RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting — Agenda Packet

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Mar 5, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHESTERFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AGENDA WEDNESDAY, MARCH 5, 2025 Public Meeting Room 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield VA 23832 NOTE: Attachments are generally available the Wednesday prior to the Board of Zoning Appeals meeting. Any subsequent changes to this agenda prior to the date of the meeting, and more detailed information regarding items on the agenda can be found at chesterfield.gov/plan, or by calling the Planning Department at 804-748-1050 during regular business hours, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday. A map of each case can be found at chesterfield.gov/plancases. Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service 12:00 p.m. Lunch/work session in Executive Session Room, 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield, Virginia 23832 1. 1 p.m. Meeting called to order in the Public Meeting Room, Lane B. Ramsey Administration Building, Chesterfield, Virginia 2. Invocation 3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America 4. Approval of Minutes • February 5, 2025 5. Acknowledgements of withdrawal and requests for deferral 6. Consideration of variance requests A. 24VA1317 (Deferred from 02/05/2025): In Dale Magisterial District, Vili and Jasmin Ascencio request a variance to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Upton Road) for dwelling purposes and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District lying on the north line of Upton Road approximately 1160 feet off the northern terminus of Indian Springs Road also known as 7711 Upton Road. The 2.1 acre property is proposed for 1 single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 781-675-0598. Access will be across portions of Indian Springs Road and Upton Road which are dedicated but unimproved. B. 24VA1341: In Bermuda Magisterial District, Angela Ruiz-Cue requests a 495 square foot variance to the required 7,000 square feet of lot area using a zoning lot comprised of two (2) lots (Lots 46 & 47) and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District fronting the east line of Elokomin Avenue approximately 50 feet north of Melba Street. The 0.15 acre property is proposed for one single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property Page 1 of 39 Chesterfield County Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting March 5, 2025 is appropriate for Corporate Office/Research & Development/Light Industrial uses. Tax ID 796-664-2556. C. 24VA1344: In Bermuda Magisterial District, Josue Cuellar Lopez requests a variance to use a parcel of land that fronts on a dedicated but unimproved public road (Sylvania Road) for dwelling purposes and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District known as 3207 Sylvania Road. The 1.12 acre property is developed with one single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 797-637-4124. Access will be across a portion of Sylvania Road which is dedicated but unimproved. 7. Miscellaneous 8. Adjournment Page 2 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 1 of 16 24VA1317 – Vili & Jasmin Ascencio Magisterial District – Dale Applicant's Contact – Vili Ascencio (804-475-7891) BZA Public Hearing – March 5, 2025 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Variance to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Upton Road) for dwelling purposes in a Residential (R-7) District. Staff Recommendation Denial The Property 7711 Upton Road Site Size 2.1 Acres Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Street View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended conditions, and an access plan are located in the report. STAFF - DENIAL • There are no physical surroundings, shape, or topographical conditions on this property that a particular hardship would result to the owner if the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance were carried out and a public road is constructed to State standards. • No extraordinary circumstances or conditions apply to this property which do not apply generally to all other properties in the area. • A practical alternative exists that would eliminate the need for the variance request. Recommendation Page 3 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 2 of 16 PLANNING • This lot is within a subdivision, recorded with the expectation that lots have State road frontage. • Constructing Indian Springs and Upton Road to State standards would benefit the subject property as well continue to incrementally improve the street network for the multiple properties fronting the unimproved portion of these streets. • Vacant lots fronting Upton Road provides the potential for additional no public road frontage variance requests. CDOT • A license agreement must be obtained from the County to use Curtis Circle as a dedicated but unimproved right of way. • Although a license agreement requires private maintenance agreement, the County often is requested to perform road maintenance without budgeted funds. • Chesterfield Department of Transportation (CDOT) supports improvements and acceptance of a sections of Indian Springs and Upton Road into the State system. Summary of Identified Topics Page 4 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 3 of 16 Background • The Board of Zoning Appeals hears requests for no public road frontage for parcels meeting