RecordWell Data

City Council Retreat — Other

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Jan 9, 2026 · Other

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

© PFM 1 City of Charlottesville Emerging Economic Trends and Financial Outlook PFM Group Consulting LLC PFM Financial Advisors pfm.com Vieen Leung, Director, PFM January 9, 2026 © PFM 2 Agenda  Regional Trends and Local Government Outlook  FY2027 City of Charlottesville Financial Outlook  Credit Rating Pressures  Key Takeaway © PFM 3 Regional Trends and Local Government Outlook © PFM 4 Rating Agencies’ Local Government Outlook  “With a slow-growth national economic forecast as the backdrop, LGs facing a widening structural imbalance will be unable to expand their way out of it”  “Federal retrenchment is pushing costs to states and will create additional challenges for local governments”  “Budgets tighten and payrolls contract as LGs downshift from pandemic-level staffing” Source: S&P 2026 Local Government Outlook © PFM 5 National and Regional Outlook Regional Strengths Regional Challenges Considerable fiscal strength with real estate tax making up most of the tax revenue Continued uncertainty regarding federal government employment and shutdown Improved commercial vacancy rates, but still lower than pre- pandemic levels Further softening of economic and revenue growth based on FY2025 ACFRs Overall economic uncertainty persists Drying up of ARPA dollars Source: 2025 Fiscal Conditions, National League of Cities, November 2025 © PFM 6 Credit Rating Agencies Actions  In Spring 2025, several regional entities were downgraded • State of Maryland • Prince George’s County, Maryland • Washington, D.C. • Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Agency (WMATA)  Factors that culminated in the downgrade include significant cuts to the federal workforce (D.C.), economic and financial underperformance (MD), and structural imbalance (Prince George’s County)  Northern Virginia jurisdictions’ ratings were maintained due in part to • Significant defense-related jobs in Virginia • Strong property tax base and reliance (versus income tax as a main revenue source in Maryland) © PFM 7 Slowing Revenue Growth Emerging in FY2024 0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0% 12.0% Virginia Jurisdictions' Local Revenue Average Year-Over-Year Growth City/Town County All Source: Virginia Auditor of Public Accounts (APA) Comparative Reports of Local Government Revenues and Expenditures, FY2010 to FY2024  Across all Virginia jurisdictions, revenue growth declined in FY2024  As shown, among Virginia counties, local revenue growth dropped from 10.0% in FY2023 to 5.6% in FY2024 © PFM 8 Collective Bargaining Status  Of the eight Virginia jurisdictions (excluding school divisions) that have adopted a collective bargaining ordinance, seven have ratified public safety collective bargaining agreements, while status with civilian units varies  The City of Portsmouth adopted a collective bargaining ordinance in November 2023 that authorized collective bargaining, but the City has not yet adopted a subsequent ordinance Ordinance Adoption Police Fire Transit Labor and Trades Administrative and Technical Professional General Government City of Alexandria 5/1/2021 7/1/203- 6/30/2026 7/1/203- 6/30/2026 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 Pending Pending N/A City of Richmond 7/25/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A 7/1/2025- 6/30/2028 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2025- 6/30/2028 N/A City of Charlottesville 10/3/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2026 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2025- 6/30/2029 Pending Pending N/A Arlington County 7/17/2021 7/1/2023- 6/30/2026 7/1/2023- 6/30/2026 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 Pending Pending N/A Fairfax County 10/19/2021 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A N/A N/A N/A 7/1/2026- 6/30/2029 Loudoun County 12/7/2021 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A Pending N/A N/A 7/1/2025- 6/30/2028 Prince William County 11/22/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2028 7/1/2024- 6/30/2028 N/A N/A N/A N/A Pending City of Portsmouth 