RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting — Agenda Packet

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Sep 4, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHESTERFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AGENDA WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 4, 2024 Public Meeting Room 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield VA 23832 NOTE: Attachments are generally available the Wednesday prior to the Board of Zoning Appeals meeting. Any subsequent changes to this agenda prior to the date of the meeting, and more detailed information regarding items on the agenda can be found at chesterfield.gov/plan, or by calling the Planning Department at 804-748-1050 during regular business hours, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday. A map of each case can be found at chesterfield.gov/plancases. Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service 12:00 p.m. Lunch/work session in Executive Session Room, 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield, Virginia 23832 1. 1 p.m. Meeting called to order in the Public Meeting Room, Lane B. Ramsey Administration Building, Chesterfield, Virginia 2. Invocation 3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America 4. Approval of Minutes • August 7, 2024 5. Acknowledgements of withdrawal and requests for deferral 6. Consideration of variance request A. 24VA1123 (Deferred from 08/07/2024): In Clover Hill Magisterial District, King Solomon Shepherd requests a two (2) foot three (3) inch variance to the four (4) foot maximum fence height located in the front and corner side yards and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District known as 9964 Reams Road. The 0.26 acre property is developed with 1 single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 748-702-9721. 7. Review of 2023 BZA Annual Report 8. Miscellaneous 9. Adjournment Page 1 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 1 of 14 24VA1123 – King Solomon Shepherd Magisterial District – Clover Hill Applicant's Contact – King Shepherd (804-340-9003) BZA Public Hearing – September 4, 2024 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Two (2) foot three (3) inch variance to the four (4) foot maximum fence height located within the front and corner side yards in a Residential (R-7) District. Specifically: a fence constructed prior to 2007 located within the corner side yard, a fence that was constructed in 2024 located within the front yard and proposed completion of the fence from 2004 located within the front and corner side yards Exhibit A Staff Recommendation Denial The Property 9964 Reams Road Site Size 0.26 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Access Plan or Elevation or Street View Image Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended condition, Applicant’s Concept Plan - Exhibit A, and other Exhibits are located in this report. STAFF - DENIAL • There are no conditions, as required by the Zoning Ordinance, upon which this request is based that is unique to the property and are not applicable generally to other properties in the area. • No information has been provided by the applicants that would indicate there are unusual circumstances about this property such that adherence to the required fence height limitation in this area would cause undue hardship. • Alternative exists that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Recommendation Page 2 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 2 of 14 PLANNING • Three (3) construction timelines are part of this request: 1- a fence constructed prior to 2007 located within the corner side yard, 2- a fence that was constructed in 2024 located within the front yard and 3- proposed completion of the fence from 2004 located within the front and corner side yards. Applicant’s Concept Plan – Exhibit A • Topography of the lot is not unique to this subdivision. This request is based on perception of personal protection and confidence in secure surroundings. • Reduction of the six (6) foot three (3) in fence to four (4) feet in the front and corner side yards accompanied by landscaping with taller vegetation would allow for the fence to meet Ordinance standards while providing for a barrier. Summary of Identified Topics Page 3 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 3 of 14 Background • The Ordinance allows for a fence or wall to be a maximum height of four (4) feet within a front or corner side yard. In 2018 an Ordinance amendment was adopted to allow for more flexibility in height within the corner side yard if meeting certain design standards below: Section 19.1-301 Fences and Walls Height. Except where otherwise specified a fence or wall, to include posts or supporting structures, shall not exceed the following height limitations: 1. Front yards: 4 feet; and 2. Rear and side yards: 7 feet. 3. Corner side yard: a. 4 feet; or b. 7 feet, provided the fence or wall meets the required corner side yard setback for a principal structure, does not extend towards the front of the dwelling beyond the rear façade and incorporates a minimum of two (2) design elements listed herein. Such elements shall be continued for entire length of fence or wall facing a road: • Decorative fencing such as rot resistant wood, vinyl, wrought iron, or other decorative metal fencing materials. • Fencing has decorative features such as shadow box, scallops or other design as approved by director of planning. • Wall is constructed of, or fence incorporates, quality materials such as brick, stone, masonry materials or durable products intended to have appearance of such materials; • Side of the fence or wall facing a road and adjacent properties has a decorative appearance or does not have support structures or framing; or • Supplemental landscaping. Along exterior of fence adjacent to road, minimum of 1 medium shrub every 5 feet and 1 tree every 30 feet. Plantings and materials shall comply with Sec. 19.1-250. • The applicant purchased the property in October 2020. • The applicant intents to create a barrier around his property for protection of his personal property and to provide for a secure surrounding. Planning Page 4 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 4 of 14 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Summary of Identified Topics ................................................................................................................................................. 