_01212026-3671
City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Jan 21, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Suffolk
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
1
Regular Meeting of the Suffolk City Council was held in the City Council Chamber , 442 West
Washington Street, on Wednesday, January 21 , 202 6 , at 6 :0 0 p.m.
PRESENT
Council Members -
Michael D. Duman, Mayor, presiding
Lue R. Ward, Jr., Vice Mayor
Leroy Bennett
Shelley Butler Barlow
Timothy J. Johnson
John T. Rector
LeOtis L. Williams
Ebony N. Wright
Erika S. Dawley, City Clerk
William E. Hutchings, Jr. , City Attorney
Kevin Hughes , Interim City Manager
ABSENT
None
CALL TO ORDER/INVOCATION/PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Mayor Duman called the meeting to order . Counci l Member Butler Barlow offered the Invocation and
led the Pledge of Allegiance.
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT CERTIFICATION
City Clerk Dawley presented a resolution certifying the Closed Meeting of January 21 , 202 6 , pursuant to
Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended.
Council Member Williams , on a motion seconded by Council Member Butler Barlow , moved to approve
the resolution, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: May or Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
A RESOLUTION OF CERTIFICATION OF THE FIRST CLOSED MEETING OF JANUARY
21 , 202 6 , PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.2-3712 OF THE CODE OF VIRGINIA (1950), AS
AMENDED
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
2
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
Council Member Wi lliams , on a m otion seconded by Council Member Bennett , moved to appr ove the
minutes from the Octo ber 1 , 20 2 5 , Work Session and Regular Meeting , as presented , by the followi ng
vote :
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
S PECIAL PRESENTATION S
There were no items under this portion of the meeting .
R E MOVAL OF ITEM S FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA AND ADOPTION OF THE
AGENDA
Council Member Rector , on a motion seconded by Council Member Johnson , moved to adopt the
agenda , as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett ,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
AGENDA SPEAKERS
There were no speakers under this portion of the agenda.
C ONSENT AGENDA
There were no items under this portion of the meeting.
P UBLIC HEARING S
Public Hearing - An ordinance approving an Amendment to the Devolution Agreement and Quitclaim
Deed with the Virginia Department of Transportation for the Transfer of Roadway Maintenance
Responsibilities to the City of Suffolk dated June 27, 2006.
Utiliz ing a PowerPoint presentation, Public Works Director Gregg Benton provided a summary of the
background information as printed in the official agenda.
Hearing no speakers, the public hearing was closed.
Council Member Bennett , on a motion seconded by Council Member Williams , moved to approve the
ordinance as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
3
AN ORDINANCE APPR OVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE DEVOLUTION AGREEMENT
AND QUITCLAIM DEED WITH THE VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
FOR THE TRANSFER OF ROADWAY MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES TO THE CITY
OF SUFFOLK DATED JUNE 27, 2006.
Public Hearing - An ordinance to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a live entertainment after
10PM and public assembly uses on property located at 209 North Saratoga Street, Zoning Map
34G18(A), Parcel 49, Account Number 350407000; CUP2025-011
Utilizing a PowerPoint presentation, Plann ing and Community Development Director Kevin Wyne gave
an overview of the background information as printed in the official agenda.
Dwight James, 211 Linden Avenue, representing self, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance , with
conditions, as presented .
Domenick Epps, 2245 Wisteria Drive, Snellville, Georgia, representing self, spoke in support of the
proposed ordinance , with conditions, as presented.
The following individuals spoke in opposition to the proposed ordinance , with conditions, as prese nted :
Kerry Holmes, 23 0 Clay Street, representing self .
David Edgell, 313 Westwood Drive, representing First Baptist Church .
Tom Woodward, 223 North Main Street, representing self .
Kyle Pas qua re lla, no address given, attorney for Fred Walker, applicant and property owner, spoke in
support of the proposed ordinance , with conditions, as presented .
Hearing no additional speakers, the public hearing was closed.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Wright queried about the surrounding properties.
Planning and Community Development Director Wyne reported there is an insurance business to the
south, stated he does not know who owns the property to the north , and concluded he does not know if
the properties behind the subject property are inhabited.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Wright solicited additional information about a reported
violation in January 2025. Planning and Community Development Director Wyne said the location was
issued a notice of violation for operating after permi ssible hours .
