Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Minutes
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Aug 19, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
August 19, 2025 – 5:00 PM
Hybrid Meeting (In person at City Council Chambers & virtual via
Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall identify
themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s purview;
that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s discussion and
prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to respond.
Members Present: James Zehmer, Carl Schwarz, Jerry Rosenthal, Jennifer Lauer, Cheri Lewis, Katherine
Tabony, Ron Bailey, Roger Birle, David Timmerman
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Jeff Werner, Kate Richardson, Remy Trail, Kellie Brown, Ose Akinlotan
Pre-Meeting:
Staff went over the incredible public interest of the project at West Main Street. Mr. Zehmer would like to pull
the Martha Jefferson House project from the Consent Agenda. Mr. Zehmer thinks that the door is the original
historic door. Ms. Lewis asked about moving the 4th Street NE project onto the Consent Agenda. There was
discussion among the BAR members about the actionable and public hearing items.
There was also discussion regarding the time when members of the public will speak to the West Main Street
project. Ms. Brown spoke to the timeliness of public comments for the West Main Street. Members of the public
will be allowed to speak at the beginning and again at the time of the West Main Street project.
The Chairman called the meeting to order at 5:35 PM.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – As permitted by the adopted bylaws of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review and to ensure that we can perform our duties tonight in a timely and orderly manner, we move to
amend the usual meeting agenda as follows:
• For items 2 through 7 on tonight’s agenda, staff will introduce each item, followed by the
applicant’s presentation, which will not exceed 10 minutes. We are going to be strict about that
tonight.
• Following the staff and the applicant presentation, the Chair will invite comments from the public.
• The speakers should identify themselves and give their address.
• Speakers will be allowed to speak for 3 minutes. That will include either questions or comments.
• Comments should be limited to our purview. That is regarding the exterior aspects of a project,
per our charge from City Council.
• Per city code, for a major historic review, following public comments, the BAR will offer questions
and comments.
• The applicant will have 3 minutes to respond. That can be extended by the Chair.
2
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• We will allow any comments at the beginning of the meeting.
Second by Mr. Birle. Motion passes 9-0.
A. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Latricia Giles (911 Nassau) – I serve as the executive director of the Public Housing Association of Residents
(PHAR). PHAR is the resident-led voice of Charlottesville’s public housing neighborhoods. I come before you
with the concerns of West Haven and the 10th & Page neighbors, who have already lived through decades of
broken promises, displacement, and exclusion. The proposal before you is not just about design. It is about
whether the city repeats the mistakes of the past choices or chooses a different path. Charlottesville already
scarred West Haven once when it destroyed Vinegar Hill in the name of progress. Families were uprooted,
culture was erased, and communities were left carrying the wounds for generations. For decades, West Haven
has lived at the bottom of the hill looking up at a wall. This is a daily view that residents wake up to now. This
project would raise that wall even higher. If built, families will sleep with headlights shining into their bedrooms
and children will be playing in the shadows of parking decks instead of under trees. Instead of the porches and
open sky, they will be looking onto dumpsters, and service doors of the backside of someone else’s convenience
pushed out into our front yards. This is not repair and not healing. This is exclusion dressed as development. We
are not opposed to change. Residents have been for years have begun to design a future for West Haven that
honors, history, strength, and safety. It keeps community at the center. This project does none of that. It
overshadows and walls off. It predetermines the future of our neighborhood without our consent. That is why
over 300 neighbors and allies to date have signed on for our call to change online and on paper. Together we are
asking for major reductions in the height and scale of the building, for real setbacks, for safe pedestrian
connections, and development that lives alongside community rather than looming over it. We are asking you to
listen not only to the drawings and renderings but to the lived reality of the people who will carry out the weight
of this decision every day. Charlottesville still carries the wounds of Vinegar Hill. We cannot afford to make that
same mistake again. The city can choose a different path, one that uplifts residents, overshadowing them. We
urge you to stand with the residents and say ‘no.’
Rucia Parker (Hardy Drive) – I have lived in the West Haven neighborhood for 20 years. I have been a resident
planner since we started 3 years ago. The height of the building does not match the neighborhood field that we
are trying to create with our masterplan. At ground level from Hardy Drive, it would be visible from all angles.
If our buildings are going up 4 stories from the bottom of Hardy Drive and 11 stories on West Main Street, we
would be looking at a 16-story skyscraper on top of us. It feels like a penitentiary, and we are living in the yard.
Deep step-backs on the West Haven side might make this a little better and make our walkway/ramp feel more
open. Setbacks along the memory walk side could also help avoid creating a closed-in feeling. The BAR can and
should require step-backs as for pictures showing a building with big step-backs.
Mary Anderson – I have lived in West Haven for 8 years. I am a resident planner. I do not like the building. It
is too big to be on top of our neighborhood. The only way to make it better is to have many big step-backs and
have more setback spaces from the property line.
Shirley Gentry – I have been living at West Haven for over 20 years. I am a resident planner. I do not like the
plan for the building. It will be seen from everywhere in West Haven and block us off from the rest of
Charlottesville.
Michael Salvatierra (1321 Welford) – I have been a teacher at Trailblazer Elementary for the last 16 years. I
teach the kids who live in West Haven. With all the history that we have in Charlottesville of residents and
neighborhoods and communities whose voices have been pushed to the side, especially around housing, it is
absurd that we would not put the concerns of the West Haven community as the first priority when making
3
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
decisions above profit or convenience or any of the privileges of students or developers. The community has
been isolated physically. I cannot believe that it is going to happen again. Please listen to and prioritize the
members of the West Haven community.
Betty Jones – I have been in West Haven since April 1992. I pay my rent for a whole year. I am not paying rent
until January. The place is too big. I like it where I am.
Cindy Ivey – I have lived in West Haven for 21 years. I am a resident planner. We need bigger setbacks. We
understand that a setback that is more than what is required is being planned. However, it is not enough. More
space and distance need to be found to reduce the feeling of being crowded. This also is a safety issue. When we
created our masterplan, we removed any small spaces where bad people could gather to do bad things. Having
openness creates visibility. Space on the ground will make the memory walk and the area used to get to the
sports court more open and usable. We need more space between the access road, memory walk, and the sports
court with safety measures in place. We do not want to be walking along an ugly access road. We need to see
drawings that show more setbacks and lighting plans combined with step-backs. More setbacks might keep a
neighborhood feel safe.
Paul Reeder (211 5th Street SW) – I wish to talk about the other student housing project that is being proposed
and is on the agenda tonight. I wish to talk to you about the 7th Street Southwest luxury student housing
proposal. I am the president of the Oak Grove Condominium Owners Association, which backs directly onto the
land subject to this proposal. When I asked Mr. Werner if I might speak tonight, he asked that I be brief because
he anticipated a busy agenda. We welcome the development of this site. As a resident here of over 30 years, I
know it is a wonderfully located parcel of land in the heart of Charlottesville. It should be developed. However,
we want affordable housing, not luxury student housing with a swimming pool. I suspect that you will hear the
same from our friends in West Haven and the opposition that we have already heard tonight. These 2 projects
together are over 1300 students. The good news for Fifeville, which I hope will make your agenda shorter, is that
this land is outside the half-mile radius of the University contemplated by the zoning code and related ordinances
for student housing. Therefore, this land cannot be developed as student housing. You will see from this handout
the language that is used in the zoning code that relates to this half-mile radius. You will also see on that map
from the University of Virginia that shows Central Grounds. There is specific reference to the edge of Central
Grounds. The language of the affordable dwelling regulation specifically says that the land must be within a half
mile of the University with measurement being in a direct line from the edge of the main campus areas to the
edge of the subject parcel. Outlying university owned parcels are not considered part of the campus for the
purpose of this ordinance. According to Apple Maps, this land is 0.7 miles away from the Memorial to Enslaved
Labor. With Google Maps, it is 0.8 miles away from the Memorial to Enslaved Labor. Student housing is an
inappropriate use for this land per the city’s own code.
