Board of Supervisors Meeting — Other
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Supervisors · meeting of Sep 25, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
9/25/2024 Page 1 of 11
Citizen Comments Received Through the Comment Portal
September 25, 2024 Board of Supervisors Meeting
Comment Type Comment Name District
Unscheduled
matter
Subject: Why does Dominion
get preferential treatment?
hollandj@chesterfield.gov
Dear Supervisor Holland,
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant. I do
not understand how such a
massive energy project with
all the air pollution it will
spew can be approved by the
county without any public
discussion by our Board of
Supervisors. This inaction by
the Board raises serious
questions whether Dominion
Energy is unfairly getting
favorable treatment when an
ordinary resident may be
subjected to a hearing if
they want to build an
oversized garage in their
backyard. This makes no
sense.
Duane
Brankley
Bermuda
Unscheduled
matter
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant. I do
not understand how such a
massive energy project with
all the air pollution it will
spew can be approved by the
county without any public
discussion by our Board of
Supervisors. This inaction by
the Board raises serious
questions whether Dominion
Energy is unfairly getting
favorable treatment when an
ordinary resident may be
subjected to a hearing if
they want to build an
oversized garage in their
backyard. This makes no
sense.
On September 25th, I expect
the board to announce that it
will schedule a hearing and a
vote on Dominion’s dirty gas
plant.
Melinda
Lewis
Midlothian
9/25/2024 Page 2 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
Unscheduled
matter
I respectfully urge the Board
to have a hearing and a vote
on the proposed gas plant. If
we truly care about
Chesterfield’s citizens and
health of our environment, we
need to have, at the very
least, a public hearing. You
have a mass of citizens who
have educated themselves on
the dangers of this plant and
we urge you to do the same.
Rebekah
Kusterbeck
Clover Hill
Unscheduled
matter
Dear Supervisor Holland,
One of the most daunting
challenges in the fight
against climate change is
that it's easy to dismiss the
slow moving, happens-to-
other-people narrative. Sure
there are fires and floods,
but they are not happening in
Chesterfield County, whereas
the need for reliable
electricity is ever-present.
Sadly, that doesn't help with
the fact that the impact of
the changing climate -- slow
though it may seem -- is of a
magnitude well beyond the
experience most of us have
with modern life. Climate
change promises the end of
life as we know it --
certainly for our kids and
grandkids, but most likely
for ourselves as well.
This is where courageous
leadership comes in, and
where the Chesterfield Board
of Supervisors risks going
down as a gathering of
cowards. As many residents of
Chesterfield have pointed out
repeatedly at hearings,
citizens deserve a hearing
and a vote on Dominion
Energy’s dirty gas power
plant. In this country, the
public gets a voice in
matters that affect their
well-being, and here is your
chance to respond
appropriately to that voice.
Dominion Energy is collecting
favors denied to ordinary
citizens.
At your meeting on September
25th, I expect the board to
announce that it will
Thomas Beach Bermuda
9/25/2024 Page 3 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
schedule a hearing and a vote
on Dominion’s dirty gas
plant.
Sincerely,
Tom Beach
Unscheduled
matter
Chesterfield County needs to
have a zero tolerance policy
towards Route 60's lack of
pedestrian infrastructure. In
that it has been having a lot
of pedestrian deaths lately
due to Route 60's lack of
sidewalks and streetlights
and crosswalks. And
Chesterfield County could
easily use funds from all the
new data centers being built
in the county to crank up
building sidewalks along it's
pedestrian death hotpots such
as Hull Street Route 60 and
Route 1. A example is
Powhatan County is looking at
getting one data center and
it will raise $17 million by
itself but Chesterfield is
getting several new data
centers so one data center
would triple funding for
sidewalks which is currently
at 6 million. Or it could
take some funding from the
Powhite Parkway Extension
which is getting $150 million
for 2 miles and 350 million
for nothing but roads from a
road funding bond. But it's
at the point there should be
no excuse for no sidewalks or
crosswalks construction along
Route 60 and other major
roads.
