RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting — Agenda Packet

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Dec 4, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHESTERFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AGENDA WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 4, 2024 Public Meeting Room 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield VA 23832 NOTE: Attachments are generally available the Wednesday prior to the Board of Zoning Appeals meeting. Any subsequent changes to this agenda prior to the date of the meeting, and more detailed information regarding items on the agenda can be found at chesterfield.gov/plan, or by calling the Planning Department at 804-748-1050 during regular business hours, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday. A map of each case can be found at chesterfield.gov/plancases. Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service 12:00 p.m. Lunch/work session in Executive Session Room, 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield, Virginia 23832 1. 1 p.m. Meeting called to order in the Public Meeting Room, Lane B. Ramsey Administration Building, Chesterfield, Virginia 2. Invocation 3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America 4. Approval of Minutes • November 6, 2024 5. Acknowledgements of withdrawal and requests for deferral 6. Consideration of variance requests A. 24VA1240: In Midlothian Magisterial District, Jean Carlos requests a variance to use parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Starview Lane) for dwelling purposes in a Residential (R-7) District and amendment of zoning district map known as 1335 Starview Lane, fronting the east line of Starview Lane measured approximately 80 feet south of the State maintained portion of Starview Lane. The 0.8 acre property is proposed for 1 single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 766-701-3594. Access will be across a portion of Starview Lane which is dedicated but unimproved. B. 24VA1245: In Matoaca Magisterial District, Jonathan Taylor requests a seventeen (17) foot variance to the required 50 foot road frontage to use a parcel of land for dwelling purposes and a one (1) foot variance to the required 50 foot lot width in a Residential (R-7) District and amendment of zoning district map known as 3613 Main Street and located on the south east corner of Main Street and Cemetery Road. The 0.34 acre property is proposed for 1 single family Page 1 of 25 Chesterfield County Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting December 4, 2024 dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 795-609-3159. 7. Consideration of Proposed Meeting Dates for Calendar Year 2025 8. Miscellaneous 9. Adjournment Page 2 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 1 of 12 24VA1240 – Jean Carlos Magisterial District – Midlothian Agent – Jean Carlos (703-801-0415) BZA Public Hearing – December 4, 2024 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Varian ce to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Starview Lane) for dwelling purposes in a Residential (R-7) District. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 1335 Starview Lane Site Size 0.8 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Street View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended conditions, and an access plan are in this report. STAFF - APPROVAL • Strict application of the Ordinance requirements for public road frontage would unreasonably restrict use of the property. • There are conditions upon which this request is based that are unique to the property. • No practical alternative exist that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Recommendation Page 3 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 2 of 12 Background • The Board of Zoning Appeals hears requests for no public road frontage for parcels meeting one of the following criteria:  Recorded prior to April 1976  Subdivided for a member of the property owner’s immediate family  Recorded through the plat validation process • The Zoning Ordinance requires a property being used for dwelling purposes to have a minimum of fifty (50) feet of public road frontage. • Subject property was created on November 15, 1954, prior to County road frontage requirements. • The applicant, Jean Carlos, is representing the landowner, Fermin Milian Garcia, who is full owner of FMG Investment LLC. • The landowner purchased the property in April 2024. • The landowner intends to rectify the deficiency in require d road frontage to building one (1) single family dwelling. • Pending building permit for a single family dwelling. (20240506-105) • The lack of public road frontage may be rectified by receiving a variance for no public road frontage. N ote: 1335 Starview Lane has frontage along unimproved right-of-way for Starview Lane. For this section of Starview Lane, this road would be designated as an ultimate right-of-way width of fifty (50) feet, measured twenty-five (25) feet from the centerline of the proposed road. This would likely require the property plat to show the ultimate right-of-way at least ten (10) feet east of the existing right-of-way line with the setback established from that location. Planning Page 4 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 3 of 12 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 8 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 8 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 8 Real Property ...................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Access Plan – Exhibit A .......................................................................................................................................................... 10 Carriage Pines Subdivision Plat ............................................................................................................................................. 