Police Chief Recommendation Committee — Agenda
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Police Chief Recommendation Committee · meeting of Jun 21, 2024 · Agendas
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
POLICE CHIEF RECOMMENDATION COMMITTEE
Second In-Person Meeting
June 21, 2024 @ 4:00 p.m.
Main Administration Building, Room 502
9901 Lori Road, Chesterfield, VA 23832
ATTENDEES
Police Chief Recommendation Committee Members
□ Dr. Joseph Casey, County Administrator, Chair of PCRC
□ The Honorable Jessica Schneider, Member, Board of Supervisors, Clover Hill District, Vice Chair of PCRC
□ The Honorable Kevin Carroll, Member, Board of Supervisors, Matoaca District
□ The Honorable Edward A. Robbins, Jr., Judge, Chesterfield County Circuit Court
□ Dr. Kevin Sykes, County Resident & Senior Pastor of St James Baptist Church
Staff Support to the Committee
Susan Wilson, Clerk to the Board of Supervisors
Jeff Mincks, County Attorney
Mary Martin Selby, Director of Human Resources
Julie Seyfarth, Sr. Deputy County Attorney
- AGENDA -
I. Opening Remarks Dr. Joseph Casey, County Administrator
a. Approval of Minutes
b. Adoption of Remote Attendance Policy
c. Introduction of Executive Recruitment Firm
II. Executive Recruitment Firm Anne Lewis, Managing Director
a. Overview Baker Tilly
b. Present Proposed Recruitment Plan/Timeline
III. Adopt Recruitment Plan/Timeline PCRC Members
Proposed Recruitment Plan/Timeline
Action Item Date
Review and Adopt Final Recruitment Profile June 21, 2024
Online Surveys Review and Approval June 21, 2024
Input Sessions Review and Approval June 21, 2024
Assessment Tool Options/Preliminary Background June 21, 2024
Recruitment Period June 26 to July 29, 2024
Community and Employee Feedback Schedule June 26 to July 29, 2024
Presentation of Community/Employee Feedback August 29, 2024
Closed Session for Initial Screening of Candidates August 29, 2024
IV. Round Table and Closing Remarks Dr. Joseph Casey, County Administrator
V. Next Meeting
a. August 29, 2024
Page 1 of 7
Police Chief Recommendation Committee 1
Organizational Meeting 2
May 28, 2024 3
County Administration Building, Room 502 4
5
MINUTES 6
7
Present: The Honorable Jessica Schneider, Member, Board of Supervisors, Clover Hill District 8
The Honorable Kevin Carroll, Member, Board of Supervisors, Matoaca District 9
The Honorable Edward A. Robbins, Jr., Judge, Chesterfield County Circuit Court 10
Dr. Kevin Sykes, County Resident & Senior Pastor of St. James Baptist Church 11
Dr. Joseph Casey, County Administrator 12
13
Absent: None 14
15
Also present were Mr. Jeffrey Mincks, County Attorney; Ms. Julie Seyfarth, Sr. Deputy County 16
Attorney; Ms. Mary Martin Selby, Director, Human Resources ; Ms. Mandy Pilk, Assistant 17
Director, Human Resources; Ms. Liz Marker, Chief of Administrative Services, Human 18
Resources; Ms. Carrie- Lynn Edwards, Administrative Analyst, Human Resources; Lt. Colonel 19
Brad Badgerow, Acting Police Chief; and Mr. Chuck Hale and Mr. Sheldon Cohen, Resource 20
Management Associates (RMA). 21
22
Dr. Casey called the meeting to order at 3 p.m. 23
24
WELCOME AND INTRODUCTIONS 25
26
Dr. Casey w elcomed ev eryone to the meeting and invited attendees and guests to introduce 27
themselves. 28
29
30
COMMITTEE COMPOSITION/CHARTER/LEGAL ISSUES/PARLIAMENTARY 31
PROCEDURES 32
33
Mr. Mincks reviewed Section 6.7 of the County Charter which mentions the Police Chief 34
Recommendation Committee. He discussed the concept of employment at will and stated the chief 35
of police is a non-at-will employee and can only be removed for cause. He provided details of the 36
county’s Code of Ethics and Law Enforcement Code of Ethics. He reviewed Parliamentary 37
Procedures, which mirror the Rules of Procedure of the Board of Supervisors, and recommended 38
they be used at the committee’s meetings . He also reviewed the Fre edom of Information Act 39
(FOIA), which is applicable to the committee’s public meetings and communications related to 40
the business of the committee, other than discussions about potential candidates. 41
42
In response to Mr. Carroll’s question relative to note s taken during closed sessions about an 43
applicant’s qualifications, Mr. Mincks stated the notes are not subject to disclosure. He further 44
stated closed sessions work because they are confidential. He then continued his review of FOIA. 45
46
Page 2 of 7
Dr. Casey discussed the importance of preserving the anonymity of candidates who may interview 1
in person. 2
3
Mr. Mincks completed his review of FOIA. 4
5
In response to Mr. Carroll’s question relative to remote attendance by committee members at 6
committee meetings , Mr. Mincks distributed a draft policy and encouraged the committee to 7
consider adopting it. Mr. Mincks then provided the committee with an overview of the Virginia 8
State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act (“COIA”). 9
10
11
OVERVIEW OF THE POLICE DEPARTMENT 12
13
Lt. Colonel Badgerow provided the committee with an overview of the police department. He 14
reviewed the organization chart, key 2023 statistics for operations and support, five-year crime 15
totals, patrol functions, and sworn/police service aide staffing. He provided details of 2023 top 10 16
calls for service, the department’s beat structure, and calls for service broken down by day of week 17
and time of day. He discussed responses to mental health calls and trends. He reviewed Marcus 18
Alert protocols, statistics pertaining to heroin overdoses, the community connect program, 19
wellness and peer support, and accreditation. He discussed facilities updates, community 20
partnerships, and the Police Activities League. He reviewed recent employee awards and 21
recognitions. 22
23
Discussion ensued relative to the police department’s response times and clearance rates. 24
25
In response to Dr. Sykes’ question relative to what other partnerships the police department is 26
working on, Lt. Colonel Badgerow provided details of the de partment’s community engagement 27
division, neighborhood/business/commercial watch programs, Triad, and citizen academies. 28
29
30
RECRUITMENT, SCREENING AND CANDIDATE INTERVIEWS 31
32
Discussion of Related Processes 33
34
Mr. Hale discussed the process and estimated it would take 90 to 100 days. 35
36
Mr. Cohen encouraged the committee to select a single point of contact to work directly with 37
RMA. He discussed the optional use of an assessment center and a deep background investigation. 38
39
Discussion ensued relative to the assessment center, the professionals who would serve on the 40
assessment center, the scenarios that would be utilized, conflicts of interest between applicants and 41
panelists, and criteria important to committee members. 42
43
In response to Judge Robbins’ question relative to the difference between a deep background 44
investigation and some other type of investigation that goes beyond what RMA already described, 45
Mr. Hale stated the investigator gets information first- hand from the source by going to the 46
Page 3 of 7
applicant’s hometown. He further stated the investigator spends a day or two talking to people who 1
know the person on a first-name basis. 2
3
Mr. Cohen stated the investigator would talk with the county administrator or city manager; a 4
member of the board or council; subordinates; union president; and local business owners. 5
6
Mr. Hale stated applicants will provide a list of references, but it is important to note who they did 7
not list and ask why. 8
9
Judge Robbins inquired if RMA has a methodology so that each candidate is evaluated in the same 10
or a similar way. 11
12
Mr. Cohen answered affirmatively, and stated RMA uses the same exact structure from the initial 13
evaluation criteria for the universe of applicants. He further stated it is the same behaviors for the 14
same universe of candidates judged by the same dimensions and benchmarks. He stated RMA will 15
process each candidate at each stage of the evaluation exactly the same. He further stated they are 16
very careful about consistency. 17
18
Discussion ensued relative to candidates signing a waiver allowing review of their internal affairs 19
files at their current agency. 20
21
In response to Dr. Casey’s question relative to the background check and whether it emulates a 22
certain security clearance level, Mr. Cohen stated he did not think it emulates a certain security 23
clearance level. 24
25
Mr. Hale stated their investigator does have that security clearance. 26
27
Mr. Cohen stated their investigator is a retired police chief in the Chicago area and a retired NCIS 28
commander, and he could look anywhere. 29
30
31
Timelines and Action Items 32
33
Mr. Cohen reviewed the timetable and stated it would be updated after the meeting. He discussed 34
scheduling interviews with key officials and holding community meetings. He suggested 35
interviewing a broad range of stakeholders. 36
37
Mr. Carroll stated the sheriff needs to be on the list of stakeholders. 38
39
In response to Judge Robbins’ question relative to what the topic of the interviews would be, Mr. 40
Hale stated he wants to get input from stakeholders about how they view t he police department, 41
what is important to them as a community resident or leader, what they hope to see in the future, 42
what is missing, and what the department should be doing. 43
44
Page 4 of 7
Judge Robbins suggested the profile be expanded to include others outside of county government 1
such as the public defender, the chief judges of the county’s two district courts, and named people 2
