Board of Supervisors Meeting - January 22, 2025 — Other
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Supervisors · meeting of Jan 22, 2025 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1/22/2025 Page 1 of 9
Citizen Comments Received Through the Comment Portal
January 22, 2025 Board of Supervisors Meeting
Comment Type Comment Name District
Unscheduled
matter
I would like to hear an
update on the status of
county high school fields
being upgraded to artificial
turf
Nick
Nestlerode
Clover Hill
22SN0089 -
Thackers
View
Rezoning and
Exceptions -
Clover Hill
Please vote to DEFER the
Thacker Rezoing case to the
February 2025 Board of
Supervisor meeting.
This application remains
incomplete and inconsistent
per the community advocacy
group FOSCR - Friends of
Swift Creek Reservoir, and
myself.
Jessica Schneider-We NEED you
on this.
Tom Baker Clover Hill
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
This proposed Zoning
Amendment to the original MG
development plan would
dramatically alter the
originally intended
integrated vehicular and
pedestrian design approach of
a singular Town Square. This
holistic design approach can
be maintained while still
allowing for the construction
of the development in phases
consistent with the developer
requests.
The Amendment would allow for
the development of individual
phased projects with no
correlation to each other,
absolutely not the
requirements of the original
Development Plan.
The requested Amendment
should be denied and the
process restarted to much
more closely represent the
original requirements in a
much more inclusive and
transparent process allowing
for the participation of all
Magnolia Green residents.
Amado
Fernandez
Matoaca
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
I have been of strong belief
Tom Page and iStar’s end game
is to accelerate their exit
and expand their profits at
the expense of Magnolia Green
home owners. There are many
already existing examples of
Paul Rowson Matoaca
1/22/2025 Page 2 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
this. Tom has dragged his
feet on the maintenance of
community amenities. The HVAC
system at the Grille and Pro
Shop is woefully undersized
in tonnage to maintain even
OSHA ambient work temperature
standards for employees, let
alone community patrons. The
Pirate Playground at our
Aquatic Center is a child
safety issue and has become
an eyesore. The pool
furniture is insufficient
when at capacity and is in
disrepair. This will only
become worse as new homes and
resident families are added
to existing Magnolia Green
homeowners. The Farmers
Market is non-existent yet
still appears as a community
amenity in iStar’s online
marketing materials (see link
below):
https://magnoliagreen.com/the
-market/
We have no walking trails as
advertised (sidewalks along
major roads and in owner
maintained neighborhoods do
not constitute “nature
walking trails). We have no
health/gym facility as
advertised. And having been
an owner/general manager of a
restaurant and worked at
Marriott Corporate
Headquarters, I can tell you
that the iStar leased space
to The Cardinal is a flawed
business model that will most
likely fail before Tom Page
and iStar exit Magnolia Green
with their profits and leave
us residents with expenses.
The proposed plan for multi-
family housing exceeds the
residential zoning density
plan. The singular “Town
Center” design for the
commercial amenity iStar
advertised to attract
Magnolia Green home owners
under the new proposed plan
1/22/2025 Page 3 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
would allow iStar develop an
architecturally non-cohesive
460,000 square feet of
commercial property with
little-to-no concern for
resident’s needs.
These proposal on the table
is solely in iStar’s
financial interests. iStar is
relying on
Magnolia Green residents
being uninformed and unaware
of the extent of the negative
impact this land use and
development plan will have on
the quality of life and
property values of their
community. For public record,
the Board of Supervisors
should however be able to
discern the impact of the
proposed plan to Magnolia
Green residents and hold
iStar to plan.
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
While I support lifting
restrictions on retail/office
space square footage, I don’t
support waiving the
requirement for 50% of
retail/office space to be
under construction before
residential uses are
permitted. I also don’t
support elimination of the
requirement for an
“integrated schematic plan”
for the entire project.
This developer has a track
record of not delivering
promised amenities. The
developer marketed the
neighborhood as a resort-
style neighborhood complete
with a residents’ club and
fitness center coming in
2021. In late 2020, they
quietly removed the clubhouse
from the amenities list – not
because they couldn’t afford
it, but because they weren’t
required to build it – houses
were selling without it and
they had record sales in
2020.
Richard
Latham
Matoaca
1/22/2025 Page 4 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
If you allow the developer to
build apartments without
additional retail/office
space in an area that was
billed as “The Marketplace at
Magnolia Green,” the
marketplace will consist of
apartments and a daycare
center, that’s it. Not much
of a marketplace.
The developer wants to build
a 224-unit apartment complex
in an area totaling about
12.4 acres. This would exceed
current zoning restrictions
of 14 units per acre, which
would allow a maximum of 173
units for that one parcel.
They’re relying on the total
acreage for ALL parcels to
stay within density limits
for ONE parcel, but they want
to remove the requirement to
submit an integrated plan for
ALL parcels
You can’t have it both ways;
you can’t include all parcels
to stay within residential
density limits on one parcel
while ignoring how the
remaining parcels might
eventually be developed.
Also, allowing the parcels to
be developed in a piecemeal
fashion will lead to a
disjointed end product; think
Westchester Commons – part
strip mall, part town center,
not very walkable,
dysfunctional traffic flows,
and looks ridiculous!
Removing the requirement for
an integrated plan increases
the potential for housing
density limits to be
exceeded. The existing
daycare center was planned,
approved and expanded without
an integrated plan and in
violation of current zoning
restrictions regarding
retail/office square footage,
and nobody caught it.
