RecordWell Data

Planning Commission — Agenda Minutes

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Planning Commission · meeting of Apr 16, 2024 · Other

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

April 16, 2024 CPC Online Form Citizen Comments recieved as of 3 p.m. on 4/12/2024 4/10/2024 Mark CooperComment on comprehensive plan amendments I live right down the road where they plan on putting the Agrihood. While I am in support of the housing I am not in support of rezoning for a vocational building and private park. We are a complete neighborhood already with a County park that has a huge community building and parking for events. There is absolutely no need for a vocational building for classes yet alone for Yoga that can be offered at the already standing community center, As for the private park. We have a park 500 yards down the street we don't need a "private" park that excludes the rest of the neighborhood. What a way to come into the neighborhood but to already exclude the current residents. Also living on Swineford Rd the traffic is already hellacious with the apartments and the construction of the additional apartments on the other side of the park not including events held at the park. We do not need any additional traffic multiple days of the week. I've already seen multiple near misses with pedestrians!!! Not to mention the horrible condition our roads are in ad what the increase of traffic will do to make matters even worse! Also the hours starting at 7am is a little early for noise not everyone is up that early. Bermuda Continued on page 2 1 Hare, Kelly From: Planning, E-Mail Subject: 9701 Hull Street Road- Agricultural to RTN: Zoning Case: 22SN0147 From: KA Bell <Email Address Redacted> Sent: Tuesday, April 9, 2024 7:55 AM To: Planning, E-Mail <Planning@chesterfield.gov> Cc: Holland, James <HollandJ@chesterfield.gov> Subject: 9701 Hull Street Road- Agricultural to RTN: Zoning Case: 22SN0147 Dear Supervisor Holland and Planning Commission, We strongly oppose any planned development to put up to 260 apartments or townhomes in this largely meadow ecosystem, in Falling Creek Farms. We would not have bought a home here (in Mayfair Estates) had we understood that the County intended to make Rockwood an urban area. This particular lot of land is home to many species, including the Eastern Towhee, found nowhere else nearby, and to many birds of prey such as red-shouldered hawks and barred owls. The development would destroy this ecosystem. Alongside proposed apartments being built in the Big Lots parking lot (Rockwood Square), the traffic congestion and ongoing public safety concerns (the police presence is already high at Hull St. and Courthouse due to problems-- see County data) will only amplify with the increased density. No conditional use exceptions should be made nor should this plan move forward. The County should buy this land and create a natural native plant and outdoor space instead. Please reject this application. Thank you, Karen Ann Bell -- KA Bell, MS, MSW, CFRA, CRA 1 April 12, 2024 Greg Allen 3803 Timber Ridge Road Midlothian, VA 23112 Chesterfield County Planning Commission Via Email RE: Zoning Cases 22SN0147 (Rockwood Grove) & 22SN0155 (Benton Woods) Dear Planning Commission: You are hearing two zoning requests on April 16, 2024, that seek to increase density while asking for exceptions to the zoning ordinance. These cases do not adequately address the considerations of the zoning ordinance for approving a Conditional Use Planned Development as stated in Sec. 19.1-12 (included at the end of this document). Despite the length of this letter, you can quickly scan the bolded and highlighted text to see the primary content, and then decide which supporting explanations you need to read. There are numerous deficiencies with both cases. It is unclear why Planning continues to recommend approval for these cases in the face of extensive deficiencies. It places you in an awkward position of having to be the gatekeeper when the Planning Department recommendation should be the primary professional position upon which you can rely. I have listed these deficiencies and others below that staff did not include. I am asking you to defer these cases until the applicants address these issues. Case 22SN0147 – Rockwood Grove Rockwood Grove fails to address the requirements of the Comp Plan and the Zoning Ordinance as follows: 1. The concept plan does not abide by the Special Focus Area Plan for Rockwood. Explanation: The northern 11.7 acres of the site is recommended by the Special Focus Area (SFA) to be Corporate Office and not medium to high density residential. The Rockwood Special Focus Area Plan is a recent addition to the Comp Plan. Why are we ignoring the land use recommendation? This builds a precedent that Comp Plan recommendations, even in a very localized geography, are not important. Citizens will not believe the Comp Plan decisions of the Commission and Board. 2. T he residential yield on this site is higher than anticipated by the Rockwood SFA. Explanation: The Rockwood SFA expected a residential density in this quadrant based upon 21.62 acres of Medium-High Residential Use and not increasing the residential yield by adding 11.7 acres from the Corporate Office designated area. 2 3. Construction of the shared use path is a requirement of the zoning ordinance. Explanation: Horner’s Run shared use path is a key element of the site. The Rockwood Special Focus Area Plan added this path to the county-wide bike and trail plan. Also, without the paved shared-use trail, the amenity area cannot be counted as amenity area. For both these reasons, construction is required by the zoning ordinance during development. It is the only benefit provided to the adjacent existing residents impacted by this development and a key amenity for the new residents. The concept plan also needs to be updated to show the shared use path separated from the westernmost townhouse road where it shows up disconnected. It also needs a sidewalk extension along Oxbridge Drive to reach a safe crossing to Oxbridge Shopping Center. 