadium requirements • Continues annual maintenance reserve to ensure completion of basic maintenance needs and on-going compliance with MLB stadium requirements • $150K annually up from $100K • Early termination penalties • $100K cash payment for each year remaining on agreement • Payment of unamortized amount of the initial $5.25M capital improvements Page 126 of 207 FINANCIAL DETAILS Revenue Projections - Baseline         Revenue Type Year One 15-Year Total Rent - Base $132,500 $2,375,980 Rent - Naming Rights $25,000 $375,000 Rent - Parking $25,000 $375,000 Sales / Meals Tax $100,000 $1,793,193 Amusement Tax $136,500 $2,447,708 Total $419,000 $7,366,881 Revenue Projections - Pessimistic         Revenue Type Year One 15 Year Total Rent - Base $132,500 $2,375,980 Rent - Naming Rights $25,000 $375,000 Rent - Parking $25,000 $375,000 Sales / Meals Tax $75,000 $1,344,894 Amusement Tax $102,375 $1,835,781 Total $359,875 $6,306,655             Revenue Projections - Optimistic         Revenue Type Year One 15 Year Total Rent - Base $132,500 $2,375,980 Rent - Naming Rights $25,000 $375,000 Rent - Parking $25,000 $375,000 Sales / Meals Tax $125,000 $2,241,491 Amusement Tax $170,625 $3,059,635 Total $478,125 $8,427,106 • Rent – Base, Sales / Meals Tax, Amusement Tax adjusted for inflation at 2.5% per year Page 127 of 207 City Council Agenda Item IV.11. Public Comment AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY May 13, 2025 Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water Resources AGENDA ITEM # IV.11 Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-036 authorizing a Water & Sewer Contract between the City of Lynchburg and CertainTeed, LLC that, among other terms, will set fixed rates for water and wastewater services. RECOMMENDATION Upon conclusion of the Public Hearing, adopt an ordinance authorizing the City Manager to execute the attached Water and Sewer Contract with CertainTeed, LLC. SUMMARY Historically, the City of Lynchburg has entered into Water and Sewer Contracts with very large industrial water users. For the past several decades, there has been a contract in place for the industry located at 1801 Concord Turnpike. Previous contracts were with RockTenn and Westrock. Currently, CertainTeed, LLC, a subsidiary of Saint-Gobain North America, owns and operates the facility specializing in a specific building product. CertainTeed, LLC is Lynchburg's single largest water and sewer user, providing critical revenues to the Water and Sewer Funds. Our Water and Sewer contracts are based on a cost of service methodology that looks at the specific infrastructure that provides service to the facility and the specific treatment costs for the volume of water purchased and volume of sewer used including high-strength waste in the form of Total Suspended Solids (TSS) and Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD). The methodology is also consistent with the terms of our CSO Consent Order which includes certain financial requirements associated with contract customers. This cost of service study is performed by an independent outside consultant and is updated every five years. PRIOR ACTION(S) April 8, 2025, City Council Work Session Business Item Briefing FISCAL IMPACT Revenues associated with Water and Sewer use. CONTACT(S) Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water Resources Page 128 of 207 ATTACHMENT(S) 1. O-25-036 2. Proposed Contract - City & CertainTeed Water and Sewer Rates 3. CertainTeed Contract - Water and Sewer Appendix A 4. CertainTeed Water and Sewer Contract Presentation 4-8-25 5. Affidavit of Publication REVIEWED BY Date: May 05, 2025 Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water Resources Date: May 08, 2025 Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager Date: May 08, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 129 of 207 AN ORDINANCE APPROVING A WATER AND SEWER CONTRACT, DATED MAY 13, 2025, BETWEEN THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG AND CERTAINTEED, LLC ORDINANCE: #O-25-036 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: 1. That the Water & Sewer Contract, dated May 13, 2025, between the City of Lynchburg and CertainTeed, LLC is hereby approved, and expressly incorporated herein by reference. Such contract, among other terms, sets fixed rates for water and wastewater services that will equal the City’s cost of providing water and wastewater services to CertainTeed. The Water & Sewer Contract is designed to be long-term in nature and the rates described therein are to be adjusted every five (5) years until the contract terminates as provided therein. The proposed “usage rates” for water and wastewater services for CertainTeed for the first five (5) years of the contract (January 1, 2025 to December 31, 2029) are as follows: Usage Rates 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Water Rate/HCF $1.79 $1.85 $1.89 $1.95 $1.98 Water Rate/1000 gallons $2.39 $2.47 $2.53 $2.61 $2.65 Sewer Rate/HCF $2.64 $2.88 $3.01 $3.03 $3.05 Sewer Rate/1000 gallons $3.53 $3.85 $4.02 $4.05 $4.08 Excess BOD Per 100/lbs. over 300 mg/l $38.82 $42.85 $46.01 $46.25 $46.41 Excess TSS Per 100/lbs. over 400 mg/l $35.29 $39.05 $40.50 $40.65 $40.95 A monthly Non-Process Charge will be billed. The Non-Process Charge is intended