City Council Meeting — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Oct 8, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
October 8, 2024
1
// A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of October,
2024, at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The
following Members were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, MaryJane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, Martin Misjuns
Larry Taylor, Sterling A. Wilder 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #1, Ms. Finney stated that as a result of an
advertisement placed in The News and Advance on September 12 and September 20, one bid
was received on October 1 from Griffin Pipe Products Co, LLC. She read the bid into the record.
There were no additional bids. Mayor Reed closed the bidding.
Councilmember Taylor motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to accept the sole bid.
With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Helgeson, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Misjuns 1
// In the matter of Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance, Agenda Item #2, Council conducted a
work session on the Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance (LRBA) Overview of Site and
Building Readiness. CEO of the LRBA, Megan Lucas, provided a presentation to Council.
Competition in economic development is fierce, especially in terms of attracting capital
investment for business and industrial projects – among 3,141 counties, 19,000 municipalities,
and 90,000 taxing jurisdictions, just in the United States. Speed to market is often a deciding
factor for relocating and growing companies, and it has shortened tremendously over the years
as communities have gotten aggressive in preparing themselves to recruit and retain
businesses. Today, as we compete globally for new capital investment, many companies
require a pad-ready site so they start producing as quickly as possible.
October 8, 2024
2
Councilmember Misjuns expressed concerns that there were 90,000 taxing jurisdictions.
He said that they needed to ensure taxes were not high in the City.
Mayor Reed asked if the City’s taxes had been a concern for developers. Ms. Lucas said
that in her 10 years of working in the City, taxes had not been a factor preventing developers
from doing business in the City. Mayor Reed asked if there were other concerns related to the
City that they should consider. Ms. Lucas said that existing buildings were a significant factor
when recruiting businesses to the region, and many industries did not relocate to the region
because other areas had existing buildings or buildings in better condition. She said that the age
of the existing buildings in the region made it difficult for contemporary manufacturers to
upgrade the infrastructure.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked how the City could shorten the gap to site-readiness. City
Manager Mr. Wynter Benda said that they should consider more investment in site creation. He
explained that it was more expensive to repurpose old buildings than to build new ones. Ms.
Lucas said that they should focus on increasing wages, job opportunities, and investment in an
industrial spec-building program. She explained that high-wage jobs supported all other jobs.
She said that in order to have a thriving economy, they had to grow their economic base by
focusing on basic industries.
Mayor Reed said that it was crucial for the City to offer jobs that would retain local talent
from the universities and colleges in the region and students who were looking to enter into the
trades.
// In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #3, Council conducted a work session
on the Office of Economic Development & Tourism Sports Tourism Update. Director of
Economic Development and Tourism Marjette Upshur provided a presentation to Council.
Sports Tourism is integral to local and national economies across the United States. Travelers
attending sports tournaments, races, and other events, either as participants or spectators,
generate significant economic benefits for households, businesses, and governments and
October 8, 2024
3
represent a critical driver of the overall economy. While some states generate a larger share of
economic impact given their size, seasonality, and location within the U.S., the Sports Events
and Tourism Association State of the Industry Report ranks Virginia in the Top 10 States in
Sports Tourism Impact for 2023.
// In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #4, Council was briefed regarding
Consolidation of Erosion Control and Stormwater Management Requirements & Revising Illicit
Discharge Requirements. Water Quality Manager Erin Hawkins briefed Council on the item. The
City is one of many cities in the Commonwealth required to have ordinances to meet federal
and state requirements for erosion and sediment control management, stormwater runoff, and
illicit discharge controls. City Code chapters 16.1 and 16.2 currently outline those requirements.
Recent changes by the state require the consolidation of the erosion control requirements and
stormwater control requirements into one ordinance. The illicit discharge revisions are separate,
related, and included as part of this process under the proposed revised City Code chapter
16.2. The proposed ordinance amendments to the erosion control requirements and stormwater
control requirements are consistent with the state-mandated regulations.
// In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #5, Council was briefed regarding 273 Riverside Drive
– Rezoning: R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to R-C, Conservation District &
FLUM Amendment: Low Density Residential to Resource Conservation – Riverside
Conservation. Mayor Reed stated that the item would appear before Council for action at the
October 22, 2024 meeting. City Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided a briefing to Council.
