RecordWell Data

Minutes (July)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Jul 15, 2024 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of July 15, 2024 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Julie Arrington Shanda Horner, Chair Tracey Langseth Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair Emmett Lifsey OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission , Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. ANNUAL BUSINESS Commissioner Sherayko nominated Commissioner Horner to be Chair. The nomination was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Commissioner Arrington nominated Commissioner Erquiaga to be Vice-Chair. The nomination was seconded by commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 There were no revisions to the bylaws or historic district advocacies. 2. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Arrington made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote. 3. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (No Advocate): Request of Gospel Community Church to install a sign and mailbox at 1101 Floyd Street. (HPC2407-0001) Mr. Steve Timmons, Director of Facilities for Gospel Community Church, Inc. was present to represent the application. A new tenant is leasing a portion of the building and they frequently send and receive mail. A 2 dark locking mailbox will be placed inside th e alley near the door and will blend into the existing black metal fence. A sign will also be installed on four by four (4x4) posts to the left of the the door. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 b) ACTION (Advo cate-Arrington): Request of Gospel Community Church to extend an existing fence and close a wall opening at 1301 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2407 -0002) Mr. Steve Timmons, Director of Facilities for Gospel Community Church, Inc. was present to represent the application. Hill City Montessori School is the tenant for this portion of the building. These doors are used to access the playground at the corner of Ruffner Place and Rivermont Avenue. For the safety of the children, the existing fence will be extended with a four (4) foot tall fence and include a double gate in front of the doors. The existing chain link fence is five (5) feet tall. The gate is needed to maintain ADA access. The air conditioner between the windows will be removed and the opening will be fil led to match the existing brick wall. Chair Horner asked what the material of the fence will be. Mr. Timmons replied that it will be black chain link to match the existing fencing. Commissioner Sherayko noted that there is already chain link fencing on the property. Extending the fence with another material may look awkward. Commissioner Langseth noted that the extension will go in front of the doors. She understands the need for the extension. Commissioner Arrington stated that she understands the a pplicant is trying to match the existing fencing but the Design Review G uidelines state that chain link fences are not considered appropriate and would not be approved except for repairs to existing non -conforming fences. She asked if there is a possibilit y of using a different material in the same color. Commissioner Sherayko noted that the existing chain link fence most likely predates the historic district designation. He understands that chain link is not appropriate per the Guidelines but the extensi on of the fence with a different material may look worse. The extension is only a few more feet of fencing. He is willing to make an exception in this case. He noted the varying height of the fence. Commissioner Arrington noted that the variation in heigh t may lend more reasoning to use a different material. Commissioner Alexander asked why the applicant wants to use chain link fencing. Mr. Timmons responded that chain link was chosen to match the existing fencing. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 4 3 NOES: Arrington 1 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Lifsey, Erquiaga 2 c) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Lynchburg Covenant Fellowship, Inc. to replace a portion of the front porch at 412 Madison Street. (HPC2407-0003) Ms. Connie Snavely, Executive Director of Lynchburg Covenant Fellowship and Mr. Gary Harvey, Interim Board President and the Principal and Senior Architect with Architectural Partners were present to represent the application. The existing porch decking and some framing will be replaced. The decking will be replaced with Aeratis Traditions tongue and groove porch flooring and will be painted. Commissioner Sherayko commented that the porch must be in a worse condition than it looks in the photo as this is not an inexpensive solution. Ms. Snavely responded that the structure is rotten underneath, the size of the porch is a factor, and they want to do the entire porch at once. Commissioner Arrington made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Lifsey, Erquiaga 2 d) ACTION (Advocate-Arrington): Request of Kevin and N ancy Brandt to do extensive work at 2021 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2407-0004) Mr. Kevin Brandt was present to represent the application. The proposed work will return the property to a more appropriate condition and is shown on the concept plan . Previous chan ges to the property include: the installation of a n aluminum fence at the front and side ; removal of a stone wall , front concrete walk, and concrete retaining wall; installation of a front pea gravel driveway; and changes to the grading. Some of the propos ed work includes: the installation of a segmented block retaining wall to replace the previous concrete wall; installation of patio, walkways, and stairs; and removal of the pea gravel drive and aluminum fence. Commissioner Arrington commended him on the work they have done to the house. