City Council Budget Work Session — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Mar 19, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
Tuesday, March 19, 2024 | 4:00 PM
City Hall- 2nd Floor Training Room
900 Church Street
Lynchburg, VA 24504
AGENDA
I. Welcome Stephanie T. Reed, Mayor
II. Budget Work Session Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III. Budget Work Session Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III.1. Water, Sewer, and Stormwater FY 2025 Budget Overview and Rate
Recommendations
III.2. FY 2025 Proposed Budget Reconciliation
Page 1 of 26
City Council
Agenda Item III.1.
Information Only
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
March 19, 2024 Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water
Resources
AGENDA ITEM # III.1
Water, Sewer, and Stormwater FY 2025 Budget Overview and Rate Recommendations
RECOMMENDATION
Proceed to a Public Hearing for the Water, Sewer, and Stormwater proposed FY 2025 Rate
increases.
SUMMARY
Staff will present an overview of the FY 2025 Proposed Water, Sewer, and Stormwater Funds
budgets including rate recommendations. Reasons for the proposed rate increases will also be
discussed.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
None.
FISCAL IMPACT
As presented in the FY 2025 Budget
CONTACT(S)
Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water Resources
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. LWR Budget Rates Presentation 3-19-24
REVIEWED BY
Date: March 13, 2024
Timothy Mitchell, Director of Water Resources
Page 2 of 26
Date: March 14, 2024
Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager
Date: March 14, 2024
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 3 of 26
LYNCHBURG WATER RESOURCES
BUDGET & RATE UPDATES
March 19, 2024
Page 4 of 26
PROPOSED RATE SUMMARY
Water
Proposed rate
$3.29 PER HCF
____________
CURRENT RATE IS
$2.93 PER HCF
Sewer
Proposed rate
$8.30 PER HCF
____________
CURRENT RATE IS
$8.10 PER HCF
Stormwater
Proposed rate
$4.93 PER SFU
____________
CURRENT RATE IS
$4.48 FOR SFU
HCF = Hundred Cubic Feet (748 gallons) SFU: Single Family Unit (2,672 square feet)
Average residential bill
increase per month:
$3.22
Water: +$1.78 per month
Sewer: +$0.99 per month
Stormwater: +$0.45 per month
Based on 4.95 HCF average usage
Page 5 of 26
WATER AND SEWER: HOW DO WE COMPARE?
LYNCHBURG
$81.41*
Water: $22.75 per month
Sewer: $58.66 per month
VIRGINIA AVERAGE
$93.73
Water: $40.99 per month
Sewer: $52.74 per month
Other Virginia localities
Amherst County $130.59
Bedford County $129.00
Town of Bedford $129.00
City of Charlottesville $123.41
City of Richmond $122.31
Town of Appomattox $121.65
Town of Amherst $115.95
City of Salem $92.16
Campbell County $87.02
City of Harrisonburg $81.44
------------ LYNCHBURG ($81.41) ------------
Roanoke City/County $72.60
* The average Lynchburg residence uses 3,700 gallons/month ($60.24 average for water, sewer)
- Numbers based on FY 2024 rates; data from TRC’s Virginia Water & Wastewater Rate Report 2023
How the water and sewer cost for a Lynchburg household using
5,000 gallons/month compares with the Va. average, other localities:
Page 6 of 26
STORMWATER FEE: HOW WE COMPARE
Page 7 of 26
BEST RATE PRACTICES & GOALS
Best Practices
• Rates are fair and
equitable
• Rates reflect true
cost of providing
services
• Rate structures
charge customers
receiving certain
services the actual
cost of those
services
Our Goals
• Minimize rate increases
• Provide quality water, sewer,
stormwater services to every resident,
business, and visitor every single day
• Meet extensive regulatory requirements
• Efficiently operate and maintain water,
sewer, and stormwater infrastructure
