RecordWell Data

Board of Historic and Architectural Review Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)

City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · meeting of Nov 5, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

H I S T O R I C & A R C H I T E C T U R A L R E V I E W B O A R D N o v e m b e r 5 , 2 0 2 6 Board of Historic and Architectural Review November 5, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center 2130 S Military Hwy, Chesapeake, VA 23320 5:30 PM A. Call To Order B. Roll Call C. Approval of October 1 regular meeting minutes. D. Committee Reports E. Administrative Approvals F. Zoning Report G. Old and New Business a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates H. Consent Agenda Items I. Regular Agenda Items 1. 1302 Jefferson Street (PLN-CAPP-2026-112) Exterior renovations including windows, exterior siding, doors, columns, porticos/canopies, removal of ramp and garage doors, and installation of brick-paved walkway. 2. 1115 Park Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-114) Replacement of existing tubular metal handrail with two black metal handrails on front porch steps. 3. 1239 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-118) After-the-fact installation of 24-gauge 5V crimp metal roofing, shingle roofing on rear addition, and wood railing on front porch. J. Public Input K. Legal Guidance L. Adjournment These applications and related documents are available for public review on the Planning Department’s website through the following link: https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/AgendaCenter/Board-of-Historic-Architectural- Review-4 The City of Chesapeake will provide reasonable accommodations and services necessary for sensory-impaired and disabled persons by contacting the Facilities Maintenance Administrator, Public Works at (757) 382-8951 at least three-working days in advance and language assistance to individuals with limited English proficiency to the extent possible by contacting the Planning Department at (757) 382-6176 at least 10 days in advance of this meeting. *While his is not a public hearing, the public and any one or several members of the Chesapeake City Council may choose to attend. 1 Meeting Minutes Historic and Architectural Review Board (HARB) October 1, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center ROLL CALL HARB Members Present: Chair Frank Lilley, Vice Chair Scott Grinels, Ervin Young, Kaydee Moore. Dave Walski Staff: Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Jessica Hadley, Assistant City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Carlos Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Officer – Developments and Permits; Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Kevin Finn, Comprehensive Planning Administrator – Planning Department Chair F. Lilley called the meeting to order at 5:33 p.m. MINUTES Approval of September 3 regular meeting minutes. Motion to approve the minutes as written made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (5-0). COMMITTEE REPORTS None. ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS A. Nagorniuk reported seven (7) administrative approvals since the September 3 meeting, including a roof-mounted solar project at 1419 Jackson Avenue, a non-contributing property. ZONING REPORT None. OLD AND NEW BUSINESS a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates None; CLBA has not yet met for the month of October. CONSENT AGENDA None. REGULAR AGENDA 1. 1312 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-081) Original Request Replacement of existing front door, storm door, and transom window.  Motion to approve the COA as written made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (5-0). 2. 1120 Jackson Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-094) Original Request Installation of a wheelchair lift on front porch.  Motion to approve the application as written made by S. Grinels and seconded by K. Moore, with all members present voting for (5-0). 3. 1016 Park Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-104) Original Request 2 Replacement of existing double-hung wood windows with new vinyl windows.  Motion to deny the COA as presented made by E. Young and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (5-0). PUBLIC INPUT None. LEGAL GUIDANCE None. ADJOURNMENT Motion to adjourn the meeting made by S. Grinels and seconded by D. Walski, with all members present voting yes (5-0). Meeting adjourned at 6:08 p.m. MEETING MINUTES APPROVED: _________________ 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 1 Staff Report Version October 26, 2026 Proposal Exterior renovations including windows, exterior siding, doors, columns, porticos/canopies, removal of ramp and garage doors, and installation of brick-paved walkway. Address 1302 Jefferson Street Year Built c. 1920 (Contributing) Applicant Trish O’Brien After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒ Owner Children’s Health Investment Program, Inc. Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐ HARB Hearing Date November 5, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1302 Jefferson Street Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-112 Staff Recommendation Approval 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 2 Aerial Map 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 3 Project Proposal The applicant is proposing the following alterations: 1. Replacement of all siding with PlyGem Mastic Quest Premium Vinyl Siding, Double 4” , (.046 Thickness) to match HC-5 Weston Flax with white vinyl trim; 2. Replacement of siding on curved addition with CertainTeed vinyl board-and-batten Single 8” Cedar Extra Wide Flat Face vertical vinyl siding (.048 thickness) in Colonial White; 3. Remove existing overhead garage doors; 4. Remove existing doors and replace with half-lite 9-lite doors for primary public entrances and solid 6-panel doors for secondary entrances; 5. Replace all existing windows with new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; Installation of 8 new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; 6. Installation of flat-roof porticos with square wrapped 9½” x 9½” columns in a simple traditional style at primary public entrances (North elevation); 7. Remove existing window and door shutters; replace shutters like-for-like on 5 windows on original Jefferson Street elevation; 8. Entrance at South and West elevations to be covered with flat roof portico and round columns in simple traditional style in white and installation of new brick steps and landing; Install new portico in same style as others over existing doors and brick stairs facing Jackson Ave; 9. Existing iron railings to be painted black; 10. Addition of two architectural-shingle shed roof canopies at exit doors on West Elevation (Staff Parking) to extend out 4 feet; 11. Addition of two canopies above single doors on west and south elevations facing staff parking; 12. Installation of 75' X 6' brick-paved walkway between 2 public entrances facing parking lot on Jefferson Street. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Wood Siding and Trim 2. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic trim and ornamentation replacement applies: a. Replacement material must match the existing or documented historic siding, trim and ornamentation in general composition, shape, size, profile, and finish. b. Avoid wrapping historic trim or ornamentation with another material. (pg. 72) Windows 1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows. Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 4 2. If a historic window needs to be replaced, match the historic window in size, dimensions, configuration, and materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL)… 3. If non-historic windows are in place and require replacement, use a documented historic configuration if possible. If the historic configuration is unknown, consider replacing it with a design that is appropriate to the architectural style and period of the building’s construction. Refer to Chapter 3 for appropriate window configurations for each architectural style… 5. Historic window openings should not be modified or eliminated to accommodate interior changes. (pg.75-76) Doors 2. Existing modern doors can be replaced with a different door style, provided it is compatible with the style of the building. a. Only replace historic doors that cannot be repaired; avoid wholesale replacement of all historic doors in a building. (pg.78) Awnings and Canopies 2.) New awnings or canopies may be introduced onto a historic building to provide code-required covered entry points. a. The design should be contemporary yet compatible. b. Care should be taken to ensure the installation of a new awning or canopy does not alter the historic character of the building or damage or obscure historic materials or features. c. The placement of the new awning or canopy should align with the size, scale, and style of the associated doorways and fenestration. d. The shape, scale, massing, material, and color of the new awning or canopy should be compatible with the building and the surrounding district. (pg.79) General Analysis The applicant has received several COAs for ongoing exterior renovations at 1302 Jefferson Street, which were intended to improve the property to better align with the historic context of the surrounding neighborhood. Proposed improvements will better integrate the numerous additions and alterations made to the property over time. With the extensive scope of work, the applicant has received extensions/reissues of previous COAs. Now, the applicant is seeking to integrate all previously approved work, with several revisions (detailed below), on one application. The updated revisions/additions include: installation of a 75' X 6' brick-paved walkway between the 2 public entrances facing Jefferson Street, additional roof canopies/porticos to match others on all existing entrances, and the re-integration of several existing windows previously covered by siding. All other work described was previously reviewed and approved. Additionally, it should be noted that previous items related to painting/repainting have been removed due to repainting no longer requiring a COA. Staff find the proposed work to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval. Staff Findings 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 5 Additional Photos 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 6 [AI image] [AI image] 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 7 [AI image] 1302 Jefferson Street – PLN-CAPP-2026-112 8 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on October 29, 2026. 