Minutes (April)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Apr 15, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of April 15, 2024
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair
Shanda Horner, Chair
Tracey Langseth
Emmett Lifsey
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Julie Arrington
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Langseth made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by
Commissioner Erquiaga, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Alec Gilman of Gilman & Associates, LLC, on
behalf of Sylvia Johnson, to expand a deck and relocate a staircase at 507 13th Street.
(HPC2404-0001)
Mr. Alec Gilman of Gilman & Associates, LLC was present to represent the application. The property owner
would like to change the shape of the existing deck to be more rectangular and the staircase will be moved
to the other side. The existing pvc boards will be removed and the new material will be wood.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if the deck and stairs will be painted.
Mr. Gilman replied that the wood needs time to age before it can be painted.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Lauren Smyk of Jamerson-Lewis Construction,
Inc., on behalf of AHC Investments, LLC, to replace a front porch roof at 1312 Church
Street. (HPC2404-0002)
Ms. Lauren Smyk, a project manager for Jamerson-Lewis Construction, Inc., was present to represent the
application. The proposal is to replace the front porch roof with a composite terra cotta in a “Desert Red”
color. The rotten wood will also be removed and replaced.
2
Commissioner Erquiaga thanked the applicant for her work on the project.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
c) ACTION (Advocate-Arrington): Request of Joshua Dugan to install a privacy fence at
1312 & 1314 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2404-0003)
Mr. Joshua Dugan was present to represent the application. The rear of the property has been landscaped
and he would like to install a dog ear, wood privacy fence. The fence will have a four - to six-foot height
depending on where it is installed. There will also be several gates installed to provide access to the rear.
Discussion about the allowable fence height ensued.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
d) ACTION (Advocate-Arrington): Request of Ryan Plice to install a privacy fence at 1310
Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2404-0004)
Mr. Ryan Plice was present to represent the application. He wants to install a dog ear, wood privacy fence
to match his neighbor, Mr. Dugan. They plan to share the portion of the fence that runs between their
properties. The fence will adjoin the existing retaining wall.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
e) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Aaron Boyce to install a picket fence with an
arch gate and replace the roof and gutters at 1419 Clay Street. (HPC2404-0005)
Mr. Aaron Boyce was present to represent the application. A 3½ foot tall, wood picket fence will be installed
at the sides and rear of the property. There is an existing retaining wall that runs through the yard and the
fence will also be installed on top of that. An arch and gate will be installed and will go with the picket
fence. The roof will be replaced with charcoal black CertainTeed Landmark shingles. The existing roof has
brown asphalt shingles.
Commissioner Erquiaga asked for more information regarding the arched gate.
3
Mr. Boyce responded that the arch and gate will blend with the picket fence. The arch will be wood and
most likely have lattice sides. The gate will be inside of the arch, be able to swing out, connected to the
arch with a hinge, and have the same pickets as the fence.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if the fence will be painted.
Mr. Boyce replied that the fence will be stained.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitte d. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
f) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co., on behalf
of R. Mark Bogia, to construct a rear addition at 315 E Street. (HPC2404-0006)
Mr. Casey Servis of Servis Architecture Co. was present to represent the application. This structure is
noncontributing to the district. It is approximately seven hundred fifty (750) square feet and was previously
CMU block. The house has since been worked on and now has fiber -cement siding. The current owner
would like to construct a prim ary suite addition at the rear to achieve more living space. The existing
ceilings are low, so a shed roof style is proposed for the addition. It will still remain below the existing
ridgeline to reduce visibility from the street.
Chair Horner noted that this is the only structure that fronts on that portion of E Street and that the existing
windows are vinyl.
Commissioner Alexander asked how big the addition is.
Mr. Servis replied that the proposed addition is approximately four hundred (400) square feet.
Chair Horner stated that it would be an improvement for the owner to have more living space.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
g) ACTION (Advocate-Lifsey): Request of Mark Smith of MWSmith-Architect, on behalf of St.