Stacy Rush – I work for PHAR. I am the community intern coordinator for the Public Housing Association of
Residents. Caged like a bird, I look behind me. There are no birds here. Caged like a zoo, I look behind me.
There are no animals. There are caring residents. This building is a clear disservice to this community. The
structure is a direct impact on the residents’ safety, their health, and their lives. Luxury housing is being built
instead of affordable housing that can be managed is the residents who are already waking up to a concrete wall.
The Standard is that concrete wall. They are blocking sunlight. They are blocking everything else that is in the
city. The impact this has on the mental health is real. Imagine waking up to a wall as a child and expecting to be
happy and even further to learn. There are so many more issues that this development will cause. Let’s do the
right thing by the West Haven community and listen to the residents and their concerns and their needs.
4
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular agenda if
a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to comment on it.
Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Meeting Minutes – May 20, 2025, and June 17, 2025
Motion to Approve Consent Agenda – Mr. Schwarz – Second by Mr. Bailey – Motion passes 9-0.
Mr. Zehmer did pull the Martha Jefferson House from the Consent Agenda.
C. Deferred Items
NA
D. New Items
1. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 25-0100
1600 Gordon Avenue, Tax Parcel 090016000
Rugby Road, University Circle, Venable Neighborhood ADC District
Owner: Martha Jefferson House
Applicant: Mark Barstow
Project: Door replacement
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – Request CoA to replace exterior dolor at entry vestibule.
Mark Barstow, Applicant – I was the director of building and grounds at The Martha Jefferson House. I am
now in charge of special projects there. That is why this project falls under my purview. City staff and I have
been going back and forth on this for several months now. Our interest in this is because of the way our facility
is used. The people that live there now need more assistance getting around using wheelchairs, walkers, etc. Our
current entry system is this front door and another entry door just inside of that. It is going to create some
bottleneck for our residents. As many of you are aware, this is probably the primary concern for us. There have
been an increasing number of safety incidents in our neighborhood. With student housing there, we are
surrounded by the fraternities and sororities. Some of our residents have expressed concern about our current
front entrance from a safety perspective. It is not substantial enough to keep out somebody that really wanted to
get in. With those factors in mind, we feel, from a practical standpoint, that we need to change to a more secure
entrance. Our desire would be to replace the front door. I understand that there are questions about that.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – With the existing door that you are removing, do you need to make it wider? Is that part of it?
Mr. Barstow – When we change it out, we would like to make it wider. I think it is 39 inches. It might be a little
less than that. We propose increasing it to a 40- to 42-inch door.
Mr. Schwarz – Is that the primary reason? I am trying to understand why you want to get rid of the existing
sidelights. Is that the primary reason? Is there a structural reason?
5
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Mr. Barstow – To get the sized door we want with the posts there that are beside the door that frame the
sidelights and the door, we cannot get a bigger door in there with that in place. This would be an aluminum type
storefront door. Our objective is to put an opener that people could use to push to get in and out. With that in
mind, the frame would reduce the width even more to the point of not being practical for us. Whether it happens
out here or inboard of that, that is our objective
Mr. Bailey – What do you know about the historicity of the door? Is it original?
Mr. Barstow – I don’t know that. We have tried to come up with older photographs. Nobody seems to know.
Mr. Bailey – You see it primarily as a safety issue.
Mr. Barstow – That is our primary concern; safety and allowing easier access.
Mr. Bailey – The door would now open outward.
Mr. Barstow – We have considered both options. There is an inner door behind this that has sidelights as well.
If we had an in-swinging door on the outermost part and we are allowed to take that intersection out, it would
make a nice entryway. In that case, we would like to swing it in. If we had to keep the inner part of it, we would
swing it out. It is not as convenient for the residents. It would be an option that we would explore.
Mr. Birle – I have a question about the muttons. Are they applied to both the exterior and the interior surface of
the plaz?
Mr. Barstow – They would be both surfaces. What staff asked me today; I did not have the opportunity to
confirm whether they would have the spacer between. I would assume that would be available. It is not what we
talked about when we had this door quoted.
Mr. Timmerman – What is your reason for going with glass and not just another solid door?
Mr. Barstow – It would be for visibility. Our security guard is just inside and to the right. He can see into the
doorway there. It is also nice to let light in.
Mr. Schwarz – We have 2 options in here. I don’t know if staff made that or if you did between divided lights
and no divided lights. Did you have a preference?
Mr. Barstow – I am not a big fan of the fake lights. It is hard to make them look real. We did that as a way that
it could be appealing in one sense. Personally, I would like to see it open. If it was an issue with this board or
anybody else, we are happy to do it the other way. That is why we wanted to present both options.
Mr. Timmerman – Have you considered a half-window instead of a full window?
Mr. Barstow – We have not considered it. I don’t know if that would be available in this type of door. It is an
aluminum frame door. We are really trying to beef up the security of that area by putting in a legitimate door
system, not just replacing that door with another door. We are trying to get a more secure entryway one way or
another
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
6
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Zehmer – I stopped by this afternoon. I want to thank you for letting me look at the door. I did have a big
question after we looked at this project a couple months ago. With the photographs, it was hard to tell how
historic the door was. I think that the door is probably original based on the historic floor plans that you found.
The molding profile around the panels of the 8-panel door matches the molding profiles of the 2 closet doors
that are immediately adjacent to it. They also match the original rear door to the building, which is an 8-panel
door. The archetrates around the door match the closet doors and the rear door. It seems to me that this is the
original door along with the original sidelights. By our guidelines, I cannot support replacing this door. I
empathize with what you are trying to achieve. I talked with Rebecca about talking to a hardware consultant.
They could find a way to beef up the hardware on the door to provide some additional security and an
operator. I have done a lot of projects where we have retrofitted historic doors with operators. I know it is not
our purview. There is a sprinkler pipe right over the door on the inside. That might be a challenge. Looking at
our guidelines under Section 4: Rehabilitation, Part D: Entrances, Porches, and Doors, entrances and porches
are often the primary focal points of historic buildings. Their decoration and articulation help define the style
of the structure. Entrances are functional and ceremonial elements for all buildings. The important focal point
of an entrance or porch is the door. Doors are often character defining features of the architectural style of the
building. In this case, it would include the skylights and the mullions that frame the door separating it from the
skylights. In the details, do not remove or radically change entrances or porches important in defining the
building’s overall historic character. The original size and shape of the door opening should be maintained.
These things steer me towards not being able to approve this. I would welcome discussion from the rest of the
BAR. There might be a way considering storm that windows with safety glass over the sidelights would be
another way to achieve higher security on the sidelights without having to remove the historic feature.
