Planning Commission — Agenda Minutes
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Planning Commission · meeting of Oct 15, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
From:
To:
Subject:
Date:
Jules Shepard
Planning. E-Mail
24SN1200
Wednesday, October 9, 2024 5: 18:33 PM
You don't often get email from I earp wh>: this is important
CAUTION: External Email
Good evening,
I am emailing about the prope1iy that is adjacent to my property and has been submitted to
change its zoning and split the lots.
I am completely opposed to this, we just closed on this prope1iy the 16th of August and it was
sold with the idea that the prope1iy beside us was private.
What are my options?
It is tmly sad that this beautiful prope1iy will be destroyed by building on it, not to mention all
the wild animals that will be displaced. I think it should be left as agricultural prope1iy.
Please let me know what my options are.
Sincerely,
--d
1
Hare, Kelly
From: Planning, E-Mail
Subject: FW: Astoria
From: Kevin McNulty <Email Address Redacted>
Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2024 2:03 PM
To: Owens, Tommy <OwensTommy@chesterfield.gov>
Cc: Kevin McNulty <Email Address Redacted >
Subject: Astoria
Mr. Owens,
I am writing today in support of HHHunt’s zoning case for their proposed Astoria project on Bethia Road. In full
disclosure, I am one of the landowners under contract to sell land to HHHunt for this project. I am also a residential real
estate professional who has done business with HHHunt on other projects. They have a strong reputation for executing
high-quality and well-managed projects, and I have every confidence that they will do the same for the Matoaca district
of Chesterfield with the Astoria project.
The overall proposal fits well within the surrounding area and integrates with density and amenities already in place.
HHHunt’s plan to cul-de-sac Bethia Road to reduce traffic impacts for those existing homeowners on Bethia Road is an
example of their commitment to work with the surrounding community to minimize impacts.
I am a proud citizen of Chesterfield County, currently residing in the Dale district. My wife and I recently purchased an
existing home on almost 17 acres on River Road in the Matoaca district. We are excited to be planning to move to the
Matoaca district once we complete some renovation work on the home. As a Chesterfield Citizen, I am encouraged to
see high-quality development. I believe the proposed Astoria project represents high quality residential development
that we can all be proud of. I hope you will consider approving the Astoria project.
Sincerely,
Kevin McNulty
Sent from my iPhone
Unfortunately, this area zoned for commercial has, due to Chesterfield County
ordinances, allows for multifamily rental units. This area should be maximizing true
business (commercial) development over residential development. Chesterfield
County should implement a Commerical-Residential zoning category where
commercial land where rental residential areas will be allowed.
3. This portion of Chesterfield County does not have the school infrastructure to
support the addition of 384 multifamily units and the school age students this
development will bring.
However, based on what I've seen in Chesterfield County the claim will be made that
the county's hands are tied, and the amendment approval has to occur. With that
said, the County can help their constituents that live in Magnolia Green and create a
better managed development.
Any agreement with the developer of Magnolia Green should be closely scrutinized
by Chesterfield County and should be written so agreements are enforceable. The
agreement must specifically state the amount of true business space in the rezoned
area, the phasing of the business and residential to be built, the specific Magnolia
Green Property Owner Association (POA) amenities that residential will be allowed to
use, the specific funds the businesses and residential will contribute to the Magnolia
Green POA budget.
The developer of Magnolia Green needs to be held accountable for any reasonable
and safe amenities.
Magnolia Green was to include a community clubhouse. The clubhouse was
prominently displayed on advertising material, on the map in the Magnolia Green
sales center and on the map of the community in the front lobby of the Magnolia
Green golf course and restaurant building.
The developer simply decided not to build
the clubhouse although individuals purchased homes in the community expecting this
amenity.
At this time the Magnolia Green POA will receive from the developer at
some unknown point in the future an empty lot filled with construction debris rather
than a community center.
Members of the Magnolia Green community have asked the developer-controlled
Property Owners Association to replace the "Pirate playground" next to our aquatic
center for the last three years.
We get promises that they will look into the
playground maintenance and substandard condition, but nothing gets done. At a
builder's liaison meeting the developer apparently agreed to transfer funds to the
community POA prior to their departure.
The following statement was written by one of the community members who
attended the builder's liaison meeting held on July 24, 2024:
"Pirate playground will NOT be replaced while Tom is controlling the board. They did get
estimates to replace which came in to around 250-275kish. Numbers are not completely
finalized. Starfield will GIFT the HOA this money to replace the pirate playground at the time the
HOA is turned over for the community to choose the design."
