Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Feb 18, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Packet Guide
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Regular Meeting
February 18, 2026 5:30 p.m.
Hybrid Meeting (In-person at Council Chamber and virtual via Zoom)
Pre-Meeting Discussion [5pm in the NDS conference room]
Regular Meeting [5:30pm in Council Chamber]
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda [or on the Consent Agenda]
B. Consent Agenda
1. Meeting minutes November 18, 2025. [Attached in draft form to this agenda.] Video
recording available here.
C. Deferred Items - N/A
D. New Items
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST26-0001
701-705 West Main Street; TMP 320157000
West Main Street ADC District
Owner: Rocky Mountain LLC
Applicant: Calder Kegley
Project: Window replacements
3. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST26-0004
Historic Downtown Pedestrian Mall
Downtown ADC District
Owner: City of Charlottesville
Applicant: Clifton Dooms, Department of Parks & Rec
Project: Downtown Mall trashcan replacement plan
E. Pre-Application Conferences
[Including continued, preliminary discissions]
(6:40) 4. Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0002
528 Valley Road; TMP 11-70 and portion of 11-71
Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District
Owner: Andrew Fossen; AVP 528 Valley LLC
Applicant: Raymond Gaines, The Gaines Group
Project: Construction of nine townhomes
February 2026 BAR Packet 1
(7:20) 5. Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0003
0 Lexington Avenue; TMP 520152001
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner: David T. & Cristine S. Gardner
Applicant: Bridget Ridenour, Alloy Architecture + Construction
Project: Construct single-family home
F. Other Business
[Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items]
(7:45) 6. Staff Discussion
G. Adjourn (8:00)
Public Participation & Access
Regarding public comment(s): The BAR values community participation and input and welcomes public comments at
meetings. The intent is to allow public input; not initiate a dialogue or debate with the board.
Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call
the ADA Coordinator at 434-987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of
Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made.
The Board of Architectural Review’s regular meetings are held in person and online via Zoom webinar which requires
advance registration. Access event details and Zoom link under the City of Charlottesville’s event and meetings calendar.
Additionally, the webinar is broadcast on all the City's streaming platforms. For a complete list and direct links, please visit:
www.charlottesville.gov/streaming.
2026 Meeting Schedule
Tuesday March 17, 2026 Tuesday August 18, 2026
Tuesday April 21, 2026 Tuesday September 15, 2026
Tuesday May 19, 2026 Tuesday October 20, 2026
Tuesday June 16, 2026 Tuesday November 17, 2026
Tuesday July 21, 2026 Tuesday December 15, 2026
February 2026 BAR Packet 2
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
November 18, 2025
Hybrid Meeting (In person at City Council Chambers & virtual
via Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall
identify themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s
purview; that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s
discussion and prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to
respond.
Members Present: James Zehmer, Carl Schwarz, Jerry Rosenthal, Cheri Lewis, Katherine Tabony, Ron
Bailey, Roger Birle
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Kate Richardson, Jeff Werner, Remy Trail, Missy Creasy, Matt Alfele,
Sarah Kim
Pre-Meeting:
Staff brought up that there was a complicated agenda for the meeting. Staff decided to make changes to the
original meeting agenda. 7
th Street will be back on the BAR meeting agenda next month. Mr. Alfele went
over the changes to the procedure manual and the new zoning code and the role of the BAR within the new
zoning code. Mr. Alfele did bring up the amount verticality within the new zoning code. The CoA is a check
on the final site plan for projects. Mr. Werner went over the process for an applicant getting to a pre-
application conference in front of the BAR.
There was discussion surrounding the role of the BAR under the new zoning code.
Mr. Zehmer called the BAR meeting to order at 5:35 PM.
There was the election of Mr. Zehmer and Mr. Timmerman as Chair and Vice-Chair. Mr. Rosenthal made
the motion to nominate Mr. Zehmer and Mr. Timmerman for Chair and Vice-Chair. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Schwarz. Motion passes 7-0. Mr. Zehmer and Mr. Timmerman accepted the positions of
Chair and Vice-Chair respectively.
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda.
No Public Comments
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular
agenda if a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to
comment on it. Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST25-0110
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
1
1314 Rugby Road, TMP 380092000
Individually Protected Property
Owner: Pete Snyder
Applicant: Jeff Dreyfus / Buschmann Dreyfus
Project: Replace pool pavilion
Motion to Approve the Consent Agenda – Mr. Schwarz – Second by Ms. Lewis – Motion passes 7-0.
Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design
Guidelines, I move to find the proposed pavilion at 1314 Rugby Road satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is
compatible with this IPP, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted.
C. Deferred Items
NA
D. New Items
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST25-0112
159 Madison Lane, TMP 090145000
The Corner ADC District (contributing structure)
Owner: Montalto Corporation
Applicant: Paul Tassell / The Gaines Group
Project: Misc. repairs/improvements to south porch
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – The project narrative identifies several elements that staff has determined are
maintenance and repair, and therefore not subject to BAR review. The elements subject to this CoA request are
as follows:
• Removal and reconstruction of the concrete (lower) stairs on the west side of the portico.
• Removal and reconstruction of the brick and concrete (upper) stairs on the east and west sides of the
portico. In lieu of the concrete caps on the outside stingers, the new concrete treads will be exposed
with a 1” overhang. This will replicate the original design at these stairs, which is shown on the original
Makielski drawings dated February 1, 1928.
• Install a metal door and frame at the lower wall at the west side of the portico.
• The proposed work includes infilling with brick the three, basement-level windows at the front of the
porch. The BAR approved that work with conditions in June 2022; however, that CoA expired.
Paul Tassell, Applicant – It is self-explanatory. We have the original drawings. We just want to repair what
has been damaged by water over the years and neglect. We want to have a safer entry and exit out of the
building.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Question from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Rosenthal – I was wondering why you could not put windows back instead of infilling with brick. I
understand the security issue; maybe put bar or something behind the windows. It would at least allow light
into the basement.
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
2
Mr. Werner – The BAR had that discussion in 2022 with a couple of scenarios. This seemed like the most
ideal for their situation.
Mr. Tassell – They continuously get broken up. The kids don’t care.
Mr. Rosenthal – A type of plexiglass would make it difficult to break.
Mr. Tassell – They broke through a door in the second-floor hatch to get into the building.
Ms. Lewis – It is inappropriate on a historic building like this. Perhaps, we have approved in the past. It would
be unusual.
Mr. Zehmer – There are original windows there. I don’t know what you are suggesting.
Mr. Schwarz – The staff report said that we are calling for 1 or 2 inches of recess. The proposal calls for the
brick to be recessed a quarter inch.
Mr. Werner – That was in the prior CoA.
Mr. Schwarz – I don’t know if that bothers anybody up here or there is a reason that you went with a
shallower inset. Is there some structural reason?
Mr. Tassell – No.
Mr. Zehmer – Would you be opposed to recessing it further?
Mr. Tassell – No.
Mr. Zehmer – It maintains a shadow line at a depth.
Mr. Schwarz – On the stairs that are brick, you are going to replace the cap and extend the treads over. Is the
brick being reused? Is there enough brick there?
Mr. Tassell – We spoke with a local brick mason. He believes that he has something like what is there now.
We were going to try to repurpose it as much as we could.
Mr. Rosenthal – I saw that you are putting drains in the concrete on that deck. Where is the water being
drained?
Mr. Tassell – If you are facing the building, on the left-hand side at the parking area, there is a storm drain that
we were hoping to pipe it down and out that way. That was the last discussion.
Mr. Zehmer – On the railing replacements/handrails, one thing I want to confirm is that you are not planning
to replace the railings in between the columns that was not shown on the plans. Are you trying to retain those?
Is that correct?
Mr. Tassell – We were going to replace them as they are on the original drawings.
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
3
Mr. Zehmer – Those did not show up on any of the plans. All the arrows were pointing at the hand stairs, but
not those 3 center sections. I do want to clarify that.
Mr. Werner – My understanding is that the whole deck is going to be reworked.
Mr. Zehmer – Those are all mounted to the columns. I think there is a way you could potentially save those
even if you replace the deck. You said that you are going to replace them as is. I am worried that code
requirements are going to make you follow the 4-inch rule and they are going to have a different appearance.
Mr. Tassell – We spoke to staff about that. We were under the impression that since we were putting back
what is currently there that we were Ok.
Mr. Zehmer – Reinstalling the existing railings?
Mr. Werner – There are a couple of ways to look at it. Because it is a historic structure, there are certain
things that, to meet code, don’t necessarily have to comply. I have not had a conversation with the code official
about this. I agree with that in some. I am not comfortable when it is a life and safety issue. If there is a railing
height issue, and that is why the condition is in here. It is the first bullet. If it is replaced, it would be replaced
with the understanding that it might have to be a different height. I don’t have an answer for that. I know that
Virginia code allows some flexibility with historic structures.
Mr. Zehmer – I understand that. They are rounded and curved. They are not just straight railings. At a
minimum, that is an important detail to match if you must replace them with new railings. I would match that
curve.
Mr. Tassell – On Drawing A2, facing the building, on the right-hand side between the far-right column, we
have a note that addresses that to match the existing. We, not only address the handrails going up, but we also
hit it in the center.
Mr. Zehmer – Do you know how tall the existing railings are?
Mr. Tassell – I believe it is 42 inches.
Mr. Zehmer – I think the only hangup would potentially be if the code official required you to do a 4-inch
spacing.
Mr. Tassell – We are concerned with the same thing. Everything was bringing you back to the original
drawing that is shown. On the left stairs going down, they did a hodge-podge repair. It is not the greatest.