James and Carolyn Wicks are petitioning to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) from Low
Density Residential to Resource Conservation and to rezone approximately two and one
hundred twenty-five thousandths (2.125) acres from R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential
District to R-C, Conservation District located at 273 Riverside Drive to allow the conservation of
the property.
October 8, 2024
4
The property is recommended for Low Density Residential and Resource Conservation uses on
the City's Future Land Use Map (FLUM). The property fits the description of a Resource
Conservation area in its current state, which is undeveloped, vegetated open space. The
absence of street frontage and presence of steep terrain severely limit any development
potential on the property. No future improvements are proposed.
// In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #6, Council was briefed regarding 1600 Graves Mill
Road – Rezoning: B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to B-3C, Community
Business District (Conditional) - Rosedale Gas Station. Mayor Reed stated that the item would
appear before Council for action at the October 22, 2024 meeting. City Planner Rachel
Frischeisen provided Council with a briefing on the item. Daniel Cyrus, on behalf of Rosedale
Investments, LLC, is petitioning to rezone approximately three and three tenths (3.3) acres
located at 1600 Graves Mill Road from B-3C, Community Business District Conditional to B-3C,
Community Business District Conditional to revise proffers and allow an adjustment in
orientation of a fueling station canopy and parking area.
The property is recommended for Mixed Use on the City's Future Land Use Map
(FLUM). A fueling station design was proffered with the Phase 1 & 2 concept plan as part of the
2014 rezoning. The design showed an intentional canopy orientation that was discussed with
staff and reviewed by the Design Review Board (DRB). The proffered site layout from 2014 also
follows development principles for connectivity, mixed use, and building placement as called for
by the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030's Goals and Policies in Chapter 6: Land Use
Development & Community Design.
The voluntarily submitted proffer indicates development in conformance with a revised
concept plan, which shows the canopy located in front of the store, along Graves Mill Road, with
a parking area fronting Rosedale Boulevard. This is contrary to the walkable, mixed use
development that the area received previous approvals to become.
October 8, 2024
5
Vice Mayor Faraldi expressed concerns about traffic and walkability related to the layout
and design of the site. He said that he had concerns about the runoff generated from the site
and the relocation to the other side of the road.
Councilmember Misjuns said that he did not support an exit onto Graves Mill Road. He
expressed concerns about the traffic impacts and the design changes.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if the City would need to alter its traffic improvement plans for
Graves Mill Road due to the change in layout. Ms. Frischeisen said that City engineering staff
did not have any comments or concerns regarding the alternate layout. She explained that there
would only be a right-in/right-out on Graves Mill Road, so all traffic would be routed through the
roundabout and light.
Vice Mayor Faraldi expressed concerns about how the project had changed its scope.
He asked if there were zoning issues related to changing the scope and layout of the project.
City Attorney Matthew Freedman said that he would defer to staff since it relied on an
interpretation of what was permitted under the plans, and that was typically a discretionary
matter. Ms. Frischeisen explained that the Zoning Administrator determined that the orientation
of the uses was more important than the locations of the uses. She said that so long as the
developer followed City code and met the spirit and intent of the CCD and rezoning proffers,
then the Zoning Administrator would be likely to approve any changes.
Councilmember Misjuns asked if they could ask the developer to submit a revised site
plan reflecting the proposed changes. Ms. Frischeisen said that they could ask the question, but
she was not sure if they could require a new site plan to be submitted. City Manager Mr. Wynter
Benda said that they could return to the developer with the comments and concerns from
Council. Councilmember Misjuns said that he would support tabling the item until they were
presented with a revised site plan.
