Board of Supervisors Meeting — Other
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Supervisors · meeting of Jun 26, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter I appreciate the efforts of anyone who steps up and takes a shot at managing the complexities of 21st century
Chesterfield. Interests, demands, limitations. There's a lot to sort out, a lot of people to keep happy. And there are
lots of worldwide problems that find their way down to the local level. Inflation, immigration, climate.
We've just kicked off the summer season with warning shots from the weather ‐‐ a fire here, a flood down there, dire
warnings from the National Hurricane Center. This summer could be quite a show!
The good news is that you have an opportunity to do something about that scenario ‐‐ too late for this summer of
course, but not for the many summers to come. The better news is you can do that while offering financial relief to
the citizens of Chesterfield, cooling off those energy bills that seem to go nowhere but up.
I get it. Saying no to Dominion Energy's Chesterfield gas plant is no easy call. You run the risk of irritating one of your
most fundamental partners in local governance. But at a time when Virginia ranks at the high end of electricity costs
(about 14 out of 50 states), you might consider the benefits of a little distance from Dominion. Or better yet, a little
oversight. From new data centers alone, energy forecasters see an increase in energy needs of 40% by 2035, yet
Dominion is still trying to meet 21st century energy demands with 20th century technology: pipes, smokestacks,
pollution. The smart money is on smart grids, upgraded power lines and efficient energy from the wind and sun. Do
you want to be with the buggy makers as the Model Ts role by?
Meanwhile, citizens are catching on to better ways to get their power. Your citizens. As elected representatives, it's
your job to respond to them. Solar companies across the state have scores of projects ready to go on rooftops, former
industrial sites and fallow fields. Leaders in past years are remembered for stepping up at historic moments of
challenge: WWII, the Marshall Plan, the space race. Are we a nation of quitters and shirkers, or innovators and
achievers? You can stay on the later side of that choice. Go boldly into the modern energy world for your citizens and
for their power provider by forcing the right choice: no to gas, yes to green.
Thomas Beach Bermuda
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter The Virginia Clinicians for Climate Action encourages the Board to listen to community voices regarding the need for a
public hearing about the proposed Dominion gas plant. VCCA reminds the Board this siting is in an environmental
justice neighborhood that has dealt with coal ash pollution for 80 years and is NOT suitable for more fossil fuel
infrastructure. There are better options for the provision of energy and the health of Chesterfield.
Susan Miller Midlothian
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter I have been a resident of Chesterfield County since 1980 and have worked, played, and raised a family here. I have
always found it a wonderful place to call come home. The idea that a nasty, polluting has plant plant is being
considered for this county by Dominion Energy sickens me. I am very aware of the current and future needs for
electricity in not just this county and state but entire country. AI will consume energy in amounts we cannot even
really understand yet. But regardless of who is in the White House, we have a responsibility to our citizens to pursue
clean energy sources not as a side job or hobby but as the primary source of power. Our power companies will not
invest in cleaner energy if we continue to accommodate the old polluting methods of the past that the entire global
scientific community has condemned as what must change of we are to have a chance of saving the ozone.
I beg you as a citizen to have a public hearing on this matter and let out voices be heard. We elected you in good faith
to represent our interests, not to allow large corporations to do as they please with our environment.
Thank you in advance.
Barbara Patterson
Barbara Patterson Bermuda
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter Please vote no on the Dominion Fracked gas plant. We don't need or want this in Chesterfield or anywhere. Pamela Hill Matoaca
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter Brent Archer recently sent out a mass mailing on behalf of Dominion Energy in support of their peaker plant. There are
a few problems with his statements. The spot market price of natural gas has gone to extra ordinary levels at peak
demand periods. Also, the firm of Goehring & Rozencwajc stated on June 30,2023 that the Permian Basin is depleting
faster than once thought. That is because all the tier 1 sites are being exploited. They expect the standard price at the
Henry Hub will increase by four times after 2030 and approach the world price. Taken together, this means that
Dominion's peaker plant will produce electricity at extra ordinary prices. Also, natural gas is not replacing coal. Solar
and wind are replacing coal. About 60 GW of solar capacity was added last year along with 15 GW of battery storage
capacity. Battery storage greatly lessens the need for any peaker plant. That which is needed can be supplied by
geothermal energy. There are geothermal sites in and around Bath County. The health hazards form particulate matter
and nitrous and sulfur dioxides have been well documented. Regulations protect people over a wide area. They do not
protect people who live close to these plants. We all pay for the asthma and COPD that they cause in higher insurance
payments.
