RecordWell Data

Historic Landmarks Commission Meeting Packet (PDF)

City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Mar 12, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Suffolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Suffolk HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION March 12, 2026 THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION WILL BE HELD AT 9:00 A.M. IN CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS CITY HALL BUILDING Note: If You Cannot Attend This Meeting, Please Notify the Planning Division by 12:00 Noon, Wednesday, March 11, 2026 (757) 514-4060 PREPARED BY THE CITY OF SUFFOLK DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF PLANNING AGENDA Historic Landmarks Commission Meeting Thursday, March 12, 2026 9:00 a.m. __________________________________________________________ I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Approval of the Minutes IV. Public Hearings A. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2025 -00005, submitted by Chris Shelton of Cure, applicant on behalf of Elliott Apartments LLC, property owner, to install externally lighted marque sign on the front façade at 177 N. Main Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*324, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District Zoning District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District. B. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2026 -00006, submitted by Thomas Powell, applicant and property owner, to reopen and restore the original storefront window openings on the front facade, and restore and repaint the existing windows and door at 155 E. Washington Street. The property is further identi fied as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*281*B, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District V. New Business A. National Registry Nomination of the Ames-Old Farm B. By-Laws Change VI. Staff Reports A. Administrative Approvals B. Property Maintenance Update C. Zoning Update VII. Announcements VIII. Adjournment MINUTES HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION December 11, 2025 9:00 A.M. The regular meeting of the Historic Landmarks Commission was held on Thursday, December 11, 2025, at 9:00 a.m., in the Council Chambers of Suffolk City Hall, 442 W. Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia, with the following persons present: MEMBERS PRESENT: STAFF: Susan Coley Meg Pittenger, Assistant Director of Planning Keith Emerson Michael Patterson, Assistant City Attorney II Oliver Hobbs Jonathan McBride, Comprehensive Planning Manager Edward King Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner Kristy McCormally Darryl King, Housing/Property Maintenance Inspector Marsha Reid Nathan Davidson, Zoning Inspector Brian Shaffer Vivian Turner Chairman Hobbs called to order the Decembe r (2025) meeting of the Historic Landmarks Commission at 9:00 a.m. Meg Pittenger called the roll, and Chairman Hobbs was informed that a quorum was present. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: The minutes of the previous meeting were approved as presented. Ms. Pittenger introduced the new Commissioner, Ms. Marsha Reid to the Commission. NEW BUSINESS: Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2025 -00018, submitted by Fabiola Medina, applicant on behalf of Libra Capital Investments LLC, property owner, to replace a metal roof with 30 year rated architectural shingles at 208 Clay Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*43, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District. The first item of business was introduced by Chairman Hobbs followed by a staff report from Jonathan McBride, Comprehensive Planning Manager. Per Mr. McBride, the applicant is proposing 2 to replace a standing seam metal roof with 30-year architectural shingle asphalt shingles in the color “shadow charcoal”. Along with the roofing material , the applicant is proposing to install a roof underlayment, leak barrier for ice, water shielding, and a ridge vent. The applicant was previously approved on July 1, 2025 to replace or repair the current standing seam metal roof with in- kind materials outlined in application HLC2025- 00010. While architectural asphalt shingles may be considered an acceptable alternative in cases where in-kind replacement is not feasible , the applicant has not provided documentation demonstrating that the existing metal roof cannot be replaced in- kind nor has evidence been submitted to indicate structural limitation, significant financial hardship, or technical constraints that would justify a deviation from the established guidelines. Based on the findings, staff recommended denial of application, HLC2025-00018. The public hearing was opened, and no one spoke in favor or opposition of the application. The public hearing was closed and after a brief discussion, Commissioner McCormally made a motion to a ccept staff’s recommendation for denial of application HLC2025-00018. The motion was seconded by Commissioner King. The motion passed with a roll call vote of 8 to 0. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2025 -00019, submitted by Anton B. Johnston, applicant on behalf of Little Piggy Properties LLC, property owner, to install LED neon signs on the front façade windows and door at 165 N. Main Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*323, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District Zoning District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District. The second item of business was introduced by Chairman Hobbs followed by a staff report from Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner. Mr. Borges informed the Commission that the applicant is proposing to install four LED neon light signs on the windows, vestibule, and door located in the front retail façade facing the public right-of-way. The signs will replace the existing signs associated with a previous business operating at this location. Per the applicant’s narrative, all signage is proposed to be located inside the window glazing and is fully removable without altering the structure’s façade. Upon review by staff, the LED neon light signs are deemed in conformity with the standard set in section 31.714G of the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). They also cover less than 25% of the total area of the window s in which they are displayed. Also, the proposed signage does not have pulsating or moving lights which is deemed inappropriate by the Historic District Guidelines. Mr. Borges informed the Commission that the proposed signage is a set of LED replicating neon and therefore conforms with the historic standards set by the Historic D istrict 3 Guidelines. Based on these findings, staff recommended approval of application HLC2025-00019 for the four LED neon light signs on the windows vestibule, and door located in the front retail façade facing the public right-of-way. The public hearing was opened, and no one spoke in favor or opposition of the application. The public hearing was closed and after a brief discussion, Commissioner McCormally made a motion for the denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness of HLC2025-00019. The motion was seconded by Commissioner King. The motion passed with a roll call vote of 7 to 1. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2025 -00020, submitted by Ralph Nahra, applicant and property owner, to install white vinyl siding at 222 Bank Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*182, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned RM, Residential Medium Density Zoning District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District The last item of business was introduced by Chairman Hobbs followed by a staff report from Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner. Mr. Borges informed the Commission that the applicant is proposing to install white vinyl siding on the exterior of the building to cover the existing asbestos shingle siding. Also, if vinyl siding is not deemed appropriate by the Commission, the applicant requests authorization to paint the existing asbestos shingles in the color of Soleil PPG1093-2. The proposed actions include the installation of Georgia-Pacific Vision Pro Double 5” Dutch Lap white vinyl siding on the structure covering the existing asbestos shingle siding. Staff finds that installing vinyl siding on the asbestos shingles does not conflict with the Historic District Guidelines for the maintenance and repair of siding woodwork. Staff also finds that the proposed color as an alternative to the installation of the vinyl siding is appropriate for the subject property because it conforms with the Historic District color collection. Mr. Borges encourages the property owner to add an approved color to the wood trim details for contrast since that will conform with the already existing aesthetics of the district and other structures on the 200 blk of Bank Street. Based on these findings, staff recommends approval of HLC2025-00020. The public hearing was opened, and the applicant, Mr. Ralph Nahra, spoke in favor of the application. There were no other speaker s in favor or opposition of the application. The public hearing was closed and after a brief discussion, Commissioner Emerson made a motion to accept staff’s finding and approve application HLC2025-00020. The motion was seconded by Commissioner McCormally. The motion passed with a roll call vote of 8 to 0 4 STAFF REPORTS: HLC Administrative Approvals: Meg Pittenger • No Administrative Approvals Property Maintenance Update: Darryl King • Report included in December Meeting Agenda Packet Zoning Update: Nathan Davidson • Report included in December Meeting Agenda Packet ANNOUNCEMENTS: Ms. Pittenger informed the Commission that we will not have a meeting in January of 2026. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. MINUTES HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION Work Session, February 12, 2026 9:00 A.M. The work session of the Historic Landmarks Commission was held on Thursday, February 12, 2026, at 9:00 a.m., in the Council Chambers of Suffolk City Hall, 442 W. Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia, with the following persons present: MEMBERS PRESENT: STAFF: William Bissell Meg Pittenger, Assistant Director of Planning Susan Coley Jonathan McBride, Comprehensive Planning Manager Oliver Hobbs Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner Edward King Darryl King, Housing/Property Maintenance Inspector Marsha Reid Nathan Davidson, Zoning Inspector Vivian Turner Sean Dolan, Assistant City Attorney III Telesa Bleakley, Downtown Development Manager Chairman Hobbs called to order the February (2026) work session of the Historic Landmarks Commission at 9:00 a.m. Meg Pittenger called the roll, and Chairman Hobbs was informed that a quorum was present. Today’s work session presentation was presented by Jonathan McBride, Comprehensive Planning Manager. Mr. McBride opened the session with allowing the members of the Commission an opportunity to introduce themselves and to express their favorite memories of Downtown Suffolk and what they believe a vibrant Historic District should look like. Mr. McBride , new to the Commission, was also able to introduce himself and to give some of his background. Annual Report Summary: Mr. McBride gave an annual summary report of the total reviews done in 2025. There were a total of 22 reviews in 2025. There were 19 approvals, 13 of which were done administratively, while 6 of the approv als were made by the Commission. Th ree (3) applications that came before the Commission were denied. 2 Mr. McBride explained the code inspections to the Commission using a map of the downtown Suffolk Overlay District. Darryl King, Housing/Property Maintenance Inspector and Nathan Davidson, Zoning Inspector, were also present to discuss their role in the district as inspectors. Mr. King enforces the health and safety of the district while Mr. Davidson enforces any modifications to the exterior of the properties in the district with the approval of a certificate of appropriateness through Planning and the issu ance of permits through Community Development . Both inspectors work hand and hand. Mr. Davidson mentioned that a good portion of his job is educa ting homeowners in the district, unfortunately it’s done after the work has been done. HLC Guidelines Reminders – Role of HLC Reviewers: Mr. McBride informed the Commission that they play a vital role in maintaining the character of the residential properties as well as the commercial properties by abiding by the guidelines. The goal of the Commission is to be as consistent as possible in the decision-making processes which will help the property owners to know what is expected of them in the district. Guidelines: Local Decisions Within a State + Nationals Framework: Mr. McBride informed the Commission of the local and states guiding standards. NPS (National Park Service): balances continued use with protection of historic significance. The Department of Interior gives the broadest guidance around preservation. Virgina DHR: encourages consistency in preservation review, based on NPS standards. Local guidelines: provides practical tools for applying NPS standards in community- specific contexts. Mr. McBride informs the Commission that maintaining local guidelines is the goal. Guidelines Reminders – Administrative Layers: Goncalo Borge, Senior Planner, informed the Commission of the three different layers of review that are found in our Unified Development Ordinance (UDO ). Those layers are no review, administrative review and HLC Board Review. An example of no review is if an owner is painting a structure and using in the same approved color choice for the district, a review is not required. An example of an administrative review is when an owner is repairing a roof or siding and using the same type, color and texture of material. An example of an HLC Board Review is if an owner installs an illuminating sign. 3 Upcoming 2026 Planning Highlights: Mr. McBride shared with the Commission that staff is exploring HLC resources and tools, incentive opportunities, tax credit programs and grants that will be a support for the downtown historic district. Mr. McBride introduced Telesa Bleakley, Downtown Development Manager, to the Commission. Ms. Bleakley explained her role in trying to bring vibrancy back into downtown. Ms. Bleakley also informed the Commission that she is also the staff liaison to the downtown advisory committee who are a group of stakeholders that are responsible for guiding priorities, making recommendations and advising City Council on matters concerning downtown. Announcements: Meg Pittenger informed the C ommission that we will be having a meeting in March. She also informed the Commission that their packets will include HLC By-Laws with proposed changes for the Commission. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION December 11, 2025 Motion: Denial of HLC2025-00018 Motion: Denial of HLC2025-00019 Motion: Approval of HLC2025-00020 COMMISSIONERS ATTENDANCE 1st: McCormally 2nd: Turner 1st: McCormally 2nd: King 1st: Emerson 2nd: McCormally PRESENT ABSENT YES NO YES NO YES NO Bissell, William N.     Coley, Susan     Emerson, Keith     Hobbs, Oliver, Chairman     King, Edward L.     McCormally, Kristy     Reid, Marsha     Shaffer, Brian     Turner, Vivian     Quorum Present: Yes Vote: 8-0 Motion Denied Vote: 7-1 Motion Denied Vote: 8-0 Motion Approved CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 W. WASHINGTON ST., P.O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning To: Historic Landmarks Commission From: Jonathan McBride, Comprehensive Planning Manager Date: March 12, 2026 Subject: Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC2026 -00005, submitted by Chris Shelton of Cure, applicant on behalf of Elliott Apartments LLC, property owner, to install externally lighted marque sign on the front façade at 177 N. Main Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*324, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District Zoning District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District. STAFF REPORT Overview and Proposed Actions The subject property is a portion of a contributing structure located at 181 N. Main Street (also known as “Suffolk Towers Apartments, Elliot Hotel, or Elliot Apartments” ), and it is within the Original Suffolk District (1987) and the Suffolk Historic Conservation Overlay Zoning District . According to the National Register of Historic Places’ Inventory Nomination Form for the Original Suffolk District (1987), the subject portion of the structure is a one-story commercial building constructed around 1924 in the American Renaissance architectural style. The inventory describes the entire property in the following way: 181[N. Main. St]: Residential/Commercial (condominiums), Suffolk Towers Apartments, American Renaissance, 1924. Brick (stretcher bond); 8 stories; 4 bays; parapet roof (material not visible); classical motifs throughout facade; jack arches with keystones; full classical entablature below parapet including triglyphs and modillions; only urban scale apartment and retail structure in the historic district. – Suffolk Historic District Nomination, pg 38 The structure’s significance as a mixed -use, urban scale structure is highlighted in the following analysis of the structure’s contribution to the district: The Jones Building connects into the 8 stories-tall Suffolk Towers. Presently being used as an apartment house, the Suffolk Towers was known as the Elliott Hotel well into the nineteen sixties. A pamphlet published in 1922 showed a rendering of Italianate style HLC2026-00005 March 12, 2026 Page 2 design. The eventual design did not include tiled pent roofs or as many semi -circular windows but actually is a triumph of the American Renaissance architectural vocabulary with a conservative use of classical detailing onto shaft and a sophisticated cornice lin e with triglyphs and modillions. Along with two other tall structures (not included in the district) this imposing urban scale building dominates the downtown skyline and is a testimony to the final years of Beaux Arts-influenced architecture before the Depression. The applicant is proposing to install a lighted sign bracket to hang and hang an illuminated two- sided PVC sign onto the front retail façade along the public right -of-way. The proposed action includes the following details: 1. Front façade, right of the entry: install black lighted sign bracket to the front façade near the entryway to the bay, suspend a PVC wood appearance marquee sign, 30” long x 18” high, 3.75 sq ft, with engraved black lettering on a white background. Case History None Public Notice This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements in Section 15.2-2204 of the Code of Virginia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance. A notice, containing a copy of the staff report, was also provided to the applicant on February 23, 2026. Applicable Regulations A. Unified Development Ordinance • Section 31-413(f)(1)D, Issuance of Certificates: The Historic Landmarks Commission shall not issue a Certificate of Appropriateness authorizing issuance of any permit if it finds that the action proposed would adversely affect the primary character of the district or the setting of structures and premises of substantial public interest. • Section 31 -413(g)(2), General Considerations : The compatibility with the design, development standards and criteria as included in the City’s adopted Historic District Design Guidelines. • Section 31-714 (f), (2), Awning, marquee, projecting and suspended signs shall not be lower than seven and one-half feet (7.5) from the sidewalk to the base of the sign. • Section 31 -714 (g), Permanent Signs Permitted for Non -Residential Uses (Includes Multi-family): Wall, Marquee, Projecting, Suspended and Awning within RU-24, MUC-40, CBD, VC, FRRD districts; 1 SF per each linear foot of building frontage up to 100 SF maximum; however, each marquee, projecting, suspended, and awning signs shall not exceed 9 SF. HLC2026-00005 March 12, 2026 Page 3 B. Suffolk Historic District Design Guideline (8-16-2023) • Chapter 5, Site & Setting – Signage Signage Placement and Style (Page 86): While the main goal is to attract customers, signage placement and size should also be considerate of architectural features and respect nearby businesses. It should not overpower or obscure. It should maintain a strong connection to the streetscape while clearly establishing the location of the business. 