Police Chief Recommendation Committee — Agenda Minutes
Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Police Chief Recommendation Committee · meeting of May 28, 2024 · Other
Open the original document More from Chesterfield County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
May 28, 2024 Page 1 of 7
Police Chief Recommendation Committee
Organizational Meeting
May 28, 2024
County Administration Building, Room 502
MINUTES
Present: The Honorable Jessica Schneider, Member, Board of Supervisors, Clover Hill District
The Honorable Kevin Carroll, Member, Board of Supervisors, Matoaca District
The Honorable Edward A. Robbins, Jr., Judge, Chesterfield County Circuit Court
Dr. Kevin Sykes, County Resident & Senior Pastor of St. James Baptist Church
Dr. Joseph Casey, County Administrator
Absent: None
Also present were Mr. Jeffrey Mincks, County Attorney; Ms. Julie Seyfarth, Sr. Deputy County
Attorney; Ms. Mary Martin Selby, Director, Human Resources ; Ms. Mandy Pilk, Assistant
Director, Human Resources; Ms. Liz Marker, Chief of Administrative Services, Human
Resources; Ms. Carrie -Lynn Edwards, Administrative Analyst, Human Resources; Lt. Colonel
Brad Badgerow, Acting Police Chief; and Mr. Chuck Hale and Mr. Sheldon Cohen, Resource
Management Associates (RMA).
Dr. Casey called the meeting to order at 3 p.m.
WELCOME AND INTRODUCTIONS
Dr. Casey welcomed ev eryone to the meeting and invited attendees and guests to introduce
themselves.
COMMITTEE COMPOSITION/CHARTER/LEGAL ISSUES/PARLIAMENTARY
PROCEDURES
Mr. Mincks reviewed Section 6.7 of the County Charter which mentions the Police Chief
Recommendation Committee. He discussed the concept of employment at will and stated the chief
of police is a non-at-will employee and can only be removed for cause. He provided details of the
county’s Code of Ethics and Law Enforcement Code of Ethics. He reviewed Parliamentary
Procedures, which mirror the Rules of Procedure of the Board of Supervisors, and recommended
they be used at the committee’s meetings. He also reviewed the Fre edom of Information Act
(FOIA), which is applicable to the committee’s public meetings and communications related to
the business of the committee, other than discussions about potential candidates.
In response to Mr. Carroll’s question relative to notes taken during closed sessions about an
applicant’s qualifications, Mr. Mincks stated the notes are not subject to disclosure. He further
stated closed sessions work because they are confidential. He then continued his review of FOIA.
May 28, 2024 Page 2 of 7
Dr. Casey discussed the importance of preserving the anonymity of candidates who may interview
in person.
Mr. Mincks completed his review of FOIA.
In response to Mr. Carroll’s question relative to remote attendance by committee members at
committee meetings, Mr. Mincks distributed a draft policy and encouraged the committee to
consider adopting it. Mr. Mincks then provided the committee with an overview of the Virginia
State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act (“COIA”).
OVERVIEW OF THE POLICE DEPARTMENT
Lt. Colonel Badgerow provided the committee with an overview of the police department. He
reviewed the organization chart, key 2023 statistics for operations and support, five-year crime
totals, patrol functions, and sworn/police service aide staffing. He provided details of 2023 top 10
calls for service, the department’s beat structure, and calls for service broken down by day of week
and time of day. He discussed responses to mental health calls and trends. He reviewed Marcus
Alert protocols, statistics pertaining to heroin overdoses, the community connect program,
wellness and peer support, and accreditation. He discussed facilities updates, community
partnerships, and the Police Activities League. He reviewed recent employee awards and
recognitions.
Discussion ensued relative to the police department’s response times and clearance rates.
In response to Dr. Sykes’ question relative to what other partnerships the police department is
working on, Lt. Colonel Badgerow provided details of the department’s community engagement
division, neighborhood/business/commercial watch programs, Triad, and citizen academies.
RECRUITMENT, SCREENING AND CANDIDATE INTERVIEWS
Discussion of Related Processes
Mr. Hale discussed the process and estimated it would take 90 to 100 days.
Mr. Cohen encouraged the committee to select a single point of contact to work directly with
RMA. He discussed the optional use of an assessment center and a deep background investigation.
Discussion ensued relative to the assessment center, the professionals who would serve on the
assessment center, the scenarios that would be utilized, conflicts of interest between applicants and
panelists, and criteria important to committee members.