Carl
Schwendeman
Midlothian
Zoning case
- 23SN0062 -
Caliber
Collision
Boulders –
Midlothian
Chesterfield County needs to
ask for a new sidewalk along
Route 60 and Boulders
Parkway. In that the current
proposed buffer landscaping
with no sidewalk along Route
60 will force pedestrians
into the shoulder of Route 60
with the traffic.
Carl
Schwendeman
Midlothian
Zoning case
- 23SN0041 -
North
Hallsley -
Midlothian
Chesterfield County needs to
ask North Hallsley to build a
new sidewalk along all of Old
Hundred Road from the old
opening of Hallsley to the
new opening of Hallsley. Due
to the strange layout of the
lot of land that only touches
Carl
Schwendeman
Midlothian
9/25/2024 Page 4 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
Old Hundred Road at two tips
of it but yet the land
follows Old Hundred Road and
will house a lot of houses in
it at 300.
Unscheduled
matter
I strongly feel that The
residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant.
Dominion Energy has
repeatedly stated that this
gas plant is needed to serve
the electricity demands of
data centers mostly
concentrated in Northern
Virginia. Why should we see
our electric bills increase
to subsidize some of the
richest and biggest tech
firms in the world? As county
leaders, you have an
opportunity to keep our bills
from rising and ensure
Dominion doesn't build this
dirty gas plant in our
backyard.
Paul Price Matoaca
Unscheduled
matter
Chairman Holland, Members of
the Chesterfield Board of
Supervisors:
All of us need to take
responsibility for addressing
climate change, and the
Chesterfield County Board of
Supervisors may take
responsibility by denying a
permit for Dominion Energy's
CERC. As you should know, the
attorney for Friends of
Chesterfield is of the
opinion that the 2010
conditional use granted
Dominion Energy is not a
carte blanche for a new gas
plant 14 years later. It
makes no sense. We are
waiting on the Planning
Department to respond to a
July 24, 2024 attorney's
letter requesting written
zoning certification on the
500 Coxendale Road site
challenging the validity of
the county administration's
position that Dominion has
the required zoning.
Glen Besa Dale
9/25/2024 Page 5 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
Neither does it make sense
that a resident building an
oversized garage in their
backyard has to have a
hearing, but a 1000 MW
heavily polluting gas plant
gets a pass. That appears to
be preferential treatment to
a powerful, politically
influential corporate
monopoly.
Methane is a potent climate
pollutant, and the more we
use, the more that leaks into
the atmosphere worsening
climate change. This summer
was the hottest on record and
it seems like every year is a
new record. Dominion Energy
may be inclined to put profit
over the well being of the
people, but as elected
officials you have a greater
responsibility to represent
Chesterfield residents and
protect us from pollution.
With the disproportionate
impacts of this project on a
neighboring predominantly
lower income community of
color, the people of
Chesterfield County have a
right to be heard regardless
of whatever advice you may be
getting from county staff who
work for you. A VA DEQ
hearing on an air pollution
permit is no substitute for
county decision making on
zoning and suitability.
This methane burning
powerplant does not make
sense economically either if
one accounts for the social
costs of carbon pollution as
calculated by the US EPA.
That cost is over $190 per
ton of CO2. That means that
the CERC emitting 2.2 million
tons of CO2 per year shifts
costs of over $400 million
per year onto the public.
That does not include the
cost of building this gas
plant that will show up on
our electric bills as we are
asked to subsidize the
electricity needs of tech
9/25/2024 Page 6 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
firms which are the richest
corporations in the world.
How is that fair to your
constituents?
We deserve a hearing on the
zoning and suitability of
this site. It's just that
simple.
Sincerely,
Glen Besa
Unscheduled
matter
Dear Supervisor Holland,
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant. Our
neighbors who live especially
close to the proposed gas
plant have endured almost
eighty years of toxic air
pollution from Dominion’s
coal plant which was just
retired last year. Why should
they, why should all of us be
subjected to another 30 or 40
years of toxic air pollutants
from this gas plant when
Dominion Energy can invest in
solar, wind, energy storage
and efficiency to meet our
future energy needs.