11/14/2023 Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending © PFM 9 Charlottesville’s Financial Outlook © PFM 10 Key Revenue Trend: Slowing Tax Base Growth  Post pandemic, the City experienced extraordinary growth with assessed values growing by 10.5% in 2022 and by 10.3% in 2023 • More recently, however, the City is beginning to see its tax base growth slow (4.4% in 2024 and 7.4% in 2025)  After an extraordinary growth of over 28% in FY2022 driven by growth in sales, meals and lodging tax, non-property tax revenue growth has significantly declined • FY2024 revenues showed a 0.9% decline, and FY2025 revenue was essentially flat Sources: City of Charlottesville FY2013 to FY2024 Annual Comprehensive Financial Reports; FY2026 budget Property Tax 50% Meals Tax 8%Sales Tax 6% Lodging Tax 4% Other Taxes 4% Intergovernmental 17% Licenses, Permits, and Fees 6% Transfers 4% Other Revenues 1% FY2026 General Fund Revenues ($265.2 Million) © PFM 11 Tax Base and Tax Burden Comparison with Albemarle County  Most recent data indicates that Charlottesville’s per capita tax base is slightly lower than the surrounding Albemarle County  Charlottesville also has a higher tax burden, which limits its ability to continue increasing rates while remaining competitive within the region Sources: U.S. Census Bureau 2024 Population Estimates, FY2026 Adopted Budgets $262,034 $270,029 $0 $50,000 $100,000 $150,000 $200,000 $250,000 $300,000 Charlottesville Albemarle County 2025 Per Capita Taxable Assessed Value $0.98 $0.894 $0.00 $0.20 $0.40 $0.60 $0.80 $1.00 $1.20 Charlottesville Albemarle County 2025 Tax Rate (Per $100 of Assessed Value) © PFM 12 2025 Tax Rate Comparison  Charlottesville’s tax rates are relatively high even when compared to Northern Virginia (NOVA) jurisdictions  The following table shows the weighted average of Northern Virginia tax rates based on population and tax rates among NOVA counties (Loudoun, Fairfax, Prince William, Arlington) and cities (Alexandria, Falls Church, Fairfax, Manassas) • Charlottesville’s median household income is less than half of the median household income among NOVA jurisdictions • At the same time, its real property tax rate is only 4.1% lower • The City’s current personal property tax rate is already higher than NOVA jurisdictions’, and its meals tax is more than double the NOVA average (3.5%) Source: U.S. Census Bureau Five-Year American Community Survey; FY2026 adopted budgets City of Charlottesville Northern Virginia Variance Median Household Income $69,829 $142,893 -51.1% CY25 Real Property Tax $0.98 $1.02 -4.1% CY25 Personal Property Tax $4.40 $4.36 +0.9% CY25 Meals Tax 7.0% 3.5% +102.0% © PFM 13 Another Way to Measure Tax Burden: Revenue Effort  The Commonwealth of Virginia Commission on Local Government (CLG) reports on the fiscal condition calculates revenue effort each year  Revenue effort is own-source revenue collections (e.g., real estate taxes, personal property taxes, local option sales taxes) divided by revenue capacity • Revenue capacity measures how much tax revenue a locality could collect per person from its base if it used statewide average rates. The five factors included are: true value of real estate, true value of public service corporation real estate, registered vehicles, local option sales tax receipts, and adjusted gross income • In general, lower revenue effort calculations lead to lower fiscal stress  On average, revenue effort among Virginia cities is 1.2702  As shown, Charlottesville’s revenue effort is higher than the statewide average and Northern Virginia cities Revenue Effort (Higher Means More Effort) Rank (Lower Means More Effort) Charlottesville City 1.3485 13 Alexandria City 1.1876 34 Fairfax City 1.1582 38 Falls Church City 1.2476 26 Manassas City 1.2890 22 Source: FY2022 Report on Comparative Revenue Capacity, Revenue Effort, And Fiscal Stress of Virginia’s Cities and Counties © PFM 14 Key Expenditure Trend: Rising Costs Limits Investment Dollars  New round of collective bargaining agreements will create personnel cost pressures  Schools collective bargaining will also create pressures for schools contribution  Inflation remains sticky and continues to drive operating and construction costs  Conservation