Mr. Zehmer – I had another question about handrails. If you look at the Stannis-Lowkelski drawing, I noticed
a detail like a fidal cap. They are all missing. Were they there? I would support putting them back.
Mr. Rosenthal – What are you doing to ensure that you will repeat the mistake with the brick and concrete?
Mr. Tassell – It is hopefully installed per our specifications, and we don’t have this issue anymore. We have
consulted with several different ‘experts’ with waterproofing slabs like this that are over a finished space. We
are trying to find the best solution for this application. That is our intent. We don’t want this to happen again.
When we were first looking at this, we went through different options. One was to discharge the water and
come over the top of that brick on the front. You would have the same thing when the freeze and thaw happen
again. We decided to go with the internal drain system, run it down and out. RE Lee Contracting did a building
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
4
across the street from this. We went over and saw that elevated slab and saw how they did it. They provided
the drawings. We matched that with this one. That is the intent.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Ms. Lewis – I want to commend the applicant for trying to go back to the Stannis-Lowkelski drawings and
trying to restore those aspects of the railings and front porch.
Mr. Tassell – The new board is going to make sure that that is handled in the future.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including City’s
ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed masonry-related rehabilitation work
at 159 Madison Lane satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this district and that the BAR
approves the application with the following conditions:
• Existing railings will be reused; however, if existing are not salvageable, the new will reasonably
replicate the existing, with the understanding that dimensions might be modified to meet code
requirements.
• Approval of the infill, with brick, of the three basement-level windows at the front of the porch
must follow these parameters: the coursing, brick color and mortar be matched as closely to the
historic as possible, and that the infill with brick be set 1 inch back from the plane of the brick
wall.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Bailey and passed 7-0.
The meeting was recessed at 5:58 PM and readjourned in the NDS Conference Room at 6:02 PM.
3. Staff questions/discussion
• Update on workplan for review of design guidelines
o Staff did bring up that the Design Guidelines are Council’s Guidelines and are adopted by
City Council.
o There was a discussion regarding the review and update of the new design guidelines.
o Mr. Rosenthal brought up an email sent out by Mr. Timmerman to the other members of the
BAR.
o There was a robust discussion surrounding the application of the design guidelines.
o Mr. Werner believes that the height, scale, and the massing are the easiest to apply with the
guidelines.
o Members of the BAR expressed interest in having a workflow chart and a checklist for the
members of the BAR to follow with projects.
o There was discussion about the administrative approvals without coming to the BAR for
approval.
o Ms. Tabony brought up identifying where the guidelines and zoning code come into conflict
or collision.
o Ms. Lewis did bring up that most of the neighborhoods were not that well organized during
the Comp Plan and Zoning rewrite.
o There was discussion about the project in Fifeville and Fifeville becoming a historic district.
Staff did mention that there would have to be overwhelming support.
o There was discussion about when the previous neighborhoods became Historic
Conservation Districts (Woolen Mills and Martha Jefferson).
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
5
o Staff reminded the BAR that there can be no partial CoAs. All aspects of the applications
need to be complete and full.
o Mr. Birle did bring up the details of the renderings that applicants submit for a CoA
application.
o Mr. Schwarz did bring that each member of the BAR needs to be clear in their comments to
the applicants in the feedback.
o Ms. Lewis brought up that a checklist for the 7
th Street project might have been a good idea.
o There was an idea of partial CoAs for massing and scale at the beginning of projects.
o Staff stressed the difference between an IPP (Individually Protected Properties) and ADC
Districts and the timing of the West Main and 7
th Street projects.
o Ms. Lewis brought up the high cost of construction in offering and building affordable
housing. Ms. Lewis did bring up the idea that the city should focus on renovation of existing
housing.
o Mr. Schwarz suggested that the Guidelines are not too far off, except for materiality when it
comes to the big projects.
o Mr. Zehmer did note that the new zoning code and ordinance is promoting bigger buildings.
It is something that Charlottesville historically has not had.
o There was a discussion among the members of the BAR about the public perception of the
BAR. There are members of the public who do not understand what the role of BAR is.
o Mr. Schwarz asked a question about whether the BAR tries to make projects better or
projects just good enough.
o There was discussion surrounding the question asked by Mr. Schwarz.
o There was discussion surrounding the differences between contributing and non-
contributing buildings.
• New development review policy. Development Review Procedures Manual
E. Adjourn
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:45 PM.
BAR Meeting Minutes November 18, 2025
6
Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST26-0001
701-705 West Main Street; TMP 320157000
West Main Street ADC District
Owner: Rocky Mountain LLC
Applicant: Calder Kegley
Project: Window replacements
Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to the report pages):
• Staff Report
• Application Submittal
• Historical Survey
February 2026 BAR Packet 3
Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST26-0004
Historic Downtown Pedestrian Mall
Downtown ADC District
Owner: City of Charlottesville
Applicant: Clifton Dooms, Department of Parks & Rec
Project: Downtown Mall trashcan replacement plan
Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages):
• Staff Report
• Litter Receptacle Spec Sheet
February 2026 BAR Packet 4
Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0002
528 Valley Road; TMP 11-70 and portion of 11-71
Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District
Owner: Andrew Fossen; AVP 528 Valley LLC
Applicant: Raymond Gaines, The Gaines Group
Project: Construction of nine townhomes
Components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages):
• Staff Report
• Photographs of Adjacent Houses
• Application Submittal
February 2026 BAR Packet 5
Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0003
0 Lexington Avenue; TMP 520152001
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner: David T. & Cristine S. Gardner
Applicant: Bridget Ridenour, Alloy Architecture + Construction
Project: Construct single-family home
Components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages):
• Staff Report
• Application Submittal
February 2026 BAR Packet 6
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
February 18, 2026
Certificate of Appropriateness
BAR # HST26-0001
701-705 West Main Street; TMP320157000
West Main ADC District
Owner: Rocky Mountain LLC
Applicant: Calder Kegley
Project: Window replacement
Background
Year Built: c. 1922
District: West Main ADC District
Status: Contributing
701-705 West Main Street features three storefronts each with a recessed vestibule, and copper or
bronze framed windows separated by brick piers. The residential entrance door is topped with a
quarry-faced stone lintel, and repeated at each of the second-story windows combined with keystone
ornamentation. In the first quarter of the 20
th-c. residential parcels in the immediate vicinity were
redeveloped. In 1920 this block of West Main had a drugstore, dry goods store, and confectionary.
The extent brick commercial/residential buildings (including 707-709 W. Main) were constructed
between 1922-1925. [See Appendix; survey attached.]
Prior BAR Reviews
None. Staff recovered drawings from 1979 which indicate the second-floor units were reconfigured,
including addition of storm windows, and a rear entrance doorway. However, the majority of the
primary and 7
th Street façade’s windows appear unchanged, with the exception of #11 [see applicant
submission] on the east elevation.
Application
• Submittal dated January 14, 2026: 701 West Main Street (2nd story), 15 pages; Marvin window
cut sheets, 4 pages.
• Request CoA for window replacements on the second floor only.
701-705 West Main Street – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 1
Discussion
BAR staff were consulted on window replacements in 2023 while the property was under different
ownership (see attached email correspondence dated January 7, 2026 and August 22, 2023). The
application shows varying levels of age and deterioration, and staff cannot confirm whether the
windows are irreparable. The applicant’s objective is to install replacement windows [frame inserts,
retaining the exterior trim] that provide insulated, properly fitting, operable units.
Historical survey forms identify this property and the neighboring building at 707-709 West Main
Street as the best-preserved stretch of historic commercial buildings on West Main Street. BAR should
discuss if allowing replacement of the windows would be appropriate for this historic property and this
ADC District. In reference to Ch. 4.C.8 of the Design Guidelines, “If a window on the primary façade
of a building must be replaced and an existing window of the same style, material, and size is
identified on a secondary elevation, place the historic window in the window opening on the primary
façade.” In the past we’ve encouraged applicants to consider this recommendation as an alternative to
replacing all the windows.
West Main Street façade, c. 2008
Rear elevation in 2012, prior to window and porch alterations.
701-705 West Main Street – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 2
Staff Recommendation
A rigid application of the guidelines would recommend repair in lieu of replacement, however the
BAR has more recently approved window frame inserts for 20
th-century buildings. If the BAR
considers the frame inserts, consideration of the exterior trim and sill should be discussed.
Provided below is a summary of staff recommendations for the applicant:
• Preference is wood, metal, or metal-clad. Vinyl or plastic windows are not allowed. For
window frame inserts, we have approved Pella Reserve, Marvin Ultimate, and Andersen 400
Series Woodwright. Insulated glass is fine.
• Most of your windows are 1-over-1, but for the 6-over-6 you can use insulated with the applied
grilles, provided there is an internal spacer bar. Muntin width should be between 5/8” and 7/8”.
• Insert frames must fit relatively tight into the opening and retain the existing exterior trim or at
least have something new that is similar. Inserts that require wide metal flashing that eliminates
or conceals the exterior trim are not allowed.
Suggested motion
Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including City’s ADC
District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed window replacements at 701-705 West
Main Street satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in the
District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted.
Or with the following conditions: […]
Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District
Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed window replacements at 701-705 West Main
Street do not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are not compatible with this property and other properties
in the District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the application as submitted…
Criteria, Standards, and Guidelines
Review Criteria Generally
Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a
design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major
Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34-
5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction,
alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a
building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance
with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.”