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Lifsey, Erquiaga 2 e) ACTION (Advocate-Lifsey): Request of Mark Smith of MWSmith-Architect, on behalf of St. John’s Episcopal Church, to paint the building at 24 77 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2407 - 0005) Mr. Mark Smith , MWSmith-Architect and Mr. Neal Davidson , on behalf of St. John’s Episcopal Church , were present to represent the application. The church wants to paint the old BB&T building to match the 4 colors of the ch urch. The building is a noncontributing structure and is now part of St. John’s campus. The original church is painted brick and the additions from the 1950s are also painted brick. The old BB&T building has non -historic brick. It is hard fired with Portla nd cement mortar, so painting it will not cause the same moisture issues. Included in the submittal are some cut sheets for mineral based masonry paint, which is typically used for porous bricks. The church will do a test for moisture content and if there are moisture concerns, the mineral based paint will be applied. Both the body and trim colors will match the colors of the church. Commissioner Arrington asked if any alternatives to painting had been considered to make this building more cohesive with the church. Mr. Smith replied that there were no other viable suggestions . The church members had a lot of ideas but they did not fit the building. He contacted other architects who agreed that painting the building was a good option. Commissioner Arri ngton expressed concern over painting of the brick . She does not want to set a precedent for that area and noted that the two (2) buildings are different architectural styles. Painting the trim to match would help the building blend with the church. Commissioner Langseth acknowledged the points made by both Commissioner Arrington and the applicant. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Commissioner Sherayko expressed appreciation for the additional details included in the submittal. He noted that the building was not originally considered contributing but is now over fifty (50) years old. The motion to approve was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 4 NOES: Arrington 1 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 f) ACTION (Advocate -Arrington): Request of Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co., on behalf of Across the Bridge, LLC, to do extensive work at 465 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2407-0006) Mr. Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co. was present to represent the application . In-kind repairs have been previously approved. This application i ncludes repairing as much of the wood siding and shingles as possible and replacing them with fiber cement on the back and side ; painting in a new color scheme ; replacing missing windows to match existing; and adding parking at the rear off of an existing shared driveway. The parking area will include landscape buffers. Commissioner Sherayko expressed excitement that the property will be painted in a new color scheme. He noted that the proposed work is similar to previous projects in this area that have come forward and were approved. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote. AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 5 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 g) ACTION (Advocate -Arrington): Request of Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co., on behalf of Westla, LLC, to do extensive work at 1705 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2407 -0007) Mr. Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co. was present to represent the application. This property has a noncontributing apartment complex with four (4) existing structures that are painted CMU block. The project is still in the design phase but there will be t hirty-two (32) apartments total. The proposed work includes cladding the buildings with new lap siding and shingle gables; tearing down the existing concrete porches; reconfiguring the building circulation; adding new porches; adding a few new doors; keeping windows where they are, but lowering the sills to put in bigger windows ; and repairing existing walkways and parking. Commissioner Sherayko commended the fact that they are improving the buildings. Commissioner Alexander asked if the Commission was okay with the windows being enlarged. Commissioner Sherayko responded that the structure is noncontributing. Chair Horner shared agreement. Commissioner Arrington asked about the new paint colors and the roof color. Mr. Servis responded that the paint colors are shown on the plans. The roof color will be charcoal or slate gray. If the paint colors change, they will resubmit. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The Motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 h) ACTION (Advocate -Horner): Request of Shan non Rudelis of LillyLu Homes, LLC to do extensive work at 312 F Street. (HPC2407-0008) Ms. Shannon Rudelis of LillyLu Homes, LLC was present to represent the application. Proposed work includes: repainting and reinstalling s hutters found in the crawlspace ; replacing the second -floor door with a decorative stained -glass window; painting the exterior in a new color scheme to match the stained-glass window; and replacing door hardware. She acknowledged that she bought the house quickly and did not look into the historic status of the property until after she owned it. Commissioner Sherayko noted that the outline for the shutters are visible in older photos so they should be reinstalled. He then asked about the second-floor door. Ms. Rudelis responded that the door had to be removed because there were water issues. Commissioner Sherayko stated that there was previously a window in place of the door as seen in the older photograph. Commissioner Arrington asked if the mismatched front window will be replaced as part of this application. 