and prioritization should continue to be the strategy while revenue growth slows, economic environment remains uncertain, and recession risks remain FY2025 General Fund Expenditures ($265.2 Million) Source: City of Charlottesville FY2026 adopted budget Cash compensation 21% FICA 1% Health Benefits 4% Pension 5% Schools Contribution 30% Operating Expenses 13% Debt Service 6% Other Contributions 11% CIP 3% Transfers 6% © PFM 15 Charlottesville’s Collective Bargaining Cycle  The City is currently negotiating contracts with Police (for the next contract) and Fire (for FY2027)  Next year, the City will negotiate the second contract with its Fire and Transit unions  Depending on the length of the contract negotiated, the City may have at least one contract negotiation each year that adds fiscal pressure and uncertainty  While the first contract was primarily focused on bringing wages to competitive market rates, the second contracts will likely be more focused on cost-of-living adjustments FY2025 FY2026 FY2027 FY2028 FY2029 Police FY25-FY26 Contract (3% Steps) Fire FY25-FY27 Contract (2% Steps) One-Yr Reopener (1.75% adj.) Transit FY25-FY27 Contract (Increase Varies Year-Over-Year) Labor and Trades FY26-FY29 Contract (2% Steps) © PFM 16 Schools Collective Bargaining Cycle  In March 2023, the Charlottesville School Board voted to approve the Collective Bargaining Resolution  In March 2025, the School Board approved the agreement with Licensed Personnel, which includes an annual 1.5 percent “step” increase plus a 4% pay increase, or an overall increase of 5.5% for all teachers • Because of how Virginia school divisions are funded, schools’ contract provisions are often subject to sufficient appropriation from the locality • In Fairfax County, compensation increases as required by the original contract with the Fairfax Education Union was reduced in FY2026 due to the County’s budget gap and funding availability FY2025 FY2026 FY2027 FY2028 FY2029 Licensed Personnel FY26-FY28 Contract (1.5% Steps + 4% annual adj.) School Support Professionals Pending Contract © PFM 17 Health Care Fund Challenges  While surpluses in the Health Care Fund prior to FY2022 allowed the City to build up its reserves and use them to mitigate funding pressures, the City’s Health Care Fund now falls below the reserve target , even after the surplus in FY2025  Moving forward, the City not only has to increase its funding given the recent steeper growth trends in claim costs, but it also needs to start replenishing the reserve, creating even more funding pressures on the General Fund Note: The City contributed an additional $3.5 million to the Health Care Fund in FY2025 using FY2024 surplus dollars based on Council’s approval in June 2025 ($2.2) $0.4 $1.6 $2.3 $1.4 $0.7 ($1.9) ($0.4) ($3.2) $1.3 ($4.0 M) ($3.0 M) ($2.0 M) ($1.0 M) $0.0 M $1.0 M $2.0 M $3.0 M FY16 Actual FY17 Actual FY18 Actual FY19 Actual FY20 Actual FY21 Actual FY22 Actual FY23 Actual FY24 Actual FY25 Prelim Health Care Fund Surplus/(Deficit) © PFM 18 Structural Pension Pressures Funded Ratio  Even with this increased funding, the Retirement Plan for the City of Charlottesville has a funded ratio of 76.2% as of July 1, 2025  The funded ratio is the ratio of actuarial assets to actuarial liabilities  A funded ratio of less than 100% indicates the presence of unfunded actuarial accrued liabilities (UAAL). These unfunded liabilities must be paid down over time in addition to normal cost (actuarial value of benefits earned in a given year) – creating additional expenditure pressures  The Retirement Plan for the City of Charlottesville’s funded ratio is substantially below the GFOA’s target funded ratio of 100%, as well as: • The federal government’s designation for “endangered” private sector multi-employer pension plans through the Pension Protection Act (PPA) • The aggregate funded ratio for state and local pensions as estimated by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College * PPA = U.S. Pension Protection Act; ** National Average from Center for Retirement Research Sources: City of Charlottesville Actuarial Valuation (July 1, 2024); U.S. Pension Protection Act of 2006 (Public Law 109-280, 109 th Congress); Center for Retirement