Minutes (October)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Oct 21, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of October 21, 2024
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair
Shanda Horner, Chair
Tracey Langseth
Emmett Lifsey
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Julie Arrington
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission , Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning
Technician; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:01 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by
Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate -Langseth): Request of the City of Lynchburg to make access
improvements and install signage at 901 Court Street. (HPC2410-0003)
Ms. Amanda Adams , AIA of A2L Design + Consulting was present to represent the application. The City
of Lynchburg is requesting to do work at the back of the Museum to make it more accessible to visitors.
Improving accessibi lity at the rear will preserve the front and side facades of the building. Changes
include an accessible concrete path connecting the parking deck and the back door, new signage ,
stainless steel railings, and removing the metal gate from the backdoor.
Commissioner Alexander asked if there were preliminary designs for the signage.
Ms. Adams replied not at this time.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler noted that the commission is approving the location. Final design would require
additional review and approval.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that all the requested changes were necessary to increase access to the
museum.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
2
b) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Josh Standeven to install a conc rete slab at
618 Pearl Street. (HPC2410-0004)
Mr. Josh Standeven was present to represent the application. He is requesting to install a concrete slab at
the rear of his home.
Commissioner Sherayko noted that he is fine with th e petition given that it is at the back of the house
and that the material is concrete.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
c) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Nancy Marion to construct a two -car garage
and apartment at 1322 Church Street. (HPC2410-0005)
Ms. Nancy Marion was present to represent the application. She is requesting to build a two -car garage
with an apartment over top. She submitted several materials she is considering using. There will also be
a door on the left side of the structure and windows and a deck at the rear that will not be seen from the
street.
Commissioner Sherayko said that what was proposed looks good since it is set back from the street and
front façade of the house. He deferred to Commissioner Lifsey regarding materials.
Commissioner Lifsey said that he did not have any problem with the submitted materials. Hardie board is
acceptable and cellular PVC windows have been previously approved for use. Aluminum clad wood
windows may hold up better over time than the PVC.
Ms. Marion said that she thought that either one for the windows would look the same from the street.
She has not found the exact garage door design as what is in her request, but she is looking for
something that fits the craftsman style carriage house.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that the siding colors are appropriate choices.
Ms. Marion said that the trim would be white and the roof a dark color.
Ms. Langseth asked if the Commission needed to speak to the side of the house and the door there.
Commissioner Lifsey replied that the side door as presented would be fine , either with a window or solid.
The metal roof is acceptable and a darker color will be suitable.
Commissioner Sherayko said that the structure will add to the street scape . He then asked if there will be
windows at the rear.
Ms. Marion replied that there would be windows for the view. A small deck would also be installed.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that if the garage doors were in the design of what was shown it would not
matter if the doors were painted metal or stained wood.
3
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
3. OLD BUSINESS
d) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Shawn and Sarah Hyska to install solar panels
at 117 Madison Street. (HPC2409-0003)
Mr. Shawn Hyska was present to represent the application.
Commissioner Horner expressed gratitude for the additional information regarding other Districts’
Guidelines for solar panels.
Mr. Hyska said that it was a learning experience for them as well, seeing what historical commissions
were doing in the United States with solar panels.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that treatment of solar panels seemed to still be all over the place.
Commissioner Lifsey asked Ms. Merg enthaler what th e overall feel was for solar panels in historic
districts.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied that other Certified Local Governments (C LGs) generally treat solar panels as
approvable with some restrictions, like what the Commission has in place. Solar panels are ge nerally
considered a reversable change.
Commissioner Lifsey said that in Portsmouth solar panels don’t even go before a Commission. They are
approved administratively because the city wants to encourage investment in the historical districts and
panels help make them more affordable.
Commissioner Langseth asked if they approved panels on terracotta.
Commissioner Lifsey replied th at they did. He said that there is some blight in areas in the Portsmouth
historic districts, so the city is doing everything in their power to encourage investment in the district.
Commissioner Horner stated to Mr. Hyska that it was good to receive a letter from a neighbor supporting
his application.
