Police Civilian Oversight Board — Agenda Packet
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Police Civilian Oversight Board · meeting of Jan 8, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Regular Meeting Agenda
Police Civilian Oversight Board
January 8, 2026
CitySpace
100 5th St NE
Charlottesville, VA 22902
6:30 PM Regular Session
I. Call to Order | Roll Call
II. Agenda Approval
- Approval of agenda: January 8th, 2026
III. Minutes Approval
- Approval of meeting minutes: December 11th, 2025
IV. Announcements
- Next internal CPD CommStat is Tuesday, January 27th, 2026 (member interest)
- March PCOB meeting will be held in the Parks & Recs Conference room below
- City Budget Forum next week, PCOB at Public Safety table (see news alert)
V. Public Comment One (Including Guest Speaker, Lt. Jake Via, CPD Internal Affairs)
VI. Ordinance Model
- Preparation for Board opinion on PCOB Ordinance oversight model
VII. Board 2026 Work Plan
- Discussion of Work Plan process, purpose, and structure
- Discussion of any alterations, feedback, or additions/removals
- Identification of commitment to specific aspects of the Work Plan by Board
members
VIII. Community Understanding
- Report from PCOB Acting Director on community outreach
- Report on historical perspectives from early Board documentation
- Report on any Board member community outreach
IX. Public Comment Two
X. Adjournment
Notice: For members of the public participating virtually, if you experience technical difficulties, you
may call 434-970-3115, and a staff person will assist you. Individuals with disabilities who require
assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator
at (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville
requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made.
Police Civilian Oversight Board
Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Chair
Dr. Kyle Dobson, Vice Chair
Andrew Frye, At Large
George Dillard Jr., LE Rep
Ruairi Vaughan, At Large
Albe LaFave, At Large
CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD
MEETING MINUTES
Date: December 11, 2025
Scheduled Time: 6:30 p.m.
Location: CitySpace - 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902
Board Members Attending: Dr. Jeffrey Fracher (Chair), Dr. Kyle Dobson (Vice
Chair), Andrew Frye, Albe LaFave.
Board Members Not Attending: George Dillard Jr., Ruairi Vaughan.
Guests: N/A
Call to Order | Roll Call:
• The meeting was called to order at 6:30 p.m. by Chair Dr. Jeffrey Fracher.
Agenda Approval:
• A motion was made by Mr. LaFave to approve the current meeting agenda for
December 11, 2025. Motion seconded by Dr. Dobson and approved
unanimously.
Minutes Approval:
• A motion was made by Mr. Frye to approve the meeting minutes from
November 13, 2025. Motion seconded by Dr. Dobson and approved
unanimously.
Announcements:
• Mr. Walker reported that Mr. Dillard was absent due to work in Washington,
D.C.
• Mr. Walker provided an update on board member appointments: the
application window closed November 17, 2025, and City Council has
scheduled interviews for January. Five applications were received, with three
candidates selected for interviews. New members would join the Board at the
February meeting, giving the Board a full eight members.
• Mr. Walker explained changes to the parking garage access system. The new
system uses license plate scanning technology. Board members will need to
provide their license plate information to be added to the validation system for
official Board business.
• Dr. Fracher provided an update on independent counsel. The City Attorney's
office is screening potential attorneys, and they have narrowed the selection
to two or three firms. There has been a shift in utilization rules such that
outside counsel would only be engaged if there is a dispute between the
Board and the City. The City Attorney will represent the Board in all matters
that do not involve an adversarial position with the City. Mr. Walker indicated
the Board has budget allocated for attorney fees. The final determination for
selecting an attorney will be subject to the full Board’s consideration and
approval.
Public Comment One:
• Kate Fraleigh (KF), who has followed the Police Civilian Oversight Board
since 2018, encouraged the Board to review historical documents and consult
with original founders. KF read elements the original members considered
critical to successful oversight, including: independent authority to review
complaints, independent authority to conduct parallel investigations, access to
CPD documents and data, professional support staff with appropriate budget,
and public engagement and reporting. KF noted the original proposed
ordinance was changed before adoption.