Herbert Loveless Bermuda
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter June 24, 2024
Re: Proposed Chesterfield County Power Plant
Dear Mr. Chair and Members of the Board,
I am sending this testimony in regards to the proposed Dominion power plant to be built here in Chesterfield County.
Prior to moving to Chesterfield County I lived in a state that had deregulated utilities. Because of that deregulation, I
had the option to choose my source for electricity, one’s that were more environmentally friendly. I chose wind
power. I also opted to recycle my waste before pickup was available by taking my recyclables to a drop off point, My
cars have been hybrids. I have composted my kitchen waste for most of my adult life. All of those choices were made
out of concern for the environment.
In 2017, when I moved herein 2017 and created my account for powering my home , I was unable to opt out of coal, a
major polluter for the Chesapeake Bay area. This plant was one of the reasons that I had chosen an alternate provider
in my previous location. I was relieved when it closed then was alarmed when I learned of Dominions intention to
create another major polluter in its stead.
Please consider carefully what the impact of the plant would be the residents in the county?
According to Harvard, the incidence of cancer for those in close proximity to a coal fired plant is double to those who
live elsewhere. Despite the coal powered plant being shuttered, the residual impact from the facility is ongoing.
Please spare the residents of Chesterfield County from bearing the brunt of future local pollutants by voting no for the
proposed Dominion plant.
As a side note, I was appalled to learn that Virginia allows those running for office to take campaign donations from
Dominion. Can there be any greater conflict of interests for the residents of this state? Do our elected officials work for
Dominion or for their constituents?
Alison Beall Clover Hill
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
Dear Supervisors,
I am submitting a comment for your consideration on two matters which may seem unconnected. The first item is the
proposed Rockwood Grove project, which would be located adjacent to my neighborhood. We have been told that the
developers have compromised quite a bit on this project and now the time has come to accept the revised proposal.
Please keep in mind, the first submission by the applicant was completely inappropriate for the site. While they have
adjusted the plan in response to community pushback, this development, in combination with others in progress in
this area, will add significantly to congestion and traffic. The Planning Commission was dismissive of these concerns.
Who then is ultimately accountable for decisions that will have significant negative impacts on the thousands of
residents who live and travel these corridors? I hope you, our elected leaders, will ask the necessary questions. In
addition, with much fanfare, residents were told that the Rockwood Special Focus Area would enhance our community
with new amenities. We have seen zero amenities, only more development. The applicant of Rockwood Grove initially
included a multiuse path, which many of us looked forward to utilizing, and this would be connected to improvements
so we can safely cross Hull Street to Rockwood Park. Now, the applicant is only providing an easement for a path to
(maybe) be built at some future date. The Rockwood SFA may have been an enhancement for developers, but it has
surely not been for current residents.
The other item I wish to comment on is the proposed Dominion gas plant. I see these as related topics because, once
again, I am asking for the Supervisors to exercise their role as both the representatives of Chesterfield citizens and as
an oversight body. There are thousands of residents of the county who oppose this plant. Surely you owe them at least
the courtesy of a public hearing. You are our elected leaders. These two issues involve the damaging impact of
overdevelopment and the devastating environmental effects of a major new source of pollution in the county. I am not
anti‐growth or anti‐housing. But count me among the many Chesterfield residents who would like to see more
attention paid by our leaders to appropriately balancing growth with protection of our quality of life.
Respectfully submitted, Caroline Emmons
Caroline Emmons Dale
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
As a citizen that will be affected by Rockwood Gove project, let it be known that some of us are not happy. When
moving to the neighborhood, I was pleased with my neighbors, trees and wildlife. If I wanted to be surrounded by 4
story townhomes/condos, I would have moved somewhere else!! Please reconsider building in our neighborhood!!
There’s plenty of open space in chesterfield to build. It’s called a NEIGHBORHOOD for a reason. Thank you.