to recover the cost for treating wastewater from water sources at the Mill that are unrelated to the Company’s manufacturing process. The formula to calculate the monthly Non-Process Charge shall be as follows: Number of Employees x Days/Month Basis x Gallons/Day Basis x Current Sewer Rate. 2. That the City Manager is authorized to execute the said contract on behalf of the City, and take any further actions necessary to finalize the same. 3. That this Ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: May 13, 2025 Certified: ________________________________ Clerk of Council Page 130 of 207 Page | 1 WATER & SEWER CONTRACT THIS CONTRACT, is made and entered into on this 13th day of May, 2025, by and between CertainTeed, LLC, a company duly authorized to engage in business in the Commonwealth of Virginia, hereinafter referred to as the “Company”, and the City of Lynchburg, a municipal corporation of the Commonwealth of Virginia, hereinafter referred to as the “City”, who are the sole parties to this Contract. RECITALS A. The Company’s production facilities located on Concord Turnpike, hereinafter referred to as the “Mill”, pump wastewater directly to the City of Lynchburg’s Regional Water Resource Recovery Facility, hereinafter referred to as the “WRRF”, and does not benefit from the City’s wastewater collection and conveyance lines. The costs of the City’s wastewater collection and conveyance lines are not included in the stated sewer rates. B. It is the intent of the parties to have fixed rates for water and wastewater services that will equal the City’s cost of providing water and wastewater services to the Company. It is also the intent of both parties to have a long-term renewable contract that can be adjusted every five (5) years for changes in cost until such time as the Contract is terminated as provided herein. The initial contract period for this Contract will be from January 1, 2025, through December 31, 2029. C. The rate methodology used in this Contract is consistent with the requirements of that certain Special Consent Order between the City and the VA-DEQ, dated July 15, 2015, and the authority described under Code of Virginia §§ 15.2-2119 and 15.2-2143. NOW, THEREFORE, WITNESSETH: that for and in consideration of the terms, conditions, and provisions hereof, the Company and the City agree as follows: ARTICLE I. OPERATION OF THE WATER AND WASTEWATER FACILITIES A. The City will operate the water and wastewater facilities that it owns or controls in compliance with all applicable statutes, ordinances, rules, and regulations, present and future, and meet all applicable standards and requirements, present and future, of the Commonwealth of Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (VA-DEQ), the Virginia Department of Health (VDH), and other applicable regulatory agencies. B. The City will maintain the water and wastewater facilities in good working order and condition, will make necessary repairs thereto, and shall operate the facilities at all times properly and at a capacity that will permit the Company to meet its water needs and to dispose of wastewater from the Mill as provided in Article II and III of this Contract, except as provided for in Article VI (Force Majeure). Page 131 of 207 Page | 2 C. The Company agrees that the operation and maintenance of the pump station and force main is the responsibility of the Company. ARTICLE II. COMPANY WATER USE A. The Company agrees to draw all of its water needs at the Mill from the City and the City agrees to supply the Company with all of its water supply needs. B. The quality of water delivered to the Company under this Contract shall be the same as that furnished to domestic customers and shall meet the requirements of the VDH and/or the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and other State and Federal agencies which have jurisdiction over public water supplies. ARTICLE III. TREATMENT OF COMPANY’S WASTEWATER A. The Company will pre-treat its wastewater in accordance with the City’s ordinances and regulations, its Wastewater Discharge Permit, and shall not discharge to the WRRF any wastewater that would be harmful to the operation of the WRRF. Nor shall the Company cause the City to be in violation of its permit with VA-DEQ or any federal or state regulatory agency. B. Beginning January 1, 2025, the City agrees to provide the Company with wastewater treatment up to the levels shown below at the “Usage Rates” described in Article IV(A): Daily Wastewater Flow Limit 1.0 mgd Daily TSS Limit 15,000 lbs/day (TSS = Total Suspended Solids) Daily TSS Exceedance Limit 20,000 lbs/day Daily BOD Limit 15,000 lbs/day (BOD = Biological Oxygen Demand) Daily BOD Exceedance Limit 17,000 lbs/day C. Should flows and/or loadings exceed these limits, then the City will proceed with action on the following events: (1) When levels are above Peak Daily Limits a Corrective Action Required Letter will be generated. (2) When levels are above Exceedance Limits a Notice of Violation Letter will be generated. D. Effective January 1, 2025, the Company agrees to comply with a modified Wastewater Discharge Permit with the limits as stated above. Page 132 of 207 Page | 3 ARTICLE IV. SERVICE CHARGES (EFF. JANUARY 1, 2025 TO DECEMBER 31, 2029) A. The City will