2 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Aerial – Pre-Fence Construction ............................................................................................................................................. 5 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 9 Supplemental Analysis .......................................................................................................................................................... 10 Environmental Engineering ............................................................................................................................................... 10 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................. 10 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................. 10 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................. 10 Utilities – Water and Wastewater .................................................................................................................................... 10 Virginia Department of Health .......................................................................................................................................... 10 Department of Real Property ............................................................................................................................................ 10 Condition ............................................................................................................................................................................... 11 Applicant’s Concept Plan – Exhibit A .................................................................................................................................... 12 Subdivision Plat ..................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Flagged Picture ...................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 14 Table of Contents Page 5 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 5 of 14 Proposal The applicant is requesting approval for a six (6) foot three (3) inch privacy fence in the front and corner side yards of his property within the Reams Run Subdivision. Three (3) construction timelines are part of this request: 1- a fence constructed prior to 2007, 2- a fence that was constructed in 2024 and 3- proposed completion of the fence from 2004. Applicant’s Concept Plan – Exhibit A The applicant indicated the following as justification for this request: Aerial – Pre-Fence Construction Planning Fence in corner side yard prior to 2007 Page 6 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 6 of 14 “The existing scalloped fence within the corner side yard was existing when I purchased the property in 2020 and has been in existence for over 17 years. The newly constructed fence within the front yard was constructed to protect my personal property and to provide for more security for me and my home. I have had my vehicle broken into and have experienced people using my property as a cut through, and a place for their dogs to use the bathroom. I have experience neighbors parking their cars to deliberately shine their lights into my house and observe my every movement. The newly constructed fence is to provide a barrier between my property and adjacent properties to allow for security of my personal property and to protect my mental status”. Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth Standards and Findings for granting a Variance if the applicant provides evidence that: • a strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability; • the property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant; • substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located; • the condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter; • the application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and • the relief is not available through an administrative variance, special exception or conditional use. Page 7 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 7 of 14 Figure 3: Fence Construction Prior to 2007 Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following: Fence constructed prior to 2007: • The fence six (6) foot three (3) inch wood privacy fence is of a scallop construction. • County records reflect its existence since 2007. • Landscaping exists between the fence and the right of way. • It is possible the location of the fence that was constructed in 2007 may allow for the higher height within the corner side yard meeting the more flexible Ordinance requirements. The fence appears to meet the required corner side yard setback for the principal structure of twenty (20) feet (approximately twenty- three (23) feet ) and does not extend towards the front of the dwelling beyond the rear façade. Additionally, the fence incorporates a minimum of two (2) design elements, scalloped design, and landscaping. However, no survey has been provided for confirmation of the above. Fence construction in 2024: • Two six (6) foot three (3) inch fences are located on the subject property. 