Mr. Barstow – Another consideration of ours was taking out that inner door and putting the substantial door
in there, which would not change the front of the building.
Mr. Zehmer – That is outside our purview. It is inside the building. You can do whatever you want to that
door. Since I was able to see it, I do not think it is historic. From that perspective, it is not shown on the
original floorplans. That is not our purview. I also don’t think that was historic.
Mr. Barstow – You are focused on the exterior of the building. That is it. Is that under staff’s guidelines? I get
your concerns about the exterior. I don’t see a way to do it and keep it looking historic. We do need to achieve
something with this entryway. If this is where your decision stops and you all don’t agree to move forward
with this request, that is probably the place we would go. It does create a little more of a bottleneck for people.
Currently, that is our secure door.
Mr. Schwarz – As an assisted living facility, I think for the functionality of it and because they would be
maintaining the entire ornate surround around the door, I would be willing to accept the new door in its place.
I think I would favor the not having divided lights. I will leave that up to you to decide as long as those
divided lights meet our guidelines with the spacer and all the other requirements.
Mr. Birle – I was also taking into consideration the use and was willing to think about a wider door until you
said the existing door is 39 inches. That is a wide door.
Mr. Barstow – I cannot remember. I was not there today. I did not have an opportunity to measure it.
7
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Mr. Birle – Whether it is original or a 1950s Milton Greg edition, it is still significant. There is some fine
detailing in the mullion and the leaded glass. With the thought that this is not a small door, it is a door that a
wheelchair can easily get through. I agree with Mr. Zehmer.
Ms. Lewis – With our guidelines, looking at the portions that Mr. Zehmer referenced under rehabilitation,
entrances, porches, and doors should not strip entrances and porches of historic materials or details. Do not
remove or radically change entrances or porches. It is important in defining the building’s overall historic
character. Don’t remove transoms or sidelights, which is part of your proposal.
It seems like a solid door would be more secure. You want to bolster security, maybe have a push-button
where somebody could open it if they need that help. It just seems like a solid door. A glass door would offer
security from the exterior that you want. I would remove the sidelights and the things that are choking down
the entryway from the interior of the building. I think that would mostly solve your problem. The original
architecture with the closets made that passage narrow.
Mr. Barstow – That door would not be usable by our residents as a primary door. We keep that open most of
the time. It is too heavy and cumbersome. It is an old, heavy, wooden door. From a practical standpoint, we
keep that open most of the time now. The inner door is the secure one. It is not something that is navigable by
our residents for the most part. When they need to get out and we have that closed in bad weather, there is a
security guy who will go out and assist them out the door. It is not a practical entrance for this type of facility.
Mr. Werner – I found the notes from when you and I talked. The opening for the wood door is 40 inches. The
idea was that when you assemble a commercial storefront frame to put in there, if it fits into that opening, it
reduces it below 36 inches. It is also anchoring it into the wood frame that is there. If it allowed the entire
opening to be used, that gave them freedom to have a wider door that anchored into the wall frame itself.
Mr. Bailey – With regards to Beth Israel, we allowed them to change the doors for safety purposes. I don’t
know what changes were done. The doors in that case would open outward as opposed to inward. I assume
they had to do something with the original doors that modified them to do that.
Mr. Zehmer – That is what I was suggesting. They could talk to a hardware consultant to see if they could
retrofit the existing door with electronic strike. A pushbutton-door operator could also be tied into your
security system. The person at the front desk could buzz somebody in. There would not have to be a person
out there. I would be Ok with that because that is trying to modernize the historic door to suit your purposes.
Mr. Barstow – We have not investigated the opener part. We do have the strike system on the inner door right
now. I am sure that part could be done. The opener would be an issue because it is such a hard door to open.
Mr. Timmerman – Mr. Zehmer’s idea would be my number 1. If that would not work for whatever reason, I
would be willing to entertain a replacement. However, I don’t think that the kind of aluminum storefront is
appropriate here. I would want a replacement that is historically more in line. I agree with Ms. Lewis. A smaller
light might be more advantageous to your purpose. It is such a beautiful door. I would not want to get rid of the
sidelights. The width is adequate for what you need given your use. I don’t want to hamper the people that are
in need.
Mr. Barstow – I appreciate what you are saying. The issue was if we had put an aluminum frame inside of
that, it would have squeezed the door too much. We need to do more homework on this part if we want to
change that up.
8
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Mr. Zehmer – There are a couple of different ways we can go about this. We can either vote on it and see
where we land, which would be approval or denial. We can defer it, which would mean you would have to
bring it back to us within a month. You can request a deferral. If you would like to explore a different
hardware option, those are the 3 options.
Mr. Werner – My recommendation would be that Mr. Barstow ask for a deferral, and we tinker with this a
little bit more.
Mr. Barstow requests a deferral – Motion to accept the applicant’s deferral – Ms. Lewis – Second by
Mr. Zehmer – Motion passes 9-0.
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 24-0051
300 Ridge Street, Tax Parcel 280151000
Ridge Street ADC District
Owner/Applicant: Carla Shifflett
Project: Alteration/addition
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA request for a second-floor addition onto and within the footprint of an existing
single-story, brick structure. Notes from discussion with applicant:
• The tower and railing on the roof are the preferred option; however, that decision will be evaluated as the
project budget is finalized.
• New windows will be metal, storefront to match existing.
• Roof will drain to the south (rear) elevation. Anticipate two external scuppers and downspouts.
Greg Jackson, Applicant – Our intent is to add another level. One of the previous times that we came to you
we were thinking that we had to go to the side. What we are doing is going up above it like the sketch. We are
raising the height of the main floor there. We are trying to keep it all together, keep the original building but
having the addition be something different, but work with it complimentary. What we are doing is adding 3
layers of soldier course, the brick with the similar brick. We are going with cast stone. It is a typical material
used in these types of brick structures, just trying to get that base high because the next floor has height. We
need the height for the Pilates studio. That whole upper level is metal siding. We kept the corners because the
original building has these interesting jut out corners of a foot. We looked at maybe just trying to keep it clean
up top. There are a lot of corners to track when we are doing with all the metal trim. We felt that was interesting
enough to keep going with it. Capping it at the top and making it regular all the way around with the band there,
all tracking to keep the height. You can see that in this section, going with canopies instead of those portico
roofed structure with columns on the Monticello Avenue side with these more modern type of canopies with
gables, balconies on the east side. With an earlier version with the sketches, we had the stairs and the tower on
the Monticello side. The tower ended up being on that corner, which makes it not too much right there
demanding too much attention. It was just a much better location for the staircase to go up and down there. We
have different levels because there is another level below this. It is a 9-foot, 10-foot, and 11-foot heights. The
intent is to have the roof deck access up there. We will have to see how that pans out with the budget, code, and
considerations like that. It is a low sloped roof to the backside, to the northside. The northside is without
windows and plain. There is a chance and opportunity that there might be a building of some size up against it
on that property line.
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Rosenthal – What is your HVAC situation?
9
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Mr. Jackson – On the north elevation, that is directly against the adjacent property. There is an area for the
units to be out there. There is a compressor unit already out there. We would just add more.