// In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #7, Council was briefed regarding 1101 & 1107 5th
Street – Conditional Use Permit – 5th Street Auto Body Shop. Mayor Reed stated that the item
October 8, 2024
6
would appear before Council for action at the October 22, 2024 meeting. City Planner Rachel
Frischeisen briefed Council. Kerr Holdings, LLC, is petitioning for a CUP to allow the use of an
existing structure as an auto body shop at 1101 5th Street and associated parking at 1107 5th
Street. The properties are included in the area covered by the Fifth Street Corridor Master Plan
adopted by City Council on May 23, 2006. The Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 Future Land
Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Neighborhood Commercial land use for the property. These
areas are intended to consist primarily of office, retail, personal service, and restaurant uses
that are scaled and designed to be compatible with and serve their immediate neighborhood. A
petition to rezone 1101 5th Street from B-4, Urban Commercial District to B-5, General Business
District was denied by City Council on July 9, 2024. That rezoning would have allowed a
number of more intense uses that are inappropriate in this setting, in addition to the auto body
repair use. Approval of the CUP would allow auto body repair without altering the zoning.
// In the matter of the Legislative Agenda, Agenda Item #8, Council was briefed regarding the
2025 Legislative Agenda Draft. Mayor Reed stated that the item would appear before Council
for action at the October 22, 2024 meeting. Assistant to the City Manager Mercedes Braun
provided a briefing to Council. The 2025 Legislative Agenda Draft outlines Lynchburg's key
priorities for the upcoming 2025 General Assembly Session. These include Public Safety,
Economic Development and Lifelong Learning as well as other key priorities.
Vice Mayor Faraldi requested to add an item to the legislative agenda regarding a
reconsideration of removing mandatory minimums for violent crime and the use of deadly force
in the act of a crime. He said that he would support increasing the emphasis on school
construction funding.
Councilmember Misjuns noted that school choice funding had been removed from the
agenda, and it should be added back.
// In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Helgeson said that a year and a half ago, they had
discussed funding and drafting the comprehensive plan internally. He said that since then, they
October 8, 2024
7
had hired a consultant, and it had been some time since they had received any update. He said
that there were questions about the comprehensive plan pushing road diets, which had negative
consequences. He said that he wanted to ensure that some properties did not have conflicting
zoning with the FLUM because property investors bought properties based on the FLUM. He
requested an update on the comprehensive plan process.
Councilmember Wilder said that the Day at the Point event was held over the weekend.
He commended staff for organizing the event. He said that the Party on Pierce event was held
successfully. He commended staff for the White Rock community engagement event. He
commended Riverviews on hosting a talk on how art could be an economic driver in the
community. He offered his prayers to the community regarding the recent losses due to crime.
Councilmember Misjuns said that if people thought they were being followed, they
should not go home, but they should contact 911 or go to a police station. He said that they
needed to ensure they were teaching children how to make smart decisions and how to pay
attention to their surroundings. He said that there had been four homicides in the City since the
previous meeting, and even one murder was too many. He said that they needed to unchain law
enforcement to allow them to aggressively pursue the people who committed these crimes. He
said that morning, he was dropping his son at RS Payne Elementary, and 10 minutes later, he
received notification that there were police presence two blocks away due to a homicide. He
said that he did not receive any notification about this from the school. He said that he saw
parents walking to school with their children. He said that parents should be notified when things
happen around the school, especially related to crime. He questioned why school security
officers were not armed. He said that they needed to arm the school security officers to protect
students.
Councilmember Taylor offered his prayers to the bus driver who discovered the murder
victim and to the children who were nearby. He said that any crime in the City was personal to
him, as he took an oath to protect the citizens of the City.
October 8, 2024
8
Vice Mayor Faraldi said that he received a request related to short-term rentals. He said
that the request was regarding regulations around offering RV parking spots that could be used
for Airbnb-style rentals. He said that the concept was to allow another way for property owners
to use their property. He requested follow-up information on how this would work with the
current short-term rental system.
Mayor Reed expressed her prayers and condolences to the families affected by recent
tragedies. She acknowledged the impact on the public safety officials tasked with responding to
and investigating these events. She announced that October was Breast Cancer Awareness
Month, a time to reflect on the strength and courage of those afflicted with the illness and to
raise awareness about the importance of early detection, education, and research. She noted
that her sister was battling breast cancer and had recently rung her bell for her final round of
chemotherapy.
// On the motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, by the
following recorded vote, Council elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the investment of
public funds, where competition or bargaining is involved, where, if made public or discussed
publicly initially, the financial interest and bargaining position of the City would be adversely
affected, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(6) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended; the
subject of the closed meeting being specific to a Campbell County Utilities and Service Authority
(CCUSA) sewer capacity request; and to discuss appointments for vacancies to the Social
Services Advisory Board, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, Business
Development Center, Greater Lynchburg Transit Company, Lynchburg Parking Authority, and
Board of Zoning Appeals, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as
amended.