4. Whenever we grant exceptions, it is important to maintain consistency so as not to appear arbitrary and to determine if exceptions warrant an eventual change in the zoning ordinance. Explanation: If an exception is implemented consistently by the county over time and deemed acceptable, then staff will prepare an ordinance amendment to consider if the exception should become a new standard. In this zoning request, the county seeks consistency in the number and placement of 16-foot-wide townhomes. The staff’s request to integrate 16-foot-wide units with wider units should be addressed and not ignored. 5. The concept plan fails to address sufficient visitor parking. Explanation: The zoning ordinance requires at least one (1) visitor parking space for each five units. However, this site needs more visitor parking because all units have street- facing garages (no alleys) which limits on-street parking, and 25% of the units are 16 feet wide which increases the density along each street and prevents the ability to have double-loaded parking in front of those units. Any development that uses 16-foot-wide townhouse units should increase the visitor parking provided. 6. Public safety on this site needs to be protected with sufficiently wide streets. Explanation: It is unclear what street widths are proposed. Residents and visitors will park wherever they can along each of the streets. The increased need for on-street parking for higher density townhome developments requires a minimum of a 29-foot- wide street cross-section with street trees and sidewalks within the right of way. This uses the VDOT standard 54-foot-wide street right of way. If the plan has not ensured this minimum is in place, then the Commission and Board will create a public safety issue due to on-street parking blocking emergency equipment traveling to a location within the development. The Fire and Emergency Medical Services Department is only beginning to learn how difficult these higher density townhome developments can be to gain access. They may prefer a 32-foot-wide street cross-section as the 29-foot-wide cross-section is bare minimum for this density. 7. Public safety needs to be protected with common area at the rear of lots. Explanation: The purpose of common area at the end of each group of units and around the rear of the lots is for public safety. Attached units cause the need to reach residents by a rear entry if a fire occurs at the front of a house. 3 8. An exception is needed to the ordinance requirement in Table 19.1-111.A.E. Note 4. Explanation: The concept plan shows the majority of the building groups as seven units long. This section of the ordinance requires “the number of lots in each group of attached lots shall be varied throughout the subdivision”. Building mixes of 4-7 units creates more visual interest along the streetscape and adds more open space. 9. No allowance should be made for sidewalks to be privately maintained. Explanation: All sidewalks along public streets need to be within the right of way and maintained by VDOT. This is standard practice and ensures the length of the driveway to the townhouse garage will be of sufficient length (20 feet) to keep the car out of the sidewalk. 10. All pedestrian paths should be paved with asphalt. Explanation: The developer suggests it is okay to put the sidewalk maintenance burden on the homeowners yet argues that pedestrian paths should be allowed to be a natural material so as not to burden the homeowners. However, asphalt paths are maintenance- free for at least 10 years and often much longer. It is far more difficult for an HOA to maintain natural paths, and natural paths cannot be used adequately by residents walking strollers, riding bikes, or walking in inclement weather. 11. Sidewalks along all roads need to be continuous. Explanation: Failure to connect sidewalks is one of the main complaints of residents in their communities. The sidewalks need to connect along the East/West collector street. 12. Buffers are inadequate on this project. Explanation: Despite intensifying the development considerably through exceptions, the county has not sought any increased benefit to adjacent residents. The county can impose additional buffer requirements as deemed appropriate. The buffer adjacent to the Falling Creek Farms is not proffered by the applicant to be wider or denser in vegetation than the minimum ordinance requirement. Instead of 1.5 times Perimeter Landscape C, the Commission should at least impose a condition of 2.5 times Perimeter Landscape C adjacent to Falling Creek Farms. Similar to Genito Towns in Clover Hill, the buffer could include a 6-foot-high fence to provide additional separation from the Falling Creek Farms community. 13. The conceptual elevation does not reflect the proffered requirements nor the size of the typical building. Explanation: The elevation shows a flat façade and a continuous roof line. This is confusing to the case as the requirement is for each unit to have a 2-foot offset from adjacent units. This would reflect an offset through the roof line. Also, most buildings in this development are shown to be 7 units so the conceptual elevation should reflect the predominant building design. 