1. A sign should be placed within existing architectural elements and not cover them. The shape of a sign should bring continuity to the façade. 2. Signs should be placed to be read at street level. 3. If mounting the sign to the brick or stone portion of a structure, it must be done within the mortar joints. 4. If historic signage exists (50+ years or older) and is part of the architecture, even if it advertises a non -existent business, it should be retained and not be covered. This signage does not count towards the current business’ allotted signage. 5. First-floor businesses should keep their signage below the second -floor window sills. 6. When determining scale and dimension of signage, please refer to the underlying zoning district requirements located in the UDO. Illuminating signage and façades calls attention to a business or the architecture of the structure. It should be in keeping with the overall streetscape design. 1. Neon signs are permitted if they are authentic neon or LED replicating neon. Plastic-encased lighting is not appropriate. 2. Pulsating or moving lights are not appropriate. 3. Box interior-illuminated awnings and signs are not appropriate. 4. Silhouetted back -lit signage is appropriate provided that it only highlights the signage and does not overpower the architecture (see examples to left). 5. Any electrical conduits should not be installed through masonry or historic details. Like mounting hardware, it should go between the mortar joints so that if it is removed in the future, it will not permanently damage the historic structure. Any exposed conduit and/or junction boxes should be concealed or painted to match the structure’s surface. C. The Secretary of Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation • The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided. (36 CFR §67.7) • Most properties change over time; those changes that have acquired historic significance in their own right shall be retained and preserved. (36 CFR §67.7) • Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a historic property shall be preserved. (36 CFR §67.7) • New hanging signs may be appropriate for historic commercial buildings, if they are of a scale and design compatible with the historic buildings. (Preservation Brief 11) HLC2026-00005 March 12, 2026 Page 4 Staff Analysis The applicant is proposing to suspend a double-faced sign on an illuminated metal bracket with corresponding exterior illumination on either side of the sign face. The bracket will be mounted to the front retail façade over the sidewalk adjacent to the public right -of-way. The sign face is approximately 3.75 square feet, measuring 30” by 18”, consisting of a white background with black lettering engraved. The sign will be constructed out of engraved PVC with a wood-like appearance as depicted in the COA application. Upon reviewing the proposed signs and consulting with the City of Suffolk Zoning Administrator, the signage and lighting are deemed in conformity with the standards set in Section 31-714. It is the staff’s opinion that the location proposed for installation or the lighting of the signage does not adversely affect the primary character of the historic district or the historic character of the subject structure, and it is compatible with the design, development standards and criteria included in the City’s adopted Historic District Design Guidelines , particularly, in the guidelines set on Chapter 5, Signage (page 86-88). While the sign is to be mounted on the façade, historic photos show the front of the structure’s façade covered partially by awnings in this portion of the structure. Therefore, the proposed sign choice appears to be less obtrusive and would not obstruct the existing architectural details of the façade. As such, the sign that is proposed is determined to: 1) be installed within existing architectural elements and will have minimal impact to the façade of the building and any other key architectural features; 2) be placed in a manner that can be read at the street level; and 3) meet the dimensions in conformity with the UDO. Concerning illuminated signage (page 88), the Historic District Guidelines state that externally lit signs are permitted and preferred. The guidelines specifically state: All lighting is faced towards the building or signage. The projecting sign is illuminated by external spotlights, and all conduits are hidden. Additionally, the proposed signage also does not have pulsating or moving lights, which are deemed inappropriate by the guidelines, and these signs are simple in design and easy to read from the public right-of-way. The proposed sign is compatible with the character of the structure, which is an authentic commercial building from the 1920s, and they are also compatible with the use that will be operating in the structure. Summary and Recommendation Based on the above findings -of-fact and conditions outlined above , staff recommends approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the request sought under HLC2026-00005 for the following actions as summarized below and as further detailed and specified in the COA application: 1. Front façade, right of the entry: install black lighted sign bracket to the front façade near the entryway to the bay, suspend a PVC wood appearance marquee sign, 30” long x 18” high, 3.75 sq ft, with engraved black lettering on a white background. HLC2026-00005 March 12, 2026 Page 5 Attachments: Site Maps (Location, Property, Zoning, Historic District) COA Application Zoning Application Bracket Specifications Signage Examples (Applicant Provided) Current View & Historic Examples (Staff Provided) Sources: Esri, TomTom, Garmin, FAO, NOAA, USGS, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community 0 2 4 6 81 Miles ^_ Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-09-2026 ± GENERAL LOCATION MAP HLC2026-00005 Subject Property VILLAGE TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD SUBURBAN NEIGHBORHOOD RIGHT OF WAY RURAL NEIGHBORHOOD RURAL CONSERVATION RURAL AGRICULTURE PARKS AND OPEN SPACE OFFICE/INSTITUTIONAL MIXED USE CORE MULTIFAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD Employment Center COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR Central Growth Area ^_ SUBJECT PROPERTY MARKET ST N SARATOGA ST N MAIN ST N SARATOGA ST BANK ST 34G18(A)*324 353164600 0 60 120 180 24030 Feet EXHIBIT B Subject Property Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-09-2026 ± PROPERTY MAP HLC2026-00005 BANK ST MARKET ST W W A S H I N G T O N S T PINE ST E W A S H I N G T O N S T S SARATOGA ST N SARATOGA ST COMMERCE ST N MAIN ST C A R O L I N A R D PINE ST S M A I N S T OAKDALE TER JACKSON ST C A R O L I N A R D GRACE ST T E R R A C E C T COLLEGE CT FREEMASON ST FINNEY AVE W F I N N E Y A V E W F I N N E Y A V E FRANKLIN ST C O M M E R C E S T CLAY ST N SARATOGA ST RU RM CBD RM B-1 34G18(A)*324 353164600 0 160 320 480 64080 Feet Subject Property Image: Suffolk Pictometry 2024 Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-09-2026 ± ZONING / LAND USE MAP HLC2026-00005 CBD N MAIN ST M A R K E T S T W WASHINGTON ST CEDAR ST E WASHINGTON ST CANNON ST FAYETTE ST N SARATOGA ST T R A D D S T HULL ST C O U N T Y S T LINDEN AVE RENO ST WELLONS ST FAYETTE ST CULLODEN ST PITCHKETTLE RD SMITH ST M A R Y L A N D A V E P I T C H K E T T L E V I L L A G E S T J A C K S O N S T KATHERINE ST PITCHKETTLE RD S SARATOGA ST JOHNSON AVE B E D F O R D P L W C O N S T A N C E R D BANK ST C A R O L I N A R D CAROLINA RD ELEY CT BUTE ST W FINNEY AVE LINDEN AVE IBIS BLVD J E F F E R S O N S T NEWPORT ST P A R K R D MORGAN ST M I L I T A R Y R D S MAIN ST HIGHLAND AVE HENLEY PL AZALEA CT JOHNSON AVE MULBERRY ST WESTERN AVE PRINCETON RD SPRUCE ST CHURCH ST HALL AVE HILL ST W H I T E H E R O N S L N YORK CT D A Y S T TYNES ST CHERRY ST PINE ST SPRING ST OAKLAND ST MADISON AVE YORK ST POPLAR AVE F O R E S T H I L L C R E S E PINNER ST N BROAD ST NANSEMOND AVE DUMVILLE LN ORCHARD AVE GRAYSON CT CENTRAL AVE RIVERVIEW CT B O A T S T CAUSEY AVE KENNEDY CT J O H N S O N A V E M A S O N A V E ASHLEY AVE OAKDALE TER P A R K W A Y NORTH ST WILSON ST S BROAD ST MAHAN ST VIRGINIA AVE GAYS ROW POLK ST ASHLEY AVE MULBERRY ST KINGSBORO ST MADISON AVE HARRISON ST TERRACE CT PINNER ST PINE VALLEY DR HOLLADAY ST W RIVERVIEW DR ADAMS ST COLLEGE CT GRANBY ST BATTERY AVE FIRST AVE