With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Helgeson, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 7
Noes: 0
October 8, 2024
9
// The meeting was reopened to the public.
// Councilmember Wilder made the following motion:
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this
date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The
Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and
WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City
Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg
certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully
exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed
meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters
as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or
considered by Council.
The motion was seconded by Councilmember Taylor, and Council, by the following
recorded vote, adopted the motion:
Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
October 8, 2024
10
// On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, Council by the
following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and
commissions:
Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// The meeting was recessed at 6:19 p.m.
// A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of October,
2024, at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The
following Members were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, MaryJane Dolan, Martin Misjuns, Larry Taylor,
Sterling A. Wilder 6
Absent: Jeff Helgeson 1
// Councilmember Misjuns led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
// In the matter of Recognitions, Item #1, Mayor Reed presented a Proclamation recognizing
October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Amy McIvor with the YWCA accepted the
proclamation and gave remarks.
October 8, 2024
11
// In the matter of Recognitions, Item #2, Mayor Reed presented a Proclamation recognizing
Fire Prevention Week. Fire Chief Greg Wormser accepted the proclamation and gave remarks.
// In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #3, Council conducted a second reading
and adopted Resolution #R-24-066 approving the allocation of the Program Year 2021 HOME
American Rescue Plan funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
(HUD). On motion of Vice Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the
following recorded vote approved Resolution #R-24-066.
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #4, Council considered adopting
Resolution #R-24-070 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and
appropriating $100,200 to fund a Behavioral Health Docket Coordinator. On motion of Vice
Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote
approved Resolution #R-24-070.
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #5, Council considered adopting
Resolution #R-24-072 approving the FY 2024 Fourth Quarter Adjustments. On motion of Vice
Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote
approved Resolution #R-24-072.
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
October 8, 2024
12
// In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #6, copies of the minutes of the September
10, 2024 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Vice Mayor
Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved
the minutes as presented:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #7, Council held a public hearing in
consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-24-073 authorizing the City’s grant conveyance of an
ingress/egress easement to Griffin Pipe Products Co., LLC at 4 Adams Street, Lynchburg,
Virginia. Director of Water Resources Timothy Mitchell provided a summary of the item to
Council. This is associated with the Blackwater CSO Tunnel Project and is in accordance with
the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) previously discussed with Council and executed
between the City of Lynchburg and Griffin Pipe Products Co., LLC. The purpose of the
ingress/egress easement is to provide Griffin Pipe employees/agents access to a newly
constructed employee parking lot that will offset the loss of parking during the construction of
the Blackwater CSO Tunnel.
In accordance with Virginia Code, an Invitation for Bids and a Public Hearing
advertisement was published in the News & Advance on September 12, 2024, and September
20, 2024, with bids due on, or before, 5:00 p.m., on October 2, 2024.
There was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone or in-person so
the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council.
On motion of Vice Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to adopt
Ordinance #O-24-073 authorizing the City’s grant conveyance of an ingress/egress easement to
Griffin Pipe Products Co., LLC at 4 Adams Street, Lynchburg, Virginia.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
October 8, 2024
13
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #8, Council heard from a citizen regarding
“LCS capital improvement plan.” Cynthia Capps addressed Council. She urged City Council to
invest more attention and financial support in their public schools, specifically related to
rebuilding Sandusky Elementary School.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #9, Council heard from a group representative
regarding “rebuilding Sandusky Elementary.” Colleen Larkins, Save Sandusky, addressed
Council. She urged City Council to prioritize the city’s schools and to collaborate with citizens
and the School Board in their work.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #12, Council agreed by consensus to move the
following public comment ahead of Agenda Item #10. Council then heard from a group
representative regarding “a citizen’s view of the key ingredients to keep our city great and to
look for the future.” Chal Nunn, Citizens for Community Connections, addressed Council. He
expressed that his diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease provided him with a new outlook on many
parts of life, but it did not change his heart. He explained the importance of maintaining strong
relationships, listening to each other despite their differences, and coordinated efforts of City
government and other organizations to facilitate efficient progress in Lynchburg.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Council heard from a group
representative regarding “rental inspections.” Darlene Holland, UDDUP, LLC, addressed
Council. She expressed concern that the requirement of installing screen doors for ventilation
was largely unnecessary and not cost-effective for local landlords.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #11, Peter Cefaratti was not present to
address Council.
