RecordWell Data

City Council Joint Meeting with Police Civilian Oversight Board (PCOB) — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Sep 11, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City Council Joint Meeting with Police Civilian Oversight Board Agenda September 11, 2025 CitySpace 100 5th St NE Charlottesville, VA 22902 C i t y C o u n c i l J u a n d i e g o R . W a d e , M a y o r B r i a n R . P i n k s t o n , V i c e M a y o r N a t a l i e O s c h r i n M i c h a e l K . P a y n e J . L l o y d S n o o k , I I I 6:30 PM Regular Session I. Call to Order/Roll Call Agenda Approval Approval of meeting agendas not possible due to lack of quorum for September 11, 2025; August 14, 2025; and July 10, 2025. Minutes Approval Approval of meeting minutes not possible due to lack of quorum for August 14, 2025; July 10, 2025; and May 8, 2025. Announcements Presentation & Discussion of Staff-Recommended Ordinance Revisions The Police Civilian Oversight Board Acting Executive Director will present a series of staff-recommended ordinance changes applicable to office operations, ordinance clarity, and office functionality. Community Matters Adjournment *Notice: For members of the public participating virtually, if you experience technical difficulties, you may call 434-970-3115, and a staff person will assist you. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. Police Civilian Oversight Board Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Acting Chair Dr. Kyle Dobson, Comm. Rep W. Andrew Frye, At Large George Dillard Jr., LE Rep JOINT MEETING City Council & the Police Civilian Oversight Board Ordinance Review: Staff Recommendations September 11, 2025 STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS The ordinance recommendations included here enhance community access to the services of the Police Civilian Oversight Board by enabling the professional office staff to facilitate and implement authorized duties of the Board on its behalf. The goal is to improve the operational functionality of the Office and ensure compliance with existing city policies, procedures, and practices. Recommendations also include language clarification, strikes of redundant or irrelevant content, and adjusted placement of sections for easier access and understanding. The recommendations presented here do not alter and have no impact on the powers and duties of the Board but only ask the City Council to grant the City Manager authority to delegate certain office-level functions on the Board's behalf to the Director. Redlined Version Markers Specific revisions, strikes, and clarification requiring section movement. Specific revisions, strikes, and clarification of existing sections in place. Specific revisions, strikes, and clarification related to the Office and Director. Slide 1 of 15 UNIVERSAL RECOMMENDATIONS Recommendations described here are redlined in the ordinance but are not identified by the color- coded methodology displayed on the prior slide, as they occur continually throughout the ordinance. Replace “Executive Director” with “Director” throughout ordinance for the purpose of consistency with the City’s established organizational structure. Recodification revisions are redlined but not explicitly identified by the color-coded methodology unless newly added. This includes revisions or strikes to codification references, especially when unnecessary. Some references remain or are generalized as needed. References to the “Office of Police Civilian Oversight” as simply “the Office” are included for consistency within the ordinance in alignment with “the Board” and “the Department.” Revision of language is included which only improves grammar, syntax, or sentence flow. Additionally, any revisions which had already been specifically addressed prior and continued. Slide 2 of 15 ESTABLISHMENT OF OFFICE (p.1) Establish recodified § 2-452 from existing § 2-455 “Executive director” to be newly titled “Office of police civilian oversight established” for operational and functional necessity in alignment with language from the Office of Human Rights (OHR) ordinance. Revisions to existing language are redlined and referenced on this slide. (p.6) Add recodified § 2-452(c) “Duties of the city manager” and (d) “Duties of the director” for organizational clarity. (p.6,11) Move and Revise existing § 2-460(a) “Operating procedures” to recodified § 2-452(c)(1) and revise to indicate operating procedures are to be approved by the City Manager with consent of Council consistent with VA Code, but also to improve efficiency of operating procedure changes. (p.6) Revise and Strike recodified § 2-452(d)(1) “Duties” language regarding the duties of the Director to clarify majority vote of the Board for oversight functions and City Manager authorization of administrative functions, which is in alignment with language from the OHR ordinance. Strike unnecessary and redundant language. Slide 3 of 15 ESTABLISHMENT OF OFFICE (p.6,13) Move, Revise, and Strike existing § 2-462(b) to recodified § 2-452(d)(2) “Director’s authority to conduct audits” and revise to allow greater autonomy of the audit function as approved by the City Manager or requested by a majority vote of the Board. Includes a requirement for the Director to produce audit summary reports. Strike unnecessary language. (p.1) Add recodified § 2-452(a), (b), and (d)(3) to establish the “Office of Police Civilian Oversight” with a full-time Director, which reflects language from the OHR ordinance. Add language which provides affirmation of the existing practice of the Director to engage in oversight functions autonomously under the authority of the City Manager on behalf of the Board within the context of the Board’s authorized authority. Also allows for the Board to assign specific oversight functions to the Director by majority vote and requires summary reporting by the Director to the Board and City Manager. See specific language to add on following slides. Slide 4 of 15 ESTABLISHMENT OF OFFICE (p.1) Add recodified § 2-452(a) stating “ Office established. There is hereby established an Office of Police Civilian Oversight, which shall be referred to as “the office,” with powers granted as provided within this article to facilitate and support the authorized functions of the board. The office shall have the authority to carry out its duties and responsibilities under this ordinance with respect to all law enforcement activities and all sworn and civilian personnel operating under the authority of the Charlottesville Police Department, which shall be referred to as ‘the department.’” (p.1) Add recodified § 2-452(b) stating “ Director. There shall be a full-time director of the office. The director will be responsible for and report to the board in the day-to-day operational activities of the board and office. The director shall report to the city manager, and the city manager shall delegate to the director the authority to employ such additional staff as authorized and funded by the city council for the board to effectively fulfill its obligations under this article.” Slide 5 of 15 ESTABLISHMENT OF OFFICE (p.1) Add recodified § 2-452(d)(3) stating “ Director’s authority to engage in oversight activities on behalf of the board . The director, with approval from the city manager, or at the request of the board by a majority vote, may engage in additional oversight activities which support and inform the functions of the board authorized in this ordinance. This may include but is not limited to review of department systems, attendance at department meetings, review of department policies, practices, and procedures, participation in department interview panels, participation in use of force and similar conduct review panels, and other activities which are reasonably necessary for the board to effectuate its lawful purpose. The director shall report all activities to the board and city manager in accordance with the limitations outlined in § 2-454 of this article. Slide 6 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.1,4) Move existing § 2-452(b) “Objectivity” to recodified § 2-455(a) “Board membership, appointment, and terms” for organizational clarity. (p.2) Strike recodified § 2-453(c)(3) “self-defense” language due to irrelevancy to definition. (p.3) Add, Revise, and Strike recodified § 2-454 “Information access and limitations” for organizational clarity. Revise § 2-454(a) language to clarify access is administered by the Director and strike unnecessary, outdated, or irrelevant language. Reflects current and most efficient practice of board access to information. (p.3) Strike recodified § 2-454(h) “Procedures must be adopted before the board