In response to Judge Robbins’ question relative to the difference between a deep background
investigation and some other type of investigation that goes beyond what RMA already described,
Mr. Hale stated the investigator gets information first- hand from th e source by going to the
May 28, 2024 Page 3 of 7
applicant’s hometown. He further stated the investigator spends a day or two talking to people who
know the person on a first-name basis.
Mr. Cohen stated the investigator would talk with the county administrator or city manager; a
member of the board or council; subordinates; union president; and local business owners.
Mr. Hale stated applicants will provide a list of references, but it is important to note who they did
not list and ask why.
Judge Robbins inquired if RMA has a methodology so that each candidate is evaluated in the same
or a similar way.
Mr. Cohen answered affirmatively, and stated RMA uses the same exact structure from the initial
evaluation criteria for the universe of applicants. He further stated it is the same behaviors for the
same universe of candidates judged by the same dimensions and benchmarks. He stated RMA will
process each candidate at each stage of the evaluation exactly the same. He further stated they are
very careful about consistency.
Discussion ensued relative to candidates signing a waiver allowing review of their internal affairs
files at their current agency.
In response to Dr. Casey’s question relative to the background check and whether it emulates a
certain security clearance level, Mr. Cohen stated he did not think it emulates a certain security
clearance level.
Mr. Hale stated their investigator does have that security clearance.
Mr. Cohen stated their investigator is a retired police chief in the Chicago area and a retired NCIS
commander, and he could look anywhere.
Timelines and Action Items
Mr. Cohen reviewed the timetable and stated it would be updated after the meeting. He discussed
scheduling interviews with key officials and holding community meetings. He suggested
interviewing a broad range of stakeholders.
Mr. Carroll stated the sheriff needs to be on the list of stakeholders.
In response to Judge Robbins’ question relative to what the topic of the interviews would be, Mr.
Hale stated he wants to get input from stakeholders about how they view the police department ,
what is important to them as a community resident or leader, what they hope to see in the future,
what is missing, and what the department should be doing.
May 28, 2024 Page 4 of 7
Judge Robbins suggested the profile be expanded to include others outside of county government
such as the public defender, the chief judges of the county’s two district courts, and named people
who represent constituencies outside of county government.
Mr. Cohen emphasized the meetings would be one -on-one, closed door, and anonymous to
encourage interviewees to be completely forthcoming. He stated the confidentiality of the
interviews would go far beyond what you would get out of a focus group.
Discussion ensued relative to interviewing representatives from homeowners associations and
parent/teacher associations.
Mr. Carroll stressed the importance of consistency of the questions.
Dr. Casey discussed the distinction between who might be invited to a closed-door interview and
who might be invited to a community meeting.
Judge Robbins concurred with Mr. Carroll and stated if groups are not asked the same questions,
then the consultants are going to get random information of limited utility.
Dr. Sykes stated the community needs to hear these things, too. He inquired about how this practice
has worked for the consultants outside of doing it at-large.
Mr. Cohen stated they are listening for common themes , interests, and concerns which may
consistently emerge.
Dr. Sykes stated he could understand the value of common themes if the committee is looking at
someone inhouse moving up in the ranks. He inquired about how common themes address or help
with getting candidates from outside.
Mr. Cohen stated he would be looking for common themes articulated by interviewees here in the
county, not the candidates. He further stated w hat is learned in interviews becomes important in
formulating interview questions for the six finalists and f ormulating the assessment center
exercises.
Mr. Carroll inquired about how everything is put together to target what is being sought in a
candidate.
Dr. Sykes expressed appreciation for Mr. Carroll’s clarification that the common theme is focused
on the county.
Dr. Casey stated during the last police chief recruitment process, most of the i nsight came from
the police department employees themselves about what they wanted and need ed out of a police
chief to make them better. He further stated the committee had honest and fair discussions, with a
lot of anonymit y, and there was an overall theme of what is good and what can be better. He
inquired about how to survey others, namely the whole police department as a workforce and the
whole community, and how to extrapolate the data to define the will of the people.
May 28, 2024 Page 5 of 7
Mr. Cohen stated they have been having discussions about how to do the surveys.
Dr. Casey stated the questions asked at community meetings should be similar to those on a general
survey. He further stated the questions asked of command staff in private interviews should be the
same as those asked of police employees to determine if command staff thinks the same as the rest
of the staff.