Commissioner Alexander asked if the commission had received a letter opposing the application.
Commissioner Horner replied that they did before the previous meeting from the next-door neighbor.
Mr. Hyska stated that when he came before the commission several weeks ago, they were considering
two (2) colors to pain the roof , either a light grey or black. They would be more than willing to paint the
roof black to camouflage the solar panels.
Commissioner Langseth asked if anyone in the City expressed how they feel on the matter of solar panels
in the historic district.
4
Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the Design Review Guidelines have been in place for several years and are
limited. They encourage the use of solar panels where not visible.
Commissioner Sherayko replied that the panels would be visible from the side street. Moving forward with
technology is understandable, but he is still on the fence with the solar panels. They will be visible, and
the panels are a 21st technology on the roof of a 19th century home.
Commissioner Erquiaga said that the sight of the panels would be forced on the neighbors.
Commissioner Lifsey replied that the panels would be visible to those at the rear of the home . There may
be a glimpse of the smaller array on the side. The vast majority are in the back and visible from a side
street, if the commiss ion started taking that into account, then anything on a hill w ould be held to
separate visibility standards and restrictions . Embracing solar panels will also help the viability of historic
homes.
Commissioner Erquiaga noted that each application is reviewed on a case by case basis.
Commissioner Langseth replied that the commission have had to say no to window changes as per the
guidelines that could be more energy efficient.
Commissioner Lifsey replied that they are often saying no to cheaper, vinyl al ternatives that aren’t energy
efficient. The Commission approves storm panels, inside and outside, as well to make the windows more
functional. Solar panels are something the Commission needs to consider approving, especially if it is
going in the rear of the home.
Commissioner Langseth stated that the roof and the panels were very visible from the back-side streets.
Commissioner Horner replied that she looked at it as a utility. When installing utilities, they are allowed to
put them wherever they want. Given that this is new technology, later down the road the Commission
may see something completely new. A black roof would make the panels less conspicuous.
Commissioner Langseth responded that they all embrace the new technology but the question is how t o
apply it in the historic district.
Commissioner Horner replied that if the panels were proposed to go in the front of the home, then the
Guidelines would say no. It says to hide as much as you can and with a black roof that can be done.
Commissioner Sherayko asked if the black roof would undermine the efficiency of the solar panels.
Mr. Hyska replied no, it would draw more heat. The panels would still be efficient as they are also black,
it would just camouflage them more from the side street.
Ms. Mergenthaler noted that other CLGs encourage the use of a color that blends or hides the panels.
Commissioner Lifsey said that the Commission should look at the guidelines holistically. He is in favor of
this application. This will be an option to encourage the viability of the home, and is not in the front.
Commissioner Erquiaga reiterated that that it would be imposed on the street behind the house and the
Guidelines say they should not be visible.
5
Commissioner Lifsey replied that in his work with histor ic buildings and historic tax credits that when
fixing flat roofs , condensers are always put on the roof. The restrictions there are that it can’t be seen
from the front, and it does not matter if it is seen from other streets.
Commissioner Sherayko asked both Commissioners Lifsey and Erquiaga how they felt about the
compromise of painting the roof black.
Commissioner Lifsey shared support for it.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated that it would help conceal them, but that doesn’t change his position.
Mr. Hyska stated that the panels do not change anything structurally about the roof as they only clip on.
As technology changes, so too will the panels and they could become less conspicuous down the road.
Commissioner Horner stated it was up to the Historic Pre servation Commission to take the lead on the
matter of the solar panels.
Commissioner Sherayko asked about other solar panel applications.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied there have been other approvals, but they were mainly administrative. There
was an application in 2016 for solar panels on the front of a carriage house. That application was denied
by the Historic Preservation Commission but approved by Council through an appeal.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application with the stipulation that the roof
be painted black . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following
vote:
AYES: Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 4
NOES: Alexander, Erquiaga 2
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
4. DISCUSSION
The Commission discussed updating the Guidelines.
5. NEXT MEETING DAY:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for November 18, 2023.
6. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:53 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.