RecordWell Data

Housing Advisory Committee Meeting — Minutes

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Housing Advisory Committee · meeting of Nov 12, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Page 1 of 5 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE To be a place where everyone thrives. Housing Advisory Committee Wednesday, November 12, 2025, noon Location: 100 Fifth Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902 CitySpace - Large Conference Room HAC Members Present: • Joy Johnson, Chair, Affordable Housing Beneficiary (JJ) • Sunshine Mathon, Vice Chair, Non- profit - Piedmont Housing Alliance (SM) • Mike Parisi, Secretary, At-Large (MCP) • Rich Bard, Affordable Housing Beneficiary (RB) • Heather Griffith, Real Estate Professional (HG) • Peppy Linden, At-Large (PL) • Michael Payne, City Councilor (MP) • Dan Rosensweig, Non-profit - Habitat for Humanity (DR) • Nicole Scro, Real Estate Professional (NS) HAC Members Absent: • Phil d'Oronzio, Real Estate Professional (PdO) • John Sales, Non-profit - Charlottesville Redevelopment & Housing Authority (JS) Staff Attendees: • Madelyn Metzler, Acting Housing Program Manager, Neighborhood Development Services (MM) Online Attendees: • Wendy Gao, Public Housing Association of Residents (PHAR) • Kathleen Glenn-Matthews, CRHA • Paul Reeder, city resident 1. Welcome SM: Calls meeting to order 12:05pm. 2. Introductions and Attendance 3. Staff Updates MM: Not a lot of updates, last HAC meeting 3 weeks ago. Going to Council next month re: CSRAP (Charlottesville Supplementary Rental Assistance Program), amendments. NS: Has HUD’s Fair Market Rent figure gone up or down? MM: Not marked for change right now. Page 2 of 5 MCP: FMR released in August, 1 bedroom ~$1600, 2 bedroom $1800, 3 bedroom $2200. MM: CAHF (Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund) applications are open, workshop for applicants last week. Not as many applicants as for HOPS (Housing Operations and Program Support grant program) typically. Receiving Kindlewood and CRHA applications, JPA and Ivy student housing buildings. Shows City’s Development Dashboard with current and upcoming projects. Not shown is Vista29 by SupportWorks (formerly Virginia Supportive Housing) at Premier Circle site. PL: Did City Council vote on CRHA director being able to designate a proxy representative to attend HAC meetings? MM: Not on Council agenda right now. JJ: Not enough orgs focused on deep affordability right now. Only CRHA, PHA, HfH. Not enough units available that accept housing vouchers. If someone loses a voucher, likely to become homeless. SM: In talking with City Manager Sam Sanders (SS), using example of 501 Cherry Avenue project which has 30%, 50%, 60% AMI units. 30% AMI is 10% of all units. Applied to CAHF for money to buy down debt in order to bring 60% AMI units to 30% AMI at a cost of $150,000 per unit. Got funding for 2 units at $250,000. Similar request for MACAA project. SS wanted to know how much it costs to go from various levels of AMIs, 60% to 50% etc. Made spreadsheet with amounts, $60-130k per unit (one time payments), depends on bedroom type. Hoping to spur conversation with City Council about creating deeper affordability. MM: City Council holding an Affordable Housing Work Session in December. Also reviewing proposals from 3 consultants re: Housing Department reorganization, Kellie Brown (KB) NDS Director is leading. What are the typical staffing, skills, activities of housing departments in similar sized cities? Primary activity in here in Cville is grant management, CSRAP program. DR: How much time is spent reviewing quarterly reports? Not much changes in between quarterly reports. Interesting to put all review obligations on the table, what is statutory, what is Council action, can we help staff free up time? SM: Comments from reviewers due at the end of this week. RFP timeline consultant has ~8 weeks, timeline mid-Q1 work completion (Feb, Mar). MM: Three more housing funding agreements need to be developed in next 6 months, but that staff member is no longer here. Complexity and knowledge required not on staff at present. 4. Agenda a. October 15, 2025, Regular HAC Meeting Minutes Approved Page 3 of 5 b. Review of FY2025 HAC Annual Work Calendar MM: Reviews Workplan items One update, HAC did fill an affordable housing beneficiary slot (member Rich Bard), but not as a result of recruitment as described in workplan. MP: Memo from City Attorney re: payments to board members, but no timeline. MM: Changes to ADU Manual haven’t gone to City Council yet, but going through another round of changes re: in-lieu fee structures. NS: Confusing on website what the latest ADU Manual is. Could use a redline version to show changes. MM: Can fix that broken link. DR: Distinction between ADU Program changes and Zoning Ordinance changes. HAC hasn’t been brought any material on discussion of Zoning Ordinance changes. Staff has been helpful, but the Zoning Ordinance isn’t helping affordable housing. Engineering requirements, other pieces are still in the way. See some areas where HAC’s expertise and experience would be beneficial; Zoning Ordinance is very significant and situations like this are why HAC was created. Would like to see this be a HAC priority over the next several months. KB inherited process of improvements to the Zoning Ordinance. Tiers of changes, Tier one is typos, simple changes, Tier Two more complex, Tier Three largest. A lot of what's