charge the Company the following “Usage Rates” for water and sewer services: Usage Rates 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Water Rate/HCF $1.79 $1.85 $1.89 $1.95 $1.98 Water Rate/1000 gallons $2.39 $2.47 $2.53 $2.61 $2.65 Sewer Rate/HCF $2.64 $2.88 $3.01 $3.03 $3.05 Sewer Rate/1000 gallons $3.53 $3.85 $4.02 $4.05 $4.08 Excess BOD Per 100/lbs. over 300 mg/l $38.82 $42.85 $46.01 $46.25 $46.41 Excess TSS Per 100/lbs. over 400 mg/l $35.29 $39.05 $40.50 $40.65 $40.95 B. A monthly Non-Process Charge will be billed. The Non-Process Charge is intended to recover the cost for treating wastewater from water sources at the Mill that are unrelated to the Company’s manufacturing process. The formula to calculate the monthly Non-Process Charge shall be as follows: Number of Employees x Days/Month Basis x Gallons/Day Basis x Current Sewer Rate. Non-Process Monthly Charge Calculation Example # Employees as of January 1 Days/Month Basis Gallons/Day Basis Current City Sewer Rate/HCF* Non-Process Monthly Charge 90 29.25 25 $8.30 $730.27 (*748 gallons per HCF) (1) The Company will provide the actual number of full-time employees as of January 1st each year. (2) Day/Month Basis is based on the following: (365 days/year – 14 days for holiday shutdown)/12 months. (3) City Sewer Rates typically update July 1st of every year. Regardless when sewer rate changes incur, the current City sewer rates will be used. C. The methodology used to determine the rates shown in paragraph A of this Article IV is based on the Company’s Water and Sewer Contract Rate Calculations prepared by PJ SUN LLC, dated December 27, 2023 (see Appendix A). Page 133 of 207 Page | 4 D. To continue to receive the contract rates described above, the Company shall guarantee a minimum annual water consumption of 149,600,000 gallons or 200,000 hcf and a minimum annual wastewater flow of 149,600,000 gallons or 200,000 hcf. The minimum annual water consumption and the minimum annual wastewater flow shall be the total volume consumed or discharged respectively from January 1st to December 31st of each year. Should the annual total for either fall below the respective amount, the Company’s contract volume rate shall be recalculated for the water consumption and/or wastewater discharge so that the combined total bill from January 1st to December 31st will be equivalent to 200,000 hcf. The Company shall then be billed for the difference. The Contract volume rate shall then revert to the Contract rates established in the Usage Rate table above beginning January 1st immediately following the period of low consumption. E. The amount of water drawn by the Company will be determined based on monthly readings performed by the City of all water meters at the Company’s Plant. F. The City shall be responsible for the accuracy of water meters and will provide the Company with a certification, upon request, as to the accuracy of the meters. The accuracy of the meters will be maintained to the standards of the American Water Works Association (AWWA) Standards for Water Meters. G. Wastewater flows shall be measured by an in-line magnetic flow meter located at the WRRF dedicated to flow only from the Mill’s pump station. The WRRF shall have the meter calibrated as recommended by the manufacturer at least once per calendar year. The flow meter shall have a totalizer that shall record at least once per day to use for the calculation of daily flows. H. In the event the device identified in Article IV(G) fails or is otherwise deemed incorrect in measuring daily flows, for billing purposes, flows will be estimated based on other available data to include but not be limited to the current or previous month’s daily average, fresh water usage or other agreeable methods. If the Mill believes the flow to be incorrect due to malfunction of their equipment (such as a check valve), the Mill must notify the industrial monitoring coordinator in writing about the malfunctions as soon as known and before the bill is generated (on or about the 10th of the month). The information should include the date of the equipment malfunction, cause, corrective action, and date of correction. On a case by case circumstance, the City will consider a reasonable adjustment to the flow for each day if deemed appropriate. I. TSS and BOD shall be sampled and analyzed at the WRRF in accordance with procedures specified in the latest version of “Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater” as published jointly by the American Public Health Association, the AWWA and the Water Environment Federation, or any other method mutually acceptable to the City and the Company. Charges for BOD and TSS will be calculated using actual measured sewer flow, measured as described herein. Calculations from these tests along with the Page 134 of 207 Page | 5 totalized flow from the Wastewater flow measuring device described herein shall be used to calculate the monthly invoice, excess flow, excess loadings, permitted loadings, and any other parameters included herein or in the discharge permit. BOD and TSS charges shall be calculated based on the total calculated BOD and TSS minus the amount of normal strength domestic wastewater, which is defined as 300 mg/l for BOD and 400 mg/l for TSS as indicated below and as provided