On September 25th, I expect
the board to announce that it
will schedule a hearing and a
vote on Dominion’s dirty gas
plant.
Whitney
McCrum-
Morrison
Bermuda
Unscheduled
matter
Subject: Don’t let Dominion
raise our electric bills for
a new gas plant
hollandj@chesterfield.gov
Dear Supervisor Holland,
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant.
Dominion Energy has
repeatedly stated that this
gas plant is needed to serve
the electricity demands of
data centers mostly
concentrated in Northern
Virginia. Why should we see
our electric bills increase
to subsidize some of the
richest and biggest tech
firms in the world? As county
leaders, you have an
opportunity to keep our bills
Duane
Brankley
Bermuda
9/25/2024 Page 7 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
from rising and ensure
Dominion doesn't build this
dirty gas plant in our
backyard.
On September 25th, I expect
the board to announce that it
will schedule a hearing and a
vote on Dominion’s dirty gas
plant.
Sincerely,
Duane Brankley
Unscheduled
matter
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant. I do
not understand how such a
massive energy project with
all the air pollution it will
spew can be approved by the
county without any public
discussion by our Board of
Supervisors. This inaction by
the Board raises serious
questions whether Dominion is
unfairly getting favorable
treatment when an ordinary
resident may be subjected to
a hearing if they want to
build an oversized garage in
their backyard.
Dominion has acknowledged
that this gas plant is mostly
needed to serve the
electricity demands of data
centers, largely located in
Northern VA. Why should we
see our electric bills
increase to subsidize some of
the richest and biggest tech
firms in the world? As county
leaders, you have an
opportunity to keep our bills
from rising and ensure
Dominion doesn't build this
dirty gas plant in our
backyard.
Our neighbors who live
especially close to the
proposed gas plant have
endured almost 80 years of
toxic air pollution from
Dominion’s coal plant which
was just retired last year.
Why should they, and all of
us, be subjected to another
30-40 years of toxic air
pollutants from this gas
plant when Dominion can
invest in solar, wind, energy
Elysia Reed Bermuda
9/25/2024 Page 8 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
storage and efficiency to
meet our future energy needs.
The Virginia DEQ requires
counties to determine the
suitability of major
pollution sources like this
gas plant in local
communities before it will
grant an air pollution
permit. Chesterfield has
greenlighted this gas plant
without determining the
suitability of the site and
its impact on the surrounding
community of largely lower
income and people of color.
Dominion’s gas plant raises
serious questions related to
environmental justice that
our county has an obligation
to consider in determining if
this site is suitable. There
are also serious questions
whether Dominion has
necessary zoning approval for
this gas plant.
Under the VA Clean Economy
Act, Dominion Energy is
supposed to phase out its
reliance on gas and coal
fired power plants by 2045 to
address climate change. This
new gas plant with an
expected operational lifespan
through 2060 and beyond is
inconsistent with that law.
With all the concerns raised
by residents regarding this
gas plant, why is the county
signing off on this project
that raises serious questions
as to its compliance with
state law? Residents deserve
to have their concerns heard
by their supervisors in a
county public hearing.
Unscheduled
matter
Subject: Dominion Energy's
proposed gas plant
Dear Supervisor Holland,
The residents of Chesterfield
County deserve a hearing and
a vote on Dominion Energy’s
dirty gas power plant. The
Virginia Department of
Environmental Quality
requires counties to
determine the suitability of
Alisa Booze
Troetschel
Dale
9/25/2024 Page 9 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
major pollution sources like
this gas plant in local
communities before it will
grant an air pollution
permit. Chesterfield County
has greenlighted this gas
plant without determining the
suitability of the site and
its impact on the surrounding
community of largely lower
income and people of color.
Dominion’s gas plant raises
serious questions related to
environmental justice that
our county has an obligation
to consider in determining if
this site is suitable.