14. Despite extensive ordinance exceptions being requested in this case, the applicant has not submitted any proffers above what the development community naturally includes on a townhome development or that staff could not effectively require through administrative review of the plans using ordinance requirements. Explanation: The county has created a mirage of improved quality through the zoning process. This project reduces the quality of townhome development by current county 4 standards. The proposal ignores the Comprehensive Plan land use recommendation. The design of the townhomes in the Corporate Office area is of little quality and does not apply an appropriate buffer adjacent to one of the busiest arterial streets in the county. The amenities overall are reduced in quality. The Watermark and Silverleaf developments within the Dale Magisterial District resolved many of these design issues with rear alleys. Both of these developments provide affordable homes at a high density with significant amenities. At least half of the units in this development could have alley access. Case 22SN0155 – Benton Woods The applicant is getting tremendous value out of this land with lots being reduced from 12,000 s.f. down to as low as 3500 square feet. The zoning ordinance is very clear in Sec. 19.1- 12.B.2. In granting development standards exceptions, consideration shall be given as to whether the exceptions are solely for the purpose of promoting an integrated plan no less beneficial to the occupants of the development and area property than would be obtained under this chapter's development regulations. Surrounding area property owners will be negatively impacted by this small lot development as opposed to a standard lot development. It will cause far more traffic, nearly a complete loss of forested vegetation, and a character of wall-to-wall housing wedged into this property. The only offset to these impacts is for the project to be of the highest visual quality possible. My comments below help address this. For the future occupants of this development, the higher density can be further addressed by having effective amenities as residents will have little room for any on their small lots and adding a segment of affordable homes. My comments below also address these issues. 1. The conceptual plan does not provide for adequate Strategic Amenity Area. Explanation: The southern triangular area is hidden and wedged between lots and sits over a Commonwealth Gas Line easement. This area is best left undisturbed in its current forested condition and used as part of the forested trail area. Little forested area in this project is shown to remain. The small dog park, again hidden and wedged behind 4 lots, is inappropriate given the small lot size and houses so close to it. The most strategic area for an amenity is to have those four lots turned into a visible play area (not hidden) in combination with the associated dog park. Parents with children and dogs can all be together and be adjacent to the wooded area and trail. This meets the intent of what should serve as a Strategic Amenity Area. 2. The case needs to clarify the road widths to ensure public safety. Explanation: Roads need to use the minimum 54 foot wide right of way that includes a 29 foot pavement width in the street. Any less width will cause blockages from on street 5 parking. The concept plan seems to show this but no dimension is shown for the width of the street right of ways. The Fire Department has been slow to address this, but during construction the work trucks and construction debris bins are too wide for even the 29- foot street width and often block the streets until all the houses are built. They may eventually realize that a 32-foot-wide street width is far better at protecting public health and safety when we have a small lot size like 3500 square feet. On-street parking becomes a necessity with short driveways. 3. Per Proffer 6.b. Streetscape, a sentence should be added to provide for a more complete streetscape. Explanation: An additional sentence at the end of the proffer should read, "Storm drainage and utilities shall be located as effectively as possible to provide for the street tree plantings as shown on the conceptual plan." Otherwise, it is easy to cause the removal of many street trees because the engineer did not bother to consider how drainage and utilities can be routed to provide for tree plantings. 4. Per Proffer 7.g. Garages, this “standard” proffer on quality needs a simple word change. Explanation: Some builders have argued that hinge straps and matching door handles should count as two upgrades. While I managed Plans Review, I disagreed and said these hardware elements were to act as one upgrade as "ornamental hardware". It would be better to start getting this proffer to reference "ornamental hardware" rather than just hinge straps. 5. Per Proffer 8.c. Other amenities. This proffer does not offer anything. Explanation: Unless the applicant is willing to commit to some of these features, then this is wasted text that makes future homeowners angry that the developer did not provide any of these features. We find that marketers take the same language and add it to documents that potential buyers see. The county needs to remove such language unless the developer commits to some degree of implementation. 6. Per Proffer 8.d., there is no value for new residents unless the trail system is paved. Explanation: A trail needs to be 5 feet wide and be asphalt. The argument that a paved trail will be costly to maintain is not valid. The residents will constantly struggle with maintaining an unpaved trail and would likely not use it. A paved trail will last at least 10-15 years before possibly needing some repaving. That is what their HOA dues are meant to cover, but once it is done it is maintenance free and highly usable for another 10-15 years. If EE does not accept the paved trail, then the applicant will not have enough acreage in their amenity area. 7. The loss of natural tree cover on this site will be highly impactful to surrounding property owners. Explanation: Per Proffer 9. Tree Preservation, the tree preservation strip and all other areas shown on the Conceptual Plan as forested should remain fully forested except for drainage and utilities that generally cross in a perpendicular manner. Do not allow the removal of understory trees as is suggested by the current proffer. Leave the forested character intact and do not allow grading within it except for the perpendicular crossings. 