begins to operate” to remove outdated language as operating procedures are established and this requirement is specified elsewhere. Slide 7 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.3-4) Move, Revise, and Strike recodified § 2-454(d-e) “Confidentiality” and “Records to remain department records” from existing § 2-453(e-f) for organizational clarity. Revise language to clarify the Board or the Office and identify the chief and city attorney’s office as sources of determination for other confidential information. Strike unnecessary or irrelevant language. (p.4-5) Revise and Strike recodified § 2-455(d) “Terms” to clarify city code reference and strike outdated language. (p.6) Move recodified § 2-456(e) “Rules and procedures” language referring to hearings to recodified § 2-461(a) “Matters on which the board may conduct hearings” for organizational clarity. (p.7) Revise recodified § 2-457 “Board legal counsel” to change contract authorization from the Board Chair to the Director for alignment with city procurement policies and procedures. Slide 8 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.7) Strike existing § 2-457 “Matters the board may investigate” due to redundancy with other existing sections or redundancy with content in the existing operating procedures. (p.7) Revise existing § 2-458 to “Investigation exclusions, limitations, and suspension” to more accurately reflect the content of the section. (p.8) Revise existing § 2-458(c)(7) to change language from “complaints” to “complainants” for a more accurate and realistic process, as individuals should be referred to outside agencies, not the content of any complaint. (p.8) Elevate existing § 2-458(f) “Subpoenas” to newly recodified § 2-459 of the same name for organizational clarity. Slide 9 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.9) Strike recodified § 2-459(c, e) language regarding “shall” directives to the Cricut Court, as this has no meaningful authority or placement within the City’s ordinance in dictating the Court’s actions, nor is the content necessary in this context . (p.9) Elevate and Revise existing § 2-458(g) to newly recodified § 2-460 “Conduct of investigations” for organizational clarity. (p.9) Revise recodified § 2-460(a) language referring to “an investigative report” to “a closure letter” as this reflects current CPD practice. (p.9-10) Strike and Revise recodified § 2-460(b) language referring to “with department staff” as this is not current practice and is not necessary, based on the current method of information access. One exception where it should remain is related to “observing any real-time interviews.” Revise specification of “active criminal investigations” in the second half of subsection (b). Slide 10 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.11-12) Strike existing § 2-460(a) “Operating procedures” language referring to “a hearing examiner” as this is misplaced information and already implied by the section on hearings and contained in the existing operating procedures. (p.12) Add and Move recodified § 2-462 “Alternative resolution” to include movement of existing § 2-468 “Mediation” and recodified § 2-462(b) “Informal resolution” for organizational clarity. (p.12) Strike and Revise recodified § 2-463 “Disciplinary recommendations” language related to “prerequisite” as this is unnecessary. Strike language related to “consult with the employee’s direct supervisor...complainants and witnesses” as this is not realistic nor consistent with CPD policy, the collective bargaining agreement, nor VA Code. Consulting supervisors is only relevant for binding disciplinary authority. Revise wording with the addition of “only” to clarify the discipline matrix is the only place specific recommendations can originate. Slide 11 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.12) Strike recodified § 2-463 “Grievance rights” as this is irrelevant for non-binding disciplinary recommendations and the collective bargaining agreement more suitably contains this language. This is a limiting clarification of a non-existing power of the Board, which is irrelevant in this context. (p.13) Add language to recodified § 2-464 “Board review of law enforcement policies...” to include clarity of the Board’s ability to “conduct research and collaborate” as this is fundamental to the Board’s function here and represents language consistent with the OHR ordinance. (p.13) Revise recodified § 2-465 “Request annual reports of police expenditures” to identify the Director as the recipient of access who, in turn, presents information to the Board, as this both reflects current practice and is the most efficient way for access to be meaningfully provided. (p.13) Revise recodified § 2-466 to include “Community engagement, legislative recommendations, and reporting” for organizational clarity as these are each public-facing engagement activities of the Board. Slide 12 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.13) Move and Revise recodified § 2-466(a) “Community engagement” to combine all content from existing § 2-465 “Community engagement and community relations” into one more robust section. Revise to include language which clarifies “collaboration, education, awareness, and guidance” which is consistent with the OHR ordinance. Revise to reduce “shall” statements to “may” statements related to specific public functions and activities of the Board to reduce demand on volunteer appointees. Revise to include clarifying language which delineates and affirms public engagement activities of the Board and the Office already practiced. (p.13-14) Revise, Strike, and Add recodified § 2-466(c) “Annual report” to “Reporting” with primary responsibility shifted to the Director, as this is current practice and more realistic for a volunteer Board. Additionally, strike a specific due date which is consistent with the ordinances of other volunteer boards and commissions. Revise to include activities of the Office and include additional language to specify reporting on any public input or recommendations from engagement sessions. Finally, add a “may” statement to include additional reporting of activities which may be more suitable to specific one-time, monthly, or quarterly report. Slide 13 of 15 SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS (p.14-15) Revise recodified § 2-467 to “Board member training” with language reducing the training demand on volunteer Board members to make the requirements more practical and achievable. Revise to allow the Director more autonomy in providing or facilitating training. Additionally, include language which reflects an existing practice of Board members engaging in ride-along experiences and the Citizen’s Police Academy. Slide 14 of 15 NEXT STEPS There are a range of additional ordinance topics which are within the purview and specific interest of the City Council and the community, or which have a direct impact on the powers and duties of the Board. Some of these topics include conflicts with existing law or policy, unrealistic expectations of a volunteer Board, or the practical dynamics of the collective bargaining environment. The staff of the Office of Police Civilian Oversight have drafted a series of options which may address many of these ordinance topics in a way that improves functionality of the Board and maintains the oversight expectations of the community. The goal of these options is to make oversight duties of the Board, which it is already authorized to perform, more practical and accessible to the Board as volunteer representatives of the community. It is also the goal of the Office staff to facilitate any future collaborative discussion with City Council to achieve these long-term improvements. Slide 15 of 15 - CODE Chapter 2 - ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD Charlottesville, Virginia, Code of Ordinances Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 1 of 15 ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD1 Sec. 2-450. Title. This article shall be known as the Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Ordinance. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-451. Police civilian oversight board established. Pursuant to Virginia Code § 9.1-601, there is hereby established a Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board, which shall be referred to as "the board," with powers granted as provided within this article. The board is a body established and appointed by the city council of Charlottesville pursuant to Virginia Code § 9.1-601(B) to perform functions authorized by the city council in accordance with Virginia Code § 9.1-601(C). It shall not be able to bring suit or to be sued in its own name, except to the extent needed to request and defend subpoenas as authorized by this article. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-452. 2-453. Powers and duties of the police civilian oversight board. (a) Purpose. The purpose of the board is to establish and maintain trust between and among the Charlottesville Police Department, which shall be referred to as "the department," the city council, the city manager, and the public. (b) Objectivity. It is of fundamental importance that members of the board be fair and objective in the conduct of their duties, and that they be perceived as fair and objective in the conduct of their duties. (b) Powers and duties. The board shall have the following powers and duties: (1) To receive, investigate, and issue findings on co mplaints from civilians regarding the conduct of law enforcement officers and civilian employees of the department; (2) To investigate and issue findings on incidents, including the use of force by a law enforcement officer, death or serious injury to any individual held in custody, serious abuse of authority or misconduct as defined in this section, allegedly discriminatory stops, and other incidents regarding the conduct of law enforcement officers and civilian employees of the department; (3) At the conclusion of any investigation conducted pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2), above, if the board has found that an employee has committed misconduct, to recommend disciplinary action to the chief of police; 1Editor's note(s)—Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, adopted De c. 20, 2021, repealed the former Art. XVI, §§ 2-450—2- 464, and enacted a new Art. XVI as set out herein. The former Art. XVI pertained to the police civilian review board, and derived from an ordinance adopted Nov. 4, 2019(1)); and Ord. No. O-21-062, 5-3-21. Establishment of New Section – See Presentation Details for Sec. 2-452. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 2 of 15 (4) To investigate policies, practices, and procedures of the department and to make recommendations regarding changes to such policies, practices and procedures., as set forth within section 2-462 of this article; (5) To review investigations conducted internally by the department , as set forth in section 2-458 of this article, and to issue findings regarding the accuracy, completeness, and impartiality of the investigations and the sufficiency of any discipline resulting from such investigations; (6) To request reports of the annual expenditures of the department, and to make recommendations to the city council concerning future appropriations; (7) To make public reports on the activities of the board, including investigations, hearings, findings, recommendations, determinations and oversight activities; (8) To hold hearings and, if, after making a good fa ith effort to obtain the voluntary attendance of witnesses and the production of books, papers, and other evidence necessary to perform its duties, the board is unable to obtain such attendance or production, to apply to the Circuit Court for the City of Charlottesville for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witness or the production of such books, papers and other evidence; and (9) To undertake other duties, as reasonably necessary, for the board to effectuate its lawful purpose as provided for in this article, to effectively oversee the department. (c) Definition of "serious abuse of authority or misconduct." "Serious abuse of authority or misconduct" shall include the following: (1) Verbal or other conduct regarding an individual or group that maligns or shows hostility for the individual or group because of race, color, religion, gender, national origin, age, disability, sexual orientation, or gender identity and expression; (2) Harassment or discrimination based on race, color, sexual orientation, gender, religion, national origin, marital status, age, familial status, immigration status or disability; (3) Acting in a rude, careless, angry, retaliatory or threatening manner not necessary for self-defense; (4) Reckless endangerment of a citizen, detainee, or person in custody; (5) Violation of laws or ordinances; (6) Criminal or other misconduct occurring on or off the job which is related to job performance or is of such a nature that to continue the employee in the assigned position or in any city employment capacity would constitute negligence in regard to the city's duties to the public or to other city employees; (7) In any matter within the jurisdiction of an y officer, department or agency of the city: a. The knowing falsification, concealment or cover-up of a material fact; and/or b. The knowing making of any false, fictitious or fraudulent statement or representation, and/or the making or using of any writing or document knowing the same to contain a false, fictitious or fraudulent statement or entry; (8) Sexual activity, including consensual sexual activity, on the job; and (9) Other serious violations of Charlottesville or department policies or procedures, including the department code of conduct. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 3 of 15 Sec. 2-454. Information access and limitations. (a) Access to department information. The board, administered by the director, is authorized to receive, and shall be provided full access to, all department reports, files and records pertinent to board investigations of complaints and incidents or to its review of department internal affairs investigations, as authorized in this article. All records, documents and materials in the possession of the department or the city that are determined by the board to be necessary and requested by the board to carry out its authorized powers and responsibilities shall be provided to the board subject to board procedures adopted, with council approval, for the protection of confidential information as defined in such procedures. Within forty-five (45) days of the enactment of this article, The city manager, in consultation with the chief of police and the board, shall establish a standard operating procedure setting forth how this access shall be given by the department to the board, how personal information shall be managed and protected by the board in accordance with the requirements of Virginia Code § 2.2-3800 et seq., and under what circumstances or conditions it may be made available to the parties. (b) Department information to which the board may not have access. the executive director and the board shall not have access to: (1) Juvenile records; (2) Records that may reveal the identity or personal in formation, as defined in Virginia Code § 2.2-3801, of a confidential informant; (3) Investigative files for an active civil or crimin al investigation by the commonwealth attorney, the Virginia Attorney General, the Virginia State Police, or the United States Department of Justice; (4) Files related to an active EEOC claim, human rights commission investigation, or civil claim involving a department employee; (5) Files containing information exempt from public disclosure pursuant to Virginia Code §§ 2.2-3706(B)(2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), (8), (10), (11); 2.2-3706(C); 2.23706.1(C)(1) through (C)(6); 2.2-3706.1(D); and 2.2- 3706.1(E); or (6) Any information that the police department is not legally authorized to share. (c) Disputes over access. If the executive director and the board seek access to information the disclosure of which the department believes would compromise ongoing investigations, disclosure may be withheld until such time as the need for maintaining confidentiality is no longer present, or until the city manager has determined that the matter will not be compromised by the release of the information. If the board believes that the city manager is unreasonably withholding such information, the board may consider whether to seek a subpoena requiring the production of such information pursuant to subsection 2-458(f) section 2-459. (h) Procedures must be adopted before the board begins to operate. The board shall not exercise the powers and duties set forth within paragraphs (c)(1)—(9) until city council approves operating procedures, after consultation with the board, pursuant to subsection 2-460(a). (d) Confidentiality. Each member of the board and the director shall maintain the confidentiality of all confidential or privileged information, including, but not limited to: (1) Materials from police internal investigative files; (2) Disciplinary actions, memos and reports; (3) Statements of any police officer or civilian empl oyee who was required by the department to give a statement; (4) Criminal investigative files; or Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 4 of 15 (4) Any other information that the board chief or city attorney’s officehas deemed confidential. (e) Records to remain department records. The chief of police, as the custodian of the original records of which copies may be provided to the board by the department, shall be responsible for decisions as to whether copies of such records (or information contained in such records) may be publicly disclosed, subject to the direction and control of the city manager. Nothing in this paragraph shall preclude the city manager from including with the standard operating procedure required by subsection 2-452(e) guidelines for public disclosure of certain types of information contained within department records. In the standard operating procedure required by subsection 2-452(e), the city manager shall issue guidelines for what information may be included in board or office reports or otherwise publicly disclosed. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21; Ord. No. O-24-155, 11-18-24) Sec. 2-453. 2-455. Board membership appointment, and terms. (a) Objectivity. It is of fundamental importance that members of the board be fair and objective in the conduct of their duties, and that they be perceived as fair and objective in the conduct of their duties. (b) Appointment process. The city council shall appoint the members of the board. The council shall announce a public application process with applications available online and by hardcopy in English and Spanish for individuals interested in serving on the board. Council will seek to appoint fair-minded and objective members with a demonstrated commitment to community service who have training and experience, including lived experience, with topics relevant to the business of the board, including law, police practices, human resources practices and procedures, trauma-informed mental health issues, and the sociology of historically overpoliced communities. (c) Board composition. The board shall reflect the demographic diversity of the City of Charlottesville. The board shall be composed of seven (7) voting members and one (1) non-voting member appointed by the city council. The members shall be removable by the city council for cause as specified in the board code of ethics, violating the duty of confidentiality, failing to participate in required training, or other good cause. (1) Council shall appoint at least three (3) members who are residents of public housing or who come from historically disadvantaged communities that have traditionally experienced disparate policing. (2) Council may appoint one (1) member who represents an organization that seeks racial or social justice on behalf of historically disadvantaged communities. (3) The non-voting member of the board shall be an individual with policing expertise or experience. The non-voting member may be a retired law enforcement officer who prior to his or her retirement was employed in a locality similar to the City of Charlottesville. (4) The seven (7) voting members of the board shall be residents of, or shall be employed in, the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County, with priority given to city residents and those with significant and demonstrable ties to the city. (5) No board member shall be a current candidate for public office, a former member of the department, an immediate family member of a current department employee, or a current employee of a law enforcement agency, the fire department, the emergency communications center, or the sheriff's office. If council considers appointing a board member who is employed by the City of Charlottesville, council will seek to avoid potential conflicts of interest. (d) Terms. Each board member shall be appointed for a term of three (3) years. Appointments and terms shall be subject to the provisions of section chapter 2, article I § 2-8 of this the city code. The membership of the board, and the terms of each board member, shall be the same as for the police civilian review board that was serving as of December 20, 2021, and that membership shall continue as the police civilian oversight Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 5 of 15 board established by this article, with no change in the date of appointment, or length of term, for any member. (e) Conflicts of interest. No board member may participate in any matter before the board under circumstances in which the objectivity of the board member could reasonably be questioned, including, without limitation, the consideration of a complaint of someone who is a family member. For purposes of the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act, the board shall be deemed a "governmental agency" and each board member shall be an "officer," as those terms are defined in Virginia Code § 2.2-3101. All board members shall comply with the requirements of the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act. (e) Confidentiality. Each member shall maintain the confidentiality of all confidential or privileged information, including, but not limited to: (1) Materials from police internal investigative files; (2) Disciplinary actions, memos and reports; (3) Statements of any police officer or civilian empl oyee who was required by the department to give a statement; (4) Criminal investigative files; or (5) Any other information that the board has deemed confidential. (f) Records to remain department records. The chief of police, as the custodian of the original records of which copies may be provided to the board by the department, shall be responsible for decisions as to whether copies of such records (or information contained in such records) may be publicly disclosed, subject to the direction and control of the city manager. Nothing in this paragraph shall preclude the city manager from including with the standard operating procedure required by subsection 2-452(e) guidelines for public disclosure of certain types of information contained within department records. In the standard operating procedure required by subsection 2-452(e), the city manager shall issue guidelines for what information may be included in board reports or otherwise publicly disclosed. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21; Ord. No. O-24-155, 11-18-24) Sec. 2-454. 2-456. Meetings. (a) Number of meetings. The board shall hold public meetings at least once per calendar quarter. Additional meetings may be called by the chair or any two (2) board members. (b) FOIA. The board shall comply with all applicable requirements of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA") pertaining to disclosure of public records and the conduct of its meetings, including the requirement that all meetings shall be open to the public except under circumstances when the topic is authorized by FOIA to be discussed in a closed meeting. (c) Quorum. A quorum of the board shall be four (4) members. (d) Minutes. The board shall keep minutes of its meetings, which shall include: (1) The date, time, and location of the meeting; (2) The members present and absent; (3) A summary of the discussion on matters proposed, deliberated, or decided; (4) A record of any votes taken. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 6 of 15 (e) Rules and procedures. Meetings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with Robert's Rules of Order or such other procedures as the board may adopt. Hearings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with the operating procedures approved by city council for the board. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-455. Executive director. See Presentation for New Sec. 2-452 with Subsections (a), (b), and (d)(3) Added. (1) Appointment. The city manager shall appoint an executive director with the approval of a majority vote of the city council. (2) Interview process. As a part of the executive director appointment process, the city manager shall convene an interview panel that includes two (2) members of the board. If those two (2) members recommend a candidate for appointment as executive director, the city manager shall provide a written justification to the board if a different candidate is appointed. (c) D uties of the city manager. (1) Operating procedures. The city manager, with consent of city council, shall approve operating procedures for the performance of duties by the board. Those procedures may be amended from time to time by city council, or as designated to the city manager, in consultation with the board and director. (2) Supervision. The city manager or a designee shall supervise the work of the executive director and may delegate that responsibility to a deputy city manager. The city manager's annual evaluation of the executive director's performance shall consider a written performance review submitted by the board to the city manager. The board may request that the city manager meet with the board's chair to discuss the executive director's performance. (3) Vacancy. If there is a vacancy in the position of executive director, the city manager or their designee may designate some other city employee who is not an employee of the department to act as executive director until a new executive director is hired. (d) Duties of the director. (1) Duties. The executive director shall support the board in the implementation and exercise of all of its oversight functions authorized under this article and to undertake or ensure the performance of specific tasks assigned by majority vote of the board pursuant to the powers and duties of the board authorized in this ordinance. The director shall be responsible for all administrative and fiscal needs of the board and the office as authorized by the city manager. including the monitoring of investigations conducted by the department. If authorized by the city manager or their designee, the executive director may engage the services of such investigators as may be necessary to perform the executive director's duties to conduct or to monitor investigations. (2) Executive Director's authority to conduct audits. The board may direct the executive director, with approval from the city manager, on its behalf to may conduct retrospective examinations and audits of patterns in internal affairs investigations, arrest and detention, department expenditures, and other public-police interactions pursuant to the powers and duties of the board authorized in this ordinance. The board may request the director to conduct additional audits by majority vote. The director will provide a summary report of any audit conducted to the board and city manager upon completion. The board may request information from the department, may seek subpoenas as authorized above, and may conduct such an investigation as is necessary to permit the board to perform the audit. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 7 of 15 (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-456. 2-457. Board legal counsel. The board director may retain independent legal counsel to represent the board in all cases, hearings, controversies, or matters involving the interests of the board. Such independent legal counsel shall be chosen from a list of attorneys recommended by the city attorney. The board's chair director is authorized to execute a contract in the name of the board for legal services if the contract has first been approved by the board and endorsed by the city's finance director to verify that funding is available and has been appropriated to support performance of the payment obligations of the board under such contract. The board's legal counsel shall be paid only from funds that have been appropriated to the board's budget by city council. The board and the executive director are encouraged to consult the office of the city attorney for legal advice except in cases, hearings, investigations, controversies that are before the board, or in any other matter in which the board's and the department's interests may conflict. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-457. Matters that the board may investigate. (a) Investigate complaints. The board and the city manager shall jointly develop and administer a process for receiving and investigating complaints from members of the public regarding the misconduct of law enforcement employees of the department and referring complaints to the department for investigation. The process, to be set out in detail in a standard operating procedure established by the city manager in consultation with the chief of police and the executive director, shall permit complainants to file complaints online, in writing, or orally. The SOP shall permit the complainant to choose whether the complaint will be investigated by the board only or by the department with monitoring by the executive director. Regardless of how a complaint is received, it shall be promptly provided to the department and to the executive director. The executive director, in consultation with the board, may decline to investigate a complaint. (b) Investigate incidents. If the board becomes aware of an incident, including the use of force by a law enforcement officer, death or serious injury to any individual held in custody, serious abuse of authority or misconduct as defined in this article, an allegedly discriminatory stop, or another incident regarding the conduct of an employee of the department, even if no complaint has been filed, the board may initiate its own investigation of the incident, by notice from the board chair to the city manager and the chief of police, who shall ensure the department's cooperation with the investigation. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-458. Investigations of complaints and incidents exclusions, limitations, and suspension. (a) Compliance. Any investigation shall comply with all federal, state, and local laws, as well as with requirements for the initiation and conduct of investigations described in the procedures promulgated by the city council under section 2-460 as authorized in this article. (b) Compelled statements. The board may not compel a statement from any department employee, other than by means of its subpoena powers. (c) Exclusions. The board shall not consider complaints, incidents, claims or issues involving the following: Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 8 of 15 (1) Any incident that occurred more than one (1) year before the filing of the complaint, or one (1) year before the board received notice of the incident, except as otherwise authorized by subsection (d) of this section; (2) Except as otherwise authorized by subsection (d) of this section, a matter that was the subject of an investigation where more than seventy-five (75) days has elapsed since the department sent notice to the complainant informing the complainant that the department's internal affairs investigation is complete (unless the board determines that there is good cause to extend the filing deadline); (3) Matters that are the subject of a pending criminal proceeding in any trial court, a pending or anticipated civil proceeding in any trial court (as eviden ced by a notice of claim or a filed complaint), or any pending City of Charlottesville grievance proceeding; (4) Any financial management related issue; (5) Any complaint, incident, claim or issue where the complainant requests that the board not have access to their files; (6) Any complaint, incident, claim or issue that has previously been the subject of an investigation by the board, unless substantial new information has come to the attention of the board; (7) An allegation of misconduct only by employees of law enforcement agencies other than the department. Such complaints complainants should be referred to the appropriate law enforcement agency; (8) An allegation of conduct that does not violate the Charlottesville Police Policies and Guidelines, Disciplinary Orders, or Code of Conduct; (9) Any other claim outside the scope of the board's authority expressly set forth within this article. (d) Exceptions to time limits. With the concurrence of the city manager, the board may review investigations beyond the time limits specified in subsections (c)(1) and (c)(2) if: (1) The board determines that there is good cause for doing so; or (2) As part of an audit taking place under subsection 2-462(b) 2-452(d). (e) Suspension of investigations. If a complaint asserts criminal conduct by an employee of the department, or if at any point in an investigation of a complaint or incident the board becomes aware that an employee may have committed a criminal offense, the board shall: (1) Suspend the investigation and notify the chief of police and commonwealth's attorney of the alleged conduct, ensuring that no statements obtained from the police department employee(s) whose actions are the subject of the matter are shared with criminal investigators or any prosecuting authority except in accordance with applicable law; and (2) Evaluate, in consultation with board legal counsel, the city attorney, and the commonwealth's attorney, whether competing public interests and civil rights involved permit the resumption of continued, parallel investigation by the board. Sec. 2-459. Subpoenas. (f) Subpoenas. (a) If the board determines that there is evidence (including witnesses) not within the