Friends of Chesterfield has
also raised serious questions
whether a Dominion has
necessary zoning approval for
this gas plant. Chesterfield
County residents deserve a
hearing and a vote on both
the zoning and the
suitability of this gas
plant.
On September 25th, I expect
the board to announce that it
will schedule a hearing and a
vote on Dominion’s dirty gas
plant.
Cordially,
Alisa Booze Troetschel
Zoning case
- 23SN0114 –
Collington
Neighborhood
Recreational
Facility –
Matoaca
REGARDING: CASE 23sn0114- I
emailed my concerns to this
address for the July planning
meeting, but they were not
read or addressed. It was
acknowledged but not
addressed. I was at the
August meeting but the case
was deferred until 9/25. I
will be out of the country
that date, so I called one of
the Board members to discuss
the case and left a message,
but never heard back from
him. There hasn't been a lot
of Brandy Oaks people in
attendance, and I have to
wonder if it's because
they're discouraged because
no one seems to care and they
feel that it's a done deal.
Nevertheless, my concerns
are:
1. There are 17+ acres for
that property, so why can't
Velma Brown Matoaca
9/25/2024 Page 10 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
the RV storage area be
located far enough back from
the road so it cannot be seen
from Hensley road? That would
also eliminate the problem of
being adjacent to the
neighboring properties.
2. Collington said they will
put a fence around the
storage area that will be a
minimum of six feet high,
which obviously mean they
will settle for the least
expensive and make the fence
six feet. Upon further
research, I find that the
average RV is seven to twelve
feet high, so the vehicles
will be in plain sight. Can
they make it 12?
3. As it stands now, the
property is not maintained,
but the legal counsel for
Collington said at the July
meeting that the proposed
facility will benefit Brandy
Oaks residence because it
will be maintained as a
requirement of a Chesterfield
County code. Collington has
owned this property for nine
years and it has never been
properly maintained. That
being said, how can we trust
Collington to adhere to that
code, since they never have,
and Collington residence are
not impacted at all, This
code has never been enforced,
so who will enforce this now?
4. At the last meeting, a
Brandy Oaks Board member
talked about the
environmental hazard from
possible leaking vehicles
which is a great concern.
Should this occur Collington
won't be concerned because
it's not near their homes and
families. Brandy Oaks
residence won't have access
to the property, so we can't
report the issue, and who
would we report it to?
5. I am not against the
recreational facility,
however I think it is so
unfair that we have to
contend with this RV storage
eye sore while Collington
reap the benefits with no
9/25/2024 Page 11 of 11
Comment Type Comment Name District
negative impact. Move it away
from our homes and the county
road.
Velma Brown
Brandy Oaks Residence
(Clerk note: this comment was
received via email to the
Planning Department.)
Unscheduled
matter
Eryn Little continues to
remain without Access to
Education in simply, a Public
School, and this begins year
3. Not only has the School
Board lost Grant Funding
already, due to non-
compliance issues, there may
be quite a bit more
forthcoming. I have clear
evidence of inappropriate,
unethical, and unlawful
collusions which created and
have maintained this ongoing
issue of illegally denying
Access to Education to a
scholar with disabilities.
Unfortunately, some of the
same verbiage, tactics, and
massive resistance techniques
seem to have infiltrated some
of the departments in
Chesterfield County, as is my
understanding. Sadly, just
like as with the School
Board/School Division, there
are quite likely 'happenings'
in your organization as a
County Government that 'bad
actors' of course would not
want to be exposed or shared
with leadership positions. I
would argue that it is
imperative that Chesterfield
County Board of Supervisors
closely scrutinize Legal
Invoicing attributable to
Eryn Little billed to the
School Board in your role as
the 'provider and supervisory
ownership of taxpayer funds,
to infer how their
expenditures with Sands
Anderson and Blankingship &
Keith Law are proper use of
Taxpayer funding.
Wendy Little
(Eryn's Mom)
Wendy Little Clover Hill
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.