RecordWell Data

Minutes (June)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Jun 16, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of June 16, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT: Austin Englund Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair Shanda Horner, Chair Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Peter Alexander Tracey Langseth OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Linda Napier -King to install railings on the front porch at 307 F Street. (HPC2505-0011) Ms. Linda Napier-King was present to represent the application. She previously received approval for different wooden spindles, but the y were too deteriorated to use. She is now requesting approval for a different type of wooden spindle that she already has in her possession. Commissioner Lifsey said they look appropriately sized. He asked if they were long enough for use with the railing system. Ms. Napier-King replied they were longer than they looked in the image and would fit nicely. Commissioner Lifsey advised her to consult the building official as to spacing requirements. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 b) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Christopher Jordan to replace and expand a front porch at 144 Stonewall Street. (HPC2505-0003) 2 Mr. Reggie Jordan was present to represent the application on behalf of Christopher Jordan . The front porch deck will be replaced and expanded. The material will be wood. Chair Horner noted that the building was noncontri buting to the Daniel’s Hill historic district and asked how large the proposed expansion was. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler replied that the original porch was four feet by six feet and the proposed expansion would be eight feet by six feet. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the porch would have a roof. Mr. Jordan replied that a roof would not be added to the porch. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote: AYES: Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Chair Horner requested that items C and D on the agenda be discussed at the same t ime. There were no objections from the Commission. c) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Mitchel Gilman of Home Development Institute, LLC to replace a metal roof at 707 & 709 14th Street. (HPC2505-0008) & d) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Mitchel Gilman of Home Development Institute, LLC to replace a metal roof at 1301 Harrison Street. (HPC2505-0009) Mr. Mitchel Gilman, property owner, and Mr. Alec Gilman, manager of Perimeter Roofing, were present to represent the application. The roof at 707 & 709 14th Street is in disrepair. Patches and seals have been applied to it since 2020. The roof has sixteen (16) inch seams and the replacement roof will have the same dimensions but will be replaced in a copper color. The roof at 1301 Harrison Street is a lso in disrepair and has sixteen (16) inch seams. It will be replaced to match the seam width and the color. Ultimately, both roofs are at end of life. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the problem was just the paint peeling off. Mr. Gilman replied that was an issue, but there are also places where the metal had rusted through. Commissioner Lifsey asked if a coating like Acrymax had been used to try to preserve it. Mr. Gilman said th at they had tried a coating on the roof at 1301 Harrison Street and were s till having problems. Several patches have been applied on the roof but at this point it is beyond salvageable. Commissioner Englund asked if they had tried replacing panels. Mr. Gilman replied th at the previous owner had, but there are still problems where the modern-roofing and older roofing meet. Commissioner Englund asked what exactly he meant by that. 3 Mr. Gilman elaborated that someone had tried to hand crimp replacement panels to match what was there. Bonding the different roofing systems d id not do well. The roofs were not well maintained before purchase. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the replacement roofs would match the existing panel widths. Mr. Gilman responded that the replacement roofs would be sixteen (16) inch standing seam with hidden fasteners. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the seams would-be low-profile. Mr. Gilman replied yes, they will be three quarter (3/4) inch. Commissioner Englund said he was uncomfortable not seeing any damage. Mr. Gilman replied the damage is there. There have been significant leaks and interior damage. Commissioner Englund continued that he was not a fan of Acrymax coating as it is a film forming finish . Ultimately film forming paints have been a let down for modern architecture. A linseed oil paint would be a good option, though that doesn’t help with the holes. He asked if the flat seam roofing is able to be uncrimped and only portions replaced or repaired where needed. Commissioner Lifsey replied that it is very difficult to do so. Mr. Gilman said that the more that you bend the seam back and forth, the more likely it is to shear/break from stress. What Commissioner Englund was suggesting isn’t impossible, but it is impractical. Commissioner Englund explained that from what he saw and gathered from t he application, it seemed like the damage was just from peeling paint. Replacing the roofs seemed a bit extreme since there was no visible damage. Mr. Gilman replied th at they had coated the roof at 1301 Harrison Street four (4) years ago and it was already starting to fail and leak. The cost to coat it was roughly $5,500 at the time. Commissioner Englund asked if a new hand crimped roof could be put back on 1301 Harrison Street . There is a visual difference between the panel types, especially with ridge caps. Mr. Gilman stated that they had installed the exact same type of roofing system on 1317 & 1319 Harrison Street and also on a Washington Street property. Commissioner Englund stated that replacing a hand crimped roof with a snap lock standing seam roof should not be the preference. Mr. Gilman stated that visually the main difference is that anywhere the roof has a ridge or a hip there is a piece of metal that caps over it. Aesthetically otherwise, they are almost identical. Commissioner Lifsey commented that there are metal ridges that can be used instead of caps. Mr. Gilman responded yes, there are, but ridges are more prone to leaking. The standing seam that runs along the ridge is a leak point. Perimeter Roofing has installed many of the propo sed type of metal roofing systems. Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement that this type of roofing has been previously approved. 4 Other Commissioners shared agreement. Commissioner Englund stated that, for him, there is still an ability to do an authenti c replacement. The proposed roofing system is nice, but it would not match the integrity of the original historic style. Mr. Gilman replied that there are minimal differences between hand turned and snap lock seams. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the roof replacements for 707 & 709 14th Street and 1301 Harrison Street as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 4 NOES: Englund 1 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 e) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Jolynn Johnson Smith of Whirlwind Johnson, LLC to replace windows at 1422 Pierce Street. (HPC2506-0001) Mr. Matt No vak, of LG Flint General Contractors , and Mr. Fred E senwein, Architect of record with Hill Studio, were present to represent the application. LG Flint has been working on this house for a few years. Previous approval was granted in 2023 for work to wood wi ndows, but that work was not able to be completed in t he two-year time limit. The residence has not been lived in for the past 20 -30 years. The goal is to rehabilitate the house and most likely use it in a similar fashion to the Anne Spencer House. T he wood windows of the home have deteri orated and many are at end of life. The current request is to replace all of the wood windows with aluminum clad wood windows . There is an etched window that will be removed and replaced with a one -over-one window. The etch ed window will be put in storage. If damaged, due to vandalism, which has previously been an issue, it would be difficult to find a replacement to match. The Whirlwind Johnson F oundation may choose to display it elsewhere. The replacement aluminum clad wood windows are proposed to match the existing wood windows in terms of dimensions, number of lites, muntins, and profiles. Commissioner Lifsey asked if Dr. Johnson’s home will be made into a museum. Mr. Esenwein responded that the use has not been decided yet. There have been some feasibility studies done. The intention, so far, is not to use the house as a residence. The Foundation has considered using it as a type of facility in relation to tennis. Commissioner Lifsey asked if it would be a historical artifact of the period when Dr. Johnson lived there. Mr. Esenwein said it would still be a historic artifact, at least the exterior. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the wood windows should be restored. R emoving and replacing them would be the same as pulling out chunks of history. The property has high historical value and removal of the windows does not seem to be the right approach. T he home would not be an artifact as a whole without them. He asked if the windows could be restored. Mr. Novak replied the windows could be restored, but it would significantly increase the cost. Mr. Esenwein said there is additional concern with f inding f unding sources. If the windows must be repaired, it will increase the cost and the existing windows will continue to deteriorate further in the meantime. 5 Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that this property maintains strong historic importance and integrity. The windows should be restored. He understands that money is always an issue. An option to protect the windows would be to board them up until they are able to be restored. This is called “mothballing” and is recommended at the national level. T his home is an important part of Lynchburg’s history. He hopes the United States Tennis Association (USTA) will come to acknowledge the significance of the site. Commissioner Sherayko agreed with Commissioner Lifsey and noted that the USTA has invested in the restoration of the tennis courts on site. Repair of the wood windows is in line with the Design Review Guidelines though he is unsure about the long-term effects of boarding the windows. Mr. Esenwein asked about concerns of vandalism if they were to restore the wood windows in the long term. Damage to replacement windows would not matter. Commissioner Lifsey said that the hypothetical argument is not valid. That would be true for every historic site in the country. Mr. Esenwein replied that there has been more evidence of damage here than with other houses. Commissioner Lifsey replied that if it becomes a pristine and res tored element, the respect for the site will be elevated. The Pierce Street Group has come before the Commission with plans as wel l, so restoration is taking place in the neighborhood. Commissioner Englund asked if they had looked into storm windows. Mr. Novak replied there are currently some storm windows in place, but they would prefer not to use them. Storm windows have no historical value and the Foundation does not like them. Commissioner Englund responded that storm windows could be a good “mothba lling” option to help protect the windows as they go through the process of restoration. Mr. Esenwein said that the Foundation felt that by not doing storm windows , and instead doing replacement windows, the character of the home would be better presented from the street view. Commissioner Erquiaga stated that the windows appear to be repairable, though he understands the cost of restoration. Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to deny the comprehensive replacement of wood windows with aluminum clad wood windows. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey. Mr. Novak asked if the original approval could be extended. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler responded that the Commission could make a separate motion. Commissioner Sherayko asked for a reminder of what was in the original approval. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the approval was to replace missing and/or deteriorated wood windows in - kind. A motion for a new approval would be better than an administrative extension, which has a shorter time limit. The motion to deny passed by the following vote: AYES: Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Commissioner Lifsey noted that he would like to change the language of the previous approval. Chair Horner stated that they should be able to remove the etched window due to the concern of vandalism. Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that the windows should be mothballed until restoration is a possibility. The etched glass should be protected. Commissioner Sherayko asked for clarification as it seemed the Commissioners were asking for different things. Commissioner Lifsey said they could remove the glass and leave the sash. Chair Horner clarified she meant they should take the glass out with the sash. Commissioner Lifsey replied that was different and he didn’t believe it was appropriate. Commissioner Sherayko agreed with Commissioner Lifsey. Commissioner Lifsey said they should not remove the whole window, but it should be protected. It could be covered with plywood or they could remove the sash and store it. Either way, the window will need to be covered, but the end goal would be to restore it. Commissioner Erquiaga asked if the etched glass was mentioned in the original COA application. Ms. Mergenthaler responded no, but at that point most of the windows were boarded up and a full evaluation was not able to be completed . The house had not been a ccessible for a long time and the etched glass was probably one of the windows they were not able to get to. Commissioner Erquiaga commented that it seemed the etched window was elevated. The likelihood of someone breaking the window to get in seems slim. Mr. Novak asked if the aluminum clad wood window replacements were denied because the house is more of an historical artifact than others that LG Flint had previously requested replacements for. Commissioner Sherayko responded the structure is a historic house in a historic district that has windows that can be restored. The Design Review Guidelines say very clearly that the windows should be restored. The etched glass should also not be removed. It is part of the historic fabric of the house’s exterior and should stay in place. The Commission is being consistent by saying the wood windows should be restored. If there was absolutely nothing left to restore, that would be different. Commissioner Englund commented it may be appropriate to have shutters made to cover the windows. Mr. Esenwein replied there is some evidence that there were once shutters. Commissioner Lifsey said shutters would be far costlier than plywood. Commissioner Englund responded they were, but it would look better than plywood and is approvable long term. 7 Commissioner Sherayko reiterated that he didn’t agree with removing the etched glass. Commissioner Lifsey responded the etched glass should stay in place but i n the short-term, they could remove it and replace it in the future. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the in -kind restoration of existing wood windows and the in -kind replacement of missing wood windows . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote: AYES: Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 f) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Daryl Calfee of Calfee & Hansen, LLC to construct two single-family houses at 317 Hancock Street. (HPC2505-0002) Mr. Tyler Sherbine was present to represent the application , with Mr. Casey Servis and Mr. Daryl Calfee on speaker phone. Mr. Sherbine went on to read the following statement, “Thank you for the opportunity to present our proposal for the construc tion of two new single-family homes on these currently vacant lots within the Daniels Hill Hist oric District. Our intent with this project is to thoughtfully contribute to the ongoing story of the neighborhood by introducing homes that reflect the vernacul ar workforce housing that defines much of Daniel Hill's architectural character while offering new home ownership . While these homes are designed to meet modern standards of comfort , efficiency, and livability , they deliberately draw inspiration from the scale, proportions, materials, and rhythms that have long shaped the historic streetscape here . The result is an approach that respect s the fabric of the district while allowing for appropriate forward -looking infill that serves today's families . We are als o stakeholders here on lower Rivermont with the Bacon Street Bagels property and our office building at 400 Victoria A venue. We look forward to sharing the design in more detail and welcome your input to ensure these homes are a fitting and positive addition to the Daniels Hill neighborhood.” Chair Horner said it was exciting to see new construction coming to Daniels Hill. She asked the Commission to review the application line by line and started with doors. Commissioner Sherayko asked what the Design Review Guidelines say about materials for doors for new construction. He noted that the materials listed in the plan are wood, or fiberglass, or metal. Commissioner Lifsey noted that a basic metal door would not be appropriate. The front door should be wood. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the Commission should use the remainder of the D esign Review Guidelines as a supplement to the New Construction Guidelines, which may not be comprehensive. Commissioner Erquiaga summarized from a previous new construction application on Harrison Street : “The Residential Design Review Guidelines state that doors and door surrounds are important featur es in defining the style and character of a building . The new construction section is not specific on the types of doors to be used but notes that detail s should be consistent with adjacent historic buildings .” This supports the consideration of a wooden door. Commissioner Sherayko added that another consideration is the sides and rear of the homes . They will be very visible, so the rear doors should not be vinyl. 8 Commissioner Lifsey replied th at th e back doors should be some form of wooden door, though they wouldn’t have to be as stylized as the front doors. Ms. Mergenthaler recommended that the Commission ask for changes and table the item so that it could be revised and then approved as a whole at the next meeting. The design should be reviewed holistically, as a change to one aspect could impact the whole look of the home. Mr. Servis responded he was happy to take input on any of the materials , though they have been working for several months on this project, including submittal of a subdivision. They would like some type of approval. Ms. Mergenthaler said the Commission would give verbal approval of certain aspects and request revisions for other s. Any revisions would need to come back next month and the design would be approved all at once. Mr. Servis asked if they could get a conceptual approval so they could move forward with getting permits. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that she wouldn’t approve a building permit until all of the materials and designs were confirmed. The subdivision also hasn’t been approved yet. Commissioner Lifsey stated that they didn’t want to hold up progress, but they did want to make sure things are in order. To reiterate the doors should be made of wood and have historic character. Mr. Servis noted that in other projects he has done , the intent was to honor historic structures but not to emulate them. Their goal in this design was to scale it appropriately and honor the homes in the area. Commissioner Sherayko stated that all of the windows should be aluminum clad wood windows, including the side and rear windows. All sides of the house are visible so vinyl should not be used. The Commission had no revisions to the proposed siding. Commissioner Erquiaga noted that in other new construction, asphalt shingles have not been used. Commissioner Lifsey responded that a metal roof would be more appropriate. It would not have to be a historically accurate hand crimped metal roof b ut materially speaking asphalt shingles wo uld not be appropriate. It should not be 5V tin either. While new construction should not be a clone of historic homes, they should still fit with massing, setbacks, certain materials, etc. Commissioner Erquiaga stated that the front porch posts should be six-by-six wrapped posts instead of four-by-four posts, to make them look less modern. Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement, thicker would be better. Smaller posts take away from the look. Commissioner Erquiaga noted that ogee gutters are modern. The Commission shared agreement that the gutters should be half round gutters per the Guidelines. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the rear of the house is visible and almost as prominent as the front. The rear decks should not resemble residential suburban decks. They should have some historic character. He recommended thicker columns and one-by-fours rather than two-by-twos. Chair Horner asked for feedback on the trim. 9 Commissioner Lifsey responded that the trim should follow the same trend, and to make sure the corners are strong as opposed to spindly. The Commission had no revisions to the proposed foundations, driveways, sidewalks, or HVACs. Commissioner Lifsey noted that lighting should not be “colonial”. Fixtures can be more modern. What is shown on the plans would be fine. Chair Horner asked what the proposed colors are. Mr. Servis replied that the colors are shown on the plans. The Commission had no revisions to the proposed paint colors. Mr. Servis stated that the New Construction Guidelines were not specific about materials beyond window materials. Visibility of the houses from the bridge is far away and people won’t be able to see the windows that well. Commissioner Erquiaga replied that people would get closer to the homes as they went across t he bridge. Mr. Servis said that they are trying to put an affordable home on the market . Changing the windows and roof materials will cause the homes to be more exp ensive. The National Park Service (NPS) has allowed the use of asphalt shingles in some cases. Commissioner Lifsey noted that it has not been a practice of this Commission to approve asphalt shingle roofs. If he wants to provide additional information in support of asphalt shingles, he is welcome to do so at the next meeting. Chair Horner added that these homes will be at the entrance to the Daniels Hill Historic District. Commissioner Lifsey agreed and stated that the homes need to respect the character of the district . He commended the design that was presented and noted that th e Commission is looking forward to seeing the final product with the revisions made at the next meeting. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the item for revisions. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote: AYES: Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 5. NEXT MEETING DAY: The next regular meeting is scheduled for July 21, 2025. 6. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:27. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.