one of the following criteria:  Recorded prior to April 1976  Subdivided for a member of the property owner’s immediate family  Recorded through the plat validation process • The Zoning Ordinance requires a property being used for dwelling purposes to have a minimum of fifty (50) feet of public road frontage. • The subject property was recorded in 1951 as part of Reedy Branch Subdivision prior to County road frontage requirements. • The applicants purchased the property October 28, 2022. • The applicants intend to rectify the deficiency in required road frontage to building one (1) single family dwelling. • A new home was constructed fronting Upton Road in 2024. In March of 2024 building permit 20240327- 064 was reviewed and approved by Planning without discovering the deficiency in required road frontage. • Four (4) variance requests for no public road frontage have been approved for properties using the same unimproved right of way (Cases: 77SN0016, 77SN0177, 94AN0101 and 10AN0143). • Two (2) single family dwellings have been constructed deficient in required road frontage using the same unimproved right of way (constructed in 1991 & 2024). • Two (2) single family dwellings were constructed prior to County road frontage requirements (constructed 1900 &1973). • One (1) single family dwelling was constructed deficient in required road frontage but now achieves required road frontage with the extension of Indian Springs Road into the State system 200 feet beyond the bridge reconstruction (7901 Indian Springs Road). • The lack of public road frontage may be rectified by either receiving a variance for no public road frontage or constructing the roads to State standards. Planning Page 5 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 4 of 16 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Summary of Identified Topics ................................................................................................................................................. 2 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Aerial - Overview ..................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Current Zoning Map .............................................................................................................................................................. 10 Supplemental Analysis .......................................................................................................................................................... 11 Environmental Engineering ............................................................................................................................................... 11 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................. 11 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................. 11 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................. 11 Utilities – Water and Wastewater .................................................................................................................................... 11 Virginia Department of Health .......................................................................................................................................... 11 Real Property .................................................................................................................................................................... 12 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................. 13 Proposed Access Plan – Exhibit A.......................................................................................................................................... 14 Reedy Branch Subdivision Plat .............................................................................................................................................. 15 Public Hearings ...................................................................................................................................................................... 16 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 16 Table of Contents Page 6 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 5 of 16 Aerial - Overview Vacant Vacant – 14AN0130 94AN0101 & 06AN0124 (amended) - Built in 1994 Built in 1973 10AN0143 - Built in 2011 7906 Indian Springs Road Built in 1978 77sn0177 7901 Indian Springs Road Built in 1994 No Variance Built in 1977 77sn0016 Built in 1991 No Variance Built in 2024 No Variance End of State Maintenance 21 feet 12 feet 8 feet 9’ 3” Built in 1900 Page 7 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 6 of 16 Proposal The applicants offer the following justification for this request: “In trying to establish a home for my family of five, the experience of acquiring land and planning to build a home has transformed from a hopeful venture into a multifaceted challenge. One of the most significant obstacles we face is the lack of public road frontage on our property, which complicates our housing project. We've attempted to reconcile the road frontage deficiency before applying for the exception. Since staff cannot support our request as this request is within a recorded subdivision, the roads need to be constructed to serve the community's needs. The dream of building a home for our family on our land has been marked by significant hardships, primarily stemming from the lack of public road frontage. As we continue to navigate these challenges, we remain committed to finding solutions that will allow us to create a safe and nurturing environment