6 8. There is no abiding reason for reducing lot sizes except to achieve affordability. This is not addressed with this application. Explanation: My last comment relates to the Comp Plan and one of the abiding purposes of the zoning ordinance (Sec. 19.1.1 - 10th bullet) which I copied below: Promote the creation and preservation of affordable housing suitable for meeting the current and future needs of the county as well as a reasonable proportion of the current and future needs of the planning districts within which the county is situated; When the county is supporting a huge reduction in development standards to the zoning ordinance to provide additional housing, the developer needs to offer a small percentage, say 10-15%, of the housing as affordable housing. Otherwise, the CUPD request does not integrate any value at all into the needs of the community. Not as in subsidized housing but as the segment of homes that can be purchased by teachers, nurses, and other common professions that are currently squeezed out of the 1800 sf - 2800 sf market with a garage. The segment that is sorely needed is the 1000-1600 s.f. home without a garage that a young couple could afford. I will continue to ask the county to consider incentivizing this segment of affordable homes by waiving the cash proffer and utility connection fees for affordable homes under $300,000 purchased by first time homebuyers, thereby reducing the cost by $20,000. This waiver of fees is fully supported by State Code 15.2-2305.1. A CUPD acts as the zoning ordinance for a development which further aligns with the language of the State Code. Authority Provided to the Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors by the Zoning Ordinance: Explanation: You are not obligated to approve these requests. You have tremendous authority to uphold the Comprehensive Plan and zoning ordinance. The most important section of the zoning ordinance that protects your authority is Sec. 19.1-12. The portions highlighted below address the issues with the two cases before you this month. Over the past four years, this section of the ordinance has been ignored by the county in all staff reports involving a Conditional Use Planned Development (CUPD). Neither of these staff reports in your packet for April adequately address this requirement. It is clear that a recommendation for approval will be forthcoming from the Planning Department regardless of how many staff comments remain unaddressed. Sec. 19.1-12. Conditional Use Planned Developments. A. Generally. Planned developments are of such substantially different character from other conditional uses that specific and additional standards and exceptions are necessary. A conditional use planned development may be authorized for either a limited or an indefinite time period and may be revoked by the board of supervisors at any time, after notice and a hearing, for failure to adhere to the stipulated conditions. 7 B. Use and Development Standards Exceptions. In the case of planned developments, the planning commission may recommend, and the board of supervisors may authorize, specific uses not permitted in the district or exceptions to development standards. 1. Use Exceptions. a. Considerations for Granting Use Exceptions. In granting use exceptions, the following shall be considered: • the exceptions are necessary, desirable and appropriate with respect to the primary purpose of the development; and • the exceptions are not of such a nature or located so as to have a detrimental influence on the area. b. Limitations. Use exceptions shall only be granted on a maximum of 30 percent of the gross acreage of a total project unless the use is not specifically enumerated in this chapter as permitted by right, with restrictions, with conditional use, or with special exception in any district excluding those uses which may be specifically prohibited. 2. Regulation Exceptions. a. Considerations for Granting Regulation Exceptions. In granting development standards exceptions, consideration shall be given as to whether the exceptions are solely for the purpose of promoting an integrated plan no less beneficial to the occupants of the development and area property than would be obtained under this chapter's development regulations. b. Lot Area Reductions. The minimum lot area requirements may be decreased without limitation, provided that at least 50 percent of the land area being reduced within the individual lot is dedicated as common area within the development. A minimum of 30 percent of this required common area must be conveniently located within the development and not located along the perimeter of the development, and shall be identified as “strategic common area”. 3. Conditions and Guarantees. Conditions and restrictions may be imposed on the use, operation, establishment, location and construction as necessary to protect the public interest and secure compliance with the guidelines. In addition, a guarantee or bond may be required to ensure that conditions are satisfied. Reasonable guarantees shall be provided that required common area will always remain available and be reasonably maintained. A CUPD is a serious matter! You are being asked by the development community to undermine the standards of the zoning ordinance which our citizens rely upon for minimum standards of quality. On every zoning case, Planning staff should be educating you on what makes a CUPD appropriate and necessary versus abiding by the zoning ordinance. It should not be focused on goals to achieve density or to make it affordable. It must be of a “substantially different character from other conditional uses that specific and additional standards and exceptions are 8 necessary.” The staff report should also clearly explain how “the exceptions are solely for the purpose of promoting an integrated plan no less beneficial to the occupants of the development and area property than would be obtained under this chapter's development regulations.” These two statements from the zoning ordinance relating to CUPD’s seek to achieve