11 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 12 Table of Contents Page 5 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 4 of 12 Proposal The applicant intends to construct one single family dwelling and offers the following justification for this request: “The unique physical hardship for the variance arises from the parcel's location on Starview Lane, a dedicated yet unimproved public road, which limits access and usability for dwelling purposes. Unlike other parcels within the Residential (R-7) District that benefit from developed infrastructure, this property faces challenges such as inadequate road accessibility, potentially affecting emergency services, utilities, and overall livability. The lack of improvements on Starview Lane creates an extraordinary situation that significantly hampers the property's development potential, warranting the need for a variance to enable residential use. The proposal for a variance to use land on an unimproved public road for residential purposes can provide opportunities for growth and increased housing options, it also brings significant considerations regarding community character, infrastructure demands, safety, and compliance with zoning regulations both for adjacent neighborhoods and the county as a whole”. Aerial Planning 7101 Carriage Pines Drive Page 6 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 5 of 12 Access Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following: • State maintenance of Starview Lane ends just south of the intersection with Carriage Pines Drive. • The unimproved portion of Starview Lane is approximately 130 feet north of the subject property. o The unimproved portion of Starview Lane consists of a mixture of grass, gravel, private fencing, storm water manhole and mature vegetation. o The unimproved portion of Starview Lane serve s one (1) single family dwelling, 7 101 Carriage Pines Drive . A lthough 7101 Carriage Pines Drive enjoy s the access from the unimproved portion of Starview Lane, this property does achieve required road frontage on Carriage Pines Drive. o This portion of the access does not meet the standards typically imposed with similar request relative to construction. Additionally, Starview Lane is designated as a fifty (50) foot ultimate right of way measured twenty-five (25) feet from the centerline of the proposed road. This would likely require the property plat to show the ultimate right-of-way at least 10’ east of the existing right-of-way line with the setback established from that location. Conditions ensure compliance with minimum access road standards from Point A to Point C ( Proposed Access Plan) to support fire equipment and/or ambulances, as requested by the Chesterfield County Fire Department. Figure 3: Google view of access 7101 Carriage Pines Drive Page 7 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 6 of 12 Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Staff has examined the request and a s required by the Zoning Ordinance the property owner has provided information which would serve as a basis for granting this variance. Conditions upon which this request is based are unique to the property and do not apply generally to other properties in the area. The landowner purchased the property in April 2024 and did not create the hardship. Staff encourages any construction accessing within a dedicated but unimproved right of way to be developed with the infrastructure to support the use as the expectation is that all lots have State road frontage. Staff evaluated the possible construction of the unimproved portion of Starview Lane to State standards. The unimproved portion of Starview Lane is dedicated to Chesterfield County which allows for roadway construction . However, one of Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) standards for road acceptance is that a minimum of three (3) occupied dwellings must be served by the improved portion of the right of way. In this situation, 7101 Carriage Pines Drive is the only dwelling that enjoys the unimproved portion of Starview Lane. The subject property being the possible second dwelling to be served by this portion of the unimproved right of way would not meet VDOT’s standards for State acceptance. Staff has determined no practical alternative exists that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Given VDOT would not accept the road construction without three (3) occupied dwellings being served by the roadway, it is reasonable to support this request. However, should this variance request be approved, the maintenance responsibility of the unimproved right of way would fall on one (1) landowner (subject property) with the use enjoyed by the public. It should be noted that staff is supportive of request where VDOT standards cannot be met; however, upon the third single family dwelling enjoying the use of this portion of Starview Lane staff will recommend Starview Lane be improved to State s tandards. Incrementally improving the street network provides for orderly development. Among other things, the applicant received the subject property in good faith and did not create the hardship. As such, the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance requirements for road frontage would unreasonably restrict the use of the property. Page 8 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 7 of 12 Current Zoning Map Page 9 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 8 of 12 The Fire Department recommends the owner provide a fifteen (15) foot all -weather road capable of supporting 75,000 pounds in order to provide access for fire apparatus and ambulances. This road should extend from the improved public road to the proposed dwelling. Traffic generated by this request will access via a section of Starview Lane, which is dedicated but unimproved county right of way (i.e., not in the State Highway System for maintenance). To use county rights of way, a license agreement must be obtained f rom the county. The license agreement usually requires the applicant to maintain the access road within the right of way. In similar situations throughout the county, residents often request the county to perform maintenance on the right of way even though a private maintenance agreement exists. County funds are not budgeted for this service. The unimproved section of Starview Lane should be improved and accepted into the State System; therefore, a variance would not be required. No comment Connection to public water is required by County code. Unless required by utilities to hook up to public sewer, prior to issuance of a building permit, applicant shall apply (and obtain) a valid septic permit from the Health Department. Need a license agreement for driveway construction in the County unimproved right of way. Contact Andrew Martin for application information at MartinA@chesterfield.gov . Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 10 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 9 of 12 1. Prior to approval of a building permit , the property owner shall provide a copy of the approved license agreement with the County to use the dedicated and unimproved County right- of-way from Point A to Point B, as shown on the plat attached to the staff report. The license agreement shall include a condition that requires the landowner of the subject property to be responsible for maintenance of the access in accordance with Condition 2 of the Staff Report. (P) 2. A fifteen (15) foot wide roadway shall be constructed and maintained to all weather standards from Point A to Point C, extended to the proposed house once the location has been determined, in accordance with the following standards: (a) This roadway shall consist of not less than the following: compacted soil sub-base with six (6) inches of compacted 21-B crushed stone or equivalent approved by Planning and Fire Departments, if an asphalt based surface is to be applied, it shall be designed and constructed to Chesterfield County subdivision street requirements or an equivalent design approved by the Subdivision Team, capable of supporting the projected 75,000 pound vehicle weight and shall be maintained to this standard. The roadway shall not be approved if it is rutted or potholed. (b) There shall be an additional three (3) foot clear area beyond the edge of the roadway. (c) There shall be a minimum vertical clearance of fourteen (14) feet of area above the roadway. (d) The roadway shall have a maximum grade of ten (10) percent with an appropriate transition at the street connection. (e) The minimum inside turning radius for any curve shall be approved by the Fire Department prior to building permit approval. (f) Any cross drains shall be designed per County standards and approved by the Department of Environmental Engineering. (P) 3. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy , the Planning Department shall inspect this roadway to determine compliance as set forth above. (P) 4. The house number shall be installed on the mailbox or a pole and located at the driveway entrance of the State maintained road as well as at the driveway entrance to the property. The house numbers shall be displayed in at least four (4) inch high numbers. (P) 5. The subject property shall not be further subdivided, including any family subdivisions, unless public road frontage is provided. (P) Conditions Page 11 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 10 of 12 Access Plan – Exhibit A Point B shall extend 50 feet beyond northern property line Page 12 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 11 of 12 Carriage Pines Subdivision Plat Page 13 of 25 Jean Carlos 24VA1240 Page 12 of 12 Applicant • Applicant/Agent: Jean Carlos (704-801-0415) hispanosunidosms@gmail.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 14 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 1 of 11 24VA1245 – Jonathan Taylor Magisterial District – Matoaca Applicant's Contact – Jonathan Taylor (804-721-3520) BZA Public Hearing – December 4, 2024 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Requests: I. Seventeen (17) foot variance to the required fifty (50) foot road frontage to use a parcel of land for dwelling purposes. II. One (1) foot variance to the required 50 foot lot width in a Residential (R-7) District. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 3613 Main Street Site Size 0.34 Acres Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Street View Image NOTES FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS 1. No conditions are recommended for Request I or Request II. 2. Two (2) Exhibits are located within the report. STAFF - APPROVAL • The strict application of the Ordinance requirements for public road frontage and lot width would unreasonably restrict the use of the property. • There are conditions upon which these requests are based that are unique to the property. • No practical alternatives exist that would eliminate the need for these variance requests. Recommendation Page 15 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 2 of 11 Background • The Board of Zoning Appeals hears requests for no public road frontage for parcels meeting one of the following criteria:  Recorded prior to April 1976  Subdivided for a member of the property owner’s immediate family  Recorded through the plat validation process • Request I. The Zoning Ordinance requires a property being used for dwelling purposes to have a minimum of fifty (50) feet of public road frontage.  Subject property Lot 8 was recorded July 1946 as part of The Ponds & Eanes Subdivision Plat. At the time of recordation, Lot 8 contained fifty (50) feet of road frontage along Main Street. See Recorded Subdivision Plat – Exhibit B  In December 1968, Cemetery Road (corner side yard) was conveyed to the County of Chesterfield, approved, and accepted by the Board of Supervisors as a public road. This dedication altered the original layout of Lot 8 which caused the deficiency in required road frontage. Deed Book 943 Pages 142-146 • Request II. The Zoning Ordinance requires residential (R-7) properties to have a minimum lot width of fifty (50) feet.  