who represent constituencies outside of county government. 3
4
Mr. Cohen emphasized the meetings would be one-on-one, closed door, and anonymous to 5
encourage interviewees to be completely forthcoming. He stated the confidentiality of the 6
interviews would go far beyond what you would get out of a focus group. 7
8
Discussion ensued relative to interviewing representatives from homeowners associations and 9
parent/teacher associations. 10
11
Mr. Carroll stressed the importance of consistency of the questions. 12
13
Dr. Casey discussed the distinction between who might be invited to a closed-door interview and 14
who might be invited to a community meeting. 15
16
Judge Robbins concurred with Mr. Carroll and stated if groups are not asked the same questions, 17
then the consultants are going to get random information of limited utility. 18
19
Dr. Sykes stated the community needs to hear these things, too. He inquired about how this practice 20
has worked for the consultants outside of doing it at-large. 21
22
Mr. Cohen stated they are listening for common themes , interests, and concerns which may 23
consistently emerge. 24
25
Dr. Sykes stated he could understand the value of common themes if the committee is looking at 26
someone inhouse moving up in the ranks. He inquired about how common themes address or help 27
with getting candidates from outside. 28
29
Mr. Cohen stated he would be looking for common themes articulated by interviewees here in the 30
county, not the candidates. He further stated w hat is learned in interviews becomes important in 31
formulating interview questions for the six finalists and f ormulating the assessment center 32
exercises. 33
34
Mr. Carroll inquired about how everything is put together to target what is being sought in a 35
candidate. 36
37
Dr. Sykes expressed appreciation for Mr. Carroll’s clarification that the common theme is focused 38
on the county. 39
40
Dr. Casey stated during the last police chief recruitment process, most of the i nsight came from 41
the police department employees themselves about what they wanted and needed out of a police 42
chief to make them better. He further stated the committee had honest and fair discussions, with a 43
lot of anonymit y, and there was an overall theme of what is good and what can be better. He 44
inquired about how to survey others, namely the whole police department as a workforce and the 45
whole community, and how to extrapolate the data to define the will of the people. 46
Page 5 of 7
1
Mr. Cohen stated they have been having discussions about how to do the surveys. 2
3
Dr. Casey stated the questions asked at community meetings should be similar to those on a general 4
survey. He further stated the questions asked of command staff in private interviews should be the 5
same as those asked of police employees to determine if command staff thinks the same as the rest 6
of the staff. 7
8
Mr. Cohen stated they will work with staff to refine the interv iews and work with Dr. Casey’s 9
office to get the interviews and community meetings scheduled around June 12, 2024. 10
11
Dr. Casey stated staff will start working right away to reserve meeting locations and disseminate 12
information about the meetings. 13
14
Mr. Cohen provided details of background information to be used for recruitment materials and 15
emphasized reviewing CALEA reports. He then reviewed the scope of search and suggested 16
compensation be stated as a range. He discussed the use of national advertising and the job 17
advertisement itself. 18
19
In response to Ms. Schneider’s question relative to advertising through the National Association 20
of Counties (NACo) in addition to Virginia Association of Counties (VACo) , Dr. Casey stated 21
advertising could be done through NA Co, National League of Cities , and Virginia Municipal 22
League. 23
24
Mr. Cohen concurred. 25
26
In response to Dr. Casey’s question relative to whether there is a draft of the job advertisement for 27
Chesterfield’s individual search, Mr. Cohen stated RMA has not worked on that yet. He further 28
stated what is learned from the interviews and community meetings would be used to ensure the 29
most accurate profile of the chief’s position. 30
31
Dr. Casey stated advertising for the position would not begin until the middle of June at the earliest. 32
33
Mr. Cohen concurred. He stated an advertisement should be out for thirty days to ensure a 34
sufficient window to apply. 35
36
Mr. Carroll inquired whether committee members had a chance to review the recruitment brochure 37
and stated it should be linked wherever the recruitment is advertised. 38
39
Mr. Cohen stated RMA has been working with Ms. Martin Selby on a set of documents , which 40
should be linked to the home page on the county’s website. 41
42
Dr. Casey stated a special meeting could be called to go into closed session for the applicant 43
review. 44
45
Page 6 of 7
Mr. Cohen stated RMA would solicit people through its own professional network. He further 1
stated RMA would continue to work as expeditiously as possible on community and employee 2
input sessions and surveys. He stated RMA would take another look at content/development and 3
think about how it can be worked to the county’s advantage. He discussed the survey sample. 4
5
Dr. Casey stated the result of asking questions is a public product, and the questions have to be 6
careful. He further stated anything written in an open comment field is public record, even if it is 7
private information the respondent did not realize would be made public. 8
9
Mr. Mincks stated under FOIA, documents do not get protected until there are live candidates 10
being evaluated. He further stated the process of how to get those candidates is all open. 11
12
Mr. Cohen reviewed i nitial screening criteria and stated a Word document would be sent to the 13
committee members with a request to return responses to RMA promptly. He further stated RMA 14
would compile the responses and share them with the committee. He discussed the need for the 15
committee to consider whether to isolate candidates or allow them to interact while they are here. 16
He stated RMA would prepare both standard and individual interview questions. 17
18
19
COMMITTEE DISCUSSION ITEMS 20
21
Committee Structure 22
23
Dr. Casey stated the committee needs to appoint a chair and vice chair, one of whom could be the 24
point of contact. He further stated a staff member could be the point of contact. He provided June 25
21 and June 27 as possible meeting dates. He provided details of the point of contact’s 26
responsibilities. 27
28
Mr. Carroll recommended Dr. Casey be the chair, who could then designate a direct assistant or 29
point of contact. 30
31
Judge Robbins concurred. 32
33
Ms. Schneider volunteered to be vice chair. 34
35
Dr. Sykes and Judge Robbins concurred with Ms. Schneider being vice chair. 36
37
On motion of Mr. Carroll, seconded by Dr. Sykes, Dr. Casey was selected to be the chair, and Ms. 38
Schneider was selected to be the vice chair. 39
40
Ayes: Schneider, Carroll, Robbins, Sykes, and Casey. 41
Nays: None. 42
43
Dr. Casey stated if everything goes well with the interviews, community meetings, and building 44
the best profile and recruiting method, the committee may be positioned at its next meeting to 45
begin recruiting. 46
Page 7 of 7
1
In response to Ms. Schneider’s question relative to when committee members need to respond to 2
RMA on the decision points, Dr. Casey stated he would begin working on that promptly. 3
4
Ms. Schneider inquired about what decisions are needed first. 5
6
Mr. Cohen stated the first decision would be the dates for the interviews and community meetings. 7
8
Dr. Casey stated the decisions on the assessment center process and deep background check could 9
be made later. 10
11
Ms. Schneider inquired if the survey would be emailed to the committee members the next day. 12
13
Mr. Cohen stated RMA would have the survey to comm ittee members probably by the afternoon 14
of the next day. 15
16
On motion of Mr. Carroll, seconded by Ms. Schneider, the committee adjourned at 5:28 p.m. 17
18
Ayes: Schneider, Carroll, Robbins, Sykes and Casey. 19
Nays: None. 20
1
121432.2
Remote Attendance Policy for the
2024 Police Chief Recommendation Committee
In accordance with the requirements of the Code of Virginia §2.2-3708.3,
A. A member of the 2024 Police Chief Recommendation Committee (“PCRC”) may
participate in a PCRC meeting through electronic communication means from a remote location
as follows:
1. If the request is due to a member’s personal matter,
a. on or before the day of the meeting the member notifies the Chair of the PCRC
(or Vice-Chair if the Chair is the member) that such member is unable to attend the
meeting due to a personal matter and identifies with specificity the nature of the
personal matter and the remote location from which the member is to participate;
b. the PCRC records in its minutes the specific nature of the personal matter and
the remote location from which the member participated;
c. the member has not previously within the calendar year participated remotely
due to a personal matter in two meetings or 25% of the calendar year meetings of
the PCRC, whichever is greater;
d. a quorum of the PCRC is physically assembled at the primary or central meeting
location; and
e. the PCRC makes arrangements for the voice of the remote participant to be heard
by all persons at the primary or central meeting location.