Ms. Tabony – With the windows on the upper level, the grey area, there are 2 flanking windows around a
vertical window. Are those double hung?
Mr. Jackson – They are probably going to be awnings. I imagine there is one fix and an awning. We want to
have some operable windows. We wanted to have some articulation. They are the same proportion and size of
the lower ones. We wanted to change it up a little bit.
Mr. Schwarz – You gave us this sheet. It looks like you have the vertical siding profile on there. What are you
thinking for the horizontal siding? Is it a lap siding?
Mr. Jackson – This is the kind of siding. You can have it directly against each other or you can have a variation
of gaps. (The applicant brought in a sample). We are going to have this going horizontal on the middle section.
We are probably going to go with something like 16 or 18. For the vertical on the corners, we are going to keep
that at the minimum they have in these at 1-foot.
Mr. Timmerman – What do you do at the soffit where the indent is?
Mr. Jackson – That could still be the same material. That is one foot and that would fit in there. We have not
detailed all the trim. There is a good company. They cover everything. It is just the color that I was thinking
about. I am happy to provide that when we think more about it. It could easily just be the same as what wraps
the corner. I thought it might be interesting to make it a little bit darker and a little bit cooler. It is a detail that I
am not sure.
Mr. Timmerman – With the metal paneling, what do you do at the corners?
Mr. Jackson – That is a trim. It is going to be a trimmed piece. They have all that. We are happy to show what
that is. I don’t think there are options on wide or thin. We will go with the thinnest profile the most.
Mr. Timmerman – Was the idea that you would keep the existing windows below?
Mr. Jackson – I think so. Ideally, we might change them up. They are not in bad condition. There is an intent
to stay within a certain budget. There are newer windows down below.
Mr. Birle – With the face that has no windows (south)
Mr. Jackson – All the lighting and colors on the main façade are going to be north. We tried it. When we were
selecting, we tried direct light and indirect light. We realized that a lot of it is going to be in shade/shadow.
Mr. Birle – What is that color facing? I am trying to get a sense of what that blank wall is up against.
Mr. Jackson – There is about 5 feet to the property line. There is a parking lot behind, which is currently a
tattoo bar and then a little market.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
10
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Bailey – I like the design. It is a very elegant design for a space that is really boring right now. It will be an
enhancement to the block.
Ms. Lewis – I agree. Thank you for retaining those big windows on the ground floor and taking them up and
using the corners, those interesting brick corners and using the first story existing brick. I hope that you can do
the deck. It really ups the beauty of the building.
Mr. Rosenthal – I like the design. If you can pull off doing the deck, that would enhance the property.
Motion – Ms. Lewis - Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC
District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed alterations to 300 Ridge Street satisfy the BAR’s
criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the
BAR approves the application as submitted. Second by Mr. Bailey. Motion passes 8-0.
3. Certificate of Appropriate Application
BAR # 25-0099
310 4th Street NE, #201; Tax Parcel 330205L00
North Downtown ADC District
Owner: Court Square LLC; Great Eastern Management Co.
Applicant: Caitlin Byrd Schafer
Project: New roof structure over existing patio
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA for installation of a roof and columns at the existing patio facing East High
Street.
Mark Kestner, Applicant – I don’t think there should be a return on the roof gables. The 2 wings are not
symmetrical. That create an asymmetrical condition on each side, which would draw more emphasis to that
condition. It is just a polite shed with a straight termination.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Birle – With the gabled end, what material are you putting in that little piece of gable end that is sticking
out?
Mr. Kestner – It will be fiber cement to match the rest of the trim work.
Ms. Lewis – Is this being driven by the occupant/tenant in that space?
11
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Mr. Kestner – Both. I think there is a desire to have a more inviting space. I don’t think there is a lot of use of
that patio now. If we had a cover over it and created more of a room outside, there are 2 tenants on that floor.
They would both use it and appreciate it.
Ms. Lewis – This will encourage use.
Mr. Kestner – A ceiling and some slow-moving fans will bring it down to a pedestrian scale. It does not feel
good when you are out there on the space. It feels like you are exposed. The roof will add to that atmosphere.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Motion – Mr. Timmerman - Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including
the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed patio roof at 310 4th Street NE satisfies
the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and
that the BAR approves the application as submitted. Second by Ms. Lewis. Motion passes 9-0.
The Chair recessed the meeting until 7 PM.
The meeting was called back to order at 7:02 PM.
E. Other Business
4. Pre-Application Conference
No formal action will be taken.
BAR # 25-0097
714 Ridge Street, Tax Parcel 250077000
Ridge Street ADC District
Owner: 270 Partners LLC
Applicant: Kevin Schafer, Design Develop
Project: Two residential structures with dwelling units
• Staff presented this project to the BAR.
• The proposal is 2 residential units on a vacant lot in the Ridge Street ADC District.
• Staff laid out how these proposed 2 residential units relate to other buildings and structures within the ADC
District.
• The parcel is the most southern parcel of this ADC District.
• This proposal does include a boundary line adjustment with 2 parcels.
• This area is zoned R-A. Height is 3 stories.
• Applicant stated that more attention does need to be paid to the mass of the proposed residential structures.
• Adjacent properties are residential in nature and residential in scale.
• The applicant is committing to a gable roof over a 2-story brick mass and embracing that gable roof form.
• The applicant does like to evaluate things from the street level and a pedestrian level.
• The large retaining walls with this proposal will be removed to work with the topography.
• The R-A zoning does allow for a duplex.
• Ms. Tabony asked moving closer to the Lankford side of the property. There are topographical issues on that
side of the parcel.
12
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• Ms. Tabony asked if there was an opportunity to address Ridge Street given the adjacent properties.
• Mr. Zehmer would like for there to be slight differences with the 2 buildings, such as addressing the corner.
• Ms. Tabony did point out that some of the best views of the city are at this location.
• Members of the BAR did provide suggestions and feedback on how the proposed project can be improved.
• Ms. Lewis and Mr. Zehmer did bring up the importance and appearance of porches in the Ridge Street ADC
District.
• The applicant did take note of the importance of addressing the corner, outdoor spaces/porches, and removing
of the retaining walls in the back.
5. Pre-Application Conference
No formal action will be taken.
BAR # 25-0095
835 West Main Street, Tax Parcel 310183000
843 West Main Street, Tax Parcel 310175000
847 West Main Street; Tax Parcel 310174000
West Main Street ADC District
Owners: Kim T. & Chris Dabney; Fluvanna Holdings, LLC
Applicants: Megan Nedostup & Andree Sahakian, Contractor
Project: Multi-story housing development
• Staff presented this proposed project.
• There has been a series of houses on this parcel. The lot is currently vacant and a parking lot.
• The proposal would be a combination of 3 separate parcels for this project.
• Applicant does need to address the questions and issues about the height. Applicant also needs to address the
concerns raised by the neighbors.
• The guidelines do say that there needs to be recognition and care for the neighborhoods that surround this
project.
• BAR approval is required for the applicant to build this proposed project on this property.
• The applicant did go through the site plan and building design.
• The applicant has started neighborhood outreach to Westhaven and 10th & Page neighborhoods.
• The applicant did emphasize the importance of the pedestrian connection from West Haven to West Main
Street in the Westhaven Redevelopment Plan.