• Comply with Council’s fiscal policies
• Comply with the State of Virginia’s CSO
Consent Special Order’s financial
requirements
Page 8 of 26
WATER FUND
BUDGET SUMMARY
FY 2024: $17.0 M | FY 2025: $18.8 M
FY 2025 Operating Fund Primary Cost Increases
• Salaries and benefits: $650,000
• Includes one new Assistant Chemist position to handle
increased sampling requirements associated with the
Lead and Copper Rule Revisions
• Includes operator progression pay adjustments
• Debt service: $484,000
• Supplies and materials: $229,000
• Utilities: $95,000
• Contractual services: $63,000
Page 9 of 26
WATER CAPITAL
BUDGET SUMMARY
New Projects in FY 2025
• $3.48 million, Downtown Area Business, Phase IV
• $3.1 million, Clay Street Reservoir
• $2.95 million, 6th & Madison Waterline Replacement
• $2.95 million, Fillmore Waterline Replacement
• $2.4 million, College Hill/13th St. Waterline
Replacement
• $1.88 million, Cellular Meter Replacements
• $1 million, Carroll Avenue Pump #3
Page 10 of 26
OUR WATER INFRASTRUCTURE
We are responsible for 455 miles of waterlines
serving Lynchburg. That’s equal to the distance
from here to New York City
Today, we have 95.1 miles of waterlines in need
of replacement
Over the next 25 years, another 31.6 miles of
waterlines will reach 100 years in age
From 2050-2060, another 53 miles of waterlines
will reach 100 years in age
Page 11 of 26
A CLOSER LOOK AT OUR
AGING INFRASTRUCTURE
• Aging cast iron pipes (76 miles by 2050): Most
susceptible to corrosion and breaks, which can
impact water quality, cause service disruptions,
put strains on staffing, and are costly to repair
• Undersized pipes (18 miles): Unsuitable for city
fire hydrants and do not provide adequate fire flow
capacity
• Asbestos cement (33 miles): Inferior pipe that
hasn’t been used since the late 1970s, requires
special handling and disposal
Page 12 of 26
WATER CAPITAL
FUNDING OPTIONS
• Scenario 1: Keep capital spending at current
levels, slow current pace of replacement
• Scenario 2: Adjust capital spending to account
for inflation, retain current pace of replacement
• Scenario 3: Adjust capital spending to eventually
get to a 100-year replacement cycle, likely around
2070 – our recommended option
• Scenario 4: Adjust capital spending to catch up to
a 100-year replacement cycle by 2050
Page 13 of 26
COMPARING THE SCENARIOS
- The current water rate is $2.93 per HCF
Page 14 of 26
WHAT DOES OPTION 3 GET US?
Begins implementation of Water System Master Plan
• Replacement of aging and inadequate waterlines across
city: 100-year cast iron, undersized pipe, asbestos cement
• Addresses growth needs: Carroll Avenue Pump Station
upgrade serving Liberty University/Wards Road area;
second Mill Lane tank serving western portion of city
• Sustainable path forward: Puts us on track to eventually
reach 100-year replacement cycle
What it doesn’t get us
• We don’t catch up to 100-year replacement cycle by 2050;
“catch up” would likely happen around 2070
Page 15 of 26
OPTIONS 1 & 2: FALLING BEHIND
Delays critical projects in Water System Master Plan
• Will require tough decisions between replacing city’s
aging infrastructure and keeping up with city’s growth
and capacity needs
Puts us on a 200- to 270-year replacement cycle
• Industry standards call for a 100-year cycle
• Will compromise our ability to deliver a reliable supply
of safe and quality drinking water to residents,
businesses, hospitals, schools
• Doesn’t fully address concerns about water main
breaks, fire flow, asbestos cement pipes
• The Jackson, Miss., water crisis was the result
of decades of water infrastructure neglect.
• We don’t want to be in that position in 30 or 40
years from now.
