RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Regular Meeting — Other

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Planning Commission · meeting of Jan 13, 2026 · Other

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charlottesville Tax Abatement Feasibility Analysis Planning Commission January 13, 2026 Outline • Study Purpose • Tax Abatement Overview • Study Methods • Charlottesville Development Feasibility Assessment Tool • Development Feasibility Findings • Key Takeaways Findings Overview "TYPICAL" PROJECT FINANCIALS Yield on Cost Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 6.2% 6.0% 5.8% 5.6% 5.6% Mid Rise 5.0% 4.8% 4.5% 4.3% 4.8% Low Rise 4.4% 4.1% 4.3% 4.1% 4.2% Garden Apt 4.2% 3.9% 4.1% 4.0% 4.1% Townhouse 4.5% 4.1% 4.2% 4.1% 3.9% Single Family 5.1% 4.6% 4.8% 4.6% 4.4% IRR Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 8% 8% 7% 6% 7% Mid Rise 4% 3% 2% 0% 4% Low Rise 1% -2% 0% -1% -1% Garden Apt -1% 0% -2% -3% -2% Townhouse 1% -2% 0% -2% 0% Single Family 4% 2% 3% 2% 1% • Limited development feasibility for “typical” housing projects, regardless of type or location • This would be true with or without inclusionary zoning… but IZ further limits feasibility • Tax abatements help, but it may be advisable to use a non- traditional approach to address “overpaying” , “can’t pencil” , and “we need more housing” concerns Likely Feasible Possibly Feasible Likely Not Feasible Findings Overview PROJECT FINANCIALS WITHOUT IZ REQUIREMENT Yield on Cost Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 6.6% 6.4% 6.2% 5.9% 5.9% Mid Rise 5.3% 5.1% 4.8% 4.5% 5.0% Low Rise 4.7% 4.3% 4.4% 4.3% 4.3% Garden Apt 4.4% 4.1% 4.2% 4.1% 4.2% Townhouse 4.8% 4.4% 4.5% 4.3% 4.1% Single Family 5.6% 5.1% 5.2% 5.0% 4.7% IRR Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 10% 9% 9% 8% 8% Mid Rise 6% 5% 3% 2% 5% Low Rise 2% 0% 1% 0% 0% Garden Apt 0% -3% -1% -2% -1% Townhouse 2% 0% 1% 0% -2% Single Family 7% 5% 6% 5% 4% • Limited development feasibility for “typical” housing projects, regardless of type or location • This would be true with or without inclusionary zoning… but IZ further limits feasibility • Tax abatements help, but it may be advisable to use a non- traditional approach to address “overpaying” , “can’t pencil” , and “we need more housing” concerns Likely Feasible Possibly Feasible Likely Not Feasible Study Purpose Overall Purpose • Evaluate current housing market feasibility • Evaluate the current financial impacts of inclusionary zoning • Evaluate the current financial impacts of a tax abatement • Provide a mechanism for continued monitoring of these impacts and findings What This Project Is and Isn’t • This project is… • A means to inform policy decisions by calculating the financial impact of public policy interventions • A method that is transparent, flexible, and adaptable • A collaborative effort that relies upon reliable and ongoing cost/revenue inputs • This project isn’t… • A tool to determine policy • A way to determine the feasibility of a specific project • A black box model with set-in-stone assumptions Background and Need • Affordable Housing Needs Assessment - need for 4,020 AHUs by 2040 • New zoning code adopted in December 2023 includes inclusionary zoning • Charlottesville City Council commits $10m per year to affordable housing • Market rate projects with affordable units have been slow to materialize • City interested in researching tax abatement as a potential option to improve the feasibility of housing construction • Our scope – develop a development feasibility model that can inform policy discussions and decisions Tax Abatement Overview Tax Abatement • Temporary reduction or exemption from taxes levied by a unit of government, typically to encourage a particular activity • Purpose could be to improve financial feasibility of ADU production while preserving base tax revenue • Authorized under §15.2-4905 (Industrial Development and Revenue Bond Act) • In Virginia it must be executed as a performance-based grant that reimburses a portion of real estate taxes Study Methods Method Overview • Collaboratively determine “typical” costs and revenues • Build a development feasibility tool that mirrors the private sector analysis process, but infuse that tool with the ability to analyze the impacts of public interventions • Calculate current “typical” feasibility impacts for tax abatements (and other interventions) Method Overview • Why a tool? Your inputs and findings change alongside changing market conditions • Such a tool also allows for analysis of a range of policy interventions including: • Tax abatement • Land provision • Gap financing • Expedited review/approval Model Inputs • Inputs include: • Costs – Land, hard costs (materials & labor), soft costs (fees, plans), etc. • Revenues – Market rate and affordable rents • Financial Assumptions – Interest rates, ROI requirements, etc • Importantly, many of these inputs can be unique to a single project, and can and do change with regularity • Our overall goal is to be in the right range on overall financial viability more than it is to be exactly right for each input Hard Costs • Used existing projects in the City as size & materials examples, plugged into an outside cost estimating software • Findings were vetted with and adjusted by local developers based on their project experiences Hard Costs • Used existing projects in the City as size & materials examples, plugged into an outside cost estimating software • Initial findings were vetted with and adjusted based on input by local developers based on their project experiences • Again, these can be changed over time "TYPICAL" HARD COSTS (LABOR & MATERIALS) Housing Type Price Per Unit High Rise $243,750 Mid Rise $300,000 Low Rise $297,000 Garden Apt $275,275 Townhouse $387,600 Single Family $412,000 Land Costs • Too few land sales to use existing comps, so started with assessed land values • Created 5 “tiers” representing land costs across the city (but not specific locations!) • Tier 1 – Most expensive areas • Tier 5 – Least expensive areas • Land values by land use type were assigned to our “typical” housing styles Land Costs PER UNIT LAND COSTS Housing Type Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 Garden Apt 47,500 $ 36,000 $ 31,000 $ 26,500 $ 18,500 $ Low Rise 25,000 $ 20,500 $ 17,500 $ 13,000 $ 10,500 $ Mid Rise 21,500 $ 16,000 $ 12,000 $ 11,333 $ 9,333 $ High Rise 21,500 $ 16,000 $ 12,000 $ 11,333 $ 9,333 $ Single Family 81,000 $ 58,167 $ 45,000 $ 36,500 $ 30,500 $ Townhouse 67,833 $ 48,556 $ 37,611 $ 30,056 $ 26,333 $ • Findings were vetted and updated by local development community, though with very little consensus. As such, these are most subject to change over time Soft Costs CONSULTANT FEES Type Amount Standard 15% Minimum 12% MUNICIPAL FEES Amount Notes 4.50% of hard costs • Consultant soft costs are generally tied to hard costs and project timeframes, and are merely rough estimates • Municipal fees can vary by project needs, so rough estimate here too Revenues & Financial Costs • Pulled asking rents from ~20 complexes (city and urban ring of county) • Calculated affordable rents based on latest AMI figures • Other financial assumptions needed to be made as well (such as construction loan rates, capitalization rates, etc.) but all can be modified as needed Charlottesville Development Feasibility Assessment Tool Tool Overview • Charlottesville Development Feasibility Assessment Tool provides: • Yield on cost and IRR for a “typical” project, with and without public incentives • Ability to analyze across building types, submarkets, and varying levels of affordability • The key information is the difference in financial performance with and without policy interventions, more than the performance itself Interface Development Feasibility Overview Key Questions We Explored • What is the feasibility of a “typical” project today? • What does the inclusionary zoning policy do to feasibility? • What do incentives (tax abatement + others) do to feasibility? • How are City revenues affected by incentives? Current Market Feasibility • Assessed the market feasibility under current conditions, which includes the inclusionary zoning requirement • New construction feasibility is limited, with no product reaching the yield or IRR thresholds for “likely feasible” "TYPICAL" WITHOUT INCENTIVE PROJECT FINANCIALS Yield on Cost Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 6.2% 6.0% 5.8% 5.6% 5.6% Mid Rise 5.0% 4.8% 4.5% 4.3% 4.8% Low Rise 4.4% 4.1% 4.3% 4.1% 4.2% Garden Apt 4.2% 3.9% 4.1% 4.0% 4.1% Townhouse 4.5% 4.1% 4.2% 4.1% 3.9% Single Family 5.1% 4.6% 4.8% 4.6% 4.4% IRR Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 8% 8% 7% 6% 7% Mid Rise 4% 3% 2% 0% 4% Low Rise 1% -2% 0% -1% -1% Garden Apt -1% 0% -2% -3% -2% Townhouse 1% -2% 0% -2% 0% Single Family 4% 2% 3% 2% 1% Inclusionary Zoning Feasibility Impact • Next, looked at market feasibility without inclusionary zoning • Yields increase by as much as 0.5% and IRR increases up to 2+% • However, market conditions are still difficult for nearly all “typicals” , suggesting a real need for improvements in costs or revenues to make projects pencil "TYPICAL" WITHOUT INCENTIVE PROJECT FINANCIALS Yield on Cost Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 6.7% 6.4% 6.2% 5.9% 6.0% Mid Rise 5.3% 5.2% 4.8% 4.6% 5.1% Low Rise 4.7% 4.3% 4.4% 4.3% 4.3% Garden Apt 4.5% 4.1% 4.2% 4.1% 