Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Minutes
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Aug 18, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
August 18, 2026 – 5:00 PM
Hybrid Meeting (In person at Council Chambers & virtual via
Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall
identify themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s
purview; that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s
discussion and prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to
respond.
Members Present: Carl Schwarz, Kate Tabony, Cheri Lewis, Ron Bailey, Jennifer Trompetter, David
Timmerman, Jerry Rosenthal, Roger Birle,
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Kate Richardson, Jeff Werner, David Dillehunt
Pre-Meeting:
The chairman called the meeting to order at 5:30 PM.
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda.
No Public Comments
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular
agenda if a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to
comment on it. Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Meeting Minutes – April 21, 2026 & May 19, 2026
Mr. Schwarz asked to pull BAR #24-0042 from the Consent Agenda.
Motion to Approve remainder of Consent Agenda – Ms. Lewis – Second by Mr. Bailey – Motion passes
9-0.
C. Deferred Items
1. Certificate of Appropriateness [*Deferred by applicant January 22, 2025] BAR #24-0042
116 West Jefferson Street, Tax Parcel 330183000
Downtown ADC District
Owner: West Jefferson Properties, LLC
Applicant: Joshua Batman
Project: Rear porches & exit stairs
2
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – Request CoA for approval of rear porches and modified trim details due to
alterations necessary to accommodate code-required egress stairs. The applicant’s submittal reflects the
entirety of the planned rehabilitations and alterations to the original house and the contemporary structure
behind it. The BAR has previously approved CoA’s for that work. This review is singularly limited to the
modifications to the balconies at the rear (south) elevation of the 1913 house.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – It might help to look at sheet eight, which is page 57 of the agenda packet. That corner post
that sticks out ‘funny’ on the roof. It will stick out ‘funny’ on the west and south side symmetrically around the
corner. When it meets the floor below, does it start aligning again how the drawing shows?
Mr. Batman – Yes. It is the width of the stairs.
Mr. Schwarz – The trim and everything on the new construction is going to look normal.
Mr. Batman – That is correct.
Mr. Zehmer – On the column on the detail on sheet 14, page 63 on the agenda packet, the beam on top of the
column is not centered on the column
Mr. Batman – Up at the top, that is correct. It is the only way we can get the required egress width for the
stairs.
Mr. Zehmer – Is that an existing beam?
Mr. Batman – That is correct. I don’t want to mess with the cornice work since it is so pretty. We don’t want
to mess with that.
Mr. Schwarz – When it was a smaller column, it used to line up. They had to switch to a 6-by-6 to hold it up
because of the egress component.
Mr. Batman – That is correct. The width of the stairs is that close. It is as close as we could possibly squeeze
it to get it to work.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – I personally would be Ok with both options. I think the unfinished wood is atypical for this
location. I just want to see it painted.
Mr. Batman – That is fair.
Mr. Schwarz – If you guys agree or disagree, that was my thought. Option two shows an unfinished cedar. I
want to see that painted if that is something you guys want to go with.
3
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Mr. Batman – I did not put all the mockups. I agree. It should be painted.
Mr. Zehmer – You indicated that you preferred option two. Is there a particular reason why?
Mr. Batman – We are worried that it might feel like a birdcage underneath that porch. There is a little unit that
you access under there.
Mr. Zehmer – Is it a mechanical unit?
Mr. Batman – No. It is a room. It is like a suite. It has a kitchen and stuff there.
Mr. Zehmer – Out from under the steps is an exterior space just outside of that?
Mr. Batman – It is like a patio.
Mr. Zehmer – This would be a privacy screen.
Ms. Lewis – It is enclosed. There are a lot of conditions downtown where you have porches and space
underneath. I did not realize it was an entrance. I prefer the lattice. I cannot give you a good design guideline
reason. I will be transparent about that.
Mr. Batman – It is more traditional. That is why I have it. We don’t mind it.
Ms. Lewis – If it is a used space, I would believe that someone would enjoy the sunlight too and the openness.
Mr. Zehmer – I agree with Mr. Schwarz if they go with the solid panel. That should be painted. Personally, I
have a little preference for the lattice. Even a diagonal lattice might work. Both are probably within our
guidelines.
Mr. Schwarz – I have a preference. I don’t think that the solid violates our guidelines.
Mr. Bailey – I don’t think it is for us to choose. I also have a preference. The lattice looks better.
Mr. Werner – There is Hedge Street just south of the hospice. They have lattice on the back. In the large
picture there, I would not have an opinion as far as a staff opinion of having lattice above. That is where we
felt the strongest that lattice on the upper panels if privacy enclosure made sense at the bottom. That was where
we were looking at. What was on the building at your place and that place on Hedge Street, those were two
examples we could fall back on.