1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: October 6, 2026 Record Number: PLN-capp-2026-112 Record Name: 1302 Jefferson St Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Replacement of all siding with PlyGem Mastic Quest Premium Vinyl Siding, Double 4”, (.046 Thickness) to match HC-5 Weston Flax with white vinyl trim; Replacement of siding on curved addition with CertainTeed vinyl board-and-batten Single 8” Cedar Extra Wide Flat Face vertical vinyl siding (.048 thickness) in Colonial White; Remove existing overhead garage doors; Remove existing doors and replace with half-lite 9-lite doors for primary public entrances and solid 6-panel doors for secondary entrances; Replace all existing windows with new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; Installation of 8 new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; Installation of flat-roof porticos with square wrapped 9½” x 9½” columns in a simple traditional style at primary public entrances (North elevation); Remove existing window and door shutters; replace shutters like-for-like on 5 windows on original Jefferson Street elevation; Entrance at South and West elevations to be covered with flat roof portico and round columns in simple traditional style in white and installation of new brick steps and landing; Install new portico in same style as others over existing doors and brick stairs facing Jackson Ave; Existing iron railings to be painted black; Addition of two asphalt shingle shed roof canopies at exit doors on West Elevation (Staff Parking) to extend out 4 feet; addition of two canopies above single doors on west and south elevations facing staff parking: Installation of 75' X 6' brick-paved walkway between 2 public entrances facing parking lot on Jefferson Street. Address: 1302 JEFFERSON ST, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone CHILDRENS HEALTH INV PROGRAM INC Yes Page 1 of 4 PLN-capp-2026-112 Parcel Information Parcel No: 1340000001770 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Trish O'Brien Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Replacement of all siding with PlyGem Mastic Quest Premium Vinyl Siding, Double 4”, (.046 Thickness) to match HC-5 Weston Flax with white vinyl trim; Replacement of siding on curved addition with CertainTeed vinyl board-and-batten Single 8” Cedar Extra Wide Flat Face vertical vinyl siding (.048 thickness) in Colonial White; Remove existing overhead garage doors; Remove existing doors and replace with half-lite 9-lite doors for primary public entrances and solid 6-panel doors for secondary entrances; Replace all existing windows with new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; Installation of 8 new double-hung 3-over-1 vinyl windows with applied mullions; Installation of flat-roof porticos with square wrapped 9½” x 9½” columns in a simple traditional style at primary public entrances (North elevation); Remove existing window and door shutters; replace shutters like-for-like on 5 windows on original Jefferson Street elevation; Entrance at South and West elevations to be covered with flat roof portico and round columns in simple traditional style in white and installation of new brick steps and landing; Install new portico in same style as others over existing doors and brick stairs facing Jackson Ave; Existing iron railings to be painted black; Addition of two asphalt shingle shed roof canopies at exit doors on West Elevation (Staff Parking) to extend out 4 feet; addition of two canopies above single doors on west and south elevations facing staff parking: Installation of 75' X 6' brick-paved walkway between 2 public entrances facing parking lot on Jefferson Street. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Page 2 of 4 PLN-capp-2026-112 Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1920 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. - One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application - One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application - ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. - NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) - Front and side elevations - Samples - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. - ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan or city tax map - Elevations - Photographs of the existing structure and property. - Samples, photos, and brochures - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. - ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. - Written description of work to be performed - Photographs of the building/structure. - 2 quotes each are required for the following: - Photos numerically keyed - RELOCATIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. - Photographs of the premises to which the building or - Page 3 of 4 PLN-capp-2026-112 structure will be relocated. Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. - DEMOLITIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. - Written report on condition of building or structure. - Written description of work to be performed - SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached - METAL ROOFS Explanation - Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. - Picture - Specification Sheet - Roof color sample - Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. - Quotes - Roof color sample (asphalt) - Page 4 of 4 PLN-capp-2026-112 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 1 Staff Report Version October 28, 2026 Proposal Replacement of existing metal handrail with two metal handrails on front porch steps. Address 1115 Park Avenue Year Built c. 1900 (Contributing) Applicant Deborah Rountree After-the-Fact Yes ☐ No ☒ Owner 1115 Park LLC Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐ HARB Hearing Date November 5, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1115 Park Ave Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-114 Staff Recommendation Denial 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 2 Aerial Map 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing to replace existing tubular metal handrail with two black metal handrails on front porch steps. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Handrails 2. If a porch no longer has a handrail, but there is evidence a handrail was previously in place, the historic handrail should be replicated based on pictorial or physical evidence. If no historic or pictorial evidence remains, or if no handrail existed historically and is required for fall protection, use a contemporary, compatible rail like the one illustrated below or a simple metal rail like cast iron. (pg. 74) General Analysis The existing tubular metal single handrail is a modern addition that is incompatible with the historic context of the District. The applicant is proposing to install two black metal handrails on the front porch steps. The proposed handrail system is a more modern style, with visible flexible joints and fasteners, that is inconsistent with the context of the Historic District. It should be noted that the installation plan may also be revised to meet building code. Staff find the proposed metal railing to be inconsistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend denial. Staff Findings Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 4 Additional Photos 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 5 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 6 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 7 1115 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP—2026-114 8 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on October 29, 2026. 1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: October 7, 2026 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-114 Record Name: 1115 Park Ave Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Replacement on damaged front porch handrail with new (Black Galvanized Iron Railing). Address: 1115 PARK AVE A, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone 9611 6TH VIEW ST, NORFOLK, VA 23503 1401115 PARK LLCYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1330000006090 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Deborah L Rountree 1115 PARK LLC Applicant (757) 648-0999 Address 261 Melonie Drive, Chesapeake, VA 23322 140 Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Replacement of damage front porch handrail. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-114 Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1925 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. CHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application CHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application CHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed CHECKED RELOCATIONS Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-114 Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-114 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 1 Staff Report Version October 27, 2026 Proposal After-the-fact installation of 24-gauge 5V crimp metal roofing, shingle roofing on rear addition, and wood railing on front porch. Address 1239 Seaboard Avenue Year Built 1905 (Contributing) Applicant Marizabel Vasquez After-the-Fact Yes ☒ No ☐ Owner Hustle Investment Group LLC Special Power of Attorney Yes ☒ No ☐ HARB Hearing Date November 5, 2026 Staff Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1239 Seaboard Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-118 Staff Recommendation Approval with Stipulations 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 2 Aerial Map 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing the following after-the-fact alterations: 1. Replacement of existing standing-seam metal roof with 26-gauge 5V crimp metal roofing in silver; 2. Installation of architectural shingle on rear first-story addition; 3. Replacement of existing front porch railing with wooden railing with 0.75”x 1.5” (actual) balusters, and 2”x 4” top and bottom rail. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Roofs 2. If the historic roofing material is no longer available, use an alternative material that conveys a scale and texture similar to the historic material; reference the replacement material flow chart in Chapter 9 to guide the selection of an appropriate alternative material. a. Provide photographic documentation illustrating the historic roof cannot be repaired, as well as documentation of the sources checked for the historic material. (pg.64) Handrails 1. Historic porch handrails and balustrades should be retained and restored. a. If portions of handrails or balustrades are missing or damaged, they should be replicated and replaced in-kind. 2. If a porch no longer has a handrail, but there is evidence a handrail was previously in place, the historic handrail should be replicated based on pictorial or physical evidence. If no historic or pictorial evidence remains, or if no handrail existed historically and is required for fall protection, use a contemporary, compatible rail like the one illustrated below or a simple metal rail like cast iron. (pg.74) General Analysis The applicant previously received an approved COA in July 2026 for after-the-fact and other proposed exterior alterations, which included replacement of existing siding, replacement of standing-seam metal roof with 5V crimp, replacement of front porch columns and railing, replacement of wooden windows with vinyl windows (with SDLs), and removal of an existing side door. The original request was modified on the floor to include new 24-gauge standing-seam metal roofing and front porch railings with 2”x 2” actual