Joint City Council and School Board Presentation - February 3, 2021 - Suffolk Public Schools Facilities Master Plan Draft Options
City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Feb 3, 2021 · Other
Open the original document More from City of Suffolk
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
FACILITIES MASTER PLAN |
DRAFT OPTIONS
JOINT CITY COUNCIL & SCHOOL
BOARD PRESENTATION
FEBRUARY 3RD, 2021
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
1
A G E N D A
1
▪Visioning Meeting Outcomes
▪Facility Condition
▪Demographic Overview
▪Facility Options
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
VISIONING
2
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
3
V I S I O N I N G M E E T I N G O U T C O M E S
3
• Classroom design/renovation
o All-in-One Classrooms: Each classroom needs to be highly reconfigurable to accommodate different
methods of teaching, learning, and collaborating.
o Furnishings need to allow for simple and rapid modification of the classroom: sectionalized, large
group, and active/ collaborative learning.
• Division priorities
o Specialty Center focused on the production side of the Visual and Performing Arts.
o Branding: The central themes of the Division’s brand should be designed into the facility, not added
in afterwards.
o JFK MS, Kilby Shores ES, Elephants Fork ES, Nansemond Parkway ES should be top schools looked at
for major renovation or replacement
o Look at the near-term community needs when determining facility actions: location, population
demands.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
FACILITY CONDITION
4
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
5
K E Y T E R M S & D E F I N I T I O N S
5
Bullet points below define terms on the following pages used to develop and prioritize facility assessments and options
• Deferred Maintenance – unperformed maintenance, repairs and/or replacement of equipment or systems due to a lack of
resources or a perceived low priority and deferral of the activity resulting in a progressive deterioration of the school condition or
performance.
• Replacement Value – The cost to construct the square footage of the existing building in today’s dollars. This is not the cost to
design and create a new campus with modern standards, and does not account for changes in square footage or site.
• FCI (Facility Condition Index, based on Category 1 only) – The ratio of total Category 1 deferred maintenance costs divided
into the Replacement Value of the school
• Category 1 Deferred Maintenance Repairs – High priority (0-3 years) deferred maintenance costs
• Category 2 Projected Deferred Maintenance Repairs – Medium priority (4-6 years) deferred maintenance costs
• Category 3 Projected Deferred Maintenance Repairs – Low priority (7-10 years) deferred maintenance costs
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
6
F A C I L I T Y C O N D I T I O N A S S E S S M E N T S
6
• Building System/Component Ratings
Each building system/component provided rating (i.e.
poor, fair, good, excellent) based on a number of factors.
• Deferred Maintenance Schedules
Factors above (i.e. condition, age, estimated remaining
useful life, maintenance, etc.) determined priority for
recommended replacement date and cost of
systems/components in the development of the Deferred
Maintenance schedules for each school.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
7
F A C I L I T Y C O N D I T I O N A S S E S S M E N T S
7
• Building FCI Rating Calculation
The building FCI formula is summarized as the ratio of the Total Deferred Maintenance Costs (High Priority
Only) divided into the Current Replacement Cost for the school.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
8
F A C I L I T Y C O N D I T I O N A S S E S S M E N T S
8
• Schools with most needs (all “Poor” and over 25% FCI’s)
o Forest Glen MS (38.35%)
o John Yeates MS (38.02%)
o John F Kennedy MS (34.09%)
o Elephants Fork ES (31.71%)
o Kilby Shores ES (26.53%)
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
9
F A C I L I T Y C O N D I T I O N A S S E S S M E N T S
9
• Schools with most needs (all “Poor” and over 25% FCI’s)
o Forest Glen MS (38.35%)
o John Yeates MS (38.02%)
o John F Kennedy MS (34.09%)
o Elephants Fork ES (31.71%)
o Kilby Shores ES (26.53%)
o Nansemond Parkway ES
Highlighted schools represent schools the division
prioritized for replacement prior to assessments.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
10
D E F E R R E D M A I N T E N A N C E C O S T S
10
Red text indicates schools that are proposed to be rebuilt in Facility Options. Replacement school may save on Deferred
Maintenance Costs, depending on timeline for new construction.