Research at Boston College (publicplansdata.org); Government Finance Officers Association, Sustainable Funding Practices for Defined Benefits Pensions and Other Postemployment Benefits (OPEB), 1/1/2016) Pension Funded Ratios 65.0% 76.2% 77.7% 80.0% 100.0% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% 90.0% 100.0% © PFM 19 One-Time Revenue Winding Down  Over the last several years, the City was able to advance its strategic priorities and make additional capital investments using the following one-time revenue sources: • ARPA Dollars: The City received $18.0 million through the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) and all but $1.6 million of the funds have already been assigned. Projects funded by ARPA include a property purchase from the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority, grant programs for special events, and affordable housing initiatives • Year-End Surplus: The City’s financial policies require that the City maintains a fund balance equivalent to 17% of General Fund expenditures, including a 14% general reserve and a 3% downturn reserve. Any additional surpluses are to be dedicated toward one-time expenses. In both FY2024 and FY2026, the City was able to allocate surpluses toward one-time investments, retiree contributions, and capital projects  Even though the City followed the best practice of allocating these non-recurring revenues toward one - time investments, the anticipated loss of these one-time revenues mean that the City will have to create room its General Fund budget to fund future strategic priorities, creating additional fiscal constraints given other funding pressures © PFM 20 Moving Forward © PFM 21 Rating Agency Comments “The rating reflect Charlottesville’s demonstrated ability to make budgetary adjustments toward maintaining balance, supported by growing economy and longstanding financial management policies.” “The city has a history of maintaining robust financial operations, leading to the maintenance of very strong reserves and cash balances, while pay-as-you-go cash funding covers a substantial portion of capital needs.” “The city’s financial position will remain strong and stable, supported by conservative budgetary management.” “The city continues to see strong economic growth due both to the appreciation in existing property valuations, particularly residential, and steady building permit activity.” “Low fixed costs that will likely rise over the next few years due to increased capital investment and as the city works to fund its retirement liabilities.” “As the city undertakes school infrastructure projects over the next several years, debt ratios could weaken.” “Although unlikely, we could take a negative rating action should Charlottesville operate with persistent budgetary imbalances requiring the city to draw reserves without a credible plan to replenish.” Source: S&P Global Ratings Report, Charlottesville, Virginia, General Obligation, July 25, 2024; Moody’s Ratings, Update to Credit Analysis, City of Charlottesville, VA, July 25, 2024 © PFM 22 Charlottesville’s FY24 S&P Scorecard Individual Credit Profile 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 Institutional Framework Assessment 1 aaa aaa aa+ aa aa- 2 aaa aa+ aa aa- a+ 3 aa+ aa aa- a+ a 4 aa- a+ a a- bbb+ 5 a a- bbb+ bbb bbb- 6 bbb+ bbb bbb- bb+ bb FY24 Inputs 1 (Best) 2 3 4 5 6 (Worst) Weight FY24 Score Economy 20% 1.0 Gross City/County Product (GCP) per capita as % of US GDP per capita 125% >110% 110 – 95% 95 – 85% 85 – 75% 75 – 65% <65% 50% 1 City/County Per Capita Personal Income (PCPI) as a percent of the U.S. PCPI 148% >100% 100 – 90% 90 – 80% 80 – 75% 75 – 70% <70% 50% 1 Management 20% 1.0 Budgeting Practices 1 Budgets are forward-looking with robust monitoring Budgets are realistic with sufficient monitoring Budgets are limited in scope with informal monitoring Budgets are unrealistic and lack monitoring - - 35% 1 Long-term Planning 1 Robust culture of long-term planning Some long-term planning Informal long-term planning No long-term planning - - 35% 1 Policies 1 Robust, well- defined policies with thorough reporting Basic policies with regular reporting Informal policies exist with little or no reporting No policies