• The applicant is focused on safety and security using lighting and bollards along the pedestrian connection to
West Main Street.
• The applicant did go over the design for this proposed project and the need for housing outlined in the
Comprehensive Plan.
• The parcel is zoned CX-8. The setbacks for this zoning are 0 feet. The applicant is not intending to have
setbacks at 0 feet.
• There are future trees planned for this project.
• 11 stories/156 feet are allowed for the CX-8 zoning.
• The applicant introduced a 25-foot step-back at the northwest corner of the proposed building.
• The applicant introduced the massing strategy and massing plan for this proposed building.
• The applicant did provide the context of the building and the surrounding buildings, structures, houses, and the
neighborhoods around the proposed building.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
13
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Joy Johnson (Hardy Drive) – I am the Chair of PHAR. I have lived in Westhaven for many years. I do not
appreciate using my name in your presentation after the fact of what you did. I know some of what I might say
you cannot consider. You need to know the facts. They started their planning in April. For 3 years, we worked
on our site plan. The first I heard of it was when they came to a meeting to say that ‘this is what we are going to
build.’ That is not how we operate in Westhaven. That is not how we operate in the whole redevelopment of our
public housing. We suggested to them that what they should have done was have a meeting with the whole 10th
& Page Neighborhood and include Westhaven to talk about the design and to incorporate what we were doing
in their plans. This is very disrespectful the way this went down. Our residents work very hard to come up with
a design of what their neighborhood could look like. I am hoping tonight that you all can do some setbacks with
what they are doing. We talked about the memory walk. That is the idea you all took and went back. If you look
at the side of the building, it is going to block our memory wall. It is going to be a wall that is blocking the
history of Vinegar Hill, the history of what we are trying to present. You have the Drewery Brown Memory
Wall Bridge right there, which is very historic. What I am pleading to you all is to think about how Westhaven
was built, how it was dug out, how we were sitting in the bottom. If you can look at our plans, they showed you
some of our site plans. There is a rendering of where we can show where we are looking up. We are not looking
at a building. We are looking into a community that we would like to be connected to. Please don’t ever use my
name unless I ask you to use it in not telling the truth.
Avana Key – I am a resident of Westhaven. I have been a resident of Westhaven for 8 years. Can you show
more images and ranges of lighting along the memory walk? The way that you showed the image of the
walkway, the memory walk to Main Street, is very little. The Standard is right there. I am on the bottom. I have
kids. I don’t want my kids to be going up to Main Street. You have steps. I understand you have steps on this
side. You have a very narrow spot. Where the train is, can you show more space, put more space if you are
going to put this building up? That is all I am asking.
Betsy Roettger – I am on the Planning Commission. Some of my issue with this whole thing is the city’s fault.
That site should have been looked at more sensitively. Since we are here and it is by right, there are some things
that could be looked at. You will hear a lot about how Westhaven feels and literally is often walled off. We
heard from people on Westhaven Day talking about how the chain-link fence used to be locked to West Main
Street at 9 PM every night. There is a lot of want and to get some connection back up to that street. That is what
the site plan does. It connects people to bus stops. Right now, there is no accessible way to get up there. You
must walk all the way to 10th Street and around. The basketball court is up there. One of the concerns is how
that is going to fit in with this large student housing project. Some of the things that I was looking at in the
guidelines was how the building should relate to the adjoining neighbors. ‘Relate’ is a subjective term. I did
think a couple of things reinforced the human scale. Along the promenade, that edge is seen as a side street. In
this case, it should be seen as a public walkway just as important as Main Street. Some of the images showed
coming over the bridge looking at the building. That is the entrance to this cavern of student housing. That edge
having the parking garage along the walkway loses some of the liveliness that was alluded to along West Main
Street. With the transparency, that does not have transparency along that edge because we are looking at cars.
That whole edge is problematic on the street level. There is one exit door. On the back elevation, start showing
the HVAC equipment, delivery service, the garage doors, and how those trees might screen some of that. I don’t
think we have seen what that back looks like. We mentioned the headlights shinning into the apartments from
that side. With working with the resident planners, a couple of things have come up. One of the things that we
don’t see is the way some spaces are used. What I thought was striking was the way private security influences
neighbors. We have heard that the security at The Standard has been difficult. That edge needs a lot more work.
Any step-backs in getting more sunlight down the hill would be helpful.
Brandon Collins – I have lived here my whole life. I have had the great honor to work with Westhaven
residents for the past 3 years on developing their masterplan and moving forward with a buildable and livable
14
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
new community with 5 main goals. Those goals have been hard to meet. The reason why we bring up their plan
is because it relates to this building that you are talking about today. If you understand our plan, you will see the
same things we are seeing. I think you will find the same issues. You will find that your design guidelines allow
you to comment on these issues that we have seen. Two of the biggest goals we have had are how we increase
density for affordable housing but still have a neighborhood that is not crowded, not too tall, and how we access
West Main Street in a meaningful way. That has been blocked off. The neighborhood has been secluded from
sight and from access since before 1964. Our resident planners, who have spent a lot of time on this, have come
up with something. It is very uncomfortable to increase density. They have come up with some buildings about
as tall as they can handle in the neighborhood. As a result, we are providing more affordable housing. They
have also expanded their usable open space by 4.5 times. When they are looking east, it is not a giant cavern
between the apartment buildings they will have and the townhomes they will have on the other side. What this
building does is present 11 stories on top of 3 or 4 stories that they are building for about a 15- to 16-story
skyscraper from every point in the bottom of Westhaven. People in Westhaven must deal with this from The
Standard. It is a psychological burden and a symbol of exclusion. No matter how much of a setback there is, it is
still going to be there. It is a giant wall there psychologically blocking the community from the rest of
Charlottesville. That is a shame. One of our goals is making up for those past injustices. We are not going to be
able to do that if we continue to seclude the neighborhood. How do you address it? Maybe step-backs and a tree
line. The footprint needs to be smaller for that building. With the walkway to West Main, it is not enough space.
They need to put in an access road. It is unsafe because of how people gather.
Janet Nordinson – I have been at Westhaven for 31 years. This building is a big distraction to what the
residents want. It blocks everything. I don’t like it, and it is ugly. What they have planned to put there, without
this building, looks nice. I hope you all consider it. The safety issue is another thing for everyone around it.
Wendy Goyo – I am a community organizer at the Public Housing Association of Residents. Westhaven and
10th & Page neighbors are greatly concerned about the incredible height of this building and how it would tower
over Westhaven, making residents feel more crowded in, claustrophobic, and entrapped. I know that I am
supposed to comment on architecture. There are several historians on this board. You cannot talk about
architecture or height without understanding the history of Westhaven. This is an 11-story building, which is
already a gigantic building from ground level. To talk about height, you must acknowledge the fact that
Westhaven was purposefully dug into the ground 16 feet when it was constructed in 1964 to house the displaced
residents of Vinegar Hill. When we are talking about an 11-story building, this is an 11-story plus building to
residents of Westhaven because Westhaven already sits at the base of a hill. The thing with architecture is you
cannot divorce it from the legacies of enslavement, Jim Crow, urban renewal, and gentrification. It has long a
been priority for Westhaven residents to have an accessible walking path from Westhaven to West Main Street
once Westhaven redevelopment is complete. This building would sit on top of the Westhaven residents’
proposed walkway and obstruct their accessibility and visibility. Things that might help include adding several
step-backs on the Westhaven side to gradually increase height, increase the step-backs even more than the
developer’s voluntary proposal of 60 to 75 feet, and improve the safety on the pedestrian walkway by adding an
access road for the Westhaven residents’ memory walkway.