• Alec Pandaleon (AP) asked whether the Board member candidate interviews
are public. Dr. Fracher confirmed they are private and conducted by City
Council. AP asked how many 8 or 12-hour shifts each Board member and the
Acting Director have completed as ride-alongs with CPD. Dr. Dobson and Mr.
Frye each reported one 8-hour shift. Mr. LaFave reported none with CPD. Mr.
Walker indicated he is looking forward to engaging in this once the Board and
Office are set on firm footing again and replacement staff are hired.
Office Presentation:
• Mr. Walker presented an overview of civilian oversight models as identified by
NACOLE (National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement).
i. Investigation Focused Model: Emphasizes independent investigations
conducted by the oversight body or professional staff. Allows for
independent intake of complaints, investigation, findings, and disciplinary
recommendations. Requires trained investigators, officer interview
capabilities, and greater staffing. Mr. Walker noted this model is limited for
the PCOB because the Board cannot compel officer testimony due to an
inability to extend Garrity protections.
a. Dr. Fracher elaborated that there are other legal barriers beyond
Garrity, including resource and staffing constraints. Many investigative
models require paid board members or dedicated investigative staff.
b. Mr. Walker explained Garrity protections: public sector employees can
be compelled to testify in administrative investigations under threat of
discipline, but that testimony cannot be used in criminal proceedings.
Only entities with disciplinary authority over officers can provide Garrity
protection; since the PCOB lacks this authority, it cannot compel
testimony.
ii. Auditor/Monitor Focused Model: Involves active engagement during
complaint investigations conducted by law enforcement, including
monitoring officer interviews and auditing case files. Focuses on systemic
changes, policies, and trends. Mr. Walker rated PCOB's status in this
model as moderate. The Office currently attends Internal Affairs interviews
as an observer, monitors systems like the automated license plate
readers, and sits on the use of force review panel.
a. Dr. Fracher clarified that while Mr. Walker can attend interviews, he
does not have authority to ask questions, as that would constitute
compelling the officer to answer the PCOB's questions.
iii. Review Focused Model: A quality assurance function where the board
reviews completed Internal Affairs investigations. Provides accountability
over the police department's process without direct engagement in
investigations. Mr. Walker rated PCOB's status as developing, noting the
Board can review completed cases but has not yet done so in practice.
iv. Hybrid Model: A combination of characteristics from other models. The
PCOB is authorized as a hybrid model with authority under all three
approaches. Mr. Walker suggested the Office could focus primarily on
audit/monitor functions while the Board focuses on review functions.
• Mr. Walker listed Virginia oversight entities: Alexandria, Arlington, Richmond,
and Fairfax operate hybrid models; Norfolk and Virginia Beach operate
review-focused models. Charlottesville was among the first in Virginia to
establish civilian oversight.
• Dr. Fracher noted the Board will need to develop a recommendation to City
Council for changes to the ordinance to make the current model workable, as
the Board has struggled to function effectively in six years under the current
structure.
• Dr. Dobson encouraged public observers to look past labels and focus on the
concrete actions and work the Board is doing, rather than getting caught up in
which model category applies.
• Mr. Walker emphasized the goal is to codify the Board's work more clearly
and focus it so that outcomes are accomplishable by a volunteer board with
limited staff.
• Mr. Walker presented an evaluation of the PCOB against NACOLE's 13
Principles of Effective Oversight, providing rankings from 1-5. Key findings
included: Independence rated 3/5 (developing); Unfettered Access to Records
rated 4/5 (strong access through current Chief, but not fully codified in
ordinance); Access to Law Enforcement Executives rated 4/5; Full
Cooperation rated 3/5 (limited by inability to compel testimony); Sustained
Stakeholder Support rated 2/5 (limited and inconsistent); Adequate Funding
and Resources rated low (current resources insufficient for full mandate; four
full-time staff recommended); Public Reporting and Transparency rated 4/5.
• Dr. Fracher noted that the current Chief has been very open about providing
access, but the previous Chief provided little to no access. Without
codification in the ordinance, access remains at the discretion of whoever
holds the position.
