RecordWell Data

Denial

City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake

This document is no longer listed on City of Chesapeake's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 1 Staff Report Version October 28, 2026 Proposal A conditional use permit to construct a relocated billboard sign. Location 3277 Western Branch Boulevard Tax Parcel 0051001000001 Applicant Adams Outdoor Advertising Planning Area Western Branch Owner Kuber Suraj Donuts Corporation Planning Commission Hearing Date November 12, 2026 Agency Williams Mullen Staff Planner Love Ott Name Western Branch Billboard Application Number PLN-USE-2026-020 Staff Recommendation Denial PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 2 Preliminary Site Plan (PSP) PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 3 Project Proposal The applicant requests a conditional use permit to construct as per the City billboard relocation regulations, a two-sided light-emitting diode (LED) billboard sign at 3277 Western Branch Boulevard, near the intersection with Collins Boulevard. The subject property is zoned B-2, General Business District, and is located within the Suburban Overlay District. Section 14 -706 of the Chesapeake Zoning Ordinance (CZO) establishes conditions and standards for billboard signs, including provisions allowing City Council to modify the prescribed standards. The applicant requests the following reductions: • A reduction in the required setback from Western Branch Boulevard from thirty-eight and one-half (38.5) feet to thirty-seven and four-tenths (37.4) feet. • A reduction in the required setback from Collins Boulevard from thirty-eight and one-half (38.5) feet to thirty-three and four-tenths (33.4) feet. Elevation Project Proposal and Background PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 4 • A reduction in the required separation from the existing building on the subject property from thirty- eight and one-half (38.5) feet to nine (9) feet. • A reduction in the required distance from property zoned or used for residential purposes from three hundred (300) feet to approximately one hundred eighty-seven (187) feet. The proposed billboard would be supported by a monopole and measure thirty-five ( 35) feet in height. Each digital face would measure ten (10) feet by thirty (30) feet, for a sign area of three hundred (300) square feet per face. The proposed height and sign area meet the maximum standards established by Section 14 -706 of the CZO. The preliminary site plan states that no existing billboards are located within one thousand (1,000) feet of the proposed location and depicts landscaping along Western Branch Boulevard and Collins Boulevard. The applicant has submitted a lighting analysis prepared by Media Resources Inc. describing the proposed SITELINE display technology. According to the analysis, the displays would incorporate directional baffles to restrict light emission toward nearby light -sensitive areas and automatic brightness controls that adjust illumination in response to ambient light conditions. The manufacturer indicates that on-site measurements could be provided following installation to verify lighting performance. Background The applicant seeks to relocate a billboard previously located at 900 Battlefield Boulevard North. A notice dated October 17, 2024, issued by the property owner’s attorney, advised Adams Outdoor Advertising that the lease would terminate effective December 31, 2024, and directed the applicant to remove its billboard from the premises. Section 14-706.B.3 of the CZO allows qualifying involuntarily removed billboards to be relocated to another property, subject to conditional use permit approval and applicable criteria. The applicant requests approval to relocate the billboard to 3277 Wes tern Branch Boulevard, with modifications to the required setbacks and residential separation. A text amendment approved in January 2026 allows City Council to modify the design standards applicable to qualifying relocated billboards. PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 5 Comprehensive Plan Analysis The subject property is located within the Western Branch Planning Area, Suburban Overlay District, and Community/Regional Commercial Character District. The 2045 Comprehensive Plan envisions the Suburban Overlay District as primarily-low-and mid-scale neighborhoods with commercial corridors along major roads. The Community/Regional Commercial Character District em phasizes commercial destinations that attract residents and visitors, with larger developments incorporating unique public spaces. The Comprehensive Plan envisions these areas evolving to look and function more like traditional pedestrian-focused main streets. The proposed billboard would introduce a prominent digital structure that does not advance these placemaking objectives and raises compatibility concerns regarding the established character of the Western Branch Boulevard corridor. Relevant policies considered: DES 14 & DES 23 There currently is no approved small area plan that provides more specific recommendations for this property; however, the Western Branch Area Plan is underway. • Connectivity and Infrastructure The applicant requests reductions in the required billboard setbacks from Western Branch Boulevard from 38.5 feet to 37.4 feet, Collins Boulevard from 38.5 feet to 33.4 feet, and the existing building from 38.5 feet