HIGH PRIORITY
(0 - 3 YEARS) FCI RATING (%)
MEDIUM PRIORITY
(4 - 6 YEARS)
LOW PRIORITY
(7 - 10 YEARS) TOTALS
Elementary Schools
Booker T. Washington $3,767,801 15.23% $2,873,098 $2,464,346 $9,105,245
Creekside $2,918,906 11.32% $1,858,347 $3,326,926 $8,104,179
Elephant's Fork $4,957,676 31.71% $2,329,513 $1,009,336 $8,296,525
Hillpoint $573,021 2.22% $3,792,732 $2,328,655 $6,694,408
Kilby Shores $4,147,687 26.53% $2,174,934 $1,135,508 $7,458,129
Mack Benn Jr. $4,661,709 20.36% $2,986,637 $2,004,219 $9,652,565
Nansemond Parkway $4,046,526 25.88% $1,978,274 $2,730,826 $8,755,626
Northern Shores $1,570,797 8.11% $5,903,258 $1,743,698 $9,217,753
Oakland $2,695,650 16.35% $4,659,737 $2,199,245 $9,554,632
Middle Schools
Forest Glen $7,764,331 38.35% $2,647,027 $1,693,455 $12,104,813
John F Kennedy $12,763,098 34.09% $3,889,128 $2,496,497 $19,148,723
John Yeates $10,506,110 38.02% $5,319,383 $2,226,935 $18,052,428
Kings Fork $1,993,137 4.05% $4,931,656 $10,130,076 $17,054,869
High Schools
Kings Fork $5,507,783 5.49% $6,461,373 $10,597,967 $22,567,123
Lakeland $6,664,222 8.22% $9,494,077 $6,208,127 $22,366,426
Nansemond River $8,677,131 10.71% $7,284,136 $5,198,527 $21,159,794
Specialty Schools
Turlington Woods School $1,859,590 20.39% $1,352,809 $833,911 $4,046,310
College & Career Academy @ Pruden $5,460,836 20.15% $3,557,846 $2,629,622 $11,648,304
TOTAL DEFERRED MAINTENANCE
COSTS (BY CATEGORY) $90,536,011 14.72% $73,493,965 $60,957,876 $224,987,852
DEFERRED MAINTENANCE COSTS
SCHOOL NAME
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
DEMOGRAPHICS
11
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
12
H I S TO R I C A L & P RO J E C T E D E N RO L L M E N T
• 10-year enrollment projections
▪ By school, by grade
• Developed using the cohort survival method
▪ 10 years of historical enrollment by grade, by year
▪ Historical resident live birth counts
• Housing
▪ Building permits
• Census data
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
13
M E T H O D O LO G Y
COHORT SURVIVAL METHOD
• Uses historical live birth data
and historical student
enrollment to “age” (or
progress) a known population
(cohort) throughout the school
grades
• Survival ratios analyzed
• Projection ratios developed
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
14
B I RT H S
• Birth data is used to project kindergarten enrollment 5 years later
Year 23432 23433 23434 23435 23436 23437 23438 23487
2003 11 9 670 325 6 34 15 75
2004 15 13 719 336 3 54 24 77
2005 8 6 732 358 9 39 21 70
2006 9 9 687 382 12 52 24 76
2007 10 13 725 344 12 50 18 71
2008 9 7 659 346 7 44 13 72
2009 15 13 725 343 15 33 19 65
2010 10 10 658 346 8 43 15 54
2011 15 13 647 347 14 44 16 57
2012 11 11 654 349 8 28 18 62
2013 9 4 618 371 7 48 19 55
2014 10 5 608 371 13 41 23 64
2015 18 7 673 396 9 44 15 79
2016 14 12 653 356 14 34 19 75
2017 11 9 642 405 8 44 19 56
Source: Virginia Department of Health
RESIDENT LIVE BIRTH COUNTS
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS ZIP CODES
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS ZIP CODES
RESIDENT LIVE BIRTH COUNTS
23432 23433 23434 23435 23437 23438 23487
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
15
P O P U L AT I O N E S T I M AT E S
• Total population in Suffolk City is estimated to
increase by approximately 7% from 2019 to 2024.
• School-aged population (ages 5-18) is estimated to
increase by 873 children, or 4.8% from 2019 to 2024.