Mr. Cohen stated they will work with staff to refine the interviews and work with Dr. Casey’s
office to get the interviews and community meetings scheduled around June 12, 2024.
Dr. Casey stated staff will start working right away to reserve meeting locations and disseminate
information about the meetings.
Mr. Cohen provided details of background information to be used for recruitment materials and
emphasized reviewing CALEA reports. He then reviewed the scope of search and suggested
compensation be stated as a range. He discussed the use of national advertising and the job
advertisement itself.
In response to Ms. Schneider’s question relative to advertising through the National Association
of Counties (NACo) in addition to Virginia Association of Counties (VACo) , Dr. Casey stated
advertising could be done through NACo, National League of Cities , and Virginia Municipal
League.
Mr. Cohen concurred.
In response to Dr. Casey’s question relative to whether there is a draft of the job advertisement for
Chesterfield’s individual search, Mr. Cohen stated RMA has not worked on that yet. He further
stated what is learned from the interviews and community meetings would be used to ensure the
most accurate profile of the chief’s position.
Dr. Casey stated advertising for the position would not begin until the middle of June at the earliest.
Mr. Cohen concurred. He stated an advertisement should be out for thirty days to ensure a
sufficient window to apply.
Mr. Carroll inquired whether committee members had a chance to review the recruitment brochure
and stated it should be linked wherever the recruitment is advertised.
Mr. Cohen stated RMA has been working with Ms. Martin Selby on a set of documents , which
should be linked to the home page on the county’s website.
Dr. Casey stated a special meeting could be called to go into closed session for the applicant
review.
May 28, 2024 Page 6 of 7
Mr. Cohen stated RMA would solicit people through its own professional network. He further
stated RMA would continue to work as expeditiously as possible on community and employee
input sessions and surveys. He stated RMA would take another look at content/development and
think about how it can be worked to the county’s advantage. He discussed the survey sample.
Dr. Casey stated the result of asking questions is a public product, and the questions have to be
careful. He further stated anything written in an open comment field is public record, even if it is
private information the respondent did not realize would be made public.
Mr. Mincks stated under FOIA, documents do not get protected until there are live candidates
being evaluated. He further stated the process of how to get those candidates is all open.
Mr. Cohen reviewed i nitial screening criteria and stated a Word document would be sent to the
committee members with a request to return responses to RMA promptly. He further stated RMA
would compile the responses and share them with the committee. He discussed the need for the
committee to consider whether to isolate candidates or allow them to interact while they are here.
He stated RMA would prepare both standard and individual interview questions.
COMMITTEE DISCUSSION ITEMS
Committee Structure
Dr. Casey stated the committee needs to appoint a chair and vice chair, one of whom could be the
point of contact. He further stated a staff member could be the point of contact. He provided June
21 and June 27 as possible meeting dates. He provided details of the point of contact’s
responsibilities.
Mr. Carroll recommended Dr. Casey be the chair, who could then designate a direct assistant or
point of contact.
Judge Robbins concurred.
Ms. Schneider volunteered to be vice chair.
Dr. Sykes and Judge Robbins concurred with Ms. Schneider being vice chair.
On motion of Mr. Carroll, seconded by Dr. Sykes, Dr. Casey was selected to be the chair, and Ms.
Schneider was selected to be the vice chair.
Ayes: Schneider, Carroll, Robbins, Sykes, and Casey.
Nays: None.
Dr. Casey stated if everything goes well with the interviews, community meetings, and building
the best profile and recruiting method, the committee may be positioned at its next meeting to
begin recruiting.
May 28, 2024 Page 7 of 7
In response to Ms. Schneider’s question relative to when committee members need to respond to
RMA on the decision points, Dr. Casey stated he would begin working on that promptly.
Ms. Schneider inquired about what decisions are needed first.
Mr. Cohen stated the first decision would be the dates for the interviews and community meetings.
Dr. Casey stated the decisions on the assessment center process and deep background check could
be made later.
Ms. Schneider inquired if the survey would be emailed to the committee members the next day.
Mr. Cohen stated RMA would have the survey to committee members probably by the afternoon
of the next day.
On motion of Mr. Carroll, seconded by Ms. Schneider, the committee adjourned at 5:28 p.m.
Ayes: Schneider, Carroll, Robbins, Sykes and Casey.
Nays: None.
Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.