for in City Code. lbs. of BOD = Total BOD, lbs. – ((monthly sewer flow, MG) x avg. BOD (300 mg/I) x 8.34) lbs. of TSS = Total TSS, lbs. – ((monthly sewer flow, MG) x avg. TSS (400, mg/l) x 8.34) J. For wastewater related charges, the City will issue a monthly miscellaneous invoice which includes all wastewater charges to the Company. Undisputed wastewater bills unpaid within five (5) days after due date as shown on the bill will be subject to a five percent (5%) penalty. K. For water related charges, the City will read the water meters and issue an automated system bill for monthly water use to the Company. Undisputed water bills unpaid within five (5) days after due date as shown on the bill will be subject to a five percent (5%) penalty. L. The City will bill the Company for water and sewer services based on the provisions described in this Article IV. The Company must notify the City in writing within twenty (20) days of receipt of any bill for which there are questions to avoid potential penalties. ARTICLE V. CONTRACT EXTENSION A. Effective January 1, 2030, and every five-year increment thereafter, the water and sewer rates will be adjusted to reflect changes in cost unless the contract is terminated as described herein. However, should any of the City’s calculated cost of service rates increase by more than five percent (5%) in any year due to events that were not known or were indeterminable as of the date the water and sewer rates were revised per this section of the Contract, the Contract water and sewer rates will be adjusted to reflect changes in cost of service prior to the end of the five-year increment period. Costs associated with any additional evaluation(s) shall be divided equally between the City and the Company. B. The intent of the City and the Company is to adjust the rates to cost of service levels every five (5) years based on the same methodology included in Appendix A to this Contract. C. The City reserves the right to reevaluate this Contract and circumstances prior to renewal and reserves the right to terminate this Contract upon giving the Company two (2) years prior written notice should the evaluation indicate that it is not in the City’s best interest to continue this Contract. Page 135 of 207 Page | 6 D. The Company may terminate this Contract by giving the City two (2) years prior written notice. E. The City agrees to contract with an independent rate consultant every five (5) years to perform the analysis required to adjust the water and sewer rates to cost of service levels for the ensuing five (5) years. As part of the consultant’s analysis, the methodology for calculating the water and sewer rates will be evaluated and agreed upon by the City and the Company as to its applicability to prevailing conditions. In the event both parties cannot agree on changes that may be proposed by either party, the methodology in Appendix A of this Contract shall prevail. F. The City will provide the Company with the rate analysis described in this Contract six months before the effective date of the renewal provision specified in this Article V. If the City and the Company cannot agree on what the rates should be by the effective date of the renewal provision, and if the Company notes objections in writing to the consultant’s analysis regarding the new rates no later than sixty (60) days prior to the effective date of the renewal provision, then a provisional rate equal to one hundred ten percent (110%) of the rates in effect prior to such effective date will be used to bill the Company for services until such time that agreement on the rates is reached, which agreement shall be reached within six (6) months of the City’s receipt of the Company’s objections. If agreement is not reached by such date, the City and the Company shall agree as to the identity of a third- party consultant, which shall be a recognized consulting firm with experience in municipal water and sewer rate analyses, and such third-party consultant shall be employed to provide, within ninety (90) days of its employment, a separate analysis of rates which shall be binding on both parties. The City and the Company shall share equally in the costs for such third-party consultant. The rates resulting from such analysis shall become effective, and the City will retroactively adjust all bills submitted to the Company for the difference between the provisional and actual rates agreed upon. ARTICLE VI. FORCE MAJEURE A. The City will not be liable for its failure to provide any of the services under this Contract if such failure to provide services is the result of an act of God, war or public enemy, seizure of legal process, strikes, lockouts, labor disputes, work stoppages, riots or civil disturbances, equipment or system failures, power failures or any other event beyond the City’s control. B. Neither the Company nor the City shall be liable for damages to the other for any act, omission, or circumstances occasioned by or in consequence of any act of God, strikes, lockouts, acts of public enemies, wars, blockades, insurrections, riots, epidemics, landslides, lightning, civil disturbances, explosions, breakage or accident to machinery or lines or pipe, the binding order of any court or government authority which has been Page 136 