Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Minutes
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Feb 18, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
February 18, 2026 – 5:00 PM
Hybrid Meeting (In person at City Council Chambers & virtual
via Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall identify
themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s purview;
that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s discussion and
prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to respond.
Members Present: Ron Bailey, James Zehmer, Cheri Lewis, Roger Birle, Katherin Tabony, Carl Schwarz,
Jerry Rosenthal
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Kate Richardson, Jeff Werner, Remy Trail, Sarah Kim
Pre-Meeting:
Ms. Lewis had a question about West Main Street window replacement. Ms. Lewis wanted to know what
past window replacements have been done. Staff said that it was about the BAR composition. People often
say that there is nobody who can repair old windows. Staff said that is generally true. There was a
discussion surrounding restoring versus replacing windows on West Main Street.
Ms. Lewis had a question about the County Courthouse, and the BAR had approved for the courthouse
windows. Staff did go over what was happening to the windows in the courthouse.
The meeting was called to order by Mr. Zehmer at 5:33 PM.
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda.
No Comments from the Public
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular agenda if
a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to comment on it.
Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Meeting Minutes – November 18, 2025
Motion to Approve – Mr. Schwarz – Second by Ms. Lewis – Motion passes 7-0.
C. Deferred Items
N/A
D. New Items
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
2
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
BAR # HST26-0001
701-705 West Main Street; TMP 320157000
West Main Street ADC District
Owner: Rocky Mountain LLC
Applicant: Calder Kegley
Project: Window replacements
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – Request CoA for window replacements on the second floor only.
Calder Kegley, Applicant – I am here representing the owner of 701-705 West Main Street. Since buying this
building, almost 10 months ago, we have been faced with many challenges and have gotten plenty of surprises.
After bringing Mitchell Matthews Architects, we began to formulate a plan to heavily renovate and revive the 5
apartment units that are upstairs. With the help of Martin Quarles, who has a long history of building and
renovating both commercial and residential properties in Charlottesville, we investigated the necessities to help
preserve the building for at least another 100 years. It was evident early on that to improve the thermal barriers
of the units; the windows had to be examined. With Mr. Quarles’ help and Mark Wingers from Gaston &
Wyatt, we were able to find and inspect the Marvin Ultimate Series inserts that fit nicely into space. Best of all,
they do not come with storm windows. By using these inserts, we will be able to satisfy the thermal needs while
also presenting an unrecognizable exterior façade. During this process, all the exterior trim will be repainted.
The rest of the rust-crated seals will be repaired and preserved. There will be no storm windows. Any damage
that those incurred to the original frames will be repaired. With all the brick work, we are planning on
repointing and replacing the existing brick that is not repairable and going around the entire exterior. With all
the previous and upcoming high-rise construction that is happening on West Main Street, we hope that we can
be recognized for our effort in not only preserving but creating space that is inviting within a historic building
inside a historic district. Perhaps by example, others will take this path rather than building anew.
Charles Quarles – As mentioned earlier, the building was renovated in the early 70s. I am certain the sash on
the streetscape is not original. They represent that and they do not perform well.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – Did you say that the window air conditioner units are going away?
Mr. Kegley – That is correct. I did not mention that. When we acquired this building, there was an air conditioner
unit just about every other window around West Main Street and 7th Street. What led us to taking them out was all
the tenants left around the end of December. We had a big cold snap. To prevent any water from freezing, all the
AC units came out. We put sealed plastic around the entire interior. That made an incredible difference in the
heating capabilities of that space. Every piece of plastic was blowing in like a sail on a boat.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – The windows there are simple, easily replaceable. We are not losing any historic fabric that
represents any handicraft. I recognize staff’s comment about finding a sash on another elevation building. There
are none. If there was one, it would be piecemeal. There are no sashes that match these. I am in support of this.