2. If the request is due to a member’s te mporary or permanent disability, or other
medical condition of the member or the member’s family, that prevents the
member’s physical attendance,
a. on or before the day of the meeting the member notifies the Chair of the PCRC
(or Vice-Chair if the Chair is the member) that such member is unable to attend the
meeting due to the disability or medical condition and identifies with specificity the
nature of the matter and the remote location from which the member is to
participate;
b. the PCRC records in its minutes the fact that a temporary or permanent disability
or other medical condition prevents the member’s physical attendance and the
remote location from which the member participated;
c. a quorum of the PCRC is physically assembled at the primary or central meeting
location; and
d. the PCRC makes arrangements for the voice of the remote participant to be heard
by all persons at the primary or central meeting location.
3. Conduct of meeting with member participating remotely.
a. the member participating remotely will be joined telephonically to the meeting
in such a manner that all voice communications can be heard clearly throughout the
entirety of the meeting. The Chair of the PCRC (or Vice-Chair if the Chair is the
2
121432.2
member) will confirm that the remotel y connected member can be heard clearly,
and that the remotely connected member can hear clearly the proceedings of the
meeting, prior to the commencement of the remainder of the meeting.
b. the member participating remotely will ensure that he or she is physically located
in a reasonably quiet location to avoid disruption to the meeting proceedings.
c. the remote attendance of any member at the meeting shall be announced at the
beginning of the meeting or, in the event the member participates remotely after the
beginning of the meeting, as soon as the member’s remote participation begins.
B. As soon as possible after receiving a request for remote participation the Chair ( or Vice -
Chair if the Chair is the requesting member) shall advise the requesting member as to whether the
request is approved or denied. Any rejection of the remote participation, along with the
justification for the rejection, which rejection shall be only due to the failure to satisfy one or more
of the required conditions listed abov e or due to technical difficulties rendering such remote
participation unreasonably disruptive, shall be recorded in the meeting minutes with specificity.
CHESTERFIELD COUNTY, VIRGINIA
Police Chief Search Timeline
Updated: June 14, 2024
Project Tasks Deliverables Target Date
Project Kickoff Conduct 1/1 calls with designated PCRC members June 5 – 14, 2024
Brochure Approval PCRC reviews and approves the brochure June 21
Survey Approval PCRC reviews and approves the community and
employee survey materials June 21
Advertising and
Recruitment
Launch date and deadline for receipt of resumes and
application materials June 26 - July 29
Community / Employee
Surveys Launch date and deadline for completion of surveys June 26 - July 29
Stakeholder Engagement Community and employee feedback meetings July 9 – 11 in person
July 14 – 17 virtual
Leadership-Management
Style Benchmark
PCRC / designated others complete Benchmark
Survey July 15 - 26
Applicant Review
Baker Tilly to screen applications and
administer/review supplemental questionnaires;
video interviews; media background checks; initial
telephone interviews
July 30 - August 14
Semi-Finalist Report and
Video Interviews
PCRC receives confidential electronic Semi-Finalist
Report and link to candidate recorded video
interviews; reviews all candidate materials
August 15
Semi-Finalists Selected
PCRC reviews community and employee survey
results; selects semi-finalists; discusses preferences
for the interview process
August 29
Interviews with Semi-
Finalists
PCRC conducts interviews with Semi-Finalists and
selects top candidates; makes recommendation to
Board of Supervisors
TBD
Background
Check/Reference Checks
Baker Tilly completes reference checks/background
checks/academic verification on finalists and online
media scans.
10-15 business days from
finalist selection
Interviews with Finalists Board of Supervisors conduct interviews with
Finalists and selects top candidate TBD
Deep Background Check To be conducted by law enforcement agency
selected by BOS on top candidate TBD
Employment Offer
Made/Accepted Employment offer extended to selected candidate TBD
Chesterfield County, Virginia
announces recruitment for the position of
Chief of Police
DRAFT 06/14/24
To Serve
To Protect
To Lead
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 2
Living, Learning, Working and Playing in Chesterfield County
Strategic Location
Chesterfield County is ideally located in the mid-Atlantic
region of the United States. This strategic location on the
eastern seaboard is a valuable asset. It puts local busi-
nesses halfway between the markets of the north and
south, within a one-day
commute of 50% of
the U.S. population,
65% of the nation’s
manufacturing
operations and 60%
of the corporate
headquarters in the
country.
Chesterfield is part of the Richmond region and is
situated between the James and Appomattox Rivers.
Chesterfield boasts an array of live, work and play
options that are within a two-hour drive of Virginia
beaches, the Blue Ridge Parkway and Washington, D.C.
The county has an area of 437 square miles.
Chesterfield is the largest locality in the Richmond region
and the fourth largest county in Virginia. The county has a
population of over 380,000 people and continues to
attract new residents. About 58% of the population is
White, 26% is Black or African American, 4% is Asian, 0.6%
is American Indian and Alaska Native, 0.1% is Native
Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander and 3% is classified as
“two or more races,” while 11% are of Hispanic and Latino
origin. The median age of a county resident is 39 years.
Chesterfield’s climate provides generally mild winters
and warm, humid summers. An average year provides
206 clear days and 114 days of precipitation (including
10 inches of snow). January has an average temperature
of 27 degrees and July has an average temperature of 89
degrees.
Safety and Security
Public safety is a top priority for Chesterfield. Police,
Fire & EMS, Sheriff and the Emergency Communications
Center work in partnership to provide a safe and secure
community, which preserves the highest quality of life
for our residents. Chesterfield is also proud of its
progressive juvenile justice system, which works in
conjunction with the criminal justice system, to help
ensure public safety while supporting rehabilitation.
Chesterfield is devoted to ensuring the safety and security of
the community through prevention, readiness and professional
response, which require appropriate public safety staffing
levels. The 2024 public safety workforce statistics include:
• Police Department has 675 full-time employees
• Fire & EMS Department has 601 full-time employees
• Sheriff’s Office has 295 full-time employees
• Emergency Communications Center has 62 full-time
employees
The public safety workforce is among the best in the
nation. Recruitment and retention of quality public safety
professionals is an ongoing priority.
The Chesterfield County Police Department has been
accredited by the Commission on Accreditation for Law
Enforcement Agencies (CALEA) since 2017.
Educational Excellence
Education is another top priority in Chesterfield. The
county is responsible for its own public school system
under the direction of an elected school board. With
more than 64,000 students, it is the largest school system
in the region and has established innovative, state-of-the-
art programs to challenge all students at all levels.
Financial Integrity and Stability
Chesterfield is one of fewer than 35 counties in the nation
to hold AAA ratings from all three major bond rating
agencies. This status reflects exceptional management of
financial operations and conservative fiscal policies. The
Chesterfield Utilities Department is one of only a few
water and wastewater utilities in the nation to have
achieved AAA ratings on its revenue bonds from the
three top rating services. The highest of bond ratings
recognizes the Utilities Department’s excellent financial
profile, low-debt burden, manageable capital plan and
affordable rates as the keys to the department’s success.
The county holds both the Award for Distinguished
Budget Presentation and the Certificate of Achieve-
ment for Excellence in Financial Reporting from the
Government Finance Officers Association. The FY2025
budget for the county totals $2 billion, with the two
largest components of the budget being the county’s
general fund ($998.4 million) and the school fund ($997.8
million). The county’s total assets of $4.7 billion are
distributed throughout the county.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 3
Accessibility
Transportation and Commerce
Chesterfield’s road system is a model of efficiency and
convenience, with the county’s main business corridors
providing easy access to I-95, I-295, I-85 and I-64. The
interstate and beltway system within the county can handle
today’s traffic flow without the gridlock experienced in other
metro areas. The Chesterfield Airport is the executive
gateway into and out of the Greater Richmond area, and
business and personal fliers have long preferred the county’s
airport for its
convenience
and personal
attention.