• Mr. Walker presented 2022-2025 complaint statistics from Internal Affairs. In
2025 to date: 46 external complaints (from public or PCOB) and 28 internal
complaints (from within the department). Mr. Walker noted the increasing
trend in internal investigations suggests a growing culture of accountability
within the department.
i. Top allegation types across all years: unsatisfactory performance,
courtesy, conformance to law, unbecoming conduct, truthfulness, and
excessive force.
ii. Finding distribution across 2022-2025: approximately 42% of allegations
were sustained, with roughly equal representation of unfounded versus
sustained findings. Mr. Walker noted the exonerated category (allegation
occurred but officer followed policy) could be a focus area for policy
review.
• Mr. Walker demonstrated the PCOB website, highlighting the data and
reporting section, the 2024 annual report, complaint filing portal, and ongoing
development efforts for transparency.
Board Member Discussion and Activity Items:
• Dr. Dobson presented a draft work plan developed with Mr. Walker. The
vision involves a four-stage monthly process: (1) Seek Understanding -
gathering community experiences through canvassing, surveys, and
engagement at community events; (2) Analysis - coding and interpreting
community feedback to identify themes and focal points; (3) Prioritize Work -
using community input to determine monthly oversight priorities; (4) Report
Outcomes - communicating work completed to the community, Chief of
Police, City Council, and City Manager's office.
• Dr. Dobson emphasized the goal is to put community concerns first while
creating a documented, evidence-based approach to oversight work with a
clear monthly cadence.
• Mr. Walker noted the draft work plan is very rough, developed in
approximately one hour, and is intended to introduce the concept for further
development. The goal is to formalize and make sustainable the Board's work.
• Dr. Fracher expressed support for the model but suggested waiting until the
Board has its full membership to formally adopt the work plan through a vote.
• Dr. Dobson indicated he would commit to participating in downtown mall
canvassing and attending community events during December.
• Mr. Walker offered to provide historical documents for Board members to
review, including a report from a previous town hall and original documents
from the PCOB's founding.
• The Board discussed potential December activities including: stationary
canvassing on the downtown mall, attending neighborhood association
meetings and community events, and reviewing historical documents.
• Mr. LaFave indicated he would visit the office the following afternoon.
Public Comment Two:
• Kate Fraleigh (KF) provided a list of organizations for potential community
outreach: Legal Aid Justice Center, Virginia Organizing, People's Coalition,
one-stop shop at Carver Recreation Center, Jefferson School African-
American Heritage Center, and the NAACP (noting Mr. Dillard is Vice-
President of the local chapter). KF noted that original PCOB Board members
were selected through a public process at the Jefferson School where
candidates gave speeches and attendees provided input to the City. KF
expressed concern that City Council's sole control over Board appointments
may limit diversity of perspectives.
• Dr. Fracher noted that Board appointment procedures are in the ordinance
and could be addressed in future joint conversations with City Council.
• KF offered to connect Board members with original PCOB founders, including
Gloria Beard, for conversations about the Board's history and original intent.
• Dr. Fracher reminded attendees that if more than two Board members are
present for community engagement, it constitutes a public meeting with
associated requirements.
• Dr. Dobson noted interest in exploring whether public input on Board
appointments could still be gathered and submitted to City Council, even if not
formally required.
Adjournment:
• A motion to adjourn was made by Dr. Dobson, seconded by Mr. Frye, and
approved unanimously.
• Meeting adjourned at 8:11 p.m.
Certified by James Walker, Acting PCOB Director
Date Adopted: ____________________________
Certified: ________________________________
Police Civilian Oversight Board
MODELS OF OVERSIGHT — SUMMARY FOR BOARD REVIEW
Overview
The National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement (NACOLE) defines three
primary oversight models, plus a hybrid approach. NACOLE emphasizes that any model must
be implemented fully in accordance with their Thirteen Principles of Oversight to be effective
and maintain community trust. The following table lays out these models with defined
characteristics and implications. The final column identifies the status of the PCOB to
implement characteristics of each model. An example of an oversight entity which
predominantly represents each model is also provided.
Oversight Models Comparison
Model Key Characteristics Implications PCOB Status
Investigation
Focused
Example:
Cincinnati CCA
Independent and full investigative
authority conducted by oversight body
and/or professional staff.
Allows independent intake of
complaints, followed by investigation,
findings, and disciplinary action or
recommendations.
Strengthens community trust by
removing perceived conflict of interest
from Internal Affairs investigations.
