Audit and Finance Committee Meeting Agenda and Documents — Agenda Minutes
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Audit and Finance Committee · meeting of Jul 31, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING NOTES
AFC Members in Attendance: Mr. Jim Holland & Mr. Kevin Carroll
Staff in Attendance: Dr. Joe Casey, County Administrator; Matt Harris, Deputy County Administrator;
Gerard Durkin, Budget Director; Steven Sanderson, IA Assistant Director; Consuela Wilson, Accounting
Director; Stephanie Brown, Procurement Director; Mary Martin Selby, Human Resources Director; Dave
Johnson, Risk Management Director; Clay Bowles, Deputy County Administrator, Community Operations;
Trent Jones, Risk Management Assistant Director; Kyle Campbell, Risk Management Assistant Director;
Kristi Brittle; HR Assistant Director; Dot Heffron, CCPS Chair, Ann Coker, CCPS Vice Chair; John
Murray; CCPS Deputy Superintendent; Bob Meister, CCPS Chief Financial Officer; Kim Hough, CCPS
Chief Human Resources Officer.
Call to Order: Mr. Jim Holland called the meeting to order at 2:00 p.m.
Audit and Finance
Committee of the
Board of Supervisors
DATE: July 31st, 2024
Time: 2:00 p.m.
Location: Room 502
Attendees:
Jim Holland
Kevin Carroll
Dr. Joe Casey
Matt Harris
Ann Coker
Dot Heffron
Dave Johnson
Gerard Durkin
Steve Sanderson
Mary Martin Selby
Consuela Wilson
Item Person Responsible Outcome
1. Healthcare Update Mary Martin Selby/
Claire Harlin
2. Budget Updates Matt Harris/
Gerard Durkin
3. Risk Management Update Dave Johnson
4. Internal Audit:
a. FY25 Audit Plan and Hotline Activity Update
b. Periodic Report Review
Steve Sanderson
1. Healthcare Update: Ms. Mary Martin Selby, Director of Human Resources introduced presenter Claire
Harlin, CEBS
a. 2025 Health & Dental Renewal Preliminary Review
i. Anthem 2025 Medical / Prescription Drug Renewal
ii. Chesterfield County is in its third year of contract with Anthem for medical and
prescription drug benefits.
iii. Recommended 4.8% renewal increase for the 2025 calendar year for both Government
and Schools were based on claims paid May 1, 2022, through April 30, 2024, with a
current enrollment of 11,070 employees.
iv. The increase in claims is primarily driven by an increase in the number of claims
between $50,000 and $200,000.
v. The monthly administrative expense is unchanged since 2021 as was negotiated during
the RFP process.
vi. Anthem shares prescription drug rebates with the County through a monthly
prospective administrative fee credit. This credit is increasing from $8.1 million to $15
million in 2025. The increase reflects higher rebates expected to be earned.
vii. At the 2024 renewal CC increased the specific stop loss limit from $300,000 to
$400,000. Anthem is proposing an increase to the specific stop loss fee of 14.2%.
viii. The only plan design change recommended for 2025 is to increase the deductible on
the HDHP with HSA plan from $3,200 Single / $6400 Family to $3400 / $6,800. This
increase is required for the plan design to remain compliant with IRS regulations for a
HDHP plan with a Health Savings Account.
ix. Mr. Jim Holland asked about the participants this year compared to last year.
x. Ms. Harlin responded that enrollment has remained consistent with a total enrollment
increasing 1.8%.
xi. The decision to renew with the required deductible change on the HDHP plan and
maintain all other benefits. Ms. Harlin provided a detailed projected expense chart
comparison of 2024 monthly rates and 2025 monthly rates.
b. 2025 Delta dental renewal will be the fifth year in contract with the County.
i. The rates are subject to a rate cap of 5%.
ii. Delta Dental is requesting a 2.3% increase, and this is supported by paid claims that
have increased 2.5% year over year.
iii. Chesterfield County and Schools currently contributes $10 per employee per month
towards the cost of the dental premiums. The value of this contribution based on
current enrollment in the dental plan of 15,129 is $1.82 million.
iv. Mr. Jim Holland asked if there were any changes requested by employees.
v. Ms. Selby explained that a weight loss drug was added, and nothing further was
requested.
2. FY25 Budget Update: Matt Harris, Deputy County Administrator; Gerard Durkin, Budget Director
a. Mr. Harris began the meeting with a Budget and Finance update.
i. G.O. Bond Sale Update sold July 16th, 2024.
ii. Confirmed Triple-AAA rating from Moody’s, S&P, and Fitch.
iii. Total $98.9 Million provided: County $39.6 million, Schools $59.3 million
iv. 3.43% interest rate
v. 10 total number of bids
vi. 0.06 bps spread between highest and lowest bid.
vii. County projects funded: Replacement Ettrick Fire Station, Swift Creek Police Station,
Horner Park, Falling Creek Park Development, and Conservation Area Park
Development.
viii. Schools Projects Funded: AM Davis Elementary (rebuild), Bensley Elementary
(rebuild), and Western Area Elementary.
ix. Mr. Jim Holland asked about the trends and comparisons with other triple-AAA
localities.
x. Mr. Harris explained the spread was very competitive with triple-AAA peer localities.
b. Mr. Durkin introduced the FY24 Year-End Results Timeline and an economic overview.
i. FY24 Year-end accrual period, which is currently underway, ends August 15th, 2024.
ii. FY24 Annual Financial Audit will be completed in fall.
iii. FY24 Year-end recommendations will be presented to BOS in November.