1- located within the front yard positioned between the horseshoe driveway (Fence B) and 2- located within the front yad along the right (eastern) side yard extending beyond the front plane of the home into the front yard toward Reams Road (Fence A) (see “existing fence A and B“ Applicant’s Concept Plan - Exhibit A). • Staff measured the distance between the ultimate right of way and Fence B and determined the measurement to be approximately thirty (30) feet one (1) inch. o Reams Road has an ultimate right of way of forty -five (45) feet; therefore, staff is concerned Fence B may be located within the right of way and not within subject property. Subdivision Plat o The applicant advises he ha d his property surveyed and placed Fence B within his property boundary. Flagged Picture • The fences are a wood privacy fence. • The fences do not appear to obstruct visibility from the right of way or adjacent driveway. • The fences are in good condition but out of character with the residential area. • The proposed construction connecting the existing fencing continues to be out of character with the residential area. Page 8 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 8 of 14 Fence height is typically reduced in the front and corner side yards to maintain visibility along rights of way and ingress/egress from neighboring driveways. The applicant has indicated his concern for his personal property and his desire to restrict pedestrian traffic , lights and visual contact which impacts his mental state . Fences typically enclose yards for privacy and security when constructed for the enjoyment of a single-family dwelling. In this case, one (1) report has been filed for larceny from an automobile. Staff has examined both timelines of fence construction provided in this request a s required by the Zoning Ordinance, and the property owner has not provided information which would serve as a basis for granting the variance associated with the 2024 fence construction . The fence construction from 2007 was installed prior to the applicant owning the property. The applicant purchased this property in good faith and did not create the hardship. Additionally, the time that this fenc e has existing on the property could be considered as nonconforming so long as no additions or board replacements have taken place. Sec. 19.1-3. Nonconforming Uses, Buildings and Structures--Excluding Signs 6. Additionally, a nonconforming building or structure shall include those circumstances where the county has: • issued a building permit or other permit authorizing construction and the building or structure was constructed in accordance with the building permit, and upon completion, the County issued a certificate of occupancy; or • the owner of the building or structure has paid real estate taxes to the County for such building or structure for a period of more than the previous 15 years. For the reasons shared above and the possibility that this fence may meet the more flexible Or dinance requirements, staff believes other options such as securing a survey of the property to verify the fence meets current Ordinance requirements for the higher fence height within the corner side yard. If the fence does not meet current Ordinance requirements, the fence may be considered as nonconforming ; however, no replacement or alterations may occur. Although the applicant desires privacy, the fence construction in 2024 to include proposed construction, is not unique to the property. Staff has determined an alternative exists that would bring the fence into compliance with Ordinance requirements by lowering the fence to four (4) feet and adding additional landscaping to provide more screening. The four (4) foot fence would discourage pedestrian traffic from entering onto the property and protect from the head light beams as the typical height of a vehicle lens is approximately 30 inche s. This request is based on the applicants need for secure surroundings to protect his personal property which a four (4) foot fence provides such barrier. The applicant did construct the fence not meeting Ordinance requirements; therefore, he created his own hardship. Additionally, the proposed construction within the front and corner side yards equally does not meet the basis for approving a variance. This request is not unique, and if approved, may set a precedent for other fences to be constructed within the front and corner side yards greater than four (4) feet in height within the vicinity. The fence could be altered to meet Ordinance requirements and continue to serve as a barrier from the rights of way and adjacent property. For the reasons stated above staff believes the requirements for the granting of a variance has not been satisfied. Page 9 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 9 of 14 Current Zoning Map Page 10 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 10 of 14 No comment No comment No objections to the fence height variance request. Advisory: Ensure there's adequate area for vehicle stop in order to open/close gate without blocking incoming traffic to Wenatchee Rd. It appears adequate room is provided along Reams Rd to accommodate a vehicle to open/close gate at this access. No comment No comment Not applicable No issue so long as the fence does not impede sight distance for intersection Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Department of Real Property Page 11 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 11 of 14 Fence Location: This variance to the fence height shall be limited to the height, and location s as depicted in Exhibit A within the staff report. No other walls or fences shall be permitted except those in compliance with Zoning Ordinance requirements. (P) Condition Page 12 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 12 of 14 Applicant’s Concept Plan – Exhibit A Page 13 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 13 of 14 Subdivision Plat Flagged Picture Page 14 of 15 King Shepherd 24VA1123 Page 14 of 14 Board of Zoning Appeals August 7, 2024: ACTION – DEFERRED TO SEPTEMBER 4, 2024, ON THE BOARD’S OWN MOTION WITH THE APPLICANT’S CONSENT FOR PRIVATE MATTERS Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: King Shepherd (804-340-9003) kingshepherd1956@gmail.com Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals • Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Jonathan Phillippe (804-674-2384) Jonathan.Phillippe@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov • Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Public Hearings Case Contacts Page 15 of 15

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.