control of the department that the board is unable to obtain voluntarily, the board by two- ƚŚŝƌĚƐ;аͿǀŽƚĞŵĂLJĚŝƌĞĐƚƚŚĞ executive director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Charlottesville Circuit Court for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witness or the production of such books, papers, and other evidence, Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 9 of 15 and the court, on finding that the witness or evidence is material to the discharge of the board's duties, may issue the requested subpoena. (b) If the executive director is denied access to material witnesses, records, books, papers, or other evidence within the control of the department that the executive director deems necessary to perform their duties and the duties of the board, the executive director may request the city manager to require the department to produce the requested witnesses and documents. The city manager, or their designee, shall not unreasonably deny such a request, but may place conditions on the production of the requested witnesses and documents as necessary to preserve confidentiality for the reasons set forth in this article. The city manager, or their designee, shall issue a decision on the executive director's request within five (5) business days from the date of that request. (c) I f the city manager, or their designee, denies the executive director's request made pursuant to subparagraph (2) above, the board by two-ƚŚŝƌĚƐ;аͿǀŽƚĞŵĂLJdirect authorize the executive director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Charlottesville Circuit Court for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witnesses or the production of such books, papers, and other evidence. The court, on finding that the witness or evidence is material to the discharge of the board's duties, shall cause the subpoena to be issued with such conditions as the court may deem necessary to protect the department's concerns about the need for confidentiality. The board shall give the city manager and the department reasonable notice of its intent to subpoena such witness or records and shall give the city attorney a copy of the request for subpoena. The board shall not unreasonably withhold its agreement to limitations on the scope of the subpoena requested by the city manager that may be necessary to protect confidential information. The parties may request that any hearing to be held in the circuit court on the request for a subpoena be conducted in a closed courtroom, to the extent permitted by state law. Upon request, the court file for any such subpoena request shall be kept under seal to the extent permitted by state law. (d) I f a subpoena is granted, the board shall digitally record any interviews or depositions conducted pursuant to the subpoena and shall make copies of any documents obtained by subpoena. The board shall provide the department with copies of any such interview/deposition recordings and documents. The board shall delegate its authority to subpoena and question witnesses to the executive director, who shall conduct any interviews, depositions, or questioning of witnesses in a non-public forum that adequately protects the privacy of the individual being subpoenaed, the confidentiality or sensitivity of information shared or sought, and the integrity of any pending or concurrent investigation. (e) I n deciding whether, and under what conditions, the circuit court will issue any subpoena, the court shall refer to procedures and case law decided under Rule 3A:12 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia. Sec. 2-460. Conduct of investigations. (g) Conduct of investigations pursuant to subsection 2-457(a). (a) If the complainant asks that thei r complaint be investigated by the department, the complaint will be investigated by the department with monitoring by the executive director. When the department's investigation is concluded, the department will provide the complainant with a n investigative report closure letter of its findings and the resolution of the complaint and will provide the board a summary of the department's resolution of the complaint. (b) Th e executive director may actively monitor all investigations of complaints of employee misconduct conducted by the department and shall have access to records and witnesses to the same extent as the department, subject to the limitations or requirements set out in this article. Such monitoring may include reviewing the investigative plan of the department, reviewing with the department any records within the department's digital evidence management system, reviewing with the department any pertinent law enforcement records within the department's records management system, observing any and all real-time interviews of witnesses with the department, reviewing all any recorded interviews which the executive Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 10 of 15 director chooses not to attend in real time, providing feedback during the interview to be relayed to department staff conducting the interview, providing feedback to department staff in determining next steps in the investigative process, and reviewing facts gained from investigation with department staff. For active criminal investigations, the executive director shall be limited in their participation to the same extent the department is limited in its participation in such investigations. The executive director may monitor the department's administrative investigation of employee misconduct after the close of the active criminal investigation in the same manner as all other investigations of employee conduct handled by the department as described in this section. When monitoring department investigations, during the pendency of the investigations the executive director shall not disclose information to the board, any board member, or any person other than as authorized in writing by the chief of police or the city manager. (c) I f the complainant asks that the complaint be investigated only by the board, the executive director shall initiate an investigation on behalf of the board. The executive director will provide the chief of police with enough identifying information to allow the department to give the executive director access to information, records and witnesses as required by subsections 2-452(e) and (f) as may be relevant to the complaint. When the board's investigation is concluded, the executive director will provide the board, the complainant and the department with an investigative report that includes a summary of the circumstances of the incident(s) of alleged misconduct, the evidence related to whether there was any misconduct, and any suggested findings related to each allegation. (d) Conduct of incident investigations pursuant to subsection 2-457(b). If the board is investigating an incident under the authority of subsection 2-457(b), the board may request information from the department, may seek subpoenas as authorized above, and may conduct an investigation of the incident. When the board's investigation is concluded, the executive director will provide the board, the department, and (if a complaint has been filed) the complainant, with an investigative report that includes, at a minimum, a summary of the circumstances of the incident, the evidence related to whether the incident involved any police or employee misconduct, and any suggested findings related to the incident. The executive director may make recommendations as to whether an allegation, if substantiated, could constitute serious misconduct as defined in subsection 2-452(d). The investigative report shall also be provided to any employees identified within the investigative report as having committed employee misconduct. (e) Duration of investigations. Investigations of complaints and incidents will be completed, and any investigative report will be submitted, within seventy-five (75) days from the date the complaint is received, or the board received notice of the incident. The board may extend the seventy-five-day period upon request of the police chief or the executive director to protect an ongoing investigation or prosecution, or for other good cause, with notice to the complainant and the city manager. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21; Ord. No. O-22-164, § 1, 12-19-22) Sec. 2-459. 