Sofia Marrero – I am a community organizer with the Public Housing Association of Residents. There are a lot
of concerns concerning this building. I am here to further demand that consideration is taken into place about
Westhaven residents. More step-backs starting at the second floor increased, more step-backs starting at the
second floor are added. Increasing the step-backs improving pedestrian safety by adding space to separate the
road from the memory walk and removing the massive wall along the Westhaven walking path to West Main in
the current plans to allow for more connection.
15
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
James Bryant (10th Street Northwest) – I am the Vice-President of the 10th & Page Neighborhood Association.
I was compelled to come tonight because I have a deep connection and affection for the residents of Hardy
Drive. I once lived on Hardy Drive from 1965 to 1975. When I first heard about this project/building being
placed on West Main Street, I was astonished and dismayed that the residents again must endure this tall
building, feeling boxed in. I am hoping that this Board of Architectural Review will take into consideration that
the residents, based on the feedback that they received at the community meeting at the Heritage Center, is not
in favor of this project. I cannot imagine waking up every morning looking at this tall building hovering over
Hardy Drive. I walked over there yesterday. I stood in the middle of Hardy Drive. I looked to my left, my right,
and up. I was probably more depressed after having taken that walk. The residents of Hardy Drive have not
even had an opportunity to rebuild. Hardy Drive has not had a makeover since 1964. It is time for them to have
a makeover. To have a makeover and to look up at this building hovering over them, it is not what the residents
want to see or have in the neighborhood. The 10th & Page residents feel the same way. The 10th & Page
neighborhood does not yet have a small area plan, but neighbors have consistently said that ‘we want gradual,
not abrupt building height increases.’ As you are looking and dissecting this project, I hope that you will take
that into consideration; the height, the way it looks, and the residents of Hardy Drive and of the 10th & Page
neighborhood.
Michael Payne – I echo what everyone else has said. This is the only body that the residents of Westhaven and
10th & Page have any opportunity to make their voices heard or have any opportunity to have democratic
control over what is built in an area that they have spent years designing. This will not go to the Planning
Commission or City Council. There is a reason for that. The zoning on this parcel is CX-8. It allows 11 stories
by right with unlimited density. There is a reason it is that designation. When we developed the zoning, there
was a strong push to maintain special use permits around 10th & Page, Fifeville, Rose Hill, Kindlewood,
Westhaven, and other public housing sites. Not to say that increased density or height could not be built, but to
give the residents a voice and have the ability for them to have what is built match the designs they have spent
years building. That decision was rolled back by planners who thought they knew better. One of the exact words
was, ‘This area of West Main is an area where large student apartments want to go.’ That change was rolled
back. We all know the history of urban renewal. There are a lot of lessons to take from it. One of the lessons I
take is the importance of humility in city decision makers and the danger of arrogance for decision makers who
never have to live with the consequences of the decisions they have made. There is a great documentary about
West Main Street. It is about the 80s and 90s on West Main Street. It is a fascinating look at the history of West
Main when it was an intersection of historic black neighborhoods, working class white residents, and UVA
students. It made me think of what alternative futures could have been. Now, it is a corridor of, by, and for
UVA students. What if the city had been as intentional about creating a black business district as we were in
creating the Downtown Mall? What if we thought beyond either or decision-making and beyond the free market
delivering what is going to create historic justice? Are we confident that we are not able to repeat the mistakes
of urban renewal? Is this time different? Is this time the decision makers who did not grow up in Westhaven,
did not live in Westhaven, don’t socialize in Westhaven? Do they know better this time? If on reflection,
anyone listening feels that they are not confident that this time we do know better, we need to return special use
permits and discretionary decisions into more areas of the zoning, especially areas where we are allowing 7 and
10 stories by right. It does not block change in density. Our largest apartments were approved under the old
zoning with special use permits. It allows for community benefits, agreements, addressing hyper-local concerns
and addressing the history of the city. If anybody in the audience is concerned about this, you need to email City
Council to change the zoning, to reintroduce more special use permits. You need to come to our meetings and
let us hear that. You need to go to Planning Commission meetings and let us hear that. Unless that changes, this
is going to be the future throughout Fifeville, 10th & Page, and Rose Hill. There will be nothing you can do
about it.
16
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Anthony Malabad (4000 City Walkway) – While I was here listening to the first public comment period, there
was something that struck me, the idea of being caged in, being blocked from the outside world. I investigated
the numbers. What I found was concerning. I understand the Board only dealing with exterior things with
buildings. I feel that this is pertinent to the exterior and to the Westhaven community. The elevation of the front
of the parcel in question is 505 feet above sea level. I looked on the city GIS website to get these figures. The
closest building in Westhaven sits at 476 feet. That is a difference of about 30 feet. Assuming 10 feet per story,
that is 110 feet. That is 140 feet difference in total. Assuming there is 90 feet in between the building and
Westhaven. That means someone standing on the ground in West Haven would be looking at the top of this new
building would be looking up at a 57-degree angle. If you extend that to the 100-foot distance from the
presentation, 75-foot distance between buildings, and a 25-foot setback, you only lower that angle to 54.5
degrees. This is the problem. We sit almost exactly on the 38th parallel north. The sun at equinox reaches a
maximum of 52 degrees above the horizon. While the sun gets higher in the summer, what this building would
mean is that there would be parts of Westhaven that would be in complete shadow for more than half the year.
That is unacceptable. I would urge the Board to listen to the concerns of Westhaven residents.
Earl Hicks (808 Hardy Drive) – I am a resident of Westhaven and a native of Charlottesville. I come here today
to say this. I don’t approve of this building. I don’t approve of the design of this building. I want to say that you
look at generations that have lived on Hardy Drive. I stand on my porch every day. I look up and down Hardy
Drive. I see kids playing in the street. I see kids running up and down the sidewalks. When in my backyard, I
look up and imagine an 11-story building standing in our backyard depriving us of, not only sunshine, but
locking us in. I know that some of you heard about urban renewal. Do we want to go back to that again? Do we
want to relive that? I know I don’t. I am 52 years old. I have family that lived on Hardy Drive from the 70s, 80s,
and onward. I am the next generation. I am speaking for the next generation. I had to say something. I could not
let this pass without saying something. I am for my residents, my Westhaven community.
.
Emily Axelboom (Monticello Road) – I agree with so many that have spoken tonight about the massiveness of
the building, not only 11 stories tall, but 120 feet long. The height is out of scale with all the surrounding
buildings. It is even out of scale with The Standard. In terms of context for each proposal tonight, I have heard
you talk about your feelings about a historic door, a rooftop patio, a porch, and these small details. I have heard
the community reacting to a very large structure/building. I hope you are listening closely to how those
individuals that are living the closest are feeling about this project and taking their feelings at the center of your
decision making. I heard at the beginning that you don’t have all the power. You do have some power as
individuals in this community and as the volunteers that you are on this board, I am encouraging you to use the
power that you have, even if it is a small piece of a larger puzzle of ways that we can ask for changes that the
community wants to see.