6 Ms. Rudelis responded that it will not. She purchased the property with that window already in place. Before she knew the property was historic, she was planning to replace with all vinyl windows but is now having the existin g wood windows restored. She noted that neighboring properties seem to have vinyl windows and other non-historic aspects to them. Commissioner Arrington stated that restored wood windows will last much longer than vinyl windows. Ms. Rudelis added that she is paying much more than she would have for vinyl windows. Commissioner Sherayko stated that vinyl windows often fail and have a fog in them and need to be replaced with frequency. Chair Horner and Commissioner Arrington shared agreement. Commissioner Arrington noted that the neighboring properties may have had non -historic work done prior to the area becoming a historic district. She experienced a similar issue with her own historic house. Ms. Rudelis stated that F Street is a side street and there is nothing historic about it. Commissioner Sherayko noted that replacing the second -floor door with a window would be approvable but questioned replacing it with the proposed stained-glass window. Ms. Rudelis stated that the proposed color scheme of th e house is centered completely around the proposed decorative window. Commissioner Sherayko asked if the decorative window would fill the entire space. Ms. Rudelis responded that it would not. T he decorative window is smaller than it appear s in the image. It measures 28 ¾ wide x 30 ¾ tall. Commissioner Langseth asked about the comparison of sizes between the decorative window and the existing windows. Chair Horner responded that it is smaller. Commissioner Langseth stated that the stain ed-glass window would not be in keeping with the original window and so it would not be in line with the Design Review Guidelines. Chair Horner shared agreement. It is not appropriate. Ms. Rudelis reiterated her opinion that this is a side street with nothing historic. Commissioner Langseth reiterated her position on the decorative window. Commissioner Arrington stated that the photo shows that the long side windows remained in place around both the window and the door that replaced it. A smaller window in that space would not be appropriate. The proposed window is also very ornate. Changes need to be appropriate for the style of the house. Ms. Rudelis stated that the proposed parking pad will be made of brick pavers and will be big enough for one car. 7 Commissioner Alexander asked where it will be located. Ms. Rudelis replied that the parking pad will be located on the left side of the front of the property. Chair Horner asked if there was on-street parking. Ms. Rudelis said that there is on-street parking , but th at it is difficult given the slope . The previous owners were using the area for parking but only had gravel in place. The brick pavers will be an improvement and blend with the brick foundation. Commissioner Langseth noted that the Guidelines call for rear or side parking. Commissioner Arrington asked if there was slate or another material under the gravel. Ms. Rudelis responded that there is only gravel in place. She reiterated that it is difficult to park on the street. Commissioner Sherayko asked if there was anywhere to park in the back or on the side. Ms. Rudelis replied that there is not . The proposed lighting will be for the back. There is an existing center light in the front that will be replaced with a matching light. Commissioner Langset h made a motion to approve the shutters as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Commissioner Arrington made a motion to deny the request to replace the second -floor door with a decorative stained-glass window. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Commissioner Arrington noted that the Guidelines use clear langu age. A nything that is original to the front can be redone. Parking that is not original should not be added to the front. Commissioner Sherayko stated that he is conflicted. The Guidelines are clear but the on -street parking is on a steep slope. Chair Horner noted that she did not have any difficulty parking when she visited the property. Ms. Rudelis responded that parking is okay for one (1) car on the incline but if there is more than one (1) car it becomes even more difficult. Commissioner Sherayko noted that he would be willing to approve the parking pad in this instance. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the parking pad as submitted. 8 Commissioner Alexander asked if the owners could park in the space without the brick parking pad. Ms. Rudelis responded that the previous owners had been parking multiple cars in front of the house, even in areas without gravel. It is likely future homeowners will continue to park in that area. Commissioner Arrington noted that the Commission should consider previous, similar applications. Commissioner Sherayko withdrew his motion to approve. Commissioner Alexander asked about alternate materials. Commissioner Arrington responded that it is a location issue, not a material issue. Ms. Rudelis e xpressed her dissatisfaction with the direction of conversation and the state of the historic homes on F Street. She reiterated her opinion that her opinion that this is a side street with nothing historic. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that this home wa s originally located on Cabell Street and then moved to its current location. It is a historic structure. Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification that the other structures on F Street are not historic. Ms. Mergenthaler responded that the area is located in the local historic district. Ms. Rudelis continued to express her dissatisfaction. Commissioner Arrington responded that the Guidelines would apply to the other properties on F Street. Ms. Rudelis reiterated that the incline makes the on -street parking more difficult and less desirable to homeowners. Commissioner Arrington responded that she is sympathetic to the difficulty of on -street parking. Future homeowners will need to consider the location of the house before they buy it and what c an or cannot be done. Commissioner Arrington made a motion to deny the parking pad. Ms. Mergenthaler suggested tabling the item so that the absent commissioners could weigh in on the matter. Commissioner Arrington withdrew her motion to deny. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to table the parking pad until the next meeting . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Discussion regarding work done without approval versus work done prior to the historic district being established ensued. 9 Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the lighting as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Commissioner Arrington made a motion to approve painting scheme as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 i) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Dwayne Martin of Uprising Restorations S.D., LLC to do extensive work at 712 Hancock Street. (HPC2407-0009) Mr. Dwayne Martin of Uprising Restorations S.D., LLC was present to represent the application. The project will be a full remodel. On the lower level: t he rear side door will be removed from the side of the home and a French door will be installed at the r ear; the previous location of the side door will be converted into a window ; and a kitchen window w ill be shortened to allow for a kitchen sink . On the second floor, a w indow was proposed to be removed but he plans to keep it. Other work includes removing a window to allow for a bathroom. Chair Horner asked about proposed materials. Mr. Martin responded that some work was already done on the house and that the windows had already been replaced with vinyl prior to his purchase of the home. The front door will be replaced with a wooden one and the back French doors would be fiberglass. Commissioner Arrington asked if the French doors will be full panes. Mr. Martin stated that they would be full pane French doors. Commissioner Arrington asked about the design of the windows in the house. Mr. Martin stated that we would use the windows already installed as they had just been replaced before he purchased the home. Commissioner Sherayko asked for clarification about shortening the side kitchen window and removing the window upstairs. Mr. Martin showed where the windows were located. Commissioner Sherayko confirmed that the windows are not located on the front of the structure. Chair Horner asked about the front porch railing. Mr. Martin stated that the r ailing will be replaced in-kind to match the existing railing. The existing railing has rotted. 10 Chair Horner expressed concern over the second-floor deck. Commissioner Arrington noted that her house originally had a second-floor deck. Mr. Martin stated that it will be located at the rear of the home and will not be visible from the road. Chair Horner stated that it is a major modification and looks modern. Commissioner Arrington asked about extending the deck all the way across the structure to match the length of the front porch. Mr. Martin responded that is an option if the Commission wants that. The deck will be accessible from the bedroom. Commissioner Langseth asked about the visibility of the windows being modified. Mr. Martin replied that th e kitchen window, which will be shortened, has some visibility but there is essentially none for the window that will be removed. Commissioner Sherayko noted that he feels the windows are approvable but is questioning the deck. Commissioner Arrington rea d from the Design Review G uidelines. Porches are preferred to decks, but decks are acceptable at the rear facades of the building . Decks should be stained or painted to match or blend with the building and should be simple rather than ornate. Balusters should be square. Chair Horner expressed concern over the deck being on the second floor and that the design looks very modern. Commissioners Langseth and Arrington responded that the guidelines do not dictate that the deck has to be on the lower level. Mr. Martin stated that the deck was shortened so that it would be less visible from the street. Chair Horner asked about materials and colors for the deck. Mr. Martin responded that the deck and railings would be wood and he has not decided on colors yet. He plans to add one (1) light fixture to the front and two (2) light fixtures at the rear. Commissioner Arrington stated that the proposed light fixture is too ornate for the house. It should be simpler and match the examples in the Guidelines. Mr. Martin stated the patio will be located at the rear of the home. The fence will be a six-foot-tall wood privacy fence. It will also be located at the rear and will be painted. The retaining wall is necessary to protect the home from future damage and erosion. He will submit a new application when he has chosen paint colors. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to allow administrative approval, if possible, for a future submittal of light fixtures and paint colors . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Sherayko 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 11 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the remainder of the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Langseth, Sherayko 4 NOES: Horner 1 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Erquiaga, Lifsey 2 4. NEXT MEETING DAY: The next regular meeting is scheduled for August 19, 2024. 5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:34 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.