Also easily
accessible is
the Richmond
International
Airport. Rail
services,
including CSX
and Amtrak,
are readily ac-
cessible, no matter where you live or work in the county; and,
in addition to deep-water industrial sites within the county,
the Ports of Richmond and Virginia are within easy reach.
Digital Community
Chesterfield continues to set an example for innovative tech-
nology in local government. This is the seventh consecutive
year being ranked in the top three among counties nation-
wide with populations between 250,000 and 499,000. This
award recognizes Chesterfield’s innovation in the use of tech-
nology to proactively address resident
needs and expectations. As a digital
county, Chesterfield recognizes that
technology strengthens and connects
the community.
Leaders in Healthcare
Chesterfield residents have access to exceptional medical
care, with leaders in the healthcare and medical research
industry. There are more than 2,000 physicians, 4,000 hospital
beds, a trauma center, a major cancer center and a major
medical school in the region.
Caring Community
• With a growing aging population, Chesterfield
recognizes that older adults want to live active and
independent lives. The county offers a valuable resource,
Aging and Disability Services, which serves residents
ages 60 and older, their family members and caregivers.
It also provides information and referral services relat-
ed to aging, caregiving and disabilities. The county is a
collaborative partner working with other organizations to
meet the needs of older residents.
• The county has a long-term commitment to reinvesting
in its older communities and commercial areas to help
maintain the vitality and high quality of life known within
Chesterfield. The school-based revitalization approach
targets public investment in older schools, as well as
supporting capital and community improvement
projects in surrounding areas. In 2022, Chesterfield
County voters approved a $270 million bond referendum
to support school facility improvements.
• The county has been recognized as one of the 100 Best
Communities for Young People because of its efforts to
ensure that young people graduate high school and go
on to lead healthy, productive lives. These efforts are
advanced through the Communities in Schools mentor-
ing program and the Chesterfield Youth Services
Advisory Board, which provides young leaders with the
opportunity to have a voice regarding youth-related
issues by planning programs and offering
recommendations to the Board of Supervisors.
Lifelong Learning
County Residents
Chesterfield Public Library is an award winning 10-branch
public library system that annually helps hundreds of
thousands of residents transform information into usable
knowledge through a hands-on learning approach. This
transformative learning experience enables residents of all
ages to work with professional staff who provide access to
up-to-date material collections in a variety of formats; aid in
the use of hands-on, self-service digital resources and
networks that allow residents to expand their knowledge
base; and assist them in finding and interpreting
information. In addition, the county’s 10 library branches
provide meeting space for hundreds of community organi-
zations every year, and programs and events see over 60,000
attendees. The library also features small business centers,
makerspaces, and serves as an important resource in disaster
relief and preparedness.
County Employees
Chesterfield is currently among the leaders of local gov-
ernments providing in-house development opportunities
for over 4,400 county government employees and over
8,400 schools employees. Investing in the staff’s
professional development has produced an outstanding
workforce that consistently delivers quality services in an
efficient manner. Grounded in the county’s mission, the
Learning & Performance Center provides a wide variety of
developmental opportunities to county employees while
offering consulting services to enhance organizational
effectiveness. Services focus on eight core competencies
that enhance career development; reinforce employee
performance expectations; drive the business strategy in
departments; and encourage continual improvement of
services to the residents and other customers of the
county.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 4
Award Winning County
Chesterfield County has a history of being an award-winning
locality. Recognitions include:
• 2024, 2023 & 2022 Top Workplaces USA
• 2024, 2023 & 2022 Richmond Times Dispatch Top
Workplaces
• 2024 Top Workplaces for Compensation & Benefits,
Innovation, Leadership, Purpose & Value, and Work-Life
Flexibility
• 2023, 2022 & 2021 Top Workplaces for Diversity, Equity
and Inclusion
• 2023 & 2021 Forbes America's Best-In-State Employers
• Chesterfield County ranked 41st in Money Magazine's
Top 50 Best Places to Live
• Numerous achievement awards from the National Associ-
ation of Counties (NACo) and the Virginia Association of
Counties (VACo)
• Training Magazine’s Top 125 employers in the nation that
provide outstanding employee development opportunities
• 100 Best Communities for Young People by America’s
Promise - The Alliance for Youth
• Diversity All Star Award from the Greater Richmond
Chamber of Commerce and the Richmond Human
Resource Management Association
• One of the Best Places to Live in America by American
City Business Journal
• Award for Continuing Excellence (ACE)
• Gold Medallion Senate Productivity Award
• Nationally recognized leader in technology. Four times
recognized as the #1 digital county in the USA.
Chesterfield County Government
Chesterfield provides complete local government services,
including public water and sewer utilities, mental health support
services, fire and emergency medical services, sheriff and police
protection. The county contains no incorporated cities or towns. It
is divided into five magisterial districts, each of which is
represented by one supervisor elected to serve four years.
Chesterfield County Board of Supervisors
These officials form the Board of Supervisors, the legislative body
of the county. The Board of Supervisors elects a chairman from its
membership for a one-year term. The Board appoints the County
Administrator, who serves as the county’s chief administrative
officer under the board’s direction.
James "Jim" Holland
Chair
Dale District
Mark S. Miller, Ph.D.
Vice-Chair
Midlothian District
The Board of Supervisors is responsible for establishing local
public policy, raising local resources for the support of public
programs, and overseeing the conduct of the county’s affairs
through its appointed administrative officials. County
government, as a political subdivision of the state, also assists in
the local implementation of state laws and programs.
Jim Ingle
Bermuda District
Jessica Schneider
Clover Hill District
Kevin Carroll
Matoaca District
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 5
Chesterfield County Organizational Structure
Chesterfield County Strategic Plan
Mission
Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public
service
Vision
To be an extraordinary and innovative community in which to live,
learn, work and play
Values
Results, Innovation, Service, Ethics
Everyday Excellence
Safe and Secure Community
Robust Economy
Healthy Living and Well-being
Thriving Communities
Learning for a Lifetime
Chesterfield County Police Department Organizational Structure
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 6
The Department
Office of the Chief – The Chief’s Office provides overall
planning, development and direction for police services for this
CALEA-accredited agency. Three deputy chiefs manage
Operations, Standards and Training, and Strategic Management.
Media and Messaging and Employee Wellness are managed and
coordinated under Strategic Management.
Emergency Communications - The Emergency Communications
Center (ECC) is responsible for answering, entering and
dispatching calls for service while gathering and relaying
information accurately and professionally. Staff in this division
handle 911 calls, non-emergency calls, other public safety
services and Police, Animal Control, Sheriff and Fire & EMS
dispatching. ECC serves as a vital link between the public and
other public safety organizations.
Strategic Management
Technology and Project Management – This team manages the
use of and facilitates the acquisition of police department
technology. The team also serves as support for all major
projects for the entire department. Department systems aid in
providing data to support strategic decision making. Police
systems support staff is responsible for the computer hardware
and software utilized by the department including remote sites
and mobile data computers in police vehicles.
Operations
Special Operations Division (SOD) – This division provides
specialized police services throughout the county. SOD enforces
state laws through specialized teams such as traffic safety, the
emergency response team and marine patrol. The division
supports patrol operations in the apprehension of suspects,
location of missing persons, and other general support functions
through specialized teams such as K9, aviation, and unmanned
aerial systems. Team members provide crime prevention
education, citizen academies, crime prevention through
environmental design, apartment safety awareness, and
numerous other services such as neighborhood watch and
project lifesaver. SOD develops impactful problem-solving
partnerships through community engagement. This division also
supports individuals experiencing mental health challenges
through the co-responder partnership with the Mental Health
Support Services Department. SOD also assists with operational
preparedness, homeland security and emergency management.
Animal Services - This division serves, protects and promotes
safety through the education of the community regarding
responsible pet ownership and the enforcement of violations of
law pertaining to animal welfare. The Chesterfield Animal Shelter
is also responsible for pet adoption services.
Patrol Services – The patrol division provides first responder
services to the residents, customers and businesses of
Chesterfield. Officers patrol beats to resolve, prevent, and deter
crime and support community policing efforts.
Special Investigations - This division investigates organized
criminal activity, including narcotics organizations and gangs.
Members of the team investigate offenses such as
prostitution, sex solicitation and gambling, and they
investigate mid to high-level drug traffickers and
organizations. Duties also include identifying and seizing
assets obtained through criminal activity. Special
Investigations also coordinate and conduct crime and traffic
analysis and provide investigative support in real time and
management of criminal intelligence. The special
enforcement team is also a part of this division.