Subject property Lot 8 was recorded July 1946 as part of The Ponds & Eanes Subdivision Plat. At the time of recordation, Lot 8, contained fifty (50) feet of lot width.  The conveyance of Cemetery Road in December 1968 altered the lot width of Lot 8 along Main Street and Cemetery Road; however, it is unclear how the entire side lot line was adjusted to 49 feet as currently platted. See Current Survey Plat – Exhibit A • The applicant purchased the property on September 24, 2019. • The applicant intends to rectify the deficiency in required road frontage and lot width to building one (1) single family dwelling. • The deficiency in public road frontage and required lot width may be rectified by receiving a variance. Planning Page 16 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 3 of 11 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 8 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 8 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 8 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 8 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 8 Real Property ...................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Current Survey Plat – Exhibit A ............................................................................................................................................... 9 Recorded Subdivision Plat – Exhibit B ................................................................................................................................... 10 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 11 Table of Contents Page 17 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 4 of 11 Proposal The applicant intends to construct one single family dwelling and offers the following justification for this request: There is not enough road frontage to meet the [Ordinance] requirements. Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; Aerial Planning Cemetery Road Main Street Page 18 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 5 of 11 • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Request I: Road frontage The subject property fronts a State maintained road, Main Street. The subject property is deficient in the amount of required road frontage by seventeen (17) feet. The applicant is requesting a seventeen (17) foo t variance to the required fifty foot road frontage required to use a parcel of land for dwelling purposes . The deficiency in road frontage was revealed when the applicant applied for a building permit to construct a single family dwelling (building permit 20230921 -062). Staff has examined the request and finds, as required by the Zoning Ordinance, conditions upon which this request is based are unique to the property and do not apply generally to other properties in the area. In this case, the request property was recorded in 1946 as part of The Ponds & Eanes Subdivision plat meeting Zoning Ordinance requirements (fifty (50) feet along Main Street). See Recorded Subdivision Plat – Exhibit B In December 1968, Cemetery Road which is the corner side yard for the subject property was conveyed to the County of Chesterfield and accepted by the Board of Supervisors as a public road. This dedication altered the original layout of the subject property which caused the deficiency in required road frontage. Staff examined the possibility of a Line Modification with the adjacent property to rectify the deficiency in road frontage ; however, the adjacent property does not have ample frontage to remedy the deficiency. Page 19 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 6 of 11 Request II: Lot width The subject property is deficient in the required lot width by less than one (1) foot. The request has been rounded to request a one (1) foot exception to the required fifty (50) foot lot width. Secondly, the applicant is requesting a one (1) foot variance to the required fifty (50) lot width requirement for property zoned Residential R-7. As stated above, the subject property met Zoning Ordinance requirements when recorded in 1946. The dedication and acceptance of Cemetery Road altered the subject property making it deficient in lot width. Staff examined the possibility of a Line Modification with the adjacent property to rectify the deficiency in lot width; however , the adjacent property does not have sufficient area to conduct a Line Modification to remedy the lot width deficiency. The applicant purchased the property in 2019 in good faith and did not create the hardship for either the road frontage or lot width deficiency. The intent of the applicant is to rectify the deficiencies by seeking the variances which would allow for the construction of one single family dwelling on an existing lot. Staff has determined that there are no practical alternatives available that would alleviate the need for this variance request. Page 20 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 7 of 11 Current Zoning Map Page 21 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 8 of 11 No comments No comments No comments No comments Connection to public utilities is required. No comments No comments Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 22 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 9 of 11 Current Survey Plat – Exhibit A Page 23 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 10 of 11 Recorded Subdivision Plat – Exhibit B Page 24 of 25 Jonathan Taylor 24VA1245 Page 11 of 11 Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: Jonathan Taylor (804-721-3520) taylorchomes@gmail.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Douglas Miles (804-768-7797) Milesd@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 25 of 25

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.