Age 2019 2024
Ages 0-2 3,567 3,861
Ages 3-4 2,509 2,668
Ages 5-10 7,915 8,182
Ages 11-13 4,093 4,226
Ages 14-18 6,273 6,746
Ages 5-18 18,281 19,154
Total Population 95,864 102,505
Source: ESRI BIS
SUFFOLK CITY, VA
POPULATION ESTIMATES
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
Ages 0-2 Ages 3-4 Ages 5-10 Ages 11-13 Ages 14-18
SUFFOLK CITY, V A
POPULATION ESTIMATES
2019 2024
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
16
H O U S I N G DATA
Year Single-Family Multi-Family
2000 639 134
2001 1,003 334
2002 994 306
2003 1,108 296
2004 848 287
2005 1,090 0
2006 642 202
2007 474 117
2008 332 4
2009 378 8
2010 295 2
2011 265 13
2012 593 60
2013 592 516
2014 297 51
2015 362 436
2016 395 312
2017 514 48
2018 501 216
2019 500 195
2020* 193 0
*preliminary through May 2020
SUFFOLK CITY, VA
BUILDING PERMITS
Source: SOCDS Building Permits Database
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
SUFFOLK CITY, V A
BUILDING PERMITS
Single-Family Multi-Family
From 2010 to 2019
• Total of 4,314 single-family
permits or 431 per year
• Total of 1,849 multi-family
permits or 185 per year
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
17
H I S TO R I C A L E N RO L L M E N T
Grade 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
PK 513 506 499 501 475 445 493 503 501 513
K 1,148 1,063 1,087 1,064 1,040 1,050 1,050 1,044 933 1,007
1 1,120 1,143 1,097 1,113 1,076 1,083 1,061 1,096 1,061 989
2 1,122 1,117 1,127 1,148 1,117 1,068 1,102 1,061 1,091 1,049
3 1,059 1,124 1,117 1,127 1,151 1,194 1,108 1,107 1,112 1,092
4 1,057 1,067 1,138 1,133 1,131 1,127 1,155 1,127 1,073 1,071
5 1,052 1,048 1,045 1,109 1,090 1,088 1,111 1,127 1,086 1,078
6 1,075 1,061 1,060 1,036 1,154 1,082 1,054 1,123 1,124 1,111
7 1,094 1,082 1,066 1,043 1,006 1,129 1,058 1,019 1,127 1,122
8 1,043 1,066 1,034 1,082 1,018 987 1,095 1,079 1,038 1,121
9 1,291 1,242 1,208 1,228 1,283 1,253 1,182 1,304 1,287 1,208
10 1,158 1,089 1,177 1,139 1,170 1,240 1,123 1,035 1,110 1,148
11 911 967 868 848 835 840 906 919 876 1,006
12 864 845 898 905 819 797 786 815 846 807
K - 12 Total 13,994 13,914 13,922 13,975 13,890 13,938 13,791 13,856 13,764 13,809
Grand Total 14,507 14,420 14,421 14,476 14,365 14,383 14,284 14,359 14,265 14,322
Grade 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
PK 513 506 499 501 475 445 493 503 501 513
K - 5 6,558 6,562 6,611 6,694 6,605 6,610 6,587 6,562 6,356 6,286
6 - 8 3,212 3,209 3,160 3,161 3,178 3,198 3,207 3,221 3,289 3,354
9 - 12 4,224 4,143 4,151 4,120 4,107 4,130 3,997 4,073 4,119 4,169
K - 12 Total 13,994 13,914 13,922 13,975 13,890 13,938 13,791 13,856 13,764 13,809
Grand Total 14,507 14,420 14,421 14,476 14,365 14,383 14,284 14,359 14,265 14,322
Historical Enrollment - District-wide
Source: Virginia Department of Education
Historical Enrollment - District-wide
Source: Virginia Department of Education
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
HISTORICAL ENROLLMENT -
DISTRICT-WIDE
Total enrollment has declined by 185
students from 2010-11 to 2019-20
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
18
P R O J E C T E D E N R O L L M E N T
• Recommended, Low, Moderate, and High enrollment projections
were developed
• Recommended = based on more recent trends in the District
• Low = conservative approach
• Moderate projection = in this case reflects a 3–year weighted
average of survival ratios
• High projection = liberal approach
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
19
H I S TO R I C A L & P RO J E C T E D E N RO L L M E N T
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
HISTORICAL & PROJECTED ENROLLMENT - SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS
Historical Projected - Recommended Projected - Moderate Projected - Low Projected - High
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
20
P RO J E C T E D E N RO L L M E N T
Grade 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 2024-25 2025-26 2026-27 2027-28 2028-29 2029-30
PK 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513
K 1,096 1,041 1,068 1,070 1,070 1,070 1,070 1,070 1,070 1,070
1 1,048 1,142 1,084 1,115 1,115 1,115 1,115 1,115 1,115 1,115
2 984 1,044 1,137 1,080 1,111 1,108 1,108 1,108 1,108 1,108
3 1,085 1,024 1,086 1,183 1,123 1,151 1,151 1,151 1,151 1,151
4 1,060 1,047 992 1,053 1,146 1,086 1,119 1,118 1,118 1,118
5 1,068 1,058 1,049 995 1,062 1,156 1,095 1,126 1,128 1,128
6 1,102 1,094 1,081 1,073 1,018 1,090 1,186 1,123 1,156 1,155
7 1,110 1,101 1,095 1,080 1,072 1,019 1,093 1,188 1,126 1,158
8 1,120 1,106 1,098 1,092 1,076 1,071 1,018 1,090 1,186 1,123
9 1,304 1,301 1,285 1,278 1,269 1,249 1,246 1,183 1,263 1,373