October 8, 2024
14
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #13, Council heard from a group
representative regarding “Lynchburg politics.” Gary Taylor, Citizens for a Better Lynchburg,
addressed Council. He expressed concern that the Republican Party was in total disarray due to
local politics and division.
// In the matter of Lynchburg Hillcats Baseball, Agenda Item #14, Council considered adopting
Resolution #R-24-074 consenting to Lynchburg Baseball, LLC selling, assigning, or transferring
its rights under its Baseball Stadium Franchise Agreement with the City to Hillcats Baseball,
LLC. This item was previously presented to Council during their September 24, 2024 work
session. Lynchburg Baseball Corporation, the current owner of the Lynchburg Hillcats baseball
team, has entered into an agreement to sell the team to Hillcats Baseball, LLC. The city must
approve the transfer of the franchise lease of City Stadium before the sale can be completed.
On motion of Vice Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to adopt
Resolution #R-24-074 consenting to Lynchburg Baseball, LLC selling, assigning, or transferring
its rights under its Baseball Stadium Franchise Agreement with the City to Hillcats Baseball,
LLC.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
Mr. Dylan Narang, new owner of the Hillcats, emphasized his excitement on this venture.
// In the matter of Towing and Recovery Operations, Council considered adopting a resolution
approving the City’s award and execution of a Towing and Vehicle Recovery Services Contract
with Bee Line Transport, Inc. This item was previously presented to Council at their September
24, 2024 work session. Deputy City Manager Gregory Patrick provided some further clarifying
details regarding this item. The City's towing and vehicle recovery services contract with Bee
Line Transport reached the end of its renewal year options and needed to be resolicited. This
October 8, 2024
15
contract is primarily used for City-owned fleet vehicles, including Refuse Trucks and Fire
apparatus, and Lynchburg Police Department initiated tows. It also covers towing of derelict
vehicles requested by Community Development. The Towing Advisory Board convened to
finalize the scope of services and terms of a request for proposals which was then posted on
May 14, 2024 with all proposals due by June 13, 2024. Three proposals were received - Bee
Line Transport, Cash's Garage, and Mitchell's Towing and Recovery.
An evaluation subcommittee composed of four Board members was established to
review all proposals and bring forth their observations to the full Board. The full Board then
performed site visits to examine facilities, operations, and equipment. There was full consensus
to bring forth a recommendation to City Council to award the contract to Bee Line Transport.
Councilmember Wilder asked if the amount paid by a vehicle owner offset what the City
paid. Mr. Patrick replied no; the City received no funding back from the chosen provider.
Councilmember Wilder asked if staff could provide the amount paid by vehicle owners. Mr.
Patrick answered that the proposed amount was $110 plus $50 per day.
Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to deny the
resolution. Councilmember Misjuns stated that a Towing Advisory Board member expressed her
concern to him that the process leading up to this proposal was not in line with the Virginia
Public Procurement Act. He requested that they restart the process in order to allow fair and
transparent competition.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if Councilmember Misjuns could name the member of the
Towing Advisory Board who made this communication. Councilmember Misjuns answered that
it was Kelly Currier. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if Ms. Currier could answer some of his
questions. He asked the City Attorney if this communication offered to one Councilmember
implicate the City in any capacity since Ms. Currier declined to communicate with other
Councilmembers. Mr. Freedman replied no. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked why Ms. Currier chose to
only communicate with Councilmember Misjuns. Ms. Currier replied that she did not; she sent
October 8, 2024
16
Vice Mayor Faraldi an email as well. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if Ms. Currier could tell the public
the information she had provided. Ms. Currier explained that on September 26, she sent an
email to Council regarding her current term on the Towing Advisory Board, and her discomfort
with signing the document given to the Board to endorse the RFP award. She said that she had
asked Ms. Suter why there was so much controversy around this issue and if she was missing
something. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if Ms. Currier could elaborate on her concerns. Ms. Currier
stated that as part of this process, she had asked if there had been audits to ensure they were
paying the correct amount for this contract. She said that there was no audit; it was stated that if
someone claimed they had been overpaid, it was reviewed and a refund was determined. She
emphasized there was nothing to determine if the contracted prices were correct or not. She
noted that there was a general consensus and that the decision had already been made, but
she believed there was one other member of the Board who did not agree. Vice Mayor Faraldi
asked how many Board members expressed concern prior to the vote. Ms. Currier replied there
were none. She expressed concern that based on her experience and feedback received, she
felt her position as a citizen did not allow her to adequately voice her concern or vote as she felt
was necessary. Vice Mayor Faraldi expressed concern that Ms. Currier’s insinuation could not
be substantiated with the information provided. He clarified that the City’s policy did not allow
police officers to recommend to the public any services of a particular towing service, and he
expected that policy would be followed.