Ms. Lewis – Since your presented options to us, are you asking us to choose? For staff, do we need to choose?
Could we say either as long as the panels are painted?
Mr. Batman – We would be happy with that. With the solid, in the porch entablature, they look like little
cutouts and solid pieces like a floral thing. I did not have time to put together the mockups for that. I agree. It
does not want to be unstained. It should be painted. You are right. We are honestly happy for either option.
Either option will look good. If you give a little leeway, I would like to try doing something with the cutouts
and get a little bit more in depth on it.
Ms. Lewis – Would staff need to approve that?
4
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Mr. Werner – I am thinking about First Street North. There is a gate that is rounded out grape vine and leaves.
I am fine with that as long as it is not a dragon or a bright green.
Mr. Batman – I would love your input on it when we get to that point.
Mr. Werner – A serious way to look at it would be some of the railings on the café spaces on The Mall. I
recently worked with people at The Paramount. I encouraged them to be creative. Something of that nature,
that would be great if there was a way to be expressive about it. It would be nice if you asked.
Mr. Batman – I would be happy to run it by you guys.
Ms. Tabony – I want to say how great it is to see these renderings from the evolution since the last time we
looked at this project is phenomenal. Thanks for doing that. In terms of my opinion, I like the solid. It brings
the new building’s materiality a little. It mixes in the center there, which I think is nice. I would like to see the
cutouts.
Mr. Barman – As I was thinking about this, you can see it. Those porches downtown have it. That is where I
was leaning towards. I did not get a chance to put it all in this packet. I am happy to run it by you. Either
option is fine with us at this point.
Mr. Zehmer – It seems like we are Ok with either option. If you choose option two, it should be painted. If
you want to articulate option two, just submit the final to the staff for record. One thing that staff brought up
was the mechanical units along the side yard. Are they on the street side?
Mr. Batman – It is between two houses. We are putting it on the front porch right now. We transplanted all
the bushes in front around and screened the HVAC unit with it. We got it after the drought. They have taken
well. It is already screened quite well with the existing bushes.
Mr. Zehmer – I don’t think we can require a condition of this CoA. On sheet five, you have some screening.
That is basically what you said that you did.
Mr. Batman – They are nice and big, mature bushes.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed treatment for the rear exit stairs at 116
West Jefferson Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other
properties in the District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the conditions
that the applicant may opt for option one or option two as presented in the materials with the caveat
that option two would need to have the panels painted. The applicant preserves the option to do
carpentry cutouts on those solid wood panels. As a condition of approval, we will require that the
original rear porch columns be retained on site for a potential reuse and reinstatement as part of the
future restoration of the property. Second by Mr. Schwarz. Motion passes 9-0.
D. New Items
N/A
E. Pre-Application Conferences
2. Pre-Application Conference – Certificate of Appropriateness
Continued discussion from December 2023
5
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
No formal action will be taken
915 East High Street, Tax Parcel 530247000
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner: LO-HI, LLC
Applicant: Dan Bracey, Two Street Studio
Project: Construction of multi-story, mixed-use building.
• Staff introduced the project to the BAR. It is currently a vacant parcel and a parking lot.
• There were concerns about the length of the structure as it faces Lexington Avenue and breaking it up.
There was support for the materials.
• This project is being reviewed under the old code. There is nothing in the code that limits the length of
the proposed building.
• There was a question about The Taylor Walk. Taylor Street went all the way through to Locust. City
Council in 1988 voted to vacate that last section of Taylor Street on the west end. Council requested
that there be a continuous pedestrian path through to Locust Avenue.
• There is a path that was established. It goes through the 2-level parking garage at the hospital.
• The planner is not aware of any legal provision for Taylor Walk. The Taylor Sidewalk has been moved
off the property. The new plat has been recorded.
• There has not been much work done on the project since 2023. Most of the work has been focused on
site plan approval.
• There has been the creation of the lot along Lexington Avenue.
• The new zoning would allow the building height to be 12 stories.
• The deck is oversized because it needs to serve the office use and the residential use. The applicant
would like to keep the deck concealed from view.
• The height on Lexington Avenue is proposed to be 1 story.
• Mr. Zehmer did not have a big issue with the overall length of the building.
• The proposed building is not a tall building, and it is following the grade.
• Mr. Zehmer did bring up that with there being a cemetery across the street, there will not be the
possibility of a canyon effect with another building across the street.
• Ms. Tabony did recommend breaking down the volume of the building.
• Mr. Schwarz did recommend seeing this proposed project in 3-D and 3-D views due to not
understanding the elevation.
• Members of the BAR provided feedback and constructive criticism on what the applicant can do to
improve the project for a formal CoA application.