4.2% Townhouse 4.8% 4.4% 4.5% 4.3% 4.1% Single Family 5.6% 5.0% 5.2% 4.9% 4.7% IRR Typology Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 4 Tier 5 High Rise 10% 9% 9% 8% 8% Mid Rise 6% 5% 4% 2% 5% Low Rise 3% 0% 1% 0% 0% Garden Apt 1% -2% -1% -2% -1% Townhouse 3% 1% 2% 0% -2% Single Family 6% 5% 6% 5% 4% Tax Abatement Methods • We modeled the impacts of two different tax abatement approaches • Value-Based Abatement • A percentage of the incremental tax revenue post-development is returned to the owner as a performance grant. Relies on assessed property values • Rent-Gap Abatement • Abatement is calculated based on the gap between market rent and affordable rent Value-Based Tax Abatement Impacts • Value-based abatement has a positive impact on yields that rises as abatement percentage rises • But abatement “return” is lower than rent “loss” • Similar patterns emerge across housing types and locations Mid-Rise Tier 3 Value-Based Abatement Example (135 unit development, ~$2,500 avg rent) Abatement Percentage Yield Change IRR Change Monthly “Loss” from Affordable Units Abatement “Return” for Affordable Units Annual Revenue “Waived” New Tax Revenue 25% 0.02% 0.17% $13,636 $1,162 $13,944 $527,943 50% 0.05% 0.35% $13,636 $2,324 $27,888 $513,599 75% 0.07% 0.52% $13,636 $3,486 $41,382 $500,035 100% 0.09% 0.67% $13,636 $4,516 $54,189 $487,699 Rent-Gap Tax Abatement Impacts • A “rent gap” method for calculating the abatement has a greater benefit to yields and IRR • A development can be “made whole” using this but comes at a greater cost to the City • The abatement amount is tied to market prices, so as prices change so too does abatement Mid-Rise Tier 3 Rent-Gap Abatement Example (135 unit development, ~$2,500 avg rent) Abatement Percentage Yield Change IRR Change Monthly “Loss” from Affordable Units Abatement “Return” for Affordable Units Annual Revenue “Waived” New Tax Revenue 25% 0.07% 0.51% $13,636 $3,409 $40,909 $500,797 50% 0.14% 0.99% $13,636 $6,818 $81,817 $460,070 75% 0.21% 1.45% $13,636 $10,227 $122,726 $419,162 100% 0.29% 1.90% $13,636 $13,636 $163,634 $378,253 Tax Abatement Pros & Cons Value-Based Abatement • Pros: Tried and true • Cons: Doesn’t fully close the current market gaps; Can lead City to over-subsidize if abatement only utilized in good market conditions Rent-Gap Abatement • Pros: Tied to market conditions; Directly addresses the financial loss from inclusionary zoning ordinance; May reduce the risk of over-subsidizing development • Cons: Rarely used (Baltimore only found example, and it’s new there), so administration hurdles may exist; may still risk over-subsidizing in strong markets Other Potential Incentives • Gap financing, land provision, reduced review/approval timeline, and forgivable loans all improve yields and IRRs • Tool can be used to further explore alternative incentives (alone or in combination) OTHER POTENTIAL INCENTIVES (135 unit Mid-Rise Tier 3 development, ~$2,500 avg rent) Abatement Type Amount IRR Change Gap Financing $1.4m 0.5% Land Provision $1.6m 1.4% Reduced Timeline 6 months 0.9% Forgivable Loan $1.5m 1.5% Findings Key Findings • Market conditions are challenging right now • Inclusionary Zoning adding to that challenge • Traditional tax abatements help, but are insufficient on their own (right now) • Rent-gap tax abatement merits consideration as a better balance between public and private priorities • Other incentives/policies may still be needed • Leave-behind tool allows for future adaptability and exploration Contacts • Jeremy Goldstein • Jeremy@3tpventures.com • Mike Callahan • Mike@3tpventures.com City Council Presentation January 20, 2025 Kellie Brown, Director Neighborhood Development Services Department ADU Manual In Lieu Fee/ Student Housing Study • Goals: • Get feedback on scope of work to inform study approach and desired outcomes St aff will return with updates after research and community engagement • Agenda • Background • Initial Observations • Study Focus and Scope of Work • Community Engagement Approach • Potential Options • Timeline • Discussion Goals and Agenda Student Housing Background Information • UVA enrollment growth has s teadily increased demand for student housing. • Historically, students lived: • On Grounds (limited capacity) • In older apartment complexes near UVA • In converted single-f amily homes in neighborhoods adjacent to the university • As enrollment grew, private developers inc reasingly stepped in to build purpose-built student housing. • Within walking distance to Grounds • 4-b edroom units, rental by bedroom Student Housing History Neighborhood Key Student Housing Features The Corner / University Area Oldest off-Grounds student district; dense housing near