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
701-705 West Main Street – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 3
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character
of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic
Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given
to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive
Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design
guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane to this request]
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1:
a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and
factors:
i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed
addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the
site and the applicable District;
ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs;
iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of
Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant;
iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures;
v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as
gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks;
vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an
adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures;
vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the
standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and
viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
Pertinent ADC District Design Guidelines
Pertinent Design Review Guidelines for Rehabilitations
Link: Chapter 4 Rehabilitation
C. Windows
1. Prior to any repair or replacement of windows, a survey of existing window conditions is
recommended. Note number of windows, whether each window is original or replaced, the material,
type, hardware and finish, the condition of the frame, sash, sill, putty, and panes.
2. Retain original windows when possible.
[…]
5. Repair original windows by patching, splicing, consolidating or otherwise reinforcing. Wood that
appears to be in bad condition because of peeling paint or separated joints often can be repaired.
6. Replace historic components of a window that are beyond repair with matching components.
7. Replace entire windows only when they are missing or beyond repair.
8. If a window on the primary façade of a building must be replaced and an existing window of the
same style, material, and size is identified on a secondary elevation, place the historic window in the
window opening on the primary façade.
[…]
701-705 West Main Street – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 4
10. Avoid changing the number, location, size, or glazing pattern of windows by cutting new openings,
blocking in windows, or installing replacement sash that does not fit the window opening.
11. Do not use inappropriate materials or finishes that radically change the sash, depth of reveal,
muntin configuration, reflective quality or color of the glazing, or appearance of the frame.
12. Use replacement windows with true divided lights or interior and exterior fixed muntins with
internal spacers to replace historic or original examples.
13. If windows warrant replacement, appropriate material for new windows depends upon the context
of the building within a historic district, and the age and design of the building. Sustainable
materials such as wood, aluminum-clad wood, solid fiberglass, and metal windows are preferred.
Vinyl windows are discouraged.
14. False muntins and internal removable grilles do not present an historic appearance and should not
be used.
15. Do not use tinted or mirrored glass on major facades of the building. Translucent or low (e) glass
may be strategies to keep heat gain down.
[…]
APPENDIX
1920 and 1968 Sanborn Map
Charlottesville Census listings for business operators and residents, 1922-1960:
Unit #701- Carter Blakey Drug Co. (1931), Durrer’s Drug (1940-50) then West Main Druggist’s
(1960)
Unit #701 ½- residence of Fred Holt, Elias Commings, Cecil Carrol, Thomas Businger (1940), Thomas
J. Businger, Mary K Humphreys (1950), Lonzie J. Carter (1960).
Unit #703 was the location of Midway Market Meats and Grocery for more than fifty years.
Unit # 705 Albemarle Maytag (1940-1950s), George’s Place, general merchandise (1960).
701-705 West Main Street – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 5
Key For Identifying Windows
Control Picture
Google Slide Deck Notated Windows:
Apt A 1 = 1 Apt B 1 = 6 Apt C 1 = 13
Apt A 2 = 2 Apt B 2 = 7 Apt C 2 = 14
Apt A 3 = 3 Apt B 3 = 8 Apt C 3 = 15
Apt A 4 = 4 Apt B 4 = 9
Apt B 5 = 10
Apt B 6 = 11
Apt B 7 = 12
701 West Main
Street (2nd story)
Replacing windows
for units A, B, C, D, E
Apartment
Apartment A Window 3 -
38” x 66 ¼”
Apartment B Window 1 -
Apartment B Window 2 -
38” x 66 ¼”
Apartment B Window 3 -
38” x 66 ¼”
Apartment B Window 4 -
36” x 54”
Apartment B Window 5 -
36” x 54”
Staff note: Not the
correct exterior image
for Apt. B window 6.
Apartment B Window 6 -
Staff note: Exterior
photograph for Apt. B
window 6 (#11 in the
control image).
Apartment C Window 2 -
36” x 54”
Apartment C Window 3 -
36” x 54”
Apartment C Window 4 -
36” x 54”
Apartment C Window 6 -
Apartment C Window 5 -
Apartment D Window 1 -
Apartment D Window 2 -
Line #1
Qty: 8
Mark Unit: Front
FS 37 5/8" X 66 17/64"
IO 38" X 66"
Stone White Clad Exterior
Primed Pine Interior
Ultimate Double Hung Insert G2
Inside Opening 38" X 66"
#ALLOWANCE FOR FRAME EXPANDERS
8° Degree Frame Bevel
Top Sash
Stone White Clad Sash Exterior
Primed Pine Sash Interior
IG - 1 Lite
Low E2 w/Argon
Silver Stainless Steel Perimeter Bar
Ogee Interior Glazing Profile
Bottom Sash
Stone White Clad Sash Exterior
Primed Pine Sash Interior
IG - 1 Lite
Low E2 w/Argon
Silver Stainless Steel Perimeter Bar
Ogee Interior Glazing Profile
White Interior Weather Strip Package
White Exterior Weather Strip Package
White Sash Lock
White Top Sash Strike Plate Assembly Color
Extruded Aluminum Screen
Stone White Surround
Bright View Mesh
***Screen/Combo Ship Loose
3 1/4" Jambs
# Non system generated Pricing
***Note: Unit Availability and Price is Subject to Change
OMS Ver. 0004.19.01 (Current) Processed on: 2/10/2026 1:30:35 PM Page 3 of 4
For product warranty information please visit, www.marvin.com/support/warranty
Line #2
Qty: 11
Mark Unit: Side/Back
FS 35 5/8" X 54 17/64"
IO 36" X 54"
Stone White Clad Exterior
Primed Pine Interior
Ultimate Double Hung Insert G2
Inside Opening 36" X 54"
#ALLOWANCE FOR FRAME EXPANDERS
8° Degree Frame Bevel
Top Sash
Stone White Clad Sash Exterior
Primed Pine Sash Interior
IG
Low E2 w/Argon
Silver Stainless Steel Perimeter and Spacer Bar
7/8" SDL - With Spacer Bar - Silver
Rectangular - Special Cut 3W2H
Stone White Clad Ext - Primed Pine Int
Ogee Interior Glazing Profile
Bottom Sash
Stone White Clad Sash Exterior
Primed Pine Sash Interior
IG
Low E2 w/Argon
Silver Stainless Steel Perimeter and Spacer Bar
7/8" SDL - With Spacer Bar - Silver
Rectangular - Special Cut 3W2H
Stone White Clad Ext - Primed Pine Int
Ogee Interior Glazing Profile
White Interior Weather Strip Package
White Exterior Weather Strip Package
White Sash Lock
White Top Sash Strike Plate Assembly Color
Aluminum Screen
Stone White Surround
Bright View Mesh
***Screen/Combo Ship Loose
3 1/4" Jambs
# Non system generated Pricing
***Note: Unit Availability and Price is Subject to Change
OMS Ver. 0004.19.01 (Current) Processed on: 2/10/2026 1:30:35 PM Page 4 of 4
For product warranty information please visit, www.marvin.com/support/warranty
%
U
O
T
l
o
X h W W
]
¡ �
Á½
«
Ð Ð
�
µ
X OWW
O
YX R S
O T
W\W
Q U
U
T T R UO eO
]
] ]
]Q]
\ W
O
O
Y]
W
W
X O
X ] V
O O
O
X
W
W
O O _ W
W
R XO
O
U U UO OO
O O S U l TeO Q ]
T RlQ RU X
X
X Q XTU OO
X l X R X Q U O X
W O
QQO
O
O
O
�
° ˜ ! "
! #
$
%
!
& ' (
)
!
"
!
˘
* +
ˇ
,-
ˆ
. /
!
˙
0
˝
1 2
3 4
˛
1
5
6 ˜ 7 8 9 : 9 ; < ; = > ? @ = A B
C D. E ! # $ / E 0 ( * / E 0 3 F . E ! ,4 E/ 2 3 - E5 G H - . ) / ! F # I / ! ( - / 0 - . ) / ! F J > ,4 E/ 2 3 - E5
NO
K L
P Q R
2 -
S
. /
U
!