of 207 Page | 7 resisted in good faith by all reasonable legal means, and any other cause, whether of the kind herein enumerated or otherwise, not reasonably within the control of the party claiming suspension and which by the exercise of due diligence such party is unable to prevent or overcome. Failure to prevent or settle a strike or strikes shall not be considered to be a matter within the control of the party claiming suspension. Such causes or contingencies affecting the performance hereunder by either the Company or the City, however, shall not relieve it of liability in the event of its negligence or in the event of its failure to use due diligence, nor shall such causes or contingencies affecting such performance relieve either party from its obligation to make payments of amounts then due with respect to water and sewer services therefore delivered. ARTICLE VII. MISCELLANEOUS A. For information purposes only, the Company will provide the City with estimates of its future water demands, wastewater flows, and loads annually and the City will inform the Company of any events or circumstances that it becomes aware of that could cause the water and wastewater rates described herein to be materially different than the cost of providing water and wastewater services to the Company. B. Appendix A is incorporated herein and made a part of this Contract. C. If any part, provision, or portion of this Contract is deemed unenforceable by a Court of competent jurisdiction, then the parties agree all remaining parts, provisions, and portions of this Contract shall remain in full force and effect. D. This Contract embodies the entire understanding of the parties hereto, and, except for attached appendices, there are no future or other agreements or understandings, written or oral in effect between the parties related to the subject matter hereof. Further, this Contract supersedes all previous agreements that may have existed between the parties hereto with respect to the subject of equal formality signed by the parties hereto or by their duly authorized officers or representatives. E. Modifications, additions, amendments, and/or alternations to any of the provisions of this Contract shall be in writing and signed by duly authorized representatives of the parties. F. This Contract shall be governed in its entirety by the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia. Any litigation arising between the parties hereto, in relation to this Contract, shall be filed in the courts of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. G. The Company shall not discriminate, nor permit discrimination, against any person in its employment practices, in any of its contractual arrangements, in any services or accommodations it offers the public, or in any of its other business operations on the grounds of race, color, sex, national origin, or any other basis prohibited by state or federal law, nor exclude any person from participation in, deny the benefits of, or otherwise subject any person to discrimination in providing services on the grounds of race, color, sex, Page 137 of 207 Page | 8 national origin, or any other basis prohibited by state or federal law. Additionally, the Company shall not discriminate against and will make all reasonable efforts to accommodate persons with disabilities as required by Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). H. The Company shall pay promptly when due any and all taxes related to its operations. Further, the Company shall maintain all necessary licenses, permits, approvals, and the like connected to its operations, this Contract, or both. I. All notices or other writings required to be given under this Contract shall be given by date- and-time stamped facsimile, hand delivery with signed receipt, overnight or other courier with signed receipt, or by return receipt certified or registered mail, addressed to the proper party to the following addresses, or at such other address as may be subsequently given pursuant to this Section, and shall be deemed given within seven (7) days of being sent or provided: If to the City: City of Lynchburg, Virginia Attn: Director of Water Resources 525 Taylor Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 If to the Company: Ryan Long Plant Manager CertainTeed Interior Products Group 1801 Concord Turnpike Lynchburg, VA 24504 J. The titles of articles, sections, paragraphs, etc. of this Contract are for reference purposes only and shall be of no binding effect. K. The parties hereto shall be deemed and construed as independent contractors with respect to one another for all purposes and nothing contained in this Contract shall be determined to create a partnership or joint venture between the Company and the City with respect to the parties' activities under this Contract. The Company and the City are each responsible for their own respective liabilities under this Contract. L. The waiver by either the Company or the City of any default or breach by the other party of any of the provisions of this Contract shall not be deemed a continuing waiver or waiver of any other breach by the other party of the same or another provision hereof. M. This Contract shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. Further, this Contract, nor