RecordWell Data

Minutes (May)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of May 19, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of May 19, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund Shanda Horner, Chair Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair Tracey Langseth OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Branden Grosvalet to install porch brackets and paint at 209 Madison Street. (HPC2504-0008) Mr. Oliver Geoghegan was present to represent the application on behalf of Branden Grosvalet. He would like to install decorative porch brackets and paint the exterior in a new color scheme. Chair Horner asked if the brackets would be located on the back porch. Mr. Geoghegan replied they would be. Commissioner Sherayko noted that the brackets seemed to reference the design of the screen door. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to motion to approve the installation of decorative brackets on the rear porch as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 Commissioner Lifsey stated that the color scheme is appropriate . The first floor of the home is clapboard and the upper floor is shingle. Mr. Geoghegan replied that there are sections on the home that are shake as well. 2 Commissioner Lifsey asked if they plan to make the shake a separate color as well. Mr. Geoghegan replied no, the second level would be the green color, including the shake. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the sashes were proposed to be a darker color than the trim, which was appropriate. Mr. Geoghegan said it would be a black color to add some depth. They are mimicking the colors of a house that is on Washington Street. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the front door would be a different color. Mr. Geoghegan replied the front door was natural wood. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve painting the exterior in a new color scheme as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 The Commission agreed that the applicant could have some flexibility with the submitted color scheme, as long as it was not drastically different. Commissioner Sherayko asked if a color was proposed for the foundation Mr. Geoghegan replied a color has not been chosen . The foundation is soft brick so paint removal is difficult and it will likely always have some paint on it. b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Joshua Alatis to replace a fence, install gravel parking, and install a gravel walkway at 832 & 834 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2504 -0007) Mr. Joshua Alatis was present to represent th e application. Due to renovations, the backyard of the home was left unstable and mostly mud . The gravel was installed to stabilize the yard and allow continued use of the backyard. A fence was also previously removed. It was in disrepair and he plans to i nstall a new fence in its place. Chair Horner asked if there was a fence there before. Mr. Alatis replied that it seemed like there was a fence there, as posts had been left in the yard. Commissioner Sherayko stated that a new fence would be acceptable. Commissioner Englund replied that the finished side of the fence should be facing out , like the neighboring property. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the installation of approximately 95’ of new 6’ tall wood privacy fence as submitted wit h the finished side out. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 3 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 Commissioner Lifsey asked what the Residential Design Review Guidelines say about parking area material in backyards. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler summarized from the Residential Design Review Guidelines : driveways and parking lots that are new should be located at the rear or side of the building and should be of brick, brown pea gravel, concrete, concrete exposed aggregate , or concrete tracks. Gravel parking in the rear should be brown pea gravel. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the type of gravel is the issue. What was installed, is typically used under streets. Pea gravel, or river rock, is acceptable in historic districts. Mr. Alatis commented that there are neighboring properties with the same type of gravel. Commissioner Lifsey replied th at those gravel areas may have been in place before the area became a historic district. Commissioner Sherayko asked if it would be acceptable if the gravel was left in place until construction was over. After that, a layer of pea gravel could be used to cover the existing gravel. Commissioner Lifsey replied that could be an option , though he questions how thick the pea gravel layer would need to be to not have the original gravel come up through the pea gravel layer. Commissioner Englund noted that if the gravel is crush and run , it should compact down and not be an issue. Commissioner Lifsey added that the gravel could also be covered with concrete but not asphalt. Mr. Alatis asked if the pea gravel on top would work. Commissioner Lifsey replied, as mentioned, if the original gravel is compacted first, it could work. Commissioner Alexander commented that in his experience, it is easier to remove the base layer of gravel and start fresh. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to appro ve the installation of a 38’x6’ gravel walkway and a 40’ x 12’ gravel parking area with the stipulation that the base layer of crush and run be reduced, if needed, and compressed and then completely covered with an overlay of pea gravel/round river rock. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 c) ACTION (Advocate -Englund): Request of Phillip Warrick Sr. to replace a metal roof at 1500 Grace Street. (HPC2504-0009) Ms. Michelle Ware was present to represent the application on behalf of her father. She previously spoke with a staff member about replacing the metal roof. She was under the impression that if she replaced 4 the existing roof with a metal roof, she would not need approval. Her father is elderly and she is trying to improve the home for him. Commissioner Alexander asked for clarific ation as to how much of the new roofing had already been installed. Ms. Ware replied that the main roof has been completed. She believes that t he front and back porch roofs have not been replaced yet. Commissioner Alexander asked if there was any issue with the color of the roof being different. Chair Horner said she doesn’t have a problem with the color. Commissioner Sherayko noted that this roof would not normally be accepted in the historic district and said he wanted to make sure the Commission stayed consistent in holding