for our children. While the journey has been fraught with financial obstacles, it has also strengthened our resolve and deepened our appreciation for the importance of community and accessibility in pursuing our family's future. The lack of public road access has also increased financial strain. VDOT requires us to fix the road out of our finances before accepting the road. As we navigate these financial implications, the stress of meeting our family's needs intensifies, particularly as we strive to stay within budget while accommodating our children's requirements for safe and stable housing. Before applying for permits, we saw a house constructed within months just two lots down just recently. We assumed that since the house was being completed, the public road was up to standards. To our surprise, when we applied, we were informed that the applicants from that home were not required to apply for a variance since the Chesterfield County Planning Department had yet to recognize the lack of public roads and approved the permits without hesitation. We find it unjust that this burden has fallen on my wife and me, especially since the house was constructed by a construction company that perhaps could have helped with the financial burden of building a road”. Access Access will be across parts of Indian Springs Road and Upton Road which are dedicated but unimproved from Point A to Point B as shown on the Access Plan. Access Plan Aerial - Overview Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following: • Indian Springs Road is State maintained to approximately 200 feet across Reedy Creek where a large multi-barrel culvert was constructed to replace the decaying bridge crossing.  The transition of Indian Springs Road to the dedicated but unimproved right of way is approximately twenty-one (21) feet in width, consisting of very little gravel and potholes.  Indian Springs Road then tapers to approximately twelve (12) feet in width moving closer to the intersection with Upton Road. The base continues to have minimal gravel and potholes. • Upton Road is dedicated but unimproved terminating west of the subject property.  Upton Road further narrows in width to approximately nine (9) feet three (3) inches beyond the intersection with Indian Springs Road. Upton Road continues to have a poor base with mature vegetation along the roadside which may make it difficult to achieve three (3) foot clear on either side. Planning Page 8 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 7 of 16  Upton Road further narrows to approximately eight (8) feet in width to the subject property continuing to consist of very little gravel and poor base. • Majority of the access does not meet standards typically imposed with similar requests relative to construction. Conditions ensure compliance with minimum access road standards from Point A to Point B (Access Plan) to support fire equipment and/or ambulances, as requested by the Chesterfield County Fire Department. • The unimproved portions of Indian Springs Road and Upton Road serves nine (9) single-family dwellings.  Two (2) single family dwellings, 7901 & 7906 Indian Springs Road now achieve required road frontage with the extended road construction associated with the bridge repair on Indian Springs Road. Although VDOT has accepted approximately 200 feet beyond the bridge which parallels the above properties, their access is still within the unimproved portion of this right of way.  Two (2) single family dwellings were constructed prior to County road frontage requirements (built in 1900’s and built in 1973).  Four (4) single family dwellings received a variance for no public road frontage, Cases 77SN0016, 77SN0177, 10AN0143 and 94AN0101.  One (1) lot is vacant but has received a variance for no public road frontage, Case 14AN0130.  Two (2) single family dwellings have been constructed deficient in required road frontage and without an approved variance for no public road frontage (built in 1991 and 2024). Access Closest to Subject Property Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or Page 9 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 8 of 16 improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Staff has examined the request and as required by the Zoning Ordinance; the property owner has not provided information which would serve as a basis for granting this variance. Conditions upon which this request is based are not unique to the property and generally apply to other properti es in the area. The subject property was recorded as part of Reedy Branch Subdivision with the expectation that lots have State road frontage. With the recordation of the subdivision plat, the right of way was dedicated to the County; therefore, construction of a State road can be constructed within the recorded right of way. Staff encourages any construction within a recorded subdivision to be developed with the infrastructure to support the use. During the site visit, staff did not find physical conditions of the property (topography) that would restrict the construction of Indian Springs Road and Upton Road to Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) standards. Currently, nine (9) single family dwellings enjoy the use of the unimproved portion of these roads, and if approved, the subject property would be the tenth . In this situation, the owner of the subject property could construct Indian Springs and Upton Roads extending a minimum of fifty (50) feet beyond the eastern property line bringing the subject property