GRACE ST THIRD AVE SECOND AVE FINNEY AVE CAUSEY AVE PENDER ST P E L H A M P L MCKINLEY AVE R I D L E Y S T BOSLEY AVE LEXINGTON AVE FACTORY ST FORT ST VAN BUREN AVE DUMVILLE AVE ELEY ST EUGENIA ST ALLEN ST GITTINGS ST J O H N S O N L N D O G W O O D L N FREEMASON ST CAROLINA AVE NEVADA ST SECOND AVE L A K E P O I N T L N LEE ST E RIVERVIEW DR E C O N S T A N C E R D N & W A V E S BROAD ST SAINT JAMES AVE PEARL ST AZALEA CT C O M M E R C E S T SKIMMERS LN SOUTH ST JONES ST N E L M S W A Y CHARLES ST LINDEN AVE LINDEN AVE BREWER AVE FOREST ST GARFIELD AVE H O W A R D P L W F I N N E Y A V E L I N C O L N A V E SAINT JAMES AVE FRANKLIN ST CHESTNUT ST PINE ST C O M M E R C E S T FOURTH ST M A U R Y P L CLAY ST RAILROAD AVE LIBERTY ST DELAWARE AVE VIRGINIA AVE PENNSYLVANIA AVE BUTLER AVE N SARATOGA ST DARDEN AVE B I S H O P P L SHIPWRIGHT LN PRENTIS ST E R I V E R V I E W D R F A I R G R O U N D S L N MOORE AVE C O N S T A N C E W O O D S D R NANSEMOND RIVERLAKE MEADE Disclaimer: THE CITY OF SUFFOLK MAKES NO WARRANTY, REPRESENTATION, OR GUARANTEE OF ANY KIND REGARDING EITHER ANY MAPS OR OTHER INFORMATION PROVIDED HEREIN OR THE SOURCES OF SUCH MAPS OR OTHER INFORMATION. THE CITY OF SUFFOLK SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS ALL REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILIY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. The City of Suffolk assumes no liability for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the information provided regardless of the cause of such or for any decision made , action taken, or action not taken by the user in reliance upon any maps or information provided herein. Parcel and Zoning information has been developed to provide a graphic representation of the Real Estate Property Tax Maps. The boundaries of any parcel may have been adjusted to provide a more visually pleasing presentation. User should refer to the instrument of transfer (deed or plat) for legal boundary location and perimeter or area measurements. Amended 8/16/2011 by Ordinance No. 11-O-073 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.40.05 Miles SCALE: 1:10,000 Legend BUILDING FOOTPRINTS SUFFOLK HISTORIC CONSERVATION OVERLAY NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC DISTRICTS ORIGINAL SUFFOLK DISTRICT (1987) NORTH MAIN STREET DISTRICT EXTENSION (1998) EAST WASHINGTON STREET DISTRICT (2002) WEST END DISTRICT (2004) WEST END DISTRICT EXPANSION (2004) SUFFOLK DISTRICT EXPANSION (2004) CEDAR HILL DISTRICT (2006) ^_ Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-09-2026 µ Suffolk Historic Conservation Overlay District & National Register GENERAL LOCATION MAP HLC2026-00005 Subject Property CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 W. WASHINGTON ST., P.O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning To: Historic Landmarks Commission From: Goncalo Borges, Senior Planner Date: March 12, 2026 Subject: Request for Certificate of Appropriateness HLC202 6-00006, submitted by Thomas Powell, applicant and property owner, to reopen and restore the original storefront window openings on the front facade, and restore and repaint the existing windows and door at 155 E. Washington Street. The property is further identified as Zoning Map Number 34G18(A)*281*B, Suffolk Voting Borough, zoned CBD, Central Business District, and HC, Historic Conservation Overlay District. STAFF REPORT Overview and Proposed Actions The subject structure is a contributing structure located at 155 E. Washington Street, and it is located within the National Register of Historic Places - East Washington Street District (2002) , and the Suffolk Historic Conservation Overlay Zoning District. According to the National Register of Historic Places Inventory’s Nomination Form for the East Washington Street District (2002), 155 E. Washington Street is a 1-story vernacular commercial contributing structure, built sometime in the first half of the 20th Century, possibly in the early 1940s. The building has a solid foundation, shed style roof, and a masonry structural system with brick veneer. Currently, the structure has a non-original infill metal storefront, composed of three window panels and an entry door. A large, superior window opening above the storefront is currently boarded up and used to be covered by a black awning that was attached to the façade of the structure. This superior grid- style window is visible in pictures from the 1940s , provided by the applicant , and it was a wide grid-style window. Per the application and correspondence with City staff, the property owner/applicant is proposing the following: • Reopen the superior window opening by carefully removing the non -historic materials currently occupying this opening. HLC2026-00006 March 12, 2026 Page 2 • Installing new windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match the historic commercial storefront proportions. The window size is 36” in height by 15’ width and will have a window framing 3250 Series 3-1/4” Thermal Fixed, Casement & Projected Windows manufactured by Winco. • The superior window will be painted using the color Midnight Hour PPG1038-7 from the HLC’s approved PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection. • Refurbish and paint the existing facade’s lower windows and door, inclusive of frame and trim, by using the same selected color, Midnight Hour PPG1038-7. The applicant also added that the existing masonry will be cleaned and prepared using non - abrasive methods, and any necessary masonry repairs will be completed using compatible mortar and materials to match the existing historic brick in color, texture, and joint profile. No historic brick will be removed beyond what is necessary to reopen the original window opening. Lastly, the property owner -applicant states that no original historic materials are proposed for removal beyond what is required to reinstate the documented storefront openings. Please note that the narrative that was initially provided was subject to clarification, which w as confirmed by email on February 12, 2026. The property owner-applicant confirmed that they “are keeping the same windows/doors and painting the trim with the approved HLC paint color.” The proposed action includes the following details: 1. Reopening the superior window opening, repair and re-pointing the existing brick masonry around the opening by using compatible mortar, and install new windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match the historic commercial storefront proportions: window size - 36” in height by 15’ width (3250 Series 3-1/4” Thermal Fixed, Casement & Projected Windows manufactured by Winco). 2. Painting the newly installed superior window and the existing windows and door, inclusive of frame and trims, with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038 -7 from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection. Case History On November 17, 2004, Ordinance Number 04 -O-134, the subject property received an encroachment permit for an awning with a 3.5-foot encroachment into the East Washington Street right-of-way. On September 12, 2025, the subject structure received a Commercial Building Permit from the City of Suffolk for interior renovations. HLC2026-00006 March 12, 2026 Page 3 Public Notice This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements in Section 15.2-2204 of the Code of Virginia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance. A notice, containing a copy of the staff report, was also provided to the applicant on March 5, 2026. Applicable Regulations A. Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) • Section 31-413(f)(1)D, Issuance of Certificates: The Historic Landmarks Commission shall not issue a Certificate of Appropriateness authorizing issuance of any permit if it finds that the action proposed would adversely affect the primary character of the district or the setting of structures and premises of substantial public interest. • Section 31 -413(g)(2), General Considerations : The compatibility with the design, development standards and criteria as included in the City’s adopted Historic District Design Guidelines. B. Suffolk Historic District Design Guidelines (8-16-2023) • Chapter 2, Historic Treatments – District Guidelines: Masonry, Woodwork, Windows, Commercial Storefronts and Paint (pages 13 – 54). • Chapter 6, Alternative Materials Considerations (pages 94 – 98). C. The Secretary of Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation • Deteriorated historic features should be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities, and where possible, materials. Replacement of m issing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical, or pictorial evidence. • Not Recommended: Radically changing the type of paint or coating or its color. Staff Analysis The applicant is proposing to reopening the superior window opening, repair and re -pointing the existing brick masonry around the opening by using compatible mortar, and install new windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match the hi storic commercial storefront proportions: window size - 36” in height by 15’ width (3250 Series 3 -1/4” Thermal Fixed, Casement & Projected Windows manufactured by Winco). The applicant is also proposing to paint the newly installed superior window and the existing windows and door, inclusive of frame and trims, with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038 -7 from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color HLC2026-00006 March 12, 2026 Page 4 Collection. Per the Historic District Guidelines (Guidelines), historic storefronts are important character - defining features of historic