Criminal Investigations – Investigations of all crimes against
persons and property are conducted by this division. The
crime solvers program and the forensics and cyber unit
report to this division.
Vulnerable Populations – This division is responsible for
investigating crimes against vulnerable populations including
domestic violence, human trafficking, sex crimes, crimes
against children and the elderly. The department’s domestic
violence coordinator reports to this division. Team members
also provide school safety services through the school
resource officer program in middle and high schools and the
success through education and proactive policing program in
all elementary schools.
Standards and Training
Training – This division is responsible for providing all recruit,
in-service, specialized and career development education as
well as firearms and vehicle operations training. The training
division also administers the field training program and
ensures compliance with Department of Criminal Justice
Services training standards. The firearms training center and
emergency vehicle operations course facilities are also part of
the training division.
Personnel – Staff assigned to this division are responsible for
recruiting, testing, conducting background investigations and
selecting personnel for recommendation of hire. This division
also administers the career development program and
process certain permits and licenses.
Management Services – Members of this division provide
logistical support and maintain custodial care of property and
evidence in the possession of the department. Management
Services develops and maintains inventory accountability for
the handling of property and evidence, as well as the
procurement and administration of department issued
uniforms, equipment, vehicles and supplies. This division also
has oversight of the police records management system and
responds to Freedom of Information Act requests.
Finance – Fiscal oversight and control of the department’s
operating budget, asset forfeiture funds, and grant funds are
managed by the Finance team. The members also manage
the department’s time accounting function and
administration of the false alarm ordinance.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 7
The Department (cont'd)
Standards and Training (cont'd)
Internal Affairs – The division is entrusted to provide
independent internal inspection services for the police chief
and members of management. Members of this division
manages regulatory services such as off-duty employment,
towing coordination, and state and national accreditation.
Budget – The department’s budget for fiscal year 2025 is
$101.7 million, an 8.4% increase from the prior year’s budget.
Additionally, animal services, a division of the police
department, has an operating budget of $2.3 million.
The Position
The Chief of Police leads the CALEA-accredited Police
Department in providing police services that enhance the
quality of life for those that visit, live and work in Chesterfield.
The department has 540 sworn and 135 non-sworn full-time
personnel and responds to approximately 230,000 calls for
service annually. The Chief of Police is responsible for
planning and administering policing programs and activities
of the county, to include design and implementation of
policies and programs in the enforcement of laws and
ordinances; prevention of crime and protection of life and
property and overall improvement in the community’s quality
of life; analysis of department operations, service demands,
community needs and budget costs; coordination of police
services with other agencies to address community problems;
and building cooperative and positive relationships with the
Board of Supervisors, County Administrator, department
leaders, local/regional/state public safety agencies, media
and citizens. In addition, the Chief of Police will also analyze
data, prepare reports, and make recommendations for
continued improvement of the Police Department. The Chief
of Police, as defined in the county charter, will serve as a
member of the executive leadership team and is under the
oversight of the Board of Supervisors, but administratively
reports to the County Administrator.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 8
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 9
The Ideal Candidate
The county is seeking a dedicated, innovative, forward-
thinking public service professional with extensive
experience in modern policing. The ideal candidate will have
impeccable integrity, ethics, a high level of professionalism,
and a track record of being both kind and results-driven. The
successful individual will bring proven leadership experience,
excellent interpersonal and communication skills, and a
commitment to delivering outstanding customer service
through others. The candidate will be expected to be well-
versed in cultivating a healthy, high performing
organizational culture, innovative policing strategies,
technology, and problem-solving partnerships. They will
offer a record of accomplishments in implementing
innovative, compassionate, and effective solutions to a wide
array of complex community challenges. Specific experience
in successfully addressing domains including, but not limited
to, criminal conduct, quality of life concerns, mental health
response, and substance abuse disorder are imperative. In
addition, strong knowledge of regional and national policing
trends and practices will be expected. The ideal candidate
will be a hands-on leader, an active listener, and a consensus
builder; however, they will also have the courage, fortitude,
and leadership acumen to make key decisions, in a timely
manner, often with incomplete information, when
circumstances merit such action.
The individual will have a clear vision of the demands of law
enforcement and will provide effective leadership, training,
and support to maintain high morale within department’s
staff. They will assume command and responsibility for the
outcomes of agency efforts and be fully engaged in
protecting the brand and credibility of the organization
through effective training, messaging, and oversight of
personnel and organizational outputs. The individual will
have high standards, cultivate an expectation of performance
excellence, and communicate openly with stakeholders
within the department and the broader community. A proven
track record of demonstrating initiative, cutting-edge
collaboration, informed by relevant and thoughtful analysis is
a must. The individual will have excellent diplomacy and
relationship building skills to foster positive and cooperative
interactions with elected officials, county leadership, county
departments, local, state and federal agencies and the
community.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 10
Professional Skills and Management Style
• A clear and inspiring communication style that elicits under-
standing and authenticity.
• The ability to effectively balance the stability of sound
management practices and the disequilibrium of effective
leadership; coupled with the ability to communicate a vision,
garner buy-in, and deliver high quality services through
others in an efficient manner.
• The ability to operate interdependently with other county
departments in order to deliver on the county’s vision of a
First Choice community.
• Forward-looking vision to read, anticipate, and respond
to evolving an operational environment in areas such as:
community expectations, staffing and equipment allocations,
training needs, and evolving trends/potential threats to the
community as well as to public safety operations.
• Excellent judgement and discernment on matters of law,
policy, constitutional policing, organizational wellness,
human performance conditions, finance, and
communications.
• The willingness and ability to effectively negotiate
competing interests in such a way as to foster cooperation,
build partnerships, and maintain best practices in service
delivery outcomes.
• Compassionately meet the needs of staff, collectively and
individually, to ensure organizational wellness, personnel
readiness, and esprit de corps.
• Cultivate an environment in which those with varied abilities,
perspectives, and insights feel seen, valued, and appreciated.
• A willingness to speak on behalf of the workforce on
matters pertaining to their performance, even when – and
especially when – doing so might place the incumbent in a
position of vulnerability.
• A dogged commitment to marketing the organization’s
brand, promoting career and volunteer opportunities, and
appealing to a wide array of diverse perspective applicants.
• The ability to plan for, respond to, and effectively lead
agency operations in the midst of a large scale, high profile,
critical incident.
• Critical thinking skills. The ability and willingness to
consider varied and competing perspectives in decision-
making processes, with an eye toward human needs over
process demands.
Performance and Expectations
Administrative Ability: Ability to plan, organize, direct, coordinate
and administer law enforcement activities of the Police
Department; to effectively communicate and serve as the lead
representative of the Police Department; to achieve the goals
and guidelines established by County Administration and the
Board of Supervisors; and ability to listen to and communicate
with various segments of the community.
Performance and Expectations (cont'd)
Community Relations: Ability to maintain positive working
relationships with citizens, public interest groups and
community organizations in a multiracial, socioeconomically
diverse setting; to continuously assess public safety concerns
in the community and to ensure that existing resources are
focused effectively on high priority issues.
Human Resources: Excellent communication skills with ability
to effectively communicate the county’s goals to department
staff. Must be able to inspire and motivate employees and
demonstrate fairness in dealing with staff. Must have
demonstrated a commitment to recruitment and retention,
teambuilding, equal employment opportunity, diversity and
upward mobility of staff.
Intergovernmental Relations: Ability to relate to and develop
good working relationships with regional partners, community
organizations and local, state and federal agencies.
Willingness and ability to provide strong, visible law
enforcement leadership through effective articulation of
policing approaches and programs among local and area
criminal justice agencies, community organizations and citizen
groups.
Chesterfield County, Virginia Page 11
Future Challenges
Recruitment and Retention of Police Officers: The Chief of
Police will need to continue focusing on attracting qualified
officers and implementing best practices for retention.
Increasing Complexity of Crime: The Chief of Police will be
expected to be well versed in innovative policing strategies,
technology and practices. The chief will focus on developing
strategic priorities for policing operations and will remain
abreast of growing crime trends.
Rapid Advances in Technology: The Chief of Police will be
progressive and innovative in ways to meet the technological
demands of the department, in alignment with budget
limitations, to anticipate, and adjust to the pace at which
technology changes.
Growth of the County: Future growth in the county will require
a Chief of Police who has proven experience in using proactive
policing and preventative activities to help meet the department
goals and objectives.