P
7
V
0
U
" #
W Q
M
X
/
O
Y Z
( ! 2 - . / ! 7 0 " / ,- . / ! 0 1 2 3 4 1 5
[
U \ ] ^ O _ T X ` X ` O \ Y T ] Y a V T W S T R b ] _ R O Y X _ ] c O Q Y U Q b ] Z d O ec P ] eeO R X U a O W ] _ f _ ` T P ` [ U ` Q Y O S _ T X ` g O h T R i T S S W O W Q U X jQ c Z
k O l
m n o pn q r n q s t u v w
xy z { | } y ~ � } • z • } † ‡ { y | … —
– • z y ƒ … � ⁄ ‡ … … • }
‹ › X c ] l − ` Q Y W ] X O U T O
‰ O T b ` a ] Y `] S „ O h O W ] \ eO R X d O Y h T P O U
“ ” “ ‘ ’ ‚ ™ ‘ ” f ” ™ f
Ł Œ Š Ÿ Œ Š Ž ı łœ š ž Š � € ¡ Œ ¢ £ ¤ � Œ ¥ ¦ € £
§ ¨
¶
©
·
ª« ¬�
¸ « ¹ º � »
®
¼
¯ �
³
®
°
°
¾
± �
º
²
¿
®
º
�
»
³
À
´
Á ° Á Â Á Ã Á Ä Å Á Æ Ç
È © ± É ´ É Ê Ë Ì É ½ ͽ » ο ͽ Ï Ð É Ñ Ò ÍÓ
Ô Õ « Ǻ ® Ö × ³ ° ÇÒ Ð Ï � Ê Íº ® Ö × ³ ÍÒ ÎÑ × ½ ® Ð Ò Ø � » Ù Ï Ð � É ¿ Ò Ù Ó
µ Ú Û Ü ¶ Õ ¸ « Ý Þ Ä ¬Ï ¯ ¼ Ò ß ® � Ö Ð ½ Ñ � Í� ¯ À ½ À à  Šá à  ⠬� » À ǽ Ï ¯ ã À ® � À
k ä å
U T b R S Q \ \ W P Q X T R Q R S P ` O P ^ l ] Y ë f ê ì l O Z
í Y O l O Y O R P T U _ S f eO X Q W f ] Y X Q W ‘ P W Q S Z é ` O ä ç i ` Q U Q \ \ Y ] h O S Q \ Y ] î O P X V U T R b ç R S O Y U O R ï U /245 /246 /247 /248 /249 /250 f _ ` T P ` T U Q P ] e\ ] U T X O eQ X O Y T Q W Z /251 T R c W ] Y \ X P _ S ] _ Q Y O
RX Q W ] _ O S Z /252 ] _ T R S ] _ l Y Q eO T R U O Y U f _ O ` Q h O Q \ Y ] h S í W Q /253 /249 /254 /249 /248 /255 /249 f jQ Y h T R � /246 /249 Q R S ç R S O Y U O R /249 /248 /246 /249 /254 /248 /246 [ R U V W Q X S b Q U T U l T R O Z j] U X ] l
eV R X T R S ] O U R ï X eQ X O Y X ` Q X eV P ` f a V X X ` O _ T S X ` U ` ] V W S a O a O X _ O R ì Q R S ‚ Z
c ] V Y _ T R S ] _ U Q Y O f ‘ ] h O Y ‘ f f a V X l ] Y ` O ‘ ] h O Y ‘ c P Q R V U T R U V W Q X O S _ T X ` X ` O Q \ W T O S b Y T W O U f \ Y ] h T S O S X ` O Y O T U Q R T R X O Y R Q W U \ Q P O Y a Q Y f U O a O W ] _ Z é ` O \ Y ] l T W O ] l X ` O
i O \ W Q P T
R b Q W ` O _ T _ U _ T
W O æ V T Y O ä ç i \ \ Y ] h Q W Z ‰ O è X eO O X T R b T U d O \ X O ea O Y f ’ f _ T X ` U V a eT X Q W S O Q S W T R O R O è X é V O U S Q c f ç V b V U X ê ’ Z NO _ ] V W S R O S l Y ] e
cV Q
X ` Q X T U U T eT W Q Y Z d O ç a O W ] Z ˘ é ` O c ` Q h O R ] X Q W ] O S T R U O Y X l Y Q eO U X ` Q X Y O æ V T Y O _ T S O eO X Q W l W Q U ` T R b X ` Q X O W T eT R Q X O U ] Y P ] R P O Q W U X ` O O è X O Y T ] Y X Y T eZ d O ä a O W ] _ Z ˘
d O P ] R S f X ` O ä ç i` Q U Q \ \ Y ] h O S T R U O Y X l Y Q eO U f a V X X ` O c eV U T X Y O W Q T h O W c X T b ` X T R X ] X ` O ] \ O R T R b QS Y O T R X ` O O è T X T R b O è X Y T ] Y Y T e
] Y Q X W O Q U X ` Q h O U ] eO X ` T R b R O _
í Y T eQ Y c
_ _
æ V O T ] R l ] Y c ] V f X ` ä ç i_ T W _ R X X ] ^] __ ` c Y \ W Q P O eO R X T U RP Q Y c f T R X O Q S ]Y O \ Q T Y U Z é ` _ S ] _ U eQ c R S R O b Q T R b Q R S \ Q T X f a V X ` Q X
S ] O U R ï X Q R ` O c eV U X a O Y O \ W P O S f U c ] V ï W R X ] \ Y ] h T S O \ ` ] X ] ] X ` O O è T U X R b Z ç U [ eO R X T ] R O S W Q U X _ O ^ f [ a O W T O h O X ` O ä ç i _ T W a O e] Y O Q eO R Q a W O X ]
Y \ W Q P O eO R X U Q X X ` T S O Q R S Y Q Y f T l c ] V U Q W h b O Q R S Y O V U O O è U X T R b U U ` l ] Y X ` O T b ` _ T R S ] _ U l P T R b NO U jQ T R Z
�
'ˇ
ˆ ˙ ˇ ˇ
ˇ .
˙
� � �
�
�
�
�
�
�
/ �
? =
ˇ
�
�
t
“ i
W
j �
ƒ
�
�
�
� t t c � � � � … …
�ƒ
t �b
c t�� � i c � � �t
�
�
�
j
j
g g
�
�
�
� c ‹t t �
ƒ i
ƒ
ƒ
�
�
�
a
�
�
j
�
� � j jŁ Œ �
�
� a j
ƒ �
�
�
�
W
� � �
u
ƒ ƒ
�
�
�
�
� � ˘ � ˇ
˝
ˆ
˘ ˙
˛
�
ˇ
˙
!
"
ˇ
#
"
$
%
ˇ
&
°
'
˜ �
( '
˙
)
�
*
0
�
1
+
0
"
&
ˇ
2
,
)
�
"
-
1
�
'
1
�
)
.
& ) .
* ˜ ˇ / � 3 4 5 6 4 5 7 8 9: ; < 5 = > ? 4 @ A B = 4 C D > A
[
G
] ^ �
J L � N
b
P
�
RQ TU
h
`
RQ
j k
X W
�
R
k l l
�
E F
\
HI
I _`
K K M O
d
Q
f
S
i � l
V
k
P Y
�
Z
k �
r G st�
“
I
�
t J � e ua u
”‘ ’ ‚
t
™ ‚ f f � Ł
v
Œ
u
…
t
i
d
� t
� L y y
‹c …
� M w x
ƒ � Œ c
x z
i � ` u …
N O
h … a
TX
c
{
j t b
Q W
�
Y
Š
y
u
|
`
} Y U W V S x P x
‹� G ~ ^ Ÿ Ž ı \ � G
}
ł �
Z
^ œ \ � G F š ž ] Ž � ž € G ] K � ¡ ` � a ` j � ⁄ ƒ … ⁄ ¢ � ƒ … a ¢ i � ` u � ` – t a � c £ c ⁄ Œ ‹t a j i � g a ƒ t i � d ` g � u t ⁄ ` h a … ¤ t � j Œ t � i t a b t u � c a b � ¢ a ` — � j Œ t � ⁄ ` a j t a j � … i � i c Š t K “ “
[ ~ � • \ † ^ I � ‡
a
t o
c
� s…
e
a
g
b
g
— � u t – ƒ
e
c ⁄
m
t ‹t
n
a �
o
c j
p
� ›
q
m
_
l − › m ‰ � st i j _c … a � „ j u t j
¥ … � J t v e
¦ � Œ c § t ¨ a � j ƒ ¢ … a h — … j Œ i ` ‹t ` Š � j Œ t � s… a b ` — © ` ‹– c a t i � j Œ c j � — t � c u t � ⁄ ` a i … b t u a h � ` a � j Œ t — … a b ` — � u t – ƒ c ⁄ t ‹t a j K � Ł Œ t � — … a b ` — i � — … ƒ � ¨ t � ⁄ g i j ` ‹� j ` � ª j � j Œ t � c ⁄ j g c ƒ � ` – t a … a h � c a b � j u … ‹
— ` g ƒ b � ¨ t � — u c – – t b � … a � c � © ` c j t b � f ƒ ‹… a ‹� c a b � ¨ t � « ` � — … t u � j Œ c a � j Œ t � u … ‹� j Œ c j … i – u i t a j a ` — K
Ł Œ t d � Œ c § t � i t § u c � ‹c j t u … c ƒ ` – ¬ ` a i � Š ` u � u t – ƒ c ⁄ t ‹t a j — … a b ` — � ` j Œ t u � Œ a … a d ƒ � … Š j Œ t L f ‡ — … ƒ a ` j � c – – u ` § t � … a d ƒ K � © a � d ` g � h … § � ‹t � c a � … b t c � ` Š � — Œ c j � j d – t � ` Š � ‹c j t u … c ƒ � j Œ t � L f ‡ � — ` g ƒ b
c – – u ` § t � Š ` u � u t – c ⁄ t a j e � ƒ … ¢ f ƒ g ‹… a g ‹e � _t j c ƒ e � f � © ` ‹– ` i … j t � _c j t u … c ƒ e � ® j ⁄ K ¯ � f a d � Œ t ƒ – � d ` g � ⁄ ` g ƒ b � h … § t � — ` g ƒ b � ¨ t � c – – u t ⁄ … c j t b K
¦ c ƒ i ` � ⁄ c ƒ t b � c a b � ƒ t ° � c � ‹t i c h t � ` a � d ` g u � ` ±⁄ t � a g ‹¨ t u � j ` b c d K
�
Ł Œ c a ¢ � d ` g
J L � f h t t
�
² a Ł
v
Œ g e � f g h � l m e � k m k n � c j � l l o m n ³ f _� J K L K � M N O P Q RQ S TU RQ V W P X Y R Z � — u ` t o
`
J t e
` ` ` ` ¨ ` ` ¨ ¨ `
¨ ` `
�
c
t
b
i
c
c
a
i
b
Œ t
—
i � c
u a �
b �
g
Š u
j
c
K
‹t i � a � j Œ t � Š u a j � — … a b — i � c u t � a j c i � c b � c i � j Œ t � — … a b — i � a � j Œ t � i … b t � c a b c ⁄ ¢ e � g � Œ t � j u c ⁄ ¢ i � j Œ c j � j Œ t � — … a b — i � i t j � … a � c a b � ‹` § t � g – � c a b � b — a � … a � c u t � § t u d
Ł Œ t � a t — — … a b ` — i � — ` g ƒ b ` � u t ´ g … u t � i j ` u ‹� — … a b ` — i � ƒ … ¢ t � j Œ t � ` a t i � ` a � j Œ t u t � a ` — � Œ c § t � — Œ … ⁄ Œ � b … i j u c ⁄ j i � j Œ t � Œ … i j ` u … ⁄ � ƒ ` ` ¢ � ` Š � j Œ t � ¨ g … ƒ b … a h K � Ł Œ t � a t — � — … a b ` — i � — ` g ƒ b � h … § t � j Œ t
¨ g … ƒ b … a h � c � ‹` u t � Œ … i j ` u … ⁄ c ƒ � a c j g u c � ƒ ` ` ¢ ¦ � j Œ … a ¢ K
J L
�
² a
µ
�
¶
²
Ł
t
`
a
Œ
i
`
�
K
g
Ł
�
b
st
e
Œ
�
f
_`
g
g
e
�
�
c
f
h
u
�
g
a
t
l
h
�
m
…
ƒ
a
�
`
e
l
�
h
`
k
m
� J
m
¢
e
t
�
…
k
k
a
v
n
m
h
K �
k
�
c
c
n
j
j
�
�
�
l
c
u
j
m
t
�
–
o
l
n
ƒ
m
c
‰
o
⁄
�
m
f
…
¸
a
_�
�
h
f
� c
Q RQ
_� st
J K L
ƒ � j
K � M N
Œ t
O
u
� —
a
P
t
… a
u e
S
b
� J
`
t
—
TU RQ
v
i
u t
� `
d
a
� L
P W V
�
X
j
�
Œ
M
t
w
Y R
� i
x
t ⁄
y z
Z
`
x
� —
a
y
�
N
b
u j
O
`
… Œ � u
TX
·
t
`
o
`
{ Q
—
y W
⁄
Y | x
Œ i
S
� … k �
} V
p
W x
j
P
�
U
j
Y
` ƒ
}
c
Z �
K
—
� ²
u
a
`
ƒ
j
d
t
�
o
` a � i t ⁄ ` a b � · ` ` u K � « ` a t � — … ƒ � ¨ t � u t – ƒ c ⁄ t b � ` a � ª u i j � · ` ` u K
J L
�
$ /
˛
�
˘
ˇ
ˆ
˙ ˝
˛ ° ˜
ˆ
° ˝ ˙ ! ° ˙ " ˝ " # ˝ ˙ # $ % ˆ & ' ( ˝ ˜
˙ " ! # ° ˝ ˙ ˝ $
� �
�
�
�
� ˝ �
� � � � � � �
� � � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � ˘ �
� � ˇ � � � ˘ � ˆ ˙
˝
˝ ˆ ˜ ˝ ˇ ! ˙ ˆ
!