commercial structures. The details of the storefronts provide important information about the structure's style and era, though it is important to recognize that storefronts are often updated to reflect current trends and marketing techniques. As the Guidelines further explain, many of Suffolk’s storefronts are second-generation historic storefronts. This means that while such storefronts have been altered from their original designs, these alterations happened so long ago that they are historic in their own right. Because of this, the retention of original and second-generation storefronts is considered in this review process. The maintenance guidelines state that property owners shall repair damaged historic storefront components as feasible. Any replacement of historic materials should be with matching materials and detailing. If the existing storefront is modern and requires repairs, the repairs should be accomplished with a matching finish and size. When replacing materials, those shall match the historic materials, dimensions, and profile, as well as replicate any historic features, details, or ornament. Furthermore, the Guidelines suggest that if the existing storefront is modern and requires replac ement, the property owner should consider designing the replacement to match the historic configuration. Additionally, the property owner should try to avoid using materials that were unavailable at the time the storefront was constructed. It is also encouraged to use clear glass in a storefront. The subject structure on 155 E. Washington Street presents a mixture of original characteristics and other second -generation elements that have been in the structure for decades. The first proposed action, the reopening of the superior window opening and reinstallation of the grided - style window, visible in the picture from 1942, aligns with the aforementioned guidelines , by reestablishing an important historic feature that has been covered by both wood and an awning. Hence, the proposed action promotes the revival of the historic features of the subject structure, as well as accurately contributes to the Historic District by rehabilitating this storefront to its original overall design. The proposed reopening utilizes clear glass and an alternative material (metal: 3- 1/4” deep frame depth with a nominal wall thickness of .125 inch, extruded from 6063 -T6 alloy) that keeps the same appearance, texture, style, pattern , finish, and size, as the historic material (which appeared to be wood). Hence, the materials being used in the reopening and reconstruction of the superior window match the existing materials found on the second -generation storefront, thus respecting both the original features and the second -generation features of the subject structure. Regarding the second proposed action: the applicant proposes to paint the newly installed superior window, and also the existing modern second -generation storefront windows and door with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038 -7 from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection . Staff finds that these proposed repairs are being accomplished by reviving an important storefront feature, such as the superior grid -style window, as well as by respecting the second generation features in the storefront by maintaining and repainting the existing metal framing . Currently the existing windows and door have a stainless steel and metallic appearance. The applicant is proposing to change this appearance. The choice of color aligns with the Guidelines because it is HLC2026-00006 March 12, 2026 Page 5 chosen from the approved PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection, it does not alter the finishing or size of the storefront features, and the color does not conflict with the façade’s red brick tone, and matches some of the urban features present on East and West Washington Street and throughout the historic district, a such as the City’s light poles and signage that are painted in a similar dark color . Staff find that the proposed color treatment does not negatively impact the character of the district. Summary and Recommendation In sum, staff have reviewed the proposed actions with respect to the applicable requirements of the HC Overlay zoning district and determined that the proposed project meets the applicable requirements. It is staff opinion that reopening and reinstalling a superior window based on the original design using a modern material that matches the materials and finishing of the existing second-generation storefront is appropriate because it aligns with the standards set by the Guidelines and by the UDO, a s well as it follows the recommendations set by the Secretary of Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation. Staff also finds that the proposed paint treatment on the superior window and on the existing second -generation store-front with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038-7 (from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection ) as appropriate, because it follows the Guidelines and the chosen color is selected from one of the approved collections. Based on the above findings -of-fact and conditions outlined above , staff recommends approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness for the request sought under HLC2026-00006 for the (1) reopening the superior window opening, repair and re-pointing the existing brick masonry around the opening by using compatible mortar, and install new windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match the historic commercial storefront pr oportions: window size - 36” in height by 15’ width (3250 Series 3 -1/4” Thermal Fixed, Casement & Projected Windows manufactured by Winco); and (2) painting the newly installed superior window and the existing windows and door, inclusive of frame and trims, with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038 -7 from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection. Staff recommends approval of the following actions as summarized below in regard to HLC2026-00006 and as further detailed and specified in the COA application: 1. Reopening the superior window opening, repair and re-pointing the existing brick masonry around the opening by using compatible mortar, and install new windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match the historic commercial storefront proportions: window size - 36” in height by 15’ width (3250 Series 3-1/4” Thermal Fixed, Casement & Projected Windows manufactured by Winco). 2. Painting the newly installed superior window and the existing windows and door, inclusive of frame and trims, with the color Midnight Hour PPG1038 -7 from the PPG Paints’ Historic Paint Color Collection. 3. Any additional exterior work on the façade or roo f of the st ructure, inclusive of the installation of signage (such as illuminated signs) will, or may, require an additional COA application. HLC2026-00006 March 12, 2026 Page 6 4. All required building and zoning permits shall be obtained from the City of Suffolk. Attachments • Site Maps • Correspondence and Narrative • Photographs of the Structure, and Proposed Work • Specifications Sources: Esri, TomTom, Garmin, FAO, NOAA, USGS, © OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community 0 1 2 3 40.5 Miles ^_ Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-17-2026 ± GENERAL LOCATION MAP HLC2026-00006 Subject Property VILLAGE TRADITIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD SUBURBAN NEIGHBORHOOD RIGHT OF WAY RURAL NEIGHBORHOOD RURAL CONSERVATION RURAL AGRICULTURE PARKS AND OPEN SPACE OFFICE/INSTITUTIONAL MIXED USE CORE MULTIFAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD Employment Center COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR Central Growth Area ^_ SUBJECT PROPERTY N MAIN ST MARKET ST W WASHINGTON ST CEDAR ST E WASHINGTON ST CANNON ST FAYETTE ST N SARATOGA ST TRADD ST HULL ST COUNTYST LINDEN AVE RENOST WELLONS ST FAYETTE ST CULLODEN ST PITCHKETTLE RD SMITH ST MARYLAND AVE PITCHKETTLEVILLAGE ST JACKSON ST KATHERINE ST PITCHKETTLE RD S SARATOGA ST JOHNSON AVE BEDFORD PL W CONSTANCERD BANK ST CAROLINA RD CAROLINA RD ELEYCT BUTE ST W FINNEY AVE LINDEN AVE IBIS BLVD JEFFERSONST NEWPORT ST PARK RD MORGAN ST MILITARY RD S MAIN ST HIGHLAND AVE HENLEY PL AZALEA CT JOHNSON AVE MULBERRY ST WESTERN AVE PRINCETON RD SPRUCE ST CHURCH ST HALL AVE HILL ST WHITE HERONSLN YORK CT DAY ST TYNES ST CHERRY ST PINE ST SPRING ST OAKLAND ST MADISON AVE YORK ST POPLAR AVE FOREST H ILLCRE S E PINNER ST N BROAD ST NANSEMONDAVE DUMVILLE LN ORCHARDAVE GRAYSON CT CENTRAL AVE RIVERVIEW CT BOAT ST CAUSEY AVE KENNEDY CT JOHNSON AVE MASON AVE ASHLEY AVE OAKDALE TER PARK WAY NORTH ST WILSON ST S BROAD ST MAHAN ST VIRGINIA AVE GAYSROW POLK ST ASHLEY AVE MULBERRYST KINGSBORO ST MADISON AVE HARRISON ST TERRACE CT PINNER ST PINE VALLEY DR HOLLADAY ST W RIVERVIEW DR ADAMS ST COLLEGE CT GRANBY ST BATTERY AVE FIRST AVE GRACE ST THIRD AVE SECOND AVE FINNEY AVE CAUSEY AVE PENDER ST PELHAM PL MCKINLEY AVE RIDLEY ST BOSLEY AVE LEXINGTON AVE FACTORY ST FORT ST VAN BUREN AVE DUMVILLE AVE ELEY ST EUGENIA ST ALLEN ST GITTINGS ST JOHN SO N LN DOGWOOD LN FREEMASON ST CAROLINA AVE NEVADA ST SECOND AVE LAKEPOINT LN LEE ST E RIVERVIEW DR E CONSTANCE RD N & W AVE S BROAD ST SAINT JAMES AVE PEARL ST AZALEA CT COMM ER CEST SKIMMERS LN SOUTH ST JONES ST NELMS WAY CHARLES STLINDEN AVE LINDEN AVE BREWER AVE FOREST ST GARFIELD AVE HOWAR D PL WFINNEY AVE LINCOLN AVE SAINT JAMES AVE FRANKLIN ST CHESTNUT ST PINE ST COMM ERC EST FOURTH ST MAURYPL CLAY ST RAILROAD AVE LIBERTY ST DELAWARE AVE VIRGINIA AVE PENNSYLVANIA AVE BUTLER AVE N SARATOGA ST