or policies not followed - - 30% 1 Financial Performance 20% 1.0 Operating Result (%) Net Revenues / Operating Revenues (General Fund) (3-year Average) 3.2% -4.3% (past three years) >3% 3 – 0% 0 – (-3)% <(3)% - - 20% 1 Reserves and Liquidity 20% 1.0 Available Reserves (%) (assigned + unassigned as % of revenues (General Fund) 27.8% >15% 15 – 8% 8 – 4% 4 – 1% <1% 20% 1 Debt and Liability 20% 3.7 Current cost for debt service & liabilities as % of governmental revenues 15.6% <8% 8 – 14% 14 – 20% 20 – 25% 25 – 30% >30% 50% 3 Net direct debt per capita $3,531 >500 500 – 1,500 1,500 – 2,500 2,500 – 3,500 3,500 – 4,500 >4,500 25% 5 Net pension liability (NPL) per capita $1,876 <500 500 – 1,500 1,500 – 2,500 2,500 – 3,500 3,500 – 4,500 >4,500 25% 3 Individual Credit Profile Score 1.50 Institutional Framework 1 Score mapping aaa Source: S&P’s Methodology For Rating U.S. Governments, dated September 9, 2024 © PFM 23 Moody’s Scorecard for Charlottesville  Using FY24 results, PFM estimates Charlottesville’s indicated score remains in the ‘Aa1’ category  Between FY23 and FY24, the City’s indicated score slightly worsened, due to lower fund balance and liquidity ratios Moody’s Local Government Methodology 2023 Input1 2024 Input 2024 Subfactor Category Weight 2023 Weighted Score 2024 Weighted Score Factor 1: Economy 30% Median Household Income as Percentage of US Median 90.2% 90.2% A 10% 0.597 0.597 Full Value per Capita $279,899 $314,210 Aaa 10% 0.105 0.089 Economic Growth 0.1% 0.2% Aaa 10% 0.147 0.140 Factor 2: Financial Performance 30% Available Fund Balance Ratio 49.7% 37.8% Aaa 20% 0.104 0.262 Liquidity Ratio 50.7% 38.8% Aa 10% 0.097 0.187 Factor 3: Institutional Framework 10% Institutional Framework Aa Aa Aa 10% 0.300 0.300 Factor 4: Leverage 30% Long-term Liabilities Ratio 128.8% 109.0% Aa 20% 0.473 0.354 Fixed Cost Ratio 7.3% 7.1% Aaa 10% 0.123 0.121 Notching Factors 0.0 0.0 Indicated Rating 100% 1.95 2.05 Aa1 Aa1 Indicated Rating Weighted Score Aaa 0.0 - 1.50 Aa1 1.51 – 2.50 Aa2 2.51 – 3.50 Aa3 3.51 – 4.50 A1 4.51 – 5.50 Sources: FY24 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report; calculations based on Moody’s “US Cities and Counties Methodology,” November 2, 2022. 1 FY23 inputs from Moody’s Annual Commentary Report, dated April 22, 2025 © PFM 24 Considerations Why can’t we… Rationale Increase tax rates to fund priorities? Revenue growth should be a tool in achieving fiscal balance, but the City must also be aware of its already-high tax burden. Overusing tax increase as a tool for revenue enhancement can potentially cause the City to lose its regional competitiveness (and create adverse impact, e.g., population decline) Use reserves to fund priorities? Using one-time revenue to fund recurring spending is not a sustainable fiscal strategy. That is also why the City has historically dedicated one-time surpluses to one-time needs (e.g., capital investments, one-time retiree funding) Cut spending to fund priorities? Spending reduction can be a tool to reallocate resources, but it can also be challenging given that so much of the budget is allocated to core local government services Grow our tax base to fund priorities? Tax base growth should be a key strategy for any local governments, but relying on the prospective growth to fund current spending needs today can create significant fiscal risks A sustainable fiscal strategy relies on multiple tools to grow revenues, curb spending growth, and invest in capital needs and strategic priorities. These three prongs must work together and adapt to changing economic conditions and investment needs. © PFM 25 Summary  Local governments across the nation are facing headwinds from slowing economic growth and ARPA dollars winding down  For Charlottesville, collective bargaining, health care fund challenges, and continued need to improve pension funding will add another layer of fiscal pressures  These dynamics point to a budget that should focus on conversation and prioritization  While rating agencies cite the City’s strong management and financial operations, the City needs to have sufficient financial buffer to adapt and adjust given overall economic and federal uncertainty

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.