into conformance with Zoning Ordinance standards. The criterion for acceptance by VDOT is that the road be built to State standards and a minimum of three occupied dwellings use the road. As conditioned by Cases 77SN0016 & 77SN0177 the landowners are responsible for fifty (50) foot wide all-weather road with ditches through their access points. Additionally, as conditioned by Case 10AN 0143, the landowner is responsible for a fifteen (15) foot wide roadway constructed and maintained to all weather road standards the entire length of Indian Springs Road to its intersection with Upton Road. Furthermore, as approved by Case 06AN0124, the landowner is responsible for a fifteen (15) foot wide roadway constructed and maintained to all weather road standards the entire length of Indian Springs to the western terminus of Upton Road (entire road length). As such, cost sharing should occur related to the construction requirement for bringing Indian Springs and Upton Roads up to State standards. There are no conditions which this request is based that are unique to the property and are not generally applicable to other properties in the area. Given this variance alternative, new single-family dwellings should be served by a State maintained road. Examination of Future Development Vacant lots to the west and east of the subject property, recorded as part of Reedy Branch Subdivision, are also deficient in required road frontage and have potential for future development. Each lot meets zoning requirements to be buildable lots with the exception of the required road frontage. As such, the potential for three (3) variance requests could occur due to the nonconstruction of Indian Springs and Upton Roads . Page 10 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 9 of 16 Incrementally improving the street network within the undeveloped portion of the subdivision, through the construction plan process, provides for orderly development. Among other things , staff finds this request is based exclusively upon financial consideration rather than a hardship due to the physical condition of the property. Approval of this request would set a precedent for other variances for no public road frontage to be granted. For the reasons above, staff believes the requirements for the gran ting of a variance has not been satisfied. Constructing Indian Springs and Upton Roads to State requirements will not unreasonably restrict the use of this property, and given this variance alternative, new single family dwellings should be served by a State maintained road. Page 11 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 10 of 16 Current Zoning Map Page 12 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 11 of 16 No comments on this no public road frontage Variance request due to the recent VDOT Bridge project that was completed over Reedy Branch on Indian Springs Road connecting to Upton Road. Any other items will be addressed at time of Building Permit. The Fire Department recommends the owner provide a fifteen (15) foot all-weather road capable of supporting 75,000 pounds in order to provide access for fire apparatus and ambulances. This road should extend from the improved public road to the proposed dwelling. Traffic generated by this request will access via sections of Upton Road and Indian Springs Road, which are dedicated but unimproved county rights-of-way (i.e., not in the State Highway System for maintenance). To use county rights-of-way, a license agreement must be obtained from the county. The license agreement usually requires the applicant to maintain the access road within the right-of-way. In similar situations throughout the county, residents often request the county to perform maintenance on the right-of-way even though a private maintenance agreement exists. County funds are not budgeted for this service. The unimproved section of Upton Road and Indian Springs Road should be improved and accepted into the State System; therefore, a variance would not be required. (In November 2023, County Drainage Improvement Bond funds were used to extend Indian Springs Road approximately 200 feet across Reedy Creek to the Reedy Branch Subdivision. A large multi-barrel culvert was constructed to replace the existing temporary bridge crossing. Once completed, this improvement was taken into the VDOT/state system for maintenance.) If the portion of dedicated but unimproved right of way (ROW) on Upton Road and Indian Springs Road is brought up to and constructed to state standards, the addition could be accepted into the state system as a rural addition. The roadway/ROW is shown on a plat 20+ years old and has provided a public service to at least 3 homes for those 20 years. If the ROW is improved the roadway would need to include a turnaround at its termination. Connection to public water and sewer will be required by County Code. No adverse comments as summary states proposed development to be connected to public water and public sewer. If there are any existing private wells on the property/properties to be developed, owner shall apply at the Health Department for an abandonment permit (one per each well) for any wells that are required to be abandoned (i.e., wells that do not meet regulations and/or County Ordinances). Once issued, the owner shall Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Page 13 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 12 of 16 have the well(s) properly abandoned per conditions contained in the individual private well abandonment permit. A license