10 1,078 1,170 1,161 1,152 1,143 1,137 1,117 1,114 1,058 1,133
11 1,015 953 1,035 1,027 1,020 1,012 1,007 990 984 935
12 936 943 886 962 954 947 939 935 920 915
K - 12 Total 14,006 14,024 14,057 14,160 14,179 14,211 14,264 14,311 14,383 14,482
Grand Total 14,519 14,537 14,570 14,673 14,692 14,724 14,777 14,824 14,896 14,995
Projected Enrollment - Recommended - District-wide
Grade 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23 2023-24 2024-25 2025-26 2026-27 2027-28 2028-29 2029-30
PK 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513 513
K - 5 6,341 6,356 6,416 6,496 6,627 6,686 6,658 6,688 6,690 6,690
6 - 8 3,332 3,301 3,274 3,245 3,166 3,180 3,297 3,401 3,468 3,436
9 - 12 4,333 4,367 4,367 4,419 4,386 4,345 4,309 4,222 4,225 4,356
K - 12 Total 14,006 14,024 14,057 14,160 14,179 14,211 14,264 14,311 14,383 14,482
Grand Total 14,519 14,537 14,570 14,673 14,692 14,724 14,777 14,824 14,896 14,995
Projected Enrollment - Recommended - District-wide
Source: Cooperative Strategies
Source: Cooperative Strategies
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
PROJECTED ENROLLMENT -
RECOMMENDED - DISTRICT-WIDE
• PK-12 enrollment is projected to
grow 370 students by the 2024-25
school year
• PK-12 enrollment is projected to
grow 673 students by the 2029-30
school year
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
21
P RO J E C T E D E N RO L L M E N T
School 2019-20
Enrollment
Projected 5 Year
Enrollment Growth
Projected 10 Year
Enrollment Growth
Booker T. Washington Elem. 343 13 16
Creekside Elem. 748 -28 -25
Elephant’s Fork Elem. 599 -23 -13
Florence Bowser Elem. 821 284 298
Hillpoint Elementary 786 32 28
Kilby Shores Elementary 511 6 11
Mack Benn, Jr. Elem. 606 -33 -23
Nansemond Parkway Elem. 482 20 23
Northern Shores Elem. 819 -6 2
Oakland Elem. 454 15 19
Pioneer Elem. 630 61 68
ES Total 6,799 341 404
Col. Fred Cherry Middle 794 -74 -12
Forest Glen Middle 454 -7 23
John F. Kennedy Middle 551 -54 -53
John Yeates Middle 552 -18 117
King’s Fork Middle 1,003 -35 7
MS Total 3,354 -188 82
King’s Fork High 1,518 79 36
Lakeland High 1,049 -63 -82
Nansemond River High 1,602 201 233
HS Total 4,169 217 187
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
22
P RO J E C T E D E N RO L L M E N T
North Suffolk Schools 2019-20
Enrollment
Projected 5 Year
Enrollment Growth
Projected 10 Year
Enrollment Growth
Creekside Elem. 748 -28 -25
Florence Bowser Elem. 821 284 298
Nansemond Parkway Elem. 482 20 23
Northern Shores Elem. 819 -6 2
Col. Fred Cherry Middle 794 -74 -12
John Yeates Middle 552 -18 117
Nansemond River High 1,602 201 233
Total 5,818 379 636
Central Suffolk Schools 2019-20
Enrollment
Projected 5 Year
Enrollment Growth
Projected 10 Year
Enrollment Growth
Hillpoint Elementary 786 32 28
Elephant’s Fork Elem. 599 -23 -13
Mack Benn, Jr. Elem. 606 -33 -23
Oakland Elem. 454 15 19
King’s Fork Middle 1,003 -35 7
King’s Fork High 1,518 79 36
Total 4,966 35 54
South Suffolk Schools 2019-20
Enrollment
Projected 5 Year
Enrollment Growth
Projected 10 Year
Enrollment Growth
Booker T. Washington Elem. 343 13 16
Kilby Shores Elementary 511 6 11
Pioneer Elem. 630 61 68
Forest Glen Middle 454 -7 23
John F. Kennedy Middle 551 -54 -53
Lakeland High 1,049 -63 -82
Total 3,538 -44 -17
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
FACILITY OPTIONS
23
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
24
K E Y T E R M S & D E F I N I T I O N S
24
Bullet points below define terms on the following pages used to develop and prioritize facility options
• Program Capacity – Number of students a school can reasonably accommodate based on its current program, as defined by Suffolk Public
Schools
• 2019 Actual Enrollment – Actual enrollment for each school in the 2019-20 school year
• 2019 Utilization – 2019-20 enrollment divided by capacity, or what % of a school facility is full. The target range for utilization is 80%-100%, with
schools below 80% considered under-utilized and schools above 100% considered over-utilized
• 2024 Projected Enrollment – The number of students projected to attend each school in the 2024-25 school year
• 2024 Projected Utilization – 2024-25 projected enrollment divided by capacity
• 2029 Projected Enrollment – The number of students projected to attend each school in the 2029-30 school year
• 2029 Projected Utilization – 2029-30 projected enrollment divided by capacity
• Deferred Maintenance – unperformed maintenance, repairs and/or replacement of equipment or systems due to a lack of resources or a
perceived low priority and deferral of the activity resulting in a progressive deterioration of the school condition or performance.
