RecordWell Data

Minutes (April)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Apr 21, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of April 21, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair Shanda Horner, Chair Tracey Langseth Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of James Warinner to do extensive work at 844 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2504-0003) Mr. James Warinner was present to represent the application. He plans to fix up the exterior of the home. This includes replacing missing crown molding , having working windows, relocating a side door, and painting. He has the material s and funding to do the work, including the original railing and pos ts to reinstall on the front porch. Commissioner Sherayko asked if he had found all of the missing railing and posts for the porch. Mr. Warinner replied that he had found all of the missing parts. He had also found the missing trim within the house. He stated he had been doing historic restoration for a long time. Commissioner Erquiaga said that he would be in favor of approving several of the items. Those being repair and reinstall wood porch posts and railing s, replace porch floorboards with 1” tongue and groove , and replace damaged crown cornice with reclaimed oak. Commissioner Lifsey asked about the material to be used for the 1” tongue and groove flooring. Mr. Warinner stated that he was unsure what the Commission would prefer as there are newer materials being frequently proposed. He would like to replace with wood tongue and groove flooring. Commissioner Lifsey said that wood would be the most appropriate material. Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the repair and reinstallation of wood front porch posts and railings; replacement of front porch flooring with 1” wood tongue and 2 groove; and replacement of damaged crown cornice with reclaimed oak crown cornice . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Erquiaga moved on to the relocation of the door and noted that his preference would be to keep the existing door in its current location and frame it closed on the inside. Mr. Warinner replied that he could do that . He already planned to replace the door in the ne w location with a wider one. He wants to move the location of the door closer to the kitchen and add a bathroom where the existing door is located. Commissioner Sherayko clarified that Commissioner Erquiaga would like the existing door to remain visible on the outside of the home. Commissioner Erquiaga replied yes. Mr. Warinner noted that he was planning to remove the door, close the hole with siding, but keep the trim and transom where it was. The existing door is not original. Commissioner Sherayko asked what material the existing door was made of. Mr. Warinner replied that it was a newer metal door. He had replaced an older door that was falling apart. He stated that he could put the old door back in instead of using siding. Chair Horner replied that would be preferred. Commissioner Erquiaga asked what material the new door would be. Mr. Warinner responded that he had a six-panel door in the basement that was previously on the house. Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification that the door from the basement would be six panel. Mr. Warinner replied yes. Commissioner Sherayko asked if he would move the staircase to the new doorway. Mr. Warinner replied that he would move the staircase to access the new door, but noted the location would be more wheelchair accessible if someone wanted to build a ramp. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the replacement of the side metal door with a six-panel door that was previously installed; and the installation of a matching six -panel door, but three-foot wide , facing Victoria Avenue . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 3 Mr. Warinner continued on to the proposed paint colors, which include dark green, red, and a lighter green for the trim. He plans to make the roof metal, doors, and shutter s red. He has ten (10) of the original shutters to reinstall on the outside of the house. Historic homes were painted in bold colors originally and he wants this home to pop and stand out. Commissioner Sherayko stated that the house is a Queen Anne style and the colors may fit with th at style. Commissioner Lifsey disagreed and noted that the trim color, “Nautical” was inappropriate. Mr. Warinner replied he could change the trim color to something greener. Commissioner Lifsey replied that it could be a much lighter green, cream, or tan color. Mr. Warinner responded that he was trying to stay away from tans. Commissioner Lifsey stated that it should be something less blue. Mr. Warinner proposed a lime green. Commissioner Lifsey recommended taking the body color and toning it down to get a trim color. He added that painting the sashes of the windows another color such as white would help them pop . The gable in the front of the house could also be a fourth color as they were commonly used as an accent. Mr. Warinner stated he thought red would look good on the gable. Commissioner Lifsey replied the red on the door was on the burgundy side, which he believed was appropriate. He asked about the color for the shutters and the roof metal. Mr. Warinner responded he wanted to paint them the same red. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the roof metal could be black. Mr. Warriner expressed that he would be okay with that change. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve painting the body of the house with “Four -Leaf Clover” (dark green); the trim with a much lighter tone of the body color; the doors, shutters, and upper front gable with “Classic Red”; the window sashes with white; and the roof metal with black . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 c) ACTION (Advocate -Englund): Request of Oscar Rodriguez to replace do ors at 617 Washington Street. (HPC2504-0002) Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to motion to table the item to allow for applicant attendance. He noted that he had questions regarding the application. The motion to table was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: 4 AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 d) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Frankie Len Scoggins to replace windows at 713 Pearl Street. (HPC2503-0007) Mr. Chris Erich, of A.R. Pike Law Firm, and Mr. Stephen Milacci, the previous owner of the property, were present to represent Mr. Frankie Len Scoggins, the current owner o f the property, and the application. Mr. Milacci stated that the request was to replace windows with two-over-two Anderson 100 series Fibrex windows, which are a composite material. They will have the same trim and sizing. Mr. Scoggin s previously received approval for other work from the Commission. Chair Horner asked for clarification, as the Commission had already approved replacement windows. Mr. Milacci responded that there was confusion as he believed the previous Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) approval did not specify approval for the windows that were requested in the application. He had done research and believed these windows would work as replacements. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the approval specified aluminum clad wood windows. Mr. Milacci replied that the windows submitted for consideration previously were not aluminum clad wood windows, so he was confused as to why the COA approval specified aluminum windows. Commissioner Lifsey responded th at the Commission would not have app roved a purely aluminum window, as those are a storefront, commercial grade material. Mr. Milacci stated that the COA specifically said aluminum. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler pulled the previous COA approval up and asked if he meant aluminum clad wood. Mr. Milacci replied yes, it said aluminum clad. Chair Horner replied that the Commission would have approved aluminum clad wood windows. Commissioner Lifsey added that aluminum clad wood windows are standard replacement windows in the historic district and come pre-finished. Mr. Milacci replied that his concern comes from the fact that the original replacement window previously submitted (Jeld Wen windows) for review doesn’t contain aluminum. It was a wood material. He noted that he had spoken with Ms. Mergenthaler about the possibility of replacing with composite windows. He recommended these Anderson 100 Series windows to Mr. Scoggin s as they would have lower maintenance requirements and would still fit the general style and are simulated divided light (SDL) windows. They would be a better long term fit. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the HPC has approved cellular PVC windows in the past. Ms. Mergenthaler replied th at the Andersen 100 Series Fibrex windows are different from cellular PVC windows. The Anderson Fibrex material is wood fiber and thermoplastic polymer and is unique to Anderson. 5 Commissioner Lifsey stated that it would be prudent for the Commission to have Ms. Mergenthaler look more into these windows and see what experience other Certified Local Governments (CLGs) in the state have with the material. Commissioner Erquiaga agreed as he is also unfamiliar with the material and would like to make an informed decision. Commissioner Alexander made a motion to table for more information. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 3. OLD BUISNESS a) ACTION (Advocate -Englund): Request of Victor Jose Munoz Guerrero of Maintenance, Services, and Supplies, LLC to replace metal roofs at 1308 Clay Street. (HPC2501 -0002) Mr. Victor Guerrero was present to represent the application. He explaine d to the Commission that he had called the roofing contacts provided to him but they were not responsive, so he was unable to obtain a local contractor. He brought with him the roofing contractor from Richmond, Mr. Gustavo Flores. Chair Horner summarized from the Residential Design Review Guidelines, metal roofs should be preserved in original size, shape , and pitch, and, if possible, with original roof material. If replacement is necessary, the new roof should match the original as closely as possible in dimensions, seam crimping , and seam spacing. At the last meeting , the Commission spoke about a hand crimped, flat seam metal roofing being the only appropriate option due to the pitch . The pitch must also be retained to match the sister house next door. Mr. Flores replied that the panels that will be put on will be the same twelve (12) inch panels that are there now, and the gauge would be twenty -four (24). The pitch would stay the same , and they would just replace with something newer. Chair Horner asked if it would be a hand-crimped flat seam roof. Mr. Flores replied they would be sized pieces that would be shipped and then installed. Commissioner Alexander asked why the roof can’t be replaced with the original type of roof. The pitch seemed adequate. Mr. Flores replied the original roof was flat and appeared to be welded . There was no pitch with the original. Commissioner Alexander asked if there was a photo of the original roof. The pitch of the roof had been changed as it was not the same as the neighbors at 1304 Clay Street. Mr. Flores responded they would not be changing the pitch. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler clarified that the pitch had already been altered and the question being asked is if the cricket would be removed and the pitch returned to its original state. 6 Commissioner Alexander replied in comparison with the neighbor’s roof and seeing the photo of the studs of the porch roof it looked like they had plenty of pitch to replace the original style of roof. Commissioner Lifsey said the origina l roof was not flat, it just had a low slope and was crimped tin. It was not welded, it was soldered, and they were individual sheets that were folded. The sheets are folded down flat and soldered at the joint to keep water out of the home. If they get off the shelf factory material then that will have a standing seam that laps and crimps, but it will not lay flat. Also, it won’t have a warranty a t that low of a slope with a standing seam . The Commission has approved standing seam on high pitched roofs. For this home, the flat seam, hand crimped soldered metal is the material that is historically accurate. Chair Horner noted that this was previously discussed. Mr. Flores asked if the pitch could remain altered. Chair Horner responded no. Commissioner Lifsey agreed that it is better to restore it to the original. Mr. Flores noted that he needed to find out what the pitch of the neighboring roof was. Commissioner Alexander replied they could tell that from the marks on the brick. Commissioner Lifsey added that they could tell from the original joints. Mr. Flores asked if the pitch was enough to place panels, would that be okay. Commissioner Lifsey asked if he was talking about prefabricated panels. Mr. Flores said yes. Commissioner Alexander stated that material would not be appropriate. Chair Horner and Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement. Commissioner Lifsey reiterated th at off the shelf panels have a factory standing seam. The roof needs to be replaced with hand-crimped, flat seam metal to preserve the historic visual. Commissioner Alexander reiterated that there was no cricket in the original design. Mr. Flores asked if a hand-crimped, flat seam metal roof was the only option. Commissioner Lifsey responded yes, given the low slop, condition, and area. Mr. Flores asked if commercial grade, flat roofing was an option. Chair Horner replied no. Commissioner Lifsey responded that the roof is too visible for an application of commercial grade, flat roofing like EPDM rubber. 7 Commissioner Sherayko added that the roof is part of the historic aesthetic. It was a mistake to rip it off without approval. There are rules and regulations in the historic districts. The Commission is there to be as helpful as they can and guide work to be done appropriately. Commissioner Alexander stated the original replacement roof that was installed was a quality one and it is unfortunate it must be removed now, but it was not appropriate for this house. Mr. Flores asked what could be done with the side porch and rear d eck roofing. The roofs are in ba d shape but have not yet been altered by the applicant. He asked if there were any coatings that would be appropriate. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the side roof was all metal or partially EPDM. Mr. Flores replied he didn’t remember as it had been some time, but he believes there is some EPDM. Commissioner Lifsey replied that if the re is hand crimped tin under the EDPM rubber, the tin can be coated in an appropriate material and left in place. He will send the material to the Secreta ry. If there is rotted metal, pieces can be replaced with hand crimped, in-kind. Mr. Flores asked about the back-deck roof. Commissioner Lifsey said the individual panels are also appropriate. They were generally twelve (12) by eighteen (18) panels and often hand soldered. This roof could also be left in place and coated with the same material. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve leaving the side and rear metal roofs in place and coating them with an appropriate material fo r water tightness ; and replacing the front porch roof with a hand crimped flat seam tin roof in at the original slope to match the previous roof. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund. Commissioner Alexander asked if the Commission was discussing roof color for the front. Commissioner Lifsey replied th at th e hand -crimped porch roof would have to be painted in the field. Typically, the tin is left to weather for a year or so and then painted. Mr. Flores asked if the downspouts could be replaced with something different or if they would have to match the original. Commissioner Lifsey responded that if they are deteriorated past the point of function, t hey should be replaced to match the original. Chair Horner stated that a new COA application would nee d to be submitted to the Secretary for gutt er replacement. The conditional motion to approve passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Lifsey asked if a roof color was determined. 8 Mr. Flores noted that it would probably be red. Commissioner Lifsey responded that there is typically only one red, green, or black option for painting tin. Commissioner Sherayko recommended checking with the secre tary for the color and any future work before the work is done. Commissioner Alexander shared agreement. Chair Horner recommended that the paint be removed from the front mason ry window sills and that the remainder of the window sills not be painted. 4. NEXT MEETING DAY: The next regular meeting is scheduled for May 19, 2025. 5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:56 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.