agreement is required to make drive improvements within the unimproved County right of way. Contact Andrew Martin (804)748 1362 to start process. Real Property Page 14 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 13 of 16 1. Prior to approval of a building permit , the property owner shall provide a copy of the approved license agreement with the County to use the dedicated and unimproved County right- of-way from Point A to Point B, as shown on the plat attached to the staff report. The license agreement shall include a condition that requires the landowner of the subject property to be responsible for maintenance of the access in accordance with Condition 2 of the Staff Report. (P) 2. A fifteen (15) foot wide roadway shall be constructed and maintained to all weather standards from Point A to Point B, extended to the proposed house once the location has been determined, in accordance with the following standards: (a) This roadway shall consist of not less than the following: compacted soil sub-base with six (6) inches of compacted 21-B crushed stone or equivalent approved by Planning and Fire Departments, if an asphalt based surface is to be applied, it shall be designed and constructed to Chesterfield County subdivision street requirements or an equivalent design approved by the Subdivision Team, capable of supporting the projected 75,000 pound vehicle weight and shall be maintained to this standard. The roadway shall not be approved if it is rutted or potholed. (b) There shall be an additional three (3) foot clear area beyond the edge of the roadway. (c) There shall be a minimum vertical clearance of fourteen (14) feet of area above the roadway. (d) The roadway shall have a maximum grade of ten (10) percent with an appropriate transition at the street connection. (e) The minimum inside turning radius for any curve shall be approved by the Fire Department prior to building permit approval. (f) Any cross drains shall be designed per County standards and approved by the Department of Environmental Engineering. (P) 3. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy , the Planning Department shall inspect this roadway to determine compliance as set forth above. (P) 4. The house number shall be installed on the mailbox or a pole and located at the driveway entrance of the State maintained road as well as at the driveway entrance to the property. The house numbers shall be displayed in at least four (4) inch high numbers. (P) 5. The subject property shall not be further subdivided, including any family subdivisions, unless public road frontage is provided. (P) Conditions Page 15 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 14 of 16 Access will be across portions of Indian Springs Road and Upton Road which are dedicated but unimproved. Proposed Access Plan – Exhibit A Page 16 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 15 of 16 Reedy Branch Subdivision Plat Page 17 of 39 Vili and Jasmin Ascencio 24VA1317 Page 16 of 16 Board of Zoning Appeals February 5, 2025: ACTION – DEFERRED TO MARCH 5, 2025, AT THE BOARD’S REQUEST AND THE CONSENT OF THE APPLICANT TO FURTHER EXAMINE THE HISTORY OF THE PROPERTY Applicant • Applicant’s Agent: Vili Ascencio (804-475-7891) Vili804@gmail.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Public Hearings Case Contacts Page 18 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 1 of 10 24VA1341 – Angela Ruiz-Cue Magisterial District – Bermuda Applicant's Contact – Angela Ruiz-Cue (954-290-3645) BZA Public Hearing – March 5, 2025 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance 495 square foot variance to the required 7,000 square feet of lot area using a zoning lot comprised of two (2) lots (Lots 46 & 47) in a Residential (R-7) District. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 10437 Elokomin Avenue Site Size 0.15 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Street View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS An Exhibit is located in this report. STAFF - APPROVAL • Strict application of the Ordinance requirements for lot area would unreasonably restrict use of the property. • Approval would not reduce or impair the value of the surrounding property nor impair area’s character. • There are conditions upon which this request is based that is unique to the property. Recommendation Page 19 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 2 of 10 Background • The ordinance requires that residential R-7 zoned lots recorded prior to January 1, 1989, have a minimum of 7,000 square feet of lot area. • Subject property is located within Bellmeade Subdivision, which was recorded in 1931, prior to County road frontage requirements. The majority of lots recorded within Bellmeade Subdivision are twenty (25) feet in width with a shallow depth ; therefore, requiring multiple lots be used to meet ordinance requirement s to achieve lot area, lot width and road frontage. • The applicant has owned Lots 46 & 47 since January 18, 2024. • The subject property is encompassed as a zoning lot which is comprised two (2) lots; Lots 46 & 47. • If this request is granted, the landowner(s) will be required to retain both lots as a zoning lot to conform with ordinance standards i.e. lot width, minimum square footage and setbacks. • The applicant intends to rectify the deficiency in lot area for the construction of one (1) single family dwelling. • The lack of square footage may be rectified by either receiving a variance to lot area or through a conditional use planned development