My first request is for you to hold the developer of Magnolia Green accountable to
provide reasonable and saft amenities to residents of Magnolia Green.
1. I request that, prior to any rezoning amendment approval, Chesterfield County
engage with the developer of Magnolia Green to get an agreement on funding to
replace the playground. The agreement should identify the amount of funds to be
transferred ($275,000), the specific date the funds will be transferred to the Magnolia
Green POA (January 2, 2025) and that the playground will be designed based on a
committee of Magnolia Green property owners selected by the Chesterfield County
Matoaca supervisor.
The second request has to do with parks in Chesterfield County. The county staff
continually points to the need to be consistent with the County comprehensive plan,
yet the county isn't consistent with the County Parks and Recreation plan.
The
western neighborhood park for which land was to transfer to the county by the
Magnolia Green developer was not built as identified in the 2018 Chesterfield County
Parks and Recreation Master Plan.
The county needs to create more community parks and playgrounds. The
community, in Northern Virginia where I lived (Home - Courts and Ridges HOA) had
412 homes and five playgrounds. Magnolia Green will have approximately 2,700
residence and two playgrounds. We force families to drive out of their neighborhoods
to find playgrounds that are sometimes in other communities or parks miles from their
home.
2. I request that funds be allocated to the Chesterfield County Parks and
Recreation department to build the Western neighborhood park as identified in
the 2018 Chesterfield County Parks and Recreation Master Plan.
The third request has to do with playgrounds. Don't believe the developers when
they come to the board requesting rezoning approvals for developments with passive
recreation, i.e walking trails. This is only the developer's way to minimize their costs,
and these walking trails are primarily used as routes to adjacent communities that
have playgrounds for their residents and their guests to use.
There is a simple way for the county to increase the number of playgrounds. This
solution creates a neighborhood where residents can stay in their community
lessening the burden on our road system and increasing the availability of active
recreation.
3. I request a change the Chesterfield County building standards to require a
playground for every 100 residences. This cost will be passed from the developer to
10/14/2024 Larry Bertolet MatoacaI live off of Springford Parkway in the Collington subdivision. I realize
that this case is but a piece of the larger development, however I have
concerns.
1. The additional traffic on Winterpock will result in more congestion,
then present, at the Winterpock/Rt 360 intersection. Traffic turning left
on to Winterpock from Rt 360 west, at times already requires more than
1 light cycle. It is worse at rush hour. Traffic turning left from northbound
Winterpock on to westbound Rt 360 sometimes requires now more than
one light cycle. This will only get worse with the added traffic. I also
question the capacity of the recently constructed roundabout on
Winterpock to handle the additional traffic.
2. Not requiring the developer to extend the widening of Winterpock to
at least beyond the proposed intersection with Harpers Mill Pky
Extension, I feel is a mistake. Is there not a concern that southbound
traffic when slowing to turn right off of Winterpock on to Harpers Mill Pky
Extension, will impede traffic continuing south on Winterpock? As well
as eastbound traffic on Harpers Mill Pky Extension turning left and
merging into a single lane with vehicles already traveling northbound on
Winterpock?
3. Developers should be required to pay all cost - infrastructure,
services and obtain all land needed for their development at time of
approval. County taxpayers should not have to foot the bill when the
developer reaps the benefits. Proffered condition 20 - if 60 ft of R/W is
needed along Winterpock, then developer should provide 60 ft, not 45 ft.
Per staff's recommendation, "The request will generate additional traffic
which will contribute to the need for future widening". Proffered condition
21c - talks about additional R/W and easements and seems to be
worded that allows developer an out not to fulfill the County's
requirements if the County does not assist the developer. As stated
above, if the purchase of additional R/W or easements will fall on the
taxpayer in the future, then this is the developers responsibility.
4. In communications with County staff on Sept 18, 2024, it was stated:
"Please note that developer and county transportation is still discussing
how the case will adequately address traffic impacts along Winterpock
Rd and Bethia Rd in proximity to the property. County Transportation
(CDOT) is still evaluating this case." Unless all issues have been
resolved to the County's satisfaction, action on this case should be
delayed to a future date.
Thank you
October 15, 2024 CPC Citizen Comments
recieved as of 5 p.m. on 10/14/2024
24SN1182 - Astoria South Rezoning
and Exceptions
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.