Requires trained
investigators, officer/witness
interview capability, evidence
access, greater
staffing/funding, and strict
adherence to timelines and
administrative policies.
Often encounters legal and
practical resistance,
especially in collective
bargaining environments.
LIMITED
Audit/Monitor
Focused
Example: Seattle
CPC & OIG
Active engagement during complaint
investigations conducted by law
enforcement.
Prioritizes systemic change through
policy and trend analysis.
Addresses deficiencies in policies,
procedures, and practices with broad
scope including training, budget, and
technology deployment.
Requires trained
analysts/auditors, access to
police records, moderate
staffing/funding with advisory
legal support.
Must produce clear outcomes
and products for decision-
making stakeholders.
MODERATE
Review
Focused
Example:
Cambridge PRAB
Quality assurance function over
investigation of misconduct
complaints by law enforcement.
Provides accountability mechanism
over policies, procedures, and
disciplinary action.
Prioritizes transparency into existing
law enforcement adjudication
procedures.
Requires access to police
records, minimal
staffing/funding with advisory
legal support, and moderate
adherence to timelines and
appeals processes.
Must produce clear outcomes
and products for decision-
making stakeholders.
DEVELOPING
Hybrid
Example:
Berkeley PAB &
ODPA
Blends characteristics, authorities,
and outcomes of multiple models.
Allows customized powers and duties
shaped to locality needs and capacity.
Most common structure nationwide,
often dividing responsibility between
professional staff and
appointed/elected community
representatives.
Requires trained staff, access
to police records, flexible
staffing/funding with advisory
legal support.
Must produce clear outcomes
and products for decision-
making stakeholders.
DEVELOPING
*The PCOB ordinance establishes a hybrid model with an implied investigation focus. Current limitations stem
from legal, policy, and procedural barriers requiring revisions to the ordinance, CPD General Orders, and the
CPD Collective Bargaining Agreement for effective functionality and intended outcomes.
Virginia Localities with Civilian Oversight:
Hybrid: Alexandria, Arlington, Richmond, and Fairfax County
Review-Focused: Norfolk and Virginia Beach
Reference: Ordinance revisions reviewed at joint City Council and PCOB meeting, September 11, 2025. Source:
NACOLE oversight models.
2026 Work Plan
Police Civilian Oversight Board
The City of Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board (PCOB) was established
pursuant to Virginia Code § 9.1- 601 and Charlottesville City Code Article XVI to provide
objective and independent civilian-led oversight of the Charlottesville Police Department
(CPD). As stated in Section 2- 453 of the City Code, the purpose of the Board is to
establish and maintain trust between and among the Department, the City Council, the
City Manager, and the public.
This 2026 Work Plan serves as the guiding framework for the Board's activities and
priorities. The plan outlines how the Board and the PCOB Office will fulfill statutory
obligations within Article XVI of the City Code. The plan establishes a monthly cadence
of community engagement, analysis, oversight , and reporting, enabling the Board to
remain responsive to community concerns while systematically advancing oversight. The
plan also delineates the respective roles of the Board and the Director in carrying out this
work, ensuring accountability and coordination between the Board and Office staff.
Police Civilian Oversight Board Members
Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Chair
Dr. Kyle Dobson, Vice Chair
Andrew Frye, At Large
George Dillard Jr., LE Rep
Ruairi Vaughan, At Large
Albe LaFave, At Large
Office of Police Civilian Oversight
James Walker, Acting Director
Glossary of Terms
As part of the PCOB’s ongoing effort to make its work more accessible to the
community, the Board has developed a Glossary of Terms which helps to define and
provide understand both internally and to the community what is meant by certain
terminology and phrasing related to the Board’s work.
Purpose
This work plan establishes a monthly process by which the Police Civilian Oversight
Board organizes and conducts oversight work aligned with the regular monthly meeting
schedule. The process ensures that meetings are responsive to community experiences
and needs related to law enforcement while enabling meaningful prioritization of efforts
given the Board's limited time and volunteer structure.
Process
The work plan follows a four-step cycle: (1) Seek Understanding from the community, (2)
Conduct Analysis to identify themes and priorities, (3) Conduct Oversight through
structured Board action, and (4) Report Outcomes to stakeholders. Each step builds on
the previous, creating a continuous feedback loop between community input and Board
action. The Director of the PCOB Office supports the Board throughout this process,
facilitating research, conducting audits, and managing administrative functions.