• Ms. Trompetter did ask if the applicant had done extra historic research on the parcel. The cemetery
boundaries have not changed historically.
• Ms. Trompetter did make recommendations for possible trees, bushes, and shrubs.
• Mr. Schwarz did ask the applicant to consider large trees along the sidewalk. The applicant does
believe that the power lines there might be buried underground.
• There was a question of whether this project fell under Entrance Corridor or Conservation District.
According to staff, it fell under Conservation District.
• Ms. Lewis did emphasize the importance of elevations on High Street. The elevations will need to be
shown in 3-D.
• There were confusion and discussion surrounding the tiny building at the corner of the property. The
applicant needs to show that the lot is a buildable lot.
• The tiny 2-story building is included in the site plan and will need to be designed.
• Staff would like to see a formal CoA application the next time this project comes before the BAR.
• Mr. Schwarz provided his comments and feedback surrounding the project. Having residential units
open on East High Street feels inappropriate according to Mr. Schwarz.
6
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
• The zoning along this corridor does provide increased height up to 8 and 10 stories.
The BAR meeting was recessed five minutes before the next Pre-Application Conference.
Mr. Timmerman recused himself for the next Pre-Application Conference due to a conflict of interest.
3. Pre-Application Conference – Certificate of Appropriateness
No formal action will be taken
BAR #26-0034
301 East Hight Street, Tax Parcel 330070000
North Downtown ADC District
Owner: Village School
Applicant: Design Develop
Project: Addition
• Staff introduced this project and the different aspects of this project.
• The Head of The Village School did present a brief history and the purpose of the school to members
of the BAR.
• The Village School has made use of city of Charlottesville and Albemarle County facilities and parks.
• The applicant presented the proposed project and the addition to The Village School to the BAR.
• The proposed addition would be an outdoor sports court and an outdoor classroom.
• The applicant is proposing a new crosswalk across 3rd Street Northeast to the new sports court and
outdoor classroom.
• The applicant is also proposing some street art on 3rd Street Northeast in addition to the proposed
crosswalk.
• The applicant did have some concern about the height of the fence given the height requirements
according to the code. The applicant would like a taller fence or a creative solution.
• Mr. Zehmer did express the possible concern of a taller fence preventing balls from going out into the
street. Mr. Zehmer also brought up the possibility of a speed bump to slow drivers down near the
proposed crosswalk.
• Staff recommended the fence be an aesthetic fence with a netting feature on top of the fence.
• The applicant would have the same signage that was in front of the building. It would be a hanging
sign in front of the building. The proposed signage would require a sign permit.
• There was agreement about possibly having a couple possible shade trees next to fence.
• There were questions and feedback from members of the BAR regarding the different aspects of the
project.
• Ms. Tabony had some concerns surrounding the astroturf/playing surface for the sports court. There is
precedent for use in front of some of the Greek houses.
• Mr. Schwarz, Ms. Lewis, and Ms. Trompetter did recommend exploring some other play surfaces
given the failure of astroturf at the Greek houses.
• Ms. Lewis did recommend preserving the historical features such as the railings on the front.
• Ms. Lewis also recommended rumble strips or speed bumps to reduce the speed of drivers going up or
down 3rd Street Northeast.
• There was overall support for this proposed addition project with The Village School.
F. Other Business [Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items]
4. BAR Training
• Roles & Responsibilities (per City Code 34-5.1.5)
7
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
• At least one hour of BAR training is required by the state each year. This training will be about 30
minutes.
• Staff did go over the history of historic preservation and the role of the BAR. It is through the National
Park Service and administered by the Virginia Department of Historic Resources.
• Staff did go over the different individual roles of every person on the BAR. Staff went over the makeup
of the BAR membership.
• Staff did go over the process for how neighborhoods can become a locally recognized neighborhood.
Several neighborhoods are in the national register but don’t have designation locally.
• There are 8 local ADC Districts and 3 Historic Conservation Districts.
• Staff did remind the members of the BAR what falls under the purview of the BAR for CoA
applications. There are specific review criteria that the BAR must use in reviewing projects.
• Staff emphasized the importance of following the guidelines in reaching a decision on CoA
applications.
• The Guidelines did and should correspond to the Secretary of Interior Guidelines. The Design
Guidelines are approved by the City Council and interpreted by the BAR.
5. Staff Updates
• Minor Historic Reviews
• Staff did go over the responsibilities and other job duties that staff are doing in addition to getting
materials ready for BAR meetings.
• DT Mall café spaces
o Ms. Lewis asked about café spaces that operated without approval and non-compliance.
o There was discussion surrounding the non-compliance with the café spaces.
o There has not been enforcement of the café spaces guidelines passed by the BAR and approved
by the City Council.
G. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 9:38 PM.
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.