DARDEN AVE BISHOP PL SHIPWRIGHT LN PRENTIS ST ERI VER VIEW DR FAIRGROUND S LN MOORE AVE CONS TANC EWOODS DR NANSEMOND RIVERLAKE MEADE Disclaimer: THE CITY OF SUFFOLK MAKES NO WARRANTY, REPRESENTATION, OR GUARANTEE OF ANY KIND REGARDING EITHER ANY MAPS OR OTHER INFORMATION PROVIDED HEREIN OR THE SOURCES OF SUCH MAPS OR OTHER INFORMATION. THE CITY OF SUFFOLK SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS ALL REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILIY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. The City of Suffolk assumes no liability for any errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the information provided regardless of the cause of such or for any decision made , action taken, or action not taken by the user in reliance upon any maps or information provided herein. Parcel and Zoning information has been developed to provide a graphic representation of the Real Estate Property Tax Maps. The boundaries of any parcel may have been adjusted to provide a more visually pleasing presentation. User should refer to the instrument of transfer (deed or plat) for legal boundary location and perimeter or area measurements. Amended 8/16/2011 by Ordinance No. 11-O-073 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.40.05 Miles SCALE: 1:10,000 Legend BUILDING FOOTPRINTS SUFFOLK HISTORIC CONSERVATION OVERLAY NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC DISTRICTS ORIGINAL SUFFOLK DISTRICT (1987) NORTH MAIN STREET DISTRICT EXTENSION (1998) EAST WASHINGTON STREET DISTRICT (2002) WEST END DISTRICT (2004) WEST END DISTRICT EXPANSION (2004) SUFFOLK DISTRICT EXPANSION (2004) CEDAR HILL DISTRICT (2006) ^_ Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-17-2026 µ Suffolk Historic Conservation Overlay District & National Register GENERAL LOCATION MAP HLC2026-00006 Subject Property E WASHINGTON ST COMMERCE ST COMMERCE ST 34G18(A)*281*B 353753800 0 30 60 90 12015 Feet Subject Property Image: Suffolk Pictometry 2024 Author: KOSSAI Date: 02-17-2026 ± ZONING / LAND USE MAP HLC2026-00006 CBD CBD You don't often get email from tom@theaddisongroup.com. Learn why this is important To: Goncalo Borges <gborges@suffolkva.us> Subject: Re: 155 East Washington Street - Facade Renovations - HLC in March Good morning, Goncalo. I have submitted my application documents to the SharePoint link. I will be dropping off a hard, wet-signed copy by Tuesday, February 17 right before our Monthly Planning Commission meeting. Regarding your question about the current windows/doors, they are all addressed in the addendum. We are keeping the same windows/doors and painting the trim with the approved HLC paint color. Thanks for helping with this. I really appreciate it. Let me know if I'm missing anything. Tom Powell 757-285-7454 theaddisongroup.com From: Goncalo Borges <gborges@suffolkva.us> Sent: Wednesday, February 11, 2026 10:42 AM To: Tom Powell <tom@theaddisongroup.com> Subject: 155 East Washington Street - Facade Renovations - HLC in March Hello Commissioner Powell, Good morning. The HLC will be able to hear and vote on the 155 East Washington Street façade renovation in the March meeting. To that end, we will need a complete scanned application (or original if that works best), inclusive of all support documentation, submitted to the City’s Sharefile by February 18, so we can ensure that we meet the legal advertisement dates for the public hearing. The original application with wet signatures will also be required, but you can drop that off by the end of February at your convenience. Sharefile link (see the section “Online Submission”: https://www.suffolkva.us/628/Regular- Plan-Review-Applications I am seeking some clarification from you with regards to the work being done, since application narrative is what is used for advertising and COA content, so we need it to be specific as possible, in addition to attaching material specs and mockups. Director Kevin Wyne forwarded me the narrative. In the narrative you specify that you will be reopen and restore the window openings, and add new storefront windows. Will the existing door be removed and replaced as well (similar to the windows)? Or will you simply clean and paint the door? Please kindly include that clarification and detail in the narrative that you will be submitting – for HLC purposes, the door is considered an independent item from the windows. Once you submit everything, the City will invoice you, and we will prepare everything for the March 13th hearing. The meeting is similar to the Planning Commission, with a presentation, discussion, and vote. It is usually quick. If any questions emerge during the review and report process, I will reach to you. Is this your best email or do you have any other contact that you prefer me to use? I look forward to take your case and present it at the HLC. Please do not hesitate in reaching out if you have any questions or concerns. I am always happy to help. Enjoy a great Wednesday. Best regards, Goncalo Borges, M.A., C.Z.A. Senior Planner City of Suffolk Department of Planning & Community Development 442 W. Washington St Suffolk, VA 23434 gborges@suffolkva.us Thomas Powell 155 East Washington St. Suffolk, V A 23434 (757) 285-7454 tom@theaddisongroup.com APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Property Address 155 East Washington Street, Suffolk VA 23434 Tax Map Number 34G18(A)*281*B Account Number 353753800 Zoning District Historic Conservation Overlay District Property Owner Thomas Powell Date February 3, 2026 1. Full detailed description of proposed alterations inclusive of existing materials and proposed materials, specifications and dimensions with regards to the scope of the project, paint colors, and a sketch, drawing, and/or color elevations showing the proposed changes or improvements (attach more sheets if needed): The proposed work at 155 East Washington Street is a facade restoration project intended to return the storefront to its original historic configuration, based on archival photographs of the building and surrounding historic context. Existing Conditions: The existing street-facing façade consists of historic brick masonry with a later, non-original infill storefront system. The original storefront window openings have been partially obscured or altered over time, and the current display configuration does not reflect the building’s original proportions or material intent. Existing materials include historic brick masonry, modern storefront glazing, metal framing, and non-historic paint treatments. Proposed Scope of Work: The proposed renovation will reopen and restore the original storefront window openings in their historically documented locations and proportions. New storefront windows will be installed within the original masonry openings using clear glass with dark metal framing, consistent with early 20th-century commercial storefronts in Downtown Suffolk. All new glazing and framing will be installed in a manner that is reversible and does not damage historic masonry. The existing masonry will be cleaned and prepared using non-abrasive methods, and any necessary masonry repairs will be completed using compatible mortar and materials to match the existing historic brick in color, texture, and joint profile. No historic brick will be removed beyond what is necessary to reopen the original window openings. Paint and Finish Treatments: Proposed paint colors have been selected from the City of Suffolk’s approved historic paint color collections. Paint application will be limited to non-masonry elements, including storefront framing and trim, ensuring that historic brick surfaces remain unpainted. Final color selections are submitted for staff review of this application. Design Intent and Context: The design intent is to restore the building’s historic commercial storefront appearance, reinforcing Downtown Suffolk’s architectural character and pedestrian streetscape. The proposed façade treatment is consistent with other approved historic restorations in the immediate area, including the renovation of the Elliott Hotel, and aligns with the scale, rhythm, and material vocabulary of East Washington Street. Thomas Powell 155 East Washington St. Suffolk, V A 23434 (757) 285-7454 tom@theaddisongroup.com Documentation: Drawings and color elevations illustrating the proposed storefront configuration, window placement, and finish treatments are included with this application. 2. If painting, consult the City’s three approved paint color collections (located online as well as in the City’s Planning and Community Development Department) and provide the name of the paint color(s) selected, paint swatch, and color code: In compliance with the City’s requirement to consult the City of Suffolk’s three approved historic paint color collections, we have selected the paint color for non-masonry elements of the storefront exterior: Approved Historic Paint Color: • Color Name: Midnight Hour • Collection: Historic Paint Color Collection – PPG Paints • Color Code / Swatch Reference: Midnight Hour (PPG Historic Collection) Application Location: Storefront metal framing and trim only Color Swatch and Code: (Reference provided per the City of Suffolk’s published Historic Paint Color Collection) PPG Historic Color Code: Exact code as shown in the City’s paint collection swatch (Midnight Hour) Finish Selection: Low-sheen exterior enamel, compatible with metal framing surfaces Visual Intent: A dark, rich tone that complements the historic brick and aligns with adjacent historic storefront restorations within the downtown context Application Scope: Paint will be applied only to non-masonry elements, including new storefront metal framing and trim. Historic brick masonry will remain unpainted to preserve the original material character of the building façade. 