Council Member Wright asked Mr. Holmes about the proximity of his residence on Clay Street to the
applicant ’s property. Mr. Holmes said he is the first house on Clay Street at the intersection with Finney
Avenue.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
4
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Butler Barlow inquired whether the applicant would still
be allowed to operate within current hours if the C onditional U se P ermit under consideration was not
approved. Planning and Community Development Director Wyne replied in th e affirmative. Mr.
Pasquarella advised that the business currently operates until 2 :00 a.m., seven days per week. He
clarified that the application asks for an extension of two hours for live entertainment beyond the current
restriction so that artists can perform.
Vice Mayor Ward called for clarification about the hours the applicant is requesting to be extended. Mr.
Pasquarella replied that the applicant is asking for live events until 11 :00 p.m. Sunday through Thursday
and until midnight on Friday and S aturday.
Vice Mayor Ward asked about the length of time the applicant has been in operation. Mr. Pasquarella
replied the applicant has been operating at the location for almost three years.
Vice Mayor Ward solicited information about violations. Mr. Pasquarella said there have been some fire
violations but would not discuss them in detail due to pending litigation.
Council Member Williams questioned the applicant ’s attorney about the location of entertainment. Mr.
Pasquarella said all activity will be in side the building.
Council Member Williams inquired about the existence of a picnic table outside in relation to the deli.
Mr. Pasquarella said it is used for the deli.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Williams asked Police Chief James Buie about any
reported problems with parking. Chief Buie said he has not heard that parking has been a problematic
issue but would research the matter.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Bennett opined about noise violations. Planning and
Community Development Director Wyne said any noise complaints would be addressed by the City ’s
noise ordinance.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Wright inquired about the potential of a noise decibel
monitor being included as a condition. Planning and Community Development Director Wyne advised
that noise complaints are already addressed by the noise ordinance.
Council Member Wright asked Police Chief Buie about reported problems with noise. Chief Buie said
he has not heard that noise problems have be en an issue on North Saratoga.
Vice Mayor Ward requested information about the capacity for parking in the area. Mr. Pasquarella
replied 48 cars could be accommodated in the area.
Vice Mayor Ward inquired about the meaning of “ live entertainment ” . Mr. Pasquarella advised that jazz
or a DJ is envisioned, one in a quieter atmosphere in order to foster socialization.
Council Member Rector asked if the applicant canvassed the North Saratoga Street area regarding the
Conditional Use Permit. Mr. Pasquarella a dvised he did not speak to the pastor at F irst Baptist Church,
but he went down a few houses from the subject property to speak to property inhabitants.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
5
Council Member Rector, on a motion seconded by Council Member Johnson, moved to deny the
ordinance , with conditions, as presented.
Vice Mayor Ward asked whether the Conditional Use Permit could be issued for one year to see how the
business operates. City Attorney Hutchings advised that a one-year permit is not permissible by the
Unified Development Ord inance. He concluded that a public hearing would be required to revoke an
approved Conditional Use Permit.
Council Member Wright, on a substitute motion, moved to amend the proposed ordinance to include a
condition to require a noise decibel monitor in the conditions and approve the remainder of the
ordinance as presented. The motion failed for lack of a second.
Mayor Duman requested clarification of the motion in relation to the Unified Development Ordinance.
Council Member Wright advised she is asking for a noise decibel monitor to be required as a condition.
Mayor Duman asked whether a noise decibel monitor could be required as a condition. City Attorney
Hutchings advised that a noise decibel monitor could not be required but could be voluntary. He further
explained that a condition setting a specific decibel level could be included.
Council Member Wright, on a substitute motion seconded by Vice Mayor Ward, moved to approve the
ordinance, with conditions, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Vi ce Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett, Williams and Wright 4
NAYS: Mayor Duman and Council Members Butler Barlow, Johnson and Rector 4
Council Member Rector, on a motion seconded by Council Member Johnson, moved to deny the
ordinance , with conditions, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman and Council Members Butler Barlow, Johnson and Rector 4
NAYS: Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett, Williams and Wright 4
Mayor Duman asked the City Attorney for clarification of the v ote. City Attorney Hutchings said that
the conditional use permit is denied since there were not five affirmative votes on the motion to approve.