3
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
Mr. Zehmer – It seems like there are no sashes that date to the original construction either if this assessment is
correct. My biggest thing is making sure that the Marvin Windows match as closely as they can to the one-over-
one and proportions of the existing windows. The existing windows are a replication of what was originally there
most likely. I don’t have any objection to the application.
Ms. Tabony – The cumulative benefit of new windows in the overall preservation of the building is a net positive
for the user benefit, comfort, and general appreciation of the building. I do support this.
Ms. Lewis – I think Mr. Kegley did a window-by-window survey. I appreciated that. It allowed me to see all the
different conditions, not just the front but the back windows. Some of them were poor and irreparable. Some were
okay. I appreciated that work that was done on behalf of the owner.
Motion – Mr. Schwarz – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
City’s ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed window replacements at 701-705
West Main Street satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in
this ADC district, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted noting the following conditions:
• Preference for wood, metal or metal-clad windows.
• For the 6 over 6 you may use insulated glass with applied grills, provided there is an internal spacer
bar.
• Insert frames must fit relatively tight into the opening and retain the existing exterior trim or at least
have something new that is similar.
Second by Mr. Bailey. Motion passes 7-0.
3. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # HST26-xxxx [TBD]
Historic Downtown Pedestrian Mall
Downtown ADC District
Owner/Applicant: City of Charlottesville
Project: Downtown Mall trashcan replacement plan
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA request for proposed litter receptacles to be installed on the Downtown Mall.
Existing cans, which are not original to the Mall, are no longer available. The currently used cans did not replicate
the original cans designed by Lawrence Halprin & Associates for the initial phase of the Mall, in fact, they are
entirely different. Therefore, the only reason for selecting a type/style that is similar to the current trash cans is for
continuity of design, and not to reflect on or represent an original element. No immediate replacements are
planned; however, this review is necessary to establish the new type that will be used moving forward, when
necessary. (See the Appendix for staff correspondence with the applicant.)
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Ms. Lewis – I see that the new ones have a hinge lid. That is how they would empty them. How are the current
ones emptied if they are hanging?
Mr. Werner – It is very difficult. I did not get into it. It seems like they swing and remove the bag.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
4
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – Does it really matter that the new one matches the old one so precisely? Does it matter that it is
just black and round? We have 6 replacement receptacles and 25 base covers. For $19,500, that is a lot of
money for 6 trash cans. There are a lot of them out there. We are going to be replacing these trash cans over
time. Are we stuck with the same manufacturer? I am just throwing that out to Parks & Recreation. Does the
BAR care that this trash can looks exactly like the one that showed up sometime in the early 2000s? Do we care
that it fits in with all the other trash cans that are out there?
Mr. Zehmer – It sounds like they are trying to do a phased rollout. I do see value in them matching the older
ones so that you have a consistent look on The Mall even if it takes 10 years to roll out. You start back at
replacing the ones we started with. I take your point. Is there a cheaper option that still achieves the goal? I do
see value in consistency and appearance.
Mr. Schwarz – My other concern is that if you look at those little attachments to the pavers, some of them are
really rusted out. The city throws down way too much salt every winter. I wish we could discuss that. It is
destroying the buildings and all The Mall furniture. This new trash can is made of steel that has been powder
coated. When it is sitting directly on the ground, are the bottoms going to rust out in a short amount of time?
Has it been considered?
Ms. Lewis – Maybe that is why the current ones were hung.
Mr. Schwarz – I am wondering if that might have been part of the reason for that. I noticed on this
manufacturer’s website, I did not see if they had any trash cans that were hung. I don’t know if that is just
something people don’t do anymore. I am curious about the longevity of these trash cans sitting in so much salt
every winter, especially if they are just made of plain steel. Do those steel hangers provide any protection? The
big cast iron planters don’t get busted up, but other people’s planters do. I am wondering if once we take these
trash cans out from their protective ballard areas, are they going to be subject to being kicked over and busted
up? If the BAR thinks that these trash cans should match exactly minus the ballards, I guess the conversation
does not matter. If we are less concerned about that, I am wondering if it would be worth shopping around
more.