˝
"
ˆ
ˆ
˙
ˆ
!
˝
˝
˝
˛
°
°
˘ ˇ ˆ ˙
ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ
8
A
S Q
)
0
0
4
� ˘ ˇ
˜
�
˜
˙
"
˝
˜
˛
°
!
�
ˆ
˘
!
#
�
*
�
7 .
8
.
G
0
C
1.
I
:
�
ˇ
;
%
3
K
E
&
MN
C
>
0
'
E
P
4
?
Q
@
)
R H U H U
˜
6
F
+
$
/
9 4
/
2
˘
,
-
A
B
H
B
ˇ
J
(
H
2
8
D
I
4
ˇ
<
4
ˇ
L
0
=
5 2
)
?
C
O
(
,
0
I
?
S T V Q W X R
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
February 18, 2026
Discussion: Certificate of Appropriateness
Downtown Mall – Pedestrian sections of East & West Main Street
Owner: City of Charlottesville
Applicant: Michael Goddard, Deputy Director, Public Works
Project: Downtown Mall Trashcan Replacement Plan
Background
The Downtown Pedestrian Mall was designed by Lawrence Halprin Associates from 1973-76. The first
five blocks of East Main Street were pedestrianized in 1976. In 1980 the mall was extended by two
blocks on West Main Street. The west end (at the Omni) was completed in 1985. The east end
completed in 2006 with construction of the Transit Center, Freedom of Expression wall, and the
Amphitheater.
Wallace, Roberts and Todd, LLC (WRT) prepared a Downtown Mall Schematic Design Report in
Spring 2004, revised in May 2005, as part of a coordinated series of projects downtown. The report
recognized the success of the 1970’s Lawrence Halprin mall design and recommended minimal
intervention to repair age-related decline. The report also recommended expanding the perceived width
of the mall to include Market and Water Streets, with pedestrian connections to other neighborhoods
via West Main, Second, and Fourth Streets.
Prior BAR Reviews (For brevity, a complete summary has been omitted.)
May 20, 2025 – BAR approved with conditions, repairs to vehicular crossings at 4
th Street East and 2nd
Street West.
November 18, 2008 – BAR approved paving design for vehicular crossings at 4th Street East and 2nd
Street West.
Application
• Applicant submittal: Petoskey Litter Receptacles Product Data Sheet and Product Drawing,
submitted February 2, 2026, 2 pages.
CoA request for proposed litter receptacles to be installed on the Downtown Mall. Existing cans,
which are not original to the Mall, are no longer available. The currently used cans did not replicate the
original cans designed by Lawrence Halprin & Associates for the initial phase of the Mall, in fact, they
are entirely different. Therefore, the only reason for selecting a type/style that is similar to the current
trash cans is for continuity of design, and not to reflect on or represent an original element. No
immediate replacements are planned; however, this review is necessary to establish the new type that
will be used moving forward, when necessary. (See the Appendix for staff correspondence with the
applicant.)
Discussion and Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of the requested CoA with the condition that damaged granite pavers
(where tube frames are removed) will be replaced in-kind.
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 1
Suggested Motion
Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District
Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed replacement trash cans on the Downtown Mall satisfy
the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with the Downtown Mall and this ADC District, and that the
BAR approves the application [as submitted].
Or, [as submitted with the following conditions: …].
Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District
Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed replacement trash cans on the Downtown Mall do not
satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are not compatible with the Downtown Mall and this ADC District, and
that for the following reasons the BAR denies the application as submitted: …
Criteria, Standards and Guidelines
Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a
design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major
Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34-
5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction,
alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a
building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance
with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.”
Review Criteria Generally
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character
of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic
Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given
to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive
Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design
guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane to this request.]
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1:
a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and
factors:
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 2
i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed
addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the
site and the applicable District;
ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs;
iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of
Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant;
iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures;
v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as
gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks;
vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an
adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures;
vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the
standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and
viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
Pertinent Design Review Guidelines for Public Design and Improvements
Chapter 6 Public Improvements
B. Plazas, Parks & Open Spaces
1. Maintain existing spaces and important site features for continued public use consistent with the
original design intent.
[…]
5. Exterior furniture and site accessories should be compatible with the overall character of the park
or open space.
Appendix
Existing
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 3
Proposed
Simulation of replacement
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 4
From: Dooms, Clifton Sent: Monday, February 2, 2026 12:09 PM
Context
A representative from the manufacturer, Landscape Forms, has confirmed that the existing trash
receptacles—identified as the Petoskey Litter Tube Support units (attached)—are no longer being
produced and were officially discontinued on December 5, 2025.
Prior to this discontinuation, all static assets on the Downtown Mall were inventoried and
assessed for condition. That assessment identified seven (7) trash receptacles requiring
immediate replacement, with additional units requiring servicing or lower mounting covers. Due
to funding availability and procurement timelines, six (6) replacement receptacles matching the
existing installations, along with 25+ base covers, were ordered at a cost of approximately
$19,500. These units have since been installed.
Following installation, a subsequent assessment identified additional receptacles that will require
replacement in the near future. Upon contacting the manufacturer again, I was informed of the
product discontinuation and provided with a recommended replacement unit, the Petoskey Litter
– No Tube Support model (also attached).
Details and Comparisons
• The current unit and the recommended replacement are very similar in appearance, with the
primary difference being the absence of tubular supports on the replacement unit.
• Unit dimensions are comparable:
o Current unit: 47” H × 23.75” D × 27” W
o Recommended unit: 42” H × 20.5” D (width not provided in the specification sheet)
• Replacement units will be ordered in the same finish, Gloss Black.
• Replacement units will be mounted in the existing locations with no changes to servicing
procedures.
• The current units require clearance to allow for emptying, whereas the recommended units
utilize a hinged lid, eliminating impacts to pedestrian circulation.
• The perforated patterns of the new unit match the preexisting unit
• The trash receptacle openings are an exact match
• The trash receptacles referenced are not historic features and are not original to Halprin’s
design.
Request
Based on the context provided, we are seeking approval to move forward with ordering the
manufacturer-recommended replacement units and to begin phasing out the current trash
receptacles. This phase-out would occur over time rather than through immediate removal or
replacement. This approach will allow for an orderly transition while maintaining operational
continuity and minimizing visual impact.
Hyperlink for the recommended unit- Petoskey Litter - Landscape Forms
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 5
From: Dooms, Clifton Sent: Friday, February 13, 2026 8:26 AM
Jeff, The preexisting trash receptacle and its tubing would be completely removed. In its place,
the newer surface mounted receptacle would be mounted or anchored down. No tubing would
remain.
History has shown that there were no repairs conducted once removed. 90% of the receptacles
are mounted in the granite bandings on the Mall (the rest in either concrete or pavers themselves).
Back to the history, there is current evidence where receptacles have been replaced due to
damage or simple corrective alignment with their old placement apparent from the drill holes or
ground off hardware. If this practice is an issue (assuming it is). Granite, concrete, or pavers that
once held the receptacles would require replacement. With that said, we just awarded a contract
for paver/ granite repair on the Mall. When the time comes to phase the older receptacles out, a
repair can be made as we have the specs on the stone/ materials and the means to get it complete.