John’s Episcopal Church, to do extensive work at 2477 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2404 -
0007)
Mr. Mark Smith of MWSmith -Architect and Mr. Neal Davidson were present to represent the application.
The church bought this p roperty and plan to use it as a youth house and community center with a
playground. The structure was constructed in 1972 and previously used as a bank. It is noncontributing to
the district. The proposed changes will improve the structure, depart from the bank fe el of the building,
and make the church campus co hesive. Proposed changes include painting the brick exterior a
complimentary color to the church, which is also painted brick. There are a number of other brick buildings
in the area that are also painted, so this change would not be out of character . The Elmwood Avenue
entrance will be removed and replaced by curb and gutter, sidewalk, grass , and a playground. The
4
playground will be enclosed by a six (6) foot metal fenc e. Two (2) types of fen cing are proposed for
approval and the church will make a final decision on which one to use later. A new asphalt connection will
be installed between the existing parking lot and the church parking lot, which will allow better traffic flow.
The mechanical equipment will be enclosed by either a lattice or picket e nclosure. It will be made of Azek
or a PVC material with a low sheen f inish. The drive thru area will be replaced by either a sunroom or an
outdoor patio area. The roof and columns will remain in place. If the church chooses the patio area, it will
be enclosed by a steel fence to create a buffe r. The teller window will be replaced by a door and a new
window will be installed to the left of the area. The sunroom option also includes a new window to the left
of the area. The surrounding landscaping will be cleaned up and make the site more welcoming. Some of
the existing post lighting will be relocated when the parking areas are reconfigured.
Commissioner Sherayko asked how the parking area will change.
Mr. Smith responded that the parking to the right of the structure will rema in the same. At the rear of the
structure, the parking will be reduced to accommodate the playground and the new connection to the
Church parking area. A walkway will be installed to connect the church and the playground. An ADA ramp
of brick pavers or concrete will be installed at the front of the structure.
Commissioner Langseth asked about access.
Mr. Smith replied that the playground will have two (2) gates. The church walkway to the playground is
just for the day school use. There is an existing sidewalk near the rear of the struc ture that can be used
by the community. The youth house can be accessed through the parking lot if the playground is occupied.
Chair Horner noted that this is a big project for the church.
Commissioner Sherayko asked what the Design Review Guidelines say about painting brick.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler read an excerpt from the Guidelines.
Mr. Smith noted that the Guidelines are for historic brick. This structure is noncontributing and painting the
brick will make the structure cohesive with the church and less bank like. There is also context across the
street for painting brick.
Chair Horner stated that painting the brick would help the structure match the church and soften its
appearance. Many structures across the street are painted brick
Commissioner Langseth shared agreement and noted t hat the Guidelines allow mismatched brick to be
painted.
Commissioner Sherayko noted that the post office and the apartments are not painted. There is a mix of
brick that is painted and not painted. He is conflicted as to whether this structure should be painted based
on the Guidelines.
Chair Horner reiterated that the structure is not co ntributing so there is some leniency in applying the
Guidelines.
Commissioner Erquiaga asked about the age of the church and whether there have been issues with the
brick being painted.
Mr. Davidson responded that he believes the church is around 100 years old.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that painting brick affects the porosity of the brick and the way moisture moves.
It could create mold issues.
5
Mr. Smith responded that he understands that would happen with historic brick and lime mortar. This brick
is from the 1970s, hard fired, clay brick, with Portland cement mortar, and most likely has a vapor barrier
on the inside. It is a more modern construction.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that he is not in support of painting the brick. Everything else proposed for the
project looks great and he is glad the church is going to work on the property rather than it sitting vacant.
There are other things that can be done to make the structure look less like a bank without painting it.
Chair Horner stated that she would feel similar if this were a stand alone building . She feels differently
given the context , the effort to blend the building into the church campus , and the fact that it is a
noncontributing structure.
Commissioner Langseth shared agreement.
Chair Horner asked what material the new window will be.
