Board of Supervisors Meeting — Other
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Supervisors · meeting of Nov 13, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
11/13/2024 Page 1 of 5
Citizen Comments Received Through the Comment Portal
November 13, 2024 Board of Supervisors Meeting
Comment Type Comment Name District
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
While I support lifting
restrictions on retail/office
space square footage, I don’t
support waiving the
requirement for 50% of
retail/office space to be
under construction before
residential uses are
permitted. I also don’t
support elimination of the
requirement for an
“integrated schematic plan”
for the entire project.
This developer has a track
record of not delivering
promised amenities. The
developer marketed the
neighborhood as a resort-
style neighborhood complete
with a residents’ club and
fitness center coming in
2021. In late 2020, they
quietly removed the clubhouse
from the amenities list – not
because they couldn’t afford
it, but because they weren’t
required to build it – houses
were selling without it and
they had record sales in
2020.
If you allow the developer to
build apartments without
additional retail/office
space in an area that was
billed as “The Marketplace at
Magnolia Green,” the
marketplace will consist of
apartments and a daycare
center, that’s it. Not much
of a marketplace.
The developer wants to build
a 224-unit apartment complex
in an area totaling about
12.4 acres. This would exceed
current zoning restrictions
of 14 units per acre, which
would allow a maximum of 173
units for that one parcel.
They’re relying on the total
acreage for ALL parcels to
stay within density limits
for ONE parcel, but they want
to remove the requirement to
submit an integrated plan for
ALL parcels.
Richard
Latham
Matoaca
11/13/2024 Page 2 of 5
Comment Type Comment Name District
You can’t have it both ways;
you can’t include all parcels
to stay within residential
density limits on one parcel
while ignoring how the
remaining parcels might
eventually be developed.
Also, allowing the parcels to
be developed in a piecemeal
fashion will lead to a
disjointed end product; think
Westchester Commons – part
strip mall, part town center,
not very walkable,
dysfunctional vehicular
traffic flows, and looks
ridiculous!
Removing the requirement for
an integrated plan increases
the potential for housing
density limits to be
exceeded. The existing
daycare center was planned,
approved and expanded without
an integrated plan and in
violation of current zoning
restrictions regarding
retail/office square footage,
and nobody caught it.
Please do not allow (1)
residential uses on ANY
parcel without requiring
construction of additional
retail/office space, or (2)
individual parcels to be
developed without an
integrated plan for ALL
parcels.
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
Issues:
1) inaccurate justification
for the building of
apartments on Parcel 7.
2) too many dwelling units
per zoning on Parcel 7.
3) the use of multiple site
plans vice one integrated
site plan for the CC
district.
4) inadequate amenities for
the apartments to be built on
Parcel 7.
5) lack of communication with
residents of Magnolia Green
regarding design changes of
Robert
Altland
Matoaca
11/13/2024 Page 3 of 5
Comment Type Comment Name District
the CC district and impact to
Magnolia Green amenities by
the residential dwelling
units.
The land is broken into five
parcels; Parcel 1 where the
Cardinal is located, Parcels
4, 5, a new Parcel 7 that are
currently vacant and Parcel 6
where the Magnolia Green
Academy is located.
The CC was identified in the
original Magnolia Green
development plan to have a
“town square” design with
pedestrian walkways.
The CC was to have a singular
site plan that could have
created an integrated set of
businesses, residences, open
space and pedestrian walkways
in a “village” type of
development. Now there will
be a site plan for each
Parcel approved at different
times resulting in a
disjointed strip mall style
development.
The original zoning
restricted business to 5,000
square feet maximum,
Chesterfield County approved
the Magnolia Green Academy, a
12,000 square foot building.
The Magnolia Green Academy on
Parcel 6 is not included in
the rezoning amendment. There
is no business/retail
development on Parcel 7.
It appears that a Parcel 7
was carved out of Parcel 6.
The developer has a site plan
to build 224 apartments as
"Magnolia Green Apartments"
on 12.36 acres. This would
result in 18.1 dwelling units
per acre. This is more
dwelling units than allowed
by current zoning that
restricts the parcels to 14
dwelling units per acre.
It is unknown where the
developer will build the
other 140 dwelling units
11/13/2024 Page 4 of 5
Comment Type Comment Name District
(apartments or rental
townhomes) in this CC
district.
For comparison purposes, the
248 Glenmoor Apartments are
on 20.4 acres so 12.1
dwelling units (apartments)
per acre.
The amenities for the
Magnolia Apartments on Parcel
7 appear to have a pool and
clubhouse. The type/number of
amenities are insufficient
for this development.
Only property owners within
1,500 feet of this impacted
rezoning are notified
although this rezoning
impacts the entire Magnolia
Green community.
This rezoning amendment is
not ready for approval, it
should be denied and sent
back to the planning staff to
correct the deficiencies
identified.
24SN1209 -
Magnolia
Green Tract
CC Amendment
- Matoaca
Rezoning Case 24SN1209 -
Magnolia Green Tract CC
Amendment
I have two main issues with
this case and I urge you to
vote against it.
First the process was not
transparent. This change to
the zoning impacts all the
residents of Magnolia Green
directly and none received
notice of this case. . Myself
and many others who purchased
homes in Magnolia Green were
told this space was to be
developed as mastered planned
community center. Something
that is non-existent in the
Moseley area and would be a
significant asset to the
community. The fact that
there was no community notice
should be more than enough to
vote against this case and
send it back to the Planning
Commission.
My second concern is for all
the citizens in the Moseley
Wayne
Carbiener
Matoaca
11/13/2024 Page 5 of 5
Comment Type Comment Name District
area that surrounds this
land. The Magnolia Green
development was approved
years ago after much debate
and resistance from
landowners in Moseley. To
their credit the leaders at
the time at least recognized
some of the impacts of such a
large development and
included provisions to
address them. A CDA was
created to address road
impacts by assessing property
owners in the community for
improvements to Woolridge
Road and a portion of
Otterdale. To address the
lack of any true community
center in the Moseley area
the approved plan also
included a community center
(a town square as it was
described to many) that would
be a mix of commercial,
residential and open space.
Something closer to a true
village rather than a strip
mall masquerading as a
village. If the Chesterfield
County BOS approves this case
we will have just one more
multifamily/townhouse
project, behind a big box
store, with parking lot in
front and fast food joints
and gas stations fronting
Hull Street. We already have
Cosby Village, Hancock
Village and who knows how
many other "villages" all the
way to the City of Richmond
and Chesterfield does not
need another.
The Planning Commission has
already approved abandoning
the original plan and agreed
to divide the parcel into 7
different parcels all with
their own plan rather than a
single unified plan. Please
do not accept their
recommendation and vote
against approval of this
case.
Thank you.
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.