Cynthia King Dale
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter Dear Board of Supervisors
I am again appealing to you to ensure proper oversight of Dominion Energy’s proposal to build a 1000‐megawatt
methane gas plant near Dutch Gap. Dominion should not have received certification from the Chesterfield Deputy
County Administrator without Board of Supervisors approval. It is incumbent upon you to ensure sufficient information
about the potential harmful health, financial, and environmental impacts of the proposed plant are fully considered
before Dominion is allowed to proceed. Moreover, your consideration should include a full public hearing to ascertain
the views of Chesterfield County residents—your constituents—especially those who will live closest to the proposed
plant and are most vulnerable. Ignoring the concerns of local residents and allowing this project to move forward
without citizen input is unacceptable.
The proposed plant is expected to generate more than 1,110 tons of toxic air pollutants per year and is likely to raise
electric bills for Dominion customers. In light of the pernicious effects of global warming—as evidence of the present
excessive heat we are experiencing right now—new projects should rely on clean, renewable sources of energy, not on
dirty, fossil fuels.
I urge you to put a halt this project immediately until a full public hearing is provided and the detrimental
environmental, health, and environmental impacts of the proposed methane gas plant are fully considered. A project
of this magnitude should only move forward with the full vote of the Board of Supervisors.
Sincerely,
Harold V Hartley III
8125 Lake Margaret Terrace
Chesterfield, VA 23828
Harold V Hartley III Matoaca
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
I am opposed to the overdevelopment of Chesterfield County... Specifically Rockwood Grove. After all the
community meetings and planning sessions I am astounded that these boards do not realize that there simply isn’t
sufficient infrastructure to support this growth. By the county’s own admission, the intersection of Courthouse Rd and
Hull Street is one of the busiest in the county. To continue to build and overdevelop will only add to this congestion.
All evidence suggests that our police department, dispatch and 911 facilities are under staffed. These are areas that
need to be addressed before further building.
Most people I know moved to Chesterfield because it was a county. In other words, to escape the high density areas
and the problems that excess population brings. In the past few years, you have been bringing all the problems we
wished to escape to our front door. Growing the population has unwelcome side effects that we are just beginning to
see. Namely congested traffic, noise, crime and loss of green space. I hesitate to point out the issues with our schools.
For whatever reason, only the residents see these problems.By doing this you are doing a great disservice to your
residents. These are the same people that support this county with taxes but are never considered when you make all
these decisions.
I get that the county was proud to have lured Lego… but at what cost to the residents? I’d be willing to bet that they
were granted huge tax breaks. This year the tax assessment office lowered assessments for apartments but raised
assessments for homeowners yet again . The reason I was told was they had vacancies and had to maintain their
properties. Really? Your residential home owners also have to maintain their property. With no consideration from
any of the boards of the county.
I’ve been told that planning and BOS do not consider comments made on platforms like Nextdoor. Perhaps that
should change. Your residents are not happy.
I beg you to not approve Rockwood Grove. You will be ruining a long standing, established community. It is a slap in
the face that CDOT wants to turn this neighborhood into a thoroughfare to try to eliminate traffic on Hull St that all of
you approved without a thought at the side effects. We enjoy our neighbors and our wildlife. Please don’t take this
away. Thank you for your consideration.
Jamie Carson Dale
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
I oppose approval of case number 22SN0147, Rockwood Grove, as currently proposed.
First, a question. Is the Utilities Easement included in the 35.41 acres mentioned in the case description? My
following comments presume that it is.
The Comprehensive Plan says 4 to 8 dwelling units per acre for this property. This proposal calls for 260 units or 7.33
units per acre which is close to the maximum. The easement appears to be 3 or more acres which means density on
the usable property is more like 8.1 dwelling units per acre.
The applicant proposes to take credit for the unusable utilities easement as a “common area” which means the
applicant is effectively contributing nothing while increasing density in the non‐easement part of the property. A more
appropriate density would be about 6 units per usable acre or a total in the range of 190 to 200 units.
I urge the Board to not approve this application. Either reject it outright or defer it so the applicant can reduce the
proposed density to a level more in keeping with the spirit of the comprehensive plan and with the character of the
nearby residential sub‐divisions.
Respectfully,
William P. Brown, PhD, CPA
Dale Magisterial District
William Brown Dale
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
There are so many new apartments/condos/homes that it is ridiculous. If this is approved we know y’all could care less
about the voice of the people. We don’t want it none of it. The county is so overcrowded now. I can hardly drive on
Hull Street without fear of being killed, because the traffic is unbelievable now. I can’t imagine what it will be like when
all these other places are finished! Please listen to the majority. The county use to be such a nice place to live, but not
anymore. I understand progress, but every 1/2 mile up Hull Street is new houses/apartments/condos and businesses.