Mr. Zehmer – The ballards could be modified to have a hanger that holds the new trash can. Leave the ballards
in place. You could have it where it has a padlock.
Mr. Schwarz – We are then modifying every trash can to fit that.
Ms. Tabony – The replacement has a hinged lid. That might not be optimal
Mr. Schwarz – If this is not time sensitive, I don’t want to stand in the way of us approving a trash can that is
perfectly acceptable. If Parks and Recreation wanted to consider some of these questions, I don’t know if that
would hurt.
Ms. Tabony – I think the cost is an interesting question. Is that the trash cans or is that the masonry repair of
the granite? Is that going to be happening regardless?
Mr. Schwarz – I think the $19,500 was for preemptively buying 6 trash cans for when some of these fail in the
future. They could just put a new one in place. The cost of the granite would be something extra. Is that correct?
5
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
Mr. Werner – I don’t know. I know what you just said is correct. These were no longer available. They got
what they could. My answer to Cliff was what the BAR would be concerned about is consistency. While we
recognize that we will not remake these, there is consistency in that intent. They are round, black, and located in
similar locations. The fact that there was visibly similar made it easier. I certainly could ask if there were other
options that they wanted to consider. It is possible that they selected this. There is a lot. I am still tamping this
down all the time. You do see other departments responding to this fear. The BAR did this or did that. 99
percent of the time it is not true.
Mr. Schwarz – I am worried that they chose this because someone decided that the existing trash cans that
aren’t original.
Mr. Werner – It is possible. I am working with Cliff on a couple things. This is not imminent. It would be
helpful to approve it. They may not need to buy one of these for a couple of years. I can have a conversation
with him about it.
Mr. Rosenthal – These trash cans have already been purchased?
Mr. Werner – They have some that match. That is what is there now. They have not purchased anything
beyond those trash cans.
Mr. Schwarz – They knew that these were being discontinued. They spent $20,000 to buy six. They have them
ready to replace. They are of the old style. They will still have 6 more trash cans that can fail that they can
replace before they move onto the new ones.
Mr. Werner – Since I came on, I have been pushing for a long-term maintenance plan and management plan
for The Mall; short-term, mid-term, and long-term. You can see the condition of The Mall. I walked it today
looking at some things. It is in rough shape. We need a plan. We can’t wake up one day and realize that the
bricks need to be replaced. We should not be surprised by those things. This is trying to get ahead of that. There
is a lot happening out there. I am trying to keep you involved with The Mall as much as possible. To what
extent do I bring things to you. I am glad that they are asking about this. If you think there is something that
would be more suitable or if you think there is something a design part or an aesthetic, I think Parks and
Recreation would be more than happy to hear some ideas if you have any. We are going to talk about that at the
end of the meeting.
Mr. Schwarz – I want to make sure that my comments are framed more as not this is unacceptable, and we
want to cause more work for you. It is more of if you had the opportunity to choose something else, would you?
If you didn’t think that you had to match it exactly, would there be a better option out there?
Mr. Zehmer – These are good questions. They do have a CoA before us.
Mr. Schwarz – We can vote to approve this. I am fine with that if those questions get answered. They can
always come back to us later and ask, ‘Is this different trash can, okay?’ I doubt the city is charging themselves
a fee to apply for a CoA.
Mr. Birle – I went out there at lunch time. I did not see any problems with the trash cans that I saw. I did not do
an extensive search. This trash can is perfectly fine. This is the least of the concerns of the Downtown Mall
right now. Why don’t we have recycling cans that are obvious?
6
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
Mr. Werner – Some services are single stream. You throw it all in one bin and they sort it out. I don’t know if
that is the case. I do have a reminder to ask.