DT Mall trash can replacements – February 18, 2026 (2/13) 6
Product Data Sheet
Petoskey™
1
Revised September 27, 2024 | Landscape Forms Inc. | 800.521.2546 | F 269.381.3455 | 7800 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI 49048
Like the prized coral fossil stone that shares its names, Petoskey is
pleasing to the eye and solid as a rock. The Petoskey Litter receptacle
is engineered for active commercial and institutional spaces and has
become a favorite for courtyards, city parks, university campuses, open
air retail malls, and transportation hubs.
Litter Receptacles
• Formed of 11-gauge steel.
• Receptacles with hinged lid features a standard freestanding/surface
mount base.
• Recycling receptacles are available in 5" opening, 3"h x 11 newspaper
slot opening, or standard side opening.
• Recycling receptacles come with 10"x10" signs. Select standard
wording from options available on landscapeforms.com. (Custom
wording is available for an upcharge)
• Custom fit 30-gallon polyethylene liner supplied with both litter
receptacle styles.
Metal Finishes
• Metal parts are fnished with Landscape Forms’ exclusive Panguard
II® polyester powdercoat, a hard yet fexible fnishing process that
resists rusting, chipping, peeling and fading.
To Specify
• Litter Receptacle: Select Petoskey receptacle, choose top or side
opening, and select powdercoat color.
• For Recycling Receptacle: Select opening style, powdercoat color, and
signage.
Designed by Beckett and Raeder, Inc. and Arno Yurk, AIA, IDSA.
Click here for patent information related to this product.
Style Depth Width Height Product
Weight
litter
receptacle, 20.5" n/a 42" 112 lb
hinged lid
recycling
receptacle,
w/ 20.5" n/a 42" 112 lb
signage
Visit landscapeforms.com for more information. Specifcations are
subject to change without notice. Landscape Forms supports the
Landscape Architecture Foundation at the Second Century level.
©2024 Landscape Forms, Inc. Printed in U.S.A.
Litter Receptacle Date: June 22, 2016
Installation Guide www.landscapeforms.com Ph: 800.521.2546
Petoskey™
Fig. 1 –H i n g e d lid latch
Hinged lid receptacle
Tools Required
• Safety glasses
Surface mounting hinged‐lid receptacle:
• (2) non‐corrosive anchors, maximum 3/8” diameter (not included)
PROCEDURE FOR INSTALLATION:
FOR HINGED LID FREESTANDING LITTER RECEPTACLE:
Unit ships fully assembled and can be set in place.
FOR SURFACE MOUNT LITTER RECEPTACLE:
NOTE: It is not recommended to locate holes for anchoring until unit is on site.
1. Place the unit in the desired position. Lift lid and remove liner.
2. Mark anchor locations through the holes in the anchor plates.
3. Move the unit to allow access for drilling holes.
4. Drill holes at marked locations according to anchor manufacturer’s specification.
5. Complete the anchor installation according to the anchor manufacturer’s instructions.
TO OPEN UNIT:
Hinged lid: See Fig. 1. A plastic putty knife with a minimum 3‐1/2” blade may be also be used to
push down on the lever by sliding it in the gap between the lid and the body near the hinge.
Fig. 2 –H i n g e d lid clearances
LITTER
[610mm]
Ø24” MIN
CONCRETE
PAD
LITTER
OPENING
Fig. 3 ‐ Hinged lid receptacle anchor tabs
ASSEMBLE WITH CARE! Pangard II Polyester Powdercoat is a strong, long‐lasting finish. To protect
this finish during assembly, place unwrapped powdercoated parts on packaging foam or other non‐
marring surface. Do not place or slide powdercoated parts on concrete or other hard or textured
surface – this will damage the finish causing rust to occur. Use touch‐up paint on any gouges in the
finish caused by assembly tools.
Page 1 of 1
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
February 18, 2026
Pre-application Discussion
BAR # HST26-0002
528 Valley Road; TMP 11-70 (and portion of 11-71)
Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District
Owner: Andrew Fossen; AVP 528 Valley LLC
Applicant: Raymond Gaines, The Gaines Group
Project: Construction of nine townhomes
Background
Year Built: 1937
District: Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District
Status: Contributing
The vernacular Colonial Revival-style brick dwelling is 1-1/2 stories with a gabled roof and three
gabled dormers. The façade features a five-bay integral porch with brick posts and round-arched
bays. Initially the home of Peter Witzel and his family, from 1950 until at least 1961 it was
occupied by Jack Compton and his family. More recently, the dwelling has been a rental.
Prior BAR Review
n/a
Project
• Applicant submittal: 528 Valley Road, undated. 10 sheets.
Pre-application discussion. Construction of three (3) multi-unit structures immediately adjacent to a
1937 brick dwelling. No alterations to the existing building are currently proposed. (Note: The
parking area, which is within the BAR’s purview, encroaches onto 526 Valley Road. For this pre-
app discussion, and for simplicity, staff is referring to the project as 528 Valley Road.)
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 1
Per code section 5.2.7. Major Historic Review, B. Application Requirement, a pre-application
conference with the entire BAR is mandatory for a development having a projected construction
cost of $350,000.00 or more.
Discussion
Objectives of a preliminary discussion: Introduce the project to the BAR; and allow the applicant
and the BAR to establish what is necessary for a successful final submittal. That is, a final submittal
that is complete and provides the information necessary for the BAR to evaluate the project using
the ADC District Design Guidelines and related review criteria.
During a preliminary discussion the BAR may, by consensus, express an opinion about the project
as presented. (For example, the BAR might express consensus support for elements of the project,
such as its scale and massing.) Such comments will not constitute a formal motion and the result
will have no legal bearing, nor will it represent an incremental decision on the required CoA.
In response to any questions from the applicant and/or for any recommendations to the applicant,
the BAR should rely on the germane sections of the ADC District Design Guidelines and related
review criteria. While elements of other chapters may be relevant, staff recommends that the BAR
refer to the criteria in Chapter 2--Site Design and Elements and Chapter 3--New Construction and
Additions.
Of assistance are the following criteria from Chapter 3:
• Setback • Windows & Doors
• Spacing • Porches
• Massing & Footprint • Foundation & Cornice
• Height & Width • Materials & Textures
• Scale • Paint [Color palette]
• Roof • Details & Decoration
• Orientation
Elements:
• Roof • Railings
• Gutters & Downspouts • Balcony details
• Exterior walls • Plantings/Landscaping
• Trim • Patios & walks
• Doors & Windows • Public spaces
• Lighting • Screening (HVAC, utilities.)
The BAR should also consider the building elements and details necessary to evaluate the project. Renderings
and schematics communicate mass, scale, design and composition; however, a complete application should
include details and specific information about the project’s materials and components. For example:
• Measured drawings: Elevations, wall details, etc.
• Roofing: Flat, hipped, etc. Metal, slate, asphalt. Flashing details.
• Gutters/downspouts: Types, color, locations, etc.
• Foundation.
• Walls: Masonry, siding, stucco, etc.
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 2
• Soffit, cornice, siding, and trim.
• Color palette.
• Doors and windows: Type, lite arrangement, glass spec, trim details, etc.
• Porches and decks: Materials, railing and stair design, etc.
• Landscaping/hardscaping: Grading, trees, low plants, paving materials, etc.
• Lighting. Fixture cut sheets, lamping, etc.
Oakhurst-Gildersleeve Neighborhood ADC District
Located in the southwestern section of the City near the University of Virginia, this neighborhood
has a remarkable collection of houses and apartment dwellings that have housed University faculty
and students for over 90 years. Properties dating from the 1910’s to the 1960’s include a range of
architectural styles including Craftsman, Colonial Revival, Dutch Colonial Revival, Tudor Revival,
Minimal Traditional and Cape Cod.
b. Valley Road/Valley Circle/Maywood Lane: At the bottom of the hill is Valley Road with a
small creek running alongside it. Mostly 1930’s dwellings on smaller lots. Both Valley Road
and Maywood Lane feature some older stone and frame dwellings.
Spatial Elements
The following comments are intended as a general summary of key design criteria and to provide a
framework for the BAR’s discussion. To establish the general characteristics and spatial elements of
the surrounding area, staff looked at 15 properties within the eastern section of Subarea B.
• Setbacks: Within 20 percent of the setbacks of a majority of the neighborhood dwellings.
o The median front setback is approximately 33-ft, ranging between 14-ft and 64-ft.
The recommended setback for a new building would be between 26-ft and 40-ft feet.
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 3
Front setback for the proposed new structures: Building #1 is approximately
14-ft; Building # 2 is approximately 55-ft. Building #3 is behind #2.
Per R-B zoning, a front setback can be between 10-ft and 20-ft, or within the
existing range of nearby properties.
• Spacing: Within 20 percent of the average spacing between houses on the block. [Note: The new
structures are on the same parcel as the existing dwelling at 528 Valley Road.]
o The median side spacing is approximately 46-ft, ranging between 13-ft and 100-ft.
The recommended spacing for a new building would be between 38-ft and 55-ft from
the adjacent buildings.
Building #1 is approximately 20-ft from 528 Valley Road.
Building #2 is approximately 12-ft from 528 Valley Road.
Building #3 is approximately 12-ft from Building #2.
• Massing and Footprint: Relate to the majority of the surrounding historic dwellings.
o The average footprint (1st floor area) is approximately 926 sq ft, ranging from 558 sq
ft to 1,562 sq ft. The dwelling at 528 Valley Road is 1,132 sq ft.
Each of the proposed buildings will have a footprint of approx. 1,500 sq ft.
Per R-B zoning, the maximum footprint permitted is 3,500 sq ft.
