Police Civilian Oversight Board — Minutes
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Police Civilian Oversight Board · meeting of Oct 9, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD
MEETING MINUTES
Date: October 9, 2025
Scheduled Time: 6:30 p.m.
Location: Neighborhood Development Services Conference Room (NDS) - 610 E
Market St, Charlottesville, VA 22902
Board Members Attending: Dr. Jeffrey Fracher (Acting Chair), Andrew Frye, George
Dillard (Remote), Dr. Kyle Dobson (Remote – left meeting at 55-minute mark).
Board Members Not Attending: N/A
Guests: N/A
Call to Order:
• The meeting was called to order at 6:30 p.m. by Acting Chair, Dr. Jeff Fracher.
Announcements:
• Dr. Fracher discussed lack of quorum, the inability to approve the agenda and
meeting minutes, and made an appeal to City Council on the status of
appointments of new members.
• James Walker (Acting Executive Director) noted two upcoming dates to the
Board members for participation in events hosted by CPD: Community Statistics
Meeting and the Community Police Academy (see agenda for dates, times, and
locations).
PCOB Office Operational Highlights and Monthly Report:
• Mr. Walker presented the September 2025 monthly office report, available on the
PCOB website under the Data & Reporting page:
https://www.charlottesville.gov/1450/Data-Reporting
o Mr. Frye suggested Board members could review other cases (UoF and
IA) so that Board members have a baseline of comparison and familiarity
with CPD policy. Dr. Fracher affirmed this as an important objective.
o Dr. Fracher explained and provided context to the recruitment pipeline for
officer hiring and interviews to which Mr. Frye confirmed the benefit of
participating in this for additional context.
o Dr. Fracher requested an overview of Sivil during the next meeting.
o Dr. Dobson cautioned use of Google Analytics to track website traffic and
to simply ensure the public is aware of the reasoning and it is done with
transparency so that community members do not feel they are being
“tracked.”
o Board members discussed the need to get legal clarification about
member interactions with CPD outside of the PCOB context.
o Dr. Fracher discussed the value of attending smaller community meetings
like Board member attendance at neighborhood meetings. Dr. Dobson
stated the community meetings should have more structure and input from
the members of the Board.
o Dr. Fracher discussed the importance of the independent legal counsel,
and the process the City Attorney’s Office is following to establish a list
from which the Board can select an attorney.
o Mr. Frye asked about the personnel budget and process of Mr. Walker
becoming full-time in the role.
o Dr. Dobson mentioned the value of the memo created by the Office related
to FLOCK Safety and the discussion over renewal of the system. Dr.
Dobson also emphasized the need for additional education to the public
on how data collection systems work and how government entities obtain
data. Mr. Frye mentioned that the ALPR (license reader) technology is not
new to policing but has become a highlight in the current political climate.
Board Member Discussion and Activity Items:
• Mr. Walker shared a draft position statement of the Board which outlined the
need for a fresh look at the PCOB Ordinance.
• Mr. Frye mentioned the value of looking again at the PCOB Ordinance now that
there is greater understanding of its implications.
• Dr. Fracher affirmed the need to review the ordinance by describing the
limitations and obstacles in the current ordinance and mentioned the value of an
audit/review model to focus the actions of the Board.
• Dr. Dobson agreed with the format of the position statement and indicated this
was a good way to go.
• Mr. Walker stated the goal of this position statement is to help Council determine
the direction of the PCOB to ultimately provide the community with more of what
they asked for, not less, but to do so in a more clarified and focused way.
• Mr. Walker reminded everyone the window for Board applications is open again
and any interest in membership would be a part of helping to direct the progress
of the Board towards a clarified mission and purpose.
• Mr. Frye mentioned the need to re-brand and re-market the PCOB to specify its
purpose.
• Mr. Walker mentioned the experience and feedback of the community at the
School Resource Officer (SRO) town hall. Mr. Walker also mentioned the nexus
of the SRO position back to general orders of the CPD, which directly relates to
the authority of oversight for the Board.
• Mr. Dillard provided his view of SRO and his own experience as part of the DARE
program and the benefit of the officer building relationships with students in the
school. Mr. Frye also affirmed the value of connections between students and
SRO and how that can work positively.
Community Matters:
• No comment was provided by members of the public.
Adjournment:
• Dr. Fracher called for an unofficial adjournment to the meeting without a motion
due to lack of quorum.
• Meeting was unofficially adjourned at 7:39 p.m.
Appr
oved by Vote of the Board (Unanimous)
Certified by James Walker, Acting PCOB Executive Director
Date Adopted: ____________________________
Certified: ________________________________
November 13, 2025
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.