Ms. Lewis – I am only finding one guideline which is what we are supposed to talk about that pertains to trash
containers. It is in Section G of Chapter 6-Public Improvements. Trash containers should be metal and should
match other street furniture. We have encouraged black furniture on The Mall. I would say that it meets that.
There is number 3 criteria that says, ‘attempt to make street furniture compatible in design, color, materials with
existing elements.’ To the extent that there is any benefit, I think there are two benefits. The new ones are the
same manufacturer and generally match the existing. There is a user component here. I don’t even have to think
that these are trash cans. I am used to the trash cans on The Mall. If we change to another shape, I wonder how
that would compete. We must consider the application before us. It meets the guidelines.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
City’s ADC District Design Guidelines [specifically Ch. 6, sect. G], I move to find that the proposed
replacement trashcans for the Downtown Mall satisfies the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with the
Downtown Mall and this ADC district, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the
following condition:
• That the damaged granite pavers [where tube frames are removed] will be replaced in-kind [and
not simply repaired or patched].
Second by Mr. Birle. Motion passes 7-0.
We would encourage a holistic look at recycling containers on The Mall and how they might be located next
to the trash containers to efficiently get recycled items collected.
E. Other Business
4. Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0002
528 Valley Road; TMP
Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District
Owner: Andrew Fossen; AVP 528 Valley LLC
Applicant: Raymond Gaines, The Gaines Group
Project: Construction of nine townhomes
• The BAR will review the project under New Construction criteria [and not as an addition to the site].
See ADC Districts Design Guidelines, Ch.3
• The BAR compliments and thanks the team for saving and respecting the original house (528 Valley
Road).
• The scale and massing of building #1 (situated at the street) is more of a challenge [for this review]
than buildings #2 and #3 (at rear of parcel).
• Perhaps reduce the size of Building #1 and use dormers to achieve the third floor.
• Consider flipping the floorplan around to reduce the façade of building #1 along the street-facing side.
This might conflict with zoning.
• Switch from a horizontal to a vertical emphasis to help break down the façades; embrace the verticality
of the buildings.
• For the roofline, the BAR suggests picking a style- noting that the current design does not feel either
contemporary, modern or traditional.
• Give more consideration to the entrances and windows.
• The BAR questions how close building #2 is to the original house (528 Valley Road).
• The new structures should complement the (neighboring) historic assets and the district.
7
BAR Meeting Minutes February 18, 2026
• Consider materiality and other elements of design: the BAR asks the applicant to explore brick, dormer
windows, the Cape Cod style and avoid vinyl.
5. Pre-Application Conference
BAR # HST26-0003
714-716 Lexington Avenue; TMP 520152000
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner: David T. & Cristine S. Gardner
Applicant: Bridget Ridenour, Alloy Architecture + Construction
Project: Construct single-family home
• The project is within a Historic Conservation district therefore the BAR will have a lighter touch [on
review]; focus will primarily be on what can be viewed from the street.
• The proposed dwelling is sympathetic to the neighboring house and fits into the district well.
• There is some support [from the BAR] for the carport; it is definitely a better option than a garage.
• Breakdown of the carport’s side elevation, either through additional columns, screening, or low wall to
give some visual separation for the neighboring property.
• Consider the carport and driveway materiality- concrete is preferable to asphalt for both the parking
surface and driveway and should be continuous to the street.
• For exterior siding brick is preferred. The alternate of Hardie plank is acceptable.
• Explore breaking down the house as it progresses to the rear of the lot to perhaps mirror the additions
of the neighboring house [at 716 Lexington Ave.], including roofline changes which could be cost
effective to allow for the use of brick at the front porch [and façade].
• The two walls of the interior carport should match the exterior of the house.
• The BAR will act on this project at a future meeting. [In lieu of a staff administrative approval which is
allowable within HC districts.]
6. Staff questions/discussion
• Lighting on the Downtown Mall.
• Exploring design options – Removing barriers for the Downtown Mall Fountains.
F. Adjourn
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:50 PM.
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.