unique, beneficial designs that integrate the land use in a way that is at least equal to the quality and standards of the zoning ordinance even while some exceptions are granted. This was done exceptionally well with Chester Village Green, Brandermill, Winterfield Crossing and Winterfield Park, and to a great degree at Watermark, Silverleaf, Wynwood, and Lower Magnolia Green developments. In my 40-year career, I have sought the highest quality for the built environment that can be achieved. Proper planning is like measuring in carpentry. Measure the space and the board that goes in it 2-3 times so you don’t waste another board. Make sure the zoning case and the construction plans for a new development are written and designed properly since it will become the structure of our community long past our lifetimes. Deferring these two cases to get the designs, conditions, and proffers to build a strong and resilient community is the greatest benefit the Planning Commission can offer our county. Thank you for considering the information I have provided. Best regards, Greg E. Allen – Community Advocate Some people who received this message don't often get email from dimess65@gmail.com. Learn why this is important From: Diane Messenger To: Ramsey, Ryan Subject: Re: Proposed Rockwood Grove 22SN0147 Date: Wednesday, June 14, 2023 4:20:42 PM You don't often get email from dimess65@gmail.com. Learn why this is important CAUTION: External Email Hello Mr. Ramsey, Yes sir, You may put the letter on record. Thank you! On Wed, Jun 14, 2023 at 3:52 PM Ramsey, Ryan <RamseyRP@chesterfield.gov> wrote: Hi Mrs. Messenger, Thank you for your message. I will place your message below as a letter of opposition to the zoning application request in the digital case file. Please advise if you do not want this message on the record and I will not proceed to add it to the case file. Otherwise, this message will be shared with the Planning Commission prior to the public hearing (once a public hearing is scheduled for the request). If you have any questions on the zoning request or process, please let me know. Thank you and best regards, Ryan Ramsey, AICP || Planning Administrator || Chesterfield County Planning Department || (804) 751-4474 (O) From: Diane Messenger <dimess65@gmail.com > Sent: Tuesday, June 13, 2023 9:48 AM To: Holland, James <HollandJ@chesterfield.gov>; Ramsey, Ryan <RamseyRP@chesterfield.gov> Subject: Proposed Rockwood Grove 22SN0147 CAUTION: External Email Dear Sirs, Reference subject above, I implore you to disapprove this proposed development. I live at 3900 Oxbridge Rd , N Chesterfield VA 23236 and the last thing we need near our Mayfair Estates neighborhood is the time of development proposed for our area. The best use of that property would be single family homes. It should be in the best interests of the county to have quality neighborhoods and not quantity. I recommend keeping the rift raft on the northern/eastern side of Chippenham Parkway. It’s no secret that to residents in Chesterfield county that that is the “other side of the tracks” for both Hull St Rd and Midlothian Turnpike. Let’s keep it that way. Build quality single family homes if you build anything at all. Add to the value of the Bexley and Mayfair Estates neighborhoods. If you are intent on building, choose homes in the price range of $400k-500k for single family use. The proposed plan as of now will increase traffic exponentially! Both vehicular and pedestrian. Hull St. Rd is not an ideal road for pedestrian traffic as proven by all the accidents and pedestrian who have been hit and died. Look at the statistics. Let’s keep Chesterfield County as it is or improve it. I can say with great certainty that along with the county’s proposal that the next thing to rear it’s head will be GRTC buses coming into our county. We don’t want or need that!! With your proposal you will only drive people of middle income farther west into Amelia or other counties altogether. We need quality neighborhoods! Not quantity of residents in an area prone to decreasing in value and crime. Speaking of which, just last night there was a break-in of cars in Mayfair Estates. Check the police report. We don’t need more of this! Thank you for your thoughtful consideration. V/r, Mrs. E.D.W. Messenger June 1, 2023 James Holland Supervisor, Dale District Ryan Ramsey Planning Administrator Re: Rezoning Request 22SN0147 Community Mee�ng Sign #451 Rockwood Grove Messrs. Holland and Ramsey, Jim, I was glad to see you at LaPrade Library on May 17. I thought you would be there. Thank you for atending. Ryan, I was hoping I would be able to introduce myself to you at the May 17 mee�ng at LaPrade Library. I have serious concerns about the proposed Rockwood Grove. Residences on the east side of the proposed Rockwood Grove development have a density of 4 or 5 per acre. The proposed development would have a density of 12 to 13 residences per acre. This seems like a very large increase in housing density. This development could add 700 or more vehicles to morning and evening traffic on Hull St. Rd. We were told that roads and traffic conges�on were VDOT’s responsibility. As I understand the process, VDOT has a budget to allocate to all Virginia ci�es and coun�es for road improvements. Then each locality decides how the funds will be spent. Thus, I believe that road improvements take place long a�er the conges�on develops. In the mean�me, residents in the area will have to live with the increased traffic. In this area, a lot of commuters want to go west on Hull St. Rd. to reach the Powhite Parkway or 288. We were told that VDOT recommends a right turn and then a U-turn instead of trying to make a le� turn onto Hull St. Rd. East of Oxbridge Road, there are le� turn / U-turn lanes 500 feet to the east, at the Amberleigh Blvd. & Lynchester Dr. crossover and at the Gregory Pond Rd. & Fordham Rd. traffic signal. These le� turn lanes are not very long. I worry about the hazard when drivers wai�ng to make