to 9 feet. These reductions would place the structure closer to the adjoining rights-of-way and existing building. Its placement should maintain safe vehicle circulation, pedestrian access, and visibility within the site and at the intersection. Relevant policies considered: CON 16 & DES 36 • Economic Prosperity The Community/Regional Commercial Character District supports commercial development that attracts customers and cont ributes to the City’s economic vitality. Although the billboard would provide advertising opportunities for businesses, it would not directly expand the existing business or provide additional commercial services on the property. Its location and long -term presence should also be considered in relation to future redevelopment opportunities and the overall attractiveness of the commercial corridor. Relevant policies considered: ECON 1 & ECON 5 • Placemaking and Design Policy DES 14 promotes high -quality non -residential development, particularly in highly visible locations and near residential neighborhoods. The proposed billboard would be thirty-five (35) feet tall, with two three-hundred-square-foot (300) digital sign faces. Although these dimensions meet the applicable billboard standards, the structure ’s height, scale, and visual prominence raise compatibility concerns, particularly given the requested reduction in residential separation from three hundred (300) feet to approximately one hundred eighty -seven (187) feet. In addition, an Staff Analysis PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 6 existing monopole sign on the property will remain, and the addition of the proposed digital billboard would contribute to sign clutter on the parcel, further increasing the visual impact on surrounding properties and the streetscape. Policies DES 25 and DES 37 encourage screening, buffering, and vegetation to mitigate incompatible uses and improve parking lot env ironments. The preliminary site plan depicts small crape myrtles near the billboard and existing shrubs. Enhanced landscaping around the structure and throughout the parking lot, where feasible , could improve visual compatibility. However, ground-level landscaping would provide limited screening of the elevated digital displays. Relevant policies considered: DES 14, DES 25, and DES 27 • Quality of Life The applicant’s lighting analysis indicates that the proposed SITELINE technology would incorporate directional baffles and automatic brightness controls to limit light emission toward nearby light -sensitive areas. These features may reduce lighting impacts on surrounding properties; however, they do not address the billboard’s overall visual promin ence. The reduced residential separation remains a concern when considering the potential effects of the proposed use on nearby residents and their enjoyment of surrounding properties. Relevant policies considered: DES 23 & DES 30 Smart Growth Principles The 2045 Comprehensive Plan identifies creating attractive, amen itized communities and directing development to target areas as Smart Growth principles. The proposed billboard would occupy an existing developed commercial property within the Suburban Overlay District, avoiding expansion into rural areas or undeveloped land. However, its location within an established commercial corridor does not re solve concerns regarding its compatibility with surrounding uses. The billboard’s height, elevated digital displays, and requested reductions in setbacks and residential separation do not support the principle of creating attractive communities with a strong sense of place. Although the proposed SITELINE technology and landscaping may reduce certain impacts, they would not fully address the structure’s visual prominence along Western Branch Boulevard or its relationship to nearby residential properties. Summary Analysis Section 14-701 of the CZO establishes the intent for signs to be compatible with their surroundings and protective of the public’s health, safety, and welfare, while avoiding detrimental effects on the City’s visual environment and economic vitality. Section 14 -706 establishes standards for billboard signs and allows City Council to modify those standa rds through the conditional use permit process. Although the proposed billboard meets the maximum height and sign area standards, the applicant requests reductions in setbacks from both adjoining streets and the existing building, as well as a reduction i n residential separation from three hundred (300) feet to approximately one hundred eighty-seven (187) feet. PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 7 The proposed billboard’s height, elevated digital displays, and proximity to residential property raise concerns regarding compatibility with surrounding development and the character of the Western Branch Boulevard corridor. Policies DES 14 and DES 23 of the 2045 Comprehensive Plan promote high -quality non-residential development and compatibility with residential uses through appropriate height, massing, and setbacks. While the applicant’s lighting analysis indicates that SITELINE te chnology would limit light emissions toward nearby light-sensitive areas, these measures would not address the st ructure’s overall visual prominence. Similarly, the proposed landscaping would soften views of the monopole but provide limited screening of the elevated displays. Staff does not support the requested setback and residential separation reductions. The proposal does not adequately demonstrate compatibility with nearby residential uses or advance the Comprehensive Plan’s objectives for an attractive commercial corridor. As such, staff recommend denial of this request. If the application is approved, staff have provided suggested stipulations below for consideration. 