Public Hearing - An ordinance to grant a Conditional Use Permit to establish a solar energy facility on
property located on Whaleyville Boulevard, Zoning Map 65, Parcel 12, Account Number 100010000;
CUP2025-016
Utilizing a PowerPoint presentation, Planning and Community Development Director Wyne gave an
overview of the background information as printed in the of ficial agenda.
Steve Romine, 222 Central Park Avenue, Virginia Beach, Virginia, representing Chaberton Energy
Holdings, Inc., applicant, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance , with conditions, as presented .
Avery Clemens, 1436 Minor Ridge Court, Charlottesville, Virginia, representing Chaberton Energy
Holdings, Inc., applicant, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance , with conditions, as presented.
Hearing no additional speakers, the public hearing was closed.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
6
Referring to the presentation, Cou ncil Member Williams solicited information about community
outreach. Mr. Romine reported there were three meetings: an in -person meeting at Liberty Springs
Baptist Church, a virtual meeting and a site walk.
Council Member Williams, on a motion seconded by Council Member Wright, moved to approve the
ordinance, with conditions, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
AN ORDINANCE TO GRANT A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ESTABLISH A SOLAR
ENERGY FACILITY ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON WHALEYVILLE BOULEVARD,
ZONING MAP 65, PARCEL 12, ACCOUNT NUMBER 100010000; CUP2025-016
Public Hearing - An ordinance to rezone and amend the official zoning map of the City of Suffolk to
change the zoning from A, Agricultural Zoning District, to RLM, Residential Low-Medium Density
(Conditional) Zoning District for properties located at 494 Manning Road, Zoning Map 33, Parcels 75
and 75A, Account Nu mbers 151078000 and 151069000; RZN2024-013 (Conditional) (T his item was
deferred from the November 19, 2025, City Council Meeting .)
Utilizing a PowerPoint presentation, Planning and Community Development Director Wyne gave an
overview of the background information as printed in the official agenda. Transportation Planning
Manager Jason Souders provided additional information.
Grady Palmer, 222 Central Park Avenue, Virginia Beach, Virginia, representing Matt Howard, applicant
on behalf of Manning Road Deve lopment Group, LLC, property owner, spoke in support of the
proposed ordinance with modified proffer.
Sam Baraki, no address given, civil engineer on behalf of Matt Howard, applicant on behalf of Manning
Road Development Group, LLC, property owner, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance , as
presented .
Ben Fitzgerald, 6705 Castlewood Drive, representing self, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance ,
as presented .
The following individuals spoke in opposition to the proposed ordinance , as presented :
Jenny Willman , 4305 Ainslie Court South, representing self.
Karla Carter, 3003 Autumn Circle, representing self.
Diana Klink, 133 Winterview Drive, representing self.
Jacob Siegel, 123 Springfield Terrace, representing self.
Grady Palmer, 222 Central Park Avenue, Virginia Beach, Virginia, representing Matt Howard, applicant
on behalf of Manning Road Development Group, LLC, property owner, spoke in support of the
proposed ordinance , as presented.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
7
Elizabeth Self, 1319 Manning Road, representing self, spoke in support of the proposed ordinance , as
presented .
Hearing no additional speakers, the public hearing was closed.
Council Member Rector, on a motion seconded by Vice Mayor Ward, moved to approve the ordinance,
with conditions, as presented.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Bennett asked about the number of traffic accidents in
the area. Transportation Planning Manager Souders said there were nine accidents over the past five
years, and seven of them have been single vehicle accidents .
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Bennett inquired about the legality of the proposed
proffers. City Attorney Hutchings advised he could provide legal advi c e in a closed session.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Johnson opined about the cost for the specified road
widening. Planning and Community Development Director Wyne said the developers estimated th e
amount.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Wright sought information about the future of the
development if the road cannot be widened. Mr. Grady advised the City will be paid by the security
bond that is put up and payable in the event the improvements are not made by the developer .
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Wright reiterated her question about the future of the
development if the road cannot be widened. Mr. Grady said if they cannot fulfill the proffers, the project
will not proceed.
Council Member Wright asked whether the scenario is feasible. City Attorney Hutchings said if City
Council is not ready to approve, then they should table until such time they are ready to take action. He
further explained, there is no provision that allows City Council to revisit a rezoning that has been
approved if the conditions are not satisfied.