the same standards. Commissioner Englund asked what type of roof the previous roof was as it looked like there was another layover. Ms. Ware replied the red parts of the roof were the original roof and the silver parts were repai rs her father had put on decades ago. Commissioner Lifsey said the original roof was standing seam metal, which traditionally had +/ -18-inch width and was used on historic homes all across the City. The new roof is what is called 5V metal and was historically used for buildings such as barns or other farm buildings. It is not historically a residential roofing material. It has exposed fasteners and is screwed down. It is a more of a utilitarian structure. He is okay with a red, green, black, or silver color but the materiality is inconsistent with the Guidelines. Commissioner Englund clarified that a standing seam metal roof would be most appropriate for all of the roofs on this structure. The Commission shared agreement. Chair Horner summarized from th e Residential Design Review Guidelines, “if replacement is necessary , the new roof should match the original as closely as possible in dimension s, seam crimping, and seam spacing.” Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that the 5V metal roof is the wrong materia l for the historic district. The replacement roof needs to be a standing seam metal roof to match the original roof. Standing seam metal panels can be gotten from a manufacturer with panels 18-20 inches wide. Commissioner Sherayko noted that the replacem ent her father had previously installed seemed to be appropriate. Commissioner Englund asked Ms. Ware to get in touch with him . He would like to take a look at the remaining roofs to determine if they could be repaired instead of replaced. Commissioner Lifsey recommended an Acrymax coating if possible. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to deny the replacement of the standing seam metal roof with a 5V metal roof; and approve the replacement of the standing seam metal roof with a standing seam metal roof to match as closely as possible in dimensions, seam crimping, and 5 seam spacing in a green, red, black, or silver color. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 d) ACTION (Advocate-Lifsey): Request of St. John’s Episcopal Church to do extensive work at 2477 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2505-0001) Mr. Mark Smith was present to represent the application on behalf of St. John’s Episcopal Church . He stated that t his application was a continuation of the project to incorporate the old BB&T B ank into the Church’s youth house community center. The pla yground has already been installed and interior renovations have begun. This portion of the project includes installing extensions for the dumpster enclosure and a flat roofed tool shed. The church is not located in the historic district and o nly a small portion of the dumpster enclosure and shed area will be located in the historic district. Along Rivermont and Elmwood Avenues, a painted brick wall with a sign will be installed. This wall will be similar to other brick walls along Rivermont Avenue. The walls will have different styles and will range in height. The wall along Rivermont Avenue will range from 30 -46 inches high and the wall along Elmwood Avenue will range from 24 -34 inches high . Two (2) concrete patio areas, a bike rack , additional concrete sidewalks, an ADA ramp, and reconfigured parking will also be installed. Commissioner Lifsey stated that he didn’t see a problem with the extension of the dumpster enclosure and the installation of a tool she d. They will only partially be located in the hi storic district and the dumpster enclosure is already existing. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the dumpster enclosure and tool shed as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 Commissioner Sherayko stated that he was fine with the proposed concrete patios and the bike rack. Commissioner Alexander made a motion to approve two (2) patio areas and a bike rack as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve additional concrete sidewalks, ADA ramps, and reconfigure existing parking with a new layout as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 6 Commissioner Sherayko stated that a painted brick wall would radically change the historic nature of the property and the surrounding historic district. Mr. Smith replied that the church would like to create borders for the property since the building will be a youth center and Elmwood is an increasingly busy street. The church felt the proposed wall would be less intrusive than a fence in terms of aesthetics. Chair Horner shared agreement with Commissioner Sherayko. The proposed wall would change the whole project. Commissioner Alexander shared agreement regarding the wall changing the appearance . He does not have an issue with it a esthetically and the wall would serve a purpose, but questions if it would fit within the district and the Guidelines. Mr. Smith stated that the context of the wall is Rivermont Avenue. Commissioner Alexander stated that while there are other brick walls along Rivermont Avenue, there has not historically been a brick wall on this property. Chair Horner noted that painting the wall is also an issue. Commissioner Lifsey stated that he is less against the brick wall itself and more against painting brick. If he had been at the meeting where painting the brick building was discussed, he would have voted no. he questions the noncontributing status of the property, as it is now over 50 years old and was designed by a local architect. Painting the brick wall is a step in the same direction, and he does not support it. He understands why the church would want a wall , as they are trying to make a campus, but he is against painting it. Chair Horner responded that she was against both putting in a brick wall and painting it. Commissioner Englund stated that painting a brick wall would not match the other Rivermont Avenue walls. He noted that there are different types of paint that are more appropriate for use with brick. Mr. Smith replied they would use a silicate paint. Commissioner Englund agreed that an unpainted wall would be better. He quoted from the Residential Design Review Guidelines that walls, “of stone, brick, or concrete may be added in front of a property if historically appropriate and consistent with the character of the district.” The question there is what does that language mean. Commissioner Sherayko noted that he understands the church wants to paint the brick wall to match the building, but an unpainted brick wall would fit more within the historic district. Commissioner Lifsey stated that new walls and fencing have been approved for use in the front, so a new wall here is viable. The real decision is what material to use, a brick wall there is fine, but not painted. Commissioner Alexander agreed. Commissioner Sherayko said he was willing to accept the wall , as it would not be o ut of place along the streetscape, but he is against painting it. 7 Mr. Smith said the church would prefer the installation of a brick wall over a fence , even if the brick cannot be painted. Commissioner Lifsey agreed that a picket fence wouldn’t be appropriate. Commissioner Horner noted that an iron fence may be appropriate. Commissioner Lifsey replied that a wall gives it more of a campus feel. Commissioner Alexander made a motion to approve a brick wall, that is not painted, along the perimeter of the property on Rivermont and Elmwood Avenue . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 3. OLD BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Oscar Rodriguez to replace doors at 617 Washington Street. (HPC2504-0002) Mr. Oscar Rodriguez was present to represent the application. He would li ke to remove a door on the front of the home because the interior ceiling is too low for the height of the existing door. It will be relocated to the rear, in place of windows. Two (2) other rear doors will also be replaced. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the rear doors were visible from the street. Mr. Rodriguez replied they weren’t visible. Commissioner Lifsey noted the new rear location, which would provide more functional access, would be okay. The style and dimensions of the front door should be matched for the replacement back doors. The glass panels, featured in the front door, could be changed to wood, if more privacy was desired . Commissioner Englund asked if interior work had altered the height of the ceiling near the front door. He noted that the front door could remain in place but be walled off from the interior. Commissioner Sherayko shared agreement. The door is located on the front façade and should remain in place. It would be visible from the outside, but could be walled off on the inside. Commissioner Lifsey asked for clarification that the other doors were located at the rear. Mr. Rodriguez replied yes. Ms. Mergenthaler noted that the screen door, at the rear, but on the other side, was somewhat visible from the street. She asked Mr. Rodriguez if he was replacing the screen door or the inside door. Mr. Rodriguez replied the inside door. Commissioner Alexander stated that if the vegetation was removed, the doors might be visible. 8 Commissioner Sherayko responded that the screen doo r would block visibility of the interior door and matching the front door would make the replacement doors appropriate for the district. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve restoring the existing front addition wood door and close access from the interior; replacing two (2) rear doors; and replacing windows with a new door located at the rear of the addition; with the stipulation that the three (3) new rear doors mimic the existing front door but they may have glass or wood panels and that the e xisting screen door remain in place . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 b) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Frankie Len Scoggins to replace windows at 713 Pearl Street. (HPC2503-0007) Mr. Christopher Erich was present to represent the application on behalf of Mr. Frankie Len Scog gins. Following the last meeting, h e reached out to Anderson Windows to gain information on the composite Fibrex material and whether it is appropriate. He was not able to obtain a sample in time for the meeting but based on the information he received, he believes that the Fibrex windows are superior to aluminum clad windows. Commissioner Lifsey stated that Ms. Eve Mergenthaler reached out to several other Certified Local Governments (CLGs) within the state and found that the Fibrex windows, or similar co mposite windows, were generally only approved for use in new construction or to replace nonhistorical windows . These responses came from localities with historic districts of varying sizes. Aluminum clad wood windows are an appropriate material that has been approved for decades in historic districts. Chair Horner noted that this lot is very visible from the street, as it is a corner lot. The Fibrex windows also have a completely different look. Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement and stated that he is not in support of their use. Commissioner Englund stated that a key aspect of aluminum clad wood windows is that they are still, at their core, a wood window. Wood windows are repairable and last for a long time. Historic buildings are holistic, and bits and pieces should not be altered. W hile the Fibrex material would probably beat vinyl, which isn’t hard to do, it is not the best choice. He asked why wood windows were not proposed for use. Commissioner Lifsey replied that this project goes back a long time and was very controversial. The original windows were removed, without approval, and disposed of . New vinyl windows, of a different size and design, were then installed, also without approval, and aluminum was put in place of trim to cover the size difference. Aluminum clad wood windows to match the original windows were approved at a previous meeting. The Commission discussed the use of wood versus aluminum clad wood windows. Wood windows are the preference but aluminum clad wood windows are often approved for use as replacements. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to deny the application as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 9 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Langseth 2 Commissioner Lifsey stated that the approval of aluminum clad wood windows still stands. Mr. Erich noted that the issue with the aluminum clad wood windows is that they take a long time for production. Ms. Mergenthaler stated that there was some confusion at the last meeting regarding material. A quote or estimate of the proposed aluminum clad wood windows should be provided for approval prior to any purchase being made. 4. DISCUSSION: a) New Construction Committee The Commission discussed the idea of a New Construction Committee to have a more focused review of any proposed new construction in relation to the existing Guidelines, but ultimate ly decided that a Committee is not needed at this time. 5. NEXT MEETING DAY: The next regular meeting is scheduled for June 16, 2025. 6. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:37 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.