Mr. Smith responded that it would be aluminum clad, white, and have the same muntin pattern as the
existing windows.
Commissioner Langseth mad e a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was not
seconded.
Commissioner Alexander noted that there are conflicting opinions. He asked if there w as anything other
than painting that the Church could do to reduce the bank look of the structure.
Mr. Smith responded that this has been discussed with the church. They would like to make the structure
inviting from Rivermont and make it part of the church campus. Color is significant in this approach.
Commissioner Sherayko asked if the Commissioner’s opinions would be different if the application came
from a different applicant, like a bagel shop.
Commissioner Langseth stated that she is willing to allow the painted brick given the presentation, the
context, the use in sense of the campus, and the status of noncontributing regardless of the applicant.
Chair Horner shared agreement.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve all items as submitted except the painting . The
motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the painting as submitted . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Alexander and failed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Horner, Langseth 3
NOES: Erquiaga, Lifsey, Sherayko 3
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
Commissioner Lifsey stated that even without painting the brick the structure will still be part of the church.
The drive thru will be removed, a portico could be added, signs will be installed, and the day to day activity
6
will all show that it is part of the church. College campuses, for example, are very diverse and still look like
a campus. If the brick is painted, it could unintentionally encourage others to paint their brick buildings.
Commissioner Langseth re sponded that this application is in relation to the church campus. Color is a
powerful connection and the structure is noncontributing. The Commission could have voted to approve it.
Chair Horner shared agreement and noted that it is a mistake to not approve it.
Mr. Davidson stated that this is a huge project for the church . There have been many opinions regarding
how to move forward. The one thing all of the parishioners agree on is painting the building so that it looks
the same as the church.
Discussion regarding next steps ensued.
3. OLD BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Alexander): Request of James Jean Louis Jeune to do extensive
work at 1014 Jackson Street. (HPC2402-0006)
Mr. James Jean Louis Jeune was not present to represent the application.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that window measurements were taken from the neighboring house and
included a range of original sizes. The applicant submitted a window quote from Lowes f or replacement
arch windows. The proposed replacement windows show simulated divided lite (SDL) with a spacer. The
location of each proposed window was not indicated.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the proposed replacement windows did not match the origi nal windows.
The original windows had a flat arch rather than a half arch. There is a dramatic difference.
Ms. Mergenthaler continued that the applicant did not submit any new information for the rectangular
windows or for the front door.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the Commission previously approved replacing windows using the original
openings.
Ms. Mergenthaler responded that the window openings have been altered beyond using the original
openings.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that the Commission’s approval of the initial application was to keep the original
openings in place and to find new windows or sashes that would fit in those openings. That has been
completely ignored. The applicant should rebuild as close as possible to the original windows and openings.
Commissioner Langseth asked if there is a way for the applicant to use the photos of the original windows
to calculate the original sizing.
Commissioner Lifsey shared agreement that the applicant could approximate sizing using the photos.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to deny the replacement arch windows . The motion to deny
was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
7
Commissioner Lifsey noted that the applicant previously discussed merging the existing front doors into
one (1) front door.
Discussion ensued regarding the feasibility of merging the doors or building a new door in the image of the
original doors.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the two (2) doors could remain separate.
Commissioner Langseth noted that the shape of the transom needs to be corrected to match the original.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the reconditioning of the historic front doors into a
functioning format, either as two (2) independent leaves or one (1) leaf, and the transom to be restored
as original. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga.
Commissioner Erquiaga noted that the Guidelines do not address a situation like this.
Commissioner Lifsey responded that merging the original leaves into one (1) would still preserve the visual
of the two (2) front doors when closed.
Commissioner Lifsey revised his motion to approve the restoration of the two (2) front door leaves
or the construction of two (2) new leaves to match and the restoration of the transom as
original. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to deny the rectangular replacement windows, the altered
window openings, and the altered window locations . The motion to deny was seconded by
Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Arrington 1
4. NEXT MEETING DAY:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for May 20, 2024.
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:12 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.