RecordWell Data

Minutes (September)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Sep 16, 2024 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of September 16, 2024 MEMBERS PRESENT: Julie Arrington Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair Shanda Horner, Chair Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Peter Alexander Tracey Langseth OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Me rgenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission , Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Arrington, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Arrington): Request of Sharon Crites to do roof and gutter work at 2200 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2409-0001) Ms. Sharon Crites was present to represent the application to extend the existing shingle roof past the hidden gutters, install hanging gutters to match the rear gutters, and repair damage to the front porch roof and ceiling. Commissioner Erquiaga stated that he was not in favor of the petition. It takes away from the façade and the new aluminum gutters would look out of place . The roof extension would hide part of the roofline and impact the architecture. He has owned homes that had hidden c overs and understands the cost, but he is not in favor of replacing them with hanging gutters. Commissioner Lifsey asked if Ms. Crites had spoken with contractors about repairs to the hidden gutters. Ms. Crites said that she and her husband had done repairs for the twenty-nine (29) years that they had lived there. The passing of her husband has impacted her ability to do repairs. W ater comes flooding into the home in several rooms and the porch roof is falling apart. She cannot stay in the home without ge tting this work done. Commissioner Sherayko stated that hidden gutters are an old technology and not designed well. He works at Randolph College and noted that every single building that has hidden gutters has problems. He understands why she would want to get rid of hidden gutters. Commissioner Erquiaga said that the Guidelines say hidden gutters should be repaired not replaced. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the best approach for repairs would be to install EPDM rubber membrane. Hidden gutters are a historical artifact and part of the structure. Any gutter can be clogged and will need maintenance, including hanging gutters. 2 Mr. Ted George of Sentry said that there would still be issues with EPDM in the long run. They are proposing to build up to the hidden gutters, overlap them, and fix any rot. They will sheath them in , continuing with new roof shingles all the way down and put up an external gutter. Ms. Crites stated that the hanging gutters will match the existing gutters on the rear addition. She does not want to have to worry about water getting into the house every time it rains. Commissioner Erquiaga noted that the asphalt shingles and hanging gutters would adversely change the look of the house. Commissioner Horner stated that she agreed wi th Commissioner Sherayko and that she was aware of the problems Randolph and others have with their hidden gutters. They are not easy to maintain. Commissioner Arrington replied that her home has hidden gutters , which they had repaired. Since the repairs, they have had no problems with them. She asked if the proposal for the new gutters was for the entire home or just on the sides or back. Ms. Crites replied that it would be on the main house and not on the rear addition. Commissioner Arrington asked if they would be on the side of the house facing Rivermont. Ms. Crites replied yes. Commissioner Arrington asked if there was a possibility to compromise on that or to integrate the two gutter systems. Mr. George replied that they could install the downspouts on the sides of the home, so they were not directly in line of sight. Commissioner Arrington stated that you can still see the side of the home from Rivermont . She noted that the hidden gutters can be repaired. Commissioner Lifsey asked if it the leaks were just above the porch zone. Ms. Crites replied that the porch was in bad shape, but that the leaking was a problem throughout the whole house. Commissioner Lifsey asked if there was a gutter on the gabled piece in the front of the home. Mr. George replied there is not. Commissioner Lifsey noted that there is an angled molding at the edge of the roof and asked where the gutter would go. Mr. George replied that nothing would be removed. The gutters would be installed with a hidden hanger. Ms. Crites stated that the downspouts location would not be changed. Commissioner Lifsey asked if they would be using half-round gutters. Mr. George replied that they could do so. The rear addition has k-style gutters. Commissioner Lifsey asked if they would be putting in a wedge when installing the gutters. 3 Mr. George replied that they would do a wedge every two (2) feet to install properly. Commissioner Lifsey said that they would be covering up the historic trim of the house. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. There was no second. Commissioner Arrington reiterated that hidden gutters can be repaired. The Guidelines call for preservation and maintenance of the integrity of the home. Commissioner Horner replied that the hidden gutters have failed and need to be addressed practically. Commissioner Arrington replied that there is a difference between home repairs and a professional. There have been historic buildings recently restored with hidden gutters . This is a prominent home in front of the park. Commissioner Horner stated that the motion dies with no second. Commissioner Lifsey said that there is a fix for hidden gutters that would enable them to stay. Regular, good maintenance would fix the problem. Commissioner Horner noted that the Commission could table the application to allow the two (2) absent commissioners a chance to weigh in. Commissioner Lifsey said he would like to see additional information on the possibility of using EPDM. Commissioner Arrington agreed. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to table the application until the next meeting . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 b) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Mark Borel of Borel Construction Co., Inc. to modify a previously approved design for new construction at 1101 Harrison Street. (HPC2409-0002) Mr. Borel was present to represent the application. The newly constructed home on the property included several items that were not reviewed by the commission in the original plans. The first item he addressed was the front concrete sidewalk to the home. It connects the front door to the sidewalk and allows for ease of access. Commissioner Lifsey said that if it had been in the original plan, it would have likely been approved. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the front concrete sidewalk as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 4 Mr. Borel continued, a standing seam metal roof with snow guards was installed over the backdoor of the home. In the original plans , the back of the house was never addressed. Once constructed, it was just a door and looked “ugly” so he added the roof. Commissioner Erquiaga commented that the roof would have been approved if it had been on the original plan. Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the rear standing seam metal roof/awning as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Mr. Borel continued, the next item included the double door and concrete patio on the side of the home. In the original plans, the double door had been large windows with no patio. The doors have the same profile as the windows that were approved. The concrete patio was an afterthought. Commissioner Arrington made a motion to approve the side double door and concrete patio as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Mr. Borel continued, the fourth item was included in the letter that he wrote to commission . In the original plans there was a round window in the front gable. At that time, he had planned on putting in a shingle roof that allowed for a continuous vent. A metal roof does not have a continuous vent so he put in vents in at the front and back of the house to release the hot air out and that left no room for a window. Commissioner Lifsey asked Mr. Borel if he could have gotten a round vent. Mr. Borel said that he probably could have, but certain items take longer to get. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the vent looked out of position aesthetically, flushed up at the top. Mr. Borel said that he put it up as high as he could since hot air rises. Commissioner Lifsey said that he would have preferred to see it in a diamond shape. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the rectangular vents as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Mr. Borel continued, the last item included screening the gas tank and HVAC system on the side of the home. He asked the Commission if planting was acceptable as a form of screening. 5 Commissioner Arrington replied landscaping or fencing would work. Commissioner Lifsey added that diamond lattice would not be acceptable. Mr. Borel said that he preferred to landscape. He asked if the landscaping could mature over time. Commissioner Arrington replied that it didn’t need to be the full height upon installation. Mr. Borel asked if the plants could be eighteen (18) to twenty (20) inches from the units and three (3) bushes around both. Commissioner Lifsey replied that distance was fine. Discussion over number of plants ensued. Commissioner Arrington made a motion to approve the screening of the mechanical unit and propane tank with 10 evergreen bushes as discussed. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 Commissioner Lifsey noted that t he front columns of the home are different from what was ori ginally reviewed and approved by the Commission. Mr. Borel replied that the columns are round. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the columns were round, there were more of them, and they were significantly smaller. Mr. Borel replied that he drew eight s and the columns that were put in are six es. He can add three-quarter by three-quarter corner board to make it an inch and a half wider and give them more heft. The Commission shared agreement with this. c) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Shawn and Sar ah Hyska to install solar panels at 117 Madison Street. (HPC2409-0003) Mr. Shawn Hyska was present to represent the application . Mr. Ryan Gurga, a representative from Convert Solar, was also present . The plan is to install solar panels on the back and sid e of the roof to offset utility costs for the home. Commissioner Horner noted that the Commission received a letter from a neighbor. Commissioner Lifsey said that he had been by the home and that the panels in the back fall within the Guidelines. The seven (7) panels on the side roof can be seen briefly from the front of the home. He is supportive of the application. Commissioner Arrington replied she had a different interpretation of the Guidelines as it says not to be installed where visible. The panels would be very visible from Harrison Street. Commissioner Lifsey responded that Harrison Street is not the front street. 6 Commissioner Arrington agreed but said she interpreted it to mean that it should not be visible from any street. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the Commission has generally been more lenient for applications at the back of homes. Commissioner Erquiaga said there is a gray area as the Guidelines say “readily visible facades of a building”. Commissioner Lifsey replied that he attributed that to the primary street. Commissioner Erquiaga said he understood that, but the Guidelines do not specify that. If someone could see the panels out their front door then it is primary to them. Commissioner Lifsey replied the Commission has never said that in regards to windows. Commissioner Arrington replied that cases she could remember in which they made an exception were for houses that were very difficult to see from the street. There is a large difference between windows and solar panels. This is a prominent house in the neighborhood. The Commission does not receive many applications for solar panels. Commissioner Lifsey noted that he is excited that they have received one. Mr. Hyska stated that he looked for examples and there were very few. Commissioner Arrington responded th at th e language in the Guidelines is ambiguous . The National Park Service (NPS) encourages using secondary buildings with an emphasis on very low visibility. It is new technology and there is not a lot of precedence in this area. Commissioner Sherayko said that solar panels are a newer technology and he would like to see more of it . He noted the cost of utilities for larger historic homes. These panels would be located in a historic district and would be visible from the side and front street. He asked if the other commissioners would be more comfortable if the panels were located differently. Commissioner Lifsey replied there’s no street on the other side of the house. He asked if moving the location of the panels would be a viable option. Mr. Gurga replied that the southeast quadrant is the best performing array of the design. It would be a waste of money to put the panels elsewhere on the roof. The panels themselves are black on black and have a low profile. Commissioner Lifsey asked if rear array of panels could be enlarged. Mr. Gurga replied they could not because of setback laws. Commissioner Lifsey asked how much loss would happen if the side array was removed. Mr. Gurga responded it would drop the production from 10,705 Kilowatt hours to 7,324 Kilowatts hours Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko. Commissioner Horner asked if there was any more discussion. 7 Commissioner Arrington stated that the solar panels would disrupt the neighborhood significant ly, especially if the Commission were to begin approving solar panels for every large home in the area. It would take a lot from the character of the neighborhood and this one in particular is one of the oldest historic neighborhoods. Commissioner Erquiaga shared agreement and noted that the home is up on a hill so the solar panels will be very visible. Commissioner Horner suggested tabling the item. Commissioner Lifsey asked if they would come back with just the rear array if the item was tabled. Commissioner Arrington replied th at the rear panels were the biggest problem due to the high visibility of them, especially with the panels on a light-colored roof. Mr. Hyska said that they planned to paint the tin roof before the panels are installed and asked if the panels would be more acceptable with a darker roof color. Commissioner Arrington asked if the solar panels will impact the snow guards on the roof. Mr. Hyska replied th at the company would only have to remove a few of the snow guards . The panels are able to fit around most of them and won’t impact the functionality of the snow guards. Commissioner Sherayko said that solar panels are a difficult question for the commission and noted that two (2) of the other Commissioners were not present. Commissioner Lifsey asked Ms. Mergenthaler to reach out to other Certified Local Governments (CLGs) and find out how they treat solar panels in historic districts. That information could help inform the Commission’s decision. He withdrew his earlier motion for approval. Commissioner Sherayko withdrew his second. Commissioner Arrington asked if the solar panels could be placed on the ground. Mr. Gurga replied that they could not. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the application until the next meeting. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 d) ACTION (Advocate -Horner): Request of Linda Napier -King to do extensive work at 307 F Street. (HPC2409-0004) Ms. Linda Napier -King was present to represent the application. There will be major remodeling work done on the exterior of the home. All wood siding that is damaged w ill be replaced with new board and batten siding to match . The roof w ill be replaced with a slight increase in pitch as the roof is too flat currently to drain properly. The existing porch poles will be repaired and remain. The two rear doors in close proximity to each other will be turned into patio doors with windows. A rear window will be reopened and restored. It is currently covered. Commissioner Sherayko asked if there was a garage door in the right corner of the house. 8 Ms. Napier-King replied no that it was paneled wood. Commissioner Sherayko asked about the condition of the inside of the home. Ms. Napier-King replied that the inside was just as challenging as the outside, but there was good space on the inside. She planned on making living space in the above ground basement and that is why she requested the French doors. She also plans to widen the existing concrete patio to a six (6) by six (6) square at the back of the house outside of the doors. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the patio doors could be wood paneling at the bottom and glass at the top. Ms. Napier-King replied she was not opposed to that, but that having wood near the ground and vegetation brings about damage. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the existing doors are the original doors. Ms. Napier King respond ed that the original doors are in the basement of the home, but they are worn and not restorable. Commissioner Lifsey said that full glass doors with metal frames would not fit with the home. Ms. Napier-King said that she would look for a door with wood at the bottom and glass at the top . The goal is to also bring more light into the basement. Commissioner Lifsey stated that enlarging the concrete slab in the back was no problem. Ms. Napier-King said there is a window in the basement that looks out from underneath the front porch and she would like to close that opening. She plans to put a vertical skirt around the bottom of the porch. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the skirt would be lattice. Ms. Napier-King replied it would be wood. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the porch seemed to sag in the center and may need support underneath. Ms. Napier-King replied she would be putting in eight (8) supports underneath the porch. At the rear of the home she would like to install a metal awning to go over the basement doors. It would match the color of the metal roof. Commissioner Horner replied the commission would have to see the awning before approving it. Ms. Napier-King asked if it was acceptable to replace the metal roof. Commissioner Lifsey replied that standing seam replacement in-kind was fine. Ms. Napier-King asked if it had to be the snap metal. Commissioner Lifsey replied that it would need to match the existing profile. Ms. Napier-King asked if she could not do the fold over. Commissioner Lifsey responded that she will want to do tha t as the fold over is what keeps the water from getting in. 9 Ms. Napier-King asked if she could expand an existing cement sidewalk on the right side of the home and turn it into a driveway and put a new sidewalk in at the middle of the house. Commissioner Lifsey said that it did not seem against the Guidelines, but Ms. Napier-King will need to submit another application with more details. Commissioner Erquiaga questioned if there is enough room for a driveway. Ms. Napier-King replied that she will get a surveyor to determine the property lines. Commissioner Sherayko noted that the driveway could not be asphalt. Ms. Napier-King replied that the driveway would be concrete. Commissioner Lifsey asked if she planned on using a light blue color for the whole porch. Ms. Napier-King responded no, that the house would be white and the trim, bannisters, and wrap around the windows would be blue -green. She would also like to have the blue -green on the raised strip on the board and batten siding. Commissioner Lifsey responded historically the board and batten would be all white. Ms. Napier-King asked if the Commission was completely against painting the raised strip a different color. Commissioner Lifsey replied the Guidelines would be against it. Ms. Napier-King stated that in that case, she wanted to change the color scheme . The house would be blue- green and the trim would be white. The roof would be charcoal gray. Commissioner Lifsey re sponded that a gray or black roof would be acceptable. He asked what architectural style the house falls under. Ms. Mergenthaler said that the house was listed as “other” or “workers cottage”. Commissioner Arrington asked if there was a color sample included in the application. Ms. Napier replied there was not, but she had a photo of the color. Commissioner Sherayko asked if the porch railing and posts would be white. Ms. Napier-King replied she was unsure. Ms. Mergenthaler asked if she was ready to paint now. Ms. Napier-King said she was not and that she could come back with color samples in a later application. Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement and recommen ded including the colors in the sam e application as the rear awning and the driveway. Ms. Mergenthaler stated that the Commission had not yet talked about the porch railing, trex decking, or the front door. Ms. Napier-King said she would like a front door with glass in it to bring more light into the house. 10 Commissioner Lifsey responded that she could include a front door with the next application. The front door should fit with the cottage style. Ms. Napier-King said she was looking at antique doors. Commissioner Lifsey stated that trex decking had been approved by the Commission before. Ms. Napier-King said that she is still deciding whe ther or not she wants to use trex decking . If she uses it, it will be in a charcoal gray color. If she does not, she will redo the porch with wood and paint it an appropriate color. Commissioner Horner asked if the proposed railing was previously installed on the porch. Ms. Napier-King replied that there was no railing installed when she purchased the home. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the porch railing as shown ; replacement of the front porch decking with trex decking in a gray color; standing seam metal roof replacement in a gray or black color with an increase in front porch r oof pitch; expansion of the rear concrete patio to six (6) by six (6) ; removal of the window under the front porch; and restoration of the existing window in the rear that is currently covered. The doors, canopy /awning, sidewalk, driveway, and paint colors are to be submitted in a subsequent application . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Alexander, Langseth 2 4. NEXT MEETING DAY: The next regular meeting is scheduled for October 21, 2024. 5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:40 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.