1. The proposed billboard sign with requested reductions in setbacks and distance from residential property is not compatible with adjacent uses, would be a detriment to the visual environment, and could negatively affect the economic viability of the property. 2. The property supports a viable economic use under its current use. 3. The proposed lighting controls and landscaping would not sufficiently mitigate the billboard’s visual prominence or establish compatibility with nearby residential properties. 4. All conditional uses are presumed to be incompatible with the surrounding area. 1. The location of the sign shall be as depicted on the submitted preliminary site plan dated July 20, 2026 (Revised September 30, 2026) and prepared by CivilTek. 2. The applicant/owner shall install landscaping as depicted on the preliminary site plan dated July 20, 2026 (Revised September 30, 2026) , subject to review and approval of the City’s Landscape Coordinator. 3. The applicant/owner shall preserve the existing shrubs along Western Branch Boulevard and Collins Boulevard and shall maintain them for the duration of this use. 4. The proposed sign shall not exceed thirty-five (35) feet in height and three hundred (300) square feet in sign area. Staff Findings Recommended Stipulations dated October 20, 2026 PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 8 5. The proposed freestanding sign shall be a monopole sign and shall substantially adhere in appearance and size to the submitted Elevations Exhibit dated June 3, 2025 , and prepared by Bennett & Pless, as determined by the Director of Development & Permits or designee. 6. The applicant/owner shall obtain all required permits and/or licensing and provide copies of the same to the Director of Development and Permits or designee, prior to the issuance of a building permit for the billboard sign. PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 9 Zoning Map 2045 Character District Map PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 10 Aerial Map PLN-USE-2026-020 Western Branch Billboard 11 In an effort to encourage robust stakeholder involvement as is required by Smart Growth, the applicant is encouraged to reach out to nearby community, property owners and civic leagues. To this end, the applicant did not include any additional outreach. As required by state law, this request was advertised in the Virginian-Pilot on October 25, 2026 and November 1, 2026. Also, notification letters were mailed to adjacent properties on or about October 23, 2026. As required by the Zoning Ordinance, public notification signs were posted on the property by October 28, 2026. 1. Departmental Review Comments 2. Preliminary Site Plan dated July 20, 2026 (Revised September 30, 2026) 3. Elevations Exhibit dated June 3, 2025 4. Renderings 5. Lighting Study dated September 18, 2026 Supplemental Documents Public Outreach (757)382-6176 | CityOfChesapeake.net | Planning@CityOfChesapeake.net | 306CedarRoad,Chesapeake,Virginia23322 DEPARTMENTALREVIEWINGCOMMENTS PLN-USE-2026-020WesternBranchBillboard DEVELOPMENT&PERMITS: BUILDING:PROVIDEDONSeptember16,2026 Advisory:  A commercial building permit for the foundation is required to erect the proposed billboard. Plans will need to be designed to the 2021 Virginia Uniform Statewide BuildingCodeforacceptance. LANDSCAPING:PROVIDEDONOctober5,2026 Advisory:  Per Chesapeake Landscape Ordinance §19-601-610 and §14-706-3-i, a final landscapeplanisrequired.PleaserefertotheChesapeakeLandscapeOrdinancefor detailed instructions and to the Chesapeake Landscape Ordinance and SpecificationsManualforguidanceregardingtreespeciesandsizingdetails.  Further conditions may be required during the administration of applicable City Ordinances and Standards relevant to subsequent submittals. Any site plan submittedwiththisapplicationmayrequirerevisionduringdetailedsiteplanreview tomeetallapplicableCityCodesandStandards.Finalconstructionplansshallmeet allapplicablerequirementspriortoCityapproval. ZONING:PROVIDEDONOctober20,2026 Advisory:  Alldeviationsfromrequiredsetbacksareshownontheplanmustberequestedand approvedbyCityCouncil. FIREPREVENTION:PROVIDEDONAUGUST31,2026 Advisory:  Height is notedfrom ground tobottom of billboardat 22 ft.which meetsminimum 13'6"clearancepertheFireCode.   1-800-667-4554  1387 Cornwall Rd.  Oakville, ON L6J 7T5 mediaresources.com 1   Re: Use of SITELINE digital display atat3277 Western Branch Blvd    To whom it may concern, Media Resources Inc. has been engaged by Adams Outdoor to review and assess the  lighting impact of theproposed digital billboard installation at 3277 Western Branch  Blvd. This document will describe the lighting impacts of our VISIONiQ SITELINE digital  billboards in this specific application, and furthercommit a maximum luminance value  of the display as observed from the nearby light-sensitive areas.  