UVA Venable Early 20th-century homes converted to rentals; adjacent to Grounds JPA Corridor Mix of apartments + subdivided homes; close to hospital & Grounds West Main Longstanding transition zone; now major student-housing corridor Fifeville (edges) Increasing student-housing pressure near West Main 10 th and Page Early 20th-century homes converted to rentals; increasing student housing pressure Student Housing Supply and Demand Total Undergraduate and Graduate Enrollment ~ 27,000* • ~ 7,000 beds on Grounds (4,000 for First-Years) • 2030 Plan aspires to house all first year and second-year students • 5 projects currently under construction off Grounds, totaling 3,515 beds • Verve (442 Units / 1,332 beds) • Aspen Heights (119 Units / 390 beds) • 1117 Preston Avenue (16 Units / 32 beds) • Ivy (Blume) (231 Units / 641 beds) • 2033 Ivy Rd (780 beds) • Darden Graduate Housing (County) (340 beds) North Grounds Central Grounds *Darden Graduate Housing not pictured *Source: Facts and Figures | The University of Virginia Student Housing – National Perspective - National report note a continued trend toward: • Private bedrooms and bathrooms • High-end amenities (fitness centers, study lounges, pools) • Mix ed-use developments near campus • Preference for private space and modern amenities Ivy (Blume),Charlottesville, VA (UVA) The Verve, Charlottesville, VA (UVA) * Inland-Insights-Robust-Student-Housing.pdf Jolly Roger, Greensboro (ECU) Development Code Context Residential Districts: • R-A , RN-A, R-B, R -C Mixed Use Districts: • Corridor: NX-3 , NX-5, NX-8, NX-10, DX • Node: RX-3 , RX -5 • Residential Mixed Use: CX-3, CX-5, CX-8 Other Zoning Districts: • Industrial Flex: IX-5, IX-8 • Special: CM, CV , Alternate For ms Zoning Categories and Overlay Districts Overlay Districts (* Design review required): • Core Neighborhood Co rridors • Entrance Corridors * • Architectural Design Cont rol Districts * • Historic Conservation Dist ricts * • Individually Protected Pr operties * • Floodways and F loodplains The Current Development Code was Adopted on December 18, 2023 – Designed to facilitate a more form-based zoning ordinance, increasing density in alignment with the 2021 Comprehensive Plan. Residential Development: • Projects ≥10 units provide 10% at ≤60% AMI or pay in-lieu fee • Bonus height for units at ≤50% AMI or same fee • In-lieu fee = average total cost per unit of developing a residential unit in the Charlottesville market, based on bedroom count up to 3 bedrooms Student Housing • Projects that rent by the bedroom within ½ mi le of Campus Grounds • No on-site affordable units are required • Bonus height may also be realized • In-lieu fee is required • In-lieu fee = difference between the value of a market rate unit and that of an affordable unit (i.e.value gap), based on bedroom count up to 3 bedrooms Affordable Housing and Student Housing Requirements Non-Student Housing Student Housing • Student housing projects do not typically include non- student housing • Unique requirements for student housing projects (rental by bedroom, parental preferences for student living conditions and amenities) • Value gap method resulted in a lower in-lieu fee requirement • Lower fee requirement deemed appropriate given the lack of an on-site affordable unit requirement Rationale for Different Student Housing Requirements Non-Student Housing Student Housing Area within ½ Mile of GroundsUVA Grounds Locations Where Affordable Housing Expectations for Student Housing Apply Residential Development (Non-Student Housing): • Inconsistent in-lieu fee payment structure for bonus height • Projects opting to pay the in-lieu fee are being charged for bonus height as if the on-site requirement is 60% AMI, not 50% AMI Student Housing • Lack of requirement for on -site units limits new affordable housing where student housing is most financially feasible reinvestment option • Student housing have lower per-b edroom cost requirement for in-lieu fee, which further incentives student housing • No consideration for conversions to non-student housing • No consideration for four-b edroom units • Large geography applies this policy to neighborhoods where d isplacement is a concern Initial Observations and Concerns Non-Student Housing Student Housing Study Focus and Scope of Work Development Code Amendments: Background • Need for Amendments – Staff is identifying both minor and significant issues requiring revisions to better support City goals. • Three-Tier Approach: • Tier 1 – Minor grammatical corrections, small adjustments, and state requirements. • Tier 2 – Modifications addressing oversights and clarifications to support the Intent sections of the code. • Tier 3 – Policy changes