Step 1: Seek Understanding
Engage in regular community outreach and collaboration to understand the community's
experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department and identify which law
enforcement topics the community prioritizes for oversight work. Seek the assistance and
input of community members while providing education, awareness, and guidance on
policing matters and the role of the Board.
Contacts
• Utilize the Community Connections Directory to identify candidates for outreach
• Structure outreach to achieve a well -balanced sample across the City’s diverse
neighborhoods, business districts, and community demographics
• Track connections and maintain relationships with community connections
Methods
• Utilize outreach methods such as canvassing, surveys, listening sessions, and
interviews
• Host public community listening and discussion sessions on policing matters of
pressing public concern
• Reference and build upon past work of the Board
Locations
• Engage at community events, town halls, neighborhood association meetings,
organization-led events, and individual meetings
• Host or participate in public police-community relations meetings
Messaging
• Utilize the Outreach Process to guide conversations
• Prioritize listening rather than explaining
• Be prepared to answer questions, but also note questions requiring later or Office-
led response
Documentation
• Record understanding gained from the community using the Community
Understanding Survey or the Internal Community Insights form.
• Document public input and recommendations received during listening sessions
Step 2: Conduct Analysis
Utilize shared community experience and understanding, along with available data and
Director-conducted audits, to identify themes, establish context, and determine focal
points for oversight work.
Collation
• Summarize experiences gathered through community understanding efforts
• Establish clear themes and throughlines across community input
Data Collection
• Identify data sets that speak to and provide context on the themes identified
Relevant data may include: complaint records and patterns, internal affairs
investigation outcomes, use of force data, arrest and detention patterns,
department expenditures, policies and procedures, training records, and crime
statistics
• Request the Director conduct or provide audits examining patterns relevant to
identified themes
Discussion
• Hold internal Board discussion to understand experiences at a narrative level
• Establish connections between identified themes and the Board's oversight
authorities
• Consider which type of oversight action is most appropriate for each identified
concern
Prioritization
• Set the focus for the following month based on collection and analysis of
community experience, trend discussion, and context identified
• Establish oversight work priorities through Board consensus
• Assign specific oversight tasks as needed to Board members and the Director
Step 3: Conduct Oversight
Execute the prioritized oversight work through structured Board action, with the Director
supporting implementation. Work culminates in findings, recommendations, or public
reports as appropriate to the type of oversight conducted.
Scope
• Define the specific oversight question or focus area based on the prioritized topic
• Identify the type of oversight work to be conducted:
Internal affairs review: Reviewing department investigations for accuracy,
completeness, impartiality, and sufficiency of discipline
Policy, practice, or procedural review: Investigating policies, practices, and
procedures of the department
System review or a udit: Examining patterns in system use, application, and
impact, internal affairs investigations, arrests and detentions, expenditures, or
other public-police interactions
Expenditure review: Analyze annual department expenditures and making
budgetary recommendations
• Establish clear boundaries for the inquiry, including what is and is not within scope
• Identify the intended output: findings, recommendations, disciplinary
recommendations, or public reporting
Research
• Engage the Director to gather relevant information from authorized sources
Sources may include: department policies and procedures, complaint and
disciplinary records, internal affairs files, use of force data, training materials,
department data systems, contracts and agreements, industry standards and
best practices, and comparable jurisdiction approaches
• The Director may actively monitor department investigations of complaints with
access to records
• Request additional information from CPD or through the City Manager as needed
• If information cannot be obtained voluntarily, consider whether to seek subpoenas
through the Circuit Court
Analysis
• Examine gathered information through the lens of community experience and
oversight objectives
• Identify gaps, concerns, policy violations, or areas for improvement
• Develop preliminary findings and potential recommendations
• The Director may prepare an analysis report summarizing circumstances,
evidence, and suggested findings
Deliberation
• Present findings to the full Board for discussion and refinement
• Conduct closed session deliberations or public review hearings as appropriate to
examine facts, issues, and findings
• Consider diverse perspectives and potential unintended consequences
• Refine recommendations to ensure they are actionable, timely, achievable, and
measurable
• Develop written findings with supporting rationale
Action
• Issue findings through formal Board vote:
For IA reviews: state concurrence with findings, non- concurrence with
recommendations, or finding of incomplete/unsatisfactory investigation
For systems, budgetary, policy, practice, or procedure reviews: develop
written findings and recommendations with supporting rationale
• Document the Board's decision, including any dissenting views if applicable
• Assign responsibility for implementation or follow-up as appropriate
Step 4: Report Outcomes
Provide transparent reporting on the activities of the Board to relevant stakeholders,
maintaining accountability to the community that informed the work. Make public reports
on reviews, audits, hearings, findings, recommendations, determinations, and oversight
activities as appropriate while protecting confidential information.