2-461. Matters on which the board may conduct hearings. (a) Hearings. Hearings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with the operating procedures approved by the city manager with consent of city council for the board. (1) At the conclusion of an investigation of an inci dent or a complaint the board may conduct a review hearing whose scope and procedures are described in the board's operating procedures, approved by city council. Review hearings shall be defined as any hearing conducted by the board to review the facts, issues and findings of an investigative report closure letter of the department related to an internal affairs investigation, or of an investigative report of the executive director related to a complaint or incident investigation. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 11 of 15 (2) The board may conclude that no hearing, or a hearin g only on a limited issue, is necessary to support the board's decision related to a particular complaint or incident. If so, the board may issue a report without a hearing. (b) Within thirty (30) days of a review hearing of an in ternal affairs investigation, the board shall report their findings publicly and to the city manager, the police chief, and the complainant with respect to each allegation or issue under review as follows: (1) That the board finds that the investigation of the complaint was satisfactory, and the board concurs with the findings of the investigation; (2) That the board finds that the investigation of the complaint was satisfactory, but the board does not concur with the findings of the investigation, in which case the board may make recommendations to the city manager concerning disposition of the review request; or (3) That the board finds that the investigation is incomplete or otherwise unsatisfactory and provides a detailed written explanation of the basis for such finding. (c) If the board makes a finding under subsection (b)(3) above, the board may conduct an independent investigation of the matter that is the subject of the complaint. The board shall report publicly and to the city manager, the chief of police and the complainant that the board has made one (1) of the following findings: (1) That the board now finds that, despite the defects in the original internal affairs investigation, the board's own investigation has produced no material evidence to dispute the original findings of the internal affairs department. (2) The board's independent investigation has produced substantive new information that causes them to disagree with the findings of the internal affairs investigation. In this case, the board shall make recommendations to the city manager concerning disposition of the complaint; or (3) That despite the board's best efforts, the evidence is insufficient to allow the board to determine whether the findings of the internal affairs investigative report are correct. (d) Within thirty (30) days of a review hearing of a comp laint or incident investigation, the board shall report their findings publicly and to the city manager, the police chief, and the complainant with respect to each allegation or issue under review as follows: (1) That the board finds that the department employee committed misconduct; (2) That the board finds that no department employee committed misconduct; or (3) That despite the board's best efforts, the evidence is insufficient to allow the board to determine whether any department employee committed misconduct. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21; Ord. No. O-22-164, § 2, 12-19-22) Sec. 2-460. Operating procedures. (a) Operating procedures. The city council shall approve operating procedures for the performance of duties by the board. Those procedures may be amended from time to time by city council, in consultation with the board. The board shall conduct all hearings in accordance with hearing procedures set forth within the operating procedures approved by city council. A hearing examiner, chosen as set out in the operating procedures, shall preside over the hearing; however, the board shall serve as the factfinding body. Parties to the hearing shall have no right to a particular set of procedures. The hearing examiner may make reasonable modifications to the procedures as circumstances concerning a particular complaint may require, provided that: Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 12 of 15 (1) Any such modifications are within the authority of the board under this article or the approved operating procedures; and (2) No such modification deprives any party to a hearing of substantial justice. Sec. 2-462. Alternative resolution. (a) Mediation. The board may propose procedures for the use of mediation or other alternative dispute resolution techniques to resolve complaints against employees of the department. Such procedures shall not affect the ability of complainants to pursue remedies under other sections of this article. (b) Informal resolution. At any time after receiving a complaint and before issuance of the written findings required at the conclusion of a hearing, the board and any party may propose an informal resolution within the scope of the express authority granted to the board within this article, which informal resolution may be adopted if all parties and the board agree to such a resolution. At any time, the parties may agree to refer the matter to mediation or other alternative dispute resolution methods, without prejudice to the right to have a hearing on the review request. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-461. 2-463. Disciplinary recommendations. Prerequisite to the board making disciplinary recommendations. The board shall be authorized to make disciplinary recommendations in a manner that protects personnel information regarding identifiable employees against public disclosure, in accordance with the operating procedures established by city council pursuant to subsection 2-460(a) 2-452(c) and the standard operating procedures established pursuant to subsection 2-452(e) 2-454(a). Subject to the foregoing provisions, the following process may be used, as appropriate: (a) Upon making a finding that an employee has engaged in a serious breach of departmental and professional standards, the board shall meet to discuss appropriate recommendations for disciplinary action. The board shall consult with the employee's direct supervisor or commander, complainants and witnesses when discussing the appropriate disciplinary action to be recommended. Prior to commencement of any such disciplinary deliberations, the subject employee shall be given notice of the proceedings and of the range of disciplinary actions under consideration for recommendation, and the employee shall be offered an opportunity to be heard. If permitted by FOIA, some or all of the disciplinary hearing may be held in closed session. No employee, and no other city employee, shall be compelled to provide statements to the board during its deliberations. Disciplinary action to be considered for recommendation by the board shall only include those specified within any applicable disciplinar y matrix utilized by the department. After considering these sources of information, the board may make a disciplinary recommendation to the department. (b) I f the board makes a disciplinary recommendation to the department, and the department declines to implement the board's disciplinary recommendations, the chief of police shall, within thirty (30) days of the board's recommendation, provide a written explanation of their reason for declining to implement the board's recommendation. This explanation shall be made available to the board, the city council, the city manager, and the public. (b) Grievance rights. Nothing in this article shall affect in any way any right of an employee to file a grievance requesting a hearing before the city's personnel appeals board, which right shall be governed by the provisions of Virginia Code §§ 9.01-507 and 9.1-601(F), or the provisions of Virginia Code § 15.2-1507(A)(3) and the city's employee grievance procedures, as may be applicable. No finding by the board, nor any recommendation of the board, shall be admitted in any personnel appeal or grievance hearing. Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 13 of 15 (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-462. 