a U-turn at these le� turn lanes back up onto the traffic lane, at best, slowing eastbound traffic, at worst crea�ng the risk of a rearend collision. On a number of occasions, I have been unable to make a right turn on red from Oxbridge Rd. onto 360 East due to the heavy volume of eastbound traffic, or because a truck or SUV in the le� turn lane has prevented me from seeing oncoming traffic. At �mes, drivers wai�ng to turn le� from Oxbridge Rd. cannot make it through the green light during the first cycle. I would like to see the two mul�story apartment buildings facing Hull St. Rd. replaced with townhouses so that 100 to 150 fewer residences are constructed in Rockwood Grove. Thank you for your efforts in this mater. Michael Trancynger 4419 Oxbridge Rd. April 16, 2024 CPC Online Form Citizen Comments and Emails received as of 5 p.m. on 4/15/2024 Charlie Gilmer23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Hello. I live on Westwood Street, across from the woods that would be the entrance to this Agrihood. Hadn't said anything because I figured nothing I could do to stop it, and my real objection was just that I like having vacant woods across the street. A neighbor told me the people in the houses on that side of Westwood, ie their backs to the project, hadn't shown any interest. I always figured that area being developed was inevitable. Is it a done deal now? Thanks. Btw The community meetings were always during my work hours, so couldn't go. Continued on page 2 Amber Steel23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Dear Planning Commissioner Sloan, Supervisor Ingle, and Planning Committee members, Thanks, Regarding: 23SN0043 Amber Steel I voice my full and enthusiastic support for Bensley Agrihood. As a Chesterfield Extension Master Gardener and previous volunteer at Sankofa Orchard, I'm familiar with Duron's extensive and impactful work in the Richmond community. His innovative projects address pressing issues around food insecurity, food deserts, and health inequalities. Bensley Agrihood expands on these missions with affordable housing and job training for the next generation of farmers and horticulturalists. Duron is building momentum in putting RVA on the map for sustainable urban agriculture and the local food movement. I'm excited to see where this goes and hope you approve the project to move forward. Meghan Gough23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Good morning, This entrepreneurial concept is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan (2019), designed to support a growing and evolving community. The innovative nature of the Bensley Agrihood will bring great attention to the Route 1 Corridor and continue revitalization efforts in this area that are critical for Chesterfield County. Moreover, because the Bensley Agrihood project pairs affordable housing and urban agriculture, this project will help support the community and address critical challenges with housing stability and food insecurity. A decision to support this proposal will act to strengthen the overall health and wellbeing of the County. I am a resident of Chesterfield County and I would like to express my strong support for the Bensley Agrihood proposal. Sincerely, Meghan Gough Continued Margaret Rittenhouse, LCSW 23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Dear Planning Commissioner Sloan, Supervisor Ingle, and other planning commission members, Thank you for your time and consider I have seen the hard work done by these groups, and I'm excited to see it move forward. It will be the right thing for us to do as Chesterfield County in support of environmental Justice, and will be the first Community Land Trust in the Commonwealth of Virginia. Margaret Rittenhouse, LCSW I am writing to share my wholehearted support for the Bensley Agrihood project, led by Duron Chavis from Happily Natural Day, Girls For a Change, and the Maggie Walker Community Land Trust. I ask you to approve their rezoning request (case number 23SN0043). Their vision is amazing and I would love to see this project be an example of how we can bring affordable housing, farm, fresh food, and job training to our vibrant community. Respectfully Midlothian Jennifer Einolf23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Hello, I am a resident of Chesterfield county and I want to express my enthusiastic support for the Bensley Agrihood project. I encourage you to facilitate the necessary rezoning. This project impacts our citizens, our future and the profile of Chesterfield County as a place where citizen-forward, innovative solutions benefit everyone. Thank you for your consideration. Jennifer Einolf Continued Mollee Sullivan23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Dear Planning Commissioner Sloan, Supervisor Ingle and other Planning Commission members, I am writing today to express my support for the Bensley Agrihood project led by The Happily Natural Day, Girls For a Change and the Maggie Walker Community Land Trust, and to ask you to approve their rezoning request (Case No. 23SN0043). I've been following this project for years and am excited to see it moving forward, since it will be a huge step for environmental justice in Chesterfield County, and it will be the first Community Land Trust (CLT) in the commonwealth of Virginia. Warmly, This project could serve as a model for how we can bring more desperately needed affordable housing, along with farm-fresh food access and job training, to our rapidly growing community. Thank you for your service and for your time and consideration. Mollee Sullivan Clover Hill Dr. Leni Sorensen23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Over the past 4 years I have followed the practical and community work done by these groups. I am excited to see such an ambitious move forward with the Bensley Agrihood project. Such projects accrue to the benefit of any locale and certainly will be in Chesterfield County, particularly in support of environmental