3. Color photographs in hard copy or via email, including photos taken from all public right-of-ways, to show the area of the proposed alterations and close-up images of any materials to be repaired or replaced. (See following page for images) Thomas Powell 155 East Washington St. Suffolk, V A 23434 (757) 285-7454 tom@theaddisongroup.com 155 East Washington Street in 1942 155 East Washington Street today 4. A condition statement, if proposing to replace materials, signed by a licensed general contractor is required that 1) identifies the condition of existing materials, 2) ability to be repaired, 3) need for replacement, 4) proposed corrective measures and 5) options for replacement. Condition Statement – Existing Materials and Proposed Replacement Prepared by: Ferguson Building Corp., Cliff Ferguson Signed: _____________________________________ Date: February 3, 2026 Property: 155 East Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia 1. Condition of Existing Materials — Based on a visual inspection of the street-facing storefront and façade, the existing storefront system consists of non-original materials, including modern storefront glazing, metal framing, and infill elements installed during prior renovations. These elements do not reflect the building’s original construction and have deteriorated over time due to age, weather exposure, and prior modifications. The historic brick masonry remains generally sound but shows localized mortar deterioration, evidence of prior patching, and areas where original window openings were altered or partially infilled. No structural failure of the masonry was observed; however, the current storefront assembly is not consistent with historic storefront construction and does not align with the original design intent of the building. Thomas Powell 155 East Washington St. Suffolk, V A 23434 (757) 285-7454 tom@theaddisongroup.com 2. Ability of Existing Materials to Be Repaired — The existing non-historic storefront materials are not suitable for repair in a manner that would restore the building to its original historic appearance. Due to their non-original nature, continued repair of these elements would perpetuate an inaccurate façade condition. The historic brick masonry is repairable, and proposed work will prioritize preservation of original brick wherever feasible. Masonry repairs will be limited to re-pointing and localized repair using compatible materials. 3. Need for Replacement — Replacement is necessary only for non-original storefront components that currently obscure or alter the original window openings. Replacement is required to allow the reopening of the historic storefront configuration and to properly reinstall windows within their original proportions and locations. No original historic materials are proposed for removal beyond what is required to reinstate the documented storefront openings. 4. Proposed Corrective Measures — Corrective measures include: • Careful removal of non-historic storefront framing and infill materials • Reopening original masonry window openings based on historic documentation • Repair and re-pointing of existing brick masonry using compatible mortar • Installation of new storefront windows with clear glazing and dark metal framing designed to match historic commercial storefront proportions • Window Size: 36” in height by 15’ in width • Window Materials: (See separate attachment) • Window Color: Midnight Hour PPG1038-7 • All work performed using non-destructive and reversible methods 5. Options for Replacement — Replacement options were evaluated with an emphasis on compatibility and reversibility. The selected approach utilizes: • Clear glass storefront windows • Dark metal framing consistent with early 20th-century storefront systems • Installation methods that preserve historic masonry and allow for future removal without damage *Alternative options, including continued use or cosmetic repair of the existing storefront system, were evaluated and rejected due to their incompatibility with the building’s historic character. 5. N/A 6. We are not requesting Federal or State Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for this project. 7. Yes. We have already requested real state tax abatements for this project and have already been approved. Signed __________________ Thomas Powell, Owner, 155 East Washington Street Thomas Powell 155 East Washington St. Suffolk, V A 23434 (757) 285-7454 tom@theaddisongroup.com 155 East Washington Street Proposed Historic Facade Upgrade < AFTER > Current photo of the existing building. 155 East Washington Street Proposed Historic Facade Upgrade < BEFORE > The same historic window design that currently installed in the restored Elliott Hotel in Downtown Suffolk 155 East Washington Street in 1942 155 East Washington Street Proposed Historic Facade Upgrade < AFTER > Current photo of the existing building. CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 WEST WASHINGTON STREET, P. O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 MEMORANDUM TO: Historic Landmarks Commission FROM: Margaret Pittenger, Secretary RE: National Register Nomination – Samuel Eley House, DHR No. 133-0101 DATE: March 5, 2026 Attached for your review and comment, please find a copy of the National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Ames-Old Farm, which is located at 6700 Knotts Neck Road in the City of Suffolk. The subject property contains a farmhouse and several accessory structures that have been surveyed and determined to be locally significant in architecture. The nomination to recommend listing the property on the National Register and the Virginia Landmarks Register is scheduled to be presented to Virginia’s State Review Board and Historic Resources Board on March 19, 2026. Because Suffolk is a Certified Local Government, the Historic Landmarks Commission is entitled to a sixty-day comment period to review the proposed nomination of this property and provide any comments to the Virginia Department of Historic Resources (DHR) prior to its presentation to the state review boards. The nomination being offered for consideration was prepared by the owner with the assistance of the Virginia DHR. Staff has also reviewed the nomination and supports the listing of this property on National Register of Historic Places. Should the Historic Landmarks Commission wish to offer formal support for this nomination, it may wish to do so in the form of a motion to recommend it for approval to the state review boards. This action would then be relayed to the state prior to the scheduled meeting date. Should you have any questions pertaining to this nomination, please do not hesitate to contact me. DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 WEST WASHINGTON STREET, P. O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 MEMORANDUM TO: Historic Landmarks Commission FROM: Margaret Pittenger, Secretary RE: Proposed By-Laws Changes DATE: March 5, 2026 Attached for your review and consideration are the proposed revisions to the Historic Landmarks Commission Bylaws. The proposed amendments are intended to clarify procedural language, improve administrative efficiency. The revisions do not alter the statutory authority, purpose, or core responsibilities of the Commission. Key revisions include: • Elimination of conflicting language distinguishing “public hearing” and “public meeting,” • Refinement of meeting procedures and notice provisions to align with public meeting requirements, and • Reduction of the required waiting period for resubmission of a substantially similar application from one (1) year to thirty (30) days. These revisions are intended to strengthen procedural clarity, improve predictability for applicants, and maintain the Commission’s authority as the designated review board for the Historic Conservation (HC) Overlay Districts pursuant to Section 31-413 of the Unified Development Ordinance. Should the Commission desire to adopt the proposed amendments, such action may be taken in accordance with Article XI of the Bylaws, which requires an affirmative vote of a majority of the entire Commission membership. If you have any questions regarding the proposed revisions, please do not hesitate to contact me prior to the meeting.. DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning City of Suffolk Historic Landmarks Commission Bylaws 2 BYLAWS OF THE CITY OF SUFFOLK HISTORIC LANDMARKS COMMISSION ARTICLE I. NAME The name of this board shall be the Historic Landmarks Commission of the City of Suffolk, hereinafter called the “ Commission.” The Commission is established by the Code of the City of Suffolk. ARTICLE II. PURPOSE/DUTIES This Commission shall have such duties and shall exercise such powers as are specified by state law and the Code of the City of Suffolk. The Historic Landmarks Commission is hereby designated, pursuant to Section 31- 413 of the Unified Development Ordinance, as the review board for the Historic Conservation (HC) Overlay Districts. ARTICLE III. MEMBERS Section 1. Composition The Commission shall be composed of nine (9) members appointed by the City Council at large for staggered terms of four (4) years beginning on July 1 of the applicable year. Section 2. Qualifications All members of the Commission shall be residents of the City and shall have a demonstrated interest, competence, or knowledge in historic preservation and shall meet the qualifications designed by the Virginia Department of Historic Resources. Section 3. Vacancies Vacancies shall be filled by appointment by the City Council for the unexpired term only within sixty (60) days of the vacancy. Members may be removed for malfeasance in office. 