Gloria Beard (1116 Page Street) – It took my 30 years to buy my home. I am from Staunton. I used to come
over here as a teenager to visit friends on Hardy Drive. It is 2025. They have never given these people air
conditioning. That is horrible. Everybody is building up, fixing up, doing whatever. Why haven’t these people
been raised up? What is going on? They want to build a big and tall building. My taxes are going to go up. I
work too hard. I use my social security check to pay more taxes for other people. I don’t know how long I have
left on this earth. You consider these people on Hardy Drive and us on 10th & Page. You can find another spot
to build this 11-story building. It does not have to be right there. It cannot be all about money all the time. Think
about all the people, not just some of the people.
Jessie Gamman (810 Page Street) – Everyone has already had a lot of beautiful comments. I don’t think I need
to add much. I hope that you support the residents of Hardy Drive and do the right thing.
17
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
Zyanna Bryant (North Downtown) – I want to make it clear that there are people in this room who have
spoken to you this evening, who have been advocating for the Westhaven community for decades. Ms. Joy
Johnson is an example of that. They are all examples of people, who have been advocating for this
neighborhood since before I was born. Being that I am 24, this is an intergenerational fight. This is something
that people, who are my age and younger are paying attention to. As someone, who is a homeowner at a young
age, I am thinking about how I want to continue to invest in this community and invest in Charlottesville, the
greater metropolitan area. It is important to think about what the trajectory of that future looks like. Councilor
Payne is correct. This is the only public on the record forum where people can come and bring their concerns. I
hope that they are being taken seriously. We appreciate your time. Thank you for not cutting anyone off who
has gone off the design comment parameter. It is important to make sure that everyone feels like they have a
voice, and they can make their voice heard. In 1975, there was a riot. There are historians who are on your
body. It is important to remember that in 1975, there were young people who were walking from Westhaven to
the Safeway. They were being harassed by the police. When we think about this idea of design and architecture
and how that can either stand in the way of community or it can create open dialogue and open opportunities for
community to be built. That 1975 riot is a prime example of what neighbors are fearing. It is an incident that
was documented in the newspaper. It is discussed how the young people from Westhaven felt very unwelcome
in that corridor, that space between Westhaven and Main Street and the surrounding neighborhoods there. It is
important to think about how space will be navigated and how people will exist in space who are from
Westhaven, 10th & Page, and what it looks like when students, those who have wealth, access, and privilege are
put into a neighborhood where there are people who do not have as much wealth, access, and privilege and that
confrontation within space and how that happens. Students are looking for affordable housing. That is the part
that nobody is saying out loud. Students at UVA are not willingly just paying $2,000 for rent. If they have
cheaper options, it pushes them into low-income neighborhoods. Keep that in mind.
Eugene Yong – I am a resident of Charlottesville and in the unique position of being the landscape architecture
consultant for both projects: Westhaven and for LB Collective. They have their own landscape architects. We
have been asked to work on the promenade or the connection from Westhaven to Main Street. We joined this
project to be an advocate for Westhaven. We have not had the position to be an advocate because we were
given the path on the edges of the building. We have not been able to work on the promenade or connection.
We were just given a space to plant. We spent 3 years working with the community to design a real
neighborhood. If you could step back and designed a neighborhood and someone built a couple block long 140-
foot building right over it and you were in shadow half the year, you would think differently about it. This is
from the last meeting we attended. It was the security issue. Security for white students or white people usually
means violence for black, brown, and low-income people. That is something to consider as well. If there is a
promenade that honors memory and history, it would have some width and breadth to it. Maybe it becomes a
city and safe promenade for everyone.
Multiple letters were sent to city staff and added into the record. Those letters will be added to the minutes for
this BAR meeting. The letters reiterated many of the comments made by members of the public during
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC.
COMMENTS/QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
• Staff reminded the BAR that the BAR is responding to the ordinance and development code by the City
Council.
• There are 2 tools relative to height, massing, and scale that the BAR can use. Conditions can be adopted that
might require a reduction in height or massing consistent with the city’s design guidelines subject to the
following limitations.
o BAR may reduce the allowed height by no more than 2 stories.
o BAR may require upper story step-backs of up to 25 feet.
18
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• Staff is concerned about some of the comments made by members of the public. The BAR is operating ‘in a
box’ with a zoning ordinance that was not adopted by the BAR. The BAR does not have the purview to change
the zoning ordinance.
• The BAR can only go as far as Council has given permission to go.
• There are still conflicts with the zoning ordinance that still need to be evaluated and understood.
• Since the building has more than 10 units, 10 percent of those units would have to be affordable at a certain
rate. The other choice is to pay into a fund.
• If the BAR reduces the height, there will be complaints about reducing the number of units or reducing the
amount of money going into the fund.
• There is the question of what the BAR can do with a structure that has an affordable housing bonus.
• Staff recommended that the BAR look at the proposal through the design guidelines and what the guidelines
say.
• Staff reminded that the BAR cannot require a private landowner to make their property accessible.
• The BAR discussion started with the measured height of the building and how the height is measured.
• Mr. Birle stated that the building was too tall for West Main Street.
• The Chair reminded everybody that there would be no vote on this proposed project.
• Mr. Schwarz did state that he voted for the new zoning ordinance. Commissioner Schwarz voted for this, and
that the BAR would have full control.
• Special use permits were taken out because there was the thought that special use permits would interfere
with housing production.
• Mr. Schwarz said that there needs to be 25-foot step-backs on the north, east, and south sides of this building.
• Mr. Schwarz said that the height of the building should be reduced by 2 stories for a good part of the north
side, creating 2 step-backs facing Westhaven.
• Commissioner Schwarz said that the base being parking is a hostile environment for pedestrian use along
there.
• With the memory walk, it is going to feel dangerous with all the parking. There is also going to be a lot of
lighting going into Westhaven and 10th & Page.
• Mr. Schwarz did not know why the Westhaven masterplan with the walkway up to Main Street did not make
it into city planning and not become part of something.
• Mr. Schwarz would like for the applicant to make the walkway to Main Street happen.
• Mr. Schwarz had concerns about the height and heaviness of the tower piece coming down Main Street on the
northeast corner. It is not an entry feature to the University.
• Mr. Schwarz commented on the massiveness and breaking down the façade.
• Ms. Tabony stated that there was a missed opportunity with the walkway to Main Street and incorporating the
Westhaven Master Plan and engaging the neighborhood in a public partnership.
• Ms. Tabony stated that this is not a celebration of anything and ‘shove you out of the way.’
• Ms. Lauer asked the applicant to talk about the concept of the promenade and connecting the historic bridge
with the community.
• The applicants stated that they were taking the backgrounds and finding a way to connect that to Main Street.
• From the property line, there is 20 to 25 feet of a setback to allow the access, according to the applicant.
• The renderings that are being shown by the applicant are highly conceptual at this point.
• Mr. Zehmer did visit the site. Mr. Zehmer told the applicant that this proposed building is entirely too big and
too tall.
• Mr. Zehmer also asked the applicant to engage the surrounding neighborhoods including 10th & Page and
Westhaven.