seeking an exception to lot area. • Section 19.1-15 addresses variance requests on a singular property; therefore, applying the aggregate area within the zoning lot allows for the consideration of this request. • Adjacent property to the south, 10439 Elokomin Avenue , received a variance to reduce lot area, Case 11AN0158, approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals on January 5, 2011. Planning Page 20 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 3 of 10 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 6 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 7 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 7 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 7 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 7 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 7 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 7 Real Property .......................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Lot Layout – Exhibit A.............................................................................................................................................................. 8 Subdivision Plat – Part of ........................................................................................................................................................ 9 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 10 Table of Contents Page 21 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 4 of 10 Proposal The applicant provides the following justification in support of this request: “New home to be built. I do not own any land adjacent to the property that I own to be able to combine and meet requirements. I have attempted to contact and purchase adjacent vacant lots at the start of this project. I was unable to make contact. However, at this time I am no longer able to make that purchase if the land were to become available. New home available to buyers at an affordable cost. The home will conform with the homes that are already on the street and adjacent streets. County will be able to collect tax dollars on a home instead of just on the land. This is a piece of land is "land locked", Due diligence has already been done in an attempt to acquire the neighboring parcels. I even went so far as to hire Joe Homebuyer to skip trace the neighbor’s info and contact the neighbors. None of which have responded.” Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a Aerial Planning 10439 Elokomin Avenue - Vacant Case 11AN0158 10435 Elokomin Avenue Page 22 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 5 of 10 reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Staff has examined the request and as required by the Zoning Ordinance, conditions upon which this request is based are unique to the property and do not apply generally to other properties in the area. The subject property is comprised of two (2) lots (46 & 47) each having a lot width of twenty -five (25) feet , that together form a zoning lot with a cumulative total of 6,505 square feet Lot Layout – Exhibit A. The ordinance requires residential R-7 lots recorded prior to January 1, 1989, to have a minimum of 7,000 square feet of lot area. This request is being considered as a zoning lot (tracts of land within a single block developed under single ownership) for the purpose of achieving ordinance requirements related to lot area. The applicant purchased Lots 46 & 47 in good faith not realizing the deficiency in lot area. Once the applicant was made aware of the deficiency, she contacted adjacent landowners in hopes to purchase a recorded lot to rectify the deficiency in lot area. She never received any responses to the request to purchase adjacent property to achieve 7, 000 square feet of area. Staff also determined the property to the south of the subject property did not have ample area to accommodate the deficiency in the subject property related to square footage, as that property received a variance for lot area in 2011. The property to the north contains a single family dwelling which is located close to the side property line making it difficult to adjust a side property line while keeping the existing dwelling in conformance with ordinance requirements. Staff also examined the possibility of the applicant applying for a conditional use planned development (CUPD) which is another option for seeking lot area exceptions. In this case, the applicant purchased two (2) recorded lots which alone do not meet minimum requirements. The applicant is not seeking to further divide the property through the subdivision process but only to rectify the existing deficiency. Additionally, the applicant meets the Zoning Ordinance findings set forth for granting a Variance; therefore, the CUPD process may not be the best option. Given, the adjacent properties are not sufficient to rectify the deficiency in lot area, the applicant has exhausted all practical options. As such, a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict the use of the property. Page 23 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 6 of 10 Current Zoning Map Page 24 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 7 of 10 No comments No comments No comments No comments Public water 350 feet from property line. Public sewer along Elokomin Avenue. No adverse comments regarding the variance. However, applicant is made aware that prior to issuance of a building permit, if public water is not available, then the applicant shall apply (and obtain) a valid well permit from the Health Department that meets all state and local regulations and ordinances. It is recommended that the applicant consult with a DPOR licensed Onsite Soil Evaluator or Professional Engineer before proceeding. No comments Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 25 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 8 of 10 Lot Layout – Exhibit A Page 26 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 9 of 10 Subdivision Plat – Part of Page 27 of 39 Angela Ruiz-Cue 24VA1341 Page 10 of 10 Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: Angela Ruiz-Cue (954-290-3645) angelaruizcue@yahoo.