1/22/2025 Page 5 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
Please do not allow (1)
residential uses on ANY
parcel without requiring
construction of additional
retail/office space, or (2)
individual parcels to be
developed without an
integrated plan for ALL
parcels.
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
Please do not expand the
amount of residence in the
planned apartments in
magnolia green near the
children's center. Magnolia
green is quickly becoming
overpopulated as it is And
that area specifically is
already too dense with the
apartments, aquatic center
and children's center all
within a mile of each other.
The increase in traffic will
probably already overwhelm
the plan infrastructure and
roads that are already built.
William Cole Matoaca
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
I am concerned that the space
is not sufficient for the
proposed 224 unit apartment
and will have negative impact
to the environment and public
safety.
Sanish Rai Midlothian
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
Please do not allow rezoning
for higher density apartment
units. Every resident of the
existing community I have
spoken to is strongly opposed
to it. Most citizens do not
have the time or awareness of
how their voice can be heard
and actually make a
difference, but I suspect if
you actually surveyed
residents, you would find an
overwhelming opposition to
this amendment and the
developer's intention. Please
listen to community members
instead of developers in this
instance. We do not believe
it is in the best interest of
Chesterfield County to allow
this type of development to
Trevor
Badorrek
Matoaca
1/22/2025 Page 6 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
be built in the intended
location.
Unscheduled
matter
Chairman Ingle, Members of
the Chesterfield Board of
Supervisors,
As you may know, on October
29th, 2024, the Friends of
Chesterfield conducted at
People's Hearing on Dominion
Energy's gas-fired power
plant after the Board
declined hear from its
residents on this major
electricity generation
facility. As the Board's
comment portal does not
provide for the submission of
attachments, I will be
sending an email to each of
you with the transcripts of
the testimony shared at that
October hearing attached. I
will reference that testimony
in my public comments to the
Board at your Wednesday,
January 22, 2025 meeting.
Sincerely,
Glen Besa
Glen Besa Dale
22SN0089 -
Thackers
View
Rezoning and
Exceptions -
Clover Hill
Please include file emailed
to Ryan Ramsey and
distributed to the Board of
Supervisors on January 21,
2025.
Kathleen
Medaries
Clover Hill
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
We live in the Magnolia Green
Townhomes, close to the
existing Glenmoore Oaks
apartments. Adding another
224 units across the street
will lower the value of our
homes and the quality of our
life. The tract should be
developed as planned. Even
another 173 rental units is
too much. Please deny this
zoning request. Thanks!
Terry
Finazzo
Matoaca
1/22/2025 Page 7 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
24SN1192 -
Ivymont
Square
Signage -
Dale
The Board of Supervisors need
to ask the Ivymount Shopping
Center to build a new
sidewalk along LeGorden Drive
and build a new 10 foot wide
path or sidewalk along Route
60.
Carl
Schwendeman
Midlothian
22SN0089 -
Thackers
View
Rezoning and
Exceptions -
Clover Hill
Board of Supervisors:
Thank you for your continued
hard work and dedication to
this zoning case for
Thacker's View. I truly
appreciate the progress made
with the additional proffered
conditions that support the
tree canopy, even though it's
not as much as initially
hoped. Your efforts regarding
the ordinances for RPA
violations are also
commendable.
However, I do feel that these
recent updates have come
through a bit too quickly. I
haven’t had sufficient time
to fully review the changes,
and there doesn’t appear to
be a clear solution presented
for the utility line issue.
Additionally, there seems to
be insufficient attention
being given to the wetlands
adjacent to Red Fern, and I’m
concerned about their
protection from potential
destruction, particularly for
a utility connector or any
other reason.
Given these concerns, I
respectfully request that you
consider deferring this
decision until more
stakeholders can come
together to reach a
consensus. This would ensure
that the plans are as
thoughtful and thorough as
possible before moving
forward, especially for a
project that will leave a
lasting legacy on the
reservoir.
Paula Gordon Clover Hill
1/22/2025 Page 8 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
I’m confident that by doing
this, you’ll be in a strong
position with the public to
ensure the best outcome for
everyone involved.
Once again, thank you for all
that you do on behalf of our
community. I understand these
decisions are not made
lightly, and I trust you will
continue to do everything
necessary to get this right
for all parties involved.
I urge you to defer.
Consider
Amendments
to County
Ordinance
Regarding
Control of
Animals and
Leash
Requirements
To ensure public safety and
prevent harm, I support a
significant increase in fines
for those who fail to comply
with leash laws. I have
neighbors in my area who let
their unfriendly dogs roam, I
ran into an off-leash dog
while running at Point of
Rocks Park just last week
whose owner was down by the
water birding and not within
100 yards of the dog. I was
also at a Chesterfield
playground with an owner with
two off-leash dogs over
Christmas break. I hope the
increased fines act as a
deterrent.
Jacilyn
Lipford
Dale
22SN0089 -
Thackers
View
Rezoning and
Exceptions -
Clover Hill
This case should be deferred
or voted No. The citizen
comments have not fully been
addressed. Additional
proffers were added on
January 17 2025 but the
community has not had a
chance to engage the
community on these. The
community needs more time for
engagement.
Kim Owens Matoaca
22SN0089 -
Thackers
View
Rezoning and
Exceptions -
Clover Hill
We are not interested in any
mthing but a potential
restaurant, the constant
reasoning and building of
high density homes, the
extension of 76 and the
congestion you all are
creating in our schools with
zero plans to accommodate the
Kyle
Zawadzki
Clover Hill
1/22/2025 Page 9 of 9
Comment Type Comment Name District
population growth are
disgusting. We don’t want any
of this.
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.