Evolving Community Expectations: The Chief of Police will
focus on continued relationship building with the community
and have the ability to successfully build ties with key
community leaders and organizations.
Maintaining Officer Safety: The Chief of Police will fully
embrace the county’s strategic goal of safety and security and
support new technology and training to maintain police officer
safety and well-being.
Qualifications
Education and Experience
• Bachelor’s degree in criminal justice, business
administration, public administration, or a related field
from an accredited college or university is required;
master’s degree is preferred.
• Evidence of continuing professional education and training
in relevant technical and managerial areas, including
advanced law enforcement programs such as FBI National
Academy, Southern Police Institute or Northwestern School
of Police Staff & Command. Designation as a Virginia
certified law enforcement professional or the ability to
obtain certification as soon as possible is required.
• Minimum of 10 years of progressively responsible law
enforcement managerial and leadership experience,
including five years of law enforcement experience in a
senior management capacity.
• Ideal candidate will have excellent leadership and
communications skills and proven experience in a law
enforcement agency including significant involvement in a
wide range of law enforcement activities such as field
operations (patrol), investigations, drug enforcement, and
community policing.
Page 12
Compensation and Benefits
Salary for the Police Chief’s position is negotiable based on qualifications and experience.
The successful candidate will be provided a take-home police vehicle and have access to a
comprehensive benefits package to include:
• Virginia Retirement System • Health and Dental Insurance
• Executive Leave Benefit • Paid Time Off Benefit
• Paid Holidays • Group Life Insurance
• Professional Development Opportunities • Short-Term and Long-Term Disability
Opportunity to:
• Work for a nationally
respected and award-
winning local government
that values both team-
work and individual
contribution
• Become part of an
outstanding and highly
stable team of elected
and appointed officials
• Tuition Assistance and Reimbursement
Program
• Long-Term Care Insurance • Lead a team of dedicated
personnel consisting of
experienced
professionals
• Employee Assistance Program • Flexible Spending Accounts
• Deferred Compensation • Paid Parental Leave
Application Process
The application deadline date is Monday, July 29, 2024.
Interested applicants should submit a resume with cover letter to:
https://www.governmentjobs.com/careers/bakertilly
For more information, please contact A nne Lewis at
anne.lewis@bakertilly.com o r 703 -932-8214, or
Yolanda Howze at yolanda.howze@bakertilly.com o r
312-240-3401.
The C hief of Police is not an at-will position. An extensive background investigation and
relevant testing necessary to fully assess a law enforcement leader's readiness to assume
the responsibilities and meet the expectations of a top tier police department will be
required.
An Equal Opportunity Employer Committed to Workforce Diversity.
• Live and work in an
exceptional community
For more information
visit www.chesterfield.gov
DRAFT
CHESTERFIELD COUNTY POLICE CHIEF RECRUITMENT
Community and Employee Input Meetings
Chesterfield County is currently recruiting for its next police chief. Community and employee meetings are planned in
July to gather input. Executive search firm, Baker Tilly, will hold in-person and virtual sessions to offer an opportunity
for attendees to provide input about the knowledge, skills and abilities they believe the new police chief should
possess. For those unable to attend an in-person or virtual session, an online survey is also available to provide input
during the recruitment process. The survey will be available through July 29. Survey results, as well as information
gathered through the in-person and virtual sessions, will be compiled in time to help inform the selection of the semi-
finalists by the Police Chief Recommendation Committee for first-round interviews, from which the Chesterfield County
Board of Supervisors will choose its finalists for further vetting, including additional interviews.
Thank you for being part of the process to select Chesterfield County’s next police chief.
In-Person Meetings
DAY TIME TYPE LOCATION
Wednesday,
July 10
7:15 a.m. All Police Employees Chesterfield County – Public Meeting Room
10001 Iron Bridge Road
Chesterfield, VA 23832
2:00 p.m. Community Midlothian Library
521 Coalfield Road
Midlothian, VA 23114
6:30 p.m. Community Chesterfield County – Public Meeting Room
10001 Iron Bridge Road
Chesterfield, VA 23832
Thursday,
July 11
7:15 a.m. All Police Employees Chesterfield County – Public Meeting Room
10001 Iron Bridge Road
Chesterfield, VA 23832
2:00 p.m. All Police Employees Chesterfield County – Public Meeting Room
10001 Iron Bridge Road
Chesterfield, VA 23832
6:30 p.m. Community Chesterfield Career & Technical Center
13900 Hull Street Road
Midlothian, VA 23112
Virtual Sessions
DAY TIME TYPE LOCATION
Monday,
July 15
1:00 p.m. All Police Employees Virtual – Microsoft Teams
6:30 p.m. Community Virtual – Facebook Live
*Note: Police Department employee meetings are in bold.
By COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDER SURVEY
CHESTERFIELD COUNTY, VIRGINIA
POLICE CHIEF
Chesterfield County, Virginia has retained Baker Tilly to conduct a search for a new Police Chief. As we
initiate the search, Chesterfield County would appreciate any input that community stakeholders wish
to contribute on the experience, management and leadership qualities they would like to see in the
County’s next Police Chief, along with any other issues they may feel are relevant to the selection
process.
Survey results will be compiled in time to help inform the selection of the Semi-Finalists by the Police
Chief Recommendation Committee for first-round interviews, from which the Chesterfield County Board
of Supervisors will choose its Finalists for further vetting, including additional interviews. Chesterfield
County will be provided with a copy of the community stakeholder survey results when completed. The
number of survey participants and the collected results will be made publicly available by the County
after receipt, though the identities of respondents will not be known or available.
Chesterfield County values your input and thanks you in advance for your time to complete this survey.
Please respond no later than 12:00 noon ET, Monday, July 29, 2024.
Question 1:
Which of the following represents your age group?
o 17 and under
o 18-24
o 25-49
o 50-74
o 75 or older
Question 2:
Select the option that best represents your relationship to Chesterfield County:
o Resident
o Business Owner
o Chesterfield Government Employee (police employees: please use police-specific survey)
o Chesterfield Public Schools Employee
o Community Organization/Partner
o Elected or Appointed Government Leader
o Student
o Other (please specify)
Question 3:
In your opinion what are the most important qualifications the next Police Chief must have? (Please rank
from Not Important to Very Important)
o Virginia Law Enforcement Experience
o Law Enforcement Credentials
o FBI Academy or similar academy training
o Prior Experience with a community of similar size and demographics
o Education (BS, MA, JD, Ph. D)
Question 4:
What are the most important areas of professional experience and expertise that the next Police Chief
should have? Please select four from the following list:
o Cultural competency on issues of equity, diversity, and inclusion
o External communications with the public and business community
o Internal communications with County staff and elected officials
o Participation in County and community events
o Skilled in administrative and financial management
o Skilled in aligning the organization with the strategic direction established by the Board of
Supervisors
o Skilled in intergovernmental relations and advocacy
o Leadership, integrity and character
o Police accountability
o Commitment to following the Board of Supervisor’s lead on policy issues
o Experience with mental health and substance use issues and policing
o Experience with juvenile crime and related issues
o Community policing
o Intergovernmental relations
o Skilled in utilizing technology in policing
Question 5:
What are your public safety priorities? Please select four from the following list:
o Responding to property crimes
o Strengthening community-police partnerships
o Enhancing emergency response capabilities
o Addressing substance abuse and mental health issues in the community
o Implementing community policing strategies
o Improving communication and transparency between law enforcement and the community
o Promoting education and awareness on public safety issues
o Utilizing technology for crime prevention and detection
o Implementing community-based training programs for emergency preparedness
o Enhancing youth engagement and after-school programs to prevent juvenile delinquency
o Fostering collaboration with local businesses to promote safety in commercial areas
o Addressing traffic safety concerns and implementing measures to reduce accidents
o Improving coordination with social services to support at-risk populations
o Investing in crime data analysis for targeted interventions
o Supporting community-led initiatives aimed at reducing crime and promoting safety
o Evaluating and updating firearm safety measures and regulations
o Responding to property crimes
Question 6:
What are the most important management and leadership qualities that the next Police Chief should
demonstrate? Select up to six critical qualities from the following list:
o Customer service focus
o Command presence
o Confidence
o Compassion
o Teamwork and collaboration
o Interpersonal communications
o Relationship building
o Ability to actively listen to concerns of others
o Negotiation
o Transparency
o Adaptability and resiliency
o Coaching and developing others
o Commitment to values-based leadership
o Conflict management
o Cultural competency (ability to work well with a wide variety of citizens)
o Championing change
o Decisive judgment
o Problem solving
o Fiscal prudence
o Planning and organizing
o Able to balance competing priorities
o Driving for results
o Transformational
o Continuous improvement
o Forward thinking
Question 7:
Rank the below issues in order of highest to lowest priority that the next Police Chief must be prepared
to address.
o Reducing Crime Rates: Implementing effective strategies to decrease crime rates and enhance
public safety throughout the community.
o Building Trust and Accountability: Establishing transparent policies and practices to build trust
between law enforcement and the community while ensuring accountability for officer conduct.
o A ddressing Mental Health and Addiction: Developing protocols and partnerships to effectively
respond to mental health crises and addiction-related issues with empathy and support.
o P romoting Diversity and Inclusion: Enhancing diversity within the Police Department and
fostering an inclusive culture that respects and values the community's diverse demographics.
o I mproving Community Relations : Strengthening relationships between law enforcement and
community members, particularly in neighborhoods in need of revitalization, through proactive
engagement and communication efforts.