• Mr. Timmerman provided feedback to listen to what the community members have said and respond to the
feedback provided by the community.
19
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• Mr. Timmerman did point that past BAR decisions have been overturned by City Council. Mr. Timmerman
did point out that the BAR is happy to take this project on.
• Ms. Lauer asked the applicant how they have responded to the concerns of the community in the public
engagement in the spring.
• The applicant did say that the proposal does have a step-back in it in addressing the looming feeling members
of the community had expressed.
• The applicant also stated that there is a step-back in the distance from their building and where those outdoor
spaces are located.
• The applicant did state that the intent is to follow the design guidelines and code. The applicant also stated
that they do extensive research on the code and rules before proposing a project.
• Mr. Zehmer and Mr. Schwarz did have feedback surrounding the materiality of the building. Mr. Zehmer did
state that the applicant should make the building pretty.
• Ms. Lewis agrees with other members of the BAR by reducing the height of the proposed building by 2
stories. Ms. Lewis did ask the applicant to reduce the height by more than 2 stories. The step-backs need to be
on 3 sides.
• Ms. Lewis did ask that the materiality and architecture reflect the city of Charlottesville.
• Ms. Lewis did state that there should be a reference to Charlottesville in the building. The memory walk
should have a direct and straight access to Main Street.
• Ms. Lewis stated that Cedar Street/8 ½ Street needs to be reinstated and directly connect to West Main Street.
• Ms. Lewis did encourage members of the public to contact the councilors and commissioners regarding the
zoning ordinance and development code.
Meeting was recessed for 10 minutes until 9:40 PM.
6. Pre-Application Conference
No formal action will be taken
BAR # 25-0084
Tax Map 29 Parcels 71,73,74,75,76
202, 204, 208 & 214 7th Street SW & 613 Delevan Street
204 & 208 7th Street SW - Individually Protected Properties
Owners:
202: Monticello Media LLC
204: William Lynch & 204-7 LLC
208: Michael J. Christian
214: 7th St LLC
613 Delevan St: Mattie L. Hall
Applicant: Mitchell-Matthews Architects
Project: New multi-story, mixed-use building
• There was a prior discussion on this project and the applicant is presenting materials and information to the
BAR based on the prior conversation.
• The applicant presented the proposed project to the BAR. The applicant wants to make sure that they are
following the comments from the previous conversation.
• Two smaller parcels have been added to the proposed project and to incorporate the comments on the project.
• The applicant did add pictures of the conditions of the existing buildings and deterioration of the existing
buildings. The 2 existing buildings are going to be documented.
• The applicant did present the roof plans for the project. The bulk of the massing has been moved to the back
of the property near the railway line.
20
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• Most of the shadows of the proposed project are cast on the railway and on the backs of West Main Street
with the change in the massing. The applicant did have shadows studies.
• The center of the building has been moved back 114 feet from the street.
• There has been a marginal increase in the size of the building. The wings of the building have been stepped
down from the street.
• The applicant did remove the brick towers. It allowed for a 2-story stepping up along with the houses to pull
into the street façade.
• A 1-story element was kept behind the houses and that opened into the courtyard and an amenity space.
• The primary entry space will be on the left side (A). Students will enter through that left side and exit on the
right side (B).
• The applicant did present renderings of what the pedestrian experience will look and feel like as people walk
along the front of the proposed project.
• The applicant is going to preserve, protect, and maintain the existing buildings as part of this proposed
residential project.
• The proposed names of the 2 buildings are Hawkins Cottage/House 1 and Hawkins Cottage/House 2.
Historical markers are also going to be provided.
• The vertical brick elements have been removed in response to the comments from the BAR.
• The applicant did present the landscape plan and lighting plan for the proposed building.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
James Snyder – I am the original owner of 206b 5th Street Southwest. That is one of the cottages built in 2005.
The architects have done a lovely job of talking about this project. Is this even an allowed use? I would remind
you of my neighbor Paul Reeder’s early discussion to you about the half-mile radius. We now face projects that
show the dangers of treating student housing as if it was apartments. The 800-unit, 11-story project and this
project reveal the flaws in our zoning code. It is as if the Starship Enterprise landed on a small heavily treed
village in this site. That is not really planning. That is market speculation, which has overwhelmed the
community fabric. The ceiling of the RX-5 zone has become the floor. If you read the intent, it was supposed to
develop duplexes, cottages, 4-plexes, middle housing. What you have now is that they have gone to the
maximum. Student housing is an asset class that is economically more competitive than any other use. As long as
you are allowing this, that is all you will get. They can finance it. The company that does this is skilled with this.
They rent by the bed. You are not going to have any affordable housing. You are going to have student housing,
and you will be selling density. You are going to get money. You are going to risk the neighborhood character.
Historic neighborhoods like Fifeville will be overshadowed, destabilized, and economically displaced.
Charlottesville has recognized the needs for limits. That is where the half-mile issue came up. Other universities
have defined student housing as a distinct use. It is not the same as apartments. You need to have that half-mile
overlay rule work and contain student housing where it belongs: within walking distance of UVA. Special use
permits need to be involved. You are not getting the things that people want. There are a lot of issues with student
housing that can be at odds with a community. The city is at a crossroads where we allow the market to build
these starship dorms that land in our neighborhoods. We can set clear, fair, and forceful rules to protect the
residents while accommodating student demand.
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
• There was concern and questions about the distance of this proposed project to the University Grounds.
• The applicant was told by staff that the site was outside the half-mile radius to the University Grounds.
• There needs to be clarity on the distance from the University Grounds with regards to the zoning.
• Staff reminded the BAR that this site is not within a historic district. The review is to be the compatibility of
the architecture to the surrounding neighbors.
21
BAR Meeting Minutes August 19, 2025
• Staff reminded the Board to continue to refer to the guidelines with this proposed project.
• Mr. Zehmer did like the improvements made to this proposed project from the prior discussion.
• Ms. Lewis did not have any concern about the demolishment of the buildings.
• Ms. Lauer also had positive comments about the changes that have been made for this proposed project.
• Ms. Tabony did say that this proposed project was inappropriate with regards to the historic neighborhood.
Ms. Tabony did have hesitations about approving this possible CoA application.
• The applicant did mention that there was a setback from the street, a step-back, and another step-back to the
backside of the building.
• The applicant did have concerns about the community engagement and whether community engagement
would be a requirement.
• Mr. Bailey and Mr. Birle did have positive comments with the improvements made to the proposed project.
• Mr. Timmerman did have questions regarding the height of the proposed building.
• Mr. Timmerman said that the scale is inappropriate. Mr. Timmerman stated that this is a part of the zoning
and a massive increase in scale.
• Mr. Timmerman wants to see a response to the surrounding neighborhoods further down the street.
• Ms. Lewis mentioned the guidelines and the applicability of the guidelines with this proposed project.
• There was discussion about the applicability of the guidelines on IPPs (Individually Protected Properties),
such as this site. There was the concern of where the guidelines and zoning are in conflict.
• Mr. Schwarz did say that there needs to be streetscape provided where it is possible. Mr. Schwarz did express
the need for more street trees where possible, especially along Delevan.
7. Staff Questions/Discussion
• Administrative approvals
• Reminder: CLG training requirements
F. Adjourn
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 11:10 PM.
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 3, 2026.