• Replacement Value – The cost to construct the square footage of the existing building in today’s dollars. This is not the cost to design and
create a new campus with modern standards, and does not account for changes in square footage or site
• Category 1 Deferred Maintenance Repairs – High priority (0-3 years) deferred maintenance costs
• Category 2 Projected Deferred Maintenance Repairs – Medium priority (4-6 years) deferred maintenance costs
• Category 3 Projected Deferred Maintenance Repairs – Low priority (7-10 years) deferred maintenance costs
• FCI (Facility Condition Index, based on Category 1 only) – The ratio of total Category 1 deferred maintenance costs divided into the
Replacement Value of the school
• Cumulative Projected Index (based on Category 1-3 Total) – The ratio of total Category 1-3 deferred maintenance costs divided into the
Replacement Value of the school
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
25
K E Y C O N S T R U C T I O N C O S T S F A C T O R S
25
Two Key Factors Driving School Construction Costs
• $ Per Square Foot
• Historical Data from Actual Schools Constructed in Virginia
• Weighting Factor Used for Local and Regional School Costs
• Square Foot Per Student
• Determines School Size
• Desire to Unify UDO and CIP Guidelines
• Scale Below to Address Variations in School Size
Square Foot Per Student by School Type and Size/Capacity
School Type Range of School Sizes/Numbers of Students
Up to 750 750 to 1050 1,050 to 1,350 1,350 to 1,650 1,650 and abv.
Elementary School 145 125 Note 1 Note 1 Note 1
Middle School 175 160 145 Note 1 Note 1
High School Note 1 Note 1 Note 1 175 150
Note 1: This school size not recommended by Suffolk Public Schools.
Note 2: Variations in school type such as K-8 schools or alternative schools will be case by case based on grade levels included.
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
26
H I G H S C H O O L S
Enrollment & Facility Data Summary
All three comprehensive high schools have been built within the last 30 years
and are in good condition. Overall high schools are utilized within the target
range of 80% - 100%. Nansemond River HS was 107% utilized in 2019-20 and
projected to reach 121% in the 2024-25 school year. Lakeland HS was 70%
utilized in 2019-20 and is projected to decline to 66% in the 2024-25 school year.
Key factors | utilization imbalance and moderate projected growth
26
Schools
") Elementary
#* Middle
^_ High
High School Zones
KINGS FORK HS
LAKELAND HS
NANSEMOND RIVER HS
Facility Construction
Year/Age
Square
Footage Acreage Program
Capacity
Mobile
Units/Capacity
Category 1
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 2
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 3
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Replacement
Value
FCI (based on
Category 1
only)
Cumulative Projected
Index (based on
Category 1-3 Total)
2019
Actual
Enrollment
2019
Utilization
2024
Projected
Enrollment
2024
Projected
Utilization
2029
Projected
Enrollment
2029
Projected
Utilization
King’s Fork High 2004/16 yrs. 275,300 80 1634 0 $ 5,507,783 $ 6,461,373 $ 10,597,967 $ 100,327,579 5.5% 22.5% 1,518 92.9% 1,597 97.7% 1,554 95.1%
Lakeland
High 1991/29 yrs. 222,400 69.5 1,498 0 $ 6,664,222 $ 9,494,077 $ 6,208,127 $ 81,049,232 8.2% 27.6% 1,049 70.0% 986 65.8% 967 64.6%
Nansemond
River High 1991/29 yrs. 222,400 50 1496 0 $ 8,677,131 $ 7,284,136 $ 5,198,527 $ 81,049,232 10.7% 26.1% 1,602 107.1% 1,803 120.5% 1,835 122.7%
College Career
Academy 1973/47 yrs. 74,354 19.4 $ 5,460,836 $ 3,557,846 $ 2,629,622 $ 27,096,828 20.2% 43.0%
High School
Totals 794,454 219 4,628 $ 26,309,972 $ 26,797,432 $ 24,634,243 $ 289,522,871 4,169 90.1% 4,386 94.8% 4,356 94.1%
Building Information Building Condition Building Enrollment & Utilization
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
2727
H I G H S C H O O L S – D R A F T O P T I O N S
Option # Options Cost Description Benefits Challenges
A Rezone between high schools to
balance utilization.