3 ARTICLE IV. OFFICERS Section 1. Personnel The officers shall consist of a Chairman, Vice Chairman, and Secretary. Section 2. Election and Term of Office The Chairman and Vice Chairman shall be elected from among the appointed members of the Commission for a term of one year or until their successors are elected and shall be eligible for re-election. A Secretary from the Department of Planning and Community Development staff shall be appointed for a term of one year. Section 3. Duties The powers and duties of the officers shall be as follows: a. Chairman The Chairman shall preside at all meetings of the Commission and shall perform such duties as are usually exercised by the Chairman of a Commission or a Board, including the appointment of all committees. b. Vice Chairman The Vice Chairman shall assist the Chairman and shall preside and perform the duties of the Chairman during the absence or disability of the Chairman. c. Secretary The Secretary shall notify members of meetings, publish notices , keep a record of the proceedings of the Commission, and have responsibility for keeping all records, correspondence, and other papers and materials pertaining to the affairs of the Commission. Section 4. Vacancies A vacancy in any office shall be filled by the Commission within sixty days and the appointed member shall serve until the expiration of the original term of office or until a successor is elected. The Chairman and Vice Chairman may be removed from office without cause by majority vote of the Commission. 4 ARTICLE V. MEETINGS Section 1. Administrative Year The Administrative Year shall be from July 1 through June 30. Section 2. Regular and Special Meetings Regularly scheduled meetings of the Commission shall be held at least four times during the administrative year. Special meetings may be called by the Chairman or by a majority of the Commission members and held at any time or place fixed in the notice . The Secretary shall give the Commission members at least ten (10) days’ notice of the time, place, and purpose of the special meeting. Section 3. Election Meeting and Annual Meeting The annual meeting for the election of officers of the Commission shall be a designated regular meeting in the month of July of each year. Section 4. Quorum/Voting A quorum shall consist of a majority of the members of the Commission. The concurring vote of a majority of the Commission members present shall be required for the exercise of powers or functions of this Commission. Section 5. Public Notice of Meetings All meetings of the Commission shall be publicly announced. Notice of all meetings shall name the time, place, and purpose of the meeting. Section 6. Attendance at Meetings Members of the Commission are expected to attend all meetings. Whenever any member misses four (4) meetings within any twelve (12) month period, the Chairman shall report this information to the City Council, along with a recommendation for retention or removal of said member of the Commission. When making these recommendations, the Chairman shall consider not only the reasons for the absence of the member, but also any deleterious affect said absence may have upon the Committee as a whole or its members. ARTICLE VI. COMMITTEES 5 When so resolved by action of the Commission membership, the Chairman shall create such committees as deemed appropriate to further the general Commission program. The Chairman may appoint individuals or members of the Commission to such committees. ARTICLE VII. RULES OF PROCEDURE Section 1. Order of Business a. Call to Order. b. Approval of minutes of previous meeting. c. Review of applications for Certificates of Appropriateness. d. New Business. e. Unfinished Business. f. Announcements. g. Adjournment. Section 2. Agenda a. An agenda shall be prepared and distributed to members of the Commission prior to each meeting. An agenda shall also be made available to the public prior to the meetings. b. In order that an agenda may be prepared in an orderly and timely manner, the Secretary, with the concurrence of the Chairman, may designate a date and time by which any new business to be brought before the Commission shall be received by the Secretary. Any new business received after the deadline shall be placed on the agenda for the next meeting of the Commission. Section 3. Minutes Written minutes of the proceedings of all Commission meetings are required and shall be kept on file and available for public inspection. The minutes shall include the reasons and criteria upon which all decisions and actions of the Commission were based. Section 4. Final Action by Commission An application can be withdrawn at any time. If a public meeting has been advertised , and the applicant requests to w ithdraw an application after such advertisement, no substantially similar application concerning the same property shall be accepted for filing within thirty (30) calendar days from the date of withdrawal. This provision, however, may be waived by a majority vote of the members of the Commission. ARTICLE VIII. ANNUAL TRAINING 6 Members of the Commission are expected to attend an annual training or information workshop locally or regionally, for continuing education. Any member unable to do this, must convey a valid excuse to the Chairman. Failure to comply with this requirement shall be reported to the staff of the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission for consideration of official waiver under the Certified Local Government Program. ARTICLE IX. CONFLICT OF INTERESTS PROHIBITED Commission members are required to abide by the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act in the exercise of the powers or functions of this Commission. It is the intent of this section of the By -Laws to prohibit any and all conduct, which would amount to a conflict of interest as defined in any rules, regulations or guideline s of the Virginia Department of Historic Resources or the National Park Service. ARTICLE X. PARLIAMENTARY AUTHORITY The Commission and its proceedings shall be governed by the latest edition of Robert’s Rules of Order, Newly Revised. ARTICLE XI. AMENDMENTS The foregoing bylaws, or any part thereof, may be amended at any regular meeting of the Commission. Proposals for amendments shall be submitted to the Commission at a regular meeting and shall be scheduled for consideration and action at the next regular meeting. An affirmative vote of the majority of the entire Commission shall be required to amend the Bylaws and Rules and Procedures. Adopted: 7/21/87 Amended: 6/14/01 Amended: 4/11/13 Amended: 7/14/16 Amended: 4/11/24 Amended: 3/12/26 ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL December 1, 2025 – February 28, 2026 FILE NUMBER ADDRESS ALTERATIONS APPROVAL DATE HLC2025-00021 130 N. Commerce Street Install 2 non-illuminated wall signs 12/4/2025 HLC2025-00022 220 N. Main Street Replace existing asphalt roof shingles, Upgrade structural rafters, Install solar panels 12/11/2025 HLC2026-00001 119 Oakdale Terrace Replace concrete masonry unit and brick veneer landscaping wall 1/13/2026 HLC2026-00002 124 St Jame Avenue Replace siding, Replace roof, Replace windows, Repaint shutters, Replace front and side door, Repaint foundation skirt, Repaint existing columns, soffit fascia, and gutters 1/13/2026 HLC2026-00003 221 Bank Street Repair and power wash shingles, Re-paint siding, Replace all windows, Replace front door, Install black metal railings 2/10/2026 HLC2026-00004 312 Bank Street Install Solar Panel 2/4/2026 1 HLC PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE ENFORCEMENT UPDATE MARCH, 2026 ADDRESS CODE VIOLATION(S) STATUS 223 BANK ST PROPERTY MAINTENANCE • WINDOWS DAMAGE • ROOF DAMAGE • D ETERIORATED EXTERIOR WALL • INTERIOR SURFACE DAMAGE • DETERIORATED PORCH PROPERTY STILL IN VIOLATION PROPERTY IS NO LONGER FOR SALE THE CITY IS LOOKING INTO AVILIABLE OPTIONS FOR THE PROPERTY 112 W WASHINGTON ST PROPERTY MAINTENANCE • ELEVATORS IN DISREPAIR • FIRE / ELECTRICAL VIOLATIONS VACANT BUILDING OWNER HAVE MADE ALL REPAIRS FROM THE RECENT ACCIDENT. AND MAKING OTHER NECESSARY REPAIRS 221 BANK ST PROPERTY MAINTENANCE • PEELING/CHIPPING PAINT • INSECT SCREENS APPLICATION HAS WAS APPROVED IN JANUARY 301-307 BANKS ST PROPERTTY MAINTENACE • NO RENTAL C.O. FOR ALL UNITS • D ETERIORATING CONCRETE • DETERIORATING HANDRAILS • PE ELING/CHIPPING PAINT • DETERIORATING COLUMNS RENTAL C.O. HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE BUILDING 301-303 318 BANK ST PROPERTY MAINTENANCE • PEELING PAINT • OVERHANG IN DISREPAIR • SURFACE COAT ROOF NEW OWER HAS STARTED MAKING REPAIRS 222 BANK ST PROPERTY MAINTENANCE • FOUNDATION DAMAGE • BROKEN RETENTION WALL • BROKEN WINDOWS • DETERIORATING WOOD ON • OVERHANG PLANS WERE APPROVED BY THE BOARD IN DECEMBER SWEEP OF CLAY STREET ON 06/27/2024 224- PORCH,WINDOWS,PEELING PAINT THE TITLE HAVE BEEN RECEIVED PROPERTY IS ON THE DEMO LIST 219 CLAY ST A TREE FELL ON THE GARAGE NOTICE OF VIOLATION HAVE BEEN MAILED TO THE OWNER ON FILE TO REMOVE THE GARAGE 166 S MAIN INOPERABLE VEHICLE IN THE PARKING LOT NOTICE OF VIOLATIONS HAVE BEEN ISSUED AND THE VEHICLE IS CURRENTLY WAIT TO BE TOWED March 2, 2026 Property Owner(s) Location Violation(s) Judgement Inspector Dymon & Deja Ward 216 Pinner Work does not match COA Work not completed, no communication. Summons issued Davidson TJ Beaumont LLC 162 S Main Living in trailer NOV Issued Davidson Little Piggy Properties LLC 165 N Main Signs in windows Summons Issued Davidson Zoning Case Activity Report

Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.