Background on Media Resources Digital Display Ambient-Aware Brightness Controls During dusk, dawn, or cloudy days, the operation of the digital display according to  ambient light readings is the ideal way to maintain a glare-free, light-trespass free image. Media Resources digital billboards are all equipped with factory-mounted dual photocell  sensors that are redundant and capable of reading ambient brightness even if one unit  suffers a hardware failure. The ambient brightness to output brightness response curves  have been carefully developed into a standard to provide good readability on the  display while keeping in line with the brightness of the overall visual context.   Figure 1. Media Resources standard - dual ambient brightness measuring photocells for  hardware redundancy    1-800-667-4554 1387CornwallRd. Oakville,ONL6J7T5 mediaresources.com 2 Duringnight-time,brightnesscontrolbecomescriticalasthedigitalbillboardsmustbe operatedatasmallpercentageofitsmaximumbrightnessinordertoavoidglareor lighttrespass.MediaResourcesendeavorstohavethemostcomprehensivesystemof safetiesandtraceabilityfornight-timebrightnessmanagement.Theproposeddigital billboardsarewellequippedwithmodernbrightnesscontrols.Besidestheredundant photocellsabove,anumberofsecondaryfail-safesarealsoimplementedincludingaa communicationswatchdog(automaticreductiontonight-timebrightnessintheevent ofacommunicationloss),andfailbacktoalocation/seasonawaretime-based scheduleintheeventofcatastrophicphotocellsystemfailure.Withthesesafety featuresinplace,itbecomesextremelyunlikelyforthedigitalbillboardtooperateat highbrightnesslevelsatnight. Additionally, theMedia ResourcesNetworkOperationsCentrecanmonitorbrightness and recall brightness history for traceability.See Figure2and Figure3below on our internalcontrolsystemforconfiguringbrightnessandrecallingbrightnesshistory. Figure2.MediaResourceswebportalshowingbrightnessconfigurationandhistoryofthecurrent day   1-800-667-4554  1387 Cornwall Rd.  Oakville, ON L6J 7T5 mediaresources.com 3    Figure 3. Media Resources web portal showing brightness history of any selected previous date.  Brightness history data is logged indefinitely on Media Resources servers.    SITELINE and Site Specific Considerations  Media Resources Inc. invented the SITELINE product specifically to address the issues  surrounding individual areas where light emission into nearby areas is undesirable.  The SITELINE system employs a patent-pending mechanical baffle system similar to  luminaire baffles to eliminate all projection of light from the Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs)  into a “protected region”. As a result, the protection is physical (See Figure 4 and 5) –  reliable, permanent, and not the outcome of any programming or settings.  For a video reference of the effectiveness of the Media Resources SITELINE product,  please see https://vimeo.com/365082755. In the many applications of SITELINE deployed  across North America, I can affirm that we have never received a single brightness  complaint after installation. 1-800-667-4554 1387CornwallRd. Oakville,ONL6J7T5 mediaresources.com 4 Figures4and5..CloseupphotographsofSITELINEmodulefaceviewedfromfront(left)andfrom side(right).Notethered,greenandbluediodelensesaredirectlyvisiblefromfrontdirectionbut areobscuredbehindbafflesviewedfromtheside. MediaResourcescommitstotheeffectivenessofthislightrestrictiontechnologywhen deployedat3277WesternBranchBlvd. Wehavecalculatedtheexpectedilluminanceimpacttosurroundingareasofconcern, showninFigure6,alongwithatableshowingfcfcvaluesatvariousdistancesandangles fromthefaceofthedisplay.MediaResourcesguaranteesthatthedisplaywilloperate within20%ofilluminanceimpactcalculatedbelow.Ifapprovedandconstructed,we can provide on-site lighting measurements to confirm correct installation and light restrictionperformance. 1-1-800-667-4554 1387CornwallRd. Oakville,ONL6J7T5 mediaresources.com 55 Figure6.Sitesatellitephotooverlayofdistancesandanglesfromproposeddigitalbillboardsite, correspondingtocalculatedilluminancefiguresinfcfcprovidedinTable1. SiteCalculations-10'x30'300NITSRight-Blocking MeasurementAngle Distance(ft) -80° -60° -40° -20° 0°0° 20° 40° 60° 80° 200' 0.018fc 0.058fc 0.131fc 0.176fc 0.185fc 0.157fc 0.003fc 0.001fc 0.000fc 400' 0.005fc 0.015fc 0.033fc 0.045fc 0.048fc 0.042fc 0.001fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 600' 0.002fc 0.007fc 0.015fc 0.020fc 0.022fc 0.019fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 800' 0.001fc 0.004fc 0.008fc 0.011fc 0.012fc 0.011fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.000fc SiteCalculations-10'x30'300NITSLeft-Blocking MeasurementAngle Distance(ft) -80° -60° -40° -20° 0°0° 20° 40° 60° 80° 200' 0.000fc 0.001fc 0.003fc 0.157fc 0.185fc 0.176fc 0.131fc 0.058fc 0.018fc 400' 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.001fc 0.042fc 0.048fc 0.045fc 0.033fc 0.015fc 0.005fc 600' 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.019fc 0.022fc 0.020fc 0.015fc 0.007fc 0.002fc 800' 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.000fc 0.011fc 0.012fc 0.011fc 0.008fc 0.004fc 0.001fc Table1.SitecalculationsinfcfcbasedofMRIVIQSiteline16.67BlockingModule. 1-800-667-4554 1387CornwallRd. Oakville,ONL6J7T5 mediaresources.com 6 WearealwayscommittedtotheresponsibleapplicationofLEDdigitaltechnologyand are happy to engage with regulatory stakeholders at any time. Please feel free to contactusifyouhaveanyquestions. Sincerely, Anthony Knight Product Implementation Specialist Media Resources Inc. (289)289-0035 aknight@mediaresources.com

Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.