• Height and Width: Keep the height and width within a maximum of 200 percent of the
prevailing height and width.
o Height. The prevailing height is one-and-one-half stories. The recommended max
height of a new building would be three stories.
The proposed buildings will be three stories.
Per R-B zoning, for a duplex, a maximum height of three stories (40-ft) is
permitted.
o Width. The average building width is approximately 36-ft, ranging between 28-ft
and 68-ft. The recommended max width of a building would be approximately 72-ft.
Building #1 is approximately 60-ft wide.
Buildings #2 and 3 are approximately 48-ft wide.
Per R-B zoning, the maximum permitted width of a new building is 60-ft.
Architectural styles and materials
Characteristics within the east section of Subarea B:
• Year built: Median is 1938, ranging from 1930 to 1948. The majority (10) were built in the
1930s.
• Styles: The majority (11) are Cape Code or Colonial Revival cottage style.
• Materials: The majority (9) are brick.
Recommendations:
This project represents a primary goal of the Code of Development: to introduce infill, residential
development. In that context, the BAR is likely to see similar requests going forward, which
suggests how the BAR evaluates this project will likely inform those later projects.
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 4
Second, it is worth noting that one option for this project was to raze (if approved) the existing,
historic dwelling. The applicant opted to retain it. In that context, the project might already be
viewed as a preservation success.
Prior to discussing the proposed structures, staff recommends the BAR establish a framework to
guide that evaluation. For example, should the primary focus be compatibility with the surrounding
ADC District, the entirety of Subarea B, the eastern section of Subarea B (as presented by staff), or
the existing brick dwelling on the subject property? Additionally, the three proposed buildings are
essentially identical. In evaluating compatibility, consideration might be given to the respective
locations on the lot and in relation to the existing dwelling. For example, while the new and existing
buildings on the same parcel, Buildings #2 and 3 might be evaluated as additions, and therefore
should be subordinate to the existing dwelling; whereas Building #1 might be evaluated as a new
building on a separate parcel, and not necessarily require it be subordinate to the existing dwelling.
Suggested Motions
Pre-application conference. No action will be taken.
Criteria, Standards and Guidelines
Review Criteria Generally
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and
character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or
Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration
will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the
Comprehensive Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with
the City’s design guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [Not germane to this
request.]
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1:
a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features
and factors:
i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed
addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with
the site and the applicable District;
ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs;
iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of
Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant;
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 5
iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures;
v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as
gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks;
vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an
adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures;
vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the
standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and
viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
Pertinent Guidelines for New Construction and Additions
Link:
Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions
A. Introduction
[…]
3. Building Types within the Historic Districts
When designing new buildings in the historic districts, one needs to recognize that while there is an
overall distinctive district character, there is, nevertheless, a great variety of historic building types,
styles, and scales throughout the districts and sub-areas that are described in Chapter 1:
Introduction. Likewise, there are several types of new construction that might be constructed within
the districts the design parameters of these new buildings will differ depending on the following
types
[…]
b. Residential Infill
These buildings are new dwellings that are constructed on the occasional vacant lot within a
block of existing historic houses. Setback, spacing, and general massing of the new dwelling
are the most important criteria that should relate to the existing historic structures, along
with residential roof and porch forms.
528 Valley Road – Pre-application Feb 18, 2026 (2/12) 6
Oakhurst-Gildersleeve ADC District, east section of Subarea B For discussion only 2/12/26 1 of 3
505 Valley Road (1948)
528
505
507
513
515
521
507 Valley Road (1940) 513 Valley Road (1940)
515 Valley Road (1937) 521 Valley Road (1935)
Oakhurst-Gildersleeve ADC District, east section of Subarea B For discussion only 2/12/26 2 of 3
523 Valley Road (1935)
528
523
525
526
524
528 Valley Road (1937) 525 Valley Road (1937)
526 Valley Road (1935, altered) 524 Valley Road (1940)
Oakhurst-Gildersleeve ADC District, east section of Subarea B For discussion only 2/12/26 3 of 3
520 Valley Road (1940)
528
520
510
506
514
516
516 Valley Road (1939) 514 Valley Road (1936)
510 Valley Road (1935) 506 Valley Road (1930)
N
VALLEY ROAD
VALLEY ROAD
JEFFERSON PARK AVENUE
JEFFERSON PARK AVENUE
EMMET STREET
GILDERSLEEVE WOOD
OAKHURS T CIR.
RAILROAD
SITE
PROJECT DESCRIPTION528 VALLEY ROAD
CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA The project proposes the construction of three buildings containing nine townhomes and an accompanying parking lot at
528 Valley Road in Charlottesville, Virginia. The project site consists of three lots that include two existing houses. The project
directly responds to the pressing need for student housing in close proximity to the University of Virginia. By situating new
housing within walking distance of grounds, the development reduces reliance on cars, alleviates pressure on the city’s
infrastructure, and helps slow the spread of university-related growth into outlying areas of Charlottesville. In doing so, the
project advances goals of smart growth, sustainability, and responsible urban design—providing students with high-quality
housing while supporting a healthier balance between the university, its students, and the broader Charlottesville community.
EXISTING
VIEW EAST
EXISTING
VIEW WEST
EXISTING
VIEW SOUTH
526
VALLEY RD.
528
VALLEY RD.
BUILDING BUILDING BUILDING
#1 #2 #3
ALLEY ROALLEY RO
ADAD
VV
526
VALLEY RD.
528
VALLEY RD.
BUILDING BUILDING BUILDING
#1 #2 #3
SITE PLAN
526 VALLEY ROAD
528 VALLEY ROAD
BUILDING #1
BUILDING #3
BUILDING #2
VALLEY ROAD
SITE LA YOUT
ASPHALT SHINGLES
VINYL D.H. WINDOW - WHITE
BUILDING #1 ELEVATION LAP SIDING - GRAY BUILDING #1 ELEVATION
FRONT ELEVATION RIGHT ELEVATION
SQUARE COLUMNS - WHITE
TRIM - WHITE
BOARD & BATTEN SIDING - GREEN
PARGED CONCRETE
KEY PLAN
1
3
2
ASPHALT SHINGLES
VINYL D.H. WINDOW - WHITE
BUILDING #1 ELEVATION LAP SIDING - GRAY BUILDING #1 ELEVATION
REAR ELEVATION LEFT ELEVATION
TRIM - WHITE
BOARD & BATTEN SIDING - GREEN
PARGED CONCRETE
KEY PLAN
1
3
2
ASPHALT SHINGLES
VINYL D.H. WINDOW - WHITE
BUILDING #2 & #3 ELEVATION BUILDING #2 & #3 ELEVATION
LAP SIDING - GRAY FRONT ELEVATION RIGHT ELEVATION
SQUARE COLUMNS - WHITE
TRIM - WHITE
BOARD & BATTEN SIDING - GREEN
PARGED CONCRETE
KEY PLAN
1
3
2
ASPHALT SHINGLES
VINYL D.H. WINDOW - WHITE
LAP SIDING - GRAY BUILDING #2 & #3 ELEVATION BUILDING #2 & #3 ELEVATION
REAR ELEVATION LEFET ELEVATION TRIM - WHITE
BOARD & BATTEN SIDING - GREEN
PARGED CONCRETE
KEY PLAN
1
3
2
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
February 18, 2026
Pre-application discussion: CoA in HC District
BAR # HST26-0003
716 & 0 Lexington Avenue, TMP 520152000 & 520152001
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner:David T. & Christine S. Gardner
Applicant: Bridge Ridenour, Alloy Architecture + Construction
Project: Construct single-family home
Background
Year Built: No prior structures at 0 Lexington Avenue
District: Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Survey: The 600 & 700 blocks of Lexington Avenue are described on pages 62-78 of the Martha
Jefferson Neighborhood HCD inventory [link].
Prior BAR Review
N/A
Application
• Submittal: Alloy Workshop, Gardner Renovation, dated February 6, 2026, 9 pages; including
material selections: 714 Lexington Look and Feel, 4 pages.
Pre-application conference re: construction of a single-story residence. No action will be taken.
The proposed single-story home is to be situated on the vacant portion of the lot [0 Lexington Avenue]
between 716 and 712 Lexington Avenue.
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 1
Arial View East - yellow arrow indicating approximate project area.
716 Lexington Avenue, view East.
Properties immediately West, across Lexington Avenue - not within M.J. HCD.
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 2
Rear lot, view N-NW. Proposed structure to be situated on the left.
Discussion
Note: The regulations and guidelines for projects within a Historic Conservation District (HCD) are,
by design, less rigid than those for an ADC District or an IPP. The HCD designations are intended to
preserve the character-defining elements of the neighborhoods and to assure that new construction is
not inappropriate to that character, while minimally imposing on current residents who may want to
upgrade their homes.
The BAR should discuss whether additional elements and details are necessary to evaluate the
project. For example:
• Measured drawings: Elevations, wall details, etc.
• Foundation and exterior walls
• Exterior trim, ornament, details, etc.
• Doors and windows: Type, lite arrangement, etc.
• Porches and decks: Materials, railing and stair design, etc.
• Landscaping/hardscaping
For the proposed dwelling at 0 Lexington Avenue (TMP 52015200), the project team was advised
by planning and zoning staff to address the necessary boundary line adjustment with 716
Lexington in order to meet required development regulations. Resolution of this matter will not
alter the design.
In addition to any comments, suggestions, or questions from the BAR, staff requests feedback on
the proposed setback.
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 3
Yellow line showing approximate existing front setback at 716 & 712 Lexington Avenue
Additionally, per Code Sec. 5.2.6.A.1., while this request is subject to a Major Historic Review, the
BAR may delegate to staff the final review (approval of the CoA).