- High schools currently utilized at
90%, but Nansemond River HS is
107% and Lakeland is 70%.
Rezoning would bring all high
schools closer to the division
average.
• No capital
improvement for
new construction
• Rezoning
B 400 seat addition (incl. new
Auxiliary Gym and Cafeteria
Expansion) to Nansemond River
HS to reduce over-utilization.
$14,970,000 Utilization at Nansemond River HS
is projected to reach 120% based
on 2024-25 projected enrollment.
Building a 400-seat addition will
reduce facility utilization to 95%.
• No rezoning • Cost
• Lakeland HS
remains under-
utilized without
rezoning
C New 1,500 seat high school on
new site
$118,885,625 Building a new HS and rezoning
all existing high school
boundaries would better balance
all high schools across the division
• Cost
• Extensive rezoning
Cost estimates are Total Project Costs, including Soft Costs. These estimates are shown
in 2020 dollars and are not escalated.
• Option B - 400 seat addition reduces 2024 projected utilization from 120% to
95% at Nansemond River HS, and total 2024 projected high school utilization
from 95% to 87%
• Option C – New 1,500 seat high school reduces 2024 projected high school
utilization from 95% to 72%
Cost with rezoning only: $0
Cost with no rezoning: $14,970,000
Cost with new HS and rezoning: $118,885,625
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
28
M I D D L E S C H O O L S
Forest Glen, John F. Kennedy, and John Yeates middle schools are all 55 years old
with poor FCI scores. Overall middle schools are utilized within the target range
of 80% - 100%, but Forest Glen is at 110% utilization and John Yeates is 70%
utilized. Enrollment is projected to decline moderately by 2024-25, before
slightly surpassing current levels by 2029-30.
28
Key factors | utilization imbalance and poor condition schools
Schools
") Elementary
#* Middle
^_ High
High School Zones
Middle School Zones
COL FRED CHERRY MS
FOREST GLEN MS
JFK MS
JOHN YEATES MS
KINGS FORK MS
Enrollment & Facility Data Summary
Facility Construction
Year/Age
Square
Footage Acreage Program
Capacity
Mobile
Units/Capacity
Category 1
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 2
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 3
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Replacement
Value
FCI (based on
Category 1
only)
Cumulative Projected
Index (based on
Category 1-3 Total)
2019
Actual
Enrollment
2019
Utilization
2024
Projected
Enrollment
2024
Projected
Utilization
2029
Projected
Enrollment
2029
Projected
Utilization
Col. Fred Cherry
Middle 2018 / 2 yrs. 125,000 26 800 0 794 99.3% 720 90.0% 782 97.8%
Forest Glen
Middle 1965/55 yrs. 77,000 61.7 410 5/110 $ 7,764,331 $ 2,647,027 $ 1,693,455 $ 20,244,070 38.4% 59.8% 454 110.7% 447 109.0% 477 116.3%
John F. Kennedy
Middle 1965/55 yrs. 142,400 39.2 650 0 $ 12,763,098 $ 3,889,128 $ 2,496,497 $ 37,438,384 34.1% 51.1% 551 84.8% 497 76.5% 498 76.6%
John Yeates
Middle 1965/55 yrs. 105,100 28.5 785 18/396 $ 10,506,110 $ 5,319,383 $ 2,226,935 $ 27,631,841 38.0% 65.3% 552 70.3% 534 68.0% 669 85.2%
King’s Fork
Middle 2001/19 yrs. 187,000 35.4 1150 0 $ 1,993,137 $ 4,931,656 $ 10,130,076 $ 49,164,170 4.1% 34.7% 1,003 87.2% 968 84.2% 1,010 87.8%
Middle School
Totals 636,500 190.8 3,795 $ 34,424,393 $ 16,787,194 $ 16,546,963 $ 134,478,465 3,354 88.4% 3,166 83.4% 3,436 90.5%
Building Information Building Condition Building Enrollment & Utilization
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
2929
M I D D L E S C H O O L S – D R A F T O P T I O N S
Option # Options Cost Description Benefits Challenges
A.1
A.2
A.3
Rebuild Forest Glen MS on
current site at 600 capacity
Rebuild John F. Kennedy MS on
current site at 600 capacity
Rebuild John Yeates MS on
current site at 800 capacity
$34,135,500
incl. demo of FGMS
$35,214,600
incl. demo of JFKMS
$41,798,150
incl. demo of JYMS
Current facilities are 55 years old and have
poor FCI’s. New facilities will address
condition needs and provide for
modernized learning opportunities.