Councilmember Wilder asked if Bee Line Transport was chosen through the RFP
process, as part of public procurement. Ms. Suter replied that was correct. Mr. Patrick noted that
the Towing Advisory Board actively selected the approved provider and approved the RFP,
including the language of important aspects and how they would judge the received proposals.
Councilmember Wilder asked if Ms. Suter reviewed the numbers and compared them. Ms. Suter
said yes; they compared them and used a scoring matrix. They came up with pros and cons for
October 8, 2024
17
each submittal, and the Towing Advisory Board all agreed on this proposal. Through their
discussion, they amended it as necessary to reflect their discussion.
Councilmember Misjuns asked if a police officer mentioning the name of the City’s
contracted towing service was the same as a recommendation. Mr. Patrick said that he was
unsure. Councilmember Misjuns expressed his discomfort with approving this five-year contract
that excluded all other businesses and did not give them any opportunity, as well as Ms.
Currier’s experience with the process. He recommended that Council deny the resolution and
begin the process again.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked what the proposal failed to accomplish in terms of
Councilmember Misjuns’ concerns. Councilmember Misjuns expressed concern that the five-
year contract kept other small businesses out of the loop; the police-initiated tows and City
vehicle tows should be separated; there should be rotation of tow companies; and small
businesses should be included in the ability to do this business. He expressed concern that they
had received adequate documentation of consensus, approval, and acceptance of the RFP, but
were now hearing concerns that those documents were incorrect or unfair in some manner. He
emphasized that inclusion of police-initiated tows was an integral part of holding the City and the
towing company responsible in a legally binding agreement when those situations occurred. He
requested that Council table this item until their next meeting to receive stakeholder input and
offer another opportunity for public comment.
Councilmember Wilder asked if the request for proposal had been advertised. Ms. Suter
replied that it was advertised as they did all RFPs; it was on the City’s website and the state’s
website, eVA, which sent it to all towing providers registered with the state.
Councilmember Dolan asked if all submittals had the appropriate equipment to tow City
vehicles. Ms. Suter answered that two companies out of the three proposals had the appropriate
equipment for heavy vehicle tows.
October 8, 2024
18
Mayor Reed noted that the RFP was reviewed by a subcommittee, the Towing Advisory
Board, and that Board was entrusted to make an informed vote on the information provided.
She asked if Council had the authority to tell the Towing Advisory Board that Council
disapproved of their decision and to reconsider the vote. She asked if there was a legal
consideration of getting involved in the public procurement process in that way.
// Due to heightened public participation, Mayor Reed recessed the meeting to allow time for the
situation to de-escalate and restore order. The meeting was recessed at 8:24 p.m.
// The meeting was reopened to the public at 8:29 p.m.
Mr. Freedman said that he would attempt to answer Mayor Reed’s earlier question. The
towing contract for the locality was not necessarily bound by the determination of the Towing
Advisory Board; the Council has the power to award one towing contract, two towing contracts,
or no towing contract. The written recommendation from the Towing Advisory Board was
something he had drafted based on the resolution creating the Towing Advisory Board earlier in
the year. The resolution had mentioned the Council receiving a written recommendation or
some type of guidance on how to proceed. The written recommendation included everyone’s
signature except for Ms. Currier’s, and she had spoken about that this evening. He stated that
the written recommendation still had validity, as there was nothing disproving the other
signatures. City Council did have options; however, if a majority of Council did not want to
proceed tonight, staff would request guidance on what information to bring back at the
subsequent meeting. If they did not approve anything under this item, they would continue on
the month-to-month basis they currently had with Bee Line Transit.