size balusters. Since then, 5V crimp metal roofing was installed on the primary roof, and asphalt shingle was installed on the rear addition roof. The new front porch railing was constructed with what appears to be the previous pickets/balusters repurposed and rotated, with 2”x 4” lumber as the top and bottom rails. All other work has been completed to the letter of the previous COA. Roof While the Design Guidelines strongly encourage like-for-like replacement of character-defining standing- seam metal roofs, the proposed 5V crimp metal roofing is an alternative material that has sometimes been Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 4 deemed appropriate for homes in the historic district. The replacement roofing has been completed on the majority of the roof: the rear addition roof should be replacement with 5V crimp metal roofing to match. Porch The 1987 nomination report for the property details the materials of the porch as primarily “wood” with “heavy turned posts. ” The original approved COA included a wooden railing system consisting of a top and bottom rail with 2”x2” actual size balusters between, which is more similar to the typical 4-piece handrail often seen in the district on vernacular-style homes. The railing as installed is not a like-for-like replacement of the previously existing railing, nor does it meet the style of the previously proposed railing system. The railing should be revised to include the 2”x 2” actual balusters as originally approved, to be more consistent with the typical 4-piece handrail. The bottom rail should also be revised to be solid flat or solid sloped to ensure water does not gather in the recesses of the wood. The products proposed in the previous application (attached below) better meet this style than the materials as currently installed. Staff find this application to be inconsistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval with the following stipulations to bring proposed work into alignment with the Design Guidelines. 1. Rear addition roof to be replaced with 24-gauge 5V crimp metal to match the primary roof. 2. Front porch railings to be replaced as originally approved, with a moulded/beveled top rail, solid bottom rail, and 2” x 2” actual-size balusters. Recommended Stipulations dated October 27, 2026 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 5 Additional Photos 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 6 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 7 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 8 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 9 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 10 1239 Seaboard Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-118 11 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on October 29, 2026. 1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: October 15, 2026 Record Number: pln-capp-2026-118 Record Name: 1239 Seaboard Avenue Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Amendment to approved COA PLN-CAPP-2026-047 to request after-the-fact approval of the following: After-the-fact installation of a 24-gauge 5V crimp metal roof on the main house, in place of the approved 24-gauge standing-seam metal roof. After-the-fact installation of architectural asphalt shingles on the roof of the one-story rear addition. Retention of the existing wood porch railing and balusters as currently installed, in place of the approved 2"x2" (actual) square balusters. All other work approved under PLN-CAPP-2026-047 has been completed as approved: double 5" smooth gray vinyl siding, repair of the existing wood porch columns, 2-over-2 vinyl windows with simulated divided lites and wood trim, and removal of the side door on the rear addition, covered with vinyl siding. Address: 1239 SEABOARD AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone HUSTLE INVESTMENT GROUP LLC Yes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1280000001830 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Marizabel Vasquez Soporte Hispano LLC Applicant Address Page 1 of 4 pln-capp-2026-118 Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Amendment to COA PLN-CAPP-2026-047 asking for after-the-fact approval of: A 24-gauge 5V crimp metal roof on the main house, in place of the approved 24-gauge standing-seam roof. Asphalt shingles on the roof of the one-story rear addition. Keeping the existing wood porch railing and balusters as installed. All other approved work has been completed as approved. The roof meets the approved 24-gauge specification. 5V crimp is a traditional metal roof profile common in the historic district. The rear addition is not part of the original historic structure, is not visible from the street, and its roof was not included in the original COA. The porch keeps its original structure and design. The house keeps its historic character, and we ask the Board to approve the work as completed. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1905 Is this an After-the-Fact application? Yes $250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Page 2 of 4 pln-capp-2026-118 Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. CHECKED Written description of work to be performed CHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED RELOCATIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Page 3 of 4 pln-capp-2026-118 Explanation CHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. CHECKED Picture CHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 4 of 4 pln-capp-2026-118

Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.