2-464. Board review of law enforcement policies, practices and procedures. Authority to make policy recommendations. The board may review and make recommendations regarding policies, practices, and procedures of the department, including written policies, procedures and standing orders. To achieve this, the board may conduct research and review of existing studies and literature and may collaborate with research organizations. The board shall present in writing its findings and recommendations with supporting rationale to the city manager and chief of police. If the department declines to implement any changes recommended by the board, the chief of police shall explain in writing, which shall be made available for public inspection, why the department declines to implement the board's recommendation, unless the board instead withdraws the recommendation based on the rationale provided. The board's withdrawal of any such recommendation shall be made available for public inspection. (b) Executive director's authority to conduct audits. The board may direct the executive director on its behalf to conduct retrospective examinations and audits of patterns in internal affairs investigations, arrest and detention, and other public-police interactions. The board may request information from the department, may seek subpoenas as authorized above, and may conduct such an investigation as is necessary to permit the board to perform the audit. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-463. 2-465. Request annual reports of police expenditures. During the city manager's preparation of a proposed city budget, the budget office shall provide the board director with annual expenditure estimates and future year projections for the department, itemized to the same level of detail as provided to the city manager. The estimates shall be presented to the board by the director at the same time they are presented to the city manager. The board may review the estimates and may make budgetary recommendations to the city manager and/or to the city council during the annual budget process. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-464. 2-466. Community engagement, legislative recommendations, and annual reporting. (a) Community outreach engagement. The board and the executive director shall engage in regular community outreach and collaboration to seek the assistance and input of community members and to provide education, awareness, and guidance on policing matters. At least twice a year, The board shall may host public community listening and discussion sessions to discuss regarding policing matters of pressing public concern, such as questions about transparency, availability, legitimacy, mutual respect and trust, and community safety and order. The board and the director may also host or participate in public police- community relations meetings focused on topics such as including the impacts of local policing on historically disadvantaged communities that currently experience or traditionally have experienced disparate policing. (b) Legislative recommendations. The board may make recommendations to city council of any proposed changes in state law, for the council's consideration to include in its annual legislative program to present to the General Assembly. These recommendations shall be presented to the city attorney's office by August 15 of each year. (c) Annual Reporting. On or before April 15 of Each calendar year, the board director shall provide the board and city council with an annual report of activities conducted during the preceding calendar year. The report shall Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 14 of 15 detail activities of the board's activities and the office in the prior calendar year, with sections related to the appointment of committees and their actions; the establishment of any community advisory panels; an overview of complaints received during the calendar year including the number of complaints, the complaints' findings, and the number of complaints deferred due to pending proceedings; the number and outcome of any independent investigations; an overview of proposed policy recommendations and amendments to department policies and whether the recommendations and amendments were implemented by the department; the number, type, and attendance at community listening sessions; a summary of public input and recommendations of the public during those sessions; recommendations of the board about policing within the city; and any other information necessary to provide an overview of the board’s and officeactivities. The director may provide the board, city council, and the city manager additional reports as deemed relevant by the director to provide transparency into oversight activities of the board and the office. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-465. Community engagement and community relations. (a) Community outreach. The board and the executive director shall engage in community outreach to seek the assistance and input of community members. At least twice a year, the board shall host public community listening sessions to discuss policing matters of pressing public concern, including the impacts of local policing on historically disadvantaged communities that currently experience or traditionally have experienced disparate policing. (b) Community meetings. The board may also host or participate in public police-community relations meetings, in which board members, supported by the executive director, department officials, designated by the chief of police, and community members discuss policing matters of pressing public concern, including questions about transparency, availability, legitimacy, mutual respect and trust, equitable treatment, social and racial justice, equal rights, and community safety and order. (c) Include in reports. The board shall report on its community outreach and engagement activities, public input, and any recommendations for community-policing initiatives or for improved police-community relations at least annually as part of the annual report provided for in subsection 2-464(b). (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-466. 2-467. Board member training. (a) NACOLE training. At least once every two (2) years, and within ninety (90) days six (6) months of any new board appointments, the city, assisted by the executive director, shall facilitate or provide board members with at least eight (8) four (4) hours of training, presented by using training content from the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement or a comparable professional organization. The training shall be consistent with the board's mission, this article, and the operating procedures. (b) City or and CPD training. At least once every two (2) years, and within six (6) months of any new board appointments, the city, assisted by the executive director, and the chief of police or their designees, shall facilitate or provide board members with at least two (2) hours of training or information: (1) Describing the legal and ethical ob ligations of members of a public board, including the need to comply with FOIA and other statutes and ordinances governing their service; (2) Explaining police department procedures, policies, and regulations; (3) Describing the substance of police department personnel record-keeping; Created: 2025-03-04 12:56:53 [EST] (Supp. No. 61, Update 1) Page 15 of 15 (4) Describing such other city policies, procedures and systems relevant to the duties of the board; and (5) Explaining the operating procedures and code of ethics for the board. (c) Additional training. As needed, the city shall provide board may request members with additional relevant training by subject matter experts on subjects that may include mental health, trauma-informed policing, civil rights and constitutional law, race and racism, community outreach, mediation, investigation, and policing practices. The board may also request opportunities for ride-along experiences with the department and participation in the Citizen’s Police Academy. The director shall facilitate or provide this training as is feasible with available funding and time commitment from trainers. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-467. 2-468. Commendations for exceptional community service. (a) Soliciting public comment. The board may solicit comments from the public concerning incidents of exceptional performance by employees of the department. (b) Exemplary employees. The board may consult with the chief of police regarding individual employees who have made outstanding contributions exemplary of equitable, just, and professional policing. (c) Recognition of outstanding contributions. The board may issue public citations recognizing individuals deemed to have made such contributions. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Sec. 2-468. Mediation. The board may propose procedures for the use of mediation or other alternative dispute resolution techniques to resolve complaints against employees of the department. Such procedures shall not affect the ability of complainants to pursue remedies under other sections of this article. (Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, 12-20-21) Secs. 2-469—2-479. Reserved.

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.