happening is great, but areas where it could be more comprehensive. JJ: West Main Street, LV Collective project discussion should be in Tier Two. PHAR didn’t realize the implications of the Zoning Ordinance on Westhaven and 10th & Page. Can’t pay attention to everything that happens in the city. Ex: 7th St Project breaks my heart. Hearing church hymns is important to the community, this project would block that, and separate people in the neighborhood from a crucial part of their community. NS: A benefit of a Land Bank would be an organization focused on community-based development. Might be able to take action in context of proposed student housing projects that are being opposed by community. MM: Re: Landlord Risk Reduction Fund, question of resources needed to start. On the list, along with Land Bank and Tax Abatement program, of what would return most benefit once more staff has been hired. HAC has done their part, question of staff capacity. Re: Place-Based Incentives, on staff’s radar. I.e., City-funded project-based-voucher program. Not explicitly connected to a TIF (Tax Increment Financing) right now. SM: Pushing for a while about fee waivers for affordable housing developments. Building permit fees $200-300,000. PHA essentially taking money from City in aid, then returns it to City for these fees. Discussed at recent Virginia Housing meetings, Cville is most expensive area in the state to develop. MM: Reduced tap fees for water and sewer, promissory notes, waivers possible, but not quick or easy for staff to manage and process. Page 4 of 5 SM: Propose choosing three items to focus on for 2026 using straw poll approach. Runs through items, HAC members acknowledge whether it’s a top three priority or not. TOPIC VOTES Zoning Ordinance and related regulations 9 Land Acquisition and Holding 7 Member Orientation and Recruitment 0 Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILOT) 0 Landlord Risk Reduction Fund 1 Tax Abatement ? Place Based Incentives 6 Fee Waiver Programs 1 Budget Advocacy 3 DR: 7 years ago, proposed and developed an Intervention Analysis Tool based on City study of affordable housing shortage and goal of 4,000 affordable units by 2040–would be useful now. Individual decisions are being made, but no framework for decision- making or references back to overall goal. Need examination and categorization of all possible interventions across policy, organizations and their costs. This is how we got to $10M year affordable housing funding figure. In the meantime, a lot of turnover among staff and City Managers. Compares using the prior analysis tool to using a proforma for a real estate project to help guide where you’re going. NS: Encouraged by 3TP’s model, could be used in this context. SM: Affordable Housing Plan provides broad goals, but not how to achieve or measure actions. JJ: Discussions with Jeff Meyers, Sunshine, John Sales helped us understand costs involved in building a unit of affordable housing. KGM: Essential to have knowledge and think about how conditions are changing rapidly, a tool can inform decision-making and point out gaps, size of gaps, funding necessary. SM: Change in AMI analysis, rent for 30% AMI household now 63% more than in 2017 (w/o voucher). Construction costs are also increasing, aid/subsidy climate is not favorable right now. MP: Notes that it’s not explicit that in-lieu fees are on top of $10M affordable housing commitment. DR: This would help show constraints, impacts of $ for Council. Notes only $800,000 looking for new funding from affordable housing fund right now. Page 5 of 5 SM: 4,000 unit gap is both about unit construction, also programs that help people stay in their units. List includes CRHA replacement units, addition units, PHA units, permanent supportive housing units, Affordable Dwelling Units, Low Income Housing Tax Credit units, but also many other interventions depending on where people are on the spectrum of need. TOPIC VOTES VOTES (round 2) Ordinance and related regulations 9 8 Land Acquisition and Holding 7 Member Orientation & Recruitment 0 PILOT 0 LRRF 1 Tax Abatement Place Based Incentives 6 2 Fee Waiver Programs 1 Budget Advocacy/IAT 3 8 DR: Need City Manager support for HAC priorities but also notes that Council is CM’s boss. MM: December City Council Work Session on Affordable Housing agenda will discuss bringing down AMI for LIHTC projects (location-based subsidies), land acquisition, CSRAP. MP: January Work session re: West Main Street zoning. Tier 3-ish item. 5. Public Comment Paul Reeder: Lived in Cville since 1994, 211 5th St SW. Re: 7th St student housing development. James Freas told developer they were within 0.5 mile radius of UVA Grounds; patently untrue. City definition of 0.5 radius is too expansive, includes historic hospital, pocket park as part of UVA Grounds. Notes railroad makes grounds non- contiguous, and language in ordinance about definition of what is “grounds” i.e., Central Grounds and North Grounds. Freas’ interpretation is against the spirit and letter of ordinance. NDS Planner Reed Broadhead in process of making final determination now. Contribution of in-lieu fees should not be cut in half. I will appeal to Board of Zoning Appeals if City staff determines project is within 0.5 mile radius. DR: Diff btw half and full payment for this project? PR: $2-3M vs ~$5M 6. Next Scheduled Meeting: December 17, 2025 7. Adjourn Adjourned 2:00pm.

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.