Question 8:
Rank the below issues in order of highest to lowest priority that the next Police Chief must be prepared
to address immediately and as soon as they are on the job.
o Assessing Departmental Policies and Procedures: Reviewing existing policies and procedures to
identify areas for improvement in accountability, community engagement, and officer training.
o Bu ilding Relationships with Community Stakeholders : Initiating dialogue with community
leaders, organizations, and residents to understand their concerns and priorities while
establishing trust and collaboration.
o A ddressing Immediate Public Safety Concerns: Implementing strategies to address pressing
public safety issues such as crime spikes, traffic safety, or emergency response preparedness.
o E valuating Staffing and Resource Allocation: Assessing staffing levels, resource distribution, and
budgetary needs to ensure effective deployment of personnel and equipment.
o I mplementing Accountability Measur es: Instituting mechanisms for Police Department
accountability, transparency, and ethical conduct.
Question 9:
How would you like the next Police Chief to foster relationships and communication between law
enforcement and different cultural or minority groups within the community? Please rank the following
from highest to lowest priority.
o Community Engagement Events: Organizing cultural awareness events, festivals, or
neighborhood gatherings where community members and law enforcement can interact in a
relaxed and informal setting.
o D iverse Hiring and Training Practices : Implementing additional recruitment strategies to
increase diversity within the Police Department and providing more cultural sensitivity training
for officers to better understand and respect diverse perspectives.
o A dvisory Boards or Councils: Establishing advisory boards or councils comprised of
representatives from various cultural or minority groups to provide input on policing strategies,
policies, and community concerns.
o M ultilingual Support Services : Enhancing language interpretation services and employing more
officers proficient in languages spoken within minority communities to improve communication
and accessibility.
o Community Policing Initiatives: Increasing community policing initiatives that emphasize building
trust, collaboration, and problem-solving partnerships between law enforcement and cultural or
minority groups.
Question 10:
What initiatives or programs do you believe would enhance community policing efforts in Chesterfield
County?
o Publicly Accessible Policies and Procedures: Publishing all department policies, procedures, and
protocols online for easy public access and review.
o R egular Public Reports and Updates : Issuing regular reports and updates to the community on
department activities, initiatives, and performance metrics.
o I ndependent Audits : Conduct regular audits and reviews of department operations, practices,
and complaints and take action as appropriate.
o B ody -Worn Camera Usage: Continue to mandate the use of body-worn cameras for all officers
during interactions with the public and ensure timely and appropriate release of footage in
accordance with privacy laws.
Question 11:
Rank the following initiatives and programs from most to least preferred that you would like the Police
Chief to continue to engage the youth in the community.
o Youth Police Academies: Establishing youth police academies or mentorship programs where
young people can learn about law enforcement, leadership skills, and civic responsibility in a
supportive environment.
o S chool Resource Officer Programs : Expanding school resource officer programs to build positive
relationships between law enforcement and students, while also addressing safety concerns
within educational institutions.
o C ommunity Youth Outreach Events : Organizing youth-focused events such as sports
tournaments, art workshops, or leadership summits to provide opportunities for positive
interactions between police officers and young people.
o Y
outh Advisory Councils : Creating youth advisory councils or committees to give young people a
voice in shaping police policies, programs, and initiatives that directly affect them.
o Y outh Dive rsion and Support Programs: Implementing diversion programs and support services
aimed at providing alternatives to juvenile detention and addressing underlying issues such as
substance abuse, mental health, and homelessness among young people.
Optional Open-Ended Questions (for PCRC discussion)
Question 12: What existing practices, policies and/or programs do you believe the next Police Chief
should continue?
Question 13: If you could ask candidates for the Police Chief position one question, what question
would you ask?
Question 14: What advice, if any, would you give the next Police Chief?
Question 15: Please feel free to share additional input on the professional experience,
leadership/management characteristics, and priority issues and challenges that are relevant to the
recruitment and selection of the next Police Chief.
Chesterfield County values your input and thanks you for participating in this survey.
POLICE DEPARTMENT EMPLOYEE SURVEY
CHESTERFIELD COUNTY, VIRGINIA
POLICE CHIEF
Chesterfield County has retained Baker Tilly to conduct a search for a new Police Chief. As we initiate
the search, the Board of Supervisors would appreciate your input. What experience, management and
leadership qualities would you like to see in our next Police Chief?
Your responses to this survey will be completely anonymous. We are committed to ensuring the
confidentiality of your feedback.
Survey results will be compiled in time to help inform the selection of the Semi-finalists by the Police
Chief Recommendation Committee for first-round interviews, from which the Chesterfield County Board
of Supervisors will choose its Finalists for further vetting, including additional interviews. The County will
be provided with a copy of the employee survey results when completed. The number of survey
participants and the collected results will be made available by the County after receipt, though the
identities of respondents will not be known or available.
Chesterfield County values your input and thanks you in advance for your time to complete this survey.
Please respond no later than 12:00 noon ET, Monday, July 29, 2024.
Question 1:
Which of the following represents your years of service with Chesterfield Police Department?
o Less than one year
o 1-5 years
o 6-10 years
o 11-19 years
o Over 20 years
Question 2:
In your opinion what are the most important credentials the next Police Chief must have? (Please rank
from Not Important to Very Important)
o Virginia Law Enforcement Experience
o Law Enforcement Credentials
o FBI Academy or similar academy training
o Prior Experience with a community of similar size and demographics
o Education (BS, MA, JD, Ph. D)
Question 3:
What are the most important areas of professional experience and expertise that the next Police Chief
should have? Please select four from the following list:
o Skilled in aligning the organization with the strategic direction established by the Board of
Supervisors
o Leadership, integrity and character
o Commitment to following the Board of Supervisors’ priorities and direction when carrying
out policy issues
o Effective Police Department culture builder that establishes healthy norms and ensures
equity and inclusion
o Ability to model and teach community policing
o Intercultural competency
o Proven success in fostering equity, diversity, and inclusion
o Accountability
o External communications with the public and business community
o Internal communications with County staff and elected officials
o Participation in County and community events
o Skilled in administrative and financial management
o Skilled in intergovernmental relations and advocacy
o Experience with mental health issues and policing
o Experience with substance abuse issues and policing
o Experience with juvenile crime and related issues
o Skilled in utilizing technology in policing
Question 4:
What are your public safety priorities? Please select four from the following list:
o Strengthening community-police relationships
o Enhancing emergency response capabilities
o Addressing substance abuse and mental health issues in the community
o Implementing community policing strategies
o Improving communication and transparency between law enforcement and the community
o Promoting education and awareness on public safety issues
o Utilize technology for crime prevention and detection
o Implementing community-based training programs for emergency preparedness
o Enhancing youth engagement and after-school programs to prevent juvenile delinquency
o Fostering collaboration with local businesses to promote safety in commercial areas
o Addressing traffic safety concerns and implementing measures to reduce accidents
o Improving coordination with social services to support at-risk populations
o Investing in crime data analysis for targeted interventions
o Supporting community-led initiatives aimed at reducing crime and promoting safety
o Evaluating and updating firearm safety measures and regulations
o Ensuring equity for all, especially within neighborhoods in need of revitalization
Question 5:
What are the most important management and leadership qualities that the next Police Chief should
demonstrate? Select up to six critical qualities from the following list:
o Customer service
o Command presence
o Confidence
o Compassion
o Teamwork and collaboration
o Interpersonal communications
o Relationship building
o Ability to actively listen to the concerns of others
o Negotiation
o Transparency
o Adaptability and resiliency
o Coaching and developing staff
o Commitment to values-based leadership
o Conflict management
o Intercultural competency (ability to work well with a wide variety of citizens)
o Commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion
o Championing change
o Decisive judgment
o Problem solving
o Fiscal prudence
o Planning and organizing
o Able to balance competing priorities
o Driving for results
o Transformational
o Continuous improvement
o Forward thinking
Question 6:
Rank the below issues in order of highest to lowest priority that the next Police Chief must be prepared
to address.
o Community Relations and Trust Building: Enhancing transparency, accountability, and trust
between the police department and the community.
o C rime Reduction and Public Safety : Implementing effective strategies to reduce crime rates and
ensure the safety of all residents.
o P olice Training and Professional Development: Ensuring officers receive comprehensive training
on de-escalation, cultural competency, mental health wellness and modern policing techniques.
o R esource Management and Budgeting: Efficiently managing departmental resources, inc luding
personnel, technology, and budget constraints.
o Addressing Internal Morale and Workforce Issues: Improving morale as needed, addressing
burnout, and fostering a positive and supportive work environment for all officers and staff.