requiring in-depth analysis and community engagement. • Next Steps: • Tier 1 & 2 – Advancing to Public Hearing with Planning Commission January 13, 2026, then a Public Hearing with City Council later in the winter of 2026. • Tier 3 – Considered in the broader FY26 NDS workplan and beyond. • Ongoing Process – Annual updates for Tier 1 & 2 to ensure adaptability, best practices, and sustainable growth. Tier 3 Amendments • Purpose – Foc uses on policy changes and confirmations requiring in-depth analysis and broader community engagement. • Scope – Significant amendments that impact long-term planning and require careful evaluation of goals and implications. • Community Input – Ex tensive outreach to gather feedback and ensure alignment with public priorities. • Process – Wi ll be prioritized within the broader future NDS workplans, given the complexity and resources required. • Future Considerations – Hel ps shape long-term regulatory strategies to maintain an adaptable and effective Development Code. Tier 3 Study: ADU Manual In Lieu Fee/Student Housing Study Purpose of the Study • Annual review and update of the Affordable Dwelling Unit (ADU) Monitoring and Procedures Manual • Focus on refining expectations for: • In-lieu fee payments • Bonus height projects • Student housing Research and Analysis • Do the current in-lieu fee payment structures accurately reflect constructioncosts (for non-student housing) and the value gap (for student housing)? • What are the approaches of other Virginia jurisdictions? • Using the financial model created for the tax abatement study, determine what approach to requirements fo r in-lieu fee payments provide the best balance of incentivizing production of on-site units without limiting development feasibility? Goals and Guiding Principles • What should be the City's goals for in-lieu fee payment policies? • What should be the City's goals for student housing? • What should be the relationship between in-lieu fee expectations for student housing and non-student housing? • Should in-lieu fee payments be greater for bonus height than for non-bonus height? Scope of Work / Key Study Questions Community Engagement Approach Key Stakeholders and Engagement Strategies Key Stakeholders • Housing Advisory Commission • Planning Commission • Property Owners • UVA • Albemarle County • Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission • Advocacy Organizations Eng agement Strategies • Commission Presentations • Co nnect Charlottesville digital outreach and engagement opportunities • Focus Groups • Pop Up Visits • What do you believe is the most important outcome this policy should accomplish fo r our community? • What impacts or unintended consequences should we work (hardest) to prevent? Key Questions for Stakeholder Engagement Potential Options Residential Development (Non-Student Housing): • Study the creation of an in-lieu fee payment structure that increases requirement for bonus height to reflect that the on-site requirement for bonus height is 50% AMI, not 60% AMI Student Housing • Consider requiring on-sit e units for student housing, or allow an in-lieu fee equivalent to requirement for non- student housing • Addresses potential conversions to non-student housing • Allows for on-s ite affordable units when financial and market conditions are favorable • Add in-li eu fee requirement for four -bedroom units • Consider geographic criteria – consider if needed given potential merit of equivalency with expectations for non- student housing • Removes unintended incentive to build student housing Al l Housing Projects (10+ units) • Consider potential for tax abatement strategies to offset costs associated with affordable housing production an d facilitate investment, to be further explored One Set of Potential Options to Explore Study Timeline Timeline • Do the current in-lieu fee payment structures accurately reflect construction costs and the value gap? • What are the approaches of other Virginia jurisdictions? • What approach to requirements for in-lieu fee payments best incentivize production of on-site units without limiting development feasibility? December 2025 – January 2026: Consultant Evaluation of Key Study Questions • What are the most important things for the policy to achieve? • What impacts do we want to avoid? January 2026 – February 2026: Stakeholder Engagement • Guiding Principles • Policy Recommendations* • Manual and Development Code Amendments March– May 2026: Develop Proposals and Commission and Council Review *Development of recommendations will be coordinated with presentation of key findings and recommendations from tax abatement study Thank You

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.