Community
• Summarize Board actions through community events, newsletters, or public
communications
• Communicate outcomes in accessible language, showing how community input
shaped the work
• Report findings to specific complainants within required timeframes
• Engage news outlets as appropriate for broader public awareness
Chief of Police
• Report findings and recommendations in monthly Community Statistics meetings
• Provide written policy recommendations with supporting rationale
• Track CPD response to recommendations; if declined, request written explanation
within 30 days
City Council
• Communicate through brief presentations or written reports
• Board members lead communications with Council on policy matters
• Submit budgetary recommendations during the annual budget process
• Present proposed state legislative recommendations by August 15 annually for
consideration in the City's legislative program
• The Director provides an annual report detailing Board and Office activities for the
preceding calendar year
City Manager
• Communicate through brief presentations or written reports
• The Director leads administrative communications and provides reports on
oversight activities
• Report findings from audits, reviews, and hearings
• Escalate resource or structural concerns as appropriate
Work of the Board vs. Office
While Charlottesville City Code Article XVI provides a high-level delineation of the duties
and authority of the Board and the Office, this detailed list is meant to focus on more
specific duties of each side of the PCOB.
Public Relations & Community Engagement
Shared
• Engage in outreach to community organizations, businesses, leaders, advocates,
and residents to ascertain the needs and priorities of the community related to
law enforcement
• Host or participate in public community listening and discussion sessions on
policing matters of pressing public concern
• Participate in public police-community relations meetings
• Provide education, awareness, and guidance on policing matters and the role of
the Board
• T rack outreach connections made using the Community Understanding Survey
or the Internal Community Insights form.
Board Members
• Represent the Board at community events, neighborhood association meetings,
and organization-led events
• Build and maintain ongoing relationships with community members, inviting them
to participate in Board meetings through public comment
• Communicate Board activities and findings to the public through presentations
and community engagement
Office Staff
• Develop any digital or print materials needed for engagement, whether for
collection of input from community or creation of resources, educational
materials, or information to provide
• Set up any event spaces or locations through the city and run any marketing or
news alert posts needed
• Act as primary point of contact for media entities and ensure timely response to
media inquiries
• Maintain the Community Connections Directory as a place to track outreach
connections
• Document public input and recommendations received during listening sessions
• Coordinate logistics for community events hosted by the Board
Evidence-Based Review of Policies, Practices, & Procedures
Shared
• Identify themes and throughlines from community input that warrant analysis
• Discuss audit findings and their implications for oversight priorities
• Review department expenditure estimates and projections
Board Members
• Request the Director to conduct additional audits by majority vote
• Review and interpret audit findings in the context of community concerns
• Make law enforcement budgetary recommendations to the City Manager and/or
City Council during the annual budget process
• Prioritize data sets and topics for audit based on community understanding and
Board discussion
Office Staff
• Conduct internal audits of prioritized data sets identified by the Board and/or by
the City Manager's Office and CPD.