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 28 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 1 of 11 24VA1344 – Josue Cuellar Lopez Magisterial District – Bermuda Applicant's Contact – Josue Cuellar Lopez (804-536-6275) BZA Public Hearing – March 5, 2025 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Variance to use a parcel of land that fronts on a dedicated but unimproved public road (Sylvania Road) for dwelling purposes. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 3207 Sylvania Road Site Size 1.12 Acres Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Street View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended conditions, and an access plan are in this report. STAFF - APPROVAL • Strict application of the Ordinance requirements for public road frontage would unreasonably restrict use of the property. • Approval would not reduce or impair the value of the surrounding property nor impair area’s character. • Conditions unique to the property. Recommendation Page 29 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 2 of 11 Background • The Board of Zoning Appeals hears requests for no public road frontage for parcels meeting one of the following criteria:  Recorded prior to April 1976  Subdivided for a member of the property owner’s immediate family  Recorded through the plat validation process • The Zoning Ordinance requires a property being used for dwelling purposes to have a minimum of fifty (50) feet of public road frontage. • Subject property was recorded as part of Sylvania Subdivision which was recorded in 1957 prior to County road frontage requirements. • The existing single family dwelling was constructed in 1990 without a variance for no public road frontage. • The applicant purchased the property on October 2, 2018. • The applicant submitted for a building permit for a two (2) story detached garage and the permit was held by Planning due to the deficiency in required road frontage. Permit 20240909-068 • The applicant intends to rectify the deficiency in required road frontage to secure the building permit for the detached garage. • The lack of public road frontage may be rectified by receiving a variance for no public road frontage. Planning Page 30 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 3 of 11 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 8 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 8 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 8 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 8 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 8 Real Property ...................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Access Plan – Exhibit A .......................................................................................................................................................... 10 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 11 Table of Contents Page 31 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 4 of 11 Proposal The applicant offers the following as justification for this request: “Variance for no public road frontage. Paved road stops before reaching the property. Customer wants to add a detached garage to the property. House was built in 1990”. Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following: • The subject property is located on the north line of Sylvania Road with the driveway access from the temporary turnaround. • The unimproved portion of this right of way serve s three (3) single -family dwellings; one (1) of which was built prior to road frontage requirements ( 1966); one (1) being the subject property built in 1990 and one (1) a dwelling built in 1991. • The unimproved portion of this right of way is constructed with asphalt and it appears to be part of Virginia Department of Transportation’s (VDOT) maintenance although the “End of State maintenance” falls short of the existing asphalt. • The unimproved portion of Sylvania Road is constructed as a temporary turnaround. Aerial Planning End of State Maintenance 3209 Sylvania Road Page 32 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 5 of 11 Figure 3: Temporary Turnaround Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Staff has examined the request and a s required by the Zoning Ordinance the property owner has provided information which would serve as a basis for granting this variance. Conditions upon which this request is based are unique to the property and do not apply generally to other properties in the area. The landowner purchased the property in October 2018 unaware of the road frontage deficiency . Staff encourages all single family dwellings accessing within a dedicated but unimproved right of way to be developed with the infrastructure to support the use. In this situation, the house was constructed in 1990 by others without obtaining a variance for no public road frontage. The landowner felt the property had required road