Mayor Duman asked whether they could enter into closed session for legal advice. City Attorney
Hutchings advised it is permissible , and a motion would be needed.
City Attorney Hutchings presented a Closed Motion for City Council ’s consideration:
1. Pursuant to Virgi nia Code Section 2.2-3711(A)(8), c onsultation with legal counsel employed or
retained by a public body regarding specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice
by such counsel , specifically the proffers related to RZN2024-013 .
Council Member Bennett, on a motion seconded by Council Member Wright , moved that City Council
convene in a closed meeting for the above referenced purpose, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, John son, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
C ity Council convened in Closed Meeting at 8:49 p.m. The Closed Meeting concluded at 9:04 p.m.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
8
City Clerk Dawley presented a resolution certifying the Second Closed Meeting of January 21, 2026,
pursuant to Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended.
Council Member Williams, on a motion seconded by Council Member Butler Barlow, moved to approve
the resolution, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor War d, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
A RESOLUTION OF CERTIFICATION OF THE SECOND CLOSED MEETING OF
JANUARY 21, 2026, PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.2-3712 OF THE CODE OF VIRGINIA (1950),
AS AMENDED
Referring to the presentation, Mayor Duman asked if the widening of Manning Road would be up to
Virginia Department of Transportation Standards. Transportation Planning Manager Souders said the
road would be safer than it is currently.
Referring to the presentation, Mayor Duman questioned whether drainage concerns would be addressed.
Mr. Baraki said the developer would present a stormwater plan, and staff would have approval authority.
Council Member Rector, on a motion seconded by Vice Mayor Ward, moved to approve the ordinance,
with conditions, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Rector, Williams and Wright 6
NAYS: Council Members Butler Barlow and Johnson 2
AN ORDIN ANCE TO REZONE AND AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY
OF SUFFOLK TO CHANGE THE ZONING FROM A, AGRICULTURAL ZONING
DISTRICT, TO RLM, RESIDENTIAL LOW-MEDIUM DENSITY (CONDITIONAL) ZONING
DISTRICT FOR PROPERTIES LOCATED AT 494 MANNING ROAD, ZONING MAP 33,
PARCELS 75 AND 75A, ACCOUNT NUMBERS 151078000 AND 151069000; RZN2024-013
(CONDITIONAL)
O RDINANCE - An ordinance to rezone and amend the official zoning map of the City of Suffolk to
change the zoning from RL, Residential Low Density Zoning District, to RLM, Residential Low
Medium Density (Conditional) Zoning District for property located off Sweetwood Drive, Zoning Map
25, Parcel 74, Account Number 254000460; RZN2024-003 (Conditional) (T his item was deferred from
the December 17, 2025, City Council Meeting .)
Utilizing a PowerPoint presentation, Planning and Community Development Director Wyne
summarized information printed in the official agenda.
Council Member Rector moved to approve the ordinance, with conditions, as presented. The motion
failed for lack of a second.
Referring to the presentation, Council Member Johnson inquired about the park. Grady Palmer said the
homeowners ’ association will own the park with deed restrictions.
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
9
Council Member Rector, on a motion seconded by Council Member Johnson, moved to approve the
ordinance, with conditions, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
AN ORDINANCE TO REZON E AND AMEND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY
OF SUFFOLK TO CHANGE THE ZONING FROM RL, RESIDENTIAL LOW DENSITY
ZONING DISTRICT, TO RLM, RESIDENTIAL LOW MEDIUM DENSITY (CONDITIONAL)
ZONING DISTRICT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED OFF SWEETWOOD DRIVE, ZONING
MAP 25, PARCEL 74, ACCOUNT NUMBER 254000460; RZN2024-003 (CONDITIONAL)
RESOLUTIONS
There were no items under this portion of the agenda.
STAFF REPORT
There were no items under this portion of the agenda.
M OTION S - A motion to schedule a City Council Work S ession, for Wednesday, Februar y 4 , 202 6 , at
4:00 p.m., unless canceled by the Mayor and the Interim City Manager
Council Member Williams , on a motion seconded by Vice Mayor Ward , moved to schedule a City
Council Work Session, for Wednesday, Febr uary 4 , 202 6 , at 4:00 p.m., unless canceled by the Mayor
and the Interim City Manager , by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
NON-AGEND A SPEAKERS
Dwight James, 211 Linden Avenue, representing self, opined about development in the City.