Question 7:
Rank the below issues in order of highest to lowest priority that the next Police Chief must be prepared
to address immediately and as soon as they are on the job.
o Strengthening Community Trust: Building and improving relationships with community
members to enhance trust and cooperation.
o A ddressing Crime Hotspots : Identifying and targeting higher crime areas with focused strategies
to reduce incidents and increase public safety.
o Bo osting Officer Morale : Implementing initiatives to improve the morale and well-being of the
Police Department, including addressing concerns and fostering a positive work environment.
o I mproving Response Outcomes: Enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of police response to
emergencies and incidents.
o R eviewing Department Policies : Conducting a comprehensive review of current policies and
procedures to ensure they are up-to-date, effective, and aligned with best practices in law
enforcement.
Question 8:
How would you like the next Police Chief to foster relationships and communication between law
enforcement and different cultural or ethnic groups within the community? Please rank the following
from highest to lowest priority.
o Community Engagement Events: Organizing cultural awareness events, festivals, or
neighborhood gatherings where community members and law enforcement can interact in a
relaxed and informal setting.
o D iverse Hiring and Training Practices : Implementing additional recruitment strategies to
increase diversity within the Police Department and providing more cultural sensitivity training
for officers to better understand and respect diverse perspectives.
o A dvisory Boards or Councils: Establishing advisory boards or councils comprised of
representatives from various cultural or minority groups to provide input on policing strategies,
policies, and community concerns.
o M ultilingual Support Services : Enhancing language interpretation services and employing more
officers proficient in languages spoken within minority communities to improve communication
and accessibility.
o C ommunity Policing Initiatives : Increasing community policing initiatives that emphasize building
trust, collaboration, and problem-solving partnerships between law enforcement and cultural or
minority groups.
Question 9:
What initiatives or programs do you believe would enhance community policing efforts in Chesterfield
County?
o Publicly Accessible Policies and Procedures: Publishing all department policies, procedures, and
protocols online for easy public access and review.
o R egular Public Reports and Updates : Issuing regular reports and updates to the community on
department activities, initiatives, and performance metrics.
o I ndependent Audits : Conduct regular audits and reviews of department operations, practices,
and complaints and take action as appropriate.
o B ody -Worn Camera Usage: Continue to mandate the use of body-worn cameras for all officers
during interactions with the public and ensure timely and appropriate release of footage in
accordance with privacy laws.
Question 10:
Rank the following methods from most to least preferred for the next Police Chief to ensure
transparency within the Police Department.
o Regular Internal Reports and Updates: Providing police employees with frequent updates on
departmental activities, crime statistics, and policy changes through internal reports and
communications.
o E mployee Forums and Q&A Sessions : Hosting regular forums and Q&A sessions where police
employees can engage with the Police Chief, ask questions, and express their concerns.
o I nternal Access to Body Worn Camera Footage: Ensuring that relevant body worn camera
footage is accessible to police employees, following privacy and legal guidelines.
o T ransparent Internal Complaint and Investigation Processes : Ensuring that the processes for
filing internal complaints and conducting investigations are clear, accessible, and transparent to
police employees, as permissible.
o I nternal Data Sharing Initiatives: Creating an internal data portal where police employees can
access information on police activities, departmental budgets, use-of-force incidents, and other
relevant data, as appropriate.
Question 11:
Rank the following initiatives and programs from most to least preferred that you would like the Police
Chief to continue to engage the youth in the community.
o Youth Police Academies: Establishing youth police academies or mentorship programs where
young people can learn about law enforcement, leadership skills, and civic responsibility in a
supportive environment.
o S
chool Resource Officer Programs : Expanding school resource officer programs to build positive
relationships between law enforcement and students, while also addressing safety concerns
within educational institutions.
o C
ommunity Youth Outreach Events : Organizing youth-focused events such as sports
tournaments, art workshops, or leadership summits to provide opportunities for positive
interactions between police officers and young people.
o Youth Advisory Councils: Creating youth advisory councils or committees to give young people a
voice in shaping police policies, programs, and initiatives that directly affect them.
o Y outh Diversion and Support Programs: Implementing diversion programs and support services
aimed at providing alternatives to juvenile detention and addressing underlying issues such as
substance abuse, mental health, and homelessness among young people.
Optional Open-Ended Questions (for PCRC discussion)
Question 12: What existing practices, policies and/or programs do you believe the next Police Chief
should continue?
Question 13: If you could ask candidates for the Police Chief position one question, what question
would you ask?
Question 14: What advice, if any, would you give the next Police Chief?
Question 15: Please feel free to share additional input on the professional experience,
leadership/management characteristics, and priority issues and challenges that are relevant to the
recruitment and selection of the next Police Chief.
Chesterfield County values your input and thanks you for participating in this survey.
Chesterfield County Police Chief
Questions for Community/Employee In-Person Input Sessions
(For PCRC Review & Discussion)
1. What management/leadership characteristics should the new Police Chief possess?
2. What experience and expertise should Chesterfield’s next Police Chief possess?
3. What are the County/Department priorities Chesterfield’s next Police Chief should
address as soon as they are on the job?
4. What are the most important County/Department issues the new Police Chief will face
over the next five years?
5. Please share additional comments you would like the Police Chief Recommendation
Committee and Board of Supervisors to consider when evaluating candidates for the
position of Police Chief.
6. What are existing practices, policies and/or programs you feel the new Police Chief
should continue?
7. What are policies or practices you feel the new Police Chief should change or
discontinue?
8. How do you think the community views the Police Department and the services
provided? What can be done to enhance the Police Department’s image with the
public?
Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and Baker Tilly US, LLP, trading as Baker Tilly, are members of the global network of Baker Tilly
International Ltd., the members of which are separate and independent legal entities. Baker Tilly US, LLP is a licensed CPA firm that
provides assurance services to its clients. Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and its subsidiary entities provide tax and consulting services to
their clients and are not licensed CPA firms.
Leadership-Management Assessment Tool
Part of Baker Tilly’s screening and evaluation process for the Chesterfield County Police Chief
recruitment involves asking the Police Chief Recommendation Committee and designated
stakeholders (up to 10 total) to identify the preferred management styles, work related values and
leadership competencies that will be essential for success in the position. The results of this survey
will assist us in creating benchmark criteria for assessing the most promising candidates.
This process involves three steps:
First, individual members of the PCRC and designated stakeholders complete the assessment via an
on-line survey. This assessment takes 30-45 minutes to complete and must be completed in one
sitting. The questions will focus on the leadership and management qualities that are most desirable
in the Police Chief role. The individual results are combined into one profile, or benchmark.
Next, the finalist candidates complete their own questionnaire on their individual management styles,
work related values and leadership competencies.
Lastly, the individual candidate results are compared to the benchmark developed by the PCRC and
designated stakeholders. The resulting Gap Analysis allows Baker Tilly to more accurately probe
during the interview process. Under our guidance, you will be able to see where there is a match and
where there are differences. More importantly, this process will give us a high degree of confidence
when the final decision to make an employment offer is made.
We will provide a link to the assessment survey on July 15, 2024 and participants will be given until
July 26, 2024 to complete. The Gap Analysis results will be provided prior to interviews with the
finalist candidates.
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.