• New
facilities
• Cost
• No reduction in
operating costs
B.1
B.2
Consolidate Forest Glen MS and
John F. Kennedy MS into a new
1,200 seat MS (on Forest Glen
site or a new site)
Rebuild John Yeates MS on
current site at 800 capacity
$55,732,500
incl. demo of FGMS
$41,798,150
incl. demo of JYMS
Both schools are 55 years old with poor
FCI’s. Forest Glen is significantly
undersized with a 410 capacity. Students
from both schools could be served in a
new 1,200 seat middle school.
Current facility is 55 years old and has a
poor FCI. New facility will address
condition needs and provide for
modernized learning opportunities.
• New
facilities
• Reduced
operating
costs
• Cost
• Transportation
• Potential land
acquisition
Cost estimates are Total Project Costs, including Soft Costs. These estimates are shown
in 2020 dollars and are not escalated.
• Option A.1, A.2, A.3 adds a combined 155 middle school seats and reduces 2024 projected
middle school utilization from 83% to 80%
• Option B.1, B.2 adds a combined 155 middle school seats and reduces 2024 projected
middle school utilization from 83% to 80%
Total cost with no rezoning (A.1, A.2, A.3): $111,148,250
Total cost with rezoning (B.1, B.2): $97,530,650
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
30
E L E M E N T A R Y S C H O O L S
30
Key factors | utilization imbalance and poor condition schools
Schools
") Elementary
#* Middle
^_ High
Middle School Zones
Elementary Zones
BOOKER T WASHINGTON
CREEKSIDE
DRIVER/FLORENCE BOWSER
ELEPHANTS FORK
HILLPOINT
KILBY SHORES
MACK BENN
NANSEMOND PARKWAY
NORTHERN SHORES
OAKLAND
PIONEER
Overall elementary schools are currently utilized within the target range of 80% -
100% and projected to remain within this range over the next 10 years. There are
currently 4 schools above 100% utilization, and 6 schools projected to be above
100% by 2024-25. Elephant’s Fork, Kilby Shores, and Nansemond Parkway are all
41 years old, with poor FCI’s.
Enrollment & Facility Data Summary
Facility Construction
Year/Age
Square
Footage Acreage Program
Capacity
Mobile
Units/Capacity
Category 1
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 2
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Category 3
Projected
Deferred
Maintenance
Repairs
Replacement
Value
FCI (based on
Category 1
only)
Cumulative Projected
Index (based on
Category 1-3 Total)
2019 Actual
Enrollment
2019
Utilization
2024
Projected
Enrollment
2024
Projected
Utilization
2029
Projected
Enrollment
2029
Projected
Utilization
Booker T.
Washington Elem. 1999/21 yrs. 93,000 15.8 588 0 $ 3,767,801 $ 2,873,098 $ 2,464,346 $ 24,731,490 15.2% 36.8% 343 58.3% 356 60.5% 359 61.1%
Creekside Elem. 2006/14 yrs. 97,000 18.5 865 7/154 $ 2,918,906 $ 1,858,347 $ 3,326,926 $ 25,795,210 11.3% 31.4% 748 86.5% 720 83.2% 723 83.6%
Elephant’s Fork
Elem. 1979/41 yrs. 58,800 14.3 520 13/286 $ 4,957,676 $ 2,329,513 $ 1,009,336 $ 15,636,684 31.7% 53.1% 599 115.2% 576 110.8% 586 112.7%
Florence Bowser
Elem. 2018 / 2 yrs. 116,000 21 1000 0 821 82.1% 1,105 110.5% 1,119 111.9%
Hillpoint Elem. 2008/12 yrs. 97,000 15.9 869 0 $ 573,021 $ 3,792,732 $ 2,328,655 $ 25,795,210 2.2% 26.0% 786 90.4% 818 94.1% 814 93.7%
Kilby Shores Elem. 1979/41 yrs. 58,800 15.3 497 8/176 $ 4,147,687 $ 2,933,731 $ 1,135,508 $ 15,636,684 26.5% 52.5% 511 102.8% 517 104.0% 522 105.0%
Mack Benn, Jr. Elem. 1998/22 yrs. 86,100 26.6 699 3/66 $ 4,661,709 $ 2,986,637 $ 2,004,219 $ 22,896,573 20.4% 42.2% 606 86.7% 573 82.0% 583 83.4%
Nansemond
Parkway Elem. 1979/41 yrs. 58,800 14.6 479 4/88 $ 4,046,526 $ 1,978,274 $ 2,730,826 $ 15,636,684 25.9% 56.0% 482 100.6% 502 104.8% 505 105.4%
Northern Shores
Elem. 1996/24yrs. 72,800 15.1 780 13/286 $ 1,570,797 $ 5,903,258 $ 1,743,698 $ 19,359,704 8.1% 47.6% 819 105.0% 813 104.2% 821 105.3%
Oakland Elem. 1997/23yrs. 62,000 8.5 520 1/22 $ 2,695,650 $ 4,659,737 $ 2,199,245 $ 16,487,660 16.3% 58.0% 454 87.3% 469 90.2% 473 91.0%
Pioneer Elem. 2014/6 yrs. 85,000 47 668 0 630 94.3% 691 103.4% 698 104.5%
Elementary School
Totals 885,300 212.6 7,485 $ 29,339,773 $ 29,315,327 $ 18,942,759 $ 181,975,899 6,799 90.8% 7,140 95.4% 7,203 96.2%
Building Condition Building Enrollment & UtilizationBuilding Information
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
3131
E L E M E N T A R Y S C H O O L S – D R A F T O P T I O N S ( W / R E Z O N I N G )
Option # Options Cost Description Benefits Challenges
A.1 Rebuild Kilby Shores at 1,000 capacity.