See staff comments under the review criteria.
Suggested Motions
No action will be taken.
Criteria, Standards and Guidelines
Review Criteria Generally
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character
of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic
Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given
to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive
Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design
guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane].
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34. Div. Section 5.2.7.D. Criteria for Review and Decision
2. Historic Conservation District
Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration, or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to the exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features
and factors:
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 4
a. Whether the form, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed construction are visually
and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable conservation district;
b. The harmony of the proposed changes in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances and windows;
c. The impact of the proposed changes on the essential architectural form and integrity of the
existing building;
d. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; and
e. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
Historic Conservation Districts: Design Guidelines for New Construction and Additions
Note: In reviewing the design guidelines, staff examined the 31 primary structures within the district
located on the 500, 600, and 700 blocks of Lexington Avenue.
Building Location – setback and spacing
1. Align a new building close to the average building setback line on the same street, if established, or
consistent with the surrounding area.
2. Maintain average spacing between buildings on the same street.
Staff Comment:
1. The proposed front setback is shown at 20 feet. The average front setback on this street is 36
feet, and ranges between 24 and 56 feet.
2. Spacing between the new dwellings and those on the adjacent parcels (716 Lexington Avenue
and 712 Lexington Avenue) are 12 and 14 feet respectively. Spacing between nearby structures
ranges between 6 and 30 feet, with an average of 17 feet.
Building Scale – height and massing
1. Keep the footprint, and massing of new buildings consistent with the neighborhood characteristics
and compatible with the character of buildings on the same street.
2. Keep the height and width of new buildings within the prevailing average height and width.
Exceptions up to 200% of the prevailing height and width may be approved by the BAR when
contextually appropriate.
Staff Comment:
1. The estimated footprint and façade widths are compatible with other structures in the district,
most especially the single-story dwelling immediately adjacent (716 Lexington Ave). The
perspective view on page A1.6 of the submittal indicates the proposed massing and scale
relative to adjacent properties.
2. On this segment of Lexington Avenue, the existing dwellings are overwhelmingly 2-stories. The
new building is a single-story home. The established lot width is typical. In the district, average
building width is 30 feet, ranging between 26 and 38 feet. The maximum width as shown would be
42 feet, therefore the BAR should discuss appropriate building width.
Building Form – roofs and porches
1. Roof forms should reference contributing buildings on the same street or surrounding area. Other
roof forms may be approved by the BAR when contextually appropriate.
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 5
2. If many of the contributing buildings on the same street have porches, then it is strongly
recommended that the design of a new residence includes a porch or similar form of similar width
and depth.
Staff Comment: The proposed gabled roof is compatible with the district. The new dwelling
features both front and rear porches.
Building Openings – orientation, doors and windows
1. A single entrance door (or main entrance of a multifamily dwelling) facing the street is
recommended.
Staff Comment: The primary entrance is at the front, from the street-facing porch.
2. Window and door patterns and the ratio of solids (wall area) to voids (window and door area) of
new buildings should be compatible with contributing buildings in the surrounding area.
3. Windows should be simple shapes compatible with those on contributing buildings, which are
generally vertically oriented in residential areas.
Staff Comment: On the primary façade, window and door alignments and patterns are compatible
with the district.
Building Materials and Textures
1. The selection of materials and textures for a new building should relate architecturally to the
district, and should be compatible with and complementary to neighboring buildings.
2. Long-lasting, durable and natural materials are preferred, including brick, wood, stucco, and
cementitious siding and standing seam metal roofs. Clear glass windows (VLT of 70% or more) are
preferred.
Staff Comment: Throughout this district, brick and horizontal siding are common.
Building Paint
1. Painting unpainted brick or other masonry is discouraged because it is irreversible and may cause
moisture problems.
Staff Comment: n/a
Site
1. Fences or walls that abut a City street (or fences located in a side yard between a street and the
front of the principal structure on a lot) should not exceed three and one-half feet in height.
Staff Comment: n/a
Architectural character-defining features of the Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District:
1. Encourage one-story front porches;
Staff Comment: The new dwelling features front and rear porches.
2. Encourage garages to be located in the rear yards;
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 6
Staff Comment: A carport is proposed at the front elevation.
3. The levels of a building’s stories should be consistent with those on surrounding structures with
respect to the natural grade [for example, a first floor should not be raised so that it is higher than
most surrounding first floors];
Staff Comment: The level of the first floor aligns with those on the adjacent dwellings.
4. Do not exclude well-designed, new contemporary architecture [there may be a misconception that
only historic-looking new buildings are permitted];
Staff Comment: The form and style reflect that of the house at 716 Lexington Avenue.
5. Encourage standing seam metal roofs;
Staff Comment: The roof will be either standing seam metal, or asphalt shingles.
6. Maintain and encourage tree canopy [Maintain the existing tree canopy and encourage new large
shade trees];
Staff Comment: No existing large trees will be removed. Per zoning a 10% tree canopy will be
required.
7. The following Historic Conservation Overlay District Design Guidelines are especially pertinent:
a. maintain neighborhood massing and form;
b. encourage the use of sustainable materials;
c. limit the height of fences in front yards to 3 ½ feet in height.
Staff Comment:
a. Height, massing, and scale is compatible with nearby dwellings within the district.
b. Materials, as presented, are compatible.
c. No fencing is proposed.
8. Regarding the future development of the hospital properties, the neighborhood’s focus has been:
a. not to tear down the old houses; to encourage low density residential development north of
Taylor Walk (with the suggestion that Taylor Street be reinstated);
b. to expect the High Street area to develop as a sensitively designed, high-quality, mixed use
development;
Staff Comment: n/a
9. Encourage good stewardship of Maplewood Cemetery.
Staff Comment: n/a
7014-716 Lexington Ave. Prelim – February 18, 2026 (2/10) 7
SHEET INDEX
New single-family home ~2000 SF with small pool and garage.
PROJECT SUMMARY
3 GIS
Not to Scale
Martha Jefferson Historic
Conservation District
PROJECT INFORMATION
Parcel ID: 520152001
Zoning: R-B
County: City of Charlottesville
Year Built: n/a
Neighborhood: North Downtown
Construction Type: n/a
Existing SF:
Proposed Addition SF:
Proposed Renovated SF:
Front Setback: 20'
Rear Setback: 4'
Side Setback: 4'
1
A0.0 - Cover Page
A0.1 - Survey
A0.2 - Site Plan
A1.1 - Proposed Floor Plan
A1.2 - West Elevation
A1.3 - North Elevation
A1.4 - East Elevation
A1.5 - South Elevation
A1.6 - Perspective View
Vicinity Map View 2
Not to Scale Not to Scale
714 Lexington Ave
~5 mins from Alloy
Lexington Ave
St Charles Ave
Cover PageA0.0
Gardner Renovation 714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902 DATE: February 6, 2026
ISSUE: Schematic Design I
1
Survey
Scale: 1" = 20'
True Project
North North
Demo
Demo
N N
A0.1
Survey
Gardner Renovation 714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902 DATE: February 6, 2026
ISSUE: Schematic Design I
1
Site Plan
Scale: 1/16" = 1'-0"
Lexington Ave
True Project
North North
N N
20' 0"
~95' 0"
4' 0"
8' 0"
Fence 5' Pedestrian Easement
Fence
Building Setback Line
4' from property line,
8' from existing building
5' 0"
4' 0"
Fence
Property Line
4' 0"
Site PlanA0.2 St. Charles Ave.
Gardner Renovation 714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902 DATE: February 6, 2026
ISSUE: Schematic Design I
1
A1.3
1
A1.2
Driveway Carport
Hallway
Room 2
Tools
X-MAS
CL
Pantry
Laundry
Kitchen Dining Living Room
Room 1
Primary
Bedroom
Patio Pool
Proposed Floor Plan
Scale: 1/8" = 1' - 0"
N N
1
1
A1.5
True Project
North North
Proposed Floor Plan
A1.1
Gardner Renovation
714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902
DATE: February 6, 2026 ISSUE: PRELIMINARY DESIGN
1
A1.4
Gardner Renovation
714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902
DATE: February 6, 2026 ISSUE: PRELIMINARY DESIGN
714 Lexington
West Elevation
1 Scale: NTS
West Elevation
A1.2
Gardner Renovation
714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902
DATE: February 6, 2026 ISSUE: PRELIMINARY DESIGN
North Elevation
1 Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0"
North Elevation
A1.3
Gardner Renovation
714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902
DATE: February 6, 2026 ISSUE: PRELIMINARY DESIGN
East Elevation
1 Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0"
East Elevation
A1.4
Gardner Renovation
714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902
DATE: February 6, 2026 ISSUE: PRELIMINARY DESIGN
South Elevation
1 Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0"
South Elevation
A1.5
A1.6
Perspective View
Gardner Renovation 714 Lexington Ave.| Charlottesville, VA, 22902 DATE: February 6, 2026
ISSUE: Schematic Design I
714 LEXINGTON | Look & Feel
2.6.26
Overall Vibe:
714 LEXINGTON | Look & Feel
2.6.26
Exterior Cladding: Brick or Hardi-plank Lap Siding
James Hardie: Timber Bark or Espresso
Benjamin Moore: Bear Creek 1470
Red brick
714 LEXINGTON | Look & Feel
2.6.26
Roofing: Metal Standing Seam or Asphalt Shingle
Dark Bronze
Charcoal
Charcoal Gray
Weathered
Wood
714 LEXINGTON | Look & Feel
2.6.26
Aluminum-clad wood double-hung windows
Grille pattern variations
Exterior color options
Iron Ore
Black
Matte Grey
Windows: Pella Lifestyle Series
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.