Kelly Hengler, 9345 Eclipse Drive, representing self, opined about First Amendment rights in relations
to changes in City Council ’s Rules of Order and Procedure.
Jason Fawcett, 4235 Sleepy Hold Road, representing self, opined about development, the City ’s
compensation plan, and the status of the City Manager search.
N EW BUSINESS
New Business - An ordinance to amend Article II of Chapter 2 of the Code of the City of Suffolk to
amend the Council of the City of Suffolk ’s Rules of Procedure
City Attorney Hutchings summarized the current item and following item on the agenda .
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
10
Referring to the presentation, Mayor Duman asked whether the y should vote on the current and
following item at the same time. City Attorney Hutchings advised that separate vote s for the items are
needed.
Mayor Duman opined about amending the registration time for non-agenda speakers and realized the
amendment would be germane for the following resolution.
Council Member Rector , on a motion seconded by Council Member Johnson , moved to approve the
ordinance , as presented , by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND ARTICLE II OF CHAPTER 2 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
OF SUFFOLK TO AMEND THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SUFFOLK ’S RULES OF
PROCEDURE
New Business - A resolution to adopt the Council of th e City of Suffolk ’s Rules of Procedure
Council Member Rector , on a motion seconded by Council Member Wright , moved to amend the
resolution attachment on page 11 to change the registration deadline under c. 11. from 5:00 p .m . to
5:30 p .m . and approve the remainder as presented , by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
A RESOLUTION TO ADOPT THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SUFFOLK ’S RUL ES OF
PROCEDURE , AS AMENDED
City C lerk Dawley presented the following nomination s for appointment : Wetlands Board - Sidney
Hazelwood and the Downtown Advisory Committee (Culinary and Restaurant Representative ) - Vance
McGhee.
Council Member Johnson , on a motion seconded by Council Member Rector , moved to nominate and
appoint the aforementioned individuals to the respective bodies, as presented, by the following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnso n, Rector, Williams and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
ANNOUNCEMENTS AND COMMENTS
Utilizing a PowerPoint presentation, Communications Assistant Director William Franklin provided a
report on the following: Cynthia Cale named Refuse Supervisor; Watson Okai named Assistant Director
of Information Technology; grand opening for Golden Luxe Arena; Playdate for Providers event;
City Council Regular Meeting January 21 , 202 6
11
Spectrum ’s Rural Broad b and Initiative; opening of the Western Tidewater Shelter; Route 58/Holland
Road speed limit update; nam ing contest for new Suffolk Transit routes; Parks & Recreation ’s Master
Plan community input opportunities; Suffolk Public Libraries ’ Black History Month activities;
availability of the Public Safety Portal; and update of incoming hazardous weather preparations.
Council Member Bennett reported maintenance issues in Cypress B orough.
Council Member Rector opined about the City Manager search.
Council Member Rector opined about the opening of the Western Tidewater Homeless Shelter.
Council Member Wi lliams said he attended the Spectrum Day of Service at Suffolk Christian
Fellowship .
Vice Mayor Ward reported he attended M artin L uther K ing, Jr. Day Citywide event at Oak Grove
Baptist Church and Cardinal Center for senior citizens event.
Mayor Duman opined about the Western Tidewater Homeless Shelter and Route 58 project.
Mayor Duman said he attended the Eastern Adult Day Care ribbon cutting, M artin L uther K ing, Jr. Day
Citywide event at Oak Grove Baptist Church and Spectrum Day of Service at Suffolk C hristian
Fellowship.
Council Member Wright , on a motion seconded by Council Member W illiams , moved to adjourn, by the
following vote:
AYES: Mayor Duman, Vice Mayor Ward, and Council Members Bennett,
Butler Barlow, Johnson, Rector, Williams, and Wright 8
NAYS: None 0
There being no further business to come before City Council, the regular meeting adjourned at
10 :11 p.m.
Teste: ____________________________________________
Erika S. Dawley, MMC, City Clerk
Approved: ____ _____________________________________
Michael D. Duman, Mayor
APPROVED: MAY 6 , 2026
Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.