• Conduct retrospective examinations of patterns in internal affairs investigations,
arrests and detentions, department expenditures, and other public-police
interactions
• Review department data systems to support oversight functions
• Provide summary reports of any audits conducted to the Board and the City
Manager upon completion
• Present department expenditure estimates to the Board for review
• Prepare data visualizations and summaries to support Board analysis and
decision-making
Policy & Legal Review
Shared
• Find specific general orders and policies related to the topic(s) of the month
• Decide state legislative recommendations after considering what the biggest
challenges of the year were together
• Make comments on the specific general orders and policies chosen for the month
•
Board Members
• Review and make recommendations regarding policies, practices, and
procedures of the department
• Present written findings and recommendations with supporting rationale to
Council, the City Manager, and Chief of Police
• Approve retention of independent legal counsel from a list recommended by the
City Attorney
• Authorize subpoenas by two-thirds vote when information cannot be obtained
voluntarily
Office Staff
• Conduct and report on research on city policy, policing practices, and legal
implications related to the work of the PCOB
• Draft and redline specific PCOB policy documents for preparation to City Council
agenda
• Review department policies, practices, and procedures as part of ongoing
oversight activities
• Attend department meetings relevant to oversight functions
• Retain independent legal counsel on behalf of the Board after Board approval
and finance director endorsement
• Apply for subpoenas on behalf of the Board when authorized by two-thirds vote
Direct Oversight of Law Enforcement
Shared
• Discuss findings and suggested recommendations from monitoring and audit
reports
• Consider whether to propose mediation or alternative dispute resolution to
resolve complaints
Board Members
• Hold closed session deliberations or public review hearings examine facts,
issues, and findings of internal affairs investigations or law enforcement policies,
practices, and procedures
• Issue findings on deliberations or public review hearing outcomes within 30 days
Office Staff
• Receive, document, refer, and monitor citizen complaints of police misconduct
submitted to the PCOB
• Participate in regularly scheduled use of force panel reviews
• Decide when to include and ask PCOB members to join into aspects of the
processes above to gain additional perspective
• Actively monitor department investigations of complaints with access to records
• Prepare reports to the Board on selected review cases summarizing
circumstances, evidence, and suggested findings for each allegation
• Participate in candidate interviews for CPD employment
Reporting & Administration
Shared
• Ensure transparency in Board activities while protecting confidential information
• Comply with all applicable FOIA requirements for public records and meetings
Board Members
• Attend and participate in regular monthly public meetings and work sessions
• Complete required ordinance training on ordinance-specified topics within the
required timeline
• Maintain privacy of all confidential or privileged information indefinitely
• Submit a written performance review of the Director to the City Manager for
inclusion in annual evaluation
• Communicate with City Council through brief presentations or written reports on
policy matters
• Participate in the Director interview and appointment process
Office Staff
• Manage all administrative and fiscal needs of the Board and the Office
• Report to the Board on day-to-day operational activities of the Office
• Report all oversight activities to the Board and the City Manager or designee
• Provide an annual report to the Board, City Manager, City Council, and the
community detailing activities for the preceding calendar year
• Provide additional reports as deemed appropriate to ensure transparency into
oversight activities and audits
• Facilitate or provide Board member training on ordinance-specified topics within
the required timeline
• Coordinate with the City Manager on operating procedures and standard
operating procedures
• Maintain meeting minutes including date, time, location, attendance, discussion
summary, and vote records
• Communicate with City Manager's Office through reports and presentations on
administrative matters
DECEMBER 2025 - JANUARY 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Identify requirements for stationary canvasing on the
Downtown Mall or other public venues. Organize
Work Plan documentation for Board access.
Kyle Dobson
• Gain a historical understanding of community
experience from past Board documentation and
community input.
Andrew Frye
• Create a glossary of terms to provide transparency
for all stakeholders of the City of Charlottesville.
Sharing reality through consultation of
asynchronous definitions through PCOB,
community, and literature
Ruairi Vaughan
• Select a CPD General Order to gain understanding
of policy and summarize for the Board with a stated
priority level.
Unassigned
• Choose an ordinance topic to understand and
summarize to the Board in lead up to a joint meeting
with City Council.
Jeff Fracher
JANUARY - FEBRUARY 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
FEBRUARY - MARCH 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
MARCH - APRIL 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
APRIL - MAY 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
MAY - JUNE 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
JUNE - JULY 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
JULY - AUGUST 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
AUGUST - SEPTEMBER 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
SEPTEMBER - OCTOBER 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
OCTOBER - NOVEMBER 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
NOVEMBER - DECEMBER 2026
TASK DUE DATE COMMITMENT BOARD MEMBER(S) COMPLETION
• Task 1
Subtask 1
• Task 2
Subtask 2
• Task 3
Subtask 3
• Task 4
Subtask 4
• Task 5
Subtask 5
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 27, 2026.