justice. And I am told it will be the first Community Land Trust in the Commonwealth of Virginia. What a win- win! I am a historian, a teacher of rural skills, and a gardener who, although I live in Albemarle County, drives to RVA to donate time to several of the community garden/urban farming projects organized by Happily Natural Day. In 2023 I gave a workshop at Sankofa Orchard on Home Canning and on Raising Chickens for Eggs. Thank you for your time and consideration, Respectfully Today I want to express my wholehearted support for the Bensley Agrihood project, led by Duron Chavis from Happily Natural Day, Girls For a Change, and the Maggie Walker Community Land Trust. Please approve their rezoning request (case number 23SN0043). Dear Planning Commissioner Sloan, Supervisor Ingle, and other planning commission members, Dr. Leni Sorensen This visionary project is an example of how dedicated and skilled people can join together to bring farm fresh food, and job training to their vibrant community. I am writing to provide my support for the Bensley Agrihood Project in North Chesterfield County, with support for Mr. Duron Chavis and his role in this important project. Attached is a formal letter of support put forward from my position as Professor and Director for the Center for Food Systems and Community Transformation in the College of Agriculture and Life Sciences at Virginia Tech. Please do not hesitate to reach out to me if you have any questions. Thank you, Kim Niewolny Dr. Mr. Gibb and Mr. Ingle Kim Niewolny23SN0043 - Bensley Agrihood Continued Bonnie JohnsonComment on comprehensive plan amendments I disagree with the plan whole heartedly. We have enough apartments and enough traffic. Clover Hill Alyssa RoyerComment on comprehensive plan amendments I protest any rezoning for, or building of, apartments and/or condos next to falling creek farms or anywhere on hull street without the building of schools and roads to support the influx of people. Build the support system FIRST. Don't try to bandaid the mistake after. Mark Longo22SN0147 - Rockwood Grove Totally 100. % AGAINST this project !!!! All adjoining neighborhoods are single family average of 1 acre or more lots. Most are brick houses. 35 acres is enough for about 35 brick homes. Don NOT want Paulette Road connected to Oxbridge Shopping Center. We have too many speeding issues as it is. These will turn into mostly rental which will decrease owner pride in keeping the area safe and clean. We are Chesterfield County NOT Richmond City and we never wanted or will want to be like Richmond City! Stop this travesty NOW ! Continued Dale Jamie Carson22SN0147 - Rockwood Grove I am vehemently opposed to the Rockwood Grove proposal for a variety of reasons. Not only is there not sufficient infrastructure to support this project, but it is not necessary. For whatever reason ( and I'm sure it's money) there is no need for another apartment/ townhome complex. Even more vexing is that while residents appraisals continue to rise, apartments/townhome's assessments have been lowered. While I'm sure this is an additional perk for developers, it is very unfair for the residents that have to continually cope with excess development and traffic. When we moved tho Chesterfield there were many mitigating factors. Top on the list was to escape the hustle and bustle of high density areas and enjoy exemplary schools and police . Since the mad rush to develop every piece of dirt, schools have suffered drastically due to overcrowding, police, fire and rescue is stretched to the limit and traffic is a nightmare. A month or so ago I read an embarrassing headline— paraphrasing- if your vehicle has expired tags don't leave Chesterfield. Not a winning endorsement for our once fair county. Last month the county posted on Facebook how “ green “ they were because they planted a few trees and bushes. Not sure I would have made that statement considering the amount of green space you are destroying. I implore you to listen to the people and deny this project and take a long look at the amount of development that you are allowing in the county. The developers are the only people that are for this development. We the residents are not . Michael Foy22SN0147 - Rockwood Grove Dear Members of the Chesterfield Planning Board: My wife and I are 34 plus year residents of Chesterfield. 23 year residents of Falling Creek Farms. The current plan for Rock Grove is entirely unsuitable for the plat between the Mayfair and Falling Creek neighborhoods. Zoning for the area under scrutiny should be Single Family Dwellings, individual, separate houses. Such a plan would not meet any opposition from owners in either neighborhood or from the County at large. Any density of dwelling other than houses, is inconsistent with the zoning and development of these older neighborhoods. Objections: traffic congestion from increased population density and connecting thru road, damage to property values, potential for higher crime, destruction of forest and habitat, increasing student population and class size in nearby CCPS, drastically altering neighborhood suburban archtitecture, and current zoning and lifestyle, and arborscape. Rock Grove will permanently alter this area, as it is more an Urban plan and not a suburban, pastoral plan. The two neighborhoods bordering Rock Grove will lose their current desirability. Houses are only on the market for less than a week, and sell higher than assesed and often market value, profiting owners in equity, resale, and tax deduction. The County receives higher revenues than could be expected from similar neighborhoods. This will end with Rock Grove approval. There will be an exodus of established home owners, and not just to other areas of the county, taking their discretionary income and taxes out of area. We ask the Board to vote down the current plan and insist Rock Grove be zoned and plotted for less dense, appropriate single family housing. Thank You for your consideration. Michael