Can we take a break on building, until there are hospitals, schools and roads to accommodate all the other new places
and people Please quit ruining our county!
Terri Deel Dale
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Unscheduled matter My name is Jenny Morand. I’m a parent and a Midlothian resident of 15 years. I work as the Central Virginia Organizer
at the Virginia League of Conservation Voters, and like my employer, I vehemently oppose the construction of the
Chesterfield Energy Reliability Center or any gas‐fired power plant at any projected site in Chesterfield.
Methane gas is the dirtiest and most expensive energy source, and continued reliance on fossil fuels is an unaffordable
and dead‐end road for Chesterfield. It is unacceptable to increase the levels of asthma‐ and cancer‐causing pollution in
a corridor where families are already experiencing 80‐100% rates of particulate matter, hazardous waste, and
superfund proximity. This power plant would be a stranded asset that residents and ratepayers would pay for over and
over again, forcefully invested in regressive technology that would impact their wealth and their health for
generations. We’re already paying for coal ash clean up at the Dutch Gap Reservoir!
As state legislators advised in March of this year, Dominion’s proposal conflicts with the 2020 Virginia Clean Economy
Act, requiring Dominion to clean up their energy production by 2045. In accordance, the State Corporation
Commission (SCC) did not approve Dominion’s 2023 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP), which included the Chesterfield
gas plant, and instead instructed them to submit a new plan. While many issues matter to me, supporting and electing
leaders who understand the existential threat of climate change is paramount which is why, in my free time, I knock
doors, educate neighbors, greet folks at the polls, and drop everything for special elections. Chesterfield voters elected
a new board majority in 2023, but nothing has changed if officials ignore their constituents, their party, and the values
they ran on. The Board and planning commission should only consider zoning proposals that invest in Chesterfield’s
most vulnerable communities, combat the devastation of climate change, create local revenue, and advance
environmental justice. Pollution impacts every citizen, every zip code, and every income bracket in Virginia. Equitable
solutions implemented at the local level will ensure that municipalities stay on track to meet state and federal
environmental standards. Elected officials should exercise their authority to wade in, serve constituents rather than
greedy polluters, and reject this proposal.
https://ejscreen.epa.gov/mapper/
https://docs.google.com/document/
Jennifer Morand Midlothian
Meeting Date Comment Type Comment Name District
6/26/2024 Zoning case ‐
22SN0147 ‐ Rockwood
Grove
We as the communities of Falling Creek and Mayfair, have steadfastly opposed Rockwood Grove in any zoning
amendment that was not single‐family houses. Townhomes and/or condominiums will degrade and diminish the
material and enviromental value of our neighborhood and homes. This is an old an established neighborhood, so
houses more than 60 years old, both with original owners and 1st time homeowners. We did not buy into our mostly
quiet, large lot, mostly forested community with the expectation of the traffic congestion, noise and light pollution,
and natural landscape, bulldozed and clear cut for a multi‐family construction project. Make no mistake, these will not
be affordable Townhomes, these are not for moderate or low income renters or owners. The developer has bern
completely disingenuous with their description of the dwellings in this development. VDot and County traffic engineers
are using deflated, overly optimistic data for the coming huge increase in traffic, the impact of a thru road from
Oxbridge Road and Lynchester Drive will have on safety and our community environment. The CCPS estimates for
potential students from Rock Grove are ludicrously low and the local school populations are artificially lower, than
actual students matriculated. All the numbers for almost every evaluating metric have been skewed by the Planning
Board, the Developer, and the agencies of the County, reporting this data. We feel both the Developer and the
Planning Board have been very dismissive of our concerns, and particular I'd like to call out the Dale representative of
the Planning Board, who at the Board meeting which voted to recommend approval of Rock Grove, REFUSED to admit
any of our comments into the record at that meeting. We feel as a community that gentlemen, has been dismissive,
condescending, and that his expert opinion never took any of our concerns into his decision making. His mind was
made up, when the Rockwood area development plan was approved, almost in secret during the Covid Pandemic. As
this is an appointed and not elected position, we do not feel that ANY member represents the County. Please carefully
consider, your vote and deny this zoning smendement.
Michael Foy Dale
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.