frontage as the driveway entrance connects to the temporary turnaround which appears to be maintained by VDOT. The landowners submitted a building permit for a detached garage which has triggered this request. Page 33 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 6 of 11 Staff evaluated the possible construction of the unimproved portion of Sylvania Road to State standards. However, the unimproved portion of Sylvania Road is already constructed as a temporary turn around with each driveway beyond the State maintenance connecting to that portion of the road. Staff has been made aware that VDOT maintains the temporary turnaround with the portion of road that is considered to be in their State system. Ordinarily, staff would encourage the additional construction of the right of way to be accepted by VDOT; however, this construction would be a hardship since this portion of the right of way appears to already enjoy the benefit of VDOT’s maintenance. S taff has determined no practical alternative exists that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Among other things, the applicant received the subject property in good faith and did not create the hardship. Given the portion of Sylvania Road that is dedicated but unimproved appears to be maintained by VDOT, it is reasonable to support this request. As such, the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance requirements for road frontage would unreasonably restrict the use of the property. Page 34 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 7 of 11 Current Zoning Map Page 35 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 8 of 11 A Resource Protection Area Determination (RPAD) would need to be completed on this lot and potentially a FEMA Elevation Certificate prior to a Building Permit request. The Fire Department recommends the owner provide a fifteen (15) foot all-weather road capable of supporting 75,000 pounds in order to provide access for fire apparatus and ambulances. This road should extend from the improved public road to the proposed dwelling. No comment/objection. Note there is an existing home on the property. The total length of Rt. 1140 is .9 miles. The latest road extension towards the NE was accepted into the state system in 1958. The most accurate measurement is .33 miles from the intersection of Rt. 1136, North Street. This puts the end of state maintenance just past the driveway at 3209 Sylvania Road. No comments No adverse comments as the property is connected to public water and sewer. It appears the existing drive connects into the State maintained temporary turnaround. Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 36 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 9 of 11 1. Should any construction be required to comply with Condition 2 below, the property owner shall provide a copy of the approved license agreement with the County to use the dedicated and unimproved County right-of-way from Point A to Point B, as shown on the plat attached to the staff report. The license agreement shall inclu de a condition that requires the landowner of the subject property to be responsible for maintenance of the access in accordance with Condition 2 of the Staff Report. (P) 2. A fifteen (15) foot wide roadway shall be constructed and maintained to all weather standards from Point A to Point B, extended to the proposed house once the location has been determined, in accordance with the following standards: (a) This roadway shall consist of not less than the following: compacted soil sub-base with six (6) inches of compacted 21-B crushed stone or equivalent approved by Planning and Fire Departments, if an asphalt based surface is to be applied, it shall be designed and constructed to Chesterfield County subdivision street requirements or an equivalent design approved by the Subdivision Team, capable of supporting the projected 75,000 pound vehicle weight and shall be maintained to this standard. The roadway shall not be approved if it is rutted or potholed. (b) There shall be an additional three (3) foot clear area beyond the edge of the roadway. (c) There shall be a minimum vertical clearance of fourteen (14) feet of area above the roadway. (d) The roadway shall have a maximum grade of ten (10) percent with an appropriate transition at the street connection. (e) The minimum inside turning radius for any curve shall be approved by the Fire Department prior to building permit approval. (f) Any cross drains shall be designed per County standards and approved by the Department of Environmental Engineering. (P) 3. Should any construction be required to comply with Condition 2 above, the Planning Department shall inspect this roadway to determine compliance as set forth above. (P) 4. The house number shall be installed on the mailbox or a pole and located at the driveway entrance of the State maintained road as well as at the driveway entrance to the property. The house numbers shall be displayed in at least four (4) inch high numbers. (P) 5. The subject property shall not be further subdivided, including any family subdivisions, unless public road frontage is provided. (P) Conditions Page 37 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 10 of 11 Access Plan – Exhibit A Page 38 of 39 Josue Cuellar Lopez 24VA1344 Page 11 of 11 Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: Josue Cuellar Lopez (804-536-6275) josuecuellar92@gmail.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 39 of 39

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.