Charles Foy Continued Dale Roxanna Payne22SN0147 - Rockwood Grove I am opposed to the new community being planned. I feel this area of Hull Street Road is already saturated with enough housing. Heavy traffic is already an issue getting into and out of our neighborhood. I am also opposed to the Paulette Road being extended to Oxbridge Road. For the same reasons. We do not need more traffic flowing through to our neighborhood. There is also the concern with the impact on the schools in our jurisdiction. I know your information states certain statistics. But from what we are hearing from other parents, those statistics are not correct. Schools are overcrowded now. Submission Date Ci�zen First Name Ci�zen Last Name Case #/Name Comments Other Informa�on Provided 4/15/24 Ellen Hill 23SN0043 Yes, I want to submit my opposi�on to approval of the Bensley Agrihood proposal that's going to the Planning Commission on Tuesday, April 16th. The number is 23SN0043. My name is Ellen Hill my phone number is [redacted]. I'm not sure which magisterial district we are but I live in the Bensley neighborhood and I do not trust the organiza�on submi�ng this proposal. They keep changing what they plan to do and are not addressing the concerns of the community. I do not think this project would be beneficial to our community. The Brnsley neighborhood was developed in 1909 as one of the first planned villages in the area. It has several historic homes (including the one in this planning request. (Swineford House had one of he few remaining Gillette gardens in the state.) The Route One Assoc.(formerly the JDA) has worked since 1991 trying to improve the Rt. 1 corridor (Historic Rt. 1). The JDA developed the first incubator in Richmond (BizWorks) and improved conditions in the trailer parks in the area. It seems that all of the intended uses of the Agrihood project will be counteractive to all of the improvements we have made and the Bensley Village area will no longer be considered a Historic Village. Even though I no longer live in the area, I grew up there and my heart is still there. I would hate to see all of the work done by our ancestors (Volunteer Fire Dept, Volunteer Rescue Squad and the beginning of the Bensley Community House for example changed into something that is certainly not compatible to the area. From: To: Planning, E-Mail Subject: comment for planning commission meeting for 4/16/2024 Date: Sunday, April 14, 2024 8:02:16 PM [You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ] CAUTION: External Email I am unable to attend the meeting scheduled for 4/16/24 concerning the proposal on Swinfeord Road in the Bermuda district re: the zoning for the Agrihood. I would like to go on record as being unable to cast a vote for or against the proposal. To my knowledge, the plans for the Agrihood have been changed three times, leaving me unsure of what I would be voting for to be built in my neighborhood. Thank you, Name: JamieSeagravesTitle: GrantsManagerDepartment: External Affairs Capital OneServices, LLC15000Capital OneDriveRichmond, VA23238 123.456.7890123.456.7890Faxcapitalone.com February15,2024 Mr.GibSloanViceChairmanChesterfieldPlanningCommission9800GovernmentCenterPkwyChesterfield,VA23832 DearViceChairSloan: IamwritingonbehalfofCapitalOnetosupporttheBensleyAgrihoodrezoningcase23SN0043,locatedat2600SwinefordRoad.CapitalOneisastrongsupporterofTheMaggieWalkerCommunityLandTrust(MWCLT),theleadapplicantforthisinnovativedevelopment. WebelieveaffordablehousingdevelopmentsliketheBensleyAgrihoodimproveopportunityandfinancialwell-beingforunderservedcommunitiesandresidentswhoarepricedoutofthehousingmarket. WewerepleasedtolearntheCountystaffreportrecommendsapprovingtheapplicationandwehopethePlanningCommissionwillconcur. Thankyouforyourconsideration. Sincerely, JamieSeagravesGrantsManager,CommunityImpactandInvestment Additionally, the Bensley Agrihood Project aligns with the food system education goals of the Virginia Tech Center for Food Systems and Community Transformation. I am confident that Mr. Chavis has the knowledge, skills, and enthusiasm to succeed in this project. My team and I remain available to consult with and provide educational assistance to support Mr. Chavis and other partners involved with the project as needed. In closing, I wish to reiterate my full support for Bensley Agrihood Project. Thank you for your time and consideration of the project and its many positive impacts. Please do not hesitate to reach out to me if you have any questions. Sincerely, Kim L. Niewolny, PhD {01616943;v1} Stream Realty Acquisition, L.L.C. 2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 400 Dallas, TX 75201 Attn: Albert Jarrell Re: Ruffin Mill Project, Chesterfield County, VA Dear Mr. Jarrell: I am writing this letter in support for this project as an active member of the Richmond MSA industrial real estate market. Having advised on over $1.5 billion worth of projects in the region over the last 18yr, I can attest to the importance of such projects like Stream’s that will continue to diversify the local economy and support regional job growth and economic prosperity. Recent years have shown the significance of the supply chain and the need for commercial/industrial space to accommodate goods moving through the state and region. Now more than ever, national and global business are looking for supply chain diversification, and our region gets a lot of attention given the geographic location and proximity to Port of Virginia terminals. With historic low vacancies for the last 6yrs, this project can help our region meet that demand and allow the County and region to continue to prosper. I appreciate your consideration and am glad to answer any questions if needed. Thank you. Regards, Matt Anderson, SIOR Executive Vice President, Range Commercial Partners, Inc. MATT ANDERSON EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT D: 804.240.8833 manderson@rangecommercial.com

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.