Councilmember Misjuns asked if Councilmember Taylor would consider adding Vice
Mayor Faraldi’s request to table the item for two meetings as a friendly amendment to the
original motion.
Councilmember Wilder stated that he did not support the motion because the request for
proposal went through proper procurement process, and the Towing Advisory Board made the
October 8, 2024
19
decision to accept the contract. He did not agree on the particular motion to deny the contract.
He stated that he was amenable to tabling it, but was unsure of the reason why because more
time would not change his vote.
Councilmember Dolan asked Vice Mayor Faraldi what would be accomplished by tabling
the item. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that he believed that if delaying this item ensured that
everyone, including Ms. Currier, the stakeholders, Councilmembers, and staff could get on the
same page and feel confident in making the right decision, and that they could clarify with City
staff what the policy is regarding towing recommendations, then they could move forward. He
expressed his hope that they could unanimously support this item after that time.
Councilmember Misjuns accepted the amendment to table the item for two meetings.
Councilmember Taylor accepted the amendment.
Mr. Freedman asked if Council could provide staff with direction on next steps for this
item.
Councilmember Wilder requested that the other members of the Towing Advisory Board
provide comments to give context to Ms. Currier’s concerns.
Mayor Reed confirmed there was consensus from Council to table this item until the
November 12, 2024 meeting of Lynchburg City Council.
// In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #16, Council considered introducing a resolution
amending the FY 2025 Adopted Budget to align City Council salaries with the requirements of
Lynchburg City Code Section 2-16.1 (Option A). In December 2019, by adopting Lynchburg City
Code Section 2-16.1, the City Council set its salaries at $14,000 per member, per year, and
$16,000 for the Mayor, per year, beginning July 1, 2020. However, because of budget
uncertainties associated with the COVID-19 Pandemic, the City Council maintained its salaries
at $10,000 per member, per year, and $12,000 for the Mayor, per year, beginning July 1, 2020,
as part of the FY 2021 Adopted Budget. Technical changes were made to the proposed
resolution.
October 8, 2024
20
Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to table the
item indefinitely. Vice Mayor Faraldi emphasized that a sitting politician should not vote on a pay
increase for their self.
Councilmember Misjuns noted that the proposal was to align practices with written City
Code. He recommended they table this item until they had all seven Councilmembers present,
rather than tabling it indefinitely.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder 5
Noes: Misjuns 1
Absent: Helgeson 1
On motion of Vice Mayor Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Dolan, to reintroduce
Option B regarding City Council’s salaries, keeping Councilmembers’ pay at $10,0000 and the
Mayor’s pay at $12,000.
Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion to align the Mayor’s pay with
Councilmembers’ pay at $10,000. Mayor Reed noted that there was no second for the motion,
so the motion died.
Councilmember Wilder stated that he did not support the motion because he would
prefer to have Councilmember Helgeson present for the vote.
Councilmember Misjuns said that he agreed with Councilmember Wilder; Council had
previously determined that it was essential that all seven members be present to vote on this
item, so they should remain consistent in that regard. He would not support the motion without
the presence of all seven Councilmembers at the dais.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked Clerk of Council Alicia Finney if she heard from
Councilmember Helgeson; she replied that she had not. Vice Mayor Faraldi noted that at the
September 24th meeting where this was first voted on, Councilmember Dolan let Council and
staff know with ample time that she would not be able to attend that meeting.
October 8, 2024
21
Mayor Reed called the vote on reintroduction of Option B.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan 3
Noes: Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 3
Absent: Helgeson 1
Vice Mayor Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Dolan, to place Option B on
the agenda at the October 22, 2024, City Council meeting under General Business.
With no further discussion from Council, the following was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Helgeson 1
// The meeting adjourned at 8:47 p.m.
____________________________
Clerk of Council
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.