Rezone portions of Pioneer and
majority of Elephant’s Fork to new
Kilby Shores. Repurpose Elephant’s
Fork
$38,010,825
incl. demo of
KSES
Elephant’s Fork and Kilby Shores are
both 41 years old with poor FCI’s. A
rebuilt Kilby Shores at 1,000 capacity
could accommodate the majority of
Elephant’s Fork students and some
projected growth at Pioneer ES. Some
EFES students would be rezoned to
Hillpoint and Oakland.
• New facility
• Reduced
operating costs
• Cost
• Transportation
A.2 Rebuild Nansemond Parkway at 800
capacity. Rezone portion of Florence
Bowser ES to new Nansemond Parkway
ES to account for future growth
$30,602,700
incl. demo of
NPES
Current facility is 41 years old and has
a poor FCI. A new facility will address
condition needs and provide for
modernized learning opportunities.
Will alleviate projected over-utilization
at Florence Bowser.
• New facility • Cost
A.3 200 seat addition to Northern Shores
ES (incl. Cafeteria Expansion)
$4,871,875 • Reduces facility
over-utilization
A.4 400 seat addition to Northern Shores
ES (incl. Cafeteria Expansion)
$9,371,875 • Reduces facility
over-utilization
Cost estimates are Total Project Costs, including Soft Costs. These estimates are shown
in 2020 dollars and are not escalated.
• Option A.1, A.2, A.3 adds a combined 504 elementary school seats and reduces 2024
projected elementary school utilization from 95% to 89%
• Option A.1, A.2, A.4 adds a combined 704 elementary school seats and reduces 2024
projected elementary school utilization from 95% to 87%
Total cost with rezoning (A.1, A.2, A.3): $73,485,400
Total cost with rezoning (A.1, A.2, A.4): $77,985,400
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
3232
E L E M E N T A R Y S C H O O L S – D R A F T O P T I O N S ( N O R E Z O N I N G )
Option # Options Cost Description Benefits Challenges
B.1 Rebuild Elephant’s Fork at 750
capacity. Rebuild Kilby Shores
and Nansemond Pkwy at 600
capacity each
$86,696,494
incl. demo of
EFES, KSES and
NPES
All three schools are 41 years old
with poor FCI’s. New facilities
would address condition needs
and provide for modernized
learning opportunities.
• New facilities
• No rezoning
• Cost
• No operational cost
savings
B.2 200 seat addition to Florence
Bowser and Northern Shores
(incl. cafeteria expansion), 100
seat addition to Pioneer
$10,793,750 Additions to elementary schools
will address projected over-
utilization
• Addresses projected
over-utilization
• Cost
B.3 200 seat addition to Florence
Bowser, 400 seat addition to
Northern Shores (incl.
cafeteria expansion), 100 seat
addition to Pioneer
$15,293,750 Additions to elementary schools
will address projected over-
utilization
• Addresses projected
over-utilization
• Cost
Cost estimates are Total Project Costs, including Soft Costs. These estimates are shown
in 2020 dollars and are not escalated.
• Option B.1, B.2 adds a combined 804 elementary school seats and reduces
2024 projected elementary school utilization from 95% to 86%
• Option B.1, B.3 adds a combined 1,004 elementary school seats and reduces
2024 projected elementary school utilization from 95% to 84%
Total cost with no rezoning (B.1, B.2): $97,490,244
Total cost with no rezoning (B.1, B.3): $101,990,244
SUFFOLK PUBLIC SCHOOLS/CITY OF SUFFOLK| DRAFT FACILITY OPTIONS | FEBRUARY 2021
CONCLUSIONS, NEXT STEPS &
CLOSING COMMENTS
33
Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.