iv. FY24 Year-end recommendations will be voted on by BOS in December.
v. Transitions into serious delinquencies are rising. Transition into serious delinquency
chart, explained by loan type. (Auto Loan, Credit Card, Mortgage, Student Loan)
shows all categories rising.
vi. Durable goods downturn chart, showing 1993-2024 percentage change year over year
on manufacturers’ new orders/durable goods shows a weakening picture for such
goods.
vii. Mr. Durkin noted that the Federal Reserve met today to decide interest rates and then
presented a chart on Real Interest Rate trends detailing 1982 – 2024.
viii. Interest on debt outstrips defense spending for the first time in recent history. The chart
displays federal government surplus / deficit, net interest payments on federal debt,
and federal defense spending shown from 1962 and projected into 2034.
ix. Dr. Casey mentioned the comparison of the national debt per capita averaging $70,000
per person vs. just over $2,000 for County Debt per capita.
x. Mr. Durkin concluded with the FY26 Budget Development Process, providing details
of emerging major topics including compensation and capital / referendum projects
and the timeline development details.
3. Risk Management Update: Mr. Dave Johnson, Director of Risk Management introduced Trent Jones,
Assistant Director for Claims Administration and Finance and Kyle Campbell, Assistant Director for
Environmental, Health and Safety.
a. Mr. Johnson introduced the Risk Management mission and responsibilities as well as providing
a brief agenda of the presentation to include a summary of key performance indicators, trends,
challenges and time for questions with his colleagues.
i. Mr. Jim Holland asked how many people work in Risk Management.
ii. Mr. Johnson explained that currently, 20 people are working in the department with a
new position coming available for one additional person.
b. Quick Facts – FY23
i. 3,700 total insurance claims managed by the County’s Self Insurance Program
ii. 15,000 County and School employees are covered by the Self Insurance Program.
iii. 2,600 County and School vehicles are protected by the Self Insurance Program.
iv. 950 County buildings and structures and 220 Schools and structures are covered by the
County’s Property Self Insurance Program.
v. Hundreds of events are reviewed to ensure student and citizen safety are covered by
the County’s Liability Self Insurance Program.
c. Key Performance Indicators, total cost of risk per $1000 of County Revenue based on Workers
Compensation, Auto Liability, General Liability & Property Claims paid in FY23 for County
and Schools. 2019-2023 indicators show a downward total trend.
i. Mr. Jim Holland inquired to what the downward trend would be attributed to.
ii. Mr. Johnson noted several factors that have influenced the trend.
d. Workers Compensation was the next section, Mr. Johnson explained the dip on the chart from
2019-2023 County and Schools during the COVID timeframe and most claims were from public
service employees, as they did not take time at home when schools and other departments did
during that time.
i. Approximately 12.9% decrease over the five-year period adjusted for inflation to
FY23. The average cost of workers compensation claims has remained the same.
ii. Mr. Johnson spoke of how Risk Management wants people to have the best care and
be able to get back to work and explained over 95% of claims are accepted, 98%
coming from the public safety sector are accepted.
iii. Mr. Johnson also noted that Medical Case Managers are assigned to employees and
the claim, and work with pharmaceutical people to insure employees are treated well
and adhere to the appropriated fee structure.
e. OSHA Recordable Case Rate – School District, reflected as cases per 100 full time employees
working for one year. National average compared to CCPS, shows the Schools are lower over
the National average, the last three years. The County is very similar to the National average.
f. Mr. Johnson provided a high-level description of Risk and Insurance trends and asked if anyone
had any questions regarding his presentation.
4. Internal Audit Update: Steven Sanderson, IA Assistant Director
a. FY25 Audit Plan and Hotline Activity Update
i. Mr. Sanderson shared FY25 Projects completed, for County and Schools to include the
FY24 Internal Audit Annual Report and FY24 Fraud, Waste and Abuse Annual Report.
ii. FY25 Projects - In-Progress
iii. FY25 Projects - Not Started
iv. Mr. Sanderson noted that two new hires would join IA to increase staffing and leave one
opening for an additional employee.
v. FY25 County Hotline Activity includes no recommendations issued for Fraud, Waste
and Abuse as of meeting date.
b. Audit Report Review FY23 APA Comparative Report Analysis
i. Mr. Sanderson summarized how the report is an annual non-audit project provided to
County and CCPS management summarizing Chesterfield year over year data for
FY23 and FY22 as reported to the APA.
c. FY24 Internal Audit Annual Report
i. Mr. Sanderson summarized our process for comparing our FY results to the ALGA
(Association of Local Government Auditor) benchmarked data and how the IA
department meets and exceeds most areas benchmarked (e.g., peer review results, %
of staff meeting CPE requirements, total planned vs completed audits).
d. FY24 Fraud, Waste and Abuse Annual Report
i. Mr. Sanderson provided insight from the volume of hotline activity from 2015–2024
and how 2024 has been the lowest amount of allegations for the past 10 years.
ii. Contact sources (Management, Employee, Citizen and Anonymous) discussed where
management and employees are the majority.
iii. Method of contact (E-mail, Hotline, IA Phone, Internet reporting, In person and Mail)
discussed where email is now the leading method.
iv. 18 cases completed in FY24, including 5 initiated in prior fiscal year.
a. 9 investigations
b. 8 referrals
c. 1 no action required.
d. 4 pending cases were carried over to FY25.
e. Dr. Joe Casey noted that audits have brought forth information that has resulted in
new policies and controls and this is a good thing.
Board members adjourned the meeting at 3:33 p.m.
The next AFC meeting will be held in November.
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.