Page 16 of 26
SEWER FUND
BUDGET SUMMARY
FY 2024: $28.4 M | FY 2025: $29.9 M
FY 2025 Operating Fund Primary Cost Increases
• Salaries and benefits: $497,000
• Includes new Lab Technician to meet additional
sampling needs of our Industrial Pretreatment Program
• Includes operator progression pay adjustments
• Admin/payments to water fund: $366,000
• Debt service: $342,000
• Indirect costs paid to general fund: $95,000
• Contractual services: $63,000
Page 17 of 26
SEWER CAPITAL
BUDGET SUMMARY
New Projects in FY 2025
• $96 million, Blackwater CSO 52 Tunnel
• $6.3 million, Richland Hills Sewer Extension
• $3.8 million, Golf Park CSO
• $1.12 million, Sewer System Evaluation Survey
• $860,000, Solids Improvement Study
• $720,000, James River Interceptor Bank
Stabilization
• $700,000, 13th St. CSO Separation
Page 18 of 26
MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD
INCOME CALCULATION
• CSO Consent Order requires that the average annual
sewer bill must equal or exceed 1.25% of Median
Household Income (MHI)
• Calculated MHI increased this year from $58,876 to
$59,290, leading to $0.20 increase to sewer rate
• MHI calculation includes the $7.69 monthly service fee
• MHI compliance July 1, 2023: $8.10 per HCF
• MHI calculation for compliance as of July 1, 2024:
$8.30 per HCF
Page 19 of 26
STORMWATER FUND
BUDGET SUMMARY
FY 2024: $4.1 M | FY 2025: $4.5 M
FY 2025 Operating Fund Primary Cost Increases
• Debt service: $128,000
• Public Works leaf collection/engineering:
$104,000
• Indirect costs paid to general fund: $65,000
• Salaries and benefits: $57,000
• Admin/payments to water fund: $41,000
• Community Development charges: $28,000
Page 20 of 26
STORMWATER CAPITAL
BUDGET SUMMARY
New Projects in FY 2025
• $2 million, College Park Improvements
• $559,000, Downtown Area Business, Phase IV
• $460,000, Pipe & Manhole Rehabilitation
• $420,000, Heath Avenue Improvements
• $400,000, Moseley, Landover Outfalls
• $350,000, Moseley Pond Rehabilitation
College Park Rate Impacts
• Project is accounted for in the proposed
$4.93 monthly stormwater fee for FY 2025
• Not including the project would result in a
7-cent reduction in the proposed
stormwater fee for FY 2025 ($4.86)
• $130,000 in annual principal and interest
payments will begin in FY 2026, requiring
an additional 15 cents to be added to the
monthly stormwater fee ($5.08)
Page 21 of 26
OUR STORMWATER INFRASTRUCTURE
• We have significant stormwater
infrastructure needs in all parts of the city,
including nearly 300 outfalls in need of
repair in the next 5 years.
• Failing stormwater infrastructure can lead
to private property damage, stream
erosion, sewer line breaks, and more.
Page 22 of 26
FUTURE STORMWATER DEBT SERVICE
Page 23 of 26
THE SERVICE CHARGE:
WHAT DOES IT COVER?
• The service charge helps cover the cost of utility
billings & collections, meter reading, and water meter
maintenance and replacements
• The typical monthly residential service charge is $7.69,
well below surrounding localities
• Without the $2.6 million service charge revenues,
water and sewer rates would need to increase to
meet City Council’s adopted financial minimums
and the Consent Order’s MHI requirements
• FY 2025 proposed rates would increase to:
o $3.71 for water
o $8.93 for sewer
- The current proposed rates are
$3.29 for water and $8.30 for sewer
Page 24 of 26
SERVICE CHARGE: HOW WE COMPARE
Page 25 of 26
IN SUMMARY
• All 3 funds – water, sewer, and stormwater – face significant infrastructure needs, rising
project and operational costs, staffing challenges, and increasing regulatory demands.
• Despite these challenges, Lynchburg residents will continue to pay below the state
average for these essential services even with the proposed increases.
• We have a unique opportunity over the next 25 years to significantly address our
infrastructure needs and finally put Lynchburg on a sustainable path forward.
Page 26 of 26
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.