any part thereof, may not be assigned without the written consent of the non-assigning party. N. No third-party beneficiaries are intended by this Contract. Page 138 of 207 Page | 9 O. The parties hereto agree to abide by all laws, regulations, and industry standards which may be applicable to their operations under this Contract. P. Prior to this Contract’s execution, this Contract shall be approved by an Ordinance adopted by the Lynchburg City Council after a public hearing has been advertised and held pursuant to the requirements of Va. Code Sec. 15.2-107. Q. The parties agree this Contract may be executed by electronic signature. Without limitation, “electronic signature” shall include faxed versions of an original signature or electronically scanned and transmitted versions (e.g., via pdf) of an original signature. This Contract may be executed in counterparts. Each of which when so executed shall be deemed to be an original and all of which taken together shall constitute one document. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto, or authorized agents on their behalf, do hereby execute this Contract as of the date first above written. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) Page 139 of 207 Page | 10 CERTAINTEED, LLC Signature: ______________________________________________ Printed Name: ____________________________________________ Title: ___________________________________________________ (SEAL) ATTEST: Signature: ______________________________________________ Printed Name: ____________________________________________ Title: ___________________________________________________ Page 140 of 207 Page | 11 CITY OF LYNCHBURG Signature: _______________________________________________ Printed Name: ____________________________________________ Title: ____________________________________________________ (SEAL) ATTEST: Signature: ______________________________________________ Printed Name: ____________________________________________ Title: ___________________________________________________ APPROVED AS TO FORM: ____________________________ City Attorney / Designee Page 141 of 207 Page 142 of 207 Page 143 of 207 Page 144 of 207 Page 145 of 207 Page 146 of 207 Page 147 of 207 Page 148 of 207 Page 149 of 207 Page 150 of 207 Page 151 of 207 Page 152 of 207 Page 153 of 207 Page 154 of 207 Page 155 of 207 Page 156 of 207 Page 157 of 207 Page 158 of 207 Page 159 of 207 Page 160 of 207 CERTAINTEED WATER AND SEWER CONTRACT April 8, 2025 Page 161 of 207 PURPOSE & ACTION Purpose: Enter into a long term industrial water and sewer contract with CertainTeed Why: CertainTeed is our largest water and sewer customer. Revenues from them help stabilize City-wide water and sewer rates and helps to minimize future increases. The contract also establishes certain high strength waste parameters to help optimize our wastewater treatment process while maintaining permit compliance. Page 162 of 207 CONTRACT INFORMATION • Historically the industry at this location has had an industrial water and sewer contract • The City’s largest water user • Rates based on an independent cost of service study • Excludes facilities that the industry does not use. For example: CertainTeed pumps their wastewater directly to the Water Resource Recovery Facility so they do not pay sewage collection costs • Methodology is consistent with certain industrial contract requirements in our CSO Consent Order Page 163 of 207 INDUSTRIAL RATES CITY CURRENT RATES: • Water volume (HCF) = $3.29 • Sewer volume (HCF) = $8.30 • Excess BOD = $26.30 • Excess TSS = $28.50 CURRENT CONTRACT RATES: • Water volume (HCF): $1.80 • Sewer volume (HCF): $2.42 • Excess BOD = $35.16 • Excess TSS = $31.98 Note: As part of the rate negotiations we provided options to phase in rate increases which resulted in lower rates in the initial years but higher rates in the outer years. The overall result is the same calculated revenue over the 5 year period. Page 164 of 207 SUMMARY Industrial contracts for the very largest industries provide rate stability for the industry, while recognizing the importance of the industries’ large base revenue stream in minimizing city-wide rates increases. For this reason and those previously discussed, Water Resources supports entering into an industrial water and sewer contract with CertainTeed. Page 165 of 207 Public Hearing for Lynchburg Water Resources - Page 1 of 2 [def:$signername|printname|req|signer1] [def:$signersig|sig|req|signer1] [def:$notarysig|sig|req|notary] [def:$date|date|req|notary] [def:$state|state|req|notary] [def:$county|county|req|notary] [def:$disclosure|disclosure|req|notary] [def:$seal|seal|req|notary] AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION State of Florida, County of Broward, ss: Edmar Corachia, being first duly sworn, deposes and says: That (s)he is a duly authorized signatory of Column Software, PBC, duly authorized agent of Lynchburg News & Advance, a newspaper printed and published in the City of Lynchburg, County of Campbell, State of Virginia, and that this affidavit is Page 1 of 2 with the full text of the sworn-to notice set forth on the pages that follow, and the hereto attached: PUBLICATION DATES: Apr. 25, 2025, May. 2, 202

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 26, 2026.